New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Some specific protections (Snow or specificially spectra ward) are not counted as protections to be gained or shared #4

Open
silasary opened this Issue Apr 3, 2017 · 4 comments

Comments

4 participants
@silasary
Member

silasary commented Apr 3, 2017

From spreadsheet

Affects: [Concerted Effort], [Death-Mask Duplicant], [Cairn Wanderer]

@NARFNra

This comment has been minimized.

NARFNra commented Mar 12, 2018

It seems that while some protections are not written on the card many of them are still functional. I am commenting here about this despite having another open ticket regarding the graphical bug because the issue specifically noted here (Harbinger of Spring) seems to be a graphical bug where the protection still functions.

Please observe: Fanatical Firebrand cannot target anything on the field after the Concerted Effort trigger, even though the card text does not appear to change.

concerted_effort_harbinger

@NARFNra

This comment has been minimized.

NARFNra commented Mar 12, 2018

So far, the protection from all colors granted by Spectra Ward appears to be the only protection I've seen so far that Concerted Effort fails to FUNCTIONALLY grant as well as visibly grant. Protection from all colors is visible and functional if granted with Concerted Effort from Pristine Archangel...

image

And protections granted by auras work fine with Concerted Effort, as we can see from Holy Mantle's "protection from creatures"...

image

But Spectra Ward does not seem to grant its protection from all colors to any other creature. Fan Bearer can tap Firebrand here.

image

@BackAlleyG BackAlleyG changed the title from [Concerted Effort] Specific protections are not shared among all creatures. (example Harbinger of Spring Protection from non-Spirit Creatures) to [Concerted Effort] Some specific protections are not shared among all creatures. (example: Proctetion from all colors) Mar 13, 2018

@BackAlleyG BackAlleyG changed the title from [Concerted Effort] Some specific protections are not shared among all creatures. (example: Proctetion from all colors) to [Concerted Effort] Some specific protections are not shared among all creatures. (example: Spectra Ward's Protection from all colors) Mar 13, 2018

@BackAlleyG

This comment has been minimized.

Collaborator

BackAlleyG commented Mar 15, 2018

Have done some further testing and so far it seems this happens only for spectra. Have tested other similar auras with "this effect doesn't remove ~" auras but there aren't any other auras with "this effect doesn't remove auras" so may be confined to spectra ward. Still testing some specific protections and working on compiling a list of protections and whether or not they need testing yet or have been and aren't bugged.

@BackAlleyG BackAlleyG moved this from 3.4.101.1120 to 3.4.102.2007 in Verification Mar 15, 2018

@BackAlleyG

This comment has been minimized.

Collaborator

BackAlleyG commented Mar 15, 2018

Okay so seem that the only protections that aren't shareable are pro snow and protection specifically from spectra ward. Everything else I've tested has worked. See #327 's initial comment for my short untested list

pro snow not being shared.
image

Also found out the same is true for cairn wander and death-mask duplicant (see below) so updating post and will try to figure out a good general title

image
image

@BackAlleyG BackAlleyG changed the title from [Concerted Effort] Some specific protections are not shared among all creatures. (example: Spectra Ward's Protection from all colors) to Some specific protections (Snow or specificially spectra ward) are not coutned as protections to be gained or shared Mar 15, 2018

@BackAlleyG BackAlleyG changed the title from Some specific protections (Snow or specificially spectra ward) are not coutned as protections to be gained or shared to Some specific protections (Snow or specificially spectra ward) are not counted as protections to be gained or shared Mar 15, 2018

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment