Jimmy Angelakos edited this page Mar 13, 2018 · 7 revisions

We consulted on the DMP themes last year and iterated these down from 29 to 14. You can see the revised list of themes and new joint DCC and UC3 guidance here. We have also done a mapping to explain how themes have been merged which you can find below. This will be useful when editing your guidance.

PDF of themes available in the roadmap docs repo

Theme DCC & UC3 Guidance
DATA DESCRIPTION
  • Give a summary of the data you will collect or create, noting the content, coverage and data type, e.g., tabular data, survey data, experimental measurements, models, software, audiovisual data, physical samples, etc.
  • Consider how your data could complement and integrate with existing data, or whether there are any existing data or methods that you could reuse.
  • Indicate which data are of long-term value and should be shared and/or preserved.
  • If purchasing or reusing existing data, explain how issues such as copyright and IPR have been addressed. You should aim to minimise any restrictions on the reuse (and subsequent sharing) of third-party data.
DATA FORMAT
  • Clearly note what format(s) your data will be in, e.g., plain text (.txt), comma-separated values (.csv), geo-referenced TIFF (.tif, .tfw).
  • Explain why you have chosen certain formats. Decisions may be based on staff expertise, a preference for open formats, the standards accepted by data centres or widespread usage within a given community.
  • Using standardised, interchangeable or open formats ensures the long-term usability of data; these are recommended for sharing and archiving.
  • See UK Data Service guidance on recommended formats or DataONE Best Practices for file formats.
DATA VOLUME
  • Note what volume of data you will create in MB/GB/TB. Indicate the proportions of raw data, processed data, and other secondary outputs (e.g., reports).
  • Consider the implications of data volumes in terms of storage, access and preservation. Do you need to include additional costs?
  • Consider whether the scale of the data will pose challenges when sharing or transferring data between sites; if so, how will you address these challenges?
DATA COLLECTION
  • Outline how the data will be collected and processed. This should cover relevant standards or methods, quality assurance and data organisation.
  • Indicate how the data will be organised during the project, mentioning, e.g., naming conventions, version control and folder structures. Consistent, well-ordered research data will be easier to find, understand and reuse.
  • Explain how the consistency and quality of data collection will be controlled and documented. This may include processes such as calibration, repeat samples or measurements, standardised data capture, data entry validation, peer review of data or representation with controlled vocabularies.
  • See the DataOne Best Practices for data quality.
METADATA & DOCUMENTATION
  • What metadata will be provided to help others identify and discover the data?
  • Researchers are strongly encouraged to use community metadata standards where these are in place. The Research Data Alliance offers a Directory of Metadata Standards. Data repositories may also provide guidance about appropriate metadata standards.
  • Consider what other documentation is needed to enable reuse. This may include information on the methodology used to collect the data, analytical and procedural information, definitions of variables, units of measurement, any assumptions made, the format and file type of the data and software used to collect and/or process the data.
  • Consider how you will capture this information and where it will be recorded, e.g., in a database with links to each item, in a ‘readme’ text file, in file headers, etc.
ETHICS & PRIVACY
  • Investigators carrying out research involving human participants should request consent to preserve and share the data. Do not just ask for permission to use the data in your study or make unnecessary promises to delete it at the end.
  • Consider how you will protect the identity of participants, e.g., via anonymisation or using managed access procedures.
  • Ethical issues may affect how you store and transfer data, who can see/use it and how long it is kept. You should demonstrate that you are aware of this and have planned accordingly.
  • See UK Data Service guidance on consent for data sharing.
  • See ICPSR approach to confidentiality and Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) regulations for health research.
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS
  • State who will own the copyright and IPR of any existing data as well as new data that you will generate. For multi-partner projects, IPR ownership should be covered in the consortium agreement.
  • Outline any restrictions needed on data sharing, e.g., to protect proprietary or patentable data.
  • Explain how the data will be licensed for reuse. See the DCC guide on How to license research data and EUDAT’s data and software licensing wizard.
STORAGE & SECURITY
  • Describe where the data will be stored and backed up during the course of research activities. This may vary if you are doing fieldwork or working across multiple sites so explain each procedure.
  • Identify who will be responsible for backup and how often this will be performed. The use of robust, managed storage with automatic backup, for example, that provided by university IT teams, is preferable. Storing data on laptops, computer hard drives or external storage devices alone is very risky.
  • See UK Data Service Guidance on data storage or DataONE Best Practices for storage.
  • Also consider data security, particularly if your data is sensitive e.g., detailed personal data, politically sensitive information or trade secrets. Note the main risks and how these will be managed. Also note whether any institutional data security policies are in place.
  • Identify any formal standards that you will comply with, e.g., ISO 27001. See the DCC Briefing Paper on Information Security Management - ISO 27000 and UK Data Service guidance on data security.
DATA SHARING
  • How will you share the data e.g. deposit in a data repository, use a secure data service, handle data requests directly or use another mechanism? The methods used will depend on a number of factors such as the type, size, complexity and sensitivity of the data.
  • When will you make the data available? Research funders expect timely release. They typically allow embargoes but not prolonged exclusive use.
  • Who will be able to use your data? If you need to restrict access to certain communities or apply data sharing agreements, explain why.
  • Consider strategies to minimise restrictions on sharing. These may include anonymising or aggregating data, gaining participant consent for data sharing, gaining copyright permissions, and agreeing a limited embargo period.
  • How might your data be reused in other contexts? Where there is potential for reuse, you should use standards and formats that facilitate this, and ensure that appropriate metadata is available online so your data can be discovered. Persistent identifiers should be applied so people can reliably and efficiently find your data. They also help you to track citations and reuse.
DATA REPOSITORY
  • Where will the data be deposited? If you do not propose to use an established repository, the data management plan should demonstrate that the data can be curated effectively beyond the lifetime of the grant.
  • It helps to show that you have consulted with the repository to understand their policies and procedures, including any metadata standards, and costs involved.
  • An international list of data repositories is available via re3data and some universities or publishers provide lists of recommendations e.g., PLOS ONE recommended repositories.
PRESERVATION
ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES
BUDGET
  • Carefully consider and justify any resources needed to deliver the plan. These may include storage costs, hardware, staff time, costs of preparing data for deposit and repository charges.
  • Outline any relevant technical expertise, support and training that is likely to be required and how it will be acquired.
  • If you are not depositing in a data repository, ensure you have appropriate resources and systems in place to share and preserve the data. See UK Data Service guidance on costing data management.
RELATED POLICIES
  • Consider whether there are any existing procedures that you can base your approach on. If your group/department has local guidelines that you work to, point to them here.
  • List any other relevant funder, institutional, departmental or group policies on data management, data sharing and data security.

Theme changes

Mapping table

old theme new theme Explanation of change
ID none theme deleted
Project description none theme deleted
Data type none theme deleted - concept rolled into Data description
Existing data none theme deleted - concept rolled into Data description
Relationship to existing data none theme deleted - concept rolled into Data description
Data quality none theme deleted - concept rolled into Data collection
Documentation none theme deleted - concept rolled into Metadata & Documentation
Discovery by users none theme deleted - concept rolled into Metadata & Documentation
Data security none theme deleted - concept rolled into Storage & security
Data selection none theme deleted - concept rolled into Preservation
Period of preservation none theme deleted - concept rolled into Preservation
Expected reuse none theme deleted - concept rolled into Data sharing
Timeframe for data sharing none theme deleted - concept rolled into Data sharing
Restrictions on data sharing none theme deleted - concept rolled into Data sharing
Managed access procedures none theme deleted - concept rolled into Data sharing
Related policies Related policies theme retained - associated guidance shortened
Data description Data description theme retained - associated guidance shortened
Data format Data format theme retained - associated guidance shortened
Data volumes Data volume theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
Data capture methods Data collection theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
Metadata Metadata & documentation theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
Ethical issues Ethics & privacy theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
IPR ownership and licensing Intellectual Property Rights theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
Storage and backup Storage & security theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
Preservation plan Preservation theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
Data repository Data repository theme retained - associated guidance shortened
Method for data sharing Data sharing theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
Responsibilities Roles & responsibilities theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened
Resourcing Budget theme retained - name changed & associated guidance shortened

Notes on merging:

29 themes have become 14. Most of this has been done by merging concepts as noted below. 2 themes have been deleted completely (ID and project description) and 13 have been deleted via merging into broader concepts as noted below. 14 themes have been retained, sometimes with name changes to encompass broader concepts.

New theme Old theme names encompassed in this revised version
Data description Data description, Existing data, Relationship to existing data and Data type (4 to 1)
Data collection Data capture methods and Data quality (2 to 1)
Metadata & documentation Metadata, Documentation, and Discovery by users (3 to 1)
Storage & security Storage and backup, and Data security (2 to 1)
Preservation Preservation plan, Data selection, and Period of preservation (3 to 1)
Data sharing Method for data sharing, Expected reuse, Timeframe for data sharing, Restrictions on data sharing, and Managed access procedures (5 to 1)

8 additional themes were retained without merging other concepts into them. Their names sometimes changed. These are:

  • Related polcies
  • Data format
  • Data volume
  • Ethics & privacy
  • Intellectual Property Rights
  • Data repository
  • Roles & responsibilities
  • Budget

Migrating from DMPonlineV4

The above theme mapping table is reflected in the upgrade rake tasks which can be run to migrate from the old theme structure to the newest themes. These can be found in lib/tasks/upgrade.rake:

  • Remove deprecated Themes
    rake upgrade:theme_delete_deprecated
  • Create new Theme list
    rake upgrade:theme_new_themes
  • Transform existing Themes and their associations into new Theme list
    rake upgrade:theme_transform
  • Delete migrated Themes and their associations
    rake upgrade:theme_remove_migrated
  • Deduplicate multiple associations resulting from Theme merges
    rake upgrade:theme_deduplicate_questions
  • Warning: Make sure there are no items of guidance with multiple themes before the following step!
  • Concatenate Guidance which refers to the same Theme as a result of merges
    rake upgrade:single_guidance_for_theme
You can’t perform that action at this time.
You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session. You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.
Press h to open a hovercard with more details.