Fix bootloop on Android Q

[kotori2]

I fixed permission issue which cause bootloop in upstream library whale.
Modified source code can be found here.
Only tested on Android Q OB1 on OP7P.
Compiled zip file was attached below.
magisk-EdXposed-YAHFA-v0.4.5.5_beta-release.zip

Edit: SandHook was also fixed. Also I changed version number to 0.4.6.0.
magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.6.0_beta-release.zip

[coderstory]

mi9 miui10 anroid Q
boot success

[eebssk1]

android 9成功翻车。日志暂未获取。

[eebssk1]

找到问题了。找不到libandroid_servers.so

[eebssk1]

art初始化过早了，那个时候64位的liband......还没被镜像

[NYCJames]

多謝你幫忙我們

[reyqn]

Booted without any issue on my pixel 3a (android Q stock)

[kotori2]

找到问题了。找不到libandroid_servers.so

并没有动过启动顺序。如果你用我这个崩的话，用官方release应该也会崩？
@eebssk1

[Cryolitia]

It works on mi 9 MIUI 9.8.29, thx for your work a lot

[eebssk1]

找到问题了。找不到libandroid_servers.so

并没有动过启动顺序。如果你用我这个崩的话，用官方release应该也会崩？
@eebssk1

我知道。。我也很奇怪啊，我一直用的官方4468，一换上你的就会这样，，，，真是玄学。。

[kotori2]

@eebssk1 机型和系统？

[HpNoTiQ56]

Working great with xposed modules loading and working (YBPB, LP, ChromePie, ...) I Only miss gravity box!

[eebssk1]

@eebssk1 机型和系统？

Xiaomi Mi6(sagit)
RR-P-v7.0.2

[s3axel]

Also working great here on another OP7Pro with OB1 - thanks !!

[Cryolitia]

疑似黑名单无效，会导致云闪付无法启动，未验证
mi9，MIUI 9.8.29

[zhanglianxin]

Working great on Xiaomi Mi6 (sagit) PixelExperience_sagit-10.0 (Android 10), thanks!

[DarkSJ1998]

@s3axel Does it also work fine on OB2? Some guy on XDA reported he faced bootloop. And you're using Sandhook or Yahfa?

[s3axel]

Works also on OB2. Here I'm presently using Sandhook, haven't tested YAHFA...

[tardeaux]

I also had a bootloop on OP7pro, but uninstalling XPrivacyLUA resolved it. Don't forget to disable your modules before upgrading from Pie 😉

[Rakau]

MIUI10 安卓10 Working magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.6.0_beta-release.zip

[gozilla-paradise]

Confirmed working on Android 10 with one plus 7 pro

[infoflo7]

Works on Redmi Note 7 on Android 10 custom ROM (Atom OS)! Thanks!

[nialler82]

Can @Alienhack please link me to the edxposed manager that installed for them on oneplus 7 pro, Android q stable. I cannot get any to install for me. Thanks

[limstash]

Still bootloop on Xiaomi MI 8 with Pixel Experience ROM

[NYCJames]

I also can't boot after reinstalling this edxposed.

Edit: Found a fix for me
Keep Resource hooking support disabled in EdXposed Installer settings if possible

[SukkaW]

OnePlus 7 with OxygenOS 10.0 Boot successfully.

[nialler82]

Booting successfully on Op7pro.

[Howard20181]

Work well in Mi9
MIUI 11 9.10.10
Android 10
(SandHook & YAHFA)

[soaresden]

Stuck on fastboot screen on mi8 latest rom
Both sand and yahfa

Thanks mm to be able to remove each time

[KaizerHanz]

Work Well on Xiaomi Mi8 EU ROM, 9.10.11 MIUI11 Android Q, thanks to @kotori2 for pointing out bootloop, just used YAHYA version, Sandhook version give me some app "force closed" error. But YAHYA working well.

[soaresden]

How did you do ? I just tried and always fastboot screen.. can't even boot on miui

[KaizerHanz]

I was give instruction on xda, but here tutorial what I'm doing to do :

after install riru-edxposed (YAHYA or Sandhok), reboot, then if you got "fastboot" mode, reboot to recovery and then go to file manager, go to data/adb/modules/riru-edxposed then search "post-fs-data.sh" (you can delete it or rename it). Then Reboot.

if you use stock kernel then you must have SELinux Permissive (you can google it app to make SELinux Enforced to Permissive).

[soaresden]

I just renamed via twrp explorer the file you said and all good now.
Many thanks !

[parambika]

I was give instruction on xda, but here tutorial what I'm doing to do :

after install riru-edxposed (YAHYA or Sandhok), reboot, then if you got "fastboot" mode, reboot to recovery and then go to file manager, go to data/adb/modules/riru-edxposed then search "post-fs-data.sh" (you can delete it or rename it). Then Reboot.

if you use stock kernel then you must have SELinux Permissive (you can google it app to make SELinux Enforced to Permissive).

Thank you, this solves the problem of phone getting stuck on boot logo (splash screen), works on Redmi Note 5 Pro (whyred) Android 10 on Aosp based rom

[Mikanoshi]

Why 0.4.6.0 is spamming the log with
E/EdXposed-Bridge: android.content.pm.PackageManager$NameNotFoundException:
and also
D/SandXposed: method <...> hook in?

[ecompton59]

OnePlus 7pro oos 10.01 runs both good sandhook is faster i believe

[Udzi142]

Sadly not working on OnePlus 7T 10.0.4 (YAFHA or Sandhook)

[lllinusss]

It's sad that this simple fix works flawlessly while the official 4.6.0 beta release causes bootloops.

[ghost]

Thanks a lot for this. The official 0.4.6.0 doesn't work on my OnePlus 6 on Android 10 beta.

[ChaliceChore]

Really lots of thanks! This version works wonders on my OnePlus 7 Pro OOS 10.0.1. Official version won't work.

[solohsu]

@kotori2 Sorry for late reply. What is the difference between this and #355 ?
@ganyao114

[kotori2]

@solohsu
第一条commit是一样的，我从whale里修的权限，@ganyao114 在调whale之前修的权限，另外我写得比较丑
第二条是把sandhook的代码直接复制过来，然后照葫芦画瓢改了下XposedCompat.java
我也不知道我的fix那么长为什么反正it works

[solohsu]

@kotori2 嗯，按道理讲对whale的修改应该去whale那边提交PR。
现在我看很多人说你这个修改编译出来的没问题，#355 有问题。不清楚到底是哪里的差异造成的问题。

[kotori2]

@kotori2 嗯，按道理讲对whale的修改应该去whale那边提交PR。
现在我看很多人说你这个修改编译出来的没问题，#355 有问题。不清楚到底是哪里的差异造成的问题。

idk
not tested
works on my device

[KenMizz]

虽然说是支持了Android 10但是最新commit的edxposed还是会在我的Oneplus 7 Pro上导致bootloop，只有这个才能用，为啥啊

[Howard20181]

虽然说是支持了Android 10但是最新commit的edxposed还是会在我的Oneplus 7 Pro上导致bootloop，只有这个才能用，为啥啊

试试这个呢？https://ci.appveyor.com/project/ElderDrivers/edxposed/builds/27518070/artifacts

[KenMizz]

@Howard20181 谢谢

[p1r473]

Hi, I got myself in a pickle
Im on a Pixel 4 XL. I accidently installed EdXposed 0.4.5.1_beta instead of 0.4.6 and it caused a bootloop
I was able to get back into the OS by reflashing the latest OTA update.
Any time I reflashed Magisk, it recreates /data/adb/modules/riru-core and riru_edxposed_sandhook , the old versions that cause bootloop
No matter how many times I went in and delete these folders with ADB, they get recreated any time I reflashed Magisk

Edit: Saved my ass by flashing this core-only Magisk boot.img: https://forum.xda-developers.com/pixel-4-xl/themes/magisk-modules-disabler-booting-magisk-t3990557

[kotori2]

@p1r473 Create an empty file named "disable" in /data/adb/modules/blabla/

[kattza]

still get bootloops on miui 11.1 xiaomi.eu on both versions....
the only way I can get away with it is renaming the posts-fs-data.sh file but then EdXposed doens't work anyways on the modules, can anyone help? :/

[nc7s]

@Udzi142's reply still happens on OnePlus 7T, stock 10.0.7.HD65, with no other modules than Riru core and EdXposed installed. Since TWRP can't decrypt /data, the Magisk Manager for Recovery Mode aka mm is useless, and I had to flash a full system image to recover from the broken Magisk installation.

Note that only installing EdXposed will bootloop it - Riru core alone is fine.

[MlgmXyysd]

@Noctfield u can use Magisk rescue shell: "magisk --remove-modules" in bootloop-adb

[nc7s]

@MlgmXyysd Thanks for the advice, will try next time when booting into recovery. The problem now is that I'm not quite confident about trying the SandHook variant 😐

[MlgmXyysd]

@Noctfield Note u must open adb and auth ur computer after bootloop