diff --git a/Sources/TorusUtils/Helpers/NodeUtils.swift b/Sources/TorusUtils/Helpers/NodeUtils.swift
index 034b1e26..74b90c8c 100644
--- a/Sources/TorusUtils/Helpers/NodeUtils.swift
+++ b/Sources/TorusUtils/Helpers/NodeUtils.swift
@@ -403,10 +403,10 @@ internal class NodeUtils {
         var sessionTokens: [String?] = []
         var nodeIndexes: [Int?] = []
         var sessionTokenDatas: [SessionToken?] = []
-        var isNewKeys: [String] = []
+        var isNewKeys: [IsNewKeyResponse] = []
 
         for item in shareResponses {
-            isNewKeys.append(item.isNewKey)
+            isNewKeys.append(IsNewKeyResponse(isNewKey: item.isNewKey == "true", publicKeyX: item.keys.first?.publicKey.X ?? ""))
 
             if !item.sessionTokenSigs.isEmpty {
                 if !item.sessionTokenSigMetadata.isEmpty {
@@ -506,7 +506,12 @@ internal class NodeUtils {
             throw TorusUtilError.privateKeyDeriveFailed
         }
 
-        let thresholdIsNewKey: String? = try thresholdSame(arr: isNewKeys, threshold: threshold)
+        var isNewKey = false;
+        for item in isNewKeys {
+            if (item.isNewKey && item.publicKeyX.lowercased() == thresholdPublicKey!.X.lowercased()) {
+                isNewKey = true
+            }
+        }
 
         let oAuthKey = privateKey!
         let oAuthPublicKey = try SecretKey(hex: oAuthKey).toPublic().serialize(compressed: false)
@@ -520,8 +525,7 @@ internal class NodeUtils {
             finalPubKey = oAuthPublicKey
         } else if TorusUtils.isLegacyNetworkRouteMap(network: network) {
             if enableOneKey {
-                let isNewKey = !(thresholdIsNewKey == "true")
-                let nonce = try await MetadataUtils.getOrSetNonce(legacyMetadataHost: legacyMetadataHost, serverTimeOffset: serverTimeOffsetResponse, X: thresholdPublicKey!.X, Y: thresholdPublicKey!.Y, privateKey: oAuthKey, getOnly: isNewKey)
+                let nonce = try await MetadataUtils.getOrSetNonce(legacyMetadataHost: legacyMetadataHost, serverTimeOffset: serverTimeOffsetResponse, X: thresholdPublicKey!.X, Y: thresholdPublicKey!.Y, privateKey: oAuthKey, getOnly: !isNewKey)
                 metadataNonce = BigInt(nonce.nonce?.addLeading0sForLength64() ?? "0", radix: 16) ?? BigInt(0)
                 typeOfUser = UserType(rawValue: nonce.typeOfUser?.lowercased() ?? "v1")!
                 if typeOfUser == .v2 {
diff --git a/Sources/TorusUtils/Helpers/jsonRPC/Responses/IsNewKeyResponse.swift b/Sources/TorusUtils/Helpers/jsonRPC/Responses/IsNewKeyResponse.swift
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ed268ebf
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Sources/TorusUtils/Helpers/jsonRPC/Responses/IsNewKeyResponse.swift
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
+import Foundation
+
+internal struct IsNewKeyResponse: Codable {
+    public var isNewKey: Bool;
+    public var publicKeyX: String;
+
+    public init(isNewKey: Bool, publicKeyX: String) {
+        self.isNewKey = isNewKey
+        self.publicKeyX = publicKeyX
+    }
+}