1IP2: Formalize and Clarify 1IP Procedure and Statuses

[sambacha]

1IP: 2
title: 1IP Procedure and Statuses Framework
status: Active
type: Information
author: Sam Bacha
created: 2020-12-25

---

Summary

This 1IP proposes a formalization of 1IP statuses, much like how EIPs or YIPs are categorized by their status, adhering to a formal status categorization for governance proposals reduces friction by clearing communicating to the community where exactly a proposal is in terms of acceptance and consensus.

Proposed Statuses:

WIP - a 1IP that is still being developed.
Proposed - a 1IP that is ready to be reviewed in a governance call.
Approved - a 1IP that has been accepted for implementation by the 1INCH community.
Implemented - a 1IP that has been released to mainnet.
Rejected - a 1IP that has been rejected.
Withdrawn - a 1IP that has been withdrawn by the author(s).
Deferred - a 1IP that is pending another 1IP/some other change that should be bundled with it together.
Moribund - a 1IP that was implemented but is now obsolete and requires no explicit replacement.

Additional Sources

Theses statuses are the current regime in use in the Yearn Ecosystem, see source

1IP Generator

Currently, YIP boilerplates can be generated via this yyip yeoman generator. Obviously, 1INCH processing Token Listings will incur high overhead. By utilizing a clear and concise proposal system as outlined above, tooling such as a 1INCH 1IP Yeoman generator can be used to ensure that the countless of asset requests are at least, properly formatted.

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.