Community Audit - Reward Distribution! 💸

[sebayaki]

🙏🏻 Thank you!

The community audit event for Mint Club V2 contract is now complete.
In total, 15 developers contributed to this review process:

• @dzypherit
• @exd0tpy
• @web3isthefuture
• @0x3agle
• @ddimitrov22
• @the-first-elder
• @madMax92221
• @Tech-Icons
• @sirius651
• @weed0607
• @KupiaSecAdmin
• @holyhansss
• @alsldl
• @Paschal695
• @inmarelibero

Thank you all for your valuable time and contributions! 👍🏻

I have evaluated all contributions as fairly as possible, considering the importance of the contributions and the amount of work put into the reviewing process.

🎅🏻 Here is the reward distribution table:

Please double-check your wallet address on the distribution table. If you haven't included your wallet address in your first contribution, please leave your Ethereum wallet address here to receive your USDT reward. The missing addresses are:

• @web3isthefuture
• @0x3agle
• @ddimitrov22
• @the-first-elder
• @madMax92221
• @weed0607
• @holyhansss
• @Paschal695
• @inmarelibero

If you prefer not to share your address publicly, you can send it to our email instead: admin@hunt.town.

The reward will be distributed on the 26th of December as promised.
Thank you, everyone, and Merry Christmas to all! 🎄

[litchdoteth]

I apologize, but I've run out of time to review the code thoroughly. Some urgent priorities have come up on my end. Congrats participants.

[web3isthefuture]

Thanks for having me here :)
0x8db78825497Bf47Cea2c2d65333Cc6Faf4a7A7F6

[0x3agle]

Hey all, I'm glad to contribute to strengthening Mint Club V2's smart contracts.
A big thanks to @sydneyitguy for this incredible opportunity 🙌

Merry Christmas 🎄

• Polygon/ETH Mainnet Address: 0x6DC8236735e0c60B511a57b5A9c38C3559617D5B

[the-first-elder]

Thank you @sydneyitguy for the opportunity. I'm always open to working with you guys. Merry Christmas to everyone.

0xf0009d96f8061411146f19393525349C5F74b90C

[Paschal695]

Thanks for the opportunity,here’s my address

0x381aCa102D5d10712a4429d1106b80D10c12ab45

[madMax92221]

Happy Holidays all! Thanks for having me! :

ETH mainnet:

0x59dA688CF5d3Bc3E29FC5d0EdFEb6196Cae196cE

[thisisdaniel333]

Thank you for having me in this opportunity. It was fun doing auditing. Happy Holidays guys, Merry Christmas! @holyhansss ETH Address: 0x010f79879241cd6cDDFFC67B809CeF8a31Cf6319 2023년 12월 23일 (토) 오후 12:01, sydneyitguy ***@***.***>님이 작성:

…

🙏🏻 Thank you! The community audit event for Mint Club V2 contract is now complete. In total, 15 developers contributed to this review process: - @dzypherit <https://github.com/dzypherit> - @exd0tpy <https://github.com/exd0tpy> - @web3isthefuture <https://github.com/web3isthefuture> - @0x3agle <https://github.com/0x3agle> - @ddimitrov22 <https://github.com/ddimitrov22> - @the-first-elder <https://github.com/the-first-elder> - @madMax92221 <https://github.com/madMax92221> - @Tech-Icons <https://github.com/Tech-Icons> - @sirius651 <https://github.com/sirius651> - @weed0607 <https://github.com/weed0607> - @KupiaSecAdmin <https://github.com/KupiaSecAdmin> - @holyhansss <https://github.com/holyhansss> - @alsldl <https://github.com/alsldl> - @Paschal695 <https://github.com/Paschal695> - @inmarelibero <https://github.com/inmarelibero> Thank you all for your valuable time and contributions! 👍🏻 I have evaluated all contributions as fairly as possible, considering the importance of the contributions and the amount of work put into the reviewing process. 🎅🏻 Here is the reward distribution table: image.png (view on web) <https://github.com/Steemhunt/mint.club-v2-contract/assets/1332279/a0fbda87-416b-4625-9403-8051aa350b4e> Please double-check your wallet address on the distribution table. If you haven't included your wallet address in your first contribution, please leave your Ethereum wallet address here to receive your USDT reward. The missing addresses are: - @web3isthefuture <https://github.com/web3isthefuture> - @0x3agle <https://github.com/0x3agle> - @ddimitrov22 <https://github.com/ddimitrov22> - @the-first-elder <https://github.com/the-first-elder> - @madMax92221 <https://github.com/madMax92221> - @weed0607 <https://github.com/weed0607> - @holyhansss <https://github.com/holyhansss> - @Paschal695 <https://github.com/Paschal695> - @inmarelibero <https://github.com/inmarelibero> If you prefer not to share your address publicly, you can send it to our email instead: ***@***.*** — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#72>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/APFUJS3LDKR63IQEUKXU653YKZCRVAVCNFSM6AAAAABBAPQPP6VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43ASLTON2WKOZSGA2TINRTGMZDCMA> . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[ddimitrov22]

Happy Holidays all! Thanks for having me! :

ETH mainnet:

0x59dA688CF5d3Bc3E29FC5d0EdFEb6196Cae196cE

Happy holidays from me as well! You can send my share to the same address as madMax92221:

ETH mainnet:

0x59dA688CF5d3Bc3E29FC5d0EdFEb6196Cae196cE

[inmarelibero]

ETH wallet: 0xa9De8755FaCD88Fd82894afD2C014C860993042f

thank you, enjoyed it!

[weed0607]

eth wallet: 0x9A3032f0321396D3378D3681F42006144346d860
Thank you, although didn't find anything...

[KupiaSecAdmin]

Happy holidays!
This was the first time we worked on a community audit and we appreciate the opportunity.
We have a suggestion regarding the "rule" though. (rewarding formula, giving points to findings)
It is a bit disappointing that the LOW severity findings and comments are valued and rewarded much more than a HIGH severity finding. We see there were only a single HIGH severity finding and 3~4 MEDIUM findings and bunch of LOW ones.
In the sense of impact, we believe a HIGH finding is 100 times more valuable than a LOW finding.
Most of the low ones are something that could be found using static analyzers and seemingly the current rewarding rule strongly discourages manual reviewers.
Maybe, we did not understand the rule clearly (were there any rules specified somewhere? like giving X points for 1 valid comment?)
We respectfully suggest the team to reconsider the rewarding formulas while we understand it might be not feasible to change the result at this point.
Regards.

[KupiaSecAdmin]

Just guessing from the result sheet, it seems like 33:28:18 are the weights of HIGH:MEDIUM:TRIVIAL for the contribution point.
While the team is a rule maker, we want to remind that the HIGH:MEDIUM ratio is 10:3 at Code4rena and 5:1 at Sherlock

[0x3agle]

@KupiaSecAdmin

"Maybe, we did not understand the rule clearly (were there any rules specified somewhere? like giving X points for 1 valid comment?)"

( From COMMUNITY_AUDIT.md)

Collaborate and Provide Feedback: Engage with the community by commenting on and providing feedback to other contributors' submissions. These interactions will also contribute to your participation.

[0x3agle]

Just guessing from the result sheet, it seems like 33:28:18 are the weights of HIGH:MEDIUM:TRIVIAL for the contribution point.

While the team is a rule maker, we want to remind that the HIGH:MEDIUM ratio is 10:3 at Code4rena and 5:1 at Sherlock

C4 and Sherlock is different as the rewards are distributed to all finders of the issue.
In this audit type only the first finder is rewarded for the issue.