• Commit Comments

    defunkt Apr 10

    In the past, maybe 100 years ago, I worked at a company where the diff of each commit was emailed to the developers. If anyone had a comment or question, they’d “reply-all” and top-post their remark. Efficient, but oh so messy. Especially as the threads grew.

    Enter: commit comments. We saw the Django Book and instantly knew this was the best (and coolest) solution.

    Leave a comment at the bottom of any commit, or on a single line. Up to you. Comments show up in your feed and each repository has its own comment feed.

    On the commits log or the source browser, commits that have been commented on will be marked with a comment bubble.

    Try it on the Facebox commit and have fun.

    • Comments

    • thedaniel 41 minutes later

      I was just on the fence about leaving github for my preexisting gitosis setup because I am too damn cheap to pay 7 bucks, but this tipped me back over to your side. Keep up the shiny groupware additions, this is great.

    • drnic about 2 hours later

      Will you be adding this to the standard file source view? Some times it is difficult to find the commit for a particular chunk of code, or github can throw a “This is taking too long” error when viewing a commit and not show you anything.

    • drnic about 2 hours later

      Sorry, the specific error message is “Sorry, this commit is taking too long to generate.”
      For example, commit: http://github.com/jrun/rstack/commit/6c7c81bf3ea672f669f9e2d7238fb826d23ef133

    • rsanheim about 17 hours later

      Is there going to be a way to expose the comments beyond the web interface? Maybe as its own branch or something?

    Participate

    Please log in to comment.
rss