ProxyJump #1172
Comments
|
Can you add some more details on how to do this in a simple setup? Perhaps using the local sshd endpoint as a proxyjump onto itself? |
|
Of course. I've seen it generally concerns ProxyJump. So it doesn't depend on the ssh_config. You can reproduce it simple by running Output: |
|
I get the same error I use OpenSSH_for_Windows_7.6p1, and Windows 10 Education ssh -J user1@jumphost user2@server
|
manojampalam
added
Issue-Bug
Area-ssh
and removed
Issue-Discussion-Deprecated/use GitHub discussions
labels
|
Just decided to try the native ssh in Windows 10 - and found this bug immediately. I can't access anything since the ProxyJump is required to specify the bastion to jump through. How can I help troubleshoot this? Windows 10 Enterprise 1803 Build 17134.320 |
|
Have the same issue on Microsoft Windows [Version 10.0.17134.471] Bad stdio forwarding specification ''[example.com]:22'' |
|
Workaround: |
|
Any idea when this will be fixed? It's very irritating to have to run a find-replace every time I copy a SSH configuration from a Linux setup. |
|
After the 1809 update, the workaround is now also no longer working for me. PS C:\> systeminfo | findstr /B /C:"OS Name" /C:"OS Version"
OS Name: Microsoft Windows 10 Home
OS Version: 10.0.17763 N/A Build 17763
PS C:\> ssh myexample
CreateProcessW failed error:2
posix_spawn: No such file or directoryIn my |
|
I'm bothered by this issue. (10 Pro 1809) Latest OpenSSH: Without using jump host (successfully connected): |
|
I am also suffering from this issue. Does anyone have an update? I redacted the hostnames. However, they are correct. |
|
Can you try if this private works: |
|
Private fix works for me. My testenvironment is 3 windows and one CentOS machines. All windows machines are running OpenSSH_for_Windows_7.9p1 Running the command ssh -J automate2@jumphost.test.local administrator@dc1.test.local with the old SSH.exe it gives the known failure. With the new ssh.exe it works as expected and I get my remote shell |
|
Can confirm @manojampalam patched copy fixes the issue. |
|
@manojampalam thanks for providing a workaround 🎉! However, I feel dicey to trust the authenticity of your private patched build... Can it be pushed as a PR so we can review the changes made which fix the issue? |
|
@manojampalam I agree with @kumarharsh and am also hesitant to download and execute a binary that is not from a known trusted source. Considering it has been tested and confirmed to be working by more than one party, when can we expect a new official release to be available including this patch? |
|
Change in PR referenced. Next release should be out towards end of Feb. |
|
The issue persists with the build OpenSSH_for_Windows_7.9p1, LibreSSL 2.6.5 |
|
@Zetanova Correct, the patch to this has not been released yet. A link to a version with just the patch can be found earlier in the through. My builds also include the change: https://github.com/NoMoreFood/openssh-portable/releases/tag/v7.9-merge-3 |
|
@NoMoreFood thx, but still the issue persists. it does not contain simple PR PowerShell/openssh-portable#373 that would fix the issue. |
|
@Zetanova I apologize, I thought that fix had been merged into master but it has not so my builds do not have it. You are correct. That said, are you seeing the private build mentioned earlier also doesn't fix the issue? |
|
@NoMoreFood manojampalam patch works for this ProxyJump issue. |
|
The work around I found was to use netcat with ProxyCommand. It is working fine with Windows. Replace: with: |
|
This issue has been open standing for a long time. It seems like we have a patch available. When will this be released? |
ProxyCommand requires netcat/nmap-ncat installed on the JumpHost. |
ProxyJump commandline constructed by ssh following Unix commandline argument convention using single quotes. Added a #ifdef block to use double quotes for Windows. PowerShell/Win32-OpenSSH#1172
|
@orgito thanks but indeed nc is installed on the jump host |
|
@eagleamon , sorry to hear that. I actually don't use it with paramiko. My use case is VS Code Remote Development Kit. |
|
Manually patching the OpenSSH binary with the private build above works, but I would very much appreciate a released version for the same concerns as others mentioned above.
@manojampalam Any chance of this release coming up? This issue is now blocking microsoft/vscode-remote-release#18. |
|
After upgrading to Windows 10 1903 it is necessary to add the full path to ssh.exe, eg:
|
|
Got error when using vscode remote ssh It is not acceptable to use full path in ~/.ssh/config . version : OpenSSH_for_Windows_7.7p1, LibreSSL 2.6.5 |
|
This was fixed as part of #1185. Try v7.9 or later |
|
I use this config on my windows 10 machine.it is successful!!!!!!! Host jump
HostName xxx
User xxx
Port xxx
Host your_machine
HostName xxxx
User xxx
ProxyCommand c:/Windows\System32\OpenSSH/ssh.exe jump -W %h:%p |
Works! For me the ProxyCommand could use only generic ssh executable instead of specifying exact path: ProxyCommand ssh jump -W %h:%p |
|
Pretty embarrassing that a simple issue such as this that was patched over a year ago hasn't made it to release yet. This is why people dislike Windows so much. |
|
@niklasholm |
It works. But it hardcoded the ssh command as well as parameters. If I want to refer ssh_config from other locations like |
|
Windows 1909 and this still doesn't work. Full path is not an option as I use this config file inside wsl as well. |
|
@silviuvulcan If you can't wait for this to be released into Windows (I know I couldn't), you could always patch it yourself. |
|
same issue |
|
I'm on 20H2 and the issue persists. Can confirm that the full-path workaround is effective. Took me a long time to figure this out... |
Both worked for me; took me a day to solve that issue. Since it wasn't patched since a while, the paper trail on the web is pretty long, which doesn't make debugging easier. |
|
Updating to the latest beta version on the releases page fixed it for me. I am running version I assume we have to wait for Windows to update via Windows update. I recommend managing the version yourself. You can also use Choco to install via command line |
@alshdavid The omission of an up-to-date version of OpenSSH in the latest Windows 10 release was addressed by Microsoft in #1693. You can track this problem there. I'm hoping that they will add it via a servicing update, but no news yet. |
感谢回复答案，你解决了我的问题。但答案不严谨， ssh 的绝对路径每个人的不同，可以先运行 where ssh 查看，再替换 |
and others
"OpenSSH for Windows" version
7.6.0.1
Client OperatingSystem
Windows 10 Pro
What is failing
If I use ProxyJump within SSH URI Usage within my config, I'll get:
Bad stdio forwarding specification ''[192.168.0.1]:22''
Seems like it is doubled escaped.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: