Skip to content

quickJump activates open mail tab instead of jumping to Folder in current tab #389

Closed

Description

@PotatoCarl

I have with the latest Pre-Version (the one that offers the filter dialog again) a new issue:
If I enter a folder name in the QuickJump Field and press enter, it jumps to an open Tab in that folder, but not as it is supposed to to the folder view.

Activity

  1. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 13, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    If there is already a tab open with a folder and you search for it (jump to it) using quickMove, then activating that tab is by design. My thinking behind this is that one may have the tab open for a reason (maybe working on some invoices etc.) and may have forgotten that it is open in another tab for some focused work. While it may be unexpected, there is definitely a reason behind it. Should the behavior be configurable?

  2. changed the title [-]QuickJumps does not jump to Folder[/-] [+]quickJump reuses a Thunderbird tab instead of jumping to Folder in current tab[/+] on Aug 13, 2023
  3. PotatoCarl commented on Aug 13, 2023

    @PotatoCarl
    Author

    Absolutely not. I have tabs open to remember the messages and handle them later(hours, days...)
    I use Folder Tabs for folders, but open Tabs for emails as a reminder. The folders are in fact different important, frequently used folders.
    The behaviour should be configureable, as I personally use quickjump to go to folders (I have hundreds) or sort messages into them/create filters.
    I use mail tabs as reminders and folder tabs for a few frequently used folders ("Draft"...).
    Thank you.

  4. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 13, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    Please distinguish between single mail tabs and folder tabs. It's not quite clear in your answer. jumping to a folder will not open an email tab, but it will "recycle" a folder tab. This is currently "by design" (not a bug) but I can look into adding options to disable this behavior.

  5. PotatoCarl commented on Aug 13, 2023

    @PotatoCarl
    Author

    Actually, QucikJump jumps here to a MAIL TAB (if the mail is in the folder that I want to jump to), NOT to a folder tab (which would be the same as walking down the tree, i.e. no problem).
    When I sort an email with QuickJump and there is a Mail Tab in that folder open, I cannot sort it away.
    So I have some mail tabs above the quickfolder line folder tabs. When I have an email open in the folder "mailingliste" in the mail tab, then sort from "posteingang" an email via quickjump to "mailingliste", instead of sorting and moving that email, he openes the mail tab (not the folder tab).
    This behaviour ocurred with 6.2.

  6. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 13, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    ok this description is weird and confusing.
    quickJump = Shitf+J and it goes to a folder
    quickMove = Shift+M and it moves mails (same as dragging an email to the quickJump / quickMove button
    which is it? Can you just provide a step by step description on what you do exactly I am getting confused because you seem to describe 3 different things. Can we just stick to one thing at a time?

  7. PotatoCarl commented on Aug 14, 2023

    @PotatoCarl
    Author

    grafik

    Move email on the button marked with arrow (where the popupmessag says "QuickJump". Then enter a folder name.

    Screenshot_20230814_174434

    If an email tab with an email in that folder is existing, it jumps to that tab. If not, it sorts into the corresponding folder...

    Clearer?

  8. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 14, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    ok, I am out of office. I will test that tonight... that behaviour is certainly not by design. it seems a regression caused by the new tab modes

  9. changed the title [-]quickJump reuses a Thunderbird tab instead of jumping to Folder in current tab[/-] [+]quickJump opens mail tab instead of jumping to Folder in current tab[/+] on Aug 16, 2023
  10. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 16, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    I have tested it and seems to happen once in a session, then not anymore. Stand by I am investigating this further.

  11. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 16, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    Ok, did some more testing, but couldn't reproduce it for now, there seems to be some additional condition that triggers it. For the moment, I made a minor fix that avoids throwing an error when I attempt to get the keyboard focus back to the thread pane:

    QuickFolders-mx-6.1.2pre8.zip

  12. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 16, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    I think I have fixed that now. The code to "reuse open folders" will now only look at the folder URI of tabs in mode "mail3PaneTab", so it will ignore single message tabs.

    QuickFolders-mx-6.1.2pre11.zip


    To test the version above, download the zip file, drag into Thunderbird Add-ons Manager, do not extract contents or if won't install.

  13. changed the title [-]quickJump opens mail tab instead of jumping to Folder in current tab[/-] [+]quickJump activates open mail tab instead of jumping to Folder in current tab[/+] on Aug 16, 2023
  14. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 18, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    I think I have fixed that now. The code to "reuse open folders" will now only look at the folder URI of tabs in mode "mail3PaneTab", so it will ignore single message tabs.

    @PotatoCarl does pre 6.1.2pre11(above) fix the issue for you?

  15. added a commit that references this issue on Aug 21, 2023
    49af73f
  16. PotatoCarl commented on Aug 21, 2023

    @PotatoCarl
    Author

    Yes.
    But I am really pissed at the moment at (probably) Thunderbird, as even after installing any "pre" version it takes some time and he goes back to the last stable version. How can I make sure that the pre-version is kept with Thunderbird. I had installed the pre-11 and today was back on 6.1.1.

  17. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 21, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    Yes. But I am really pissed at the moment at (probably) Thunderbird, as even after installing any "pre" version it takes some time and he goes back to the last stable version. How can I make sure that the pre-version is kept with Thunderbird. I had installed the pre-11 and today was back on 6.1.1.

    that is really strange / unexpected. everything 6.1.2 necessarily > than 6.1.1 - no idea what's happening on that front.

  18. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 21, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    Yes. But I am really pissed at the moment at (probably) Thunderbird, as even after installing any "pre" version it takes some time and he goes back to the last stable version. How can I make sure that the pre-version is kept with Thunderbird. I had installed the pre-11 and today was back on 6.1.1.

    Does this happen immediately when you click "check for updates" on the Extension Manager tools menu?

    image

  19. PotatoCarl commented on Aug 21, 2023

    @PotatoCarl
    Author

    Nope. Then it shows "no update found". But sometime later, sometimes one or two days later, it kind of downgrades. No idea where it comes from. But happened several times now. It also does not show any message, but reverts back to the old version.

  20. RealRaven2000 commented on Aug 21, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    Nope. Then it shows "no update found". But sometime later, sometimes one or two days later, it kind of downgrades. No idea where it comes from. But happened several times now. It also does not show any message, but reverts back to the old version.

    hmmm, never heard of such a behavior before. Some backup / restore / wayback machine / antivirus stuff interfering? I have absolutely no idea, it doesn't sound like it's done by Thunderbird voluntarily....

  21. RealRaven2000 commented on Sep 2, 2023

    @RealRaven2000
    Owner

    Fixed in 6.2 - Published 30/08/2023

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions