apaj edited this page Sep 3, 2018 · 1 revision

I have finished the Chisel Learning Journey and in addition to that, I have also went through several other Chisel tutorials. The Chisel Learning Journey is a very good website that definitely helps learning Chisel, but I have few suggestions for improvement:

  • the training jumps straight to Chisel language with practical code examples but not so much theoretical explanation behind the code and the syntax. I propose to add more pages about Chisel language (especially the syntax) before going to examples. But this may be a bit subjective - depends on type of person that is learning, someone prefers complete explanation of language and its constructs before jumping directly to working with the code. I believe that this could be easily solved by just changing the structure of the pages in such a way that the page Setting-up-Chisel points to Documentation as the next page, not Chisel-Introductory-Examples. I would also change the Documentation page to include other tutorials that are more theoretically oriented and I would add a pointer to the next page, which would be the Chisel-Introductory-Examples. In other words, I recommend to place the Chisel theory between Sitting-up-Chisel page and Chisel-Introductory-Examples. Thanks to this, the people that will work with the examples will already have some theoretical background about the Chisel.
  • the examples for working with Chisel are really good, but unfortunately they are incomplete. I am talking about pages Examples-Line-by-Line and Tutorial-Home. These two pages are also quite confusing because they are describing the same content more or less and each page is accessed from different places. The Examples-Line-by-Line is accessed from Comparison-to-Verilog page, while the Tutorial-Home is being accessed from Chisel-Introductory-Examples. My proposal is to combine these pages together into one practical tutorial.
  • the example code is mostly written in Chisel 2. We will have to update the pages to contain Chisel 3.
  • I recommend to add and highlight these two pages somewhere in the beginning of Chisel Learning Journey (e.g. Documentation page) because I find them really good and useful:
  • as long as the Chisel 2 is still relevant for us, I suggest to add a new page called Chisel 2 vs 3 or Migrating Chisel 2 to Chisel 3 and link it to

In overall, the Chisel Learning Journey is very good and my points above are just to improve it so that it will be even better. :slightly_smiling_face:

Clone this wiki locally
You can’t perform that action at this time.
You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session. You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.
Press h to open a hovercard with more details.