qrexec-agent does not correctly set $PATH variable for root user who has fish as default shell

[najamelan]

Qubes OS version:

R4.0

Affected TemplateVMs:

sys-net

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

qvm-run -p -u root sys-net 'env'

Expected behavior:

PATH should include /sbin and /usr/sbin for root.

Actual behavior:

PATH doesn't have /sbin and /usr/sbin

General notes:

The security impact should be minor. This does keep privileged processes from working correctly though.
The problem breaks functionality like SuspendPre because prepare-suspend uses lsmod and other commands that are in /sbin.

Solution

I'm not sure how this is best resolved. I'm not sure if the best option is to have an environment identical to when one logs into a interactive shell, because that implies parsing shell specific files like .bashrc or config.fish, ...

A consideration to make is that the user might have different shells installed, and so remote commands should never assume bash or sh, or should invoke the correct shell explicitly. I have not looked through qubes rpc code, but I just figured that is a possible source of bugs for people who use different shells. Maybe that could be documented in the qrexec documentation.

Workaround

For fixing suspend for the wifi card with a quick hack, one can add:
PATH=/sbin:/usr/sbin:$PATH at the beginning of:
/usr/lib/qubes/prepare-suspend in the template for sys-net.

Related issues:

qrexec-agent do not setup process environment correctly - #3416
wireless does not automatically reconnect on resume on R4-rc1 - #3151

[marmarek]

What template you use there (by default it's fedora-25, have you changed that?)?
Also, what version of qubes-core-agent package do you have (check with rpm -q qubes-core-agent, or dpkg -l qubes-core-agent depending on distribution)?
I've just tried on fedora-26 and debian-9, both with qubes-core-agent 4.0.15 and $PATH is set correctly (contains /usr/sbin and on Debian additionally /sbin).

[marmarek]

What template you use there (by default it's fedora-25, have you changed that?)?
Also, what version of qubes-core-agent package do you have (check with rpm -q qubes-core-agent, or dpkg -l qubes-core-agent depending on distribution)?
I've just tried on fedora-26 and debian-9, both with qubes-core-agent 4.0.15 and $PATH is set correctly (contains /usr/sbin and on Debian additionally /sbin).

[najamelan]

hi,
qubes-core-agent-4.0.15-1.fc26.x86_64

I made a new sys-net hoping I wouldn't get the "mac address already in use" because I have to restart my computer every time I want to restart sys-net, but in this new one this problem is still the same.

What I did:

• install the fedora-26 template from the qubes repository
• upgrade it from the testing repository, hence the core-agent version.

I installed fedora 26 because I like to keep things up to date and because it was available from qubes, I thought I might at least try it.

Ok, I tested with a stock fedora-25. The path is correct. 3 differences with the other one:

• it's 25
• it's not upgraded from testing
• root user does not have fish as it's default shell.

I will narrow it down.

[najamelan]

hi,
qubes-core-agent-4.0.15-1.fc26.x86_64

I made a new sys-net hoping I wouldn't get the "mac address already in use" because I have to restart my computer every time I want to restart sys-net, but in this new one this problem is still the same.

What I did:

• install the fedora-26 template from the qubes repository
• upgrade it from the testing repository, hence the core-agent version.

I installed fedora 26 because I like to keep things up to date and because it was available from qubes, I thought I might at least try it.

Ok, I tested with a stock fedora-25. The path is correct. 3 differences with the other one:

• it's 25
• it's not upgraded from testing
• root user does not have fish as it's default shell.

I will narrow it down.

[najamelan]

Ok,

after setting fish shell to the root user default shell the path no longer has /usr/sbin.

I wonder whether this is a problem on the fish end or the qubes end, but in any case when logging in interactively on the terminal, sbin is in the path, but when called through qvm-run it isn't.

[najamelan]

Ok,

after setting fish shell to the root user default shell the path no longer has /usr/sbin.

I wonder whether this is a problem on the fish end or the qubes end, but in any case when logging in interactively on the terminal, sbin is in the path, but when called through qvm-run it isn't.

[marmarek]

Yes, it may be a problem with fish. We expect that a login shell load appropriate startup scripts and setup environment. This especially include /etc/profile. At least on Fedora, /etc/profile contains a code to do add /usr/sbin to PATH. According to documentation fish should do that too...

[marmarek]

Yes, it may be a problem with fish. We expect that a login shell load appropriate startup scripts and setup environment. This especially include /etc/profile. At least on Fedora, /etc/profile contains a code to do add /usr/sbin to PATH. According to documentation fish should do that too...

[najamelan]

what I propose it to set this to priority minor, as it's not a very common setup and it can be worked around easily by using 'sudo fish' interactively, leaving the default shell to bash. I will try to look into this a bit further. If it is fish's fault for not setting up the environment than I will file an issue there, although it works on interactive tty, I have not yet figured out how fish sets up the environment exactly. The bigger problem here is that the breakage is unexpected and not trivial to debug, so if the problem is not on the fish end, say if this might break also on other shells like zsh, it would probably be good to mention in the docs for template VM's or AppVM that setting other default shells for root might break things.

[najamelan]

what I propose it to set this to priority minor, as it's not a very common setup and it can be worked around easily by using 'sudo fish' interactively, leaving the default shell to bash. I will try to look into this a bit further. If it is fish's fault for not setting up the environment than I will file an issue there, although it works on interactive tty, I have not yet figured out how fish sets up the environment exactly. The bigger problem here is that the breakage is unexpected and not trivial to debug, so if the problem is not on the fish end, say if this might break also on other shells like zsh, it would probably be good to mention in the docs for template VM's or AppVM that setting other default shells for root might break things.

[najamelan]

Resetting my default shell to /bin/bash has also magically fixed other things:

• I can now restart sys-net without rebooting qubes
• clocksync works

so yeah, documenting this might avoid some future problems for other users.

[najamelan]

Resetting my default shell to /bin/bash has also magically fixed other things:

• I can now restart sys-net without rebooting qubes
• clocksync works

so yeah, documenting this might avoid some future problems for other users.

[najamelan]

btw I would also propose to take it off the 4.0 milestone

[najamelan]

btw I would also propose to take it off the 4.0 milestone