Skip to content
This repository
Fetching contributors…

Octocat-spinner-32-eaf2f5

Cannot retrieve contributors at this time

file 144 lines (143 sloc) 12.679 kb
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143
<!DOCTYPE html>
<html data-require="math word-problems graphie">
<head>
    <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8">
    <title>Logical arguments and deductive reasoning</title>
    <script src="../khan-exercise.js"></script>
</head>
<body>
    <div class="exercise">
        <div class="problems">
            <div id="detachment">
                <div class="vars">
                    <var id="QUESTIONS">
                        [[person(1)+" misses the bus", he(1)+" will be late for school",
                            [person(1)+" missed the bus",
                             person(1)+" is late for school",
                             person(1)+" did not miss the bus",
                             person(1)+" is not late for school"]],
                         ["it is Tuesday", "I will have a hamburger for lunch",
                            ["it is Tuesday",
                             "I will have a hamburger for lunch today",
                             "it is not Tuesday",
                             "I will not have a hamburger for lunch today"]],
                         ["Wiggles are walking", "Tiggles are talking",
                            ["Wiggles are walking",
                             "Tiggles are talking",
                             "Wiggles are not walking",
                             "Tiggles are not talking"]],
                         ["I go to practice today", "I will play in the game tomorrow",
                             ["I went to practice today",
                              "I will play in the game tomorrow",
                              "I did not go to practice today",
                              "I will not play in the game tomorrow"]]]
                    </var>
                    <var id="Q_TYPE">randRange(0, QUESTIONS.length - 1)</var>
                    <var id="IF_CLAUSE">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][0]</var>
                    <var id="THEN_CLAUSE">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][1]</var>
                    <var id="TYPE">randRange(0, 3)</var>
                    <var id="IMPLICATION">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][2]</var>
                    <var id="CONCLUSION">[IMPLICATION[1], IMPLICATION[0], IMPLICATION[3], IMPLICATION[2]]</var>
                    <var id="SOLUTION">(TYPE === 1 || TYPE === 2) ? "No logical conclusion possible" : capitalize(CONCLUSION[TYPE])</var>
                </div>
                <p class="problem">Use the given information to make a logical conclusion, if possible. If a logical conclusion is not possible, choose "no logical conclusion possible."</p>
                <p class="question">If <span id="if-clause"><var>IF_CLAUSE</var></span>, then <span id="then-clause"><var>THEN_CLAUSE</var></span>. <span id="second-sent"><var>capitalize(IMPLICATION[ TYPE ])</var></span>. </p>
                <p class="solution"><var>SOLUTION</var></p>
                <ul class="choices" data-category="true">
                    <li><var>capitalize(CONCLUSION[TYPE])</var></li>
                    <li>No logical conclusion possible</li>
                </ul>
                <div class="hints">
                    <div>
                        <p>Identify the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span>, the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span> of the first sentence, and the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span>.</p>
                        <div class="graphie">
                            $("#if-clause").addClass("hint_blue");
                            $("#then-clause").addClass("hint_green");
                            $("#second-sent").addClass("hint_purple");
                        </div>
                    </div>
                    <p>Does the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> refer to the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span> of the first sentence, or the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span> of the first sentence?</p>
                    <div data-if="TYPE === 0 || TYPE === 2">
                        <p>The <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> refers to the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span> of the first sentence, because they both talk about whether or not <var>IMPLICATION[0]</var>.</p>
                        <p>Does the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> state the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span>, or the opposite of the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span>?</p>
                    </div>
                    <div data-else>
                        <p>The <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> refers to the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span> of the first sentence, because they both talk about whether or not <var>IMPLICATION[1]</var>.</p>
                        <p>Does the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> state the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span>, or the opposite of the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span>?</p>
                    </div>
                    <div data-if="TYPE === 0" data-unwrap>
                        <p>The <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> states the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span> of the first sentence.</p>
                        <p>Because the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> states the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span> of the first sentence, the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> implies the first sentence.</p>
                        <p>Since we are implying the original statement, we can conclude the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span> of the first statement.</p>
                    </div>
                    <div data-if="TYPE === 1" data-unwrap>
                        <p>The <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> states the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span> of the first sentence.</p>
                        <p>Because the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> states the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span> of the first sentence, the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> implies the converse of the first sentence.</p>
                        <p>Converses are not logically equivalent to their original statements, so we cannot form a logical conclusion.</p>
                    </div>
                    <div data-if="TYPE === 2" data-unwrap>
                        <p>The <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> states the opposite of the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span> of the first sentence.</p>
                        <p>Because the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> states the opposite of the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span> of the first sentence, the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> implies the inverse of the first sentence.</p>
                        <p>Inverses are not logically equivalent to their original statements, so we cannot form a logical conclusion.</p>
                    </div>
                    <div data-if="TYPE === 3" data-unwrap>
                        <p>Because the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> states the opposite of the <span class="hint_green">conclusion</span> of the first sentence, the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> implies the contrapositive of the first sentence.</p>
                        <p>Since the contrapositive is implied by the first sentence, the <span class="hint_purple">second sentence</span> implies the opposite of the <span class="hint_blue">hypothesis</span>.</p>
                    </div>
                    <p>Thus, the answer is "<var>SOLUTION</var>"</p>
                </div>
            </div>
            <div id="syllogism">
                <div class="vars">
                    <var id="QUESTIONS">
                        [[true, true, ["a figure is a square", "it is a rectangle", "a figure is a rectangle", "it has four right angles"]],
                         [false, true, ["you play basketball", "you are athletic", "you play volleyball", "you are athletic"]],
                         [true, true, ["it is Saturday", "you don't have to go to school", "you don't have to go to school", "you can play in the park"]],
                         [false, true, ["you live in Los Angeles", "you live in California", "you live in Sacramento", "you live in California"]],
                         [true, true, ["a ray bisects an angle", "it creates two congruent angles", "there are two congruent angles", "the two angles have the same measure"]],
                         [false, false, ["a shape is a pentagon", "the shape has five sides", "a shape is a pentagon", "the shape has five angles"]],
                         [true, true, ["a student is in the twelfth grade", "he or she is in high school", "a student is in high school", "he or she is not in college"]],
                         [false, true, ["you have a picnic", "you will see ants", "it rains a lot", "you will see ants"]]]</var>
                    <var id="Q_TYPE">randRange(0, QUESTIONS.length - 1)</var>
                    <var id="CONC_POSSIBLE">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][0]</var>
                    <var id="HYP_DIFF">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][1]</var>
                    <var id="HYP_A">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][2][0]</var>
                    <var id="CONC_A">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][2][1]</var>
                    <var id="HYP_B">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][2][2]</var>
                    <var id="CONC_B">QUESTIONS[Q_TYPE][2][3]</var>
                    <var id="SOLUTION">CONC_POSSIBLE ? ("If "+HYP_A+", then "+CONC_B+".") : "No logical conclusion possible."</var>
                </div>
                <p class="problem">Use the given information to make a logical conclusion, if possible.</p>
                <p class="question">If <span id="hyp_a"><var>HYP_A</var></span>, then <span id="conc_a"><var>CONC_A</var></span>. If <span id="hyp_b"><var>HYP_B</var></span>, then <span id="conc_b"><var>CONC_B</var></span>.</p>
                <p class="solution"><var>SOLUTION</var></p>
                <ul class="choices" data-category="true">
                    <li data-if="CONC_POSSIBLE">If <var>HYP_A</var>, then <var>CONC_B</var>.</li>
                    <li data-else-if="HYP_DIFF">If <var>HYP_A</var>, then <var>HYP_B</var>.</li>
                    <li data-else>If <var>CONC_A</var>, then <var>CONC_B</var>.</li>
                    <li>No logical conclusion possible.</li>
                </ul>
                <div class="hints">
                    <div>
                        <p>Identify the <span class="hint_blue">first hypothesis</span>, the <span class="hint_green">first conclusion</span>, the <span class="hint_red">second hypothesis</span>, and the <span class="hint_purple">second conclusion</span>.</p>
                        <div class="graphie">
                            $( "#hyp_a" ).addClass( "hint_blue" );
                            $( "#conc_a" ).addClass( "hint_green" );
                            $( "#hyp_b" ).addClass( "hint_red" );
                            $( "#conc_b" ).addClass( "hint_purple" );
                        </div>
                    </div>
                    <div>
                        <p>Do the two sentences come in the form "If <span class="hint_blue">P</span>, then <span class="hint_green">Q</span>. If <span class="hint_red">Q</span>, then <span class="hint_purple">R</span>", where <span class="hint_green">first conclusion</span> and <span class="hint_red">second hypothesis</span> are the same?</p>
                        <p>In other words, do the sentences look like <code>\blue{P}\implies \green{Q}</code>. <code>\red{Q}\implies \purple{R}</code>?</p>
                    </div>
                    <div data-if="CONC_POSSIBLE" data-unwrap>
                        <p>Yes. Because the middle two statements both say <span class="hint_green"> <var>HYP_B</var></span>, we can chain the statements together: <code>\blue{P}\implies\green{Q}\implies\purple{R}</code> or <span class="hint_blue">"<var>HYP_A</var>"</span><code>\implies</code><span class="hint_green">"<var>CONC_A</var>"</span><code>\implies</code><span class="hint_purple">"<var>CONC_B</var>"</span>.</p>
                        <p>We can now remove the middle statement, and arrive at the conclusion <span class="hint_blue">"<var>HYP_A</var>"</span><code>\implies</code><span class="hint_purple">"<var>CONC_B</var>"</span>. So, the answer is "If <span class="hint_blue"> <var>HYP_A</var></span>, then <span class="hint_purple"> <var>CONC_B</var></span>."</p>
                    </div>
                    <p data-else>No. So, we cannot form a logical conclusion.</p>
                </div>
            </div>
        </div>
    </div>
</body>
</html>
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.