Skip to content


Devise `new_user` vs `user_new` bug (very odd) #325

coryschires opened this Issue · 2 comments

3 participants


Recently I noticed that live validations were no longer working on my devise signup form. They had worked previously and still worked everywhere else. Somehow I had broken devise validations.

My exact error was:

Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read property 'user[email]' of undefined     
Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read property 'user[password]' of undefined
# etc ... for each field as I tabbed through the form

My relevant gems are mostly up to date:

gem 'rails',                      '3.2.3'
gem 'client_side_validations',    '~> 3.1.4'
gem 'simple_form',                '~> 1.5.2'
gem 'devise',                     '~> 2.1.0.rc'
gem 'jquery-rails',               '~> 1.0.19'

After poking around for a quite a while I realized that the primary key of the validators object was somehow being transposed:

window['user_new'] = {"type": ... } # rather than ...
window['new_user'] = {"type": ... } # ... wtf?

So the (slightly hacky) fix is obvious. Just add a form id of user_new in order to override rails default id of new_user. So it should look something like:

simple_form_for(resource, as: resource_name, url: registration_path(resource_name), validate: true, html: { id: 'user_new' }) do |f|
  # devise fields ...

I don't mind adding the id. It's not the worst hack. This post is mostly for documentation in case someone else encounters the issue.

Nonetheless, I very confused about the root cause. If anyone wants to entertain my curiosity:

  • Has anyone else seen this?
  • @bcardarella Do you have any idea why this would happen?

Thanks for posting this, I came across the exact same issue. The above fix helped get me by the issue for the mean time.


This is a Devise specific issue. The solution here is to either set a custom id or, in the case of ClientSideValidations 3.2 to release a custom Devise plugin similar to

In any event, the code as-is for Rails default is correct.

@bcardarella bcardarella closed this
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.