Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner. It is now read-only.

Dashing is no longer maintained #711

Closed
pushmatrix opened this issue Apr 12, 2016 · 42 comments
Closed

Dashing is no longer maintained #711

pushmatrix opened this issue Apr 12, 2016 · 42 comments

Comments

@pushmatrix
Copy link
Member

@pushmatrix pushmatrix commented Apr 12, 2016

As of today, Dashing is no longer being actively maintained. That doesn't mean that it's going away, though. This repo will still be around as reference for all to use.

Dashing was built to be a simple project to quickly hack together dashboards. There were plans for a 2.0 version, but unfortunately those had to be put aside as we've significantly reduced our use of Dashing internally ( a lot has been moved over to DataDog ). Apologies for the pull requests that did not get merged. I wanted to keep this project as simple and stripped down as possible so that it was easy for people to read the source and pick it up. For those learning ruby, it's a great library to tinker with, and for those with more experience, it provides a great base to expand upon.

I am extremely blown away by the popularity this little gem has managed to attract. The large list of community widgets and all of the help answering issues and Stack Overflow questions is greatly appreciated. An especially large thanks goes out to @tylermauthe who has gone above and beyond to help maintain this project in recent times.

I have no doubt that Dashing will still be useful for years to come. Keep it classy!

Daniel

@brint
Copy link

@brint brint commented Apr 12, 2016

😢 We've used dashing for tons of dashboards over the years. Thanks for all the work you put in to make dashing a thing.

@tylermauthe
Copy link
Contributor

@tylermauthe tylermauthe commented Apr 12, 2016

Thanks for the shout out and all your work creating Dashing and making it the simple, yet powerful tool it is.

Dashing was the first Ruby project I took a real interest in and got involved with -- because I love data, Ruby and visualizations. The simplicity and readability of the source really showed me how elegant Ruby can be. It was immediately evident that this was a tool made with love by developers for developers.

I'm happy to have been a part of the journey and I'm sure that Dashing will still enlighten a few as to the elegance of Ruby.

@micke2k
Copy link

@micke2k micke2k commented Apr 12, 2016

So @tylermauthe, when are you forking and continuing development ? :)

Also thanks for all the work made so far by everyone!

@tylermauthe
Copy link
Contributor

@tylermauthe tylermauthe commented Apr 12, 2016

@micke2k I don't have enough time to spare for that sort of effort at the moment -- maybe in the future (unless someone beats me to it!)

@micke2k
Copy link

@micke2k micke2k commented Apr 13, 2016

Alright, i will keep a look out 👍

@pmyjavec
Copy link

@pmyjavec pmyjavec commented Apr 13, 2016

Devastating,

Thanks for everything thus far.

@machadolab
Copy link

@machadolab machadolab commented Apr 15, 2016

Thanks guys!

@jordan-thoms
Copy link

@jordan-thoms jordan-thoms commented Apr 18, 2016

Thanks! I think we will be using this for a while yet regardless 👍

@dragonai
Copy link

@dragonai dragonai commented Apr 18, 2016

I had lots of fun with Dashing and very much enjoyed contributing a few widgets myself! Thanks for this awesome little framework. :)

@bscott
Copy link

@bscott bscott commented Apr 21, 2016

@pushmatrix Thank you for such a awesome project!, have you tried transfering ownership to others as DataDog is a cool product, some folks can't justify the $ to move over to it.

@anatol
Copy link

@anatol anatol commented Apr 22, 2016

Just found this great project. And also learned that it had been abandoned :(

pushmatrix@, could you hand off the project ownership to some other developer?

@davefp
Copy link
Contributor

@davefp davefp commented Apr 25, 2016

@pushmatrix Thanks for keeping Dashing going all this time, and congrats on building one of the most popular dashboard projects out there. You're awesome 👍

@labynocle
Copy link

@labynocle labynocle commented Apr 25, 2016

I created first monitoring dashboards at Deezer with Dashing... Very sad to see this thread :(

Thanks for all @pushmatrix ! Dashing is a great project :)

@knowledgewarrior
Copy link

@knowledgewarrior knowledgewarrior commented Apr 25, 2016

Used Dashing for over 2 years. If there's enough interest, it should be continued to be maintained.

@anatol
Copy link

@anatol anatol commented Apr 25, 2016

Agree that such a useful project should live and kept developing.

@pushmatrix, could you please move dashing to a github organization and add a few current active contributors?

@krongk
Copy link

@krongk krongk commented Apr 26, 2016

Dashing是我见过的最简单的仪表盘设计,非常棒!

@Guildenstern
Copy link

@Guildenstern Guildenstern commented Apr 27, 2016

I hope someone will adopt this neat piece of FOSS.
Are there any good alternatives for a self-hosted dashboard?

@davefp
Copy link
Contributor

@davefp davefp commented Apr 28, 2016

I've been building a Dashing clone that uses React on the frontend for a while now: https://github.com/davefp/handsome

It's still a work in progress and doesn't have anything in the way of integrations yet, but if anyone is interested in helping out or using it they can get in touch with me!

@jetrois
Copy link

@jetrois jetrois commented May 4, 2016

Sad to see it go I didn't know thee well.

@alexmoras
Copy link

@alexmoras alexmoras commented May 19, 2016

I've forked it and moved it over to an org. Don't know how useful it will be but here's the link. https://github.com/Dashing-io/dashing. Will be adding contributors soon, just hit me up with who I should be adding.

@casdr
Copy link

@casdr casdr commented Jun 3, 2016

Thank you for creating this great piece of software. We're running Dashing at 8 displays and I've been working on building widgets for internal tools.

I think we should set up an "official" fork which the current repo will redirect to. This way the Shopify team won't be bothered anymore but it will be still centralized.

@fuzzy76
Copy link

@fuzzy76 fuzzy76 commented Jun 7, 2016

Would you be willing to link to the new fork on the homepage and in the readme?

@webmaster128
Copy link

@webmaster128 webmaster128 commented Jun 10, 2016

And do you agree that some new fork continues to use the current name "dashing"?

@kinow
Copy link

@kinow kinow commented Jun 12, 2016

Happy to contribute and keep using the fork (that's Dashing-io/dashing right?).

@pushmatrix
Copy link
Member Author

@pushmatrix pushmatrix commented Jun 13, 2016

@fuzzy76 @webmaster128 Yes of course!

@mgifford
Copy link

@mgifford mgifford commented Jul 15, 2016

@pushmatrix Seems that there's some critical mass behind https://github.com/Dashing-io/dashing

Can you point references from http://dashing.io/ & https://github.com/Shopify/dashing to this new organization to help maintain this code base?

It seems that there are already 52 people contributing there (which is amazing) but all of the documentation still points to the discontinued code github project page.

Thanks @fuzzy76 @AlexMorasUK and of course the original team (was this entirely a Shopify project that was open-sourced?)!

ps. @pushmatrix looks like most of the developers are in Ottawa. Hopefully we meet in person at some point and I can buy you a beer for this neat project.

@webmaster128
Copy link

@webmaster128 webmaster128 commented Jul 16, 2016

@mgifford Do you consider 3 commits a critical mass? As far as I can see, those 52 comitters are from the original project. AlexMorasUK never contributed anything to the original code.

Would be great to see some people maintaining a fork, who have been active in the original project and knowing the code structure.

@kinow
Copy link

@kinow kinow commented Jul 16, 2016

@webmaster128 there are some people already involved, talking in GitHub, working on issues, but you are correct none has committed yet (I think).

There is already one pull request that I think would be useful, but not sure about security (Smashing/smashing#7). I don't want to start committing things without a consensus from the newly formed team and the rest of the community - and I believe others feel the same way.

Different from other projects, where a fork started with some of the previous committers, this fork has been created as the committers stopped working on the code base. So it is expected that there may be a hiatus until the members of the newly created group get to know each other.

We are slowly getting to know each other, and talking about the issues we have, and how to fix. You can contribute there if you'd like 😃

@alexmoras
Copy link

@alexmoras alexmoras commented Jul 16, 2016

Hey, just wanted to say that I started the org as a way to move everything over to a new place so we could start again, in a sense, by moving away from Shopify. Only reason I haven't taken an active part is because I was planning on doing a little bug-hunting and fixing however work and school took over. Just a little update for y'all.

@webmaster128
Copy link

@webmaster128 webmaster128 commented Jul 17, 2016

@AlexMorasUK @kinow @mgifford I really welcome the effort and as a user of dashing, I'd love to see an active, reliable community around the product.

I am just wondering what the plans for the fork are. Who the maintainers are, what your plans are. Who is going to get write-access of the repo? Is it a one-man show or a team? Should the organization remain Dashing-io when you don't get the domain dashing.io. Is it necessary to give the product a new name to get a new gem entry?

I think some kind of announcement that leave space for discussion is just as necessary as working on the code base.

@kinow
Copy link

@kinow kinow commented Jul 17, 2016

I am probably not the best to answer your questions, but I believe they are valid concerns, and will leave my own opinion here :-)

I am just wondering what the plans for the fork are.

I believe the main goal is to keep the project being maintained, rather than seeing it simply stop the development.

Who the maintainers are, what your plans are.

I was invited to the organisation, but haven't contributed much yet. I have been using Dashing for the last three years I think. Used the NodeJS version too, which is not being maintained any more. My plan is simple; try to help as much as I can (specially given I can use some hours at $work, as they have almost 10 dashboards now, used by different departments).

Is it a one-man show or a team?

That will probably, and hopefully, a team. But again, it is rather in the beginning of the fork, and as I said before, we are getting to know each other. Expecting that the whole team will start working, as fast and effective as the previous team, is probably asking too much right now.

Should the organization remain Dashing-io when you don't get the domain dashing.io.

For the time being, shopify is kindly maintaining the domain. I believe we are almost reaching the consensus to use GitHub pages instead. Then options would be find a way to maintain the domain name ourselves (under a group of users, foundation, company, etc), or start redirecting dashing.io to the GitHub page (HTTP 301), inform users, update links and give enough time for people to get used to the new domain.

Is it necessary to give the product a new name to get a new gem entry?

Good question. If you could file an issue we could perhaps discuss it there, as I think we could end up digressing from the question in this issue 😃

@mgifford
Copy link

@mgifford mgifford commented Jul 18, 2016

@webmaster128 It is sad to see a good project die. I think there are ways to revitalize it.

There's a much better chance of https://github.com/Dashing-io successfully carrying this forward than anyone else. At least at this time.

Putting a link to https://github.com/Dashing-io would be a good first step. If there's momentum after an acknowledgement then perhaps you'd want to see switching the domain.

I've got no idea how gem entries are managed. I'd hope that it wouldn't need a whole re-branding. I wouldn't expect Daniel Beauchamp to relinquish the domain unless this transition is successful. However, eventually I think it would make sense.

Given that there's been no official acknowledgement of either fork, it's encouraging to see that there is any support behind it. Imagine how many folks will be interested if:

  1. the fork is acknowledged
  2. there is a call for developers to sign on to maintain the code
@pushmatrix
Copy link
Member Author

@pushmatrix pushmatrix commented Jul 18, 2016

@mgifford Maybe not big enough, but there has been mention of the fork for some time:
screen shot 2016-07-18 at 10 26 47 am


screen shot 2016-07-18 at 10 27 45 am

@mgifford
Copy link

@mgifford mgifford commented Jul 18, 2016

Whoops.. I missed that..

@chrisdwheatley
Copy link

@chrisdwheatley chrisdwheatley commented Aug 28, 2016

I've been working on something similar to Dashing for a while now and wanted to share my initial implementation and hopefully get some feedback.

It's called Radiate and you can see a demo at http://radiate.site.

It relies on an experimental CSS feature called Grid Layout right now so support is a little patchy but there are instructions on how to get up and running on the site and in the readme.

@jschulenklopper
Copy link

@jschulenklopper jschulenklopper commented Jan 12, 2017

For the people visiting this issue (for example via a Google search on "Dashing"): the project lives on as "Smashing" at https://github.com/Smashing/smashing.

@alexschwartz
Copy link

@alexschwartz alexschwartz commented Jan 20, 2017

Great to hear that "Dashing" is lives on as "Smashing".

I wonder, could this be told on the dashing.io website?

@webmaster128
Copy link

@webmaster128 webmaster128 commented Jan 20, 2017

I wonder, could this be told on the dashing.io website?

Smashing is linked on the website in

Heads-up: Dashing still works great, but is no longer maintained. Read up about it over here.
You can also use the fork of the project.

@jschulenklopper
Copy link

@jschulenklopper jschulenklopper commented Jan 20, 2017

That would be a great change, @alexschwartz. I don't know where the repository for the website behind http://dashing.io/ is though, so don't know where to register a Pull Request.

@jschulenklopper
Copy link

@jschulenklopper jschulenklopper commented Jan 20, 2017

@webmaster128, Smashing is linked, but only indirectly. Only when forking the project, the fork of https://github.com/dashing-io/dashing is 301-redirected to the Smashing repository... and "Read up about it over here" links to... this issue :-)

I guess it is @alexschwartz's intention that the dashing.io page contains an explicit and comforting notification "Good news: Dashing lives on as Smashing", in addition to the implicit redirect that people discover when forking the project.

@tylermauthe
Copy link
Contributor

@tylermauthe tylermauthe commented Jan 20, 2017

@Jackuna
Copy link

@Jackuna Jackuna commented Jan 25, 2018

You made a very awesome work together, Your Dashboards gives a cool feeling everyday when i see my big monitoring screen.

Hats off to your work.

rdoproject pushed a commit to rdo-infra/rdo-dashboards that referenced this issue Feb 6, 2018
Context: https://trello.com/c/q1nNrcOz

This commit updates the dashboards to include release specific
dashboards for master, pike, and ocata RDO releases that obtain
promotion metadata from the dlrnapi.

It also updates from dashing (old) to smashing (new).  Smashing is the
community updated/maintained fork of the original dashing project, which
has now been mothballed.

Note that when the dashing community forked the project, they
renamed it to "smashing" but did not rename the underlying classes.
The template for config.ru requires 'dashing' and the Gemfile pulls
in the newer 'smashing'

- https://github.com/Smashing/smashing/blob/master/lib/dashing.rb

The deployment role has also been updated to execute "smashing start"
vs. "dashing start"

- https://review.rdoproject.org/r/#/c/11662

More information:

- https://smashing.github.io
- Shopify/dashing#711
- https://github.com/halcyondude/delorean-metrics/tree/master/dlrnapi-dashboard
- https://github.com/softwarefactory-project/DLRN/blob/master/doc/api_definition.yaml
- https://github.com/softwarefactory-project/dlrnapi_client

Change-Id: I3156407d388d20febed3840568e7b5992e727ee7
rdoproject pushed a commit to rdo-infra/ansible-role-rdo_dashboards that referenced this issue Feb 6, 2018
This is part of a multi repo / patch set.

Background / More Info:

- https://smashing.github.io
- Shopify/dashing#711

Depends-On: https://review.rdoproject.org/r/#/c/11575

Change-Id: Icee7050e6ec9be0814cf12cb60e1bc8b99d5eb96
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Projects
None yet
Linked pull requests

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

None yet
You can’t perform that action at this time.