Tutorial Knowledge Base
This repository contains the code that is referred to in the tutorial Integrating Rasa with knowledge bases.
- Chat with the Bot
- Limitations of Knowledge Bases
pip install -r requirements.txt
Setting up the Graph Database
Our knowledge base is represented by a graph database. In this repository Grakn is used as a graph database. However, you can also use any other graph database or use an alternative (see below).
In order to use this code example, you need to install Grakn. To be able to run this bot, you need version 1.5.7. Please check the installation instruction of Grakn in order to install it. Once you installed Grakn, you need to start the Grakn server by executing
grakn server start
You can stop the server by running
grakn server stop.
In order to get some data into the graph database you need to execute the following steps:
- Create the schema by executing
This will create a keyspace
grakn console --keyspace banking --file <absolute-path-to-knowledge_base/schema.gql>
bankingin your Grakn graph database with the schema defined in
- Load data into your schema by running
Grakn recommends you to write a
migrate.pyscript (see migration-python) to load data from csv files into your graph database. Our migration script loads the data located in
knowledge_base/datainto the keyspace
The graph database is set up and ready to be used.
Alternative to Graph Databases
If you just have a small knowledge base and you don't want to install and set up a graph database, such as Grakn,
you can also encode your domain knowledge in a data structure, such as a python dictionary.
You can find an example in the file
The file contains an implementation that uses a graph database (class
GraphDatabase) and an implementation
that simply uses a python dictionary as domain knowledge (class
If you want to use the
InMemoryGraph instead of the
GraphDatabase in the bot, you need to exchange the
initialization of the graph database in
But be aware of the fact, that the
InMemoryGraph does not cover the same knowledge as the
It just knows about banks and their attributes.
Chat with the Bot
Make sure you installed all requirements and your grakn server is running.
If you want to chat with the bot, execute the following steps:
- Train the bot using
- Start the action server with
rasa run actionsin a separate terminal.
- Chat with the bot on the command line by executing
If you want to see what slots are set and how confident the bot is in predicting the next action, you should run
the bot in debug mode:
rasa shell --debug.
Here are some example questions you can ask the bot:
- “What are my bank options?”
- “What is the headquarter of the first bank?”
- “What accounts do I have?”
- “What is my balance on the second account?”
- “What are my recent transactions?”
Limitations of Knowledge Bases
Before we look at the limitations of knowledge bases, let's first take a look, in what way an entity can be referenced:
|direct mention||Rasa is located in Berlin.||An entity was mentioned by its name in the text, such as Rasa or Berlin.|
|ordinal mention||Where is the headquarters of the third company?||The user was confronted to a list of entities. The user refers to an entity of that list by its position.|
|mention by synonym||What's my balance? vs. How much cash do I have?||The user refers to the same entity with different names.|
|ambiguous mention||I want to transfer money to John?||The bot can find multiple entities with the referenced name (e.g. John). The entity needs to be specified.|
|mention by pronoun||Rasa is located in Berlin. It is an open source company.||Reference to a previous mentioned entity by its pronoun, such as it.|
|mention by hypernyms & hyponyms||Here are some recent transactions: Raynair 99.95€, Spotify 9.99€. Which do you want to dispute?||The user can answer many things, such as "the subscription", or "the plane ticket". The bot needs to understand what entity the user refers to by those answers.|
|mention by attribute(s)||Where is the headquarters of the open source company that builds chatbots?||Find an entity in the knowledge base that fits the mentioned criteria.|
|mention by attribute comparison||Your last transactions: Amazon 99.95€, Netflix 4.99€. Which do you want to dispute?||If the user says, for example, "the bigger one", the bot needs to first resolve the comparison before he can detect the entity the user is referring to.|
The bot in this repo can handle some but not all of the cases above. Let's go over them one by one and take a closer look at what is possible and what are current limitations:
The direct mention is handled by the NER of Rasa. No knowledge base is needed to recognize an entity in a text. However, your knowledge base can be used to create lookup tables, that can then be used to improve the NER.
mention by pronoun
If an entity is referred to by its pronoun, the bot cannot detect it. Let's look at the example "My sister has a dog. She loves him." In the example "him" is referring to "dog" and "she" refers to "sister". However, for the bot it is hard to figure that out. Typically, coreference resolution models are used to solve this kind of mention. Here are some links to repositories:
With the smart use of slots, your bot is able to resolve an ordinal mention to its real-world entity (see code snippet).
As soon as multiple entities from the knowledge base are listed, the bot stores those in a specific slot (
The recognized ordinal mention needs to be mapped to an index and the entity can be picked up from the list of entities using the identified index.
mention by attribute(s)
Theoretically, your bot can find any entity by its attributes in its knowledge base. However, if you requested, for example, to name the transaction you did last month to Max, multiple nodes and relations in your graph database are involved. The query to fetch the requested entity becomes quite complex. The bot is currently not able to handle such complex requests. But, if you simply ask for a specific entity that just involves a node and its attributes in the graph database, the bot can answer your request.
Your bot should be able to help you resolve an ambiguous mention. For example, if you want to transfer money to John, but you have transferred money to John Doe and John Mustermann in the past, the bot needs you to confirm which exact John you meant. In order to archive that, the bot looks up the ambiguous entity in the knowledge base. If multiple entities are found, you will be confronted with the list of entities. You can then specify the entity you meant by, for example, using an ordinal mention.
mention by synonym
The bot uses mapping tables in the knowledge base to resolve synonyms, e.g. mapping
balance to the same entity.
However, this is limited to the names you defined in those mapping tables.
mention by hypernyms & hyponyms
The bot cannot handle mentions by hypernyms & hyponyms at the moment. Knowledge about, for example, Rynair selling plane tickets is missing. If such knowledge can be encoded in your knowledge base, more complex queries could be used to retrieve the information of interest.
mention by attribute comparison
If you say something like "Please, dispute the biggest of the just listed transactions.", the bot first needs to compare multiple entities by certain attributes before it can pick the entity of interest. As the bot currently cannot perform a comparison, this kind of mention cannot be handled by the bot at the moment.
Apart from the limitation already listed per mention type, the bot has some further limitations:
Comparing entities is still limited: The bot is not able to detect the comparison operator and can therefore not compare multiple entities in a proper way. For example, if the bot listed your accounts and you are asking "On what account do I currently have more money?". The bot needs to recognize not only that you are interested in the balance of the listed accounts, but also that "more money" means that the accounts need to be compared by their balance and you only want to know about the account with the highest balance. So far, the bot just lists the requested attribute for all entities and you have to "compare" yourself.
Executing complex queries: The bot tries to handle requests in a generic way. However, some user requests, such as "How much money did I transfer to Max from my N26 account in the last month.", require complex queries. The example request involves the nodes "person", "bank", and "account" as well as the relations "transaction" and "contract". As those requests are very specific and the resulting query is complex, the bot needs to handle them separately. However, this special treatment is currently not implemented, so that the bot is not able to answer complex queries that involve multiple nodes and relations.
If you have any questions about the tutorial or this repository, feel free to share them on Rasa Community Forum.