Permalink request within group #1748
Conversation
| @@ -1,5 +1,6 @@ | |||
| import React, {PropTypes, Component} from 'react'; | |||
| import { connect } from 'react-redux'; | |||
| import { LinkContainer } from 'react-router-bootstrap'; | |||
kwm4385
Feb 28, 2018
Contributor
What's the reasoning behind using LinkContainer over the standard react-router Link or an onclick handler?
What's the reasoning behind using LinkContainer over the standard react-router Link or an onclick handler?
benheng
Feb 28, 2018
Author
Contributor
Link doesn't play nice with bootstrap components. I also wanted the URL to change when a user clicked on a request ID which is why I went with LinkContainer. Would it have been better to have an onClick handler and wrap the component using withRouter?
Link doesn't play nice with bootstrap components. I also wanted the URL to change when a user clicked on a request ID which is why I went with LinkContainer. Would it have been better to have an onClick handler and wrap the component using withRouter?
kwm4385
Feb 28, 2018
Contributor
If we were already using react-router-bootstrap I'd say this is the best solution, however, I'm hesitant to add another dependency for this single use case since we already have so many. For that reason I'd say go with handling it via onClick and withRouter.
If we were already using react-router-bootstrap I'd say this is the best solution, however, I'm hesitant to add another dependency for this single use case since we already have so many. For that reason I'd say go with handling it via onClick and withRouter.
| </NavItem> | ||
| <LinkContainer | ||
| eventKey={requestId} | ||
| key={index} |
andyhuang91
Feb 28, 2018
requestId is a logical key here
requestId is a logical key here
| @@ -13,7 +14,7 @@ class GroupDetail extends Component { | |||
| constructor(props) { | |||
| super(props); | |||
| this.state = { | |||
| showRequestId: _.first(props.group.requestIds) | |||
| showRequestId: props.params.requestId || _.first(props.group.requestIds), | |||
andyhuang91
Feb 28, 2018
component state isn't needed anymore, and you can get rid of onSelect={this.handleRequestSelect} on the Nav component
component state isn't needed anymore, and you can get rid of onSelect={this.handleRequestSelect} on the Nav component
|
|
Previously, request groups didn't support permalinks for requests within the group. It would simply select the first request and display that.
You'd have link that looked like this:
Which would contain some requests: RequestGroup1-foo1, RequestGroup1-foo2, RequestGroup1-foo3
Now you can link them directly:
The default behavior is maintained, no request ID means display the first request. Incorrect request ID will still load the selected group page, but the request data will not be displayed since there is none.