• New Git Homepage

    schacon 5 Jan 2009

    A few hours ago, Petr Baudis, the man who put up git.or.cz and repo.or.cz and has worked on TopGit and a ton of other useful Git projects, just redirected the git.or.cz main site to git-scm.com, a fork of the git.or.cz site that I started a few months ago.

    His email to the Git mailing list reads thusly:

    Hi,
    
    thanks for the changes, Scott!
    
    Based on the previous feedback of other developers and my last 
    review of git-scm.com, I have changed git.or.cz to redirect to 
    git-scm.com.
    
    The wiki is still hosted at the original place for the time being, 
    as well as the man/ gitbot redirect. To reach the original 
    manpage, use <a href="http://git.or.cz/index.html">http://git.or.cz/index.html</a>.
    
    Have a fun year,
    
    --
    Petr "Pasky" Baudis
    

    So, I’m now the maintainer of the main Git website. If you have ideas for features, please let me know, or even better – fork the project, make the changes and send a pull request.

  • Comments

    drnic Mon Jan 05 16:02:49 -0800 2009
    paulca Mon Jan 05 17:33:15 -0800 2009

    Power to the people. They’ll have you for antitrust soon! Nice work Scott, congratulations.

    spovich Mon Jan 05 22:30:58 -0800 2009

    Very cool. May I suggest using git-scm.org rather than git-scm.com? Currently git-scm.org redirects to git-scm.com, but I would reverse that. There is nothing commercial about git. I think the .org domain more properly reflects the open source GPL quality of git.

    dylanz Mon Jan 05 22:36:51 -0800 2009

    Perhaps a link to http://whyhgisbetterthanx.com/

    Oh, snap!

    I am a fan of Mercurial however… I won’t lie :)

    jlecour Tue Jan 06 02:10:19 -0800 2009

    Congrats Scott. Your amazing work is paying

    pablete Tue Jan 06 03:14:04 -0800 2009

    Congratulations Scott!, you are unstoppable.

    Keep the cool work!

    imbaczek Tue Jan 06 05:51:05 -0800 2009

    link to msysgit with proper disclaimers, please?

    technomancy Tue Jan 06 10:10:26 -0800 2009

    I agree about the .org and .com switch; the official site should be .org.

    schacon Tue Jan 06 10:34:18 -0800 2009

    @drnic – i hesitate to link to ‘whygit’ specifically because of things like @dylanz comment.

    I feel that all of the points I make on that site are valid, but it is a simplistic apologia, not a presentation of points and counterpoints, which I think people need to feel that it’s ‘fair’. So, I may re-use a lot of that content in a new format for the git homepage at some point, but it’s unlikely I will link to it.

    People have simply reacted much more negatively than I expected to it, even doing ad-hominem based websites mocking it – which, although somewhat flattering, is not the reaction I want to elicit via the main git homepage.

    @spovich and @technomancy – I don’t own the .org, it was already taken when I registered the .com – git.org itself is also taken, so this was the best I could do, domain-wise. The .org guy started redirecting to the or.cz site, but in order to switch them, we would have to transfer the ‘git-scm.org’ domain to me, which is painful and problematic, especially since I don’t really know the guy who owns it.

    @imbaczek – what proper disclaimers? if you fork the site and change it, i’ll be happy to pull in the changes.

    sr Tue Jan 06 10:34:56 -0800 2009

    how about a link to http://whyhgisnotbetterthanx.com/ ? ;-)

    seriously, awesome work!

    imbaczek Wed Jan 07 12:24:13 -0800 2009

    schacon: msysgit is almost bare-bone git; e.g. git-svn is broken and horribly slow. core git functionality works, but not in potentially important cases like over UNC paths; autocrlf defaults may be a bit intrusive; such things.

    don’t have time to do actual work, though ^^ currently there’s absolutely no mention that it is possible to use git on windows without cygwin, and IMHO it’s very important for windows people to know that it exists, works, and does so quite well at that.

    imbaczek Wed Jan 07 12:25:38 -0800 2009

    woops no edit – i see that there’s “other download options”, didn’t occur to me that it could contain a link to msysgit at first. it’s not as bad as i thought it is, though.

    Please log in to comment.