From 3b1730d0816524cadb3621932f596f0f4229bd18 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: FlowMemory HQ Agent Date: Wed, 13 May 2026 21:35:08 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] Refresh real-value pilot HQ status --- docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md | 43 +++--- .../real-value-pilot-hq/CHECKLIST.md | 23 ++-- .../real-value-pilot-hq/COMPLETION_AUDIT.md | 130 +++++++++--------- .../real-value-pilot-hq/EXPERIMENTS.md | 18 ++- docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/NOTES.md | 64 ++++----- docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/PLAN.md | 32 +++-- 6 files changed, 170 insertions(+), 140 deletions(-) diff --git a/docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md b/docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md index c458ae37..7852ef6e 100644 --- a/docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md +++ b/docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md @@ -19,20 +19,24 @@ approval. ## Current Baseline -Current `main` at the start of this HQ pass: +Current `main` after PR #132 merged at +`14f378b7f2dee9bfd29aec691ebda41e2b6fa101`: - `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` exists as the local product testnet gate. - `npm run flowchain:full-smoke` exists as the private/local L1 baseline gate. -- `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` is added here as the current L1 baseline alias to +- `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` exists as the current L1 baseline alias to `flowchain:full-smoke`; it can be tightened by the ops branch when the dedicated L1 wrapper is merged. -- `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` is added here as the final pilot +- `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` exists as the final pilot gate. It fails by default while required subsystem proof commands are missing. GitHub source-of-truth state checked for this pass: - Draft PR #129 adds the copy-ready real-value pilot goal pack. -- Issue #130 defines the required gate work before public-network pilot work. +- Issue #130 is closed; PR #132 merged the capped owner-pilot release-gate + boundary. +- Issue #131 is closed; PR #132 merged the optional-Slither default hardening + policy while keeping `contracts:hardening:slither` as the explicit audit gate. - Open PRs #110, #112 through #117, #71, and #73 remain useful context only until merged. @@ -84,7 +88,7 @@ the proof is branch-local or verified from `main`. | Required proof | Owning agent | Required command | Current state | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Existing product testnet gate remains green. | HQ/Ops | `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` | Existing command; run before PR when practical. | -| L1 baseline gate remains green. | HQ/Ops | `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` | Added as current alias to `flowchain:full-smoke`. | +| L1 baseline gate remains green. | HQ/Ops | `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` | Exists on `main` as current alias to `flowchain:full-smoke`; latest local main-equivalent run passed. | | Base chain ID `8453` is verified before any live observer or deployment action. | Contracts + Bridge + Ops | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:contracts`; `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:bridge`; `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops` | Missing dedicated pilot commands. | | Lockbox address is loaded from ignored local config or env, not hardcoded as a blanket endorsement. | Contracts + Ops | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:contracts`; `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops` | Missing dedicated pilot commands. | | Per-deposit cap, total pilot cap, supported-asset allowlist, pause, release, recovery, and replay protection are covered by tests and dry-run deployment evidence. | Contracts | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:contracts` | Missing dedicated pilot command. | @@ -97,7 +101,7 @@ the proof is branch-local or verified from `main`. | Dashboard labels the flow as capped owner testing and shows live/degraded/error state plus exact next operator commands. | Control plane/dashboard | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:control-dashboard` | Missing dedicated pilot command. | | Browser stores no private keys or RPC credentials. | Control plane/dashboard + Wallet/operator | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:control-dashboard`; `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:wallet` | Missing dedicated pilot commands. | | Ops path verifies required env, tiny caps, explicit owner ack, emergency stop, export evidence, restart recovery, and no-secret scans. | Ops/installer | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops` | Missing dedicated pilot command. | -| Final pilot gate runs baseline commands plus every available dedicated proof command. | HQ/Ops | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` | Added here; expected incomplete until subsystem commands land. | +| Final pilot gate runs baseline commands plus every available dedicated proof command. | HQ/Ops | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` | Exists on `main`; strict mode still fails until subsystem commands land. | ## In-Flight Implementation Status @@ -108,12 +112,12 @@ from `main`. | Area | In-flight branch state | Required next step | | --- | --- | --- | -| Contracts | `agent/real-value-pilot-contracts` reports passing contract tests, hardening, deploy dry-run, and product E2E after dependency install. | Merge reviewed contract work and expose a dedicated root pilot contracts proof command. | -| Bridge relayer | `agent/real-value-pilot-bridge` contains Base `8453` observer and mock pilot E2E work, with verification rows still pending. | Finish bridge verification, then expose a dedicated root bridge proof command. | -| Chain runtime | `agent/real-value-pilot-chain` contains bridge-credit runtime work in progress, with current pilot experiments still pending. | Finish runtime apply/replay/restart/export proof, then expose a dedicated root runtime proof command. | -| Wallet/operator | `agent/real-value-pilot-wallet` contains pilot signing, validation, schema, and operator-doc work with test rows still pending. | Finish wallet negative vectors and public metadata checks, then expose a dedicated root wallet proof command. | -| Control plane/dashboard | `agent/real-value-pilot-control-dashboard` contains pilot API/dashboard work and a service-local E2E, with checklist rows still incomplete. | Finish API/dashboard verification, then expose a dedicated root control-dashboard proof command. | -| Ops/installer | `agent/real-value-pilot-ops` contains root pilot wrappers, emergency stop, sanitized export, and a passing local checklist after an ops-side static-analysis wrapper change. | Reconcile product E2E hardening policy and merge a reviewed ops proof command. | +| Contracts | `agent/real-value-pilot-contracts` checklist reports the contracts proof complete, including hardening, deploy dry-run, and product E2E. | Rebase onto `14f378b`, expose `flowchain:real-value-pilot:contracts`, rerun evidence, and open a PR. | +| Bridge relayer | `agent/real-value-pilot-bridge` checklist reports the bridge proof complete; service-local `pilot:e2e` exists. | Rebase onto `14f378b`, expose `flowchain:real-value-pilot:bridge`, rerun evidence, and open a PR. | +| Chain runtime | `agent/real-value-pilot-chain` checklist reports runtime credit/replay/restart/export proof complete through the direct wrapper; root package command is missing. | Rebase onto `14f378b`, expose `flowchain:real-value-pilot:runtime`, rerun evidence, and open a PR. | +| Wallet/operator | `agent/real-value-pilot-wallet` checklist reports wallet/operator schemas, signing, validation, negative cases, scans, and product evidence complete. | Rebase onto `14f378b`, expose `flowchain:real-value-pilot:wallet`, rerun evidence, and open a PR. | +| Control plane/dashboard | `agent/real-value-pilot-control-dashboard` checklist reports API/dashboard proof complete and has branch-local `flowchain:real-value-pilot:control-dashboard`. | Rebase onto `14f378b`, rerun evidence, and open a PR. | +| Ops/installer | `agent/real-value-pilot-ops` checklist reports ops proof complete; root lifecycle commands exist branch-locally, but `flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops` is missing. | Rebase onto `14f378b`, expose `flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops`, rerun evidence, and open a PR. | ## Owner Go/No-Go Checklist @@ -146,12 +150,11 @@ in committed files, or if any document presents the pilot as public readiness. - Dedicated real-value wallet/operator gate does not exist; tracked by issue #136. - Dedicated real-value control-plane/dashboard gate does not exist; tracked by issue #137. - Dedicated real-value ops/installer gate does not exist; tracked by issue #135. -- GitHub issue #130 must define and be accepted as the release-gate boundary before - any owner pilot work is treated as more than capped validation. -- GitHub issue #131 has a branch-local policy fix in this HQ PR: default - `contracts:hardening` skips optional Slither unless the audit gate is - explicitly requested. The issue remains open until the fix is reviewed and - merged. +- Issue #130 is closed by PR #132; the release-gate boundary is now on `main`. +- Issue #131 is closed by PR #132; default `contracts:hardening` skips optional + Slither unless the audit gate is explicitly requested. +- HQ posted refresh comments on issues #133 through #138 with the latest local + worktree evidence and next integration actions. ## Tracking Issues @@ -163,8 +166,8 @@ in committed files, or if any document presents the pilot as public readiness. | Wallet/operator | #136 | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:wallet` | | Control plane/dashboard | #137 | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:control-dashboard` | | Ops/installer | #135 | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops` | -| Release-gate boundary | #130 | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e -- -AllowIncomplete` until proofs land | -| Static-analysis policy | #131 | `npm run contracts:hardening`; `npm run contracts:hardening:slither` | +| Release-gate boundary | #130, closed by PR #132 | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e -- -AllowIncomplete` until proofs land | +| Static-analysis policy | #131, closed by PR #132 | `npm run contracts:hardening`; `npm run contracts:hardening:slither` | ## Required PR Evidence diff --git a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/CHECKLIST.md b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/CHECKLIST.md index 7a51573e..4b978b99 100644 --- a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/CHECKLIST.md +++ b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/CHECKLIST.md @@ -20,7 +20,9 @@ Last updated: 2026-05-14. - [x] Run `git diff --check`. - [x] Run the new pilot gate in incomplete mode. - [x] Run `npm run flowchain:product-e2e`, or document why it was not practical. -- [x] Open a draft PR with exact commands run and current blockers. +- [x] Open a PR with exact commands run and current blockers. +- [x] Merge the HQ gate PR to `main`. +- [x] Post HQ refresh comments on subsystem issues #133 through #138. ## Gate Blocker Rows @@ -55,9 +57,9 @@ and `NOTES.md`. ## Release-Gate Boundary -- [x] Branch documents issue #130 capped owner-pilot boundary in +- [x] `main` documents issue #130 capped owner-pilot boundary in `docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md`. -- [ ] Issue #130 boundary is reviewed and accepted on GitHub. +- [x] Issue #130 boundary is reviewed and accepted on GitHub. ## Baseline Check Result @@ -65,22 +67,23 @@ and `NOTES.md`. `npm run contracts:hardening` because local Slither reported existing findings in `contracts/bridge/BaseBridgeLockbox.sol`. -This branch now updates the allowed `infra/scripts/` static-analysis wrappers +PR #132 updated the allowed `infra/scripts/` static-analysis wrappers so default `contracts:hardening` matches the documented policy: Slither is optional by default and required only through `contracts:hardening:slither`, `-RequireSlither`, or `REQUIRE_SLITHER=1`. -Current branch result: `npm run contracts:hardening`, +Post-merge main-equivalent result: `npm run contracts:hardening`, `npm run flowchain:product-e2e`, and `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` pass locally. -GitHub blocker: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/issues/131 +Closed GitHub blocker: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/issues/131 -Draft PR: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/pull/132 +Merged PR: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/pull/132 ## Completion Audit Audit file: `docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/COMPLETION_AUDIT.md`. -Result: not complete. `origin/main` lacks both new scripts, the default pilot -gate fails with the intended missing-proof report, and local branch-only -`flowchain:l1-e2e` evidence is not on `main`. +Result: not complete. `origin/main` contains the HQ scripts and +`flowchain:l1-e2e` passes locally, but the default pilot gate still fails with +the intended missing-proof report until the six dedicated subsystem proof +commands land on `main`. diff --git a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/COMPLETION_AUDIT.md b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/COMPLETION_AUDIT.md index 1eb0fc71..2bdb6fbf 100644 --- a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/COMPLETION_AUDIT.md +++ b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/COMPLETION_AUDIT.md @@ -23,38 +23,53 @@ are true on `main`: | Requirement | Evidence inspected | Current result | | --- | --- | --- | -| Read current main before editing. | `git fetch origin main --prune`; `HEAD` before edits was `9b025c5`; `origin/main` was `9b025c5`. | Complete for this HQ pass. | -| Inspect active worktrees for reusable work. | Worktree status/diff inspections recorded in `PLAN.md` and `EXPERIMENTS.md`. | Complete for this HQ pass. | -| Stay inside allowed folders. | `git status --short --branch`; PR #132 changed only `docs/`, `infra/scripts/`, and `package.json`. | Complete. | +| Worktree `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-hq` and branch `agent/real-value-pilot-hq`. | `git status --branch --short` showed `agent/real-value-pilot-hq...origin/agent/real-value-pilot-hq`. | Complete. | +| Read current main before editing. | Initial `git fetch origin main --prune`; later refresh showed `origin/main` at `14f378b Add real-value pilot HQ gate`. | Complete for HQ passes. | +| Inspect requested active worktrees. | Original worktrees and live pilot worktrees are recorded in `PLAN.md`; latest refresh inspected branches, heads, dirty counts, package scripts, and checklists. | Complete. | +| Stay inside allowed folders. | PR #132 changed only `docs/`, `infra/scripts/`, and `package.json`; this refresh changes only `docs/`. | Complete. | | Create `docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/PLAN.md`. | File exists and records scope, source docs, worktree inspection, and blockers. | Complete. | | Create `docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/CHECKLIST.md`. | File exists and records acceptance state plus blocker rows. | Complete. | | Create `docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/EXPERIMENTS.md`. | File exists and records command outcomes. | Complete. | | Create `docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/NOTES.md`. | File exists and records source-of-truth notes and boundaries. | Complete. | -| Create `docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md`. | File exists with purpose, final gate, integration matrix, go/no-go checklist, blockers, and PR evidence rules. | Complete on branch, not on `main`. | -| Add or update `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e`. | `package.json` on branch contains the script. `git show origin/main:package.json` shows `origin/main` lacks it. | Complete on branch, missing on `main`. | -| Add or maintain `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e`. | `package.json` on branch contains the alias. `git show origin/main:package.json` shows `origin/main` lacks it. | Complete on branch, missing on `main`. | -| Pilot gate must fail clearly until subsystem pieces exist. | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` exited nonzero and listed contracts, bridge, runtime, wallet, control-dashboard, and ops proof gaps. | Complete. | -| Integration matrix maps every required proof to owning agent and command. | `docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md` matrix maps baseline, contracts, bridge, runtime, wallet, control-dashboard, ops, and final gate proofs. | Complete. | +| Create `docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md`. | File exists on `main` after PR #132 and includes purpose, final gate, release boundary, integration matrix, go/no-go checklist, blockers, tracking issues, and PR evidence rules. | Complete. | +| Add or update `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e`. | `git show origin/main:package.json` contains `flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e`; strict command runs and fails on missing proof commands. | Complete. | +| Add or maintain `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e`. | `git show origin/main:package.json` contains `flowchain:l1-e2e`; post-merge local main-equivalent run passed. | Complete. | +| Pilot gate must fail clearly until subsystem pieces exist. | Strict `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` exited nonzero and listed contracts, bridge, runtime, wallet, control-dashboard, and ops proof gaps. | Complete. | +| Integration matrix maps every required proof to owning agent and command. | `docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md#integration-matrix` maps baseline, contracts, bridge, runtime, wallet, control-dashboard, ops, and final gate proofs. | Complete. | | Pilot go/no-go checklist for project owner. | `docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md#owner-gonogo-checklist`. | Complete. | -| Keep public-readiness claims out of docs. | `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs` passed. | Complete for touched docs. | -| `git diff --check` passes. | Ran after edits and after follow-up updates; only Windows line-ending warnings appeared. | Complete. | +| Keep public-readiness claims out of docs. | `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs` passed after PR #132 and again after post-merge product E2E. | Complete for inspected docs. | +| `git diff --check` passes. | Passed after PR #132 and again after post-merge product E2E. | Complete. | | New pilot gate in incomplete mode. | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e -- -AllowIncomplete` passed and wrote `devnet/local/real-value-pilot/flowchain-real-value-pilot-e2e-report.json`. | Complete. | -| Existing `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` remains passing, or failure is documented with owner and next action. | Initially failed under local Slither. After the allowed `infra/scripts/` static-analysis policy update, `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` passed and wrote `devnet/local/product-e2e/flowchain-product-e2e-report.json`. | Complete on branch; not yet on `main`. | -| Open a PR with exact commands run and current blockers. | Draft PR #132 opened: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/pull/132. | Complete. | -| PR CI state. | `gh pr view 132` showed all CI checks successful and merge state `CLEAN` after push. | Complete for current PR. | -| GitHub blocker state. | `gh issue view 130`, `gh issue view 131`, and `infra/scripts/status-report.ps1` show issues #130 and #131 open. PR #132 now contains a branch-local #130 boundary doc expansion and #131 policy fix. | Not complete; blockers remain open until reviewed/merged. | -| Final success: `flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` passes on `main`. | `origin/main` lacks the script; branch gate fails by design because dedicated subsystem proof commands are missing. | Not complete. | -| Final success: `flowchain:l1-e2e` passes on `main`. | `origin/main` lacks the script. The branch alias now passes locally after the static-analysis policy update. | Complete on branch; missing on `main`. | +| Existing `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` remains passing, or failure is documented. | Post-merge local main-equivalent run passed and wrote `devnet/local/product-e2e/flowchain-product-e2e-report.json`. | Complete. | +| Open a PR with exact commands run and current blockers. | PR #132 opened, was marked ready, and merged: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/pull/132. | Complete. | +| Resolve release-boundary blocker. | Issue #130 is closed; PR #132 merged the capped owner-pilot boundary. | Complete. | +| Resolve default static-analysis blocker. | Issue #131 is closed; PR #132 merged optional-Slither default hardening while keeping `contracts:hardening:slither` explicit. | Complete. | +| Post subsystem blocker coordination. | HQ refresh comments posted on issues #133 through #138 with current branch-local evidence and next integration action. | Complete for current coordination pass. | +| Final success: `flowchain:l1-e2e` passes on `main`. | `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` passed on the post-merge main-equivalent tree. | Complete locally; should be rerun from clean `main` before owner go. | +| Final success: `flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` passes on `main`. | Strict gate exists on `origin/main` but fails because six dedicated proof commands are missing. | Not complete. | -## Command Evidence +## Latest Command Evidence -Latest command evidence: +```powershell +gh pr view 132 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json state,mergedAt,mergeCommit,url +``` + +Result: PR #132 is `MERGED`; merge commit +`14f378b7f2dee9bfd29aec691ebda41e2b6fa101`. ```powershell -git show origin/main:package.json | rg -n "flowchain:l1-e2e|flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e" -S +gh issue view 130 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json state,closedAt,url +gh issue view 131 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json state,closedAt,url ``` -Result: no matches; `origin/main` lacks both scripts. +Result: both issues are `CLOSED`. + +```powershell +npm run flowchain:l1-e2e +``` + +Result: passed. Report path: +`devnet/local/full-smoke/flowchain-full-smoke-report.json`. ```powershell npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e @@ -69,67 +84,56 @@ Result: failed clearly with missing dedicated proof commands for: - control-plane/dashboard; - ops/installer. -```powershell -npm run flowchain:l1-e2e -``` - -Result after static-analysis policy update: passed. Report path: -`devnet/local/full-smoke/flowchain-full-smoke-report.json`. - ```powershell npm run flowchain:product-e2e ``` -Result after static-analysis policy update: passed. Report path: +Result: passed. Report path: `devnet/local/product-e2e/flowchain-product-e2e-report.json`. ```powershell -gh issue view 131 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json number,title,state,url +git diff --check +node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs ``` -Result: issue #131 is open. PR #132 now contains the branch-local policy fix; -the issue remains incomplete until reviewed and merged. +Result: both passed after the post-merge product E2E run. ## In-Flight Worktree Evidence -The following evidence was inspected after PR #132 opened. It is not source of -truth until the work lands in reviewed PRs and merges to `main`. +The following evidence is not source of truth until each branch is reviewed, +merged to `main`, and the strict HQ gate passes from `main`. -| Area | Live branch evidence | Completion impact | +| Area | Latest branch-local evidence | Completion impact | | --- | --- | --- | -| Contracts | `agent/real-value-pilot-contracts` reports `forge test`, `npm run contracts:hardening`, deploy dry-run, and `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` passing after local dependency install. | Candidate proof exists branch-locally, but no dedicated root pilot proof command is merged. | -| Bridge relayer | `agent/real-value-pilot-bridge` has Base `8453` observer and mock pilot E2E files, but the checklist still records observer, replay, local-credit, and product E2E proof rows as pending. | Still incomplete. | -| Chain runtime | `agent/real-value-pilot-chain` has bridge-credit runtime changes in progress; baseline cargo test passed before edits and current experiments remain pending. | Still incomplete. | -| Wallet/operator | `agent/real-value-pilot-wallet` has pilot signing, schemas, and docs in progress; all verification commands are still pending in its checklist. | Still incomplete. | -| Control plane/dashboard | `agent/real-value-pilot-control-dashboard` has pilot API/dashboard files and a service-local E2E, but its checklist still marks implementation and test rows incomplete. | Still incomplete. | -| Ops/installer | `agent/real-value-pilot-ops` has root pilot wrappers, emergency stop, sanitized export, and a passing checklist, including product E2E after an ops-side static-analysis wrapper change. | Candidate proof exists branch-locally, but not merged; it must reconcile with contracts hardening policy. | +| Contracts | `agent/real-value-pilot-contracts` checklist reports `forge test`, `npm run contracts:hardening`, deploy dry-run, product E2E, caps, allowlist, pause, release/recovery, replay, events, and docs complete. | Candidate proof exists branch-locally; root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:contracts` is still missing on `main`. | +| Bridge relayer | `agent/real-value-pilot-bridge` checklist reports Base `8453` observer, wrong-chain rejection, approved lockbox guard, confirmation depth, deterministic evidence, duplicate replay handling, local credit once, withdrawal/release evidence, tests, mock pilot E2E, wrong-chain negatives, local-credit smoke, and product E2E complete. | Candidate proof exists branch-locally; root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:bridge` is still missing on `main`. | +| Chain runtime | `agent/real-value-pilot-chain` checklist reports bridge credit mapping, include-once behavior, replay evidence, receipt lookup, handoff export, restart preservation, export/import roots, multi-node smoke, and direct wrapper proof complete. It records missing dependency and root package-script blockers. | Runtime proof needs a rebased PR adding `flowchain:real-value-pilot:runtime` and rerunning product/HQ gates. | +| Wallet/operator | `agent/real-value-pilot-wallet` checklist reports schemas, metadata boundary, config validation, cap guardrails, signing/validation CLI, pilot E2E, negative cases, next-command CLI, scans, product evidence, and issue #131 handoff complete. | Candidate proof exists branch-locally; root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:wallet` is still missing on `main`. | +| Control plane/dashboard | `agent/real-value-pilot-control-dashboard` checklist reports API, dashboard, schemas, docs, tests, smoke, build, branch-local `flowchain:real-value-pilot:control-dashboard`, and branch-local pilot E2E complete. | Candidate proof exists branch-locally; no PR currently exists. | +| Ops/installer | `agent/real-value-pilot-ops` checklist reports dry run, live-mode env refusal, owner ack refusal, Base guard, tiny cap checks, next commands, emergency stop, sanitized export, docs, troubleshooting, unsafe-claims, diff check, and product E2E complete. | Candidate proof exists branch-locally; root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops` is still missing on `main`. | ## Uncovered Or Incomplete Requirements -- The new gates are not on `main`; PR #132 is still draft and unmerged. -- GitHub issue #130 is still open. This branch contains the release-gate - boundary doc expansion, but it is not accepted until reviewed and merged. -- GitHub issue #131 is still open. This branch contains a policy fix and local - product/L1 E2E now passes, but `main` is unchanged until PR #132 merges. -- `flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` does not pass without `-AllowIncomplete`. -- Dedicated subsystem proof commands do not exist yet and are tracked by: - contracts issue #133, bridge issue #138, runtime issue #134, wallet issue - #136, control-dashboard issue #137, and ops issue #135. -- `flowchain:l1-e2e` is only a branch alias to `flowchain:full-smoke` in this - HQ PR; it is not on `main`. It now passes locally after the branch static- - analysis policy update. +- `flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` does not pass without + `-AllowIncomplete`. +- Dedicated subsystem proof commands do not exist on `main`: + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:contracts`, + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:bridge`, + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:runtime`, + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:wallet`, + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:control-dashboard`, and + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops`. +- No PR currently exists for the six live `agent/real-value-pilot-*` + subsystem branches. - The owner go/no-go checklist remains no-go. ## Next Concrete Actions -1. Keep PR #132 open as the HQ gate/documentation branch until reviewed. -2. Review and merge the issue #130 release-gate boundary, or request narrower - acceptance language before subsystem proof PRs claim readiness. -3. Review and merge the #131 static-analysis policy fix, or replace it with a - contracts-owned fix if the owner chooses to require Slither findings in the - default gate. -4. Merge or rebase the richer ops `flowchain:l1-e2e` wrapper when ready. -5. Have each subsystem agent close its dedicated pilot proof issue: - #133, #138, #134, #136, #137, and #135. -6. Rerun `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` without - `-AllowIncomplete` only after all dedicated proof commands exist. +1. Rebase or refresh each subsystem branch onto main commit `14f378b`. +2. Add the dedicated root proof command required by its issue. +3. Rerun the issue-specific proof commands plus `git diff --check`, + `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs`, and + `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` where practical. +4. Open PRs for issues #133, #138, #134, #136, #137, and #135. +5. Rerun `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` without + `-AllowIncomplete` after all dedicated proof commands are merged. diff --git a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/EXPERIMENTS.md b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/EXPERIMENTS.md index 8077ed1c..ac299501 100644 --- a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/EXPERIMENTS.md +++ b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/EXPERIMENTS.md @@ -25,15 +25,15 @@ Last updated: 2026-05-14. | `npm ci --prefix crypto` | Passed | Installed crypto dependencies from lockfile. | | `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` | Failed after dependency install | Reached `npm run contracts:hardening`; local Slither reported existing `BaseBridgeLockbox.releaseNative` findings in `contracts/bridge/BaseBridgeLockbox.sol`, so product E2E stopped. | | Draft PR creation through GitHub connector | Passed | Opened https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/pull/132. | -| `git show origin/main:package.json \| rg -n "flowchain:l1-e2e\|flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e" -S` | No matches | Confirmed `origin/main` lacks both new scripts. | +| `git show origin/main:package.json \| rg -n "flowchain:l1-e2e\|flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e" -S` | No matches | Historical pre-merge check: the scripts were absent before PR #132. | | `gh pr view 132 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json ...` | Passed | PR #132 is open draft, merge state `CLEAN`, CI checks successful, not merged. | | `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` | Failed as expected | Default gate failed clearly with six missing dedicated proof commands and wrote the report. | | `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` | Failed locally | Alias invoked full smoke and stopped in `contracts:hardening` because local Slither reported the same `BaseBridgeLockbox.releaseNative` findings. | | Live pilot worktree inspection | Passed | Inspected `flowmemory-live-contracts`, `flowmemory-live-bridge`, `flowmemory-live-chain`, `flowmemory-live-wallet`, `flowmemory-live-control-dashboard`, and `flowmemory-live-ops` statuses, package scripts, and run notes. | | Requested original worktree inspection refresh | Passed | Rechecked `flowmemory-chain`, `flowmemory-bridge-full`, `flowmemory-contracts`, `flowmemory-crypto`, `flowmemory-indexer`, `flowmemory-dashboard`, `flowmemory-review`, and `flowmemory-hq-review-loop` statuses and relevant package scripts. | -| `gh issue view 130 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json ...` | Passed | Confirmed release-gate issue #130 remains open and is the accepted-boundary blocker. | -| `gh issue view 131 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json ...` | Passed | Confirmed Slither/static-analysis issue #131 remains open and blocks coherent local product/L1 E2E evidence. | -| `powershell -NoProfile -ExecutionPolicy Bypass -File infra/scripts/status-report.ps1` | Passed | Confirmed PR #132 is the only open real-value pilot implementation PR, many sibling worktrees are dirty, and issues #130/#131 are open. | +| `gh issue view 130 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json ...` | Passed | Historical pre-merge check: release-gate issue #130 was still the accepted-boundary blocker. | +| `gh issue view 131 --repo FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory --json ...` | Passed | Historical pre-merge check: Slither/static-analysis issue #131 still blocked coherent local product/L1 E2E evidence. | +| `powershell -NoProfile -ExecutionPolicy Bypass -File infra/scripts/status-report.ps1` | Passed | Historical pre-merge check: PR #132 was the only real-value pilot implementation PR, many sibling worktrees were dirty, and #130/#131 were still open. | | Post blocker-link docs checks | Passed | `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs`, `git diff --check`, and `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e -- -AllowIncomplete` passed after linking issues #130/#131. | | PowerShell parser for `infra/scripts/contracts-static-analysis.ps1` | Passed | Parser accepted the updated opt-in Slither policy. | | `bash -n infra/scripts/contracts-static-analysis.sh` | Passed | Passed after normalizing the script line endings and applying the same opt-in Slither policy. | @@ -45,6 +45,14 @@ Last updated: 2026-05-14. | Post release-boundary docs checks | Passed | `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs`, `git diff --check`, and `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e -- -AllowIncomplete` passed after adding the issue #130 release-gate boundary. | | `gh issue create ...` for subsystem proof commands | Passed | Created contracts #133, runtime #134, ops #135, wallet #136, control-dashboard #137, and bridge #138. | | Post subsystem-issue mapping checks | Passed | `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs`, `git diff --check`, and `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e -- -AllowIncomplete` passed after mapping #133 through #138 into HQ docs. | +| PR #132 merge verification | Passed | `gh pr view 132` reported state `MERGED`, merge commit `14f378b7f2dee9bfd29aec691ebda41e2b6fa101`, merged at `2026-05-14T02:19:55Z`. | +| Issue #130/#131 closure verification | Passed | `gh issue view 130` and `gh issue view 131` reported `CLOSED`; #130 closed at `2026-05-14T02:22:17Z`, #131 closed at `2026-05-14T02:22:35Z`. | +| Post-merge `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` | Passed | Main-equivalent tree passed and wrote `devnet/local/full-smoke/flowchain-full-smoke-report.json`. | +| Post-merge strict `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` | Failed as intended | Gate exists on `main` and failed clearly with the six missing dedicated subsystem proof commands. | +| Post-merge `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` | Passed | Product Testnet V1 E2E passed and wrote `devnet/local/product-e2e/flowchain-product-e2e-report.json`. | +| Post-merge policy checks | Passed | `git diff --check` and `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs` passed after the product E2E run. | +| GitHub issue comments for #133 through #138 | Passed | Posted HQ refresh comments with local worktree evidence, missing root proof command state, and next integration action on each subsystem proof issue. | +| Post-merge docs refresh checks | Passed | After updating HQ docs for PR #132 merge, #130/#131 closure, and issue comments, `git diff --check`, `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs`, and `npm run flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e -- -AllowIncomplete` passed. | ## Static Analysis Policy Update @@ -55,7 +63,7 @@ This branch updates `infra/scripts/contracts-static-analysis.ps1` and matches the repo-level policy in `docs/CURRENT_STATE.md`: Slither remains an explicit audit gate, not an environment-dependent default gate. -GitHub blocker: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/issues/131 +Closed GitHub issue: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/issues/131 The explicit audit gate still owns the observed Slither findings: diff --git a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/NOTES.md b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/NOTES.md index f8fc9b21..9256e717 100644 --- a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/NOTES.md +++ b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/NOTES.md @@ -11,18 +11,15 @@ Last updated: 2026-05-14. assumptions. - Draft PR #129 is prompt/launcher-only for real-value pilot agents. It is useful context, not merged source of truth. -- Issue #130 is the active gate issue for defining release boundaries before - public-network pilot work. -- PR #132 now expands `docs/FLOWCHAIN_REAL_VALUE_PILOT.md` with the issue #130 - release-gate boundary for observer reads, deposits, release/recovery, local - credit application, dashboard display, and explicitly out-of-scope public - readiness claims. +- Issue #130 is closed. PR #132 merged the release-gate boundary for observer + reads, deposits, release/recovery, local credit application, dashboard + display, and explicitly out-of-scope public-readiness claims. - Missing subsystem proof commands are now tracked by GitHub issues #133 through #138. -- Issue #131 is the active contracts/static-analysis issue for reconciling - local Slither findings that block product and L1 E2E evidence. -- PR #132 now includes an allowed `infra/scripts/` fix for #131: the default - hardening path skips Slither unless the explicit audit gate is requested. +- Issue #131 is closed. PR #132 merged the allowed `infra/scripts/` policy fix: + default hardening skips Slither unless the explicit audit gate is requested. +- HQ refresh comments are posted on issues #133 through #138 with each local + worktree's current proof evidence and next integration action. ## Reusable Work @@ -41,22 +38,27 @@ Last updated: 2026-05-14. - Contracts branch `agent/real-value-pilot-contracts` reports passing contract tests, hardening, deploy dry-run, and product E2E. It remains unmerged and has no dedicated root pilot proof command on `main`. -- Bridge branch `agent/real-value-pilot-bridge` contains Base `8453` observer - and mock pilot E2E work, but its run checklist still records the key proof - commands as pending. -- Chain branch `agent/real-value-pilot-chain` has runtime bridge-credit work in - progress. Baseline cargo test passed before edits; current pilot experiments - are not recorded as complete. -- Wallet branch `agent/real-value-pilot-wallet` contains pilot signing, - validation, schemas, and operator-doc work, with test rows still pending in - its checklist. -- Control-dashboard branch `agent/real-value-pilot-control-dashboard` contains - pilot API and dashboard work plus a service-local E2E, but its checklist still - marks implementation and verification rows incomplete. +- Bridge branch `agent/real-value-pilot-bridge` checklist now reports the + observer, replay, local-credit, withdrawal/release, negative, smoke, and + product E2E proof rows complete. It remains unmerged and lacks the dedicated + root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:bridge` command on `main`. +- Chain branch `agent/real-value-pilot-chain` checklist reports the direct + runtime wrapper proof complete for credit-once, replay, receipt lookup, + restart, and export/import roots. It still needs the root + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:runtime` package script and a clean product E2E + rerun after dependency setup. +- Wallet branch `agent/real-value-pilot-wallet` checklist reports pilot + schemas, validation, signing, negative cases, scans, and product evidence + complete. It remains unmerged and lacks the dedicated root + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:wallet` command on `main`. +- Control-dashboard branch `agent/real-value-pilot-control-dashboard` checklist + reports API/dashboard tests, build, smoke, and branch-local + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:control-dashboard` complete. It remains unmerged. - Ops branch `agent/real-value-pilot-ops` contains the most complete root wrapper/runbook path, including emergency stop and sanitized export. Its - product E2E result depends on an ops-side static-analysis wrapper change that - is not present in this HQ PR. + checklist reports product E2E complete, but the dedicated root + `flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops` alias expected by the HQ gate is still + missing on `main`. ## Boundaries @@ -78,10 +80,10 @@ Last updated: 2026-05-14. - After updating `infra/scripts/contracts-static-analysis.ps1` and `infra/scripts/contracts-static-analysis.sh`, default `contracts:hardening`, `npm run flowchain:product-e2e`, and `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e` pass locally. -- GitHub issue #131 remains open until this static-analysis policy update is - reviewed and merged; the explicit Slither audit gate still owns the native - release findings. -- Draft PR opened: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/pull/132. -- Completion audit result: not complete. PR #132 is not merged, `origin/main` - lacks both new scripts, and the default pilot gate fails with missing - subsystem proofs. +- The explicit Slither audit gate still owns the native release findings. +- PR #132 merged: https://github.com/FlowmemoryAI/FlowMemory/pull/132. +- Post-merge local main-equivalent verification passed + `npm run flowchain:product-e2e`, `npm run flowchain:l1-e2e`, + `git diff --check`, and `node infra/scripts/check-unsafe-claims.mjs`. +- Completion audit result: not complete. The default pilot gate exists on + `main`, but still fails with missing dedicated subsystem proof commands. diff --git a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/PLAN.md b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/PLAN.md index e413fb17..4b906574 100644 --- a/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/PLAN.md +++ b/docs/agent-runs/real-value-pilot-hq/PLAN.md @@ -57,16 +57,25 @@ Read before edits: - `docs/FLOWCHAIN_SECOND_COMPUTER_SETUP.md` - `docs/FLOWCHAIN_HQ_INTEGRATION_STATUS.md` -Current `origin/main` was checked before edits: +Current `origin/main` was checked before the initial HQ edits: ```text 9b025c5 Include HQ review in L1 long-loop launcher (#128) ``` +Post-merge refresh: + +```text +14f378b Add real-value pilot HQ gate +``` + GitHub source-of-truth state checked before edits: - Draft PR #129: real-value pilot goal pack, CI passing, draft. -- Issue #130: required release gates before public-network pilot work. +- Issue #130: closed by PR #132 after the capped owner-pilot release-gate + boundary landed on `main`. +- Issue #131: closed by PR #132 after the optional-Slither default hardening + policy landed on `main`. - Open draft PRs #110, #112 through #117, #111, #129, #73, and #71. - Issues #99, #100, #101, #102, #108, and #78 are closed on GitHub even where local docs may still mention earlier open state. @@ -93,12 +102,12 @@ root commands on `main`. | Worktree | Branch | Current evidence | HQ state | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-contracts` | `agent/real-value-pilot-contracts` | Checklist reports `forge test`, `npm run contracts:hardening`, deploy dry-run, and `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` passing after dependency install. Work is in `contracts/`, `script/`, and tests. | Useful contracts proof candidate; no dedicated root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:contracts` command exists on HQ/main yet. | -| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-bridge` | `agent/real-value-pilot-bridge` | Adds bridge relayer pilot observer files, Base `8453` script, mock E2E code, and a branch-local `flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e` script. Checklist still has implementation and verification rows unchecked. | Bridge proof remains in progress and unmerged. | -| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-chain` | `agent/real-value-pilot-chain` | Runtime model/CLI/tests show pilot bridge-credit work in progress. Baseline cargo test passed before edits; current experiments are still pending. | Runtime proof remains in progress and unmerged. | -| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-wallet` | `agent/real-value-pilot-wallet` | Adds pilot schemas, wallet/operator docs, and signing/validation code. Checklist still has implementation and test rows unchecked. | Wallet proof remains in progress and unmerged. | -| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-control-dashboard` | `agent/real-value-pilot-control-dashboard` | Adds pilot control-plane API/dashboard files and a service-local `real-value-pilot:e2e` script. Checklist still shows API/dashboard/test rows unchecked. | Control-dashboard proof remains in progress and unmerged. | -| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-ops` | `agent/real-value-pilot-ops` | Adds pilot ops/runbook scripts, emergency stop, sanitized export, and branch-local root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:e2e`; checklist reports unsafe-claims, diff check, and product E2E passing after an ops-side static-analysis wrapper change. | Ops proof candidate exists branch-locally, but it is not merged into HQ/main. | +| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-contracts` | `agent/real-value-pilot-contracts` | Checklist reports `forge test`, `npm run contracts:hardening`, deploy dry-run, and `npm run flowchain:product-e2e` passing after dependency install. Work is in `contracts/`, `script/`, and tests. | Candidate proof complete branch-locally; no dedicated root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:contracts` command exists on `main`. | +| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-bridge` | `agent/real-value-pilot-bridge` | Checklist now reports Base `8453` observer, chain-id rejection, approved lockbox guard, confirmation depth, deterministic evidence, replay handling, withdrawal/release evidence, tests, mock pilot E2E, wrong-chain negatives, local-credit smoke, and product E2E complete. | Candidate proof complete branch-locally; root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:bridge` is still missing on `main`. | +| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-chain` | `agent/real-value-pilot-chain` | Checklist reports runtime bridge credit, replay, receipt lookup, restart, export/import root preservation, and direct wrapper evidence complete; product E2E remains blocked in that branch by missing dependencies and the root command is absent. | Runtime proof needs a rebased root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:runtime` command PR. | +| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-wallet` | `agent/real-value-pilot-wallet` | Checklist reports pilot schemas, public metadata, config validation, cap guardrails, signing/validation CLI, E2E, negative cases, next-command CLI, scans, and product evidence complete. | Candidate proof complete branch-locally; root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:wallet` is still missing on `main`. | +| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-control-dashboard` | `agent/real-value-pilot-control-dashboard` | Checklist reports API/dashboard proof complete and branch-local `flowchain:real-value-pilot:control-dashboard` passing. | Candidate proof complete branch-locally; no PR currently exists. | +| `E:\FlowMemory\flowmemory-live-ops` | `agent/real-value-pilot-ops` | Checklist reports dry-run/live-refusal, Base guard, cap checks, next commands, emergency stop, sanitized export, docs, unsafe-claims, diff check, and product E2E complete. | Candidate proof complete branch-locally; root `flowchain:real-value-pilot:ops` is still missing on `main`. | ## Implementation Plan @@ -111,7 +120,7 @@ root commands on `main`. 4. Keep the gate failing by default until dedicated contracts, bridge relayer, runtime, wallet/operator, control-plane/dashboard, and ops commands exist. 5. Run the requested checks and record exact results in `EXPERIMENTS.md`. -6. Open a draft PR with exact commands run and current blockers. +6. Open a PR with exact commands run and current blockers. ## Initial Blockers @@ -121,5 +130,6 @@ root commands on `main`. - No dedicated real-value pilot wallet/operator command exists. - No dedicated real-value pilot control-plane/dashboard command exists. - No dedicated real-value pilot ops/installer command exists. -- Issue #130 must define the accepted release-gate boundary before the owner - pilot can move beyond capped validation. +- The issue #130 release-gate boundary is now merged on `main`; the owner + pilot still cannot move beyond capped validation until the six subsystem + proof commands land and pass from `main`.