An integration test framework for practically anything.
Smoke is designed to test anything that can be wrapped with a command-line interface. In practice, this amounts to almost any application or large piece of code. Whatever you're working on, no matter how big or complicated, you can usually wrap a CLI around it with minimum effort.
Smoke works especially well for testing large applications, especially after the fact. It allows you to create regression tests, golden master tests, and other things that make refactoring a legacy application much easier.
It's not a replacement for other, smaller tests. We recommend writing unit tests (perhaps even first), especially for new code.
Currently, Smoke is in alpha, and as such is not packaged. You will need to build it yourself.
- Install Stack, which we will use to compile the Haskell code.
- Clone the repository and
cdinto the directory.
stack setupto download the correct version of GHC.
stack install --local-bin-path=out/buildto build the application.
- Copy the application binary at
out/build/smoke-exeto wherever you need it to go.
If you are using Nix you can build Smoke via
Smoke is distributed under the MIT license.
Writing Test Cases
A test case consists of input and expected output. It is constructed of a number of files with the same name and different extensions.
First off, you need to specify the command itself.
- The command is specified in a file named
command, with parameters each on a new line. It is executed from the current working directory.
- The command can be overriden for each individual test case by creating a file with the
Input can come in two forms: standard input and command-line arguments.
- Standard input is specified by naming the file with the extension
- Command-line arguments are specified in a file with the
.argsextension, one per line.
Outputs that can be observed by Smoke consist of standard output, standard error and the exit status of the program.
- Expected standard output is specified with the
.outextension. Alternatively, multiple possible expected outputs can be specified by using an extension that starts with
.outc. If there are multiple outputs, a match with any of them will be considered a success.
- Expected standard error uses the
.errextension, but otherwise works in exactly the same way as expected standard output.
- The expected exit status is a file with the
.statusextension. It contains a single number between
At least one of standard output and standard error must be specified, though it can be empty. If no exit status is specified, it will be assumed to be
Our simplest calculator test case consists of three files:
2 + 2
We might want to assert that certain things fail. For example, postfix notation should fail because the second token is expected to be an operator. In this example, our calculator is expected to produce a semi-reasonable error message and exit with a status of
2 to signify a parsing error.
5 3 *
"3" is not a valid operator.
In order to run tests against an application, you simply invoke Smoke with the command required to invoke the application, and the directory containing the tests. Given an application that is invoked with
ruby bin/calculator.rb, and the tests in the test directory, we would run the tests as follows:
Tests can also be passed on an individual basis:
smoke test/addition test/postfix-notation-fails
To override the command, or to specify it on the command line in place of the
command file, you can use the
smoke --command='ruby calculator.rb' test
Bear in mind that Smoke simply splits the argument to the
--command option by whitespace, so quoting, escaping, etc. will not work. For anything complicated, use a file instead.
Smoke will exit with a code of
0 if all tests succeed, or
1 if any test fails, or if the invocation of Smoke itself was not understood (for example, if no test locations are provided).
Output will be in color if outputting to a terminal. You can force color output on or off with the
Enjoy. Any feedback is welcome.
We had a problem at work. It was a pretty nice problem to have. We were getting too many job applicants and we needed to screen them quickly. So we put some tests online and pointed the
guinea pigs at 'em.
We quickly found we had another problem: it was taking a lot of developer time to decide whether we should bring in the furballs for real-life interviews. So one night, while more than a little tipsy, I wrote Smoke.
We let our interview candidates write code in whatever they like: Java, C#, Python, Ruby… I needed a test framework that could handle any language under the sun. At first, I thought about ways to crowbar RSpec into running tests for applications in any and all languages. This was a stupid idea. Eventually I decided the only thing every language has in common is the command line: every language can pretty easily support standard input and output (with the obvious exception of Java, which makes everything difficult).
I have to stress that this is not a replacement for looking over people's code. I've invited people for further interview even when failed every one of my test cases, because they understood the problem and mostly solved it. Similarly, someone that passes every case but writes Python like people wrote C in the 80s makes me very sad, despite all the green output from Smoke.
Issues and pull requests are very welcome. Please don't hesitate.
Developers of Smoke pledge to follow the Contributor Covenant.
You will need to set up Stack as above, and install a few dependencies:
We dog-food. Smoke is tested using itself.
Before committing, these four commands should be run, and any failures should be fixed:
make build # Builds the application using Stack. make test # Tests the application using itself, with the tests in the "test" directory. make lint # Lints the code using HLint. make reformat # Reformats the code using hindent.
On Windows, Makefiles don't work very well, so run the commands directly:
stack install --local-bin-path=out\build .\out\build\smoke-exe --command=.\out\build\smoke-exe test stack exec -- hlint . stack exec -- hindent Setup.hs $(find app src -name '*.hs')
Smoke should work on Linux and macOS without any issue. Almost all features should also work on Windows, with the exception of allowing scripts as commands. This is due to a (quite reasonable) limitation of Windows; you can't make text files executable.