Skip to content

Document the discrepancies of :visible/:hidden on select options between Firefox & the rest #1149

Open
@mgol

Description

@mgol

From jquery/jquery#4463 (comment) by me:

:visible & :hidden which are jQuery selector extensions defined in src/css/hiddenVisibleSelectors.js. :hidden is defined as a negation of :visible so we can focus on the latter. And browsers differ here:

  • Chrome 76, Safari 12.1 & Edge 18 match 0 elements for :visible
  • Firefox 68 matches 2 elements. Its results for those two:
    offsetWidth: 39
    offsetHeight: 14
    getClientRects().length: 1
    
  • IE 11 matches 3 elements for :visible. The results are not affected by display: none:
    offsetWidth: 0
    offsetHeight: 0
    getClientRects().length: 1
    
    The rect returned by getClientRects() has all properties set to 0.

The test case for the results I provided above: https://output.jsbin.com/bawosuv


From jquery/jquery#4463 (comment) by me:

From a quick look at the CSSOM spec, all three properties (offsetWidth, offsetHeight & getClientRects) are expressed in terms of CSS layout box which has a note in the spec:

ISSUE 1 The terms CSS layout box and SVG layout box are not currently defined by CSS or SVG.

That indicates we're in a gray area here.


From jquery/jquery#4463 (comment) by @gibson042:

It is an inconsistency, but I don't know that we should solve it. Lots of elements default to not having layout (<meta>, <style>, <template>, etc.), and in some cases that can be overridden. For example, <style> elements can have display: block, and—especially relevant here—<option>s in a <select multiple> really do take up space.

I think the right approach here is to push for a fix in Firefox, acknowledge that IE is just wrong, and add documentation recommending increased caution when using :hidden and :visible.


Issue reported in Firefox's bug tracker at https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1584752.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions