diff --git a/data_for_second_barchart.csv b/data_for_second_barchart.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2901976 --- /dev/null +++ b/data_for_second_barchart.csv @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +,Alt-Ergo-0.95.2,Alt-Ergo-1.01,Best,CVC3,CVC4,Random,Where4 Forest,Worst,Yices,Z3-4.3.2,Z3-4.4.1,veriT +Failure,0,0,7,8,0,0,0,10,16,8,9,13 +Invalid,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0 +Timeout,58,50,19,61,103,88,55,161,72,107,105,112 +Unknown,41,36,34,27,13,17,30,30,62,3,4,38 +Valid,164,177,203,167,147,158,178,62,113,145,145,100 diff --git a/data_for_second_linegraph.csv b/data_for_second_linegraph.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..de17b97 --- /dev/null +++ b/data_for_second_linegraph.csv @@ -0,0 +1,264 @@ +,Alt-Ergo-0.95.2 result,Alt-Ergo-0.95.2 time,Alt-Ergo-1.01 result,Alt-Ergo-1.01 time,CVC3 result,CVC3 time,CVC4 result,CVC4 time,Yices result,Yices time,Z3-4.3.2 result,Z3-4.3.2 time,Z3-4.4.1 result,Z3-4.4.1 time,and,as,avg_op_arity,case,depth,divisor,eps,exists,false,file,float,forall,func,goal,if,iff,impl,int,let,n_branches,n_ops,n_preds,n_quants,not,or,size,theory,true,var,veriT result,veriT time,wild,zero_ar,Z3-4.4.1,Z3-4.3.2,CVC3,CVC4,Yices,veriT,Alt-Ergo-1.01,Alt-Ergo-0.95.2,Predicted Alt-Ergo-0.95.2,Predicted Alt-Ergo-1.01,Predicted CVC3,Predicted CVC4,Predicted Yices,Predicted Z3-4.3.2,Predicted Z3-4.4.1,Predicted veriT,key,rf,rf time,rf result,best,best time,best result,worst,worst time,worst result,dt,dt time,dt result,rand time +algo64:Algo64:WP_parameter qs,Valid,0.1417702986,Valid,0.144168389909,Valid,0.155903339425,Valid,0.199770886,Timeout,10.1305134988,Valid,0.1495368046,Valid,0.17330425934,7.0,0.0,2.344828,0.0,14.0,29.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,algo64.mlw,0.0,2.0,17.0,WP_parameter qs,1.0,0.0,2.0,13.0,3.0,37.0,30.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,69.0,Algo64,0.0,24.0,Valid,0.1196706252,0.0,0.0,0.17330425934,0.1495368046,0.155903339425,0.199770886,14.2347217658,0.1196706252,0.144168389909,0.1417702986,4.26685939935,3.43642548724,3.38178364817,6.73819915356,5.43466965013,2.83260687622,2.70743703092,4.55185777932,algo64:Algo64:WP_parameter qs,Zz3Aavy4,0.17330425934,Valid,vaAz3Z4y,0.1196706252,Valid,y4Z3zAav,10.3302843848,Valid,vzZ3Aa4y,0.1196706252,Valid,1.42118913065 +algo64:Algo64:WP_parameter quicksort,Timeout,11.10764641,Valid,1.24336445806,Unknown,3.37014803291,Timeout,10.2428171616,Timeout,10.1320052184,Timeout,10.1500691392,Timeout,10.1493484674,34.0,0.0,2.306306,0.0,24.0,111.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,algo64.mlw,0.0,7.0,66.0,WP_parameter quicksort,1.0,0.0,7.0,24.0,4.0,138.0,112.0,1.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,257.0,Algo64,0.0,114.0,Timeout,10.1065849062,0.0,0.0,14.2481323096,14.2486456736,13.3701480329,14.3148630244,14.2357834258,14.2177022921,1.24336445806,14.9458960511,7.88000225134,6.7929752646,8.16490970922,9.15878456321,9.02266845236,8.17730474566,8.21970739423,10.6557307963,algo64:Algo64:WP_parameter quicksort,Aa3zZy4v,1.24336445806,Valid,A3vyZz4a,1.24336445806,Valid,a4zZyv3A,66.5019837938,Valid,yzZA4a3v,31.6747872831,Valid,33.8726741259 +assigning_meanings_to_programs:Division:WP_parameter division,Valid,0.1134789336,Valid,0.123863276735,Valid,0.09831209516,Valid,0.125075420022,Unknown,0.09332588692,Valid,0.141274788732,Valid,0.1206830878,9.0,0.0,2.179487,0.0,16.0,39.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,assigning_meanings_to_programs.mlw,0.0,4.0,26.0,WP_parameter division,1.0,0.0,4.0,9.0,0.0,42.0,40.0,1.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,86.0,Division,0.0,33.0,Unknown,0.09441667634,0.0,0.0,0.1206830878,0.141274788732,0.09831209516,0.125075420022,10.0933258869,10.0944166763,0.123863276735,0.1134789336,4.14417615234,3.14845977375,3.54499499595,4.49844400208,6.98473493236,4.11217982169,3.77965182962,6.96368593158,assigning_meanings_to_programs:Division:WP_parameter division,A3Zza4vy,0.123863276735,Valid,3aZA4zyv,0.09831209516,Valid,vyz4AZa3,0.329017351992,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.09831209516,Valid,0.147268299855 +assigning_meanings_to_programs:Sum:WP_parameter sum,Valid,0.1249513174,Valid,0.135712000522,Valid,0.1129616778,Valid,0.172411418174,Valid,0.128384678128,Valid,0.153488968591,Valid,0.185854883902,13.0,0.0,2.215686,0.0,17.0,51.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,assigning_meanings_to_programs.mlw,0.0,4.0,34.0,WP_parameter sum,1.0,0.0,4.0,20.0,0.0,58.0,52.0,1.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,114.0,Sum,0.0,38.0,Timeout,10.084403065,0.0,0.0,0.185854883902,0.153488968591,0.1129616778,0.172411418174,0.128384678128,14.2019430071,0.135712000522,0.1249513174,4.51579275603,3.8062975406,3.3917606168,5.42344614141,5.3065873028,3.75034275169,3.61558538603,6.19894701457,assigning_meanings_to_programs:Sum:WP_parameter sum,3ZzAay4v,0.1129616778,Valid,3ayAz4Zv,0.1129616778,Valid,vZ4zAya3,10.2702579489,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.1129616778,Valid,1.40537394663 +balance:Puzzle12:WP_parameter solve12,Valid,1.3147664975,Valid,1.3298766946,Failure,7.28657493114,Valid,0.370115346,Valid,0.161969135909,Valid,0.20464282693,Valid,0.219374184105,142.0,0.0,1.836842,26.0,43.0,570.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,balance.mlw,0.0,29.0,385.0,WP_parameter solve12,1.0,0.0,16.0,226.0,26.0,624.0,597.0,27.0,29.0,1.0,0.0,1150.0,Puzzle12,0.0,296.0,Valid,0.17624770069,2.0,100.0,0.219374184105,0.20464282693,12.3731230588,0.370115346,0.161969135909,0.17624770069,1.3298766946,1.3147664975,13.9459425044,12.465102573,12.6984858291,13.8936246491,13.3961793487,11.9697976019,12.1982365507,13.157081494,balance:Puzzle12:WP_parameter solve12,zZA3vy4a,0.20464282693,Valid,yvzZ4aA3,0.161969135909,Valid,3Aa4Zzvy,8.61645162574,Valid,ZzyvA34a,0.219374184105,Valid,1.45039220721 +balance:Puzzle8:WP_parameter solve3,Valid,0.157569828564,Valid,0.161820824447,Valid,0.1417758008,Timeout,10.1758916292,Valid,0.1202484854,Valid,0.1426334326,Valid,0.17424867724,11.0,0.0,2.019608,2.0,17.0,51.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,balance.mlw,0.0,4.0,35.0,WP_parameter solve3,0.0,0.0,2.0,13.0,3.0,61.0,53.0,2.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,112.0,Puzzle8,0.0,42.0,Timeout,10.11438929,0.0,6.0,0.17424867724,0.1426334326,0.1417758008,14.2670519186,0.1202484854,14.2232510598,0.161820824447,0.157569828564,5.15611511337,4.06474251534,5.59293177728,7.33202122844,7.85425131453,5.10889175585,5.31160507831,7.78498044306,balance:Puzzle8:WP_parameter solve3,AzaZ34vy,0.161820824447,Valid,y3zaAZv4,0.1202484854,Valid,4vZAaz3y,20.4645295964,Valid,zZyAa34v,0.1426334326,Valid,3.04832773473 +balance:Puzzle8:WP_parameter solve8,Valid,0.538552520429,Valid,0.3009765912,Valid,0.367690690833,Valid,0.1882675976,Valid,0.1308563852,Valid,0.163259126238,Valid,0.186368899554,24.0,0.0,2.06383,4.0,29.0,94.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,balance.mlw,0.0,6.0,62.0,WP_parameter solve8,0.0,0.0,3.0,50.0,5.0,116.0,98.0,4.0,6.0,0.0,0.0,210.0,Puzzle8,0.0,55.0,Timeout,10.1261881286,1.0,10.0,0.186368899554,0.163259126238,0.367690690833,0.1882675976,0.1308563852,14.2316438269,0.3009765912,0.538552520429,10.752187053,8.2928771612,9.15807056809,11.0038035423,10.876243374,9.97152115949,10.7260504098,11.0683416836,balance:Puzzle8:WP_parameter solve8,A3zZay4v,0.3009765912,Valid,yzZ4A3av,0.1308563852,Valid,va3A4Zzy,10.664740649,Valid,A34vayzZ,0.3009765912,Valid,1.53376948908 +binary_multiplication:BinaryMultiplication:WP_parameter binary_mult,Valid,0.757276057808,Valid,0.2237095019,Valid,0.169027771138,Timeout,10.13305623,Unknown,0.114402532042,Valid,0.748093149429,Valid,1.2825707406,11.0,0.0,2.145161,0.0,20.0,62.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,binary_multiplication.mlw,0.0,7.0,41.0,WP_parameter binary_mult,2.0,0.0,7.0,17.0,0.0,63.0,64.0,2.0,7.0,3.0,0.0,134.0,BinaryMultiplication,0.0,46.0,Unknown,0.108327632556,0.0,0.0,1.2825707406,0.748093149429,0.169027771138,14.2365314793,10.114402532,10.1083276326,0.2237095019,0.757276057808,5.51621829741,4.50912924025,4.90805578232,7.65420647752,6.59248549427,5.064387828,4.98224158181,7.68918171793,binary_multiplication:BinaryMultiplication:WP_parameter binary_mult,A3Zzay4v,0.2237095019,Valid,3AzaZvy4,0.169027771138,Valid,4yvZazA3,11.6383571352,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.169027771138,Valid,2.36209984327 +bresenham:M:WP_parameter bresenham,Timeout,11.0676253986,Unknown,0.858467579065,Unknown,9.0416894748,Unknown,0.090520135,Unknown,0.060191617,Timeout,10.0736214624,Timeout,10.083126864,11.0,0.0,1.57377,0.0,21.0,122.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,bresenham.mlw,0.0,5.0,104.0,WP_parameter bresenham,1.0,0.0,6.0,37.0,1.0,95.0,123.0,1.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,193.0,M,0.0,28.0,Unknown,0.0576639224,0.0,30.0,14.2010368409,14.1942893224,19.0416894748,10.090520135,10.060191617,10.0576639224,10.8584675791,14.9161768548,10.2842163041,8.48356350485,8.19230331973,10.8038794716,9.51120547795,11.2081471071,11.5452543122,11.2326390217,bresenham:M:WP_parameter bresenham,3Aya4zvZ,41.3329064533,Unknown,vy4AzZa3,41.3329064533,Unknown,3aZzA4yv,41.3329064533,Unknown,3yaA4Zzv,41.3329064533,Unknown,41.3329064533 +bresenham:M:closest,Unknown,0.1142938202,Unknown,0.1013040062,Timeout,10.0967881118,Unknown,0.0911569306857,Unknown,0.0581544408,Timeout,10.072398026,Timeout,10.0735476504,0.0,0.0,1.928571,0.0,8.0,14.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,bresenham.mlw,0.0,2.0,13.0,closest,0.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,12.0,14.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,28.0,M,0.0,10.0,Unknown,0.0608577299796,0.0,0.0,14.1942369385,14.1934210814,14.2107399587,10.0911569307,10.0581544408,10.06085773,10.1013040062,10.1142938202,6.04511016627,5.42032685376,6.01267064463,6.59965541055,9.25674154313,8.29480104972,7.65837010447,7.8094890188,bresenham:M:closest,A3a4Zvzy,30.6685007161,Unknown,yv4AazZ3,30.6685007161,Unknown,3ZzaA4vy,30.6685007161,Timeout,3Aa4vyzZ,30.6685007161,Timeout,30.6685007161 +coincidence_count:CoincidenceCount:WP_parameter coincidence_count,Timeout,11.1148179528,Timeout,10.1366336926,Timeout,10.1274726576,Timeout,10.9729206656,Timeout,10.144977455,Timeout,10.1705519766,Timeout,10.1677239066,40.0,0.0,1.952381,0.0,32.0,210.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,coincidence_count.mlw,0.0,7.0,160.0,WP_parameter coincidence_count,4.0,0.0,7.0,34.0,2.0,190.0,214.0,4.0,7.0,1.0,0.0,411.0,CoincidenceCount,0.0,156.0,Timeout,10.1153559096,0.0,0.0,14.2612274872,14.2632439336,14.2325578316,14.8460428375,14.2450190439,14.2239384552,14.2390780115,14.9512266428,11.1086361357,8.59278664599,10.5944262117,10.8420352475,10.2522455674,9.13613609642,9.18056534419,11.4667391213,coincidence_count:CoincidenceCount:WP_parameter coincidence_count,AzZy34av,82.9504542164,Timeout,v3AyZz4a,82.9504542164,Timeout,a4zZyA3v,82.9504542164,Timeout,4Avy3zZa,82.9504542164,Timeout,82.9504542164 +coincidence_count:CoincidenceCount:drop_left,Valid,1.715279489,Valid,0.39030722875,Timeout,10.1157230196,Timeout,10.2046373894,Unknown,3.4744544762,Timeout,10.1576843438,Timeout,10.14933989,1.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,7.0,11.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,coincidence_count.mlw,0.0,1.0,9.0,drop_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,11.0,11.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,23.0,CoincidenceCount,0.0,9.0,Timeout,10.1037543566,0.0,0.0,14.2481261997,14.2540713913,14.2241995279,14.2875688712,13.4744544762,14.215690349,0.39030722875,1.715279489,6.2308583431,5.69737550787,5.51510463781,5.72067509435,8.94422734512,8.94745105106,8.7448118051,7.37014827986,coincidence_count:CoincidenceCount:drop_left,3A4avZyz,10.5060302484,Valid,Aayv3Zz4,0.39030722875,Valid,4zZ3vyaA,55.9208729646,Valid,3Aa4vyzZ,10.5060302484,Valid,19.1213245174 +coincidence_count:CoincidenceCount:not_mem_inter_l,Valid,1.499697942,Valid,0.340782697122,Valid,0.399686826108,Valid,0.280584835359,Unknown,3.74135713329,Timeout,10.163610409,Timeout,10.1554138796,1.0,0.0,1.933333,0.0,8.0,15.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,coincidence_count.mlw,0.0,1.0,11.0,not_mem_inter_l,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,14.0,15.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,30.0,CoincidenceCount,0.0,12.0,Timeout,10.1133186036,0.0,0.0,14.2524535104,14.2582950084,0.399686826108,0.280584835359,13.7413571333,14.2224896969,0.340782697122,1.499697942,7.04528705351,6.37895433127,7.35877820526,8.86823394237,9.74683611814,9.71031018873,9.38324081689,8.13736192929,coincidence_count:CoincidenceCount:not_mem_inter_l,Aa3v4Zzy,0.340782697122,Valid,4A3ayvZz,0.280584835359,Valid,zZvya3A4,35.6733979675,Valid,34vyAaZz,0.399686826108,Valid,7.46492808025 +coincidence_count:CoincidenceCount:not_mem_inter_r,Valid,1.5406932768,Valid,0.334315156143,Valid,0.391827212882,Valid,0.274825327545,Unknown,3.7750570662,Timeout,10.1540815342,Timeout,10.144258963,1.0,0.0,1.933333,0.0,8.0,15.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,coincidence_count.mlw,0.0,1.0,11.0,not_mem_inter_r,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,14.0,15.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,30.0,CoincidenceCount,0.0,12.0,Timeout,10.101846845,0.0,0.0,14.2445073593,14.2515041944,0.391827212882,0.274825327545,13.7750570662,14.2143346548,0.334315156143,1.5406932768,7.04528705351,6.37895433127,7.35877820526,8.86823394237,9.74683611814,9.71031018873,9.38324081689,8.13736192929,coincidence_count:CoincidenceCount:not_mem_inter_r,Aa3v4Zzy,0.334315156143,Valid,4A3ayvZz,0.274825327545,Valid,zZvya3A4,35.7159376852,Valid,34vyAaZz,0.391827212882,Valid,7.47046412502 +cursor:IntArrayCursor:WP_parameter create,Valid,0.15074125836,Valid,0.151605868273,Valid,0.174823940704,Valid,0.179380702846,Valid,0.148179251462,Valid,0.1685609418,Valid,0.166482982357,0.0,0.0,2.125,0.0,7.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,WP_parameter create,0.0,0.0,1.0,3.0,1.0,10.0,8.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,18.0,IntArrayCursor,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.13556041362,0.0,1.0,0.166482982357,0.1685609418,0.174823940704,0.179380702846,0.148179251462,0.13556041362,0.151605868273,0.15074125836,3.71980853664,3.54471757757,3.84551165868,5.00508368217,7.88713004897,5.93085592607,5.41323033238,6.61093619693,cursor:IntArrayCursor:WP_parameter create,Aa34Zzvy,0.151605868273,Valid,vyaAZz34,0.13556041362,Valid,43zZAayv,0.179380702846,Valid,aZv3Az4y,0.15074125836,Valid,0.159416919928 +cursor:IntArrayCursor:WP_parameter has_next,Unknown,0.167640710182,Unknown,0.321806656065,Timeout,10.173802068,Valid,0.180384163844,Timeout,10.1276511838,Valid,0.16406051476,Valid,0.161685108743,1.0,0.0,2.1,0.0,6.0,10.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,1.0,7.0,WP_parameter has_next,0.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,11.0,11.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,22.0,IntArrayCursor,0.0,9.0,Timeout,10.1247139242,0.0,1.0,0.161685108743,0.16406051476,14.2655616265,0.180384163844,14.2326848662,14.2305949295,10.3218066561,10.1676407102,5.45671054318,4.91386267461,4.92771743233,3.72160354839,7.34091015823,5.226687752,4.11118341084,6.78182216804,cursor:IntArrayCursor:WP_parameter has_next,4ZA3zavy,0.180384163844,Valid,Zz4aAvy3,0.161685108743,Valid,3yvAa4zZ,31.0959987061,Valid,A43ayzZv,0.502190819909,Valid,7.89761356468 +cursor:IntArrayCursor:WP_parameter next,Unknown,0.216911671906,Valid,0.246775392122,Valid,0.195958455047,Timeout,10.1979957792,Unknown,7.2272241682,Failure,8.140191337,Failure,8.29477946285,7.0,0.0,2.081081,2.0,18.0,37.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,4.0,24.0,WP_parameter next,0.0,0.0,4.0,3.0,1.0,44.0,39.0,2.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,84.0,IntArrayCursor,0.0,36.0,Timeout,10.1261029798,0.0,3.0,12.9924349657,12.8942900155,0.195958455047,14.2828259778,17.2272241682,14.2315832414,0.246775392122,10.2169116719,6.26129468816,4.98381797627,7.05185737186,7.74436626168,8.76066722988,9.77240436942,9.70216687682,10.9570011704,cursor:IntArrayCursor:WP_parameter next,Aa34yZzv,0.246775392122,Valid,3AazZv4y,0.195958455047,Valid,y4vZzaA3,44.4499807911,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.195958455047,Valid,14.9557687232 +cursor:IntArrayCursor:WP_parameter reverse_cons,Valid,0.313617198185,Valid,0.54038478864,Valid,0.198475564,Timeout,10.455537809,Valid,0.1702550301,Valid,0.1747446182,Valid,0.1677246122,4.0,0.0,2.093023,0.0,13.0,43.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,1.0,35.0,WP_parameter reverse_cons,1.0,0.0,2.0,6.0,2.0,46.0,44.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,91.0,IntArrayCursor,0.0,40.0,Timeout,10.128648722,0.0,0.0,0.1677246122,0.1747446182,0.198475564,14.4678357357,0.1702550301,14.2333947087,0.54038478864,0.313617198185,6.95188060512,6.05235433751,3.75700775481,7.64479319518,7.30242874426,5.56943858629,4.5990591251,7.07851773572,cursor:IntArrayCursor:WP_parameter reverse_cons,3ZzAavy4,0.198475564,Valid,Zyz3aAv4,0.1677246122,Valid,4vAa3zyZ,21.1245713196,Valid,3A4zZvay,0.198475564,Valid,3.20146504441 +cursor:IntListCursor:WP_parameter create,Valid,0.153419078878,Valid,0.160719895625,Valid,0.1426910613,Valid,0.1641082329,Valid,0.13697393462,Valid,0.159770151872,Valid,0.157771060726,0.0,0.0,1.666667,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,WP_parameter create,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,IntListCursor,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.131404292764,0.0,1.0,0.157771060726,0.159770151872,0.1426910613,0.1641082329,0.13697393462,0.131404292764,0.160719895625,0.153419078878,7.030080019,6.06476543298,4.87434189078,4.13088193487,7.76970848605,8.29208619839,4.74938078248,7.21864610923,cursor:IntListCursor:WP_parameter create,4Z3Aavyz,0.1641082329,Valid,vy3aZzA4,0.131404292764,Valid,4AzZa3yv,0.1641082329,Valid,4Z3Avyza,0.1641082329,Valid,0.150857213586 +cursor:IntListCursor:WP_parameter has_next,Valid,0.146107732538,Valid,0.156209215638,Valid,0.129619729932,Valid,0.153873661811,Valid,0.12622134487,Valid,0.149583561978,Valid,0.145351250955,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter has_next,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,IntListCursor,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.128680055905,0.0,0.0,0.145351250955,0.149583561978,0.129619729932,0.153873661811,0.12622134487,0.128680055905,0.156209215638,0.146107732538,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,cursor:IntListCursor:WP_parameter has_next,3aAvyzZ4,0.129619729932,Valid,yv3Zaz4A,0.12622134487,Valid,A4zaZ3vy,0.156209215638,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.128680055905,Valid,0.141955819203 +cursor:IntListCursor:WP_parameter next,Valid,0.154725497305,Valid,0.158763429415,Valid,0.160632107511,Valid,0.182257215906,Valid,0.143308410984,Valid,0.618739614077,Valid,0.583572288882,4.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,14.0,25.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,3.0,17.0,WP_parameter next,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,30.0,27.0,2.0,3.0,1.0,0.0,57.0,IntListCursor,0.0,25.0,Timeout,10.1344835048,0.0,3.0,0.583572288882,0.618739614077,0.160632107511,0.182257215906,0.143308410984,14.237547398,0.158763429415,0.154725497305,4.4363309815,3.63039276455,4.83748623681,5.35837624007,5.47908019197,11.4498166547,11.3446996222,12.4224761081,cursor:IntListCursor:WP_parameter next,Aa34yZzv,0.158763429415,Valid,yaA34Zzv,0.143308410984,Valid,vzZ43Aay,10.7532231189,Valid,34yAaZzv,0.160632107511,Valid,1.55281023297 +cursor:TestArrayCursor:WP_parameter array_sum,Valid,8.6528159242,Valid,0.210523780214,Valid,0.425543758273,Valid,0.4080733158,Valid,2.8712259074,Timeout,10.1708076088,Timeout,10.1850648942,13.0,0.0,2.013514,1.0,27.0,74.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,7.0,49.0,WP_parameter array_sum,1.0,1.0,6.0,7.0,4.0,75.0,77.0,3.0,7.0,2.0,0.0,153.0,TestArrayCursor,0.0,61.0,Timeout,10.1215484328,0.0,6.0,14.2735961446,14.2634262159,0.425543758273,0.4080733158,2.8712259074,14.2283429351,0.210523780214,8.6528159242,8.15867417562,6.75274796402,8.01932093566,9.17601857222,8.93936986434,9.74351598042,9.89390809775,11.2443489814,cursor:TestArrayCursor:WP_parameter array_sum,A3ay4zZv,0.210523780214,Valid,A43yavzZ,0.210523780214,Valid,Zzvay34A,39.13023686,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.425543758273,Valid,7.59320669314 +cursor:TestArrayCursor:WP_parameter array_sum_array_to_list,Valid,0.19380581981,Valid,0.161508097138,Timeout,10.1311732842,Timeout,10.2016203256,Valid,1.00018792542,Timeout,10.163387735,Timeout,10.1725380088,2.0,0.0,2.259259,0.0,11.0,27.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,1.0,21.0,WP_parameter array_sum_array_to_list,1.0,0.0,2.0,3.0,2.0,33.0,28.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,62.0,TestArrayCursor,0.0,30.0,Timeout,10.1173410104,0.0,0.0,14.2646601621,14.2581362826,14.2351913269,14.2854141441,1.00018792542,14.2253502284,0.161508097138,0.19380581981,8.20336717212,6.87968164857,5.95277585036,7.52350181385,9.62286789631,8.34816028198,6.19210673603,8.08336715839,cursor:TestArrayCursor:WP_parameter array_sum_array_to_list,3ZA4vazy,20.4652193901,Valid,Aayv3zZ4,0.161508097138,Valid,4Zz3vyaA,51.7862482894,Valid,Z3v4zAya,50.9475684611,Valid,13.1483490385 +cursor:TestArrayCursor:WP_parameter harness1,Timeout,11.1252867182,Timeout,10.1292345376,Valid,3.17609041744,Valid,0.4271922818,Unknown,3.1985163436,Timeout,10.1609671986,Timeout,10.1553477104,10.0,0.0,2.04878,1.0,18.0,41.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,5.0,24.0,WP_parameter harness1,0.0,0.0,4.0,8.0,2.0,44.0,42.0,1.0,5.0,1.0,0.0,88.0,TestArrayCursor,0.0,32.0,Timeout,10.1374980062,0.0,3.0,14.2524063624,14.2564109933,3.17609041744,0.4271922818,13.1985163436,14.2396933192,14.2338115878,14.959010815,4.85784791829,3.93667941579,4.59931367577,6.15748932965,7.4727157667,5.17976130947,5.0452607197,7.36106706545,cursor:TestArrayCursor:WP_parameter harness1,A3aZz4vy,13.305324955,Valid,43yAvZza,0.4271922818,Valid,azZvAy34,58.082940932,Valid,vzZ3Aa4y,33.6299033326,Valid,20.1039248545 +cursor:TestCursor:WP_parameter sum,Valid,0.217177424071,Valid,0.162862251893,Valid,0.194209358255,Timeout,10.183004417,Valid,0.152965743833,Valid,0.169354802062,Valid,0.1739266884,19.0,0.0,2.050505,0.0,29.0,99.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,9.0,72.0,WP_parameter sum,1.0,1.0,5.0,13.0,3.0,96.0,105.0,2.0,9.0,0.0,0.0,208.0,TestCursor,0.0,81.0,Valid,0.154551762844,0.0,2.0,0.1739266884,0.169354802062,0.194209358255,14.2721259438,0.152965743833,0.154551762844,0.162862251893,0.217177424071,11.1624011867,9.68258141389,10.0687417239,12.106103944,10.6841620607,10.9142217711,11.0793801876,11.6450321008,cursor:TestCursor:WP_parameter sum,A3yzZav4,0.162862251893,Valid,yvAzZ3a4,0.152965743833,Valid,4a3ZzAvy,10.4001818411,Valid,yvZ3zA4a,0.152965743833,Valid,1.44788241375 +cursor:TestListCursor:WP_parameter list_sum,Valid,0.1687637184,Valid,0.160869906682,Valid,0.165688766306,Valid,0.209915636429,Valid,0.152082673611,Timeout,10.1560090138,Timeout,10.161624689,13.0,0.0,1.859155,1.0,22.0,71.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,cursor.mlw,0.0,7.0,51.0,WP_parameter list_sum,1.0,1.0,5.0,2.0,0.0,61.0,74.0,3.0,7.0,2.0,0.0,136.0,TestListCursor,0.0,52.0,Valid,0.142458867046,0.0,6.0,14.2568796137,14.2528775722,0.165688766306,0.209915636429,0.152082673611,0.142458867046,0.160869906682,0.1687637184,8.11355053014,6.96563202271,7.55723358732,7.82222612046,8.80851148916,10.3712885999,10.2906602972,11.8068873657,cursor:TestListCursor:WP_parameter list_sum,A34ayZzv,0.160869906682,Valid,vyA3a4zZ,0.142458867046,Valid,Zz4a3Ayv,20.5275493392,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.165688766306,Valid,3.06914902848 +decrease1:Decrease1:WP_parameter search,Unknown,0.531188237848,Unknown,0.437311551306,Timeout,10.1022164102,Valid,0.21718312649,Valid,0.15447432104,Valid,0.142680658297,Valid,0.145394888054,32.0,0.0,2.06383,0.0,22.0,141.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,decrease1.mlw,0.0,12.0,82.0,WP_parameter search,3.0,0.0,16.0,38.0,1.0,136.0,144.0,3.0,12.0,8.0,2.0,292.0,Decrease1,0.0,98.0,Valid,10.095078004,0.0,0.0,0.145394888054,0.142680658297,14.2145972999,0.21718312649,0.15447432104,10.095078004,10.4373115513,10.5311882378,6.15707527796,5.09965114373,6.2590801596,7.65625374975,7.45431336238,5.33934964737,5.46713852632,9.03705663754,decrease1:Decrease1:WP_parameter search,AzZa3y4v,0.579992209603,Valid,zZy4vAa3,0.142680658297,Valid,3aAv4yZz,21.1657942034,Valid,Aa3yZzv4,11.2251905204,Valid,3.99608156614 +decrease1:Decrease1:WP_parameter search_rec,Unknown,0.867201336016,Unknown,0.411409808154,Unknown,0.250476237633,Valid,1.0984645526,Timeout,10.0910272814,Valid,0.15907394007,Valid,0.154404564833,52.0,0.0,2.009709,0.0,23.0,206.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,decrease1.mlw,0.0,15.0,117.0,WP_parameter search_rec,3.0,0.0,15.0,37.0,4.0,191.0,209.0,3.0,15.0,12.0,6.0,415.0,Decrease1,0.0,154.0,Valid,0.21928678407,0.0,0.0,0.154404564833,0.15907394007,10.2504762376,1.0984645526,14.2066474439,0.21928678407,10.4114098082,10.867201336,10.0834458089,7.54393810233,9.94343677378,10.7031752755,10.1357459758,8.78783181129,8.82712878925,11.0908673796,decrease1:Decrease1:WP_parameter search_rec,AzZ3ay4v,0.570483748224,Valid,Zzv43Aay,0.154404564833,Valid,yaA34vzZ,12.7185792158,Valid,Aa3yZzv4,11.774519228,Valid,2.73183039303 +decrease1:Decrease1:decrease1_induction,Unknown,0.162022485625,Unknown,0.162300526449,Timeout,10.1005712326,Timeout,10.1848952876,Unknown,8.96542041289,Unknown,2.5650194787,Unknown,3.41980003473,2.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,9.0,14.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,decrease1.mlw,0.0,2.0,10.0,decrease1_induction,0.0,0.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,13.0,14.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,29.0,Decrease1,0.0,12.0,Timeout,10.0900982768,0.0,0.0,13.4198000347,12.5650194787,14.2134281306,14.2734751206,18.9654204129,14.205987584,10.1623005264,10.1620224856,6.34245153623,5.92940793625,6.15177177496,6.31716097257,8.30898124133,7.89985143733,7.65138149797,6.98838298959,decrease1:Decrease1:decrease1_induction,A34avZzy,45.6501277354,Unknown,aAzZv34y,45.6501277354,Unknown,y43vZzAa,45.6501277354,Unknown,43vAayZz,45.6501277354,Timeout,45.6501277354 +defunctionalization:CPS:cps_correct,Valid,0.123491812781,Valid,0.118242689659,Valid,0.106786494889,Valid,0.1280335357,Valid,0.100139976769,Valid,0.129148266538,Valid,0.137043817667,0.0,0.0,1.666667,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,cps_correct,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,CPS,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.0917457086,0.0,0.0,0.137043817667,0.129148266538,0.106786494889,0.1280335357,0.100139976769,0.0917457086,0.118242689659,0.123491812781,7.3881075488,6.69397287511,5.69224982089,5.6533301898,8.33123530514,8.67827364545,6.21696245483,7.90057113604,defunctionalization:CPS:cps_correct,43ZAavyz,0.1280335357,Valid,vy3Aa4zZ,0.0917457086,Valid,Zz4aA3yv,0.137043817667,Valid,4Z3Avyza,0.1280335357,Valid,0.116829037825 +defunctionalization:CPS:cps_correct_expr,Unknown,0.155399568759,Unknown,0.137226163909,Unknown,0.1246296134,Timeout,10.135506018,Unknown,1.0682644129,Timeout,10.124657931,Timeout,10.1172525946,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,4.0,cps_correct_expr,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,9.0,CPS,0.0,4.0,Unknown,0.111265264962,0.0,0.0,14.2252873455,14.2305550918,10.1246296134,14.2382752551,11.0682644129,10.111265265,10.1372261639,10.1553995688,13.1378608267,12.3553167302,10.1934535098,4.73936337188,10.1852963507,10.944801371,7.9804973844,10.3489744779,defunctionalization:CPS:cps_correct_expr,4Zy3vzAa,31.9742015675,Timeout,v3AayZz4,31.9742015675,Unknown,4zZyaA3v,31.9742015675,Timeout,4Z3yvzAa,31.9742015675,Timeout,31.9742015675 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization2:WP_parameter continue_2,Unknown,0.451704532636,Valid,0.137147810691,Valid,0.110293678227,Valid,0.291426207,Valid,0.10847371325,Valid,0.168748423037,Valid,0.166866295701,2.0,0.0,1.935484,3.0,9.0,31.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,26.0,WP_parameter continue_2,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,41.0,34.0,3.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,71.0,Defunctionalization2,0.0,32.0,Timeout,10.1117987028,0.0,7.0,0.166866295701,0.168748423037,0.110293678227,0.291426207,0.10847371325,14.221408967,0.137147810691,10.4517045326,5.9860369969,4.85509038411,7.1651081903,7.07858809455,8.2617430602,10.7909626795,10.6966007113,11.8868469346,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization2:WP_parameter continue_2,Aa43yZzv,0.137147810691,Valid,y3AZz4av,0.10847371325,Valid,va4zZA3y,10.8549294424,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.110293678227,Valid,1.67289791209 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization2:WP_parameter eval_2,Unknown,0.4720438266,Unknown,0.179645774711,Valid,0.176412536657,Timeout,10.1288889294,Unknown,1.3208177794,Timeout,10.1265120874,Timeout,10.125194481,2.0,0.0,1.84375,3.0,9.0,32.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,27.0,WP_parameter eval_2,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,37.0,35.0,3.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,69.0,Defunctionalization2,0.0,29.0,Timeout,10.1036901412,0.0,6.0,14.2309368377,14.2318743339,0.176412536657,14.2335656441,11.3208177794,14.2156447082,10.1796457747,10.4720438266,5.5242768429,4.1787891142,6.11532453826,6.73576974808,7.45221450418,9.82520583283,10.0240762386,11.6942527673,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization2:WP_parameter eval_2,Aa34yzZv,0.828102137968,Valid,3AayvZz4,0.176412536657,Valid,4zZvyaA3,42.6332055564,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.176412536657,Valid,21.4048090465 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization2:WP_parameter interpret_2,Valid,0.127644638674,Valid,0.136184071767,Valid,0.101998360929,Valid,0.135779767082,Valid,0.0996714621481,Valid,0.13232463429,Valid,0.139430331594,0.0,0.0,1.833333,0.0,6.0,6.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,2.0,5.0,WP_parameter interpret_2,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,6.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,12.0,Defunctionalization2,0.0,4.0,Valid,0.086042466,0.0,1.0,0.139430331594,0.13232463429,0.101998360929,0.135779767082,0.0996714621481,0.086042466,0.136184071767,0.127644638674,7.90404121827,6.85185002956,6.89865424833,7.28298001744,9.06774655197,8.30737792174,8.90743936303,9.04812924799,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization2:WP_parameter interpret_2,A34azZvy,0.136184071767,Valid,vy3az4AZ,0.086042466,Valid,ZA4za3yv,0.139430331594,Valid,4Zzv3Aay,0.135779767082,Valid,0.119884466561 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization2:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.126797916762,Valid,0.126628469184,Valid,0.102089385324,Valid,0.129352450194,Valid,0.0968117787927,Valid,0.123496185571,Valid,0.12910370454,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,Defunctionalization2,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.09520416713,0.0,0.0,0.12910370454,0.123496185571,0.102089385324,0.129352450194,0.0968117787927,0.09520416713,0.126628469184,0.126797916762,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization2:WP_parameter test,3aAvyzZ4,0.102089385324,Valid,vy3zAaZ4,0.09520416713,Valid,4ZaAz3yv,0.129352450194,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.09520416713,Valid,0.116185507187 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:WP_parameter continue_2,Valid,0.147182401067,Valid,0.131869465628,Valid,0.1057867582,Valid,0.165148054137,Valid,0.1009333748,Valid,0.133283034161,Valid,0.1233821624,4.0,0.0,2.033333,1.0,9.0,30.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,23.0,WP_parameter continue_2,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,33.0,31.0,1.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,66.0,Defunctionalization,0.0,30.0,Valid,0.10003155556,0.0,1.0,0.1233821624,0.133283034161,0.1057867582,0.165148054137,0.1009333748,0.10003155556,0.131869465628,0.147182401067,5.03602209517,4.16643622483,5.2257697214,6.19561034282,7.57407981021,8.06413102774,7.04543673727,8.57221230608,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:WP_parameter continue_2,Aa34Zyzv,0.131869465628,Valid,vy3ZAza4,0.10003155556,Valid,4azAZ3yv,0.165148054137,Valid,3AzZa4yv,0.1057867582,Valid,0.125952100744 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:WP_parameter eval_2,Valid,0.2113810909,Valid,0.142854404865,Valid,0.271237087842,Timeout,10.1462623914,Unknown,1.3526700802,Valid,0.142631321947,Valid,0.138788433571,4.0,0.0,1.837838,1.0,9.0,37.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,30.0,WP_parameter eval_2,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,31.0,38.0,1.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,72.0,Defunctionalization,0.0,29.0,Valid,0.1035027872,0.0,0.0,0.138788433571,0.142631321947,0.271237087842,14.2459341749,11.3526700802,0.1035027872,0.142854404865,0.2113810909,4.01433560724,3.13694794365,3.96929035153,5.4552135274,6.47357662647,6.06703745822,5.41654398141,6.7725554169,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:WP_parameter eval_2,A3aZ4zyv,0.142854404865,Valid,vZzAa3y4,0.1035027872,Valid,4y3aAzZv,11.7701695594,Valid,3AzZa4yv,0.271237087842,Valid,1.81110382652 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:WP_parameter interpret_2,Valid,0.136337153667,Valid,0.130619601357,Valid,0.103787143625,Valid,0.152632299706,Valid,0.0900415792,Valid,0.131612349676,Valid,0.134056097329,0.0,0.0,1.833333,0.0,6.0,6.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,2.0,5.0,WP_parameter interpret_2,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,6.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,12.0,Defunctionalization,0.0,4.0,Valid,0.0960638568421,0.0,1.0,0.134056097329,0.131612349676,0.103787143625,0.152632299706,0.0900415792,0.0960638568421,0.130619601357,0.136337153667,7.90404121827,6.85185002956,6.89865424833,7.28298001744,9.06774655197,8.30737792174,8.90743936303,9.04812924799,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:WP_parameter interpret_2,A34azZvy,0.130619601357,Valid,yv3AzZa4,0.0900415792,Valid,4aZzA3vy,0.152632299706,Valid,4Zzv3Aay,0.152632299706,Valid,0.121893760175 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.12832657527,Valid,0.132188254159,Valid,0.104317949717,Valid,0.1286441958,Valid,0.0987864122987,Valid,0.126798840211,Valid,0.121685772357,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,Defunctionalization,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.09784561725,0.0,0.0,0.121685772357,0.126798840211,0.104317949717,0.1286441958,0.0987864122987,0.09784561725,0.132188254159,0.12832657527,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:WP_parameter test,3aAvyzZ4,0.104317949717,Valid,vy3Zza4A,0.09784561725,Valid,A4azZ3yv,0.132188254159,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.09784561725,Valid,0.117324202133 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:size_c_pos,Unknown,0.122915697365,Unknown,0.131081872094,Unknown,0.156103028818,Unknown,0.13030593894,Unknown,1.939238055,Timeout,10.0977301552,Timeout,10.1075912542,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,size_c_pos,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,Defunctionalization,0.0,1.0,Unknown,0.10187816923,0.0,0.0,14.2184176673,14.2114092998,10.1561030288,10.1303059389,11.939238055,10.1018781692,10.1310818721,10.1229156974,8.68855167255,8.69859302022,8.86794921839,11.5588640231,11.422929724,10.8202147785,11.9153648686,11.2827327204,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:size_c_pos,aA3zvy4Z,22.7868441708,Unknown,va4A3yzZ,22.7868441708,Unknown,Zzy3A4av,22.7868441708,Timeout,Aa3zZ4vy,22.7868441708,Unknown,22.7868441708 +defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:size_e_pos,Unknown,0.120850022762,Unknown,0.13031503389,Unknown,0.136938464097,Timeout,11.115034652,Timeout,10.0874137098,Timeout,10.1098911334,Timeout,10.0982506462,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,size_e_pos,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,Defunctionalization,0.0,1.0,Unknown,0.10065654975,0.0,0.0,14.2117791326,14.2200526978,10.1369384641,14.9513877388,14.2040809401,10.1006565497,10.1303150339,10.1208500228,8.68855167255,8.69859302022,8.86794921839,11.5588640231,11.422929724,10.8202147785,11.9153648686,11.2827327204,defunctionalization:Defunctionalization:size_e_pos,aA3zvy4Z,41.8993502119,Unknown,vaA3yZz4,41.8993502119,Unknown,4zZy3Aav,41.8993502119,Timeout,Aa3zZ4vy,41.8993502119,Unknown,41.8993502119 +defunctionalization:DirectSem:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.11747951806,Valid,0.121899186119,Valid,0.09651463903,Valid,0.117789699951,Valid,0.0838701486,Valid,0.122223962167,Valid,0.1059060436,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,DirectSem,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.0895958547442,0.0,0.0,0.1059060436,0.122223962167,0.09651463903,0.117789699951,0.0838701486,0.0895958547442,0.121899186119,0.11747951806,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,defunctionalization:DirectSem:WP_parameter test,3aAvyzZ4,0.09651463903,Valid,yv3Za4Az,0.0838701486,Valid,zA4aZ3vy,0.122223962167,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.0895958547442,Valid,0.106909881534 +defunctionalization:DirectSem:eval_p3,Valid,0.11947183325,Valid,0.118648233879,Valid,0.0974640007042,Valid,0.121280187775,Valid,0.0881769128718,Valid,0.119559524508,Valid,0.122817017885,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,0.0,2.0,eval_p3,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,DirectSem,0.0,0.0,Valid,0.08722879039,0.0,1.0,0.122817017885,0.119559524508,0.0974640007042,0.121280187775,0.0881769128718,0.08722879039,0.118648233879,0.11947183325,3.57902074699,3.49475505106,0.842222691885,1.81088167674,2.51499742456,1.62406917546,0.72205683347,2.12824615651,defunctionalization:DirectSem:eval_p3,Z3z4vyAa,0.122817017885,Valid,vy3Aaz4Z,0.08722879039,Valid,Z4zaA3yv,0.122817017885,Valid,3Zzv4yAa,0.0974640007042,Valid,0.109330812658 +defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter eval_1,Valid,0.167171306614,Valid,0.163629656262,Valid,0.166698549391,Timeout,11.1587000192,Unknown,1.8075691246,Timeout,10.1306743644,Timeout,10.1325530666,5.0,0.0,1.735849,1.0,10.0,53.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,47.0,WP_parameter eval_1,1.0,0.0,0.0,11.0,1.0,41.0,55.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,96.0,RWithError,0.0,29.0,Timeout,10.1244559518,0.0,1.0,14.2361733499,14.2348362505,0.166698549391,14.9838775395,11.8075691246,14.2304113897,0.163629656262,0.167171306614,7.34621335336,6.03300084078,7.97631832278,7.29754192576,8.60738070601,8.29409310012,8.19971810791,9.24146816588,defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter eval_1,A4a3Zzyv,0.163629656262,Valid,A3ayvzZ4,0.163629656262,Valid,4Zzvya3A,43.5211238332,Valid,Av4y3zaZ,0.163629656262,Valid,11.0043213024 +defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter eval_2,Timeout,11.117774502,Valid,0.426329131652,Unknown,0.325514292655,Timeout,11.1549219478,Timeout,10.1462523192,Failure,6.9681329548,Failure,7.7182924054,4.0,0.0,1.721311,1.0,12.0,61.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,54.0,WP_parameter eval_2,1.0,0.0,1.0,13.0,2.0,48.0,63.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,110.0,RWithError,0.0,33.0,Timeout,10.1085366378,0.0,2.0,12.6321826164,12.1883090245,10.3255142927,14.9810641699,14.2459270012,14.2190897373,0.426329131652,14.9534246873,8.97441513071,6.86937893706,9.20860077176,9.40284901198,8.79801440526,9.30378831929,9.88458845603,10.2003863386,defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter eval_2,Aya3z4Zv,0.426329131652,Valid,A3zZvya4,0.426329131652,Valid,4ayvZz3A,57.9657541913,Valid,Av4y3zaZ,0.426329131652,Valid,29.1960416615 +defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter interpret,Valid,0.152075264114,Valid,0.159811501429,Valid,0.143770704519,Valid,0.174722127833,Failure,5.20734500364,Valid,0.155528861823,Valid,0.157987664913,0.0,0.0,1.4,0.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,WP_parameter interpret,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,RWithError,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.126919919118,0.0,1.0,0.157987664913,0.155528861823,0.143770704519,0.174722127833,11.2745927637,0.126919919118,0.159811501429,0.152075264114,7.24151514863,5.25510119385,3.67738369695,1.42431658964,7.50643461193,8.72681154353,2.99564444798,6.44350449864,defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter interpret,4Z3Avayz,0.174722127833,Valid,v3azZA4y,0.126919919118,Valid,y4AZza3v,5.38206713147,Valid,4Z3Avyza,0.174722127833,Valid,0.803891845991 +defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter recompose_underflow,Valid,0.267353776294,Valid,0.173697957065,Unknown,0.249088122474,Timeout,11.1404150976,Valid,0.17374484712,Timeout,10.1241305738,Timeout,10.127718772,4.0,0.0,1.611111,3.0,11.0,54.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,45.0,WP_parameter recompose_underflow,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,2.0,53.0,57.0,3.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,100.0,RWithError,0.0,36.0,Valid,0.143953638169,4.0,11.0,14.2327329605,14.2301798961,10.2490881225,14.9702654802,0.17374484712,0.143953638169,0.173697957065,0.267353776294,6.37639205457,5.54329335077,7.25342630134,6.41521053614,8.12932336251,10.2524961203,10.4170109232,11.4715400894,defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter recompose_underflow,Aa43yzZv,0.173697957065,Valid,vAya3zZ4,0.143953638169,Valid,4Zz3ayAv,31.9087063422,Valid,4aAy3vZz,11.4077688739,Valid,6.51795806784 +defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter recompose_values,Timeout,11.1232440614,Valid,0.327030615,Unknown,0.282280036935,Timeout,10.9375469904,Timeout,10.1112468096,Timeout,10.12219491,Timeout,10.1446322738,4.0,0.0,1.78125,3.0,12.0,64.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,53.0,WP_parameter recompose_values,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,4.0,62.0,67.0,3.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,127.0,RWithError,0.0,53.0,Valid,0.194674433225,4.0,3.0,14.2447732158,14.2288028237,10.2822800369,14.819916807,14.2210165616,0.194674433225,0.327030615,14.9574917165,6.07329598632,4.98915745802,7.85015446298,7.0140423195,8.34621940246,10.0029436957,10.1709055683,12.3819490009,defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter recompose_values,Aa43yzZv,0.327030615,Valid,vA3yzZ4a,0.194674433225,Valid,a4Zzy3Av,53.0481756971,Valid,4aAy3vZz,22.3878216668,Valid,17.8345675515 +defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.156391030529,Valid,0.152066406879,Valid,0.147085551917,Valid,0.156551003787,Valid,0.136004424278,Valid,0.151338599329,Valid,0.152475133077,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,RWithError,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.132481957837,0.0,0.0,0.152475133077,0.151338599329,0.147085551917,0.156551003787,0.136004424278,0.132481957837,0.152066406879,0.156391030529,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,defunctionalization:RWithError:WP_parameter test,3aAvyzZ4,0.147085551917,Valid,vy3zAZa4,0.132481957837,Valid,4aZAz3yv,0.156551003787,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.132481957837,Valid,0.148049263454 +defunctionalization:RWithError:size_c_pos,Unknown,0.156168401122,Unknown,0.147748289222,Unknown,6.7061937652,Unknown,0.171364997444,Timeout,10.1064784448,Timeout,10.1655721346,Timeout,10.1578608334,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,size_c_pos,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,RWithError,0.0,1.0,Timeout,10.129807158,0.0,0.0,14.2541971612,14.2596934337,16.7061937652,10.1713649974,14.2176266147,14.2342190885,10.1477482892,10.1561684011,8.68855167255,8.69859302022,8.86794921839,11.5588640231,11.422929724,10.8202147785,11.9153648686,11.2827327204,defunctionalization:RWithError:size_c_pos,aA3zvy4Z,47.7411940238,Unknown,Aa4yvZz3,47.7411940238,Unknown,3zZvy4aA,47.7411940238,Unknown,Aa3zZ4vy,47.7411940238,Unknown,47.7411940238 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter contract,Valid,0.132063726276,Valid,0.132955695523,Valid,0.104001580289,Valid,0.161432240727,Failure,4.84055579881,Valid,0.12660055887,Valid,0.130406195111,0.0,0.0,1.833333,2.0,8.0,12.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,11.0,WP_parameter contract,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,14.0,14.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,29.0,ReductionSemantics,1.0,7.0,Valid,0.09283890495,4.0,0.0,0.130406195111,0.12660055887,0.104001580289,0.161432240727,11.1099496147,0.09283890495,0.132955695523,0.132063726276,3.32282403347,2.78552096427,3.67456342838,3.40886023796,4.72470239463,6.94009062264,6.58637811252,10.8690438677,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter contract,Aa43yZzv,0.132955695523,Valid,v3zZaA4y,0.09283890495,Valid,y4AaZz3v,5.00198803954,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,4.9445573791,Valid,0.730826460815 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter decompose,Valid,0.1540077274,Valid,0.1478685383,Valid,0.128006845417,Valid,0.322065411842,Failure,5.0385204538,Valid,0.130824849,Valid,0.13892460575,3.0,0.0,2.105263,4.0,9.0,19.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,2.0,14.0,WP_parameter decompose,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,29.0,23.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,53.0,ReductionSemantics,4.0,10.0,Valid,0.10696316114,10.0,1.0,0.13892460575,0.130824849,0.128006845417,0.322065411842,11.1976197633,0.10696316114,0.1478685383,0.1540077274,3.44718618678,2.81085910723,3.62176187363,3.93487109351,4.60206921574,9.66353106668,9.33228393614,11.8763541959,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter decompose,Aa34yZzv,0.1478685383,Valid,v3zZAa4y,0.10696316114,Valid,y4aAZz3v,5.36058586564,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,5.16652729922,Valid,0.791052362275 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter decompose_cont,Valid,0.1758627595,Valid,0.153807557844,Valid,0.15091662901,Timeout,11.1223118346,Valid,0.166301050944,Failure,6.579816849,Failure,5.5000341173,4.0,0.0,1.868421,4.0,11.0,38.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,2.0,32.0,WP_parameter decompose_cont,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,43.0,42.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,85.0,ReductionSemantics,3.0,27.0,Timeout,10.0856732764,7.0,2.0,11.4127286523,11.9705467614,0.15091662901,14.9567984725,0.166301050944,14.2028449769,0.153807557844,0.1758627595,3.9276232344,2.78919362754,5.74740086115,6.1744908813,7.14369432196,8.98104587505,9.07988797808,11.8055260009,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter decompose_cont,Aa34yzZv,0.153807557844,Valid,3AyaZzv4,0.15091662901,Valid,4vzZayA3,33.4636988368,Valid,4aAy3vZz,11.2981745941,Valid,6.81928921478 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter decompose_term,Valid,0.229934028581,Valid,0.156161412167,Valid,0.165947818432,Timeout,11.1369734432,Unknown,0.643351372538,Valid,3.5131114174,Valid,3.3882798138,10.0,0.0,1.892308,8.0,11.0,65.0,0.0,0.0,7.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,51.0,WP_parameter decompose_term,0.0,0.0,3.0,2.0,1.0,74.0,73.0,8.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,148.0,ReductionSemantics,7.0,40.0,Timeout,10.091886917,16.0,2.0,3.3882798138,3.5131114174,0.165947818432,14.9677044825,10.6433513725,14.2072580587,0.156161412167,0.229934028581,5.94999864161,4.95520474855,7.53329685443,7.44198109536,8.70644289472,9.96678534111,9.96998657378,12.2937930535,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter decompose_term,Aa43yzZv,0.156161412167,Valid,A3aZzyv4,0.156161412167,Valid,4vyzZa3A,25.3853231501,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.165947818432,Valid,5.1360555202 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter eval_1,Valid,0.146925170276,Valid,0.145381549114,Valid,0.127266254278,Valid,0.181019947686,Failure,5.47884752872,Valid,0.173877699667,Valid,0.167020232167,4.0,0.0,1.695652,1.0,10.0,46.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,41.0,WP_parameter eval_1,0.0,0.0,0.0,9.0,1.0,34.0,47.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,82.0,ReductionSemantics,0.0,25.0,Timeout,10.0947962188,0.0,0.0,0.167020232167,0.173877699667,0.127266254278,0.181019947686,11.4025335011,14.2093247798,0.145381549114,0.146925170276,7.36745786445,6.10044549116,6.72925608697,6.65882072217,8.10015910362,7.73143624468,7.27552111273,8.11269313056,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter eval_1,A43Zazyv,0.145381549114,Valid,3AaZz4yv,0.127266254278,Valid,vy4zZaA3,15.7546636952,Valid,Av4y3zaZ,0.145381549114,Valid,2.38172139184 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter eval_2,Valid,0.162592841516,Valid,0.155389937556,Valid,0.168350588091,Timeout,11.1212818494,Failure,6.1708847108,Timeout,10.110135569,Timeout,10.1031557038,4.0,0.0,1.711538,1.0,10.0,52.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,46.0,WP_parameter eval_2,0.0,0.0,0.0,12.0,2.0,41.0,53.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,94.0,ReductionSemantics,0.0,28.0,Timeout,10.086195191,0.0,1.0,14.2152648648,14.2202264829,0.168350588091,14.9560325613,11.7507369179,14.2032156018,0.155389937556,0.162592841516,7.57725961772,6.17428035884,7.5446610077,7.4076390717,8.2054027556,7.47159305866,7.47181564563,8.93204288548,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter eval_2,A4zZ3ayv,0.155389937556,Valid,Aa3yvZz4,0.155389937556,Valid,4zZvy3aA,47.7600036121,Valid,Av4y3zaZ,0.155389937556,Valid,12.0600243784 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter interpret,Valid,0.136511434936,Valid,0.137003618677,Valid,0.108932734013,Valid,0.145207227265,Failure,5.1298555124,Valid,0.134346662404,Valid,0.13464264082,0.0,0.0,1.4,0.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,WP_parameter interpret,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,ReductionSemantics,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.106142753082,0.0,1.0,0.13464264082,0.134346662404,0.108932734013,0.145207227265,11.2390131941,0.106142753082,0.137003618677,0.136511434936,7.24151514863,5.25510119385,3.67738369695,1.42431658964,7.50643461193,8.72681154353,2.99564444798,6.44350449864,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter interpret,4Z3Avayz,0.145207227265,Valid,v3zZaA4y,0.106142753082,Valid,y4AaZz3v,5.27506273966,Valid,4Z3Avyza,0.145207227265,Valid,0.77020152065 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter itere,Valid,0.1386930179,Valid,0.140458425587,Valid,0.1182219064,Valid,0.1509760619,Valid,0.0974636764,Valid,0.134896686127,Valid,0.138035443553,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,9.0,15.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,11.0,WP_parameter itere,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,17.0,17.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,37.0,ReductionSemantics,1.0,11.0,Valid,0.106910905244,3.0,0.0,0.138035443553,0.134896686127,0.1182219064,0.1509760619,0.0974636764,0.106910905244,0.140458425587,0.1386930179,3.74078331268,2.95483295108,4.25263673592,4.41158752696,4.95316838034,8.11766339949,7.82402252797,11.1361468299,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter itere,Aa34yZzv,0.140458425587,Valid,yv3zZaA4,0.0974636764,Valid,4AaZz3vy,0.1509760619,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,0.0974636764,Valid,0.128207015389 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter itere_opt,Valid,0.17018406828,Valid,0.157084002952,Valid,0.134896187027,Timeout,11.1282849142,Valid,0.159155904773,Valid,0.139425528754,Valid,0.148584618074,5.0,0.0,2.0,6.0,11.0,32.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,24.0,WP_parameter itere_opt,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,44.0,38.0,6.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,83.0,ReductionSemantics,5.0,20.0,Timeout,10.1055456834,11.0,2.0,0.148584618074,0.139425528754,0.134896187027,14.9612407618,0.159155904773,14.2169635844,0.157084002952,0.17018406828,4.52639480535,3.3806913646,5.7832425167,6.17763633325,6.87169111056,10.483579679,10.4356452892,12.795724036,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter itere_opt,Aa34yZzv,0.157084002952,Valid,3zZAyav4,0.134896187027,Valid,4vayAZz3,21.4040146659,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.134896187027,Valid,3.18495942273 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter normalize,Valid,0.14194743536,Valid,0.140457465869,Valid,0.114756865493,Valid,0.146067844608,Failure,5.0176510396,Valid,0.133342293868,Valid,0.141536114382,0.0,0.0,1.4,0.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,WP_parameter normalize,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,ReductionSemantics,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.107198709211,0.0,1.0,0.141536114382,0.133342293868,0.114756865493,0.146067844608,11.1882448112,0.107198709211,0.140457465869,0.14194743536,7.24151514863,5.25510119385,3.67738369695,1.42431658964,7.50643461193,8.72681154353,2.99564444798,6.44350449864,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter normalize,4Z3Avayz,0.146067844608,Valid,v3zAZa4y,0.107198709211,Valid,y4aZAz3v,5.16371888421,Valid,4Z3Avyza,0.146067844608,Valid,0.759393055492 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter recompose_values,Valid,0.135404537685,Valid,0.144595787935,Valid,0.122787693533,Valid,0.151669297974,Valid,0.103513377867,Timeout,10.1189965044,Timeout,10.1259603834,4.0,0.0,1.78125,3.0,12.0,64.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,53.0,WP_parameter recompose_values,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,4.0,62.0,67.0,3.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,127.0,ReductionSemantics,0.0,53.0,Valid,0.102732020075,4.0,3.0,14.2314817811,14.226527695,0.122787693533,0.151669297974,0.103513377867,0.102732020075,0.144595787935,0.135404537685,6.07329598632,4.98915745802,7.85015446298,7.0140423195,8.34621940246,10.0029436957,10.1709055683,12.3819490009,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter recompose_values,Aa43yzZv,0.144595787935,Valid,vy3aA4zZ,0.102732020075,Valid,Zz4Aa3yv,20.3966261858,Valid,4aAy3vZz,0.151669297974,Valid,3.0189204841 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter reduce,Valid,0.157172260778,Valid,0.152511480359,Valid,0.124076332084,Timeout,11.134377444,Valid,0.145237106951,Valid,0.139946279671,Valid,0.15165175506,3.0,0.0,2.043478,4.0,11.0,23.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,17.0,WP_parameter reduce,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,30.0,27.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,60.0,ReductionSemantics,4.0,12.0,Timeout,10.087477652,10.0,0.0,0.15165175506,0.139946279671,0.124076332084,14.9657729859,0.145237106951,14.2041263505,0.152511480359,0.157172260778,3.40192949035,2.65685586127,3.65275933842,4.34576379869,4.64039689986,10.0848457619,9.72803583538,11.8332390843,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter reduce,Aa34yZzv,0.152511480359,Valid,3zyZAav4,0.124076332084,Valid,4vaAZyz3,21.3790273568,Valid,34yAaZzv,0.124076332084,Valid,3.17679278763 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter refocus,Valid,0.153791956404,Valid,0.15039586436,Valid,0.122493800595,Timeout,11.1210407368,Valid,0.14207279522,Valid,0.14021774299,Valid,0.151261345169,5.0,0.0,2.173913,6.0,9.0,23.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,2.0,16.0,WP_parameter refocus,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,40.0,29.0,6.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,69.0,ReductionSemantics,6.0,14.0,Valid,0.0970261414,12.0,2.0,0.151261345169,0.14021774299,0.122493800595,14.9558532712,0.14207279522,0.0970261414,0.15039586436,0.153791956404,3.05925784406,2.51696289923,3.878436596,4.27487694915,4.67238744005,10.2931882946,10.0754236878,12.222501758,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter refocus,Aa34yZzv,0.15039586436,Valid,v3zyAZa4,0.0970261414,Valid,4aZAyz3v,11.2748326932,Valid,4aAy3vZz,11.2748326932,Valid,1.52688147012 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.141674249963,Valid,0.140902409273,Valid,0.106930937233,Valid,0.13871785378,Valid,0.106112592162,Valid,0.128161852562,Valid,0.134007228706,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,ReductionSemantics,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.10548958939,0.0,0.0,0.134007228706,0.128161852562,0.106930937233,0.13871785378,0.106112592162,0.10548958939,0.140902409273,0.141674249963,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:WP_parameter test,3aAvyzZ4,0.106930937233,Valid,vy3zZ4Aa,0.10548958939,Valid,aA4Zz3yv,0.141674249963,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.10548958939,Valid,0.125249589134 +defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:size_c_pos,Unknown,0.13458307261,Unknown,0.135561741438,Unknown,0.176043767156,Unknown,0.135639678609,Failure,5.3700952522,Timeout,10.1321506584,Failure,7.6849279636,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,size_c_pos,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,ReductionSemantics,0.0,1.0,Unknown,0.109993556509,0.0,0.0,12.6118245233,14.2358869399,10.1760437672,10.1356396786,11.3506794078,10.1099935565,10.1355617414,10.1345830726,8.68855167255,8.69859302022,8.86794921839,11.5588640231,11.422929724,10.8202147785,11.9153648686,11.2827327204,defunctionalization:ReductionSemantics:size_c_pos,aA3zvy4Z,23.8789956905,Unknown,vaA43yZz,23.8789956905,Unknown,zZy34Aav,23.8789956905,Timeout,Aa3zZ4vy,23.8789956905,Unknown,23.8789956905 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter continue_4,Valid,0.5480010705,Valid,0.167580815344,Valid,0.1616826305,Valid,1.81501461367,Valid,0.776341152091,Valid,0.157145506286,Valid,0.15757102361,5.0,0.0,1.931818,1.0,12.0,44.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,34.0,WP_parameter continue_4,1.0,0.0,3.0,4.0,2.0,43.0,46.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,90.0,SemWithError,0.0,37.0,Valid,0.20885132562,0.0,2.0,0.15757102361,0.157145506286,0.1616826305,1.81501461367,0.776341152091,0.20885132562,0.167580815344,0.5480010705,6.43473078927,5.38182758299,7.53715627777,8.46909336937,9.26585797011,9.91492525224,9.56128055541,10.7946922904,defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter continue_4,Aa34yZzv,0.167580815344,Valid,zZ3Avay4,0.157145506286,Valid,4yavA3Zz,1.81501461367,Valid,Z3vzA4ya,0.15757102361,Valid,0.499023517203 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter cps3_correct_expr,Timeout,11.1165365512,Timeout,10.118550583,Unknown,0.267202864412,Timeout,11.1546833266,Unknown,5.0307383072,Valid,0.312404617176,Valid,0.316955435808,3.0,0.0,1.857143,7.0,12.0,49.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,6.0,42.0,WP_parameter cps3_correct_expr,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,59.0,56.0,7.0,6.0,0.0,2.0,113.0,SemWithError,0.0,46.0,Timeout,10.1030180624,3.0,8.0,0.316955435808,0.312404617176,10.2672028644,14.980886493,15.0307383072,14.2151670398,14.226210525,14.9525043018,5.75675868229,4.99001400415,7.26580089127,6.1214332888,7.90424327485,10.1434237153,10.2432302468,12.6498967413,defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter cps3_correct_expr,Aa43yzZv,38.0001162496,Valid,zZ3vAa4y,0.312404617176,Valid,y4aAv3Zz,48.1076851306,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,38.0046670682,Valid,16.2449232581 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter eval_4,Valid,1.2869514218,Valid,0.258034848176,Valid,0.531812965,Timeout,10.2145307646,Timeout,10.1010324288,Valid,0.391967453261,Valid,0.372013145571,5.0,0.0,1.863636,1.0,10.0,44.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,3.0,36.0,WP_parameter eval_4,1.0,0.0,2.0,4.0,1.0,38.0,46.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,86.0,SemWithError,0.0,33.0,Valid,0.184702588818,0.0,1.0,0.372013145571,0.391967453261,0.531812965,14.2946367125,14.2137558769,0.184702588818,0.258034848176,1.2869514218,5.28907962009,4.11675406838,6.57642613675,7.72080982833,8.63814334178,8.58018359455,8.30969491303,10.1549066892,defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter eval_4,Aa34Zzyv,0.258034848176,Valid,vAZz3ay4,0.184702588818,Valid,4ya3zZAv,21.6025146152,Valid,Z3vzA4ya,0.372013145571,Valid,3.40647038378 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter interpret_4,Valid,0.155440184313,Valid,0.15805497585,Valid,0.15397341524,Valid,0.780327046388,Valid,0.144228958632,Valid,0.158413100712,Valid,0.16119088628,0.0,0.0,1.833333,0.0,6.0,6.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,2.0,5.0,WP_parameter interpret_4,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,6.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,12.0,SemWithError,0.0,4.0,Valid,0.13849625181,0.0,1.0,0.16119088628,0.158413100712,0.15397341524,0.780327046388,0.144228958632,0.13849625181,0.15805497585,0.155440184313,7.90404121827,6.85185002956,6.89865424833,7.28298001744,9.06774655197,8.30737792174,8.90743936303,9.04812924799,defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter interpret_4,A34azZvy,0.15805497585,Valid,vy3aAzZ4,0.13849625181,Valid,4ZzAa3yv,0.780327046388,Valid,4Zzv3Aay,0.780327046388,Valid,0.231265602403 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.149433869393,Valid,0.152407878,Valid,0.147208676764,Valid,0.160249938563,Valid,0.138645105873,Valid,0.146821761062,Valid,0.153733651643,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,SemWithError,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.126909885396,0.0,0.0,0.153733651643,0.146821761062,0.147208676764,0.160249938563,0.138645105873,0.126909885396,0.152407878,0.149433869393,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,defunctionalization:SemWithError:WP_parameter test,3aAvyzZ4,0.147208676764,Valid,vyz3aAZ4,0.126909885396,Valid,4ZAa3zyv,0.160249938563,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.126909885396,Valid,0.146926345837 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps2_correct,Valid,0.1250733242,Valid,0.136387027925,Unknown,0.1359320622,Valid,0.15228137838,Valid,0.122007301136,Valid,0.146986235741,Valid,0.150854068359,0.0,0.0,1.666667,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,cps2_correct,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,SemWithError,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.106962284615,0.0,0.0,0.150854068359,0.146986235741,10.1359320622,0.15228137838,0.122007301136,0.106962284615,0.136387027925,0.1250733242,7.3881075488,6.69397287511,5.69224982089,5.6533301898,8.33123530514,8.67827364545,6.21696245483,7.90057113604,defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps2_correct,43ZAavyz,0.15228137838,Valid,vyaAzZ43,0.106962284615,Valid,34ZzAayv,0.28821344058,Valid,4Z3Avyza,0.15228137838,Valid,0.151356024969 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps2_correct_expr,Unknown,0.23087053835,Unknown,0.18328006362,Unknown,0.133660287286,Timeout,11.132044309,Failure,7.1531283064,Timeout,10.1299569178,Timeout,10.143509205,0.0,0.0,1.75,1.0,5.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,8.0,cps2_correct_expr,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,9.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,18.0,SemWithError,0.0,8.0,Timeout,10.0847596158,0.0,2.0,14.2439734271,14.2343256657,10.1336602873,14.9640372392,12.2950089291,14.2021961861,10.1832800636,10.2308705384,6.49985361865,5.75553299326,7.13074181079,3.75107611887,7.64008259696,8.31878671455,6.55344957417,10.2196283121,defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps2_correct_expr,4AaZ3yzv,49.1912092433,Timeout,3AayvzZ4,49.1912092433,Unknown,4ZzvyaA3,49.1912092433,Timeout,4za3AZyv,49.1912092433,Timeout,49.1912092433 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps2_correct_expr_aux,Valid,0.12792992362,Valid,0.124581359444,Valid,0.115568687385,Valid,0.15027841994,Valid,0.1007327882,Valid,0.157667290607,Valid,0.152523639308,0.0,0.0,2.8,0.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,cps2_correct_expr_aux,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,9.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,15.0,SemWithError,0.0,9.0,Timeout,10.0935958114,0.0,0.0,0.152523639308,0.157667290607,0.115568687385,0.15027841994,0.1007327882,14.208471994,0.124581359444,0.12792992362,6.77325626845,5.71032373491,8.22096810702,5.4521646078,9.60413018587,7.89594695989,7.53590000373,8.39902210052,defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps2_correct_expr_aux,4AaZz3vy,0.15027841994,Valid,y3Aa4Zzv,0.1007327882,Valid,vzZ4aA3y,10.251263102,Valid,Aa34Zzyv,0.124581359444,Valid,1.39445406335 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps3_correct,Valid,0.129737987021,Valid,0.131422128426,Unknown,0.180791758889,Valid,0.159858520217,Valid,0.113678975937,Valid,0.152147497656,Valid,0.144645325258,0.0,0.0,1.666667,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,cps3_correct,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,SemWithError,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.11255211728,0.0,0.0,0.144645325258,0.152147497656,10.1807917589,0.159858520217,0.113678975937,0.11255211728,0.131422128426,0.129737987021,7.3881075488,6.69397287511,5.69224982089,5.6533301898,8.33123530514,8.67827364545,6.21696245483,7.90057113604,defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps3_correct,43ZAavyz,0.159858520217,Valid,vyaAZz43,0.11255211728,Valid,34zZAayv,0.340650279106,Valid,4Z3Avyza,0.159858520217,Valid,0.157462191546 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps_correct,Valid,0.12868548445,Valid,0.133507747455,Valid,0.106666520968,Valid,0.14290425891,Valid,0.107598404576,Valid,0.1433174318,Valid,0.136879350552,0.0,0.0,1.666667,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,cps_correct,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,SemWithError,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.0970412448704,0.0,0.0,0.136879350552,0.1433174318,0.106666520968,0.14290425891,0.107598404576,0.0970412448704,0.133507747455,0.12868548445,7.3881075488,6.69397287511,5.69224982089,5.6533301898,8.33123530514,8.67827364545,6.21696245483,7.90057113604,defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps_correct,43ZAavyz,0.14290425891,Valid,v3yaAZ4z,0.0970412448704,Valid,z4ZAay3v,0.1433174318,Valid,4Z3Avyza,0.14290425891,Valid,0.124575055448 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps_correct_expr,Unknown,0.1213008544,Unknown,0.134341870395,Timeout,10.0941531252,Unknown,0.140154808372,Unknown,3.6794460126,Timeout,10.1159410728,Timeout,10.1315963018,0.0,0.0,2.25,0.0,6.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,2.0,4.0,cps_correct_expr,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,4.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,SemWithError,0.0,4.0,Timeout,10.0805933028,0.0,0.0,14.2354923913,14.2243546001,14.2088679111,10.1401548084,13.6794460126,14.1992380548,10.1343418704,10.1213008544,11.8878422632,10.9002139295,9.96904238778,5.66713514915,9.88586152072,9.72024850419,6.98126371987,10.4266328556,defunctionalization:SemWithError:cps_correct_expr,4Zzy3vAa,44.4975273484,Unknown,aA4yv3zZ,44.4975273484,Unknown,Zz3vy4Aa,44.4975273484,Timeout,Z4zyA3av,44.4975273484,Timeout,44.4975273484 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:size_c_pos,Unknown,0.15261045352,Unknown,0.158839956489,Unknown,6.5102987542,Unknown,0.176153448186,Timeout,10.098067337,Timeout,10.1510603088,Timeout,10.1463222508,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,size_c_pos,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,SemWithError,0.0,1.0,Timeout,10.100747816,0.0,0.0,14.2459768081,14.2493517534,16.5102987542,10.1761534482,14.2116488819,14.2135536177,10.1588399565,10.1526104535,8.68855167255,8.69859302022,8.86794921839,11.5588640231,11.422929724,10.8202147785,11.9153648686,11.2827327204,defunctionalization:SemWithError:size_c_pos,aA3zvy4Z,47.494100325,Unknown,aA4yvZz3,47.494100325,Unknown,3zZvy4Aa,47.494100325,Unknown,Aa3zZ4vy,47.494100325,Unknown,47.494100325 +defunctionalization:SemWithError:size_e_pos,Unknown,0.142098427384,Unknown,0.147565957961,Unknown,1.8226606104,Timeout,11.1204268356,Timeout,10.1067788248,Timeout,10.1310555828,Timeout,10.1235357294,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,defunctionalization.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,size_e_pos,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,SemWithError,0.0,1.0,Unknown,0.1114320644,0.0,0.0,14.2297566973,14.2351075592,11.8226606104,14.9553967853,14.2178401388,10.1114320644,10.147565958,10.1420984274,8.68855167255,8.69859302022,8.86794921839,11.5588640231,11.422929724,10.8202147785,11.9153648686,11.2827327204,defunctionalization:SemWithError:size_e_pos,aA3zvy4Z,43.7055540327,Unknown,vaA3yZz4,43.7055540327,Unknown,4zZy3Aav,43.7055540327,Timeout,Aa3zZ4vy,43.7055540327,Unknown,43.7055540327 +edit_distance:EditDistance:WP_parameter distance,Timeout,11.135601846,Timeout,10.157209245,Timeout,10.1593623554,Timeout,11.1694650292,Timeout,10.1478607798,Timeout,10.1951620184,Timeout,10.1591453562,144.0,0.0,2.166667,0.0,57.0,678.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,56.0,454.0,WP_parameter distance,2.0,0.0,71.0,191.0,9.0,734.0,680.0,2.0,56.0,0.0,0.0,1470.0,EditDistance,0.0,543.0,Timeout,10.152056596,0.0,0.0,14.2551125695,14.2808027989,14.2552672184,14.9918961122,14.2470726258,14.2500615131,14.253732832,14.9666839504,14.4291796216,12.8914443733,11.7968684972,14.4236901782,13.7606814695,11.4144975565,11.6037124271,13.7204688847,edit_distance:EditDistance:WP_parameter distance,zZ3Avy4a,83.275863226,Timeout,yvAZ3za4,83.275863226,Timeout,4az3ZAvy,83.275863226,Timeout,ZzyvA34a,83.275863226,Timeout,83.275863226 +edit_distance:EditDistance:suffix_length,Timeout,11.1216420962,Timeout,10.1398940054,Timeout,10.1291741468,Timeout,11.1743116304,Timeout,10.1538788486,Timeout,10.1678211934,Timeout,10.1892397312,1.0,0.0,1.8,0.0,6.0,10.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,8.0,suffix_length,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,8.0,10.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,19.0,EditDistance,0.0,7.0,Timeout,10.1161472692,0.0,0.0,14.2765754402,14.2612968492,14.2337686119,14.995507341,14.2513597833,14.2245012416,14.2413991743,14.9563004422,6.5020127469,5.50663068916,4.96544577244,4.6000245429,8.23694807578,6.55551703525,6.24874273935,7.27542064671,edit_distance:EditDistance:suffix_length,43AZazvy,83.1921089212,Timeout,v3AyzZa4,83.1921089212,Timeout,4aZzyA3v,83.1921089212,Timeout,zZ3vA4ay,83.1921089212,Timeout,83.1921089212 +edit_distance:Word:dist_concat_left,Timeout,11.1242766066,Timeout,10.1365122466,Timeout,10.1232526696,Timeout,11.1605659014,Timeout,10.1520709692,Timeout,10.175700483,Timeout,10.158492992,0.0,0.0,2.333333,0.0,6.0,6.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,dist_concat_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,6.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,15.0,Word,0.0,8.0,Timeout,10.1072157836,0.0,0.0,14.2546476585,14.2669155854,14.2295553203,14.9852671394,14.2500717529,14.2181507552,14.2389915558,14.9582595919,7.01353326319,6.22300598457,6.62254242026,6.53128264308,8.42879842326,8.02890459397,7.6073497176,9.45221067842,edit_distance:Word:dist_concat_left,A43aZzyv,83.138087652,Timeout,v3AyZza4,83.138087652,Timeout,4azZyA3v,83.138087652,Timeout,aAzZ43yv,83.138087652,Timeout,83.138087652 +edit_distance:Word:dist_concat_right,Valid,0.155936636457,Valid,0.15559332231,Timeout,10.1066582142,Valid,0.174543053077,Valid,0.248364845439,Valid,0.15974302285,Valid,0.156475323535,0.0,0.0,2.333333,0.0,6.0,6.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,dist_concat_right,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,6.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,15.0,Word,0.0,8.0,Valid,0.13263111489,0.0,0.0,0.156475323535,0.15974302285,14.2177544028,0.174543053077,0.248364845439,0.13263111489,0.15559332231,0.155936636457,7.01353326319,6.22300598457,6.62254242026,6.53128264308,8.42879842326,8.02890459397,7.6073497176,9.45221067842,edit_distance:Word:dist_concat_right,A43aZzyv,0.15559332231,Valid,vAaZz4y3,0.13263111489,Valid,3y4zZaAv,10.3550230596,Valid,aAzZ43yv,0.155936636457,Valid,1.43237332228 +edit_distance:Word:dist_symetry,Timeout,11.1276305782,Timeout,10.1300102526,Timeout,10.120555582,Timeout,10.1927292202,Failure,6.6284135886,Timeout,10.1795654388,Timeout,10.1940396482,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,dist_symetry,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,Word,0.0,6.0,Timeout,10.107995557,0.0,0.0,14.2800015528,14.2696724743,14.2276366726,14.2790661094,11.9973274816,14.218705081,14.2343636218,14.9607540681,4.91720920586,4.75693338516,8.52071524781,8.98857338664,10.705419866,6.73986437196,6.76845532234,6.9407056316,edit_distance:Word:dist_symetry,AazZv34y,78.6809398656,Timeout,yv3Az4Za,78.6809398656,Failure,aZ4zA3vy,78.6809398656,Timeout,a3AyzZv4,78.6809398656,Timeout,78.6809398656 +edit_distance:Word:first_last,Unknown,0.15521346323,Unknown,0.169517916845,Unknown,0.172636620455,Valid,0.356127790544,Timeout,10.1605451614,Timeout,10.114713691,Timeout,10.1311406328,1.0,0.0,1.777778,0.0,7.0,9.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,8.0,first_last,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,7.0,9.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,17.0,Word,0.0,6.0,Timeout,10.1085270012,0.0,1.0,14.235168089,14.2234817485,10.1726366205,0.356127790544,14.256110198,14.2190828865,10.1695179168,10.1552134632,8.8120683351,8.32833351889,8.41824650805,4.10593789863,9.42248373427,8.18589219504,6.55495601672,9.8150673903,edit_distance:Word:first_last,4ZzA3ayv,0.356127790544,Valid,4aA3vzZy,0.356127790544,Valid,yZzv3Aa4,41.3684222775,Valid,4za3AZyv,0.356127790544,Valid,20.862275034 +edit_distance:Word:first_last_explicit,Timeout,11.1154149036,Timeout,10.2043130928,Timeout,10.1081789986,Timeout,11.080360975,Timeout,10.1646393428,Timeout,10.1246949854,Timeout,10.1302897236,0.0,0.0,1.857143,0.0,6.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,7.0,first_last_explicit,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,7.0,7.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,14.0,Word,0.0,6.0,Timeout,10.1209699766,0.0,1.0,14.2345625112,14.230581455,14.2188354892,14.9256289427,14.2590284721,14.2279314472,14.28733725,14.9516704244,10.2635303086,9.30765067539,8.95779105219,3.29961362107,9.62406482688,9.70268278398,7.61377948246,9.88370531121,edit_distance:Word:first_last_explicit,4Z3Ayzva,83.0488619984,Timeout,3vzZyA4a,83.0488619984,Timeout,a4AyZzv3,83.0488619984,Timeout,Aa34Zzyv,83.0488619984,Timeout,83.0488619984 +edit_distance:Word:key_lemma_left,Timeout,11.1128382762,Timeout,10.124991686,Timeout,10.1193704804,Valid,0.323855917739,Timeout,10.112173885,Valid,0.168753089533,Valid,0.15870415523,2.0,0.0,2.25,0.0,9.0,12.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,9.0,key_lemma_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,14.0,12.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,28.0,Word,0.0,13.0,Timeout,10.1009783978,0.0,0.0,0.15870415523,0.168753089533,14.2267936978,0.323855917739,14.2216757339,14.2137174797,14.2307925514,14.9497549998,3.95253558522,3.61242934332,4.94683061474,3.99965840273,7.50726291829,4.9244663236,4.30903204258,5.51393010733,edit_distance:Word:key_lemma_left,Aa4Zz3vy,21.5616858799,Valid,Zz4vy3Aa,0.15870415523,Valid,aA3yv4zZ,51.8942086431,Valid,AavzZ34y,31.5075614495,Valid,13.1096925689 +edit_distance:Word:key_lemma_right,Timeout,11.1102006094,Timeout,10.125721787,Timeout,10.120507569,Timeout,11.1314531562,Failure,10.008893731,Timeout,10.1478250574,Timeout,10.1447660462,2.0,0.0,2.285714,0.0,11.0,14.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,2.0,10.0,key_lemma_right,0.0,0.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,16.0,14.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,33.0,Word,0.0,15.0,Timeout,10.1027449034,0.0,0.0,14.2448684842,14.2470471816,14.2276025195,14.9635974742,14.1484258389,14.2149729012,14.2313120164,14.9477944052,5.06872621215,4.7091368024,6.30896031079,5.77296299727,8.61737906808,6.48197581115,6.10880793695,6.19313239131,edit_distance:Word:key_lemma_right,Aa4Zv3zy,82.8921128596,Timeout,yv3AZza4,82.8921128596,Failure,4azZA3vy,82.8921128596,Timeout,43vAayZz,82.8921128596,Timeout,82.8921128596 +edit_distance:Word:min_dist_diff,Timeout,11.1266183474,Timeout,10.1284861014,Timeout,10.1044068454,Timeout,10.2563106336,Timeout,10.1191703678,Timeout,10.1443551388,Timeout,10.1489370064,0.0,0.0,2.214286,0.0,8.0,14.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,10.0,min_dist_diff,0.0,0.0,3.0,1.0,0.0,17.0,14.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,32.0,Word,0.0,16.0,Timeout,10.113761141,0.0,0.0,14.2478392172,14.2445758513,14.2161541106,14.3245212071,14.2266513605,14.2228043795,14.2332789865,14.9600011982,7.56877850969,7.13516956918,9.22928792095,9.95531698909,10.2722760535,8.89553718455,8.45123838552,9.08803468113,edit_distance:Word:min_dist_diff,AaZzv34y,82.1420455818,Timeout,3vyAzZ4a,82.1420455818,Timeout,a4ZzAyv3,82.1420455818,Timeout,AavZzy34,82.1420455818,Timeout,82.1420455818 +edit_distance:Word:min_dist_eps,Timeout,11.1203209044,Timeout,10.1365427584,Valid,1.25252017713,Timeout,11.1322974488,Timeout,10.1111651336,Failure,8.7974378484,Failure,8.6501734308,0.0,0.0,1.857143,0.0,5.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,min_dist_eps,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,8.0,7.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,14.0,Word,0.0,5.0,Timeout,10.1034408614,0.0,2.0,13.2221594448,13.3189681543,1.25252017713,14.9642255559,14.2209584895,14.215467535,14.2390132767,14.9553180179,6.86549972332,5.98167526028,5.63881251835,5.94415396421,8.42002884586,7.55281249415,7.20602845678,8.03331978625,edit_distance:Word:min_dist_eps,34AaZzvy,1.25252017713,Valid,3ZzvyAa4,1.25252017713,Valid,4aAyvzZ3,71.3038985629,Valid,zZ3vA4ay,18.7001314563,Valid,36.27820937 +edit_distance:Word:min_dist_eps_length,Unknown,0.1518303628,Unknown,0.15316901467,Timeout,10.1286054748,Timeout,11.1514886652,Timeout,10.154762921,Timeout,10.1408225628,Timeout,10.1294897112,0.0,0.0,1.666667,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,min_dist_eps_length,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,Word,0.0,2.0,Timeout,10.1134860054,0.0,1.0,14.2339931786,14.2420603232,14.2333639335,14.978507918,14.251989685,14.2226087333,10.1531690147,10.1518303628,7.030080019,6.06476543298,4.87434189078,4.13088193487,7.76970848605,8.29208619839,4.74938078248,7.21864610923,edit_distance:Word:min_dist_eps_length,4Z3Aavyz,62.1236547179,Timeout,aAv3Zzy4,62.1236547179,Unknown,4yzZ3vAa,62.1236547179,Timeout,4Z3Avyza,62.1236547179,Timeout,62.1236547179 +edit_distance:Word:min_dist_equal,Timeout,11.1184303784,Timeout,10.1280303846,Timeout,10.0994610226,Timeout,10.2286558356,Timeout,10.1324512604,Timeout,10.1496810616,Timeout,10.1316449582,0.0,0.0,2.6,0.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,edit_distance.mlw,0.0,1.0,4.0,min_dist_equal,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,14.0,Word,0.0,8.0,Timeout,10.0957149568,0.0,0.0,14.2355270208,14.2483692278,14.2126391971,14.3047334894,14.2361008898,14.2099774978,14.2329546993,14.9539123335,5.75358131634,5.05018656682,6.79325209333,7.95535175427,8.87877081679,7.59743118435,7.66453108521,9.39148345565,edit_distance:Word:min_dist_equal,Aa3zZ4yv,82.0840698582,Timeout,v3AZyz4a,82.0840698582,Timeout,a4zyZA3v,82.0840698582,Timeout,AavZz34y,82.0840698582,Timeout,82.0840698582 +fill:Fill:WP_parameter fill,Valid,0.151015392167,Valid,0.13739240692,Valid,0.120644991833,Valid,0.15427083568,Valid,0.108646386,Unknown,0.13021939761,Unknown,0.133351049136,36.0,0.0,2.162791,3.0,26.0,129.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,fill.mlw,0.0,15.0,76.0,WP_parameter fill,1.0,0.0,13.0,13.0,1.0,144.0,133.0,4.0,15.0,1.0,2.0,289.0,Fill,0.0,124.0,Failure,2.339575376,2.0,3.0,10.1333510491,10.1302193976,0.120644991833,0.15427083568,0.108646386,10.2700347098,0.13739240692,0.151015392167,7.73627785755,6.17679861319,8.05906707915,8.64552577894,8.70271618253,7.93243030562,7.90549590414,11.4278091972,fill:Fill:WP_parameter fill,AaZz34yv,0.13739240692,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,0.108646386,Valid,vZz4aA3y,2.75741665843,Valid,vyA3zZ4a,2.448221762,Valid,0.568251639644 +foveoos11_challenge3:TwoEqualElements:WP_parameter two_equal_elements,Unknown,0.758798488067,Unknown,0.828098133867,Timeout,10.1119912022,Timeout,10.275225191,Timeout,10.1040252108,Unknown,0.563519779158,Unknown,0.526107785,120.0,0.0,1.996845,0.0,37.0,634.0,0.0,10.0,0.0,foveoos11_challenge3.mlw,0.0,41.0,365.0,WP_parameter two_equal_elements,12.0,0.0,87.0,150.0,5.0,581.0,646.0,12.0,51.0,57.0,0.0,1267.0,TwoEqualElements,0.0,420.0,Timeout,10.1049495374,0.0,11.0,10.526107785,10.5635197792,14.2215458398,14.3380700489,14.215882859,14.2165398446,10.8280981339,10.7587984881,14.0273750367,12.2179977443,11.8732299007,14.1179415105,13.4833450363,11.2446658181,11.6279739234,13.546607048,foveoos11_challenge3:TwoEqualElements:WP_parameter two_equal_elements,zZ3Ayva4,43.2727153275,Unknown,ZzaAyv34,43.2727153275,Unknown,43vyAazZ,43.2727153275,Timeout,3zZvyaA4,43.2727153275,Timeout,43.2727153275 +generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:WP_parameter all_trees,Timeout,11.1000131344,Timeout,10.11945739,Valid,0.788887223429,Timeout,10.1961059762,Timeout,10.0989334492,Timeout,10.1238870844,Timeout,10.12731621,64.0,0.0,2.087302,0.0,50.0,252.0,0.0,5.0,0.0,generate_all_trees.mlw,0.0,27.0,156.0,WP_parameter all_trees,0.0,5.0,28.0,49.0,4.0,242.0,257.0,5.0,32.0,0.0,0.0,527.0,GenerateAllTrees,0.0,189.0,Timeout,10.1006268698,0.0,4.0,14.2324465085,14.2300066654,0.788887223429,14.2814767121,14.2122643098,14.2134676685,14.2268555158,14.9402239469,11.0950824188,7.54372458995,9.2002260191,9.1871188217,10.6611722071,5.65531987941,5.51715992225,12.4772216809,generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:WP_parameter all_trees,ZzA43yav,41.355653884,Valid,3yvAzZ4a,0.788887223429,Valid,a4ZzAvy3,72.6552273374,Valid,zZ34Avya,21.0400905178,Valid,36.7220572804 +generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:WP_parameter combine,Timeout,11.1042098318,Timeout,10.1311514042,Timeout,10.1197821484,Timeout,11.132516533,Unknown,5.8697355816,Timeout,10.1335917694,Timeout,10.1347742258,34.0,0.0,2.180328,4.0,23.0,122.0,0.0,9.0,2.0,generate_all_trees.mlw,0.0,16.0,77.0,WP_parameter combine,0.0,9.0,7.0,2.0,4.0,125.0,135.0,13.0,25.0,0.0,0.0,279.0,GenerateAllTrees,0.0,113.0,Timeout,10.098763657,2.0,6.0,14.2377543387,14.2369126621,14.2270865159,14.9643885394,15.8697355816,14.2121436596,14.235175755,14.9433421961,9.26827786906,6.96973687228,8.0899819871,9.95452004284,10.1982886612,9.40215807024,9.46888870185,11.6036212655,generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:WP_parameter combine,A3azZ4yv,78.7245251512,Timeout,v3AzZa4y,78.7245251512,Timeout,y4aZzA3v,78.7245251512,Unknown,zZ34Avya,78.7245251512,Timeout,78.7245251512 +generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:all_trees_0,Unknown,0.163132959696,Timeout,10.1319535648,Timeout,10.0982508398,Timeout,10.1696510194,Timeout,10.1337941604,Timeout,10.1320709614,Timeout,10.134276522,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,3.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,generate_all_trees.mlw,0.0,0.0,4.0,all_trees_0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,3.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,GenerateAllTrees,0.0,0.0,Timeout,10.1101280894,0.0,2.0,14.2374000655,14.235830217,14.2117792702,14.2626015108,14.2370567213,14.2202211651,14.2357466625,10.1631329597,3.98554800504,3.83974893801,2.7288749105,1.96991006348,5.65641776218,4.80721086294,1.48122691167,4.90864337215,generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:all_trees_0,Z43Aazvy,71.0732581169,Timeout,a3vAzyZ4,71.0732581169,Unknown,4ZyzAv3a,71.0732581169,Timeout,Z43Avayz,71.0732581169,Timeout,71.0732581169 +generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:size_left,Unknown,0.121954007971,Unknown,0.12608782926,Timeout,10.093853234,Timeout,11.1132383228,Unknown,1.139160714,Timeout,10.121229765,Timeout,10.1214391644,1.0,0.0,1.888889,0.0,7.0,9.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,generate_all_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,7.0,size_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,7.0,9.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,18.0,GenerateAllTrees,0.0,6.0,Unknown,0.103583629022,0.0,0.0,14.2282652055,14.2281162476,14.2086548663,14.9500523751,11.139160714,10.103583629,10.1260878293,10.121954008,6.12715636785,5.37025696335,5.19558551909,6.19513027488,9.25530173833,8.54343775632,8.68481505216,7.43991821317,generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:size_left,3Aa4vzZy,42.9405466665,Timeout,vaAy3zZ4,42.9405466665,Unknown,4Zz3yAav,42.9405466665,Timeout,3Aa4vyzZ,42.9405466665,Timeout,42.9405466665 +generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:size_nonneg,Unknown,0.120278038328,Unknown,0.12538001636,Timeout,10.094711126,Timeout,11.1151557886,Unknown,4.27013305846,Timeout,10.1175182144,Timeout,10.1163559244,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,generate_all_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,size_nonneg,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,GenerateAllTrees,0.0,1.0,Unknown,0.09954550944,0.0,0.0,14.2246496333,14.2254762598,14.2092643271,14.9514777933,14.2701330585,10.0995455094,10.1253800164,10.1202780383,8.68855167255,8.69859302022,8.86794921839,11.5588640231,11.422929724,10.8202147785,11.9153648686,11.2827327204,generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:size_nonneg,aA3zvy4Z,46.059077676,Unknown,vaA3Zzy4,46.059077676,Unknown,4yzZ3Aav,46.059077676,Timeout,Aa3zZ4vy,46.059077676,Unknown,46.059077676 +generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:tree_diff,Valid,0.123534745162,Valid,0.126750038933,Valid,0.1035046902,Valid,0.13703062829,Valid,0.106316722719,Valid,0.1328370775,Valid,0.128394874451,0.0,0.0,1.777778,0.0,7.0,9.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,generate_all_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,6.0,tree_diff,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,9.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,17.0,GenerateAllTrees,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.103581458409,0.0,0.0,0.128394874451,0.1328370775,0.1035046902,0.13703062829,0.106316722719,0.103581458409,0.126750038933,0.123534745162,9.26883834622,7.82474744113,7.83586452358,7.19794405038,9.98767238557,9.21671866727,8.56358094916,10.5746174751,generate_all_trees:GenerateAllTrees:tree_diff,4A3Zzayv,0.13703062829,Valid,3vyaAZz4,0.1035046902,Valid,4zZAayv3,0.13703062829,Valid,aAzZ43yv,0.123534745162,Valid,0.120243779458 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter add,Timeout,9.4068111574,Unknown,0.492215839667,Failure,7.9066373806,Timeout,10.1723141136,Unknown,0.14723080119,Timeout,10.1308356884,Timeout,10.1565745192,25.0,0.0,2.196078,0.0,24.0,102.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,16.0,62.0,WP_parameter add,0.0,0.0,12.0,16.0,1.0,108.0,102.0,0.0,16.0,2.0,0.0,225.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,91.0,Unknown,0.135389216556,0.0,1.0,14.2532805334,14.2349510623,12.748133772,14.2645004969,10.1472308012,10.1353892166,10.4922158397,13.7290966983,7.87015591767,6.10383996048,6.46577483138,7.27062581821,7.73259303005,7.31280582983,7.29140264533,10.6455847678,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter add,A34Zzyav,48.5480087166,Unknown,vyA3azZ4,48.5480087166,Unknown,4Zza3Ayv,48.5480087166,Timeout,zZ43Ayav,48.5480087166,Timeout,48.5480087166 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter clear,Valid,0.201144350779,Valid,0.191259313889,Failure,7.695803062,Timeout,10.193802825,Unknown,0.14633881258,Timeout,10.1293107658,Timeout,10.133946057,17.0,0.0,2.088235,0.0,18.0,68.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,10.0,42.0,WP_parameter clear,0.0,0.0,8.0,17.0,0.0,68.0,68.0,0.0,10.0,0.0,1.0,143.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,48.0,Unknown,0.128899888082,0.0,3.0,14.2371648402,14.2338658343,12.6184541355,14.2798324932,10.1463388126,10.1288998881,0.191259313889,0.201144350779,2.17941585775,1.77983557248,1.78100728198,2.31009140587,2.72445162306,2.06003647144,1.95270749983,5.55690106939,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter clear,A3Zza4yv,0.191259313889,Valid,Aavy3zZ4,0.191259313889,Valid,4Zz3yvaA,38.6292457612,Valid,A3Zzay4v,0.191259313889,Valid,13.0055689692 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter create,Valid,0.177039888238,Valid,0.167366630189,Failure,7.5828524586,Timeout,10.1661842896,Unknown,0.145543241773,Timeout,10.1332385828,Timeout,10.1270934978,7.0,0.0,2.068966,0.0,13.0,29.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,5.0,17.0,WP_parameter create,0.0,0.0,4.0,6.0,1.0,29.0,29.0,0.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,61.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,21.0,Unknown,0.126018277361,0.0,2.0,14.2322880351,14.2366612721,12.5498865098,14.2601298385,10.1455432418,10.1260182774,0.167366630189,0.177039888238,3.10419177742,2.46170673039,2.63826458344,3.22334219359,5.08937700874,3.76221228054,3.46929982464,5.9378761364,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter create,A3a4Zzyv,0.167366630189,Valid,Aavy3Zz4,0.167366630189,Valid,4zZ3yvaA,38.4579702362,Valid,3AzZa4yv,7.75021908879,Valid,12.9325133752 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter find,Unknown,0.412762341758,Unknown,0.171288149563,Failure,7.8182007306,Timeout,10.1781264898,Unknown,0.144590940833,Timeout,10.1351957836,Timeout,10.1329440366,6.0,0.0,2.15625,1.0,13.0,32.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,5.0,20.0,WP_parameter find,0.0,0.0,3.0,4.0,2.0,36.0,33.0,1.0,5.0,1.0,0.0,73.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,31.0,Unknown,0.126408348672,0.0,1.0,14.2364516242,14.2380544167,12.6934732309,14.2686460059,10.1445909408,10.1264083487,10.1712881496,10.4127623418,5.02777595052,3.92923477371,4.7817507596,6.16813267398,7.20053511861,6.16567614097,5.47378219289,7.8716313799,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter find,A3aZz4yv,39.1195168214,Unknown,vyAa3Zz4,39.1195168214,Unknown,4zZ3aAyv,39.1195168214,Timeout,3AzZa4yv,39.1195168214,Failure,39.1195168214 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter list_find,Valid,0.145958227857,Valid,0.151204585667,Valid,0.15692892525,Valid,0.188415820244,Valid,0.14573639925,Timeout,10.1404512032,Timeout,10.1383197448,1.0,0.0,2.107143,4.0,12.0,28.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,5.0,23.0,WP_parameter list_find,1.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,38.0,33.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,0.0,72.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,32.0,Timeout,10.1100411962,1.0,4.0,14.2402783417,14.2417959052,0.15692892525,0.188415820244,0.14573639925,14.2201593869,0.151204585667,0.145958227857,4.21992642078,3.35472567281,5.41046913103,4.49083162956,5.89637665478,10.5546058314,10.2966784406,13.0289283142,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter list_find,Aa43yZzv,0.151204585667,Valid,yaA34vZz,0.14573639925,Valid,zZv43Aay,30.5772279644,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.15692892525,Valid,5.22245081569 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter list_remove,Valid,0.157167107429,Valid,0.152794050113,Valid,0.150520102833,Valid,0.195057021292,Valid,0.140048459228,Timeout,10.1267007192,Timeout,10.128971662,7.0,1.0,2.27451,3.0,12.0,51.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,8.0,37.0,WP_parameter list_remove,1.0,5.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,62.0,61.0,9.0,8.0,5.0,0.0,127.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,53.0,Timeout,10.1084661224,3.0,4.0,14.2336245184,14.2320085531,0.150520102833,0.195057021292,0.140048459228,14.2190396071,0.152794050113,0.157167107429,5.94629639996,5.06867017656,6.26094812582,6.19511481389,7.8734819761,10.1273503485,9.80215748637,12.2435473479,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter list_remove,Aa43yZzv,0.152794050113,Valid,y3Aa4vzZ,0.140048459228,Valid,Zzv4aA3y,30.5591955249,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.150520102833,Valid,5.21980709878 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter remove,Unknown,0.420801349058,Unknown,0.168019764702,Failure,7.9646106892,Timeout,10.167973255,Unknown,0.147515739026,Timeout,10.1313036972,Timeout,10.1467984924,16.0,0.0,2.120482,2.0,26.0,83.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,13.0,53.0,WP_parameter remove,0.0,1.0,9.0,10.0,2.0,89.0,86.0,3.0,13.0,3.0,0.0,183.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,73.0,Unknown,0.134519842957,1.0,5.0,14.2463160026,14.235284142,12.7841708151,14.2614052644,10.147515739,10.134519843,10.1680197647,10.4208013491,7.90393051383,5.22872565532,6.35077035911,6.83415673541,8.41204313332,7.50783935463,7.40405888401,11.0502266545,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter remove,A34Zzayv,39.2815428295,Unknown,vyAa3zZ4,39.2815428295,Unknown,4Zz3aAyv,39.2815428295,Timeout,A43aZzyv,39.2815428295,Unknown,39.2815428295 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter resize,Timeout,11.1283713172,Timeout,10.1294030742,Timeout,10.1228434366,Timeout,10.2076174636,Unknown,0.183625716015,Timeout,10.150160612,Timeout,10.1460139996,78.0,0.0,2.346591,2.0,32.0,352.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,45.0,218.0,WP_parameter resize,14.0,3.0,32.0,54.0,10.0,420.0,371.0,19.0,45.0,11.0,3.0,833.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,361.0,Unknown,0.183390012056,1.0,3.0,14.2457572659,14.2487108346,14.2292641848,14.2896974875,10.183625716,10.1833900121,14.2339315243,14.9613050291,13.6035636608,11.5223822539,11.829374449,13.704215425,13.4606078854,10.8593424524,10.9788216944,13.5663414217,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:WP_parameter resize,zZA3yva4,62.2514256313,Timeout,vy3AZz4a,62.2514256313,Unknown,a4zZA3yv,62.2514256313,Timeout,3zZvyaA4,62.2514256313,Timeout,62.2514256313 +hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:bucket_bounds,Valid,0.140515338229,Valid,0.14084907581,Valid,0.127353002703,Valid,0.141383609,Unknown,0.11675637141,Valid,0.139837465717,Valid,0.139583668686,1.0,0.0,2.285714,0.0,7.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,hashtbl_impl.mlw,0.0,2.0,5.0,bucket_bounds,0.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,8.0,7.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,17.0,HashtblImpl,0.0,6.0,Unknown,0.112492390561,0.0,0.0,0.139583668686,0.139837465717,0.127353002703,0.141383609,10.1167563714,10.1124923906,0.14084907581,0.140515338229,3.0997180553,2.95827526437,3.55072900372,4.37396761675,7.35560929806,4.6148884038,4.41505871078,5.49563366836,hashtbl_impl:HashtblImpl:bucket_bounds,Aa34Zzvy,0.14084907581,Valid,3ZzaA4vy,0.127353002703,Valid,yv4AazZ3,0.370632370971,Valid,aZv3Az4y,0.140515338229,Valid,0.171003516496 +linear_probing:HashedTypeWithDummy:WP_parameter neq,Valid,0.16040782018,Valid,0.155869819355,Valid,0.13473620545,Valid,0.156577782222,Valid,0.132920685,Valid,0.15953639937,Valid,0.15732433347,0.0,0.0,2.125,0.0,7.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,2.0,6.0,WP_parameter neq,0.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,10.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,18.0,HashedTypeWithDummy,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.13174155582,0.0,2.0,0.15732433347,0.15953639937,0.13473620545,0.156577782222,0.132920685,0.13174155582,0.155869819355,0.16040782018,7.78151573056,6.39416829298,7.16652537388,6.51562009896,8.5961719288,9.36431204952,8.67763523759,10.9237386359,linear_probing:HashedTypeWithDummy:WP_parameter neq,A43ayZzv,0.155869819355,Valid,vy3A4Zza,0.13174155582,Valid,azZ4A3yv,0.16040782018,Valid,A43ayzZv,0.155869819355,Valid,0.148639325108 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter add,Timeout,11.1562485752,Timeout,10.1767616124,Timeout,10.1603646234,Timeout,10.2258095402,Unknown,0.202083973535,Timeout,10.1745026396,Timeout,10.1756954414,39.0,0.0,2.073034,0.0,31.0,178.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,12.0,125.0,WP_parameter add,2.0,1.0,13.0,34.0,0.0,188.0,181.0,3.0,12.0,0.0,1.0,370.0,LinearProbing,0.0,143.0,Unknown,0.203022051,0.0,11.0,14.2669119895,14.2660612631,14.2559815264,14.3026983731,10.2020839735,10.203022051,14.2676724421,14.9820520047,7.48780448823,5.4637273482,6.72498942619,7.77922683228,8.23595863659,6.31165503123,6.2339506493,10.675618653,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter add,AZz3a4yv,62.4744884567,Timeout,yv3zZA4a,62.4744884567,Unknown,a4AZz3vy,62.4744884567,Timeout,vyA3zZ4a,62.4744884567,Unknown,62.4744884567 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter clear,Timeout,11.1463973208,Valid,0.694665740417,Valid,0.32902508464,Timeout,10.218814152,Unknown,1.60771482311,Timeout,10.1710657436,Timeout,10.1723577682,18.0,0.0,2.027778,0.0,18.0,72.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,7.0,46.0,WP_parameter clear,0.0,0.0,6.0,18.0,0.0,71.0,72.0,0.0,7.0,1.0,1.0,147.0,LinearProbing,0.0,50.0,Unknown,0.1684778908,0.0,3.0,14.2645316279,14.2636102849,0.32902508464,14.2976978102,11.6077148231,10.1684778908,0.694665740417,14.9747178015,3.03224109061,2.42470023996,2.17165399722,3.25832056561,2.9844657463,2.71108549245,2.56004901168,5.33267835255,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter clear,3AZzya4v,0.32902508464,Valid,3AvyzZ4a,0.32902508464,Valid,a4ZzyvA3,44.1794934389,Valid,vyaA3zZ4,13.6172557751,Valid,15.0067879787 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter copy,Timeout,11.1602283718,Timeout,10.166964656,Valid,1.9222630104,Timeout,10.2264474234,Unknown,6.647387341,Timeout,10.1632018384,Timeout,10.166881123,10.0,0.0,2.189189,0.0,12.0,37.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,3.0,23.0,WP_parameter copy,0.0,0.0,3.0,7.0,1.0,42.0,37.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,82.0,LinearProbing,0.0,35.0,Unknown,0.181733178813,0.0,0.0,14.2606266261,14.2580037736,1.9222630104,14.3031544389,16.647387341,10.1817331788,14.2606861797,14.9850157594,2.63900582575,1.89622018982,2.07682453117,3.22556571058,5.21985637742,2.71621239023,2.47106742467,4.83751667561,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter copy,A3Zaz4vy,12.0892276664,Valid,3vzZA4ay,1.9222630104,Valid,ya4AZzv3,60.6351069428,Valid,3AzZa4yv,1.9222630104,Valid,31.2786849766 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter create,Valid,0.6766051078,Valid,0.24147155,Valid,0.213058372667,Valid,7.913706937,Unknown,0.457454828429,Valid,0.243259742529,Valid,0.24672914692,8.0,0.0,1.815789,0.0,13.0,38.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,4.0,25.0,WP_parameter create,0.0,0.0,3.0,10.0,1.0,32.0,38.0,0.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,70.0,LinearProbing,0.0,18.0,Unknown,0.172813088353,0.0,4.0,0.24672914692,0.243259742529,0.213058372667,7.913706937,10.4574548284,10.1728130884,0.24147155,0.6766051078,3.77574987333,2.72190241266,3.05825712914,3.76512859363,5.56982974874,3.57422968788,3.68992138012,4.65825349197,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter create,A3zZ4avy,0.24147155,Valid,3AzZa4vy,0.213058372667,Valid,yv4aZzA3,8.54397485378,Valid,vzZ3Aa4y,0.416072830882,Valid,1.67917674998 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter delete,Timeout,11.166143451,Timeout,10.1979013436,Valid,5.862941157,Timeout,10.2443135686,Timeout,9.8854162944,Timeout,10.193709898,Timeout,10.192493588,126.0,0.0,1.990792,0.0,60.0,543.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,27.0,340.0,WP_parameter delete,8.0,1.0,45.0,69.0,16.0,538.0,552.0,9.0,27.0,11.0,5.0,1082.0,LinearProbing,0.0,434.0,Timeout,10.168338534,0.0,35.0,14.2788979106,14.2797661565,5.862941157,14.3159337974,14.0613461416,14.2616657001,14.2827585506,14.9894215889,14.0114768808,12.5442015233,11.6289605781,13.9302223819,13.1947373462,11.2016190177,11.5552706734,13.2348267813,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter delete,zZ3Ayv4a,26.249144643,Valid,3yvZzA4a,5.862941157,Valid,a4AzZvy3,77.9112578346,Valid,3zZvyaA4,5.862941157,Valid,41.8870994958 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter dummy_const,Timeout,11.149146819,Valid,2.3521494754,Valid,0.477237553381,Valid,4.101326022,Valid,0.769885481625,Valid,0.209435780232,Valid,0.213142267414,8.0,0.0,2.131579,0.0,13.0,38.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,3.0,24.0,WP_parameter dummy_const,1.0,0.0,4.0,11.0,2.0,42.0,39.0,1.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,82.0,LinearProbing,0.0,29.0,Unknown,0.1733171403,0.0,2.0,0.213142267414,0.209435780232,0.477237553381,4.101326022,0.769885481625,10.1733171403,2.3521494754,14.9767644968,4.83601627784,3.92498423286,3.12765860457,6.11956150099,6.16233558449,3.59656133563,3.30389078688,5.85930727725,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter dummy_const,3ZzAav4y,0.477237553381,Valid,zZ3yA4va,0.209435780232,Valid,av4Ay3Zz,15.4237899813,Valid,vzZ3Aa4y,0.382752920532,Valid,2.97135761467 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter find,Timeout,11.152978424,Timeout,10.180455211,Valid,8.7458855062,Timeout,11.1749397766,Unknown,0.241235086967,Timeout,10.1724210922,Timeout,10.17768657,63.0,0.0,2.090592,0.0,29.0,287.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,15.0,191.0,WP_parameter find,8.0,2.0,24.0,43.0,3.0,310.0,297.0,10.0,15.0,0.0,6.0,601.0,LinearProbing,0.0,246.0,Unknown,0.4420945614,0.0,21.0,14.2683322052,14.2645767858,8.7458855062,14.9959754271,10.241235087,10.4420945614,14.2703072253,14.9796170754,10.9842422544,8.45584764795,10.536811853,11.0751553222,11.4339044569,8.27306961761,8.12427106913,12.2534775541,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter find,ZzA3a4yv,39.2764483794,Valid,3yvzZAa4,8.7458855062,Valid,4aAZzvy3,62.2876962284,Valid,vyA3zZ4a,19.6096703656,Valid,35.5167908673 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter find_dummy,Valid,6.1714716408,Valid,0.272109449895,Valid,0.603727066545,Timeout,11.1772849176,Timeout,10.1689656376,Timeout,10.166586746,Timeout,10.1756391604,35.0,0.0,2.041667,0.0,22.0,168.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,8.0,103.0,WP_parameter find_dummy,6.0,1.0,18.0,21.0,2.0,172.0,175.0,7.0,8.0,10.0,0.0,344.0,LinearProbing,0.0,140.0,Unknown,0.183592647455,0.0,11.0,14.2668718478,14.2604167563,0.603727066545,14.9977230982,14.2621128217,10.1835926475,0.272109449895,6.1714716408,9.00891566621,7.31945157453,8.94988775476,9.82017093063,9.40041608816,7.26636565425,7.35716406275,11.0367814153,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter find_dummy,zAZ3ay4v,10.4386961959,Valid,A3avzyZ4,0.272109449895,Valid,4Zyzva3A,48.0435407499,Valid,Aa3yZzv4,0.272109449895,Valid,12.8171199963 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter mem,Valid,0.735258705,Timeout,10.1711064152,Valid,2.1772904506,Timeout,10.2235672288,Unknown,0.195566798174,Valid,2.926904036,Valid,2.9428929714,15.0,0.0,1.925373,0.0,14.0,67.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,4.0,46.0,WP_parameter mem,0.0,2.0,5.0,9.0,0.0,65.0,69.0,2.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,130.0,LinearProbing,0.0,48.0,Unknown,0.1674199354,0.0,8.0,2.9428929714,2.926904036,2.1772904506,14.3010953036,10.1955667982,10.1674199354,14.263639287,0.735258705,5.75376402019,4.88901318892,5.43799574455,6.79879015157,6.73387284583,6.22990229745,6.45592135545,8.29189033348,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter mem,A3azZy4v,12.3483968658,Valid,a3zZvyA4,0.735258705,Valid,4AyvZz3a,23.700553349,Valid,v3Zz4Aay,2.344710386,Valid,6.34711861626 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter numof_eq,Timeout,11.1407508526,Timeout,10.157541927,Valid,8.0236227964,Timeout,10.2400299148,Timeout,10.1453064324,Valid,0.26722187551,Valid,0.267571511855,15.0,0.0,2.2,0.0,14.0,60.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,3.0,38.0,WP_parameter numof_eq,1.0,0.0,4.0,6.0,3.0,69.0,61.0,1.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,133.0,LinearProbing,0.0,63.0,Unknown,0.161485370588,0.0,0.0,0.267571511855,0.26722187551,8.0236227964,14.312868778,14.245253336,10.1614853706,14.2539699031,14.9705153405,6.61926384732,5.51321144552,3.73724734477,8.88968763791,6.38567335992,5.11221960031,4.40017515894,6.65264792089,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter numof_eq,3ZzAyav4,8.0236227964,Valid,zZ3vyA4a,0.26722187551,Valid,a4Ayv3Zz,49.8687372938,Valid,Z3vzA4ya,0.267571511855,Valid,13.3140840189 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter numof_update,Timeout,11.1546608772,Timeout,10.1723633706,Timeout,10.153620678,Timeout,10.2154779826,Timeout,10.1647139622,Timeout,10.171226875,Timeout,10.1676261826,14.0,0.0,2.194805,0.0,13.0,77.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,2.0,57.0,WP_parameter numof_update,0.0,0.0,3.0,8.0,2.0,93.0,77.0,0.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,170.0,LinearProbing,0.0,83.0,Unknown,0.173898702,0.0,2.0,14.2611578138,14.2637251846,14.2511758418,14.2953135822,14.2590816651,10.173898702,14.2645356231,14.9808697773,8.67398738408,6.82988844596,7.49019808613,8.97802953475,9.17046875686,8.65516591735,8.77639767224,10.2707966023,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter numof_update,A3zaZ4yv,72.3735886302,Timeout,v3yZzA4a,72.3735886302,Unknown,a4AzZy3v,72.3735886302,Timeout,A34azZvy,72.3735886302,Timeout,72.3735886302 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter remove,Timeout,11.1500744806,Timeout,10.174284667,Timeout,10.1613098314,Timeout,11.1906900478,Unknown,0.4333110988,Timeout,10.1839260502,Timeout,10.1756656078,63.0,0.0,1.957447,0.0,44.0,282.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,16.0,180.0,WP_parameter remove,2.0,1.0,25.0,39.0,5.0,275.0,285.0,3.0,16.0,7.0,2.0,553.0,LinearProbing,0.0,213.0,Unknown,7.346602436,0.0,23.0,14.2668907111,14.2727835336,14.2566551999,15.0077161402,10.4333110988,17.346602436,14.2659058067,14.9774550883,13.8257847185,11.57255036,12.5546947649,13.1809756109,12.694219179,11.565386147,11.8031253829,12.3083903066,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter remove,zAZv3y4a,70.8158642196,Timeout,y3AZza4v,70.8158642196,Unknown,v4azZA3y,70.8158642196,Unknown,vyzAZ34a,70.8158642196,Unknown,70.8158642196 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter resize,Timeout,11.158343951,Timeout,10.1887187478,Timeout,10.1617757218,Timeout,11.1885088564,Unknown,0.9983922184,Timeout,10.1822595734,Timeout,10.1831422378,90.0,0.0,1.991886,0.0,47.0,493.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,34.0,344.0,WP_parameter resize,6.0,1.0,48.0,78.0,10.0,477.0,500.0,7.0,34.0,0.0,1.0,983.0,LinearProbing,0.0,371.0,Unknown,0.262217547333,0.0,28.0,14.2722242778,14.2715945157,14.2569872631,15.0060897781,10.9983922184,10.2622175473,14.2762036173,14.9836123725,14.0467846609,12.5269483123,11.3729795981,14.0221842502,13.2829793492,10.9646649651,11.3678958744,13.2615441369,linear_probing:LinearProbing:WP_parameter resize,zZ3Avy4a,64.3233588539,Timeout,vy3zZAa4,64.3233588539,Unknown,4aAZz3yv,64.3233588539,Timeout,ZzyvA34a,64.3233588539,Timeout,64.3233588539 +linear_probing:LinearProbing:bucket_bounds,Valid,0.183728960538,Valid,0.1818510731,Valid,0.167058413919,Valid,0.189883988286,Unknown,0.156753710649,Valid,0.174029358174,Valid,0.17136622575,1.0,0.0,2.285714,0.0,7.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linear_probing.mlw,0.0,2.0,5.0,bucket_bounds,0.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,8.0,7.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,17.0,LinearProbing,0.0,6.0,Unknown,0.150980501328,0.0,0.0,0.17136622575,0.174029358174,0.167058413919,0.189883988286,10.1567537106,10.1509805013,0.1818510731,0.183728960538,3.0997180553,2.95827526437,3.55072900372,4.37396761675,7.35560929806,4.6148884038,4.41505871078,5.49563366836,linear_probing:LinearProbing:bucket_bounds,Aa34Zzvy,0.1818510731,Valid,3ZzAa4vy,0.167058413919,Valid,yv4aAzZ3,0.497618200263,Valid,aZv3Az4y,0.183728960538,Valid,0.22194836691 +linked_list_rev:Disjoint:WP_parameter mem_decomp,Valid,0.153900552115,Valid,0.158940720882,Valid,0.14903447213,Valid,0.287482117444,Valid,0.1504775862,Timeout,10.1835402436,Timeout,10.1808546918,2.0,0.0,2.130435,2.0,12.0,23.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,2.0,19.0,WP_parameter mem_decomp,1.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,31.0,26.0,3.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,56.0,Disjoint,0.0,25.0,Timeout,10.1584048986,1.0,3.0,14.2705922181,14.2725082551,0.14903447213,0.287482117444,0.1504775862,14.2545848794,0.158940720882,0.153900552115,2.67937566043,2.24307050954,3.34299810824,3.44248851643,3.68136424894,11.7520205668,11.5379028118,13.2922567087,linked_list_rev:Disjoint:WP_parameter mem_decomp,Aa34yZzv,0.158940720882,Valid,3yaA4vZz,0.14903447213,Valid,zZv4Aay3,30.8102819514,Valid,34yAaZzv,0.14903447213,Valid,5.26710039542 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter app,Timeout,11.119781284,Timeout,10.1450365098,Timeout,10.1253612206,Timeout,11.1629563472,Failure,4.2836718078,Failure,9.693303718,Failure,9.8747073036,22.0,0.0,1.913462,2.0,25.0,104.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,7.0,69.0,WP_parameter app,2.0,0.0,6.0,0.0,0.0,114.0,108.0,4.0,7.0,7.0,0.0,206.0,InPlaceRev,0.0,87.0,Timeout,10.1375387254,2.0,23.0,14.0538195638,13.9269572043,14.231055472,14.9870475548,10.878871456,14.239722308,14.2450611015,14.9549167769,11.5015215126,8.85967270926,9.58234756936,11.9401515121,11.5236443437,12.8833608825,12.9368579764,13.0603188447,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter app,A3ay4zZv,76.5423569164,Timeout,yzZ3vAa4,76.5423569164,Failure,4aAv3Zzy,76.5423569164,Timeout,Aa3yZzv4,76.5423569164,Timeout,76.5423569164 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter in_place_reverse,Timeout,11.121190323,Timeout,10.1440811892,Timeout,10.13585439,Timeout,11.1557710708,Failure,4.3167597292,Failure,8.7074943536,Failure,8.392931015,12.0,0.0,1.917808,2.0,27.0,73.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,8.0,53.0,WP_parameter in_place_reverse,1.0,0.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,79.0,76.0,3.0,8.0,1.0,0.0,147.0,InPlaceRev,0.0,60.0,Timeout,10.1349485858,1.0,16.0,13.0553165807,13.259730688,14.2385232456,14.9816964388,10.891942644,14.2378784528,14.2443807578,14.9559645025,7.88891497196,6.54185860055,8.02077148411,8.3431825033,9.27829573375,11.3561546839,11.3289162478,12.7007979906,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter in_place_reverse,Aa34yZzv,74.1090306566,Timeout,yZzv3Aa4,74.1090306566,Failure,4aA3vzZy,74.1090306566,Timeout,3yAa4Zzv,74.1090306566,Timeout,74.1090306566 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_append,Valid,0.351509806767,Valid,0.198249510506,Valid,0.199866763095,Valid,0.194230750852,Valid,0.159849974523,Valid,8.810267002,Valid,8.4822108634,4.0,0.0,2.652174,2.0,10.0,23.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,16.0,WP_parameter list_seg_append,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,44.0,25.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,68.0,InPlaceRev,0.0,39.0,Timeout,10.1467000222,2.0,2.0,8.4822108634,8.810267002,0.199866763095,0.194230750852,0.159849974523,14.2462458683,0.198249510506,0.351509806767,3.61387644379,2.99054697598,5.2155076144,5.24916970128,5.8217957049,11.0160219862,10.7804271029,12.7488861607,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_append,Aa34yZzv,0.198249510506,Valid,y4A3aZzv,0.159849974523,Valid,vzZa3A4y,18.9569670242,Valid,Aa4y3vzZ,0.198249510506,Valid,3.89636388437 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_frame_ext,Valid,0.232659282185,Valid,0.174791593143,Timeout,10.1324170308,Valid,0.218121635597,Unknown,2.1622573166,Failure,9.9489688106,Failure,10.179207854,7.0,0.0,2.366667,2.0,12.0,30.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,18.0,WP_parameter list_seg_frame_ext,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,47.0,32.0,2.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,78.0,InPlaceRev,0.0,43.0,Timeout,10.140079566,1.0,2.0,14.269417386,14.1060972772,14.2360765271,0.218121635597,12.1622573166,14.2415312942,0.174791593143,0.232659282185,5.02860620449,4.11760363815,6.53479928243,6.43174473735,7.28950337896,11.116829589,10.7971864197,12.5894877715,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_frame_ext,Aa43yZzv,0.174791593143,Valid,A4ayz3vZ,0.174791593143,Valid,Zv3zya4A,42.7955898602,Valid,Aa4y3vzZ,0.174791593143,Valid,10.8492568148 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_functional,Valid,0.192747967568,Valid,0.181076295263,Valid,0.186089580861,Valid,0.272123638935,Valid,0.173109201957,Timeout,10.1833692398,Timeout,10.183357609,4.0,0.0,2.115385,4.0,10.0,26.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,19.0,WP_parameter list_seg_functional,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,44.0,30.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,68.0,InPlaceRev,0.0,31.0,Timeout,10.1469245684,3.0,7.0,14.2723779446,14.2723862432,0.186089580861,0.272123638935,0.173109201957,14.2464057992,0.181076295263,0.192747967568,4.10645745113,3.49462270291,4.89119954034,5.02343047727,5.93959473021,11.1818478306,10.9218789337,12.754793629,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_functional,Aa34yZzv,0.181076295263,Valid,yA3a4vZz,0.173109201957,Valid,zZv4a3Ay,30.7857750561,Valid,4aAy3vZz,0.272123638935,Valid,5.28663790645 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_no_repet,Valid,0.215085227529,Valid,0.183800804036,Valid,0.1690048276,Valid,0.307505956067,Valid,0.1450136248,Valid,4.1904872056,Valid,4.1529401496,7.0,0.0,1.98,2.0,17.0,50.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,2.0,37.0,WP_parameter list_seg_no_repet,1.0,0.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,59.0,53.0,3.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,106.0,InPlaceRev,0.0,49.0,Timeout,10.139722672,1.0,8.0,4.1529401496,4.1904872056,0.1690048276,0.307505956067,0.1450136248,14.2412771852,0.183800804036,0.215085227529,7.30327440754,6.2555920325,8.22153016039,8.42585247095,9.36264221033,11.1878725036,11.1741469179,12.5938950234,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_no_repet,Aa34yZzv,0.183800804036,Valid,y3Aa4Zzv,0.1450136248,Valid,vzZ4aA3y,14.3302098776,Valid,Aa4y3vzZ,0.183800804036,Valid,2.6051564476 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_sublistl,Valid,0.294229931294,Valid,0.171954459238,Valid,0.247403627596,Valid,0.409092450036,Valid,0.1833693595,Failure,7.6489732288,Failure,7.8450897026,2.0,0.0,2.037037,2.0,9.0,27.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,23.0,WP_parameter list_seg_sublistl,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,39.0,29.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,62.0,InPlaceRev,0.0,29.0,Timeout,10.1507478356,2.0,7.0,12.710052417,12.5899480323,0.247403627596,0.409092450036,0.1833693595,14.2491291531,0.171954459238,0.294229931294,3.27323589469,2.7036198689,4.13691259712,4.22960149381,4.6079222313,10.9299753439,10.9195136154,12.993146286,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRev:WP_parameter list_seg_sublistl,Aa34yZzv,0.171954459238,Valid,Ay3a4zZv,0.171954459238,Valid,vZz4a3yA,26.053903217,Valid,Aa4y3vzZ,0.171954459238,Valid,4.53534509337 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter app,Timeout,11.1247468878,Timeout,10.1583354128,Timeout,10.123569181,Timeout,10.2143625684,Timeout,10.140141254,Timeout,10.1486799392,Timeout,10.1512783922,26.0,0.0,1.871795,0.0,28.0,117.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,7.0,76.0,WP_parameter app,2.0,0.0,7.0,3.0,0.0,116.0,119.0,2.0,7.0,8.0,0.0,220.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,91.0,Timeout,10.1248742804,0.0,22.0,14.2495071141,14.2476561058,14.2297804959,14.2945165248,14.2415752166,14.2307090194,14.254535361,14.9586093377,12.1136334201,9.94781209299,10.0961994638,12.7569721237,11.6528086513,12.2675518836,12.4583954802,12.4901543341,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter app,A3yazZv4,82.1859879158,Timeout,3vyzZA4a,82.1859879158,Timeout,a4AZzyv3,82.1859879158,Timeout,A3azZvy4,82.1859879158,Timeout,82.1859879158 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter in_place_reverse,Timeout,11.1258728788,Timeout,10.1395038662,Timeout,10.1318173766,Timeout,10.2185495184,Timeout,10.1416739164,Timeout,10.1398182904,Timeout,10.1480933422,15.0,0.0,1.821429,0.0,28.0,84.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,8.0,59.0,WP_parameter in_place_reverse,1.0,0.0,7.0,3.0,0.0,77.0,85.0,1.0,8.0,3.0,0.0,154.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,58.0,Timeout,10.128916169,0.0,16.0,14.2472382756,14.2413452652,14.2356497341,14.2975086732,14.242666528,14.2335850283,14.2411213973,14.9594467583,9.86980327528,8.07265562629,7.35288095013,10.0390735003,10.0968231231,10.4035795136,10.2863860242,11.1754279524,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter in_place_reverse,3Aa4yZzv,82.174245358,Timeout,v3AzyZ4a,82.174245358,Timeout,a4ZyzA3v,82.174245358,Timeout,3vy4zAZa,82.174245358,Timeout,82.174245358 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_append,Timeout,11.1313971824,Timeout,10.1452696258,Valid,0.9571768434,Timeout,10.1807113696,Timeout,10.1412818794,Valid,4.3626708334,Valid,4.5194767168,5.0,0.0,2.5,0.0,11.0,28.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,19.0,WP_parameter list_seg_append,1.0,0.0,2.0,3.0,2.0,41.0,29.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,71.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,38.0,Valid,0.938752135143,0.0,0.0,4.5194767168,4.3626708334,0.9571768434,14.2704899703,14.2423873756,0.938752135143,14.2452271228,14.9635558352,7.61893868024,6.24873869575,4.46907999138,7.03905170864,8.22314839799,7.50442002162,5.36621233723,7.60260504406,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_append,3ZA4zvay,0.9571768434,Valid,v3zZyA4a,0.938752135143,Valid,a4AyZz3v,46.118136774,Valid,Z3v4zAya,4.5194767168,Valid,11.0142511436 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_functional,Unknown,3.7210882906,Unknown,0.425765137571,Valid,2.6756660076,Timeout,10.1806972684,Timeout,10.1275001192,Timeout,10.13525359,Timeout,10.1395876616,8.0,0.0,1.97561,0.0,12.0,41.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,28.0,WP_parameter list_seg_functional,1.0,0.0,2.0,8.0,3.0,43.0,42.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,82.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,31.0,Timeout,10.12265723,0.0,4.0,14.2411810587,14.2380955655,2.6756660076,14.2704799103,14.2325773725,14.2291317162,10.4257651376,13.7210882906,5.32578789688,4.47593580447,4.35709154024,7.36304870084,6.45232839037,4.54815448064,4.38424608069,6.03627072053,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_functional,3ZAzavy4,2.6756660076,Valid,3AavyzZ4,2.6756660076,Valid,4ZzyvaA3,57.528215305,Valid,zZyAa34v,37.2248608066,Valid,30.1019406563 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_no_repet,Timeout,11.1383443034,Timeout,10.1415452322,Timeout,10.1387603358,Timeout,10.2079257854,Timeout,10.1340259846,Timeout,10.1377616394,Timeout,10.1472140084,11.0,0.0,1.945946,0.0,19.0,74.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,3.0,52.0,WP_parameter list_seg_no_repet,2.0,0.0,6.0,9.0,3.0,72.0,76.0,2.0,3.0,2.0,0.0,145.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,57.0,Timeout,10.1231070466,0.0,6.0,14.2466119528,14.2398810057,14.2405920223,14.2899177339,14.2372217324,14.2294517209,14.242574897,14.9687245222,7.14870253826,5.59835940666,8.00677076614,9.6588183226,8.47651764278,8.02306903022,8.38686247443,10.0084181946,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_no_repet,Aa3zZy4v,82.1686843358,Timeout,vyz3AZ4a,82.1686843358,Timeout,a4ZA3zyv,82.1686843358,Timeout,zZyAav34,82.1686843358,Timeout,82.1686843358 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_prefix,Timeout,11.1337203728,Timeout,10.1380365708,Timeout,10.1301089382,Timeout,10.2189835414,Timeout,10.1372754936,Timeout,10.150151557,Timeout,10.1449445782,5.0,0.0,2.170732,0.0,15.0,41.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,29.0,WP_parameter list_seg_prefix,1.0,0.0,3.0,5.0,4.0,50.0,42.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,90.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,42.0,Timeout,10.1245340516,0.0,3.0,14.2449956299,14.2487043843,14.2344338525,14.2978188763,14.2395349093,14.2304669552,14.2400767382,14.9652841383,7.30771428421,6.24115375622,5.54568959361,7.78963032108,7.84029605859,6.84481032296,5.93392675228,8.08573888109,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_prefix,3ZAza4yv,82.1777551036,Timeout,v3yAZz4a,82.1777551036,Timeout,a4zZAy3v,82.1777551036,Timeout,3A4zZvay,82.1777551036,Timeout,82.1777551036 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_sublistl,Timeout,11.1318535734,Valid,1.3663761552,Timeout,10.130539319,Timeout,11.1589502554,Timeout,10.1364378904,Timeout,10.1328783986,Timeout,10.1513817788,6.0,0.0,2.116279,0.0,13.0,43.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,33.0,WP_parameter list_seg_sublistl,1.0,0.0,3.0,5.0,1.0,52.0,44.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,92.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,42.0,Timeout,10.1144164248,0.0,5.0,14.2495807664,14.2364049058,14.2347401414,14.9840638948,14.2389386229,14.2232703558,1.3663761552,14.9638953478,7.43307438138,6.26030771921,4.84678922155,7.56905044512,7.39494740548,6.53639765294,5.83127988362,7.97283330212,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_sublistl,3ZAzya4v,21.648297253,Valid,Av3zyZa4,1.3663761552,Valid,4aZyz3vA,74.3228337956,Valid,3A4zZvay,11.4969154742,Valid,37.8446049754 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_tail,Valid,1.3527820258,Valid,0.189671375133,Valid,0.689078631143,Timeout,10.1995180714,Timeout,10.1345317606,Timeout,10.1372203006,Timeout,10.1445337236,5.0,0.0,2.242424,0.0,11.0,33.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,24.0,WP_parameter list_seg_tail,1.0,0.0,2.0,8.0,2.0,40.0,34.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,75.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,32.0,Timeout,10.1254491672,0.0,0.0,14.244703032,14.2394956169,0.689078631143,14.2839129404,14.2375817471,14.2311180459,0.189671375133,1.3527820258,4.91467736909,3.93812121575,3.65753790997,6.77451415774,6.3386621423,3.74943749322,3.26947614919,5.42006082792,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter list_seg_tail,Z3zAavy4,10.8336123547,Valid,A3avyzZ4,0.189671375133,Valid,4Zzyva3A,52.0940350492,Valid,vzZ3Aa4y,31.0962818225,Valid,13.4291572665 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter mem_decomp,Valid,1.6976058466,Valid,0.191032827208,Valid,0.423404088063,Timeout,10.190413804,Timeout,10.1207241608,Timeout,10.1382981298,Timeout,10.1418367926,4.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,14.0,34.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,2.0,27.0,WP_parameter mem_decomp,1.0,0.0,2.0,7.0,1.0,33.0,35.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,69.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,25.0,Valid,0.74236843384,0.0,1.0,14.2427825065,14.2402629529,0.423404088063,14.2774134036,14.2277565884,0.74236843384,0.191032827208,1.6976058466,4.53661178836,3.99610416578,3.66922424726,7.56141894498,5.94733602842,4.80301628406,4.39613661853,6.51224063359,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:WP_parameter mem_decomp,3AZazyv4,0.423404088063,Valid,A3vayzZ4,0.191032827208,Valid,4Zzyav3A,42.2888787338,Valid,aA43yvZz,1.6976058466,Valid,8.88185737637 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:get_tail,Valid,0.156315437208,Valid,0.157574598091,Valid,0.171037064608,Valid,0.207023091803,Valid,0.1798953642,Valid,0.176746739312,Valid,0.191962398063,1.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,7.0,11.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,9.0,get_tail,0.0,0.0,1.0,4.0,0.0,11.0,11.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,23.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,7.0,Timeout,10.1299192038,0.0,0.0,0.191962398063,0.176746739312,0.171037064608,0.207023091803,0.1798953642,14.2342988263,0.157574598091,0.156315437208,5.1167094917,4.5633642805,4.49192479385,6.04532695392,8.01036009704,8.46135306964,8.50054601807,7.29351646576,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:get_tail,3Aa4vyzZ,0.171037064608,Valid,aA3zyZ4v,0.156315437208,Valid,v4Zyz3Aa,10.3369422956,Valid,3Aa4vyzZ,0.171037064608,Valid,1.44346199952 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:list_seg_frame_ext,Valid,0.1596394302,Valid,0.1579167157,Valid,0.153218175338,Valid,3.0271775284,Timeout,10.1241237654,Valid,0.171014009182,Valid,0.183682387769,0.0,0.0,2.555556,0.0,7.0,9.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,list_seg_frame_ext,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,14.0,9.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,24.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,14.0,Timeout,10.1172481474,0.0,0.0,0.183682387769,0.171014009182,0.153218175338,3.0271775284,14.2301750522,14.2252841826,0.1579167157,0.1596394302,5.93802192448,5.08434272259,7.4249286477,7.6343004404,8.18306646971,7.43987837435,6.99071671701,9.51827930048,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:list_seg_frame_ext,AaZ3z4yv,0.1579167157,Valid,3AazZ4vy,0.153218175338,Valid,yv4ZzaA3,23.2685494412,Valid,Aa3yzZ4v,0.1579167157,Valid,3.53373260007 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:non_empty_seq,Valid,0.156768850132,Valid,0.15283419668,Valid,0.17458413165,Valid,0.214302627903,Timeout,10.1167170624,Valid,0.263973699622,Valid,0.266853894038,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,6.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,non_empty_seq,0.0,0.0,1.0,3.0,0.0,7.0,7.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,15.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,4.0,Timeout,10.1147624022,0.0,0.0,0.266853894038,0.263973699622,0.17458413165,0.214302627903,14.2249064714,14.2235163885,0.15283419668,0.156768850132,4.54305245358,4.11935621529,5.00986205081,6.7824639679,8.36517488758,8.7672479287,8.7481867091,8.09860686699,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:non_empty_seq,Aa34vyZz,0.15283419668,Valid,Aa34zZvy,0.15283419668,Valid,yvZz43aA,20.4983333586,Valid,zZ3vA4ay,0.263973699622,Valid,3.09509758542 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:seq_tail_append,Valid,0.1811126808,Valid,0.17518235028,Valid,1.2474298286,Timeout,10.199356145,Timeout,10.1235299366,Valid,8.3086910934,Valid,8.4150083466,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,6.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,7.0,seq_tail_append,0.0,0.0,1.0,3.0,0.0,8.0,8.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,17.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,5.0,Timeout,10.1338165158,0.0,0.0,8.4150083466,8.3086910934,1.2474298286,14.2837973163,14.2297525761,14.2370726337,0.17518235028,0.1811126808,4.0552933461,3.59339144564,4.13568843476,5.87313835322,7.77316655484,7.66075605242,7.69458437693,7.26618518066,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:seq_tail_append,Aa34vzZy,0.17518235028,Valid,Aa3zZyv4,0.17518235028,Valid,4vyZz3aA,38.871710944,Valid,zZ3vA4ay,8.3086910934,Valid,8.7416019595 +linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:tail_suffix,Valid,0.190664808302,Valid,0.170311230121,Timeout,10.1280004802,Valid,0.618805496326,Timeout,10.130397555,Valid,0.418352747452,Valid,0.415714749857,1.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,6.0,10.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,linked_list_rev.mlw,0.0,1.0,8.0,tail_suffix,0.0,0.0,1.0,3.0,0.0,10.0,10.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,21.0,InPlaceRevSeq,0.0,7.0,Timeout,10.1298352844,0.0,0.0,0.415714749857,0.418352747452,14.2329334196,0.618805496326,14.2346392516,14.2342391047,0.170311230121,0.190664808302,5.00812225184,4.33958372434,4.46687248697,5.26176687415,7.44272200833,7.21848397182,7.0058838156,6.48176965133,linked_list_rev:InPlaceRevSeq:tail_suffix,A3a4vZzy,0.170311230121,Valid,AaZz43vy,0.170311230121,Valid,yv34zZaA,31.0070388159,Valid,zZ3vA4ay,0.418352747452,Valid,5.42747535968 +max_matrix:MaxMatrixMemo:WP_parameter maximum,Timeout,11.0954232982,Timeout,10.1264560108,Timeout,10.1018063908,Timeout,10.1580307572,Timeout,10.08762517,Timeout,10.1200921908,Timeout,10.1238395846,68.0,0.0,1.886889,0.0,44.0,389.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,max_matrix.mlw,0.0,32.0,251.0,WP_parameter maximum,3.0,0.0,51.0,53.0,7.0,341.0,392.0,3.0,32.0,6.0,6.0,735.0,MaxMatrixMemo,0.0,258.0,Timeout,10.0857726608,0.0,30.0,14.2299728719,14.2273070519,14.2143059049,14.2543182532,14.2042311151,14.2029155516,14.2318344334,14.9368141907,14.2004455492,12.2429553274,12.2111489588,14.0646632175,13.0982067389,11.1394468204,11.5803795179,12.7817578593,max_matrix:MaxMatrixMemo:WP_parameter maximum,zZ3Avy4a,81.8990460632,Timeout,vy3zZA4a,81.8990460632,Timeout,a4AZz3yv,81.8990460632,Timeout,ZzyvA34a,81.8990460632,Timeout,81.8990460632 +max_matrix:MaxMatrixMemo:WP_parameter maxmat,Timeout,11.0882365962,Valid,0.31678185194,Timeout,10.0853511816,Valid,1.9198940564,Timeout,10.0851003426,Valid,0.14382873161,Valid,0.1462894582,6.0,0.0,1.735294,0.0,15.0,34.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,max_matrix.mlw,0.0,5.0,23.0,WP_parameter maxmat,0.0,0.0,3.0,4.0,2.0,24.0,34.0,0.0,6.0,0.0,0.0,60.0,MaxMatrixMemo,0.0,16.0,Timeout,10.111344785,0.0,4.0,0.1462894582,0.14382873161,14.2026162539,1.9198940564,14.202438133,14.221086223,0.31678185194,14.9314765115,5.64994214217,4.12027952018,5.15911569671,5.25716616572,6.76683930541,6.72028993144,6.78042324005,6.98629196422,max_matrix:MaxMatrixMemo:WP_parameter maxmat,A34azyZv,0.31678185194,Valid,zZA4y3va,0.14382873161,Valid,av3y4AZz,43.2899269618,Valid,3AzZa4yv,10.4021330335,Valid,8.90570510562 +max_matrix:MaxMatrixMemo:WP_parameter memo,Valid,0.129971051875,Valid,0.128134458346,Valid,0.155713233059,Valid,0.6923785355,Unknown,0.9696876686,Valid,0.14646045069,Valid,0.142685933364,10.0,0.0,1.808219,0.0,22.0,73.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,max_matrix.mlw,0.0,7.0,51.0,WP_parameter memo,0.0,0.0,6.0,9.0,5.0,57.0,73.0,0.0,7.0,1.0,0.0,133.0,MaxMatrixMemo,0.0,44.0,Timeout,10.0936551268,0.0,4.0,0.142685933364,0.14646045069,0.155713233059,0.6923785355,10.9696876686,14.2085141313,0.128134458346,0.129971051875,7.46615703691,5.32352503234,7.11037768068,8.45369600459,8.77960754655,7.7109614022,8.07476345823,9.10611256661,max_matrix:MaxMatrixMemo:WP_parameter memo,A3azZ4yv,0.128134458346,Valid,AaZz34yv,0.128134458346,Valid,vy43zZaA,11.7557213309,Valid,zZyAav34,0.14646045069,Valid,1.81303481934 +max_matrix:MaxMatrixMemo:sum_ind,Valid,0.939824197143,Valid,0.16784616076,Valid,0.160393725687,Valid,0.136831654975,Timeout,10.071517486,Valid,0.111160506873,Valid,0.106964475154,0.0,0.0,1.857143,0.0,9.0,14.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,max_matrix.mlw,0.0,3.0,13.0,sum_ind,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,14.0,14.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,27.0,MaxMatrixMemo,0.0,9.0,Timeout,10.0750004296,0.0,4.0,0.106964475154,0.111160506873,0.160393725687,0.136831654975,14.1927962175,14.1952680023,0.16784616076,0.939824197143,6.59237633831,5.40596980818,5.95587706944,6.42531185807,9.33630007838,8.18080477394,7.95771306062,9.01121267316,max_matrix:MaxMatrixMemo:sum_ind,A34aZzvy,0.16784616076,Valid,Zz43Aayv,0.106964475154,Valid,vyaA34zZ,21.0863421127,Valid,3Aa4vyzZ,0.160393725687,Valid,3.14857744137 +patience:PatienceAbstract:WP_parameter play_card,Unknown,2.4298033504,Unknown,0.503610333833,Unknown,0.865047308,Timeout,10.1857655154,Timeout,10.1357135326,Timeout,10.1416472018,Timeout,10.1504503004,30.0,0.0,2.328829,4.0,31.0,222.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,patience.mlw,0.0,24.0,161.0,WP_parameter play_card,4.0,0.0,27.0,54.0,4.0,272.0,230.0,8.0,24.0,0.0,0.0,526.0,PatienceAbstract,0.0,218.0,Timeout,10.1279575352,0.0,0.0,14.2489171975,14.2426475055,10.865047308,14.2740960882,14.238422975,14.2329028604,10.5036103338,12.4298033504,12.2352452978,8.96130160801,12.1439471099,12.7959808743,12.6262304028,8.02027549499,8.00608228695,12.7335438627,patience:PatienceAbstract:WP_parameter play_card,ZzA3ayv4,54.5399950776,Timeout,A3avyzZ4,54.5399950776,Unknown,4Zzyva3A,54.5399950776,Timeout,zZAayv43,54.5399950776,Timeout,54.5399950776 +patience:PatienceAbstract:WP_parameter play_cards,Valid,0.425394215,Valid,0.250099936361,Valid,0.200473205786,Timeout,10.2105430688,Timeout,10.1225381728,Valid,0.1900652572,Valid,0.1884960566,18.0,0.0,2.164706,2.0,22.0,85.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,patience.mlw,0.0,8.0,56.0,WP_parameter play_cards,0.0,0.0,8.0,3.0,3.0,98.0,87.0,2.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,191.0,PatienceAbstract,0.0,91.0,Timeout,10.1161651964,1.0,2.0,0.1884960566,0.1900652572,0.200473205786,14.2917874935,14.2290470187,14.224513991,0.250099936361,0.425394215,7.53951568494,5.47420219025,7.82189996077,8.55243796399,9.10507298702,11.0138947013,10.9249322404,12.0462731308,patience:PatienceAbstract:WP_parameter play_cards,Aa34yZzv,0.250099936361,Valid,Zz3Aavy4,0.1884960566,Valid,4yvaA3zZ,30.874640653,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.200473205786,Valid,5.32578014052 +patience:PatienceAbstract:WP_parameter play_game,Timeout,11.1270545808,Timeout,10.1389739792,Unknown,2.40483583871,Timeout,11.1541622914,Failure,5.331851024,Timeout,10.1537073222,Unknown,0.75726919775,112.0,0.0,1.99322,14.0,31.0,590.0,2.0,5.0,0.0,patience.mlw,0.0,35.0,420.0,WP_parameter play_game,1.0,0.0,49.0,120.0,7.0,561.0,607.0,15.0,40.0,2.0,0.0,1207.0,PatienceAbstract,0.0,434.0,Timeout,10.1584104012,6.0,1.0,10.7572691978,14.2512375738,12.4048358387,14.9804985372,11.3326358515,14.2545888008,14.2407441291,14.960325653,13.8676078496,11.9811145758,11.9884278077,13.8911804446,13.5524243019,11.2115935855,11.4384054567,13.6159993709,patience:PatienceAbstract:WP_parameter play_game,zZA3yva4,61.2262646353,Timeout,Zy3Azva4,61.2262646353,Unknown,4avzA3yZ,61.2262646353,Timeout,A3yvZz4a,61.2262646353,Timeout,61.2262646353 +patience:PatienceAbstract:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.14616963045,Valid,0.1573500426,Valid,0.145853492929,Valid,0.174918095769,Timeout,10.118698587,Valid,0.15644331747,Valid,0.171573784,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,patience.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,PatienceAbstract,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.136532079,0.0,0.0,0.171573784,0.15644331747,0.145853492929,0.174918095769,14.2263157948,0.136532079,0.1573500426,0.14616963045,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,patience:PatienceAbstract:WP_parameter test,3aAvyzZ4,0.145853492929,Valid,v3azAZ4y,0.136532079,Valid,y4ZAza3v,10.2936166828,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.136532079,Valid,1.42038595798 +patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter play_cards,Valid,0.139609814162,Valid,0.141518007643,Valid,0.14542020595,Valid,0.172808720143,Valid,0.1353044063,Valid,0.174924045125,Valid,0.18093613991,4.0,0.0,1.666667,2.0,12.0,21.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,patience.mlw,0.0,3.0,14.0,WP_parameter play_cards,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,19.0,23.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,42.0,PatienceCode,0.0,14.0,Timeout,10.1351504184,1.0,3.0,0.18093613991,0.174924045125,0.14542020595,0.172808720143,0.1353044063,14.238022124,0.141518007643,0.139609814162,3.46849364863,2.78707223663,3.42492623285,4.33111160956,4.16291912385,10.3325167551,10.4020741194,11.8866534758,patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter play_cards,A3ay4zZv,0.141518007643,Valid,yaA34zZv,0.1353044063,Valid,vZz43Aay,10.3160865583,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,0.1353044063,Valid,1.42268256505 +patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter play_game,Valid,0.138317620987,Valid,0.1423954134,Valid,0.131975845378,Valid,0.144932251371,Valid,0.116555761,Valid,0.143743626769,Valid,0.141840771529,0.0,0.0,0.5,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,patience.mlw,0.0,0.0,2.0,WP_parameter play_game,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,PatienceCode,0.0,0.0,Valid,0.113310808333,0.0,1.0,0.141840771529,0.143743626769,0.131975845378,0.144932251371,0.116555761,0.113310808333,0.1423954134,0.138317620987,3.98471326109,3.85657708103,1.20041652256,2.17600249577,2.58957454551,1.63109173773,0.902993447475,2.27454833098,patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter play_game,Z3z4vyAa,0.141840771529,Valid,vy3aZAz4,0.113310808333,Valid,4zAZa3yv,0.144932251371,Valid,3Zzv4yAa,0.131975845378,Valid,0.134134012346 +patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter push_card,Valid,0.274261854556,Valid,0.158648750043,Valid,0.334259485633,Valid,0.362532447086,Valid,0.239994345039,Timeout,10.1428850828,Timeout,10.1611041426,4.0,0.0,1.774194,3.0,11.0,31.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,patience.mlw,0.0,2.0,25.0,WP_parameter push_card,1.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,33.0,35.0,4.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,65.0,PatienceCode,0.0,24.0,Timeout,10.1426708278,2.0,5.0,14.2565085977,14.24352898,0.334259485633,0.362532447086,0.239994345039,14.2433764087,0.158648750043,0.274261854556,3.60389229784,2.50317826908,4.93594710604,5.5671529248,5.71816065296,8.61820759197,8.83809968629,11.7178973235,patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter push_card,Aa34yzZv,0.158648750043,Valid,Aya34vzZ,0.158648750043,Valid,Zzv43ayA,30.8091925003,Valid,Aaz4Zy3v,0.158648750043,Valid,5.34838271867 +patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.13680903631,Valid,0.13949961996,Valid,0.121981149935,Valid,0.136086106667,Valid,0.11818285235,Valid,0.131200706,Valid,0.133677869146,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,patience.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,PatienceCode,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.116457547552,0.0,0.0,0.133677869146,0.131200706,0.121981149935,0.136086106667,0.11818285235,0.116457547552,0.13949961996,0.13680903631,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter test,3aAvyzZ4,0.121981149935,Valid,vy3zZ4aA,0.116457547552,Valid,Aa4Zz3yv,0.13949961996,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.116457547552,Valid,0.12923686099 +patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter wf_rev_append_stacks,Valid,0.1647437815,Valid,0.1404648292,Valid,0.156368422932,Valid,0.240428947226,Valid,0.134719356563,Timeout,10.1449295412,Timeout,10.154416677,4.0,0.0,1.72,2.0,10.0,25.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,patience.mlw,0.0,1.0,18.0,WP_parameter wf_rev_append_stacks,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,26.0,27.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,51.0,PatienceCode,0.0,19.0,Valid,0.329916897823,2.0,3.0,14.2517429829,14.2449849209,0.156368422932,0.240428947226,0.134719356563,0.329916897823,0.1404648292,0.1647437815,2.20189640965,1.66164431399,3.00313497754,4.09659751756,3.36600664788,10.0029011011,10.0547265639,12.3741236846,patience:PatienceCode:WP_parameter wf_rev_append_stacks,Aa3y4zZv,0.1404648292,Valid,yA3a4vzZ,0.134719356563,Valid,Zzv4a3Ay,20.629263116,Valid,34yAaZzv,0.156368422932,Valid,3.09434697514 +patience:PigeonHole:WP_parameter pigeon_hole,Unknown,0.142038441089,Unknown,0.142626252967,Valid,1.11851173833,Timeout,10.2764102172,Timeout,10.1034800568,Valid,0.152011203412,Valid,0.150658580786,42.0,0.0,2.088235,0.0,28.0,204.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,patience.mlw,0.0,11.0,111.0,WP_parameter pigeon_hole,2.0,0.0,23.0,46.0,11.0,210.0,206.0,2.0,11.0,17.0,0.0,427.0,PigeonHole,0.0,164.0,Timeout,10.102715359,0.0,0.0,0.150658580786,0.152011203412,1.11851173833,14.3389193091,14.2154953926,14.2149519037,10.142626253,10.1420384411,12.6714430106,8.41929401404,11.3747995362,13.1920698144,12.6013798405,11.1930531949,11.4418334666,12.9261630645,patience:PigeonHole:WP_parameter pigeon_hole,Az3Zyav4,0.294637456379,Valid,Zz3aAvy4,0.150658580786,Valid,4yvAa3zZ,31.8857820654,Valid,A3vyzZ4a,1.2611379913,Valid,8.16554475594 +pigeonhole:Pigeonhole:WP_parameter below,Valid,0.109644705087,Valid,0.113547525345,Valid,0.122284968056,Valid,0.14688635275,Valid,0.1045621314,Valid,0.678691929298,Valid,0.667156207,9.0,0.0,2.236842,0.0,15.0,38.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,pigeonhole.mlw,0.0,5.0,24.0,WP_parameter below,1.0,3.0,2.0,9.0,3.0,40.0,42.0,4.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,86.0,Pigeonhole,0.0,30.0,Valid,0.296479871525,0.0,1.0,0.667156207,0.678691929298,0.122284968056,0.14688635275,0.1045621314,0.296479871525,0.113547525345,0.109644705087,5.10282008038,3.88209935971,5.43026152517,7.21306034559,7.90474205071,5.23868923883,5.25787216409,7.18428240737,pigeonhole:Pigeonhole:WP_parameter below,AazZ3v4y,0.113547525345,Valid,yaA34vZz,0.1045621314,Valid,zZv43Aay,0.678691929298,Valid,vzZ3Aa4y,0.296479871525,Valid,0.279906711308 +pigeonhole:Pigeonhole:WP_parameter pigeonhole,Unknown,0.245778918429,Unknown,0.120376755,Timeout,10.082877375,Timeout,11.1164678218,Timeout,10.1228060342,Timeout,10.107811535,Timeout,10.0977020808,31.0,0.0,2.182609,0.0,23.0,115.0,0.0,5.0,2.0,pigeonhole.mlw,0.0,13.0,73.0,WP_parameter pigeonhole,1.0,6.0,10.0,22.0,1.0,115.0,122.0,7.0,18.0,0.0,0.0,252.0,Pigeonhole,0.0,88.0,Timeout,10.074274358,0.0,3.0,14.2113893519,14.2185742614,14.2008596979,14.9524532045,14.2292375764,14.1947526868,10.120376755,10.2457789184,7.34423432424,6.24969865426,7.30587032309,8.2629279378,7.90811482159,7.01094036285,7.05249672487,10.3176656826,pigeonhole:Pigeonhole:WP_parameter pigeonhole,AzZ3ay4v,61.9680948782,Unknown,Aav3Zzy4,61.9680948782,Unknown,4yzZ3vaA,61.9680948782,Timeout,yzZA4a3v,61.9680948782,Timeout,61.9680948782 +remove_duplicate_hash:RemoveDuplicate:WP_parameter remove_duplicate,Timeout,11.1170365532,Valid,4.1431236648,Timeout,10.1312123456,Timeout,11.1521190738,Unknown,6.0256501808,Timeout,10.12950662,Timeout,10.1337993614,113.0,0.0,2.289277,0.0,53.0,401.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,remove_duplicate_hash.mlw,0.0,51.0,242.0,WP_parameter remove_duplicate,2.0,30.0,32.0,74.0,12.0,439.0,433.0,32.0,51.0,2.0,0.0,919.0,RemoveDuplicate,0.0,361.0,Timeout,10.1113601636,0.0,4.0,14.2370604233,14.2340052116,14.2352191269,14.9789772627,16.0256501808,14.2210971573,4.1431236648,14.9528760352,14.1349600011,12.4933534403,12.122127145,14.0907141031,13.4683115504,11.6077518272,11.7820290255,13.5293182979,remove_duplicate_hash:RemoveDuplicate:WP_parameter remove_duplicate,zZ3Ayv4a,34.5376419918,Valid,Avz3Za4y,4.1431236648,Valid,y4aZ3zvA,72.9438079632,Valid,ZzyvA34a,40.5434399906,Valid,38.543465814 +schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter cons_not_in,Unknown,0.301374843091,Unknown,0.323695897746,Failure,8.635405915,Timeout,10.3337570846,Timeout,10.2794402974,Timeout,10.2879409358,Timeout,10.2994027662,2.0,0.0,2.066667,0.0,9.0,15.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,schorr_waite.mlw,0.0,2.0,11.0,WP_parameter cons_not_in,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,15.0,15.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,32.0,SchorrWaite,0.0,13.0,Timeout,10.2716335088,0.0,0.0,14.3554065543,14.3471853929,13.2125029921,14.3800742517,14.3410910613,14.3354963269,10.3236958977,10.3013748431,5.98804154094,5.59987313823,6.47963822277,7.12183798287,8.88845080971,8.04897326435,7.76571289786,7.1293213371,schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter cons_not_in,Aa34vZzy,60.7326512486,Unknown,aA3vyzZ4,60.7326512486,Unknown,4Zzyv3Aa,60.7326512486,Timeout,43vAayZz,60.7326512486,Timeout,60.7326512486 +schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter schorr_waite,Timeout,11.4068053744,Timeout,10.378204946,Timeout,10.4356899342,Timeout,10.798526648,Timeout,10.433951906,Timeout,10.4501224692,Timeout,10.452416835,655.0,0.0,1.81026,0.0,81.0,5107.0,0.0,14.0,0.0,schorr_waite.mlw,0.0,282.0,3468.0,WP_parameter schorr_waite,82.0,13.0,609.0,327.0,87.0,4298.0,5202.0,95.0,296.0,250.0,38.0,9246.0,SchorrWaite,0.0,3421.0,Timeout,10.4244785422,0.0,550.0,14.4655804478,14.4639226913,14.4534986907,14.7176145407,14.4522438527,14.4454059436,14.412048359,15.1695487359,13.7598334745,12.3327916656,11.3773920996,13.9846987704,12.9413722509,11.1544481401,11.4557407554,12.9020108424,schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter schorr_waite,z3ZAvya4,84.780196655,Timeout,Avy3zZ4a,84.780196655,Timeout,a4Zz3yvA,84.780196655,Timeout,3zZvyaA4,84.780196655,Timeout,84.780196655 +schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter tl_cons,Valid,0.336381296846,Valid,0.325814406694,Valid,0.331791861706,Valid,0.368070087833,Timeout,10.2594384734,Timeout,10.2935216908,Timeout,10.2885129446,3.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,7.0,14.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,schorr_waite.mlw,0.0,1.0,10.0,WP_parameter tl_cons,0.0,0.0,1.0,3.0,0.0,14.0,14.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,29.0,SchorrWaite,0.0,11.0,Timeout,10.2714942016,0.0,0.0,14.347595569,14.3511877139,0.331791861706,0.368070087833,14.3267608966,14.3353965112,0.325814406694,0.336381296846,5.09599129274,4.53308861309,4.72297442474,5.40293907795,8.13307234216,7.13801020076,6.57704977877,6.33955248102,schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter tl_cons,A3a4vZzy,0.325814406694,Valid,A3a4yvZz,0.325814406694,Valid,zZvy4a3A,41.4810373982,Valid,yzZ43Ava,31.2095431966,Valid,8.56310787535 +schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter tl_stackNodes,Valid,0.330279305321,Valid,0.323864928,Valid,0.332258868161,Valid,0.372661411571,Unknown,1.6304979504,Valid,0.334092365333,Valid,0.346239359048,1.0,0.0,2.090909,0.0,8.0,11.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,schorr_waite.mlw,0.0,2.0,7.0,WP_parameter tl_stackNodes,0.0,0.0,2.0,3.0,1.0,11.0,11.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,24.0,SchorrWaite,0.0,8.0,Timeout,10.2835347208,0.0,0.0,0.346239359048,0.334092365333,0.332258868161,0.372661411571,11.6304979504,14.3440261556,0.323864928,0.330279305321,5.50892528266,5.43213506696,4.76012915623,5.921534347,8.11449097461,7.93146856302,7.71413966526,6.9981000529,schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter tl_stackNodes,3Aa4vZzy,0.332258868161,Valid,Aa3zZ4yv,0.323864928,Valid,vy4Zz3aA,12.2866940828,Valid,Aayv43zZ,0.323864928,Valid,2.04190404022 +schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter trans_path,Valid,3.7517706278,Valid,0.724317502824,Valid,0.72511657271,Valid,5.6672783188,Valid,1.2943989116,Timeout,10.3077446654,Timeout,10.2950672714,5.0,1.0,2.875,1.0,9.0,24.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,schorr_waite.mlw,0.0,1.0,17.0,WP_parameter trans_path,0.0,0.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,47.0,26.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,74.0,SchorrWaite,0.0,43.0,Timeout,10.2691853706,3.0,0.0,14.3522963362,14.3613926932,0.72511657271,5.6672783188,1.2943989116,14.3337422949,0.724317502824,3.7517706278,5.99855249238,4.91233517133,5.80897699952,6.49740497557,8.20453522956,9.09774288476,7.71399364112,9.91730676505,schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:WP_parameter trans_path,A3a4Zyzv,0.724317502824,Valid,A3ya4vZz,0.724317502824,Valid,zZv4ay3A,36.5392756262,Valid,Z3v4zAya,11.0201838441,Valid,7.57790927131 +schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:path_edge,Unknown,0.336988820824,Unknown,0.351581543087,Timeout,10.3076097174,Valid,0.399008618364,Valid,0.3258223372,Timeout,10.3009287706,Timeout,10.301372794,0.0,0.0,2.8,0.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,schorr_waite.mlw,0.0,1.0,4.0,path_edge,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,15.0,SchorrWaite,0.0,9.0,Timeout,10.3051966622,0.0,1.0,14.3568200323,14.3565014379,14.3612958359,0.399008618364,0.3258223372,14.3595639992,10.3515815431,10.3369888208,4.76048999373,4.39604389912,8.42758133207,8.86943834493,10.7415931917,7.21272978607,7.15252092866,7.90143985812,schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:path_edge,AaZzv34y,42.3026869265,Valid,y4aAzZv3,0.3258223372,Valid,3vZzAa4y,42.3026869265,Valid,AavZz34y,42.3026869265,Valid,14.3303082472 +schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:path_edge_cons,Valid,0.331955895816,Valid,0.333031042103,Valid,0.33363437492,Valid,0.416879759765,Valid,0.336534889,Valid,0.339104132212,Valid,0.34555412356,0.0,0.0,2.875,0.0,7.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,schorr_waite.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,path_edge_cons,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,16.0,8.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,24.0,SchorrWaite,0.0,15.0,Timeout,10.2733487014,0.0,1.0,0.34555412356,0.339104132212,0.33363437492,0.416879759765,0.336534889,14.3367253423,0.333031042103,0.331955895816,5.04224729287,4.86342283043,9.03178557194,8.80611260998,10.3534022473,7.66370065909,7.26281229601,8.48465914796,schorr_waite:SchorrWaite:path_edge_cons,AaZzv43y,0.333031042103,Valid,aA3yzZ4v,0.331955895816,Valid,v4Zzy3Aa,10.6902284612,Valid,Aa3yzZ4v,0.333031042103,Valid,1.63226776159 +sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter factorial,Valid,0.1429809778,Valid,0.123498068043,Valid,0.104648840606,Timeout,10.12977311,Unknown,0.0911148984375,Timeout,10.0940482248,Timeout,10.1043347956,6.0,0.0,2.025,0.0,20.0,40.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,sf.mlw,0.0,6.0,27.0,WP_parameter factorial,1.0,0.0,6.0,8.0,0.0,35.0,41.0,1.0,6.0,1.0,0.0,82.0,HoareLogic,0.0,27.0,Unknown,0.0897424765778,0.0,0.0,14.2161028999,14.2087933888,0.104648840606,14.2341948582,10.0911148984,10.0897424766,0.123498068043,0.1429809778,3.33364042156,2.66166476529,2.37365325129,5.89279435724,5.66775804457,3.49667045749,3.29495906047,5.81775459422,sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter factorial,3AZazyv4,0.104648840606,Valid,3AavyzZ4,0.104648840606,Valid,4ZzyvaA3,30.6519944832,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.104648840606,Valid,7.75096267184 +sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter parity,Valid,0.1367215165,Valid,0.119475670185,Valid,0.0949934507647,Timeout,10.1280275488,Valid,0.0910852309412,Valid,0.127554225182,Valid,0.122030667783,12.0,0.0,2.035714,0.0,20.0,56.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,sf.mlw,0.0,5.0,35.0,WP_parameter parity,1.0,1.0,5.0,19.0,0.0,52.0,58.0,2.0,5.0,1.0,3.0,115.0,HoareLogic,0.0,33.0,Valid,0.0869589960488,0.0,0.0,0.122030667783,0.127554225182,0.0949934507647,14.2329526813,0.0910852309412,0.0869589960488,0.119475670185,0.1367215165,3.65059808147,2.9457397096,3.18557810787,5.73997345947,5.11203169061,4.01087707698,4.03259688315,6.33459010765,sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter parity,A3azZy4v,0.119475670185,Valid,vy3AZza4,0.0869589960488,Valid,4azZA3yv,10.2647490653,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.0949934507647,Valid,1.37726340894 +sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter reduce_to_zero,Valid,0.1133274205,Valid,0.11664625014,Valid,0.0911912187222,Valid,0.116636730319,Valid,0.08682851765,Valid,0.11505692042,Valid,0.11896521219,3.0,0.0,2.294118,0.0,12.0,17.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,sf.mlw,0.0,3.0,10.0,WP_parameter reduce_to_zero,1.0,0.0,3.0,8.0,0.0,19.0,18.0,1.0,3.0,1.0,0.0,40.0,HoareLogic,0.0,11.0,Valid,0.0856522527746,0.0,0.0,0.11896521219,0.11505692042,0.0911912187222,0.116636730319,0.08682851765,0.0856522527746,0.11664625014,0.1133274205,5.10894916538,4.11552951184,3.74211977603,6.45225819804,6.64610514428,4.621928473,4.39080126431,6.01087843166,sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter reduce_to_zero,3AZzav4y,0.0911912187222,Valid,vy3az4AZ,0.0856522527746,Valid,ZA4za3yv,0.11896521219,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.0911912187222,Valid,0.105538065339 +sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter slow_addition,Valid,0.116761131562,Valid,0.117913947306,Valid,0.09309872836,Valid,0.11612104729,Valid,0.0859940285862,Valid,0.116885629169,Valid,0.120168340088,5.0,0.0,2.206897,0.0,15.0,29.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,sf.mlw,0.0,4.0,19.0,WP_parameter slow_addition,1.0,0.0,4.0,8.0,0.0,31.0,30.0,1.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,65.0,HoareLogic,0.0,23.0,Valid,0.0935301596316,0.0,0.0,0.120168340088,0.116885629169,0.09309872836,0.11612104729,0.0859940285862,0.0935301596316,0.117913947306,0.116761131562,4.0999481201,2.99368363675,2.84356427662,5.9708221302,5.66377634504,3.40757368651,3.14391526754,5.61911478393,sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter slow_addition,3AZzavy4,0.09309872836,Valid,y3v4azAZ,0.0859940285862,Valid,ZAza4v3y,0.120168340088,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.09309872836,Valid,0.107559126499 +sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter slow_subtraction,Valid,0.11670029612,Valid,0.1165783208,Valid,0.0917775839868,Valid,0.11579408435,Valid,0.0905076386087,Valid,0.115840012182,Valid,0.120243989957,5.0,0.0,2.206897,0.0,15.0,29.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,sf.mlw,0.0,4.0,19.0,WP_parameter slow_subtraction,1.0,0.0,4.0,8.0,0.0,31.0,30.0,1.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,65.0,HoareLogic,0.0,23.0,Valid,0.0855197425443,0.0,0.0,0.120243989957,0.115840012182,0.0917775839868,0.11579408435,0.0905076386087,0.0855197425443,0.1165783208,0.11670029612,4.0999481201,2.99368363675,2.84356427662,5.9708221302,5.66377634504,3.40757368651,3.14391526754,5.61911478393,sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter slow_subtraction,3AZzavy4,0.0917775839868,Valid,vy34zAaZ,0.0855197425443,Valid,ZaAz43yv,0.120243989957,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.0917775839868,Valid,0.106620208569 +sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter sqrt,Valid,0.114264590781,Valid,0.11845580585,Unknown,0.449949556635,Valid,0.114256750091,Unknown,0.09138589469,Valid,0.121412877691,Valid,0.121910129276,7.0,0.0,2.166667,0.0,16.0,42.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,sf.mlw,0.0,4.0,31.0,WP_parameter sqrt,1.0,0.0,4.0,11.0,0.0,45.0,43.0,1.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,92.0,HoareLogic,0.0,34.0,Unknown,0.08590607119,0.0,0.0,0.121910129276,0.121412877691,10.4499495566,0.114256750091,10.0913858947,10.0859060712,0.11845580585,0.114264590781,4.48548278151,3.56854020682,3.59167649374,4.91225466553,6.94354474074,4.81319329172,4.40445655801,7.27243561205,sf:HoareLogic:WP_parameter sqrt,A3Zaz4yv,0.11845580585,Valid,4aAzZvy3,0.114256750091,Valid,3yvZzAa4,0.749151651791,Valid,34AaZzvy,0.564206306726,Valid,0.22260028449 +sf:HoareLogic:even_noneg,Unknown,0.188466187364,Timeout,10.112968028,Unknown,0.170627480176,Timeout,10.11742126,Timeout,10.0802956134,Timeout,10.094561826,Timeout,10.101608724,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,sf.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,even_noneg,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,3.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,7.0,HoareLogic,0.0,2.0,Timeout,10.0873249194,0.0,0.0,14.2141654279,14.20915826,10.1706274802,14.2254073036,14.199026715,14.2040178833,14.222240412,10.1884661874,5.63741486587,5.73465404567,3.28823440461,3.80516133073,4.01758905614,3.75458054723,3.86361016645,5.01622231288,sf:HoareLogic:even_noneg,3z4ZyvaA,60.9532740383,Unknown,3ayvzZA4,60.9532740383,Unknown,4AZzvya3,60.9532740383,Timeout,y3Zz4vaA,60.9532740383,Timeout,60.9532740383 +sf:HoareLogic:even_not_odd,Timeout,9.2781393212,Timeout,10.1203177906,Unknown,5.0268008058,Timeout,10.1133875584,Timeout,10.0794218256,Timeout,10.0941178856,Timeout,10.0865632542,0.0,0.0,1.8,0.0,6.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,sf.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,even_not_odd,0.0,0.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,4.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,HoareLogic,0.0,2.0,Timeout,10.0732454094,0.0,0.0,14.2034769786,14.2088428765,15.0268008058,14.2225387293,14.1984064014,14.1940224418,14.2274675253,13.6412561468,4.72637673322,4.37380315869,3.89024857461,4.46132286499,6.11208186494,5.08396991071,5.28778322951,5.18046693254,sf:HoareLogic:even_not_odd,3A4azvZy,74.8719938508,Unknown,avyZz4A3,74.8719938508,Timeout,3A4zZyva,74.8719938508,Unknown,y3Aa4zZv,74.8719938508,Timeout,74.8719938508 +sf:MoreHoareLogic:WP_parameter list_member,Valid,0.167259074027,Valid,0.151944941857,Valid,0.140431964,Valid,0.2324332435,Valid,0.179849074708,Timeout,10.1448424562,Timeout,10.1711892572,20.0,0.0,1.972222,5.0,26.0,108.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,sf.mlw,0.0,9.0,66.0,WP_parameter list_member,2.0,1.0,14.0,11.0,0.0,113.0,116.0,8.0,9.0,4.0,4.0,229.0,MoreHoareLogic,0.0,83.0,Valid,0.310271082156,5.0,9.0,14.26369836,14.2449229012,0.140431964,0.2324332435,0.179849074708,0.310271082156,0.151944941857,0.167259074027,10.5510470065,8.22781525855,9.07230092393,10.8160328598,10.8380843097,10.8855400629,10.9694736427,12.1726185664,sf:MoreHoareLogic:WP_parameter list_member,A3a4yzZv,0.151944941857,Valid,3Aay4vzZ,0.140431964,Valid,Zzv4yaA3,20.6263027956,Valid,3vy4zAZa,0.140431964,Valid,3.09932180815 +sf:MoreHoareLogic:WP_parameter list_sum,Valid,0.13823098082,Valid,0.134387373031,Valid,0.11851449762,Valid,0.147363919375,Valid,0.10556530375,Valid,0.156981368117,Valid,0.15762862652,7.0,0.0,1.793103,3.0,23.0,58.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,sf.mlw,0.0,7.0,42.0,WP_parameter list_sum,1.0,0.0,6.0,1.0,0.0,51.0,62.0,4.0,7.0,3.0,0.0,114.0,MoreHoareLogic,0.0,38.0,Valid,0.10132979332,3.0,6.0,0.15762862652,0.156981368117,0.11851449762,0.147363919375,0.10556530375,0.10132979332,0.134387373031,0.13823098082,7.05672233596,5.87377650605,6.68807628742,6.61104941955,8.4425445299,9.54027241757,9.57203956588,11.9299501069,sf:MoreHoareLogic:WP_parameter list_sum,A43ayzZv,0.134387373031,Valid,vy3Aa4zZ,0.10132979332,Valid,Zz4aA3yv,0.15762862652,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.11851449762,Valid,0.132500232819 +sieve:Sieve:WP_parameter incr,Valid,0.14016976868,Valid,0.143984207103,Valid,0.129715858235,Valid,0.154894260987,Valid,0.12409531817,Valid,0.14061796585,Valid,0.13863207678,0.0,0.0,2.4,0.0,6.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,sieve.mlw,0.0,2.0,4.0,WP_parameter incr,0.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,6.0,5.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,Sieve,0.0,4.0,Valid,0.120098413633,0.0,0.0,0.13863207678,0.14061796585,0.129715858235,0.154894260987,0.12409531817,0.120098413633,0.143984207103,0.14016976868,2.29966773077,2.03885434829,2.42841635058,2.83111048981,6.33194733251,2.93454663442,2.93683473965,5.15129163004,sieve:Sieve:WP_parameter incr,Aa34zZvy,0.143984207103,Valid,vy3ZazA4,0.120098413633,Valid,4AzaZ3yv,0.154894260987,Valid,4Zzv3Aay,0.154894260987,Valid,0.13652598368 +sieve:Sieve:WP_parameter sieve,Timeout,11.1267243168,Timeout,10.1339978646,Timeout,10.114887561,Timeout,11.1403512454,Unknown,0.14942236221,Timeout,10.1575416808,Timeout,10.170228835,88.0,0.0,2.080128,0.0,40.0,312.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,sieve.mlw,0.0,31.0,187.0,WP_parameter sieve,3.0,8.0,34.0,63.0,0.0,310.0,323.0,11.0,31.0,3.0,0.0,650.0,Sieve,0.0,227.0,Unknown,0.129040197875,0.0,14.0,14.263013516,14.2539697277,14.2236053929,14.9702179634,10.1494223622,10.1290401979,14.2372017166,14.9600800139,11.4272436427,8.36476352528,10.3825953204,10.0061928018,11.1935637106,6.5673449397,6.34193419574,12.8843658709,sieve:Sieve:WP_parameter sieve,ZzA43yav,63.1221940637,Timeout,vy3AzZa4,63.1221940637,Unknown,4aZzA3yv,63.1221940637,Timeout,ZzA4y3av,63.1221940637,Timeout,63.1221940637 +skew_heaps:HeapSort:WP_parameter heapsort,Timeout,11.1239188582,Timeout,10.1440150158,Timeout,10.125024334,Timeout,10.2379815978,Timeout,10.140002214,Timeout,10.153314205,Timeout,10.158784389,97.0,0.0,2.110375,0.0,41.0,453.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,48.0,301.0,WP_parameter heapsort,0.0,0.0,44.0,110.0,7.0,456.0,453.0,0.0,48.0,4.0,0.0,957.0,HeapSort,0.0,346.0,Timeout,10.1209748188,0.0,0.0,14.2548553224,14.2509574887,14.23081578,14.3114033972,14.2414762191,14.2279348917,14.2443336327,14.9579935407,13.6863325151,11.7012541178,11.0986663139,13.0188677044,12.980215255,10.245135562,10.4830993845,13.45034666,skew_heaps:HeapSort:WP_parameter heapsort,zZ3Ay4va,82.2040154326,Timeout,v3yAzZ4a,82.2040154326,Timeout,a4ZzAy3v,82.2040154326,Timeout,ZzyvA34a,82.2040154326,Timeout,82.2040154326 +skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter add,Valid,0.159323516259,Valid,0.14812757054,Valid,0.132762938074,Valid,0.173584873589,Valid,0.12051577782,Valid,0.15017230509,Valid,0.150688970258,7.0,0.0,1.761905,0.0,14.0,42.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,4.0,30.0,WP_parameter add,0.0,0.0,3.0,2.0,1.0,31.0,42.0,0.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,75.0,SkewHeaps,0.0,27.0,Timeout,10.102426373,0.0,2.0,0.150688970258,0.15017230509,0.132762938074,0.173584873589,0.12051577782,14.2147465198,0.14812757054,0.159323516259,3.92788441745,2.87841693408,3.51416948441,3.55278452234,6.46861952711,5.6698612124,5.42963727151,6.44461360513,skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter add,A34aZzvy,0.14812757054,Valid,y3AzZa4v,0.12051577782,Valid,v4aZzA3y,10.2760112466,Valid,3AzZa4yv,0.132762938074,Valid,1.41068557543 +skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter empty,Valid,0.137374685667,Valid,0.139971635972,Valid,0.119614396079,Valid,0.14661388602,Valid,0.121551157438,Valid,0.14050901751,Valid,0.133153685723,2.0,0.0,1.6,0.0,8.0,10.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,WP_parameter empty,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,1.0,7.0,10.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,17.0,SkewHeaps,0.0,4.0,Valid,0.106775352811,0.0,1.0,0.133153685723,0.14050901751,0.119614396079,0.14661388602,0.121551157438,0.106775352811,0.139971635972,0.137374685667,7.44815363069,7.14895485948,6.96340543505,3.17378339348,8.02046407651,7.19505883202,4.61776647024,8.31223084266,skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter empty,4Z3Azayv,0.14661388602,Valid,v3yZaAz4,0.106775352811,Valid,4zAaZy3v,0.14661388602,Valid,4za3AZyv,0.14661388602,Valid,0.130695477152 +skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter get_min,Valid,0.132926977111,Valid,0.13522136807,Valid,0.122562959923,Valid,0.147524784924,Valid,0.118194436683,Valid,0.141578067292,Valid,0.13788014822,1.0,0.0,1.888889,1.0,6.0,9.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,1.0,7.0,WP_parameter get_min,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,11.0,10.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,21.0,SkewHeaps,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.110891609545,2.0,1.0,0.13788014822,0.141578067292,0.122562959923,0.147524784924,0.118194436683,0.110891609545,0.13522136807,0.132926977111,3.37127176467,2.79551458295,3.09546004913,3.55634077092,4.93264063868,5.49529683165,5.60614553742,7.68417728442,skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter get_min,A3a4yzZv,0.13522136807,Valid,vy3aAZz4,0.110891609545,Valid,4zZAa3yv,0.147524784924,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,0.118194436683,Valid,0.130847543971 +skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter is_empty,Valid,0.13470070343,Valid,0.1380526649,Valid,0.117790867421,Valid,0.14603032363,Valid,0.11601652525,Valid,0.1428582123,Valid,0.13358401082,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,1.0,4.0,WP_parameter is_empty,0.0,1.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,4.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,9.0,SkewHeaps,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.106395492202,0.0,1.0,0.13358401082,0.1428582123,0.117790867421,0.14603032363,0.11601652525,0.106395492202,0.1380526649,0.13470070343,3.89408134392,3.57122615899,3.29815390327,2.97217892507,6.23271044144,5.35137461549,3.91666519831,5.80586162215,skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter is_empty,43AaZzvy,0.14603032363,Valid,vy3ZaAz4,0.106395492202,Valid,4zAaZ3yv,0.14603032363,Valid,A3av4Zzy,0.1380526649,Valid,0.129428599994 +skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter merge,Timeout,11.1252567228,Valid,6.2291365428,Timeout,10.096668586,Timeout,10.167241072,Timeout,10.1044827494,Timeout,10.1160732502,Timeout,10.1241064122,23.0,0.0,1.794326,3.0,17.0,141.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,10.0,113.0,WP_parameter merge,1.0,0.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,111.0,145.0,4.0,10.0,0.0,0.0,263.0,SkewHeaps,0.0,105.0,Timeout,10.1122793576,1.0,3.0,14.2301627062,14.224448601,14.2106550354,14.2608832481,14.216208061,14.2217507293,6.2291365428,14.9589885069,12.1196815626,8.97342700968,10.7670655797,12.992769344,12.2987335718,12.955358649,13.0501084218,13.2130392827,skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter merge,A3ayz4Zv,6.2291365428,Valid,A3yvzZ4a,6.2291365428,Valid,a4Zzvy3A,78.075244693,Valid,Aa3yZzv4,6.2291365428,Valid,42.1521906179 +skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter remove_min,Valid,0.153769461122,Valid,0.147776893902,Valid,0.1282105285,Valid,0.154551004741,Valid,0.116418577487,Valid,0.309509018654,Valid,0.292068618882,8.0,0.0,1.782609,1.0,15.0,46.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,4.0,34.0,WP_parameter remove_min,0.0,0.0,3.0,3.0,0.0,36.0,47.0,1.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,86.0,SkewHeaps,0.0,30.0,Valid,0.1124641325,1.0,1.0,0.292068618882,0.309509018654,0.1282105285,0.154551004741,0.116418577487,0.1124641325,0.147776893902,0.153769461122,4.08078530838,3.14319318246,4.39801595774,5.1748339307,6.5112267145,6.60976919061,6.4022091555,8.40840759928,skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter remove_min,Aa34Zyzv,0.147776893902,Valid,vy3Aa4Zz,0.1124641325,Valid,zZ4aA3yv,0.309509018654,Valid,Aaz4Zy3v,0.147776893902,Valid,0.176846029474 +skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter root_is_min,Unknown,0.659349625,Timeout,10.1158456646,Valid,1.346246282,Valid,0.266669358033,Timeout,10.097333353,Timeout,10.1110884462,Timeout,10.1135849172,10.0,0.0,1.848485,4.0,14.0,66.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,1.0,46.0,WP_parameter root_is_min,3.0,0.0,4.0,4.0,0.0,68.0,73.0,7.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,135.0,SkewHeaps,0.0,49.0,Timeout,10.1053698642,4.0,7.0,14.2226790682,14.2209039645,1.346246282,0.266669358033,14.21112736,14.216838611,14.2242867487,10.659349625,7.8191119227,7.16640595809,6.70309440977,5.81661731057,8.53152480416,10.5437698877,10.5970089058,12.3575630835,skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter root_is_min,43AayzZv,0.266669358033,Valid,43ayvzZA,0.266669358033,Valid,AZzvya34,52.5488181522,Valid,4aAy3vZz,0.266669358033,Valid,17.8739817767 +skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter size,Valid,0.135881248138,Valid,0.133144981558,Valid,0.116989414,Valid,0.13682236119,Valid,0.112578009586,Valid,0.13201853119,Valid,0.126828812051,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,skew_heaps.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter size,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,SkewHeaps,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.106396847048,0.0,0.0,0.126828812051,0.13201853119,0.116989414,0.13682236119,0.112578009586,0.106396847048,0.133144981558,0.135881248138,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,skew_heaps:SkewHeaps:WP_parameter size,3aAvyzZ4,0.116989414,Valid,vy3ZzAa4,0.106396847048,Valid,4aAzZ3yv,0.13682236119,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.106396847048,Valid,0.125082525595 +snapshotable_trees:BSTree:WP_parameter bst_add,Valid,0.205413115346,Valid,0.154284581583,Valid,0.2193373075,Valid,0.222082102,Unknown,1.229603759,Timeout,10.1026742652,Timeout,10.0997846186,16.0,0.0,2.151163,3.0,18.0,86.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,8.0,50.0,WP_parameter bst_add,2.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,3.0,96.0,96.0,10.0,8.0,5.0,7.0,195.0,BSTree,0.0,87.0,Valid,0.139037485304,2.0,5.0,14.2128691453,14.214922698,0.2193373075,0.222082102,11.229603759,0.139037485304,0.154284581583,0.205413115346,7.24472904157,5.80973483389,7.12816472078,7.438802258,9.0854887054,11.2112542637,10.9589985637,12.6605051853,snapshotable_trees:BSTree:WP_parameter bst_add,A3a4yZzv,0.154284581583,Valid,vAa34yZz,0.139037485304,Valid,zZy43aAv,21.6541447448,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.2193373075,Valid,3.76004135881 +snapshotable_trees:BSTree:WP_parameter bst_mem,Valid,0.131965848261,Valid,0.130114817531,Valid,0.108079578333,Valid,0.144032772865,Valid,0.124895139857,Timeout,10.1084328262,Timeout,10.1048435642,4.0,0.0,2.205128,3.0,12.0,39.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,3.0,29.0,WP_parameter bst_mem,2.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,52.0,48.0,9.0,3.0,1.0,2.0,96.0,BSTree,0.0,41.0,Valid,0.100171433911,2.0,7.0,14.2164645203,14.2190159365,0.108079578333,0.144032772865,0.124895139857,0.100171433911,0.130114817531,0.131965848261,5.45656950231,4.62771500621,6.52237044221,6.25251179674,8.05907851279,10.3176833037,10.0112135251,12.3898969639,snapshotable_trees:BSTree:WP_parameter bst_mem,Aa43yZzv,0.130114817531,Valid,v3yAa4Zz,0.100171433911,Valid,zZ4aAy3v,20.3573091633,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.108079578333,Valid,3.01082084471 +snapshotable_trees:Enum:WP_parameter enum,Valid,0.268529762263,Valid,0.13810041524,Valid,0.1064824088,Valid,0.168405619429,Valid,0.0995062902,Timeout,10.0956977902,Timeout,10.1044390512,1.0,0.0,1.84,2.0,10.0,25.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,22.0,WP_parameter enum,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,26.0,27.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,53.0,Enum,0.0,22.0,Timeout,10.1039369266,1.0,2.0,14.2161770016,14.2099653015,0.1064824088,0.168405619429,0.0995062902,14.2158201106,0.13810041524,0.268529762263,2.06897678067,1.27023180904,2.53655563621,3.17207227522,2.89166255741,9.91164765297,10.0399780654,13.1516197677,snapshotable_trees:Enum:WP_parameter enum,Aa3y4zZv,0.13810041524,Valid,y3A4azvZ,0.0995062902,Valid,Zvza4A3y,30.5726035303,Valid,34yAaZzv,0.1064824088,Valid,5.20688386052 +snapshotable_trees:Harness:WP_parameter test,Valid,0.141119184808,Valid,0.126513658667,Valid,0.125093364941,Valid,0.151594075475,Valid,0.11566290108,Valid,0.13365844551,Valid,0.13757697825,14.0,0.0,1.989011,0.0,38.0,91.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,19.0,59.0,WP_parameter test,0.0,9.0,11.0,9.0,1.0,71.0,100.0,9.0,19.0,2.0,4.0,182.0,Harness,0.0,54.0,Timeout,10.1040393836,0.0,8.0,0.13757697825,0.13365844551,0.125093364941,0.151594075475,0.11566290108,14.2158929324,0.126513658667,0.141119184808,8.6244194994,6.85706990273,6.69543101508,7.7680557772,8.9571913205,7.907806584,8.00464727625,10.5429842014,snapshotable_trees:Harness:WP_parameter test,3A4zZayv,0.125093364941,Valid,y3AzZa4v,0.11566290108,Valid,v4aZzA3y,10.2556334591,Valid,3vy4zAZa,0.125093364941,Valid,1.39603615277 +snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter add,Valid,0.126629654488,Valid,0.12425468374,Valid,0.110280798294,Valid,0.13452474245,Valid,0.0897821228,Valid,0.125027373186,Valid,0.128819676507,7.0,0.0,2.176471,0.0,15.0,34.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,6.0,18.0,WP_parameter add,0.0,3.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,32.0,37.0,3.0,6.0,2.0,3.0,75.0,ITree,0.0,32.0,Valid,0.10201942149,0.0,0.0,0.128819676507,0.125027373186,0.110280798294,0.13452474245,0.0897821228,0.10201942149,0.12425468374,0.126629654488,6.69387008147,5.09144618754,5.807877014,6.12898878365,8.16337039161,8.46759050232,7.70563367386,9.47491992337,snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter add,A34aZyzv,0.12425468374,Valid,yv3AzaZ4,0.0897821228,Valid,4ZazA3vy,0.13452474245,Valid,A3avyzZ4,0.12425468374,Valid,0.117667309119 +snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter contains,Valid,0.121108744917,Valid,0.123829312045,Valid,0.105990086261,Valid,0.131353672383,Valid,0.0994698257778,Valid,0.124695165763,Valid,0.129782019318,1.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,8.0,11.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,8.0,WP_parameter contains,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,13.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,23.0,ITree,0.0,8.0,Valid,0.0956598604667,0.0,2.0,0.129782019318,0.124695165763,0.105990086261,0.131353672383,0.0994698257778,0.0956598604667,0.123829312045,0.121108744917,7.43512288027,5.80265122613,6.74087143111,6.51433744259,7.7669125229,9.41236359598,9.00352906016,10.504483447,snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter contains,A43ayZzv,0.123829312045,Valid,vy3aAzZ4,0.0956598604667,Valid,4ZzAa3yv,0.131353672383,Valid,A43ayzZv,0.123829312045,Valid,0.116486085866 +snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter create,Valid,0.118410491286,Valid,0.123257969965,Valid,0.100306481879,Valid,0.12889267581,Valid,0.0991470091714,Valid,0.122642576143,Valid,0.124413800722,0.0,0.0,0.5,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,0.0,2.0,WP_parameter create,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,ITree,0.0,0.0,Valid,0.09919713484,0.0,1.0,0.124413800722,0.122642576143,0.100306481879,0.12889267581,0.0991470091714,0.09919713484,0.123257969965,0.118410491286,3.98471326109,3.85657708103,1.20041652256,2.17600249577,2.58957454551,1.63109173773,0.902993447475,2.27454833098,snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter create,Z3z4vyAa,0.124413800722,Valid,yv3azAZ4,0.0991470091714,Valid,4ZAza3vy,0.12889267581,Valid,3Zzv4yAa,0.100306481879,Valid,0.114533517477 +snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter iterator,Valid,0.113625287,Valid,0.1151525938,Valid,0.0985513484545,Valid,0.13110541519,Valid,0.101898330979,Valid,0.12223408742,Valid,0.1222155286,0.0,0.0,1.666667,0.0,7.0,9.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,7.0,WP_parameter iterator,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,9.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,16.0,ITree,0.0,5.0,Valid,0.0930843678696,0.0,0.0,0.1222155286,0.12223408742,0.0985513484545,0.13110541519,0.101898330979,0.0930843678696,0.1151525938,0.113625287,10.3426488081,8.6382696492,9.44647816136,9.42495515527,10.2763337376,9.9776698508,9.30599623821,11.2241240082,snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter iterator,AZ43zyav,0.1151525938,Valid,v3yaAZz4,0.0930843678696,Valid,4zZAay3v,0.13110541519,Valid,A3y4avZz,0.1151525938,Valid,0.112233369914 +snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter snapshot,Valid,0.123307344615,Valid,0.123733973857,Valid,0.101568892743,Valid,0.12484408732,Valid,0.101146373477,Valid,0.120490850408,Valid,0.124004107268,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter snapshot,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,ITree,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.09660641512,0.0,0.0,0.124004107268,0.120490850408,0.101568892743,0.12484408732,0.101146373477,0.09660641512,0.123733973857,0.123307344615,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,snapshotable_trees:ITree:WP_parameter snapshot,3aAvyzZ4,0.101568892743,Valid,vy3zaAZ4,0.09660641512,Valid,4ZAaz3yv,0.12484408732,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.09660641512,Valid,0.114462755601 +snapshotable_trees:Iterator:WP_parameter create_iterator,Valid,0.119300838479,Valid,0.117772613952,Valid,0.09778486345,Valid,0.126700430219,Valid,0.102876699929,Valid,0.125537852405,Valid,0.13186292156,0.0,0.0,1.5,0.0,7.0,10.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,9.0,WP_parameter create_iterator,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,10.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,16.0,Iterator,0.0,4.0,Valid,0.100681714556,0.0,1.0,0.13186292156,0.125537852405,0.09778486345,0.126700430219,0.102876699929,0.100681714556,0.117772613952,0.119300838479,11.3778479913,10.3897938071,10.9638623069,8.66167943914,11.1870676268,10.1432782193,9.15559261947,11.5122596352,snapshotable_trees:Iterator:WP_parameter create_iterator,4ZzA3yav,0.126700430219,Valid,3vyAaz4Z,0.09778486345,Valid,Z4zaAyv3,0.13186292156,Valid,4AyvzZa3,0.126700430219,Valid,0.115314741819 +snapshotable_trees:Iterator:WP_parameter hasNext,Valid,0.11801164908,Valid,0.122888685265,Valid,0.0940793312667,Valid,0.12093041964,Valid,0.0957015907174,Valid,0.11807862325,Valid,0.120663328526,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter hasNext,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,Iterator,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.09755675182,0.0,0.0,0.120663328526,0.11807862325,0.0940793312667,0.12093041964,0.0957015907174,0.09755675182,0.122888685265,0.11801164908,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,snapshotable_trees:Iterator:WP_parameter hasNext,3aAvyzZ4,0.0940793312667,Valid,3yvazZ4A,0.0940793312667,Valid,A4Zzavy3,0.122888685265,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.09755675182,Valid,0.110988797446 +snapshotable_trees:Iterator:WP_parameter next,Valid,0.109987974,Valid,0.121821906316,Valid,0.107864388636,Valid,0.135876424731,Valid,0.105411733742,Valid,0.12742081265,Valid,0.133464745083,0.0,0.0,1.777778,1.0,11.0,18.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,snapshotable_trees.mlw,0.0,3.0,14.0,WP_parameter next,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,16.0,19.0,1.0,3.0,1.0,0.0,36.0,Iterator,0.0,13.0,Timeout,10.1278108508,0.0,2.0,0.133464745083,0.12742081265,0.107864388636,0.135876424731,0.105411733742,14.232798482,0.121821906316,0.109987974,4.75229573023,3.67894441936,4.94396754862,5.6056375996,6.63216896435,7.62267353713,7.70178322399,10.737558028,snapshotable_trees:Iterator:WP_parameter next,Aa34yzZv,0.121821906316,Valid,y3aAzZ4v,0.105411733742,Valid,v4ZzAa3y,10.2636872755,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,0.105411733742,Valid,1.38624035423 +swap:Swap:WP_parameter swap,Valid,0.0875844338529,Valid,0.0872651691351,Valid,0.05938124604,Valid,0.083829617023,Valid,0.058533923575,Valid,0.0892634130938,Valid,0.0842001569,1.0,0.0,2.333333,0.0,10.0,12.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,swap.mlw,0.0,4.0,8.0,WP_parameter swap,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,12.0,0.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,29.0,Swap,0.0,13.0,Valid,0.0609674124167,0.0,0.0,0.0842001569,0.0892634130938,0.05938124604,0.083829617023,0.058533923575,0.0609674124167,0.0872651691351,0.0875844338529,7.53081749693,6.53511453485,7.97215180533,7.93006522868,9.17381565553,8.86187818174,8.33640983358,10.0488608309,swap:Swap:WP_parameter swap,Aa43Zzyv,0.0872651691351,Valid,y3v4ZAaz,0.058533923575,Valid,zaAZ4v3y,0.0892634130938,Valid,AaZz34yv,0.0872651691351,Valid,0.0763781715046 +toy_compiler:Compiler:WP_parameter soundness,Valid,0.120239465086,Valid,0.127561057273,Valid,0.116564893762,Valid,0.162707036091,Unknown,0.11307625537,Valid,0.2611092395,Valid,0.263831468294,1.0,0.0,1.235294,0.0,7.0,17.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,toy_compiler.mlw,0.0,1.0,16.0,WP_parameter soundness,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,9.0,17.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,22.0,Compiler,0.0,4.0,Timeout,10.0886184998,0.0,5.0,0.263831468294,0.2611092395,0.116564893762,0.162707036091,10.1130762554,14.2049365797,0.127561057273,0.120239465086,9.10527668307,8.42380661137,8.6760931738,3.62219213809,9.83698499653,8.76129890183,6.34728308032,9.13339800494,toy_compiler:Compiler:WP_parameter soundness,4ZA3zavy,0.162707036091,Valid,3aA4zZyv,0.116564893762,Valid,vyZz4Aa3,10.4655262235,Valid,Aa4yZvz3,0.127561057273,Valid,1.63272049169 +toy_compiler:Compiler:WP_parameter soundness_gen,Unknown,1.26536043789,Timeout,10.1337646586,Timeout,10.1092274574,Timeout,11.11426746,Unknown,0.13928852085,Timeout,10.1324442426,Timeout,10.1145468786,7.0,0.0,1.91133,7.0,14.0,203.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,toy_compiler.mlw,0.0,1.0,163.0,WP_parameter soundness_gen,0.0,0.0,6.0,0.0,9.0,219.0,210.0,7.0,1.0,0.0,18.0,424.0,Compiler,0.0,201.0,Unknown,0.108235434627,6.0,6.0,14.2233631241,14.2360958949,14.2195808583,14.9508174082,10.1392885209,10.1082354346,14.2370357222,11.2653604379,10.9636197872,8.41216383225,10.3908685339,11.7412968684,11.5801301427,12.1401072842,12.3948814372,11.5594982985,toy_compiler:Compiler:WP_parameter soundness_gen,A3avy4zZ,53.1171350906,Timeout,vya3ZzA4,53.1171350906,Unknown,4AzZ3ayv,53.1171350906,Timeout,A34vayzZ,53.1171350906,Timeout,53.1171350906 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter add,Timeout,11.1098840426,Timeout,10.1147696318,Timeout,10.0834441484,Timeout,10.1770269804,Timeout,10.0721940664,Timeout,10.0840450292,Timeout,10.079396258,10.0,0.0,2.577778,2.0,15.0,45.0,0.0,3.0,2.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,5.0,29.0,WP_parameter add,2.0,2.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,69.0,51.0,6.0,8.0,0.0,1.0,123.0,RedBlackTree,1.0,52.0,Failure,2.6134407164,9.0,5.0,14.198388251,14.2016887781,14.2012621233,14.2678617235,14.1932763417,10.3358634075,14.2235215296,14.9475591131,6.30253330263,5.34807032203,6.5901056929,6.78320636306,8.29043844669,10.0510127185,9.77603177429,12.2267746216,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter add,Aa34yZzv,74.3342008732,Timeout,vyZ3zA4a,74.3342008732,Failure,a4Az3Zyv,74.3342008732,Timeout,3yAa4Zzv,74.3342008732,Timeout,74.3342008732 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter find,Valid,0.150877542286,Valid,0.143609748353,Valid,0.13571341468,Valid,0.250124682948,Valid,0.105951479553,Timeout,10.081406535,Timeout,10.0834479074,6.0,0.0,2.581395,3.0,13.0,43.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,8.0,25.0,WP_parameter find,2.0,0.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,68.0,48.0,5.0,8.0,5.0,2.0,121.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,56.0,Valid,0.09677675042,7.0,3.0,14.2012647923,14.1998154116,0.13571341468,0.250124682948,0.105951479553,0.09677675042,0.143609748353,0.150877542286,6.63037252963,5.74028472239,6.75421027437,6.95471716228,8.47712792147,10.5995604058,10.2837842875,12.4643181184,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter find,Aa34yZzv,0.143609748353,Valid,vy3Aa4zZ,0.09677675042,Valid,Zz4aA3yv,20.4149791253,Valid,3yAa4Zzv,0.13571341468,Valid,3.02786909481 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter insert,Timeout,11.1121751344,Timeout,10.1163471096,Timeout,10.085115774,Timeout,10.1470924678,Failure,5.7496559288,Timeout,10.087736768,Timeout,10.0851908202,69.0,0.0,2.481586,16.0,22.0,353.0,0.0,5.0,15.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,33.0,229.0,WP_parameter insert,17.0,13.0,33.0,2.0,5.0,536.0,399.0,46.0,38.0,0.0,17.0,926.0,RedBlackTree,11.0,361.0,Timeout,10.1025334026,100.0,47.0,14.2025023809,14.2043103705,14.2024490907,14.2465253852,11.5351004894,14.214822586,14.2246433643,14.9492620626,12.7923716257,10.9641303335,10.7472241726,13.4433687558,13.1018596561,10.7331367494,11.001240588,12.9355093812,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter insert,z3AZavy4,77.4858474054,Timeout,y3ZzvA4a,77.4858474054,Failure,a4AvzZ3y,77.4858474054,Timeout,3zZvyaA4,77.4858474054,Timeout,77.4858474054 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter lbalance,Timeout,11.1040610174,Valid,3.3475622144,Timeout,10.0806093034,Timeout,10.1569671994,Timeout,10.0783623006,Timeout,10.0920456594,Timeout,10.0852942436,7.0,0.0,2.473684,1.0,12.0,57.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,5.0,40.0,WP_parameter lbalance,2.0,2.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,86.0,62.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,3.0,145.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,75.0,Timeout,10.0785764166,1.0,8.0,14.202575822,14.2073708191,14.1992494142,14.2535603514,14.1976542662,14.1978062596,3.3475622144,14.9432316143,7.2614364738,5.90887763767,6.9964713401,7.82915908454,9.54056880037,9.99957323819,9.54304881251,10.9600655747,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter lbalance,A3a4yZzv,3.3475622144,Valid,Ayv3Zz4a,3.3475622144,Valid,a4zZ3vyA,75.0234783548,Valid,A3avyzZ4,3.3475622144,Valid,39.1855202846 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter rbalance,Timeout,11.0935907634,Valid,3.5043586724,Timeout,10.0827136052,Timeout,10.138716595,Timeout,10.0903049442,Timeout,10.0949664998,Timeout,10.0899404512,7.0,0.0,2.473684,1.0,12.0,57.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,5.0,40.0,WP_parameter rbalance,2.0,2.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,86.0,62.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,3.0,145.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,75.0,Timeout,10.0921451902,1.0,8.0,14.2058754855,14.2094457539,14.2007434187,14.2405608806,14.2061343745,14.2074415199,3.5043586724,14.9354529903,7.2614364738,5.90887763767,6.9964713401,7.82915908454,9.54056880037,9.99957323819,9.54304881251,10.9600655747,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:WP_parameter rbalance,A3a4yZzv,3.5043586724,Valid,A3Zyvz4a,3.5043586724,Valid,a4zvyZ3A,75.1867367214,Valid,A3avyzZ4,3.5043586724,Valid,39.3455476969 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:almost_rbtree_rbtree_black,Valid,0.119710727156,Valid,0.122110351172,Valid,0.0982912806304,Valid,0.107684762667,Valid,0.0959112048136,Timeout,10.0735046042,Timeout,10.0912903776,0.0,0.0,2.428571,0.0,5.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,almost_rbtree_rbtree_black,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,12.0,7.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,18.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,10.0,Failure,2.9596363984,0.0,2.0,14.2068343231,14.1942063889,0.0982912806304,0.107684762667,0.0959112048136,10.4287797757,0.122110351172,0.119710727156,6.83164662042,6.0161624537,6.71466989193,5.61476379363,8.26136352264,7.84886423041,7.12378688589,9.5140817541,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:almost_rbtree_rbtree_black,4A3aZzyv,0.107684762667,Valid,y34aAvzZ,0.0959112048136,Valid,ZzvAa43y,23.2465417314,Valid,4Zyz3Aav,0.107684762667,Valid,3.96281356199 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:bst_Leaf,Valid,0.106501806333,Valid,0.11402353063,Valid,0.0908611275,Valid,0.102438812721,Valid,0.0868004716757,Valid,0.107811930667,Valid,0.104633971789,0.0,0.0,0.5,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,0.0,2.0,bst_Leaf,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,0.0,Valid,0.0843336017541,0.0,1.0,0.104633971789,0.107811930667,0.0908611275,0.102438812721,0.0868004716757,0.0843336017541,0.11402353063,0.106501806333,3.98471326109,3.85657708103,1.20041652256,2.17600249577,2.58957454551,1.63109173773,0.902993447475,2.27454833098,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:bst_Leaf,Z3z4vyAa,0.104633971789,Valid,vy34ZazA,0.0843336017541,Valid,AzaZ43yv,0.11402353063,Valid,3Zzv4yAa,0.0908611275,Valid,0.0996756566337 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:bst_color,Valid,0.117081970459,Valid,0.12060510482,Valid,0.0920429845238,Valid,0.10319012221,Valid,0.0852695647568,Valid,0.0974755984898,Valid,0.10539901346,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,4.0,bst_color,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,16.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,10.0,Valid,0.0855142972203,0.0,0.0,0.10539901346,0.0974755984898,0.0920429845238,0.10319012221,0.0852695647568,0.0855142972203,0.12060510482,0.117081970459,4.26229844845,4.02025790044,9.5037633915,9.77481274292,11.7485790922,6.8461957476,6.92429493486,6.85505438389,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:bst_color,AazvZ34y,0.12060510482,Valid,yv3z4ZaA,0.0852695647568,Valid,AaZ4z3vy,0.12060510482,Valid,AavZz34y,0.12060510482,Valid,0.100822331992 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:bst_left,Valid,0.110594612,Valid,0.111635065737,Valid,0.0899659762222,Valid,0.101592532538,Valid,0.08625717395,Valid,0.09834886002,Valid,0.10344958441,0.0,0.0,2.5,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,bst_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,11.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.0824566885,0.0,0.0,0.10344958441,0.09834886002,0.0899659762222,0.101592532538,0.08625717395,0.0824566885,0.111635065737,0.110594612,5.63383666826,5.13141636666,5.23488391668,6.56800600284,7.41945685488,6.29703999003,6.18860870923,7.96791493309,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:bst_left,A3aZz4yv,0.111635065737,Valid,vy3z4ZaA,0.0824566885,Valid,AaZ4z3yv,0.111635065737,Valid,a3AyzZv4,0.110594612,Valid,0.0980375616722 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:bst_right,Valid,0.113160807757,Valid,0.114937671569,Valid,0.08941456755,Valid,0.100341483063,Valid,0.0882970336296,Valid,0.106731175286,Valid,0.105451639079,0.0,0.0,2.5,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,bst_right,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,11.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.081465142831,0.0,0.0,0.105451639079,0.106731175286,0.08941456755,0.100341483063,0.0882970336296,0.081465142831,0.114937671569,0.113160807757,5.63383666826,5.13141636666,5.23488391668,6.56800600284,7.41945685488,6.29703999003,6.18860870923,7.96791493309,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:bst_right,A3aZz4yv,0.114937671569,Valid,vy34ZzaA,0.081465142831,Valid,AazZ43yv,0.114937671569,Valid,a3AyzZv4,0.113160807757,Valid,0.0999749400956 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_leaf,Valid,0.0984659987317,Valid,0.107225072184,Valid,0.0818270559077,Valid,0.0958529443067,Unknown,0.0793294809079,Valid,0.0966295436905,Valid,0.10060960876,0.0,0.0,1.5,0.0,3.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,gt_leaf,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,1.0,Valid,0.0840296857143,0.0,1.0,0.10060960876,0.0966295436905,0.0818270559077,0.0958529443067,10.0793294809,0.0840296857143,0.107225072184,0.0984659987317,7.63824087499,6.99318961166,5.85378513331,6.64599355413,8.29313127876,8.5429707566,7.0110132482,7.98508600604,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_leaf,34AZavyz,0.0818270559077,Valid,3v4zaZAy,0.0818270559077,Valid,yAZaz4v3,0.186554553092,Valid,Aa3zZ4vy,0.107225072184,Valid,0.104864743584 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_left,Unknown,0.988541391,Unknown,0.260590796922,Valid,0.08897355337,Unknown,0.162431225,Unknown,0.08169920014,Valid,0.0967293355667,Valid,0.10003458675,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,gt_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,8.0,Failure,2.7924537854,0.0,0.0,0.10003458675,0.0967293355667,0.08897355337,10.162431225,10.0816992001,10.3825718463,10.2605907969,10.988541391,4.15804595168,4.05008375455,8.89617694111,9.52593471936,11.2819680735,6.71627459258,6.84615703089,6.75073939747,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_left,AazvZ34y,1.34586152349,Valid,3zZy4Ava,0.08897355337,Valid,avA4yZz3,4.38575098521,Valid,a3AyzZv4,1.07751494437,Valid,1.16667492484 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_node_gt,Unknown,1.0194041128,Unknown,0.253188972081,Unknown,0.8784678722,Unknown,0.14842099099,Unknown,0.0861065317353,Valid,0.0979244099596,Valid,0.102952750917,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,gt_node_gt,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,8.0,Failure,2.8032427146,0.0,0.0,0.102952750917,0.0979244099596,10.8784678722,10.148420991,10.0861065317,10.3854787909,10.2531889721,11.0194041128,4.15804595168,4.05008375455,8.89617694111,9.52593471936,11.2819680735,6.71627459258,6.84615703089,6.75073939747,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_node_gt,AazvZ34y,1.37051749484,Valid,zZy4Av3a,0.0979244099596,Valid,a3vA4yZz,5.29178394532,Valid,a3AyzZv4,2.33509189878,Valid,1.83004897857 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_right,Unknown,1.0041695462,Unknown,0.25342003462,Valid,0.0909498944364,Unknown,0.16667881776,Unknown,0.08332281568,Valid,0.0991468469231,Valid,0.0999130748148,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,gt_right,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,8.0,Failure,2.7779235214,0.0,0.0,0.0999130748148,0.0991468469231,0.0909498944364,10.1666788178,10.0833228157,10.3786732818,10.2534200346,11.0041695462,4.15804595168,4.05008375455,8.89617694111,9.52593471936,11.2819680735,6.71627459258,6.84615703089,6.75073939747,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_right,AazvZ34y,1.35673642774,Valid,3zZy4Ava,0.0909498944364,Valid,avA4yZz3,4.38542781047,Valid,a3AyzZv4,1.09511944064,Valid,1.16804862264 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_tree_node,Valid,0.107570951855,Valid,0.109727189982,Valid,0.08978175092,Valid,0.102268679833,Unknown,0.08394452625,Valid,0.09999239246,Valid,0.103485566952,0.0,0.0,2.5,0.0,7.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,gt_tree_node,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,12.0,8.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,21.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,12.0,Failure,2.8281772536,0.0,0.0,0.103485566952,0.09999239246,0.08978175092,0.102268679833,10.0839445263,10.3922368419,0.109727189982,0.107570951855,6.03130178073,5.23784955181,6.89274110348,7.27096868526,8.11146994659,7.4877070679,6.80673918245,9.05725417187,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_tree_node,AaZ34zyv,0.109727189982,Valid,3z4ZaAyv,0.08978175092,Valid,vyAaZ4z3,3.02184896983,Valid,Aa3yzZ4v,0.109727189982,Valid,0.518155152455 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_tree_not_in,Valid,0.109201305543,Valid,0.111374882443,Valid,0.0872568855,Valid,0.104130847933,Valid,0.08560066549,Valid,0.097734404567,Valid,0.10178585559,0.0,0.0,2.5,0.0,6.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,2.0,gt_tree_not_in,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,11.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,5.0,Valid,0.082846484625,0.0,0.0,0.10178585559,0.097734404567,0.0872568855,0.104130847933,0.08560066549,0.082846484625,0.111374882443,0.109201305543,7.22393691558,6.60782492533,6.4795642446,7.15261818787,8.06101506242,7.05352753834,6.8117644738,8.62732362692,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_tree_not_in,3AZz4ayv,0.0872568855,Valid,vy3zZ4aA,0.082846484625,Valid,Aa4Zz3yv,0.111374882443,Valid,4Zzv3Aay,0.104130847933,Valid,0.0974914164614 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_tree_trans,Valid,0.107747706739,Valid,0.108765678622,Valid,0.09161972296,Valid,0.103670973476,Unknown,0.085124592481,Valid,0.0956315683333,Valid,0.0996570750333,0.0,0.0,2.4,0.0,6.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,3.0,gt_tree_trans,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,5.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.0853698600667,0.0,0.0,0.0996570750333,0.0956315683333,0.09161972296,0.103670973476,10.0851245925,0.0853698600667,0.108765678622,0.107747706739,3.65662383511,3.04860831214,2.40598009298,2.91473670257,4.34830361546,3.82472093827,2.73340271921,4.41661892151,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:gt_tree_trans,3Z4Aazyv,0.09161972296,Valid,v3zZ4aAy,0.0853698600667,Valid,yAa4Zz3v,0.193890271103,Valid,4Z3vyzAa,0.103670973476,Valid,0.109563800522 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_leaf,Valid,0.103412766175,Valid,0.104111525111,Valid,0.08340721688,Valid,0.0973961858592,Unknown,0.0798077149831,Valid,0.0955879608824,Valid,0.0967036774615,0.0,0.0,1.5,0.0,3.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,lt_leaf,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,1.0,Valid,0.08066241525,0.0,1.0,0.0967036774615,0.0955879608824,0.08340721688,0.0973961858592,10.079807715,0.08066241525,0.104111525111,0.103412766175,7.63824087499,6.99318961166,5.85378513331,6.64599355413,8.29313127876,8.5429707566,7.0110132482,7.98508600604,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_leaf,34AZavyz,0.08340721688,Valid,v3zZ4aAy,0.08066241525,Valid,yAa4Zz3v,0.183919240094,Valid,Aa3zZ4vy,0.104111525111,Valid,0.104444785461 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_left,Unknown,1.02289266,Unknown,0.259995004818,Valid,0.0859464340606,Unknown,0.164805142829,Unknown,0.0808834670833,Valid,0.0937625297143,Valid,0.10082191206,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,lt_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,8.0,Failure,2.9043834254,0.0,0.0,0.10082191206,0.0937625297143,0.0859464340606,10.1648051428,10.0808834671,10.4132340357,10.2599950048,11.02289266,4.15804595168,4.05008375455,8.89617694111,9.52593471936,11.2819680735,6.71627459258,6.84615703089,6.75073939747,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_left,AazvZ34y,1.37665019453,Valid,3zZy4Ava,0.0859464340606,Valid,avA4yZz3,4.53378161219,Valid,a3AyzZv4,1.10883909406,Valid,1.20175021698 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_node_lt,Unknown,1.01139105535,Unknown,0.255045653062,Unknown,0.863698147692,Unknown,0.14270229685,Unknown,0.0839015357895,Valid,0.0953259937879,Valid,0.10267652984,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,lt_node_lt,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,8.0,Failure,2.8056198932,0.0,0.0,0.10267652984,0.0953259937879,10.8636981477,10.1427022969,10.0839015358,10.3861206899,10.2550456531,11.0113910553,4.15804595168,4.05008375455,8.89617694111,9.52593471936,11.2819680735,6.71627459258,6.84615703089,6.75073939747,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_node_lt,AazvZ34y,1.3617627022,Valid,zZy4Av3a,0.0953259937879,Valid,a3vA4yZz,5.26503511178,Valid,a3AyzZv4,2.30936238568,Valid,1.8197874558 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_right,Unknown,0.991123247714,Unknown,0.248952829778,Valid,0.0917924818049,Unknown,0.162806089258,Unknown,0.0803891864857,Valid,0.095871350451,Valid,0.102384571453,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,lt_right,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,4.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,8.0,Failure,2.7806219248,0.0,0.0,0.102384571453,0.095871350451,0.0917924818049,10.1628060893,10.0803891865,10.3793958537,10.2489528298,10.9911232477,4.15804595168,4.05008375455,8.89617694111,9.52593471936,11.2819680735,6.71627459258,6.84615703089,6.75073939747,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_right,AazvZ34y,1.33594742794,Valid,3zZy4Ava,0.0917924818049,Valid,avA4yZz3,4.36627784949,Valid,a3AyzZv4,1.08291572952,Valid,1.16265612075 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_tree_node,Valid,0.107120568182,Valid,0.1093270131,Valid,0.0888432938788,Valid,0.0958873242353,Unknown,0.0834695501918,Valid,0.10096706431,Valid,0.0999873499375,0.0,0.0,2.5,0.0,7.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,lt_tree_node,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,12.0,8.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,21.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,12.0,Failure,2.86752491227,0.0,0.0,0.0999873499375,0.10096706431,0.0888432938788,0.0958873242353,10.0834695502,10.4030139442,0.1093270131,0.107120568182,6.03130178073,5.23784955181,6.89274110348,7.27096868526,8.11146994659,7.4877070679,6.80673918245,9.05725417187,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_tree_node,AaZ34zyv,0.1093270131,Valid,34ZzaAyv,0.0888432938788,Valid,vyAazZ43,3.06032147556,Valid,Aa3yzZ4v,0.1093270131,Valid,0.521926073102 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_tree_not_in,Valid,0.105600848367,Valid,0.10878972875,Valid,0.08813129979,Valid,0.10436098909,Valid,0.0826749825362,Valid,0.101841708481,Valid,0.104313897957,0.0,0.0,2.5,0.0,6.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,2.0,lt_tree_not_in,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,5.0,4.0,0.0,2.0,1.0,0.0,11.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,5.0,Valid,0.0823445158036,0.0,0.0,0.104313897957,0.101841708481,0.08813129979,0.10436098909,0.0826749825362,0.0823445158036,0.10878972875,0.105600848367,7.22393691558,6.60782492533,6.4795642446,7.15261818787,8.06101506242,7.05352753834,6.8117644738,8.62732362692,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_tree_not_in,3AZz4ayv,0.08813129979,Valid,vy3zZ4aA,0.0823445158036,Valid,Aa4Zz3yv,0.10878972875,Valid,4Zzv3Aay,0.10436098909,Valid,0.0972572463468 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_tree_trans,Valid,0.107961806442,Valid,0.10948521305,Valid,0.08843122154,Valid,0.10095338568,Unknown,0.08134938293,Valid,0.103145554933,Valid,0.101987655093,0.0,0.0,2.4,0.0,6.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,3.0,lt_tree_trans,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,6.0,5.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.0812297533,0.0,0.0,0.101987655093,0.103145554933,0.08843122154,0.10095338568,10.0813493829,0.0812297533,0.10948521305,0.107961806442,3.65662383511,3.04860831214,2.40598009298,2.91473670257,4.34830361546,3.82472093827,2.73340271921,4.41661892151,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:lt_tree_trans,3Z4Aazyv,0.08843122154,Valid,v34ZzaAy,0.0812297533,Valid,yAazZ43v,0.19083459598,Valid,4Z3vyzAa,0.10095338568,Valid,0.109196471443 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:memt_color,Valid,0.106006897,Valid,0.102160011143,Valid,0.0804681043247,Valid,0.0912901348571,Valid,0.067275556,Valid,0.0941973251864,Valid,0.0936645023433,0.0,0.0,3.8,0.0,5.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,4.0,memt_color,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,14.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,20.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,14.0,Valid,3.9072400896,0.0,0.0,0.0936645023433,0.0941973251864,0.0804681043247,0.0912901348571,0.067275556,3.9072400896,0.102160011143,0.106006897,3.79991638754,3.6636861502,9.53845762132,9.6156420218,11.4711593897,6.44157897809,6.44340025568,6.55335807847,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:memt_color,AazZv34y,0.102160011143,Valid,y34ZzAav,0.067275556,Valid,vaAzZ43y,3.9072400896,Valid,AavZz34y,0.102160011143,Valid,0.567787827557 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_Leaf,Valid,0.116330056,Valid,0.11796891403,Valid,0.0916187672727,Valid,0.103547963042,Unknown,0.09021496039,Valid,0.098198801129,Valid,0.105196440487,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,0.0,2.0,rbtree_Leaf,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,0.0,Valid,0.0868344689818,0.0,1.0,0.105196440487,0.098198801129,0.0916187672727,0.103547963042,10.0902149604,0.0868344689818,0.11796891403,0.116330056,3.57902074699,3.49475505106,0.842222691885,1.81088167674,2.51499742456,1.62406917546,0.72205683347,2.12824615651,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_Leaf,Z3z4vyAa,0.105196440487,Valid,v3z4ZaAy,0.0868344689818,Valid,yAaZ4z3v,0.20818387442,Valid,3Zzv4yAa,0.0916187672727,Valid,0.114090500183 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_Node1,Valid,0.119419963182,Valid,0.1235252574,Valid,0.0953376180143,Valid,0.10643732421,Valid,0.0875457428784,Valid,0.0998633047766,Valid,0.100866016318,0.0,0.0,1.6,0.0,4.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,5.0,rbtree_Node1,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,6.0,5.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,9.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,2.0,Valid,0.0933765407143,0.0,3.0,0.100866016318,0.0998633047766,0.0953376180143,0.10643732421,0.0875457428784,0.0933765407143,0.1235252574,0.119419963182,9.9119007599,8.87940851095,7.54449504749,1.46292214251,8.59820502027,9.92376276012,4.25091404141,7.96603029359,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_Node1,4Z3vyAaz,0.10643732421,Valid,yv3zZ4aA,0.0875457428784,Valid,Aa4Zz3vy,0.1235252574,Valid,A3av4Zzy,0.1235252574,Valid,0.103296470937 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_almost_rbtree,Valid,0.127112596597,Valid,0.124226909733,Failure,5.7087314348,Valid,0.1090143135,Timeout,10.0846166398,Valid,0.162655820176,Valid,0.168080023662,0.0,0.0,2.333333,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,rbtree_almost_rbtree,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,4.0,Unknown,0.426444070806,0.0,0.0,0.168080023662,0.162655820176,11.5147563845,0.1090143135,14.2020946614,10.4264440708,0.124226909733,0.127112596597,8.66557932035,7.9073653866,6.99909627469,5.94531675514,7.88167187308,7.70764290658,6.54190523814,8.58251616093,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_almost_rbtree,4Z3zyAva,0.1090143135,Valid,4AazZv3y,0.1090143135,Valid,y3vZzaA4,16.3878721691,Valid,a3AyzZv4,0.127112596597,Valid,2.84151662363 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_almost_rbtree_ex,Valid,0.115775770476,Valid,0.120816033269,Valid,0.0976702899,Valid,0.112426546521,Valid,0.0892578073721,Valid,0.100886493971,Valid,0.105854738,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,5.0,3.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,rbtree_almost_rbtree_ex,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,4.0,Valid,0.08856668866,0.0,0.0,0.105854738,0.100886493971,0.0976702899,0.112426546521,0.0892578073721,0.08856668866,0.120816033269,0.115775770476,5.98455397811,5.7085150649,8.93262037107,9.2357393272,10.6429113888,7.2729991323,7.34679079946,7.58173502873,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_almost_rbtree_ex,AazZv34y,0.120816033269,Valid,vy3zZ4aA,0.08856668866,Valid,Aa4Zz3yv,0.120816033269,Valid,a3AyzZv4,0.115775770476,Valid,0.103906796021 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_left,Valid,0.121133618423,Valid,0.12380201275,Timeout,10.07319123,Valid,0.114861172947,Timeout,10.0754178892,Timeout,10.08580304,Timeout,10.0796556288,0.0,0.0,3.5,0.0,6.0,4.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,rbtree_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,4.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,15.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,8.0,Failure,2.786926151,0.0,0.0,14.1985723788,14.2029371245,14.1939839917,0.114861172947,14.1955642946,10.3810865217,0.12380201275,0.121133618423,4.68161460828,4.38827561437,9.63522964777,9.78193732718,11.6884900229,7.30033540204,7.27126094195,7.27494929171,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_left,AaZvz34y,0.12380201275,Valid,4aAv3yZz,0.114861172947,Valid,zZy3vAa4,43.2247959517,Valid,AavZz34y,0.12380201275,Valid,10.8951807528 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_right,Valid,0.123490990507,Valid,0.120451007855,Timeout,10.0696396214,Valid,0.117606697159,Timeout,10.0693897678,Timeout,10.090103836,Timeout,10.0822761904,0.0,0.0,3.5,0.0,6.0,4.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,3.0,rbtree_right,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,4.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,15.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,8.0,Failure,2.798291855,0.0,0.0,14.2004328518,14.2059915325,14.1914637055,0.117606697159,14.1912864215,10.3841435519,0.120451007855,0.123490990507,4.68161460828,4.38827561437,9.63522964777,9.78193732718,11.6884900229,7.30033540204,7.27126094195,7.27494929171,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rbtree_right,AaZvz34y,0.120451007855,Valid,4Aavy3Zz,0.117606697159,Valid,zZ3yvaA4,43.2331922611,Valid,AavZz34y,0.120451007855,Valid,10.8979415495 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rotate_left,Valid,0.204405216375,Valid,0.14929963973,Valid,0.0978409310909,Valid,0.126267987184,Valid,0.0875716033034,Valid,0.102996496348,Valid,0.0917279684,0.0,0.0,3.571429,0.0,6.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,rotate_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,18.0,7.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,26.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,18.0,Valid,0.0881468797027,0.0,0.0,0.0917279684,0.102996496348,0.0978409310909,0.126267987184,0.0875716033034,0.0881468797027,0.14929963973,0.204405216375,5.37661487463,5.12273319211,9.8530481108,9.18566640569,11.0423368783,7.79049501278,7.42240863585,8.47197623832,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rotate_left,AaZzv43y,0.14929963973,Valid,yvZ3z4Aa,0.0875716033034,Valid,aA4z3Zvy,0.204405216375,Valid,4Zyz3Aav,0.126267987184,Valid,0.118532090267 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rotate_right,Valid,0.22665522371,Valid,0.1607991761,Valid,0.1007365174,Valid,0.110707296444,Valid,0.08802324331,Valid,0.105198669638,Valid,0.10388383242,0.0,0.0,3.571429,0.0,6.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,rotate_right,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,18.0,7.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,26.0,RedBlackTree,0.0,18.0,Valid,0.0883850584198,0.0,0.0,0.10388383242,0.105198669638,0.1007365174,0.110707296444,0.08802324331,0.0883850584198,0.1607991761,0.22665522371,5.37661487463,5.12273319211,9.8530481108,9.18566640569,11.0423368783,7.79049501278,7.42240863585,8.47197623832,vacid_0_red_black_trees:RedBlackTree:rotate_right,AaZzv43y,0.1607991761,Valid,yv3Zz4Aa,0.08802324331,Valid,aA4zZ3vy,0.22665522371,Valid,4Zyz3Aav,0.110707296444,Valid,0.12304862718 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:Vacid0:WP_parameter create,Valid,0.122953168929,Valid,0.12497318599,Valid,0.11269474448,Valid,0.14383009303,Timeout,10.0836746874,Valid,0.123098704451,Valid,0.128285201423,1.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,7.0,8.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,2.0,7.0,WP_parameter create,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,9.0,1.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,17.0,Vacid0,0.0,6.0,Valid,0.0967818298444,0.0,2.0,0.128285201423,0.123098704451,0.11269474448,0.14383009303,14.2014258158,0.0967818298444,0.12497318599,0.122953168929,7.1507368887,6.56448526131,7.72992048622,4.21583183163,8.59401356839,8.6356194756,7.0273921058,10.0509604854,vacid_0_red_black_trees:Vacid0:WP_parameter create,4AZa3yzv,0.14383009303,Valid,v3azAZ4y,0.0967818298444,Valid,y4ZAza3v,10.2275047804,Valid,4za3AZyv,0.14383009303,Valid,1.38226175423 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:Vacid0:WP_parameter lookup,Valid,0.122454990581,Valid,0.125584507947,Valid,0.108959603958,Valid,0.13955391283,Timeout,10.0851380212,Valid,0.120178305286,Valid,0.129823147538,2.0,0.0,2.266667,0.0,9.0,15.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,3.0,9.0,WP_parameter lookup,0.0,0.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,17.0,15.0,0.0,3.0,1.0,0.0,35.0,Vacid0,0.0,17.0,Valid,0.0975722009583,0.0,0.0,0.129823147538,0.120178305286,0.108959603958,0.13955391283,14.2024648884,0.0975722009583,0.125584507947,0.122454990581,7.208169822,6.31165317191,7.26513103722,6.10375544523,7.92988744997,8.05908318605,7.12853820633,8.41336942817,vacid_0_red_black_trees:Vacid0:WP_parameter lookup,4AZa3yzv,0.13955391283,Valid,v3zaAZ4y,0.0975722009583,Valid,y4ZAaz3v,10.224691934,Valid,43vAayZz,0.13955391283,Valid,1.38123177681 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:Vacid0:WP_parameter remove,Valid,0.135615856755,Valid,0.130471600583,Valid,0.10945692005,Valid,0.139246959986,Valid,0.0938368346,Valid,0.133960470875,Valid,0.130006216632,5.0,0.0,2.482759,0.0,13.0,29.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,4.0,22.0,WP_parameter remove,2.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,36.0,33.0,4.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,73.0,Vacid0,0.0,36.0,Valid,0.0950824501455,0.0,0.0,0.130006216632,0.133960470875,0.10945692005,0.139246959986,0.0938368346,0.0950824501455,0.130471600583,0.135615856755,6.49548772128,5.40995990162,5.72098167581,5.70284884828,7.68384186489,8.5674845815,7.31238136868,9.4657791845,vacid_0_red_black_trees:Vacid0:WP_parameter remove,A43aZyzv,0.130471600583,Valid,yv3ZAza4,0.0938368346,Valid,4azAZ3vy,0.139246959986,Valid,A3avyzZ4,0.130471600583,Valid,0.120959663703 +vacid_0_red_black_trees:Vacid0:WP_parameter replace,Valid,0.19639450839,Valid,0.138537524657,Valid,0.14975571149,Valid,0.175338164973,Timeout,10.093359027,Valid,0.130013642571,Valid,0.13415981819,8.0,0.0,2.545455,0.0,15.0,33.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,vacid_0_red_black_trees.mlw,0.0,5.0,22.0,WP_parameter replace,2.0,2.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,41.0,37.0,4.0,7.0,0.0,0.0,85.0,Vacid0,0.0,41.0,Valid,0.101044367255,0.0,0.0,0.13415981819,0.130013642571,0.14975571149,0.175338164973,14.208303785,0.101044367255,0.138537524657,0.19639450839,7.38229933755,5.80206236275,6.12702997385,6.70251591822,8.98830612191,8.98242423378,7.86892434608,10.2550211139,vacid_0_red_black_trees:Vacid0:WP_parameter replace,A34aZzyv,0.138537524657,Valid,vzZA34ay,0.101044367255,Valid,ya43AZzv,10.2897535354,Valid,A3avyzZ4,0.138537524657,Valid,1.40813326945 +verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Memory:WP_parameter get_data,Valid,0.114788422167,Valid,0.116011263917,Valid,0.0924660799737,Valid,0.11348989181,Valid,0.0755640608,Valid,0.098971932,Valid,0.1207186977,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,verifythis_fm2012_treedel.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter get_data,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,Memory,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.0872641498219,0.0,0.0,0.1207186977,0.098971932,0.0924660799737,0.11348989181,0.0755640608,0.0872641498219,0.116011263917,0.114788422167,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Memory:WP_parameter get_data,3aAvyzZ4,0.0924660799737,Valid,yv3z4aAZ,0.0755640608,Valid,ZAa4z3vy,0.1207186977,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.0872641498219,Valid,0.102409312274 +verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Memory:WP_parameter get_left,Valid,0.11196616231,Valid,0.114543185704,Valid,0.09030983318,Valid,0.110778724695,Valid,0.0902228465,Valid,0.110537821304,Valid,0.11695462267,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,verifythis_fm2012_treedel.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter get_left,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,Memory,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.0864933738736,0.0,0.0,0.11695462267,0.110537821304,0.09030983318,0.110778724695,0.0902228465,0.0864933738736,0.114543185704,0.11196616231,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Memory:WP_parameter get_left,3aAvyzZ4,0.09030983318,Valid,vy3z4aAZ,0.0864933738736,Valid,ZAa4z3yv,0.11695462267,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.0864933738736,Valid,0.10397582128 +verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Memory:WP_parameter get_right,Valid,0.113763686882,Valid,0.116575489,Valid,0.09186664837,Valid,0.11214824033,Valid,0.08828264906,Valid,0.11244775215,Valid,0.116559146083,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,verifythis_fm2012_treedel.mlw,0.0,0.0,0.0,WP_parameter get_right,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0,Memory,1.0,0.0,Valid,0.0881143215238,0.0,0.0,0.116559146083,0.11244775215,0.09186664837,0.11214824033,0.08828264906,0.0881143215238,0.116575489,0.113763686882,0.126135026715,0.126706085306,0.102087500712,0.31247327408,0.240163335441,0.30766015884,0.30919704211,0.22983285944,verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Memory:WP_parameter get_right,3aAvyzZ4,0.09186664837,Valid,vy34zaZA,0.0881143215238,Valid,AZaz43yv,0.116575489,Valid,vy3zZa4A,0.0881143215238,Valid,0.104969741675 +verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:WP_parameter search_tree_delete_min,Timeout,11.1101515676,Valid,6.623894169,Timeout,10.1108869136,Timeout,11.1446081498,Unknown,4.1629453438,Timeout,10.1557051816,Timeout,10.1681425788,40.0,0.0,1.802419,10.0,45.0,248.0,0.0,0.0,10.0,verifythis_fm2012_treedel.mlw,0.0,19.0,162.0,WP_parameter search_tree_delete_min,2.0,0.0,18.0,0.0,5.0,234.0,260.0,12.0,19.0,22.0,1.0,478.0,Treedel,0.0,175.0,Timeout,10.1444105762,14.0,35.0,14.2615259879,14.2526610756,14.2207606751,14.9733860837,14.1629453438,14.2446153314,6.623894169,14.9477579541,13.1047936933,9.89532073751,11.9475125289,13.0869465666,12.8902140025,11.8325148768,12.0965153773,12.9766782763,verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:WP_parameter search_tree_delete_min,Az3Zyv4a,6.623894169,Valid,Ay3vzZa4,6.623894169,Valid,4aZzv3yA,73.6207444804,Valid,zvy3AZ4a,41.1978421842,Valid,40.1223193247 +verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:WP_parameter tree_left,Valid,0.129340811471,Valid,0.133091650655,Valid,0.137243920895,Valid,0.161206741875,Valid,0.112495222,Valid,0.142463336308,Valid,0.14941422876,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,6.0,9.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,verifythis_fm2012_treedel.mlw,0.0,1.0,7.0,WP_parameter tree_left,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,16.0,11.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,25.0,Treedel,0.0,7.0,Timeout,10.104443323,4.0,3.0,0.14941422876,0.142463336308,0.137243920895,0.161206741875,0.112495222,14.2161800378,0.133091650655,0.129340811471,2.63895645603,2.02010705137,3.21043109877,3.49154726776,3.88727033892,7.98158544818,7.9367629461,11.8684050997,verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:WP_parameter tree_left,Aa34yZzv,0.133091650655,Valid,yaA3zZ4v,0.112495222,Valid,v4Zz3Aay,10.2656500649,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,0.112495222,Valid,1.40094911708 +verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:WP_parameter tree_right,Valid,0.131257106637,Valid,0.13542722244,Valid,0.128228923316,Valid,0.159362950389,Valid,0.126513077073,Valid,0.141792128326,Valid,0.146849801364,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,6.0,9.0,0.0,0.0,2.0,verifythis_fm2012_treedel.mlw,0.0,1.0,7.0,WP_parameter tree_right,0.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,16.0,11.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,25.0,Treedel,0.0,7.0,Timeout,10.0981471726,4.0,3.0,0.146849801364,0.141792128326,0.128228923316,0.159362950389,0.126513077073,14.2117056091,0.13542722244,0.131257106637,2.63895645603,2.02010705137,3.21043109877,3.49154726776,3.88727033892,7.98158544818,7.9367629461,11.8684050997,verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:WP_parameter tree_right,Aa34yZzv,0.13542722244,Valid,y3aAzZ4v,0.126513077073,Valid,v4ZzAa3y,10.257510123,Valid,y3Aa4zZv,0.126513077073,Valid,1.40075856937 +verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:inorder_zip,Unknown,0.290226140167,Timeout,10.12594806,Timeout,10.1089685784,Timeout,10.190118209,Timeout,9.6513058068,Timeout,10.1268067746,Timeout,10.1293775284,0.0,0.0,1.888889,0.0,7.0,9.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,verifythis_fm2012_treedel.mlw,0.0,1.0,9.0,inorder_zip,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.0,9.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,18.0,Treedel,0.0,8.0,Timeout,10.1101308004,0.0,0.0,14.233913345,14.2320840164,14.2193968128,14.277202426,13.897758948,14.2202230925,14.2314730128,10.2902261402,9.5377564349,8.94527344719,9.03158381546,3.29171127859,9.39614654875,8.92550307639,7.21358605139,9.7119188662,verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:inorder_zip,4ZzA3yav,70.7328818978,Timeout,ay3vAzZ4,70.7328818978,Unknown,4ZzAv3ya,70.7328818978,Timeout,4za3AZyv,70.7328818978,Timeout,70.7328818978 +verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:main_lemma,Timeout,11.1196282856,Timeout,10.1243253856,Timeout,10.0914034388,Timeout,11.1201376624,Failure,3.664460491,Timeout,10.129105934,Timeout,10.133388801,0.0,0.0,2.045455,0.0,11.0,22.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,verifythis_fm2012_treedel.mlw,0.0,1.0,17.0,main_lemma,0.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,3.0,24.0,22.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,46.0,Treedel,0.0,23.0,Timeout,10.1110754444,0.0,1.0,14.2367681934,14.2337200697,14.2069146321,14.9551817652,10.650270921,14.2208947202,14.2303184966,14.9548030147,8.24562455389,7.67888988467,8.64064965068,7.4888030494,9.48096379669,9.68018900404,8.36003224278,10.1039428041,verifythis_fm2012_treedel:Treedel:main_lemma,4AaZ3yzv,76.4935254428,Timeout,y3vAzZa4,76.4935254428,Failure,4aZzAv3y,76.4935254428,Timeout,Aa3yzZ4v,76.4935254428,Timeout,76.4935254428 +vstte12_bfs:BFS:WP_parameter bfs,Timeout,11.0833166688,Timeout,10.1047963856,Timeout,10.0762430608,Timeout,11.1087803494,Timeout,10.1185606458,Timeout,10.1367938336,Timeout,10.139082088,21.0,0.0,2.316327,0.0,30.0,98.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vstte12_bfs.mlw,0.0,17.0,59.0,WP_parameter bfs,3.0,2.0,13.0,7.0,0.0,116.0,103.0,5.0,17.0,5.0,0.0,228.0,BFS,0.0,101.0,Timeout,10.0911461524,0.0,8.0,14.2408210995,14.2391920145,14.1961499788,14.9467388032,14.2262176822,14.2067318786,14.2164309865,14.9278232968,9.33010442967,7.76265712077,7.72323986939,9.34722372414,9.70972887835,9.10683265819,9.04831069382,11.2360517097,vstte12_bfs:BFS:WP_parameter bfs,3AZza4yv,82.8587191844,Timeout,3vAyzZa4,82.8587191844,Timeout,4aZzyAv3,82.8587191844,Timeout,3vy4zAZa,82.8587191844,Timeout,82.8587191844 +vstte12_bfs:BFS:WP_parameter fill_next,Timeout,11.0931603872,Timeout,10.11466656,Timeout,10.079095115,Timeout,10.176030429,Timeout,10.1454065304,Timeout,10.118795412,Timeout,10.1224641984,23.0,0.0,2.25,0.0,26.0,108.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vstte12_bfs.mlw,0.0,13.0,66.0,WP_parameter fill_next,2.0,1.0,11.0,2.0,0.0,122.0,111.0,3.0,13.0,8.0,0.0,244.0,BFS,0.0,118.0,Timeout,10.0949898274,0.0,2.0,14.2289943934,14.2263846634,14.198174472,14.2671509171,14.2453246248,14.2094623267,14.2234482324,14.935133323,9.30301896334,7.70094753823,8.56462273433,10.2220662766,9.70274314154,9.46595538339,9.43734842688,11.5594579844,vstte12_bfs:BFS:WP_parameter fill_next,A3aZzy4v,81.9446084594,Timeout,3vAzZy4a,81.9446084594,Timeout,a4yZzAv3,81.9446084594,Timeout,ZzA4y3av,81.9446084594,Timeout,81.9446084594 +vstte12_bfs:Graph:path_closure,Timeout,11.0980861158,Timeout,10.0959836762,Timeout,10.1034383098,Timeout,10.150089153,Unknown,3.3609992436,Timeout,10.1261215472,Timeout,10.118870787,0.0,0.0,2.333333,0.0,9.0,12.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vstte12_bfs.mlw,0.0,4.0,7.0,path_closure,0.0,0.0,5.0,0.0,0.0,13.0,12.0,0.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,29.0,Graph,0.0,13.0,Timeout,10.0680998998,0.0,0.0,14.2264382754,14.2315964526,14.2154657215,14.2486599305,13.3609992436,14.1903712281,14.2101684153,14.9387923017,7.97222374282,6.77987026393,8.4676853611,8.91226193142,9.74130332239,9.25850294873,8.89553778967,10.4984944731,vstte12_bfs:Graph:path_closure,Aa3Z4zyv,75.1216887324,Timeout,yvA3Zz4a,75.1216887324,Unknown,a4zZ3Avy,75.1216887324,Timeout,AaZz34yv,75.1216887324,Timeout,75.1216887324 +vstte12_bfs:Graph:path_inversion,Valid,0.10984001983,Valid,0.1134106225,Valid,0.0993892413043,Valid,0.126468826059,Valid,0.0944420190417,Valid,0.117600201983,Valid,0.1034516764,1.0,0.0,2.333333,0.0,8.0,9.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,vstte12_bfs.mlw,0.0,1.0,6.0,path_inversion,0.0,0.0,2.0,2.0,0.0,11.0,9.0,0.0,2.0,0.0,0.0,22.0,Graph,0.0,9.0,Valid,0.083655713587,0.0,0.0,0.1034516764,0.117600201983,0.0993892413043,0.126468826059,0.0944420190417,0.083655713587,0.1134106225,0.10984001983,3.89874369528,3.72009067755,4.49197399642,4.95478679026,7.56235876675,5.2715956878,4.98542263079,5.55349801323,vstte12_bfs:Graph:path_inversion,Aa34Zzvy,0.1134106225,Valid,vy3ZaAz4,0.083655713587,Valid,4zAaZ3yv,0.126468826059,Valid,aZv3Az4y,0.10984001983,Valid,0.106032290088 +vstte12_bfs:Graph:path_nonneg,Timeout,11.1091714104,Timeout,10.1068080946,Timeout,10.0716208396,Timeout,10.1191678164,Timeout,10.0895175152,Timeout,10.1050831826,Timeout,10.112806615,0.0,0.0,2.666667,0.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vstte12_bfs.mlw,0.0,1.0,2.0,path_nonneg,0.0,0.0,1.0,1.0,0.0,5.0,3.0,0.0,1.0,0.0,0.0,9.0,Graph,0.0,4.0,Timeout,10.0704211464,0.0,0.0,14.2221256369,14.2166348384,14.1928695596,14.2266495457,14.2055750918,14.192018252,14.2178609453,14.9470294516,6.57300771251,5.92320726565,6.2418051322,6.55807462524,7.60479871508,6.39047452099,6.06976963315,7.71957769381,vstte12_bfs:Graph:path_nonneg,AZ3z4ayv,81.7845966202,Timeout,v3yzAZ4a,81.7845966202,Timeout,a4ZAzy3v,81.7845966202,Timeout,a3AyzZv4,81.7845966202,Timeout,81.7845966202 +vstte12_two_way_sort:TwoWaySort:WP_parameter two_way_sort,Valid,0.194663445,Valid,0.1864383958,Unknown,2.1714795568,Timeout,10.1660252484,Timeout,10.1086456418,Valid,0.232844800222,Valid,0.2210551964,49.0,0.0,2.010811,0.0,29.0,185.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,vstte12_two_way_sort.mlw,0.0,17.0,115.0,WP_parameter two_way_sort,3.0,0.0,17.0,29.0,3.0,180.0,188.0,3.0,17.0,1.0,0.0,373.0,TwoWaySort,0.0,139.0,Valid,0.1825003948,0.0,12.0,0.2210551964,0.232844800222,12.1714795568,14.2600164569,14.2191672299,0.1825003948,0.1864383958,0.194663445,9.45601573942,6.31330101289,8.80869033108,9.82732081816,9.44801592372,7.73040158291,7.72139191954,11.4479890684,vstte12_two_way_sort:TwoWaySort:WP_parameter two_way_sort,AZz3ya4v,0.1864383958,Valid,vAaZz3y4,0.1825003948,Valid,4y3zZaAv,22.6789952472,Valid,4Avy3zZa,10.3524636442,Valid,3.94452552094 +zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros1,Valid,0.132046535143,Valid,0.1191238526,Valid,0.1036665692,Valid,0.137945093412,Valid,0.0997486422222,Valid,0.129819576933,Valid,0.126458112714,6.0,0.0,2.081633,0.0,20.0,49.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,zeros.mlw,0.0,4.0,33.0,WP_parameter all_zeros1,1.0,5.0,7.0,11.0,2.0,50.0,55.0,6.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,103.0,AllZeros,0.0,33.0,Valid,0.0908899624,0.0,6.0,0.126458112714,0.129819576933,0.1036665692,0.137945093412,0.0997486422222,0.0908899624,0.1191238526,0.132046535143,4.83273958245,3.97958766788,4.81803780639,7.28111194198,7.15553781952,5.08960588736,5.19075358702,7.27245897386,zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros1,A3azZyv4,0.1191238526,Valid,vy3AZza4,0.0908899624,Valid,4azZA3yv,0.137945093412,Valid,zZA3avy4,0.129819576933,Valid,0.117462293078 +zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros2,Valid,0.1181196478,Valid,0.129158921386,Valid,0.117878103207,Valid,0.146733133833,Valid,0.102477610763,Valid,0.126995427783,Valid,0.124284598333,11.0,0.0,2.12963,0.0,18.0,54.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,zeros.mlw,0.0,4.0,38.0,WP_parameter all_zeros2,3.0,4.0,4.0,11.0,1.0,58.0,61.0,7.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,116.0,AllZeros,0.0,40.0,Valid,0.104017606196,0.0,7.0,0.124284598333,0.126995427783,0.117878103207,0.146733133833,0.102477610763,0.104017606196,0.129158921386,0.1181196478,5.51693313849,4.45695802642,4.88681795652,6.70611567818,6.80770254533,5.37596077613,5.55110068601,7.76239778045,zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros2,A3zaZ4yv,0.129158921386,Valid,yv3aZzA4,0.102477610763,Valid,4AzZa3vy,0.146733133833,Valid,zZyAa34v,0.126995427783,Valid,0.121208131163 +zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros3,Valid,0.127887179536,Valid,0.130435855176,Valid,0.115851646364,Valid,0.1278889208,Valid,0.107237219162,Valid,0.121521054524,Valid,0.1213111695,11.0,0.0,2.309524,0.0,16.0,42.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,zeros.mlw,0.0,3.0,27.0,WP_parameter all_zeros3,2.0,2.0,3.0,11.0,1.0,49.0,46.0,4.0,3.0,0.0,0.0,98.0,AllZeros,0.0,38.0,Valid,0.0970997658947,0.0,0.0,0.1213111695,0.121521054524,0.115851646364,0.1278889208,0.107237219162,0.0970997658947,0.130435855176,0.127887179536,4.29983928396,3.3875052438,4.73766715715,6.61493982724,6.95726203955,4.56218567567,4.52566510462,6.42769960143,zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros3,AaZz3v4y,0.130435855176,Valid,vy3Zza4A,0.0970997658947,Valid,A4azZ3yv,0.130435855176,Valid,AaZz43vy,0.130435855176,Valid,0.11865410137 +zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros4,Valid,0.119447590172,Valid,0.123542600143,Valid,0.1058881784,Valid,0.14033066675,Valid,0.0972732388,Valid,0.127784583543,Valid,0.132093890143,13.0,0.0,2.160714,0.0,17.0,56.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,zeros.mlw,0.0,4.0,36.0,WP_parameter all_zeros4,2.0,4.0,4.0,11.0,2.0,60.0,62.0,6.0,4.0,1.0,0.0,122.0,AllZeros,0.0,45.0,Valid,0.0934960822,0.0,4.0,0.132093890143,0.127784583543,0.1058881784,0.14033066675,0.0972732388,0.0934960822,0.123542600143,0.119447590172,4.49848096046,3.5394669263,4.41773684932,6.87411250758,6.05388268185,4.49252064928,4.51109051682,7.07501177,zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros4,A3zaZy4v,0.123542600143,Valid,vy3aAzZ4,0.0934960822,Valid,4ZzAa3yv,0.14033066675,Valid,AaZz43vy,0.123542600143,Valid,0.117482103769 +zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros5,Valid,0.3713188676,Valid,0.198081250667,Unknown,0.2190246522,Timeout,10.1630544188,Valid,0.115002084268,Valid,0.138681354857,Valid,0.145005232184,18.0,0.0,2.209877,0.0,23.0,81.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,zeros.mlw,0.0,5.0,53.0,WP_parameter all_zeros5,3.0,5.0,5.0,14.0,3.0,92.0,89.0,8.0,5.0,2.0,0.0,180.0,AllZeros,0.0,72.0,Unknown,0.10714473075,0.0,6.0,0.145005232184,0.138681354857,10.2190246522,14.2578986923,0.115002084268,10.1071447308,0.198081250667,0.3713188676,7.09513425031,4.15905362012,5.93549424444,7.23152606613,8.32348615313,8.20964470401,8.14698827876,10.3248578612,zeros:AllZeros:WP_parameter all_zeros5,A3a4Zzyv,0.198081250667,Valid,yzZAav34,0.115002084268,Valid,43vaAZzy,10.8605426694,Valid,A43aZzyv,0.198081250667,Valid,1.94182172487 +zeros:SetZeros:WP_parameter harness,Valid,0.118819508038,Valid,0.1243398062,Valid,0.104439545526,Valid,0.1123340006,Valid,0.0985078535952,Valid,0.12087607287,Valid,0.119305629,7.0,0.0,2.153846,0.0,11.0,26.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,zeros.mlw,0.0,4.0,15.0,WP_parameter harness,0.0,0.0,4.0,13.0,0.0,27.0,26.0,0.0,4.0,0.0,0.0,57.0,SetZeros,0.0,14.0,Valid,0.0880008725652,0.0,0.0,0.119305629,0.12087607287,0.104439545526,0.1123340006,0.0985078535952,0.0880008725652,0.1243398062,0.118819508038,1.29336994051,1.02041761803,0.925356945198,1.37462885413,2.63575884229,1.10084766921,0.926847783706,2.43915449924,zeros:SetZeros:WP_parameter harness,3ZAza4vy,0.104439545526,Valid,vy34aZzA,0.0880008725652,Valid,AzZa43yv,0.1243398062,Valid,A3Zzay4v,0.1243398062,Valid,0.110827911049 +zeros:SetZeros:WP_parameter set_zeros,Valid,0.132412553231,Valid,0.127147406636,Valid,0.105834501963,Valid,0.126785648276,Valid,0.09757600034,Valid,0.1136772268,Valid,0.1218501005,15.0,0.0,2.161765,0.0,20.0,68.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,zeros.mlw,0.0,10.0,39.0,WP_parameter set_zeros,0.0,0.0,13.0,25.0,1.0,70.0,68.0,0.0,10.0,0.0,0.0,148.0,SetZeros,0.0,45.0,Unknown,1.6703615474,0.0,0.0,0.1218501005,0.1136772268,0.105834501963,0.126785648276,0.09757600034,11.6703615474,0.127147406636,0.132412553231,2.8673060841,2.51608811722,1.95605812132,2.51229727894,3.41348523411,1.58952684822,1.53315157479,5.82542814705,zeros:SetZeros:WP_parameter set_zeros,Zz34Aayv,0.1218501005,Valid,y3zZ4Aav,0.09757600034,Valid,vaA4Zz3y,1.80277410063,Valid,zZvA3ay4,0.1136772268,Valid,0.326692827389 diff --git a/feature_importances.txt b/feature_importances.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..51309f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/feature_importances.txt @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +func 0.199340 +avg_op_arity 0.105527 +int 0.086834 +and 0.058263 +forall 0.057446 +depth 0.054362 +impl 0.049848 +var 0.049775 +n_quants 0.046363 +size 0.046085 +let 0.039099 +n_branches 0.034041 +n_preds 0.031222 +zero_ar 0.029711 +n_ops 0.028913 +divisor 0.028435 +not 0.011819 +if 0.011468 +case 0.009691 +wild 0.009453 +false 0.003836 +iff 0.002916 +or 0.002823 +true 0.001222 +eps 0.000876 +exists 0.000370 +float 0.000261 +as 0.000000 +dtype: float64 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/forest.json b/forest.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..90ffe7b --- /dev/null +++ b/forest.json @@ -0,0 +1,147762 @@ +[ + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12857812278019354, + "veriT": 0.098913796460751602, + "Yices": 0.10111630834796453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12574243013758069, + "CVC4": 0.12583591224300003, + "CVC3": 0.10572763920200645, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12233789392022583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12263354771448388 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.75, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13983368543152727, + "veriT": 1.9168956765448641, + "Yices": 3.7640992922646004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17318907894469091, + "CVC4": 2.6832893865187555, + "CVC3": 0.10193931479526364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6808439680800578, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7086809088564414 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11377054884550769, + "veriT": 0.083928933309123085, + "Yices": 0.088579511729707683, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11158770164570769, + "CVC4": 0.10910102022686924, + "CVC3": 0.090980970275023068, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10702494434937693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10548874539786922 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0752134095813597, + "veriT": 9.8299919885274676, + "Yices": 10.0079840537212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.216100126845828, + "CVC4": 0.14850837159620003, + "CVC3": 1.5814295799326346, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14894626647396667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.235403985848498 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1964995357723, + "veriT": 9.1615652869966997, + "Yices": 10.464239804537199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34711059050549997, + "CVC4": 0.15232043194520001, + "CVC3": 0.28559596899070006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14988207760739999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0997760243300094 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.918010950088501, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 52.0, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7423438600269403, + "veriT": 10.758215776353239, + "Yices": 10.026815309788045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6592550802253037, + "CVC4": 11.669726536001845, + "CVC3": 9.7660910417297266, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.089289564510223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.089128716239143 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.789115478869682, + "veriT": 9.2554945865608644, + "Yices": 10.392826683439226, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.410002081985082, + "CVC4": 0.83525230916215343, + "CVC3": 12.102483440632836, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.666751270655586, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.418424820043267 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7916665077209473, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236179196528591, + "veriT": 10.150259421857701, + "Yices": 10.3215659704345, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955293963323665, + "CVC4": 0.15755799462960002, + "CVC3": 9.446451440344692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5005296758893443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.29071506841963 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.871747320415352, + "veriT": 10.528235038068258, + "Yices": 10.463909434929365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.520211267723049, + "CVC4": 1.5039061283803312, + "CVC3": 11.557639859073371, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4240682619593303, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.540305855771717 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.639638057399537, + "veriT": 10.729522324105387, + "Yices": 10.715661597424786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.253266426136536, + "CVC4": 3.6416426036901655, + "CVC3": 8.4757686208001033, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1911113260392661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.421244846577618 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.48388785707080001, + "veriT": 4.1881921195871996, + "Yices": 5.2834092978806, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9764170420692642, + "CVC4": 0.17545623652019998, + "CVC3": 0.60014000619850005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4807978950062353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.073139218744958 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.783645595781449, + "veriT": 12.486825588427804, + "Yices": 11.94061818582043, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.824932858765026, + "CVC4": 8.5722560000488528, + "CVC3": 12.379684038218489, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8357545352465223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.031005972171583 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7063894271850586, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.805720063398883, + "veriT": 12.851278466521862, + "Yices": 12.02060584476839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.418163062049805, + "CVC4": 11.571288530067802, + "CVC3": 14.787547231734136, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.087717521903331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.210567402014464 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2465306087704162, + "veriT": 11.792706192336462, + "Yices": 10.588017527608224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8450393260002018, + "CVC4": 2.5406352930653342, + "CVC3": 4.9325352096907933, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17333281701566663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6392268439319739 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9028766565339001, + "veriT": 11.181516793279485, + "Yices": 10.747188125853713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.955738524975027, + "CVC4": 7.3391642902212793, + "CVC3": 9.3553614825384273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4141812217833145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6907287013788359 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7714857449646342, + "veriT": 7.1583632843641567, + "Yices": 8.9606746312830126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2999294944545001, + "CVC4": 7.3868527375297601, + "CVC3": 1.2230378489620999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9990708582717431, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6521468476006955 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.514214769460162, + "veriT": 11.336361645046392, + "Yices": 10.897823111716857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.960516120367483, + "CVC4": 11.916125867683117, + "CVC3": 13.91316454380115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.245513083080146, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.760448706875858 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1760758161378186, + "veriT": 12.357167136407107, + "Yices": 0.59494668556663644, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3578238954378188, + "CVC4": 0.32511398586581819, + "CVC3": 0.24176145687454545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.678031337274797, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.677622259595749 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5972180007507522, + "veriT": 3.5182409045590668, + "Yices": 8.6416178055581678, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3211471227245326, + "CVC4": 2.5491452493381255, + "CVC3": 2.563926027747915, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3971106032126581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8330906217045921 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0413708147330001, + "veriT": 3.2130512042585311, + "Yices": 2.7225013224260834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0390182268206365, + "CVC4": 0.17308691902763634, + "CVC3": 2.3062723488424726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9834529159000422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9812962089397801 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.36978659065087499, + "veriT": 12.433728656691214, + "Yices": 5.8111035399902722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9597819999306409, + "CVC4": 7.5440912330064664, + "CVC3": 3.4183420965924554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8162215332582461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5632182373438628 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4056925239645133, + "veriT": 9.9035241253187962, + "Yices": 11.326232361477432, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0626813711242979, + "CVC4": 14.366794376027139, + "CVC3": 4.4327360273687528, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.240495614276373, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.453339881582059 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.330210579101413, + "veriT": 11.768968132775946, + "Yices": 10.601526822560647, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.913171269601513, + "CVC4": 4.9712717132465212, + "CVC3": 3.5267861982445252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237891608826363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236041503913373 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7224625489764067, + "veriT": 11.449878065229379, + "Yices": 11.164670228684317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2540156467852661, + "CVC4": 10.622301957209904, + "CVC3": 10.236976688847546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8403508679047293, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8413427063768006 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14778627550024442, + "veriT": 0.13278605457582224, + "Yices": 1.6974942614614319, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15543466428469999, + "CVC4": 1.7384951438005602, + "CVC3": 0.148098361274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15048601536312223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14987283996687775 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.971407722326816, + "veriT": 10.93954451241715, + "Yices": 6.0667885205976244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.252040973048459, + "CVC4": 3.772887590345678, + "CVC3": 12.456709616842163, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.482649753601105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.36882851620566 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5971846194019998, + "veriT": 10.518479329032985, + "Yices": 5.4766376025328327, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.141191414715256, + "CVC4": 4.8917042945599611, + "CVC3": 6.5769599220300163, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2961614105939523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5417080500429146 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 67.0, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9756852442606929, + "veriT": 13.100674280972529, + "Yices": 11.27899459910533, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8359181372760949, + "CVC4": 11.030611979075939, + "CVC3": 8.5604109240716006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228194893490105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.225164274710618 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 27.0, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.795169681571396, + "veriT": 12.457178766515305, + "Yices": 11.701050077059099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.660517708296487, + "CVC4": 14.575719328246663, + "CVC3": 11.123240353367708, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242460343461296, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.369522826797979 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2219322291785799, + "veriT": 13.29912965521037, + "Yices": 13.004603291953183, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6679374100777373, + "CVC4": 13.230123193385941, + "CVC3": 12.360664847408964, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236061205728198, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.234835203084932 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5114373966683221, + "veriT": 11.732511014549399, + "Yices": 10.610736961768129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.79078544250202, + "CVC4": 12.659426344043696, + "CVC3": 10.932416371593179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0348252483035836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2128592647898646 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.9000000953674316, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.065918526911096, + "veriT": 10.80920359138582, + "Yices": 10.328249298767568, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.575129521641994, + "CVC4": 5.1285654125927946, + "CVC3": 12.046706467644503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.116602117578832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.533465581016188 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.855954260551291, + "veriT": 11.094445701696813, + "Yices": 10.58405695729075, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.547314567366678, + "CVC4": 4.6583156304975368, + "CVC3": 12.213008089375549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8177033519715247, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.020159525122828 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1622957046754125, + "veriT": 11.203304824304817, + "Yices": 8.8442220679753074, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2868781115702372, + "CVC4": 6.528092549645593, + "CVC3": 11.200489290634152, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2699678101129077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1126894052045255 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3994965222080458, + "veriT": 13.336616942638475, + "Yices": 10.240360372564627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9132996434304061, + "CVC4": 13.177845034895862, + "CVC3": 5.7224686296173628, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.323246812854519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.321897526587584 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.236242417204126, + "veriT": 10.607242793529187, + "Yices": 10.768692426551123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.825547147515396, + "CVC4": 1.7303477664390543, + "CVC3": 9.343842585665195, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4483148309228158, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.09938968771503 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7103225938687689, + "veriT": 1.2414414645004443, + "Yices": 3.4840943946989111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7893710441754307, + "CVC4": 0.14933969120133334, + "CVC3": 0.25500118562355556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14891249632533332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3921838317442141 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5642388657381066, + "veriT": 13.190427255538012, + "Yices": 5.7974436880582489, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6921069101337256, + "CVC4": 9.631687820194756, + "CVC3": 10.649156413823061, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.201664201462682, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.438004192552413 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.868366965179999, + "veriT": 10.028470733869872, + "Yices": 2.3540688255733935, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1404584311186694, + "CVC4": 2.8452103211874742, + "CVC3": 3.6291234680219588, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.57242619442896, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.581858117283462 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6142136896034796, + "veriT": 10.551120231611259, + "Yices": 11.804852316202297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5837282862864717, + "CVC4": 12.199683315139209, + "CVC3": 7.352962883345203, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.419724673918301, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7949175697135971 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4105691554865283, + "veriT": 3.3050042855012198, + "Yices": 1.4241688630201865, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.455017253818002, + "CVC4": 2.0689650848848058, + "CVC3": 1.9871431090084395, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0544596662854813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0600238564946727 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.090278148651123, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.68876298291344, + "veriT": 10.211420044452444, + "Yices": 10.690762250130442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.159213806729923, + "CVC4": 9.8955345066570093, + "CVC3": 8.2149666967706381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.132040943526604, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.010260544281346 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3466992869881667, + "veriT": 4.1460857507154296, + "Yices": 11.639142313515874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7422204806078665, + "CVC4": 7.3692520618250663, + "CVC3": 5.3097914427465005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.495158614532881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8406540390220636 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8133328644716977, + "veriT": 7.7301453016491921, + "Yices": 14.162415852695087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8695263999090272, + "CVC4": 12.297967920291075, + "CVC3": 13.088916958143741, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0661712257307414, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0537027190653898 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15088403126247502, + "veriT": 10.872554301115082, + "Yices": 10.63846612860374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.41191132285253751, + "CVC4": 3.5606164052892595, + "CVC3": 1.50690796906975, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1075474619488546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1369845249941157 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13298995899671426, + "veriT": 5.9746594540612579, + "Yices": 4.3800562732618999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.58362317796074292, + "CVC4": 2.1398033663339611, + "CVC3": 2.1300700290611707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1319891635366228, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1326427233451519 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.195777220959247, + "veriT": 7.3052496285718007, + "Yices": 7.8482591432078461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9474855758518315, + "CVC4": 4.4386906664451429, + "CVC3": 0.21124099867171431, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7878201914698568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.800443248647194 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.73040452352066665, + "veriT": 0.70711773510431652, + "Yices": 2.3793396981530335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.72423363325201118, + "CVC4": 2.5393240547730209, + "CVC3": 0.16494161174673336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17745871520655554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17462298675472221 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3322043896636, + "veriT": 7.8093903591389076, + "Yices": 5.6280153913892894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.377386967508901, + "CVC4": 7.4840590436131835, + "CVC3": 1.8104751407677355, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.453464130831758, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.451811632865837 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2504843306408588, + "veriT": 12.668505512725137, + "Yices": 12.227158308940284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.4930749630264, + "CVC4": 11.65960068262363, + "CVC3": 10.763053148834675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.688286610286859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6463424353632332 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2926580026372503, + "veriT": 8.9259274753509263, + "Yices": 10.19498874502858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9297901599181664, + "CVC4": 2.5050594709576419, + "CVC3": 3.9527397454015341, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9518966307188705, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9553630313373382 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.514122369019935, + "veriT": 11.998840130436657, + "Yices": 10.860122001452689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.658236513450175, + "CVC4": 14.51803022121396, + "CVC3": 13.084760745398665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.735226732299139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.200298928542573 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.33748449596504, + "veriT": 14.220621064703186, + "Yices": 13.943905758426064, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.84487005851142, + "CVC4": 10.940010287284034, + "CVC3": 8.7876272164548777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.110791762200913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.969587029072596 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 54.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 21.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.148061248538, + "veriT": 1.1276480999229002, + "Yices": 1.1323398229848001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1446442546585003, + "CVC4": 1.5631827411673731, + "CVC3": 1.5489602720361733, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2756467053221576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2819422751719434 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14252768682200001, + "veriT": 9.3034634954504263, + "Yices": 0.15245970876966666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15337326753800001, + "CVC4": 0.16361177399316665, + "CVC3": 0.14178344031116666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15141826949916667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15005613583683333 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14695433279929998, + "veriT": 0.1261908611191, + "Yices": 0.13850873344119999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14531134670189999, + "CVC4": 0.1633122823059, + "CVC3": 0.1402304242686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1621760629183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15900166769679999 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16713533680485715, + "veriT": 0.14202727105828569, + "Yices": 0.16101896338799998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17359768354999999, + "CVC4": 0.19061013048114286, + "CVC3": 0.16781200180699998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17809240918314284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18030063175257144 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9685574555859997, + "veriT": 10.301500685283788, + "Yices": 5.4259402510103101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5644697097077085, + "CVC4": 1.4900516101748751, + "CVC3": 1.5127754780946252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.930876592717375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.95849169142300017 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.442689705620694, + "veriT": 10.924640652233901, + "Yices": 8.1484998337586596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6664341076145091, + "CVC4": 2.9712682356942617, + "CVC3": 5.9590954025358958, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7014118407513656, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1772238667098591 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21161206745480002, + "veriT": 9.0550892294967564, + "Yices": 1.6896400660889555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.70452598017688883, + "CVC4": 1.7602678362784552, + "CVC3": 2.852648700962289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19215709180340002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18088745972013331 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 53.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5363438347606746, + "veriT": 1.1402585022259002, + "Yices": 8.8643535464552503, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9280564308510868, + "CVC4": 1.5184425943601254, + "CVC3": 5.3657689433507718, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3360266121092357, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3304158423765395 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 245.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 71.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9586783922272586, + "veriT": 10.566233849657976, + "Yices": 5.3295300840427213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1182225322064481, + "CVC4": 8.780650492952935, + "CVC3": 3.4473318751810837, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9180303426333802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3455954494609998 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26056272810867, + "veriT": 11.650077981415377, + "Yices": 11.675508862177532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.607035671731024, + "CVC4": 6.3643070392941619, + "CVC3": 6.9070168676893928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2958112473891363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2925694165145947 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.46100035089119995, + "veriT": 4.5489856161682063, + "Yices": 5.6954829353449092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1316334678547255, + "CVC4": 6.8911771341680863, + "CVC3": 2.2454207383052078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9309582848535638, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1951158607501484 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1084835077193071, + "veriT": 14.214540876356262, + "Yices": 8.8585977750025204, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.49995680134327, + "CVC4": 6.883880038879636, + "CVC3": 5.166721093672721, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.25042201387716667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2417607327222222 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0949420928955078, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2922227097958983, + "veriT": 12.034315328202855, + "Yices": 7.0596117630986255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8341117774089328, + "CVC4": 12.286477795601625, + "CVC3": 11.913786362902144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.233621041931425, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.823414328044715 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.173676211499, + "veriT": 5.9690547679114587, + "Yices": 3.2303965306454385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0583393220885546, + "CVC4": 5.4472977462557362, + "CVC3": 6.7091559537531742, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5274785230460077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2484468717422814 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.710384173897895, + "veriT": 13.570334202870049, + "Yices": 12.419021460929931, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.293348195996096, + "CVC4": 13.355318764872621, + "CVC3": 12.551901671972836, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2096308957231026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3584536565278968 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 68.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241160809727921, + "veriT": 11.335741290603908, + "Yices": 10.403238044226642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95830202528157, + "CVC4": 14.660880610191564, + "CVC3": 10.443566187022441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.443623656774701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.630611392022349 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1336124420744147, + "veriT": 11.014518550569274, + "Yices": 11.261485701651456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.69148411494686, + "CVC4": 6.9946995759937902, + "CVC3": 6.2641505014265118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.527655918051417, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.338149888597531 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 204.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.954443843273994, + "veriT": 12.237145279987342, + "Yices": 12.3282759881457, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97191644729496, + "CVC4": 14.487889089005641, + "CVC3": 14.260748660447087, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.272327827510987, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.184719973577218 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2406172917893334, + "veriT": 14.238149480346696, + "Yices": 14.242903353635086, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.724929726441925, + "CVC4": 14.67646613393312, + "CVC3": 12.145479375968184, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260847024601727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.255223023674976 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.255992706511075, + "veriT": 13.174166864784276, + "Yices": 13.81076762436726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976205276099563, + "CVC4": 14.746796126768784, + "CVC3": 14.080735256644788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.22872837824824, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238495389585436 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25694197699819, + "veriT": 13.746887029135491, + "Yices": 14.364678164311048, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.028360720397336, + "CVC4": 14.613068793650577, + "CVC3": 13.900713090717549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.572059470725247, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.60733924676771 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.183636276487103, + "veriT": 14.245679505598632, + "Yices": 14.238582488334954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.508544274384926, + "CVC4": 14.843751393118573, + "CVC3": 9.6679711809163908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.125568926414516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.812480957206635 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.875, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12539404220889472, + "veriT": 0.09712486973186317, + "Yices": 0.10011135314141578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1226032066933158, + "CVC4": 0.12697038637236843, + "CVC3": 0.10227646135304209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12230937138326316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12023201122452634 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11269758190589375, + "veriT": 0.70275691890233127, + "Yices": 0.70562022859291873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12130230705212501, + "CVC4": 0.98452521387949721, + "CVC3": 0.083357835702649999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.98219483841769495, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.98138037878525175 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1512591938552998, + "veriT": 1.5202003218398761, + "Yices": 3.5643708395119909, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1434722923404004, + "CVC4": 1.6261999517067456, + "CVC3": 1.5339103081978647, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5431710032359731, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5794528327532462 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0115047673614994, + "veriT": 10.163895229993116, + "Yices": 10.358076493607742, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1045845655320992, + "CVC4": 0.14915463480899999, + "CVC3": 0.69730848739382867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14792991401662858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.441163125607689 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17674427172436363, + "veriT": 6.5072325639719999, + "Yices": 8.7066148814179094, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26396175076799999, + "CVC4": 0.15203822211663637, + "CVC3": 0.23832949554909089, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14820519848918179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7522686657296362 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8650795221328735, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8797572407259437, + "veriT": 6.5200508774889112, + "Yices": 8.2059522031313108, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2693437679251733, + "CVC4": 1.9078388174175349, + "CVC3": 5.6830390485459672, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4529798999090149, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9653818979192472 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.250051497185309, + "veriT": 9.4511920469621433, + "Yices": 10.329113422586, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.915722481088936, + "CVC4": 0.16736934491585714, + "CVC3": 11.669649576619301, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.856947768363243, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.296289996295643 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6863180180290254, + "veriT": 10.872923815456765, + "Yices": 8.9669130468913085, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4553167376261857, + "CVC4": 7.573758345344018, + "CVC3": 9.6814368374520754, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.70219460540717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.699402887184581 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7083334922790527, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245139825755535, + "veriT": 10.158197790460857, + "Yices": 10.351423711677857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962759238350927, + "CVC4": 0.15385621206957142, + "CVC3": 11.774197180884673, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.155495002444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.407372484126828 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237424394664965, + "veriT": 10.161439880499801, + "Yices": 10.325240385236601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95325025721437, + "CVC4": 0.22480954277240001, + "CVC3": 11.312475111893624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3423040176226841, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.240678372195664 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.716678744447046, + "veriT": 10.845710089447138, + "Yices": 10.631979231010794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.167989509371145, + "CVC4": 2.5544819325899408, + "CVC3": 14.243448177272882, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4970258517493362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.828111158495012 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17572483905096997, + "veriT": 4.6157916463645607, + "Yices": 4.9645441682260669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.201053787771, + "CVC4": 1.5746104507047007, + "CVC3": 1.5929513348031179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.154708796579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5629621177641382 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3901196920991037, + "veriT": 8.2099985384540339, + "Yices": 9.7883467710977854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5455227280913659, + "CVC4": 1.8427031437395109, + "CVC3": 7.3075284070389159, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7921422865837151, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8255651548061946 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.977351514053076, + "veriT": 12.340762870704177, + "Yices": 4.8907433044654613, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.37168662184, + "CVC4": 3.404502342089617, + "CVC3": 6.6650992225525041, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3901157564656854, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6696024271896004 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1372102107746969, + "veriT": 11.984627524431124, + "Yices": 10.902251737255696, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.146057506549402, + "CVC4": 4.8493269025574293, + "CVC3": 2.178559792043782, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.965162698836089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.962338558544708 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5227274894714355, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.411620121194174, + "veriT": 10.630797527672065, + "Yices": 10.440689771399198, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955572255471377, + "CVC4": 5.5667566103915664, + "CVC3": 12.198425545507757, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5936105876634601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.483477265127744 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.880180325674865, + "veriT": 1.3591845357442376, + "Yices": 1.3828603084345124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9688290550200842, + "CVC4": 0.124696802827125, + "CVC3": 0.24352697906347501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.129533534502625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5291212944737158 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1230910735964956, + "veriT": 8.6710415789958084, + "Yices": 5.2355236630072497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5513383419791928, + "CVC4": 0.87952312975187497, + "CVC3": 7.2127327043660898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4677678041459714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7982120775109642 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0933769163449991, + "veriT": 10.954091188557516, + "Yices": 6.6357471916936213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8058268158134769, + "CVC4": 10.573683367689089, + "CVC3": 7.2629520399228094, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8346831831164376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8387870638780228 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0627455711364746, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.860223837363367, + "veriT": 10.568213535411122, + "Yices": 10.728954141579463, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.652410163631382, + "CVC4": 1.5734880413733312, + "CVC3": 13.429308358160302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5892457511011671, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.246829990458277 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.954085811974558, + "veriT": 14.223723095368504, + "Yices": 13.741632846863375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.691948008363932, + "CVC4": 10.881616453932692, + "CVC3": 12.201236674044317, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.811475069717568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.801076792465135 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.772708255391999, + "veriT": 9.5870123755036172, + "Yices": 5.6675617087552315, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.742785737122597, + "CVC4": 5.9264041148247069, + "CVC3": 9.1677967075556683, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.99492468944525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.677960709041241 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4053495450432625, + "veriT": 12.764066921466668, + "Yices": 4.3966418185479652, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4099606803158751, + "CVC4": 3.8537229716394923, + "CVC3": 4.4606427301879066, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1622207981782755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1587834216594999 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7298884165710913, + "veriT": 7.3951073707626485, + "Yices": 12.785488172159068, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8169680822064551, + "CVC4": 12.037038459903091, + "CVC3": 10.976577729479978, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8066175472801795, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8314343046216077 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5477766382076918, + "veriT": 10.67650490483754, + "Yices": 13.027680002021617, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6154304473699481, + "CVC4": 12.196982894824366, + "CVC3": 7.5556996069854563, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.707229475905836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9618519792498645 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4814103149727664, + "veriT": 11.001167643394536, + "Yices": 5.53479599176808, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7078650129812125, + "CVC4": 8.5029692108162749, + "CVC3": 10.161218413705608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1385945817957843, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1349456551398989 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1354984895852, + "veriT": 6.1002799893981408, + "Yices": 8.9241629818218264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13235053062640001, + "CVC4": 1.5557223663464521, + "CVC3": 0.11970748672930001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.137260661906, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1370858204232 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12729393664025715, + "veriT": 7.3824829204853142, + "Yices": 7.2359700069916562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25246037914332858, + "CVC4": 5.8156742096407941, + "CVC3": 5.6754441406487697, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.115881650694126, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1272569310713987 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18224073232520005, + "veriT": 0.27250019282300003, + "Yices": 4.3725394666301529, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.67415531471580004, + "CVC4": 0.18878026417679999, + "CVC3": 0.17148261986459998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17486381464710002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17466878224509999 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 21.0, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.027778148651123, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9171185479038335, + "veriT": 5.1983289860376658, + "Yices": 11.547433032877324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5830911673061672, + "CVC4": 9.8269768273000206, + "CVC3": 3.6774911392911664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.881032557248824, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.952789397784727 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5008060587546745, + "veriT": 8.3227699508975448, + "Yices": 7.5952358424228228, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6146479061526806, + "CVC4": 9.1500236452209478, + "CVC3": 2.3860888268747349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7126607725019563, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6166786415493777 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5325444824264736, + "veriT": 8.4475016908832341, + "Yices": 8.5051140395993343, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.066524038385134, + "CVC4": 2.7820559480753673, + "CVC3": 2.5553196532324098, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2837173720398485, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4918679309070582 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0454545021057129, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6927064498644029, + "veriT": 9.7089241584558668, + "Yices": 10.349193559573301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1688185397118609, + "CVC4": 8.1870832854465867, + "CVC3": 9.1831536160077931, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.04788019174072, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.37657068478423 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9151233336859683, + "veriT": 3.9120212181955374, + "Yices": 9.6350212494308618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0290722636090464, + "CVC4": 6.7841563030569638, + "CVC3": 4.4150154154426993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6721457956862293, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6718026118424945 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 15.398701403163175, + "veriT": 10.137589526776098, + "Yices": 10.159903705647737, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.949284255436543, + "CVC4": 11.621032467499036, + "CVC3": 7.7060381950845285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.977117129026187, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.481509031065398 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6700125306965958, + "veriT": 9.9127605895441384, + "Yices": 11.929765542384889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.939780536610304, + "CVC4": 11.213348553597815, + "CVC3": 9.0273401451409594, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5700679192257869, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3190341617150718 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5331125801098411, + "veriT": 6.4972263670194081, + "Yices": 4.1460406258945683, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8923231726281076, + "CVC4": 7.2648771603603448, + "CVC3": 7.4408554538833016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6293668079878678, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5921227183982269 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0550762484788181, + "veriT": 3.9807528984484137, + "Yices": 0.1975275945086909, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0524792849874729, + "CVC4": 8.0031258832886252, + "CVC3": 3.0623719423245634, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9384341413340906, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9947465141938157 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.126834976996061, + "veriT": 12.695364389447045, + "Yices": 12.781508739589222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.415681405555908, + "CVC4": 10.19403870889732, + "CVC3": 14.539886641927524, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.399610962082225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.053336450495557 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4807689189910889, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.903740763119474, + "veriT": 10.828276204742602, + "Yices": 10.675224358665375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.943224455412045, + "CVC4": 3.810826264442214, + "CVC3": 9.8796600463430178, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.525660523621584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.46148597199798 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6230723067148571, + "veriT": 9.6410929027975065, + "Yices": 2.8484611723982409, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6482910309132186, + "CVC4": 1.2441885338844867, + "CVC3": 1.6620442707355942, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1723925461928122, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9215345730356086 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25384927599228568, + "veriT": 11.487020031134156, + "Yices": 10.043136835215074, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3977376129152366, + "CVC4": 12.367216940919759, + "CVC3": 7.7078857129011373, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243750875361465, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.948411911304675 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.593629225845758, + "veriT": 12.004038322037959, + "Yices": 9.8551845601647052, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7530875150420417, + "CVC4": 8.3967915278482188, + "CVC3": 10.21076397286498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.965207782254732, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.954025167749021 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6843645572662354, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.072448232245042, + "veriT": 10.183256359084002, + "Yices": 10.324295413504501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.094268821258762, + "CVC4": 9.3461718356762393, + "CVC3": 10.769104550832562, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257756912670226, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.779411056203532 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.473066462271333, + "veriT": 2.292772817111167, + "Yices": 4.1528928949592769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9273176537691943, + "CVC4": 1.5232235575748947, + "CVC3": 0.20165051363799999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3245255321747675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3178195734151681 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15914690091362502, + "veriT": 7.1013364194917141, + "Yices": 0.16533461106199998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16708980415874997, + "CVC4": 0.18496634431037501, + "CVC3": 0.161211100952, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16285241653950003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16397573625012499 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1706589360305, + "veriT": 0.15645261586299997, + "Yices": 0.15985838230924998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16898109073462497, + "CVC4": 0.196898434461, + "CVC3": 0.17230849047374999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18930599997900002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.183222819377 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15767478921475001, + "veriT": 0.130242691641, + "Yices": 0.15024321824662501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1630681732905, + "CVC4": 0.171171180007375, + "CVC3": 0.156073017771375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16526337264362501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.168163006323375 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 102.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0571432113647461, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.146359723311051, + "veriT": 7.0080096123880145, + "Yices": 7.2565719634210435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2711669559265242, + "CVC4": 0.31159437655642858, + "CVC3": 4.2940781449787311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.201489369252581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7961160592360468 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22399886135762501, + "veriT": 0.23525015732575, + "Yices": 10.740171789415227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.43556376732562507, + "CVC4": 0.22688600564449998, + "CVC3": 0.21558606494687502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.215127314849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20826975158762501 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6391047018518656, + "veriT": 11.43397471484348, + "Yices": 7.1166938586722344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3515295750377785, + "CVC4": 10.078602587441441, + "CVC3": 6.8894875127743314, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1142072336995437, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3535112057173979 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.39859919247628578, + "veriT": 12.493525958421932, + "Yices": 9.3852267896555066, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4083889629502977, + "CVC4": 12.295978929552872, + "CVC3": 4.6469292214285289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.236321279712696, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.897675720189083 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.471010551969082, + "veriT": 13.711771897626718, + "Yices": 9.4317618242726056, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.524290061116702, + "CVC4": 10.956491252677317, + "CVC3": 12.404857182657777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.473381820655558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.088647065956318 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.33550031651530005, + "veriT": 7.8326709571725086, + "Yices": 1.5521245301908484, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0522792114784001, + "CVC4": 4.7024357983571408, + "CVC3": 0.20595936125820002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9571507499934873, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.95701245688862 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14667357380072729, + "veriT": 3.7610070779924736, + "Yices": 5.0977511950248298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17622020550556361, + "CVC4": 1.5041879674192868, + "CVC3": 1.077368103152091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.27204675639954545, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.29506044517881819 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4739016735096078, + "veriT": 6.4654906970134434, + "Yices": 1.7722954684378165, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6231523208553145, + "CVC4": 7.2218855620170253, + "CVC3": 0.12325220683606665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4770912564409162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4723091853468628 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.177481188609496, + "veriT": 7.1828155887228009, + "Yices": 2.3791381305271249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.362302910144557, + "CVC4": 9.116043627197298, + "CVC3": 1.6023614397949999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.189725841604375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18390342777662502 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.56744927910599996, + "veriT": 7.396584081080201, + "Yices": 5.0202529812541927, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6402638694188876, + "CVC4": 10.257788025049578, + "CVC3": 3.8007616611754571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.94511415837479, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0245752056720914 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0186488530157067, + "veriT": 8.8085839179250751, + "Yices": 8.8086663139442436, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.813205985403865, + "CVC4": 8.7579881850882284, + "CVC3": 9.1680470419448366, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3594224154816263, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2747313777473899 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.908066384773948, + "veriT": 12.015826308726751, + "Yices": 12.987629119265195, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.384549121104696, + "CVC4": 14.08048195992667, + "CVC3": 10.606800207293304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.945102305644241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.946838294702207 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.49400116233100005, + "veriT": 7.4672457009019162, + "Yices": 8.0882209012927078, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9840882369483335, + "CVC4": 2.7190825349402021, + "CVC3": 0.17789464036733335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1874852170685246, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1885325267446412 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 53.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8417080289530321, + "veriT": 12.306099364224552, + "Yices": 3.9650596306464507, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7091406505078059, + "CVC4": 1.8085576011119637, + "CVC3": 2.0874758743204449, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19095735085144447, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19191095424566665 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.515506278549771, + "veriT": 14.259639694911494, + "Yices": 9.6081235533836011, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.269516591327855, + "CVC4": 2.8270985012160708, + "CVC3": 5.9944675888989671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.35169150978833336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.34572777845016667 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8718304351607271, + "veriT": 13.517203851086803, + "Yices": 8.2945398486573527, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4359603087554742, + "CVC4": 8.0849256923313551, + "CVC3": 12.899242235031892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4246610765961032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4383706901833531 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.383338839362997, + "veriT": 12.602400811037295, + "Yices": 12.272080837714011, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.342080435809217, + "CVC4": 14.554084740269747, + "CVC3": 10.141374240726959, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0754866159440244, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8528849554187161 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8747915029525757, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.262858732276539, + "veriT": 11.552740903552598, + "Yices": 10.872805978589961, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977691812895868, + "CVC4": 13.93135458498803, + "CVC3": 13.2588422171237, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25877755013642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.383908007104475 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5160090066103304, + "veriT": 10.777324881186111, + "Yices": 12.416445952330172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5264281013237735, + "CVC4": 13.085698741873308, + "CVC3": 11.64360484610217, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.636280683457791, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.662197972965698 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1283084339981349, + "veriT": 9.0674649001758603, + "Yices": 9.1873620576673698, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.391947943445301, + "CVC4": 5.5173599107321385, + "CVC3": 6.7741234792101181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.467356410517914, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.462449369054607 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 228.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.389330882040579, + "veriT": 13.787548576976162, + "Yices": 13.82213404145315, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.517070791253641, + "CVC4": 14.678665020951971, + "CVC3": 11.240773465594623, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255492941076344, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.82379514811063 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9412695950531664, + "veriT": 14.226922816235328, + "Yices": 13.985298626370247, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.639388891045462, + "CVC4": 14.582302170726193, + "CVC3": 10.458922333369561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.60501216347677, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.60059002176463 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0941383319698463, + "veriT": 14.231080097793074, + "Yices": 13.994644463624375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.091827217919548, + "CVC4": 14.634143865730362, + "CVC3": 11.965788340228775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.250556710253008, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.262366399376265 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.668531672301034, + "veriT": 13.103321740727088, + "Yices": 13.619501952657933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.970423528436299, + "CVC4": 14.663358292898494, + "CVC3": 12.762965473919893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.492221590580217, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.131255285302112 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 218.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0056072362997055, + "veriT": 11.064363953174272, + "Yices": 14.236118155116126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.67569190153977, + "CVC4": 14.638737365562697, + "CVC3": 12.973302721356765, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.78739053352377775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.80960169031644436 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.262423670984766, + "veriT": 13.810591109047614, + "Yices": 14.096551285664411, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98482694658242, + "CVC4": 14.719129386853837, + "CVC3": 11.729673370505154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.763653017366984, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.098753153577897 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.694652633535243, + "veriT": 13.093077550285685, + "Yices": 13.014002333198578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.654991981812698, + "CVC4": 14.736720224333737, + "CVC3": 14.237411425276493, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.069979807865135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.097676726545524 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7499888059926585, + "veriT": 12.372623412308835, + "Yices": 10.86660607239213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.367050078234922, + "CVC4": 10.265835869438446, + "CVC3": 9.9980706056226154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6879188602170845, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2014932757935091 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.875, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13546082230842857, + "veriT": 0.10848236309831429, + "Yices": 0.10993436950489287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13391567695771428, + "CVC4": 0.13750903634771428, + "CVC3": 0.11647712781918572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13198050569428571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13060243321142859 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11615549451956668, + "veriT": 0.088177659132633326, + "Yices": 0.092234157096791655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11441376608086669, + "CVC4": 0.11154942802060418, + "CVC3": 0.094051689634554167, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11125251028446249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1108703200243125 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8938517204493319, + "veriT": 1.3615221110612747, + "Yices": 2.6535497740899499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9812651510406507, + "CVC4": 0.13093472682687501, + "CVC3": 1.877085199712577, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13278197711537498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9136451240878425 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2105103939102881, + "veriT": 10.166540794276214, + "Yices": 10.346604321970178, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3298306248809879, + "CVC4": 0.15026597265978572, + "CVC3": 0.70557423581885714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14851679438999996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.435018436204512 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17952316997442858, + "veriT": 7.2881529267112857, + "Yices": 7.4242186987457144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31873475799714285, + "CVC4": 0.15447966944800001, + "CVC3": 0.25810216079771425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14900119761085714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5071390120011428 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0869251631088517, + "veriT": 11.554740982510156, + "Yices": 12.007224618043429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0991127687191096, + "CVC4": 12.676390876549785, + "CVC3": 7.9481746546536867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.286352910560513, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.936767945135454 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7611734066839908, + "veriT": 5.5347913088980567, + "Yices": 1.5020361911899713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9786686750439761, + "CVC4": 4.2660182176368693, + "CVC3": 4.1104824780455989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1159795188562032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1128608668175271 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5699524207201003, + "veriT": 5.8245642874226808, + "Yices": 5.8732854819109974, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7511041894343471, + "CVC4": 2.627406966781654, + "CVC3": 3.8197428397344999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.487810200680598, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1933952247579507 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17230092043341663, + "veriT": 5.1298066407441327, + "Yices": 9.3800454026220006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17617967522491665, + "CVC4": 1.3377269173781599, + "CVC3": 0.16433727123891664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3259339294274934, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9056322145596312 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244872975490281, + "veriT": 10.162432768526584, + "Yices": 10.346568440130584, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963232205606301, + "CVC4": 0.16110014311841667, + "CVC3": 12.297019731387264, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16881453249066669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.372879973173674 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23668158456424, + "veriT": 10.175442443178545, + "Yices": 10.317239078982455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954732062342298, + "CVC4": 0.16238471891645451, + "CVC3": 11.145502029129373, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3898584872465261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.502510989507256 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.687979813281201, + "veriT": 11.468670952176742, + "Yices": 10.641890588535993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.138779196009594, + "CVC4": 8.80702763148523, + "CVC3": 10.118766349653686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.476395673825147, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.08789663692732 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.123320330607584, + "veriT": 9.5046198803083595, + "Yices": 9.2012772521003328, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.688038380420084, + "CVC4": 0.17119949196644443, + "CVC3": 10.288478722919422, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.576543530153932, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.132459475520617 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.425894109580176, + "veriT": 10.970594700609768, + "Yices": 10.614805018643599, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.991410762595859, + "CVC4": 3.1925339188735289, + "CVC3": 11.269548730161626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1582273595726109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.818689311302677 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.231087746768152, + "veriT": 10.147728762019749, + "Yices": 10.235846761082751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.940603372967871, + "CVC4": 5.4858046471209798, + "CVC3": 14.215771025035624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.590012070536531, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7907964595284831 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.704237709724941, + "veriT": 10.143531172901838, + "Yices": 10.743939325029, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.351189924989745, + "CVC4": 12.970450007966496, + "CVC3": 10.694669478450717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.454900398362419, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.706853421139677 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5999999046325684, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5405714326931921, + "veriT": 1.1101227743417901, + "Yices": 1.1291459660597798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6077428872050574, + "CVC4": 0.13524605651829999, + "CVC3": 0.22252584393071997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13408829741380002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2547842517322627 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5830188621884667, + "veriT": 4.369299356100707, + "Yices": 11.989491282360666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5206859221035001, + "CVC4": 5.8139493050798787, + "CVC3": 5.6620843855765015, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1676319116930962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1907039953227629 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9726749891877944, + "veriT": 9.1957191793220776, + "Yices": 12.363070992658741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6426907297844853, + "CVC4": 8.7736565466827017, + "CVC3": 7.0357132141003165, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.338451654727908, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.179949568010755 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3671711908149033, + "veriT": 10.196578530251633, + "Yices": 7.9361060594965762, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.352986190190604, + "CVC4": 10.500736146059209, + "CVC3": 7.733836271217263, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.233313281539067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.235484767644866 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18194669928551249, + "veriT": 10.205724279743361, + "Yices": 2.6458110906024999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24698400119475, + "CVC4": 0.17516285438562501, + "CVC3": 2.7213990825871996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3189952808160781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3269408153822706 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.46267749952600001, + "veriT": 9.7383659933914721, + "Yices": 7.0886095861783849, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4913721848782968, + "CVC4": 4.1246557847885716, + "CVC3": 2.2987033980880738, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2063217353804747, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2037319533505864 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0294120311737061, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.677767607533296, + "veriT": 9.0453847608234454, + "Yices": 9.209372926565333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.315224958626864, + "CVC4": 0.15873925169166667, + "CVC3": 13.040574738146452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7227921935198525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.081388617690195 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240824174650704, + "veriT": 10.613758063555141, + "Yices": 10.787149478783284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958519970965382, + "CVC4": 0.29589093139111111, + "CVC3": 13.128173719992681, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2983727367684454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.714553546137621 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5237449972364878, + "veriT": 11.647628639575213, + "Yices": 8.5413429911751422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.022479984509086, + "CVC4": 8.4437963740430035, + "CVC3": 8.7468782810339931, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4433070790660372, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4381064014245757 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.301948070526123, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0710785388946533, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8819444179534912, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3422030629013975, + "veriT": 9.3107683602551923, + "Yices": 7.1580914201948884, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0538059417065497, + "CVC4": 0.20706478775455558, + "CVC3": 1.939949511844014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2353024821472345, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5090283542080316 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.560893762321709, + "veriT": 7.4098055150823274, + "Yices": 10.287997340696958, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2640726440432655, + "CVC4": 7.8418328789592477, + "CVC3": 5.6854719925032757, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.144114936619776, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.264451186704292 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3615982922647145, + "veriT": 5.8162453516241568, + "Yices": 7.8293965734978519, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3658865851603377, + "CVC4": 12.579793263660999, + "CVC3": 6.8081480023158116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1913499888270032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1856406694598824 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9534034893381773, + "veriT": 9.0147165320816249, + "Yices": 3.9148320939504999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1168841778278109, + "CVC4": 5.4730740586854258, + "CVC3": 1.9466974711432607, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.01563190479669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0167017685467692 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16879643305074998, + "veriT": 1.3909650120309249, + "Yices": 5.6547620846264781, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.168328609548, + "CVC4": 0.173367439772625, + "CVC3": 0.16080777811813748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16226761675625001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16647095280724999 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9866317599319463, + "veriT": 5.2636030767370254, + "Yices": 9.9037901838162661, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7432934069241615, + "CVC4": 3.0864715147715138, + "CVC3": 4.2735392187247001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6281033179881943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6466050830113446 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1916688267466142, + "veriT": 8.3949292446801156, + "Yices": 9.4004644561285104, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.11036356230154, + "CVC4": 10.84089596563193, + "CVC3": 9.7930801418618714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.811778333538735, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.526678003875062 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7007530774721862, + "veriT": 2.8509836729564184, + "Yices": 7.8032522004281786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7388171611693082, + "CVC4": 1.4419705602406134, + "CVC3": 2.540500765536692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7072501727871976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7182127735393333 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14372534801754544, + "veriT": 1.3207780044756747, + "Yices": 0.17871763029184543, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1471313626031909, + "CVC4": 1.4437392858331355, + "CVC3": 0.13575088410841818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15233515234500003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14943651143463638 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7622067086559179, + "veriT": 7.9548307448677367, + "Yices": 10.137793776628659, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9882259166991507, + "CVC4": 9.649763668903212, + "CVC3": 2.8575218629113381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7294015420580278, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7290656553621149 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5940317427371173, + "veriT": 11.475545975862671, + "Yices": 9.1137508106955138, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2960812148793242, + "CVC4": 3.0495286935701831, + "CVC3": 2.229051928334727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1344072214767991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.594428841331347 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2475983477595243, + "veriT": 11.176787302141129, + "Yices": 10.558427720341857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1525311317041425, + "CVC4": 7.8731629766638722, + "CVC3": 9.2147954030738823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4166870308370179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.541781546750213 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233534927445959, + "veriT": 10.831611894023375, + "Yices": 10.561564451258667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953242534111801, + "CVC4": 2.5555803119925189, + "CVC3": 14.478809453777126, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1011980777216444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.368592902839355 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7516755668979687, + "veriT": 9.4116905642593132, + "Yices": 10.54121907997218, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7959145855564369, + "CVC4": 2.0850869401815575, + "CVC3": 5.9323181690136764, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.086985654833542, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.330579005202468 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1815688294616695, + "veriT": 6.6652822912397394, + "Yices": 4.8508079620735005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5935045472357086, + "CVC4": 0.17269381626200003, + "CVC3": 3.5335667414939729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6782423333543348, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4474865386710682 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6901969909667969, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.595592005424621, + "veriT": 13.712905144197721, + "Yices": 14.489634315530989, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.816526220390228, + "CVC4": 14.714586574332399, + "CVC3": 14.378402178185276, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.735474770314276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.733685610363709 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.672743060234806, + "veriT": 10.837998387054613, + "Yices": 10.556093290775458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.183246503394487, + "CVC4": 10.670466137761743, + "CVC3": 14.134825358852531, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235913695970131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.730517842737987 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8983194828033447, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2892897630998759, + "veriT": 11.657070154581477, + "Yices": 8.7544894036953202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2846638632736012, + "CVC4": 9.8478449011748008, + "CVC3": 4.6194907585885634, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.610280032428609, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.338210013352118 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.227946189999749, + "veriT": 11.661711528029565, + "Yices": 10.82614662277283, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.699885941110054, + "CVC4": 11.387341513654327, + "CVC3": 11.776768907619102, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.464764636661581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.688419210350325 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22913745972461541, + "veriT": 5.677215606297092, + "Yices": 5.4153920485043079, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6104788832759045, + "CVC4": 1.4060540991226735, + "CVC3": 0.39560510698869239, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1135874105372316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8751432082253086 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5704530367744287, + "veriT": 12.613537776072727, + "Yices": 1.1038110066042857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.966049127237832, + "CVC4": 2.2338148927955079, + "CVC3": 1.3915577417032552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1764240971298818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1760044071882216 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.02788909306976, + "veriT": 13.403584331286655, + "Yices": 2.6367704810493544, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6611927851939079, + "CVC4": 3.1268867752348535, + "CVC3": 5.81242110382337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.422450068359071, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.423052532624107 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4188802517223333, + "veriT": 5.699486576780223, + "Yices": 8.1489837261901119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4335527448719456, + "CVC4": 11.126089872627109, + "CVC3": 4.8622334444411335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1038180984341928, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1234554267410335 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15804717219134998, + "veriT": 3.8054403312336587, + "Yices": 3.5608563549443004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.173156368225725, + "CVC4": 3.6905643509141175, + "CVC3": 1.8945384803197751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5037477038745812, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3377270920769528 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 34.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13793928575445455, + "veriT": 0.11499651736587274, + "Yices": 0.12617534779981818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13590783517056362, + "CVC4": 0.15064169157505455, + "CVC3": 0.13222995470345456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14874095969420001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14792267802872727 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15330332822671427, + "veriT": 0.1281842941795, + "Yices": 0.14998372924207143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15825699081192854, + "CVC4": 0.17665605884778571, + "CVC3": 0.15645210287921429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16414015713514285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16779081536821425 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5819402809352856, + "veriT": 0.127377322834, + "Yices": 0.1423048933092857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5873346402342856, + "CVC4": 0.16419968992857145, + "CVC3": 0.14728601371928571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15940638581642855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16215385999485715 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 78.0, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7418135382723712, + "veriT": 1.3693036128065976, + "Yices": 0.26245049576950003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9408733845603909, + "CVC4": 1.4961001771173281, + "CVC3": 1.4160006788432902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1889847432159166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2083625720330835 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.318594275972333, + "veriT": 8.7615829575761399, + "Yices": 0.16220792418133334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3417056244730006, + "CVC4": 2.5673146809220206, + "CVC3": 6.713083472194576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8175648735405856, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2520083918093654 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.736260001053385, + "veriT": 10.128863433915601, + "Yices": 9.4112887831795895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.338001615711004, + "CVC4": 12.508460286891843, + "CVC3": 12.150601203772407, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.625897199548946, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.966982659378449 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.46316974515742854, + "veriT": 6.2067760306650399, + "Yices": 6.1787134495724603, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2802229437462853, + "CVC4": 4.2126491908895058, + "CVC3": 5.5990170107699599, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6282342054656924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6301206728353392 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9050995111465454, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241088958765403, + "veriT": 11.966882203198905, + "Yices": 11.769294447433261, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958572962108219, + "CVC4": 12.330651331176835, + "CVC3": 12.441563553774319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.062947011918396, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.807834606751982 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.289920733887854, + "veriT": 10.245754670610751, + "Yices": 10.452442670700583, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.00618960967379, + "CVC4": 14.329486240704938, + "CVC3": 14.28766657667193, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.122946274341777, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.439352438141283 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6510031684887965, + "veriT": 13.84903858703715, + "Yices": 11.973359345919668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.922161776983689, + "CVC4": 8.7416164866422559, + "CVC3": 8.4031031103939142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.758933233706689, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.231688247187988 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.59466896429191662, + "veriT": 12.757699157172707, + "Yices": 11.347807933075535, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0489850334626554, + "CVC4": 10.859584287813155, + "CVC3": 4.7597949120297498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.058503232428114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.069266978786622 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7592507870546046, + "veriT": 1.4946059976747113, + "Yices": 1.679166797864778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2942807317916611, + "CVC4": 1.7529004435111566, + "CVC3": 1.279143375533111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7196469504012655, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4104629198895959 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7896862179649018, + "veriT": 13.939156380813325, + "Yices": 4.242129148137237, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.818055937863627, + "CVC4": 1.572276577110796, + "CVC3": 2.9353101008567277, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19546341579727275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19528833559736364 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6470516485607227, + "veriT": 12.441656126836442, + "Yices": 8.2736384878472204, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9593409305185681, + "CVC4": 8.8931362235825482, + "CVC3": 5.1584451351227161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4331870890548526, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4611552874105058 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6752111012970365, + "veriT": 6.4216622882041614, + "Yices": 7.0142413710085298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8808711918670173, + "CVC4": 8.4415555186499045, + "CVC3": 5.0588233584286133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.24564180736893, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.26681017824375 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.087390863066251, + "veriT": 11.382838671141474, + "Yices": 12.324903664974498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.094736471328689, + "CVC4": 14.505285397885512, + "CVC3": 11.945591993030465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.774293347537318, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.838017795612602 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8558791575425397, + "veriT": 13.465364924199562, + "Yices": 10.370753391463772, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.675721781633293, + "CVC4": 9.9176905581511949, + "CVC3": 12.829993925390831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.583120704170581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.543160464194619 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.130323459159369, + "veriT": 13.141050319808169, + "Yices": 11.4618956753788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962374928764545, + "CVC4": 14.596104584426406, + "CVC3": 13.097110056132163, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.500813008598334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.247070842850757 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.239438824207982, + "veriT": 14.238450568376397, + "Yices": 14.060789596526138, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965962752212132, + "CVC4": 14.456090303307841, + "CVC3": 14.253620863085468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.262369669415145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.257718527458795 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.614078553111478, + "veriT": 14.230166906974494, + "Yices": 14.232707981303118, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.242984846182756, + "CVC4": 10.535794203644567, + "CVC3": 12.969192341871082, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.846204291438198, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.902671098676132 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0580218760193025, + "veriT": 13.071996647197082, + "Yices": 13.904424879640507, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6868893079772258, + "CVC4": 12.343069230609998, + "CVC3": 8.9528444634297379, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.756077589663851, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.713352920245327 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 181.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8345752889562748, + "veriT": 11.326383499768209, + "Yices": 9.7505085526563562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.498859083519013, + "CVC4": 11.876621192066134, + "CVC3": 7.4809203288852624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1939710472631289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1944829873910692 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1531852073543227, + "veriT": 14.243197344428035, + "Yices": 14.250574045967126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.02788540459415, + "CVC4": 14.441625418845257, + "CVC3": 12.348997945779418, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1018045006646533, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0827869868271058 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1399684423599332, + "veriT": 10.930775152671284, + "Yices": 14.28183482267184, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.247997890279846, + "CVC4": 14.613031824337142, + "CVC3": 13.759124033578761, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4486380799408982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.452201773008146 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1377701759338379, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.881706652714803, + "veriT": 11.689825394744433, + "Yices": 11.938915364520795, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977008091252326, + "CVC4": 12.607648318487465, + "CVC3": 14.260976940138109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.978056940559449, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7508363106326748 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.408885439183365, + "veriT": 12.579732350969143, + "Yices": 14.301194753288538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.480843960155388, + "CVC4": 14.430854238237622, + "CVC3": 10.749385761906767, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.752735714178373, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.872162739701141 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5449207078867291, + "veriT": 6.5310080840634441, + "Yices": 5.9610407315498017, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8735963123252342, + "CVC4": 6.7227844363572924, + "CVC3": 3.6870540008826449, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9730727620173312, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8908680164822886 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4166665077209473, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12737262639103705, + "veriT": 0.099370790138837053, + "Yices": 0.099801039842522213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12450412307603706, + "CVC4": 0.12569442816266668, + "CVC3": 0.10462806049604814, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12372568904062965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12242745162703704 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2890559237243653, + "veriT": 0.085810756169421729, + "Yices": 0.089238744589960881, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2884509802317261, + "CVC4": 0.11444723210632608, + "CVC3": 0.093845931953730408, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11012271392201738, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1099112329368 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0600505685240447, + "veriT": 10.165660533269667, + "Yices": 10.354105255651305, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1550429604333474, + "CVC4": 0.15044347994109089, + "CVC3": 0.72782011041912131, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14829937906203033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.427460765463517 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1835840368896184, + "veriT": 7.2900994662692868, + "Yices": 8.2362894147035721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3481457224971574, + "CVC4": 0.15265641739649999, + "CVC3": 1.2602628488822152, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14919043949214286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0878670126354097 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1177054745592088, + "veriT": 11.763698809994379, + "Yices": 10.487479302214618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2726401389847144, + "CVC4": 11.282715268886731, + "CVC3": 8.4577051023510013, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.372863720915836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.371662668866673 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7333334684371948, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.897818605161275, + "veriT": 10.510438692455571, + "Yices": 10.439526948294333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.549323971479881, + "CVC4": 1.4229048829320536, + "CVC3": 12.118930625068336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9855992627975079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.461771180505705 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8285715579986572, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.168208358160729, + "veriT": 9.3941963625754603, + "Yices": 10.328502439847922, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.831038239503682, + "CVC4": 0.1711913394907692, + "CVC3": 12.525564532517977, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.955145444767691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.270664380501945 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.002021187082466, + "veriT": 10.836043716808412, + "Yices": 10.247121856789201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.495366590712688, + "CVC4": 3.1561265450024005, + "CVC3": 10.435056010409912, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.103311532465659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.04581202975019 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.936999983032443, + "veriT": 10.211330505416557, + "Yices": 10.316481495486666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953275601234509, + "CVC4": 1.3591970164781111, + "CVC3": 13.24623182765523, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2660716275280066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.571997865987178 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8895300002896871, + "veriT": 10.418592751767282, + "Yices": 7.8919272802376854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7831500698779923, + "CVC4": 4.1205050488297221, + "CVC3": 8.946912444387662, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2945216222227813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1218579507203792 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6909501059282475, + "veriT": 8.4954049204175011, + "Yices": 10.314473416121501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.634704434571129, + "CVC4": 0.20795023945400001, + "CVC3": 5.5777960784153917, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16897204066850002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.712674755710033 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.353278753820331, + "veriT": 11.751751985556027, + "Yices": 8.9888827838067407, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5706736152423106, + "CVC4": 2.9490998522026559, + "CVC3": 9.4227602086574898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5907388128330133, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9303740576586579 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6799165281103812, + "veriT": 3.8783191665221053, + "Yices": 6.8404775733658196, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1722150792384909, + "CVC4": 0.46762834727768415, + "CVC3": 3.9611297731479365, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1145629714908836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.7010852125683 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2815662768311213, + "veriT": 9.8470738213742504, + "Yices": 8.5831373245616565, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2287990310586743, + "CVC4": 3.713656861702967, + "CVC3": 9.5750839970213626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6722646057791883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2550074903693211 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13663713522990911, + "veriT": 6.5510199675687826, + "Yices": 7.7584682514141381, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23355078906773635, + "CVC4": 6.7903546909711698, + "CVC3": 1.4288394122169767, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6968317590551547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4378025659583431 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7551364898681641, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6076924800872803, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6231404976161281, + "veriT": 9.6738042786549379, + "Yices": 9.7188832463296198, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0758317740706866, + "CVC4": 2.3007346975944114, + "CVC3": 6.6624418939159833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5573848342411507, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3922850132559637 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6052445185828992, + "veriT": 11.031288026409062, + "Yices": 7.0280652153864054, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8894845905567452, + "CVC4": 6.5087714678954187, + "CVC3": 8.1836766651247874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.142930293062964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.868503177382694 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8895368960350361, + "veriT": 10.853596620080161, + "Yices": 3.6595668482920836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.216931584927641, + "CVC4": 2.5201269242454454, + "CVC3": 4.8375435863457232, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4926111092259107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3964912246337944 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3643363082843809, + "veriT": 12.60196356128982, + "Yices": 12.346557068523367, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.004513173509414, + "CVC4": 14.539782365617649, + "CVC3": 8.156237610938275, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.444456562076395, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.21819967081171 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2434201904049047, + "veriT": 9.5957624685840841, + "Yices": 5.5835220064692441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3657028708399865, + "CVC4": 4.3968439417388128, + "CVC3": 5.7997959238926677, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2560498099458792, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7127168305479357 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3653621099984576, + "veriT": 10.981037304539678, + "Yices": 10.671044975902644, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.527647351212115, + "CVC4": 10.977970232357753, + "CVC3": 11.792003632314627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246784817232756, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.327469544622023 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9444444179534912, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7437755347234662, + "veriT": 1.6950111135864456, + "Yices": 5.0316666320827785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2426474867017263, + "CVC4": 6.4346666757372546, + "CVC3": 1.7330186569944253, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4012681857073153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9800605331434546 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0630466032097947, + "veriT": 0.77888254776302002, + "Yices": 3.7318924756005258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1090004521076853, + "CVC4": 0.12987289701187335, + "CVC3": 0.18754486899437331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12784951230466668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.87512267944350175 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0416665077209473, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9015887473444084, + "veriT": 9.1153298731389008, + "Yices": 9.1135007568363982, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3532451117943842, + "CVC4": 2.9732915795649255, + "CVC3": 3.4982665763930392, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.391276816826622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.41632813474107 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.136093936597525, + "veriT": 5.298627633649537, + "Yices": 2.8635983889623917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.38676349888043116, + "CVC4": 2.0106554290636813, + "CVC3": 2.1294525663045434, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7254731798469032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7021794098240459 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3923075199127197, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.147582191092285, + "veriT": 12.330597820868148, + "Yices": 11.129582350659616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.670087589727965, + "CVC4": 1.3378064646457957, + "CVC3": 12.961255723575309, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6088835714546814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.900416985241542 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.224912477927203, + "veriT": 8.7234588519851428, + "Yices": 8.8765285642924301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.842473951798477, + "CVC4": 0.18663788106699999, + "CVC3": 14.665821703788639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1814986329338897, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6831133695770983 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6076134201897143, + "veriT": 1.633020633066143, + "Yices": 4.3697482102401448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6294778195197144, + "CVC4": 2.2048729603260795, + "CVC3": 1.6334132026745714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20148325517885715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19228157277185712 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6833308397648459, + "veriT": 8.7386676105519818, + "Yices": 11.080816997173402, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9235639948965773, + "CVC4": 11.385510143721323, + "CVC3": 8.9909972181654627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23801743064293, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.233664306659328 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8797850323618928, + "veriT": 7.8044658836901908, + "Yices": 13.419629015445302, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6298961353817658, + "CVC4": 9.6438520453327783, + "CVC3": 12.545450712099514, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3358677849941998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3087818810354763 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5341615233237076, + "veriT": 2.6656603989511587, + "Yices": 4.287491147727355, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5698144083620247, + "CVC4": 9.6130915094650131, + "CVC3": 0.15583999574966664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.29078141394684165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.23226689334952502 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1408628562773084, + "veriT": 9.0595777968769884, + "Yices": 1.5718222305751646, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2426690370430342, + "CVC4": 2.3136770254710832, + "CVC3": 0.14995747315721428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5699462443350001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.162197343623359 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2065306725228999, + "veriT": 3.3229145509204736, + "Yices": 11.230398089880774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2459947344989, + "CVC4": 8.6703500123094255, + "CVC3": 9.9058806524484986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5683379379774767, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.550812085313173 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1543863509021257, + "veriT": 4.9305075862331593, + "Yices": 4.9098812697555623, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1632730616969997, + "CVC4": 3.8607878904971216, + "CVC3": 4.9447030368951195, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1781771762069155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1757903443900224 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0906738393663833, + "veriT": 14.233099379845418, + "Yices": 13.088160807580083, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.029199318610386, + "CVC4": 8.2114732045481098, + "CVC3": 4.9628020125997319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.086593331629102, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.182460364863116 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7147008640952874, + "veriT": 1.9690252058106636, + "Yices": 3.6408530523835818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.66628288680699999, + "CVC4": 1.4532658153610567, + "CVC3": 1.1605060532160001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16219117158145455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1832721534486565 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.487682186438793, + "veriT": 11.378318756075847, + "Yices": 11.668695424518232, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.810513229481531, + "CVC4": 13.99385218758127, + "CVC3": 10.985129666755276, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.661454640827158, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.871374634928049 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 83.0, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13800781400046153, + "veriT": 0.11909484556539998, + "Yices": 0.13158595654761537, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13590066182592309, + "CVC4": 0.16124047767330768, + "CVC3": 2.4817972832826154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15262719142207692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14572016673123075 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5591763678105715, + "veriT": 0.11450854426228571, + "Yices": 4.3791169585269616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5617649294304428, + "CVC4": 2.2082747987624987, + "CVC3": 0.12610192337508572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13850348689385714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13518038721257145 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12015760906852939, + "veriT": 6.7065990195019136, + "Yices": 5.0769036206760294, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14753734291815881, + "CVC4": 1.8018057772440257, + "CVC3": 0.93753174398030081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19878149503642351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20492923345245295 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6295608496484491, + "veriT": 6.5722371819017678, + "Yices": 9.4881191730909915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2466303193993173, + "CVC4": 1.6431294724496734, + "CVC3": 4.0489015454787722, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2547015537543844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.076199851268028 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15839894036988572, + "veriT": 1.5711332710556287, + "Yices": 6.5056014333460874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15992151168218571, + "CVC4": 4.2210836999364725, + "CVC3": 0.16109339162299999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.36199445851744283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7620885534875048 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3600092875504792, + "veriT": 10.69112011607956, + "Yices": 8.8504619060217919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3565956951082097, + "CVC4": 12.181395919125459, + "CVC3": 8.4190636423549474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.023705649506983, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4766157407925347 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14319629900066666, + "veriT": 11.651487947655525, + "Yices": 0.15954414996908334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15914691219308333, + "CVC4": 0.16676277169608333, + "CVC3": 0.14278494534025002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14964119832016667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14818115140683333 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4471138082617561, + "veriT": 6.1607146498415206, + "Yices": 2.1466399716558437, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5746008929361777, + "CVC4": 2.2768038151377397, + "CVC3": 2.8585087452597739, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1384979900475716, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4472415887179997 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15394598728028572, + "veriT": 0.12786416102357143, + "Yices": 0.14491271811814285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15753011543142859, + "CVC4": 0.16728721172328573, + "CVC3": 0.14861642187257143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16415123802071427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16407704990385713 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0754679240964973, + "veriT": 11.780546188008739, + "Yices": 10.9948626474999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5004994714597943, + "CVC4": 8.7845948087953936, + "CVC3": 8.8455753516094706, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.713832587082766, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.777216909910234 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8383674621582031, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8276921254823335, + "veriT": 11.865280379523186, + "Yices": 4.4987802366458283, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8568949718571666, + "CVC4": 2.6335498960361412, + "CVC3": 2.4847129184105605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4929475911843189, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4888784095585081 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13123978177750001, + "veriT": 14.210062337981812, + "Yices": 0.11457104266449999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19690308166237502, + "CVC4": 0.154985957452, + "CVC3": 0.13083125852975, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.572073656796539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.614560753344186 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16612918617683334, + "veriT": 4.8320368715376718, + "Yices": 2.2842361934689017, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26060827673866666, + "CVC4": 4.8939840997243813, + "CVC3": 1.0136258066245001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17179754967449998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16299685250108334 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 78.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8642252457654385, + "veriT": 12.273378167299626, + "Yices": 11.879690509242023, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7505957985481819, + "CVC4": 13.569370771131529, + "CVC3": 9.1471074259850127, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1559741873154792, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9984092519296794 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9673441198808126, + "veriT": 12.518448249399462, + "Yices": 6.9720364477507735, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.006770863945075, + "CVC4": 1.1767510816199995, + "CVC3": 6.5373698432393867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6883215960642382, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.432525679875308 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8124675750732422, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.516496428526073, + "veriT": 12.672923333477758, + "Yices": 10.345360584066261, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.062094389705713, + "CVC4": 11.775701202357567, + "CVC3": 7.1028641544044353, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.829895821491681, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.827296708841486 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.762497062970104, + "veriT": 12.953820202739635, + "Yices": 11.648668664566571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952323903335635, + "CVC4": 14.528539188934733, + "CVC3": 13.178265304791195, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238208097305193, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.066061262867409 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6148059352075994, + "veriT": 12.499753976165245, + "Yices": 13.170274650460524, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6860192902374269, + "CVC4": 10.464320989459679, + "CVC3": 4.2762654502910564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.154108533672197, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.154427483357571 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9305135011672974, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.753089776651664, + "veriT": 10.617765273162911, + "Yices": 11.129589180910616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6353819000774674, + "CVC4": 10.854922891330673, + "CVC3": 11.187015033671814, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.748469482508874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.937332552843971 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2970412507562783, + "veriT": 6.5889209171792675, + "Yices": 6.1087424040652625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1291603458577879, + "CVC4": 4.5194270330630077, + "CVC3": 1.3848795621583674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15318070697199998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15108535399584613 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 44.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6690787339236284, + "veriT": 11.756862804417651, + "Yices": 8.9493139948530089, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2327557835089245, + "CVC4": 11.64204955658963, + "CVC3": 11.408585618180922, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234730944554874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236605709731503 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2172395661095328, + "veriT": 13.320993066336307, + "Yices": 6.9448803037287155, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968519848236374, + "CVC4": 10.698962141586549, + "CVC3": 9.6211074598932917, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.538669433343868, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4578620320230717 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4152195404537498, + "veriT": 11.285047064113842, + "Yices": 4.3852926851219589, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6313031212307489, + "CVC4": 2.3516114388513829, + "CVC3": 5.6123819476614436, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20852785415875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20444137600449999 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0885334014892578, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.185999612615698, + "veriT": 11.672310636056544, + "Yices": 11.489208734785651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.342293820412724, + "CVC4": 14.56137222538892, + "CVC3": 14.22104061591345, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.943100232771561, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.603641431013976 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.90644197357871, + "veriT": 14.221448427393048, + "Yices": 14.222674703975414, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.17331214691265, + "CVC4": 14.319860597933527, + "CVC3": 13.672023424269371, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8724776307529964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0895758516557308 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7950165411167855, + "veriT": 12.156539369594894, + "Yices": 12.53115488388627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2179317043020479, + "CVC4": 12.400184263876971, + "CVC3": 10.909287871303855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.712980076086058, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.274342987825275 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1789340972900391, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.105926258910818, + "veriT": 13.845637474919684, + "Yices": 13.700787930746142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.839255970650186, + "CVC4": 14.481399873610304, + "CVC3": 8.393989892920505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6360735132362549, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5987393218396617 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.822484143508744, + "veriT": 13.906008337545439, + "Yices": 14.241342344138525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971248015300466, + "CVC4": 14.530201044732054, + "CVC3": 12.407593592652548, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256328603384558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.25929313305511 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7436039447784424, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.820667723343057, + "veriT": 11.584278131530022, + "Yices": 11.720242277752291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.506580700416883, + "CVC4": 9.7136643950487844, + "CVC3": 14.268631835750123, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.27380414034473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.342436063920054 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 29.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.579417768361157, + "veriT": 12.03481856852247, + "Yices": 12.617041226225501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963968584466143, + "CVC4": 14.864920107636021, + "CVC3": 14.243723487849586, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.26500549561703, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.998381461258587 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.031838020854495, + "veriT": 14.23601352130591, + "Yices": 14.064048439888928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.201071593956703, + "CVC4": 14.797175971987611, + "CVC3": 12.453335623684771, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.758573963224118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.966740764529261 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 77.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12209143785011536, + "veriT": 0.092967762290730782, + "Yices": 0.096503617546188442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12049349001676925, + "CVC4": 0.12222021049965386, + "CVC3": 0.09926986924955386, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12006960199503845, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11713534661976924 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10987699126709001, + "veriT": 0.57780422487644489, + "Yices": 0.58048230567469505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11942020894497, + "CVC4": 0.80721292602446781, + "CVC3": 0.082609798520204988, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.80333232618147099, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.80285780438797139 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0480668425363646, + "veriT": 1.2445451916877546, + "Yices": 1.0279721315038892, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1167064655052164, + "CVC4": 1.7244821962370294, + "CVC3": 0.14027568131644441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15822659344666665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16118693659333336 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.304738528575761, + "veriT": 12.199739332022753, + "Yices": 10.947362382317237, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.470485926494053, + "CVC4": 11.371377146419558, + "CVC3": 11.274046442422561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.705371806402848, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.657984130254189 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.403848240898318, + "veriT": 10.181119704308216, + "Yices": 10.312275608987141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956082460203914, + "CVC4": 1.9322353247801434, + "CVC3": 11.674267838298617, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8221798191369043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.130166625777282 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.562455654401651, + "veriT": 9.1682844370022902, + "Yices": 8.6258719466495002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.042629034843296, + "CVC4": 0.17611915972066663, + "CVC3": 9.5895458058826275, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.017746419798476, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.962231117133021 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6191248022544418, + "veriT": 5.7377073658429998, + "Yices": 1.8869930300736544, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4645917261958425, + "CVC4": 4.1119849264559489, + "CVC3": 3.9235489249899356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6610843857794859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6593243530870438 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9564893972800572, + "veriT": 9.8000852087835, + "Yices": 10.901362620917004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0123564090110033, + "CVC4": 13.211079155253705, + "CVC3": 8.2082416891133061, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.062406703628103, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8345632012535518 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9782982604703059, + "veriT": 4.9574099469887658, + "Yices": 5.6035451436359143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.113394457793941, + "CVC4": 1.1934116657499001, + "CVC3": 2.7786086591447732, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8502973095880284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5835696141934745 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.221124828363514, + "veriT": 8.7440756082722864, + "Yices": 8.897327747759002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.835103910880536, + "CVC4": 0.18156996041485712, + "CVC3": 10.127157361665748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.987560566230671, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.358844926449466 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.179796908869037, + "veriT": 10.150888034140909, + "Yices": 10.317802526233546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948644152023364, + "CVC4": 0.15888268221063637, + "CVC3": 11.199608301490473, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17901964765618181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.632624393534183 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.430962096378463, + "veriT": 7.6435328318468754, + "Yices": 10.144563366189573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.696219782076019, + "CVC4": 0.24520234977687499, + "CVC3": 10.752312875085867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8954993216943552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2612334387040081 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.68600001440916, + "veriT": 10.721695579392918, + "Yices": 10.85493691241436, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.262367212170435, + "CVC4": 2.2936141864909927, + "CVC3": 14.94060747946968, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5331531932356253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.30810223165814 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2548256991135522, + "veriT": 7.8927091864639038, + "Yices": 8.6174972169067132, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7613528052021001, + "CVC4": 7.5866230201106237, + "CVC3": 5.2960944995084089, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9218952422051903, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8579975288632644 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.196834735853675, + "veriT": 9.7125418451686443, + "Yices": 9.1899742867302177, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.46860168950725, + "CVC4": 0.16719981947937501, + "CVC3": 1.9748862730994645, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16783783829587501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9260644505917097 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1339285373687744, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.229125731318177, + "veriT": 8.7286433547888578, + "Yices": 10.883874011749143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.841427540840659, + "CVC4": 0.70924688386957147, + "CVC3": 10.681917686967884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4171663893313449, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.107181689936786 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4637153787540411, + "veriT": 9.2704852914718625, + "Yices": 10.997443312896126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0422305098703593, + "CVC4": 0.184515639255875, + "CVC3": 10.066399146419649, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5655652576537138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8139725926285966 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9827812110450473, + "veriT": 14.206388248727347, + "Yices": 10.853933952822446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.727364582021794, + "CVC4": 8.9576391080218301, + "CVC3": 10.568136688360209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.304998958842614, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.344427657445863 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.548697345827192, + "veriT": 1.12391550104407, + "Yices": 7.0177252107235262, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6191663982935576, + "CVC4": 5.8268397769058682, + "CVC3": 5.8187513422243198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22965733384430004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3528496970155626 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4356232806387768, + "veriT": 11.552486425501598, + "Yices": 7.7575943697630585, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.611628404954903, + "CVC4": 11.412472846109148, + "CVC3": 9.9722978101794322, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235481997414901, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.235222831123979 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1963391586998999, + "veriT": 3.95795250937489, + "Yices": 2.5250204433042795, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2484485207562002, + "CVC4": 1.6268435970058559, + "CVC3": 1.7621820273925699, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8046292330172697, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8339691479519242 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0329402341030711, + "veriT": 14.225813236060569, + "Yices": 11.836604437763178, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.686507862707339, + "CVC4": 13.137039036687209, + "CVC3": 10.78864316881949, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25099813313177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.252714324032324 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2592399451168257, + "veriT": 6.3754687224350608, + "Yices": 13.473271838622988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3914572924413955, + "CVC4": 12.91996075187957, + "CVC3": 9.7167010176052457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4239163403561177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4169355447308369 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5491493357730584, + "veriT": 2.5441054415075, + "Yices": 8.0888097358848992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.42980591374749999, + "CVC4": 0.31339215923680003, + "CVC3": 0.39822548750319997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7905165954695672, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9038803326099538 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8686869144439697, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18255342450046666, + "veriT": 13.938307471712303, + "Yices": 1.4423786729178241, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.154330469525471, + "CVC4": 1.3015599216883875, + "CVC3": 0.91282843783842138, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0226009956561297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7884372484061357 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.185953556216, + "veriT": 12.448982184701064, + "Yices": 6.4748899990267494, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4182476041486254, + "CVC4": 2.0370184884632323, + "CVC3": 7.1730561941757562, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4324626293688505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3485565593601452 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9443661307846665, + "veriT": 14.215867647273678, + "Yices": 9.0924831806355488, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9783047619301826, + "CVC4": 8.4574710096397787, + "CVC3": 2.233880423493348, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.975206868823081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.00829728888521 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20612969720692501, + "veriT": 10.164260470419725, + "Yices": 10.352971950521425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28309254451447502, + "CVC4": 0.15047604935322501, + "CVC3": 0.62589238528872504, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14788001593785, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.243339440933976 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7067869901657104, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235630240722811, + "veriT": 10.736923721858966, + "Yices": 10.528160224711215, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955619270592226, + "CVC4": 2.1979197058063731, + "CVC3": 11.530593298758381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7186635719728418, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.76439380629445 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5391069397124388, + "veriT": 11.954298718668024, + "Yices": 5.432725841918999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.458712875299787, + "CVC4": 6.4376342542908054, + "CVC3": 3.3052347219228024, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9780349313147196, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9652036029934674 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14949171578116666, + "veriT": 5.119094247646383, + "Yices": 9.1945433230429217, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17715316789833332, + "CVC4": 7.3718370615775584, + "CVC3": 2.5012612759141239, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8320458956554742, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1387160680465 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13295031468863636, + "veriT": 7.3724433181397453, + "Yices": 7.3753993375882736, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12772714427527274, + "CVC4": 0.13630188362436366, + "CVC3": 0.11163728470536363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13188290492854546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12895765259600001 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0916664600372314, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6704006353776881, + "veriT": 11.479957135566515, + "Yices": 10.606214403991201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8086860189050524, + "CVC4": 9.7430924341268579, + "CVC3": 9.5490020215473077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.196315911889299, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.22487044791273 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.548745016232814, + "veriT": 10.817771359365642, + "Yices": 8.5925454906331655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.152378545476017, + "CVC4": 2.6270137556187514, + "CVC3": 9.5606594869278236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3592593342580059, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.99425621333185 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9013316018884276, + "veriT": 8.8685560657673754, + "Yices": 6.3922337320028753, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0011172177164354, + "CVC4": 7.3770801991695949, + "CVC3": 1.9094041629312608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4534277316376398, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4594734857503147 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22784756022009089, + "veriT": 1.2638862241235089, + "Yices": 4.7863276154791912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.74950278830381822, + "CVC4": 1.6279385794247958, + "CVC3": 0.21056750670374544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5505945176262568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5230472528962018 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3117927028582965, + "veriT": 3.9748230719363749, + "Yices": 9.8976738446691268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.136235678325507, + "CVC4": 1.5222315693577499, + "CVC3": 0.80185328314424997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4208223754195446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4170883737053348 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2111075031255, + "veriT": 8.4403053478759329, + "Yices": 10.183500012120193, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25592423465718578, + "CVC4": 6.2107625568790352, + "CVC3": 0.10288801060928572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.36754569071430004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.26386151140775715 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8652461077367057, + "veriT": 9.2281262688501826, + "Yices": 10.93659718820574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5846766059564059, + "CVC4": 7.990267028533693, + "CVC3": 9.8920165010065695, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.769105320345707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.34880762923096 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0916664600372314, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.474025665518333, + "veriT": 1.7817225357119, + "Yices": 1.7901043351638333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4886621047949995, + "CVC4": 1.8114200045328335, + "CVC3": 2.1709694970703031, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4933529086252997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4877023569227368 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16661482019891663, + "veriT": 0.15129981033158332, + "Yices": 0.9941089317110835, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16264825520066667, + "CVC4": 0.18542438848016671, + "CVC3": 0.16409102820449997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17544586592066666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17300498843158332 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3607170872317778, + "veriT": 7.5668335928149526, + "Yices": 10.877313324386911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6110019280077776, + "CVC4": 3.42587394609451, + "CVC3": 8.9354935147956382, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.451503609311029, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4516862657495482 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14400157659812499, + "veriT": 7.0603797878164753, + "Yices": 0.26249311381757501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18955115000724998, + "CVC4": 1.9405140917812422, + "CVC3": 1.7043155671654602, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5352435043069748, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5951357580904251 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21221086372219999, + "veriT": 1.1965798527236999, + "Yices": 13.085562707821031, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21411236458729999, + "CVC4": 0.24576281702860001, + "CVC3": 0.21822493142009999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21762828065249998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21574608610549997 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1898755841332376, + "veriT": 7.6535545863532493, + "Yices": 8.1297910656754979, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.917626741382813, + "CVC4": 3.8024918731010802, + "CVC3": 1.5079928825908748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4323510557338137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4304657204119362 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4344601673240458, + "veriT": 5.660250982109261, + "Yices": 3.4858050312736788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4658881962319388, + "CVC4": 6.6565953037401693, + "CVC3": 1.7404772709348693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2551427710135363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2672260335107535 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13720547514912501, + "veriT": 0.99136493853229601, + "Yices": 0.12956516986893751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13498801253845, + "CVC4": 0.15073468587403752, + "CVC3": 0.13157829403737498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14554612804594999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14805690925206247 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16143674833673333, + "veriT": 0.14199491394729999, + "Yices": 0.16532968864923334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16007497555226666, + "CVC4": 4.9088800385683458, + "CVC3": 0.1527179302071667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17195474348803333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16379373171779998 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 135.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8620392070048553, + "veriT": 9.1458734264370509, + "Yices": 8.8885589845807846, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2272137881928895, + "CVC4": 14.402833652719631, + "CVC3": 7.1996352041714546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2469355375926385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8920183866321132 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6233703002462478, + "veriT": 4.1914106030916711, + "Yices": 2.6498780625459477, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2359976176100389, + "CVC4": 4.9420930595910564, + "CVC3": 1.9902153791780002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5746930557133467, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5644605229638922 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8936359882354736, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.35178334421324997, + "veriT": 12.176009561668046, + "Yices": 10.268933788060105, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6193532275703175, + "CVC4": 14.331462503767337, + "CVC3": 12.579007276508923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.401689855074659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.157806842617292 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3125386316817, + "veriT": 12.873120450283105, + "Yices": 15.438847134816408, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8599752297636001, + "CVC4": 4.431271923424676, + "CVC3": 9.8388491428357217, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.025923013942283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.02327041665575 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3648572430444448, + "veriT": 7.9449906407768713, + "Yices": 4.3094394768172535, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3674998210475557, + "CVC4": 5.0845991919653297, + "CVC3": 3.2829654286007379, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.56056130008866678, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.55959075447922213 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5324716362924009, + "veriT": 7.8602160778317689, + "Yices": 9.6353462150668427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1620175502476009, + "CVC4": 12.121092167728053, + "CVC3": 2.2647818889894293, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9302384128547327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8504854149312671 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.33224403127811, + "veriT": 9.9791045552849393, + "Yices": 9.6233803982335875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.752102390733135, + "CVC4": 9.7697002022954411, + "CVC3": 12.780280120503443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.945856988381045, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.31453318344734 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.82474942140699, + "veriT": 13.536159142674402, + "Yices": 4.9042674397895105, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.170596019776335, + "CVC4": 0.30420448753416668, + "CVC3": 7.5704346580948254, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.891037958271141, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.883867878315675 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9821300506591797, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.04476771719143, + "veriT": 11.950218219389356, + "Yices": 7.728441580895435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8965423531739916, + "CVC4": 6.658824349510116, + "CVC3": 4.8459196822586605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.740856691932635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.755356976409265 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 230.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9949679482209999, + "veriT": 5.2810107160536255, + "Yices": 6.6763077042687051, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8271409300225265, + "CVC4": 10.733967998346836, + "CVC3": 0.14669830860650002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8900255652154414, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8897408857000804 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22167737781437141, + "veriT": 5.0858283601232284, + "Yices": 2.5776735044586139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3590918548392856, + "CVC4": 0.25948946876685713, + "CVC3": 0.13142746806725714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1363726069334636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1354719774441091 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5550415044602026, + "veriT": 13.803573316355967, + "Yices": 10.676694891453463, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.991380421376915, + "CVC4": 7.4113602999146542, + "CVC3": 6.2478349796023087, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3001409194998432, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3417831619196932 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.283747890212803, + "veriT": 14.221825207446049, + "Yices": 11.663139904909446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.938599233543085, + "CVC4": 14.698968247309381, + "CVC3": 12.641035782085551, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233685585084539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.232452374774045 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6992685966444174, + "veriT": 12.62654377725425, + "Yices": 13.206374453034419, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.406705226815573, + "CVC4": 14.447687214269722, + "CVC3": 10.450497602243702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.871400040540677, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.866360023795326 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0191295146942139, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 88.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7741725444793701, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245121782935918, + "veriT": 12.684103578986441, + "Yices": 11.579610298804194, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96431307375572, + "CVC4": 13.639271765369777, + "CVC3": 11.472638232231898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247443612496237, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.801299454532382 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7055806999169834, + "veriT": 11.810068186463624, + "Yices": 10.899601627723206, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963445293512365, + "CVC4": 4.0846770638933032, + "CVC3": 9.0300196689334005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.844643666690018, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.793102905738872 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.775676965713501, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4101976047683742, + "veriT": 12.238940322866984, + "Yices": 11.107727985683322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971684906280917, + "CVC4": 14.400805592003147, + "CVC3": 14.250624522751437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.506366534761634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.048690307158772 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.246263650550032, + "veriT": 10.187919750747856, + "Yices": 11.741749279308468, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96800256720373, + "CVC4": 14.699112927963496, + "CVC3": 14.245888416847752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256116465945427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.455012896282529 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.787669486343463, + "veriT": 13.56486288630145, + "Yices": 13.731990200604038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.563832627096021, + "CVC4": 14.455899043039699, + "CVC3": 14.24049130267216, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.083680323002881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.825392827152593 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.320733848340911, + "veriT": 13.854988158110821, + "Yices": 13.985296487191924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9406973317683898, + "CVC4": 11.925755966885772, + "CVC3": 10.074676577008757, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.162064935948258, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.139368208742644 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9344425464410522, + "veriT": 13.77966900818064, + "Yices": 14.227051048346546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.369762918299394, + "CVC4": 11.523182191431049, + "CVC3": 11.046954900618884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.857974878108356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.767345620522368 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.283018570447497, + "veriT": 11.747452019141123, + "Yices": 12.50215970179401, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.606165581857944, + "CVC4": 14.385566741428038, + "CVC3": 12.00017866991789, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.737331291472318, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.875487016574017 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1413951073865003, + "veriT": 11.497041329656852, + "Yices": 11.916332060134815, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.238060074333406, + "CVC4": 10.120399757415095, + "CVC3": 11.551441334749706, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4735121777100808, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3751850764314166 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2149412266301161, + "veriT": 14.230058821545457, + "Yices": 13.728971289704345, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959239838236538, + "CVC4": 14.560690627453434, + "CVC3": 11.02518748827525, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.711745771716885, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.721285839832346 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257400551523316, + "veriT": 13.267026140246626, + "Yices": 14.249765094614348, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97814497268031, + "CVC4": 14.594341610040258, + "CVC3": 13.485324967055606, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.643313244306613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.255695109014711 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1128157406938923, + "veriT": 9.3934338655248819, + "Yices": 4.6053417056976809, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1773978257104494, + "CVC4": 4.7236108873605227, + "CVC3": 8.9449044600820233, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3400062936684209, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6925527302908678 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.25, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12748212164003225, + "veriT": 0.097784749923358075, + "Yices": 0.099543652753438697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12321120418816132, + "CVC4": 0.12501510160561291, + "CVC3": 0.10402466109124194, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12064915970409677, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12136198689455484 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.76265847001080822, + "veriT": 1.0062827757821451, + "Yices": 0.91980080140265907, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.80209160773012045, + "CVC4": 1.3996886097113146, + "CVC3": 0.10064109203725452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.75942171023434635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.75708945947049666 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.287521368767155, + "veriT": 11.398308278377959, + "Yices": 11.802023744264391, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.47451234697653, + "CVC4": 12.324745165925309, + "CVC3": 10.249701036363236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.865396084331559, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.784358775338097 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.779141359652559, + "veriT": 10.184502230429752, + "Yices": 10.322869095576875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958242065272417, + "CVC4": 1.4998424806190001, + "CVC3": 11.22763341793287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2108758839343148, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.63803486888856 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.439807222729518, + "veriT": 11.458094180820799, + "Yices": 9.1209907028733745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.886376417808545, + "CVC4": 5.0170292933782221, + "CVC3": 7.9127849730713287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7188837476317147, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.751962453898813 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237779270144594, + "veriT": 10.163872128467279, + "Yices": 10.317837411924057, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95389718123548, + "CVC4": 0.1626141098685, + "CVC3": 13.027916848754529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.174934725890939, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.241680408243742 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.732979650530737, + "veriT": 10.689690116136106, + "Yices": 10.503999311388377, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.35494698908942, + "CVC4": 2.0606603802125805, + "CVC3": 12.397591404017456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2875804618593816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.57883388956115 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8285715579986572, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9321281409811508, + "veriT": 9.6799764506573123, + "Yices": 8.9982333228190008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7535883148141638, + "CVC4": 11.135960272765509, + "CVC3": 7.934236949559053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.715143050620648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9672913172441486 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5511701505074793, + "veriT": 8.3734932163749711, + "Yices": 3.0797683877982793, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2483635886905304, + "CVC4": 8.4446016106076289, + "CVC3": 7.1600395371076884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8598086137911831, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8575073455519373 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0480416433467408, + "veriT": 10.458871474771465, + "Yices": 10.469822782537454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3527684541139511, + "CVC4": 5.1717549430312078, + "CVC3": 11.045517289268474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7875207178078014, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.774902018799169 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9863506194123595, + "veriT": 2.1439111672843998, + "Yices": 5.3687968944822995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1200684961688365, + "CVC4": 0.18964584382869998, + "CVC3": 0.59106661993459997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1954127588482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6227293908522586 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5739594849177125, + "veriT": 9.0524144355144447, + "Yices": 9.5796006541765539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4827252362278056, + "CVC4": 0.16407333812788888, + "CVC3": 4.3122711781957355, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6666176954465781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.16468433212709 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.856757042734728, + "veriT": 11.372046288167848, + "Yices": 11.492859440974133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.475374875384205, + "CVC4": 4.5404102023338568, + "CVC3": 14.172739781453378, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1197590408658256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.831332739284004 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.01266394762985, + "veriT": 8.3768798749397995, + "Yices": 10.938360733890894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5028187138378719, + "CVC4": 4.6944332118061265, + "CVC3": 6.4052113279944551, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8827507100040766, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.937327907083306 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2803924083709717, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4682269885814199, + "veriT": 6.8852986255762714, + "Yices": 7.5865288229275158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9284700558581314, + "CVC4": 0.56282457976945466, + "CVC3": 6.6858049387065712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3642315764896171, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6973861154200982 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0580355943001423, + "veriT": 11.317909386493472, + "Yices": 12.048792188209731, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.396092229263143, + "CVC4": 7.3646604408895842, + "CVC3": 5.3786973449643671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5672493691812974, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5236000288421989 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.38389692248511109, + "veriT": 7.9106288556209741, + "Yices": 7.1014412961795212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9069746977400595, + "CVC4": 6.3326558689288159, + "CVC3": 0.35986996428233337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4285955419683241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4380480266470315 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7965514659881592, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9659064176859138, + "veriT": 5.7710724124639459, + "Yices": 11.355801160564983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.110617816350326, + "CVC4": 1.6308235068099404, + "CVC3": 5.7231776264042526, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8099112795623373, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4955908269075406 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.011448381388877, + "veriT": 8.1434120603763009, + "Yices": 8.2995428830594005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.51646706797864, + "CVC4": 0.1576852716073, + "CVC3": 13.047261435270325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9715229039849818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.042899077490187 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.588406246154765, + "veriT": 12.661887617895554, + "Yices": 9.8564188248505751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.088571594647014, + "CVC4": 11.338564303123471, + "CVC3": 10.189204776407554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.838703233511275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.862983390416879 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.775617150157743, + "veriT": 10.335552605653751, + "Yices": 11.75227277006619, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.493154507970365, + "CVC4": 0.52792308764500007, + "CVC3": 10.041819899692095, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8563403286539648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9290264519454876 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0189029737616999, + "veriT": 8.6923167623582565, + "Yices": 6.4723901744908465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.211755491302769, + "CVC4": 1.2607584807186951, + "CVC3": 4.2129249258561767, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2436008843529307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.243742558829116 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7458438314484166, + "veriT": 6.7463321332115775, + "Yices": 12.468604624285062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7515729049074165, + "CVC4": 10.86797069736941, + "CVC3": 10.050724699372925, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9684890753096083, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9975353590037779 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13552069224989999, + "veriT": 14.210347158778589, + "Yices": 1.4009327568679439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19481040573800001, + "CVC4": 1.7657323108912457, + "CVC3": 1.5322502681571517, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3687722153003685, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3630653249572946 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1537708880228998, + "veriT": 14.206850489806314, + "Yices": 0.61920056362389997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2479885268641002, + "CVC4": 0.23239934333559997, + "CVC3": 0.16168970096390001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.018718898141497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.043227369138116 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8656117704357162, + "veriT": 14.220762412114267, + "Yices": 9.9025242053933287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9167474110359231, + "CVC4": 10.091049624894938, + "CVC3": 6.1123837958747744, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.07450233408067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.07419589003611 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8528139591217041, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1350987200982061, + "veriT": 1.7657852746523661, + "Yices": 1.7964189797487664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2545495033429557, + "CVC4": 0.12494730737566667, + "CVC3": 0.22189937422889996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12139419071799999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0113170695073257 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20681697648812497, + "veriT": 10.16587068972075, + "Yices": 10.351353033090843, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28031561877303124, + "CVC4": 0.14957761934462499, + "CVC3": 0.60572101639140641, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14837754034496875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8684995065380061 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6899039745330811, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23921581713309, + "veriT": 10.152965027788801, + "Yices": 10.335018787299335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958882771522052, + "CVC4": 0.15811665865813335, + "CVC3": 12.05805064657161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.89797778105463211, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.659609784221802 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.880395526749103, + "veriT": 8.4637315764423331, + "Yices": 8.5784118745886673, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.481080699872294, + "CVC4": 0.1756226834803333, + "CVC3": 11.871421035650604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7307942519501474, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.03076690846502 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.582391008249923, + "veriT": 12.512500670294335, + "Yices": 5.3137801824934803, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.101084270094693, + "CVC4": 1.3589714432990538, + "CVC3": 2.9970332900010099, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0107218459268053, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9535086793302563 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4364102156959953, + "veriT": 4.6821898501651544, + "Yices": 8.534327978555778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5147183579657808, + "CVC4": 1.4672142262632362, + "CVC3": 6.5663999939689344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6160998694536184, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.348215560983606 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3179193620941252, + "veriT": 11.688398378852929, + "Yices": 11.674630984383993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.481990548689506, + "CVC4": 14.330804041770637, + "CVC3": 9.7553738688900253, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242652993952937, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.128574719649302 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.782649041258233, + "veriT": 10.192055358904776, + "Yices": 10.371631386743889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977707000709691, + "CVC4": 11.864091237027568, + "CVC3": 12.963924031515209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254103700631084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.318050934665635 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.191166239671858, + "veriT": 11.437851050968368, + "Yices": 5.1004399532647744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.706223607576252, + "CVC4": 2.0762082837462308, + "CVC3": 4.0378442037341236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.481803440566839, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.478930622485478 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0871210098266602, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1770438587401975, + "veriT": 1.827514989959143, + "Yices": 6.4099110178177563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9324945648728713, + "CVC4": 2.293495301890875, + "CVC3": 2.1616189724805994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1412824304367657, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1383494360299236 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0233330726623535, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9285803612352608, + "veriT": 6.38149453722475, + "Yices": 6.4194582600521253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.41569682640637495, + "CVC4": 3.684048185984194, + "CVC3": 0.23360144433174998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7616082699712106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7855089561657795 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8822397600518102, + "veriT": 10.09990443847849, + "Yices": 10.102360150359745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5041573762061127, + "CVC4": 10.465721310483886, + "CVC3": 5.023283975264305, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.268511048847415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.299245393490031 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13950242119620002, + "veriT": 9.1204841057707728, + "Yices": 8.9200704066383825, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31933445966400004, + "CVC4": 3.2859767420641175, + "CVC3": 0.16844558477940003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9740862563245356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.014079181435255 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12794557470596668, + "veriT": 6.7648913876664833, + "Yices": 9.1184568163089104, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12548375021705002, + "CVC4": 1.7989265154083836, + "CVC3": 1.8811470649159998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4418971230560804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4202146693945958 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19545510017358333, + "veriT": 2.7144031426321749, + "Yices": 3.5028763101348921, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22624571403008331, + "CVC4": 1.4300259761512057, + "CVC3": 0.18078486266300833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3582981958276079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3608600014498486 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5500795200306725, + "veriT": 4.9518346298748552, + "Yices": 14.45851933533209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0131614833124702, + "CVC4": 6.0903614618546804, + "CVC3": 11.147231354188202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0828738551803134, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0843603869172393 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 54.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13974458172399998, + "veriT": 0.12471052640742859, + "Yices": 6.4434839937006601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14416991451857145, + "CVC4": 0.14839461819600003, + "CVC3": 0.12572772173499999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1401809915732857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13708670930071429 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1547564972022222, + "veriT": 0.13968961409977779, + "Yices": 0.15587534346133333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.151806097779, + "CVC4": 0.16998863782788887, + "CVC3": 0.15581808433033334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16320960706577781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16420410456555556 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15736927143509999, + "veriT": 0.14198604328510003, + "Yices": 0.15513034376490001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15540706674989999, + "CVC4": 0.1924150330071, + "CVC3": 0.15750903591190002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17578668161569999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17544827901809995 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15091074078899999, + "veriT": 5.1911434337951778, + "Yices": 1.9900263877440878, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15593377863087499, + "CVC4": 2.0001786742090202, + "CVC3": 1.4832871948746249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4356689694161249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9187252400988741 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1286468505859375, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19968543544654549, + "veriT": 2.3656015673846826, + "Yices": 5.167735318399207, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21725086183799999, + "CVC4": 2.7946144997917366, + "CVC3": 0.19429898239837273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.32996385379220911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2194764868937575 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16998252327716667, + "veriT": 11.227086414083617, + "Yices": 6.5283198786999472, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20457545370233332, + "CVC4": 4.2176642592991564, + "CVC3": 6.5689224599492242, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0140534726767365, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.098465944120032 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3178677081619448, + "veriT": 1.2217907649646551, + "Yices": 1.2303798932334544, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3745075585327884, + "CVC4": 1.3126146027961676, + "CVC3": 1.236795414278109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2372678074869998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4039466325463843 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5858644940572439, + "veriT": 12.483358036097306, + "Yices": 8.968674654796148, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.725893304922554, + "CVC4": 9.1022760223298267, + "CVC3": 6.9453998187599373, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7411742807113355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6493404147387762 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.341420532192508, + "veriT": 9.0778221640820007, + "Yices": 9.5966648528969998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.898009943236001, + "CVC4": 3.7000601094614041, + "CVC3": 1.5563554582683332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7630108671171911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.056144134657732 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0294120311737061, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4635243776071194, + "veriT": 1.0512111305273668, + "Yices": 0.29784398761566672, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4644070174833068, + "CVC4": 13.363302016700839, + "CVC3": 0.11407826621762668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12283279226916001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12067881600449333 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5149188855092084, + "veriT": 7.6862672908474501, + "Yices": 7.8543717997741913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4537778159053962, + "CVC4": 6.9168251813415225, + "CVC3": 1.2188984275441666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5615716634420149, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5767390923435065 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7351417919338026, + "veriT": 10.819980388264741, + "Yices": 10.684505581339559, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2637201694363069, + "CVC4": 9.1022032240052191, + "CVC3": 13.146064313915099, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.007056029565955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.774096516393351 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.825968364084769, + "veriT": 9.0097431260311183, + "Yices": 8.6028128771471994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.960234878813484, + "CVC4": 4.6268194801276348, + "CVC3": 4.400442966055687, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8132567225852023, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3241481129715584 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15674055951257143, + "veriT": 10.625613895177144, + "Yices": 4.4402579585096289, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17634900922628574, + "CVC4": 6.2285680930521377, + "CVC3": 2.4888118268223569, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8443331630870001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2169157792702858 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9351869821548462, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6788599491119385, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1973605884206675, + "veriT": 10.595967119227845, + "Yices": 5.1747886795819849, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6721720736926544, + "CVC4": 5.9674039724909598, + "CVC3": 3.1814096689929565, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4064466561537081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4365127722876387 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.902492974148695, + "veriT": 14.221860145686628, + "Yices": 13.679670682840557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.882383139188855, + "CVC4": 14.674272714503529, + "CVC3": 9.8980174582834284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237315309102506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.233227188523223 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.267252219868881, + "veriT": 10.217513418850077, + "Yices": 10.418686331499078, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.993013546038267, + "CVC4": 14.310222032037366, + "CVC3": 14.273774172968619, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.267485421727539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.104552696840038 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257428113749185, + "veriT": 13.574210854886232, + "Yices": 12.817246612938343, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.007668249011852, + "CVC4": 13.666593685825589, + "CVC3": 14.262124970455835, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.588104347633257, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.114955407897769 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6825339736982188, + "veriT": 12.553451014147349, + "Yices": 12.840731941321996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8665458363738239, + "CVC4": 14.65560982532239, + "CVC3": 12.730866335174937, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.013603138063454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.03354984055165 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.835103124857977, + "veriT": 13.965091504390731, + "Yices": 12.909355007883118, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.48387846131366, + "CVC4": 11.207994791986579, + "CVC3": 11.709736733242543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.356337544583942, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.358201297906819 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 162.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.282667082979788, + "veriT": 11.591592991899049, + "Yices": 12.089077842182409, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.394246607997745, + "CVC4": 11.002792900936621, + "CVC3": 7.3505610373646944, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.770864263351438, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.553449058342691 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5714387811986157, + "veriT": 12.871742249829699, + "Yices": 8.188747601919836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8200621924689528, + "CVC4": 12.131633158524386, + "CVC3": 9.5698095056410164, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5595808153399933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5582122108321901 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1031720638275146, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.30716440176030002, + "veriT": 1.8223329444669099, + "Yices": 1.1649029650707998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7955925700178217, + "CVC4": 1.642820927008086, + "CVC3": 0.26569329811480003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5713214851615862, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2894069983477807 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14995009940677501, + "veriT": 6.8133686594876934, + "Yices": 0.12651100752319999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25449097852112496, + "CVC4": 0.156939864293625, + "CVC3": 1.7876762383079499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14528629502670001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14024698757289999 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.981293441539, + "veriT": 11.495527077391513, + "Yices": 9.1485486909302818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7998235978229502, + "CVC4": 4.3981239603169113, + "CVC3": 3.6104105343626665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2101663041112847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2506424017839528 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.971215772168925, + "veriT": 12.419602972838112, + "Yices": 10.244540620167477, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.343125187223706, + "CVC4": 9.2247126767392729, + "CVC3": 7.433274467608598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9042123875626586, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8203800120797373 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.050332863143991, + "veriT": 7.1854259518139081, + "Yices": 10.557209115544348, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7197147831584081, + "CVC4": 9.1058904138109913, + "CVC3": 4.4865845392765467, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9807977401579404, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9313154584468111 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1402695178985596, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7012847254369827, + "veriT": 13.78213208390466, + "Yices": 13.662839787082797, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.185865271266286, + "CVC4": 9.8128841865146867, + "CVC3": 13.868904365206047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4062579736872651, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3345125366593757 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 83.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1875965595245361, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1354856936909208, + "veriT": 11.377160710698806, + "Yices": 13.793570378883452, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.483291515002751, + "CVC4": 14.463403227184203, + "CVC3": 13.027567450459323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.323228303707566, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.113018393662738 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.086748760558715, + "veriT": 13.247105795971464, + "Yices": 14.006880103888101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979995196075167, + "CVC4": 14.576820013305138, + "CVC3": 13.083990299361542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.270053528584381, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.268451333238836 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242308053301979, + "veriT": 13.830475517319353, + "Yices": 13.868300786434029, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960260377872681, + "CVC4": 14.582015522099535, + "CVC3": 13.528662607781451, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.184090658034455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.893471938524437 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.997988535239971, + "veriT": 14.234679627902251, + "Yices": 14.231746663561777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.40302317566818, + "CVC4": 14.713804807247586, + "CVC3": 8.5117313164251183, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5587418753885132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8436302667481197 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12653333983215384, + "veriT": 0.097541982109288494, + "Yices": 0.10027831031955385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12166688464361537, + "CVC4": 0.12388745731823078, + "CVC3": 0.10118208823811922, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1204316948975, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11837687889186924 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11362297750777223, + "veriT": 0.63618830037944452, + "Yices": 0.64150767871076086, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12351864411037222, + "CVC4": 0.88867588281803078, + "CVC3": 0.08638101127057779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.88698218997734013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.88601725691295141 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3812035646707503, + "veriT": 0.10376522354388751, + "Yices": 1.3742295799343376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3768085977957503, + "CVC4": 0.133700528430375, + "CVC3": 0.111673342546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12751534361212502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15078927899775002 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1555554866790771, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8272863222678852, + "veriT": 3.4497556004272223, + "Yices": 3.5111328266618886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0603358055511789, + "CVC4": 0.15029414434711111, + "CVC3": 4.823952093033971, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13971699017744443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8326959923878015 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.63193630942127987, + "veriT": 10.16814864688091, + "Yices": 10.350070398117575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.72045672967984042, + "CVC4": 0.14879317748336363, + "CVC3": 0.6547186084722727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14822770920666667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.147609536876683 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8174605369567871, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5664105022473827, + "veriT": 11.727789360448376, + "Yices": 11.791611594432812, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8807229149326048, + "CVC4": 12.343579184347064, + "CVC3": 8.6569013469751219, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.703167306635939, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.965863988686035 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9468101258848929, + "veriT": 2.9434794033517924, + "Yices": 2.9855514363462841, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4944849525373396, + "CVC4": 1.3723142612745687, + "CVC3": 1.0981811853474928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1365976641288222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1338700103655075 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6794874668121338, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.41428542137146, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2567501178207365, + "veriT": 8.6590669099069046, + "Yices": 9.7424304403616357, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.271317589297162, + "CVC4": 1.37749019762775, + "CVC3": 4.8221128470248003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.89152561163525001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9543033583244274 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243174558566476, + "veriT": 10.174064816773427, + "Yices": 10.338794727030002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964197070128112, + "CVC4": 0.15455521963971428, + "CVC3": 10.798826156762443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.756565381736428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.404439552938296 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6458334922790527, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.466484810140278, + "veriT": 9.2854572212122815, + "Yices": 10.015914944013286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.771040371954514, + "CVC4": 8.5756757005927025, + "CVC3": 11.045424646843509, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1980712190895666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.320397167505675 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.334552861260789, + "veriT": 11.061452605818852, + "Yices": 10.643222776430111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.883204495370808, + "CVC4": 3.4712493465782543, + "CVC3": 11.355107708448472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2757415922855846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.567935431958437 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1714286804199219, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.428624789698809, + "veriT": 9.781841048177677, + "Yices": 11.402667522499531, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.001625304953645, + "CVC4": 7.3163340605225216, + "CVC3": 10.124682396645186, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.713580868975475, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.301593509793934 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.216627991557596, + "veriT": 10.996892285508366, + "Yices": 10.283150222228786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.752155482020495, + "CVC4": 1.1552480443136002, + "CVC3": 10.448478365835667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.458755848067935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.062362551796928 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.100867903432714, + "veriT": 10.438969176632913, + "Yices": 10.313043784301929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.601827916056289, + "CVC4": 7.0123811450908367, + "CVC3": 11.106648966712857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.015729395558429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4333821544626666 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8992531251060099, + "veriT": 11.09679308362576, + "Yices": 9.1722309372804904, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0637436133315088, + "CVC4": 7.2941490761032419, + "CVC3": 8.7814508896760692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6739371410910291, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6870807495613462 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4741843957984502, + "veriT": 5.1588107631287636, + "Yices": 9.0190129218810995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7149202193645356, + "CVC4": 1.9801794368466146, + "CVC3": 5.4581076999896192, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.57054005325592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6104167112272751 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8622126401138139, + "veriT": 5.9001269876862956, + "Yices": 6.6793383185786368, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2110870114159864, + "CVC4": 0.18286743452266666, + "CVC3": 5.8206647339097142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17401649978222222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9023796399786019 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6038964986801147, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9788231024126279, + "veriT": 7.6732966115862489, + "Yices": 8.01612457041875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1289553851034917, + "CVC4": 0.294302514116625, + "CVC3": 5.291671775955038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3768519843274394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.273124067942753 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1191246087847011, + "veriT": 8.9414206390568474, + "Yices": 4.4639889320126134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4829113782515178, + "CVC4": 2.0834152396801313, + "CVC3": 4.5402337638480583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8670062027721879, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1152257009376276 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.44443482533127782, + "veriT": 4.8063997945090815, + "Yices": 0.26428393079446666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0600378863061746, + "CVC4": 5.0661373980098423, + "CVC3": 4.8131335238948401, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8271825735820411, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8245309769254199 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6393491063844516, + "veriT": 9.7280111279646686, + "Yices": 10.72177289138229, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5189992093082858, + "CVC4": 6.261059289948129, + "CVC3": 3.4044365754050001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2331905855763994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4086043778750739 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8639927877094014, + "veriT": 14.230156029837174, + "Yices": 13.525475564650957, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.915283551188606, + "CVC4": 13.207815183931524, + "CVC3": 9.2792752016184537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237713277865543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237680769670227 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3916054148660795, + "veriT": 8.9584596901629148, + "Yices": 5.7332073800885244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3598596500180484, + "CVC4": 9.0100374101543235, + "CVC3": 7.5184824247377371, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.210064864799891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.508408902430553 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.658054736416773, + "veriT": 13.591357841485989, + "Yices": 12.590571780286332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.22316114430361, + "CVC4": 14.797635304625091, + "CVC3": 14.479899252044492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.357890630769116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.14418677021005 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0240249712927163, + "veriT": 5.1630251087385934, + "Yices": 7.8117756336278088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2705149670376925, + "CVC4": 1.5865172745106852, + "CVC3": 8.8717080330963007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9796431278004798, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2141918227416344 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5531322085834667, + "veriT": 2.5342191062122863, + "Yices": 12.382995724079251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5014798864237, + "CVC4": 7.3171025552817444, + "CVC3": 9.9216391235655781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7168976244092959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6955740631516627 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8612639904022217, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14269428364688888, + "veriT": 0.13127409133074447, + "Yices": 0.27552266833344441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13950241818255557, + "CVC4": 0.21973872934677777, + "CVC3": 0.15611877383833331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4228566749859448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4206316902876672 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1731832133321647, + "veriT": 2.1398303493509454, + "Yices": 9.1833501915255926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4457425624744724, + "CVC4": 8.3128304226902596, + "CVC3": 0.31735800252085716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20262496231328572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20397766583514285 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.65368851889542856, + "veriT": 11.541073222491931, + "Yices": 7.8311572515824919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9603650415887151, + "CVC4": 2.4014604065971659, + "CVC3": 4.7727390263887139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6544551872978102, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2189315138219099 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19679291765750001, + "veriT": 13.91671716222038, + "Yices": 1.1273938144143831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2710718384741475, + "CVC4": 2.3850129281174755, + "CVC3": 0.9480171316440229, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.414860827718254, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.165148213888051 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.955571198605039, + "veriT": 14.214427565338651, + "Yices": 12.923934684094213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2361075496446485, + "CVC4": 10.601856448306831, + "CVC3": 9.9470873349216635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225712950962372, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.227565369880164 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7067869901657104, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.101462508397859, + "veriT": 12.517500250506512, + "Yices": 6.1860201870115716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.309311364590615, + "CVC4": 2.2241897366603021, + "CVC3": 8.2095067444423364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.182642917950016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0406466022274774 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.479393459238297, + "veriT": 11.257282994949787, + "Yices": 11.429863154777566, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.108183549482364, + "CVC4": 9.1146166965814039, + "CVC3": 12.344495438106003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.304593897138085, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.166475548896365 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14277253459709091, + "veriT": 2.8484985693729268, + "Yices": 5.4157989670005566, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14231680960336363, + "CVC4": 1.4378591591016836, + "CVC3": 0.1335367951483091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14195714624754546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14631239494472728 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17949498033514286, + "veriT": 8.9485900931919993, + "Yices": 5.024186246794903, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.36363880392600001, + "CVC4": 0.41040443680728572, + "CVC3": 0.20134350069971432, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1440830898158056, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1938606572924568 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8218860405447792, + "veriT": 7.3208364372403816, + "Yices": 7.9552320504976439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4492876708029421, + "CVC4": 2.6584045925157485, + "CVC3": 4.2834784119547047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.28252774933676472, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5205843884654926 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.919561543709946, + "veriT": 9.2650434628993761, + "Yices": 10.10193032243154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.279226116188701, + "CVC4": 9.806393964991333, + "CVC3": 8.1327535727633649, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.0465534188183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.012947650798367 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5587428553128726, + "veriT": 4.8901463679765387, + "Yices": 12.494864562348706, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8509443803015291, + "CVC4": 7.4815462782823712, + "CVC3": 10.100715591311486, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0246999802305359, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0099725120574696 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0710785388946533, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.636171674356083, + "veriT": 0.94348254293511646, + "Yices": 0.94710820046258337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6420229606332497, + "CVC4": 0.9718618621691667, + "CVC3": 1.141311784123485, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3145538396567331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3110604442149516 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17811314821733334, + "veriT": 0.16734428401349999, + "Yices": 1.8425219267859168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17665607610966669, + "CVC4": 0.1931615771156667, + "CVC3": 0.17856321666066666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18661359652783335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18268393331849997 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15372839991510001, + "veriT": 0.13177132666540001, + "Yices": 0.15082193823390003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14644670470920002, + "CVC4": 0.17494778744709999, + "CVC3": 0.15213166203700001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16679444877630001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16515919568609999 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0223747749594556, + "veriT": 9.4110424184270904, + "Yices": 5.9055849836259302, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0778329845283279, + "CVC4": 1.0843564153682608, + "CVC3": 2.7816665571414152, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.020336536146675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1472350588180249 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24834919279499998, + "veriT": 2.0706008288422457, + "Yices": 8.206541128532665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.72813795433442863, + "CVC4": 0.21053769289800001, + "CVC3": 0.213818266408, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20905833999699999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20558061695000002 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17052739913312501, + "veriT": 1.912457450244508, + "Yices": 1.4274897618592501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18117268694124999, + "CVC4": 1.9531743096494087, + "CVC3": 0.4800971326615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.34767225865175, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5739944701517044 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6751704235615845, + "veriT": 2.4181685610277923, + "Yices": 2.4670783944247003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8223511570792676, + "CVC4": 8.841037585606573, + "CVC3": 0.9333440857121923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.231201345764998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2411873482789846 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1854917111174341, + "veriT": 7.1945851303120811, + "Yices": 1.6638267392248749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2818777823687793, + "CVC4": 3.7638674836173127, + "CVC3": 1.5714103332513749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7017430617530751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6960884724005778 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6223256634798915, + "veriT": 13.08694958055634, + "Yices": 8.6217502948651124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7064610545863292, + "CVC4": 13.085692687221899, + "CVC3": 7.6642625078904727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.721199404882972, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6999825615058146 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5872728749388672, + "veriT": 3.8631319293745747, + "Yices": 0.15983211862346669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5710912203911338, + "CVC4": 2.0869244970499499, + "CVC3": 0.17910453323586667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17475427299506666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17567626508619999 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.422345827292844, + "veriT": 12.858224189605151, + "Yices": 5.498061555551768, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3850721835645281, + "CVC4": 6.5446848903335715, + "CVC3": 9.5462593871062165, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5059226343161676, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5016938084785014 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4676391563150331, + "veriT": 8.6160039233516166, + "Yices": 11.644989365460665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1516169825901859, + "CVC4": 14.383074363341347, + "CVC3": 11.413189223195795, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.56334921791583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.701970327865324 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2302427231516218, + "veriT": 11.516114139527614, + "Yices": 11.561944721521442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.861794327814659, + "CVC4": 9.7401781666821954, + "CVC3": 5.7695906985678214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.541157892255232, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.336507996751452 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3386696028683049, + "veriT": 7.5976222423531823, + "Yices": 6.4990325746730617, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7202660789532294, + "CVC4": 5.3154366051590163, + "CVC3": 2.6182469819144285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0145022667164385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1975606725097112 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6513195037841797, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.200605515721703, + "veriT": 13.630109157606674, + "Yices": 6.3728706310554468, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.035602623178808, + "CVC4": 8.5768216853334422, + "CVC3": 3.6111721017529428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.130346494673285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.154101226286519 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9262801914293615, + "veriT": 11.770628559513634, + "Yices": 11.858972736081531, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.049581944147665, + "CVC4": 11.684742559427363, + "CVC3": 9.7326835845184032, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.021055370326859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.984160809445843 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236099358588932, + "veriT": 12.414267315277767, + "Yices": 11.447683842245407, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954394440569976, + "CVC4": 13.575395235540665, + "CVC3": 12.882554622437304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23310535219427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.931914990297521 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.253242696097963, + "veriT": 10.183728669317778, + "Yices": 10.337757233379545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975539179209992, + "CVC4": 14.27701930246719, + "CVC3": 14.248250069532382, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251923788098212, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.06510838572941 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9466914928764527, + "veriT": 11.851336455364937, + "Yices": 7.2646428351138459, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6143282841146549, + "CVC4": 5.6563501263791398, + "CVC3": 0.38797617227837505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6935661337522094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6912898066758286 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17071694541157501, + "veriT": 0.12265690317925, + "Yices": 1.0142758592199126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1060916410875001, + "CVC4": 0.14156934402349999, + "CVC3": 0.12819215971822501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13259083774135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1312635740607625 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9668915271759033, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0588470183308569, + "veriT": 11.994040401519987, + "Yices": 2.5250381283583336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1106986203905658, + "CVC4": 1.900199531064406, + "CVC3": 2.0523562641625706, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7803495116782615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0141976227715794 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9953250760521009, + "veriT": 12.230973283310089, + "Yices": 12.246382469459471, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4470232465269177, + "CVC4": 3.0000039948489281, + "CVC3": 2.5222104962621001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3520162543491878, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9548134954697183 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 112.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.698516752546074, + "veriT": 12.399990054086873, + "Yices": 13.430389328476323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.378638292405165, + "CVC4": 14.348214455551544, + "CVC3": 7.2131568134896611, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7159050699610425, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.712656360990108 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.652299058955636, + "veriT": 11.885787770840567, + "Yices": 12.263661625872194, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955087376145967, + "CVC4": 14.373354064136878, + "CVC3": 13.757246352605819, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244440636550328, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.239585208684044 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9440492852655717, + "veriT": 12.735578891546748, + "Yices": 9.4007600219331664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.909743513647015, + "CVC4": 10.109805768144, + "CVC3": 13.881456827021154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.767047432843972, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4784480744443371 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6235858003694994, + "veriT": 13.08094771585281, + "Yices": 14.24041662614769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1117316654828331, + "CVC4": 12.042047048713473, + "CVC3": 12.860544953555312, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.909687671057073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.908481265641006 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.216674609308411, + "veriT": 14.214602410589963, + "Yices": 13.306567636048221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.081608697703651, + "CVC4": 14.324903551101846, + "CVC3": 14.216169068552848, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.393120854405813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.393019624429606 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9162280861269263, + "veriT": 5.9592343063550004, + "Yices": 11.547911214885016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.886603971189366, + "CVC4": 14.59455397495336, + "CVC3": 6.2357665581145278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1186274226256625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1254657941207418 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 167.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8354722870983569, + "veriT": 12.888371194504552, + "Yices": 13.66795885320415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963800438482798, + "CVC4": 14.479133086361747, + "CVC3": 11.427989819604001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.005402240260178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.726461059886752 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0215737410284715, + "veriT": 14.235348362550225, + "Yices": 14.231147433284018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.14058567425554, + "CVC4": 11.09628267128933, + "CVC3": 9.3992986705489887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7502179165881948, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7701451302316906 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 77.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.162494210113776, + "veriT": 11.543170901730779, + "Yices": 12.817459857629025, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.970529415327341, + "CVC4": 14.52589490688292, + "CVC3": 14.250682742991389, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.027755811896753, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.608620038895738 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259779016131567, + "veriT": 14.246231612192737, + "Yices": 14.092993317322907, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.051285352712638, + "CVC4": 14.723773203631055, + "CVC3": 10.276778051920223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.879644383556423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.316269096549526 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4166665077209473, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12116895711175998, + "veriT": 0.091206272231820013, + "Yices": 0.093226544514149995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11810917069825333, + "CVC4": 0.11940491302002, + "CVC3": 0.097273361336476655, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11742283920322666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11533587114437335 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1013389422690598, + "veriT": 0.074972479855510005, + "Yices": 0.076302432163039988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1004938495121901, + "CVC4": 0.096292084442809997, + "CVC3": 0.078924553513179993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.09900624307054999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.099050975244909994 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2038910541556538, + "veriT": 7.4781745826748773, + "Yices": 7.5813013351966489, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5575110363796272, + "CVC4": 2.6107820758610756, + "CVC3": 5.0547310675352604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.489280466753288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6065299119631966 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2042092867347105, + "veriT": 9.6353150833521326, + "Yices": 9.8144742654137378, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28553202337834205, + "CVC4": 0.15117685105386841, + "CVC3": 0.62089644749997375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14923559888315791, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.421088620865202 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4097561882734642, + "veriT": 11.953640604037076, + "Yices": 11.292800667961943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5119902271110597, + "CVC4": 13.112733694638044, + "CVC3": 10.487201031484474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.466742189577809, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.466748891942778 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2777941390045884, + "veriT": 6.8376087702549997, + "Yices": 6.9291185594895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1694120590174091, + "CVC4": 0.15869539949083333, + "CVC3": 4.0515771158969995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14568363647849999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5576474807540466 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.441539552452108, + "veriT": 10.183786752547386, + "Yices": 10.325540642985308, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957821950887627, + "CVC4": 1.8096856288870002, + "CVC3": 10.731129950069684, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3405585135974514, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.491924769951009 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240133777726276, + "veriT": 10.164629140704271, + "Yices": 10.333615313666543, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957830194533591, + "CVC4": 0.17009387337000001, + "CVC3": 13.776409434041483, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.20732043778739, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.302221371193928 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.654514520073961, + "veriT": 10.738269292046835, + "Yices": 10.522660915749714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.263086452340348, + "CVC4": 2.3735131324652348, + "CVC3": 11.595452819941752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2940524984480675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.619388726491959 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.889982405242762, + "veriT": 8.475102210166499, + "Yices": 8.5531596892848327, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.481975576166278, + "CVC4": 4.8666620501401683, + "CVC3": 9.6924467667521252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0375340309065297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.534296896688315 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234916802368323, + "veriT": 10.15475397825489, + "Yices": 10.327286166372888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95267721393213, + "CVC4": 0.27149753741822225, + "CVC3": 13.021013177001846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.51959255511066671, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.675893934329585 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2027039250085436, + "veriT": 4.4417874109565965, + "Yices": 8.5238678742153802, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.68980113101897, + "CVC4": 2.0297163071645881, + "CVC3": 2.4766736168006873, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8484170440484036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3813048994658672 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237430311252544, + "veriT": 10.151652036395999, + "Yices": 10.323303679305857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956303971152186, + "CVC4": 0.155876293241, + "CVC3": 9.5168550760042088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3426211604498519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.255623901354038 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248258816367972, + "veriT": 10.908482051489996, + "Yices": 8.490974520809182, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.102245989889722, + "CVC4": 0.15896836722499999, + "CVC3": 11.684657137274082, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14849590013009092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3531966481958477 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1416519818413125, + "veriT": 6.2454060132401068, + "Yices": 9.5598955021212504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1748946984968125, + "CVC4": 4.7403199277205532, + "CVC3": 2.7895538378242022, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7920581770066106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15218679718293751 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1269841194152832, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8660714626312256, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.184136555433883, + "veriT": 9.7926895114563663, + "Yices": 11.936503598308811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.183955739284723, + "CVC4": 11.527304087436072, + "CVC3": 9.2986748856079817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.661356242270221, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1216287662119484 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3797970526456664, + "veriT": 6.6060092384483777, + "Yices": 7.1211618068249471, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7104895724923406, + "CVC4": 2.5419993872852462, + "CVC3": 3.3159461141083151, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7119816422761431, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0313011666688805 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.183849919361322, + "veriT": 12.652638744601514, + "Yices": 11.13328606036449, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.50329860027359, + "CVC4": 12.11155565302577, + "CVC3": 11.075243297240105, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.187893553668538, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.178292328253606 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.43707676600056367, + "veriT": 10.978782063036558, + "Yices": 3.811121606745091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8402809529479702, + "CVC4": 8.1015147111637855, + "CVC3": 2.6986640578024939, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.349798288591197, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8458103868635503 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8075406509625669, + "veriT": 8.5829366945450793, + "Yices": 11.715515769301744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5755304343294991, + "CVC4": 10.029146565335164, + "CVC3": 10.667588541072458, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9219239195761846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.937684333209452 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5005445531590498, + "veriT": 7.8900298214349789, + "Yices": 5.5606975806037067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6565765975042588, + "CVC4": 0.16035900278188889, + "CVC3": 3.6635615618686561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15025446783711108, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6879423498470669 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.869583084964223, + "veriT": 10.518799509843841, + "Yices": 10.444719575822544, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.527821414315149, + "CVC4": 2.3892110934604647, + "CVC3": 13.450373794297604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9446071801097009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.701938110697842 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5762271446990459, + "veriT": 6.2512490643402048, + "Yices": 8.3981613934712644, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0654647983779331, + "CVC4": 4.2345856095469045, + "CVC3": 4.5290158544493577, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8256117822532305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.484042444705741 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "exists", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4094389690142579, + "veriT": 9.8507579015821189, + "Yices": 11.56600143744863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4297889611173344, + "CVC4": 12.506448752595329, + "CVC3": 8.537994201409651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.372259148530185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.727349971365813 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.19971379859431, + "veriT": 12.682021622710264, + "Yices": 12.508607187725966, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.72635949840606, + "CVC4": 7.4380065613439363, + "CVC3": 14.215483564728066, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.964175430102705, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.963090031946551 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12176104237243751, + "veriT": 0.094462725661362504, + "Yices": 0.096043048958850019, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11260969345784999, + "CVC4": 0.11974870200224999, + "CVC3": 0.10132611953974999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11917294987075001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11771481036082501 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.101515531539917, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2075869424297441, + "veriT": 13.360320922840154, + "Yices": 12.167177749294021, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.194634240599425, + "CVC4": 10.061379966969895, + "CVC3": 10.025597910553676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.944729606482571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.299537132692461 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4437574483091424, + "veriT": 6.2237544590271217, + "Yices": 8.3251683199457425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8080314321638191, + "CVC4": 7.4579622037247812, + "CVC3": 3.707634332140084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7720288890218452, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3885484819911795 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9658534999907835, + "veriT": 4.5646550367911489, + "Yices": 8.8156467979488013, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1090906906953952, + "CVC4": 3.075771273438304, + "CVC3": 4.1654613327827406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5696707883938288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8136836818327531 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7080507398624549, + "veriT": 3.0691437059125879, + "Yices": 2.6951273646515777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7567807604864552, + "CVC4": 0.16957550742045455, + "CVC3": 2.0160571171539816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8166766637464011, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8118441112162191 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4767497180516607, + "veriT": 11.640056840949825, + "Yices": 8.1647697809135149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8450943244595273, + "CVC4": 12.287191050400979, + "CVC3": 12.894268578162, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.198378556308814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.179765094510921 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 37.0, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21662671758542856, + "veriT": 2.1520151802809839, + "Yices": 4.3005796257429854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.39270099511100004, + "CVC4": 0.23441178796057141, + "CVC3": 1.6493764069407142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4023270596715718, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4444574618507144 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1646121864472523, + "veriT": 9.8811845235127809, + "Yices": 12.173156297779526, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8536621126049084, + "CVC4": 2.5897482305525559, + "CVC3": 0.33970756596185719, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.74116186260571415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7782049097806745 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1147422420600002, + "veriT": 4.1293937911356586, + "Yices": 1.391964827659558, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4503292048633638, + "CVC4": 1.0874153869952727, + "CVC3": 1.125250918399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6257181064304036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6146875102705762 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0207641480738125, + "veriT": 14.209928062102497, + "Yices": 0.18045081978249999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0627927501333749, + "CVC4": 0.28917324493300001, + "CVC3": 0.12966481514606248, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.49797333695628, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.501987284040071 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.208750747448633, + "veriT": 13.956463714608171, + "Yices": 7.4256128982326555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.432844582492518, + "CVC4": 8.3550109245129836, + "CVC3": 8.4386619098997571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.09146799676558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.045636328292554 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20225155515325, + "veriT": 14.2178280615896, + "Yices": 12.748079188571394, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2093189740813335, + "CVC4": 10.67312692919387, + "CVC3": 13.019530589183512, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.589430864716626, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.57452591191344 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1206138936255829, + "veriT": 12.333468298496516, + "Yices": 4.8740880432140354, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7417940719855847, + "CVC4": 4.3296512297581708, + "CVC3": 4.8766071052367774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.408760885583847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.409411795426706 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2276568249814757, + "veriT": 8.9039683552594813, + "Yices": 8.0697706024987532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6200050466971565, + "CVC4": 2.4878860939625032, + "CVC3": 2.3001290037766302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.047085688186788, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0682167410921459 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4057160254102188, + "veriT": 8.5929980135706856, + "Yices": 10.764109705843563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7070019963765226, + "CVC4": 5.7062668185515557, + "CVC3": 1.7181447625846862, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5996292995872814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.448551942878796 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15229961045889998, + "veriT": 0.1344952207265, + "Yices": 0.14286572890669999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14878507378319999, + "CVC4": 0.17395479209100001, + "CVC3": 0.14672191899780002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16171654473039998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16247991493969999 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8102363203536667, + "veriT": 0.11894916425383335, + "Yices": 0.137261709669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8071190798358334, + "CVC4": 0.15949510055166666, + "CVC3": 0.13906109841616665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15180239506433335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15545484298316667 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16205147992233335, + "veriT": 2.4941448595005227, + "Yices": 2.5113314324116973, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16726328962616666, + "CVC4": 0.18532259401616669, + "CVC3": 0.16865009671316666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17846260492483332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17488300554866665 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12524198634833333, + "veriT": 4.3349438211291424, + "Yices": 1.2026541868043779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7605136870771529, + "CVC4": 6.5193973216760925, + "CVC3": 0.12109649930586668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11345484710791112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1153585444095111 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 53.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11236486221852308, + "veriT": 11.983274312981958, + "Yices": 9.0144713735440529, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12054419631756154, + "CVC4": 1.2195088217595047, + "CVC3": 5.7450000740893747, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5552820321545244, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5797170960537406 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6770038205869202, + "veriT": 6.9701744207633025, + "Yices": 9.8142231941524223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4387813490549028, + "CVC4": 4.4346670483036359, + "CVC3": 5.8353308765773306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.605980415163959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4128867808791732 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0429424856275711, + "veriT": 1.6782052858309999, + "Yices": 9.4461590266511699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0537076174938567, + "CVC4": 4.2673659057590001, + "CVC3": 2.2164723438854081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2014130993293461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2043774606778839 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.162741019061, + "veriT": 6.0123761594256946, + "Yices": 2.1566464913549854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1906409908889167, + "CVC4": 1.3655541525426464, + "CVC3": 1.2220776218198333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1690196840250833, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16762860472024999 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 120.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.741914595313292, + "veriT": 10.680518952119213, + "Yices": 10.5384612100545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.371306203917271, + "CVC4": 10.777637536507989, + "CVC3": 13.620508688109638, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.487894379155744, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.264189988139091 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6639115787046168, + "veriT": 10.807126129337961, + "Yices": 10.432420763314301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.265639239625644, + "CVC4": 8.9468110593189838, + "CVC3": 10.090391752090328, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.926117813369292, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.043224800863927 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.87900846499200003, + "veriT": 11.35118516447212, + "Yices": 3.4687881101900837, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4048138936228884, + "CVC4": 6.5833349736786761, + "CVC3": 4.2027099280791598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2104945564110183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5052744953560762 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0339004993438721, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7367093220674708, + "veriT": 1.5771111734897418, + "Yices": 1.3447765382381001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7514946265517644, + "CVC4": 1.8559497567718886, + "CVC3": 1.0062472817617489, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0930566330646858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6630940906685137 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.185226248634117, + "veriT": 11.815362739731258, + "Yices": 10.543250397035216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4833034097977382, + "CVC4": 7.0716493076496905, + "CVC3": 5.4691646678647885, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3763666406080155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2723581705602669 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 131.0, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5881042198797113, + "veriT": 12.208512136039527, + "Yices": 10.192784291614416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.598428170511655, + "CVC4": 11.238792164145087, + "CVC3": 8.7657456554420392, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235639814123724, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.913438890080279 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.226095344523072, + "veriT": 13.093808646614212, + "Yices": 13.109647563448272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.937232374652144, + "CVC4": 13.579062614895401, + "CVC3": 4.352714902293342, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.081990516229617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.058729813467654 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 111.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9631427445294181, + "veriT": 13.198251480125016, + "Yices": 12.851491713255015, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.292180556718808, + "CVC4": 14.743728661982022, + "CVC3": 12.600207073054765, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.296047747876065, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.292787535163001 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.84482481426623, + "veriT": 13.731236468386976, + "Yices": 13.12283293325323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96500604178242, + "CVC4": 14.419433684114235, + "CVC3": 14.24283894127479, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.561443571642323, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.120829206085009 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2444012929330741, + "veriT": 8.9376099243346339, + "Yices": 6.7574820156188808, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1427329898586587, + "CVC4": 5.8786145840499984, + "CVC3": 5.8699264616272728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.405206653745621, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.414456779557849 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.265621852810348, + "veriT": 11.142285807249733, + "Yices": 12.922956129242831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.802639160328471, + "CVC4": 14.247653123381859, + "CVC3": 9.4942694232823595, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.09328303573259, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.150988401929393 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.587631590227756, + "veriT": 11.181210855699009, + "Yices": 11.249762360722906, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.010707980352661, + "CVC4": 14.394188659686128, + "CVC3": 14.237047987525804, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.080703969288768, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.288743487672262 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 171.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3918258069466427, + "veriT": 12.87569552417134, + "Yices": 11.517322702177514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7742547476478991, + "CVC4": 12.206082457588934, + "CVC3": 9.0776045507317882, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8635244481969515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8186253088893158 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6329124714750902, + "veriT": 11.324864535436189, + "Yices": 8.9251787278778423, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7918882343615712, + "CVC4": 2.2418808720457779, + "CVC3": 4.3466136074737278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5707289425228561, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.287275446647036 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.40259176582754547, + "veriT": 9.7208733578383537, + "Yices": 1.1588884248605453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2481548639222835, + "CVC4": 0.52698416029827277, + "CVC3": 10.169749883551779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17213196257981819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.225047565461395 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.973421048673302, + "veriT": 14.27174463754624, + "Yices": 11.47324320828918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.217450794309634, + "CVC4": 3.3038708952533846, + "CVC3": 3.3743142751979605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.40335444696289996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.38978185353310002 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1087884902954102, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.779650391520672, + "veriT": 13.41023645928342, + "Yices": 13.410200159537279, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.029458591191295, + "CVC4": 8.9419068125114087, + "CVC3": 14.220667241623033, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238562406227889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.239101144394263 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.388060804593426, + "veriT": 12.083300632154197, + "Yices": 14.134236354664573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5556309295142121, + "CVC4": 13.447157964110932, + "CVC3": 10.376336340676367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9172512472709613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.45448482518615 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.533185835068451, + "veriT": 14.226617885755681, + "Yices": 14.227990881442016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.29284090187384, + "CVC4": 14.339657993478864, + "CVC3": 13.757940324587947, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.585733262092914, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.49765047663684 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 129.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9650838367458823, + "veriT": 13.42263473102107, + "Yices": 12.824028558162913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.966201907659341, + "CVC4": 13.426711951729519, + "CVC3": 8.5655278338270708, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.556852341488241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8764467071843729 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1372451782226562, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.366191727509182, + "veriT": 12.493337407194755, + "Yices": 12.510315326246662, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.495955520734087, + "CVC4": 12.949781008176403, + "CVC3": 13.977131722222738, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.469573876384223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.182135411737248 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254921271797292, + "veriT": 13.601718552983819, + "Yices": 14.243700032305846, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973894534332416, + "CVC4": 14.651341381133436, + "CVC3": 12.679238937482195, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.938401189992826, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.249362522174566 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2585049544364981, + "veriT": 5.2399893707350786, + "Yices": 4.6589832921705208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5214765788560154, + "CVC4": 5.4269326953594206, + "CVC3": 3.3508581864429625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5531994688178217, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4986246336947557 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.875, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12081023822640001, + "veriT": 0.092713634775320006, + "Yices": 0.096971180096456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11873700917800002, + "CVC4": 0.12098922169199999, + "CVC3": 0.098887830957007997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11682938709116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11643715016447199 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12659254855203333, + "veriT": 1.5131131829593858, + "Yices": 1.5152470354624239, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15109713225412377, + "CVC4": 2.1242852707074369, + "CVC3": 0.089745457432542849, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1197736320544314, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1188308694285944 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8995585161141246, + "veriT": 1.868716479144745, + "Yices": 3.1484886934251874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8945511014849998, + "CVC4": 1.9897065943125569, + "CVC3": 1.8791077856121561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8941584998663414, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9170865177768077 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1739735593920364, + "veriT": 9.8172827119944124, + "Yices": 9.9981862486817494, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2956474104985398, + "CVC4": 0.14813569603434482, + "CVC3": 0.64444191264824147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14793559897396552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.482374347546831 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5074416331366685, + "veriT": 9.565749514373195, + "Yices": 9.5500007712763697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4142392408501721, + "CVC4": 12.398057247491888, + "CVC3": 8.1639739356934129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.088691807812793, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5340211851318131 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1666665077209473, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.384967299009512, + "veriT": 9.0660745502584437, + "Yices": 10.330916113933556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.334977516571975, + "CVC4": 0.15688216472077776, + "CVC3": 5.6490537858484435, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7196355262001701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.292745221303569 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.348911996707129, + "veriT": 10.213122857113555, + "Yices": 10.335694243673778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963408904297223, + "CVC4": 3.7362072696641118, + "CVC3": 11.685633091458932, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7425376185631061, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.340812666086752 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6753089463112758, + "veriT": 6.1677911044378, + "Yices": 10.341143780670299, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1151655286116497, + "CVC4": 0.18018377047010001, + "CVC3": 8.019813269287555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.434863300849679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.301612213518526 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7907570515616182, + "veriT": 6.9641706655410474, + "Yices": 7.6807810209505121, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.071901892375001, + "CVC4": 1.1849575405572002, + "CVC3": 6.7918697333364566, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8765776563512073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0436501919319365 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14007287277716668, + "veriT": 4.1252039126934266, + "Yices": 5.8213407445651848, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13496663636466666, + "CVC4": 4.8504366236987391, + "CVC3": 0.13930099929249998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4854763212253204, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13703165589616667 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5982145071029663, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.955115602603723, + "veriT": 9.2524692554004542, + "Yices": 9.4067663638168177, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.605299657239364, + "CVC4": 0.22132048995690912, + "CVC3": 9.9407399459381978, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4238054885224551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.498625697683623 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240890300203088, + "veriT": 10.163105811585286, + "Yices": 10.347823771466286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960458301262213, + "CVC4": 0.15362453814299998, + "CVC3": 10.588952724424999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14700213028242856, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.291831165512184 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234352190777809, + "veriT": 10.161633854520771, + "Yices": 10.321662202805307, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950870752813334, + "CVC4": 0.17251621934146152, + "CVC3": 14.22973909858376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14774285840123075, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.148817023039136 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.515295518737588, + "veriT": 9.5588533428959828, + "Yices": 10.903021236882136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.996003039468553, + "CVC4": 1.6000598871773644, + "CVC3": 9.0289857196867889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9379616034732878, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.478752931898123 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8173716428653748, + "veriT": 8.4867007189869064, + "Yices": 7.9997331517902222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.539194770215778, + "CVC4": 1.9213984901276211, + "CVC3": 0.32838648050056674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7306830940858531, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4507044334759787 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1701554586920926, + "veriT": 9.6267401943133688, + "Yices": 8.5400259114954356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2748545975987509, + "CVC4": 8.3394109430180752, + "CVC3": 9.8408271501144906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.39984745665031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6331975386504745 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7750000953674316, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.240384578704834, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7321429252624512, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1735747879798999, + "veriT": 7.8665315401249867, + "Yices": 8.3465545286975633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1926760573038, + "CVC4": 7.3001076054933405, + "CVC3": 6.7858037023424318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5835426361479261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5848919661205272 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8660714626312256, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.883869617949143, + "veriT": 11.391337732798112, + "Yices": 11.607248135320233, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.47966759386396, + "CVC4": 14.740466876025392, + "CVC3": 11.873044090904465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.884850458567234, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5580990212243044 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4237101226879734, + "veriT": 8.6743954587629997, + "Yices": 9.2601840452565654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4415622948208657, + "CVC4": 0.21768670011014285, + "CVC3": 6.2500789763282114, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.209433237187161, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.206702625516039 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8023004589789773, + "veriT": 3.412961647168411, + "Yices": 3.4133807967691117, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0446198534705324, + "CVC4": 0.41629394314881113, + "CVC3": 0.086694699645644441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8026649183350516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8033398059502188 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3225587092755697, + "veriT": 12.777312224236852, + "Yices": 11.773343539769201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.069905880624975, + "CVC4": 11.589791304751381, + "CVC3": 6.7313658178531837, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.930020704337137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.935831249553281 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1972733737158583, + "veriT": 3.0804297614854286, + "Yices": 6.679358882460301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2819981640085771, + "CVC4": 0.2023509289567143, + "CVC3": 3.9853845303288575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15166144904657144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3817076873076339 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3760259085469964, + "veriT": 5.4897730630192383, + "Yices": 6.9326334235594942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0667257389347045, + "CVC4": 7.4553665296343761, + "CVC3": 1.3604200671457189, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.810145932350991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.130855012011587 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8306475545510636, + "veriT": 10.113609617678479, + "Yices": 10.105651503784859, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1150409735808449, + "CVC4": 8.7922057910748599, + "CVC3": 4.2539267831987839, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.945184080613497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.946690553691326 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2115904189067219, + "veriT": 5.8581881930237145, + "Yices": 10.503803117766953, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4384958969721922, + "CVC4": 6.2116831155639343, + "CVC3": 8.5496944684262477, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8877395538059187, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0607714644277655 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1449869850190639, + "veriT": 1.2569438835255555, + "Yices": 5.9564257739019606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8877132359994437, + "CVC4": 0.160453748955, + "CVC3": 1.7686175289868147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.590724036237555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8249685153025119 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4500000476837158, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1363505089732, + "veriT": 1.11786873608466, + "Yices": 1.5307899801391662, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1393206293823, + "CVC4": 0.14053462648259998, + "CVC3": 0.1282125251231, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13781406158429998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1348870400903 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8850667872262665, + "veriT": 10.855738094193496, + "Yices": 4.589841545398218, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5990836749592257, + "CVC4": 7.425230404337043, + "CVC3": 5.3950235979698018, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3852251919423804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8323582200364639 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2532386795828101, + "veriT": 5.9861577159002213, + "Yices": 13.098946189801744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2325131500408388, + "CVC4": 11.976467739332509, + "CVC3": 10.196096520501195, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2474724328462266, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.276210669331201 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19970785149799999, + "veriT": 0.18469030812514284, + "Yices": 3.0469575063971428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19899688931928569, + "CVC4": 0.2050597577292857, + "CVC3": 0.19646598785914285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19807139054257145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19727783877357144 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6557544528460904, + "veriT": 11.634463338286805, + "Yices": 10.460969511645978, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6952218691207293, + "CVC4": 13.178880991343101, + "CVC3": 12.31096736356027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.033913650229803, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.043740371698076 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5877494367514613, + "veriT": 9.7773513901734361, + "Yices": 5.9244997582280972, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.728499766135954, + "CVC4": 8.0513140608453799, + "CVC3": 7.9330982977695639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.647943952283594, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.541427805182757 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.217248376920079, + "veriT": 10.016213688609353, + "Yices": 11.465110132464526, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.516016974758742, + "CVC4": 5.5979954722545138, + "CVC3": 9.0284692061660525, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6038370747839004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3348498130084225 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1710810661315918, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0650153160095215, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8869049549102783, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14931913841628569, + "veriT": 0.14496251140909999, + "Yices": 4.222767053960057, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17350021438585714, + "CVC4": 0.21997523518842857, + "CVC3": 0.16280151216114286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18264240988899999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18109770989085713 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5123913846171426, + "veriT": 2.832679192870009, + "Yices": 2.8459882699288275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6430135970487889, + "CVC4": 7.8683302834299074, + "CVC3": 0.12821263678767272, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13007730356663635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12898652788595455 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5331250911437411, + "veriT": 7.8509620344559572, + "Yices": 5.8031720507859506, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9314992876529149, + "CVC4": 0.17978984253511668, + "CVC3": 0.1576184133545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5661686550997329, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5753252694994129 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.42291478562022217, + "veriT": 3.9826477498506971, + "Yices": 12.503235965475916, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5910458395625557, + "CVC4": 1.7941221059246457, + "CVC3": 2.4302127025107776, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20781956549611114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20796344184411111 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2841615676879883, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8781987567362011, + "veriT": 9.6351332165618686, + "Yices": 10.794570377851638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.028389851422341, + "CVC4": 6.6245375617753384, + "CVC3": 1.4744498266185482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3346718202257999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3753911563934 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.27351527864122221, + "veriT": 5.0711691999860165, + "Yices": 10.850820195716032, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5531859974775559, + "CVC4": 10.094944835524091, + "CVC3": 7.5902667696349999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0623332967496895, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0611763390240014 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2198815759730559, + "veriT": 10.766549660148254, + "Yices": 9.0018249294987687, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4428324239319412, + "CVC4": 12.437802221486207, + "CVC3": 9.8496552483584523, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0659740829830913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9324633273428162 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9117645025253296, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.66415800381986, + "veriT": 9.8013086098642965, + "Yices": 9.3329925080406166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.157480496389146, + "CVC4": 1.3321251622418926, + "CVC3": 12.023369688070122, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3846526708779763, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.47355644781574 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3617609148956582, + "veriT": 14.012558304448117, + "Yices": 13.991779528601352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7542465812877648, + "CVC4": 8.6717623135940194, + "CVC3": 6.492958341535414, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9479720643366516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.032749187129921 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1243402191138574, + "veriT": 7.0061582751148004, + "Yices": 6.0753067162445342, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4266330530674289, + "CVC4": 2.2115905168286223, + "CVC3": 6.1854883211585943, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4259524050354639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9951598819895935 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0690314243125121, + "veriT": 11.946394884313188, + "Yices": 10.723061357695245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.100539087409103, + "CVC4": 12.476665584208217, + "CVC3": 10.237355072815005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.271566233662437, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.064913023758717 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.630000966522422, + "veriT": 10.539934524978797, + "Yices": 10.376719618374237, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.098950529270079, + "CVC4": 5.2738793731223108, + "CVC3": 11.701020012549955, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6698145802599678, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3032147462859172 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4706460532628736, + "veriT": 2.8857079952634548, + "Yices": 3.0416529571552178, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7976722638020002, + "CVC4": 1.5923511954274217, + "CVC3": 0.38591052977963636, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21025959632972724, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0353567531636321 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6408221213463752, + "veriT": 12.445906693889709, + "Yices": 1.5137128274602252, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.67184758001325, + "CVC4": 0.16247341694299999, + "CVC3": 0.116673166669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1768891350257213, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1738608019503403 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0416333524035153, + "veriT": 9.7800725508904716, + "Yices": 5.1645779364599704, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6043967454147903, + "CVC4": 8.7955682471499514, + "CVC3": 5.276302105839437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.425574866708876, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.87493133912171 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4310012687884002, + "veriT": 10.988762855637543, + "Yices": 10.997912781290001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.034359582476462, + "CVC4": 14.410411103623906, + "CVC3": 3.0091441443211577, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252966058403683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.761079176746282 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 73.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17315185370929997, + "veriT": 14.21914073945049, + "Yices": 7.1479984662376861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.63124469055919996, + "CVC4": 0.75018693545539994, + "CVC3": 7.1868695579228854, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.286999520848003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.298760726160719 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.152106673783, + "veriT": 8.1637155647058215, + "Yices": 1.3765334726160967, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26175057976880001, + "CVC4": 1.6046094508749846, + "CVC3": 0.15892546140530001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5575293570308479, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5575832768984621 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3048153825902222, + "veriT": 12.21227915221721, + "Yices": 11.674687908415992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5873894604229999, + "CVC4": 6.6315101017891642, + "CVC3": 12.350437271611298, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0170267407130691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8994762628140691 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0119254357190997, + "veriT": 13.314504915942397, + "Yices": 6.7350599690177662, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.330615111426233, + "CVC4": 2.0355690254036247, + "CVC3": 5.5352780899663694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.284835045518534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.180306947841903 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.20982258366951, + "veriT": 12.745990537529705, + "Yices": 10.653496902534403, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9499389603943911, + "CVC4": 9.4288859873389157, + "CVC3": 10.596560308157835, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.954022322342894, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.134841245046552 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1729815006256104, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0636286735534668, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4948199269341114, + "veriT": 0.14057166711577782, + "Yices": 0.14745362401333334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4958387492742222, + "CVC4": 3.3177365497446951, + "CVC3": 0.14883739735766666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15736799252711112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15732359356055556 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7206638600792548, + "veriT": 11.021501968539976, + "Yices": 1.7328488934976563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8295985797796943, + "CVC4": 1.8218191279625755, + "CVC3": 2.2674739686123795, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7083100539265554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9451811392069998 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1460062838357333, + "veriT": 0.11451212603675333, + "Yices": 0.13430327769746669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14846328294887329, + "CVC4": 0.15676876001138668, + "CVC3": 0.14074479923539998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15385559265193999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15614844571643335 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.948264479637146, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238860609639598, + "veriT": 11.682244623110734, + "Yices": 11.396279090159233, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958593492998235, + "CVC4": 14.527780102711828, + "CVC3": 10.027726706864982, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.83932191636762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.756961895239865 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.967405287162434, + "veriT": 14.212203575644734, + "Yices": 13.572927223592623, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.834522387067096, + "CVC4": 10.280779247914854, + "CVC3": 13.298819199235229, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236911619095309, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237499389025031 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6534200833312789, + "veriT": 13.072639821221092, + "Yices": 4.8374899740822048, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6453449212583537, + "CVC4": 4.5335815401219097, + "CVC3": 4.4021084185684405, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.221397857312976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.903283276482695 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 97.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9855603067183649, + "veriT": 11.43914667951764, + "Yices": 9.3939134319095174, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.525470455518871, + "CVC4": 10.108632269378548, + "CVC3": 5.2706184092362207, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1161882250330351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1714519214966703 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7337045327306519, + "veriT": 13.723862999712605, + "Yices": 11.340902219685546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3248735049569582, + "CVC4": 5.4181595022439542, + "CVC3": 0.54758759032690918, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4833303961834423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2279800549108915 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20740922457007499, + "veriT": 5.4047544826873271, + "Yices": 2.155840123610369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.63641327976925, + "CVC4": 1.9544772440967093, + "CVC3": 0.88483896510335014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16531804193022501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16197491742163747 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.276605312783463, + "veriT": 13.461863628433477, + "Yices": 13.165543371820059, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.999612612555543, + "CVC4": 13.876003518041623, + "CVC3": 12.719273236711604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.164462247348832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9346457498630443 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 197.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.340011598112687, + "veriT": 12.766532975295087, + "Yices": 11.452577232113397, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.83595221343457, + "CVC4": 14.811687952566119, + "CVC3": 7.1738683486545147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.704950642814605, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.654337662489171 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.989205930899109, + "veriT": 13.613991781376424, + "Yices": 13.932130793478589, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.762379668851851, + "CVC4": 14.505223906270023, + "CVC3": 13.089286395724109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.156388428645037, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.926859450492 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.258829210235584, + "veriT": 10.190149728055376, + "Yices": 10.312686023512125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974690376340806, + "CVC4": 14.657193300412306, + "CVC3": 14.249112471016083, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.265787083469434, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.836168851389163 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3624574521935156, + "veriT": 11.424757450892878, + "Yices": 11.430204385464387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.489549423580842, + "CVC4": 8.2563430932166693, + "CVC3": 11.195442826907181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.275403818949032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.309397361551445 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8064009845665558, + "veriT": 14.223434875085864, + "Yices": 13.91247562435457, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.377780826055092, + "CVC4": 13.094195253605253, + "CVC3": 7.063494525624006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.981459091866697, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.991306950199064 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3460767746404105, + "veriT": 12.000848499695181, + "Yices": 8.540798269696273, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6131862319890296, + "CVC4": 5.7388852041737355, + "CVC3": 9.324179561360296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7349056770261999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3801409595577656 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8096185351606251, + "veriT": 13.477428556453301, + "Yices": 13.411542602393942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.325716411230346, + "CVC4": 14.545844785570964, + "CVC3": 11.94285441589974, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.014092267089271, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.830398204524482 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257976713424799, + "veriT": 12.825445673505673, + "Yices": 14.278539967677895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967890687007268, + "CVC4": 14.366707298067089, + "CVC3": 13.720904087096987, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.46586238158279, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.243460366586762 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238045017106106, + "veriT": 14.229571309148231, + "Yices": 14.234567856404821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954190251043844, + "CVC4": 14.556042045555166, + "CVC3": 13.148583266029718, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.212278761339174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.265881546919116 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 230.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.24042754652195, + "veriT": 13.764487208165182, + "Yices": 13.76973707344334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.139268064406972, + "CVC4": 12.496943076026744, + "CVC3": 12.576423589726993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1611970493074448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1341774808179999 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.33877322334302, + "veriT": 13.873596250512552, + "Yices": 13.348012361504974, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.988820145832722, + "CVC4": 14.534678193421797, + "CVC3": 10.780035787948638, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.223807234511801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.863373924439957 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12307460981630436, + "veriT": 0.096446194422521739, + "Yices": 0.096468725313839127, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11993501581908697, + "CVC4": 0.12359973307917391, + "CVC3": 0.10076944225726088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11899228080534784, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11899361759926086 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1276748272419235, + "veriT": 1.2659362935642178, + "Yices": 1.2684896026447234, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1474458546234706, + "CVC4": 1.7728874485651125, + "CVC3": 0.093572744595305887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7687366442200494, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7683265508336681 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4168537116489102, + "veriT": 1.3931185809031739, + "Yices": 2.4160362818605874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4941341248201194, + "CVC4": 1.9240118995154079, + "CVC3": 0.14545894706063747, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15777527543562497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18646339782137503 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2866172349350666, + "veriT": 10.164367221920147, + "Yices": 10.352800056945851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4379830537765876, + "CVC4": 0.14818711785766667, + "CVC3": 1.7004351769235566, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1466300403221111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.651587062939111 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18272143473320002, + "veriT": 7.1496284933501002, + "Yices": 9.5631898139452005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.35328322843819998, + "CVC4": 0.15055914905420004, + "CVC3": 0.25974708451939998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14869845815079999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2629353548505096 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1417263191136993, + "veriT": 11.002547056555715, + "Yices": 11.795465653383946, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1401999506160418, + "CVC4": 12.741627551370872, + "CVC3": 7.388811691148101, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.809109120131913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.020082542290556 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.930556503045417, + "veriT": 5.6780801178340097, + "Yices": 5.721541145170467, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.093674238234188, + "CVC4": 2.4263254410216035, + "CVC3": 4.1079459764082316, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3017688176238598, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9215502667448865 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9061099193464708, + "veriT": 7.3052632396434287, + "Yices": 8.8594113966525718, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5749106101233963, + "CVC4": 0.159443513304, + "CVC3": 1.0409128066978572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15484641775085711, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5727147464269979 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0555553436279297, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243627135020924, + "veriT": 10.193218115316418, + "Yices": 10.335380343444667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963858811333949, + "CVC4": 0.15776103702566666, + "CVC3": 11.634623238072473, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9691114603120448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.348765384837526 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.696244375855281, + "veriT": 8.3424892884492738, + "Yices": 10.336628441662272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.285697526304295, + "CVC4": 1.4522394096439923, + "CVC3": 11.709926381950657, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5577998279310261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.237748925597195 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.619047999382019, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238815131943813, + "veriT": 10.156266182652399, + "Yices": 10.3318093332727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958632922960907, + "CVC4": 0.18946613153290004, + "CVC3": 9.9007795004123107, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4846046680411384, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.37767317419496 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234691014857761, + "veriT": 10.158533658253999, + "Yices": 10.330068675723835, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95238837590181, + "CVC4": 0.15405329558549999, + "CVC3": 10.568068418549332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13912495283133333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.212013661386996 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23695348377375, + "veriT": 10.161729046615768, + "Yices": 10.329948729190999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955777187602306, + "CVC4": 0.1656172563000769, + "CVC3": 14.234626642722516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14532193012023076, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.470748684107393 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.486251379950446, + "veriT": 7.2554001071170839, + "Yices": 9.8928838958621252, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.034488661658367, + "CVC4": 1.4492354843283435, + "CVC3": 9.1291614834747055, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.445716845967727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5214553869984631 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3064027653480821, + "veriT": 6.5520664865529712, + "Yices": 9.0833583256313073, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5028511711893149, + "CVC4": 4.4562411592995677, + "CVC3": 7.1922518288984127, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7948241521563131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7023609270112012 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.253952523220923, + "veriT": 5.4631740789558005, + "Yices": 4.843623712807112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.077990943498266, + "CVC4": 1.7373979272616433, + "CVC3": 3.3854300719933339, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.242001941124983, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6769117496182862 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4736898554471252, + "veriT": 13.21675257103889, + "Yices": 11.485857116741617, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5322794965650004, + "CVC4": 8.476150467354687, + "CVC3": 9.6575900786745503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3072881337137261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.811443845343366 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 47.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 55.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.9000000953674316, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7321429252624512, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2753165976525556, + "veriT": 2.8238999261896396, + "Yices": 1.5768582415971111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2650961223257777, + "CVC4": 1.830631151990487, + "CVC3": 1.2958451256080001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8011935370691399, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7918544057071415 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1350275716496547, + "veriT": 4.0876884509080327, + "Yices": 1.7345786132431666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2515692356201713, + "CVC4": 2.5997413913625906, + "CVC3": 2.4250973182850495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4432595569500042, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4432870307863319 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6570834408306956, + "veriT": 12.648458512026838, + "Yices": 11.683247008535291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.50672822289682, + "CVC4": 12.450712562621598, + "CVC3": 10.717004995708161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.366906333071952, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.321441913625726 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.008941411262513, + "veriT": 7.8079961802003055, + "Yices": 12.202095262603605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1044917090094772, + "CVC4": 7.4244923528041831, + "CVC3": 8.5201829456712712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5338623905821418, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5341913907432083 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5216145936876133, + "veriT": 5.442085457883584, + "Yices": 6.1797548109055658, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9929875200306126, + "CVC4": 5.5931588685871834, + "CVC3": 3.7135783659819404, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.40492817028424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4031248891022159 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12198010229226247, + "veriT": 9.1742424495649093, + "Yices": 2.6035460821478744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11896604261225001, + "CVC4": 1.9799649968693229, + "CVC3": 0.10547119550407501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3749163634454999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3722424095527999 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9178584095514899, + "veriT": 1.40157049058075, + "Yices": 3.9256265153284997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0088362871542342, + "CVC4": 0.16411296400350001, + "CVC3": 0.2907589173565, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16549758309325002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5610593671217408 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5007601771821109, + "veriT": 2.5146846852014773, + "Yices": 13.879008579058587, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3913849965036666, + "CVC4": 12.079519207407907, + "CVC3": 14.107891282239832, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.996734522827424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9801272460698307 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.929136215143691, + "veriT": 12.86311676399712, + "Yices": 12.924756848783806, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.517010268833467, + "CVC4": 9.5926754420152154, + "CVC3": 13.658163878337717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6566831511957361, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.062066381506062 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18321127652700001, + "veriT": 3.3576864029226146, + "Yices": 0.1354447242114, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0479775512634999, + "CVC4": 0.17091665549175, + "CVC3": 0.16480951153925, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16223659781300001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16214961067550002 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6825081156252075, + "veriT": 11.2518641718416, + "Yices": 10.249465837846474, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5358660882444308, + "CVC4": 9.4104570092504005, + "CVC3": 8.9940976597365587, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.542061855315509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.934129285785762 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7506057867614284, + "veriT": 5.7396175498786048, + "Yices": 6.7600480381384864, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2906311106794215, + "CVC4": 3.533885103736536, + "CVC3": 0.26015895325971428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2029332453923773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3829579842832445 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.240501713742638, + "veriT": 10.115249167344006, + "Yices": 10.11551239252096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.96810657594785, + "CVC4": 5.1235044590770347, + "CVC3": 4.3711383467561911, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.040631393789946, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.044554992555215 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.930430571935117, + "veriT": 11.771402657274013, + "Yices": 12.154360359805102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.35693030499718, + "CVC4": 9.2303192561117235, + "CVC3": 14.591267457342806, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.23599752372227, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.329155717646419 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2731979292071696, + "veriT": 10.701923381718656, + "Yices": 8.8061714987211115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1169040117255271, + "CVC4": 4.6280920777720764, + "CVC3": 1.9929980349716268, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8609349252973539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6376201490134354 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.229184043938869, + "veriT": 10.740247388242498, + "Yices": 9.7461379177953251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.878489657434091, + "CVC4": 1.2166336819873185, + "CVC3": 13.84204419568105, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1732121050406354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.773781293350785 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2502321046548239, + "veriT": 12.570962608489882, + "Yices": 12.45950258192347, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6894183320121225, + "CVC4": 10.552349083602561, + "CVC3": 10.61221880886097, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2797015886816006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3036149238552888 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0789692110821711, + "veriT": 6.604235967919232, + "Yices": 6.0548621537953551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1714768737410513, + "CVC4": 2.8769763362702765, + "CVC3": 2.3672137529301605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.361817806954261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3614866098619354 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7875178060468944, + "veriT": 1.7048996518100317, + "Yices": 9.5510229773892341, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7813311934871052, + "CVC4": 6.1064554271974432, + "CVC3": 6.2254012028458945, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8837896246134083, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7169447237177078 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.016736832073466, + "veriT": 10.20516264273925, + "Yices": 11.161809586243621, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.176107636684844, + "CVC4": 13.925947767581427, + "CVC3": 11.667453665616074, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243195092937633, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.511418943491691 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1431820392608643, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3330810188709172, + "veriT": 3.4836195759039046, + "Yices": 10.00703028234547, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2893469489446296, + "CVC4": 6.8909784730100183, + "CVC3": 5.3877728464579668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6726556100190315, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4426503256161411 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7358607059507065, + "veriT": 11.101705174302635, + "Yices": 10.708669569959723, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1923696901485652, + "CVC4": 11.011770329597336, + "CVC3": 10.921120339843325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7941312128351523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.2649754120794 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5905894983908215, + "veriT": 5.6987302653906777, + "Yices": 6.1240503088589255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6136948611020572, + "CVC4": 7.3033739742799373, + "CVC3": 2.1249260526257316, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.25846494358579997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20434519563099288 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.907476602526645, + "veriT": 13.716129306624993, + "Yices": 4.4784932588081254, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0038004154677176, + "CVC4": 0.23502138551900001, + "CVC3": 3.6943482457934635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.220855763933658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.633730287919303 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8591270446777344, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22504657920455554, + "veriT": 5.9438234892679578, + "Yices": 1.8830832346258179, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8269670471603408, + "CVC4": 1.8910297184518683, + "CVC3": 1.416394461706258, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2522177500869622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8651279084873669 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4721328839321668, + "veriT": 9.8436358136633686, + "Yices": 12.428363989040333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0989639365534414, + "CVC4": 7.5227682699715759, + "CVC3": 1.4036404260505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.894736892956089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.205088655131457 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0582318577865455, + "veriT": 10.673174496529462, + "Yices": 2.1814767595839908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0481013598204547, + "CVC4": 2.8863141612769421, + "CVC3": 0.15025012288109094, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14293890700945455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14444057732054547 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7779856523718669, + "veriT": 12.507455955822113, + "Yices": 10.914429125928008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.337128038563133, + "CVC4": 14.446246976595146, + "CVC3": 8.0972191187330296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.297665587640447, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.301777156290848 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8418970108032227, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.510696113832489, + "veriT": 12.175574616311378, + "Yices": 8.4693339035006741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.930120843791723, + "CVC4": 5.0074196061069181, + "CVC3": 12.817464526336934, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232505829264387, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.306340553337048 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9741332499727768, + "veriT": 12.927302104979594, + "Yices": 6.3655551675813138, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8488253847065463, + "CVC4": 1.7106803549489669, + "CVC3": 1.9466422821078304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1019630802036602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.09873178415714 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8482725620269775, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7198768037225145, + "veriT": 6.3814694535688741, + "Yices": 10.453811223884404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7964213038297645, + "CVC4": 2.0154732672810871, + "CVC3": 4.9630333548523673, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9483984285576277, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1775402073563708 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15307577431681252, + "veriT": 0.1335607786906875, + "Yices": 0.14653837328487501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15051100816918747, + "CVC4": 0.16698615544168749, + "CVC3": 0.152385579075625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.162279409662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1623153561649375 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8363007413781665, + "veriT": 1.8201287952207166, + "Yices": 1.81554149250075, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8326974628485502, + "CVC4": 2.5451153818493042, + "CVC3": 0.15771254658183334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22389231250383332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.23306663407833336 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1474729300482143, + "veriT": 10.100304085786266, + "Yices": 0.14907131429485715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15612716602200002, + "CVC4": 0.17477045348364287, + "CVC3": 0.14802633208571428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15224997227214285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15377514738528569 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15795252403099999, + "veriT": 0.13503628761944445, + "Yices": 0.15051460089677776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16300199006711111, + "CVC4": 0.17454456694755557, + "CVC3": 0.15468464600088891, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17188862962766666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1708746343301111 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0918579406328224, + "veriT": 6.4718397053901375, + "Yices": 9.1421975954435553, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8626008765828832, + "CVC4": 7.6845429028467587, + "CVC3": 3.9909541792043051, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.36516324717569998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.35753971691057146 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9265552656486249, + "veriT": 1.9103867767750078, + "Yices": 0.16740747385887497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9620443790482498, + "CVC4": 0.18876187903512501, + "CVC3": 0.46857060048587501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17581611049937498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17131951657599997 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3771396063201746, + "veriT": 1.8842976753242235, + "Yices": 2.7090468015156262, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4629659113785038, + "CVC4": 5.15468079712464, + "CVC3": 0.96042743899811855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14035602426914706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13882351394315881 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 66.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6148843843228535, + "veriT": 7.6165470066347085, + "Yices": 5.330056229612417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8492527101452092, + "CVC4": 2.298852977834613, + "CVC3": 1.8219130806001427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22395415191814289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21482608050014282 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4858539288545556, + "veriT": 3.2496181996565476, + "Yices": 8.0569048444846629, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6520551480136669, + "CVC4": 12.704967952453218, + "CVC3": 5.8145247257938886, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2666130480241111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2642181130836669 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.67180991132555556, + "veriT": 12.063063502161732, + "Yices": 11.107948732997917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8848251269587779, + "CVC4": 8.2085165303869889, + "CVC3": 8.8820182240679699, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5531382763031409, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6257209768469689 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.544812844763277, + "veriT": 12.191549735280784, + "Yices": 10.453522320583366, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.326125369698786, + "CVC4": 12.781114975450722, + "CVC3": 12.497527574669185, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.445684714077885, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.593203779943494 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22225446507514546, + "veriT": 5.0642890422191105, + "Yices": 2.064922566533077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2081550047836365, + "CVC4": 1.4386841074508612, + "CVC3": 2.6711936045930522, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14627535894470911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14095078639337272 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5346708509474647, + "veriT": 12.38317733847096, + "Yices": 11.107076337084173, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2210839402074098, + "CVC4": 8.0779774792864174, + "CVC3": 6.2872029354147312, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8884800078106965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8974968507619074 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 41.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 98.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.895638724948292, + "veriT": 13.550004709375942, + "Yices": 9.7331201349483933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.519909098211455, + "CVC4": 13.926414228467266, + "CVC3": 13.558157235559655, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23719736631609, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.753323970647147 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.71332133263952, + "veriT": 11.412757873440862, + "Yices": 9.6046911294782298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1847035287098073, + "CVC4": 10.431631333363228, + "CVC3": 3.9433970184726781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24000592635568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.073576047306725 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8858979080940643, + "veriT": 11.082429857863845, + "Yices": 9.4182441255211291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3825483871442703, + "CVC4": 2.540952259221382, + "CVC3": 7.2271157175362903, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2107844332376239, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5348905422909018 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.467724652695788, + "veriT": 11.814317995144343, + "Yices": 11.878954967739533, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.013170076483187, + "CVC4": 14.418809681839502, + "CVC3": 14.232923818801638, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.250193974199618, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.318043817927819 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 53.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 103.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.269592516229654, + "veriT": 12.642104776325187, + "Yices": 11.948210205654586, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.986920716803956, + "CVC4": 10.409618683532031, + "CVC3": 6.6146861091938947, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5235031172944975, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9541154845014255 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5220453241791283, + "veriT": 12.894745849910249, + "Yices": 11.990860055648374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.164127258205099, + "CVC4": 9.6157428512537546, + "CVC3": 8.9524095097783842, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.612574794033506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.836039397967644 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 141.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.258862193439475, + "veriT": 10.591710739942734, + "Yices": 11.89801325426709, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.7985583942049, + "CVC4": 14.438129104616189, + "CVC3": 13.921667991092729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.394829388795696, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.290188012402261 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.012742951678449, + "veriT": 13.152686388823273, + "Yices": 14.257493455195311, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957352861240789, + "CVC4": 14.567227721204144, + "CVC3": 14.059722970937367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.997429856772333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.995020482096445 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0874963296643596, + "veriT": 13.875947782673462, + "Yices": 13.897780462458361, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965399362508913, + "CVC4": 14.701844864473902, + "CVC3": 10.75895260596358, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.073076499535107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.537719209527269 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3066231405183064, + "veriT": 9.9512074036386906, + "Yices": 11.657224236432551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1873680689225097, + "CVC4": 8.7568195869276675, + "CVC3": 9.4292644865365673, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.349626446738077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.344132874502117 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.048577314936372, + "veriT": 14.22481624198165, + "Yices": 14.029282522281234, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.425271004026037, + "CVC4": 14.416690072908558, + "CVC3": 14.17650915102611, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.735399885847098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.675066281787903 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.093045179317333, + "veriT": 10.895105955501132, + "Yices": 8.232345391189595, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1319898253775369, + "CVC4": 9.9835307710589127, + "CVC3": 11.153092608085693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4099040941315151, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4785544728395132 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.301614921010701, + "veriT": 14.231380402481538, + "Yices": 14.091963139034968, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962140355953551, + "CVC4": 14.348551845791539, + "CVC3": 12.527445783556612, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4131550132100812, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4445428461250645 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.811818159928393, + "veriT": 12.894596487902605, + "Yices": 13.338949904938771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972680417455472, + "CVC4": 14.696493751641166, + "CVC3": 14.039669823010726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.86379321426053, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.264649277318735 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2070759331402972, + "veriT": 11.682298813892606, + "Yices": 10.882031070197486, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0748691738315586, + "CVC4": 8.8291092673311091, + "CVC3": 7.3976280499112592, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4370044680637744, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9086842688980279 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13835808985242107, + "veriT": 0.11405960005008424, + "Yices": 0.11090839659801578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13570522799010526, + "CVC4": 0.13497050816863157, + "CVC3": 0.11802180883172629, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13462009702242106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13291087212347366 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11520960640143331, + "veriT": 0.085891114544138891, + "Yices": 0.09124074085616668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11309712221649998, + "CVC4": 0.10914634127423334, + "CVC3": 0.093268677986588888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10834036343908889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10848933589056109 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9130432030781606, + "veriT": 1.3869301470909237, + "Yices": 1.144178686503925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9888502308099936, + "CVC4": 1.9194517163334075, + "CVC3": 0.14228101326621251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16013282314124999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16222952159850001 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7143379105713883, + "veriT": 10.163767516903572, + "Yices": 10.354516597136643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8363056108186282, + "CVC4": 0.15002846729967859, + "CVC3": 0.69964983501296429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14827586763003572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.431181968798484 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17827654631475001, + "veriT": 6.3936795741517498, + "Yices": 9.3638116806653748, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28427848970862496, + "CVC4": 0.15017249884174999, + "CVC3": 0.25473080185500002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.148786916959875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8787444068962502 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.282814397216608, + "veriT": 13.776739015321095, + "Yices": 12.537724476412382, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.56442279415251, + "CVC4": 12.670080797965017, + "CVC3": 11.868678440600322, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.111869208594749, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.155246740110831 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17133899153022222, + "veriT": 1.2390197890228889, + "Yices": 5.7691400192027773, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21499899786355556, + "CVC4": 3.2862986180368261, + "CVC3": 0.20189291863622219, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7198739250353245, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9124880703964431 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5654670427547543, + "veriT": 8.5083928206505011, + "Yices": 8.6553644082424999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.487842693888981, + "CVC4": 0.16116747785833332, + "CVC3": 8.8061322849221693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0916986807909703, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.55966848831317 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237885977145078, + "veriT": 10.150161855104001, + "Yices": 10.318450944563166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956178947886292, + "CVC4": 0.15879871519283337, + "CVC3": 10.849927634531321, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0138671681430802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.278516809354002 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.726606492833739, + "veriT": 8.9000929432816243, + "Yices": 10.820193825544699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.356389647201894, + "CVC4": 0.158777130898375, + "CVC3": 14.055070855304484, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14514277924749999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8722847562843974 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.055145656565621, + "veriT": 10.163792918511751, + "Yices": 10.333434226587833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.569536582414644, + "CVC4": 0.17690691060358332, + "CVC3": 8.3557968405926282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15213210779183331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.992219314256735 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.246239655008102, + "veriT": 9.4477855145989302, + "Yices": 10.32802312765986, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.914627621123756, + "CVC4": 0.16695838349564288, + "CVC3": 11.240977114462405, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.044050047558372, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.281606775625864 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.419517201007011, + "veriT": 10.618101533494675, + "Yices": 10.286772613258199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.984262837805909, + "CVC4": 2.1575641997383004, + "CVC3": 12.34104347701629, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7448992172495963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.828545514324748 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.321545760980804, + "veriT": 10.19095821155125, + "Yices": 10.3321097412145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962356646989241, + "CVC4": 2.8410498294411255, + "CVC3": 10.575681473366529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4515609879366584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.678093716001225 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4526148825641503, + "veriT": 8.6919671618839001, + "Yices": 8.7221147436153981, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.716932718109778, + "CVC4": 8.6096261515582508, + "CVC3": 10.20614512145681, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7681099497065, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7092328011602409 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4512497191735521, + "veriT": 10.900039921070837, + "Yices": 11.427553654371463, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6483435990413233, + "CVC4": 9.8626746463694364, + "CVC3": 6.3426866674650721, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.918011491844933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.019376764944345 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.372810963866996, + "veriT": 8.8016060414086326, + "Yices": 4.0944407850132203, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5001960359014728, + "CVC4": 7.4354656783968593, + "CVC3": 7.1432374891679293, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8037242303205892, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8027174824218308 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7220103080052613, + "veriT": 9.6292414015181169, + "Yices": 10.811151229047079, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2603502045168389, + "CVC4": 12.794721795796635, + "CVC3": 6.7883464723023899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.674631035861971, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8581991004200029 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13165465591097142, + "veriT": 4.3933694716944149, + "Yices": 6.4101664941027812, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12902353408704287, + "CVC4": 1.5660502518813286, + "CVC3": 1.6345356539424287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1124492939662121, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0971779370029391 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.92017158394957888, + "veriT": 0.67457252710336113, + "Yices": 0.68754041287829437, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.95313392163602073, + "CVC4": 0.1479022917242222, + "CVC3": 0.19476986581734443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16115330062844446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.7777675956124015 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5727274417877197, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.825741379961434, + "veriT": 13.857145989694988, + "Yices": 13.348758242002464, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.129821355711481, + "CVC4": 11.627167510924595, + "CVC3": 14.533716670187609, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.132985678334522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.143725660903398 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0801279544830322, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5116468021991833, + "veriT": 11.506147990281992, + "Yices": 11.746656416325472, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5941635637202758, + "CVC4": 10.740122850730616, + "CVC3": 5.4184522855693862, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2653549175362109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2638422082156575 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5660037122958474, + "veriT": 12.580054030533045, + "Yices": 11.613966856761994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.889729313977085, + "CVC4": 13.674079700561816, + "CVC3": 10.933638074512078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.428325780533351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.424062732376353 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2611506732023576, + "veriT": 11.296261826480814, + "Yices": 10.823257241127246, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.254500115465385, + "CVC4": 12.447775683456141, + "CVC3": 10.660187465071539, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2199309605775799, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8122851897851167 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.94401393841129, + "veriT": 6.8877839783007078, + "Yices": 6.9823959505222293, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3885417571907936, + "CVC4": 2.0087741523407456, + "CVC3": 8.9342775874554103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2782373569326486, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0004291278531205 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.040260073255366, + "veriT": 10.125597139418455, + "Yices": 10.111474417520522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9875606954925225, + "CVC4": 2.3875822302844441, + "CVC3": 1.9347144554056719, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231398190297373, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.229496708308732 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1291666030883789, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4466018891366366, + "veriT": 6.6572112606294995, + "Yices": 3.9733220166367751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0442114710603709, + "CVC4": 0.173689332207625, + "CVC3": 1.9951457595666251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15863713302662499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3460078120307726 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5625, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0780630170627674, + "veriT": 8.1422967980367194, + "Yices": 8.591476373215869, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9403130838174611, + "CVC4": 9.7853569021369431, + "CVC3": 8.6354380617209383, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9804602786673389, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9826565587023373 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6157590340700001, + "veriT": 6.6643643876867236, + "Yices": 14.026402573040262, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2816772539473793, + "CVC4": 10.83957821675137, + "CVC3": 10.885074159430413, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0380193145731713, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7175130825232126 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13501828582600769, + "veriT": 4.471145761586258, + "Yices": 9.102290212565844, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15023007802684618, + "CVC4": 6.4065226619777071, + "CVC3": 5.8121534090157363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9852979813764295, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9821949905764424 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1781979659411235, + "veriT": 11.718727588260039, + "Yices": 11.714541821538045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1916264419879354, + "CVC4": 12.917122595165102, + "CVC3": 12.062558533950211, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.334886349253003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.344942890268824 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "exists", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.931977893614091, + "veriT": 6.3872565644782586, + "Yices": 4.5505173507973353, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0186978624384539, + "CVC4": 0.20094292410981815, + "CVC3": 2.0534562692268179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7485316914607578, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.746716215691773 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8619050979614258, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3607756626788072, + "veriT": 6.426870587494089, + "Yices": 13.362947952237818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5743281162247698, + "CVC4": 0.20047528000290002, + "CVC3": 8.276864915175647, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1904270495869351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2545138905405313 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242950024425728, + "veriT": 8.3146800762606361, + "Yices": 11.397428301383497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960294319063969, + "CVC4": 0.1675178947730909, + "CVC3": 13.163537754354046, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17244005369354545, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3118615382711951 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4182411144025071, + "veriT": 9.9201864792004546, + "Yices": 11.982279964690282, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.606432087907347, + "CVC4": 6.2926614610237639, + "CVC3": 3.9127849908920012, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4913263416617308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.537305642898923 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6416308762522167, + "veriT": 1.3778464849054246, + "Yices": 4.0165565031277692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.922147660299854, + "CVC4": 1.6440386689389748, + "CVC3": 5.422679361767818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5445691161147208, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.543762596521608 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 47.0, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.05718994140625, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1287972792060863, + "veriT": 6.7160005989237197, + "Yices": 6.9529588959869981, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6725622400024172, + "CVC4": 4.9217371580384217, + "CVC3": 1.4697448342141202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7832379659783064, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4890237705213281 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15901816845442857, + "veriT": 0.14275500889099998, + "Yices": 1.5787215782542858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15819381146402858, + "CVC4": 2.1882589877891667, + "CVC3": 0.15465484399842858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16249775347487144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16316924292314286 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13763854609074999, + "veriT": 7.8376827710572234, + "Yices": 3.5368901559383334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6121169652610798, + "CVC4": 0.14527420166579999, + "CVC3": 0.13080798372600003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13464342517433334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13477785594588335 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4842097996436916, + "veriT": 6.4927381375121014, + "Yices": 5.4139807679435474, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.830210211230291, + "CVC4": 11.371336482102793, + "CVC3": 3.6378357347454622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2069103022029886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6583533581692365 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.49485606830062501, + "veriT": 10.193149848851375, + "Yices": 10.34592518431575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4712457028397452, + "CVC4": 14.277433630006072, + "CVC3": 2.6743845838870728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256420848357614, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.151116495736686 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0871435962645197, + "veriT": 7.6615230764955804, + "Yices": 11.238469757596118, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5525674911986158, + "CVC4": 12.73607392089996, + "CVC3": 13.209018646958313, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.481907427116093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.231062854866483 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 59.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 21.0, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5662318395132857, + "veriT": 6.1604685181937464, + "Yices": 1.9855564349402341, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5681845622917143, + "CVC4": 2.2781089494029714, + "CVC3": 2.1506910291426178, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14518265464285715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14773329877757144 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14344619777644443, + "veriT": 14.210700704628108, + "Yices": 0.207549238912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26612644870055557, + "CVC4": 1.8171666772572042, + "CVC3": 0.12864092720244444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.867241257574946, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.853969684978805 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5891925739090849, + "veriT": 14.219557746992811, + "Yices": 9.8149809162962871, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3788194614912461, + "CVC4": 4.4143105189736698, + "CVC3": 8.6953432827742443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241669505333009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.23799270443244 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5149246947274999, + "veriT": 11.4274217650084, + "Yices": 7.0394926491136003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.489283832462883, + "CVC4": 3.9607777450027841, + "CVC3": 6.8943412724318875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6177169215586611, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1385915783058618 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15466506725028575, + "veriT": 9.5977156520395948, + "Yices": 4.9777469769072811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24603377577499999, + "CVC4": 6.2919670911126522, + "CVC3": 0.15502289417885715, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14542388751042859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14515201944485717 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4185226375841378, + "veriT": 14.215604847740027, + "Yices": 8.5712514426341482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3067922104116398, + "CVC4": 2.882150255982062, + "CVC3": 7.6122292672150147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.052182264156349, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.050481903068968 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1658120155334473, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1411777400191111, + "veriT": 1.2283461760113665, + "Yices": 2.7912198827407528, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13976302150947775, + "CVC4": 1.7200270166800715, + "CVC3": 0.12697970823544447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17946660737666667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18494910762188888 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17462419386424444, + "veriT": 4.5577060944629331, + "Yices": 5.0184840932166175, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.38471847894587774, + "CVC4": 4.8630081653291848, + "CVC3": 2.970147893741848, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0217013281002743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0444232637850632 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17206504906292855, + "veriT": 0.89352058623378561, + "Yices": 9.1035218039981824, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16893883838378573, + "CVC4": 0.19920616428171428, + "CVC3": 0.17641113458428573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18150894134542855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17673716936871428 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0146774024026701, + "veriT": 7.7544407056564371, + "Yices": 7.1380891188343538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.127757104571141, + "CVC4": 8.0403757708230277, + "CVC3": 7.2814215504281936, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0070669848195273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.105456659132396 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14341464745862501, + "veriT": 0.11962852983610001, + "Yices": 0.13197121676918749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.140451787768825, + "CVC4": 0.1555029510625375, + "CVC3": 0.1391291709005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15518648540995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1549810285910625 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14559173908533335, + "veriT": 3.2576917547700135, + "Yices": 0.14076611943122222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16682582173955557, + "CVC4": 0.16831099256688892, + "CVC3": 0.6918624426754445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15958363570455558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15846687590911113 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 75.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4888717282854067, + "veriT": 12.214973781115805, + "Yices": 10.435603740448421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.174371372200026, + "CVC4": 14.297561561875913, + "CVC3": 12.273235333110646, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4027203698252535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0787048643638926 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.872900815750707, + "veriT": 2.845237617701434, + "Yices": 4.888906788880111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.972355403644471, + "CVC4": 9.6925945532515314, + "CVC3": 1.7669609499427605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1049595037683133, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3548253936567951 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1988407807456856, + "veriT": 12.410004760342922, + "Yices": 3.9513997926568538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7630652853724733, + "CVC4": 4.4479956832736001, + "CVC3": 11.57932802042202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.721699677738632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.293445873778905 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 48.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4884975189903038, + "veriT": 9.177427933644136, + "Yices": 7.6880643528097465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6876304485155895, + "CVC4": 8.6487289726476515, + "CVC3": 5.9915095764925148, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8525653224842293, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8503082590985791 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.000894266025, + "veriT": 1.2134125264816722, + "Yices": 0.13625642666930768, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0209750498978458, + "CVC4": 0.1731288329086923, + "CVC3": 0.16233444206438463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1584577946855385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15787592228592306 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 46.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0685391426086426, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.321970573888727, + "veriT": 10.623770727387436, + "Yices": 10.822783231769451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963388801321981, + "CVC4": 14.448080383754075, + "CVC3": 9.9984769171936136, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.072775668003858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.525216715442912 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9051443848333349, + "veriT": 13.705279363021406, + "Yices": 11.432968521065646, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7029748526958119, + "CVC4": 14.330540887524801, + "CVC3": 13.646697609692382, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244100587449847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.247003755967656 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3418905279664903, + "veriT": 12.253349133589397, + "Yices": 7.2215758615417398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.128111323776656, + "CVC4": 4.9880926154402676, + "CVC3": 5.4726637800941793, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.899253617444018, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.821263140881456 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3216304241610528, + "veriT": 7.9428717369043573, + "Yices": 6.4446477765264554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1559989558297952, + "CVC4": 4.9812403105310956, + "CVC3": 5.9785383823588605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7256239681627246, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7279404005408321 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 68.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.42327356197657146, + "veriT": 12.043678710174303, + "Yices": 2.5758707188872605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0463917973395738, + "CVC4": 4.3916960916660326, + "CVC3": 0.31629711668357147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4607061446700089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5073607227769665 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6676850868625923, + "veriT": 14.244281584831374, + "Yices": 10.791936236330786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.468012317062609, + "CVC4": 2.9023327467382987, + "CVC3": 4.643922483378577, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7798978759379422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9451116897488743 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6868549585342407, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4988637515173231, + "veriT": 7.2471087287960536, + "Yices": 7.7702565364001224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.471454657291584, + "CVC4": 8.4630920951765543, + "CVC3": 5.3108349756818383, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9937320995751788, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0025141882223823 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6062931066116253, + "veriT": 13.463577969626176, + "Yices": 13.500758281639811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.8191994952033, + "CVC4": 11.152509106561064, + "CVC3": 9.2997185656862342, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230874012219907, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.203927192734342 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.285024200502455, + "veriT": 10.239183643704557, + "Yices": 10.437297128683777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.003303234306436, + "CVC4": 14.319512988095799, + "CVC3": 14.280897099070522, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.283615362743111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.433232625098064 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.152896834272841, + "veriT": 12.11207449024548, + "Yices": 11.423296251679496, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.000465744165158, + "CVC4": 11.755523033653725, + "CVC3": 14.232577264113027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.198473093797528, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.148736742447625 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.481180543909295, + "veriT": 13.785395638819621, + "Yices": 13.397716508397318, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973638428666289, + "CVC4": 14.445961670823246, + "CVC3": 8.0306743049338323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.842915187499496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9883782439698905 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 181.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7672158836169567, + "veriT": 11.240051620157436, + "Yices": 11.489432705262814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5450418045882075, + "CVC4": 12.011121802913124, + "CVC3": 9.8387031947287991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8748375258033683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8176158087124685 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5638482961337496, + "veriT": 14.217982567321492, + "Yices": 8.0162298643656431, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.419832734833538, + "CVC4": 9.5349815629167782, + "CVC3": 13.448311570130976, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9638836676057991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9638380765811085 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 168.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.492121580678516, + "veriT": 12.320726663248927, + "Yices": 14.246466416092312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.115149545409066, + "CVC4": 13.47042669228942, + "CVC3": 13.639943615127819, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5776313680549929, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3414038125627155 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247862857174871, + "veriT": 11.592330131593592, + "Yices": 13.553737887054126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960140605036223, + "CVC4": 14.516217566481577, + "CVC3": 13.924162950962474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.159087305521973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.163079177573271 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.860468658570118, + "veriT": 14.256933793952545, + "Yices": 13.869392056339683, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979127349543514, + "CVC4": 14.799431110999617, + "CVC3": 14.272802206420044, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.413634466501435, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.477872516696582 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.077974910901021, + "veriT": 13.863458065273353, + "Yices": 13.858052350195932, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.16122381358992, + "CVC4": 14.259574305266039, + "CVC3": 10.892419678387899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.065105347669526, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.779745720092508 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13072874918129035, + "veriT": 0.10064153554620968, + "Yices": 0.10412781549357743, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12796468341454839, + "CVC4": 0.12982671688496775, + "CVC3": 0.10798591824900322, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12703925794993548, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1244605939285484 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.113198260271875, + "veriT": 0.084567257087793751, + "Yices": 0.088338613899931237, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11011530572180001, + "CVC4": 0.10763348336470001, + "CVC3": 0.090015774770074997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10848249419611875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10666122864017501 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0174713997069169, + "veriT": 1.6077826138421663, + "Yices": 1.6250413009720315, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.057408126266262, + "CVC4": 1.057364801383341, + "CVC3": 1.8727549064082727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0125402178389207, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8919302632820749 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20503168999958069, + "veriT": 9.8414601237115154, + "Yices": 10.392538374746128, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27664091919338707, + "CVC4": 0.14990084443422583, + "CVC3": 0.63480234877306452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14869935584112898, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.030530014806287 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7029409408569336, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4631240178352591, + "veriT": 6.9558392766241965, + "Yices": 9.0559654444023945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1111495280704453, + "CVC4": 3.1189910376611847, + "CVC3": 2.8487646073350001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9700145979961179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5898813646726033 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6458334922790527, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235222727689335, + "veriT": 10.157041741672002, + "Yices": 10.321201393238502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.949324371155809, + "CVC4": 0.18458068866316668, + "CVC3": 12.356727570431211, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9283235785168675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.185926386844782 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.127670378778914, + "veriT": 10.49528623421457, + "Yices": 10.440180034930334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.547783459994776, + "CVC4": 1.4064006326758036, + "CVC3": 8.5141677494990997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3178263321313028, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.259836911010723 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.849817773526928, + "veriT": 9.6640381040363348, + "Yices": 8.7501013984388738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.627070665366359, + "CVC4": 4.60995141153776, + "CVC3": 10.456110514803235, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7850920092079026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0785374128212517 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.32685190572643, + "veriT": 13.708490460547964, + "Yices": 13.69043276961327, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.768749313067122, + "CVC4": 14.812991064472779, + "CVC3": 14.855164105301499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.728545408619496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.725436288239461 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9950051077080015, + "veriT": 11.073524278985674, + "Yices": 15.355681596238654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.417712716501935, + "CVC4": 5.7236413829523984, + "CVC3": 9.3848556993156951, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3779634168193269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3985653194205216 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.58571457862854, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9265702910001616, + "veriT": 3.9508109654545001, + "Yices": 5.5183699815251241, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0982152389099396, + "CVC4": 0.36186748343087505, + "CVC3": 4.910354592920088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4480110956741079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8088460275177702 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8031537234850001, + "veriT": 9.5064766951926405, + "Yices": 0.38497085971796668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8031493926941666, + "CVC4": 0.19145739914183332, + "CVC3": 0.14300283146599999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.880949517086556, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.87921370249216 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.922260004386823, + "veriT": 10.894866427887566, + "Yices": 7.9288821311339541, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.905257423424631, + "CVC4": 5.5863880218460658, + "CVC3": 5.4016373220297043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.734157470132867, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.656455827636682 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.478759675664445, + "veriT": 11.379493529463428, + "Yices": 10.832596667011444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.886472904858248, + "CVC4": 8.5645098016477839, + "CVC3": 11.464575229827327, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3836450244756424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.605528087352296 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.853061473888232, + "veriT": 10.696243170854283, + "Yices": 10.488746277184001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959569098950194, + "CVC4": 5.2358968776913999, + "CVC3": 10.56236412101536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.193482291028543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.582540431173515 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.503401531181206, + "veriT": 8.9217410479908139, + "Yices": 10.332051329376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.131543936387882, + "CVC4": 0.17190753879406251, + "CVC3": 11.784336472419309, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.681116572249376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.266378748591892 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0949575787855785, + "veriT": 9.8479893553011379, + "Yices": 7.5736921190812829, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5540521539803089, + "CVC4": 3.4457732739919629, + "CVC3": 11.883066389847817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8352061593366571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6954810504737221 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.808321748676903, + "veriT": 11.027321761758435, + "Yices": 11.048759077134394, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3187069535941003, + "CVC4": 11.661853840352906, + "CVC3": 9.2314695444409551, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.701108093853218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.732302921824656 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0777760902393949, + "veriT": 0.79029927517702669, + "Yices": 4.7629310700341678, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1241148664773517, + "CVC4": 2.0359612686295225, + "CVC3": 2.0612912133390271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17146184502626668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.91800843436222168 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9411764144897461, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7803169134274108, + "veriT": 9.5317337243308824, + "Yices": 9.738681156786031, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9194040502340484, + "CVC4": 8.1080646338726812, + "CVC3": 2.4059799413463363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8961318328145165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3004915241328687 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6556998494346757, + "veriT": 14.19757644908996, + "Yices": 11.147240814597852, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.516022999476075, + "CVC4": 13.349058850781406, + "CVC3": 10.575150789311875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.289157290312032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.289087484229713 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3560609817504883, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5761257195383447, + "veriT": 6.8341418103515004, + "Yices": 6.9627050896338334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.71854085866485, + "CVC4": 0.17436798443083334, + "CVC3": 12.172557147327472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17269559846566665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6735199070796272 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.07402674276309, + "veriT": 10.838801510120165, + "Yices": 10.756364243853584, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.727642062342442, + "CVC4": 2.6371065717230344, + "CVC3": 12.369967604240708, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6844356318389444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.946683734781777 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1525873119361902, + "veriT": 4.2934702084123311, + "Yices": 4.8466282184832838, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2723787541108029, + "CVC4": 2.6523482810238277, + "CVC3": 4.1847773100981325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1714429263259758, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1728330742164221 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5733419559702999, + "veriT": 13.647320222252258, + "Yices": 3.5467613784174739, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.606866619066571, + "CVC4": 2.1560460634809266, + "CVC3": 3.5834533769765935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6177259579374288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6355369910181998 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5601757376687102, + "veriT": 13.869933029973465, + "Yices": 5.5977306219925929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9879268248435054, + "CVC4": 6.3325289691952475, + "CVC3": 5.7761103073064666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.07015687761727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.800948643745912 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.078251838684082, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5314248630708835, + "veriT": 10.967958291427928, + "Yices": 10.907244776358349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6786183755632518, + "CVC4": 8.0167041183642436, + "CVC3": 9.5631083675795576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6328257736962035, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.04898679268624 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3083539242011284, + "veriT": 5.2773576740799353, + "Yices": 3.0430825857072712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.457252460380464, + "CVC4": 4.2025035562281756, + "CVC3": 6.142236044741769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1318685752877413, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1314539726812165 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0162624975788752, + "veriT": 8.0058066885269756, + "Yices": 11.052397192228012, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4983816577060085, + "CVC4": 8.0997362083101745, + "CVC3": 2.3937074972231245, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.635077003364071, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8585556030431345 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0517139225287302, + "veriT": 11.026914081708936, + "Yices": 10.304073114339209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3797266812340148, + "CVC4": 8.2449784422538244, + "CVC3": 6.841969311690324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.22753237476728, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.228289537055003 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0066666603088379, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8516485691070557, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14055950622249999, + "veriT": 1.7755556670122914, + "Yices": 2.4682755069349098, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14245426599108332, + "CVC4": 0.16048918064200002, + "CVC3": 2.1167609735731667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2889929942010108, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2837978125530727 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12697575494900001, + "veriT": 4.813489157188835, + "Yices": 9.0891567481671132, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15646942543433334, + "CVC4": 2.5129958439390601, + "CVC3": 0.13381125327884999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15131588855940001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15004080886928337 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3925335800767265, + "veriT": 9.0872544851924868, + "Yices": 4.3727211776966968, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7118441896995842, + "CVC4": 6.6042200461198002, + "CVC3": 1.0425361523981778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5428822148900814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2394066256720748 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.39770421169774994, + "veriT": 10.41380780651105, + "Yices": 5.8402745871044539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1569162656499259, + "CVC4": 4.0385239143121439, + "CVC3": 2.4173803762807111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4291884623907007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6530862265376509 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.33147554567499993, + "veriT": 13.20178704661946, + "Yices": 11.754014918335812, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6901718003305142, + "CVC4": 14.338655830602699, + "CVC3": 13.110224336268056, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239164247316438, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.241377264580485 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9960978474612627, + "veriT": 8.1889691601659145, + "Yices": 9.3892866813445544, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.561796897111032, + "CVC4": 14.35983523579916, + "CVC3": 6.6162411088517903, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.735430981447411, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8042701092161355 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2829638431604495, + "veriT": 13.639412321162913, + "Yices": 6.9293630947428726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6361480921113598, + "CVC4": 0.68684000655271427, + "CVC3": 6.4687968195891097, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.222265072320425, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230075264079957 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8470014999458331, + "veriT": 0.161077915253, + "Yices": 2.5036542867728642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8483849962630001, + "CVC4": 0.19423123636600001, + "CVC3": 0.17518854281816668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1882015621641667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17733568060416668 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5439236737332358, + "veriT": 7.4222914291259769, + "Yices": 3.9469548502578373, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.653546683603631, + "CVC4": 5.4908819998178471, + "CVC3": 7.2098343976459542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8563804538968176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4988685336622529 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0695884854279072, + "veriT": 11.257503684870279, + "Yices": 9.5012687848060136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0276015076078355, + "CVC4": 11.9360126808456, + "CVC3": 5.1596639980971668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18620907430317499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18506684872015833 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1017239093780518, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20684804488331249, + "veriT": 0.27979045840793748, + "Yices": 3.660007721955616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.70877058623049993, + "CVC4": 0.18200497032125001, + "CVC3": 0.18111504976849999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.176799402519625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1744508883765 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.240384578704834, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5886314673327417, + "veriT": 4.4155344551895137, + "Yices": 12.649034619988752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7782867761558785, + "CVC4": 3.9081104098957149, + "CVC3": 4.6083926537310722, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1997569526090546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9824014329479871 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14210430857766665, + "veriT": 1.7817398696510001, + "Yices": 2.4727594422327877, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17335864013616664, + "CVC4": 0.31762938452700001, + "CVC3": 2.4963034582482906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14358544115033334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14201844117766668 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.136983504521375, + "veriT": 5.7501105619275696, + "Yices": 10.400281522834804, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25375000663800001, + "CVC4": 0.34725543957462501, + "CVC3": 0.140115421468375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8793381102345847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8993155751997846 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6023713938249831, + "veriT": 11.723549203568105, + "Yices": 12.055484078118376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9174023920396559, + "CVC4": 12.950193913423433, + "CVC3": 11.939500840230092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.278674255602883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.252510629212146 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5316891885200121, + "veriT": 7.5471602191090108, + "Yices": 12.024491628467461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.8536543466297, + "CVC4": 5.0718689320932757, + "CVC3": 6.5158232950685244, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2607155598377089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3077010063534926 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16848184400607694, + "veriT": 0.92074125015269226, + "Yices": 0.93281927198130765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3033603206102597, + "CVC4": 0.19800264692730768, + "CVC3": 0.171705206187, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17901906655476921, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17987589605199999 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22397075227059998, + "veriT": 8.2240519745403322, + "Yices": 9.6370059421288214, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7828668721631844, + "CVC4": 7.9511006611030259, + "CVC3": 9.7635824098422574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1608199436222595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2473624158573218 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7632063818300496, + "veriT": 6.1948912803174592, + "Yices": 8.3111985016451957, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8640969694259095, + "CVC4": 0.23704463036611109, + "CVC3": 0.22520588413544443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7699622837419331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7702674479731639 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 73.0, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6794273829778561, + "veriT": 11.427657511795191, + "Yices": 10.555268920749988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8748301291135583, + "CVC4": 8.6374624731516843, + "CVC3": 7.600498128559356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8099757009147277, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7873105777726572 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2447737429948376, + "veriT": 12.738511226230843, + "Yices": 11.470529594502047, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.064060869508143, + "CVC4": 12.779585798561728, + "CVC3": 6.213970596429828, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.303955591722282, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.067386730649863 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1715688705444336, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 64.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15021603921099999, + "veriT": 3.2571966229432392, + "Yices": 0.15427418733922224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15771823804777779, + "CVC4": 0.17721663578166666, + "CVC3": 0.14965895459477779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16167810425655554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16126202536522222 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1559618696833329, + "veriT": 4.0457051115774707, + "Yices": 1.7999405814950002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1569374579416669, + "CVC4": 7.2395673869142243, + "CVC3": 0.13374381550549999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19448479447099998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17576975356250002 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15118792983311111, + "veriT": 0.12777806911033335, + "Yices": 0.14782323276183332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15295663056922221, + "CVC4": 0.16622908529555555, + "CVC3": 0.14977567703822223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16207793190838887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1629042419856111 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6944924035804867, + "veriT": 10.453674208550568, + "Yices": 6.4358596406911159, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.527659547191536, + "CVC4": 8.5418276234646697, + "CVC3": 8.567212034272341, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1869071829066353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4714312116216952 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20846302088883331, + "veriT": 8.8495736863728673, + "Yices": 1.6306176157944376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.63117981006325008, + "CVC4": 1.3598480682013514, + "CVC3": 5.771219705650565, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17055453371275001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16972594392600002 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 115.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1801973726448711, + "veriT": 11.581958212955222, + "Yices": 9.2804928964098377, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9151902615864351, + "CVC4": 7.5839781247132292, + "CVC3": 3.0081229673960381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8151606509142413, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5814020007387182 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.9834454114848, + "veriT": 12.618468632144136, + "Yices": 12.657050762329721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.962337755730562, + "CVC4": 14.493350655214508, + "CVC3": 13.612283930397169, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6040076577683973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1377145065221281 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.566905293920964, + "veriT": 12.48171930367457, + "Yices": 10.44778866754392, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97025529322447, + "CVC4": 14.673077735402634, + "CVC3": 13.037325740163046, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.432813796882503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.364621215015651 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8889391074873427, + "veriT": 13.552077342917881, + "Yices": 5.1058943777865489, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6171693967463519, + "CVC4": 3.9099327495498524, + "CVC3": 3.1169659007172599, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9042391165707047, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8771305652260182 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.311319380562654, + "veriT": 13.004625115887135, + "Yices": 12.82329102877291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.587726509986556, + "CVC4": 13.759793179041507, + "CVC3": 10.380416297386573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.160096974498725, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.446248809128454 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 175.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 90.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.316195586557145, + "veriT": 12.768027293754342, + "Yices": 12.838519658694429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.989638280870176, + "CVC4": 13.708280721755813, + "CVC3": 10.676168309210016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.895035499944489, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.808025180055628 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.156594925644752, + "veriT": 12.614375874887962, + "Yices": 12.551414824308214, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964363537351915, + "CVC4": 14.524063965262958, + "CVC3": 14.169476075954091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.142555254366, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.065009341887498 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1234473008981674, + "veriT": 12.952034045111279, + "Yices": 13.259145546691366, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.367631403234794, + "CVC4": 13.671408510445213, + "CVC3": 9.0666510642584193, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.949324965304006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.951652940429174 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0732043726905163, + "veriT": 12.643751564950213, + "Yices": 11.939798220337359, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955929848453152, + "CVC4": 8.0242621764566504, + "CVC3": 13.774031007474528, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8220742758281543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8358110248748591 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 137.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7990820407867432, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4251147183436794, + "veriT": 7.8584705027700688, + "Yices": 10.215947893556622, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.874130415126679, + "CVC4": 10.124043853413809, + "CVC3": 8.1866872270672353, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3107890523076584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.581747322883519 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.41824259602399999, + "veriT": 14.221781602957766, + "Yices": 13.977973861949895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2816973007561678, + "CVC4": 11.575446692110983, + "CVC3": 5.5672755028228753, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.367916207416314, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.333523151262431 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7067068375131997, + "veriT": 11.398361594818576, + "Yices": 6.1728387783861365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2216801827218, + "CVC4": 6.0595398060951968, + "CVC3": 8.765819886508023, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21033792315120001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20632566724459997 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 58.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.446354842628015, + "veriT": 13.706895639194173, + "Yices": 14.259220630664938, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.068772350582952, + "CVC4": 14.586992171438544, + "CVC3": 13.180532005736405, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.212428661565173, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.229889573525073 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.763113937382277, + "veriT": 14.24467187601684, + "Yices": 14.250336886243186, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976919090549345, + "CVC4": 14.449159442276599, + "CVC3": 13.748836163962954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.972867823223242, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.977977855468396 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.269983262178057, + "veriT": 13.120311678383244, + "Yices": 12.789525448803161, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.717768052758816, + "CVC4": 10.581138073109765, + "CVC3": 14.262748386940851, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.28063082560506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.861996713138248 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 410.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6638811430984983, + "veriT": 14.222508604375731, + "Yices": 14.284733381092416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.509305646902542, + "CVC4": 14.502059125021631, + "CVC3": 14.11561845325437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5224225279789438, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.585392753161309 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243822550811055, + "veriT": 13.082263225133925, + "Yices": 13.071595344776892, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.772897143582924, + "CVC4": 14.89282013467504, + "CVC3": 8.7458802746547182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.696432203436967, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.929652297111344 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13127421576864706, + "veriT": 0.10061511252061175, + "Yices": 0.10420848692113235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12849333062341176, + "CVC4": 0.12919650567176469, + "CVC3": 0.10799192836396469, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12657461798594116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12450324743856471 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11192402872152918, + "veriT": 0.49620044929630835, + "Yices": 0.4998157231069959, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11787997628427083, + "CVC4": 0.69175356579019809, + "CVC3": 0.084360143219074993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.69019767341988825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.68842720406045543 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1100154545783747, + "veriT": 0.081868624283250008, + "Yices": 0.081548536819612508, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1092669408648748, + "CVC4": 0.12090913381475001, + "CVC3": 0.090794567642424995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.111810036301875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11116491793512501 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.72905549455347485, + "veriT": 10.164023264275592, + "Yices": 10.350597809603554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.80586329299284909, + "CVC4": 0.14900569361559257, + "CVC3": 0.69096186747937038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14874193181988887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.455002315370216 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18286582107342858, + "veriT": 7.2905243891869995, + "Yices": 9.0538052834197149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.29882806698814285, + "CVC4": 0.15169356877442858, + "CVC3": 0.26432802153728568, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14880438526200002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1302753085447144 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7029409408569336, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2338548511465, + "veriT": 7.9264642926215165, + "Yices": 7.9629577492908385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.227467541727818, + "CVC4": 5.7164611058130852, + "CVC3": 4.2071824498062504, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4207833673703369, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1552592957745791 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.623357866161208, + "veriT": 7.9319729425328216, + "Yices": 6.3963120439287149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9334500697291856, + "CVC4": 2.2602497575591975, + "CVC3": 6.1620166381892858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8440795733858062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.683275467881321 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238778365985773, + "veriT": 10.154137037970667, + "Yices": 10.328640310456999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958492156738052, + "CVC4": 0.15607943031688892, + "CVC3": 9.8000084738952751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6343470410579961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.338766117670637 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.660786106489804, + "veriT": 10.741093856384262, + "Yices": 10.529895743291144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.269006187061407, + "CVC4": 2.3268305655689496, + "CVC3": 11.078452948541733, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7274079673498646, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.68098126491938 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.268273211652522, + "veriT": 10.150008465896999, + "Yices": 10.496888843748222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.415407110469765, + "CVC4": 0.18166606913700001, + "CVC3": 10.382759776977515, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16106415816277775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.716967266146604 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233268831089564, + "veriT": 10.159907617805693, + "Yices": 10.320653608591847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.9526958313888, + "CVC4": 0.17638123593999999, + "CVC3": 14.233154948483245, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6396783240261366, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.259707146692183 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1968787609764036, + "veriT": 9.1758615824445098, + "Yices": 7.9398589154473758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5482399924634285, + "CVC4": 2.0450929496490136, + "CVC3": 7.1846408633884842, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.319468823265352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.21022818327285 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6076924800872803, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3604898272936374, + "veriT": 11.367856419439391, + "Yices": 15.001655843267983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8689445887064382, + "CVC4": 1.5095210027278716, + "CVC3": 9.4934715465035087, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4746859669118599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.086899344478061 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1095696886595361, + "veriT": 11.902313182720563, + "Yices": 9.9731530319799955, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7329352963301554, + "CVC4": 6.3334813844765154, + "CVC3": 10.283341954391124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1882740620347656, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8556972227927835 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.334709939339101, + "veriT": 12.840071666912941, + "Yices": 12.508822295588333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.576140802655225, + "CVC4": 14.790525536107014, + "CVC3": 14.781471723380118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.774104341272142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.772509641008268 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.951466231449293, + "veriT": 9.7693984193623766, + "Yices": 10.655776181067829, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.157806723866893, + "CVC4": 5.6600378743849076, + "CVC3": 7.7725243701295961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5515607534340852, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0529134511864164 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.126032450955671, + "veriT": 11.980379502301465, + "Yices": 10.966181089183744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.348842608729774, + "CVC4": 12.329444581190293, + "CVC3": 13.561571231712556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.718106149800978, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.871995496016641 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.414895753948713, + "veriT": 10.618802621805276, + "Yices": 10.284419162888401, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.986851867451932, + "CVC4": 2.1871382742016001, + "CVC3": 9.4606385587703468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8065981015794375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.472267302657668 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0880821827075611, + "veriT": 11.082362023110724, + "Yices": 11.388067534576468, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0304735033577472, + "CVC4": 12.335123113095969, + "CVC3": 9.1526693801275858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.095745194867849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5411532335772495 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1714286804199219, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.375938221527793, + "veriT": 8.5451548014034291, + "Yices": 10.320426092307429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.917140290170815, + "CVC4": 0.17285367119043751, + "CVC3": 10.676667491173411, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.155346864282233, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.492288402992546 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235862731333432, + "veriT": 10.168382151683126, + "Yices": 10.32155712931875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951009007953873, + "CVC4": 0.16693604168675, + "CVC3": 10.766493196196222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2027158984909541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.198510290851248 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.677222557155947, + "veriT": 9.0438753411388895, + "Yices": 9.2051980461533329, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.314916381478605, + "CVC4": 0.15907686271277777, + "CVC3": 13.258492393754491, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7299207490844077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.108621923005138 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2305769653104086, + "veriT": 8.8973998543394135, + "Yices": 8.2808136836406945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8150419498858383, + "CVC4": 2.0574911960074078, + "CVC3": 7.813023434183318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.057684256051032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9273511970421673 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1366391810068889, + "veriT": 0.12164796406671112, + "Yices": 6.2666634961832228, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13755418639726669, + "CVC4": 1.7060961365463174, + "CVC3": 1.2789934382375998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18794777271366669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18584116290448888 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8309519290924072, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9335528012373935, + "veriT": 8.5968742984357753, + "Yices": 7.5537663503421157, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0445448420042762, + "CVC4": 7.9464544341780892, + "CVC3": 6.8739394013971422, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9921211657104232, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9911627850152822 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.562386115203557, + "veriT": 11.615977947196283, + "Yices": 10.851869183672251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.597758547241813, + "CVC4": 10.257413914531478, + "CVC3": 7.5411638986860954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.063698149085065, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.665352776155347 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5792059403572853, + "veriT": 14.210835289632424, + "Yices": 12.438383677780998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8609653987357468, + "CVC4": 14.876748357530495, + "CVC3": 12.220791080311743, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241841446417936, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.232630283071906 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8644444942474365, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14253879648600001, + "veriT": 11.855908397126628, + "Yices": 0.11175137059899999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23001659139733333, + "CVC4": 2.7187819984076396, + "CVC3": 0.12118101578149999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8331194989421018, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8301042786272292 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8150901178816219, + "veriT": 14.208552238411958, + "Yices": 3.0459202845925555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4580722535720807, + "CVC4": 3.4516232006461878, + "CVC3": 2.0867323634658028, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.957118483676162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.951943401024453 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.078251838684082, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.229703833420292, + "veriT": 9.3111001831279605, + "Yices": 9.0221576469534703, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.846261243183294, + "CVC4": 2.2734000723161665, + "CVC3": 12.230102163530324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1626242570253726, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.181529548666067 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.542326584566979, + "veriT": 9.0534793885976725, + "Yices": 7.9706700875478971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.068729386963103, + "CVC4": 7.7393114291809137, + "CVC3": 6.3812064443424372, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.021007690548412, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.087755054201642 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8642550192830769, + "veriT": 1.5390787619754787, + "Yices": 6.1820584493241482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.907886093537297, + "CVC4": 2.882320529017131, + "CVC3": 1.1562229379001672, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1436008992114823, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5432941430860745 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7752525806427002, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6581000719844443, + "veriT": 6.1315170386255256, + "Yices": 6.849423107057965, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5418515366444998, + "CVC4": 4.885557265205029, + "CVC3": 4.7438856246239425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9622868238524624, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2791549617895202 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6867629261191119, + "veriT": 9.4903451748183461, + "Yices": 10.219441827173618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.065289332852371, + "CVC4": 9.7492876258600116, + "CVC3": 8.5920385653578979, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.967084674894211, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.643566306823226 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.54818595462066666, + "veriT": 10.109678799249, + "Yices": 10.122439697921566, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0580474262533799, + "CVC4": 7.6713880990623844, + "CVC3": 4.4853408057305844, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.947376203922651, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.957458469682878 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9609725475311279, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1353980713428999, + "veriT": 0.11444175705404999, + "Yices": 2.9322107321889428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1346146448683001, + "CVC4": 1.5700610572252403, + "CVC3": 0.12913517864990001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5425587644979664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5395730474585301 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2041957399798751, + "veriT": 6.8945362055273725, + "Yices": 6.3546382169765829, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2399806479290127, + "CVC4": 10.236426711851133, + "CVC3": 0.18818622417782499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8711208472077958, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.77662770786708 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5137582392862334, + "veriT": 10.526088614918104, + "Yices": 9.1407527606195647, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6945286745937489, + "CVC4": 8.8736657184627585, + "CVC3": 6.7209168724091022, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.728343771271502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6820480784536649 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3484845161437988, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13555921241205335, + "veriT": 7.7067629701098577, + "Yices": 9.8614062437856855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14005892383721999, + "CVC4": 4.5663518305719775, + "CVC3": 0.83046101391420002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1399409689287654, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.131235756070105 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17611825610341666, + "veriT": 1.1671547943775833, + "Yices": 0.98989402394430026, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.69610215079241688, + "CVC4": 0.17625319923141666, + "CVC3": 0.17243367704783333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16284512129533335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16139971562116667 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8651281447503849, + "veriT": 7.4789614045628001, + "Yices": 8.5610799653419996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.176552802734224, + "CVC4": 5.6271030024443993, + "CVC3": 2.6836660051070527, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4943520395654399, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.446464085503406 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1944446563720703, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.049943649659033, + "veriT": 12.472490751968412, + "Yices": 10.198310666508643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.466286540098952, + "CVC4": 14.786754100880737, + "CVC3": 13.962400566383113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2028488914928186, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7384728860009151 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0827648682533875, + "veriT": 4.7044687261596367, + "Yices": 11.501727436928261, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2673935611145408, + "CVC4": 8.8851060682916305, + "CVC3": 8.7277106707214323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9425103029885484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9421548598367044 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8978218120547314, + "veriT": 5.8569743124497782, + "Yices": 8.8734315856053367, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9920291669543335, + "CVC4": 3.3741901995316503, + "CVC3": 4.9470435191346676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21859482468288888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4527452261529568 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9899267087343961, + "veriT": 6.450903766260744, + "Yices": 5.9438490216187656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2249120665897095, + "CVC4": 9.0038521249585699, + "CVC3": 2.4233083389906001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6322124904994375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4854444869974195 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7573598939817927, + "veriT": 13.887154972163438, + "Yices": 12.562805242466505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0226063568065378, + "CVC4": 8.5440630631767025, + "CVC3": 11.027498061591308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.318704020967624, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.289380890472756 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7333329916000366, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.826144154776118, + "veriT": 10.211071056606375, + "Yices": 10.386226260442001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.780030617790665, + "CVC4": 10.803900456018376, + "CVC3": 12.582093747870523, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.271023367704887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.390732590352528 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9831878540570371, + "veriT": 2.621116771715966, + "Yices": 4.641491455561682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.046480847066066, + "CVC4": 1.3256332357628893, + "CVC3": 0.13476384175000003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4859086997353665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3126499375598426 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1537497699979, + "veriT": 1.5403132985761137, + "Yices": 0.14358190375162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1537982398369402, + "CVC4": 1.5841819639376169, + "CVC3": 0.15346726406563999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15550798086800002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15950106654467999 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16453271471641667, + "veriT": 0.14465288546258331, + "Yices": 0.15255225423883331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16386995394916667, + "CVC4": 0.18503237840525, + "CVC3": 0.16308394491775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17744323940229167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17428356281716664 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8792774877762408, + "veriT": 5.8319965677424657, + "Yices": 5.8948325686777006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2333266123552535, + "CVC4": 4.5484077705374064, + "CVC3": 2.3889066350599699, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3484644332285132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1065459661246495 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.758799898576652, + "veriT": 9.7424312674235996, + "Yices": 4.7305089440954289, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6454553126128655, + "CVC4": 6.2984925533367004, + "CVC3": 5.1809501954962256, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2014149425852256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1652765852715588 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.045508067394143, + "veriT": 6.4123081109032141, + "Yices": 6.0949430214481426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.456051433341555, + "CVC4": 10.294052909369611, + "CVC3": 5.7216000879554043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1871593692036617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1486786423646773 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16237338200455556, + "veriT": 4.8493901487968252, + "Yices": 1.7183952232415298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18734101639888889, + "CVC4": 1.7660749235898821, + "CVC3": 3.1209644305189266, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9543367188674914, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0129056693300211 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14462304197477499, + "veriT": 1.415797799099175, + "Yices": 10.600296442546895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14298307887666251, + "CVC4": 8.9901896402750054, + "CVC3": 4.0029520483648753, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15593781593563749, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14869912876548752 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.8395400683723333, + "veriT": 12.084216507153355, + "Yices": 9.5688867079558477, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2986869157654812, + "CVC4": 3.4840907978489106, + "CVC3": 7.0048221411789182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6024989768166833, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4351700743409275 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.47181390857496, + "veriT": 11.42031266197132, + "Yices": 11.420140198149278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.936976139701567, + "CVC4": 12.821314718286876, + "CVC3": 12.458735973824981, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.400516998144788, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.185010293838145 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23374460114394, + "veriT": 12.741074077296567, + "Yices": 10.821903228815184, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95628116560987, + "CVC4": 14.838419107483809, + "CVC3": 13.081691021353707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.94723254672747, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.42261138061197 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0569748878479004, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 102.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.230316541224132, + "veriT": 13.044158660237647, + "Yices": 8.7357856960172651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.925385109226565, + "CVC4": 10.435546170274, + "CVC3": 1.4262818212810002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9252585071661574, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9397878424066599 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6178424563458345, + "veriT": 12.693154692916853, + "Yices": 10.066813979412352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8706585143630985, + "CVC4": 12.533041050466945, + "CVC3": 11.052980960675274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.248759498491317, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.510782129087103 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9652564525604248, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.156420677923875, + "veriT": 12.727630269699548, + "Yices": 4.3031885478877498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7624054060194601, + "CVC4": 4.0827726942020668, + "CVC3": 3.0670121227186056, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22378026538162502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6785928712774181 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.399030450370446, + "veriT": 12.240974448094653, + "Yices": 12.875439131601821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975166760395483, + "CVC4": 7.3979665365499931, + "CVC3": 7.4987734429623911, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.245800874561982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2018415652625727 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19803182581066667, + "veriT": 7.0550125098358922, + "Yices": 0.54792545644011115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.6632144457917778, + "CVC4": 0.18598786005177775, + "CVC3": 4.7754921167806161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16485211118988888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16035997179533334 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2799237288186633, + "veriT": 12.984614331703522, + "Yices": 9.7373773337259522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9431141557964979, + "CVC4": 7.3403250630034051, + "CVC3": 5.3295834992888969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6100718277619883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5525229246598649 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 497.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1826965808868408, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26472295459512, + "veriT": 11.722742062897058, + "Yices": 11.542803984509415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.478355980862782, + "CVC4": 13.584807350228786, + "CVC3": 14.256922230726843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257369396752637, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.475591119268538 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.2285286163547, + "veriT": 10.582147154070473, + "Yices": 11.101635765944913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.941653878372371, + "CVC4": 14.801166344418826, + "CVC3": 11.479066881860007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228359911807766, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.182105610365859 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.953422319314933, + "veriT": 11.675173945597091, + "Yices": 11.038666299661076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.784642414759283, + "CVC4": 11.069295382293893, + "CVC3": 11.499150354633151, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0672314852268059, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1444618113109435 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9868356967402985, + "veriT": 13.980288728117946, + "Yices": 12.926225599017458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955701270002438, + "CVC4": 13.646680854468629, + "CVC3": 14.006286374672911, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.184716394943917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.178521630824504 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6821663275803971, + "veriT": 13.416328557514277, + "Yices": 12.331683929799444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3397819350887783, + "CVC4": 13.091777517517105, + "CVC3": 10.606510133932455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.041793513746532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.941942213040956 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.319540398707808, + "veriT": 11.087004600483997, + "Yices": 10.221937370176242, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5527670681101302, + "CVC4": 11.379494392325764, + "CVC3": 4.6771463947607916, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.919545545999632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.857692756121025 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7104273009708812, + "veriT": 14.222853540213267, + "Yices": 14.26365381738551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8634028813992565, + "CVC4": 14.363430398216641, + "CVC3": 6.0749455249588298, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.946727674477446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.946972338406503 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.569613851519263, + "veriT": 11.913367698377398, + "Yices": 10.457912265833984, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7281046482520726, + "CVC4": 10.899486244816613, + "CVC3": 13.00999030085422, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6340552131796391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5753511248639873 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 317.0, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6856495674629794, + "veriT": 13.095565339773135, + "Yices": 13.761340168306216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.695796441297864, + "CVC4": 6.6829343666434786, + "CVC3": 14.24481540835656, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.23476343261691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8137896235903153 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.680252939502779, + "veriT": 13.550394157986204, + "Yices": 13.792939102506486, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.603576418864309, + "CVC4": 14.853167734047821, + "CVC3": 8.3873873366922993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.000938926458019, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.153576562069958 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.258832618293233, + "veriT": 13.811220963745384, + "Yices": 13.555256985085428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.982763233247409, + "CVC4": 14.661220939630319, + "CVC3": 13.644962640682982, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.036570643282111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.73806548455015 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11758840173398667, + "veriT": 0.090228519962246692, + "Yices": 0.092112971177333344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11530194962281332, + "CVC4": 0.11387863999236666, + "CVC3": 0.094064015463420012, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11265211411316664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11206822479654001 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12700001498691896, + "veriT": 0.098196454214791895, + "Yices": 0.10049835119801352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12302890311289189, + "CVC4": 0.12368431425318914, + "CVC3": 0.10309924126812703, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12314050773770267, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12099125360543783 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2035115431418557, + "veriT": 3.9437630024970458, + "Yices": 3.1984247472688248, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4611001242696044, + "CVC4": 5.4602385647290976, + "CVC3": 0.17482421694418751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19807161898737499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19545561751625001 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20762829963499996, + "veriT": 10.167035452353, + "Yices": 10.349543461934154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26342578646038467, + "CVC4": 0.14956174314557694, + "CVC3": 0.71741676367750007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1504589110988846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.43672286902712 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1929202069771111, + "veriT": 8.3822336306241958, + "Yices": 8.5117887590948769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.35392834605311108, + "CVC4": 1.7978765159099395, + "CVC3": 1.8012000355365387, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7135021019510814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7791262608722835 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8946948600580011, + "veriT": 11.817914572609157, + "Yices": 11.582988204571686, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.066705521188581, + "CVC4": 12.821894146512436, + "CVC3": 9.8753215074679286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.735392139348219, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.554604484436725 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8533235183482928, + "veriT": 3.9105550364093782, + "Yices": 2.4963184985081179, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6137205092738629, + "CVC4": 3.109003904026447, + "CVC3": 2.52318888452431, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9347942783582708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9306420777040842 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6694498148775683, + "veriT": 7.9603779422003438, + "Yices": 7.4506062733912604, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.504369190617615, + "CVC4": 3.1160574635525333, + "CVC3": 4.6796817914938043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9623382270311218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4589670885725035 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14006696511373848, + "veriT": 3.5029662978897047, + "Yices": 4.2934027434285165, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1358756270935077, + "CVC4": 1.6832369495799695, + "CVC3": 1.7700796031652308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.26798802068669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1214398101148046 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.644603899452541, + "veriT": 10.177256477260777, + "Yices": 10.323220618966332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959744339878613, + "CVC4": 2.5409197591226671, + "CVC3": 10.092941983752326, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6782797236442022, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.219154575453572 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.577519716036946, + "veriT": 11.407648598026432, + "Yices": 10.383483975836999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.005746646355814, + "CVC4": 10.744700736583557, + "CVC3": 10.882899431934216, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7266158565848375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0545026915895104 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.920093963328702, + "veriT": 8.4953273171405002, + "Yices": 10.331574913818416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.521398477792827, + "CVC4": 0.17319836048241666, + "CVC3": 11.632141973698113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.616649761384044, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.250665407405313 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3576752123910958, + "veriT": 8.6607915020557211, + "Yices": 5.2068416113399749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6991465102532697, + "CVC4": 0.89515874686124997, + "CVC3": 5.4556293283192021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.039028509383126, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8151616722781272 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7111034589138052, + "veriT": 9.8239042653751465, + "Yices": 6.4149639891072745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8782561499620076, + "CVC4": 4.201915861702588, + "CVC3": 4.7143864748658268, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8962941217797784, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2585723604867889 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6954374836440467, + "veriT": 1.2286984357445001, + "Yices": 1.2510771265413334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7702359818513749, + "CVC4": 0.13551782972033333, + "CVC3": 0.24004282630968893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13494621831855558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3795781284753585 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4775321583062917, + "veriT": 7.6967476106549242, + "Yices": 7.2986992576599148, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2820938944133209, + "CVC4": 6.3210213332812932, + "CVC3": 4.288941005856131, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.35068660770785, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.29902527971152 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242069747470847, + "veriT": 10.16207880827494, + "Yices": 10.334330112915625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959920130843718, + "CVC4": 0.17651595594887501, + "CVC3": 11.680096772717306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.84491731083402621, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.27297675991904 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7605816523111337, + "veriT": 7.420549209710213, + "Yices": 7.4887651271894953, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.241257356981988, + "CVC4": 1.3027606008319004, + "CVC3": 2.8705128747977069, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9926833884575128, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.071059414208094 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.224849455562545, + "veriT": 12.4756847165511, + "Yices": 12.113038786454299, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.567231443602491, + "CVC4": 6.6047004162334106, + "CVC3": 12.128623061496429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.444970859951184, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.939818898904221 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5477636621965498, + "veriT": 11.512727570150822, + "Yices": 10.072396885704663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.036393494787253, + "CVC4": 3.3047084881482238, + "CVC3": 12.37085138445833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2946792651995356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6185655583443541 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.229024811705647, + "veriT": 12.694209165906427, + "Yices": 12.411557749164896, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948396044958548, + "CVC4": 4.8687011602145702, + "CVC3": 9.4505579322301916, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.153338224394016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0357001704286635 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5777241293136006, + "veriT": 12.814240498228699, + "Yices": 10.378761387595715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.210517413334227, + "CVC4": 9.5085134906376485, + "CVC3": 4.5887063107942909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.413253655586963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.413624114526352 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.232645878464769, + "veriT": 13.66424087828271, + "Yices": 9.6050179094029211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.912012211793559, + "CVC4": 13.736797390160918, + "CVC3": 13.614887145978855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.68666698949125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.485767556785074 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5415852461736472, + "veriT": 4.164495051779582, + "Yices": 3.9485466138326495, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6902945297614274, + "CVC4": 2.6255438224682011, + "CVC3": 4.9136520378883839, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4956130189482693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8421690030542042 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3226069646793479, + "veriT": 6.8769554882919994, + "Yices": 12.366702857966326, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7288455468280213, + "CVC4": 4.3469720100697185, + "CVC3": 7.6431903712635663, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1995529714221194, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.751400671148041 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6966910362243652, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7639131139913999, + "veriT": 7.9898598131849816, + "Yices": 5.8156225060059095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5207181914333194, + "CVC4": 1.454192009880465, + "CVC3": 5.2619170485928635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4231653117185528, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5917696264891159 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0801279544830322, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7613635063171387, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6894273630839916, + "veriT": 9.8830186583567095, + "Yices": 9.3764969117865054, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.476183379288068, + "CVC4": 8.2917001763301297, + "CVC3": 8.7121054695366205, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1916095341651971, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.518030590654229 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23575446717776924, + "veriT": 10.435885803670601, + "Yices": 10.587283247248383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.89287105540461542, + "CVC4": 12.079263589852031, + "CVC3": 4.4048959353233661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.1478243284079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.140427501686538 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2777625192809143, + "veriT": 10.105407630222009, + "Yices": 10.109251207429855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.302903843759228, + "CVC4": 2.8894595303037272, + "CVC3": 2.4712252963370043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230299951511775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.226605164269451 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.419880314406428, + "veriT": 9.5422019395963424, + "Yices": 7.3091711640735424, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6080245538267253, + "CVC4": 8.2768178345752741, + "CVC3": 6.2013832949104293, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2202357568654687, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8439733616621261 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4352999535000519, + "veriT": 2.5183222179872167, + "Yices": 6.686059433412356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0802680266682994, + "CVC4": 2.405809440291319, + "CVC3": 3.4248807152174794, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6097377984579762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6078812351412384 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7294149627318056, + "veriT": 5.1087393154886627, + "Yices": 13.41384385399933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1167730138490928, + "CVC4": 10.165816623249043, + "CVC3": 9.9628845945494948, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2637687078721118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.201035770183335 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2040729619617263, + "veriT": 10.127491128591506, + "Yices": 10.681059891775641, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8007999474295069, + "CVC4": 12.319527686209247, + "CVC3": 7.7752193322519805, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.982812425284173, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.78521274998465 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16363546715093333, + "veriT": 0.87382029149326668, + "Yices": 12.861074368516906, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19518514178199997, + "CVC4": 7.9571905544757406, + "CVC3": 10.64705509264471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0252248301974216, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9986102418477616 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.79352493293786674, + "veriT": 14.206803307891613, + "Yices": 0.21327929605259996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.79506103343899992, + "CVC4": 0.15918442203333333, + "CVC3": 0.13709649128873333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.096766585508645, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.149022712028573 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24785423947942853, + "veriT": 13.633621456594581, + "Yices": 5.8682169414369172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2638430517180095, + "CVC4": 10.375416222233886, + "CVC3": 11.466774716688713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.291604951782352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7463540312126167 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 47.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.960270289111965, + "veriT": 9.8253081827118436, + "Yices": 9.0111102746537775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1598059945614061, + "CVC4": 8.0885401508595809, + "CVC3": 9.7530323376550676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8109037645500496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4270427676160029 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.81004422569427281, + "veriT": 3.5938171834531545, + "Yices": 5.0460152949411032, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5032002864727572, + "CVC4": 0.42170681136745453, + "CVC3": 0.32577979910918181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7186338411501221, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7128902680807587 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0111110210418701, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9267854690551758, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5937929999705713, + "veriT": 1.5720286772178285, + "Yices": 7.9395135639814116, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6049091374814284, + "CVC4": 10.265313733275846, + "CVC3": 0.16819076830757143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.74924405550641426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9527175471738429 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4118531372598175, + "veriT": 3.9585172290982467, + "Yices": 0.65061491171101815, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4130106677522178, + "CVC4": 9.1550870048529234, + "CVC3": 0.12941881579430908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12803247184009089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1288828356208 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 78.0, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.178330006412, + "veriT": 0.16973697696214285, + "Yices": 1.605929531516143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17531933768771427, + "CVC4": 0.18890967242928575, + "CVC3": 0.18011625490057143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18277440199257144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17856495201357142 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12499901072745452, + "veriT": 0.098749954209809088, + "Yices": 0.10477920228781819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12178142308084547, + "CVC4": 0.12692453345767271, + "CVC3": 0.11404627831681818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12860607958993639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12981072524095455 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17406804620916669, + "veriT": 0.15634966528233332, + "Yices": 0.22054449785416663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18117893542516669, + "CVC4": 0.20416277526649998, + "CVC3": 0.18323983270550001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18637706604449999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18636831217500002 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23123161001170001, + "veriT": 3.0763243310408028, + "Yices": 8.4602574939015689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.44202432484997506, + "CVC4": 0.2236159209415125, + "CVC3": 1.5090683263218749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.27420131626599997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.28120109149299999 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8202814813411667, + "veriT": 7.4966517691396177, + "Yices": 11.795138625088279, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8216499676954332, + "CVC4": 2.5303922320304157, + "CVC3": 4.2113695517171434, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0969953079582284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1209183475669304 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15528114905364704, + "veriT": 4.2738530156899071, + "Yices": 0.15753637665288234, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17493314930252943, + "CVC4": 0.17432223641688238, + "CVC3": 0.44239191302052949, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16323615135064706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1642004369292353 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 160.0, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9172861227889997, + "veriT": 6.6958563478888449, + "Yices": 8.0304084628381922, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1129500525672498, + "CVC4": 14.388449403592514, + "CVC3": 7.1320793050334963, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9553392404928753, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0643757395243751 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0640276394049097, + "veriT": 10.580008541999064, + "Yices": 6.0860444140657508, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2901799123196902, + "CVC4": 8.6547728557186527, + "CVC3": 6.4569461469142837, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.023792140773081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.405980635074364 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7551364898681641, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.39060248008425, + "veriT": 3.6357617978393959, + "Yices": 2.4736914085623747, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.390016215005125, + "CVC4": 1.9601536800582551, + "CVC3": 1.4373043416882498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.69812287196924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.69592769830008 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8829913385731558, + "veriT": 10.526471408657256, + "Yices": 11.018396662881537, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9002710467371244, + "CVC4": 11.993801362117113, + "CVC3": 9.4412586617608465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.267004641096824, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.842223348134516 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0167005062103271, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5830348148735354, + "veriT": 2.1613114542015999, + "Yices": 2.3538227125905999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6570495671204668, + "CVC4": 3.0240462693390269, + "CVC3": 2.9002437226099014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19111528889319998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3025233960141707 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3101349027083966, + "veriT": 10.60895948142883, + "Yices": 7.8620939783984598, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.025461187239666, + "CVC4": 3.3060940882608358, + "CVC3": 3.2429891128782833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4661122372823998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6126020113143298 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15454475342412502, + "veriT": 12.67707508272181, + "Yices": 2.2823298129396248, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17697926225837499, + "CVC4": 0.24748948250949998, + "CVC3": 1.9033162728737225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2245529618804589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2239127093796469 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7363854605886164, + "veriT": 14.222214348112557, + "Yices": 8.5065875951570078, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4666731828748256, + "CVC4": 7.0456017430764009, + "CVC3": 11.690682046008261, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234457619892821, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237633247652878 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0366614299681429, + "veriT": 9.6096092695308357, + "Yices": 9.0797774386344123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6166581365124699, + "CVC4": 10.46152888524102, + "CVC3": 3.315777106899314, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2318528901352206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9487698047813922 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 53.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.206602268678016, + "veriT": 13.109435584004981, + "Yices": 7.414128919235913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7341435678106238, + "CVC4": 7.7450425880537335, + "CVC3": 5.6201311179355651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.212058749605308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.817320628845172 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.413205494787535, + "veriT": 11.30384717700343, + "Yices": 12.08039624693115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.937461671375063, + "CVC4": 14.38191785898182, + "CVC3": 11.481922795524452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231038732348138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.039399911942237 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 87.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22485153984690004, + "veriT": 7.775112635056658, + "Yices": 1.5117898098508999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.68622679573860013, + "CVC4": 1.6761343378821452, + "CVC3": 4.3167092464310048, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9767855721883576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9756168753179959 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 38.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9853439331054688, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9182076848898655, + "veriT": 12.081313286551238, + "Yices": 12.640195949818784, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.20502902000041, + "CVC4": 12.465043897389704, + "CVC3": 9.3151455374573864, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253148031652639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.465440139971951 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0366961304064883, + "veriT": 11.985588218416117, + "Yices": 13.762190927645465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4723512782449317, + "CVC4": 13.373643765942976, + "CVC3": 3.9831490608085778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9944991860406385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5575586907110197 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5398582543541615, + "veriT": 13.148789032358481, + "Yices": 5.7318460749493161, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.801492825856586, + "CVC4": 4.8163930072003831, + "CVC3": 3.0812575630474934, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5862917342701954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4015730929031318 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0930109024047852, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6040076568234083, + "veriT": 11.765008430335541, + "Yices": 11.841979629661358, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.971698812486631, + "CVC4": 7.9348219286752633, + "CVC3": 8.7915585702567576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.346792359753602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.345994681277512 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5634936484540845, + "veriT": 13.554928280973806, + "Yices": 11.891654895468255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.793778406740667, + "CVC4": 10.121534706277945, + "CVC3": 8.0684672074019499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2639587140084867, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2597797922433607 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 197.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.052285158132074, + "veriT": 11.164812784927699, + "Yices": 11.104570221295498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.986321025070705, + "CVC4": 13.340134263843561, + "CVC3": 13.40846398393451, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.192226193573905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.356842772806331 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.561212762025065, + "veriT": 13.778812687859748, + "Yices": 13.459451657525985, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.490588535336537, + "CVC4": 11.765012238343173, + "CVC3": 8.1811857117514091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.245079631334214, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.013887477738054 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6793635763804149, + "veriT": 10.597784155977084, + "Yices": 8.3181017022539638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8583596025227678, + "CVC4": 8.9620252326125645, + "CVC3": 8.7819977655037125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.634413209974289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6481355277109664 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.735583585919267, + "veriT": 14.228010683829428, + "Yices": 14.140957018449159, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954076324181047, + "CVC4": 14.544317499641027, + "CVC3": 13.665581926125851, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.229446379685589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.140377487661878 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4597151733008888, + "veriT": 12.263207964539292, + "Yices": 12.615654873628459, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8202389245066595, + "CVC4": 12.970400212749029, + "CVC3": 8.7022346893556417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.28847846795138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.299110249123263 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1517460346221924, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.588259215598802, + "veriT": 13.62608085735412, + "Yices": 14.613899344663006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.044717423974504, + "CVC4": 14.775314070760695, + "CVC3": 14.245708301958437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.841315752483387, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.893178501601286 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25589075609196, + "veriT": 12.900017958199415, + "Yices": 14.25219738154656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.970168056207628, + "CVC4": 14.416144889945848, + "CVC3": 12.137615834393047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260535664362822, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.263668803214616 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1070566177368164, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.264962382580213, + "veriT": 13.756691022755581, + "Yices": 13.385079472972407, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980908358347596, + "CVC4": 14.600763820564733, + "CVC3": 14.267562267176011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.757653901485886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.417918125682521 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.427776740078343, + "veriT": 13.417668412207897, + "Yices": 13.27150798185977, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963891888904831, + "CVC4": 13.63366306153541, + "CVC3": 11.288472365966033, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2400462008819746, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.052599855190377 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12880981962725924, + "veriT": 0.098120143372733337, + "Yices": 0.10319254663848518, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12608994207096297, + "CVC4": 0.12873558950185185, + "CVC3": 0.10595267010879626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12173157961581482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12147807408168888 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12450298433664785, + "veriT": 0.95816367052874796, + "Yices": 0.96077486772760001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14054750195487392, + "CVC4": 1.3399215591228919, + "CVC3": 0.094615738625591278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3353686866013366, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3346689770545284 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9455437570706309, + "veriT": 2.1028079162057698, + "Yices": 2.1440836547909994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0762312139766399, + "CVC4": 0.13746903625029999, + "CVC3": 2.9314156012515831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12968286950169999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9435736072580481 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.60647866231959491, + "veriT": 9.8764211897147689, + "Yices": 10.065851824799172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.68983172262371228, + "CVC4": 0.1500201953938857, + "CVC3": 0.64330473119762843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15043594828697143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.561006374890722 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3628457364660971, + "veriT": 13.35952158390465, + "Yices": 11.180671403354365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2570908473216011, + "CVC4": 12.873095040273988, + "CVC3": 9.3133911334730506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.861686320099167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.854638549197633 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3862571974916249, + "veriT": 3.6260867095759299, + "Yices": 3.6292921800963871, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3826882603271249, + "CVC4": 1.9974838406956155, + "CVC3": 1.3911055639052501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8965424116229486, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8947684342197562 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.700435636560881, + "veriT": 2.7453945553448778, + "Yices": 1.1760835894536665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0945434902831153, + "CVC4": 1.7596324978792939, + "CVC3": 1.6372939728568996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6569256158916916, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6562786299916432 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.581384623684947, + "veriT": 10.97011820269174, + "Yices": 10.866143265181508, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.911229446601041, + "CVC4": 4.2469793612607241, + "CVC3": 12.028951469446987, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.855388933742244, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.089357918925094 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0127739982164325, + "veriT": 1.3620529059048438, + "Yices": 7.6904077686885968, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0535103397851422, + "CVC4": 1.904739919484107, + "CVC3": 4.0445972704885262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.32114175365506248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.99822210548227042 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2246680391613185, + "veriT": 9.2255984684204435, + "Yices": 8.4921377235685913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6314889633205296, + "CVC4": 8.3965069051064702, + "CVC3": 3.2858933554586032, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6867441225697046, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6957522584623925 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7852210892201206, + "veriT": 7.7426816516453316, + "Yices": 10.708454603180936, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6154634924767568, + "CVC4": 12.388713339319256, + "CVC3": 8.4670697026153317, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.701026346040699, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5316332137149349 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5911228772583925, + "veriT": 8.8580498783598358, + "Yices": 6.0692534410162216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9134632572124959, + "CVC4": 0.16758162283488889, + "CVC3": 2.8466888443222222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15142997954599999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.308835086528763 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.307106686932757, + "veriT": 9.4905313663638005, + "Yices": 10.306144839278867, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.975757634107994, + "CVC4": 0.19483346947646665, + "CVC3": 12.299387996864782, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.485587674741362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.707834535701574 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5982145071029663, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.549535233503368, + "veriT": 8.4883271783504153, + "Yices": 8.774523076874166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.086276691519393, + "CVC4": 0.15703489788266664, + "CVC3": 8.5593996917140771, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1548017376020976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6345903692306241 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.734877660932131, + "veriT": 10.690756987073229, + "Yices": 10.51385562028775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.357982797758893, + "CVC4": 2.0168686144797054, + "CVC3": 11.944502657382941, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.914499238750704, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.603800483690526 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239982934618389, + "veriT": 10.152469671754501, + "Yices": 10.334635755491124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960733888972257, + "CVC4": 0.147990705513875, + "CVC3": 14.239147727997809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14351472286325001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.290022870020724 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235430352860099, + "veriT": 11.514041189834604, + "Yices": 11.119943523824656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951668256114468, + "CVC4": 5.0917203303293306, + "CVC3": 13.612954775259162, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6519459308993909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.22963730282688 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.551637760862203, + "veriT": 7.2742610440266686, + "Yices": 8.4506436993070544, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.024290161883144, + "CVC4": 1.749783345731351, + "CVC3": 6.618874567021428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7546046893199545, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7950605780178295 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2093880649248212, + "veriT": 10.128512162986565, + "Yices": 10.979988370522856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3363661344838889, + "CVC4": 5.0045445215001267, + "CVC3": 5.5256718358696615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5397973021105151, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3006206339573203 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7032968997955322, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.035539116399713, + "veriT": 11.924623229572669, + "Yices": 11.098101535517221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.359464174686371, + "CVC4": 11.408133143848671, + "CVC3": 14.767139501637594, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.626013195775009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.200751182636159 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7817460298538208, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6632794037551557, + "veriT": 7.0161584717734238, + "Yices": 5.0032815628558369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4571219835604445, + "CVC4": 3.3296513778043657, + "CVC3": 3.2558849359467059, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2750061254727822, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2695530358634475 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7168211537530258, + "veriT": 11.760234785730294, + "Yices": 11.27393567881575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.114741504514249, + "CVC4": 13.593856115597456, + "CVC3": 9.6766947330992839, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.414482790937958, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.417922136027341 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0819571093647893, + "veriT": 13.736922597077474, + "Yices": 12.91147333709837, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4829103518727456, + "CVC4": 9.8802510099652991, + "CVC3": 4.3671660041367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.069422601615701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.485597635691988 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5912637714766742, + "veriT": 3.5405007219136668, + "Yices": 8.0374327980067122, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9295465011919406, + "CVC4": 3.3398598994571671, + "CVC3": 0.67946852370155553, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.128431209648557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8533953276255648 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5050844608232694, + "veriT": 10.856095769762328, + "Yices": 10.135590184749491, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.501959481525226, + "CVC4": 7.6249194041991295, + "CVC3": 8.0372584489153436, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.227460120165516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.653697685862614 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5231242733378818, + "veriT": 7.4693769024580021, + "Yices": 5.3738939732734323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0507461473111537, + "CVC4": 0.72109002041016657, + "CVC3": 2.6562847158567053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3394878055126247, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3085457879409352 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.622052093793664, + "veriT": 6.6056582903335608, + "Yices": 5.0565381337576225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1181035996193511, + "CVC4": 2.2964250022518811, + "CVC3": 2.1644953663249078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.6093062333718714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2901532171509067 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2480012896778874, + "veriT": 5.4279916175369802, + "Yices": 6.2722377770376969, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3693262260110117, + "CVC4": 2.8473772602563101, + "CVC3": 6.859965452297522, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.08697687797431, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.085629476995338 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12881467453076251, + "veriT": 3.6388903047509462, + "Yices": 5.3995223101601093, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13204641968274999, + "CVC4": 0.135836213914625, + "CVC3": 0.11625651221639999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13269919462325, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.131538418742775 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2535761661992, + "veriT": 10.366459565747922, + "Yices": 9.7559783500134305, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3222632591379995, + "CVC4": 7.9576267296739669, + "CVC3": 7.440686835936992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.587697040401903, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.586876101421538 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.383900830269589, + "veriT": 13.776661023721909, + "Yices": 11.093594318781534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.989905847255232, + "CVC4": 11.126405522891767, + "CVC3": 8.7874572519439607, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0877293162607931, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1005593994190921 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1944023686077578, + "veriT": 8.3137099251203779, + "Yices": 11.24139839266466, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3734635864342657, + "CVC4": 4.4997624543137054, + "CVC3": 3.0587126415702302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1853523551942331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.624333692525019 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.834623509130203, + "veriT": 9.421618438797152, + "Yices": 11.686362369475741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.417059405510072, + "CVC4": 12.167873180501438, + "CVC3": 12.539995229696768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.603405697160527, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.39423462568285 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8867868920413753, + "veriT": 8.9344513586924172, + "Yices": 5.0213459525839905, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8957049948817497, + "CVC4": 5.7155709748134251, + "CVC3": 5.4342980584637459, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.165261699373625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16692814564337502 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5768355633942857, + "veriT": 14.214474844465325, + "Yices": 3.839802295886436, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6154277304907143, + "CVC4": 4.2890630803750165, + "CVC3": 5.7913950886699306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.645311088419188, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.592797670103087 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4672374674051953, + "veriT": 10.214371475429649, + "Yices": 9.0903118486117442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7194360357344163, + "CVC4": 6.5942176543023052, + "CVC3": 10.422298292330513, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.45327012438708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.592249955681872 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.95856686133466673, + "veriT": 5.1447736655353342, + "Yices": 7.7753914457416817, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7927921226464809, + "CVC4": 0.51876838430388894, + "CVC3": 0.47260273529366675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8410151434623359, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8356181391616682 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6541415961271246, + "veriT": 0.12850507738167499, + "Yices": 1.3816953002003749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6484332665600001, + "CVC4": 0.15917508562725, + "CVC3": 0.1347711651955, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.152799427914, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14882358256075001 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14497098662927274, + "veriT": 0.12430699491363638, + "Yices": 0.13534479412454545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1415351004001818, + "CVC4": 0.16114783822963635, + "CVC3": 0.13811224644854544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15961006952027271, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15757977214927271 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15395421277999999, + "veriT": 0.13333512732712499, + "Yices": 0.150591089809375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15212011012212501, + "CVC4": 0.185978506295125, + "CVC3": 0.15406409584512498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1690779614945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.172830470992375 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1527368829405, + "veriT": 1.5442391362228578, + "Yices": 1.5569960658355186, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1551030804769, + "CVC4": 0.17416151111570002, + "CVC3": 0.15135150608760001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16973616413369999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16280495598640002 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9392158098112182, + "veriT": 3.7315436553322456, + "Yices": 3.7587625795641726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2895239992803069, + "CVC4": 7.8460645027513101, + "CVC3": 0.11550692665340909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4327011635286522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4486036960374362 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1580040454864502, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.367590262438859, + "veriT": 6.0367838518674537, + "Yices": 11.881729128307301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4317537749800171, + "CVC4": 0.22195724072772727, + "CVC3": 0.19577018880990907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7549429816098727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.749954784161547 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16877413744210001, + "veriT": 1.8458673928346165, + "Yices": 11.28515672570814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18064086222596668, + "CVC4": 5.1243116956283021, + "CVC3": 7.6426070754201438, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6051731295780702, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6145456559978641 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 178.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 163.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.396525193663237, + "veriT": 6.8250905421665458, + "Yices": 9.0083489109217965, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0086616301482394, + "CVC4": 13.633249283060783, + "CVC3": 7.2256486950072389, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8994241310519098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3655050597796974 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2942163778775706, + "veriT": 1.5587407194286287, + "Yices": 1.5522542453144286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.291282741479999, + "CVC4": 6.2176658763154782, + "CVC3": 0.12633907838514286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18011114385099997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16460424695342857 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9948009325756679, + "veriT": 12.657678761499941, + "Yices": 10.575539971885256, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.064499038867138, + "CVC4": 14.54296187645725, + "CVC3": 11.426411748140467, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.472098504103457, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.447443796985047 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.293759788025375, + "veriT": 5.4474696878615667, + "Yices": 0.18660601956362499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3005555327627496, + "CVC4": 0.24872334185412501, + "CVC3": 0.23921777319537496, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7117789657668743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7120026481523754 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1957938702018129, + "veriT": 7.1654019494003602, + "Yices": 7.2976068900725597, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4553764315779718, + "CVC4": 2.308285424480168, + "CVC3": 6.3293570032551427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1727279279226357, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9694432358738894 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.53538806780875003, + "veriT": 10.687179198343561, + "Yices": 10.99977608183325, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.516675219311785, + "CVC4": 14.265009580960751, + "CVC3": 4.7354369978220729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256819837361707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.535216499999606 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.076177286463901, + "veriT": 12.594799446962334, + "Yices": 12.886263668598847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4905975800539881, + "CVC4": 10.283925787813763, + "CVC3": 10.90200885332626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246399092054896, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.246751228078301 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.751466178360317, + "veriT": 9.4585299215758347, + "Yices": 9.2705206612422195, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.379460040014825, + "CVC4": 12.584928310969172, + "CVC3": 12.423496344355371, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.50289329745037, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.348133487244867 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 51.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9393190317211255, + "veriT": 8.6479089579576076, + "Yices": 4.9889778623457239, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2401414333997498, + "CVC4": 5.5923589303352985, + "CVC3": 1.6462153422651122, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9574488590658028, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9577972527343377 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3408749573343721, + "veriT": 13.651506782783448, + "Yices": 8.3169882145093563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8107792170392312, + "CVC4": 4.3750993274312195, + "CVC3": 11.811256376230691, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.080091826155035, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.075442687590236 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 48.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19560866310266667, + "veriT": 2.5069862423748548, + "Yices": 0.16894902535949999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2414680050836667, + "CVC4": 0.21460780256483336, + "CVC3": 0.18857972662199998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.50383670464683339, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.48926591380433337 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3413424341040301, + "veriT": 11.447007473022676, + "Yices": 7.95952682148876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7196193211261122, + "CVC4": 4.3599967425597486, + "CVC3": 0.545585318791875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2363795094127159, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2358295394818244 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1182715074724703, + "veriT": 9.2325248473185013, + "Yices": 0.92137862220758826, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4841010463552737, + "CVC4": 1.0696422451352043, + "CVC3": 1.1656018820133369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9209383738372807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.915427637625994 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 29.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1237910186162221, + "veriT": 12.471059137515537, + "Yices": 13.741139148033533, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.834720401089717, + "CVC4": 10.337962928412018, + "CVC3": 5.8968923750187852, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.907726520492291, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.907082125852931 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8636090755462646, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.262602635279684, + "veriT": 10.184492414442667, + "Yices": 10.3770045976625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.986972969402265, + "CVC4": 14.283349973369637, + "CVC3": 14.259032744136981, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25923780969134, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.433991120895756 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241580119170685, + "veriT": 10.180411217476875, + "Yices": 10.287198069519899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958192596075412, + "CVC4": 14.301845366003578, + "CVC3": 13.200758256353177, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240073213885099, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.210259161212649 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.812421154549815, + "veriT": 13.715139948147595, + "Yices": 12.634995211960195, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.351485978485297, + "CVC4": 13.818643940895166, + "CVC3": 9.4266437657120719, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233640958262919, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236666726076161 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6097365616193751, + "veriT": 14.242097429730814, + "Yices": 5.4826831384605965, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6699617499713955, + "CVC4": 12.604030452702242, + "CVC3": 10.73801189472907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.48449967694199, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.491309441763237 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0286364639807086, + "veriT": 13.712470104040628, + "Yices": 8.2434637041764045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4989000800312988, + "CVC4": 7.3645737356075704, + "CVC3": 1.9406735157124417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.222618264484073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.240971139929439 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 95.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.739298848999286, + "veriT": 2.8062054740300133, + "Yices": 2.0342729643094, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1052470239358216, + "CVC4": 1.7889910386016679, + "CVC3": 3.1674227890833864, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4228368824524269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4716919196404339 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8803301320123857, + "veriT": 12.594971840833287, + "Yices": 12.597277694853899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2602886171331633, + "CVC4": 3.6000755472582435, + "CVC3": 3.0298142856587997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6212668896628539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.619920585480358 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3095141264012113, + "veriT": 9.8138161852305839, + "Yices": 9.5636259250735911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.120811488259328, + "CVC4": 1.9129382710271585, + "CVC3": 1.8776417095232003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.29642770110900002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.29058796058922226 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.571998350503087, + "veriT": 12.899428323987705, + "Yices": 10.939093704873962, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.261842406497223, + "CVC4": 12.101108903609843, + "CVC3": 14.249505459522647, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8914946278002196, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2774624291675423 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.665861180183839, + "veriT": 13.999407355184854, + "Yices": 13.882063869598774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.545108118263711, + "CVC4": 14.300950783586874, + "CVC3": 13.900007309446544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242737567245156, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.240483742496526 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4905607891852881, + "veriT": 11.607541140469973, + "Yices": 11.31309069880642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.09651697147925, + "CVC4": 7.6610348906568415, + "CVC3": 9.507627261184572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0783943054183025, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1711153204498412 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.77194768993399998, + "veriT": 13.089014180682508, + "Yices": 9.3897686362940114, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1863314630508111, + "CVC4": 8.7740275720309118, + "CVC3": 9.2462397012611444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22755533764328573, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8909628854053351 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.267037885236972, + "veriT": 13.560820983937575, + "Yices": 13.427879133979415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.617645989003307, + "CVC4": 14.682192241385172, + "CVC3": 14.031082119961352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2635919420828996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7407776148123899 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 129.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.97138453696703, + "veriT": 12.2230687044965, + "Yices": 12.278504493337131, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.67889006053003, + "CVC4": 14.473294538281641, + "CVC3": 7.5492378622319887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.470007186091186, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.688299033027693 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9622473806428748, + "veriT": 13.718311997391, + "Yices": 13.532879711721932, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0685070369024601, + "CVC4": 14.534860868547382, + "CVC3": 10.6243317797215, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.03147543684252, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.029384069158878 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 232.0, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.83242705250092, + "veriT": 13.563870316180605, + "Yices": 14.317660079224824, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.598600068095664, + "CVC4": 13.28411010746826, + "CVC3": 13.646759821080531, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25691460605583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.255177902207263 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25468614238522, + "veriT": 10.757771257030114, + "Yices": 13.379579831533771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97131429774266, + "CVC4": 14.468836806681907, + "CVC3": 13.348630844823395, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.315226297014195, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.217075301209871 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 151 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.664005870810035, + "veriT": 13.095370527936845, + "Yices": 13.159809582972803, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.371684509326132, + "CVC4": 14.431716542304686, + "CVC3": 10.621303563089668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8317156484190846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6596107001592459 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.276437641279728, + "veriT": 14.269684524195046, + "Yices": 13.638473945183666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.993916523940989, + "CVC4": 14.931805371903311, + "CVC3": 14.275530491597264, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.764675130249959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.810146160398519 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 83.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13235946457657896, + "veriT": 1.1458255185445843, + "Yices": 1.1471523995248842, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14816134501373684, + "CVC4": 1.6071760938863533, + "CVC3": 0.097995215061121035, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5994836101874126, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5992842840872556 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.914554394369124, + "veriT": 0.085322373209800004, + "Yices": 0.08845871564324001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.91501909788473212, + "CVC4": 0.11000587785165999, + "CVC3": 0.092073443050347994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11004790600490401, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10838768167622399 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1931227926974688, + "veriT": 3.5965456439925938, + "Yices": 4.7779012556894145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2846132904685641, + "CVC4": 4.3009171142983877, + "CVC3": 2.1727055552435499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1833510031575334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2102172557703517 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0816945414975452, + "veriT": 10.163657487170997, + "Yices": 10.349880604385794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3188457508750631, + "CVC4": 0.14926576827058621, + "CVC3": 0.70946496243696555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14936194507734482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.458227825006302 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18400504381823077, + "veriT": 7.0765217566769243, + "Yices": 9.843202847510538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.43033646245453849, + "CVC4": 0.15092041918330767, + "CVC3": 0.23493044711515385, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14786168243784614, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4998525654008041 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6974084377288818, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7024226370971993, + "veriT": 3.89395965317085, + "Yices": 6.4983133723205011, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3589033383139215, + "CVC4": 0.15631953531949999, + "CVC3": 0.79226793683487495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15302084543525002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0623292873831094 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.725692151377668, + "veriT": 10.670374257888037, + "Yices": 9.9319540096182486, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.425937177986407, + "CVC4": 2.0073504457096263, + "CVC3": 8.7056328206871605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9023100875756183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.85069458836465 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.246010706193852, + "veriT": 10.163440514415335, + "Yices": 10.353748838232168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966109156079176, + "CVC4": 0.15979999597941666, + "CVC3": 11.961230385146917, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17856656337191665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.468318321469342 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.229619243890237, + "veriT": 10.656716416068003, + "Yices": 10.791571284158863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.942468177560489, + "CVC4": 2.1079033359220389, + "CVC3": 14.219185994778647, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0646004303113248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.730140124594216 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6255512235197385, + "veriT": 9.3161540317717737, + "Yices": 7.6589693602762852, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.024657159074115, + "CVC4": 0.16736029838128569, + "CVC3": 7.7413843207785877, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.528674243459292, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.251137096261633 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6172165870666504, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5322580337524414, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.216955399781892, + "veriT": 10.464392886833782, + "Yices": 11.310206658747584, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.834475553286779, + "CVC4": 3.7741896401167301, + "CVC3": 9.0291337163728969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6113737143782796, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9843486455658184 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4590569244601435, + "veriT": 10.197470421037309, + "Yices": 15.170303311293383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8079260101928565, + "CVC4": 6.3206998114246682, + "CVC3": 7.1783631496060449, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7809991470148043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7540307157093755 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.495205883475121, + "veriT": 13.205418452355893, + "Yices": 5.9115790399817598, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6440394309715085, + "CVC4": 3.7286629433667708, + "CVC3": 4.8872190263568536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6679481599650874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9774217181935514 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.625, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.995463188622434, + "veriT": 13.552812176426055, + "Yices": 11.865067519893326, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.162719022443095, + "CVC4": 14.853942056879376, + "CVC3": 11.319889065153925, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.214565462887339, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.212531908919745 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.155848349427073, + "veriT": 8.901712173226791, + "Yices": 10.324347873693318, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.746519589927329, + "CVC4": 0.62545527279809088, + "CVC3": 10.933069909153545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.648069731715351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.428412751447281 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.232736032499874, + "veriT": 10.162253899779, + "Yices": 10.309634365971126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950040173976976, + "CVC4": 0.201167074698125, + "CVC3": 12.330856853468799, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9901523563410581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.936920514527479 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.438490217004798, + "veriT": 10.428475176240903, + "Yices": 6.9252036647395663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7921553390301597, + "CVC4": 3.1711301359026258, + "CVC3": 11.958257264361148, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7888982158886675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1751712505155387 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1895828745273569, + "veriT": 11.393506568651505, + "Yices": 11.622631242189474, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9589393659526895, + "CVC4": 12.635808486901078, + "CVC3": 8.4495162419663696, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.816754148261813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.02159642178273 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234634641037122, + "veriT": 10.901126537904231, + "Yices": 11.039924276940555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953796419179655, + "CVC4": 0.38362131817736367, + "CVC3": 12.204855465234454, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1271912684937959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.816859568145121 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2566093912469505, + "veriT": 7.4338468133044797, + "Yices": 7.7327388254593741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.940247474995301, + "CVC4": 2.6671008392587914, + "CVC3": 7.247762583851034, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5355958786468675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2656505711013457 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5808286805530145, + "veriT": 11.113209584126249, + "Yices": 5.5886941523211124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5864878092295716, + "CVC4": 8.5165371575202222, + "CVC3": 3.6040136125507991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8083264233068732, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8268028728799397 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13571765698042856, + "veriT": 0.11126781716500714, + "Yices": 0.82719258312300714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1298237867057857, + "CVC4": 0.14357510860614289, + "CVC3": 0.12803313196250002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.898872685779279, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9180668440094584 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1114335284624288, + "veriT": 6.76479651634292, + "Yices": 10.381730257460315, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6254656485850001, + "CVC4": 10.38101240386624, + "CVC3": 9.4025114780049961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1260251253410694, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1245346132137168 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4404145820927567, + "veriT": 11.875135064711467, + "Yices": 10.850798070134218, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.175496635293198, + "CVC4": 11.004047092361532, + "CVC3": 7.8650544435734417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.548210944619761, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.547307898179044 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5929393583374587, + "veriT": 8.9659771214082955, + "Yices": 6.3426057192855199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0224664771315197, + "CVC4": 0.2010976387899, + "CVC3": 8.4258684643330959, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9751186159471228, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8313087411107771 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5625, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7318101758713222, + "veriT": 11.202963518678445, + "Yices": 11.891622190693235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2904525812568153, + "CVC4": 12.238653064700678, + "CVC3": 9.3383481861941764, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.046069264019472, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.800058842260455 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0454545021057129, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4166941923912502, + "veriT": 3.2933045967933019, + "Yices": 3.564945369919208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2744656576521907, + "CVC4": 4.9710749161557954, + "CVC3": 2.4677366727664682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8239386152119641, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4762553332031225 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.222638102183174, + "veriT": 7.322527975001571, + "Yices": 9.0143534090537152, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.843919808775537, + "CVC4": 0.22405696164528571, + "CVC3": 10.215171914086438, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.153742499015602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.594361570833863 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8819444179534912, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12534178794094, + "veriT": 6.0992711391829006, + "Yices": 6.9239428569703918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12307699021639999, + "CVC4": 0.13898007999699996, + "CVC3": 2.4923614149161404, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7291973700874719, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7633907837378739 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3757817715810963, + "veriT": 8.4001095086715853, + "Yices": 10.37473457797855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0515697392933605, + "CVC4": 11.396331527705176, + "CVC3": 6.1614955658383552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24525761937675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.284363990612174 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15035599297581251, + "veriT": 5.6702245623542389, + "Yices": 7.1739650421671692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.171095294865625, + "CVC4": 0.15773793488143747, + "CVC3": 0.14896984204325001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14648295044625001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14482076444899999 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2583960171987778, + "veriT": 0.12464690128440001, + "Yices": 10.524952612353296, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2561699681771108, + "CVC4": 4.8658967369050892, + "CVC3": 5.7827636041433337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2884463408489459, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2859844684309714 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4196256933675289, + "veriT": 9.569986898445844, + "Yices": 7.3801012962472186, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5007100233470352, + "CVC4": 7.6174231405788468, + "CVC3": 5.3856886738831893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.157394554250998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1286707783029897 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0501255989074707, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15602041113099999, + "veriT": 3.8899219359578363, + "Yices": 5.7735804267420798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.58431619603183338, + "CVC4": 3.9148048871450669, + "CVC3": 1.0736693999749167, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3657887245845268, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3617247003886002 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5497315526266444, + "veriT": 8.7112163963371962, + "Yices": 10.370217730247408, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.228354370614197, + "CVC4": 12.133568487598493, + "CVC3": 7.9520476881103255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.649787369183256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.206927874561647 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5917310031663732, + "veriT": 10.261580794966193, + "Yices": 11.667786157735545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.300014534615503, + "CVC4": 2.0524889591008724, + "CVC3": 3.9111120537920008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22383011563344446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.955917347409601 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7396847790159065, + "veriT": 11.193369000119269, + "Yices": 12.882007896378093, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.068791571006214, + "CVC4": 14.66327393074687, + "CVC3": 11.722389235514591, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.886723421187446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.426435461643552 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7412019968032837, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2846568537377152, + "veriT": 12.861121529503501, + "Yices": 8.8889826747257441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7527208467274979, + "CVC4": 10.201670781530401, + "CVC3": 10.54772105045987, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.646928411486961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.071403071200629 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.57704016068700004, + "veriT": 7.9610424782918887, + "Yices": 10.452327896284103, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.876324760555395, + "CVC4": 14.264304812777263, + "CVC3": 3.0030409854669537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.124060015658545, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7177668414842273 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16796439478478573, + "veriT": 11.32922519341454, + "Yices": 2.5375147169283996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24215439424457141, + "CVC4": 5.3328836143628502, + "CVC3": 0.21915560580764287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.005075862138247, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.348600889228125 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.413996696499225, + "veriT": 13.485343157475022, + "Yices": 12.227742251951979, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.91791842821404, + "CVC4": 12.495885696553087, + "CVC3": 14.190475684715118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230055751071006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.227962135245054 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2214045022024198, + "veriT": 12.774870215356732, + "Yices": 7.9424042884017219, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.03650295217858, + "CVC4": 3.8675665231474721, + "CVC3": 6.1028067555858456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.580187596786956, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.579661474279643 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16533627271144441, + "veriT": 1.5858707508685554, + "Yices": 2.359741692919322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.75259845509688883, + "CVC4": 0.33113549813311111, + "CVC3": 0.15886235542644445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6836881379045197, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9267188529609793 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3042246762508762, + "veriT": 8.1271984881608237, + "Yices": 9.6216359646146632, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7722103564435199, + "CVC4": 10.370544305945753, + "CVC3": 4.2500043314929856, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3271150965265797, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0593372565021841 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5645659956142826, + "veriT": 11.868467672774861, + "Yices": 11.273514082966292, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.894842736987812, + "CVC4": 7.8738783287397496, + "CVC3": 8.9211817408726244, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.226525395649025, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.224042238514201 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0673544406890869, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14173783031000003, + "veriT": 3.5599463887604155, + "Yices": 1.7799479387451427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13794620914528571, + "CVC4": 2.1781291843976232, + "CVC3": 0.14055558965714285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1463725711447143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14617101695328572 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3621997111716466, + "veriT": 0.16051738445288236, + "Yices": 0.18766081790411768, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3583658774995293, + "CVC4": 0.20604527313482351, + "CVC3": 0.18138847705105882, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18958532838717645, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18656139674611766 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 85.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26814393358799998, + "veriT": 0.17047809017016666, + "Yices": 4.9087240336053179, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.82917696824125009, + "CVC4": 0.22041501476258332, + "CVC3": 0.22572203413366665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2194426170419167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21689878553958331 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1471599459794, + "veriT": 14.035045036733376, + "Yices": 0.15695184839070001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1592067467036995, + "CVC4": 0.17424953220629999, + "CVC3": 0.15073986260089997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3733647898295605, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3738432464133625 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16009345793872723, + "veriT": 7.3551746854126483, + "Yices": 0.46374183618509102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.51869948324300008, + "CVC4": 0.16622584551927275, + "CVC3": 0.81566714695072728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14637631932545456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14694794681845452 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.90619314109016658, + "veriT": 4.1573416337058227, + "Yices": 4.167966408545948, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7706331728761149, + "CVC4": 0.36641544673249998, + "CVC3": 1.8698046379375002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5212472113637414, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5234273307612769 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3530758399478373, + "veriT": 5.1451456297091083, + "Yices": 5.1741286404512588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9025815394386973, + "CVC4": 0.21425020849104168, + "CVC3": 1.0413979697268334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6259058700692006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6292810096603598 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6736695056332271, + "veriT": 12.860985177632349, + "Yices": 3.4953456950918338, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9078825337094081, + "CVC4": 9.7049346519824162, + "CVC3": 9.5428713889211867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.721873419400394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.704742687259097 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4358827304374318, + "veriT": 6.8865064656003376, + "Yices": 6.6786547882335361, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6318576931692776, + "CVC4": 10.038052869598367, + "CVC3": 3.6847019262009635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7414221680659248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7204034327802455 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1279115676879883, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.712818818526008, + "veriT": 13.428065188013242, + "Yices": 10.923977997757767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.441144857180168, + "CVC4": 8.7797861088034423, + "CVC3": 8.15268850865648, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5612145694970128, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2061036841243187 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7282622320159473, + "veriT": 12.200191101865153, + "Yices": 5.1634595289904999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5703526284487115, + "CVC4": 0.25744196246833334, + "CVC3": 4.2962628717595024, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3634233323572853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3550822268179754 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8331791558511124, + "veriT": 9.919378303615682, + "Yices": 11.679321644930553, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6065898205707549, + "CVC4": 12.532167562501973, + "CVC3": 11.479205215281002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.285237072581662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.589790746246218 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2326841354370117, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9504968988505527, + "veriT": 10.966995288882215, + "Yices": 3.1962994289980333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1132613465688688, + "CVC4": 5.5488160996392821, + "CVC3": 9.6911579781318427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.397595227819842, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.167698333635821 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23405490238028573, + "veriT": 3.0071437079491572, + "Yices": 1.6738745747117143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0535692096208569, + "CVC4": 4.3137013910107038, + "CVC3": 2.2165993153002086, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.015153890475867, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0148215487256627 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.48474465127359989, + "veriT": 1.5307592636005807, + "Yices": 7.1090893951765297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6169363792435429, + "CVC4": 11.601411135093693, + "CVC3": 4.2520446867945001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3784421714812101, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.33475638031465 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.527837868990494, + "veriT": 10.600546124728165, + "Yices": 10.478498036533272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.616942722518436, + "CVC4": 13.517271957661212, + "CVC3": 13.630853737208184, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243825952226507, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.381987016229681 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2270978620699644, + "veriT": 13.549118821491637, + "Yices": 12.92753216714798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.893199363885854, + "CVC4": 10.028476406093054, + "CVC3": 4.6445754552398242, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.592304574852157, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.033969679352643 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.943373959934533, + "veriT": 11.164009286787538, + "Yices": 11.318901959567896, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979896805491725, + "CVC4": 13.921886721217231, + "CVC3": 11.185026731565845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.651228755963627, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4854040025341213 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.104823738892577, + "veriT": 10.836967420931824, + "Yices": 11.291509082034993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5843012531403335, + "CVC4": 12.77697822832136, + "CVC3": 2.2187488938418038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.725586202934698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9739746092184287 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 81.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.886688158055823, + "veriT": 9.5352955636294219, + "Yices": 5.4650659321634638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0809652017885609, + "CVC4": 0.29670991280600001, + "CVC3": 0.305358667449875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20117045797512498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19393387262049999 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6600218819738668, + "veriT": 13.594064005477021, + "Yices": 11.249287384569696, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.546629971762632, + "CVC4": 9.3617679074112665, + "CVC3": 7.4860213620768876, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1947608987281484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2232723085205919 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 159.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247990084069368, + "veriT": 11.671750266815819, + "Yices": 10.841518563438115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.668712321835658, + "CVC4": 14.619284365665353, + "CVC3": 12.228419682898384, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.207182623881131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.366415847345065 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8502017133652764, + "veriT": 9.1597200616956513, + "Yices": 8.0622439764621596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9937185862389, + "CVC4": 8.7900409455764876, + "CVC3": 7.9189885629940777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6030384188074813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6107250686510817 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8206629753112793, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5342834414880651, + "veriT": 12.602234387816992, + "Yices": 12.689959126161133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.588085932996288, + "CVC4": 14.729570036701514, + "CVC3": 9.0543014952876781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.488988716564549, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4857450842337867 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 198.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5295495577879574, + "veriT": 13.059020995630954, + "Yices": 11.078523087110215, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.707250356786771, + "CVC4": 10.455420008675484, + "CVC3": 12.2363596689953, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.232548715132451, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.224993037576557 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5828003958150401, + "veriT": 14.236074205665259, + "Yices": 14.242525245813697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955843621501185, + "CVC4": 14.365573319498056, + "CVC3": 13.249273194261109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253179482972506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.250454377041018 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4715192810889999, + "veriT": 14.253700279181432, + "Yices": 13.944545766614151, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.807121172476904, + "CVC4": 14.618694671492694, + "CVC3": 12.229438654972874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.791851629449344, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.804033192293849 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1695709228515625, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.882806504801982, + "veriT": 11.330240744801499, + "Yices": 12.762981773859009, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963241671371314, + "CVC4": 14.18586999014051, + "CVC3": 13.232120176420443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.785392290465341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.06688521932166 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.957774172716782, + "veriT": 13.948257725504462, + "Yices": 13.909194670077792, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963250167547356, + "CVC4": 14.385891608358326, + "CVC3": 14.236417525276625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.108670031711119, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.899875794123217 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.123547080138092, + "veriT": 12.26909472586474, + "Yices": 13.737153870422096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.10029251327871, + "CVC4": 14.513732205136023, + "CVC3": 13.274833720250031, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5755914066475984, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6384572109183271 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11960121088272001, + "veriT": 0.090196485861823994, + "Yices": 0.095277880835948014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11498951776244, + "CVC4": 0.11868919919728001, + "CVC3": 0.094738667172555982, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11499672199484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.113455611356424 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12402709279210952, + "veriT": 1.0392056846859477, + "Yices": 1.0411079160143049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14065543722151427, + "CVC4": 1.4545629068631338, + "CVC3": 0.091672171775642866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4508093408061733, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4494953370652124 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5534739552504653, + "veriT": 1.1194400476605699, + "Yices": 2.1558446995864697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6158839989136204, + "CVC4": 0.14725224835269998, + "CVC3": 1.5394008293075114, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14333106939029999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.572382462493374 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2140386618003283, + "veriT": 10.164761291175401, + "Yices": 10.356222373811514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3627048303019831, + "CVC4": 0.14946214189617144, + "CVC3": 0.70619307644800022, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14901717549399995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.421367388535243 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1877182616267857, + "veriT": 8.0117835239599291, + "Yices": 9.7885121243507136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.35597497500285719, + "CVC4": 0.15133682425549999, + "CVC3": 0.27453755352600001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14976779659457143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5065206403354416 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7065994739532471, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5277780294418335, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3844151249114924, + "veriT": 5.7373663170100002, + "Yices": 5.8557295077784453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3730928368006499, + "CVC4": 0.16352136837477776, + "CVC3": 3.1703305494535554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6282926201328998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.861986714976107 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.904016683119456, + "veriT": 10.513140741908757, + "Yices": 10.658266700277581, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.560650002511197, + "CVC4": 1.4034386409992436, + "CVC3": 10.154237988743963, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.057816466882878, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.548812754327159 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.872045129733715, + "veriT": 10.531602752419259, + "Yices": 10.465471031537545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.520516445484475, + "CVC4": 1.504244188522786, + "CVC3": 10.570926946594636, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4238417256029665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.533266151888013 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.212618253852886, + "veriT": 11.164178860362242, + "Yices": 8.1756248261773763, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.554797677138563, + "CVC4": 0.16593020900262501, + "CVC3": 9.6775993163560248, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13938372902874999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7914550707359043 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.055439833592166, + "veriT": 12.280974297457787, + "Yices": 13.439432019211276, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.712807376331638, + "CVC4": 2.6849447026073805, + "CVC3": 10.275527310022978, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9945795069574324, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9766322951862474 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.059235615656677, + "veriT": 10.705009958056893, + "Yices": 10.424181014245715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.565606484985816, + "CVC4": 8.5417721782124865, + "CVC3": 14.215921509512356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.045177895935552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.33724673614762 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0275139358937899, + "veriT": 10.593597803910296, + "Yices": 7.6317950733581998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.214791522479718, + "CVC4": 5.7982527606899268, + "CVC3": 5.0170970590400437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7789381952590171, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4003762758671838 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.983661379398885, + "veriT": 12.209246751043702, + "Yices": 12.487735263531528, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.498651804053805, + "CVC4": 13.061898914413081, + "CVC3": 13.221114923707322, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.026524479767152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.630296089823156 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8799246327546744, + "veriT": 8.1496498702194202, + "Yices": 8.2766520980859593, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6988304627591138, + "CVC4": 0.33038903686720006, + "CVC3": 6.083759701251612, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3051447886988683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5404096472114368 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5403697560484444, + "veriT": 8.1605071934954339, + "Yices": 4.8028466076391112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3085264379033941, + "CVC4": 1.831017570023034, + "CVC3": 0.37232949792922221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234342105935944, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.384176669993542 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.490816456252293, + "veriT": 11.712904098290469, + "Yices": 11.143212916049993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.17886049357281, + "CVC4": 11.467166441186434, + "CVC3": 10.923742845510457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.803126354533997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.354498200401336 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1833333969116211, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7391455730819914, + "veriT": 9.6793607647223503, + "Yices": 10.785178930299191, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6250982195257908, + "CVC4": 11.66771407245991, + "CVC3": 8.5683057518052426, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.713414794001931, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9710977775549168 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.924046113319733, + "veriT": 8.4993746732600002, + "Yices": 10.339680834847664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.52628186318862, + "CVC4": 0.17258779687199999, + "CVC3": 11.001453131817298, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.72657802209082, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.324245779543824 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239286989724212, + "veriT": 10.172884845979583, + "Yices": 10.319795251811833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957214269144067, + "CVC4": 0.16153695395533332, + "CVC3": 9.8466622416677883, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8524804898990528, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.211275946560159 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2161380855160413, + "veriT": 8.7245917661330008, + "Yices": 10.355956152942854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.675029932217786, + "CVC4": 6.3020978534108476, + "CVC3": 6.6847220119855288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2129076381505337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.02325262137043 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8786764144897461, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7807285908549044, + "veriT": 7.7633932824707443, + "Yices": 9.2127425587744423, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.345857796805892, + "CVC4": 10.906908329742627, + "CVC3": 5.8493762243815794, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6369778570613516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8354831507106137 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8182362696054399, + "veriT": 1.8172007099615337, + "Yices": 3.6595114895624996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0591819052960716, + "CVC4": 0.21697328784433334, + "CVC3": 2.4630188401811566, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6546650607859901, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6676065796865718 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2956646061413819, + "veriT": 11.283306296084257, + "Yices": 10.84258712274398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.677180910070968, + "CVC4": 3.502893318438594, + "CVC3": 3.9422620116792895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233849600813778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230932640982688 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5601767750481428, + "veriT": 5.694395356524538, + "Yices": 6.1897846033829662, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5617561950738572, + "CVC4": 0.1719092952584286, + "CVC3": 1.6024980769719428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3757025050101428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4147178536521428 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1958148836652853, + "veriT": 9.6340880611894502, + "Yices": 4.1903704207138155, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8557081789557142, + "CVC4": 9.1302871839743958, + "CVC3": 8.3968183713922961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3931980047997099, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3951070133263874 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9569702425052418, + "veriT": 4.1830093632331691, + "Yices": 8.274512846608447, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0426440672235451, + "CVC4": 0.20212492775854549, + "CVC3": 6.7683636985611306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0218260074888601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5791635012594867 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0662393569946289, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4922755520407902, + "veriT": 12.688940407353599, + "Yices": 8.6538346304924101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2809537032555287, + "CVC4": 11.899920603984363, + "CVC3": 6.8407689961939075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.093114887536483, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.090302693537694 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.6053910484023, + "veriT": 9.2353370324493085, + "Yices": 9.8298334641491945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.319896657077607, + "CVC4": 10.56090221107447, + "CVC3": 9.8006445435795868, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.240543101210903, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.221200475205851 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.097681079716029, + "veriT": 11.32232466003012, + "Yices": 11.16555322210983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.602130282635404, + "CVC4": 9.1067060738839682, + "CVC3": 13.325884492579586, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8046763824758747, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.16885908876298 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5750000476837158, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3708770928928313, + "veriT": 3.1389605131907503, + "Yices": 5.2743012955119974, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5819877913617564, + "CVC4": 0.15351566381500001, + "CVC3": 1.7602341657713005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3222709523742879, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.485332105327938 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14613415524490997, + "veriT": 3.8411649940630874, + "Yices": 8.7636064197990997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17318750789699999, + "CVC4": 1.5753725318375982, + "CVC3": 4.9672916579049495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7066722641401451, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6740050485075031 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4400170974769999, + "veriT": 9.6334339381727148, + "Yices": 10.464189154554537, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4516759635547141, + "CVC4": 10.527545512611548, + "CVC3": 10.680268451696437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2133613560732055, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2074650724167943 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9303144222440896, + "veriT": 11.864388401746661, + "Yices": 7.1494332957744575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.030006369754989, + "CVC4": 9.7554876571184579, + "CVC3": 11.42455522863124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.873457503600717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.869489360169545 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12722810225350001, + "veriT": 5.9174430047899715, + "Yices": 7.7389635139109627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14525365568769999, + "CVC4": 1.6464337982239521, + "CVC3": 1.5264329037305742, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12731118983350001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12721408864809999 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.842068777926011, + "veriT": 5.2223836671626138, + "Yices": 12.160774255099632, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1006942020787767, + "CVC4": 1.8271766263488332, + "CVC3": 8.5090745806759038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1621133168239597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1611166264714781 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8067902719127975, + "veriT": 9.4999613952575004, + "Yices": 9.6529461443193476, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.028430349032469, + "CVC4": 0.35748875947166669, + "CVC3": 7.7821137567832732, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7217629413595688, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4921329665847658 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 27.0, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1888826339622143, + "veriT": 0.88953195620438252, + "Yices": 3.3173399720279448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.9011005785879288, + "CVC4": 0.20076056218214286, + "CVC3": 0.90314778618000002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19032311135021432, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18670697087935714 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3124279507932222, + "veriT": 1.9077834742293309, + "Yices": 1.262410267657111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4553358980404445, + "CVC4": 1.8266863931276376, + "CVC3": 0.22508625756188888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9922683787308229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9908353119490512 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1624999046325684, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4901373910625577, + "veriT": 9.6694403292584905, + "Yices": 3.8912481080632992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.92399909413325021, + "CVC4": 2.6204593484277008, + "CVC3": 1.9784604650815432, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15211445087516665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0898798308582756 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4885813913495556, + "veriT": 12.858191112047439, + "Yices": 7.8742084563680805, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2001336594271326, + "CVC4": 8.4042839406701138, + "CVC3": 7.0893618594310199, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6061670982483243, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4475487374687299 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5354441186235559, + "veriT": 12.971247413224008, + "Yices": 5.4589287886191427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1077262667097596, + "CVC4": 4.1357059921028503, + "CVC3": 3.9590633849140349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.756039255654663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.5066410864708 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14397611759485715, + "veriT": 14.206105340373556, + "Yices": 0.1145912890342857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23651716226642858, + "CVC4": 2.2693398902696909, + "CVC3": 0.14087815049285715, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.480981505488769, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.529306756544107 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8452945965507439, + "veriT": 10.994878269919592, + "Yices": 10.849438594850451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0672866922438429, + "CVC4": 14.347151397511308, + "CVC3": 6.0997127741042423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.261225358685172, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.778390656140934 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1675236732175005, + "veriT": 4.9517038786102905, + "Yices": 9.4890659318746025, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2477251459234999, + "CVC4": 12.602041758622887, + "CVC3": 3.2519506189147225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.676928615886319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6744091234696379 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.646687578848983, + "veriT": 13.926941533051158, + "Yices": 12.25934076965771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9413849626000452, + "CVC4": 10.922755925397288, + "CVC3": 12.713486808817132, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225229379259616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.226153251539056 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0538639543845385, + "veriT": 8.1308403065435364, + "Yices": 0.26004457803276926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0522609870533843, + "CVC4": 8.1129598340639841, + "CVC3": 0.27032627436469236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.951991743161555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9515645282998264 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.935352087020874, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5757201630688886, + "veriT": 2.3276009944605334, + "Yices": 2.3299453254645996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5765496063813336, + "CVC4": 3.2883052559897408, + "CVC3": 0.1199042728938889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13288273520008886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13270862194933336 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18667871454985718, + "veriT": 1.8823111550484286, + "Yices": 3.6556104931807392, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.83050630377814294, + "CVC4": 2.1953877749308188, + "CVC3": 2.1871943637321047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7716323467642252, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7809270945369191 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15048549742866665, + "veriT": 0.12255326019216667, + "Yices": 0.13639756817883333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14559473377400001, + "CVC4": 0.16757653555083332, + "CVC3": 0.14685038550733331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15819790054366667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16222612036333331 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15053203714237501, + "veriT": 10.425468293777723, + "Yices": 0.15279764286725001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16884908209437499, + "CVC4": 0.17608028004912499, + "CVC3": 0.45638909776112507, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15955767692962503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15642284544724999 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1525574739085, + "veriT": 0.12758258260108332, + "Yices": 0.14219660369116668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15172019770325001, + "CVC4": 0.16564438173708332, + "CVC3": 0.14695375433658334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16181054616058332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16332309511958332 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2979933311295966, + "veriT": 3.5369481927908888, + "Yices": 11.305331996546258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4651364687104964, + "CVC4": 0.20555172477377778, + "CVC3": 4.8716441315268595, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.303607322843872, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3028546002340415 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1332695090252729, + "veriT": 7.6065103556286537, + "Yices": 12.0260705672664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5061152502988271, + "CVC4": 12.043689677154067, + "CVC3": 9.0124146518043258, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3245319145312973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3229774774110119 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6841002552045001, + "veriT": 6.3759699859669876, + "Yices": 7.4113562298570645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8336767801086014, + "CVC4": 5.4382773937877706, + "CVC3": 0.158124716652425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.49237893454599996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.50793212454009995 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8716193903378748, + "veriT": 3.6197476660978412, + "Yices": 1.55772162787575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8829950356946625, + "CVC4": 7.2144830560678983, + "CVC3": 1.3958789602253752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12015530706553749, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1202060764176875 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8501913236744443, + "veriT": 8.5419024716132412, + "Yices": 5.1532236901498001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1675447060679698, + "CVC4": 6.4222831810060441, + "CVC3": 6.2440741831871218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1066522664735654, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6381208384988408 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1350721622147333, + "veriT": 11.440366636487184, + "Yices": 11.438767076408926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.61945643338041, + "CVC4": 10.956928772791876, + "CVC3": 9.2021932530611323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2664467619420847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1990552282079037 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6685609817504883, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1375947692299633, + "veriT": 9.5843954257574051, + "Yices": 4.1945391612439744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2157245844399487, + "CVC4": 5.0319506785069894, + "CVC3": 3.3823889237245868, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.221833901603244, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.257752666222617 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 68.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1290440579732035, + "veriT": 12.479567042738619, + "Yices": 13.00909108083307, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.931668901152424, + "CVC4": 14.174147732758364, + "CVC3": 8.7592111998648718, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.386366334162361, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.390892672481302 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.801386159862775, + "veriT": 14.230615972554574, + "Yices": 12.438404626348069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951697831111449, + "CVC4": 14.917873827970544, + "CVC3": 14.232506061702468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251681983710899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.245413116103494 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.821798801315534, + "veriT": 12.988882500282179, + "Yices": 13.006207648764942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.458625419801525, + "CVC4": 14.679408406886434, + "CVC3": 5.0112733501884295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23059743263695, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.220000554574403 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.252855577573191, + "veriT": 10.192073340197126, + "Yices": 10.342946310516886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.983630393256007, + "CVC4": 14.304534357475685, + "CVC3": 14.258562381002715, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256007353355832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.765624677106262 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243677313531593, + "veriT": 10.187664254524, + "Yices": 10.658995015439443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961637614472687, + "CVC4": 14.368501391566394, + "CVC3": 12.82678932393228, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237942528070608, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.745994378503951 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.400323628652224, + "veriT": 12.009263906001353, + "Yices": 12.521624382682848, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.924512646628196, + "CVC4": 13.184895590089875, + "CVC3": 14.254998471274357, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.258394855345834, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.301885540565442 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 95.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 40.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5182270818637291, + "veriT": 5.8570860490893866, + "Yices": 1.8059337086529998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8684912779885654, + "CVC4": 2.6394251163621685, + "CVC3": 7.0595249423299409, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1005370530735408, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1684519706489507 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.89891398323409988, + "veriT": 9.5488581551364646, + "Yices": 7.4741683949641642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7623938761972813, + "CVC4": 0.36602976404000004, + "CVC3": 1.8482649911871334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1913166407285845, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1880469335466364 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4752018246734995, + "veriT": 6.4949122470293945, + "Yices": 6.1419489512632515, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3516430080270325, + "CVC4": 5.4395079703714933, + "CVC3": 6.2468286256165531, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1778808516743036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1785584553270221 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 140.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6050480768950628, + "veriT": 12.674767602010325, + "Yices": 11.373810218900616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.609531366538068, + "CVC4": 13.968592093425849, + "CVC3": 8.8731849605766087, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.257950448694487, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.906397771636641 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 176.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.367322736002505, + "veriT": 14.233322162678412, + "Yices": 13.664462505578719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.196710507473691, + "CVC4": 14.393383486407933, + "CVC3": 12.98665799927206, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255927089039552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.254135975388856 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233351255833737, + "veriT": 12.739759638112728, + "Yices": 13.121203651491401, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95537541286834, + "CVC4": 14.513417228238904, + "CVC3": 13.583588084863187, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234147169725377, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.223859423628253 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 370.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0336346626281738, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0418654252779884, + "veriT": 13.233897820763572, + "Yices": 7.6048988145001859, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6555447344842804, + "CVC4": 2.2972822736138379, + "CVC3": 7.2838243517349657, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9659652647933226, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8685256965630099 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.204058888807005, + "veriT": 13.891820045969148, + "Yices": 13.086684856934825, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95788420351173, + "CVC4": 13.23821125070903, + "CVC3": 12.665490404325006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9280361813390634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4577745463895724 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4449121236191402, + "veriT": 14.23107730245925, + "Yices": 14.31991134488714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.64808699644278, + "CVC4": 12.42262808652737, + "CVC3": 12.585285092609988, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3293349377295001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3095026521404167 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.807573054190927, + "veriT": 13.372099040699251, + "Yices": 13.224482201925593, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975460243346069, + "CVC4": 14.551525810668867, + "CVC3": 14.278678974220627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.136513468429886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.517809870437175 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.287418512847449, + "veriT": 13.82138229977059, + "Yices": 13.821816313167067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.999035797324899, + "CVC4": 14.773304328044455, + "CVC3": 6.6766860739990879, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.681392352394237, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.891717868604312 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11807446571273683, + "veriT": 0.08877790406587896, + "Yices": 0.092238773904236848, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11494697962152631, + "CVC4": 0.11843066960936843, + "CVC3": 0.095303769230884197, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11543796659278947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11485747714994736 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11511919761353703, + "veriT": 0.086841247093029608, + "Yices": 0.091554519743440754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11471535569634445, + "CVC4": 0.11042816921863331, + "CVC3": 0.093785606202666669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10886080279375926, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10833078488691113 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6904764175415039, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6699850557026332, + "veriT": 5.3230002425801981, + "Yices": 6.8356707720516363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1648019101989213, + "CVC4": 0.82050983903147179, + "CVC3": 4.5935534916873673, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.78620209564573917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1395152952167393 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.956848641377114, + "veriT": 10.498295982337902, + "Yices": 10.451489541401834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.553178675102492, + "CVC4": 1.3998582684463037, + "CVC3": 10.438090528389214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3207197480913024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.272461510535644 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.223726660080362, + "veriT": 7.4945798915868593, + "Yices": 7.8606375692006631, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3851837247553851, + "CVC4": 2.5866285324560012, + "CVC3": 6.5951835786153667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.99743257892807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3443463517725762 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.939477649151792, + "veriT": 6.5773307330624302, + "Yices": 12.739503047848224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.295951197513487, + "CVC4": 0.28494579137862497, + "CVC3": 13.629753576577889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9653211135347819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7895963259514911 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1632913182868112, + "veriT": 11.045224674584365, + "Yices": 11.171612188317772, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.840902468758038, + "CVC4": 1.3989471973402727, + "CVC3": 7.4435991585704073, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.269109670924395, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.10872054592558 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.157672625897874, + "veriT": 11.623475858446568, + "Yices": 10.863828030497865, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.745403138555327, + "CVC4": 11.172304595941522, + "CVC3": 13.771061135307326, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.711862327033081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.896807969437736 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.413677590046465, + "veriT": 10.603516689631675, + "Yices": 10.248417006288602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.986256007423389, + "CVC4": 5.0025682529113835, + "CVC3": 11.974858825540261, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5495284240329319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.824910283125927 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.251177952157832, + "veriT": 8.7345068964998571, + "Yices": 10.315088049897856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.858316184697856, + "CVC4": 0.17459788477185714, + "CVC3": 11.7430842214488, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.049510546860491, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.180559763353218 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.468923212480925, + "veriT": 8.7464138057475704, + "Yices": 10.340530771848213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.835310067005933, + "CVC4": 0.56353209017928574, + "CVC3": 10.331342924394226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8474402948412552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.977041444977754 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1714286804199219, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.321862990742945, + "veriT": 14.055140898191203, + "Yices": 12.540677593431063, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.015244979771602, + "CVC4": 11.543415187823511, + "CVC3": 12.421769833350792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.218364771545058, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.219778266867102 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6221069033493336, + "veriT": 12.194026735083479, + "Yices": 11.661239973544159, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1142758951927991, + "CVC4": 12.048657612558452, + "CVC3": 9.7162259827415483, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.09693618133648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.106933172230162 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4409060443059634, + "veriT": 12.688628160789072, + "Yices": 7.1955933894114068, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5691136162039214, + "CVC4": 3.7621018925615237, + "CVC3": 9.1543773865025102, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.455741645119125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7117749532768647 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.486134510866176, + "veriT": 10.162605159874374, + "Yices": 10.339569175423877, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.115723213264014, + "CVC4": 0.15939844037574999, + "CVC3": 11.302772858776626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.929077654819584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.036829007802121 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12678884154625003, + "veriT": 0.097927322650612506, + "Yices": 0.10084254606270002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12270608229996249, + "CVC4": 0.123208948199375, + "CVC3": 0.1101323433694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12119342701462502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1199370223629625 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5227274894714355, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3992879879463471, + "veriT": 14.229670485679085, + "Yices": 10.02971415031806, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.113671719361426, + "CVC4": 12.9161916339171, + "CVC3": 9.6439221553353196, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244341297653689, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.243726784118516 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1783448465665742, + "veriT": 11.396207594644107, + "Yices": 8.231698881514415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.241294066860485, + "CVC4": 8.9252173689494025, + "CVC3": 8.5904393002744115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5174913548158413, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5747988972767217 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5609610402172862, + "veriT": 8.2065631148959195, + "Yices": 12.359566538098692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5396207357407139, + "CVC4": 12.490455456742769, + "CVC3": 11.17847135120712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2445990215149294, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2462952767517557 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7425894011506742, + "veriT": 3.6704226740167152, + "Yices": 5.7912100815515419, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.859996060275324, + "CVC4": 0.19102280946478573, + "CVC3": 3.7323822371109414, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7419209110806833, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3182255851219056 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8771369457244873, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19820105019783332, + "veriT": 13.87138608119443, + "Yices": 3.399390408816187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5136496998100053, + "CVC4": 3.950799961596728, + "CVC3": 3.4325741728999462, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3975456237934099, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1083268462617717 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3782265685492456, + "veriT": 14.214051585445125, + "Yices": 10.651927633524954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8665290757320614, + "CVC4": 10.211400185897926, + "CVC3": 9.2139985578385399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.123797100069968, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.111931712916409 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7821359634399414, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1586870270728564, + "veriT": 3.4467681583946552, + "Yices": 3.5133545501369223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3953510251244658, + "CVC4": 0.12579410670911112, + "CVC3": 0.35073130763799992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1296347840208889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.905837825421651 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.209281273377, + "veriT": 10.163943254155436, + "Yices": 10.350966394150129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2606217225688261, + "CVC4": 0.14849342961000001, + "CVC3": 0.67002175084826088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14746984409265221, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.44977128210213 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19148992548700003, + "veriT": 8.4902801325196666, + "Yices": 8.6431883234531668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.42019007223416666, + "CVC4": 0.15463908335633333, + "CVC3": 0.26768032769966665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14962309513783334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1125613190383632 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24126660485086, + "veriT": 10.163900672224722, + "Yices": 10.336710615150274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960935759185967, + "CVC4": 0.15655404389077776, + "CVC3": 10.849569124473829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.645945990918888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.40013973333177 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.963564466920623, + "veriT": 10.17255484805138, + "Yices": 10.331355120739364, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.619146685539341, + "CVC4": 0.16373226820472728, + "CVC3": 12.967470433009236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15190916772090909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.338428139507805 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.960163385973893, + "veriT": 10.93335156163625, + "Yices": 8.2418139640549484, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.492064383182457, + "CVC4": 5.7027210070407701, + "CVC3": 10.715610242676009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1139201817311424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.099263624808119 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.90702133848675, + "veriT": 6.660343607893525, + "Yices": 1.4176971178846876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3994399009258127, + "CVC4": 2.8571860220861196, + "CVC3": 2.8107541084076071, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.942197269728222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.314578382953256 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1273450952895114, + "veriT": 10.193920973542999, + "Yices": 10.744530557702316, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.918466370036461, + "CVC4": 9.6378035292680178, + "CVC3": 13.147775483611754, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.468956945192256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.5030000517727 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4226188659667969, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4129414031878555, + "veriT": 9.3742976842036221, + "Yices": 12.222863829631557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5877289349637982, + "CVC4": 11.176539573987387, + "CVC3": 7.5266572994440777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.188970833463335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8267800582240241 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4496842740074887, + "veriT": 1.7428636077920503, + "Yices": 1.7407956355828833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5699474406134049, + "CVC4": 0.2585905035056833, + "CVC3": 0.082176495096200008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4495548084986374, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4491203079476818 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.700789053796631, + "veriT": 3.4374146970023336, + "Yices": 7.2638377576279538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7752282710572402, + "CVC4": 4.8560685320077965, + "CVC3": 4.8175288169171253, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3842550339432069, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0691966188452726 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20001937608666667, + "veriT": 3.7274759302126665, + "Yices": 3.2908015649845015, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.80808556349422234, + "CVC4": 0.19566254600144445, + "CVC3": 0.18775011547511111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18421067969433333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18184777259155555 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0416665077209473, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1370578773883979, + "veriT": 9.646402119992187, + "Yices": 10.255484683473496, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.828186367643478, + "CVC4": 4.0136636927222069, + "CVC3": 6.1886724622846003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.098333950925623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.403331464051035 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1664810363632556, + "veriT": 5.8504888094518277, + "Yices": 9.9039345391771434, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6087284454411777, + "CVC4": 8.3770316944939314, + "CVC3": 2.6643425228452919, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2184026807754575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8102973153047097 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.533226716662575, + "veriT": 10.137444910757301, + "Yices": 10.772839332027608, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.766549165635734, + "CVC4": 11.357504543890476, + "CVC3": 8.2002371367112747, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.968384057032836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.9773329683618 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1469258590861, + "veriT": 11.931402187654573, + "Yices": 1.6877768919312999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1533032106572998, + "CVC4": 4.6059003560570488, + "CVC3": 3.4549026072901996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8464114859744285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.008402122925727 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2320556956290911, + "veriT": 5.8533676572164799, + "Yices": 6.5369335596372951, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.370998726855527, + "CVC4": 14.292827895384127, + "CVC3": 3.7353776986967104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0001361339306696, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4791639954447602 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.359980011306125, + "veriT": 12.713234000370029, + "Yices": 11.427701502783929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4620603954402456, + "CVC4": 5.8229281739642174, + "CVC3": 6.0503062058689068, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.725923539329754, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5588367859557852 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5797554824051427, + "veriT": 8.8952945908910586, + "Yices": 5.1832406752147335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.641262123910384, + "CVC4": 5.4334402697098341, + "CVC3": 2.1794385373964746, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15771447193128571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15994269670292854 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12807337000785002, + "veriT": 9.7252130677393076, + "Yices": 9.1032613333654329, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1267103005911, + "CVC4": 2.2636657828294453, + "CVC3": 1.4566075340366875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.861410639034498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8466870005510723 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0212069119481724, + "veriT": 1.8617837888142066, + "Yices": 8.5678734067174585, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1809197562660554, + "CVC4": 4.8763092609492205, + "CVC3": 5.9814405764182856, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2201404205405919, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2171242299166924 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1980929492479, + "veriT": 0.13092783395819999, + "Yices": 4.5443697769949916, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.30008925154370003, + "CVC4": 0.17590873437759999, + "CVC3": 0.16720846065600001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15991368895700001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15989074002299999 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.699266736283275, + "veriT": 11.687961928154303, + "Yices": 11.444571599730136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8339153126015404, + "CVC4": 7.976268942932971, + "CVC3": 6.5003760334423859, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.379427906055948, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.122475985359092 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15831454121766667, + "veriT": 0.13818491396266666, + "Yices": 0.17019423965966665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15985752521516666, + "CVC4": 0.16660488725883335, + "CVC3": 0.15286973016375002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15872315362166664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15855950789749998 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5290133492320273, + "veriT": 5.8464204043862997, + "Yices": 10.136226472972757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8300392586231604, + "CVC4": 5.0603788966581158, + "CVC3": 9.0227594044301966, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0146192600196393, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0159621359141111 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16385390354828569, + "veriT": 0.15363400094857144, + "Yices": 6.1880633417317936, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15989345142657144, + "CVC4": 0.18606684892571426, + "CVC3": 0.17189460026200001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17202647066714286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17031432336757144 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23652931027662499, + "veriT": 3.9843552959610005, + "Yices": 12.034210459757631, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.44476789348962503, + "CVC4": 0.24118071441449998, + "CVC3": 0.2340939776075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22821471371874999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22354942178487497 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7002065798902943, + "veriT": 3.4468054932728558, + "Yices": 6.5446136195930391, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7818952078079431, + "CVC4": 8.0792946652050368, + "CVC3": 2.4016281955113219, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2757500148520524, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.28182330545093 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 79.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.233866619630238, + "veriT": 12.348615058989603, + "Yices": 12.563759714217875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.817812447800739, + "CVC4": 14.417657159458471, + "CVC3": 13.228278538961202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.384928779717699, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.669091146009947 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.278062907779614, + "veriT": 14.211486712728856, + "Yices": 7.2135008904838713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.488601234861667, + "CVC4": 5.0550308213988577, + "CVC3": 5.2985020573915573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5304946563719302, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5252039395748724 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.31340938834971427, + "veriT": 9.2998265170341892, + "Yices": 9.8253507842760719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2597302616442856, + "CVC4": 0.74077207400128564, + "CVC3": 2.4083198352901625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6080002404773412, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6050458184359422 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1715688705444336, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14471528233085712, + "veriT": 4.1471450288182448, + "Yices": 0.14438503172628572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15041961054971428, + "CVC4": 0.15960541903885714, + "CVC3": 0.14065856984957142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15335189069628571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15293154545642856 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1458333506416, + "veriT": 0.12200695736693001, + "Yices": 0.13602983981810002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14387670706311001, + "CVC4": 0.16169383937968002, + "CVC3": 0.14171533717149998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15871952847021001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15820166415025 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6021216403004699, + "veriT": 2.1461722920372166, + "Yices": 2.1609651576165581, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7076782503910359, + "CVC4": 2.2860481524521683, + "CVC3": 2.1709412818933456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1564122969825714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4636147073931425 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5879380239315162, + "veriT": 10.754478593215348, + "Yices": 2.9795318843444143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7246580238993419, + "CVC4": 6.2363009142936336, + "CVC3": 2.1788677990614671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1968097470908439, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1629553737239462 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 109.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248605069398344, + "veriT": 11.080219092833268, + "Yices": 10.568930215065548, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971447251345634, + "CVC4": 14.507931804455346, + "CVC3": 12.859858004971471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244122486163295, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.990222962903738 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.220713849237804, + "veriT": 12.500125218417438, + "Yices": 13.313740754653788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.933235848288485, + "CVC4": 12.216589068029725, + "CVC3": 9.0352915903524611, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.957583452432601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.958444224559697 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.495313513844803, + "veriT": 10.438323422952406, + "Yices": 9.0740743396122632, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.127864336219007, + "CVC4": 12.539879066214969, + "CVC3": 12.488189540461706, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4013777535088092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.44670031310565 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7615267691515122, + "veriT": 14.222875403645196, + "Yices": 12.192959928597906, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.060934934792922, + "CVC4": 12.012128700393705, + "CVC3": 5.6826962102032423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.175912372497779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.14681455503324 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 68.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0569748878479004, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5489224810642224, + "veriT": 11.720150491749031, + "Yices": 8.6374966136590601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3675917882347779, + "CVC4": 9.6263100296842126, + "CVC3": 8.2950581270864934, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.685822263311749, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.683965184191431 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15402692975076668, + "veriT": 6.891542424072175, + "Yices": 0.12862160635721667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15670250494483332, + "CVC4": 0.17229620004999999, + "CVC3": 0.1593521688823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15120689665546666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14756593217084998 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.77535756397066669, + "veriT": 11.960822926553028, + "Yices": 10.399146950637133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7443651397464115, + "CVC4": 4.7512121895012696, + "CVC3": 1.343625667562, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.662420678221622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6867041912141154 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2112822842903928, + "veriT": 14.266402258939822, + "Yices": 12.254340376194699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.191473176987756, + "CVC4": 5.1479843781374948, + "CVC3": 6.1022063856060713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.43984584805899996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.36766142662866663 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 29.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.698494214735923, + "veriT": 11.488885030413721, + "Yices": 11.511569569939923, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.824307713234392, + "CVC4": 13.109346524110332, + "CVC3": 12.901346721063895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.95872263234074, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.443476820835651 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1449305987009994, + "veriT": 11.113920177051018, + "Yices": 7.6562434763064617, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.663521583663661, + "CVC4": 8.0937905482130681, + "CVC3": 8.1855413409804605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.54534912645811107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.46246913732477779 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9897600412368774, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.765014179605576, + "veriT": 13.299274136939442, + "Yices": 12.446920714689922, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.401018626039319, + "CVC4": 14.442228791413244, + "CVC3": 13.26451488107452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.164015513822934, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.684114354441078 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8341255583675604, + "veriT": 8.5703742916808885, + "Yices": 9.3279362121953433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8535172633332904, + "CVC4": 8.6822674211067685, + "CVC3": 8.6358985026076791, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9564321543109147, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9514459966769677 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.041300628794449, + "veriT": 12.983048645297128, + "Yices": 12.99007334580946, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.227456561076695, + "CVC4": 14.534891595914326, + "CVC3": 12.583415471500475, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9950535289112103, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.20037466692415 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1445515155792236, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0315780639648438, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.277850703865616, + "veriT": 10.776745368695419, + "Yices": 11.301105642140135, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.992651136228204, + "CVC4": 14.539014195215822, + "CVC3": 14.27954762207537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.011338041633564, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.288333238018447 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.833171616354647, + "veriT": 14.233841377664243, + "Yices": 13.981601341999269, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.29665242938972, + "CVC4": 11.951710002550975, + "CVC3": 13.814113366512501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.808425956925698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.851749608831415 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.920309391888393, + "veriT": 13.13489558856582, + "Yices": 13.68458571063119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.93735033378748, + "CVC4": 13.340388746367545, + "CVC3": 11.803168200822103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5903319527090609, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.579752702640973 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 183.0, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9714187590794348, + "veriT": 14.250849830556739, + "Yices": 14.134796203925831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7277696766111657, + "CVC4": 14.448705294100042, + "CVC3": 10.919313014161444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.825112463692912, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.511935273370003 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6788330577334225, + "veriT": 14.242037635199781, + "Yices": 14.170158358409441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966660919293229, + "CVC4": 14.7318940454214, + "CVC3": 11.590683817480928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257070988679036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.256893216290393 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.32376635744539, + "veriT": 10.667651407951272, + "Yices": 12.222939652008909, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.577956124213673, + "CVC4": 14.684379774225549, + "CVC3": 7.7117042451940989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6607554835882166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3830747969254826 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12922241088539285, + "veriT": 0.097479306623250009, + "Yices": 0.10369597633825357, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12514421505210713, + "CVC4": 0.12599964263303573, + "CVC3": 0.10328927195354998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12303539908217855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12034053576635 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10922064646571907, + "veriT": 0.08152890307512381, + "Yices": 0.085256033941566653, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1082449967548524, + "CVC4": 0.10591824619187144, + "CVC3": 0.087281025859533318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10434167688473808, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10364299698375236 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1551693971040313, + "veriT": 1.2442729289764767, + "Yices": 2.1537514409839225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.228749200080772, + "CVC4": 1.7090740569324734, + "CVC3": 0.13115644603183332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15089816748955556, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16964006292322223 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3036740812000094, + "veriT": 8.8785841351889143, + "Yices": 8.9655831108920552, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5610903164560881, + "CVC4": 5.529279816220984, + "CVC3": 6.6866299378307099, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2597180957494478, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6098635183494476 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20743594433166665, + "veriT": 10.163706353608751, + "Yices": 10.349059202238875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2591514340005, + "CVC4": 0.14916362461704169, + "CVC3": 0.67898264677870845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14803022586679165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.434905704274238 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16922715645966668, + "veriT": 5.6923950580766665, + "Yices": 7.0735407670976667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2748206166271111, + "CVC4": 0.15376903174233336, + "CVC3": 0.22217903842922224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14791178587100001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9700823670743333 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7551364898681641, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9089560943912289, + "veriT": 8.1600423623116072, + "Yices": 7.7241750093050277, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.21574067932948, + "CVC4": 5.0904351443932585, + "CVC3": 4.7151163221065859, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.83628686144261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4739037072752641 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239002356747248, + "veriT": 10.169132966324543, + "Yices": 10.323867110940363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958135539359894, + "CVC4": 0.18953583246263636, + "CVC3": 11.399314488220391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1894822814371282, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.332446377173468 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240242894029267, + "veriT": 10.159269404719232, + "Yices": 10.343604535631767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964951388804431, + "CVC4": 0.15932452164946154, + "CVC3": 12.556136602045161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14526093457307693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.332626186505207 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.169861674378961, + "veriT": 11.314364363443401, + "Yices": 9.117216800431823, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.586210311030991, + "CVC4": 2.2099638430553781, + "CVC3": 10.015615555621716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1505015796750029, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.92400620466519 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4160019313580285, + "veriT": 6.1894079274610458, + "Yices": 6.2809651464782874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8301370572368558, + "CVC4": 0.1721652508082222, + "CVC3": 4.8935660975209654, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7861726753354912, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.933324028841991 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3877815374107554, + "veriT": 8.860389302628743, + "Yices": 8.982741076270063, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.615801871655286, + "CVC4": 6.0496074925743848, + "CVC3": 8.6017275059826996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2274973172390249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7769639224926665 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8204838572749749, + "veriT": 9.819309061372234, + "Yices": 14.83074652980244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3276274726351174, + "CVC4": 4.5856550653243513, + "CVC3": 7.9185166933040581, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6358043448758206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6717248812859111 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0008013979756964, + "veriT": 13.84797580368042, + "Yices": 8.5745605119716011, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1623861974528857, + "CVC4": 8.0372888886363292, + "CVC3": 8.8767993069823898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.092037620573347, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.748129525484485 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6172165870666504, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.580932820766524, + "veriT": 12.488026916526739, + "Yices": 11.468480016289035, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.913230437020143, + "CVC4": 14.51388197369057, + "CVC3": 13.956276737444787, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243236632921249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.637632621207429 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.791982138948931, + "veriT": 9.936074378004415, + "Yices": 6.9305486859428882, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.851917030638445, + "CVC4": 1.7281494572265104, + "CVC3": 9.5311218947417409, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9117114255921281, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4388214300806581 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5781208117413108, + "veriT": 12.057815448527528, + "Yices": 9.7944075569996851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.494805021944158, + "CVC4": 10.557678393535037, + "CVC3": 8.322720927485042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240483165642249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.250546594222602 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.321102122823442, + "veriT": 13.513264535648631, + "Yices": 11.88089918580139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.562710716051779, + "CVC4": 11.373109060184966, + "CVC3": 11.764617389523591, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.0020109566066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.09931057417837 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0362794968336742, + "veriT": 3.7350937453666124, + "Yices": 3.8815182452209376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1661472686509811, + "CVC4": 2.9437194345986875, + "CVC3": 1.8730423822965996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6401300056167369, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1682816804434051 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.6349210739135742, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3541665077209473, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8285715579986572, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3037729184615277, + "veriT": 5.6008097896249458, + "Yices": 10.292709746131637, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5662839299327063, + "CVC4": 4.0026618167286321, + "CVC3": 4.9972481616217728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.392756387901009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2721836451131594 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.885245490615079, + "veriT": 11.388794849607562, + "Yices": 10.550686233016167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.341039257708681, + "CVC4": 5.5811580284434648, + "CVC3": 11.582255434677952, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1967402810314107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.780118702125931 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.435981969713414, + "veriT": 10.678284274693047, + "Yices": 8.6923189987562157, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.742571011624804, + "CVC4": 8.4647661177415596, + "CVC3": 6.2628683699526828, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2891279066197283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2703410317015642 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.207923512961468, + "veriT": 12.849282791199178, + "Yices": 12.039845464853789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.648505995494592, + "CVC4": 8.1105485092074971, + "CVC3": 8.9007609810896327, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.960155935320062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.179224741906742 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8971064572840692, + "veriT": 9.2355829048933717, + "Yices": 8.2696782242052844, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.395485118135749, + "CVC4": 1.2437151272969831, + "CVC3": 12.535706180423954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4334570883099973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7762911856122763 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7579321090398885, + "veriT": 6.97623299857145, + "Yices": 5.9222654283646685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7707554807375088, + "CVC4": 4.1327760556842668, + "CVC3": 5.2131901205052324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0278734868460528, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2329552240195962 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9569757495484597, + "veriT": 2.6630513710276627, + "Yices": 10.483897094130228, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0242207706751203, + "CVC4": 0.22981467216337498, + "CVC3": 5.7912223502693925, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.726609695256547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.000621659733985 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6920266839720828, + "veriT": 12.934569146044367, + "Yices": 9.438915831793647, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.936510693503271, + "CVC4": 13.053937133353626, + "CVC3": 9.5985983486194169, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.216967509740449, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.211893930084006 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1829636387784004, + "veriT": 6.0050522639787278, + "Yices": 5.969050660614398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2833604350949002, + "CVC4": 2.9874300164502072, + "CVC3": 5.4751612174108999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9802336119823201, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.979794090129662 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1682676119361259, + "veriT": 5.6145085078051329, + "Yices": 11.964084188046201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3745631912735004, + "CVC4": 12.479574043276781, + "CVC3": 9.6229257953844911, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7288506628991618, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.727805733748915 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.286981935267284, + "veriT": 12.238047574755905, + "Yices": 14.210913940797193, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3064161494410564, + "CVC4": 14.863949936593823, + "CVC3": 12.019029427410311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.000154189388926, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.021405793839204 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4403504948222752, + "veriT": 8.0317516184819198, + "Yices": 10.314484226075805, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7156908910596007, + "CVC4": 7.492639868396493, + "CVC3": 7.1937690657370226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9276516720756391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9292601017720294 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4402597978860623, + "veriT": 13.452262469088856, + "Yices": 9.6531063892985376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7130948636274033, + "CVC4": 9.1998028015773716, + "CVC3": 8.5934855681821851, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.002573178925717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.945106038257268 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22796771543387498, + "veriT": 1.414258929141782, + "Yices": 11.176706241882888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6118831118178751, + "CVC4": 7.3450389581255475, + "CVC3": 6.5751091515750009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15564160139700001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15799938907212502 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16452490729400002, + "veriT": 0.14370315511168572, + "Yices": 3.3320484617012767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.3097732169887143, + "CVC4": 4.2437049756663843, + "CVC3": 1.6278218900601431, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19096918914157143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18953181400842858 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9375676047755404, + "veriT": 10.493320930426382, + "Yices": 11.337472204992814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6045753598562431, + "CVC4": 2.0628419857393485, + "CVC3": 3.3933535098958187, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2113285320057354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.113759532886908 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8984870699698755, + "veriT": 12.445838239535941, + "Yices": 5.3180417182488027, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9930093801042501, + "CVC4": 7.5962288947695846, + "CVC3": 3.885201601543625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.381538287601229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3616180251625387 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14048621915125001, + "veriT": 14.214690883780527, + "Yices": 0.18837293990624998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18777520596512498, + "CVC4": 0.17261257874899999, + "CVC3": 0.1373054983025, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.757214626850022, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.773934900705902 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1797461525615356, + "veriT": 14.218754836875586, + "Yices": 11.901112219121719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5270507181135242, + "CVC4": 8.429283573368787, + "CVC3": 10.705579540590044, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.358912036541993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.359887154417333 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2828475276135154, + "veriT": 10.103749129210254, + "Yices": 10.138100146135756, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5094103994384742, + "CVC4": 10.642445828335505, + "CVC3": 7.6037712529385066, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.156790485017686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.186908534561585 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3168669215556901, + "veriT": 9.0832970604106347, + "Yices": 9.1755475045816546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7685154760554158, + "CVC4": 4.4457869961461052, + "CVC3": 3.2927578361978651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.502867679928743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.511452083407079 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.246669118644105, + "veriT": 7.2766367314925722, + "Yices": 7.2589237089692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.019467313811278, + "CVC4": 2.6499849322578224, + "CVC3": 1.6492670104535907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7831743697187914, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7967925099947175 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12959799099516667, + "veriT": 5.0994632363862502, + "Yices": 7.4527374348729287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12821827418866669, + "CVC4": 2.4914369066220865, + "CVC3": 0.11561165030028335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12906244106166664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13017478788700002 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17637679336154163, + "veriT": 7.9684511507258931, + "Yices": 4.2239385803046465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21052263673410834, + "CVC4": 3.6794886630296042, + "CVC3": 0.12455416840675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.26727997559409167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20646109117252498 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9549678159168096, + "veriT": 9.3237709802771196, + "Yices": 12.093799558453595, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3190951666050825, + "CVC4": 11.256613384656244, + "CVC3": 12.174777853229482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1834817712177443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1795537526702589 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 61.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15394736775788234, + "veriT": 0.14016393712457648, + "Yices": 0.14786142669941177, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15053519398094117, + "CVC4": 0.16655531909270591, + "CVC3": 0.14827948067711763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16235008034817647, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15596200034764707 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5497665889819996, + "veriT": 0.098049431213942856, + "Yices": 0.10508190641579998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5476757641968857, + "CVC4": 4.1723743583822834, + "CVC3": 0.11241615984402856, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12854380770485715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12872144807285713 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3788195759506379, + "veriT": 11.04732638115842, + "Yices": 1.3787273993166815, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3920079846699562, + "CVC4": 2.8705174678968652, + "CVC3": 1.0072269278318384, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13129388663173125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13013786767554375 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7003775605453233, + "veriT": 8.0764981481213702, + "Yices": 7.4693581632784944, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7092521538503536, + "CVC4": 3.4402618395976101, + "CVC3": 3.9323380882589398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4917955544913677, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4992651220809154 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1936362407206005, + "veriT": 7.5300513299027916, + "Yices": 10.58088061011896, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5541797753459345, + "CVC4": 7.380182121684375, + "CVC3": 2.9720951163165763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7259513023010893, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.893251903736417 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6632969891591247, + "veriT": 4.9112754356815875, + "Yices": 1.3912292047972501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6901794681102502, + "CVC4": 7.2473222236381618, + "CVC3": 1.7136944431390604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5663904321456248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6113419433107501 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6067793540201427, + "veriT": 6.0103387578172738, + "Yices": 0.15930643831271432, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6268546656615712, + "CVC4": 0.19624841855214287, + "CVC3": 0.51952084932171416, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18864524106928568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17672309017857143 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17480931524300003, + "veriT": 0.15144252779044443, + "Yices": 0.15950611688855554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17458354137888887, + "CVC4": 0.19387018936600001, + "CVC3": 0.17264103673522221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18174886994188888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18028462346299998 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5573122918115043, + "veriT": 12.770559091212913, + "Yices": 6.2716281040931765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9870582514753039, + "CVC4": 8.097555870530103, + "CVC3": 7.9516209268547451, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.004263471756007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.34325090237747 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 156.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.872376072585455, + "veriT": 11.249985319485763, + "Yices": 7.5161306500745457, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5482585023861652, + "CVC4": 8.70288747872039, + "CVC3": 9.2212409240859667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.657563392897467, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.496579852203418 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.78336035232790902, + "veriT": 9.4338484193364742, + "Yices": 11.282824372902875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0956641075277762, + "CVC4": 3.0835545763683414, + "CVC3": 1.4170022431234546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3866587376148658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3446093328442394 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0153555870056152, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.250594029849493, + "veriT": 10.167725820757356, + "Yices": 10.280031583475028, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.969593557389414, + "CVC4": 14.427846602253664, + "CVC3": 13.640863224372543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.033884807272853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.404472845016613 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.126090624970846, + "veriT": 11.553985543605592, + "Yices": 10.450345878979853, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.334396019026139, + "CVC4": 14.261825277537046, + "CVC3": 11.748312867103156, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.665381360369219, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.053596416545828 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1492628054089087, + "veriT": 14.227787675337982, + "Yices": 9.1586019822125557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.569768770735838, + "CVC4": 11.327194068834332, + "CVC3": 11.4252762663873, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228176717320352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.244372746658655 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.9028376451442307, + "veriT": 7.0646486080430595, + "Yices": 1.2408689684489924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6708128377591529, + "CVC4": 0.23956186213138461, + "CVC3": 0.21177155583161539, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17731670985584616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16932241291423075 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.56321821279150008, + "veriT": 10.951105015495411, + "Yices": 2.4171610026503467, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.213117047415875, + "CVC4": 1.9716914406753829, + "CVC3": 8.6127707311710413, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20559472881124999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19865672457112499 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4880350297632856, + "veriT": 11.117764463312001, + "Yices": 10.462553314988652, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7444425185291283, + "CVC4": 3.9413659533909744, + "CVC3": 5.1199576703445091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.069037550846816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1008584581429597 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1404368897091723, + "veriT": 12.772516291472972, + "Yices": 11.241480868967654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.035219758121759, + "CVC4": 9.5919176310604772, + "CVC3": 4.4182557725949314, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5109673743049876, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2572762245927096 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7945009347999807, + "veriT": 12.297680987314056, + "Yices": 13.275663190128382, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5308800427544949, + "CVC4": 11.264419350900285, + "CVC3": 8.1488111266733547, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.275871978589727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.667829237516749 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3067952181671849, + "veriT": 8.3824962590087253, + "Yices": 8.2530608238763552, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1049516941587436, + "CVC4": 7.2941940773176039, + "CVC3": 7.6970809661245099, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8872823142989716, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.766129720572458 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 219.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8263300830793394, + "veriT": 13.614721899163369, + "Yices": 13.904740648176597, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.250286703977945, + "CVC4": 13.719353915661685, + "CVC3": 13.442855109795639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.082451646926843, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.070795115362197 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2136931419372559, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.931732576497696, + "veriT": 12.048587291894792, + "Yices": 14.251579421323978, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.978051330083996, + "CVC4": 14.62608744253169, + "CVC3": 11.337068745906011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.062261828211309, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.088642660515672 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249926479993913, + "veriT": 14.239387844448682, + "Yices": 14.24038221357802, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972450004091943, + "CVC4": 14.646758568961033, + "CVC3": 13.35252010949336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254549517620848, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.261100181561483 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.18821931319844, + "veriT": 13.775856514215238, + "Yices": 13.619229989167314, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.029223950319967, + "CVC4": 14.779115311254891, + "CVC3": 5.1293016894795054, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.851382989557354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0888569442974054 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.223633486134414, + "veriT": 14.216326410540354, + "Yices": 13.046260812616918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.728441802200081, + "CVC4": 8.1792808139512019, + "CVC3": 10.583924681440113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232485441867977, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.231051936702841 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0586085319519043, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.317330713015394, + "veriT": 13.418890780549154, + "Yices": 13.224611547486592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.159451449653442, + "CVC4": 14.416292189773193, + "CVC3": 12.936946127609378, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237022460558014, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236107296295813 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.271818954839542, + "veriT": 11.092529550783301, + "Yices": 11.685827859872578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.035499712482627, + "CVC4": 14.592144448775974, + "CVC3": 14.263671895827287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.275665500718594, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.598856648993211 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.608835468325708, + "veriT": 14.229482457788968, + "Yices": 12.073283732723022, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.606653080614912, + "CVC4": 12.147240117463546, + "CVC3": 13.356987005290264, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.589018122123592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.581832928571615 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14282057780820001, + "veriT": 1.5997298336564651, + "Yices": 1.599017509988405, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16689036827760001, + "CVC4": 2.2438513097993784, + "CVC3": 0.10422510785180998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2358904792115379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2342423874210393 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.118357008838555, + "veriT": 0.089741443287244996, + "Yices": 0.094930421870339995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11800616406039, + "CVC4": 0.11550460575712, + "CVC3": 0.096117574275069992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11172099098255499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11100289562905001 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8968013219241602, + "veriT": 1.3761963232465111, + "Yices": 1.1243912041371376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.984848737330994, + "CVC4": 1.9008683730095326, + "CVC3": 0.12295991127238751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14383553531900001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14253355480625002 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5577938629792656, + "veriT": 1.1203600729895, + "Yices": 2.1597910409259002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.61313877530302, + "CVC4": 0.1578510613322, + "CVC3": 1.5449113774353713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14566682070690001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5787804106871739 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.84567166640673819, + "veriT": 10.168270298035182, + "Yices": 10.350410375968478, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.94805312416951049, + "CVC4": 0.15034860153461363, + "CVC3": 0.65040200272081816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14803047050579546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.281938085484327 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7063894271850586, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8531658761330414, + "veriT": 8.1657623485364343, + "Yices": 8.9654334766541321, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1238521435474276, + "CVC4": 3.3331015492462308, + "CVC3": 2.9966550069842137, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1656524906460879, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4344315257389262 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.827569281297238, + "veriT": 10.569743246245883, + "Yices": 10.465258266589398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.468248069676998, + "CVC4": 1.6849934766653643, + "CVC3": 12.410687636564887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7814652223612568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.434326034175138 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242399046463655, + "veriT": 10.155800654897, + "Yices": 10.349020933427417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963055422664887, + "CVC4": 0.15267765367075001, + "CVC3": 11.723817680193379, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17490233337033334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.434876804098275 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9839293914555451, + "veriT": 7.6428666565163743, + "Yices": 7.7693441244530002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4592561474785519, + "CVC4": 0.26140501221724999, + "CVC3": 9.0042106620033877, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9723599092553288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7500851595778837 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.28523226731822, + "veriT": 13.194381180497247, + "Yices": 13.10186739936159, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.760354274609208, + "CVC4": 14.803846114524177, + "CVC3": 14.302112693345881, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.895998484571294, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.893948224272242 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.433072540873408, + "veriT": 11.14871157558377, + "Yices": 10.877567654482789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.264152069244266, + "CVC4": 1.6243269784057595, + "CVC3": 11.420045813442869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8959169500318094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7947853052768341 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.222998719082951, + "veriT": 10.399841980774672, + "Yices": 12.94061243629602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1374734792671397, + "CVC4": 10.120228686099997, + "CVC3": 10.882976601165943, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.679801414035087, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.034028221500114 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2089424947718186, + "veriT": 10.832020375720747, + "Yices": 4.8293678587683111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8269714393645478, + "CVC4": 0.20226623259422219, + "CVC3": 3.038248290553661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.105205258674504, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.123460892484083 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.533586670111129, + "veriT": 10.1938864701887, + "Yices": 9.3407687458062991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.592261456906396, + "CVC4": 10.123116609537986, + "CVC3": 9.0552706811525869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260378795316569, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.58111202846378 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.457019630075113, + "veriT": 10.935227111430176, + "Yices": 10.629347361379995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.477748454909522, + "CVC4": 8.1522872834365767, + "CVC3": 12.465854650972192, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2100901514071882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.808697768167075 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.20181826781885, + "veriT": 5.5758830256815086, + "Yices": 10.372239194717311, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5528762549745068, + "CVC4": 14.36969496807027, + "CVC3": 7.2034551298725615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.480966351001952, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4578048122036802 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.171770746146628, + "veriT": 9.3984002272476932, + "Yices": 10.331293281753846, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.832651379424844, + "CVC4": 0.17195993565384615, + "CVC3": 12.580764920902642, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8618135468679817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.267892946674952 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6191483147159134, + "veriT": 7.3539250982093876, + "Yices": 6.4717010744362886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1685042643914283, + "CVC4": 7.5521376992862237, + "CVC3": 2.3899938875349358, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5617725203455057, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5584622032620947 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.083453551710784, + "veriT": 11.191999910223627, + "Yices": 10.397983813613065, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.274343128795186, + "CVC4": 1.3504204286007491, + "CVC3": 11.779291616997144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9566203293385112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.516827653680528 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7195079818616126, + "veriT": 12.283844190461902, + "Yices": 7.5021770322176931, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.034712440373177, + "CVC4": 9.1235227727902846, + "CVC3": 5.8868873554093026, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.407499795418522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.40680797657274 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.790170909523882, + "veriT": 14.221074267378201, + "Yices": 13.597533897112422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.396909747666065, + "CVC4": 13.135509586199875, + "CVC3": 11.472353880942068, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.053210420299289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.08402594889407 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.38369307740118175, + "veriT": 12.730999792856146, + "Yices": 5.2601306072567136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5285733587270229, + "CVC4": 5.4145856595109327, + "CVC3": 6.8489340422851193, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8180379575760472, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5768064537361086 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16489197216855556, + "veriT": 0.20147861393611108, + "Yices": 12.54575541266597, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17860141899766668, + "CVC4": 5.0213405684859245, + "CVC3": 6.7045528946959942, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4531009510517965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4272991709924123 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4641380310058594, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5427037545239877, + "veriT": 11.696982614244613, + "Yices": 12.64984210680187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4017050167915546, + "CVC4": 12.509688780229075, + "CVC3": 9.4454066770904372, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.074494936737802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.145896549586386 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.027778148651123, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7147024071931525, + "veriT": 3.4512469101603775, + "Yices": 5.7395084465466661, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7899073485542425, + "CVC4": 0.15001699213122224, + "CVC3": 1.7025107598445803, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13578058766422224, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8965969698618883 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9444444179534912, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7092827222994393, + "veriT": 4.2050615127484097, + "Yices": 6.1619824209846144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4422131912499507, + "CVC4": 8.3349637840789175, + "CVC3": 2.2710451734621597, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2084528465760904, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9873289769266105 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5290007853291083, + "veriT": 4.3363174471896127, + "Yices": 2.5708149900270998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3231528028080826, + "CVC4": 2.0929699968220681, + "CVC3": 1.8410835565748873, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6225822161906183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6207951440470851 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13777874285515385, + "veriT": 6.5746952084840355, + "Yices": 7.2083916061972255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13610187581107691, + "CVC4": 1.2343070421918863, + "CVC3": 0.14260325387638462, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14053238634061541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13997396568400003 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9225646742189899, + "veriT": 10.356897736243587, + "Yices": 10.601097686306836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2598925535930983, + "CVC4": 5.8337900604868569, + "CVC3": 1.8938433494771361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4995790849188602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5066860881817012 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1684763868397736, + "veriT": 3.6104489865980378, + "Yices": 8.7625364426480843, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.374407297972974, + "CVC4": 2.3112385695253721, + "CVC3": 2.1527827040066612, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9770846554964874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9782671276690986 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6060536791138098, + "veriT": 7.9119687076740775, + "Yices": 11.036838213424106, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8936860717369672, + "CVC4": 5.5345319732781704, + "CVC3": 7.1638652272239263, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.597418257555653, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.619177186577501 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13110657778257145, + "veriT": 0.11407585393507144, + "Yices": 4.7038715695702278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13179314965921429, + "CVC4": 0.14527569382085717, + "CVC3": 0.12004408117164286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1371187949550714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13850323706214285 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6605145568447348, + "veriT": 7.2941928956082061, + "Yices": 10.4020918318617, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4105195428520894, + "CVC4": 4.3634661561939092, + "CVC3": 3.0042528012217091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9122660952138708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3339280854600997 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5073007681546047, + "veriT": 4.8160042017392142, + "Yices": 12.264484315925026, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7044745640312824, + "CVC4": 12.080953643691357, + "CVC3": 9.6563510532276666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.313370632562517, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2918011552263851 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.993908187145875, + "veriT": 11.127574765505697, + "Yices": 10.735778775996302, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.896135430362591, + "CVC4": 8.0634008920019102, + "CVC3": 7.4304588268273868, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.476447867638104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.473287033680288 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4109240283639739, + "veriT": 13.016121125410985, + "Yices": 9.760861593539838, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0945079000914486, + "CVC4": 10.679326412727063, + "CVC3": 12.597025708436279, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.141974363458331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.519358699752782 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9024311242760419, + "veriT": 11.28793717013478, + "Yices": 12.416551118648808, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.695412183725717, + "CVC4": 14.729113989538051, + "CVC3": 12.551615600073497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.672927649073454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.360127573517726 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4790093827370212, + "veriT": 9.4284983218775729, + "Yices": 11.50036794123479, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7247167812146316, + "CVC4": 4.0936694108910583, + "CVC3": 8.7037522257734388, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4193187441774118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4788335311001504 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13574054429636362, + "veriT": 4.2336084336498621, + "Yices": 5.1143117730789092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16122471242781819, + "CVC4": 1.6387360388315599, + "CVC3": 1.3759006400914544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4872308081202137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.835697451741054 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 29.0, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0916664600372314, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15249873236092309, + "veriT": 0.13416714824826154, + "Yices": 0.14128860712830771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14989952979846152, + "CVC4": 0.16686240191230775, + "CVC3": 0.14931519363738463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16168405476984615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1575999468136923 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18633519597528569, + "veriT": 0.16317552966107138, + "Yices": 3.6094318569626114, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18471133579864288, + "CVC4": 0.196141715001, + "CVC3": 0.18077378453071427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18473711985442856, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18553382327685713 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14692500106674999, + "veriT": 7.1718161854288143, + "Yices": 1.9195112135879355, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1663128721655, + "CVC4": 0.175659271017125, + "CVC3": 0.15135898678613752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15361190275067499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15668558826921247 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6969547595027696, + "veriT": 11.695871628588959, + "Yices": 1.0992861728314685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7140248792124617, + "CVC4": 1.2578460335413075, + "CVC3": 1.796659796751866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3221988822442139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3236249792541868 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4182075218818748, + "veriT": 0.13603606934874998, + "Yices": 0.14463605956299999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4224108153969999, + "CVC4": 0.180306801111625, + "CVC3": 0.16088471367524998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.62054484932187504, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.61721486812874993 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2146290221753206, + "veriT": 13.658216725919655, + "Yices": 8.2102531983837075, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4412929476218093, + "CVC4": 12.474207957683737, + "CVC3": 11.008329969218765, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.899233964285811, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.31371035630303 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.37732806402891667, + "veriT": 2.5249024627676184, + "Yices": 6.2221227139320634, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9924437018057501, + "CVC4": 1.3861660627843178, + "CVC3": 1.00763289288725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19543376175541669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18935285675533331 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.162490065990999, + "veriT": 1.0056540109977499, + "Yices": 2.5249653259019076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.166189285608249, + "CVC4": 14.339217875874015, + "CVC3": 1.1489602411774165, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3401267527738934, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.337838550413128 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.12043405960888, + "veriT": 3.0951358672199301, + "Yices": 3.0927801652340596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5981969143622079, + "CVC4": 11.021797062712963, + "CVC3": 2.37104381608366, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16293459776160998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16710840341646999 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1663618014796, + "veriT": 14.212948893630763, + "Yices": 2.5743994992860002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28008377185720001, + "CVC4": 3.2533298455331674, + "CVC3": 2.9628932443200706, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.08758203132785, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.083041312162585 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9241380420430001, + "veriT": 10.764236837092886, + "Yices": 10.808990237839859, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9959787403824674, + "CVC4": 14.36775037495724, + "CVC3": 5.2325964502518802, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25452565114141, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.593724096588597 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14126651206890908, + "veriT": 7.4248885141895107, + "Yices": 0.16061610710009092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24671223783063637, + "CVC4": 0.17441757919863637, + "CVC3": 0.13154904345200003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14333015496518181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14246978038381816 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17171355005962502, + "veriT": 7.1995687288319026, + "Yices": 7.976924446125369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17109420565262501, + "CVC4": 9.0934145780366489, + "CVC3": 2.7327955447693748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18196034029362501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16994506899500003 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4522923373176369, + "veriT": 13.253539340891725, + "Yices": 10.733416371597595, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2343284732983673, + "CVC4": 12.050511781688151, + "CVC3": 11.858793107495218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.014501981253177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.766437634229868 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0160093694631664, + "veriT": 12.950778045268459, + "Yices": 11.122593778351495, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1120366453441566, + "CVC4": 1.5715769208103332, + "CVC3": 4.7319031968898555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7077656536990267, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0748462216123187 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0175375938415527, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 32.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 103.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.503324338779246, + "veriT": 13.340835516174005, + "Yices": 12.205953647118037, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.149658646050609, + "CVC4": 12.959246679209135, + "CVC3": 7.0701152559890224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.574380252338816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.57318910312628 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3493258662608483, + "veriT": 14.213069227819377, + "Yices": 10.632123223821667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9122278314210055, + "CVC4": 11.21240550921569, + "CVC3": 4.6816176296111047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.275873667116617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.266940557134557 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25087401713594, + "veriT": 10.484287014959753, + "Yices": 10.439433287791708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975404503627582, + "CVC4": 13.861744512071548, + "CVC3": 14.247235833778294, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252408683551758, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.082422901836567 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.278968385715624, + "veriT": 11.750980382255323, + "Yices": 11.482578216353774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959553353442034, + "CVC4": 13.882619402434047, + "CVC3": 9.2044325215443319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.104293834731838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.941550794748652 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2167846439545364, + "veriT": 13.258854708295331, + "Yices": 14.241429610396265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.371015608360878, + "CVC4": 14.311700018618899, + "CVC3": 13.679840532530553, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244256068268335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.24525833107041 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.318735085315613, + "veriT": 7.3683366463361892, + "Yices": 2.2220096892622005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8734722966043225, + "CVC4": 0.28699916618099997, + "CVC3": 0.46334304345314287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19265911421199997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18390599992414283 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2110022322998679, + "veriT": 11.558062963571937, + "Yices": 11.690638384149523, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.790514006538226, + "CVC4": 9.956989386394433, + "CVC3": 12.161116147539081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2343333725395551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.594241235815105 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1451444625854492, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17445174638580002, + "veriT": 8.9163502427318413, + "Yices": 2.9501923719180092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.47823654665659998, + "CVC4": 2.990354222185295, + "CVC3": 0.15888427726660001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15621649567189999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1543765059909 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0970683097839355, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4425507489163163, + "veriT": 13.673143196138863, + "Yices": 8.1969455952932861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.0095606684523, + "CVC4": 4.5762543269765406, + "CVC3": 8.7434000938027037, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2568449660255276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.253449262376932 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.636217906643298, + "veriT": 10.468175173047465, + "Yices": 10.489242151215917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.834741212296453, + "CVC4": 12.361094597254606, + "CVC3": 12.115249819965088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.205860358525941, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.201944805221157 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 207.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.757035522730055, + "veriT": 11.163136221446875, + "Yices": 9.488372925208628, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.360334650136988, + "CVC4": 10.911444283824236, + "CVC3": 12.360939392939482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.472191806731884, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.473829279621222 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9933101765169829, + "veriT": 13.457531165058747, + "Yices": 14.135741714002387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1424575505216055, + "CVC4": 14.533345817796755, + "CVC3": 14.255291581687208, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6115565424024012, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.514584486230887 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.490274619587391, + "veriT": 11.969087049838997, + "Yices": 14.233250294522904, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.12014284903697, + "CVC4": 14.286006117579547, + "CVC3": 11.691785134240215, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8237258606233127, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9405325372866109 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7787601458433526, + "veriT": 8.7166773248781606, + "Yices": 8.5413293937432062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8845034292688991, + "CVC4": 8.2835683632242763, + "CVC3": 9.5250923180982756, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.64908220790802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.820447620658493 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0315780639648438, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.641492069216739, + "veriT": 11.060880144690429, + "Yices": 11.635611211781187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.991496574620715, + "CVC4": 14.531082196066729, + "CVC3": 14.286187287645145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.883501011053605, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.132637360751952 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.532746600432892, + "veriT": 14.24159638277005, + "Yices": 13.944232462145422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.127949284997959, + "CVC4": 14.649421212194129, + "CVC3": 13.892170882769262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.890622178014576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.924760562783076 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.009966336631589, + "veriT": 12.667981666012171, + "Yices": 14.238825768664791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.579994537278878, + "CVC4": 14.658804413588264, + "CVC3": 12.456978244041132, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.034760132864911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.931648543738804 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.029190205145218, + "veriT": 14.239882238497568, + "Yices": 14.197576822148861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.85605223351082, + "CVC4": 14.583131059473965, + "CVC3": 9.6751146410881983, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.487146413107663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.497298706171089 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.931175828909403, + "veriT": 11.551616900877242, + "Yices": 13.730647972770869, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.927705232393084, + "CVC4": 14.572338653741463, + "CVC3": 6.4913807830687755, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6877610036106443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9981607233818703 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12270165240913639, + "veriT": 0.094143275448227287, + "Yices": 0.09576569962282272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11961131465081819, + "CVC4": 0.12317240356118182, + "CVC3": 0.098965489116981817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12085931504386363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11726090445886363 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11584292448075265, + "veriT": 0.60822246358147902, + "Yices": 0.61108917000546847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12530040679665788, + "CVC4": 0.84837518240916621, + "CVC3": 0.087689573199673687, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.84700971497452193, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.84549291001088556 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3707701378054997, + "veriT": 0.095364799963800012, + "Yices": 1.3658013885975251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3705609379514998, + "CVC4": 0.12414934969949999, + "CVC3": 0.10215934031521251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12111416844387499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14113265908637501 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.62183309247899465, + "veriT": 10.166886283703471, + "Yices": 10.351721960973824, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.69664117489776245, + "CVC4": 0.15071919613167648, + "CVC3": 0.70269339764138239, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14803390935611763, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.431399691466961 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5750733494123652, + "veriT": 5.538530885235776, + "Yices": 9.0454376594507906, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7355897720420199, + "CVC4": 1.6255355998226455, + "CVC3": 2.9942522462566563, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5484844403668732, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7445999793078286 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8366665840148926, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4836163776189766, + "veriT": 7.715883046855514, + "Yices": 9.611046470780046, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3766923647540334, + "CVC4": 11.378991296760981, + "CVC3": 6.5155747466956333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.974231244697522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7485869122081805 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.954067464907526, + "veriT": 6.4073207876462499, + "Yices": 6.5037640583046255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4029704966789502, + "CVC4": 0.15931831670087498, + "CVC3": 5.0950566731495277, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5500645901959389, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0659214534574089 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4143381206748751, + "veriT": 6.6821794906656162, + "Yices": 1.9050678947192499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.403692291463625, + "CVC4": 2.0407513850836727, + "CVC3": 1.4369646365597499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7671266626476374, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7549440471011164 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1625127646369293, + "veriT": 8.3106222945413002, + "Yices": 7.9132888968631336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.040981125227511, + "CVC4": 3.1261919819299959, + "CVC3": 6.5723103649856007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7876017980606198, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.138860338863587 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.246418135110806, + "veriT": 10.173627092519666, + "Yices": 10.355098022971584, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968888456267308, + "CVC4": 0.16789568490208331, + "CVC3": 12.16604746527733, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0891322560019567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.383660552954078 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.601588099506818, + "veriT": 10.961341748369367, + "Yices": 10.665239969171553, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.998518623725715, + "CVC4": 3.0359752623323293, + "CVC3": 13.690575603511334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.235225190196255, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.815469342145985 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5014043183064745, + "veriT": 5.945549901724303, + "Yices": 6.5079057868450461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9421918083133844, + "CVC4": 0.20967312227516666, + "CVC3": 4.5766862687413035, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9689846430109033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9677084811540635 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.691209393560408, + "veriT": 10.960940194936349, + "Yices": 9.8220586512274668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.309918138059764, + "CVC4": 3.2842085054601879, + "CVC3": 13.286374641149575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3075772876667493, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.01478900438949 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236799847098972, + "veriT": 10.150894357121933, + "Yices": 10.2828995885778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955283990846075, + "CVC4": 0.21070480894593333, + "CVC3": 13.974293012372009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.61085392942827, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.84346648142518 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.734297098701704, + "veriT": 13.296286263259654, + "Yices": 11.721007922364278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.688115585873776, + "CVC4": 14.314661431358919, + "CVC3": 6.1096881009529769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5012954826211447, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5057462961246966 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4635496708255618, + "veriT": 11.179131663119563, + "Yices": 12.359780172141939, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.474766465425944, + "CVC4": 12.362584211338863, + "CVC3": 10.640368778252629, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1045090957364696, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7378517159021074 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8392122043200629, + "veriT": 10.176554812402179, + "Yices": 12.015079530362431, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8489402038117628, + "CVC4": 13.238403017416607, + "CVC3": 8.7827187853077948, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.094822343959885, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.663446908993896 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3679541811254792, + "veriT": 5.9053772166928491, + "Yices": 3.0838626806399398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5812662624079694, + "CVC4": 3.2153837380223087, + "CVC3": 2.9138628946947591, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3411053800579866, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3431036727908872 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.415418493825991, + "veriT": 10.609076512905675, + "Yices": 10.367928525647196, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.987436431791741, + "CVC4": 5.1517422163029121, + "CVC3": 12.70329945045178, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6249455744739087, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.062027135266367 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.597384633840994, + "veriT": 11.540307277952627, + "Yices": 11.13787480946992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.148305280570211, + "CVC4": 6.8221438729272412, + "CVC3": 12.745114141879908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2062426834045032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.791717824445412 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0555553436279297, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2622309544142292, + "veriT": 6.4759058462644354, + "Yices": 6.5501013443462881, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1591665592461524, + "CVC4": 7.8189033913851524, + "CVC3": 3.7612886886978125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3694106767656073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9052193176793164 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0013087557659763, + "veriT": 6.5276213179201195, + "Yices": 6.0064411977553629, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.874552421461158, + "CVC4": 7.3648980948928795, + "CVC3": 2.8734640138556764, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7374143457275339, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7324327029612352 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9936008846842799, + "veriT": 2.875149649632009, + "Yices": 2.9267555467274633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0011741464968975, + "CVC4": 0.16744074651099997, + "CVC3": 0.34338179513972727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15951335313254547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1999820470206504 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7064353301212218, + "veriT": 4.8149088776337514, + "Yices": 14.156355880206302, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7028508642439331, + "CVC4": 11.302825405138504, + "CVC3": 10.034744189194333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7576792480485084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7604296256947061 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.250897085434158, + "veriT": 9.9572924765462698, + "Yices": 11.507235544416794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.439387866708305, + "CVC4": 3.3809747330504347, + "CVC3": 10.392206110932669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4091551319994888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.339178098915449 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13474463726629998, + "veriT": 8.5108632514770157, + "Yices": 11.333672139104944, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13255722094700001, + "CVC4": 0.1394747570571, + "CVC3": 0.11599733611010002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14006515179740001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13347780145300001 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2888630630266356, + "veriT": 8.1865642299560335, + "Yices": 9.3456547780083117, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7191326016840045, + "CVC4": 4.8219405314612063, + "CVC3": 1.3944410281644444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4412136803748652, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.488492717713072 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1887763083551741, + "veriT": 10.713710680602494, + "Yices": 10.731482717250012, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5179148807312481, + "CVC4": 12.18281956847787, + "CVC3": 9.7379766692765362, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231270073420408, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.817787496688334 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4008182990505123, + "veriT": 7.2146762907454116, + "Yices": 8.9736133236899107, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.423384373712, + "CVC4": 9.1518877449679081, + "CVC3": 8.4684671333609352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9581546622447137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9447713340321293 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4889802352609003, + "veriT": 12.789938429041761, + "Yices": 12.786596900319562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4285355077626001, + "CVC4": 14.491407230990188, + "CVC3": 12.111219791576923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.466972016387356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.482795478588613 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.351426086255969, + "veriT": 10.118036129590699, + "Yices": 10.113520809450693, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.870946078949697, + "CVC4": 10.321037030210562, + "CVC3": 10.566483035308563, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.002605653725196, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.991691478891081 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22044625247585717, + "veriT": 8.1764071523694462, + "Yices": 3.7272091973922152, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31886002497299998, + "CVC4": 2.2632124646027938, + "CVC3": 0.98971172706485711, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1785873494057819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1725602929880408 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2112188286158182, + "veriT": 1.115588795820909, + "Yices": 6.3847335297464234, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1366714684568182, + "CVC4": 0.20393558290263636, + "CVC3": 1.4807980573328572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1943876140611818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19682097880454547 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9220650633652503, + "veriT": 2.5489523005670636, + "Yices": 3.1592938642220716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9512741940316252, + "CVC4": 0.1800934411855, + "CVC3": 2.7256692833997374, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4355287934311507, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4322648465608383 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.429679311280875, + "veriT": 8.6373954965581046, + "Yices": 10.207518919349669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7537138037371249, + "CVC4": 0.18667890521950001, + "CVC3": 3.5940371254363428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16711046310087502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.704232544879317 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.02380134630646, + "veriT": 8.5059327993320846, + "Yices": 11.486992548751257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.527906853872773, + "CVC4": 6.873464313319241, + "CVC3": 11.592622766965118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3954140800267778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2920682484906685 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.907935385424433, + "veriT": 4.9088454168978704, + "Yices": 4.9693158420001797, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9981491817466737, + "CVC4": 5.5935284228832591, + "CVC3": 4.5790843056429509, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4732400145718474, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4412431939369874 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14617663230754546, + "veriT": 1.0408441070898726, + "Yices": 1.0746781283075455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14929478406918181, + "CVC4": 0.19136471837336358, + "CVC3": 3.2872819370761834, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16900565495609088, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16508060672199998 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.559205469013021, + "veriT": 11.916339717611759, + "Yices": 9.5275912979413473, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.318301515605205, + "CVC4": 10.441685024479179, + "CVC3": 8.1787056837133498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.288797476602349, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.841731142664033 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6039852882160601, + "veriT": 6.563930130456427, + "Yices": 6.6499788851219224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3944657675122611, + "CVC4": 2.6012236553523231, + "CVC3": 9.326248452367297, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0572706721328284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6267303913436137 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.27609207046450002, + "veriT": 1.9058597379088376, + "Yices": 7.5726116454979779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.57020905138350009, + "CVC4": 0.35741780860312505, + "CVC3": 0.46457129022674998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.688784649847793, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6898255602444179 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.364610163625875, + "veriT": 8.8056436202152693, + "Yices": 1.871839672119298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.378422242104125, + "CVC4": 0.13388087544825, + "CVC3": 0.10675956810029999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12278282299695001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1216544823156 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15407275778349999, + "veriT": 3.65641958774708, + "Yices": 0.15919667365887499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.165446858736125, + "CVC4": 0.177711896566875, + "CVC3": 0.46250641012799998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1671208589505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16581404961687501 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19962522525950002, + "veriT": 0.17006617350778572, + "Yices": 0.21844079767578575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20414089130457147, + "CVC4": 0.21642629502692853, + "CVC3": 0.19522794786971429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19899058778171425, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19833728232392853 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.704667594251823, + "veriT": 4.9608041529421287, + "Yices": 13.263233609075835, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8801507502036872, + "CVC4": 3.9014529408047949, + "CVC3": 3.7118985336888537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6727928691531249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2017361727847495 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8215935230255127, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7063894271850586, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.37270695369288886, + "veriT": 6.611478402288081, + "Yices": 4.9523246834622228, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9126152190268613, + "CVC4": 1.789510615000812, + "CVC3": 0.49110507171911105, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.118819439307165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.40091525424309 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18402108835785716, + "veriT": 5.155036530653212, + "Yices": 5.6208393750331895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3194448427652532, + "CVC4": 5.2359996264801891, + "CVC3": 3.1777008622550098, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9816862566378457, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.929814944376659 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.790129189703705, + "veriT": 11.205746665956561, + "Yices": 10.94260891074299, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.83440123798132, + "CVC4": 11.163781923377735, + "CVC3": 8.6307343772884177, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.909582217070266, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.0317864928523 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1508236155362277, + "veriT": 14.207495361230404, + "Yices": 1.9603503290512858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3569364425667261, + "CVC4": 2.284493033514174, + "CVC3": 2.1507401467678893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.457380560715166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.519246577068413 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6115763402496253, + "veriT": 14.209254334243983, + "Yices": 13.272187552618812, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.913242731846081, + "CVC4": 7.4540698076916456, + "CVC3": 9.3242026214246359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.466027754586305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.470715657008771 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16334763248092307, + "veriT": 12.390506257938073, + "Yices": 10.115761444953231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20002280515016921, + "CVC4": 3.5504104494862481, + "CVC3": 6.6625940645093262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8209126415631953, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8159047118071108 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3550947634488058, + "veriT": 7.2656923878000335, + "Yices": 8.7683812052904901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9730208699204468, + "CVC4": 11.230787250952702, + "CVC3": 2.8705609580131499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1036491315369958, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0504496447827361 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12518343578537142, + "veriT": 2.9653058780458577, + "Yices": 6.9499204248456508, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13891739040215714, + "CVC4": 4.2728005759492733, + "CVC3": 4.5270428938635714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.25433124254142858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.26977491471999998 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15748166344631429, + "veriT": 0.13273935462020001, + "Yices": 0.13571115253227142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0185492871908144, + "CVC4": 8.2397629447729823, + "CVC3": 0.14317627488334286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0264570677991567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0189068625955287 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2999892232027523, + "veriT": 10.310656958417715, + "Yices": 6.5321989773451774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.956622842990372, + "CVC4": 10.288916454724768, + "CVC3": 11.889386092080484, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.004582901976269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9893378985794357 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.391913850885587, + "veriT": 8.1461236962490542, + "Yices": 8.142852264452225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.626542585186256, + "CVC4": 10.217526851461145, + "CVC3": 7.5541764873633781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.28299135068111109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.26401203449366661 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.10831481654945, + "veriT": 12.371783316279949, + "Yices": 9.5515317684824321, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.573399840997775, + "CVC4": 6.1970499981864924, + "CVC3": 8.721666240801957, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228178974865681, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.294381142218244 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 99.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.230632460070456, + "veriT": 13.186513544457162, + "Yices": 13.197965191318648, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.945219068336039, + "CVC4": 11.228992830619511, + "CVC3": 7.6193990240959524, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.291045815489994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.293747538416161 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8312649726867676, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.277238300360954, + "veriT": 10.894422967437464, + "Yices": 10.647957984380165, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.995118323813267, + "CVC4": 13.362331633318044, + "CVC3": 14.271786668305543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.274316261033704, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.884232694857173 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239852912676831, + "veriT": 10.166227811496778, + "Yices": 10.716449411749542, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962010607044018, + "CVC4": 14.455494391877664, + "CVC3": 13.432123022811844, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240538620812153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.999537713073005 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.512386902682245, + "veriT": 11.079641153334151, + "Yices": 10.926857252542778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.445339539843594, + "CVC4": 14.42716308562575, + "CVC3": 13.719639778131951, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240266758508463, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.963043140923169 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8057309942101476, + "veriT": 12.576732757620713, + "Yices": 9.4544069181857324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.716953083091983, + "CVC4": 9.3384313580421683, + "CVC3": 5.8259398101121151, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.245855376790143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.159127508727689 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.44690451805533327, + "veriT": 5.8098244363077898, + "Yices": 6.4953169251749179, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5221001219784798, + "CVC4": 3.0245115915443255, + "CVC3": 4.2012182818857307, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.689451180247239, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.712360502935553 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1849817486441969, + "veriT": 11.209909280203682, + "Yices": 9.6182687499890207, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7173474592951843, + "CVC4": 11.159307277203853, + "CVC3": 8.1761471080410075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5231532945549997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4747452767728557 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.444156143404197, + "veriT": 11.804679744639532, + "Yices": 11.923681050214196, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.022891036067833, + "CVC4": 14.473023660676688, + "CVC3": 14.213334937599665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.692200617037491, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.204064368770805 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.315910583681553, + "veriT": 14.234208160592067, + "Yices": 14.249679328112995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.173760685810128, + "CVC4": 14.757247759287592, + "CVC3": 9.742020327335311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255147555425319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5918956519048084 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0743676113962004, + "veriT": 14.233299740719977, + "Yices": 13.998769707566765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.047491444510284, + "CVC4": 14.698113745968987, + "CVC3": 10.790411380924301, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.469692737694851, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.465800727549 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1515917693493111, + "veriT": 6.2512162714500237, + "Yices": 0.12909640092576669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18411648090488886, + "CVC4": 0.16695356032044445, + "CVC3": 3.0982651369926, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14580289230637777, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14216762013958889 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7595177929242736, + "veriT": 10.373200496637923, + "Yices": 13.00535207890503, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3888895835909749, + "CVC4": 13.464600486128269, + "CVC3": 3.9982573372878374, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3765728249511717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3800520423004823 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8245448823491177, + "veriT": 13.291047795832243, + "Yices": 10.912256448524817, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.81574441276846, + "CVC4": 2.5848389002347769, + "CVC3": 4.1533512872430345, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6046259136651422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.602410795735663 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 217.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3838487589380826, + "veriT": 12.776688125963641, + "Yices": 12.717930348909841, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.180228701275784, + "CVC4": 13.62873832376328, + "CVC3": 6.1510726580547024, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.666249610626192, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.172516646955303 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.019916340007375, + "veriT": 13.225582446456567, + "Yices": 7.0017056510283764, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.842370772681633, + "CVC4": 4.7577462513625814, + "CVC3": 12.570773712653676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9402914193044014, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5699718561278595 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.637325772831018, + "veriT": 12.714552481325434, + "Yices": 13.930897560443695, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966799016435282, + "CVC4": 14.506680869553353, + "CVC3": 12.44935579447356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.886873640345962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.105614227427038 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.273081157956897, + "veriT": 12.521855999378952, + "Yices": 13.711806614592799, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.318614904853431, + "CVC4": 14.440698844806173, + "CVC3": 12.528401152849892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8196435653605709, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4562449796022872 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "false": 151, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0504565238952637, + "true": 150 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236486680418713, + "veriT": 13.835470656628136, + "Yices": 13.514436503644268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952087006859832, + "CVC4": 14.713282296839008, + "CVC3": 14.256800257532229, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.153861976513843, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.942500750192726 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240249080408784, + "veriT": 14.230878167543585, + "Yices": 14.171538642555561, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966427188617086, + "CVC4": 14.499158043536047, + "CVC3": 14.232839409743935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.262308117188194, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.260304377746063 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.899975932153698, + "veriT": 13.946491202879775, + "Yices": 13.847011201206348, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.123188780720477, + "CVC4": 14.65819023186115, + "CVC3": 9.9135768745142894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.154004186634838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.552247643180655 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12384061255159376, + "veriT": 0.095752877125278135, + "Yices": 0.097983415377493749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12106536594934374, + "CVC4": 0.12282501236740627, + "CVC3": 0.099476290177596863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11886941845799999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11748102246064376 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.64108207789691052, + "veriT": 0.60826520651705263, + "Yices": 0.61069447706157376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.65107532500481569, + "CVC4": 0.84987160248441884, + "CVC3": 0.086520859718468401, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.8477417007721747, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.84599595492387514 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15361989949100002, + "veriT": 0.13115092142812501, + "Yices": 5.2254460936239626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14804124224775, + "CVC4": 0.14640286796499999, + "CVC3": 0.14393874332971252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.145293798935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22579471355725 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0840251195144575, + "veriT": 10.167267208188282, + "Yices": 10.353809478355279, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1814295641767141, + "CVC4": 0.14984720740840624, + "CVC3": 0.69240521768443752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14991226953618753, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.424849641696799 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16395940670209089, + "veriT": 4.6764804184835453, + "Yices": 6.8487613187729091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25843199592581817, + "CVC4": 0.15283025204854547, + "CVC3": 0.21066742126436361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14768478606845456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1367678065062807 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0268830440573247, + "veriT": 12.590073321603681, + "Yices": 12.569992175155029, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0082661773130983, + "CVC4": 12.567118961534511, + "CVC3": 8.9496640769427014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.751215179221772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.801844092791539 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5611794621821429, + "veriT": 8.4211683772551922, + "Yices": 9.4556126060644452, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5612227129848573, + "CVC4": 10.323214038577047, + "CVC3": 2.141216028941292, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1599344765521318, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1500554443525854 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.071648542221171, + "veriT": 11.459794893755483, + "Yices": 10.338973015254776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.519565295279852, + "CVC4": 4.1604708054466206, + "CVC3": 8.7170967946636786, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3867175481879315, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.292911469428873 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7638890743255615, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2477104877454526, + "veriT": 10.158870119340763, + "Yices": 10.314524432200647, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.638997083354788, + "CVC4": 0.1707336551784118, + "CVC3": 6.4599907337615221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14487674377876469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.432773622057711 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23856242142543, + "veriT": 10.156751471007764, + "Yices": 10.323879094024765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956369654650162, + "CVC4": 0.15348790865594117, + "CVC3": 11.974800719546147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1222213388890281, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.252241652463706 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.195548971643182, + "veriT": 9.8089237715615596, + "Yices": 11.644581204039843, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.876175456560885, + "CVC4": 5.717612785600978, + "CVC3": 11.193032229993564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3512546569563315, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4082554973248929 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.250750314256512, + "veriT": 8.7354039137939985, + "Yices": 10.331275850796143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.869266116705758, + "CVC4": 0.17652894050071427, + "CVC3": 11.709409161318787, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.858753292715452, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.315847037791425 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9455550598271465, + "veriT": 9.0517745623094434, + "Yices": 9.1860005314292223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.305706394637154, + "CVC4": 0.79039747882122224, + "CVC3": 12.669806100489057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.187669023447226, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.582220090136868 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4870985157750929, + "veriT": 11.133104423145697, + "Yices": 8.4663265907472844, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9079664066600479, + "CVC4": 3.0352029603185979, + "CVC3": 2.6646455833024358, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1818388987061281, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7222027465835659 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1829048608171311, + "veriT": 6.6833467258044772, + "Yices": 8.7914898362356766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8267339358451249, + "CVC4": 9.0704860095497679, + "CVC3": 3.1988222076194224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9604653005632589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9740291385246616 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6690181722989585, + "veriT": 11.003348602744493, + "Yices": 7.471198877876045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6150057869794665, + "CVC4": 12.794781741745014, + "CVC3": 3.8282405189983573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.944656245130552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.939962266883191 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2986499667572442, + "veriT": 5.9269416160897253, + "Yices": 5.9291933069304754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3553329444334858, + "CVC4": 0.20470613246267502, + "CVC3": 0.10399110104526665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2971799921751519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2955960795031742 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1390263194368155, + "veriT": 0.82427024474941424, + "Yices": 0.83907720555527854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.184715804479048, + "CVC4": 0.1401421937715, + "CVC3": 0.19806880087942855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14911820410071427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.9466036385008948 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3550909505915225, + "veriT": 12.119439857746297, + "Yices": 11.769054743210109, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1189227717382568, + "CVC4": 10.753259630707603, + "CVC3": 6.9686103027078357, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9956944517712589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.110330571773762 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.496576665762666, + "veriT": 1.3145181936010248, + "Yices": 12.955486140252622, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4964533575786665, + "CVC4": 11.974450749428264, + "CVC3": 9.9042640834948905, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5299935582905486, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5324131579404461 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.951245876811782, + "veriT": 13.478923662946688, + "Yices": 13.363178122324911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.731971952870138, + "CVC4": 12.008196400659999, + "CVC3": 13.484762370135179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.417113858097675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.444849910170412 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238540944349854, + "veriT": 10.668685552824719, + "Yices": 10.81855010077588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956163726640083, + "CVC4": 0.31178352217143745, + "CVC3": 12.146876775317518, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2096240871995443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.669365745154337 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.719367543456138, + "veriT": 7.59161456761169, + "Yices": 5.2129726356802069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0424671250888151, + "CVC4": 5.6080611293310572, + "CVC3": 3.8168736880612535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6079745651641542, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6035857596742522 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7660473120510138, + "veriT": 14.228926097052506, + "Yices": 14.072144992666233, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2918361955707631, + "CVC4": 12.313315705460342, + "CVC3": 8.7787903044359066, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.993745342118558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.037586770471888 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.310645704839613, + "veriT": 12.359142542498182, + "Yices": 8.8051552984289678, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.952415536250108, + "CVC4": 12.26278234938386, + "CVC3": 14.189293467508032, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.367975615479033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.879815409468975 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.27616306495009096, + "veriT": 2.9374683515643638, + "Yices": 9.4214899847306821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.57395569525263646, + "CVC4": 4.1488015540198502, + "CVC3": 1.5166149437552903, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.97966321034369, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.164707082290933 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5198532192918011, + "veriT": 10.795003828181349, + "Yices": 10.105685705562149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.216158499999306, + "CVC4": 5.8378066457029725, + "CVC3": 5.1250367094250997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.550092286637081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.543132204932254 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.978905485728449, + "veriT": 9.2824756473434906, + "Yices": 9.2734632613707575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.056121646846698, + "CVC4": 9.9341248085123315, + "CVC3": 8.1927837904733583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.636544872207592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.622282072728298 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5364023885124998, + "veriT": 6.2848727006817233, + "Yices": 2.4942899120226323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0544257866648339, + "CVC4": 0.17698406450149998, + "CVC3": 3.6833739444273501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.99936504179066643, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.99692340388874989 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9916665554046631, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14788177068979999, + "veriT": 2.12962621927276, + "Yices": 8.5921610095100274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15668643174059999, + "CVC4": 3.1306831524108718, + "CVC3": 6.5710250162830004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9706781521402799, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.968580985780028 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.83400749378152, + "veriT": 10.244608541797842, + "Yices": 13.474296317273762, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.439766445263851, + "CVC4": 9.7937214168319766, + "CVC3": 13.831598126516656, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1296457392014894, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0850498331741285 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11957792130627273, + "veriT": 8.4973964004002358, + "Yices": 0.10578450104556363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12830581028194546, + "CVC4": 2.695173768458667, + "CVC3": 0.11465956755172728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12049738014056363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12053778501572726 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2887206077575684, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.661130311113947, + "veriT": 12.874028113427544, + "Yices": 12.47284930694957, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3536814165215549, + "CVC4": 8.275710222317997, + "CVC3": 6.5391783242820543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9541350129011299, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9337465502356705 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1288857212164114, + "veriT": 10.144356342600586, + "Yices": 10.262525649566429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.258715813176792, + "CVC4": 4.6424973332905077, + "CVC3": 4.3047015393212584, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0193797707053935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.242559545067655 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1698582200486798, + "veriT": 14.214719620861041, + "Yices": 3.4289702119461118, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5838153329602682, + "CVC4": 2.3880861519277028, + "CVC3": 3.6615149317622384, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237901638056419, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.231640290454163 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.291222534384759, + "veriT": 5.8294963444137915, + "Yices": 7.2960339108980108, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0955813558061296, + "CVC4": 0.42225385703083335, + "CVC3": 3.6867999569312828, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6854784060375003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.534286335049611 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1510238833935714, + "veriT": 4.9996781632143401, + "Yices": 3.7346160215494999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14393081478242858, + "CVC4": 2.2394550341178805, + "CVC3": 1.6626168036660001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6072572087512143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.151940167375713 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1571969985961914, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 21.0, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0113635063171387, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15464940897100005, + "veriT": 0.13874933213220497, + "Yices": 0.13585067801004999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18547442101314998, + "CVC4": 0.18773638011559998, + "CVC3": 0.15344518071774998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18643096006150001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18161514782740001 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22873067781988887, + "veriT": 0.19522130243722224, + "Yices": 1.8178011461499193, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.222144933519, + "CVC4": 0.24143577767533339, + "CVC3": 0.21658888254300002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.220368523397, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2161041409201111 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0036744162729998, + "veriT": 1.5527861468809141, + "Yices": 1.5624031087239574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.005657446430714, + "CVC4": 2.189111115147262, + "CVC3": 0.14377974780057143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15451264987398569, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15677192291771427 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15538765711199998, + "veriT": 4.8264939830370386, + "Yices": 0.20754626613641669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17732155908674999, + "CVC4": 0.1783570537174167, + "CVC3": 0.36097683715316659, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16153015974591667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16574769098691666 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.047149658203125, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1709267222794999, + "veriT": 3.9237076830870263, + "Yices": 3.3898755829540361, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6195437911115342, + "CVC4": 5.7893135021897528, + "CVC3": 2.9444019278349112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5103583368121622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5153122668190573 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6712038659959845, + "veriT": 10.122271127072775, + "Yices": 10.167816831629125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.635703849383322, + "CVC4": 1.4742790891543001, + "CVC3": 1.781933630924625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9904971466076746, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5165284466772224 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16782474423933333, + "veriT": 1.2860225837229153, + "Yices": 1.7213864849017171, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16476474521477777, + "CVC4": 4.8875711290360817, + "CVC3": 1.4491625143631117, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18170707617077778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17936026246444442 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6411704398590592, + "veriT": 4.0987246863980129, + "Yices": 4.7455268574072917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.991514768227435, + "CVC4": 7.4271747396502326, + "CVC3": 5.299397088296546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0365872463561185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6510318668106825 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.46215066848192, + "veriT": 13.357714541485072, + "Yices": 12.044680904940046, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.907291757760003, + "CVC4": 11.446303594126796, + "CVC3": 9.8838929172289873, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5635460354109441, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4031367900808096 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7865386009216309, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0793545817579258, + "veriT": 12.411865317935437, + "Yices": 6.1238037555974989, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.074633453197325, + "CVC4": 3.4525813852687497, + "CVC3": 10.234764628794936, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.432217077911698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.081694089253576 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9102680683135986, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.37623012803592304, + "veriT": 12.045241203660128, + "Yices": 12.160729709825175, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0705576433802779, + "CVC4": 14.456463744619088, + "CVC3": 9.8003624818164798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247639297587565, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.823096621478109 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.416067092005287, + "veriT": 12.34858420312168, + "Yices": 12.642326883734334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.118194109274906, + "CVC4": 14.70892987137487, + "CVC3": 13.511544149217521, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.132379386084592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.112786921160451 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.79910160809999997, + "veriT": 6.1832111376391978, + "Yices": 3.6765370470044845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4317667048997915, + "CVC4": 3.8505182109982328, + "CVC3": 3.0335851223276249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9276962494694807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5381266316080229 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.611300757339333, + "veriT": 7.9159411315457602, + "Yices": 9.6714730926700625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2357702252343334, + "CVC4": 5.0256216188547267, + "CVC3": 1.9384662244587929, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8524679043016654, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8490750313689128 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.80781174697299996, + "veriT": 13.268971650204088, + "Yices": 3.3654241712377999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2079136067443095, + "CVC4": 4.0236200916158369, + "CVC3": 0.37558713084266671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7366313211710387, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.734108952252976 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18438001583362501, + "veriT": 4.896097439326546, + "Yices": 0.58995778570900004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.67616129351425003, + "CVC4": 0.17370482876437499, + "CVC3": 3.5756523786343468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15976920799899999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15948841416349996 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 107.0, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0066489070425466, + "veriT": 9.4856584330240672, + "Yices": 9.1587155463030339, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5206653218634409, + "CVC4": 5.6535975059976256, + "CVC3": 1.0119455554509749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.180680110398014, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1775411049615254 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7309960574620344, + "veriT": 13.685989791635892, + "Yices": 9.6900125749678363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.55481781196508, + "CVC4": 13.365803151097964, + "CVC3": 9.8449130704638073, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0397675487330229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7693958342962732 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.299260466002858, + "veriT": 12.222512552687009, + "Yices": 10.978164949799909, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.93665018770939, + "CVC4": 12.422189269789524, + "CVC3": 13.032376416302858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.961274908810113, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.104583187382955 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.46514702898314286, + "veriT": 11.04353359611247, + "Yices": 5.7108337086716654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7348961604994284, + "CVC4": 2.2814168127619534, + "CVC3": 1.790829949143286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2047209679946658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2193181534182322 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5217814086953769, + "veriT": 12.800554714455565, + "Yices": 12.826321385498996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.026686826097063, + "CVC4": 14.539885472519362, + "CVC3": 10.393221218740479, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.16400105951166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.163079042968626 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 181.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1784543991088867, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.240201277816498, + "veriT": 10.849659668684593, + "Yices": 8.8852823408188346, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.357580927412101, + "CVC4": 12.328174161408826, + "CVC3": 9.1978319666629815, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6330029260579177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6939223628909268 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254018807334749, + "veriT": 10.208100061125, + "Yices": 10.352780226586667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976184399541751, + "CVC4": 14.274228641440178, + "CVC3": 14.251270449956252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251705604599493, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.068650633151742 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26393049047936, + "veriT": 11.555110180579964, + "Yices": 13.307277787156073, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.643385082473136, + "CVC4": 14.418155443633324, + "CVC3": 13.441474795114781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239451938192957, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.509585272109261 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3141972495817784, + "veriT": 13.346664433533377, + "Yices": 13.915724682811915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.416461097573027, + "CVC4": 14.610738189094617, + "CVC3": 11.435260888809305, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256965517131963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.176308718144096 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3798796186556732, + "veriT": 14.44661000208983, + "Yices": 13.022469703748239, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.132773158832874, + "CVC4": 7.0891931687064629, + "CVC3": 8.9410657327473455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.926775439138245, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.895891994860781 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0413305292361645, + "veriT": 11.409316858127726, + "Yices": 13.291953470754727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.979630751513575, + "CVC4": 10.937434680057482, + "CVC3": 9.9264778950076256, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0994567435172629, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1129098763015408 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3493995192636752, + "veriT": 14.214590473739435, + "Yices": 13.630436516771715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1838021849504177, + "CVC4": 14.706306767052885, + "CVC3": 5.8466890690892583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.071271979229582, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.040364102030534 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.626124593613125, + "veriT": 9.7757030564515102, + "Yices": 10.462651026946236, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8099770399880004, + "CVC4": 11.081867763909758, + "CVC3": 4.0300760920048306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9671899018447006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9631434567771919 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 87.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.916243988900627, + "veriT": 13.726875997035803, + "Yices": 14.053355917156592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.907013706388669, + "CVC4": 11.011214928660978, + "CVC3": 14.23597141460564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.250245909379222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.248093463292902 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.267393014577706, + "veriT": 13.354815964692065, + "Yices": 13.656062262094201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.984822713629869, + "CVC4": 14.565488626215496, + "CVC3": 13.933212068887158, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.038286304298978, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.091494482370551 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.964040940265136, + "veriT": 13.558734439884214, + "Yices": 13.553678558433221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.184285641330135, + "CVC4": 14.700994541739794, + "CVC3": 14.220234633617515, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1750426291806608, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2414172776492141 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11002140062002272, + "veriT": 0.53270953298683643, + "Yices": 0.5360626883397136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11818707754383634, + "CVC4": 0.74166959854482528, + "CVC3": 0.081693326925704551, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.74126299820586905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.73955177246751025 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.123660551031, + "veriT": 0.096509614553162523, + "Yices": 0.097860322365929162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12169014904229165, + "CVC4": 0.12224150848508336, + "CVC3": 0.10145312708347499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12106060201133333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11968899492684165 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6214403305980429, + "veriT": 1.6756595488650754, + "Yices": 1.3683961208844231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7203424351559926, + "CVC4": 2.3237783553585021, + "CVC3": 0.13544616091599998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15585207830538461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1615441994233846 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1714284420013428, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6983275396197883, + "veriT": 7.8996842770627858, + "Yices": 9.3899667394752147, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8746645523865508, + "CVC4": 5.7000100797032962, + "CVC3": 8.9267998204904071, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4170827393252745, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9365479674728583 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20784301120375864, + "veriT": 10.167453856445135, + "Yices": 10.350011102585931, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27582949126341377, + "CVC4": 0.14934608985617243, + "CVC3": 0.63475747269193095, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1477821091434138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.612107026605793 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "exists", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0871210098266602, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5811127460537788, + "veriT": 7.513290665600465, + "Yices": 10.661783665284114, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5727571119399109, + "CVC4": 12.867678902617802, + "CVC3": 4.711935283510833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.651269748592702, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4546938115009942 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5609680070538294, + "veriT": 2.5332005687929784, + "Yices": 3.5759506241529984, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6457249733171682, + "CVC4": 1.6375521699407922, + "CVC3": 1.3741986920659, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5475908420086588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7600119693664196 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8452379703521729, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.246825793968076, + "veriT": 10.173838547799333, + "Yices": 10.340598549723584, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96476368486187, + "CVC4": 0.16326649681075001, + "CVC3": 12.763501577310128, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5850805941461283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.337356425109524 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.82079880246501, + "veriT": 10.163981352049248, + "Yices": 10.317329335087376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.94703829266124, + "CVC4": 0.167850131845625, + "CVC3": 10.3642465229021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.140247821894875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.938371229863733 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243017522311826, + "veriT": 10.154188713396888, + "Yices": 10.337884558508334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963559849238193, + "CVC4": 0.15107432442155558, + "CVC3": 12.581718587848576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16689226841322222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.362784335613391 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.49200490242907, + "veriT": 10.162839220702873, + "Yices": 10.334712135681251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.154587090470054, + "CVC4": 1.9193043399697223, + "CVC3": 7.4850745783543076, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1968430936953851, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.66818061464525 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6399596293210195, + "veriT": 5.0476853682621075, + "Yices": 8.9161486563352437, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4221930291065465, + "CVC4": 3.4143432663970921, + "CVC3": 7.6490989783370402, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9435860620016783, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8110789563165719 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7097935169416272, + "veriT": 4.2983971011988231, + "Yices": 7.3698383203715894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7329613776658452, + "CVC4": 0.43407243816899999, + "CVC3": 2.795977634819605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0292528279522415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9695776947245012 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8184020587862868, + "veriT": 6.6963632052880175, + "Yices": 8.1962106798989449, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3844724009765743, + "CVC4": 10.677179389265349, + "CVC3": 5.4346983957826396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.385228441957894, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5730207119471977 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.91788552928243106, + "veriT": 5.760972678732788, + "Yices": 4.0933423093382535, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2233634174487884, + "CVC4": 5.3034529156564219, + "CVC3": 2.0470954716629608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0111954672219312, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0223416196303505 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 23.0, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.601862974779111, + "veriT": 12.023999269282893, + "Yices": 11.452331324815763, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.211329563583574, + "CVC4": 6.9780017647643868, + "CVC3": 13.601820285505626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.89792370180241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.048155379504657 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3895602504044344, + "veriT": 10.695379599704349, + "Yices": 10.698929196425643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8118756515937271, + "CVC4": 2.1862566620152788, + "CVC3": 4.0608913198571424, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.648377422318761, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.645684474853548 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6395062812374626, + "veriT": 9.476629080659043, + "Yices": 11.780260448500066, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0544752093554415, + "CVC4": 4.4503492027172324, + "CVC3": 5.8749805136906943, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.376016613903184, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6734191821071036 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1904698322382101, + "veriT": 10.662782435553263, + "Yices": 7.9212279320022283, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7455294627684808, + "CVC4": 0.17388851209833334, + "CVC3": 2.4926742344096815, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15552118938266665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3008853256784705 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.333302735578648, + "veriT": 9.0950967657982211, + "Yices": 11.529486244514549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.738006834020245, + "CVC4": 9.3520866415512547, + "CVC3": 12.328176339009433, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9997278597888801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.119329060408695 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8237249851226807, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14583089181985714, + "veriT": 1.561506189221143, + "Yices": 2.1927781995782798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14481552009171428, + "CVC4": 0.19984366151628571, + "CVC3": 1.8577105051954288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1867008485942945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1882458203294908 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.642582760877366, + "veriT": 8.1550692294984, + "Yices": 8.2395600453683997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.545022858982019, + "CVC4": 8.6416272300071348, + "CVC3": 7.0524456628043168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6093501284148086, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6683768482105528 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4165276075132658, + "veriT": 11.06637648231203, + "Yices": 10.796348371210165, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8255362198402594, + "CVC4": 11.91358872746545, + "CVC3": 8.5040982023011988, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.943940170684812, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.946740478858795 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.52324313333341177, + "veriT": 8.2856899434407865, + "Yices": 8.3935755268852343, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3575757553944543, + "CVC4": 8.4698786353689428, + "CVC3": 2.5721502010792228, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.899859352060439, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.404940724315086 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.796972642816302, + "veriT": 10.142450356742927, + "Yices": 10.583721354830397, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.64333422430521, + "CVC4": 10.655279199616555, + "CVC3": 9.9784320390224348, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.766582574478351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.356708289415536 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13174129907349999, + "veriT": 0.11936868542121666, + "Yices": 5.7507277375345858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18754525973651667, + "CVC4": 2.5460839832865823, + "CVC3": 0.12690218770210002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17188349318233331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17087309711516671 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.519081006980382, + "veriT": 10.676538741027713, + "Yices": 10.479327936643285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955668828575863, + "CVC4": 3.7036889890173983, + "CVC3": 9.6543972914569576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8267562924960297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.093091969570541 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7101548168904404, + "veriT": 2.8856683431269272, + "Yices": 1.9900702740320997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.832096989290704, + "CVC4": 1.5060805159385078, + "CVC3": 0.34550313442845454, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0656262226726363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1019734802445318 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.528859591290308, + "veriT": 10.518427945146023, + "Yices": 8.6487689458681984, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.877878827719464, + "CVC4": 8.2318247012682022, + "CVC3": 10.524980817440985, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9229890351408399, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7641296616608964 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.654729936817748, + "veriT": 11.318768506574298, + "Yices": 10.697293329816633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.57966526647674, + "CVC4": 2.2769046643906585, + "CVC3": 12.68466195377496, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1906407749416745, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.202241051821419 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2187475153229226, + "veriT": 8.7966023631674304, + "Yices": 3.0528469578691211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2138094622962816, + "CVC4": 2.5684277401048963, + "CVC3": 3.1034070044869249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5475199570928933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5429614288108615 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2163739204406738, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15999598455699998, + "veriT": 3.5050760005391393, + "Yices": 14.612880208136376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15888419078916666, + "CVC4": 9.5807089999439707, + "CVC3": 7.1949097086765006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15966056484316668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15956102570916664 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.435336390585686, + "veriT": 9.1761076771426673, + "Yices": 11.14582166755415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.837596847546303, + "CVC4": 7.4621413884024603, + "CVC3": 5.5730071675703758, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.460420536502812, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6515252545733059 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8109619294793333, + "veriT": 5.3108589697093889, + "Yices": 13.289847670184153, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8495561461501666, + "CVC4": 8.6935963671401257, + "CVC3": 10.567274515824957, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6162041202551021, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6219768376969088 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19770011813687999, + "veriT": 9.7147461034660658, + "Yices": 5.9870756250695578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28865536903283007, + "CVC4": 2.6025553519798823, + "CVC3": 1.2449190104517998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5760240151856482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5596448186995575 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7972731574738905, + "veriT": 4.7786278692512001, + "Yices": 11.765861169642408, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0887147725290625, + "CVC4": 8.6279401235358613, + "CVC3": 7.8110933538611604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0933888876989055, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1054483308026306 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16420124206523079, + "veriT": 0.14445520627084615, + "Yices": 2.5819361519559227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17705527264753845, + "CVC4": 0.18195772733746154, + "CVC3": 0.15819851399584614, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16972221369761537, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16873238855292308 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2831964492797852, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5003636066889525, + "veriT": 5.178206692342334, + "Yices": 5.3675107223694836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.092832761408793, + "CVC4": 9.5738006343890074, + "CVC3": 2.5970926202096383, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4947266525880649, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4952539425639997 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.58429829385728571, + "veriT": 8.8229659300799561, + "Yices": 7.9743515015842821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3681393019578225, + "CVC4": 12.664996462330668, + "CVC3": 8.7198149740088411, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.841193532735009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.268147000111187 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 38.0, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.032560300120451, + "veriT": 14.227471108998921, + "Yices": 13.780681630237757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.512219179670611, + "CVC4": 12.614833934101229, + "CVC3": 13.045136885662487, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.793671583807471, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.817293672248438 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5874990416477814, + "veriT": 9.0699144745450404, + "Yices": 10.272469381047911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.184542712460505, + "CVC4": 6.6257208732819741, + "CVC3": 7.2047642746456226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8319991892458454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7153206344731018 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.811892032623291, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.290441941484, + "veriT": 13.397426186109637, + "Yices": 2.9445231103189724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1009061684059134, + "CVC4": 3.3520678184846631, + "CVC3": 2.4327894515865642, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8803314073204875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1884736418379784 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8060091289293336, + "veriT": 7.1623885562711074, + "Yices": 2.2942924863854404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8114692021721668, + "CVC4": 2.6296855805846335, + "CVC3": 2.4985851355753872, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6133695124403067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6478876850529716 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14017810442783332, + "veriT": 14.218126778213909, + "Yices": 2.9891555335736668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22172055696250004, + "CVC4": 0.17499316740366666, + "CVC3": 2.4717423240480465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.961259995525127, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.949815435833123 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4082865796429278, + "veriT": 14.232012286033941, + "Yices": 9.9379461482629043, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4957980631612298, + "CVC4": 14.702255233033352, + "CVC3": 13.715531233677101, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254411271106079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.247756221326791 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2163657639664383, + "veriT": 13.051403003387824, + "Yices": 8.47669614909322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9670255336803892, + "CVC4": 7.3563630616887794, + "CVC3": 10.670234512811909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.716849800601004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.71967594885025 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.97341559226669239, + "veriT": 10.947253455471555, + "Yices": 3.321236403129769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4753134208231264, + "CVC4": 3.791276139329784, + "CVC3": 0.47799912700830771, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2182985849277728, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2183266426356436 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9252229928970337, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20884113074500002, + "veriT": 2.649210023513425, + "Yices": 10.498224293431115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.42828090124337498, + "CVC4": 8.9997623394517934, + "CVC3": 1.6151876612578624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4440159544495943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1251206282778403 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5377353972446002, + "veriT": 2.159343185671506, + "Yices": 4.1297569976407251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6737873194647601, + "CVC4": 3.0159209962456317, + "CVC3": 1.1408725464263021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.9807503281997717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.99514788383773578 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0312244845292948, + "veriT": 8.6370928738164654, + "Yices": 3.9414121715752231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2765701605506443, + "CVC4": 1.7939383064926693, + "CVC3": 3.3018281615488738, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9164979849810599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9022741032496722 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14759070105945457, + "veriT": 0.12302192871681818, + "Yices": 0.13988513406072728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14400341982454545, + "CVC4": 0.16442366499345454, + "CVC3": 0.14378565580299998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16008406433236363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16151371934463635 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0620231007186363, + "veriT": 5.1940680065492009, + "Yices": 0.15360016551781819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0766423295598182, + "CVC4": 0.17164804664909092, + "CVC3": 0.3738024558707273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15826552229845456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16228455384818183 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0113446269979827, + "veriT": 1.5762239310686283, + "Yices": 5.5752505150287073, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1147057114310055, + "CVC4": 8.2721758024583618, + "CVC3": 0.14161262054757146, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14791701548187142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14362556586855715 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1764709583292081, + "veriT": 12.001598023859303, + "Yices": 2.9560712959626247, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.320952321293476, + "CVC4": 3.8372234715412472, + "CVC3": 3.3729868565037835, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0028480240025295, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.641020064450859 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9430744212327822, + "veriT": 13.716488911599887, + "Yices": 11.19228931293482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.496846433848388, + "CVC4": 12.710850097552438, + "CVC3": 7.9335782628840441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4390566884526592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7064240110581483 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.828263809100223, + "veriT": 9.0893431936517679, + "Yices": 9.5119386676901829, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.516599806519753, + "CVC4": 13.190224334340314, + "CVC3": 9.7211165500497323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.119685184031066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.05991308248502 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8801050186157227, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 105.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4491573213524447, + "veriT": 13.401103529830715, + "Yices": 12.115502930861636, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.940902840538072, + "CVC4": 8.5817803080244683, + "CVC3": 10.353940611386506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.016118526958371, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.011689158804064 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.78327243428285709, + "veriT": 11.704476446279516, + "Yices": 5.3920741685740605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8697190009656945, + "CVC4": 4.3093657613171219, + "CVC3": 0.28895570563499995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.211867762016345, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.23397035026302 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.531182422173767, + "veriT": 11.74126984706834, + "Yices": 11.011422522763574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.264351941953317, + "CVC4": 14.503579711437693, + "CVC3": 14.195333143660321, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.532097044361002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.490739417685376 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2696208049683579, + "veriT": 4.9918336951121054, + "Yices": 5.5239826815821669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7802066604565714, + "CVC4": 2.414144812038129, + "CVC3": 2.1720730206309575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.182981553589026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.182375598521328 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0270281331080997, + "veriT": 14.066858984417996, + "Yices": 7.7955666939747363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.835140610929396, + "CVC4": 1.1500927104311001, + "CVC3": 1.8801104551557006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18357598491470001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18660523048960004 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.258651839819837, + "veriT": 12.944198097235311, + "Yices": 9.9020346516102613, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.142448449268013, + "CVC4": 8.9619289655324081, + "CVC3": 7.0791757288400277, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1109008678774259, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0809750347485023 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.253575441055139, + "veriT": 10.504222548297012, + "Yices": 10.668168328775554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974900647673113, + "CVC4": 14.335547544138068, + "CVC3": 13.623141886479139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.079949245220728, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.16587537230753 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 88.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0937354564666748, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 68.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1275960257722017, + "veriT": 12.446330052367351, + "Yices": 13.452577957076516, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8175313297353162, + "CVC4": 14.742753951739868, + "CVC3": 5.5778644401720969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.467145546682836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.408894302782523 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5605699583950638, + "veriT": 12.266412000872069, + "Yices": 10.817693693571039, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.077312858532078, + "CVC4": 10.061044637567225, + "CVC3": 13.336399354024167, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.163532797911074, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.803620744164297 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.839152239131582, + "veriT": 12.57826514182444, + "Yices": 12.234489254279945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.553299591932047, + "CVC4": 14.724050141572272, + "CVC3": 5.2493055298994236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.18007503716867, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.283552119065142 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.29378521101451105, + "veriT": 8.8545273548188863, + "Yices": 6.4185166112536454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1953630937362223, + "CVC4": 6.4771382347182147, + "CVC3": 9.0148230069242867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4350209069579201, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4292277335815413 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 63.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.993788480758667, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.384784746206359, + "veriT": 12.172183230926642, + "Yices": 11.14679957543523, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.94360923056955, + "CVC4": 14.583778077318829, + "CVC3": 14.210506069975375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237183631466412, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238659716690261 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8403060436248779, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.567368651997388, + "veriT": 14.236200276650081, + "Yices": 13.578687347062925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.16765459757509, + "CVC4": 14.586259326681107, + "CVC3": 13.81490981611411, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257509284513139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.255391348934996 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1762616152775589, + "veriT": 14.227321187346927, + "Yices": 14.233054111127423, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952034163100073, + "CVC4": 14.278895612287435, + "CVC3": 14.229846047272032, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242006773583796, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.243671824177387 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8381695211201023, + "veriT": 11.413731569652757, + "Yices": 8.2102011160930122, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.405239988977085, + "CVC4": 8.8288881963006585, + "CVC3": 10.731945504384111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.169261896773568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6825368698590033 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.699408858076231, + "veriT": 12.404128495021201, + "Yices": 12.783976921478267, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.550494474094377, + "CVC4": 14.465008444944516, + "CVC3": 11.632530830068388, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.181453641764422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.011942134378398 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3209175123386787, + "veriT": 13.46950200128715, + "Yices": 14.239849049817865, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2348297659029681, + "CVC4": 12.992822989476945, + "CVC3": 13.685218144891039, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.168635659760801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.399312687165029 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1445515155792236, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 70.0, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0714707280426672, + "veriT": 11.52477867543128, + "Yices": 11.922927474382254, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.323221737465138, + "CVC4": 13.092607440009624, + "CVC3": 6.4027354729445118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.033113105119134, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7202256796534305 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.829447639226789, + "veriT": 13.022517925752851, + "Yices": 13.225278951937673, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954122208254674, + "CVC4": 13.941268434509993, + "CVC3": 13.078805117661938, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6944185506246754, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0342074853970376 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 151 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6966476290889538, + "veriT": 11.531213363220598, + "Yices": 14.24744750035379, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.648298991431847, + "CVC4": 14.572066814286051, + "CVC3": 13.588788589150784, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6498077162871336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6490920934870399 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "false": 154, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 350.5, + "true": 153 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.286101766180799, + "veriT": 12.715544578510869, + "Yices": 14.026810912757771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966273548302915, + "CVC4": 14.299318735157525, + "CVC3": 12.973008233395978, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.217537755288031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.203884288170842 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259968429226481, + "veriT": 13.674425182710985, + "Yices": 14.247750420116892, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.381325660924432, + "CVC4": 14.808219334936657, + "CVC3": 9.4900802708316441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.293157361574037, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.398882185225807 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11842298278851578, + "veriT": 0.61008255076020013, + "Yices": 0.61459594912869464, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12676238167073153, + "CVC4": 0.85251688919977153, + "CVC3": 0.09059647760459473, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.84895481158433783, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.84775700693645928 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12160264558047826, + "veriT": 0.092740498329326099, + "Yices": 0.095582110160565212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11914583593808695, + "CVC4": 0.12118889980243477, + "CVC3": 0.098709743497704339, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11990467209195652, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11681307509826955 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9744785952096566, + "veriT": 2.1598836213224279, + "Yices": 3.7967643217705502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1098547800674901, + "CVC4": 2.9793101207382522, + "CVC3": 0.15427623873519, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1689988535426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2022197142355 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.84743045547892948, + "veriT": 10.121245884152218, + "Yices": 10.29151084987002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.92884949787224824, + "CVC4": 0.82375445741215725, + "CVC3": 1.6243859531333342, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.78936103105128341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.366551123448202 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19174733722250001, + "veriT": 8.9060801312213744, + "Yices": 9.0660433510922491, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31426191036587497, + "CVC4": 0.15374525661925001, + "CVC3": 0.28851356629799996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15002261801887501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3692156218010001 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7613635063171387, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4333447284796605, + "veriT": 11.891278863663132, + "Yices": 10.595369494066823, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7077183258189468, + "CVC4": 9.2626939601945768, + "CVC3": 8.5892817248803581, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6783755586276534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.338485867369439 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.437029454761355, + "veriT": 11.059475452426963, + "Yices": 10.685696218020308, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.890423490415806, + "CVC4": 3.4010789935220327, + "CVC3": 9.5057971754019643, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7571168440687348, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.912268174089515 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.694916908916888, + "veriT": 8.8266001045770661, + "Yices": 10.854139217626011, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.318514759603662, + "CVC4": 0.17228090696246667, + "CVC3": 14.046968463157539, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.90390901265375034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8711370775803857 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8641347700150099, + "veriT": 9.8326531861383533, + "Yices": 10.158750422248831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2294939153747233, + "CVC4": 7.463736662460362, + "CVC3": 11.875981083567469, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.108370719794852, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9051576565450823 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3392140637115251, + "veriT": 12.184059181357336, + "Yices": 0.15160327493842857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8808426520677131, + "CVC4": 0.13503274802657142, + "CVC3": 0.13891282616051429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12367113134442856, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12143342703285713 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4272744087530445, + "veriT": 12.541055403107231, + "Yices": 14.657863079757396, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7070716575430218, + "CVC4": 6.6610275089725066, + "CVC3": 10.686904267629769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0934228137844659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6037868979950609 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5357145071029663, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5421362506680207, + "veriT": 6.8408996500243333, + "Yices": 8.6462886344198324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.016473711415413, + "CVC4": 0.78897975413550003, + "CVC3": 9.5379877196369307, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.637073284609452, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.30665803321946 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6887350082397461, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0866770099660832, + "veriT": 8.6593624854596918, + "Yices": 5.500850613943534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5489883534512501, + "CVC4": 0.18830597320983333, + "CVC3": 1.2830576490727499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5346680239688437, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0257309578002118 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8271960901250346, + "veriT": 12.580874909331063, + "Yices": 8.4792608082184877, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5388323697134272, + "CVC4": 7.6032404866715968, + "CVC3": 6.5373860357406173, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1085077945240958, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6910161886765236 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9475087407733396, + "veriT": 10.416873471943404, + "Yices": 9.7224730087817708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.152449222698348, + "CVC4": 7.783601595496151, + "CVC3": 9.0370127146165427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235345212307541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.858015042738137 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8832054138183594, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.720897685646957, + "veriT": 7.6584665213507499, + "Yices": 10.323212020784499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.252981502383079, + "CVC4": 3.6963596803913403, + "CVC3": 10.656423176770522, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.912184092433185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4641085736013846 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3643539128612812, + "veriT": 1.1752668657623397, + "Yices": 5.4374135783301991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5765847520622565, + "CVC4": 0.20234904761520003, + "CVC3": 1.5408092514830578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7507195213663453, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1113229426716824 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1214034280957889, + "veriT": 10.806396032098085, + "Yices": 5.784643407151778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15095544470244446, + "CVC4": 0.13174348094388888, + "CVC3": 0.099957157915699993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7973016865364082, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8139721258310324 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7402679837802473, + "veriT": 12.17085579459232, + "Yices": 11.546352017460137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0363090859527286, + "CVC4": 2.4773001581585001, + "CVC3": 1.1813252250965001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.876146680022554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.947338626850277 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 23.0, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13351384740986663, + "veriT": 0.78129985069976671, + "Yices": 5.7538188860161341, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13175966175266665, + "CVC4": 0.15354488091393334, + "CVC3": 1.597186804591, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.07870008071976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0750520921974094 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5579996916775356, + "veriT": 6.9516752454096551, + "Yices": 1.23337217444323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.671250442578857, + "CVC4": 0.20109820177179999, + "CVC3": 1.5558273813428678, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5775074252367516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2678057246665013 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3360599955107602, + "veriT": 11.000414498299214, + "Yices": 8.3855408426293998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3971935499257242, + "CVC4": 11.482107640922047, + "CVC3": 4.3746405129112995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255797917561825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.769986541094077 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8174605369567871, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0888891220092773, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.952990776911033, + "veriT": 11.316750583735249, + "Yices": 12.754018948149708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.069911000421076, + "CVC4": 9.4006075091674663, + "CVC3": 10.41440254549695, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.537557435745693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.10703660715788 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4320349821954306, + "veriT": 5.6838022400711115, + "Yices": 8.4321366489739766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4804700202493315, + "CVC4": 0.36076827026934449, + "CVC3": 0.21897118613744446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.532951629085078, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1720961423372209 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3212743688841968, + "veriT": 13.307121599257638, + "Yices": 9.3460258497671198, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.379570012629285, + "CVC4": 11.706088266964576, + "CVC3": 11.705274259400875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.785817054170083, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.13782795713977 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6064889871361956, + "veriT": 7.9589678578982328, + "Yices": 6.5086417091104991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0373715414373912, + "CVC4": 1.6509054137158206, + "CVC3": 9.7407750811947409, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9761036365058469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5647137290357485 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0996774442419124, + "veriT": 12.429395505803097, + "Yices": 12.24677706400235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.307049475515411, + "CVC4": 12.533450709182723, + "CVC3": 9.4442464757571027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.171606093766599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.165405383006243 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2361111640930176, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1547620296478271, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.484911470707956, + "veriT": 12.477538003027254, + "Yices": 10.621385779925745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.199520112931642, + "CVC4": 2.2740041756832299, + "CVC3": 11.711400243352102, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.206018191145839, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.986372824491866 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4978085147001678, + "veriT": 9.500273512280808, + "Yices": 7.6728604692872979, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.359963698538408, + "CVC4": 8.9420989621304656, + "CVC3": 6.5974882679377798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1774250056922453, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1757611017208873 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.239460712529679, + "veriT": 1.9719923225122726, + "Yices": 2.9365985408181077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4814421008877847, + "CVC4": 0.42218921361709094, + "CVC3": 2.7141883625950682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1360799220823079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0587889114268014 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3443761342740492, + "veriT": 5.5578075222574874, + "Yices": 12.925493822712195, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0880009164331339, + "CVC4": 3.9739206189475089, + "CVC3": 5.1443956383671328, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20653377626333333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4285604750378558 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.416422382826752, + "veriT": 10.977462489997448, + "Yices": 11.054223403492427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.989869925325213, + "CVC4": 2.1585364186518001, + "CVC3": 10.38447766068767, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.58807274106956, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.502933876862878 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9747344124035715, + "veriT": 9.6336079521428246, + "Yices": 4.1356332485769212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9766952155260569, + "CVC4": 6.4797592966459572, + "CVC3": 3.050052950570457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5822247986860827, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5780929567115365 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.48335433103777, + "veriT": 14.200233136567055, + "Yices": 12.771516259335211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.825649712499974, + "CVC4": 13.078359943317782, + "CVC3": 11.530434866168376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.078167357019685, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.106785132402432 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.455381980603633, + "veriT": 12.854369722467, + "Yices": 6.6390033745579444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.11929109760932, + "CVC4": 6.8155613820188341, + "CVC3": 9.5691917870124534, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5371842658532469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.222138688626343 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3546527326286295, + "veriT": 11.582119506840199, + "Yices": 3.16564712691711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5691251213202175, + "CVC4": 0.19847216510330001, + "CVC3": 8.5788935671237745, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9606517586705658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1609659743650411 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5701987034742451, + "veriT": 3.8543775408383598, + "Yices": 13.045562741288345, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6378879658851608, + "CVC4": 9.4583190235850427, + "CVC3": 11.607727473704641, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2442239522523062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.226453452145972 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1387360095977783, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3218673925115072, + "veriT": 6.8732662439353343, + "Yices": 6.785002032464134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.37314159358258342, + "CVC4": 6.1456282046321098, + "CVC3": 3.6837438328242147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.304588418631381, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3105491681330168 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0502455234527588, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9268331877851665, + "veriT": 8.4322423217153997, + "Yices": 8.4335143703718831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4739083443512437, + "CVC4": 13.555714419415999, + "CVC3": 6.8683220604739281, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.404425678653576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.408192400750631 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.319862928275152, + "veriT": 8.8501670660159615, + "Yices": 8.8497255835874373, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.330923289754873, + "CVC4": 9.3942020922915948, + "CVC3": 8.2407324354534577, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.464445499860311, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.460525356784245 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9696597826892228, + "veriT": 10.154787241083364, + "Yices": 9.0698234990724274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3767572627734133, + "CVC4": 9.1543710991106604, + "CVC3": 4.8225625626199093, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4237052740408453, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4188581744371342 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1350748612271111, + "veriT": 7.8827953847562675, + "Yices": 8.3421416970734317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13428764224233333, + "CVC4": 1.709570652419943, + "CVC3": 1.2493087121614446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2800846801532222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2796253745871111 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2680498651292895, + "veriT": 9.2068631507502321, + "Yices": 8.6877876401694714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4650300743013283, + "CVC4": 8.8600123516931593, + "CVC3": 8.2699011263967126, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0175427095088434, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8321718629602373 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21068952698837498, + "veriT": 0.28500243573506245, + "Yices": 2.0559774005771252, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.83955477799493761, + "CVC4": 1.1217704254128587, + "CVC3": 0.22000179727175001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0654923899229505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0632463028953136 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1404264010771819, + "veriT": 11.613940205365482, + "Yices": 12.173124990915811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3936881418745233, + "CVC4": 10.685691184654358, + "CVC3": 9.2283331718802497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.302135911746369, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.735276132506426 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6404149557276178, + "veriT": 10.116356602973166, + "Yices": 9.1602284652272115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.495972524316402, + "CVC4": 14.676344117498571, + "CVC3": 13.773351645683574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.768325921726976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.400131798994197 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1435180912098889, + "veriT": 4.6154156796891135, + "Yices": 0.14098377004811111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1428599419147778, + "CVC4": 0.16094918099322222, + "CVC3": 0.13886246814744443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14908773575511114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15209658787111111 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15500604679790908, + "veriT": 0.1339690200157273, + "Yices": 0.14734168419263638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15639497475281819, + "CVC4": 0.17343827892372729, + "CVC3": 0.15573809656663637, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17178631229254543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16785139055381817 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17214300380112499, + "veriT": 0.1507859239845625, + "Yices": 0.16428444909137499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17477338735512499, + "CVC4": 0.19458450544262498, + "CVC3": 0.17294696222112502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18400428726168749, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18428200278706247 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1797011626731637, + "veriT": 8.6199114663450249, + "Yices": 9.2379851318167674, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2834375834973748, + "CVC4": 2.2811720269641511, + "CVC3": 2.6339929693963495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9581709961437141, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1463310608812143 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.861998941054539, + "veriT": 4.899020492092407, + "Yices": 3.3668208098902608, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.443838078399496, + "CVC4": 7.6254660139894703, + "CVC3": 4.0634147349296921, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9433099379634924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9342081558917368 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 54.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13744615517036365, + "veriT": 9.6104623348995801, + "Yices": 1.9713454458806365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24964069029063635, + "CVC4": 2.7546306211035629, + "CVC3": 0.13300202000754546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19693790398327274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17935234369136363 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4549931081187517, + "veriT": 12.589079864325791, + "Yices": 10.896982878309172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0830143510383285, + "CVC4": 9.2530622444701613, + "CVC3": 7.9396834665000267, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2100387380048634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7330487910231227 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 44.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8398091689918887, + "veriT": 7.9588830512701598, + "Yices": 5.9452147280521324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9835791493954451, + "CVC4": 8.0040927189583115, + "CVC3": 3.5576483698353334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17659117474422226, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17305194870188889 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 77.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7628881109869585, + "veriT": 11.70976650974168, + "Yices": 11.362704531811724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.690478959491246, + "CVC4": 14.494823755097936, + "CVC3": 12.711949359413827, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251755054887617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.149212432092334 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.90855686343742847, + "veriT": 12.625296114466961, + "Yices": 3.9172124113544844, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.201754344556333, + "CVC4": 6.6062545032711144, + "CVC3": 2.3354770330110197, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9999786294496662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9402724407102561 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.39554969812289, + "veriT": 13.070280097865837, + "Yices": 10.896300065411404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957835706201029, + "CVC4": 14.773389269147367, + "CVC3": 13.93370589270231, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24077674113691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.433806501194839 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.980316037384878, + "veriT": 10.469733800903903, + "Yices": 9.4529580906491404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.549384432743246, + "CVC4": 10.488533137142069, + "CVC3": 7.6219366505990189, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.549166353074858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.824467078498916 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17037502429951429, + "veriT": 5.3307404476900855, + "Yices": 0.12011910751218571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34543049871814296, + "CVC4": 0.16024173234557143, + "CVC3": 0.17551544934468571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14843382264282856, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13734676197229997 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5186669513155713, + "veriT": 11.89335236841203, + "Yices": 9.9241324112369274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5083892356857449, + "CVC4": 6.3873109668433363, + "CVC3": 6.3028848586573574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239118156224318, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.849711319909915 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6786812234817852, + "veriT": 13.949168396451702, + "Yices": 6.754084768586825, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.969827532239508, + "CVC4": 1.5160331002399556, + "CVC3": 4.0797912760962811, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2851050447857692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1769603858514881 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.412347892660407, + "veriT": 13.402842533361973, + "Yices": 12.756256364481592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951570751973378, + "CVC4": 14.326154811705795, + "CVC3": 14.223975265718892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24209075796816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.239192619087552 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0716729164123535, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240757870614136, + "veriT": 11.182881096823127, + "Yices": 11.741481762902158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956944010556791, + "CVC4": 14.17308504024329, + "CVC3": 11.68810996281603, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244361366273358, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.208121158015494 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.282935354353803, + "veriT": 10.236036852863334, + "Yices": 10.436548564787444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.997850197471438, + "CVC4": 14.317808382215011, + "CVC3": 14.279069333954251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.279081350213467, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.433222546319811 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.522448432869052, + "veriT": 11.681482830770424, + "Yices": 12.191758152132088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.271197124350687, + "CVC4": 14.53858737819329, + "CVC3": 12.810636505452097, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.640165038738941, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.48671852103735 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 447.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5228884084421317, + "veriT": 13.880678820975168, + "Yices": 13.715280719069932, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.619707921461503, + "CVC4": 14.292771095571803, + "CVC3": 11.023939486366027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.85966103173079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.856303909704897 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.645861922809935, + "veriT": 13.216645924563494, + "Yices": 14.264748309685102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960999066176692, + "CVC4": 14.431466522983477, + "CVC3": 12.743268957341712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.165930069864535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.916865259906887 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8303286415631028, + "veriT": 14.2260768946499, + "Yices": 13.675573550225129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.027737961284064, + "CVC4": 14.408734762814632, + "CVC3": 13.355285839325278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246238669495762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.245381628877608 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6715851561299422, + "veriT": 11.175004133526373, + "Yices": 10.706474099404833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3171219497907458, + "CVC4": 6.7453686774784645, + "CVC3": 11.817288096046614, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.820634588679006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.863450413354855 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 369.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 52.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8021740924169904, + "veriT": 12.72339953909224, + "Yices": 13.990166102713495, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4521649404559511, + "CVC4": 14.729453490663396, + "CVC3": 5.6887371859054028, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9476696251634245, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9726282153863242 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.729414789425714, + "veriT": 14.222649237780638, + "Yices": 12.925137261916197, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.353517052425673, + "CVC4": 13.192513767756058, + "CVC3": 13.559762030356879, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4016022382962703, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4175255559157116 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.182868480682373, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.442692791715254, + "veriT": 12.649214499913331, + "Yices": 12.318110347417356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972482945590389, + "CVC4": 14.53155322903309, + "CVC3": 12.168752626455907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.962176529402953, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.355287311136589 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.336090583873874, + "veriT": 14.258959527269656, + "Yices": 14.110233233428996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.9882796375308, + "CVC4": 14.939350675842803, + "CVC3": 13.902564443384799, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.276546086912404, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.27831870929236 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9285040817475698, + "veriT": 9.5207157998838507, + "Yices": 9.3214952413644596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.659565676748695, + "CVC4": 6.8757079274554691, + "CVC3": 7.0193170763539134, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.097945130333439, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.128734365050626 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12067460932240739, + "veriT": 0.091362357767081473, + "Yices": 0.095773160012233335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11837985313048148, + "CVC4": 0.12129332858611111, + "CVC3": 0.098216201183462956, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11695895879740743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11511646779961481 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.105473458437, + "veriT": 0.078024187725571431, + "Yices": 0.082048882546338103, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1041166094452, + "CVC4": 0.10093243751300002, + "CVC3": 0.083609120869076167, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10069413166736665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.099920846279371436 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5746354654013333, + "veriT": 0.10297298031887776, + "Yices": 1.2318853104256666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5713278575522223, + "CVC4": 0.12961786682788889, + "CVC3": 0.10888401063860001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12717308900811111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14777521191933335 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.175636239264968, + "veriT": 10.165039835786242, + "Yices": 10.351832166347588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2780244773012985, + "CVC4": 0.14972223041306898, + "CVC3": 0.70173616610531042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14885213667165514, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.435318548768008 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19339518882699999, + "veriT": 7.7135123334825026, + "Yices": 10.346786833373534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.29249652090022216, + "CVC4": 3.4402729866882122, + "CVC3": 3.3243100041267439, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2743462391237181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3144160612112232 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7637219429016113, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1970836589586931, + "veriT": 9.5327526466585777, + "Yices": 10.808452066685289, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4697372274152176, + "CVC4": 10.0253804937618, + "CVC3": 8.243356714389062, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5423858717200591, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.046994293235286 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7032968997955322, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1439503263863244, + "veriT": 8.9013160360001251, + "Yices": 10.79051894810295, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.956775687942313, + "CVC4": 0.16138092323, + "CVC3": 4.4454945531939094, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16838139426100002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7174341130776405 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.945872829135082, + "veriT": 11.345616311257096, + "Yices": 11.31023632199606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.401570362136447, + "CVC4": 4.1439803281726633, + "CVC3": 9.9460665532114607, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7145907466644785, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8059243898276947 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239834204115544, + "veriT": 10.171338715747083, + "Yices": 10.333490340400918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961792545193502, + "CVC4": 0.15616423774225002, + "CVC3": 11.126052064486764, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9585209796719583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.389386530072047 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249556910984595, + "veriT": 10.18634771865125, + "Yices": 10.368493898577748, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967623726177637, + "CVC4": 0.24869322995466667, + "CVC3": 14.253461278395768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5573573557595559, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.222788731528638 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.225080059992811, + "veriT": 10.819165822295375, + "Yices": 10.5315064082415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.940478442482451, + "CVC4": 3.1576142215691854, + "CVC3": 14.217217108710651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.421967989022967, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.352530047555623 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1917859728662545, + "veriT": 6.5459452632396449, + "Yices": 5.2544008843301002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5483778215381285, + "CVC4": 0.15628627945089998, + "CVC3": 7.2047524573900308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1640982135006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7828411375018192 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0484548519752241, + "veriT": 13.286225513544872, + "Yices": 10.217007261517022, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.522797585199136, + "CVC4": 8.250641708140666, + "CVC3": 9.0015274230922575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.22609769291789, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.830423813021044 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.451477269456671, + "veriT": 13.675138434848785, + "Yices": 13.200533128343627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.745111844616206, + "CVC4": 14.229690322427199, + "CVC3": 9.7355671854319503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1955915559776678, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9739823638034046 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5511763859572776, + "veriT": 3.2868808435183308, + "Yices": 5.7946367700711434, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2787491964021531, + "CVC4": 1.3821352374116562, + "CVC3": 1.306955868633038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3057273713501774, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3033431586755997 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3444585639769997, + "veriT": 11.462442939169168, + "Yices": 11.438782626317204, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6364756671188854, + "CVC4": 12.603539601292212, + "CVC3": 11.395218785053542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.484286355566269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.513578016726171 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.265846766058798, + "veriT": 10.197002638814002, + "Yices": 10.384514613568834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.991120205505526, + "CVC4": 13.124015217911285, + "CVC3": 14.203086811049646, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.2638760352917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.019038792652458 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.596389308194652, + "veriT": 10.780791008181657, + "Yices": 10.41164269616654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.203461499440294, + "CVC4": 6.7663545464360295, + "CVC3": 12.492932683238609, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2241941614399501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.387526467478617 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.388665587217455, + "veriT": 8.8361383204706012, + "Yices": 10.334743622708201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.011514270850236, + "CVC4": 0.17110341951526664, + "CVC3": 10.501841803939884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.427394503832982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.298883549428901 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.524977657107395, + "veriT": 10.466748130437248, + "Yices": 8.46336923049404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3442715774837364, + "CVC4": 3.8457045384364283, + "CVC3": 9.0533582136039463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1306320674484116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.129711168267386 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5999999046325684, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7900230639001684, + "veriT": 4.1631750387600706, + "Yices": 4.2317696470082602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0771135731463195, + "CVC4": 0.17718761635270003, + "CVC3": 0.58403000929591997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17578435714330001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6594694147873401 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6012943281653809, + "veriT": 6.162573204480104, + "Yices": 13.688740531056826, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5040100963862857, + "CVC4": 12.358649037728194, + "CVC3": 10.049056708593875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1465455621271525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1772351548990008 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8289194107055664, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6223781360517022, + "veriT": 8.7286276333534918, + "Yices": 5.2063557107794836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5227806567948328, + "CVC4": 3.97241574896871, + "CVC3": 3.361315261305045, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2692940390495968, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0171796127789969 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6831567057275656, + "veriT": 14.221302124236518, + "Yices": 12.019134421321127, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.630895623082779, + "CVC4": 13.267760196430505, + "CVC3": 11.324069169213928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.478840154041915, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.473437738408743 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.34415602684021, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.732832225261014, + "veriT": 10.668940933059233, + "Yices": 10.309169005833738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.358762646181038, + "CVC4": 0.16266441160512501, + "CVC3": 15.049312191944015, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6865987508874989, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.721688849554297 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6893758093952886, + "veriT": 10.419490524700993, + "Yices": 8.7785617865046248, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.994705967829776, + "CVC4": 2.0633435743219026, + "CVC3": 8.9687570594788966, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1852653546765168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5715038813628137 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4461411836548574, + "veriT": 13.647811518031991, + "Yices": 7.5785376377876235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5103451988094285, + "CVC4": 6.3924077266728849, + "CVC3": 7.6149779388076535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6461782195876298, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6637907826095439 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8213998167965242, + "veriT": 14.208795345656219, + "Yices": 6.9693849859079551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.388248503734518, + "CVC4": 9.9124856729222053, + "CVC3": 6.0100492818662419, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.950843573321599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.951797622276162 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5579932983576601, + "veriT": 11.797407373453632, + "Yices": 12.536059897771638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4476548564260554, + "CVC4": 11.977737497757724, + "CVC3": 8.490245641623952, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.536101832100135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.035897414286815 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3798074722290039, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0714285373687744, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18659158445985713, + "veriT": 1.5750128515755715, + "Yices": 7.4189035361874272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22071206656785711, + "CVC4": 8.2253677037912176, + "CVC3": 0.19993959517171428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2012297247333947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.774978990765443 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13266421558762501, + "veriT": 9.8644107954055524, + "Yices": 9.866743571708378, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.135272695035, + "CVC4": 7.1890835274339029, + "CVC3": 0.130674244964125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20238715064287502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20648191241487501 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9444444179534912, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8282082064265799, + "veriT": 5.1091508710952329, + "Yices": 6.8080413493009999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9323724937425935, + "CVC4": 3.5121658710806662, + "CVC3": 2.55897556416669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.820476152332259, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3388456228375913 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1079545021057129, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2232864520084545, + "veriT": 1.6744521626752999, + "Yices": 5.2284609694411408, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.054403038448076, + "CVC4": 0.25520605688039227, + "CVC3": 0.96022417857415399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2121297795926362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.98659904740105964 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2291332123642755, + "veriT": 2.4374467275082692, + "Yices": 11.125582729679147, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.36068601475215384, + "CVC4": 0.16399370336807692, + "CVC3": 0.17929998588005386, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15682496850961536, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0105117472641238 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1602563858032227, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13772994099087499, + "veriT": 2.6152062896374502, + "Yices": 13.585377146969668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.136406017257625, + "CVC4": 5.4569338353787398, + "CVC3": 6.9069952168208752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6575149320075999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6582229865425351 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7232278874718974, + "veriT": 6.0563750308963735, + "Yices": 13.657538915861293, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5155688557743181, + "CVC4": 6.3304003702391052, + "CVC3": 9.5731549108072453, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7002996132549644, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6805724627576559 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.59239028140111, + "veriT": 11.174984418632796, + "Yices": 11.635578478675054, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.102056952306771, + "CVC4": 7.6385411568177854, + "CVC3": 7.9689409739996417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.195756570568058, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.122735159676447 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4675585114721663, + "veriT": 6.2422922359358211, + "Yices": 5.6551420572105, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9302437715244274, + "CVC4": 3.838774567622111, + "CVC3": 3.2976832746384659, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9155530071763671, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9562392039361214 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.378294377675148, + "veriT": 10.115405084656405, + "Yices": 10.114190324232691, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.570990107642372, + "CVC4": 4.696342269956026, + "CVC3": 4.4147835438869558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.567083827371881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.590071223049668 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2808056153544607, + "veriT": 7.0574456878329226, + "Yices": 8.7037975909371639, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5397667093426808, + "CVC4": 7.6897770321751375, + "CVC3": 5.9338000382824632, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9466980627416062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9349074111522517 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5435698629997523, + "veriT": 3.9343801868184443, + "Yices": 6.9188174547629995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9626416234601223, + "CVC4": 7.7354010780114333, + "CVC3": 4.8299068272405226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.018475489702702, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3688755052156942 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2489650391243332, + "veriT": 5.9295663233616072, + "Yices": 4.5565149745374454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.275879493285889, + "CVC4": 1.898983607351129, + "CVC3": 1.5398584462441112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9852947929529501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4102522142029867 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22390366423383329, + "veriT": 0.72310334458335557, + "Yices": 6.2261094829035688, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.50763616611983331, + "CVC4": 0.99042620882699084, + "CVC3": 0.20320050221455557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19740660112171668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19571905561033334 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 63.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.147606967236, + "veriT": 5.8994741061077969, + "Yices": 0.14428846905014286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15412663297314286, + "CVC4": 0.17321061376057142, + "CVC3": 0.14372723291628572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15522793220657144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15889698398842858 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.96696582575523071, + "veriT": 0.16899038016384615, + "Yices": 0.21872450649807693, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.96530855439892294, + "CVC4": 0.21290266502923078, + "CVC3": 0.18997562091361539, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19909406431338464, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19665294133776923 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 102.0, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19611945039750001, + "veriT": 1.9151422268393732, + "Yices": 9.5671013680337342, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1933753660285, + "CVC4": 2.5685441148696415, + "CVC3": 2.1295355708036681, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21058486304516666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20501959480433332 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9927221257845233, + "veriT": 13.079635007410426, + "Yices": 5.7218301146490722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8560562461225665, + "CVC4": 8.6979628108690363, + "CVC3": 7.7100449178063117, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6292816153075362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8692823782108308 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.433381469569686, + "veriT": 1.400577842763125, + "Yices": 1.501869823729125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3876446086557008, + "CVC4": 7.2846670298196958, + "CVC3": 0.26672490377899999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18809442114212499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.186406990809 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9678016319114366, + "veriT": 8.192252094266907, + "Yices": 5.633443976355589, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8928899138657336, + "CVC4": 11.397636235547035, + "CVC3": 2.7712180355181895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2001609886574967, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2039654320687188 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8457436807519771, + "veriT": 11.859106503498937, + "Yices": 9.1487878318254214, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1465295521084986, + "CVC4": 10.873141665574286, + "CVC3": 5.3222313053834043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.909539348196018, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.354052640153473 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9300529938509341, + "veriT": 14.219004355112352, + "Yices": 13.612836113039656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6196869049689999, + "CVC4": 11.823388520344629, + "CVC3": 12.574107013943804, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230723102567575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.231355479830126 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15411440055629999, + "veriT": 10.572966600893325, + "Yices": 1.537934338350595, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20492292499459999, + "CVC4": 0.23800837766490002, + "CVC3": 0.23585256349489997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14995193038750002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1470936069812 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21635175285471431, + "veriT": 8.5443352705286202, + "Yices": 6.7454023738076216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.56320650995260002, + "CVC4": 4.2715026619297856, + "CVC3": 4.2003931182296652, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0133394120684551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7333593394614697 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9591893797312192, + "veriT": 8.6670428908784718, + "Yices": 4.6790450705024087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7078695799898167, + "CVC4": 6.1289650207450315, + "CVC3": 6.7117437943247076, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.527419411064457, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.954245813289718 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20093268998599997, + "veriT": 7.8591183588690354, + "Yices": 3.3953583483192111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.40602503522961542, + "CVC4": 3.4392443738350482, + "CVC3": 2.315470601844444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17323419584623079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16295467291676921 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 157.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7942752225146483, + "veriT": 12.073924294105137, + "Yices": 9.0889536277964655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7291592431348644, + "CVC4": 8.2589485705131818, + "CVC3": 7.6480438280158358, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1767702961199378, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3783932030665582 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1069702864908137, + "veriT": 13.77885860468044, + "Yices": 9.0848964564790844, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.969162184316881, + "CVC4": 11.460235460795065, + "CVC3": 6.9909548670265345, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0506493899256473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4368095061021915 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6518939733505249, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6971188929291143, + "veriT": 13.093437307015291, + "Yices": 6.920357123369242, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9814255951385134, + "CVC4": 6.8694449699216342, + "CVC3": 2.3690177564740544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.35582811427734, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.365302751955658 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.626544052619744, + "veriT": 11.974376488355015, + "Yices": 10.564240844639331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960571416305903, + "CVC4": 14.583590053292625, + "CVC3": 14.235957451842337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239460554523951, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.251468032989161 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.290033165848959, + "veriT": 13.54392306949749, + "Yices": 14.239664116182865, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.593204188198493, + "CVC4": 13.581908809778058, + "CVC3": 12.419644232392066, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242060587105739, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.24560292718065 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7848879851796449, + "veriT": 12.224829234511159, + "Yices": 9.7920350252299464, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7968072003869633, + "CVC4": 4.53597079169234, + "CVC3": 4.6098829594688251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2205628552129921, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2135834061608577 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 61.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.629241433002143, + "veriT": 13.806411567443154, + "Yices": 11.056633362524138, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.989141177507641, + "CVC4": 6.7508067488492491, + "CVC3": 6.543759737590908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9369999006087379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9277180190516123 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.911672231374254, + "veriT": 13.809437463638767, + "Yices": 13.539031310267585, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.625496383026411, + "CVC4": 14.691259332695498, + "CVC3": 9.3342439573913598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.015024640889971, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.037804254550034 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.137284517288208, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 241.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.262885422119925, + "veriT": 10.969957154668709, + "Yices": 10.616579704519481, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.978049625984509, + "CVC4": 13.237497212983151, + "CVC3": 14.258185443696407, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.261893759439145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.82502904965436 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.849694893323877, + "veriT": 10.176368693689001, + "Yices": 10.225318173347, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.332578516442458, + "CVC4": 14.699279234060436, + "CVC3": 13.858941810042833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.612791578863288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.822226063787729 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.258631679639729, + "veriT": 10.754683147894372, + "Yices": 13.221830875417746, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.585635847698979, + "CVC4": 14.490505989778358, + "CVC3": 12.845304072530515, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.148661092213111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.045374457633185 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.855439011868494, + "veriT": 14.233893966567619, + "Yices": 14.237102155525625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968865650143325, + "CVC4": 14.324400087014178, + "CVC3": 12.877519402161846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.219366731409348, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.097006419298845 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.547519643107389, + "veriT": 14.231643894472585, + "Yices": 13.986997585912212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959972185205276, + "CVC4": 14.636897276005522, + "CVC3": 11.59810177255059, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249088676516243, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.247205279034622 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6754621157248106, + "veriT": 11.844353623606464, + "Yices": 11.712455384089731, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.559104271405339, + "CVC4": 13.265922911602054, + "CVC3": 9.8727902864446602, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.007363249204193, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7335046483463934 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3785602397628525, + "veriT": 12.209208605715984, + "Yices": 11.821532152572997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9961133639670186, + "CVC4": 10.752960061957477, + "CVC3": 8.3417842542220786, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.105352935374341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.083404865049792 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 229.0, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0213558276984669, + "veriT": 14.251190283145458, + "Yices": 14.256824885901125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8504724767404248, + "CVC4": 14.687682827214696, + "CVC3": 14.606135723774845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8702358551207272, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9233572363931248 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.150511335305039, + "veriT": 13.927310388435949, + "Yices": 13.464208609159959, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98671043124653, + "CVC4": 14.839533591527319, + "CVC3": 13.973434712257196, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.928461161572544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.717172086495969 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3433322813076076, + "veriT": 12.877828363467131, + "Yices": 10.380491501645446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4483748486870756, + "CVC4": 10.1113278441282, + "CVC3": 6.3323679386347296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7753170897092794, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1176904392912235 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.118972878466875, + "veriT": 0.090379317744443743, + "Yices": 0.09442390252759375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1143422686119375, + "CVC4": 0.12010072309031251, + "CVC3": 0.095523936901874995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11447672503100001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11629657918414998 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2953859901327707, + "veriT": 0.089116977098064709, + "Yices": 0.092153789570541184, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2936657967812, + "CVC4": 0.11653499557084707, + "CVC3": 0.096907957223935276, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11234492942313531, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11107614941362354 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9625505344574705, + "veriT": 8.1454693070687192, + "Yices": 8.2692523027263611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4086914006471893, + "CVC4": 1.9945453092925569, + "CVC3": 3.9791513776259451, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9032673327814664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3120355619790409 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20459232785800005, + "veriT": 10.16896059456572, + "Yices": 10.347504963753281, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28816680221131247, + "CVC4": 0.15072603451831248, + "CVC3": 0.62287365461993749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14874100069240626, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5911500424443759 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7527780532836914, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6076924800872803, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.89349263117189, + "veriT": 4.3533058217048337, + "Yices": 5.2853509694548331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.404741231371184, + "CVC4": 0.16496307109133332, + "CVC3": 1.8373716609638524, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5880438149533189, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.217747675360835 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.366402844147375, + "veriT": 10.142004526149288, + "Yices": 10.600728713155787, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.916079595764668, + "CVC4": 3.3003115244122241, + "CVC3": 7.247726711865063, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6137189036394428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.825070213510338 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1892119291411998, + "veriT": 6.225497993326325, + "Yices": 7.6393593830458686, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5461452657039061, + "CVC4": 0.41095538730850006, + "CVC3": 7.1823914725618909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4878831681665554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7397941703585431 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.229807149676118, + "veriT": 11.180732217990617, + "Yices": 11.011379505442372, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.763002249369579, + "CVC4": 3.8614290440928212, + "CVC3": 10.547202827584876, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6696485881297773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.056863689183519 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.101866686812182, + "veriT": 10.149738436405499, + "Yices": 10.3175424944488, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.945596105283261, + "CVC4": 0.1621126874887, + "CVC3": 12.968425923669463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14152359616269999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.400341491840535 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.218547711746062, + "veriT": 9.9411560357457809, + "Yices": 9.7182805526349689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.375833240998896, + "CVC4": 5.1032636366783253, + "CVC3": 12.666581842943812, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8451984938468353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.697348220036115 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6276081511701888, + "veriT": 12.464701746319067, + "Yices": 12.747351936165087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.513457424653453, + "CVC4": 14.464332549854504, + "CVC3": 12.159147128723223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.064915551998743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.185969519651113 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6460412995485258, + "veriT": 6.5012032107688835, + "Yices": 14.628062014487359, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6496646196072939, + "CVC4": 2.5902976655729861, + "CVC3": 3.917780592769343, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0231818079063748, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.04081506247825 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.681365966796875, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.887496108818615, + "veriT": 11.994172748622445, + "Yices": 11.725073211598293, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.935969314150725, + "CVC4": 13.670925866392558, + "CVC3": 12.918386422335988, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252365633905864, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.67873385249279 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0140919167304769, + "veriT": 7.5003392646102389, + "Yices": 7.2355232581847941, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.223140492243358, + "CVC4": 9.6006408162789878, + "CVC3": 9.5333012696768229, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.538807909397315, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0808019860080318 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.942898848798336, + "veriT": 10.201273827204334, + "Yices": 10.328813362778668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958540308330697, + "CVC4": 1.3568939239982223, + "CVC3": 11.173092586010821, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2862217068848114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.311004854955923 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.414270177151394, + "veriT": 10.609714072281575, + "Yices": 10.324828444285597, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.986730901429993, + "CVC4": 7.9365584961848041, + "CVC3": 10.179680703441845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1654830229528859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.767202494800362 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6941944384295451, + "veriT": 5.6641974793615786, + "Yices": 4.2880008011483719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4508931804667982, + "CVC4": 5.5824965169514762, + "CVC3": 2.7010684240266909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.720797221238799, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9519591942407351 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.251950733644675, + "veriT": 8.7429210535938573, + "Yices": 10.331784233448072, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.870206702240381, + "CVC4": 0.17043285904214286, + "CVC3": 11.731327949017745, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0326199604918109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.251312504913809 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8878256181836663, + "veriT": 7.4034028293249996, + "Yices": 7.8419430208927334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6887958725028662, + "CVC4": 0.49430346054475005, + "CVC3": 7.2886723655730101, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1462701865274729, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6541709474002948 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.047656677204635, + "veriT": 13.686416745312332, + "Yices": 13.077666514213178, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.025766701831779, + "CVC4": 12.69535908968999, + "CVC3": 10.410813927559381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.219345603350607, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.829314321529129 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.764954609081407, + "veriT": 6.9373031298805357, + "Yices": 4.1868715036270192, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0520344031863864, + "CVC4": 0.13788368688239999, + "CVC3": 6.411387575717467, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5809638042146794, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2145635630007749 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.543715674664734, + "veriT": 11.378934652121385, + "Yices": 11.163764381611378, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.219720735848332, + "CVC4": 3.9282980270093519, + "CVC3": 13.443202209706914, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0937310411800372, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.681972443808103 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.758993965756626, + "veriT": 13.660820443021182, + "Yices": 11.243935438072517, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.073900873336063, + "CVC4": 8.6714758201265223, + "CVC3": 8.3664200933912785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6699958567067137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3537114610048882 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9009223866495999, + "veriT": 4.7576605714683673, + "Yices": 5.5682872808502761, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6366793758208322, + "CVC4": 0.39418428428890001, + "CVC3": 1.20614223067779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1718839654833997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1724965211851002 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7134224439496295, + "veriT": 1.6929422624593182, + "Yices": 13.03162753870037, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6317106373767778, + "CVC4": 9.5821101555440897, + "CVC3": 8.2484887691276683, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9041775243307737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9115466308310698 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5366380214691162, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2344319820404053, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3543144546868469, + "veriT": 11.039386979899897, + "Yices": 11.630601614754918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9760683601099274, + "CVC4": 11.930586506845726, + "CVC3": 8.0135061891639374, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.051910872445262, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.126560983195191 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5054933079996164, + "veriT": 1.3275086171447879, + "Yices": 1.32752316319415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2109677725004286, + "CVC4": 0.2228055591509, + "CVC3": 0.08436966170964999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8650084081701153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8662838362123861 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8856209516525269, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3599921690111616, + "veriT": 8.9555881965525028, + "Yices": 10.501647622685201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5778756692508695, + "CVC4": 3.6243537423717918, + "CVC3": 2.9919181679297679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1375602711853663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7624615607735112 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.522382217743397, + "veriT": 9.2901540630369404, + "Yices": 10.179027368407249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7103207767652044, + "CVC4": 10.992679459921019, + "CVC3": 5.481294937172823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.074774207626257, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.820286431108912 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0218000050619818, + "veriT": 8.1329797512003985, + "Yices": 6.1621265109890402, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6334542812149579, + "CVC4": 6.0950201507423198, + "CVC3": 5.1551425303762741, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5993546611369549, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0097757066693838 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.182642039004365, + "veriT": 10.11300832460029, + "Yices": 10.119641488465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.135817834991599, + "CVC4": 4.6790532468904553, + "CVC3": 5.6917066236794218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.164490120518616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.192883939276108 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16916040831005003, + "veriT": 4.1729999574694903, + "Yices": 4.5875582094508323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19626128892433001, + "CVC4": 4.3912715887132778, + "CVC3": 0.20407387845890002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9683255709090992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3471993458796128 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16272917710500001, + "veriT": 2.6603073825464447, + "Yices": 11.508928545795857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4361886460990001, + "CVC4": 5.4868717672831213, + "CVC3": 8.0248737768267517, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6932310754972693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6915619709402518 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5119707470668482, + "veriT": 9.1336741287209673, + "Yices": 11.488823154871239, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7699139622576796, + "CVC4": 11.272162922496472, + "CVC3": 11.80760985768398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.384033525236287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.390784387164368 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5106174392345313, + "veriT": 10.239898251492201, + "Yices": 11.717589097147295, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.596485077959816, + "CVC4": 13.178615414532709, + "CVC3": 7.5725312657378581, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.854326176868009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.773799097919959 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2613635063171387, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13498991477387498, + "veriT": 8.8478768440704751, + "Yices": 8.8504954046271251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13168677217899999, + "CVC4": 3.6693897367992552, + "CVC3": 0.118376537546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13121207946062502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13156702854612501 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14304440498207141, + "veriT": 2.3348387901367356, + "Yices": 2.2672249227623498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.208162219653, + "CVC4": 0.26676170043692854, + "CVC3": 0.14754708513576428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1363380431555483, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1505088114390196 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0653788888118179, + "veriT": 8.9252480563369136, + "Yices": 7.2044516302154635, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8383001072805483, + "CVC4": 4.7266781123819603, + "CVC3": 5.884809874134497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4068617385146469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.026725430511839 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 37.0, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13162591599283333, + "veriT": 0.94296625397430001, + "Yices": 0.94796755679108335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12885304639566666, + "CVC4": 0.15235150012258333, + "CVC3": 0.12418222106999999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14229857002616667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13450517644266666 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26553782075959997, + "veriT": 3.3536480269484215, + "Yices": 2.2872188178914596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3085537198702002, + "CVC4": 3.1533476991889478, + "CVC3": 0.29862516069582001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9894675533363215, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9896233068139439 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19491414721157144, + "veriT": 1.6018686859119999, + "Yices": 9.6388097399312063, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20055331227614284, + "CVC4": 0.21655578255028574, + "CVC3": 2.2097076660062878, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20200763538442854, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19727380536085715 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5241189157171111, + "veriT": 5.1990894200921121, + "Yices": 9.9044794812712631, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5862466016102221, + "CVC4": 1.8374227019745346, + "CVC3": 2.9600996911105399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8873662788837002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8889387361951551 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3830886715501123, + "veriT": 9.1916158818347551, + "Yices": 9.2173679142998459, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1914747525688067, + "CVC4": 6.6804460777401804, + "CVC3": 4.1781453892806892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9792386252075502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4194423958228466 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3151598824415123, + "veriT": 1.1606691200885788, + "Yices": 1.8564595181455432, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4305167660604834, + "CVC4": 9.2994552802655903, + "CVC3": 0.9841663090785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19490523599329285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18402069631263571 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.397856427561976, + "veriT": 11.442889567492273, + "Yices": 13.033958487780511, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.95252893422461, + "CVC4": 14.634223938678106, + "CVC3": 11.450143796623852, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.291616866150425, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.242882389722645 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6254861061451864, + "veriT": 12.382841225683762, + "Yices": 7.5187639858737141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5437906654874975, + "CVC4": 8.7052909898470467, + "CVC3": 3.1090537180112978, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.386997376065092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5926671606493699 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6009061030756557, + "veriT": 11.183264372701315, + "Yices": 13.199286948812306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8446682875187452, + "CVC4": 13.567714918447955, + "CVC3": 11.720880047932461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.708346701091701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.47651637308886 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2998035633265714, + "veriT": 8.8877075380604165, + "Yices": 8.303047616554279, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3966775327740715, + "CVC4": 6.6779922419274218, + "CVC3": 7.6204366882028349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5616811865680686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5395062740428997 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 27.0, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1785019352088999, + "veriT": 14.204484734488545, + "Yices": 0.2929124974208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3724606575472, + "CVC4": 7.5821703424402171, + "CVC3": 0.15248457479409999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.823174125857202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.817878801768554 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.27857228643699994, + "veriT": 13.451789029360915, + "Yices": 9.7605613384142913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0200067719055745, + "CVC4": 11.026220987334115, + "CVC3": 9.388519383032957, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.570624604165822, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.922633884711253 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4535493435222815, + "veriT": 13.908960968330982, + "Yices": 10.608303306732331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5187310364187638, + "CVC4": 11.395080957446782, + "CVC3": 12.915865989636471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231521821523124, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.233526848810833 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7759859577810999, + "veriT": 11.44770268466314, + "Yices": 8.9789766477559034, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9415384427587998, + "CVC4": 1.6102322206703845, + "CVC3": 4.4972589753601682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2964692675835465, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1937594091426762 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14107672299583335, + "veriT": 10.685577357070867, + "Yices": 0.15086024043616666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24580641873425002, + "CVC4": 0.17763826696399998, + "CVC3": 0.12595834593491667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9282276721433496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9445414478113356 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 37.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 54.0, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14037655485962502, + "veriT": 5.3944480014701437, + "Yices": 0.14819024889787502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15086976179051251, + "CVC4": 0.16003997182310001, + "CVC3": 0.13969166217500001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14483809335751249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14873903048193748 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.183484600338538, + "veriT": 5.8147377477061779, + "Yices": 3.4650091140176333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4306020690654648, + "CVC4": 7.2236815148015907, + "CVC3": 5.2468714841010904, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8304747327864694, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7951071319568745 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15763473305016668, + "veriT": 0.13342968010599998, + "Yices": 0.15141437355941664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16114487589074999, + "CVC4": 0.17451323788775, + "CVC3": 0.15596026084341666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16953891337816665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17051924610033331 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0014755725860596, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7460384368896484, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7250628109441326, + "veriT": 11.509568527170176, + "Yices": 8.1458798476726866, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8423184853881418, + "CVC4": 3.6966374771259165, + "CVC3": 5.9547640578053525, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.928239356580313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.527804881799515 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 27.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.965690577423166, + "veriT": 12.206580516885603, + "Yices": 11.696141487737233, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.627192334916014, + "CVC4": 14.371092616928673, + "CVC3": 11.535988516343972, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242101399260067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.220105359219593 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.603338105496329, + "veriT": 11.374361124089223, + "Yices": 11.675693737084242, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.949868451414364, + "CVC4": 8.3400699612270639, + "CVC3": 5.2969483812367972, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2444051931943143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9143674360044498 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 101.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.28425898088822221, + "veriT": 10.952278804450279, + "Yices": 8.8224522561750103, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.65185858309255551, + "CVC4": 5.149623478300378, + "CVC3": 1.7321911443163636, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5339002869596357, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5337698054850382 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17749129377622858, + "veriT": 7.0198046604755344, + "Yices": 0.14208819174532858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23833115371028571, + "CVC4": 0.17023099361814284, + "CVC3": 7.9596922750756205, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16265069805625715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15664796987644286 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1174042700523099, + "veriT": 14.232492439442744, + "Yices": 12.064740137486977, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.328379092686971, + "CVC4": 5.4162545733441148, + "CVC3": 7.4525303532655549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6860433394627694, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7150152186380001 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2043548946876657, + "veriT": 12.4630204497508, + "Yices": 12.552202411659845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4610270657360749, + "CVC4": 12.870128500876017, + "CVC3": 3.7297231899519234, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236164494604573, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.240987777774501 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 74.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.272924807554265, + "veriT": 10.619373987452278, + "Yices": 10.529773059723102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.992111076440789, + "CVC4": 13.725694102696043, + "CVC3": 14.265542109576296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.269284662211168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.711828492782491 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.230666543985649, + "veriT": 10.681247043380601, + "Yices": 10.818159162789993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.647867551041641, + "CVC4": 14.360746077949877, + "CVC3": 13.784886896466562, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242252560439994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.152829119802695 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.610371440947107, + "veriT": 13.288326060609972, + "Yices": 13.115294586330496, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.579986629083757, + "CVC4": 7.9020760636321414, + "CVC3": 11.67012345843453, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.579541238844996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.610786617733634 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 370.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7513664473847754, + "veriT": 9.5523737974168323, + "Yices": 9.4255434465796615, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.244891282184755, + "CVC4": 10.902787940055539, + "CVC3": 9.8660454936267872, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.591991058857535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0868487575987507 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 233.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0929086326665454, + "veriT": 13.861696720457712, + "Yices": 13.531478416578809, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.28452813935948, + "CVC4": 14.481495836008968, + "CVC3": 10.232279080218582, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.617956486104537, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.621822204964776 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259264669545631, + "veriT": 11.145346481609856, + "Yices": 14.261243257599546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976427295244681, + "CVC4": 14.379538777602797, + "CVC3": 12.597882555975181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.176220542489384, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.071910090929617 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.683972689948803, + "veriT": 13.747705715253151, + "Yices": 13.777182671704253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965515380870974, + "CVC4": 14.489048356963199, + "CVC3": 13.36158196330792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.509621785352603, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.153321183615668 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.29152213652266, + "veriT": 12.068822141665986, + "Yices": 13.130336387401751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.531373502383657, + "CVC4": 14.500237017270914, + "CVC3": 13.521532091429616, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4223466157317999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6978092821014092 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 874.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3343101219167268, + "veriT": 10.98965630490661, + "Yices": 5.5635648491263314, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.326863664197466, + "CVC4": 6.0533669399395498, + "CVC3": 10.729105744112122, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.26628958149600002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.264266660579625 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.258815732868134, + "veriT": 14.251594508372079, + "Yices": 14.131082745115018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.592001960922767, + "CVC4": 14.898926736038222, + "CVC3": 7.8479197219849182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.448148547743708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.548899487665677 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12616204994637933, + "veriT": 0.096281247146724119, + "Yices": 0.099711999582110356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12248310792882759, + "CVC4": 0.12418276098548274, + "CVC3": 0.10306180282087242, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12129008037672415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12069291065676549 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12284986669976841, + "veriT": 0.6159460387382053, + "Yices": 0.61976881466307376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13188199768832101, + "CVC4": 0.85761050233634517, + "CVC3": 0.094732758279942111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.85221241905264833, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.85165961868072249 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8143015758800236, + "veriT": 2.1211371284212377, + "Yices": 2.8127561400848169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8684563763674125, + "CVC4": 2.5429180221484762, + "CVC3": 1.2908536742340539, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.310700856199394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3190406619572885 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.56663735662668779, + "veriT": 9.9059150850375399, + "Yices": 10.094087995438182, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.64385732925874162, + "CVC4": 0.15038000270412821, + "CVC3": 0.64684370172917938, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14956585769410255, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.249734246780468 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8660714626312256, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0551820217482923, + "veriT": 6.1886758323203512, + "Yices": 12.006222052534911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6622324697327144, + "CVC4": 12.554375633921792, + "CVC3": 5.10807963497634, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.228728355906256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8360124822481509 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9808895534673407, + "veriT": 6.4340133991423754, + "Yices": 7.8273647465177492, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4309308956757611, + "CVC4": 0.17239788967806247, + "CVC3": 7.51182030569763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6108629133668764, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.930335404087323 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.181412245121949, + "veriT": 10.471200322534681, + "Yices": 10.422012028205538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.576742587408066, + "CVC4": 1.3278953833818956, + "CVC3": 10.303014135364556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0687553579106961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.340162220837707 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244152045197202, + "veriT": 10.152399505126153, + "Yices": 10.348490132164308, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958284391707926, + "CVC4": 0.153828351196, + "CVC3": 12.160851978619831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18113000473292309, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.377895904825966 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.384801049324873, + "veriT": 11.060011460103803, + "Yices": 10.045261825181738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.894012311702532, + "CVC4": 2.6791537084016075, + "CVC3": 11.268222032434798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5533544737039744, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.102667924893929 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6904764175415039, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.428736614648928, + "veriT": 10.52572465384209, + "Yices": 11.41139638669158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5354067424217099, + "CVC4": 5.4751291861176279, + "CVC3": 9.6870855529008679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.169380617065125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6139176986051531 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.004270872981528, + "veriT": 6.1520480299890439, + "Yices": 2.1006993751108571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0986899209552048, + "CVC4": 2.1862735417300225, + "CVC3": 2.1736183726021752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1745202788885911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1713372869002847 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.553370408263648, + "veriT": 11.494179524015699, + "Yices": 9.7792197148568327, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.014769574934208, + "CVC4": 3.7720515849007783, + "CVC3": 8.7188851324242282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7098580735663109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.906562980272717 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.950884391358837, + "veriT": 13.375209714494583, + "Yices": 11.979076895294664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.892286977262657, + "CVC4": 14.890005079778323, + "CVC3": 7.6307373199645259, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.226295391883288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9197705478304075 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.776847525038484, + "veriT": 13.09377270256307, + "Yices": 12.858065805332155, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.962328882980716, + "CVC4": 14.191075933577041, + "CVC3": 14.343848110473637, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.117503427058484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.115213305564195 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8206858889856301, + "veriT": 10.080370995108105, + "Yices": 9.6599691017129139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2194167534209654, + "CVC4": 4.6323865398013133, + "CVC3": 3.7707549640276552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0158258109087273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0929667945250006 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.6500000953674316, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.604952310511941, + "veriT": 10.570470157146332, + "Yices": 10.453160022045221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959866437730458, + "CVC4": 4.1053631239277557, + "CVC3": 12.26600219648798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1333968269901566, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.959592675941947 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.204503613799675, + "veriT": 10.949661097538019, + "Yices": 10.462300655980497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.736942912652303, + "CVC4": 5.1297604433185517, + "CVC3": 13.717528198028891, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.324638398745616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.671662325233303 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9323914637208102, + "veriT": 10.187528457449577, + "Yices": 6.9959532108187092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8279113834356435, + "CVC4": 4.9656843227134484, + "CVC3": 8.5258667087939344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1573071933471484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0550919758590256 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.722577003672791, + "veriT": 11.168995778624385, + "Yices": 10.631035927084428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.746263477619522, + "CVC4": 2.0130615218058256, + "CVC3": 10.100093437634429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.717894666680435, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.978971829079502 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1833782860710831, + "veriT": 7.1777320264196671, + "Yices": 12.806537606636994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1061708719825001, + "CVC4": 7.307670388499818, + "CVC3": 8.7810838591493905, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9364601303007598, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9515078677930013 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12530061638814288, + "veriT": 0.10463445950107142, + "Yices": 0.10934987204271428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12151463269862858, + "CVC4": 0.12348409807314288, + "CVC3": 0.11505682622519997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12287308521700001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1211833489472 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6685169696086737, + "veriT": 7.6614341003484814, + "Yices": 7.6684103820820209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3357920503940299, + "CVC4": 4.0991604645314474, + "CVC3": 4.5845290435857899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5771771711122744, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6215822873766701 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2780182490569878, + "veriT": 13.165120434986878, + "Yices": 12.442626378160567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3748542894167564, + "CVC4": 11.306809151649983, + "CVC3": 9.4326383147148665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.044101885074751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.111698070535565 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.961538553237915, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3350486965605604, + "veriT": 8.3874781424853619, + "Yices": 10.291465834189216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9914951347200502, + "CVC4": 8.1066798700168174, + "CVC3": 8.0197010280747492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228094744502755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.608264778366156 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0235669838313619, + "veriT": 2.8355686315079307, + "Yices": 1.9550902362490561, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7721937167432174, + "CVC4": 1.1659878753485653, + "CVC3": 0.97246083199243105, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.748392840368679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7508754591885856 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.387015088142, + "veriT": 6.8826525905218601, + "Yices": 10.177758529425775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4625038968215249, + "CVC4": 2.3818549889047573, + "CVC3": 6.7091953648744029, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9021343093484109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8995326243662096 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.66320093401302, + "veriT": 2.6407171520334498, + "Yices": 7.4795200425197708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.83888191525537492, + "CVC4": 0.173097990762625, + "CVC3": 0.281638270154625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15159456924225001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9328152925774029 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0916664600372314, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2113354463895698, + "veriT": 10.129522438412712, + "Yices": 10.176893697368572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6053721289570921, + "CVC4": 8.3211347685605421, + "CVC3": 4.2409278507978581, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.207406015250539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.237646906690392 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13760720179899999, + "veriT": 8.9997206146401112, + "Yices": 4.559024099566888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14786013806533332, + "CVC4": 3.2751719599675759, + "CVC3": 0.1413570930111111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19639117602033332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19865496854300002 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13085168527026667, + "veriT": 5.2694276581284329, + "Yices": 9.1169154094731528, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28074856300293338, + "CVC4": 3.7355961844759338, + "CVC3": 3.6739561707901665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0705852610471069, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0628684955049046 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4248597983906666, + "veriT": 6.8775051062611281, + "Yices": 9.5203163539071287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5637553093740002, + "CVC4": 9.7782834059167119, + "CVC3": 10.29909168279295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7213336972815618, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7488710367783948 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.922068630085557, + "veriT": 12.876561782082385, + "Yices": 8.2101053435992455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.036859258539494, + "CVC4": 13.577945148429581, + "CVC3": 10.978816790867288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.287451971244026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.291121862905928 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.22929651643666, + "veriT": 11.436701851100111, + "Yices": 12.033656170779045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948715005417531, + "CVC4": 8.2929148254710938, + "CVC3": 14.229129713955663, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.797963333798755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.785039001566538 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1303169151603001, + "veriT": 14.210046739325497, + "Yices": 2.7213128106501578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1776013822158, + "CVC4": 2.6273889064122455, + "CVC3": 2.5475287377347517, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.662517245484798, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.718598756927367 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.96948279572258345, + "veriT": 14.212309725758077, + "Yices": 6.7961509481854216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.97780348134724993, + "CVC4": 4.8618409144864847, + "CVC3": 6.9402664838904604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3879379192309216, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3184072877546367 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6060580232556858, + "veriT": 4.0055380332898354, + "Yices": 7.958585949777734, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7061454579874749, + "CVC4": 4.7722910656327793, + "CVC3": 5.1340336505847475, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1933464976150328, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0394237384890683 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238954014888296, + "veriT": 10.670724913781726, + "Yices": 10.8194666905889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.9577493876684, + "CVC4": 1.9855953289994532, + "CVC3": 13.500774729366393, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0257810532225289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.223932448937198 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2130787689285, + "veriT": 1.39443858080125, + "Yices": 7.2128572160801632, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.38527045993262499, + "CVC4": 0.218476506944625, + "CVC3": 1.6762731683657504, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.946320469535175, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9472063617892676 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.86222914641940007, + "veriT": 4.6227269136826603, + "Yices": 14.529827017578114, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6104751832078328, + "CVC4": 0.45130711443549998, + "CVC3": 0.41418291838660004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7599220225967684, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7571566712082305 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3196943108611767, + "veriT": 4.1087779122528385, + "Yices": 0.14020443847688235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3212400130356472, + "CVC4": 0.1568117677914706, + "CVC3": 0.13648383807170589, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14981369656470592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14640790495664707 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1594040366249091, + "veriT": 0.14578753774854547, + "Yices": 3.9933716325175954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15763840198163637, + "CVC4": 0.17969015100681818, + "CVC3": 0.16372103929481818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1756602498298182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17166907557672728 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16421174522029408, + "veriT": 0.14516230592888238, + "Yices": 0.15267083952147059, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17079655214888234, + "CVC4": 0.180719682149, + "CVC3": 0.16688755715288237, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17185176475676472, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17135673876482355 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.913517824256, + "veriT": 5.8016540907224501, + "Yices": 5.4918553957188356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0806652683366362, + "CVC4": 2.7549891003268789, + "CVC3": 0.39190754343019091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4448777268537638, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4460968715653433 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1455504894256592, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6106502492047126, + "veriT": 11.208968138615639, + "Yices": 12.648059355931649, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.662889195917218, + "CVC4": 10.187740045951271, + "CVC3": 12.030118089110029, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6085486371011157, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2434198012490718 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3752784163758438, + "veriT": 7.6674713628180484, + "Yices": 11.017332499457684, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5247498517464688, + "CVC4": 5.7525065084956584, + "CVC3": 6.6181902846962872, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5429470053700527, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4323976146336443 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8157260417938232, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.600553636661028, + "veriT": 7.3267617088894283, + "Yices": 4.5989218133598699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7320363018587501, + "CVC4": 6.1070921893549022, + "CVC3": 0.22206000754758334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1895622272487749, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9264321962384523 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.800352845094206, + "veriT": 10.60980459704245, + "Yices": 10.781075458544692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.063395084244245, + "CVC4": 11.911629140007696, + "CVC3": 10.708293184196162, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.430052886055002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.425280516179859 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 77.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.41291962480400002, + "veriT": 12.197339605728651, + "Yices": 5.2430208753708749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9350859216274952, + "CVC4": 10.919058336159207, + "CVC3": 0.92913381238274995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.024783318069476, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.479178891963203 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9109123317331989, + "veriT": 9.7884585082543794, + "Yices": 5.0148553215730001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4818040202359288, + "CVC4": 8.7888814655512419, + "CVC3": 0.99696107847060011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.78117745018967, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.599552109142186 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15418070401733333, + "veriT": 3.3364303996034774, + "Yices": 1.4825352998447532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20088077261994669, + "CVC4": 3.9261280034974262, + "CVC3": 0.14774326840334001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0980170672199316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1004760804809333 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.382987512987457, + "veriT": 7.7762505000153865, + "Yices": 5.3831497983997867, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.599117069591927, + "CVC4": 9.9967989153829073, + "CVC3": 4.2568729812967687, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6022645453532225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2885677685546715 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9455293639606692, + "veriT": 9.6692080337119855, + "Yices": 7.2667441795030703, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8117064882066822, + "CVC4": 9.1282685514321553, + "CVC3": 10.260109509307656, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.339742313184265, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.6939092872353 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.58064119405544445, + "veriT": 11.959872646581147, + "Yices": 9.8768801334278056, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8962805429408478, + "CVC4": 14.454343755697534, + "CVC3": 11.82823041286867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.754501856135285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.318810850573929 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2413650151302349, + "veriT": 14.218508923795389, + "Yices": 7.346807338193587, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3625571191776995, + "CVC4": 0.90688616287599988, + "CVC3": 8.9038610886905367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.42181034180213, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.420448298262063 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17096876089801538, + "veriT": 7.3422199989851205, + "Yices": 2.2916975496230534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.32286518449638463, + "CVC4": 2.3264271798524572, + "CVC3": 3.3365138822397808, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14911940724996922, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14813776400463075 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3950998594066508, + "veriT": 13.838014626456125, + "Yices": 12.837738152149587, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5193857512587687, + "CVC4": 12.600355589355386, + "CVC3": 7.2276047321033037, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6345039614892287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6694559843389256 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 40.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.214594080088709, + "veriT": 12.883406253910742, + "Yices": 10.935382842149382, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.45010935790693, + "CVC4": 14.516381806828795, + "CVC3": 13.725214222390022, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.501495353164806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.620791241745332 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3406111900892861, + "veriT": 11.576731964935492, + "Yices": 9.9744053544886224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0824550621276128, + "CVC4": 12.296720322767481, + "CVC3": 6.8756644914675533, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.246034075887135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.461764062913785 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.232397387575032, + "veriT": 11.953380083517684, + "Yices": 11.242406768815606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956433977903878, + "CVC4": 14.522206824022918, + "CVC3": 14.226974408117318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.687691437533601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.686040211449672 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2754810022685743, + "veriT": 12.901664920930116, + "Yices": 5.9879629520949207, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7126011361398703, + "CVC4": 2.9178354593131282, + "CVC3": 3.0413876488829739, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22753413700533331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.163793456491891 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 63.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.760975157880444, + "veriT": 13.204974678302477, + "Yices": 11.759935951155105, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4676377053135532, + "CVC4": 11.380351098113573, + "CVC3": 8.7527485173690209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.905705559735281, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.827864816113781 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 105.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8312649726867676, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.293367021954086, + "veriT": 10.256592322556335, + "Yices": 10.460427331247889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.00793852814996, + "CVC4": 14.337850418013305, + "CVC3": 14.290122455749007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.290502331712096, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.418908947551062 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243767045198796, + "veriT": 10.159874272148777, + "Yices": 10.257906516717778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959185987875587, + "CVC4": 14.51799190274018, + "CVC3": 14.233720967599607, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238491203953219, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.993484823614999 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 188.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3609176828428211, + "veriT": 13.221103799155268, + "Yices": 13.8730385702303, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.832994186107683, + "CVC4": 14.506077039458694, + "CVC3": 11.934914284787773, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.017227188269137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.901403858677146 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254986821389895, + "veriT": 11.352837495491627, + "Yices": 14.370400461190986, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973350623970962, + "CVC4": 14.358053816125704, + "CVC3": 13.787669260000424, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.169528752797378, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.948947717344927 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240772016060896, + "veriT": 14.233651266471638, + "Yices": 14.244634693605221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959038261086178, + "CVC4": 14.396632000213463, + "CVC3": 13.077142296590665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.926847109609664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.961278406751219 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.856818353466796, + "veriT": 14.231401986676616, + "Yices": 14.019889006780978, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.077533950329199, + "CVC4": 14.315504926215008, + "CVC3": 12.379632504853801, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.248566226598314, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.249231187034244 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0683137146240815, + "veriT": 11.301471963562541, + "Yices": 13.091952418312317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.805686699127923, + "CVC4": 14.345638219583753, + "CVC3": 9.8201567532550467, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2453808439375118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2428707247664272 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.830098069031976, + "veriT": 12.70031476192842, + "Yices": 11.518221737647853, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.304511063307354, + "CVC4": 5.7750905696103931, + "CVC3": 13.530225002282505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.277173092734394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.37176322579692 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 373.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0664472776965983, + "veriT": 14.239881989541367, + "Yices": 13.193975856522453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.128682167160575, + "CVC4": 11.549347790245605, + "CVC3": 12.564261879471486, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9616936164100913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0064877127042431 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.310422479994768, + "veriT": 13.356163941645136, + "Yices": 13.207662866059938, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.509359126662794, + "CVC4": 14.689996520988066, + "CVC3": 12.314163201638287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.724765914094753, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.815057501232692 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12143778344543449, + "veriT": 0.43505562701577238, + "Yices": 0.43672737900760694, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12507911818717932, + "CVC4": 0.60223862091727787, + "CVC3": 0.09495243370571034, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.60200665871653525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.59975362147472855 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.096430323095572743, + "veriT": 0.069030332541531805, + "Yices": 0.07314338485302728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.095853193158663641, + "CVC4": 0.091637685059509075, + "CVC3": 0.073646709233509092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.090777309603990913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.090846384505050004 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9776840235557565, + "veriT": 2.1622518876890982, + "Yices": 3.7993504876094297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1123977852637896, + "CVC4": 2.9825960688353521, + "CVC3": 0.15765572245852999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17037297675369997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2041071776726 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.59801033680158999, + "veriT": 10.166660845820639, + "Yices": 10.348043847905556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.67269166309529815, + "CVC4": 0.15032865338469448, + "CVC3": 0.71733784566600012, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14836315554519444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.431880280308405 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18814130373442858, + "veriT": 7.8706097855293944, + "Yices": 9.6216634793022724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.29176685016957143, + "CVC4": 2.2655841183302079, + "CVC3": 2.2233402460234069, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1567952305043905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0331045381870663 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8591270446777344, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5515956456855662, + "veriT": 6.9424497245495109, + "Yices": 9.5688658112457468, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8200353631032495, + "CVC4": 2.0247346669669906, + "CVC3": 4.4035703525441248, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.629435197151599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.041741959506105 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.459411501450502, + "veriT": 8.166945314169201, + "Yices": 10.3373789443986, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.035938242801482, + "CVC4": 0.17783499299710001, + "CVC3": 10.977444570156543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.833232418778119, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.28665510827812 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.071296513263087, + "veriT": 10.49794977300448, + "Yices": 10.470392940607288, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.109902202748536, + "CVC4": 1.3976639683673919, + "CVC3": 9.0776128142920278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2295897294666385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.562683542497373 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240682516568581, + "veriT": 10.152312485725888, + "Yices": 10.337004160721998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960472899011254, + "CVC4": 0.15620411149433333, + "CVC3": 10.91614325945814, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4075463101346091, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.4178017327701 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248242732435408, + "veriT": 10.174030274737275, + "Yices": 10.355493703973819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973389548754339, + "CVC4": 0.16391062270472728, + "CVC3": 14.257206610290792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15506155604154545, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.400914698828823 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.056683548571613, + "veriT": 7.0235084133135617, + "Yices": 7.0511541991210249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.101675930832313, + "CVC4": 0.7616439771748571, + "CVC3": 7.7684144462096532, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6077708737920062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7211288288401541 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5933444499969482, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.916678301942559, + "veriT": 12.120891177372057, + "Yices": 12.56803816750435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.354419921168398, + "CVC4": 7.5246257982530125, + "CVC3": 12.228105829383109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9826393721716595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1179368540148147 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.059236026728984, + "veriT": 11.380951583136914, + "Yices": 12.435626209124502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.541876265198459, + "CVC4": 13.146628415835645, + "CVC3": 12.112506089998162, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.075383969241356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.515184649901473 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.465544859503952, + "veriT": 12.348473332091856, + "Yices": 11.126119951567587, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.041735448132007, + "CVC4": 8.9542036874481603, + "CVC3": 8.2895950992560916, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.106440508455263, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.699784014900334 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3368200633638443, + "veriT": 9.1141516001691532, + "Yices": 9.6570120729433722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5741285249686747, + "CVC4": 5.5264152175234251, + "CVC3": 6.0479722250103274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6676627575973479, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7896511499173933 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20620269052910004, + "veriT": 3.1324278865819002, + "Yices": 1.6630622540809217, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.5733367581651001, + "CVC4": 0.2132895777471, + "CVC3": 0.22697411834469997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5789533027538663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5699596104682298 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7831200361251831, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16582594449683333, + "veriT": 3.7148623994817416, + "Yices": 6.602491907362662, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23010366301516663, + "CVC4": 4.8733364362803746, + "CVC3": 2.4748799176595617, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8522962148755102, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3348875156361073 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13150792574380002, + "veriT": 14.208290482173226, + "Yices": 0.60771300076659984, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13769976450319998, + "CVC4": 0.34373738337580001, + "CVC3": 0.15562508442780001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7780477732621813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7755551170978201 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17933202843785714, + "veriT": 14.226373529994936, + "Yices": 7.4577467966759103, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.59258241439985715, + "CVC4": 6.5454736746712223, + "CVC3": 4.1807232090359721, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.668302830691484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.748856481648655 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.897497215712237, + "veriT": 14.20809519151133, + "Yices": 6.9477635639881381, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2476443510778505, + "CVC4": 6.7519564346592915, + "CVC3": 4.8705168664427454, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3067757198714736, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3132174931546308 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1657397237468343, + "veriT": 8.4218382419076594, + "Yices": 4.4306284347668008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4839212006686129, + "CVC4": 2.1623426887577444, + "CVC3": 2.256303970711949, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.429659553166216, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0083058601316708 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 38.0, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3457104991876809, + "veriT": 11.689700709426532, + "Yices": 10.927864372725022, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.359019892196144, + "CVC4": 12.341581430783028, + "CVC3": 13.921909198234964, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242564373051094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.778564067064078 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8547417464272691, + "veriT": 11.779821269190473, + "Yices": 9.3063806613283191, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.100721447409493, + "CVC4": 2.5654839406371677, + "CVC3": 7.7653010550968338, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.953615783761791, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.55376323638969 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3666665554046631, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.726120529885502, + "veriT": 10.443095809895299, + "Yices": 10.277926616734499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.348155819679539, + "CVC4": 3.1681865908152398, + "CVC3": 12.371051549848723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3791993310603825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.567406128425214 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238298044536451, + "veriT": 10.169277394173999, + "Yices": 10.324090559450999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957874358096259, + "CVC4": 0.15991971107028571, + "CVC3": 11.035353821665202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8173676148577593, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.289093973592198 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.173111736046557, + "veriT": 13.195716947467297, + "Yices": 12.157118331380667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.386940803650733, + "CVC4": 10.541592938677649, + "CVC3": 11.07861913875295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.369676791665832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.233280714292219 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.221433432169778, + "veriT": 11.175579303384215, + "Yices": 10.284406991423227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.753564051492102, + "CVC4": 0.15640004435187499, + "CVC3": 11.979915111447877, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4395682569201034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.090367684480366 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4344254442136135, + "veriT": 9.8478107708328668, + "Yices": 7.3104803252347033, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2220557570993984, + "CVC4": 10.138589605172928, + "CVC3": 5.9572376697304623, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.916484978712941, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.922294477474917 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6266887914346722, + "veriT": 8.5833604957279999, + "Yices": 8.5658521640603524, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.718728463952623, + "CVC4": 1.4728856902838139, + "CVC3": 5.341032519220458, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4356516842402409, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2531933152383639 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.9000000953674316, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13589023189327501, + "veriT": 7.1536644006113175, + "Yices": 1.8614431361492143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14346977583199999, + "CVC4": 1.895272541298971, + "CVC3": 1.3877340559788625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6877087767860002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.70697759545715 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1424343290450998, + "veriT": 1.5328920041985263, + "Yices": 13.231878585449106, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1409921531088001, + "CVC4": 5.8817342534587311, + "CVC3": 8.4441620043290104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7988940059555112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7704186304115379 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.858592264863689, + "veriT": 14.196621158478784, + "Yices": 10.339305635189328, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0265981645172353, + "CVC4": 10.613058522582008, + "CVC3": 10.032976804494677, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0369209008695375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0871968500871692 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.6071429252624512, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2634673943148451, + "veriT": 5.6501722234728149, + "Yices": 8.6545879892596531, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1246004353771264, + "CVC4": 9.6591518290263156, + "CVC3": 4.9951007256325806, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.053131382360116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1336065990394255 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8738832540454844, + "veriT": 5.16858646057175, + "Yices": 7.2708833431038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5879064963545169, + "CVC4": 1.2571506389630205, + "CVC3": 1.0748487120726304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2464064652935889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6397724557061562 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3619791729914443, + "veriT": 4.6195992666188888, + "Yices": 10.273492415193388, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1998605977457779, + "CVC4": 6.0051836060621815, + "CVC3": 3.1468066365755569, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.650279694925626, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.414125768512884 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14655135493037499, + "veriT": 1.3754554884906625, + "Yices": 9.5830504537506123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14670284655312499, + "CVC4": 9.2490394460076715, + "CVC3": 6.4519930892323751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.144617878350875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14451176271924998 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2792205810546875, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16756669722529999, + "veriT": 2.1417383955276801, + "Yices": 9.3719449257770666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16817278230939997, + "CVC4": 1.5830139081696522, + "CVC3": 0.1559489775166, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1588952329227, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16422238316810001 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25505373962823075, + "veriT": 0.11891633939139232, + "Yices": 3.3667310422004948, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.4925384051572308, + "CVC4": 0.16478519679569231, + "CVC3": 0.20203489840493077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13922360363523076, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14094638915661539 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9370225734824889, + "veriT": 10.568173172011317, + "Yices": 13.383477895848776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1259137586738905, + "CVC4": 11.979202212684834, + "CVC3": 11.986719948679191, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5968146171404918, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5923915893764651 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1274553820959436, + "veriT": 11.799177389283145, + "Yices": 6.2906142144373396, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0997423364584762, + "CVC4": 14.363859701273364, + "CVC3": 8.2924436875081433, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.465776958192839, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.994910889330558 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5827276467946438, + "veriT": 9.1771979992183308, + "Yices": 10.967355767106595, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.133460262568747, + "CVC4": 5.1162701899040108, + "CVC3": 5.1188722001950016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22640217223288892, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.515040502522222 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6697899975176331, + "veriT": 6.445737328124423, + "Yices": 10.402090496967174, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8923218374392072, + "CVC4": 8.4624692582602261, + "CVC3": 11.671710537340999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9625620845157359, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9647262802541663 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.673398697601334, + "veriT": 11.825597778388941, + "Yices": 13.110712688810189, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.834705436459069, + "CVC4": 10.742890790332011, + "CVC3": 11.254884502333711, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.438102545920374, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.663630804639878 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.39982418045736839, + "veriT": 14.212488895363876, + "Yices": 5.1941050302343399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3614706973008948, + "CVC4": 4.0657215824258399, + "CVC3": 3.1109676725181723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.110375599918896, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.116876421920203 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1676625986772273, + "veriT": 1.1431086765798333, + "Yices": 3.4774739935505754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6031506641059683, + "CVC4": 1.3354546945722727, + "CVC3": 0.15840248107016666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.198521066178255, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0242297788616574 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1625148540504, + "veriT": 4.2136550152406276, + "Yices": 0.15404300939180002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16122960364979999, + "CVC4": 0.18876468027750001, + "CVC3": 0.16262939898529999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16865639362350002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16969403799489999 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16855187797246154, + "veriT": 0.1502355470803077, + "Yices": 0.15989449776130768, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16574032478299999, + "CVC4": 0.19318161183630769, + "CVC3": 0.1674647062036923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18771889622884613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18154816700853849 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15938524017614286, + "veriT": 0.13253533484342858, + "Yices": 0.15115403472899999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1647674606907143, + "CVC4": 0.17323822486400001, + "CVC3": 0.15669576580257141, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16926318992414283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16993774729914285 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5051724206303998, + "veriT": 5.4491039124304796, + "Yices": 3.5620180983392555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5126250351660011, + "CVC4": 6.4069264710777505, + "CVC3": 2.8157254514250143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7734184195400837, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7855288026828551 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0102873065161662, + "veriT": 9.1149092584474509, + "Yices": 6.7878009942641668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9601917682149894, + "CVC4": 8.1815574549086385, + "CVC3": 4.1822575930493491, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5288728680813168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5253582826799015 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15063933608340002, + "veriT": 0.1256143850691, + "Yices": 1.5890576418463271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15687862999773999, + "CVC4": 8.6259929857083115, + "CVC3": 0.14074584905189999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15172302123962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15329135273030001 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4116263491203751, + "veriT": 8.6265946726114393, + "Yices": 6.0003363258607383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0201533609481195, + "CVC4": 7.2794027674047719, + "CVC3": 1.9012990292795575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8451592722393988, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.842960788019786 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.832057777265472, + "veriT": 6.8655938930099181, + "Yices": 4.1753873056392257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.298267885890795, + "CVC4": 3.1547477302001474, + "CVC3": 2.8206199358667421, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4176785750713403, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6226969389202077 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4545083740736455, + "veriT": 11.872691298451633, + "Yices": 10.721429625237091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.655661972078553, + "CVC4": 11.098494460883222, + "CVC3": 7.6834869542936106, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23987194971141429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.23411234552485713 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0074680830051714, + "veriT": 10.213262652028403, + "Yices": 2.9965986853652162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.215870855516977, + "CVC4": 4.0697128573447356, + "CVC3": 4.3791109478994974, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3322205541895125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.521894652951814 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 46.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3146119594353438, + "veriT": 6.6132508020689835, + "Yices": 11.285623094382821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.664778804744385, + "CVC4": 11.372323334199473, + "CVC3": 10.889172049626227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4343524050688696, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.405751575824949 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15177828892763634, + "veriT": 0.15969156518181818, + "Yices": 9.2412138777620498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0597616270741819, + "CVC4": 6.5899442257756116, + "CVC3": 2.9531088473749096, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0724659401818182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0674598917232729 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.64863292811987494, + "veriT": 10.762721800354361, + "Yices": 5.520408633826575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5255680888916245, + "CVC4": 14.644073193707614, + "CVC3": 8.356393689615075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.567065762368671, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.074453796882537 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2119533792791053, + "veriT": 13.716324434534314, + "Yices": 13.746590635935201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.292728265330478, + "CVC4": 14.346844659714622, + "CVC3": 5.8624366204817413, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232458326115445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.8914921755525 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.852374609730383, + "veriT": 13.848570786812319, + "Yices": 12.617873077525077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.944699271556281, + "CVC4": 14.386409160717346, + "CVC3": 13.834906238580846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.087626771248386, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.084599385990968 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0094394166754528, + "veriT": 13.705709243165638, + "Yices": 9.1644154741065282, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5755886683700933, + "CVC4": 11.038998795563938, + "CVC3": 7.3776981343747838, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.536494198319364, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.533519181675093 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 100.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0379941049049979, + "veriT": 12.87211522186694, + "Yices": 10.538711029640274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1142720398142725, + "CVC4": 11.940536456013184, + "CVC3": 11.878274962397796, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.227041123947179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230443132183124 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.703590911850418, + "veriT": 10.230995364110001, + "Yices": 10.808139178673949, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.43882143438559, + "CVC4": 14.283546192989913, + "CVC3": 12.702559505165672, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.68524215911078, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.143529134596355 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1290986948245747, + "veriT": 10.952568021387027, + "Yices": 6.14424222719658, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6559192378034737, + "CVC4": 5.1945990448220147, + "CVC3": 3.1694662018197102, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8159569297505946, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8585809631350347 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 95.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1733946129226536, + "veriT": 3.5787601488479739, + "Yices": 2.0610335382003711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1137751429596277, + "CVC4": 2.2565526494365731, + "CVC3": 4.0260117936189257, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7937686633759777, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8541216998907009 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7420876007795947, + "veriT": 11.031161825663441, + "Yices": 13.294913952405128, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.378834042578941, + "CVC4": 14.405939520390056, + "CVC3": 10.09411800128543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9860445911095468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2978010606897676 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1059097312496728, + "veriT": 7.380328196272016, + "Yices": 8.0889835349539005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8313433851071546, + "CVC4": 8.6257907225318355, + "CVC3": 6.3912742646382625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18981489712014291, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7789006303678747 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8765127721591437, + "veriT": 14.238025908947874, + "Yices": 5.1477160165372444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2719173168803826, + "CVC4": 0.44508181445733336, + "CVC3": 4.0061514798126421, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20153545770722223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19732598103344445 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1963334083557129, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2645788325210123, + "veriT": 12.510143663405229, + "Yices": 11.088692677744127, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.68615022853043, + "CVC4": 11.45360087084773, + "CVC3": 12.195777056079701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5782053332740933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.521911720254822 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.375123228463503, + "veriT": 14.25672690648566, + "Yices": 14.255474478426031, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.575144287871947, + "CVC4": 14.572573753953542, + "CVC3": 14.260980366026722, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.53746451289366659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.48885064989144439 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 166.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 99.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.97391496242893, + "veriT": 10.789337308117043, + "Yices": 11.766739415857701, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.238826666759755, + "CVC4": 14.461818485575103, + "CVC3": 12.833358870774964, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.800871792578619, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.286851117422255 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.305528437735619, + "veriT": 14.230009059595261, + "Yices": 14.193068100807047, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964986151673411, + "CVC4": 14.515630011998956, + "CVC3": 6.7593643888809085, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7334436986067274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2367231102069045 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 302.0, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4548168577303411, + "veriT": 12.053017651847224, + "Yices": 12.298212193356417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.55156122504294, + "CVC4": 14.563287623564703, + "CVC3": 14.973599677313871, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.2954068923924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.669189522436373 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245422840397358, + "veriT": 13.166011147307627, + "Yices": 13.505282399499048, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.687971476315214, + "CVC4": 14.602122449694376, + "CVC3": 12.532980462385005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.697178612356508, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.771456312574534 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.069697973320563, + "veriT": 13.475888138510861, + "Yices": 13.285325047602722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.533674680225936, + "CVC4": 7.0520442188756061, + "CVC3": 13.699093319030419, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.680083074557967, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.632254696661601 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 54.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12106707160458334, + "veriT": 0.089541534339775006, + "Yices": 0.094379387095704162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11737024262808336, + "CVC4": 0.12006893221425001, + "CVC3": 0.096603851770970819, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11567628418770835, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11579947984070833 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1207152657588294, + "veriT": 0.092410690277476462, + "Yices": 0.097538611584564727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1190440037322, + "CVC4": 0.11723103619255293, + "CVC3": 0.098461295163876472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11397894924458235, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11412278767857058 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2227989611260321, + "veriT": 6.4863885102597916, + "Yices": 5.9519236810552716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5229357663374419, + "CVC4": 6.3226257313028542, + "CVC3": 4.2044201410715516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2066516025408189, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2126464806500286 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9951186695419998, + "veriT": 0.11143470710441429, + "Yices": 3.0229991698783714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.987881076605857, + "CVC4": 0.13504554739871427, + "CVC3": 0.12053102353528571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13340322567228571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17984515038942858 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2889378997796175, + "veriT": 10.165100781511921, + "Yices": 10.352762191995961, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3917627127239487, + "CVC4": 0.14875443508984615, + "CVC3": 0.72354569606073094, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15080046309234613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.408236403683842 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18953098495083331, + "veriT": 8.4900744083911679, + "Yices": 9.5969869494916669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.35749702229141672, + "CVC4": 0.1523301667525, + "CVC3": 0.27109298067624998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14895378441849999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3417495135583404 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2439727825988882, + "veriT": 9.8823132289910323, + "Yices": 11.350479102114507, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4411107112962664, + "CVC4": 12.753868681172433, + "CVC3": 8.4107100647991508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.318888173969066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.27511774169526 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16692396370042856, + "veriT": 5.5849352884310175, + "Yices": 9.9522736007410337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20809445426800005, + "CVC4": 4.1803282811259193, + "CVC3": 0.18329967381114284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1668042631987032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3756455977817597 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2290473532949475, + "veriT": 6.8481469910521673, + "Yices": 8.6543966503113321, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1703686249972787, + "CVC4": 0.17129407000399999, + "CVC3": 3.3217712532325376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.173606632839701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.463210998053476 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.499973646941902, + "veriT": 10.175740308451376, + "Yices": 10.338032024747751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958936617749373, + "CVC4": 0.1767155454905, + "CVC3": 12.258469471115328, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0417844902937814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.240736195537739 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.869954128079399, + "veriT": 10.743976134693551, + "Yices": 10.542288591431143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.250662094028767, + "CVC4": 2.2807346821538066, + "CVC3": 9.2197046919922165, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1593106455885902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.115756273991114 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23036642938445, + "veriT": 11.164241478293318, + "Yices": 10.754012699093861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.420072279260735, + "CVC4": 3.8526444654343015, + "CVC3": 11.692991268182809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.147970862628375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4418195998402421 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.863068668918395, + "veriT": 10.165724911274001, + "Yices": 10.280691388677354, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955728534919524, + "CVC4": 4.7342098890053981, + "CVC3": 10.501947211456628, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8059450476740047, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4968313288080566 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.919507007341119, + "veriT": 8.4967738557240011, + "Yices": 10.340023722657167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.525631803432011, + "CVC4": 0.17772334815766666, + "CVC3": 9.6470063887307944, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.897636101906143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.333649592976812 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1648882342504194, + "veriT": 8.7098415418284763, + "Yices": 7.5449310139232724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.914285357650972, + "CVC4": 0.69743772728490905, + "CVC3": 10.401387637839239, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8037433620020131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8406397051054864 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0161125200988117, + "veriT": 11.10557538037885, + "Yices": 7.7457294362381024, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4205810971639217, + "CVC4": 6.1875524583117683, + "CVC3": 4.6185814802854415, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.691815328656503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7978154992201656 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4450834660337923, + "veriT": 9.655007750387675, + "Yices": 8.4542224635460297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4610816867156364, + "CVC4": 11.131926593168867, + "CVC3": 5.5094304988640355, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7413442313301886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1969370853704557 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4895831356737288, + "veriT": 6.4450675732321434, + "Yices": 4.0923047482496893, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7280769715227811, + "CVC4": 5.0231691572725063, + "CVC3": 4.7825220223542191, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8037008727468491, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7994507060764144 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4160426202959071, + "veriT": 4.6576235439820088, + "Yices": 8.5029116559378775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4792801432001055, + "CVC4": 1.0761030319381184, + "CVC3": 2.3746451430072129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6774348030213364, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6669212342001911 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9069600590901774, + "veriT": 1.3788540070532627, + "Yices": 1.403547689004025, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9836787241288718, + "CVC4": 0.172858058490375, + "CVC3": 0.28471948924660001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20392665480024999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5947930656914784 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.047951933456973, + "veriT": 12.81543607973642, + "Yices": 10.502925400787555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.679880628432464, + "CVC4": 10.323097511476835, + "CVC3": 13.143471678774567, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.554114199978606, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.401234152283893 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2083334922790527, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.961538553237915, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.504977294611372, + "veriT": 6.9439948807659722, + "Yices": 8.4335956330353419, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0480195092029598, + "CVC4": 3.0814006275936237, + "CVC3": 2.587027582317027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9731290748653034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7849687870441606 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2609636013987346, + "veriT": 11.482334306848557, + "Yices": 11.206405898162785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0212294090893268, + "CVC4": 11.039819914017192, + "CVC3": 8.5268609652469518, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.9187383219073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.914923687981215 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0416665077209473, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2522668530073719, + "veriT": 12.136471525726169, + "Yices": 11.453389519844453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9443777182565221, + "CVC4": 11.974578194343351, + "CVC3": 8.4236480261784905, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.546104267021819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.546056861584747 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.42107308305383, + "veriT": 9.5573461078721849, + "Yices": 9.1727627528789597, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.772956530285166, + "CVC4": 7.3580289617674692, + "CVC3": 8.3001724655685809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.729241139795116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.969554284202271 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5399019063537835, + "veriT": 6.806933143109589, + "Yices": 10.637194929117355, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.01470617752971, + "CVC4": 3.2876208227296995, + "CVC3": 11.528198288332113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7225036363366302, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6098399022736363 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.34260959579977779, + "veriT": 5.0488655174562886, + "Yices": 6.1809385859034132, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8237200539133152, + "CVC4": 3.3023978862367138, + "CVC3": 2.8538098988833682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1157813565188981, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8261095382772248 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9690537530445917, + "veriT": 11.851094749672328, + "Yices": 10.323763937245941, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0611484799263815, + "CVC4": 10.952337642756268, + "CVC3": 8.5417871852441607, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5899117679350905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6140663394407078 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22526629061627271, + "veriT": 3.0510490096471661, + "Yices": 3.2990988793493967, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0737643469779092, + "CVC4": 0.21899925823445454, + "CVC3": 1.5014188991640389, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20932219480300002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20707254756745455 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.263121941006581, + "veriT": 8.6226969424098456, + "Yices": 10.055972926535967, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.721581577039412, + "CVC4": 7.5028990693114679, + "CVC3": 10.55869466116194, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5971206574757666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.560134096992424 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.442638282954567, + "veriT": 7.902304704171776, + "Yices": 11.109472988822915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.437933411732677, + "CVC4": 3.8963031117076468, + "CVC3": 9.023145798297131, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.598820039504953, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1088463217131723 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.60026878279371432, + "veriT": 7.0091835072949804, + "Yices": 3.0751640070255717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.93111475260742871, + "CVC4": 4.3568390663847598, + "CVC3": 4.6712735037551427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0743368660420947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1882154707249981 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4042226076152859, + "veriT": 5.1661497765775719, + "Yices": 13.009931564392442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8161896598198082, + "CVC4": 0.71819792481585709, + "CVC3": 0.38812797029114288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1522629145240963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1521398090712385 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13176852387104168, + "veriT": 3.4391269943553158, + "Yices": 4.2920201793801906, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3598014711974813, + "CVC4": 1.3150941952062409, + "CVC3": 0.11857440564396667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13030279830600003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0437830409412865 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.070196086788595, + "veriT": 7.5478993671907393, + "Yices": 4.1975694698757486, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.238032122741522, + "CVC4": 9.6575897928682632, + "CVC3": 2.9041705012899381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9890461473761043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9029867278329835 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3872381098489281, + "veriT": 10.1879201017965, + "Yices": 10.350858895035199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.473881369270348, + "CVC4": 14.273406911470342, + "CVC3": 9.0605557309049356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260215038642517, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.502330158553347 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1476394935235001, + "veriT": 12.814234649282801, + "Yices": 12.125568777080378, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1532942690197006, + "CVC4": 8.3038868016878098, + "CVC3": 9.602259065051161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0780536124380724, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0608021700692909 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1291251025414, + "veriT": 14.208024812748107, + "Yices": 0.26884619414819999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13949180942739997, + "CVC4": 0.17197283946599998, + "CVC3": 0.1271584979358, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.251957005996118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.242139942093823 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3862737777882501, + "veriT": 14.210795029545126, + "Yices": 0.13308231308187501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4190827620768749, + "CVC4": 0.16026683744424999, + "CVC3": 0.136175974970625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.880139119499901, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.928487501443851 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4090351346188887, + "veriT": 12.848337904625193, + "Yices": 6.4665118085800186, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.138137652056308, + "CVC4": 6.7881949296052841, + "CVC3": 4.661395739996907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4235960490329029, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6551133822192599 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5570754243727887, + "veriT": 14.21339421524533, + "Yices": 11.58019457581505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8615850571426638, + "CVC4": 12.576571652433364, + "CVC3": 12.988722780677628, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.229844426280087, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.22423999560713 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20962575509199999, + "veriT": 12.211027418109373, + "Yices": 8.2314590441022482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6021276979929349, + "CVC4": 6.3383246675579956, + "CVC3": 8.2091821124831483, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0578201639576763, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9586255607239043 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4669636490244269, + "veriT": 14.216548221361473, + "Yices": 12.533721389961169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4540087333285996, + "CVC4": 4.8082095188718403, + "CVC3": 6.1397664144958002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.821613709288973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.824850003205214 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17167646129654546, + "veriT": 1.0621474157293636, + "Yices": 6.3936192649017611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1755805288849091, + "CVC4": 5.2967946830236849, + "CVC3": 1.4541040647673393, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5657948678755069, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2493475872573034 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14776549580736364, + "veriT": 3.9104529306913252, + "Yices": 0.15006316441145454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15037032805654549, + "CVC4": 0.16666138368772729, + "CVC3": 0.14659669500163638, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15606853058409093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15575085882063636 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15233476501588891, + "veriT": 0.13031525520022222, + "Yices": 0.1433085853528889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15265540832411112, + "CVC4": 0.168677307277, + "CVC3": 0.15007989181433332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16739872023299998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16399725195922221 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16990257089588889, + "veriT": 0.14655060866344444, + "Yices": 0.16027117176988892, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17267853844966666, + "CVC4": 0.18888737479422224, + "CVC3": 0.16756039413788887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17987443179566664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1800166931874444 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3857145596919411, + "veriT": 4.1910449037496678, + "Yices": 8.5622481963310406, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9230738736121042, + "CVC4": 3.7958441874874271, + "CVC3": 3.1912876751355306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6946774402796532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6396164571570413 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5894974456667068, + "veriT": 3.2727031582346071, + "Yices": 3.1611163260654647, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.80224680699994, + "CVC4": 10.019232164931053, + "CVC3": 2.8516105390907605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1800343062074501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.970997191356026 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9902609586715698, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5241859428093276, + "veriT": 10.54174279734792, + "Yices": 11.649885376011543, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.168371766697172, + "CVC4": 10.068821434449779, + "CVC3": 12.554796951293389, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236288277239888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.343382131339297 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 164.0, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1489651628791111, + "veriT": 3.8894640243355818, + "Yices": 2.3260455770471116, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25523381902947778, + "CVC4": 3.4332856260745781, + "CVC3": 3.2614483289648799, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9882076615643651, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9846674578957866 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.476542530739561, + "veriT": 3.4399638761005669, + "Yices": 10.394328395005131, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5959338307922066, + "CVC4": 14.491728728157049, + "CVC3": 7.6031683593543073, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3636447896494706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3236584518213763 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9004712453968522, + "veriT": 9.2832061810899003, + "Yices": 8.3893641157366403, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.980022019022639, + "CVC4": 4.1249582895186574, + "CVC3": 3.8897365184045825, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9309021535279491, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.045813018359842 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 47.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2060897400664059, + "veriT": 9.6777107710841754, + "Yices": 2.9607681967146338, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6347219712463321, + "CVC4": 5.6523331460391795, + "CVC3": 3.1668489099008252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7506047342215041, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7528937163411804 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.978055992401236, + "veriT": 12.056548972114529, + "Yices": 11.86403894025249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.638191161396323, + "CVC4": 14.493802756639523, + "CVC3": 11.382608065331418, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235762000364632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.678090943942713 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6395672776053387, + "veriT": 11.09345178620538, + "Yices": 11.116304935792936, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8825389228524401, + "CVC4": 11.457516730626569, + "CVC3": 10.814501053552961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.431060881081304, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.426778366337633 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 168.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.78186266941994997, + "veriT": 10.000486377200577, + "Yices": 6.8877836426152488, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3141623063458363, + "CVC4": 0.51247389671487498, + "CVC3": 1.4282794852013501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1903519665770332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1883081982185768 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.124306835070227, + "veriT": 8.1846051472345067, + "Yices": 10.254958468863363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8549648940841781, + "CVC4": 11.463281542483641, + "CVC3": 5.2109817119453234, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5162251605338626, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4948924520215217 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5490703616601547, + "veriT": 14.257819907419572, + "Yices": 10.792396531353784, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.413311535657197, + "CVC4": 1.7159631289042203, + "CVC3": 3.0077148264535278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.30716383961863636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.29996985328290909 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 197.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9351869821548462, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.768508608418031, + "veriT": 12.882473104946529, + "Yices": 12.366043279151205, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.436562365975723, + "CVC4": 14.575477897210034, + "CVC3": 13.021604209728004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254202465637073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.521689103722158 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4912168689966467, + "veriT": 12.191598543418355, + "Yices": 12.736691559681041, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5910989403092728, + "CVC4": 8.9235632300554748, + "CVC3": 7.9553010485839764, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.041517462658376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.039025758462943 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 27.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 115.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.277037652535336, + "veriT": 10.21753220521291, + "Yices": 10.411225593886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.99873595763705, + "CVC4": 14.30698409751302, + "CVC3": 14.272631964606608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.275891874291823, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.430949393855061 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.182583248671911, + "veriT": 14.212324227688294, + "Yices": 12.36869752195101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.256619483320582, + "CVC4": 14.409771438749056, + "CVC3": 13.572214261417992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235533767993058, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.23781887427999 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8584236635189448, + "veriT": 11.234817453950354, + "Yices": 10.084834049400696, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.382957947462588, + "CVC4": 12.762307230374526, + "CVC3": 12.607859005533056, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5477027047677492, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.960601246945405 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 133.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2358478505238235, + "veriT": 10.45885554344769, + "Yices": 6.2037745530550286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0481751071040621, + "CVC4": 3.8615953342283413, + "CVC3": 7.5871770133123793, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4334275220491173, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4860439511191537 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7076641688096723, + "veriT": 12.964897584047096, + "Yices": 10.07650692910773, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.379670274576201, + "CVC4": 12.274547013855338, + "CVC3": 12.616859214580899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.999678891622276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.948276812242511 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.773496599834186, + "veriT": 12.326550248976043, + "Yices": 11.571251519576549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.683894165374333, + "CVC4": 13.329622249239282, + "CVC3": 9.5306968436538142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.232534404778917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.92044988335023 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9230519955429752, + "veriT": 13.488058889865188, + "Yices": 13.537372358879168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5042389466513404, + "CVC4": 14.307536276975117, + "CVC3": 5.3696026927111822, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.53778246533197, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.035067700692194 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4270199359773335, + "veriT": 9.7945649999524491, + "Yices": 8.0028363450876867, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4798514466204451, + "CVC4": 6.7040156639002273, + "CVC3": 10.252262842769474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8827314001710604, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8836592932134204 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.27951324827283, + "veriT": 11.157913558530298, + "Yices": 13.731031344316605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968915301369782, + "CVC4": 14.512082486166197, + "CVC3": 13.780221556775937, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.252775581550889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.252876785503636 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.521986204783774, + "veriT": 14.245745630964109, + "Yices": 14.26276126331018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.328866682088455, + "CVC4": 14.431102505487644, + "CVC3": 10.476037856578973, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4431903839870426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4430882591427352 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242339212401999, + "veriT": 13.507639199042673, + "Yices": 13.814954770100671, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.229167777504536, + "CVC4": 14.868355112633617, + "CVC3": 11.699895485454448, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.920880591493454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.195910708516907 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13062295829984613, + "veriT": 0.1020257297634346, + "Yices": 0.10389394244137305, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12741255744176924, + "CVC4": 0.12893198857853846, + "CVC3": 0.10787003924660771, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1255060506636923, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12364641753762309 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.111328612624775, + "veriT": 0.90784328776578338, + "Yices": 0.91068675992754988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12387018276135835, + "CVC4": 1.2732219866868797, + "CVC3": 0.078457458859091653, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2716213063070183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2705514104741606 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3917329438760442, + "veriT": 2.7528273276981876, + "Yices": 2.4553057858664387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4949814684152996, + "CVC4": 3.4495195720213063, + "CVC3": 1.2119567310177961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2363928071515946, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2310875489461126 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7118155047643988, + "veriT": 8.6600468105092947, + "Yices": 6.713863992787072, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9877377517081696, + "CVC4": 2.6257885646948966, + "CVC3": 5.6160726798876253, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.310669513686924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0623007874042658 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.982182659842934, + "veriT": 5.3961839911973755, + "Yices": 12.128656656963363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1531017325276611, + "CVC4": 0.23414719253210001, + "CVC3": 4.2537361196320749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.358935490926084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6096727779882078 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.275344129566983, + "veriT": 11.053128006505711, + "Yices": 10.962015433847997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.75928347387052, + "CVC4": 5.2486105442445714, + "CVC3": 10.499209314911608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.028811850551512, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.559722792733583 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245351995541199, + "veriT": 10.162806571204184, + "Yices": 10.32582232962209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95750591932806, + "CVC4": 0.16433479057445455, + "CVC3": 12.580699081561319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.445150848003642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.283536691826397 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.784591481239547, + "veriT": 10.610056874797648, + "Yices": 10.482920327884335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.417075955854168, + "CVC4": 1.8172879492045158, + "CVC3": 11.781228715197503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7131924762695148, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.592274842944756 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0096783571955505, + "veriT": 7.931952537111556, + "Yices": 9.2084281039753861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.664228817202227, + "CVC4": 1.0966083556771111, + "CVC3": 6.7152819108452801, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5424193136987476, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7130050756236681 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3553695461157638, + "veriT": 11.994142196823718, + "Yices": 11.985209888992623, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9714853565313977, + "CVC4": 13.186849590801673, + "CVC3": 10.859263705058595, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.525196838365167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0547124111243829 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.689700213562087, + "veriT": 12.04662340606683, + "Yices": 10.649010329576216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.143494325457981, + "CVC4": 3.9304258694010632, + "CVC3": 11.821861466204723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6204048515124434, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.796461202408171 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14736130203924999, + "veriT": 0.12646969239012501, + "Yices": 9.8261155717351372, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14154455131837501, + "CVC4": 7.2808475564623505, + "CVC3": 8.0227550329195001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22962620662150002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22505755499412494 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.996449631504623, + "veriT": 12.413784919904613, + "Yices": 6.7909979177784079, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3697460914005513, + "CVC4": 8.9765461084583631, + "CVC3": 6.3647558402547117, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.565273707213741, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.575486370042267 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7928569316864014, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.151681209806778, + "veriT": 13.986028354012916, + "Yices": 13.81884369946007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.251016169492555, + "CVC4": 11.311111147805558, + "CVC3": 13.010605947415945, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1934338456859965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2190652901105601 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3429803263425297, + "veriT": 14.013495074769637, + "Yices": 11.993279397243322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8081207058687863, + "CVC4": 13.11859121051952, + "CVC3": 9.9786132864030215, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.225191900955846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.821241071800264 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3739124994787173, + "veriT": 3.7533100215840669, + "Yices": 2.9169217681845008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1782321322164711, + "CVC4": 1.4265820953312671, + "CVC3": 7.7546788846658963, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3536883577210888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2877500403165696 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.09213615367884, + "veriT": 10.971853261063099, + "Yices": 11.114635767665728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.00188433192417, + "CVC4": 0.47614379405020008, + "CVC3": 7.8075514067673994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15906835073800002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9961695516434661 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4013877376783732, + "veriT": 8.6550145158390865, + "Yices": 5.095177279225398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4647519226702066, + "CVC4": 3.8616286350272677, + "CVC3": 5.7073560620198549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4713929542798123, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6108241083910197 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1379918674108, + "veriT": 14.212323767439099, + "Yices": 1.5678940079287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17303796957169998, + "CVC4": 1.6356768263917776, + "CVC3": 1.5384195799073894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.328301202821262, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.342930417577744 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3658524165857262, + "veriT": 11.647910753148354, + "Yices": 10.522492045892511, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7647303687954672, + "CVC4": 9.5333194360209443, + "CVC3": 10.465559500881376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.407174964829176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.411167931438372 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.764568567276001, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5476817694903096, + "veriT": 10.166666406920045, + "Yices": 10.35168852415838, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7428270756382358, + "CVC4": 0.14998335162414284, + "CVC3": 0.64281839235045246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15046284743690477, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.087633065949124 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.58571457862854, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249831872973548, + "veriT": 10.1766356191235, + "Yices": 10.3648298234344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968965031692615, + "CVC4": 0.16905657823619996, + "CVC3": 12.259248760991333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16477311750030002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.450446791779674 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235770714924577, + "veriT": 10.670294427478838, + "Yices": 10.445169371634162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952338574967854, + "CVC4": 2.0074093286663959, + "CVC3": 13.805165470344948, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.000497970520974, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.714194488020009 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.617874048286855, + "veriT": 7.3130918077280542, + "Yices": 3.510624532634, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9928606279487564, + "CVC4": 2.186086182092974, + "CVC3": 3.8991640151595179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2974497438648394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.09581111263905 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5040442586605716, + "veriT": 11.086899239977463, + "Yices": 7.5454551841852027, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6186312245099828, + "CVC4": 3.403947813189248, + "CVC3": 6.4226678931674899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4515307878857318, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8313221676148084 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.489678260243721, + "veriT": 11.707583275282071, + "Yices": 9.4417247715091257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.119854532178532, + "CVC4": 14.311989581588001, + "CVC3": 14.247333400844632, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249109869113676, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.435859465654543 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9582223233951437, + "veriT": 10.582976868606011, + "Yices": 11.153738020468829, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.104032487973569, + "CVC4": 7.2398326903454393, + "CVC3": 8.9032058988365961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230629423522494, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.541497151233584 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1081869602203369, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3110566386623645, + "veriT": 11.670614165419126, + "Yices": 12.006212518415664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3028546277312198, + "CVC4": 12.744859652469261, + "CVC3": 8.4371059456800452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.216940568426798, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.678251880984037 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.821372180939183, + "veriT": 5.7475554203461323, + "Yices": 3.39565106468755, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7902491290460327, + "CVC4": 4.1030300827939401, + "CVC3": 2.4633960841655331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.088015582205683326, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.087798791321883327 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9444444179534912, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.254235866452702, + "veriT": 4.7146517154908558, + "Yices": 10.533013726565912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2403497400500658, + "CVC4": 6.2163276316618274, + "CVC3": 4.8939352062375541, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.878588922823525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8282646747263982 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5790221707169747, + "veriT": 10.11314483009337, + "Yices": 10.12879789415854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9182184097226371, + "CVC4": 12.63539847067204, + "CVC3": 5.7927934434990176, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.089190149782917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.091806805426213 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.848788788825535, + "veriT": 8.625302168683417, + "Yices": 8.4563955573267666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.842275249646077, + "CVC4": 0.18310533956550001, + "CVC3": 0.42552274027499998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.446081152559435, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.499043752332476 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.04470497762855, + "veriT": 6.5282242461691817, + "Yices": 6.315854938309724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2831364988164005, + "CVC4": 5.3045800817539295, + "CVC3": 1.4170013882261243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5766641731455648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5089592290736575 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8014288233132181, + "veriT": 7.5969957274812545, + "Yices": 8.9470693182924599, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1033348006732648, + "CVC4": 11.602950954604438, + "CVC3": 8.3395786280531787, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0570045026802912, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9690190743890579 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1378897650324, + "veriT": 1.7823527800010168, + "Yices": 14.272401564938384, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13723198903002501, + "CVC4": 8.0562304649938543, + "CVC3": 6.1282838936545829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2978380580507902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2875449044797147 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13675806914146665, + "veriT": 6.8401392254595743, + "Yices": 8.6551614573699567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19441360914666669, + "CVC4": 1.192600117998768, + "CVC3": 0.12986903760579999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0618733054187786, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0738018690830182 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14748769328900002, + "veriT": 1.042103672295182, + "Yices": 2.8676377617999091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15234097102781818, + "CVC4": 0.15556347895845454, + "CVC3": 0.14267375066409091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15537543348681818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15171366901354547 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.421098562823033, + "veriT": 11.284666403374537, + "Yices": 9.7431563637548599, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.98006969913812, + "CVC4": 12.723847454499191, + "CVC3": 11.26880877679506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.234139165494087, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.463344496678445 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6358899340421633, + "veriT": 9.3072847484489731, + "Yices": 12.475243312796849, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.731439386944331, + "CVC4": 10.52095183116869, + "CVC3": 6.4817475641756701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9742938825863616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9552524131905642 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 48.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1214284896850586, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.02886962890625, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14368517076453846, + "veriT": 0.12270046525616925, + "Yices": 0.127373488965, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14173710082099999, + "CVC4": 0.16072402044892309, + "CVC3": 0.13835718189292306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15155477470538462, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.146608293473 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2548462199102222, + "veriT": 1.7012810910272342, + "Yices": 3.2569754708300747, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3115452987452223, + "CVC4": 0.17540640705866664, + "CVC3": 0.14203464372123331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18347256587804442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18122837515029999 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4096477373784446, + "veriT": 5.8361685248377979, + "Yices": 6.7348882262292529, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4213053156549997, + "CVC4": 1.3594694007763335, + "CVC3": 1.6446900837207579, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8767662977304083, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8675434068018477 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9714569420517778, + "veriT": 4.1334992110206796, + "Yices": 6.2095216322263393, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1193258277004094, + "CVC4": 8.6279233381548632, + "CVC3": 2.9700067632208884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2437665723168911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.623928571878805 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 42.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1715688705444336, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18668361268674999, + "veriT": 0.167982505044875, + "Yices": 2.1977083045784624, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21354746357437498, + "CVC4": 0.21047557066275002, + "CVC3": 0.18635583407225001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19205938371450004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18932490297812501 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17230997806335296, + "veriT": 0.15184655309658823, + "Yices": 0.75609874700441171, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17138163894688233, + "CVC4": 0.19663732270758824, + "CVC3": 0.17186747196094118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18148098974611765, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18559097402576469 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15388548863214285, + "veriT": 5.0332918200844903, + "Yices": 0.15816039140664287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16522798121650001, + "CVC4": 0.17293158936971431, + "CVC3": 0.15290894224478571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16313675782221429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16564185502421427 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18656707478957141, + "veriT": 1.6778449056783198, + "Yices": 9.6648283292125061, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19026858742414285, + "CVC4": 2.2241358773639788, + "CVC3": 5.8541617393415333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2128460807026924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2126434883014818 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7911476047129167, + "veriT": 0.93128657658290004, + "Yices": 0.95645467660865835, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0265410960245815, + "CVC4": 7.1806587315113033, + "CVC3": 0.12199457270065001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11935025985994167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12014944937095834 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21384600283845998, + "veriT": 8.3369541621232433, + "Yices": 4.1367490532782103, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1113246467034501, + "CVC4": 7.2652146953181767, + "CVC3": 0.36673231752220004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7023417729801835, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0814423694005502 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2656868604040739, + "veriT": 10.525394665233444, + "Yices": 8.0650348779780305, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.771759609654952, + "CVC4": 9.6300944685435486, + "CVC3": 6.5959866777169198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3732445373008755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3690775276156817 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3852318980428886, + "veriT": 8.4637513502150021, + "Yices": 2.3409877827937779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4407258247275556, + "CVC4": 3.3130905861949103, + "CVC3": 0.14048434388888886, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22113920582366664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19418891945766667 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3382606355030608, + "veriT": 7.0660073145075941, + "Yices": 8.6439346844837726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9147486808775742, + "CVC4": 8.3228823236269687, + "CVC3": 3.2052960341675711, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1873735063894286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1990145995031858 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1124570803957097, + "veriT": 12.222020231965333, + "Yices": 11.185707857912925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0407846799819147, + "CVC4": 14.48276156538844, + "CVC3": 9.4999783096751802, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.477320983267806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.46465361929719 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 54.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6793042304265, + "veriT": 13.559411114123712, + "Yices": 9.5537168911422992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9759066871597772, + "CVC4": 2.9218073978165369, + "CVC3": 4.6256659173320731, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.936756003077472, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.239176519155855 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3853124956372311, + "veriT": 13.339015653354551, + "Yices": 8.225026132271525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4773840930091771, + "CVC4": 0.7275138453922857, + "CVC3": 0.58186840149842856, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21568649790414282, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21359858740614285 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 59.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.237941549419144, + "veriT": 11.373297088676697, + "Yices": 11.975359663191156, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.961346972122229, + "CVC4": 13.170771636753248, + "CVC3": 9.896053323302608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.991782212427291, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.204574593381995 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241544955797588, + "veriT": 10.179652902494453, + "Yices": 10.281518959108009, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963675508904867, + "CVC4": 14.382184091324707, + "CVC3": 14.235680045532666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238921845834035, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.947926275965461 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.803588580101028, + "veriT": 13.348882269788497, + "Yices": 11.185374499231866, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.506852504527849, + "CVC4": 12.844870202552979, + "CVC3": 14.250696579866993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.80976762306187, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.805091782127811 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5951075434107853, + "veriT": 13.708410455949355, + "Yices": 12.583558497395883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.350173665648938, + "CVC4": 12.977530592274448, + "CVC3": 9.5413116453952327, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231053228089495, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.234192198316167 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.93285137830662501, + "veriT": 14.217968232119446, + "Yices": 13.729760273207255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1966407808300419, + "CVC4": 14.442662168041515, + "CVC3": 5.5907049742925725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.518405900574148, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.455731373183308 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.38614112110725002, + "veriT": 11.585355138540079, + "Yices": 7.7840335949921382, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4036404646872023, + "CVC4": 8.5650471544761224, + "CVC3": 4.9001532574473137, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2108264425181341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7477342285671931 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0065127558911637, + "veriT": 13.320765290827238, + "Yices": 12.653312807722619, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.474451286777505, + "CVC4": 13.503851278800356, + "CVC3": 11.417004787483355, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.967904452015453, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.62221515551318 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8824333613810005, + "veriT": 9.6940211933382212, + "Yices": 9.0364240221590144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0877874812191966, + "CVC4": 0.50990464732757135, + "CVC3": 5.1262417712866206, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2034193731049916, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1994292151198289 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1784543991088867, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.009580555254292, + "veriT": 10.517261543546635, + "Yices": 12.205943445808126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97065279135284, + "CVC4": 14.711093453194987, + "CVC3": 12.463893954581723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.014332851207518, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.516929867962411 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.04062461764364, + "veriT": 14.234880984633701, + "Yices": 14.152209924427863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.116679010978505, + "CVC4": 14.646320735371548, + "CVC3": 13.976309961506704, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.979966732009615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.00489224760832 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9636292857980218, + "veriT": 13.785228522675956, + "Yices": 14.023530827926606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.564334151042548, + "CVC4": 14.75804693003132, + "CVC3": 11.48472812957317, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.250075004457008, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.248356563772953 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6727399998025843, + "veriT": 1.6297301671254285, + "Yices": 3.1608303142627148, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.381991360226082, + "CVC4": 4.2451962902296358, + "CVC3": 2.2807395208084262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1683672458342125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1937660918580173 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 357.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2021349129922414, + "veriT": 12.899093847230111, + "Yices": 5.9578581335949208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7769923187432033, + "CVC4": 2.8956669717431276, + "CVC3": 3.0342409688971403, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22610146363383332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1617949357532242 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 86.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.005816753059074, + "veriT": 13.539370356104605, + "Yices": 13.767201932625124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951646073615194, + "CVC4": 13.136857773359555, + "CVC3": 12.328876865815808, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2476280271949043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4477589831286943 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.309270405595, + "veriT": 12.33667413072887, + "Yices": 14.307815449448309, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.159971530347651, + "CVC4": 14.687067398652223, + "CVC3": 14.126699070514604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7789586922959599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6225323049401941 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.787478003060979, + "veriT": 14.231363813239524, + "Yices": 12.74618670323531, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953597093789005, + "CVC4": 14.634326823136789, + "CVC3": 14.253569139882734, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.369553174319519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.419792955701441 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.270455713010284, + "veriT": 13.73079388721556, + "Yices": 13.756944240090295, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.97307014701242, + "CVC4": 14.575053426321531, + "CVC3": 13.856095574702694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.329774639028653, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.107064670978991 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13181509638982353, + "veriT": 0.10357857383062942, + "Yices": 0.10569789035412354, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13021923205388236, + "CVC4": 0.13478307751529411, + "CVC3": 0.11131828534351175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12860565308641175, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12628356902011764 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11015561341696363, + "veriT": 0.081489708595830296, + "Yices": 0.087137120786703035, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1099342009774212, + "CVC4": 0.10670282592520301, + "CVC3": 0.088141223734048493, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10509538481307576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10343782320190606 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8516485691070557, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3717595323586291, + "veriT": 2.7829057358566849, + "Yices": 3.9335802836701004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4512117362452432, + "CVC4": 1.7798378354007172, + "CVC3": 3.242926400629218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6902072194860813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2739047449416891 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20634784713100005, + "veriT": 10.16769071476056, + "Yices": 10.346932395782201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.29649942298639997, + "CVC4": 0.15048277948892, + "CVC3": 0.57737709534312021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14860716198079998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3093551306902356 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1726322914038541, + "veriT": 9.5112521940894084, + "Yices": 8.8517120797978581, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0185240667566031, + "CVC4": 10.018467162562576, + "CVC3": 8.1982213812883575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.52256997831768, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5206531854530851 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.168811304656847, + "veriT": 9.4331142276363558, + "Yices": 9.8226750272204288, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.205086419407481, + "CVC4": 0.16699877560021428, + "CVC3": 8.3288359194348036, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14204926789149999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4670473653823013 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244642182622087, + "veriT": 10.160360264920438, + "Yices": 10.335934073038187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964982882486961, + "CVC4": 0.15549166618325003, + "CVC3": 10.885348395880591, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.85621560582321765, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.414821378018727 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248334191490525, + "veriT": 10.181633284663286, + "Yices": 10.359119274576713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.970253753817499, + "CVC4": 0.17046516036642859, + "CVC3": 14.256578601546858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15588442967585717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.357153169632397 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.583906113844399, + "veriT": 11.247778480384296, + "Yices": 9.662201929714092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.501937083704645, + "CVC4": 4.2141360255284326, + "CVC3": 11.760130175205637, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.14307481615598, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.061860487146008 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.170290339788096, + "veriT": 9.3980623527860772, + "Yices": 10.332602980632229, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.834567824842591, + "CVC4": 0.17241674860361539, + "CVC3": 12.545053829484299, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.991752240373469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.293680266026453 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.329323177284663, + "veriT": 9.8670400700971346, + "Yices": 9.318705445293574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.243643172851713, + "CVC4": 3.5750073180932458, + "CVC3": 4.493869404893216, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2695797458085298, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9411946378732603 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6575735467839081, + "veriT": 8.707186377069231, + "Yices": 13.355089479169134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8186294731139871, + "CVC4": 4.324824655946939, + "CVC3": 6.0808150712424105, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1943662642170119, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8144351838435311 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9707588033081351, + "veriT": 2.950477796994853, + "Yices": 2.1689176185696, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1560835173067998, + "CVC4": 2.9744245731223833, + "CVC3": 0.13840694921772001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9566668321671843, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14504880661879999 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6977684497833252, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6076924800872803, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4406620824022305, + "veriT": 9.229682560496105, + "Yices": 13.582484034457998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7086548739673164, + "CVC4": 3.860455953214903, + "CVC3": 10.556685442130565, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8476789330090888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5040476425890059 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.896351669779163, + "veriT": 10.823987090442182, + "Yices": 8.6080107906056664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.809073416065097, + "CVC4": 4.9784006443680324, + "CVC3": 11.882283216211505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8497206182413608, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.780157971203151 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.624008879017393, + "veriT": 10.123009488110499, + "Yices": 10.183413830265501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.177627476684346, + "CVC4": 4.4044067556914461, + "CVC3": 1.6328835547709999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240413276145711, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.310043361654341 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1536518666753828, + "veriT": 3.7022648097674353, + "Yices": 5.7914943859868115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2642795801818547, + "CVC4": 0.21916625319157146, + "CVC3": 4.18145998152833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1856095549324577, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9578832128607635 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245738304108329, + "veriT": 11.279835441067712, + "Yices": 11.054302459129303, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962161595738761, + "CVC4": 9.5757636588179302, + "CVC3": 11.033317872347395, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.967650304779495, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1222838681428762 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0625, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7670040311738564, + "veriT": 11.511982375813433, + "Yices": 11.042139291134404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2828286939847997, + "CVC4": 11.922548187768724, + "CVC3": 7.607577004166072, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.205194249015998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.210326289502115 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5766515283753533, + "veriT": 5.1034838811386924, + "Yices": 5.1517146121035422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8323589547834604, + "CVC4": 1.6133065712860784, + "CVC3": 2.4951181419325144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1288161949814106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3207876488712662 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1697495233570132, + "veriT": 11.392705892168697, + "Yices": 10.515172538691713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4921744067922065, + "CVC4": 10.590551829807495, + "CVC3": 6.9408077585038503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.9992324068785, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.848820521855993 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.449395074004734, + "veriT": 9.8596923859338439, + "Yices": 9.2981326480259998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.491517051200034, + "CVC4": 5.1035843614132057, + "CVC3": 10.355408486303878, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2971809264873642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.940195876448518 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.9000000953674316, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3729836253703773, + "veriT": 13.417888850412684, + "Yices": 8.0854832894197592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9684513633264178, + "CVC4": 9.3515425181412155, + "CVC3": 7.4605562893347397, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5179810521953456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.954461389564397 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12887608517214286, + "veriT": 4.3855519240090857, + "Yices": 6.4011871038768096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12648611824428574, + "CVC4": 2.151588469273217, + "CVC3": 0.11308470088271429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12681586118899998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12745648593014286 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.29560792842635836, + "veriT": 5.653954438161084, + "Yices": 4.4459210244722458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3748335518756847, + "CVC4": 0.37988598187816675, + "CVC3": 1.3084424553064788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3115274275296251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3059836152699904 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9143655940449276, + "veriT": 6.4967318495880377, + "Yices": 11.653299011639227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1193840754936857, + "CVC4": 5.6579541487460512, + "CVC3": 1.9244828158755107, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7274113940080249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7565935368054286 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12602185179366668, + "veriT": 0.10487443687008334, + "Yices": 0.11020123212575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11833988000478333, + "CVC4": 0.12933352943000001, + "CVC3": 0.11307614031331666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12514638790783331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12444098647978334 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9621768369833159, + "veriT": 4.9673616636937163, + "Yices": 7.0028735456380442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7065302688392401, + "CVC4": 3.1269369751274114, + "CVC3": 2.311883760542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.976723670437857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1973288986516568 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.899446311244305, + "veriT": 1.8779437826823706, + "Yices": 13.850256578073743, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9896583440200315, + "CVC4": 9.0739146575542993, + "CVC3": 12.330718249590777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0883885504800084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0622387801139621 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0555553436279297, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.213948405709584, + "veriT": 11.907168760696223, + "Yices": 12.010647703400306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.125259482473748, + "CVC4": 6.3093705890865968, + "CVC3": 11.740536146107571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0669240214706379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.442961266508336 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.451092210036981, + "veriT": 12.692006628399906, + "Yices": 7.4732465533313759, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.464224216328548, + "CVC4": 5.7423901091821214, + "CVC3": 14.046924503347281, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.71572998455696, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.147267816573841 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7033171407928442, + "veriT": 9.6280155968902275, + "Yices": 12.365863869012383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.777223063036248, + "CVC4": 12.661127021550033, + "CVC3": 10.560513463557083, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.23879051333296, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.434422270252108 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4597020808178749, + "veriT": 8.1279130199648097, + "Yices": 9.3955282232680233, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1230567605842499, + "CVC4": 10.814416418778382, + "CVC3": 5.0708589873328203, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.705525569658182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.699481786823705 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.683839291580878, + "veriT": 7.8128868513193845, + "Yices": 9.3528999720403458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.493746716573877, + "CVC4": 3.1623825694054535, + "CVC3": 3.2785816736144797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7892180024507773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8217272175731392 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7413313593541107, + "veriT": 1.1607242514253333, + "Yices": 0.14464149216118888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9878293161616671, + "CVC4": 0.17326146697622222, + "CVC3": 1.7329626075952367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2837474159458289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2823298288645368 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21870385735166664, + "veriT": 3.6191331507376661, + "Yices": 4.2104822607298873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2795355763895, + "CVC4": 0.21548176786066664, + "CVC3": 0.205154360295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20851822128349998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20978800919316667 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9511904716491699, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.597057353592831, + "veriT": 4.427677625216857, + "Yices": 8.5296232223037407, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.725839758348171, + "CVC4": 4.2929087982889662, + "CVC3": 3.6192564850137705, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16504702064714288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9437037755357331 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9028041077265723, + "veriT": 8.7567005620420861, + "Yices": 11.777971255812236, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.115055592814651, + "CVC4": 11.283891653418236, + "CVC3": 9.5127369965602053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243511595762341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.846588524691295 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5727592958883347, + "veriT": 9.3858060426856795, + "Yices": 11.052551819568711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.279542074086077, + "CVC4": 3.253369393763279, + "CVC3": 5.7038492973719004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0839035441835341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.915333372532695 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5830486339439998, + "veriT": 0.14298923860418572, + "Yices": 0.14750032355375714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5954593388863001, + "CVC4": 2.1765758113052134, + "CVC3": 0.1592127446733714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15588761780514288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15510811758457144 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10463919958502857, + "veriT": 7.2179986880219991, + "Yices": 7.2187617492970286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10274972006707142, + "CVC4": 0.10507695345874286, + "CVC3": 3.0477110792707864, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.324546049426282, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3659431619064568 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18766155591436365, + "veriT": 9.5737350485664638, + "Yices": 9.3816895686838588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5772220562919799, + "CVC4": 9.1384558847852002, + "CVC3": 0.098733415267827279, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.34023055267856356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.24161425127793645 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7071405378766666, + "veriT": 3.3122273348066007, + "Yices": 5.1985013981177559, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7074579663338891, + "CVC4": 11.17826959896175, + "CVC3": 2.446127517775889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15933213667055557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15774071064299999 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.560620758968135, + "veriT": 10.311666055024517, + "Yices": 10.070482946415069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.093050561481698, + "CVC4": 13.551154995076438, + "CVC3": 11.705811351267807, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.708540475585513, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.412685306834801 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5772772785474287, + "veriT": 10.196949405378261, + "Yices": 10.697385819419734, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5788467002995716, + "CVC4": 5.6408922585103056, + "CVC3": 7.6135082677457797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7117763732223112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6972466637553305 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.743727445602417, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4108579784896365, + "veriT": 13.83892727001885, + "Yices": 0.50441902581763642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0468885331012725, + "CVC4": 4.0879058760948102, + "CVC3": 4.0135669907192471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231773443688191, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.231229290690642 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13276266998614286, + "veriT": 13.623788078946447, + "Yices": 0.12346880857314284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16559919549228572, + "CVC4": 0.15575441216985714, + "CVC3": 0.12586998332999999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8773900957732002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8971150300291271 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0425034525954979, + "veriT": 13.53446599411307, + "Yices": 7.8148392857445002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1252631686948469, + "CVC4": 6.264008198180524, + "CVC3": 11.87055457920073, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.935544641976243, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5525939595471048 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1069619655609131, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9711539745330811, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4969219306941661, + "veriT": 0.14494303105533332, + "Yices": 0.14262309281966665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.494857289898333, + "CVC4": 0.18747202574999999, + "CVC3": 0.16024299116566668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17032780637100001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16992064355883332 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22283199105954543, + "veriT": 0.17623275725363638, + "Yices": 1.4971733627648369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.37045986936381819, + "CVC4": 0.22270529235000003, + "CVC3": 0.20493420002990909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21003306946954547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20747567212645457 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1729815006256104, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15305267228200001, + "veriT": 9.6835204324360635, + "Yices": 0.25740064166560001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1813782592274, + "CVC4": 0.17638106004950002, + "CVC3": 0.39473597999410004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15814240099560001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15999522730910001 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15156490641291667, + "veriT": 0.12587804700725, + "Yices": 0.14585982118808333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15032781521791666, + "CVC4": 0.16659749292891668, + "CVC3": 0.14912513334108332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16173768726941665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16410802121758331 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9558170455415711, + "veriT": 8.9110735781309138, + "Yices": 3.7278272345985846, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9589626548658572, + "CVC4": 4.9342322356713506, + "CVC3": 6.0370397546314267, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1983171745082464, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1937322827972805 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8637946445441655, + "veriT": 4.2210703677843684, + "Yices": 7.7444370697239258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2783111484018823, + "CVC4": 3.982444992950684, + "CVC3": 1.3326233676455241, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1234442956092283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1207924831333458 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.41930173521802494, + "veriT": 7.1762360166848662, + "Yices": 4.4407138708922984, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6152343567990377, + "CVC4": 10.783616636580174, + "CVC3": 6.0999025189819314, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2922437302713874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4771128868918639 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0176829450579321, + "veriT": 11.199529397625636, + "Yices": 8.4933805405075802, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1745674955924681, + "CVC4": 8.9197177297786858, + "CVC3": 10.732063657680898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.196509732959223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.064628949433574 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9125304222106934, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6588574647903442, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0469757228025149, + "veriT": 11.766607583960853, + "Yices": 2.3226950092779997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8504034391362523, + "CVC4": 3.1655329380524089, + "CVC3": 2.2766671705931127, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2872895921979417, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2862984101905166 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7990820407867432, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.214377049729508, + "veriT": 12.525924692586367, + "Yices": 12.267172949545417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.343250555253283, + "CVC4": 11.72301758265302, + "CVC3": 10.406108887563885, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.267312434372943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.041687839748894 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0329335188213946, + "veriT": 14.222240892635639, + "Yices": 13.328231162146977, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7266774505493609, + "CVC4": 12.466800760253255, + "CVC3": 7.5239905140781813, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237145406201199, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.235244801054973 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5642778490982949, + "veriT": 11.259884624436312, + "Yices": 5.7577667847704062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8536729395457092, + "CVC4": 1.7123938216658505, + "CVC3": 3.6228865649733359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1994886810676637, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2009274980247839 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2336275351671198, + "veriT": 13.238955507005469, + "Yices": 11.545849751901299, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.244968835598902, + "CVC4": 9.308581236386706, + "CVC3": 5.9686911141559413, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5965583270880606, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9033184506948304 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257049332805991, + "veriT": 10.188121737863785, + "Yices": 10.362877280715356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977121858303063, + "CVC4": 14.27714072782914, + "CVC3": 13.368971763288318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24860888830149, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.663705868636063 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0191295146942139, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233744072069648, + "veriT": 14.231314601867515, + "Yices": 12.641311696911906, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.944852355035566, + "CVC4": 14.536286413613889, + "CVC3": 8.6885693147173928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237338902762657, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.234806953310283 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1926954974707602, + "veriT": 13.066503128483131, + "Yices": 14.249785636142621, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.159038993179269, + "CVC4": 14.600334674437578, + "CVC3": 13.475058861989268, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253786160770229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.25118325387291 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5189821462279669, + "veriT": 13.391495279616183, + "Yices": 12.318087202808067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8336387948736839, + "CVC4": 14.660763758848915, + "CVC3": 4.8316082440028243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2850643427780959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2857999445689021 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2458808293974233, + "veriT": 13.073568225457478, + "Yices": 12.349808245614929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.81195395188314, + "CVC4": 8.8572028788389385, + "CVC3": 13.896747663091466, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.266795462457837, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.01678518755463 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.359307987119529, + "veriT": 10.701980414743927, + "Yices": 11.439605140500694, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.991333956738695, + "CVC4": 14.352234607404764, + "CVC3": 14.27266964921113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.275441823991754, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.611628865234861 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.955167971699574, + "veriT": 13.922506634318307, + "Yices": 14.313362249921182, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.778222516057651, + "CVC4": 14.671802785848012, + "CVC3": 13.90380487861932, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.878982016398551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.898736452180207 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 387.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 269.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5719021859051683, + "veriT": 12.376344189740575, + "Yices": 11.10191703319075, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1226421835257216, + "CVC4": 14.45788467329824, + "CVC3": 11.179480340696381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.773952815181543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.85755776121465 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8815994223971122, + "veriT": 7.0528066516060051, + "Yices": 6.7064876302051264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6971832207566746, + "CVC4": 7.8434170135834229, + "CVC3": 3.4468852174415137, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.71408617520423634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4629594494758384 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.287485646004205, + "veriT": 12.640451325772542, + "Yices": 11.823100538668459, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.987382129166464, + "CVC4": 13.569281655569826, + "CVC3": 13.00030150837671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1122007526032611, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1072731695359384 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241829202187288, + "veriT": 12.195400236765369, + "Yices": 13.773602962397103, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961783897225413, + "CVC4": 14.314436219622158, + "CVC3": 14.002661668479915, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.219851358382744, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.206964472478324 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 53.0, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1238556174983305, + "veriT": 14.228753875114117, + "Yices": 14.017297861777891, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957719861464849, + "CVC4": 14.444822114573919, + "CVC3": 10.8414655266106, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243741408675197, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.241265858877563 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.623604670439482, + "veriT": 11.985593936430503, + "Yices": 14.248415446214979, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977306765577929, + "CVC4": 14.433172006745616, + "CVC3": 13.944598116139069, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.316615187448869, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.915326730556716 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 229.0, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9817980480784119, + "veriT": 14.239681009880188, + "Yices": 13.465718855331447, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5518823889720146, + "CVC4": 13.727391071016044, + "CVC3": 13.093639592017814, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3511216193306215, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2769712784087313 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.098099079746914, + "veriT": 14.259465817989373, + "Yices": 13.985550352455558, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.941511348327882, + "CVC4": 14.766507233689252, + "CVC3": 7.7037578857956772, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.720723371514786, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.009982835395961 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4166665077209473, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13287566838738135, + "veriT": 0.33448306523425347, + "Yices": 0.33540036794623496, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13429241456075117, + "CVC4": 0.45610632790885242, + "CVC3": 0.10608929477917441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.45365334206912372, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.45094154339227732 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1819189558583785, + "veriT": 0.082614618089467864, + "Yices": 0.086643217011282123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1812359121979785, + "CVC4": 0.10666954389967857, + "CVC3": 0.089011116941678542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10606665441021072, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10527427116627855 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1555554866790771, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.305159997709882, + "veriT": 5.4955417810491012, + "Yices": 6.4417242244226447, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4592955579963505, + "CVC4": 5.0162495662150199, + "CVC3": 4.843074497359046, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2896450517457181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8680478465681851 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.84548841098255634, + "veriT": 10.164897522181588, + "Yices": 10.354795886006819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.96702962778453316, + "CVC4": 0.15061474978822728, + "CVC3": 0.62677087133231824, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15013874297704546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5961859051792562 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3540419717356436, + "veriT": 11.301971476858309, + "Yices": 11.654023687252684, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3806304917699013, + "CVC4": 12.441674619319866, + "CVC3": 10.217879846691712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.056407769771287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.129948581632261 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2876689688970351, + "veriT": 3.4693587950510771, + "Yices": 3.5612590474195525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8382412993857793, + "CVC4": 1.8004970482355067, + "CVC3": 2.9739405499818554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.704561323237193, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1715067945604041 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7333334684371948, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.427295448613416, + "veriT": 10.973017439984467, + "Yices": 10.615790209550701, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.992731234457057, + "CVC4": 3.1927247616594285, + "CVC3": 11.283669876464124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1607770528879104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.843338622897939 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.247235577076989, + "veriT": 9.4517991608692853, + "Yices": 10.337842192252142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.913844635778554, + "CVC4": 0.17042226198300001, + "CVC3": 12.890735358504857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8528179437219077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.281019272267185 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.380376696194839, + "veriT": 10.886209315324749, + "Yices": 9.454840861252249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.915852191313801, + "CVC4": 1.8240190068706668, + "CVC3": 9.5482936971548664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4075313021290752, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.961405026491507 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8216355618654152, + "veriT": 5.9968075032719987, + "Yices": 9.6082057008020652, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.284257607260571, + "CVC4": 0.64315557147316671, + "CVC3": 10.425437109221583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8681667595903955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4923193010701965 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6458334922790527, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239652993437424, + "veriT": 10.153304510279272, + "Yices": 10.320895348128907, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958372404671616, + "CVC4": 0.15368292901781819, + "CVC3": 12.549220597624441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19247363687554547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.287904530244722 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6008172891079919, + "veriT": 9.3579497874500781, + "Yices": 6.610083771725991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0762191118888129, + "CVC4": 0.14531585902309999, + "CVC3": 5.7808124941161072, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13824537832790001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6326142101199412 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7919170693032456, + "veriT": 5.0894340691403004, + "Yices": 8.6179798544161095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9818875470771316, + "CVC4": 1.6255293905994674, + "CVC3": 4.389470066885905, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3741150936976911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4865266526438301 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6926534175872803, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4799412526197224, + "veriT": 8.6789533925863616, + "Yices": 7.4692664466910283, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.781707662463508, + "CVC4": 5.3151687544006014, + "CVC3": 5.3113463715792237, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4537743442532549, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1840070488565149 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.280715852563343, + "veriT": 11.376308121568321, + "Yices": 11.463058840346147, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.831094505740461, + "CVC4": 11.546200603029281, + "CVC3": 14.214488915223935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.541747124331661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.600344518970884 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7478571480770002, + "veriT": 9.2835034154493883, + "Yices": 8.4309196892256679, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8862033329647847, + "CVC4": 0.17529123331941668, + "CVC3": 7.3257903128543829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1941469061428358, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4055112269372003 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.194074538684587, + "veriT": 12.939245864729971, + "Yices": 13.625349985983028, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0802585218559706, + "CVC4": 10.904624309792297, + "CVC3": 4.1855849558329918, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.370553249583935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4009322686340697 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.462261971574062, + "veriT": 10.98908450211702, + "Yices": 11.111637969264956, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.380242743638139, + "CVC4": 10.574385229422065, + "CVC3": 11.168295745594955, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252558227123414, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.523761201493434 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3026083163711668, + "veriT": 13.530290748869042, + "Yices": 2.4053957039999068, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7195031352466668, + "CVC4": 2.7161973287210763, + "CVC3": 2.5116773851804197, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232019079258071, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230900952426213 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5914007590204373, + "veriT": 2.3455837718997805, + "Yices": 5.1492162015901863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1143449790018165, + "CVC4": 3.783926007378724, + "CVC3": 2.486669568749253, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6557964011139199, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4925900314854132 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1911319926102948, + "veriT": 11.219043401498196, + "Yices": 10.013363712082038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7036250761133758, + "CVC4": 12.087742656500057, + "CVC3": 7.2887716088752112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.204511311182523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.198942381767798 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12147974094183334, + "veriT": 0.09236073897375556, + "Yices": 0.094354934431866669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11654744052364444, + "CVC4": 0.11812567866133333, + "CVC3": 0.10068287980444443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11856925786933334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11778924279984444 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4299440871016245, + "veriT": 7.392846512763172, + "Yices": 7.1395248737227668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1479472687188244, + "CVC4": 4.6071694484500672, + "CVC3": 3.4934421581805615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8386501487724694, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1712886327604082 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1222219467163086, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.950569970476293, + "veriT": 10.481474656406478, + "Yices": 10.64207686941851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.724254036963792, + "CVC4": 1.7175365525299471, + "CVC3": 11.516285284322363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5242772807283416, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.229473092943588 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247469646620781, + "veriT": 10.166107021184779, + "Yices": 10.346818886883666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964764110931505, + "CVC4": 0.16558159607922224, + "CVC3": 13.596325818260032, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17412528325911111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.359817748030643 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.243971648317177, + "veriT": 10.725214173785432, + "Yices": 11.860899715731028, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5102494958131176, + "CVC4": 8.4693299352396192, + "CVC3": 10.082346492884962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5332690780742046, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0903657762716836 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.511640509368207, + "veriT": 7.9835552106029519, + "Yices": 13.499717708430344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6152648339403335, + "CVC4": 13.110961423293395, + "CVC3": 12.472929899274796, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4329128416082515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4369066436504241 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1498206583613002, + "veriT": 1.5515909775024106, + "Yices": 9.2303539463758035, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1520624912911999, + "CVC4": 4.4079397358832964, + "CVC3": 6.2868386038815096, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3755946945811282, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3687182893311824 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4968655109405518, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5241717631502176, + "veriT": 13.528189548856032, + "Yices": 4.1866259697141146, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7490384947777518, + "CVC4": 12.066630508398774, + "CVC3": 10.840906159264057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.226108684369706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.211128523584199 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3090989623025706, + "veriT": 13.470209055644814, + "Yices": 10.171189194802171, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4333957621148565, + "CVC4": 10.62510659696385, + "CVC3": 9.6266778478396482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.67253695982474, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.690702015543312 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8111854791641235, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14407773170099999, + "veriT": 0.11934101922410001, + "Yices": 2.2888210143461936, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21293732917699998, + "CVC4": 2.9889369596095694, + "CVC3": 2.1845455802538001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14847678577240001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14416828341820001 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.516397719052295, + "veriT": 7.9268972375145186, + "Yices": 7.9961116362412143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3135094133788212, + "CVC4": 2.0831923132605694, + "CVC3": 2.7603494462815723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.676492854475363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0458850400687307 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.714324253118702, + "veriT": 10.58334818555956, + "Yices": 13.676065145598212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5066320653732399, + "CVC4": 1.5921317917765345, + "CVC3": 4.0430872895322505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6633810901416846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6873679894530333 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 70.0, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15891209686437499, + "veriT": 14.207841420976894, + "Yices": 0.14715660787500001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.301924581080875, + "CVC4": 3.8640433699268342, + "CVC3": 0.12941384527962502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.154261170503737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.156409168391413 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9399801526534537, + "veriT": 14.219939307270124, + "Yices": 10.666601093462512, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7047096281392573, + "CVC4": 9.0309171022094095, + "CVC3": 10.692424742901927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.36358413112516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.361916275346831 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2180388770795401, + "veriT": 7.0307988860710307, + "Yices": 8.4345686449142256, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2749435460165448, + "CVC4": 2.7626989844389866, + "CVC3": 2.8390004000773135, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3084661717077557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2960662122626729 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1188565429208999, + "veriT": 1.5064120410057746, + "Yices": 1.5271348317985374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1185190317119003, + "CVC4": 1.5358058255295488, + "CVC3": 1.12665879010921, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1501992010267998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1488993176591999 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1692075709303751, + "veriT": 9.0036567685343449, + "Yices": 9.0051734524469662, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.010651927483172, + "CVC4": 10.062675659016884, + "CVC3": 8.3201223488303704, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.661309373437831, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.662748047948508 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.890179621428498, + "veriT": 10.687891971682077, + "Yices": 10.54296247086069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.256880420302659, + "CVC4": 7.1390019238724545, + "CVC3": 5.9114390748617556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1791008233885929, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1604082829412574 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0172414779663086, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6257807781471252, + "veriT": 0.10037676533217502, + "Yices": 0.100235200505775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6243930270434253, + "CVC4": 8.9429185445173012, + "CVC3": 0.10917777248167498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1253155173645, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12351091067847501 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9847621911059092, + "veriT": 5.6419034176699823, + "Yices": 7.6196324341946342, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0365544281740182, + "CVC4": 1.9759777223704182, + "CVC3": 2.378707207456058, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7219923246612359, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7203836611258585 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14979762459416668, + "veriT": 0.13048990110816663, + "Yices": 0.14375575581666666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14662735743825001, + "CVC4": 0.17313463401708332, + "CVC3": 0.14695171263666668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16496235988741667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16431103014966664 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.941635829370508, + "veriT": 8.7464354427654118, + "Yices": 9.9147856652173534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0785698591627115, + "CVC4": 0.13770349584178002, + "CVC3": 3.956712191046357, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0256024365051819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0293397411568663 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 51.0, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5107516964133332, + "veriT": 12.185529437640838, + "Yices": 7.2005849155390154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5164879620903329, + "CVC4": 9.5895596377532328, + "CVC3": 11.645828992935703, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.445381391831988, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.556197787886715 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.820488873636581, + "veriT": 7.1857583500453002, + "Yices": 7.3695857080643039, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.401199849032039, + "CVC4": 12.209027282484016, + "CVC3": 6.654538125151146, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.900603961755003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8951841465933272 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18129059245359999, + "veriT": 5.6640438793595127, + "Yices": 0.1949819091443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18413999085069999, + "CVC4": 0.20274591089709998, + "CVC3": 0.17664291323709999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18160448388980002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1792830080566 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9691164493560791, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0232726671608572, + "veriT": 0.14464286750171432, + "Yices": 3.6149231786867406, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0306521527935719, + "CVC4": 2.2014754372780385, + "CVC3": 0.17296070792699997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.36832460357628571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7728212183258047 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16988224553858333, + "veriT": 0.14641214156783333, + "Yices": 0.15988051405941667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17324880890475, + "CVC4": 0.18805095992341667, + "CVC3": 0.16689221720783332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17950264422333331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17857187822383333 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6428286816761033, + "veriT": 8.9628069486683088, + "Yices": 6.5599544410114428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5197434688865394, + "CVC4": 2.8654954494959388, + "CVC3": 0.47489308193616669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.902637592450322, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8985278518297637 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6675513348818249, + "veriT": 10.524046946757592, + "Yices": 11.365379667769711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.960665437585412, + "CVC4": 13.064827821781915, + "CVC3": 6.6246978886235013, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.149836177603838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.769689039879632 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1889521406022, + "veriT": 11.176360403528751, + "Yices": 5.9054105017520895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.323763390594, + "CVC4": 4.4453160496512503, + "CVC3": 7.3668377223757728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1950044620702993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5992584686491735 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3089275257419786, + "veriT": 8.4824312081173332, + "Yices": 9.8065325204501193, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.467304512827999, + "CVC4": 12.058904545791664, + "CVC3": 6.6042988815152706, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3156148756433979, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2781225054778496 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.898316393531595, + "veriT": 12.446225906425031, + "Yices": 3.3236808020026265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9742021841616788, + "CVC4": 3.7642230291646737, + "CVC3": 1.896761080152892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18207792857612498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1830848055065 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 187.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.24557487613113, + "veriT": 10.788850436841035, + "Yices": 11.402547509188066, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.96791155020188, + "CVC4": 14.556033387769661, + "CVC3": 8.1327721749654991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.767222205305959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.556646700650228 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248072581242392, + "veriT": 10.65634443666201, + "Yices": 10.267728683933726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967867955157249, + "CVC4": 14.378102573742995, + "CVC3": 13.711109148411069, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.213129316508567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.812759635056516 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2036940255171356, + "veriT": 13.311207597794395, + "Yices": 12.040401499644211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.254372072193096, + "CVC4": 14.738100446748868, + "CVC3": 12.535621959089628, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236579794511922, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.234368636262664 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1552198482631546, + "veriT": 14.21874918470022, + "Yices": 9.3462348856317625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8919099784839126, + "CVC4": 5.7049380372260687, + "CVC3": 1.393430478962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.760709706622507, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.730709042487099 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 95.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.90795098538438468, + "veriT": 11.391477851839944, + "Yices": 8.1483800851134376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9132846545579767, + "CVC4": 2.3800687345439582, + "CVC3": 2.0605282565105592, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.451707179203975, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.472145571068264 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17227620682071426, + "veriT": 3.9046310864131231, + "Yices": 2.6508492107906649, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.69919700113928573, + "CVC4": 2.1635830122273823, + "CVC3": 2.0554767989101426, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13646671051214285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13056582186271432 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1212662095719308, + "veriT": 14.244316535187956, + "Yices": 5.7255410682052084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5626247961944415, + "CVC4": 2.0545307206486516, + "CVC3": 1.0885459110597502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21316969416524997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20921842276412497 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.967509077301334, + "veriT": 12.885738596721049, + "Yices": 13.011567581209425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.100253611268446, + "CVC4": 14.562936555208987, + "CVC3": 10.892676121937599, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.699768178667158, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.621407260027876 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6072233567341749, + "veriT": 10.618485687492388, + "Yices": 4.4888861707913685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4652624020009899, + "CVC4": 4.5237230284802461, + "CVC3": 7.780963550335553, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7433738727664565, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7373128973375218 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.688408615581567, + "veriT": 13.919646075579537, + "Yices": 13.865124186165447, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.481073784218287, + "CVC4": 14.301225538419502, + "CVC3": 14.170621567504227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2654580376242466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1658513581933603 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.913559299098134, + "veriT": 12.199050396354373, + "Yices": 11.945548868192516, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.566282192151311, + "CVC4": 13.717790464231911, + "CVC3": 13.209003160056874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244551939470979, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.990106290118689 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3799866591345751, + "veriT": 13.298956464162977, + "Yices": 12.975254948155841, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.858049989690818, + "CVC4": 14.445951892489258, + "CVC3": 14.210771014814677, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.846629501922905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.948233364252646 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.435836355381737, + "veriT": 13.82205013101472, + "Yices": 12.274083563427235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.475896558339574, + "CVC4": 12.990712448607237, + "CVC3": 14.22757337592698, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1925465619719517, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6841073811656431 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 106.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9670653128621449, + "veriT": 10.091255365109618, + "Yices": 11.669688826340487, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.517950120790896, + "CVC4": 13.10176591708653, + "CVC3": 8.5044843189151909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.034255361337591, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0605654036520606 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 129.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8429157171638995, + "veriT": 13.831738146573098, + "Yices": 13.842149826192102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.923834392452756, + "CVC4": 14.709025327656434, + "CVC3": 10.554787116019462, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.490025035237252, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.427144666021027 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 239.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.622417368921774, + "veriT": 12.221781528240255, + "Yices": 12.925279666079915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.136428220126339, + "CVC4": 14.761503487970026, + "CVC3": 13.89450096991775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.887652849828472, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.922140335692767 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249404818759324, + "veriT": 13.899937286687281, + "Yices": 14.456894958989265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.006885477348833, + "CVC4": 14.539792657446943, + "CVC3": 12.463619382923175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249581895459977, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.252286397930297 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.258101018047491, + "veriT": 10.664148708338415, + "Yices": 11.609995778558098, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.475888804241524, + "CVC4": 13.077297923931582, + "CVC3": 13.840236718016246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.474345266792657, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.952433831231572 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.585579385882768, + "veriT": 13.539192016457678, + "Yices": 13.515664592815529, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.976947498171432, + "CVC4": 14.751012226641155, + "CVC3": 12.962343040462478, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.052229930264183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.500168137600655 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12448842508436363, + "veriT": 0.092319725232390903, + "Yices": 0.095415701536440883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12236155694786363, + "CVC4": 0.12225823798063637, + "CVC3": 0.10073083605852727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11896233821950002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11757744464291818 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.099680708158422227, + "veriT": 0.073242060238672232, + "Yices": 0.075824001345827785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.098094975524327763, + "CVC4": 0.096807584977544436, + "CVC3": 0.076854786128977781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.096444300540827796, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.094693251266027775 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2845132495363583, + "veriT": 0.86330954360339984, + "Yices": 0.8837459566169692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3298856181247842, + "CVC4": 0.13073191118369232, + "CVC3": 1.189391667838255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1253195688676923, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2067527500475954 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.70500867068670769, + "veriT": 9.8066514909269653, + "Yices": 9.9847765045762404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.80127685751796152, + "CVC4": 0.15077614667357145, + "CVC3": 0.61031068999014282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14712272331750001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1301610987395971 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.19783330456616, + "veriT": 11.560895057138245, + "Yices": 12.476190204392603, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.222838709901918, + "CVC4": 11.575774154296951, + "CVC3": 10.828681904904329, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.384012797645697, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.122019262759128 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0714285373687744, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0321094375147162, + "veriT": 6.9978393192989294, + "Yices": 7.8871505031514957, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.747090689574363, + "CVC4": 3.8617186117619813, + "CVC3": 3.1661853617666669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6675575872350632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2493939358855801 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.692168352128942, + "veriT": 10.46816492002805, + "Yices": 10.296764539986198, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.313027665013866, + "CVC4": 1.4933715705879331, + "CVC3": 10.781389026373517, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.074382006608806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.661397218549752 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.821136945501623, + "veriT": 11.057777669624963, + "Yices": 10.629427190813889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.875693755261722, + "CVC4": 3.5037367260715877, + "CVC3": 10.591163987638335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1190162764859544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.844902029234149 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239660243720664, + "veriT": 10.154257233422944, + "Yices": 10.336449157461891, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963142713697774, + "CVC4": 0.15561307089200002, + "CVC3": 12.31935322726145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.77139303118036007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.337842044417176 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.679276663846546, + "veriT": 9.8299410875153352, + "Yices": 9.5355257705715601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.090688408277911, + "CVC4": 2.5448436009316073, + "CVC3": 8.3653142357630461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4893591224700029, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.271557699674883 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18886118124087498, + "veriT": 1.4427963363713749, + "Yices": 5.29949305520325, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0114375843928594, + "CVC4": 0.18205675697887497, + "CVC3": 0.28022727163037503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.238432050970415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3163679500955823 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.238944574796788, + "veriT": 11.319618239849945, + "Yices": 9.4189082181491077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.675636804476861, + "CVC4": 3.7537804660754963, + "CVC3": 11.905646451618514, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6604667136158913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.784303491682437 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1643183739599934, + "veriT": 11.068101760948831, + "Yices": 11.119757741898253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.240595506065253, + "CVC4": 6.3429033643683903, + "CVC3": 10.190222972141008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8126530015632092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.702453306408309 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16563281320227272, + "veriT": 4.8520684818875726, + "Yices": 7.5192471330602055, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.3272464110263637, + "CVC4": 3.0226245122790165, + "CVC3": 0.18015857697081816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7324053338008505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7639068655216863 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4585130214691162, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 159.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0801279544830322, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8907342470668178, + "veriT": 5.4302111801795014, + "Yices": 6.3509563948654542, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8867483389422728, + "CVC4": 5.349850674665757, + "CVC3": 2.9018499756850002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2989672538504324, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4849170945510251 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.359002551796503, + "veriT": 6.2380611953421754, + "Yices": 4.9004880713869055, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6932763776832269, + "CVC4": 3.2870405953351312, + "CVC3": 3.8461412452785115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6856015427852613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.684684095750443 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4193795770593267, + "veriT": 11.442879147457935, + "Yices": 9.1854334896715208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9352676318346376, + "CVC4": 12.166705477469627, + "CVC3": 10.569701830821472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.130555719839222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.140478240010751 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0972586882110207, + "veriT": 10.373560994120027, + "Yices": 10.418947922186668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6146865316715111, + "CVC4": 5.1155835363168016, + "CVC3": 6.2025368715765863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8096715297355885, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4038227310433626 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8867476995124211, + "veriT": 6.8744065965618093, + "Yices": 7.6722582836137416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3359168594638469, + "CVC4": 3.4780311633334899, + "CVC3": 8.9847757338101459, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3063704276572468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5477618910253295 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241323767222269, + "veriT": 10.163122789602999, + "Yices": 10.3372676439646, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959748268577624, + "CVC4": 0.18469529537159998, + "CVC3": 13.444647085093115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9896398532152229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.317380118742287 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4933769163955963, + "veriT": 3.5478029026445888, + "Yices": 8.2080025113205561, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1568008862436621, + "CVC4": 3.6949704998216109, + "CVC3": 2.6682590109856226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5524454383431703, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9500481710264284 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7592795626106827, + "veriT": 11.013081809249943, + "Yices": 10.457771562306299, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.329590881507958, + "CVC4": 10.774719910222258, + "CVC3": 4.9505187276129998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237247672559006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.227724592280238 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9602957958747997, + "veriT": 6.9337192605683429, + "Yices": 8.4318575212876006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0993444089903024, + "CVC4": 2.9582105953163937, + "CVC3": 2.9379631108425355, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12994531628702, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8757372012273201 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8887866889960119, + "veriT": 10.165263266167599, + "Yices": 11.277187110225137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.103083093543333, + "CVC4": 10.583231841473301, + "CVC3": 7.329828105150261, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230848711023018, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.442548513141235 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.972684834879022, + "veriT": 10.682824054296926, + "Yices": 11.188993983853123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4253737262015846, + "CVC4": 12.514823460869366, + "CVC3": 14.250915170551011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.543868198469662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.763916552734296 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.644117719044625, + "veriT": 3.1206121057507654, + "Yices": 3.1300785224808361, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8255461807361253, + "CVC4": 5.4567322922630037, + "CVC3": 1.372451483550875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.193181171454194, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1884885918603825 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4739943058123695, + "veriT": 5.9867415940776532, + "Yices": 8.4683438454880005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7952050440782434, + "CVC4": 2.8642369369390446, + "CVC3": 1.6161646495638053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4620916282736887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8474510966114659 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15614294259918182, + "veriT": 13.833746323973445, + "Yices": 0.11799080621381819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2481508172869091, + "CVC4": 2.9077514585916977, + "CVC3": 0.13065707006809091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8868688639647768, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8784359317342432 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3945034677238213, + "veriT": 12.503577090073215, + "Yices": 7.7423295376864685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8107887789176758, + "CVC4": 9.750713608098172, + "CVC3": 10.810747935149102, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6219795328330839, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1862397401352336 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.452876294510208, + "veriT": 12.16989124282482, + "Yices": 11.024493088533776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.768747741515361, + "CVC4": 5.0233715476614993, + "CVC3": 10.718475530479123, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4325582243180568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.071826612306038 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6174828143139113, + "veriT": 1.6797875779697926, + "Yices": 1.6967121359475383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.718743105536289, + "CVC4": 0.15447204523476923, + "CVC3": 0.29695150957244615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4575466342673846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1818044965305274 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2361111640930176, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6731710901317349, + "veriT": 7.6158661048096636, + "Yices": 10.536000392561249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9414028621053392, + "CVC4": 9.1521181629901669, + "CVC3": 4.4399351677273859, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2386872829129043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2692456730308788 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13293549253618181, + "veriT": 4.6543133282762277, + "Yices": 6.311950716036022, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13409498280536364, + "CVC4": 0.14058214830227275, + "CVC3": 0.12097140152915455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13601883429299999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13272933121181818 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1623375415802002, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16427227054900001, + "veriT": 0.25900590930989997, + "Yices": 0.14858117024568002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.47599075551059994, + "CVC4": 0.16657527910470002, + "CVC3": 0.1627025452277, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16092913403210002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15701092527089999 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18127105884199998, + "veriT": 0.15719451970680001, + "Yices": 6.9787410734026638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18146300802159998, + "CVC4": 0.18519087779279997, + "CVC3": 0.16706023051239999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17867953955419999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18255253433340002 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6987292091796826, + "veriT": 9.8802196891431571, + "Yices": 12.296851560043736, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6127453061926431, + "CVC4": 14.519013382452268, + "CVC3": 11.272674254493623, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.338549190417496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.3356146349253 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5522798792044776, + "veriT": 8.3220995774054654, + "Yices": 9.9618964387242919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7633270209991903, + "CVC4": 2.3114914377232125, + "CVC3": 3.6982260767275301, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.433736642996855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.507696612984995 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1733336448669434, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24140743734529999, + "veriT": 6.0338941704979785, + "Yices": 9.4917920303570202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.912064185728938, + "CVC4": 0.23177432229640002, + "CVC3": 3.6614953187882358, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6223464545755157, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6184256163894168 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26487557878014284, + "veriT": 5.9318280929453673, + "Yices": 3.6389319964033504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7182785398078573, + "CVC4": 8.3815655897032091, + "CVC3": 5.525437563217567, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3505682936817438, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4932044418947168 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0173161029815674, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.70988252245544436, + "veriT": 0.12371490586672221, + "Yices": 0.91172655087086574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.71213261702161113, + "CVC4": 0.16997818257427777, + "CVC3": 0.14872191112044442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.6577805684550001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.65352698004755572 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13138990042166668, + "veriT": 9.5179326377989106, + "Yices": 2.1854339527391002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16214690058149997, + "CVC4": 2.6324785244813933, + "CVC3": 0.13465507252303333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15167447784246668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15153757987890001 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7182516310033542, + "veriT": 4.2913695139228984, + "Yices": 12.183722336410899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1115833536723936, + "CVC4": 0.42620768821680005, + "CVC3": 1.8433075210977432, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3910757701210947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3939185184358163 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8285510976545272, + "veriT": 11.431213925021092, + "Yices": 6.1591793028396937, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3993687783135593, + "CVC4": 4.347816624589842, + "CVC3": 7.6328315425410542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1795673727989655, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.18447062018023 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.326720967114996, + "veriT": 12.388090936560166, + "Yices": 9.0419192196459353, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8302633186826327, + "CVC4": 10.883914223614777, + "CVC3": 5.2417106891115575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.706232305211847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.956715664970869 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1892039023105063, + "veriT": 11.951333618534251, + "Yices": 10.566088230283832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2623241385378847, + "CVC4": 10.642655283664039, + "CVC3": 7.2686471538890052, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.898474518895135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.472720566099952 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0681022879144999, + "veriT": 6.6496451440149373, + "Yices": 6.6442162896606174, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7556835374146251, + "CVC4": 3.9333465592919614, + "CVC3": 1.9500662465747367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8013151388580591, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7584586701443294 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.416271605159027, + "veriT": 11.14548412553523, + "Yices": 10.678163293687554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.217917735218693, + "CVC4": 14.343188848637313, + "CVC3": 13.78696535928904, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.266595845256806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.030674429548482 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8285713195800781, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6375326437976667, + "veriT": 11.488034561965556, + "Yices": 5.547376097881104, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6118957030987637, + "CVC4": 11.457139517074211, + "CVC3": 5.5597205676096362, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.143914661895431, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.549038664627528 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.556373336891836, + "veriT": 10.18066190791663, + "Yices": 13.129232357812851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7209807644028388, + "CVC4": 13.525195758136514, + "CVC3": 11.377970607907338, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6706878025351219, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6894490368161126 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3304628220007593, + "veriT": 3.6896592502951555, + "Yices": 13.803913519668527, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3426311307211041, + "CVC4": 12.141014711553472, + "CVC3": 12.92294446860935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1782815414805254, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.160165358268916 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13950082063654545, + "veriT": 0.11489232321730002, + "Yices": 0.12887656589263635, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13423447640973638, + "CVC4": 0.15080081580761817, + "CVC3": 0.13232254876927271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14854849917219093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14935047745140909 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1582774754240909, + "veriT": 5.254977451618843, + "Yices": 0.16268526118381818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18464447691309091, + "CVC4": 0.19441883628390907, + "CVC3": 0.6090384540513637, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16879646905045453, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17040853810536363 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.029400820117206, + "veriT": 2.3350192374395817, + "Yices": 1.060482865122091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9957908937316882, + "CVC4": 4.1039315083884, + "CVC3": 1.4414266465799408, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4464127888723424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4461146114587839 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9931974411010742, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236201960760638, + "veriT": 10.482626608199453, + "Yices": 11.232856344188145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953906567721097, + "CVC4": 14.051375140843971, + "CVC3": 11.981006929567364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.971347800831126, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.032706311367795 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3663245418598731, + "veriT": 10.563642960116221, + "Yices": 9.8294054896225855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.033491229382886, + "CVC4": 8.4852146412298186, + "CVC3": 5.6122139292732145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0949689602210961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.669187040239188 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 72.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7784638507330404, + "veriT": 12.865681305729908, + "Yices": 7.7767955219418203, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1389267344287948, + "CVC4": 3.0695347988704254, + "CVC3": 5.5011872976365224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.966855998403089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.963526520481485 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0922826664766836, + "veriT": 13.072711784208396, + "Yices": 13.668906089699021, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2836081996721465, + "CVC4": 12.833002090864047, + "CVC3": 9.9947858517724448, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.137223939202865, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.110178455612475 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.542016223709666, + "veriT": 14.213549389750691, + "Yices": 11.979381318688455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.939280844364356, + "CVC4": 14.613018318672216, + "CVC3": 14.215200135984579, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243076992216151, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236497436979455 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1173825263977051, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3281833867053123, + "veriT": 12.068953461548313, + "Yices": 8.9588804650270273, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4173524713353718, + "CVC4": 0.260733763856625, + "CVC3": 0.45937408374125005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20599612612087501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1988878354925 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2638700869742501, + "veriT": 13.209844595880654, + "Yices": 6.1861496685319217, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3015515959907971, + "CVC4": 0.40359218161474997, + "CVC3": 2.7621498819576247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7088585957681972, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7028919637295239 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24345409211106, + "veriT": 11.525665390779126, + "Yices": 10.430210333382709, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962094868614306, + "CVC4": 14.38763856372176, + "CVC3": 13.544866725228138, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.863649709413822, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.779436943701844 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2734309146386442, + "veriT": 7.1379317142289453, + "Yices": 7.4087853234684911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0848317812882611, + "CVC4": 6.9758681028346654, + "CVC3": 4.5029488441787153, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0531316373506341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0856588033865155 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2402715521419285, + "veriT": 14.236195183733194, + "Yices": 7.4394168560655816, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8025947395894355, + "CVC4": 12.635129001667163, + "CVC3": 9.2516258500965503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.733291350516167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.737862077585515 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 284.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.84442241983788, + "veriT": 12.599663982363564, + "Yices": 13.415581245268873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.486698222693215, + "CVC4": 14.431865574341671, + "CVC3": 13.567044287870781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.155187919009817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.094669054476594 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1070196033136659, + "veriT": 11.203504295967923, + "Yices": 13.355813812597832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.770981107097048, + "CVC4": 13.695751789295144, + "CVC3": 14.177288486276982, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0264043319064662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8253603493320978 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1493240202088462, + "veriT": 10.823774867321593, + "Yices": 9.9106424497703642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.982084904792075, + "CVC4": 7.5529094089451148, + "CVC3": 7.3800336213437321, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.118662357113394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.086660043923898 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 90.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.052329923097743, + "veriT": 11.578904768038839, + "Yices": 11.713611317900062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.992965887422868, + "CVC4": 14.552290586452239, + "CVC3": 9.7737618330001208, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.276542859658754, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6967798609754183 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.845082608283324, + "veriT": 12.628443172997077, + "Yices": 13.50677209787192, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.301337937740653, + "CVC4": 14.71438435390661, + "CVC3": 13.942963665344536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.180359652932305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.119687005896802 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 129.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3122297053972858, + "veriT": 13.645477531985943, + "Yices": 13.372009907340626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.246950599271912, + "CVC4": 14.577139829493117, + "CVC3": 9.3914450110732854, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.133463332964029, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.141608992960309 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.40156594414966, + "veriT": 13.547769756697653, + "Yices": 13.913533811398745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.131333599219374, + "CVC4": 14.301188208303879, + "CVC3": 12.664934353254543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.220516560930593, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.212829465638194 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0222065324007534, + "veriT": 12.329278786526698, + "Yices": 13.015090083337475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.28609716783091, + "CVC4": 14.655960885610163, + "CVC3": 15.310644111829461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251842651791819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.29755121051455 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 207.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.253037915752691, + "veriT": 14.230180855193817, + "Yices": 14.234695618394253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953193406323424, + "CVC4": 10.734123744064096, + "CVC3": 12.735431058261055, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3382613885330636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.386590588196464 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26259385287438, + "veriT": 13.54359690196444, + "Yices": 14.11202602443851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.490094747274487, + "CVC4": 14.710353622711398, + "CVC3": 11.066752934878501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.954814579793153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.269974034725374 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13289850824730001, + "veriT": 0.86494997599986156, + "Yices": 0.8672375939097654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14284642840736922, + "CVC4": 1.2071239522025889, + "CVC3": 0.099534645772488453, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2030367610186015, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2015122690175022 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5966980031066, + "veriT": 0.08645088000361853, + "Yices": 0.088910372182766664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5959477579396519, + "CVC4": 0.11295438609094072, + "CVC3": 0.092747467809729645, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11155235527613332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10883630163357406 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0011842260795198, + "veriT": 8.2318643955802422, + "Yices": 8.8005625381538621, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4394726808197795, + "CVC4": 7.3290848774541546, + "CVC3": 5.4813840045223596, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9679224280365915, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.506558493311867 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20883902928671996, + "veriT": 10.16591967760292, + "Yices": 10.3485759593136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26484072169459999, + "CVC4": 0.15086376012768002, + "CVC3": 0.72092650125495994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14938231705792002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.435708175589655 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14895955641566669, + "veriT": 2.6159726939248333, + "Yices": 7.4314673919650005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20573891348141668, + "CVC4": 0.13793956843300001, + "CVC3": 0.16418870814717498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13613460122241663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4036040435817574 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.07543365222871, + "veriT": 13.832989342090677, + "Yices": 12.109564705145369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.945555353892393, + "CVC4": 13.011107683356913, + "CVC3": 11.014355285875029, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.126991414412027, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.164117512518549 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.41428542137146, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8869001026377328, + "veriT": 9.0514379540507761, + "Yices": 10.308794088829556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.857123312234023, + "CVC4": 0.15958529134799998, + "CVC3": 1.289524645407778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6865607546340269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.120405047787468 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241154695393483, + "veriT": 10.181482054390127, + "Yices": 10.330144690757001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954943836930557, + "CVC4": 0.15909495924637501, + "CVC3": 7.7367327685786531, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8429055579033875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.270058038823793 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245849434484146, + "veriT": 10.166466641788332, + "Yices": 10.32658244682178, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952886570426895, + "CVC4": 0.16929322742, + "CVC3": 13.339361615739939, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.527517469927933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.244548028840269 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.902216993418287, + "veriT": 10.1593279051009, + "Yices": 10.269183659081, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956499009335479, + "CVC4": 6.5273970385771847, + "CVC3": 10.141146475887769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2343795197170655, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7757295808713192 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.563104088655491, + "veriT": 10.838068942027805, + "Yices": 10.574911271079001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.157881557434232, + "CVC4": 2.6284206038074402, + "CVC3": 10.564166451606665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4947994480319386, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.771959623526422 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.975933913907866, + "veriT": 10.154689024883002, + "Yices": 10.330403304767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.949474880828586, + "CVC4": 0.17433644534679998, + "CVC3": 10.617155648047714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15147386578259997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.139432647866101 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4925527157176859, + "veriT": 11.207483614016249, + "Yices": 6.1576746852909308, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0443534733034543, + "CVC4": 4.3291097655707835, + "CVC3": 4.8260350306824549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5503530408998563, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.911563096741757 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9522480537723181, + "veriT": 5.4403916711560214, + "Yices": 3.4354064405195111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7653473328764067, + "CVC4": 5.0143288879579995, + "CVC3": 3.2287262117200659, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8024868141440429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2506959003733313 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.023728408463688, + "veriT": 9.8523250718813955, + "Yices": 7.8250620276880358, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3321027979803262, + "CVC4": 5.1184536321887544, + "CVC3": 4.3804397083397717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17707972225991428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4820165145716637 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.189117662750094, + "veriT": 13.089637798265455, + "Yices": 12.874617820863886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.647071313156296, + "CVC4": 14.734114413885315, + "CVC3": 15.594156549367627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.113031530053451, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.108984044525823 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5773810148239136, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240238923682895, + "veriT": 10.575514856997724, + "Yices": 10.475988789275501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960827488286327, + "CVC4": 1.596141488794911, + "CVC3": 11.215664560058785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7988270164964044, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.584354082849865 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14126840075018182, + "veriT": 4.6571827036393083, + "Yices": 6.5085362729205087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.136088544088, + "CVC4": 3.9921796622264862, + "CVC3": 0.14261494644345457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6953754836922585, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13563506996863636 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.498572480987603, + "veriT": 9.2216021025417412, + "Yices": 8.9337102498695788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.806892028663254, + "CVC4": 4.5847368875292878, + "CVC3": 10.975504358325635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7050125396006841, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.291563834227041 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.131879032003, + "veriT": 5.2261776919469245, + "Yices": 5.0999966634635996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24683028000287502, + "CVC4": 2.1076160495294487, + "CVC3": 0.12693608303830001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3874578331158247, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4566062725233904 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3689841056904708, + "veriT": 7.3924595002535147, + "Yices": 3.8885609239183752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5163869015289624, + "CVC4": 0.15670356686012499, + "CVC3": 1.001167400884325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4204534140484002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4197610982967257 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1483516693115234, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4680083493799962, + "veriT": 7.4289904974069776, + "Yices": 5.9784226509260545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8657945307422081, + "CVC4": 1.4363042176994552, + "CVC3": 2.833852812011536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4333288697877642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4260807238070474 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.601728073690783, + "veriT": 9.3707279104110945, + "Yices": 8.5153807285029313, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.54894605968413, + "CVC4": 1.6417951445208607, + "CVC3": 10.822453492533914, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.194537386241497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9590015922246682 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1534937908979934, + "veriT": 13.176358862687474, + "Yices": 10.41868711131885, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4790622445543953, + "CVC4": 14.019213099043665, + "CVC3": 6.9463120584348435, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.728158182617888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.729510366204529 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6064367411135301, + "veriT": 8.4006911417200953, + "Yices": 7.0691786243437846, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4096243776826913, + "CVC4": 6.1447358917189989, + "CVC3": 4.8592567654224714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3529107567443441, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3752501024126111 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1016160964179535, + "veriT": 9.3256188643612195, + "Yices": 5.8837447965202907, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3551590108895093, + "CVC4": 8.5866754073739795, + "CVC3": 7.0976659750840101, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8860755674373966, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8061138002487152 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.33315011412022, + "veriT": 5.3897759677591939, + "Yices": 5.1708822009029003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6552785748692838, + "CVC4": 1.5882341945152658, + "CVC3": 1.5661304450447218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5741813135596086, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3048928469286225 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.145656031898, + "veriT": 0.12404101311491667, + "Yices": 0.12992605463568332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14670953384025001, + "CVC4": 0.14502897589099997, + "CVC3": 0.13523536020466667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14343193653758335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14073709518791666 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1241946515303001, + "veriT": 4.3415105141930717, + "Yices": 8.1315266356882514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1204238353703002, + "CVC4": 1.5432795142486624, + "CVC3": 2.1406229838030599, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5357362820954754, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.534222263634387 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5463566964805557, + "veriT": 8.9858622045735377, + "Yices": 12.204599439698733, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6582920830471113, + "CVC4": 9.7516697666721512, + "CVC3": 9.8124159683480645, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.006642016115682, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.061963923506063 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.171927142170921, + "veriT": 14.196496719981072, + "Yices": 7.9456477964003538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.947795012269449, + "CVC4": 14.540118034255508, + "CVC3": 13.236681894364349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.211719881723218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.207283571347974 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.892844848026186, + "veriT": 8.0353457317887109, + "Yices": 9.8759650820019509, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.490165237038347, + "CVC4": 5.0874441166410831, + "CVC3": 11.321865746927728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2198127064156923, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0862895518586111 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3372799585956359, + "veriT": 9.8891084847778341, + "Yices": 11.230898691935634, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1211930061194755, + "CVC4": 12.256330841479118, + "CVC3": 7.1858810124292516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8526711053659124, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3995523128256533 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5959270191579176, + "veriT": 8.0083426657916892, + "Yices": 5.9178083719268635, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.180887047617576, + "CVC4": 3.5955525448913241, + "CVC3": 0.23249339411223074, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4122824277235089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4617678529329332 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21037404212666669, + "veriT": 0.13230238545197998, + "Yices": 2.0243709949800546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.36963012209113338, + "CVC4": 0.19492347796846668, + "CVC3": 1.5381699480955999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16979560426086668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16526880434806668 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0671207450540003, + "veriT": 9.9705280168094195, + "Yices": 5.3170810858812843, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6043455193290823, + "CVC4": 4.0899805060824859, + "CVC3": 0.21255953778900002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9080874615232597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9067018214469191 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1920356289808325, + "veriT": 11.155993328749849, + "Yices": 14.780415766148538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4979692504912467, + "CVC4": 0.23155026686857141, + "CVC3": 12.048069132474966, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9176187932774735, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5707750269069027 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.700054977965973, + "veriT": 12.206851906844621, + "Yices": 13.1985681803283, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.769683915785935, + "CVC4": 7.9050220642410434, + "CVC3": 11.702840905183129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.839482666676442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.798766755790865 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.36190257073744442, + "veriT": 5.701050232733345, + "Yices": 5.7797927444576001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4098153072996391, + "CVC4": 4.8618225250224576, + "CVC3": 0.6276601561837778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3148120041683864, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2424421297291515 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7025474139182979, + "veriT": 9.5976309957411559, + "Yices": 9.5981972489989626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.542422747568176, + "CVC4": 12.92758240900921, + "CVC3": 7.5545930842848561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.838989865953881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.026909397978113 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4337975345220446, + "veriT": 6.6633302806125787, + "Yices": 3.6625378066611249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1763187337079586, + "CVC4": 0.19529626763225, + "CVC3": 3.5375171676954729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1960553014438524, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.588986386909772 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3760094864847776, + "veriT": 1.6863379954068156, + "Yices": 4.7969221052177708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4493800905216667, + "CVC4": 6.482050385523551, + "CVC3": 0.15847043535800001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14649051978933336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14575220188466667 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0037050327444286, + "veriT": 14.211156401587136, + "Yices": 0.19562984503285716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0515997870566429, + "CVC4": 0.18071459982271429, + "CVC3": 0.1337360921995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.886632484440556, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.898072975794028 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6452729871107654, + "veriT": 13.540255211511697, + "Yices": 11.227731057008308, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6944195674146911, + "CVC4": 12.680613016965999, + "CVC3": 13.344791551614792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.648927856955174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.072915697638058 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6778176911091336, + "veriT": 10.838226721115857, + "Yices": 6.5645594653474122, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3174181322080933, + "CVC4": 3.9576030031750684, + "CVC3": 3.328455439167632, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8339134944670672, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8322790887756017 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6764299397105749, + "veriT": 12.202929469060887, + "Yices": 10.996848656835864, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.531236496445121, + "CVC4": 12.163907775172438, + "CVC3": 14.241423382339459, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.145473063298581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.482481280743194 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6992064714431763, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3336656635675563, + "veriT": 10.221965643224285, + "Yices": 10.360776883468144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.466372047265908, + "CVC4": 10.34666371589544, + "CVC3": 10.429325100730926, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.283774052140288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.822428164786512 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 47.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.179543502675763, + "veriT": 6.1118504959211295, + "Yices": 6.1325325531693995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5400318375104085, + "CVC4": 5.8174429763047284, + "CVC3": 2.9556993668754172, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6650250098936228, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3813604289214325 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 74.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.01586661750775, + "veriT": 0.16387306950175001, + "Yices": 0.25224130942466666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0303664653405835, + "CVC4": 1.3796543314062457, + "CVC3": 0.19799469189341665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18528088094341666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18973854980166668 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9989160299301147, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1085616707469, + "veriT": 6.847065201291163, + "Yices": 5.0838144757169754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12229196805526249, + "CVC4": 8.9754907839807565, + "CVC3": 3.6282242748752416, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11946051730153751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11772258399277501 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24528626266522224, + "veriT": 1.3424695208461113, + "Yices": 12.706485522004819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.43517711196622222, + "CVC4": 0.25001039235922223, + "CVC3": 1.8019314360238734, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7939626673907132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7931321342189095 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1185976314493784, + "veriT": 10.662624468648216, + "Yices": 8.6506510284764566, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2179297702216694, + "CVC4": 0.12685476720702857, + "CVC3": 3.0547218008672146, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3378619727557668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3794613540328102 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 34.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14616951926916666, + "veriT": 4.8164944882361187, + "Yices": 0.15296634670333334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15322967993583334, + "CVC4": 0.16422371282666667, + "CVC3": 0.14458320352983331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15238434141483334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15549860435499999 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16111052668320003, + "veriT": 0.13768381211866668, + "Yices": 0.15281583985819999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16559822293246668, + "CVC4": 0.18655083190393332, + "CVC3": 0.16371326956393331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17450483117326668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17389984272 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4452686890117139, + "veriT": 0.14228261733657141, + "Yices": 0.14802016231728571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4478759404637147, + "CVC4": 2.1919504872001605, + "CVC3": 0.14754773097271426, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15969397748200001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16167580425714287 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 78.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21518710531100002, + "veriT": 8.184611382820389, + "Yices": 2.5170768792698213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.33600562733, + "CVC4": 9.6196839739213917, + "CVC3": 8.6243604002336642, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4301420369370206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2615851670842302 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4711898513661268, + "veriT": 9.0093037932007629, + "Yices": 11.013976460743976, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1340596426957301, + "CVC4": 14.461721546185091, + "CVC3": 9.0449073550437316, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1595288124652603, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1198975969296083 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.90904119805837502, + "veriT": 10.114175392512644, + "Yices": 8.4513852559626539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1463440406624432, + "CVC4": 2.0270154980988746, + "CVC3": 0.50717867774449998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7243258671211912, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6651054687004549 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.931096076965332, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6504395008087158, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6731498894828523, + "veriT": 11.145304674957766, + "Yices": 8.1193151365923839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7587747881047733, + "CVC4": 7.5499172589243839, + "CVC3": 6.2605415672861762, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8425840137761273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.831195559849899 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7629940509796143, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.898274042737205, + "veriT": 14.014121601835893, + "Yices": 12.589210737354664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.01675959340599, + "CVC4": 12.760883441593057, + "CVC3": 14.029418925374788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254026062246371, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.096442663705394 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 141.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3582428962247146, + "veriT": 12.696740708534056, + "Yices": 12.629184586818692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.588181094618273, + "CVC4": 12.530739927086348, + "CVC3": 11.68489036611733, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.202491436876411, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.169993333141775 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.329293763233585, + "veriT": 13.831369545920614, + "Yices": 13.191531703243001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.006248208465768, + "CVC4": 14.410617275278062, + "CVC3": 12.968361583309976, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246032035871389, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.956987670949578 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.994196577265473, + "veriT": 12.060424396150466, + "Yices": 11.663415696702035, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.051048007220528, + "CVC4": 14.560122026832998, + "CVC3": 14.084451590694147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.185514914813032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.169449608642084 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7438766955799618, + "veriT": 13.731198792281527, + "Yices": 13.760985567334652, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2190528088786374, + "CVC4": 14.405373715067082, + "CVC3": 11.523132831069265, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240022182170815, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238072644389467 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6080512116262469, + "veriT": 13.037748954453491, + "Yices": 13.091673283253039, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.500884607774822, + "CVC4": 13.417295163889642, + "CVC3": 8.8831795914424045, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.794696701530821, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5285269120220049 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 280.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 29.0, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 76.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 66.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1495360242355606, + "veriT": 12.152712663576747, + "Yices": 11.665175264248216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.288653536254309, + "CVC4": 13.14654279435473, + "CVC3": 8.9769292684242785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.93841553697176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.93052675850997 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7885604423832713, + "veriT": 9.0842091684731443, + "Yices": 2.1007243853686668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7134387214627727, + "CVC4": 4.8791906204551454, + "CVC3": 7.3422183434213935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8498599842081838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5502068630918835 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 150.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6626482571343448, + "veriT": 12.203112542049194, + "Yices": 12.644349350646598, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.518633696356043, + "CVC4": 11.685851718602171, + "CVC3": 5.9467146308570893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.111010997862689, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.451023883669118 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.143306767605852, + "veriT": 12.179779980938777, + "Yices": 11.409822704621565, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.660429630603577, + "CVC4": 14.645629126812768, + "CVC3": 12.256813954322405, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.769286943167319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.680687587763934 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.718128746688107, + "veriT": 11.340496657689467, + "Yices": 5.9906844648807711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2124632157034698, + "CVC4": 1.8407568769418121, + "CVC3": 2.7292886174934998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7519911636219996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5967210949366855 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 243.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.76880836579653333, + "veriT": 9.8252668541869674, + "Yices": 10.244763840035999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5685263467134907, + "CVC4": 11.479483058635831, + "CVC3": 7.4558901346041688, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.107153098650081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1092724548185153 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 167.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8693780037518768, + "veriT": 12.33171168968865, + "Yices": 11.488541421569924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.845581476937792, + "CVC4": 6.8231591055336747, + "CVC3": 14.268494986212527, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7708392004241091, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7791543327393082 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.020036017795297, + "veriT": 13.419270646351043, + "Yices": 14.232960541121148, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.938036038907731, + "CVC4": 14.342387712876393, + "CVC3": 13.645565677146596, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0670167633562269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9838175101910807 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.726973494725073, + "veriT": 10.450272059183479, + "Yices": 11.507454095165091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.300892399199164, + "CVC4": 12.53174690780936, + "CVC3": 11.161085976003463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.944841067722383, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.973789988604155 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "false": 151, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 101.5, + "true": 150 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.255894681269814, + "veriT": 11.227254000918199, + "Yices": 13.507955896387047, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974440607100419, + "CVC4": 14.3030643596842, + "CVC3": 13.882410927415734, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.972522789971299, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.267904123026383 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.097085312739617, + "veriT": 13.75279326833479, + "Yices": 13.900426166972995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979544254030811, + "CVC4": 14.664012920865735, + "CVC3": 12.696917032655566, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.262549008033711, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.876573679862792 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.636924279327058, + "veriT": 14.250044538106476, + "Yices": 14.304504914241912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.644493767490102, + "CVC4": 12.677334571917951, + "CVC3": 9.2341933963758791, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0858947155326515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6655722935419757 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11760645910574287, + "veriT": 0.5622707137485714, + "Yices": 0.56626450600224765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12548646396114763, + "CVC4": 0.78196295907483593, + "CVC3": 0.090853385668071426, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.77916867425422476, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.77820990304334414 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1247936918817826, + "veriT": 0.097662698243304383, + "Yices": 0.099880093857491317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12269155569173913, + "CVC4": 0.12302388002830435, + "CVC3": 0.10423974860946085, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12181265324247825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12121752263475653 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7955136401233327, + "veriT": 0.097672002439950001, + "Yices": 0.098880104578333336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7884472643349989, + "CVC4": 0.13816800718583333, + "CVC3": 0.11061440319685001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12807148169499999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13327614284266667 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.70759595804899333, + "veriT": 9.804840395824856, + "Yices": 10.393426394616895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.79398619771874734, + "CVC4": 0.14976944921246424, + "CVC3": 0.63209656395646441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14988607239324997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.076891528758267 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7638890743255615, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2186233808857327, + "veriT": 5.8869675650476854, + "Yices": 7.413937724357142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0512302026070648, + "CVC4": 0.15375680673814288, + "CVC3": 4.8568334095811423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15105211981528571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1656031011251322 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5982145071029663, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235685989500444, + "veriT": 10.151852289194915, + "Yices": 10.311009523948917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.9502078460023, + "CVC4": 0.29974701745566668, + "CVC3": 11.368090547990841, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5892021799789218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.219640700664266 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.73105426236758, + "veriT": 10.668401219365228, + "Yices": 10.520975141666876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.35637598179227, + "CVC4": 2.0083135326099559, + "CVC3": 10.564999193780499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.905250996077954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.631040415547703 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235601824279899, + "veriT": 10.151055989958778, + "Yices": 10.328420011433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960860900278014, + "CVC4": 0.16348950065544443, + "CVC3": 14.237765614713702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14388407824011107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.609899085363599 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.332935699481197, + "veriT": 8.3794081091751096, + "Yices": 10.051446052744133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.357933601558001, + "CVC4": 0.16218084111011111, + "CVC3": 11.733270819054013, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20280357710566665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5371604354084605 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.499568030192581, + "veriT": 8.9134982219809373, + "Yices": 10.338562860238625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.13270978761788, + "CVC4": 0.17281903533774998, + "CVC3": 12.246110075442232, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.686179148215242, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.311625201419453 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.777125787203991, + "veriT": 10.623422134509754, + "Yices": 10.429057599524445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.415182739534199, + "CVC4": 1.8024935211997617, + "CVC3": 8.9428444575022414, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.537319087612147, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.593793759319741 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7361317035367732, + "veriT": 8.1508767349228997, + "Yices": 8.2433673561227998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.995577406664728, + "CVC4": 3.8267232383005925, + "CVC3": 10.103712258039959, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6928675790999659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1996431151146858 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6104381065521247, + "veriT": 13.185210443849442, + "Yices": 11.11170471691274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6021496128359756, + "CVC4": 11.653209969724236, + "CVC3": 7.8896744351511252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.680029589955709, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.677946697576157 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14505139710281428, + "veriT": 4.4046204334940287, + "Yices": 9.3482350145246755, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17162586329771429, + "CVC4": 6.3343095149283455, + "CVC3": 2.1484345269084062, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1983014669278349, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17462047977318568 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1519296418334073, + "veriT": 7.2841640002478556, + "Yices": 3.9985827694364886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6991051925941196, + "CVC4": 2.2327187882046782, + "CVC3": 4.5787439837877182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.349022986263841, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.330656260793126 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.170655416426948, + "veriT": 11.447223534878125, + "Yices": 10.948748349801416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3492877369393561, + "CVC4": 8.802905361780736, + "CVC3": 11.120333742868748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.616078583032143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.90731218517926 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4485914667460948, + "veriT": 1.428582099980209, + "Yices": 6.9876858086506752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1842501112656363, + "CVC4": 9.1998189285899841, + "CVC3": 1.4594567324415799, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1206673561559182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.501540040545754 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4499503193875514, + "veriT": 4.9470461545195574, + "Yices": 2.9301056077604137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2144027927855792, + "CVC4": 2.3812006507818064, + "CVC3": 2.0954850081738998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1270509682749923, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1265808677349831 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5751805202053717, + "veriT": 9.0022470565056967, + "Yices": 9.5380518452053273, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7760927725105793, + "CVC4": 8.509575866955716, + "CVC3": 8.6021673699058105, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1122049076311846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0786273252325209 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13441802731309999, + "veriT": 0.11276215075618001, + "Yices": 0.11520633205787001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12981850874456999, + "CVC4": 0.13159019828720003, + "CVC3": 0.12494548633781999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12871927302479999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12545271771127003 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5366953733639495, + "veriT": 11.921402685207534, + "Yices": 9.8594304415201446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.026807750613823, + "CVC4": 12.041304255113895, + "CVC3": 11.859766686001599, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5321414327057301, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5415380969968968 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7008773295544017, + "veriT": 12.479678153242171, + "Yices": 10.888721837383313, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8308075411000448, + "CVC4": 9.5692388131529231, + "CVC3": 4.6548284085155416, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.940589444203054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.951954180105965 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4686999187068461, + "veriT": 4.9341465395932964, + "Yices": 2.7900173972208702, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7389326948266923, + "CVC4": 0.16087867865538463, + "CVC3": 0.94021963546835385, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3108318207351166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0884016676361692 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1088167809319192, + "veriT": 7.7877985330018422, + "Yices": 7.5037477928123586, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8179056552721233, + "CVC4": 4.1484232709495652, + "CVC3": 4.1217599751438261, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8591785172284467, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8793604443506986 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1666665077209473, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239482356402975, + "veriT": 10.160710501792286, + "Yices": 10.339195061383142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955809812357362, + "CVC4": 0.38195767738557146, + "CVC3": 11.514901474228918, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.209935324760524, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.297038084285301 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1335646725876005, + "veriT": 8.5706646492351783, + "Yices": 8.8049397627861516, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1504601149698406, + "CVC4": 8.8831706862149939, + "CVC3": 7.0258348300044116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7869664954520985, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.780298445479735 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.96293135182083, + "veriT": 10.664639836458621, + "Yices": 10.602572194408163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.209093073976648, + "CVC4": 6.996813987124253, + "CVC3": 7.9317829066043739, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5454527412667485, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.942057672267685 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8270460128697272, + "veriT": 7.9530389645902391, + "Yices": 8.2842957660705689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0173088669476593, + "CVC4": 8.3291744243060251, + "CVC3": 9.4602742272615927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7458406120156091, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7476592851528681 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3570554545805882, + "veriT": 4.9074685805390716, + "Yices": 6.5221607968450446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6840411402912705, + "CVC4": 3.4899360765397138, + "CVC3": 0.14261950379988234, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2038487598471353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18144165284741182 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6265744056807812, + "veriT": 6.5986446468804001, + "Yices": 8.4525889352417991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.112950821230385, + "CVC4": 0.1809836249382, + "CVC3": 9.4291157428339396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3895032794047655, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8691880882912812 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.533316625976501, + "veriT": 12.040130016173814, + "Yices": 10.039338092458236, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3292278223540706, + "CVC4": 12.552613259890897, + "CVC3": 9.6339218607585551, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3242875371068337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1730853377325303 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1361285093065994, + "veriT": 2.5228921496724217, + "Yices": 3.2463510011093959, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1337393492536005, + "CVC4": 4.3925043799567209, + "CVC3": 2.7286797715609779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.775339211506056, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7712686331552296 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21340168930564282, + "veriT": 1.1375857570698291, + "Yices": 3.0361711207575803, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.38438774836936435, + "CVC4": 2.2132661662207034, + "CVC3": 2.3646534473531147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16621373049064284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16454647212107143 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0488577643516797, + "veriT": 10.761570741465832, + "Yices": 9.5863707561838574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.041986562276616, + "CVC4": 0.63475258737783335, + "CVC3": 0.48697589109916667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0239123555511185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.471035556558327 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9315704374910005, + "veriT": 8.7664112060118597, + "Yices": 8.2728551251246163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5904944504626668, + "CVC4": 12.962178148010153, + "CVC3": 4.9251556061155304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7555609094033073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7573797829054101 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0037762326328332, + "veriT": 9.5406085357717973, + "Yices": 13.075680812416264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8355104770650001, + "CVC4": 13.384250260411507, + "CVC3": 12.610678070843845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.621749776794575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.624814493305458 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6894794702529907, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.821232091534895, + "veriT": 11.465597218655441, + "Yices": 12.486823749077374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.464642365791807, + "CVC4": 2.1842206969525568, + "CVC3": 12.707882870505536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7449243273216553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.010898684697796 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.253093058897354, + "veriT": 10.16145428368425, + "Yices": 11.034472701570129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.688247819460068, + "CVC4": 10.966773288435251, + "CVC3": 12.01529143490054, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.936652148172376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.334042852936046 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2433768386225084, + "veriT": 10.187172120441112, + "Yices": 10.352658010971778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.62318570992881, + "CVC4": 14.276874844350914, + "CVC3": 3.4514913220209209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.2637981839496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.19896612109366 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6322445380148562, + "veriT": 10.541604402853578, + "Yices": 10.602201505153419, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8551552871111365, + "CVC4": 9.8563671434197229, + "CVC3": 3.6400737520603168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.036175270101756, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.044527145227699 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5692740508834895, + "veriT": 12.409883027390403, + "Yices": 12.064399033248765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.284877657020802, + "CVC4": 10.204465662555309, + "CVC3": 11.11913186201938, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232517431265336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.536724188776411 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13633000902963635, + "veriT": 14.208086816214109, + "Yices": 0.27128892750072731, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17704852778881819, + "CVC4": 1.5134839394299853, + "CVC3": 0.14918297889836366, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.779678552452806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.829530137413467 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 61.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2083095013248748, + "veriT": 12.691711005275799, + "Yices": 11.015951295302271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5939207954247658, + "CVC4": 9.3789834409784749, + "CVC3": 11.821182755217345, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1064463935626847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1571783618613445 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3098844556157565, + "veriT": 9.8893951230311643, + "Yices": 3.8823274784754953, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8164274587181235, + "CVC4": 4.3410669565861708, + "CVC3": 1.423136264868516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1748029667201205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.174537798168112 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.832622300536126, + "veriT": 14.223901227207683, + "Yices": 9.3327262369774111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.262009646766586, + "CVC4": 5.7681961106535704, + "CVC3": 9.3046328624074146, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.124602333456334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.091187581512431 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8020085096359253, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0790293846047341, + "veriT": 10.197035868978, + "Yices": 10.828445667801482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.382856861533563, + "CVC4": 10.822893471622343, + "CVC3": 11.714113352625342, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.131142958769475, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.359084947479452 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 47.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4451417162721523, + "veriT": 6.1537681431833793, + "Yices": 8.3651622262950731, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0396678582916898, + "CVC4": 8.6315976914954398, + "CVC3": 3.0115952055560831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3820110382992636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3302646616753373 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5630428172942854, + "veriT": 2.1258561781967966, + "Yices": 0.12493810608642855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5635008046648573, + "CVC4": 0.15145421594085715, + "CVC3": 0.12791131146328569, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14112846557114286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14067053561314286 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1525280283852857, + "veriT": 0.13156460997642858, + "Yices": 0.14244522558100001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15058400495599997, + "CVC4": 0.16935885282500002, + "CVC3": 0.15001203680185712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16440741927300001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16265802582657143 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16653973264563637, + "veriT": 0.14537544765172725, + "Yices": 0.15737523985827273, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16806449759599998, + "CVC4": 0.18805282787209093, + "CVC3": 0.16618569454027274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17610461931336363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17929103768954543 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1286468505859375, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26643621446974997, + "veriT": 1.4717292383990497, + "Yices": 13.256436776292844, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.69104889794012492, + "CVC4": 2.0065631129238546, + "CVC3": 0.23663550341562498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2267289257373625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2209249255495 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17774758079514283, + "veriT": 5.0394107342250081, + "Yices": 6.2051301505289329, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18903931053985712, + "CVC4": 0.21773607068685713, + "CVC3": 0.54325144032242856, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19298794862442856, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19760055461585715 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1498160173186198, + "veriT": 3.5355781036950304, + "Yices": 2.3518916023122398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1556409931876006, + "CVC4": 8.6463046762470501, + "CVC3": 2.2087038421084406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23793129974359997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.24949886012748004 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 50.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1889703474216242, + "veriT": 11.877092049871083, + "Yices": 5.5916985093752647, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4203665919150348, + "CVC4": 10.367021240964428, + "CVC3": 13.272852196145804, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.692262461276941, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.463591443620031 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.013888670397499, + "veriT": 7.4369361337443527, + "Yices": 12.152286160843479, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.543324892675308, + "CVC4": 9.8256789562900071, + "CVC3": 6.2847006591500589, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14646362151941178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14391757521864706 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18389528081218182, + "veriT": 6.0536220542707042, + "Yices": 1.3828359192910908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.54507152814945459, + "CVC4": 1.478747739043736, + "CVC3": 0.1710345251442727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19715781187654544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18403609341345453 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4094202907251523, + "veriT": 11.199016840423603, + "Yices": 6.3999867451057222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5093976517941341, + "CVC4": 6.3162229675173922, + "CVC3": 4.6105743338276994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8088122586882518, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3447522302963879 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8206757210924245, + "veriT": 13.710665438170857, + "Yices": 11.949741295793412, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.891602807273612, + "CVC4": 7.3428758121126307, + "CVC3": 11.037511483989729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4882996421441863, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4715634495419456 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6687737844479784, + "veriT": 9.2934694272228704, + "Yices": 9.367120555539751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3981770547775181, + "CVC4": 8.3557464710404243, + "CVC3": 2.3903577028674539, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.224125532044861, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4372640976547189 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.823519899842552, + "veriT": 13.700377085046897, + "Yices": 13.729774197909625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.013460284796659, + "CVC4": 6.5548550461952217, + "CVC3": 6.5156646525730038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.480903505280736, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0617249673905591 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15753517808346001, + "veriT": 2.11950174550981, + "Yices": 2.9343806886146604, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20960573565690002, + "CVC4": 2.976547936477735, + "CVC3": 3.007931767364735, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15397169695957999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15107589701221 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2036004855672493, + "veriT": 13.830601386664203, + "Yices": 3.2394117248421246, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3267291732894737, + "CVC4": 3.1213484747085865, + "CVC3": 4.3756441371290995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8774920377968836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9741078698825727 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2236244650429526, + "veriT": 12.570463596682515, + "Yices": 8.0865335656188879, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.127766547257066, + "CVC4": 9.6129890037903021, + "CVC3": 8.8683567677455866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.564988408591754, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.020839832389909 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.58376007750557, + "veriT": 13.911854234133937, + "Yices": 13.435408988994787, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.662260498124244, + "CVC4": 11.299280204452979, + "CVC3": 13.216152243959103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243090351081474, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.241347134424066 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.766000976074439, + "veriT": 13.000538633061462, + "Yices": 12.317135139480731, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.815064157628957, + "CVC4": 14.549035102723924, + "CVC3": 10.462197827898528, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2188725619717591, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.216094117780834 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8759739398956299, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.265348149642515, + "veriT": 11.562701679330095, + "Yices": 10.870276891916667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.982147110194896, + "CVC4": 12.408911660469442, + "CVC3": 14.268392919334103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.262951910682467, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.374014255585502 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23524008246766, + "veriT": 10.154973197180002, + "Yices": 10.845912493087864, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950150426268165, + "CVC4": 14.872569857926059, + "CVC3": 13.290528069915847, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238388742723519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.204231472131678 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 109.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0614250951630044, + "veriT": 13.655153129817819, + "Yices": 14.113802441936121, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.477430339594511, + "CVC4": 14.585801615336853, + "CVC3": 9.7529959911739006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.066417109980405, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.947753939582981 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.252032401226794, + "veriT": 12.405951249472524, + "Yices": 13.651642753350066, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968545124329067, + "CVC4": 14.465963492712159, + "CVC3": 13.742672294229092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.204516244488202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.066078011048546 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0810376444472762, + "veriT": 14.223028020182808, + "Yices": 13.992767937775538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951276963178392, + "CVC4": 14.508045890381823, + "CVC3": 14.228877497406318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244935326084091, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.24184821126312 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 166.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3614674122808728, + "veriT": 13.037487914754642, + "Yices": 12.508559320927171, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956177199452025, + "CVC4": 9.613197093792941, + "CVC3": 12.637561306062578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1395512972206925, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1602605632818541 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8578848115311954, + "veriT": 14.25828234135035, + "Yices": 14.024591641906371, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.494620093875005, + "CVC4": 14.69578550575654, + "CVC3": 14.690629833869352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.518225540486496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.589069753539968 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.593493593230507, + "veriT": 13.573257097285369, + "Yices": 14.247947151073179, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97421161671466, + "CVC4": 14.453777472353195, + "CVC3": 12.197351162324608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.076971185008423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.62544814786836 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.812596649932804, + "veriT": 12.521481995509093, + "Yices": 8.4221217299596827, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.993191625766547, + "CVC4": 9.5896101112021963, + "CVC3": 13.263361119041992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2465776482877695, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.229023281676926 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.102245121856777, + "veriT": 11.655753461159915, + "Yices": 11.5176982784952, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2425219679380231, + "CVC4": 12.01286965937668, + "CVC3": 10.222181244444929, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5888945233161049, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4281547619963968 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.75, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5973869091791548, + "veriT": 2.9873757036090565, + "Yices": 2.7024805824242435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7129608907400784, + "CVC4": 4.1739089067193884, + "CVC3": 0.12753181583672857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1597724930103888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1649311663772757 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11140590950171764, + "veriT": 0.082636517660541184, + "Yices": 0.08916938972671766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11291611357790002, + "CVC4": 0.10915137726554117, + "CVC3": 0.091127299260523528, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10549323652570587, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10488176504810587 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12654997785163635, + "veriT": 0.096270157097822703, + "Yices": 0.099420803456822734, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12447600082681819, + "CVC4": 0.12418251355527272, + "CVC3": 0.10415272515393181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12271671081118182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12150476474069095 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.79561318572175999, + "veriT": 10.334270122623574, + "Yices": 10.51339354731387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.8768122222464888, + "CVC4": 0.76660425762206075, + "CVC3": 1.2583675247543271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.73564339972419701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.575061940552104 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17629112837887501, + "veriT": 6.3930905407176253, + "Yices": 7.9389452577110005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.33993280766900003, + "CVC4": 0.15295436993299999, + "CVC3": 0.245741678677625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14925740981750002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2010919505315116 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7029409408569336, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9809564641964503, + "veriT": 5.2000320439898626, + "Yices": 6.5443502410316245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4059774493220671, + "CVC4": 0.16165119152912499, + "CVC3": 1.8004036541401249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4753089477468624, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.437441578754306 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5357145071029663, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.650498210331994, + "veriT": 8.722343881785287, + "Yices": 10.854204386102655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.258127855570701, + "CVC4": 0.98164895101571437, + "CVC3": 12.146658211266356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7759014972326126, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9681257037574333 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24131542604623, + "veriT": 10.152113636488375, + "Yices": 10.337915320623749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964381319939719, + "CVC4": 0.15307612337925, + "CVC3": 11.856528857977171, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15375891438225001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.380998127909168 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.695414559007284, + "veriT": 10.561336057650683, + "Yices": 10.460783893027001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.466133172439362, + "CVC4": 1.6895156177307644, + "CVC3": 10.751487859066335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.649084075046205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.39622028532666 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.218547551117913, + "veriT": 7.8789872935688532, + "Yices": 5.9745949020542861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.04534872343396, + "CVC4": 0.161291471568, + "CVC3": 7.3934456510641757, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16734621572471428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5663406391595895 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3872105422973631, + "veriT": 9.7725436065203812, + "Yices": 10.776158742457596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6091715444829955, + "CVC4": 10.241530811159038, + "CVC3": 10.188108782730492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2025951115465947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4604215438557269 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.90202529198416, + "veriT": 14.231778014162053, + "Yices": 13.68408241032985, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.186581773016428, + "CVC4": 14.755434802156531, + "CVC3": 14.861678030522752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.731224756947364, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.729732713930387 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.074798833347494, + "veriT": 10.773622120647095, + "Yices": 12.443150652599014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.679685812559589, + "CVC4": 1.2994450224581995, + "CVC3": 14.17511013485478, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0859297097032634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.633241541941507 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4148165021611083, + "veriT": 11.457133873592644, + "Yices": 6.487522264594209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8226752260482311, + "CVC4": 3.379700086391229, + "CVC3": 4.1701525983599987, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.383020655208403, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.3829391251231 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.904278655605927, + "veriT": 10.181062832634499, + "Yices": 10.328745232478143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962305852907921, + "CVC4": 3.2215989835947147, + "CVC3": 9.7370439339809831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8448876762140012, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.25467288473793 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.548124463852938, + "veriT": 11.693356753264005, + "Yices": 11.381035998631935, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.256865410988381, + "CVC4": 11.918104580733859, + "CVC3": 12.543579626144266, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.241022461139607, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.899356492473201 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.246894460697217, + "veriT": 9.4586727910313559, + "Yices": 10.326394643554142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.911669323612747, + "CVC4": 0.16869504183864284, + "CVC3": 12.438621600196626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.803973669670597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.247422152412396 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3333334922790527, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7928569316864014, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1684434289232204, + "veriT": 11.824266287234325, + "Yices": 7.2625380265482109, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3725128726618001, + "CVC4": 8.2037767467835057, + "CVC3": 5.2541759177338694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4246274286257274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.47729364418509096 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1600169672146432, + "veriT": 8.8453455591022063, + "Yices": 5.8719015546523385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2754413376858817, + "CVC4": 1.8211146367625, + "CVC3": 6.6608871431888383, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6261838192281415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0880332149743142 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1716030887818283, + "veriT": 12.398182311997923, + "Yices": 11.296413374379313, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3458977218965718, + "CVC4": 12.629744500440918, + "CVC3": 6.8912242251420253, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.45129238870418, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.453267535500759 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.78724460505350002, + "veriT": 14.240319610474275, + "Yices": 11.263639832588645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6889561802838262, + "CVC4": 10.346212207293245, + "CVC3": 3.6128207674938482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.575601457551663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.60484096708052 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.743683615591422, + "veriT": 9.6717001530990725, + "Yices": 9.4834952798049077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.170940111041636, + "CVC4": 0.16622230114183331, + "CVC3": 10.862746368081224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6892431752065771, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.648180496313891 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8989722772690181, + "veriT": 8.9331397564098278, + "Yices": 1.9189220136784539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8423085358827267, + "CVC4": 3.7726767550536611, + "CVC3": 5.4166510064334741, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.277200759777861, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.300319612739884 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7184917808387219, + "veriT": 9.871755955543529, + "Yices": 3.8183748843184726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8434930138260679, + "CVC4": 1.5132011869245077, + "CVC3": 2.2060210463752998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0760811162373636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1132736269720955 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0774405159581333, + "veriT": 8.6370486332145102, + "Yices": 13.172096004695893, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9434926719694987, + "CVC4": 11.674546482563532, + "CVC3": 11.740057879374884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.101011760162592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.102173016026848 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.03125, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7968366282792667, + "veriT": 9.1854779397869422, + "Yices": 9.8119702659631773, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0203791006792065, + "CVC4": 7.6224379790447729, + "CVC3": 5.7670390394264466, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3343506850281237, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4388019876768308 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9444444179534912, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6129883116277544, + "veriT": 7.8253055560412594, + "Yices": 7.4298897775025425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6318620262959733, + "CVC4": 8.536009030527925, + "CVC3": 2.4893611341876456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1426824983894113, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7035749445328312 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2371275273059843, + "veriT": 3.4127793991264772, + "Yices": 4.9791702798112754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3974448995000071, + "CVC4": 1.8825535928051582, + "CVC3": 1.655955020518977, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8004878382374452, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8025165192183161 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6895886655187486, + "veriT": 9.1473325686741269, + "Yices": 8.9645160863788202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7529174540154919, + "CVC4": 7.3361402628937737, + "CVC3": 7.0476569749781826, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.659286183305367, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.407414811418208 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9856022228421777, + "veriT": 11.59825054487222, + "Yices": 10.823818603979914, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.984562634116118, + "CVC4": 8.8563476920517488, + "CVC3": 7.0529125554259773, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233776472028255, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.226696323728799 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4226188659667969, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0954544544219971, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8336951788930982, + "veriT": 3.4603160432220776, + "Yices": 3.4596720113924775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0725638699325719, + "CVC4": 6.1134797387660207, + "CVC3": 4.8255916186387928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8398471897170658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8350071558866965 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1296621378194143, + "veriT": 7.1088812637631653, + "Yices": 10.133736081719702, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12691309206795001, + "CVC4": 1.8568599372295587, + "CVC3": 0.88372429839550004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1246443948328202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1128553639328982 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2792205810546875, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1744919304978003, + "veriT": 0.14594471835240003, + "Yices": 8.0267805828254648, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1682515429171998, + "CVC4": 2.9959271313595113, + "CVC3": 2.1961844608563998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1868391014452, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1869779187842 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12561411317361537, + "veriT": 1.1883128683511524, + "Yices": 2.4166374625580462, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13405303179753847, + "CVC4": 0.90847057632392314, + "CVC3": 1.0173729510189076, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.9014054591047691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.90308384351123072 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2917361082333882, + "veriT": 7.0649013420252924, + "Yices": 10.406688050836781, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1952561331965175, + "CVC4": 10.370602443635082, + "CVC3": 10.393136249595281, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.204395716520497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.668684469123872 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.701245308692869, + "veriT": 12.072055626265364, + "Yices": 12.062887133383386, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.939657413297571, + "CVC4": 14.027822993879902, + "CVC3": 9.6644047359746335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.22056378110373, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.037003703562712 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0333335399627686, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21336150584450003, + "veriT": 2.5487160673241553, + "Yices": 9.7742911356485038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7816991895896659, + "CVC4": 8.7738605163828112, + "CVC3": 3.8105362293442893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8965549767297822, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5465589758933962 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5304131137640544, + "veriT": 10.425070943136003, + "Yices": 11.324454925102632, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2046956916471032, + "CVC4": 5.6787109059119363, + "CVC3": 9.0681830842331674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2271938029339036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.231157840264653 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6113556464945944, + "veriT": 10.133973660234799, + "Yices": 10.167452549484, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1068259432628089, + "CVC4": 13.063071353959762, + "CVC3": 12.830508418190414, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.007414325155223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.447093400167699 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6047979283438409, + "veriT": 9.6260859935273704, + "Yices": 8.9736048761277143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7024058271485782, + "CVC4": 4.3098549431863731, + "CVC3": 8.2101841428726843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2164506288672943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.794927284408586 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4823370512361009, + "veriT": 13.597333742525393, + "Yices": 11.938251112677822, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3560641852732651, + "CVC4": 13.740244388569298, + "CVC3": 13.224829547831966, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25507668782992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.249475734981981 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5541259133331029, + "veriT": 11.454071020091925, + "Yices": 9.1240591073448751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3733312820114048, + "CVC4": 9.06595498338943, + "CVC3": 3.3636725213038687, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.245027972212569, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.206773482207376 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22977717728559996, + "veriT": 9.5812479988569077, + "Yices": 1.2404913955879999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8402997387863962, + "CVC4": 1.6194850052125755, + "CVC3": 0.45614958913479997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3787396537023096, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.069006583357246 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 79.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1410189257516998, + "veriT": 2.1171827811683199, + "Yices": 2.1238655004576001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.099274780375076, + "CVC4": 0.15601738953290001, + "CVC3": 0.13659185111870001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14070418463259998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1379261551539 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0770545342055453, + "veriT": 1.429454219262555, + "Yices": 0.35498198465193637, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1067079041964545, + "CVC4": 1.4813554803233886, + "CVC3": 0.17312178828637273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16965979672303635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1691485171396091 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14781068469445713, + "veriT": 1.5660306512243858, + "Yices": 9.6035159904115961, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.146373191918, + "CVC4": 4.2097883505457014, + "CVC3": 0.15171241160877141, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2044673488813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21123146370824286 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 48.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0158469727748001, + "veriT": 10.963013727945338, + "Yices": 6.4632117657472437, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1344862203913713, + "CVC4": 3.1816150372774632, + "CVC3": 1.631286220821357, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2143234366712692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2309955187106123 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8964832040719095, + "veriT": 1.5202890725908333, + "Yices": 11.419762514199148, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9031247779309086, + "CVC4": 9.3866674045787288, + "CVC3": 6.6644313660378378, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7294538511263498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7760451508330335 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9079070091247559, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.529002239296888, + "veriT": 13.529042972134876, + "Yices": 14.545029522268869, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4745250543171924, + "CVC4": 4.9512032697869692, + "CVC3": 9.1897468209201474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.224718927892193, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.710912425783883 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9222437037319999, + "veriT": 10.497706776360291, + "Yices": 5.1997960943509618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3708666069447233, + "CVC4": 2.7480001494602111, + "CVC3": 2.5264500262642255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8308417683366152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8281519517601783 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.515493212070835, + "veriT": 11.037477911298335, + "Yices": 10.479787916865551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.217322108879126, + "CVC4": 14.368512108563241, + "CVC3": 13.036175590070627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.277939523518047, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.96013922514507 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 71.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8454965429042502, + "veriT": 11.283922871478802, + "Yices": 10.659571981950993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5257346507655001, + "CVC4": 3.7704107253451191, + "CVC3": 1.817538860272375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17275921389712501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16384407477650001 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.63702988746644, + "veriT": 11.934400895675434, + "Yices": 11.915674400409532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0736689716133583, + "CVC4": 14.348592684293774, + "CVC3": 7.4240042873719094, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0192998371985933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0143430232831481 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5566699088492477, + "veriT": 11.089991375206827, + "Yices": 8.6959078661028553, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1230375678830971, + "CVC4": 9.9013815260588789, + "CVC3": 4.8776129229978453, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.589542455294795, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.618866875914755 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15286654039911762, + "veriT": 0.13086465606952943, + "Yices": 0.14430101916764707, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15004781633094119, + "CVC4": 0.17150650945552942, + "CVC3": 0.15104089042194119, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16523740762741176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16603804014464707 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4037785659697499, + "veriT": 7.1712200112100399, + "Yices": 0.15642526507249999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4441584639291249, + "CVC4": 0.18886151034324999, + "CVC3": 1.0785179476068749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16011781575400003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16596473628612499 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16280650204345457, + "veriT": 0.14232820917818179, + "Yices": 0.1596962083778182, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16628383559618182, + "CVC4": 0.18299745044054544, + "CVC3": 0.16197215695772726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17631725568990905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17941991952409089 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2324482207324357, + "veriT": 9.7118355273367722, + "Yices": 5.1223634502431494, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0024383179927314, + "CVC4": 9.6081887824195888, + "CVC3": 2.5033791364225455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5943772881059846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5394412723526041 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 189.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6759259700775146, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.80006450616062, + "veriT": 11.730272543238769, + "Yices": 5.1723799679865268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3965085998179116, + "CVC4": 6.6039542316773048, + "CVC3": 4.4490031829845886, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.622240654886772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.639916748739759 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 68.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7556520594915996, + "veriT": 11.454460834274061, + "Yices": 10.803556000559249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7781048204995429, + "CVC4": 11.284548335404233, + "CVC3": 5.9480767890068114, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1694082287464784, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1781295191041377 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249111146346928, + "veriT": 10.172441415704572, + "Yices": 10.889279113692117, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.969946233897664, + "CVC4": 14.336535438088115, + "CVC3": 12.616169220096372, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246391020012272, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.424669084195907 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.943140098561749, + "veriT": 12.350815455530398, + "Yices": 10.608609240639, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96967724334672, + "CVC4": 10.069302209062759, + "CVC3": 14.251275522767767, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.205515005524097, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.193060749273664 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.477238692217103, + "veriT": 13.76796865352075, + "Yices": 13.516665719239672, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.732574602097177, + "CVC4": 14.580924710338245, + "CVC3": 12.601849636073306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239988869291532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237901272558439 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1514286994934082, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7121876578152189, + "veriT": 10.941247944160242, + "Yices": 8.1377599317321572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9352968862062232, + "CVC4": 10.922498322105703, + "CVC3": 9.3029424242574397, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0799965945320609, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1943736651066761 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9052599724654833, + "veriT": 13.317406779553174, + "Yices": 11.429656560153141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.793520497475713, + "CVC4": 11.474322556130442, + "CVC3": 8.9255126635564963, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.68198639508261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.679453816684388 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.655395818533032, + "veriT": 13.248259656487521, + "Yices": 11.242073659071401, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.262225836263189, + "CVC4": 7.18619685421928, + "CVC3": 5.082107170932141, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5724082124808572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3037567995785553 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7310240728481965, + "veriT": 2.7161628517629541, + "Yices": 3.341496974664445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6539822152724546, + "CVC4": 2.7160835440836331, + "CVC3": 2.0677321555785091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7005421198486621, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5726897596530183 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1065275242759993, + "veriT": 11.723603767548132, + "Yices": 13.954740504542292, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8326456013105128, + "CVC4": 14.404108005805352, + "CVC3": 11.861064877966902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.436025343859383, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.148562938186881 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.01380609302613, + "veriT": 14.009321271778601, + "Yices": 13.916470420684757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95125653935472, + "CVC4": 14.362511961011373, + "CVC3": 14.226997636256582, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.102148922822401, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.120123508279852 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249360068223428, + "veriT": 12.626250755686542, + "Yices": 14.331820804023783, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967523251856857, + "CVC4": 14.583663576329764, + "CVC3": 12.365220536484802, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.209343888959307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.019196640651327 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.723146539451307, + "veriT": 11.711881655516246, + "Yices": 11.826727690013154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.350564044403736, + "CVC4": 12.75014060002832, + "CVC3": 13.817065883020158, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.329008994080144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.445431100199524 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 224.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3100793814132858, + "veriT": 14.24161304106987, + "Yices": 8.7981281528123372, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.977489554534853, + "CVC4": 4.4337364617832211, + "CVC3": 8.2866033082969448, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8248139871862992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8818257041308692 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.691765364215879, + "veriT": 12.389174655233248, + "Yices": 12.386924707236815, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.655000398343653, + "CVC4": 9.6793511109445927, + "CVC3": 13.904689822373133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6072206418703334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2956842979321113 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 82.0, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.747306348666148, + "veriT": 13.249299713269664, + "Yices": 11.525892829743251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973789045072893, + "CVC4": 14.711368234459975, + "CVC3": 14.26087703125804, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.01896385239419, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.30188666350301 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.277618395585565, + "veriT": 14.263837980058053, + "Yices": 14.267681601097243, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.997063286163673, + "CVC4": 13.055268746817065, + "CVC3": 12.668062728565653, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2150980901777526, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2083595379943564 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2230155807009169, + "veriT": 13.565409419384032, + "Yices": 13.559168546359045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.091387953302581, + "CVC4": 14.883582817461528, + "CVC3": 6.900648950868626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.223125031692904, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7523566787991545 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13115099114557502, + "veriT": 0.92749828942587509, + "Yices": 0.92963080265405418, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14326329541015001, + "CVC4": 1.2968129326244295, + "CVC3": 0.099443902758741667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2929982675227349, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2916770452712856 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10983607546636086, + "veriT": 0.082419231395578274, + "Yices": 0.088471751552247832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10904371258492172, + "CVC4": 0.10696905327875215, + "CVC3": 0.089197467114743481, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10606848722993478, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10511483041303915 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0059467222920944, + "veriT": 1.5435519221680141, + "Yices": 3.0215302946467353, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1033854626568145, + "CVC4": 0.13693644621307141, + "CVC3": 2.1340776801296664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13491849270200001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1708209872279629 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0795522559910036, + "veriT": 10.162541803410599, + "Yices": 10.355753252680735, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.223326048522277, + "CVC4": 0.14943585034999998, + "CVC3": 0.69835885451789992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14929684581916666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.451274759267346 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17624189841212501, + "veriT": 6.3928123621991251, + "Yices": 7.9423214501590005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28323836416699999, + "CVC4": 0.15386464361625002, + "CVC3": 0.22781849892762501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14832661346975001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5221499683195114 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0839159488677979, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7613635063171387, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6515154838562012, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2330352922394736, + "veriT": 7.3116637364192849, + "Yices": 7.4057190885128579, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5466164132124813, + "CVC4": 0.16038707532071431, + "CVC3": 4.2136988886656033, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7540631025219302, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0110681911373067 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8232441830829995, + "veriT": 4.2076629849514591, + "Yices": 2.4040114407016664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8176602302438332, + "CVC4": 0.17029206988449999, + "CVC3": 1.8062950710793331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8661631501771838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.965080452575144 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.134012471551808, + "veriT": 7.4507000726245449, + "Yices": 11.416098887395071, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.655621992679652, + "CVC4": 0.18374876843954543, + "CVC3": 12.065600226976962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1922113812696802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3331483585720072 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.543671460446078, + "veriT": 10.815940366621208, + "Yices": 10.501290641304001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.139311476760804, + "CVC4": 5.0567681553937858, + "CVC3": 14.216570944059136, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.45914486304175, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.350265535023093 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6076939893068958, + "veriT": 5.8179534704101012, + "Yices": 6.2220355288926914, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.273174244021174, + "CVC4": 0.23726561307846156, + "CVC3": 2.3291183546467478, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6533334095422907, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8300010648788438 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.939579935736514, + "veriT": 12.195761437630072, + "Yices": 10.99230923176418, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.884533185710451, + "CVC4": 10.034014367949023, + "CVC3": 11.037485585863687, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5329663438005561, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.485874995148306 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.228251132408804, + "veriT": 9.0227040691523701, + "Yices": 9.1702839321545717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.800746033331382, + "CVC4": 1.1809240226666435, + "CVC3": 12.234527277475561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1600812710320714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5222860470963457 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.797165028665329, + "veriT": 10.810298887184777, + "Yices": 7.6626153410528532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.572909885278502, + "CVC4": 10.092690138554216, + "CVC3": 10.026973896187524, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.01550787520052, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.610977090657304 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.227008468818953, + "veriT": 12.14816142603493, + "Yices": 12.051866687828257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.945381724373032, + "CVC4": 8.6756773205694024, + "CVC3": 13.363801086132959, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.353144458814159, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.128477892294514 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.60590559856662, + "veriT": 11.90770755435388, + "Yices": 11.155290840583305, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.066761032112689, + "CVC4": 14.568318804403466, + "CVC3": 5.9779911963709376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2529072542457609, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5348221741393768 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.869052558689406, + "veriT": 9.2790693291045976, + "Yices": 10.440554014688901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.287677521266332, + "CVC4": 9.9414615824171708, + "CVC3": 9.9816311510201192, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.713580928842655, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.192432441297667 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.251825854814529, + "veriT": 8.7366961686995701, + "Yices": 10.324104439886144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.865872227512169, + "CVC4": 0.17263819331671426, + "CVC3": 11.179053807948707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.865517589805579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.259205293160202 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234532689191491, + "veriT": 10.84042346748967, + "Yices": 10.861022832871832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.943763138014027, + "CVC4": 2.5323976673535267, + "CVC3": 12.029954991225082, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.780615864108407, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.628560052576482 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.421769791086552, + "veriT": 10.977613807827998, + "Yices": 8.2962338010954397, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.995757894470698, + "CVC4": 0.15723535315109999, + "CVC3": 14.027881793768993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18039650512889999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1486304704524191 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2644439783489387, + "veriT": 13.041125567234346, + "Yices": 8.5376822844169755, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.798229414803885, + "CVC4": 12.17698717194717, + "CVC3": 8.4886372862452362, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.067705700293166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.068477617628005 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7706128555081511, + "veriT": 8.7203341871831679, + "Yices": 9.1233309478297588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.916981556135396, + "CVC4": 1.8753310255276174, + "CVC3": 4.6667863016982869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1675620545209906, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9146292632355717 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9502386837016665, + "veriT": 4.0923918757730062, + "Yices": 3.4024660632190167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.434487599049366, + "CVC4": 4.1147990851930194, + "CVC3": 1.7465189872936666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4449037209781603, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4434086571959739 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.87761383816032, + "veriT": 5.1243739665152246, + "Yices": 9.5474714893815733, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9646205774970831, + "CVC4": 5.1579699216877497, + "CVC3": 0.24708809562234996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10946964406435, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5163846761800757 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5818484885247477, + "veriT": 10.119126438501375, + "Yices": 10.165065309220374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4312426978046826, + "CVC4": 3.6909828405736946, + "CVC3": 1.14499693819225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.890458726919443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.89547367496368 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.961538553237915, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4846593881877856, + "veriT": 7.4027610332277778, + "Yices": 10.510419800602181, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4414827043931355, + "CVC4": 11.690436833625398, + "CVC3": 8.6599587140220819, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255600298216345, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.109697419770168 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.538316064768471, + "veriT": 10.126705396005852, + "Yices": 10.177729567010283, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.129930551643506, + "CVC4": 7.9999286145739719, + "CVC3": 7.8447664084089768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234291364063409, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.256774016020552 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.94681045411192311, + "veriT": 7.0661097535221682, + "Yices": 9.6940540489263451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.97021769587886153, + "CVC4": 5.6971682723899866, + "CVC3": 5.4049205135452763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7085894601182332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2054494017771145 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3592970230845527, + "veriT": 9.0613196664686235, + "Yices": 8.4946728347811256, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.693287023430168, + "CVC4": 7.3634975752306948, + "CVC3": 1.1403176330877502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9879698541660389, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.325313344205142 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12991313898119999, + "veriT": 2.9695527844772216, + "Yices": 9.7074798268672104, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13692660458399999, + "CVC4": 0.18643483322659998, + "CVC3": 0.12822581928682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14217490957748, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13760094007474 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14378595110800002, + "veriT": 4.8190903308995736, + "Yices": 0.11949765642855557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14227081009588891, + "CVC4": 0.17224146910099999, + "CVC3": 0.13833585537722221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2652525224503006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.270470626337163 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15134466856091669, + "veriT": 14.209816880259204, + "Yices": 0.48778396436716664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24946547071575001, + "CVC4": 2.7245796016842228, + "CVC3": 0.15948630306775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.988374898802673, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.988661849409318 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7786710262298584, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18897506730287503, + "veriT": 8.9310088876707177, + "Yices": 6.2278939753320994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0516465811643179, + "CVC4": 7.2462855514291533, + "CVC3": 6.8746031081967329, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8014980455263601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7573363287842323 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.916667915610029, + "veriT": 14.221102139242463, + "Yices": 13.328656523290924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.172342404842337, + "CVC4": 8.0443215003795761, + "CVC3": 12.484605527002396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24098546434851, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.240073182206553 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5639193978358676, + "veriT": 13.763242549587245, + "Yices": 6.8769408116717035, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5760856012696678, + "CVC4": 0.35840088454433339, + "CVC3": 6.8716613679678069, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.674090712455364, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.672903202513595 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.137144543101353, + "veriT": 10.601502540155773, + "Yices": 9.7319857531293987, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.985458406739752, + "CVC4": 6.9260899082366238, + "CVC3": 10.405734513083601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5983604505867639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.368174604480624 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5227274894714355, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8281580238199737, + "veriT": 7.2838618974355347, + "Yices": 6.4024975436477147, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6624562619799663, + "CVC4": 3.3618258520156226, + "CVC3": 5.5160035225064297, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7776557207552588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3363218045281791 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.141509286817274, + "veriT": 1.5438606476072143, + "Yices": 1.5720007257462856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.242483275822468, + "CVC4": 0.13555236255285716, + "CVC3": 0.27135581508205714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13630098007742858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7379408280801896 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.698919525024504, + "veriT": 8.6744079844056827, + "Yices": 8.5858484546343199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.544305137838794, + "CVC4": 3.2546630726525763, + "CVC3": 9.3505076814176125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9856963351115215, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.630488673900446 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2613635063171387, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15777326538590908, + "veriT": 5.6265624116590942, + "Yices": 11.677744998588645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17561856522381816, + "CVC4": 7.8624071578667971, + "CVC3": 3.0680407487007284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1541279449930909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15419198736445455 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2883320917354517, + "veriT": 0.86264531703028891, + "Yices": 3.2733997815140352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4490522023819619, + "CVC4": 0.16649166664999998, + "CVC3": 3.2752353508893801, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16288588225044445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16161001527844446 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.150098986933, + "veriT": 0.86461169589127318, + "Yices": 0.80521963008084663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20745148194533336, + "CVC4": 0.27929162140593339, + "CVC3": 0.15185767350914001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0844564184729784, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0965668563791517 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.292077793766524, + "veriT": 11.709284262456467, + "Yices": 10.074312128290085, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.963844959116278, + "CVC4": 2.5984169974943949, + "CVC3": 3.3989558807719291, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2338760282065748, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.065386394617924 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5212618060368821, + "veriT": 7.9687936051511699, + "Yices": 8.211448580718681, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.425479823910845, + "CVC4": 10.253571995205114, + "CVC3": 7.5276661285452997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3719108491451344, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.486216781288566 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4268018838438787, + "veriT": 6.9339010831120795, + "Yices": 9.3506142830599739, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4141030368961816, + "CVC4": 7.0438864891058293, + "CVC3": 7.7893606600513863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2036953736927236, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1902777991188751 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7565665376635557, + "veriT": 8.66665618593556, + "Yices": 12.458580382226264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.716546745486208, + "CVC4": 14.51504352211022, + "CVC3": 12.184461571039854, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.784378268301241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.208861556824051 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.674353054819758, + "veriT": 12.60183961541169, + "Yices": 7.8450239571767009, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6746530576274168, + "CVC4": 3.8748203999495132, + "CVC3": 7.3120012104427028, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6886789162027855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6873000252141757 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4826932289327033, + "veriT": 12.951679554536765, + "Yices": 8.6682117192637538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4787367352277148, + "CVC4": 13.771808668669912, + "CVC3": 9.2352202090868172, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.953610983914466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.938660245274086 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0618232009151818, + "veriT": 2.8589447300559461, + "Yices": 6.3438247763892779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0675068146411819, + "CVC4": 5.288956019114778, + "CVC3": 2.7113387413152243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.320145741734732, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2270025310063173 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 64.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17030241163766668, + "veriT": 0.14941131239988889, + "Yices": 1.7232297479049192, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16983361014166667, + "CVC4": 0.19237399550388889, + "CVC3": 0.17078228662566663, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18052199901444446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17940030360188888 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15317318163749999, + "veriT": 3.6503702617556497, + "Yices": 0.15180886355775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17224502715662504, + "CVC4": 0.180594991637375, + "CVC3": 0.46067210145100007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16430934842924999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16461956557175 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.384900740219555, + "veriT": 0.14412767498488888, + "Yices": 0.15269658110833331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3856086270723331, + "CVC4": 0.18061056178733334, + "CVC3": 0.15867478442077776, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17207385770533332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.172642759231 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.043408047538255, + "veriT": 8.2228379455916585, + "Yices": 12.698740471934272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2761429163734723, + "CVC4": 3.4448469114117772, + "CVC3": 2.8982747106759352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7722417602068887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0082555391258885 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0111110210418701, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.738490025794631, + "veriT": 1.1867620160877157, + "Yices": 0.25216039322923839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.741125966201623, + "CVC4": 14.304000866042323, + "CVC3": 0.11001721069344614, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12172922049193076, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12210928332988463 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4836369208203228, + "veriT": 9.2754268684443293, + "Yices": 10.070411095180475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8898170399988237, + "CVC4": 8.3057195104393493, + "CVC3": 3.6326899658942642, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4242981324714066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4297023728490457 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9380906793488057, + "veriT": 3.1610108762582665, + "Yices": 1.446295460898875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2987521884348983, + "CVC4": 5.4916128402080231, + "CVC3": 0.17523626444937498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1965970097719247, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1883029546293096 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3561816779089551, + "veriT": 9.445384090522694, + "Yices": 8.9506990109092399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7159134656507344, + "CVC4": 7.9360831349803478, + "CVC3": 6.132273290943318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.120275940145525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5173200095846902 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254650317473423, + "veriT": 10.728775949387828, + "Yices": 10.502148136310941, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976970136626237, + "CVC4": 14.370261756196431, + "CVC3": 13.150102699977735, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247347878931752, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.369720075557105 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.954325108690728, + "veriT": 12.384167320025558, + "Yices": 12.646745849595153, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.671045237661268, + "CVC4": 12.337411754148473, + "CVC3": 8.9554347061459083, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.509067684866762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.507026362575159 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.6453732594942857, + "veriT": 13.646996209998425, + "Yices": 7.2875696677072934, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6096723249373301, + "CVC4": 4.705503542898188, + "CVC3": 4.0082061506078572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.057405261107691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.085564950886246 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1257240596357558, + "veriT": 13.20773511718315, + "Yices": 12.53520321249702, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.710693949270892, + "CVC4": 14.638928665495186, + "CVC3": 11.984506847094545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.486152604382713, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.482551522433024 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9341790676116943, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1004611122158741, + "veriT": 12.20801393454507, + "Yices": 10.971559015072613, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1804050278716316, + "CVC4": 11.7782861510325, + "CVC3": 5.9573392476601246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2279087236302404, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.334395091816118 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 181.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3030995976879955, + "veriT": 13.566778900879124, + "Yices": 8.8743427034508553, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7203922746732658, + "CVC4": 12.06578125552933, + "CVC3": 7.5977846097951689, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2675033928947945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2684323484181341 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 37.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6215796868285715, + "veriT": 9.0402149904601021, + "Yices": 0.4221756469052857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7947916439028571, + "CVC4": 0.33427708459799998, + "CVC3": 8.1328021963309123, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17812130708599999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16814901735514282 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20460241483045, + "veriT": 3.5094816294524809, + "Yices": 1.3901146555212875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.29751335680862501, + "CVC4": 0.21928579718312502, + "CVC3": 0.17910976748822502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9187936602511162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9134097910303287 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.367734979373875, + "veriT": 7.2813033535874014, + "Yices": 6.7083098680276869, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.926629137920342, + "CVC4": 8.5863731849308795, + "CVC3": 2.0938578434050701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.683064676702108, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3647831373892259 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5901494544735142, + "veriT": 14.251163590898377, + "Yices": 8.2812834899689847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.177083202926431, + "CVC4": 0.39344471701755551, + "CVC3": 1.3026350269213336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22745998890333333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22230792281711112 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5541422138336172, + "veriT": 12.011365241057073, + "Yices": 13.256648760399466, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8609733754477524, + "CVC4": 12.242577068919323, + "CVC3": 12.854246566564481, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3979833119705765, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8494822361894574 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.234099944035398, + "veriT": 13.197546118564466, + "Yices": 13.05249232713482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.358732004146061, + "CVC4": 14.436914403262946, + "CVC3": 14.216677687301825, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.428683189093535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.534477638073897 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3132013559341811, + "veriT": 11.746680387988865, + "Yices": 8.7525187475401403, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.385605072249133, + "CVC4": 9.0722749868921646, + "CVC3": 9.6162391767790361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9822606658136106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4266080970882138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4240216729434092, + "veriT": 10.120486740965891, + "Yices": 9.4381207666393827, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.294311084671607, + "CVC4": 11.121058084598328, + "CVC3": 5.3459034619462482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.314454640436335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.960043962984665 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 168.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.454825219996009, + "veriT": 11.666475716163564, + "Yices": 12.85674880613689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.961363547996234, + "CVC4": 14.493029309076956, + "CVC3": 13.674411963124761, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.035252275898374, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.485517063350621 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9424355169385414, + "veriT": 14.229441742505726, + "Yices": 13.911109760169209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957926988659203, + "CVC4": 11.164790664383998, + "CVC3": 12.217759996882807, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.725134792716972, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.725289039595905 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.283097129712418, + "veriT": 11.718196835000951, + "Yices": 12.796182472313037, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.231883605653636, + "CVC4": 14.39396634613037, + "CVC3": 13.256972584955015, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.348146831258475, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.876609522785696 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254809882432038, + "veriT": 14.253934835418786, + "Yices": 13.789166780838089, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.9729172104435, + "CVC4": 14.856027563640513, + "CVC3": 14.273741591028685, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.130165278788802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.212377252604027 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.344290262696692, + "veriT": 14.233895856403313, + "Yices": 14.403278328928605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.813115226635613, + "CVC4": 14.707605081890685, + "CVC3": 9.8806769234648488, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.05084010995726, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.319114045768814 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1666665077209473, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13131560637018749, + "veriT": 0.71952592120547498, + "Yices": 0.72308302118513756, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.138431688097125, + "CVC4": 1.0049828353458661, + "CVC3": 0.098738405233325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0013737428338074, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.998098021844258 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1265573681554826, + "veriT": 0.097169302535278279, + "Yices": 0.10137393186036088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12632063435931742, + "CVC4": 0.1249399123024478, + "CVC3": 0.10477719639966956, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12071315626914783, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11851412118251738 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4857899420987759, + "veriT": 1.7808749066853331, + "Yices": 3.5119358435081671, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5931928976300336, + "CVC4": 0.14441336266933333, + "CVC3": 2.474338003405236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13553425860516666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5092987353384566 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1128785521693891, + "veriT": 10.167344998582323, + "Yices": 10.348270725697805, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2122099099968924, + "CVC4": 0.15098944884732257, + "CVC3": 0.72050061336906468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14861522807835484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.42671594896566 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17530249663637498, + "veriT": 6.3913263659670001, + "Yices": 7.9412996115236254, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24500240083950001, + "CVC4": 0.153520610614375, + "CVC3": 0.23135999395787499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14802833141737501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5295581652086248 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.341588563751099, + "veriT": 13.607497184352184, + "Yices": 12.329992567453354, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.125304953276165, + "CVC4": 13.087542699262137, + "CVC3": 10.192526029543423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.206682281199635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.23637213870512 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3161597016518116, + "veriT": 2.2797516041085633, + "Yices": 0.99318043360627284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3785928598052752, + "CVC4": 1.4880545939603222, + "CVC3": 1.3790613236180269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3965532829263658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3958854804131808 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8894718964476036, + "veriT": 4.1787931686872009, + "Yices": 8.3173919265806671, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4009349591341778, + "CVC4": 0.16759035362453331, + "CVC3": 2.6686224858144669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0202778561661796, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9711591801599511 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.843879229965221, + "veriT": 10.153341841717499, + "Yices": 10.3247327249472, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955087273399908, + "CVC4": 0.15851070241689999, + "CVC3": 9.3496213150181493, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6810537475574217, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.272482542129371 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.619047999382019, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4513762645235957, + "veriT": 9.8762931423439291, + "Yices": 6.9728101796557143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.555949546726473, + "CVC4": 2.3064345346171971, + "CVC3": 6.4491138606363032, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7332302169596687, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7315551994802365 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8166664838790894, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247448739760545, + "veriT": 10.167864142660111, + "Yices": 10.350072937702667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965707751695639, + "CVC4": 0.16769887476533332, + "CVC3": 13.365952425912702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9932930327808869, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.385477535469514 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.728278574685238, + "veriT": 10.665175099549606, + "Yices": 10.509213647554375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.351563226748405, + "CVC4": 2.0091089574239556, + "CVC3": 10.545426175525874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8990656750073289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.576317447487469 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.56824642169045, + "veriT": 10.186928747588713, + "Yices": 10.318427240066713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95655785864464, + "CVC4": 1.6945720217477143, + "CVC3": 9.6501828547260669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8290479252142449, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.658374338441988 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.913435441283713, + "veriT": 11.573470764124711, + "Yices": 11.517038206697391, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.57940869701849, + "CVC4": 8.7744229232918762, + "CVC3": 11.693274172886809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.283480610274145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.6478055710874 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9559825981596588, + "veriT": 3.9405497278054833, + "Yices": 4.6427154659932572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9577562488376579, + "CVC4": 3.032426256547601, + "CVC3": 3.0515194631418314, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9584686623521073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0777331360834639 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2350300516758921, + "veriT": 10.362613252365339, + "Yices": 10.402894833589128, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.996600446418073, + "CVC4": 3.6576069270665457, + "CVC3": 9.4158698776309606, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.837706524359543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.679026593415358 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6110206369172069, + "veriT": 13.182771049903396, + "Yices": 10.956797574738403, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.483535966994557, + "CVC4": 12.76850867046746, + "CVC3": 9.4544626437191344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.213574039969215, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.210255000747955 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.775261400460002, + "veriT": 9.0351972173805564, + "Yices": 10.750614470260954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.413226551078875, + "CVC4": 0.25610532090477778, + "CVC3": 10.853367346191817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.385747036429346, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9716399717186608 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.467862222934466, + "veriT": 14.234586080914225, + "Yices": 12.239309659310088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.15772683565314, + "CVC4": 14.807860229367598, + "CVC3": 13.597126813384554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.228366646979239, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.226343018868661 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.609842013509323, + "veriT": 5.8718560183045572, + "Yices": 10.840113310148501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3829792724439716, + "CVC4": 1.6115644826225712, + "CVC3": 0.35242627367044282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1859465656871127, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4926808028783745 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.200162662182283, + "veriT": 7.8530883342887225, + "Yices": 7.4857371449164187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.706164562444892, + "CVC4": 2.2712290865750866, + "CVC3": 10.184577368880968, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9289721540060372, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6742131456795093 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9375, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.439460688981974, + "veriT": 11.078592178344854, + "Yices": 9.4361175722674169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.899843755331073, + "CVC4": 1.7693722643068497, + "CVC3": 12.696278680542445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7175275473650022, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.464940971813517 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.708806949571379, + "veriT": 7.2491179221490558, + "Yices": 4.4131315370373745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4593942211991724, + "CVC4": 2.0121403777693891, + "CVC3": 1.8967514562798282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.88997249055876, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8975988369297307 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2083334922790527, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9795149382912838, + "veriT": 10.116062614767001, + "Yices": 7.1509961715896493, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1879813133048969, + "CVC4": 8.6026562603679722, + "CVC3": 4.4183849627624365, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4797331370499567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4869932077750097 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13178388524519999, + "veriT": 7.9804653840468474, + "Yices": 9.1961534071023721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13340997952933334, + "CVC4": 3.9042579191352056, + "CVC3": 0.12083319942306667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13145586022113334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13273330706219999 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8036190432061667, + "veriT": 2.4689305633204301, + "Yices": 9.0341923342377601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8052593090461997, + "CVC4": 9.6997669323781697, + "CVC3": 8.2691202642251671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5748523211030476, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5749319776037796 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6245931926666222, + "veriT": 6.6904938458060483, + "Yices": 5.762501819227082, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5939453147294325, + "CVC4": 7.464695565256025, + "CVC3": 5.0223548340254665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8794196154183709, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8827242151832282 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7187592279630284, + "veriT": 13.146447441162655, + "Yices": 11.227877139346701, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4274554860474384, + "CVC4": 7.4759470998751487, + "CVC3": 7.0423907220225308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.760368157616112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.710134302932426 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2634044311927557, + "veriT": 14.206019518750386, + "Yices": 11.850736137069172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.467555167531156, + "CVC4": 9.8990993339873015, + "CVC3": 11.277574995625635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.651089427538778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.698343952958451 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.758462157908971, + "veriT": 10.474065231205447, + "Yices": 10.524018592958441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.565976033029719, + "CVC4": 11.492405154364805, + "CVC3": 8.709734431841385, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232783024694895, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.299166370432717 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2160172989488052, + "veriT": 10.710020644082395, + "Yices": 10.704990188907313, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6035990949517425, + "CVC4": 10.342427294260906, + "CVC3": 10.301480315298155, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235266468347442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.235777967548779 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2019228935241699, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14039552382083331, + "veriT": 2.4731862567890475, + "Yices": 8.0340997445260651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14386172218849999, + "CVC4": 4.8891854014002156, + "CVC3": 3.5327772888319999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5739515578433334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6250196449969998 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8247147400353332, + "veriT": 9.5115313985266265, + "Yices": 5.7887985115461467, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7775826329219999, + "CVC4": 10.528331067495978, + "CVC3": 10.438006235722742, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8814779793778715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8787059219405098 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1815295408208889, + "veriT": 4.9102462702841114, + "Yices": 8.6491612839749372, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18018148443233334, + "CVC4": 0.20496723219911112, + "CVC3": 4.4509198587448742, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1861774490923333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18859236508888888 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.606631367143098, + "veriT": 8.3083027847727458, + "Yices": 9.0738649623213909, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.037640963921625, + "CVC4": 0.16680753485450001, + "CVC3": 10.067493621841114, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1687897767652999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9428389485949644 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.96584184125492301, + "veriT": 6.4027874164889971, + "Yices": 12.045783328950883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7349571297382309, + "CVC4": 4.5969036325875221, + "CVC3": 9.5657154265527709, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7721910271017842, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7701453237309668 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8425124940666873, + "veriT": 8.7914809776036051, + "Yices": 9.4545000523322695, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.974805353686715, + "CVC4": 9.8027824106197627, + "CVC3": 4.3145269261267902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.719765673629707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9516368985867274 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2111092169445388, + "veriT": 0.88455617102255402, + "Yices": 3.1352458747773406, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2095915541268463, + "CVC4": 4.5157074989555852, + "CVC3": 0.13198298900153846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14325111658669229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13797865006953847 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5071023282590827, + "veriT": 6.4034438272204568, + "Yices": 9.1937486439641667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7512255742340459, + "CVC4": 2.6834636308165898, + "CVC3": 3.1570824933740482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5277699486422645, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.303129723011951 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16561005751178573, + "veriT": 0.15321881712507143, + "Yices": 0.16715542053321433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15917636874585714, + "CVC4": 0.19259263665221429, + "CVC3": 0.16860598153107142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18043338116978572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17581693387207142 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.177242134134, + "veriT": 4.0078569831949542, + "Yices": 5.2963274952260004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18011853111766665, + "CVC4": 0.18394615600766664, + "CVC3": 2.5147370900155024, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16845370380666669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8363801457648457 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8287931192643199, + "veriT": 6.1253489137510595, + "Yices": 7.4506799865977706, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8228002476793836, + "CVC4": 7.6680056113904387, + "CVC3": 2.2224976771688003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.33905695553714665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.30122850161090664 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4714104852413836, + "veriT": 11.288031302761848, + "Yices": 6.2355650284680539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7478918740741243, + "CVC4": 11.635358868583394, + "CVC3": 9.4234282897521648, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.695463817204073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.472281432679081 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3061681946907786, + "veriT": 9.4713590079319516, + "Yices": 9.3279340796046437, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5830417681737003, + "CVC4": 10.176873505280071, + "CVC3": 9.5980133677580888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.239423917972607, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.552884667144902 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9007689952850342, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2645241910675555, + "veriT": 14.211052614612836, + "Yices": 0.21417040929522224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.308436233496, + "CVC4": 2.0892506371576487, + "CVC3": 0.14483562398399999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8479209551333007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8433848831631945 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1333548946118, + "veriT": 14.208322063322594, + "Yices": 0.1125271471595, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16086268790659999, + "CVC4": 0.15163942416600001, + "CVC3": 0.12504625440059999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.844194748869933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.860444552235631 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22259139251745452, + "veriT": 14.220993151855561, + "Yices": 10.353596520179106, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1576618889150909, + "CVC4": 9.0020043205685383, + "CVC3": 14.236302008560484, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23168752802137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.231104714780308 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4642436018099314, + "veriT": 11.914313139592519, + "Yices": 11.107091908039394, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.630504588168852, + "CVC4": 14.502716053001183, + "CVC3": 7.0689712037224144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241819999182026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.464767968999578 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2277307958455999, + "veriT": 12.568110097658627, + "Yices": 3.3086469956569706, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6897006968421997, + "CVC4": 3.0507212074217387, + "CVC3": 2.4555835469605793, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7820063608342664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7848468224888894 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.436909221660148, + "veriT": 12.965775118044958, + "Yices": 12.193558532131707, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.925297824630034, + "CVC4": 8.0634307200466466, + "CVC3": 10.561818823488284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.533199211666114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.574817593326726 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0409836769104004, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4148021650804374, + "veriT": 0.147818344102875, + "Yices": 1.9106543418928359, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4137703513326252, + "CVC4": 0.18428228641756247, + "CVC3": 0.164071106903875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17362667873993748, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17138962949225001 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1775209903717041, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1420219110407, + "veriT": 11.32918060659795, + "Yices": 0.15279732462919998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15101629634810002, + "CVC4": 0.1694834885266, + "CVC3": 0.14295524729619999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14783566837920001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15210523314470001 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1577343266821, + "veriT": 0.12891821825260003, + "Yices": 0.14580878599609998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16151148852860001, + "CVC4": 0.16744831511920003, + "CVC3": 0.15127889793529997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16417271940560002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1660520275722 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8949975609989211, + "veriT": 5.1080658364624121, + "Yices": 5.1026648903671878, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9831489496735175, + "CVC4": 5.5178248655459683, + "CVC3": 1.8689967641058556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2413771222388466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2501449360644568 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9616844327837839, + "veriT": 5.0139727378837016, + "Yices": 5.4574289155410245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7066610495824523, + "CVC4": 11.206834972894393, + "CVC3": 1.709022302338713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7816261232385777, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0122772305179777 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21461330396813333, + "veriT": 3.4175488574318127, + "Yices": 7.2747330928161809, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24110104511859998, + "CVC4": 0.24192641233633333, + "CVC3": 1.3402431498333907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1540378105033617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1560342510023458 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5240412797784693, + "veriT": 11.190590307589099, + "Yices": 11.221177575420228, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.692331937257967, + "CVC4": 12.023508308105427, + "CVC3": 11.182608302765145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5508483441395153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0682570556802986 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.375620265102985, + "veriT": 12.172255531341383, + "Yices": 9.5255000365452016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.586671123833245, + "CVC4": 12.651052224059674, + "CVC3": 10.322403153811411, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6224095719169991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3322811518358217 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2805581851663333, + "veriT": 6.9803885170058342, + "Yices": 4.8681175555585465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0039623936998332, + "CVC4": 4.9057150788414123, + "CVC3": 6.3648278583278364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0587014607285212, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1713003377873967 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9965956211090088, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25642202796784, + "veriT": 10.179201432275184, + "Yices": 10.340239103476556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98824312867381, + "CVC4": 14.293812087736233, + "CVC3": 14.256943951752692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25372679994884, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.652126221693031 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.683786237073669, + "veriT": 11.981826864052783, + "Yices": 12.346343140880485, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956204819656541, + "CVC4": 13.526978907334762, + "CVC3": 10.744675253250835, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.095139879099824, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.710002173610572 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.100520133972168, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.257084605011034, + "veriT": 13.191132275654565, + "Yices": 12.236568463149883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9049551365356399, + "CVC4": 10.307396766675479, + "CVC3": 2.7729622342561817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2269506292043442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2281631352443831 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.832523569744581, + "veriT": 11.759031698102731, + "Yices": 9.9897245798905026, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.077813673533916, + "CVC4": 12.977779101696445, + "CVC3": 12.408279945183006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.003297603358819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.549676847686072 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7050352941757412, + "veriT": 13.479528513706027, + "Yices": 12.081180058863991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.398902773248123, + "CVC4": 14.689154393072551, + "CVC3": 11.577228176670154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236526396906273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236480567905216 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9492484829174441, + "veriT": 12.861640331698524, + "Yices": 12.865266521200162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.605666538508345, + "CVC4": 7.0179547835424145, + "CVC3": 9.2556492801349215, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.995780477294202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.988959907905453 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 45.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3750516840008751, + "veriT": 4.7167563878624712, + "Yices": 4.4056638701616126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3009436151711236, + "CVC4": 0.41269506894649999, + "CVC3": 0.208825990845625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6867490437416119, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6828155317215407 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.42731752536419998, + "veriT": 13.427369486459549, + "Yices": 0.65830318405020005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8766879777113439, + "CVC4": 0.51809837237840006, + "CVC3": 8.2679343168577883, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19767139492069999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19518514001949999 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1669975456484902, + "veriT": 13.436950295847264, + "Yices": 11.41253438653971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.450206366093109, + "CVC4": 9.1818668078661307, + "CVC3": 6.1081212590617211, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21495596460099997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21084238533419999 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1842863561820716, + "veriT": 11.917039728325785, + "Yices": 12.914767022683366, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.720469435172086, + "CVC4": 8.0829097373621241, + "CVC3": 12.495844181899798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.888884186517684, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.711097710958287 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0499608963209113, + "veriT": 12.202348767508383, + "Yices": 12.217688057506518, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.727460812052906, + "CVC4": 12.309729886201797, + "CVC3": 12.242802882402042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1447627457229261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0022008172467789 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.46360319206874, + "veriT": 12.874213002657715, + "Yices": 12.682117396590611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.478640270063837, + "CVC4": 14.459261699058546, + "CVC3": 12.959252437746619, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.123503110282298, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.824988921758518 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 151, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.293108500956567, + "veriT": 9.4461433256648917, + "Yices": 10.508082846679603, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.171212621910346, + "CVC4": 12.723125019804332, + "CVC3": 8.4230350895719805, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.065633924040469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.364547066027036 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.2425406615583, + "veriT": 10.748120995945827, + "Yices": 12.097304861437282, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.472358290647787, + "CVC4": 14.7833259150212, + "CVC3": 13.581574920736807, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.072986836876593, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.951554459200356 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.872113440904162, + "veriT": 14.232551369128071, + "Yices": 13.977472596336614, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.74219136988231, + "CVC4": 13.116034258879438, + "CVC3": 13.806739313606675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253050253693715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.253912808156525 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.140487831160277, + "veriT": 12.91265725724835, + "Yices": 12.962528179917443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975806578244386, + "CVC4": 14.607454832768077, + "CVC3": 9.9939183207203044, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.625475066917216, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.738393522653743 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.330482919249432, + "veriT": 13.760941170181642, + "Yices": 14.241848699598002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.719529844521162, + "CVC4": 13.886065129866424, + "CVC3": 11.785410805669592, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1789306415514442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4951864403005093 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6583658001300265, + "veriT": 3.6360947822846321, + "Yices": 3.4625120890457164, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8389197038850105, + "CVC4": 3.6945547790199202, + "CVC3": 2.3472042769824055, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.489711816278426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4529049007926056 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13062487509849999, + "veriT": 0.10118713659397308, + "Yices": 0.10402020836766156, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12695707954230767, + "CVC4": 0.12937191145688462, + "CVC3": 0.10730593060499229, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12384593826319233, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12331305099700771 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12967639792675789, + "veriT": 1.6649767417066001, + "Yices": 1.666314140924716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15846607345175265, + "CVC4": 2.3394682172099879, + "CVC3": 0.091124280459547388, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3346218994559189, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3313762527034361 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.548272513814128, + "veriT": 1.125925724563039, + "Yices": 1.9430061880965901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.613602687005395, + "CVC4": 1.5567183214915261, + "CVC3": 0.12822685591027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14427221170169999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16443155706990001 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0864912308721089, + "veriT": 10.165481222676252, + "Yices": 10.355856025602938, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1816946739975773, + "CVC4": 0.14969803140024995, + "CVC3": 0.71645062176159369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14891098671096872, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.418606218341857 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1339285373687744, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18153364515454548, + "veriT": 6.688830083084027, + "Yices": 6.7603846955955191, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31218074268063634, + "CVC4": 4.1840794334506697, + "CVC3": 4.0036563300902674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9786092603383811, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0576813105514224 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19245775022525, + "veriT": 8.9091224704378753, + "Yices": 10.49820693474725, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.33580221856737502, + "CVC4": 0.15059601192475, + "CVC3": 0.288058745533875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14905837356150003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7199886706136249 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7613635063171387, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5398843271703502, + "veriT": 7.29572418962813, + "Yices": 7.4064130031655724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.722357902829097, + "CVC4": 0.15615395601914286, + "CVC3": 3.9538557390195712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14768364024571429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.050667527430269 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.221798142764749, + "veriT": 11.174227769404334, + "Yices": 10.695699926421876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.754061133005859, + "CVC4": 3.8738456110334112, + "CVC3": 11.003287954633201, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6699745480646579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.381965458670368 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237032726984202, + "veriT": 10.153270901820715, + "Yices": 10.325526634436429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956992700414375, + "CVC4": 0.15537156533242857, + "CVC3": 11.040672674106464, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7633261965522118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.288062836578179 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.251350311648784, + "veriT": 10.631975282252553, + "Yices": 9.2230933782126669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.438945867227858, + "CVC4": 0.16294838539466666, + "CVC3": 12.686133658096411, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1542139011158889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.143847529613121 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7021194544474483, + "veriT": 5.1509345820678742, + "Yices": 9.523428762570072, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8036498009624147, + "CVC4": 0.79095666262212505, + "CVC3": 7.1380534886850544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6450516935758444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1434340809670323 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4807689189910889, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.228034142451911, + "veriT": 11.50452417039147, + "Yices": 11.238380214633935, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.946014034095713, + "CVC4": 5.2192248702936528, + "CVC3": 11.340266173058962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9223543188862697, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.421114314060997 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2016171018322888, + "veriT": 8.3162746517720425, + "Yices": 3.5791349114864306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5200698826446426, + "CVC4": 1.2406891423134403, + "CVC3": 1.3798923490442416, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5904979671014301, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5456230536431166 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1807615636582449, + "veriT": 13.024469833622218, + "Yices": 13.887947613575237, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3971260418602602, + "CVC4": 6.4640423484713052, + "CVC3": 10.091484140645774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2203015610462273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2152027503407776 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.206494382792355, + "veriT": 10.715787808320535, + "Yices": 9.7662620951575363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.722493319353015, + "CVC4": 8.2317002037566844, + "CVC3": 12.94372591024095, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.28761001773483, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.252026409440463 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6410397495321831, + "veriT": 9.5288329279799004, + "Yices": 7.4001547603539564, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0949224986577732, + "CVC4": 4.9159391252692446, + "CVC3": 4.8577689186342576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8381714223663872, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5098556074830896 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.979369556795861, + "veriT": 11.448114104736506, + "Yices": 10.635886622787611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.877621194246561, + "CVC4": 8.5425117948125475, + "CVC3": 12.638652899019043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.740255450218104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.896077326751071 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.018726042244559, + "veriT": 8.0612589484774837, + "Yices": 8.6355887859182232, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4248151840439558, + "CVC4": 0.18224834806927775, + "CVC3": 7.8399220142084021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.755202399318557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.026905545489448 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.699205800456063, + "veriT": 10.177289307444749, + "Yices": 10.307328791773374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.947769425609447, + "CVC4": 0.53683234765537491, + "CVC3": 14.225270563267532, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9122743845783328, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.881601807559475 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9545593170988751, + "veriT": 8.9375528387904257, + "Yices": 12.267108130387605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5361717267525909, + "CVC4": 12.554765877496035, + "CVC3": 5.8372366360344792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.895982795643461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4665632288027606 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15952087883314287, + "veriT": 0.17642221560628574, + "Yices": 7.1910588521243781, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16685817519571433, + "CVC4": 4.2889738468694416, + "CVC3": 3.6364374265721389, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.224702965583369, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.222004028451765 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3067339497319619, + "veriT": 10.990459441715634, + "Yices": 8.8368302190659573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.580450722719798, + "CVC4": 8.6490987079878998, + "CVC3": 4.3598252511347813, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.930271557451992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.059534160627116 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243925274893769, + "veriT": 11.068824266161409, + "Yices": 10.81966807573197, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967450340070153, + "CVC4": 3.4549818122223832, + "CVC3": 15.130095133602216, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7363839023004899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9226883864036086 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9468216046086804, + "veriT": 12.161007683394528, + "Yices": 7.1587510120139557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0899169352154394, + "CVC4": 3.1313032535843899, + "CVC3": 3.9608918902627188, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8252820076043492, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8531899140235928 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5341912359158929, + "veriT": 10.251498360394594, + "Yices": 11.373906700971329, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5998882432428703, + "CVC4": 11.770912124561011, + "CVC3": 6.6409848144565062, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.282910298631405, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5434262461704922 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.39193155225, + "veriT": 5.8827257561098207, + "Yices": 1.6313742093123582, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7215851629352006, + "CVC4": 4.9066414949609598, + "CVC3": 6.3398327201330256, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.091666167946866675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.092701217580211118 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9444444179534912, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24861809565824289, + "veriT": 1.5983335716851717, + "Yices": 8.8774442888175713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3302477055892861, + "CVC4": 8.2341532002969053, + "CVC3": 0.23042358859415715, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2054016197630748, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9751193895275714 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13170571549044444, + "veriT": 1.2156984273307889, + "Yices": 3.914084054769265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12856131392433331, + "CVC4": 0.14752250727533334, + "CVC3": 0.13578529371244444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13269851242211114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13639229824266666 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0444445610046387, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9030209429319604, + "veriT": 10.622487445550853, + "Yices": 10.260679983511626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9953387308425921, + "CVC4": 7.1968886570477144, + "CVC3": 7.1716625485752319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9529077886853496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.016815292097832 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1547620296478271, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23236473581105554, + "veriT": 9.0324911456428776, + "Yices": 7.0305914205978928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28795024618723336, + "CVC4": 6.446801905891701, + "CVC3": 0.14119508751366666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.44981958295466662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.32935423414425563 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.347553985568094, + "veriT": 10.975391157052647, + "Yices": 9.9843179360250769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6296060284156635, + "CVC4": 5.6314131025401704, + "CVC3": 3.1376749982878773, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5795869196477801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4051598043578144 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0871210098266602, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9705879688262939, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6746117820263517, + "veriT": 7.2486843730094277, + "Yices": 7.2552117780175722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3353283812874555, + "CVC4": 2.1780879610401098, + "CVC3": 3.0135848237370246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.200684676458248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.199416062863673 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.84986828326697, + "veriT": 10.162746063533092, + "Yices": 10.231417567870951, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957596419035269, + "CVC4": 7.9908086143764905, + "CVC3": 8.3629806847980479, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.000166512488024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.576089440760056 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6508067814615721, + "veriT": 9.2112558325002176, + "Yices": 11.46781288895229, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2661661029806996, + "CVC4": 7.5679478943992056, + "CVC3": 4.0644741767180008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.194139619268145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5857207893959782 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5158494243781671, + "veriT": 4.1582379526453082, + "Yices": 10.215926107923591, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.286133274237792, + "CVC4": 9.6902322217305912, + "CVC3": 5.9083857312640538, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.31463691091249996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.30764071322633335 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 40.0, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4698937655857289, + "veriT": 13.073990974876402, + "Yices": 11.082639113482925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7674825954668805, + "CVC4": 9.8680453046678611, + "CVC3": 10.069684841148678, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.814335842324775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.830385710189976 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.590551146890518, + "veriT": 8.408859606875021, + "Yices": 12.435844206927495, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8318441356308139, + "CVC4": 14.791351871426155, + "CVC3": 12.733820884060913, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.64553752555244, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.631644632853547 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9595607887843394, + "veriT": 13.706246973631428, + "Yices": 8.4535141752029652, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2232071547127976, + "CVC4": 3.4051170648104527, + "CVC3": 8.937084494788575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.464702941571566, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.464426503280006 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.034678147506012, + "veriT": 10.607198281518034, + "Yices": 10.396555563459827, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.937440309566833, + "CVC4": 8.4911162213472977, + "CVC3": 8.0698523265201274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0161632965635139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.296828858632473 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0466535091400146, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9002426322700907, + "veriT": 6.3668861640427004, + "Yices": 6.4388395225703752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9868279511481348, + "CVC4": 0.13592939881999999, + "CVC3": 1.9106955616068115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13442595047787501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6909097161858575 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7390912519719453, + "veriT": 3.3346731776947141, + "Yices": 5.9578012713431434, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3020028651536482, + "CVC4": 3.7665132505711054, + "CVC3": 3.5926785201969738, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.244931050422001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8470685918712064 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9626424312591553, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4308253151839994, + "veriT": 0.12297493802648572, + "Yices": 2.1373013947427411, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4321205557172858, + "CVC4": 0.15938825642414287, + "CVC3": 0.13642494457585716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14963807246285715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14638827244014285 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1495535373687744, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1695052172058889, + "veriT": 0.157571249666, + "Yices": 0.16177487088177778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16527089551444446, + "CVC4": 0.1811744400741111, + "CVC3": 0.169159893453, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17330300940800003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17101498070566665 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14616042873163637, + "veriT": 0.12237804531254547, + "Yices": 0.14093946508018185, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.140127354909, + "CVC4": 0.16685657994045455, + "CVC3": 0.14255192413218182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15949117596999998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15782742449854548 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1487788704019091, + "veriT": 3.9716671707333391, + "Yices": 0.15553343151390908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15897275810399997, + "CVC4": 0.16888388607599999, + "CVC3": 0.14855092595245456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16123749415818181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15821258901854546 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 80.0, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8937189501794522, + "veriT": 6.9166531718154154, + "Yices": 8.2941858288644479, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8051909114658899, + "CVC4": 2.5666063503864751, + "CVC3": 8.1640103229731675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2071309550338333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9274842140112352 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14772083119236365, + "veriT": 2.7016069507294738, + "Yices": 0.26626757156369085, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18950409258409093, + "CVC4": 0.20380750053190907, + "CVC3": 0.1491693325530182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17721661866761818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17974631097176363 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18799737476007145, + "veriT": 4.3596725208177141, + "Yices": 14.468999286159015, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20393470547828571, + "CVC4": 0.36288444550692855, + "CVC3": 2.4865807561636943, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2334553423886812, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2350448547704316 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3887056279508254, + "veriT": 10.485536846793712, + "Yices": 6.5464963193139543, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7617479398522988, + "CVC4": 8.2411856060243363, + "CVC3": 6.7527952103905546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.252176287110185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.020205383086823 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9976350587556775, + "veriT": 12.954340490386254, + "Yices": 4.9288939682140835, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7206504485849257, + "CVC4": 1.3501990212945596, + "CVC3": 0.71396818021328579, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.24911003835320708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2453862625645 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4847917939215465, + "veriT": 2.7781980150473138, + "Yices": 2.8267286430711605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4836262502805986, + "CVC4": 3.9184554061974608, + "CVC3": 0.15018029918949333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6042061770778702, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6149843366743397 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15252597414623076, + "veriT": 11.733417270961116, + "Yices": 4.6930366858729222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16384679229869997, + "CVC4": 2.4624872399672872, + "CVC3": 3.2441104566833951, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6109599803664105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3649906407815156 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 169.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 41.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8856502091115726, + "veriT": 6.2044312009577549, + "Yices": 12.303500685573088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9278480667827145, + "CVC4": 14.287523457065276, + "CVC3": 8.0593217340466072, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1707746553147964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1695505576116978 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9194006590473176, + "veriT": 11.618876976426176, + "Yices": 5.5173579425392871, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.362568655891382, + "CVC4": 7.793676767207792, + "CVC3": 6.0148913261050057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.230604668306984, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2247539494403008 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14522268332133334, + "veriT": 9.8141433437214918, + "Yices": 3.4859822039683332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24228574265783331, + "CVC4": 4.9055458314123657, + "CVC3": 2.0088955936170003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2138993770786666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6170783059595002 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3228568973562309, + "veriT": 9.9727449314724321, + "Yices": 5.8013373090675264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6747804010598628, + "CVC4": 8.4157576626646993, + "CVC3": 2.3612587013298958, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.166165289620309, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.035708111392964 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8190819472636797, + "veriT": 12.18038519079062, + "Yices": 10.939042267167002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1057260694594078, + "CVC4": 11.544087237995338, + "CVC3": 11.631220952934951, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.462983493793462, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.265418546730874 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7778844833374023, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 64.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.858915765751927, + "veriT": 9.0241636827725564, + "Yices": 9.0256529976544435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.448209451865932, + "CVC4": 4.0950147229802232, + "CVC3": 9.3502748335647574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.659368689912137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.668169578744127 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.267411474098825, + "veriT": 10.718283404812711, + "Yices": 10.439158597546344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.984139012914142, + "CVC4": 14.339466678554528, + "CVC3": 14.256175766525928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.270937474907143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.418337777121765 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0522866004072116, + "veriT": 12.873776907626814, + "Yices": 12.483288592349529, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9013496907731593, + "CVC4": 5.0478912775064204, + "CVC3": 3.7156079645860225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.892870880629156, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.860450243683493 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7735044956207275, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8983738874457519, + "veriT": 9.0052976229652426, + "Yices": 7.5703741421656154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8934333588407553, + "CVC4": 9.3925018661930544, + "CVC3": 5.5527254448419505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.446556859166966, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.477291258961779 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7581220612656638, + "veriT": 13.204418747240936, + "Yices": 9.8602550039257597, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.842745888982288, + "CVC4": 6.2418415652460864, + "CVC3": 9.1831100346606664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.103947552761841, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.002677467820407 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3234083996082218, + "veriT": 13.546442903294194, + "Yices": 13.051129512633381, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.696549408878584, + "CVC4": 14.632465102392961, + "CVC3": 11.807008260507319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246744674280295, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.245745153437481 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 99.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254194706262483, + "veriT": 10.187107058463857, + "Yices": 10.338191666021284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976479935907339, + "CVC4": 14.357365371711809, + "CVC3": 13.663466355665573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253435663706307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.852032722133137 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.258276912652562, + "veriT": 12.445413128152646, + "Yices": 12.623450464433791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.811479492688752, + "CVC4": 14.376270820556933, + "CVC3": 12.333029042908313, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8931088766224935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.91624156258024 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 117.0, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.227307568457329, + "veriT": 13.136213628721482, + "Yices": 13.166333248481987, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.941862927733499, + "CVC4": 14.406892994940184, + "CVC3": 3.1429080745950633, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.671800523928169, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.49629360995071 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.311488624599889, + "veriT": 13.548826319466571, + "Yices": 13.144503381654461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.558366463820741, + "CVC4": 14.452929423622669, + "CVC3": 14.222290547686447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.918988136479399, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.67712479555424 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 164.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23900829731421666, + "veriT": 7.5095843830455706, + "Yices": 4.6494081654666397, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.51728924393625009, + "CVC4": 1.4975053644518737, + "CVC3": 4.6253448440177145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0265369086330471, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.020075885413557 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1512346267700195, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1847856123229299, + "veriT": 13.339408373823572, + "Yices": 9.1938931410113085, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.438199534128008, + "CVC4": 7.7189903214306996, + "CVC3": 1.6486835326372151, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2352297846167994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9549930621306371 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5448509458865001, + "veriT": 10.044611238232473, + "Yices": 8.6680051461652017, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.651086035318336, + "CVC4": 0.95200351954039986, + "CVC3": 11.445185789191457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19322687935180002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.846642392145438 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.501573641526833, + "veriT": 12.500108350423062, + "Yices": 14.272398200551057, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.333061119632934, + "CVC4": 14.75566428890939, + "CVC3": 13.753620187355601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7043771699839145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.670066306922505 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9724578864698072, + "veriT": 13.424404703362494, + "Yices": 14.229438663584855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0344341844369236, + "CVC4": 12.323145454758922, + "CVC3": 11.059376754231973, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.891030669318098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.498264303767581 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1117300987243652, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.226723630934581, + "veriT": 12.686657326798832, + "Yices": 11.382169554133398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.333797219321998, + "CVC4": 14.649589213079008, + "CVC3": 14.216352370473119, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.941499498546817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.993440839534751 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.664489230109707, + "veriT": 14.222763830878534, + "Yices": 14.233541068184921, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955196131924405, + "CVC4": 14.298095740455251, + "CVC3": 13.767140939057603, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.980558813305992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.836585365055518 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5098051424248844, + "veriT": 12.625392048181904, + "Yices": 9.856872910234916, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.586782269316597, + "CVC4": 10.183110241403385, + "CVC3": 9.2867900061014304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6365712967532708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0133493474174013 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 455.0, + "true": 151 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3661990635749994, + "veriT": 13.7165480485942, + "Yices": 13.534583636005136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.529304914915732, + "CVC4": 14.629087293961661, + "CVC3": 9.8776767078376242, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.01057847356577, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.016660637909618 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "false": 156, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1826062202453613, + "true": 153 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "false": 155, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 154 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.76779962882093, + "veriT": 13.452726356156337, + "Yices": 13.120850169587698, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.960389901545806, + "CVC4": 14.450298230771432, + "CVC3": 13.721773722020222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.269304404265821, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.692021354112089 + }, + { + "index": 155, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.261537945859867, + "veriT": 12.52051792710115, + "Yices": 14.262109878775863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976756238655403, + "CVC4": 14.440801784866974, + "CVC3": 11.172656277990356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3947297753709131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9359261663051335 + }, + { + "index": 156, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254922247864158, + "veriT": 14.245341929279999, + "Yices": 14.242699802744317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975307135398033, + "CVC4": 14.806940873429113, + "CVC3": 13.437241678395511, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260989334314822, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.263066335555799 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12425508563376669, + "veriT": 0.096497829184166675, + "Yices": 0.097198899862596652, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12170573740413333, + "CVC4": 0.1221865001474, + "CVC3": 0.10238606409744665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11984346315773334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11921321345644666 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0044059277798989, + "veriT": 4.1322965205693478, + "Yices": 4.0286305848978188, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0696571365811736, + "CVC4": 5.2135723511639256, + "CVC3": 1.7903550760960056, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2932971227656598, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2923955759131003 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1033186515612001, + "veriT": 0.075263003259345013, + "Yices": 0.079900029798970013, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1031997991429552, + "CVC4": 0.10039242569287499, + "CVC3": 0.081500496025444999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.09776376396309501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.097427196104545005 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.41428542137146, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9639591656912205, + "veriT": 10.165516748511498, + "Yices": 10.350650503481665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0973396336914747, + "CVC4": 0.14802050726758331, + "CVC3": 0.70780292166433323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14908736067254169, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.437795447611647 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.3484845161437988, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5926178894674285, + "veriT": 4.4205942407655714, + "Yices": 8.1535863846399419, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6693044295569999, + "CVC4": 0.15819920253257141, + "CVC3": 2.0088774628082136, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15024112278685717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.576159362439 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5399020524502269, + "veriT": 4.4338644696790004, + "Yices": 7.4164775177061433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5551542366788791, + "CVC4": 0.64715774775642854, + "CVC3": 2.6730341792636048, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1666438919218636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5060438445232727 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.784695537198278, + "veriT": 12.763343432852173, + "Yices": 12.24591306186324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.068711067830908, + "CVC4": 12.097311913696634, + "CVC3": 10.957088461821842, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.250619739751015, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.311126538268232 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6417344145815638, + "veriT": 5.8130767657955538, + "Yices": 9.5423711064704744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7652353250770974, + "CVC4": 2.7960598916733486, + "CVC3": 3.025026770978728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7104490570596829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5573055804378733 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.465352538329018, + "veriT": 8.1701754164399993, + "Yices": 10.349787327350199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.043346065119646, + "CVC4": 0.1729676490249, + "CVC3": 10.369243219630302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6214732216091061, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.35482167650019 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.720375346258525, + "veriT": 10.445274407288609, + "Yices": 10.270668434592501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.348164688326134, + "CVC4": 3.1988760887820527, + "CVC3": 12.595156583495116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7576174088605176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.335518504211551 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1543455994387299, + "veriT": 5.1468007558590001, + "Yices": 8.6999314845838303, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5537352818096579, + "CVC4": 0.62855752658450004, + "CVC3": 7.1916992279879031, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6842276789481678, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1401012917252409 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238765849838579, + "veriT": 10.157126179860599, + "Yices": 10.334411456307, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956383368743268, + "CVC4": 0.1558220571152, + "CVC3": 9.9657650574468981, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.635910690834131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.267235900272487 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.990529839177091, + "veriT": 10.206785247973334, + "Yices": 10.343281827607111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.9611983161103, + "CVC4": 0.19598791451333333, + "CVC3": 12.85065099917516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16399695363166666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.281198885279723 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.231970064723892, + "veriT": 11.168296212571068, + "Yices": 10.764856199558736, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.426027121506866, + "CVC4": 3.8612686724130514, + "CVC3": 11.702286391489224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15064463038250001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5172086766493642 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.425179013524152, + "veriT": 11.91299711374927, + "Yices": 8.8885613615135082, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0073879504770904, + "CVC4": 10.607868446572668, + "CVC3": 7.60465254255225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.046421891423128, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.05794760181629 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7063894271850586, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4807689189910889, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.063252730293421, + "veriT": 13.410234860539415, + "Yices": 12.957320788078794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.569786658714291, + "CVC4": 10.930302824466358, + "CVC3": 12.822160401308642, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.312674792599774, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.435596456096309 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.602140637545, + "veriT": 9.0206923307047333, + "Yices": 3.6159797862052288, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.953555893169, + "CVC4": 0.16178769887957142, + "CVC3": 1.7119953000550001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7497792701435073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7236874902731429 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9720503074187432, + "veriT": 9.7526309912236648, + "Yices": 14.492545492842234, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1360320599318543, + "CVC4": 7.3277731742071595, + "CVC3": 8.5861527005690501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1919425506330823, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1879453410382199 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.778494986183988, + "veriT": 11.500963014490022, + "Yices": 10.794842053815444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.41500552345434, + "CVC4": 6.6166072487128496, + "CVC3": 14.226083321508391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4060666471842342, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.2607636947322 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1915207858172732, + "veriT": 9.8077649667337123, + "Yices": 7.2156512579967265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.770991974599822, + "CVC4": 5.3483866483106324, + "CVC3": 1.585617081690909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.672903069700228, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.832867076639179 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.260213066317561, + "veriT": 10.188876897663402, + "Yices": 10.3558669505856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977382414875914, + "CVC4": 9.9431312191838153, + "CVC3": 14.130580429010664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.258361529881418, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.877659958929586 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 160.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4785042653515879, + "veriT": 4.445563468808543, + "Yices": 3.0232390189714349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3563012014447402, + "CVC4": 3.8333377367093306, + "CVC3": 3.6175026056799831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6322633480733209, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6330387457089635 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4002238017235564, + "veriT": 6.3942788220578599, + "Yices": 7.4443778949656441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9653025695528283, + "CVC4": 9.186760735395799, + "CVC3": 4.4958892016894074, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0521121045678719, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9337332075869247 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2936559522415951, + "veriT": 11.839940727114882, + "Yices": 9.5117666530812901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0149149364186609, + "CVC4": 12.365863827867551, + "CVC3": 12.273113186684579, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.219701493715602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.21967247750989 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0302093176656999, + "veriT": 1.0827923425618915, + "Yices": 0.98257430705075011, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9358302794501498, + "CVC4": 1.0100427230989999, + "CVC3": 0.20417417720949996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16400629771139166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1667173973932583 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9979087114506129, + "veriT": 6.3660317641870305, + "Yices": 6.7702222058091701, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1817429549316527, + "CVC4": 1.0226971987531819, + "CVC3": 0.35299872453823627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6642568499109904, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.202382127587155 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5720491421512079, + "veriT": 10.11907347114041, + "Yices": 10.116942264111989, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.31322904669835, + "CVC4": 2.9253612207213857, + "CVC3": 2.9611484723098442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232667801212228, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230331123064227 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12643436775546152, + "veriT": 1.6394396184447229, + "Yices": 4.2663789144384046, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12582444109523075, + "CVC4": 0.1329474515483077, + "CVC3": 0.11026876952429231, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12836732207753848, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12728275670215383 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16520655706189999, + "veriT": 1.56932649967056, + "Yices": 12.708300355189536, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17795780627910002, + "CVC4": 11.568181954592802, + "CVC3": 11.003383704186598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8740590133584583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8881959665712356 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0399685511108867, + "veriT": 8.5912017049792944, + "Yices": 10.761933367986682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6654195320828009, + "CVC4": 7.3654298026910157, + "CVC3": 6.5698426112741997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4004545711792051, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3976817774035997 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.487653992704075, + "veriT": 8.9234600850753765, + "Yices": 9.0655354131144996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.113413222276479, + "CVC4": 0.73882767366062496, + "CVC3": 9.8338628370080876, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9685471549796993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9107317865264992 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7341337549751943, + "veriT": 12.369361404066687, + "Yices": 12.396439519194892, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.528903824125059, + "CVC4": 10.64848008925054, + "CVC3": 6.4016523396295417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.765943889122703, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.587135429464228 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1578214372754996, + "veriT": 14.195830687646518, + "Yices": 10.662910209255561, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1082326562099993, + "CVC4": 12.837797520751852, + "CVC3": 11.464720737483862, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.527731784376126, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.561022110458573 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0532564792137391, + "veriT": 7.0383991076196946, + "Yices": 12.760494219416453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2998855724522906, + "CVC4": 9.85245691267707, + "CVC3": 9.8088555819895547, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5776491788664355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5664925345510214 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3803866450093336, + "veriT": 2.1215536817144445, + "Yices": 1.6942132575056306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4431973458361336, + "CVC4": 1.7326158040661297, + "CVC3": 4.4144479453136505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0583469305830846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0566854100822809 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8948397023324848, + "veriT": 9.3722330255879367, + "Yices": 11.831946932073912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8202909767780699, + "CVC4": 6.0902243699714855, + "CVC3": 5.1736108582257909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7833227258429272, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4401739212964557 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.223842014269787, + "veriT": 8.7383401757839998, + "Yices": 8.9041376994858563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.736730411703727, + "CVC4": 0.17918430902342858, + "CVC3": 8.6415510014427834, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17154779444914287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2728346623681066 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 85.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4086328600458886, + "veriT": 0.17039238580555555, + "Yices": 2.3947578525912219, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4082150556047779, + "CVC4": 0.18766861997066664, + "CVC3": 0.1783692483307778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18228814899055557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18191410840311112 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16302468207163637, + "veriT": 0.14551495129181818, + "Yices": 0.16023645079854545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15456085718363635, + "CVC4": 0.19772808729172728, + "CVC3": 0.16244780685881818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18047256629672728, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17715011569727274 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0672414302825928, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12068056868811111, + "veriT": 5.4604730435657567, + "Yices": 3.8931969653779754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1400771850651111, + "CVC4": 0.14375336605566666, + "CVC3": 0.11312217611891112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7038191628127182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.694661466003633 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.3970977092995, + "veriT": 2.2446734153380397, + "Yices": 11.366519214871261, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6577657575678333, + "CVC4": 5.0749795864702643, + "CVC3": 2.315261045408501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6060825745883678, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6062975910440032 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7069252699001107, + "veriT": 11.978143794364691, + "Yices": 6.7151144047303912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1838042223797558, + "CVC4": 10.779335440585083, + "CVC3": 10.883702608348468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5912230851467726, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4149048939968907 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1950135524868, + "veriT": 3.1769248004911401, + "Yices": 7.0493119403512523, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19713791228620001, + "CVC4": 4.4513841913351371, + "CVC3": 0.20437247242079998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.47368974178968992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4344205115814264 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1977892281055951, + "veriT": 7.9608638964459209, + "Yices": 9.157509358969472, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.076160130639671, + "CVC4": 6.7012298887191335, + "CVC3": 3.6969913913919559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5460787310519279, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5432210625642266 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13510281344788, + "veriT": 7.4848280850633788, + "Yices": 7.1226331025499459, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5888611803790644, + "CVC4": 4.3429549640274905, + "CVC3": 4.6096087471450646, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2987285913717819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.333451188444402 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0458266523027788, + "veriT": 4.9062903298572564, + "Yices": 6.84869318475819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0488310878451088, + "CVC4": 14.321526520851608, + "CVC3": 2.4710107757266666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15981720083666665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1579759381128889 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7975371613211193, + "veriT": 13.268471383222124, + "Yices": 7.2763703784236942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.95547792900408, + "CVC4": 11.35995280861305, + "CVC3": 5.75879668768893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233679633675013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.962434915345758 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 61.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20679409499199999, + "veriT": 12.866813522075166, + "Yices": 3.5292795017648673, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.256692103405044, + "CVC4": 5.8524413337035206, + "CVC3": 2.70914694232565, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.202430118053305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.183618262360623 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8771369457244873, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1562315923754292, + "veriT": 12.337418387589754, + "Yices": 8.7457071562335518, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6078648614129376, + "CVC4": 4.4344490636255509, + "CVC3": 7.9029932203735296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2763229262306721, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.510651208009854 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3546831006071871, + "veriT": 13.903041998052721, + "Yices": 13.014015665061446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6176293947007601, + "CVC4": 9.6963434237819417, + "CVC3": 11.258123717943912, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232579078913371, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.993272487448555 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2962500710704445, + "veriT": 11.9476501046347, + "Yices": 5.1723075226790955, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8198661477485285, + "CVC4": 1.8248012810306053, + "CVC3": 1.8276244713479757, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.821136085076648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8170035378452853 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.32417019655292312, + "veriT": 8.3544047070327618, + "Yices": 8.6212140037417555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0598274812153077, + "CVC4": 8.9168638475547546, + "CVC3": 6.7033977376278466, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.449628459677526, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3511525303240797 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5596916128324256, + "veriT": 13.390347168934039, + "Yices": 7.7575412944910793, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.120228450561202, + "CVC4": 6.011643286399325, + "CVC3": 8.6387639341187406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1096369283975154, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9998251197716712 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13774056269583332, + "veriT": 0.11213610141438334, + "Yices": 0.13001047179849998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13397209941451665, + "CVC4": 0.15172806892179999, + "CVC3": 0.13386523648533333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14468547569685, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14910543913491667 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1535696008597143, + "veriT": 0.13400075280100002, + "Yices": 0.14608046032871427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15375912949442855, + "CVC4": 0.17371584414042857, + "CVC3": 0.15514662291842859, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16890327518971432, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16677977229528571 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16188020437362499, + "veriT": 5.4245009001909024, + "Yices": 0.16944216047475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18766348383737499, + "CVC4": 0.18919942334875001, + "CVC3": 0.47463311157725002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17242786981187502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17088844434100001 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5741967832821615, + "veriT": 1.1453173447486003, + "Yices": 1.14033413893399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6452973302010374, + "CVC4": 7.2321913494660706, + "CVC3": 1.5459660914474271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5481892855365911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5372183534685624 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2440619468688965, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 240.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.96077192351485718, + "veriT": 12.466716572561563, + "Yices": 3.5858473182608122, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0618061170411019, + "CVC4": 3.2233565564848581, + "CVC3": 1.7762152308887145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9095927804139206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9672403301152377 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9603547901729748, + "veriT": 13.27652839950979, + "Yices": 11.461745092568169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.794235352910849, + "CVC4": 5.6340533340827275, + "CVC3": 5.9329286877985794, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.069326593811507, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.062363632183095 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3591226821052675, + "veriT": 9.5976596912732628, + "Yices": 11.595285956004084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.730572767230182, + "CVC4": 13.201774576568591, + "CVC3": 7.0028333457651692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9035239890404974, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6495145352811766 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9604353644145789, + "veriT": 10.620201377633562, + "Yices": 5.6902914654482863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6715087988674124, + "CVC4": 1.6545794825801297, + "CVC3": 2.6601159135188004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.28973186443518179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.28510124797272723 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6747869547229755, + "veriT": 12.250084705921127, + "Yices": 4.9791355120800578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8910067507438479, + "CVC4": 7.9405452088850978, + "CVC3": 7.1180170746587885, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5659637168183886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5673156642688975 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9482748793103264, + "veriT": 12.601416103951051, + "Yices": 13.464103255418127, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0376491350125034, + "CVC4": 14.535004114520621, + "CVC3": 10.418869842563833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.079717505505622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.992967500339466 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.758065010616869, + "veriT": 12.129125057240971, + "Yices": 13.293678708472434, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.081611480439506, + "CVC4": 14.610648935765131, + "CVC3": 13.470680089929077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.116492690571855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.139316699526558 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6065413022319914, + "veriT": 10.713188103083972, + "Yices": 9.2344711582546992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9784874184031311, + "CVC4": 9.4464673577800227, + "CVC3": 7.6696664905481065, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.741924884599227, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.764464104139158 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7316538418228404, + "veriT": 14.228861861038011, + "Yices": 11.289769978607334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.467104651958286, + "CVC4": 8.9778400503703519, + "CVC3": 13.806273787164802, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3166327912998725, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3184293997193821 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8264142871270979, + "veriT": 11.965398321705036, + "Yices": 13.356523345659932, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.19865598823964, + "CVC4": 14.610756384495925, + "CVC3": 8.0254772915445027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5632843762916586, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9228388005282149 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 247.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.032804268896843, + "veriT": 11.774017462270619, + "Yices": 11.379746372512278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.975004391338285, + "CVC4": 14.093287143790757, + "CVC3": 13.823628394363221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.61637069068961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.129462172829783 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6648853865435189, + "veriT": 11.119358245044273, + "Yices": 10.085717990065756, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.838177730341103, + "CVC4": 10.574536915702399, + "CVC3": 6.2442017420473128, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5038910013107154, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2859147234889852 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 359.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.836053731328485, + "veriT": 14.234422810158694, + "Yices": 13.57719030514836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.101326061807566, + "CVC4": 14.395740050849453, + "CVC3": 13.973289710515328, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252603246730496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.251462786387631 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259682441202756, + "veriT": 12.53989876288483, + "Yices": 13.13564506631146, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.012268961626798, + "CVC4": 14.627095056271971, + "CVC3": 14.254118058597086, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.274893711924729, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.388155573426626 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 131.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241523069700662, + "veriT": 10.197098254083501, + "Yices": 10.340337620102101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968106071747036, + "CVC4": 14.268225380856606, + "CVC3": 14.243484202453924, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239392347650034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.117617145239894 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254484794635687, + "veriT": 12.628244193031005, + "Yices": 12.358515801969707, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968608742641745, + "CVC4": 14.555513751517413, + "CVC3": 14.277329119357324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.990796170381497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.958900583734861 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.171258390861322, + "veriT": 13.33067337870254, + "Yices": 12.797546430620875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966076430534478, + "CVC4": 14.741322714080297, + "CVC3": 13.02746107053154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.248569145920035, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.788238646552804 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.231585614133937, + "veriT": 13.77315729554533, + "Yices": 13.812010276962202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.56251224332116, + "CVC4": 14.509835803519637, + "CVC3": 8.2647084022781403, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.650380426313596, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.899899229558818 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12184316328476193, + "veriT": 0.091963818170623809, + "Yices": 0.094454187036566675, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11916349969957143, + "CVC4": 0.12156454681999998, + "CVC3": 0.098736885808099986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11825085684585716, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1167845755811905 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10984429058546499, + "veriT": 0.082002108195775011, + "Yices": 0.085434234609819998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10875641278189499, + "CVC4": 0.10536342212385001, + "CVC3": 0.087822511529664998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.105309130167105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.104537507549655 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1127221808802998, + "veriT": 0.085618945599719998, + "Yices": 0.082625309993749993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1133376549930007, + "CVC4": 0.12001532472630001, + "CVC3": 0.091901188788210006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11480595377829998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1155401210426 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.404004848135855, + "veriT": 7.4490711379803436, + "Yices": 7.1880006149096349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.92173817999231, + "CVC4": 2.7255169742188659, + "CVC3": 2.9718294473384295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17304717304690911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8447625188970411 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2099332894981428, + "veriT": 10.166518601138749, + "Yices": 10.351767407061931, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26137781280642858, + "CVC4": 0.15068400351725003, + "CVC3": 0.68356406585825014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14725781475117858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.43076594294549 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17232514150791664, + "veriT": 5.9704607179364997, + "Yices": 7.035783868712751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25500091864300001, + "CVC4": 0.154241530376, + "CVC3": 0.23413647791241665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14843103900358334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.62154731113975 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6939799785614014, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7793443640067141, + "veriT": 6.0349634680183772, + "Yices": 5.0725996718193551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1764878650565391, + "CVC4": 2.2685798027206645, + "CVC3": 1.7933684740535001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0601357440306964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2261994202634421 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.903308396734749, + "veriT": 10.501163493225738, + "Yices": 10.453930947213335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.559292617110216, + "CVC4": 1.3916803513722205, + "CVC3": 10.576400379821083, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3185653801720527, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.518535866230089 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3066489227877538, + "veriT": 8.5115740651153331, + "Yices": 8.6643141293063337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7366896595823285, + "CVC4": 0.19224826031883335, + "CVC3": 5.0351182306274067, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0366770542824133, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.466819879644234 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.006276081160996, + "veriT": 9.5966908435153346, + "Yices": 10.540434124662255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.682269241581546, + "CVC4": 0.17710711158244441, + "CVC3": 13.386528168899423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6833579300876194, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.300235915955856 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.303538644627193, + "veriT": 9.6007330364015271, + "Yices": 9.843160690918527, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.195507491653844, + "CVC4": 10.439778768739403, + "CVC3": 10.915082017304005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.634293990012079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6341824799563902 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.825871951871648, + "veriT": 11.280180796239845, + "Yices": 12.05884443881105, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.468036426746394, + "CVC4": 1.1637846158664999, + "CVC3": 11.957925772185954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.007068215769233, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3069385561270899 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.157458286951206, + "veriT": 9.5980171486222936, + "Yices": 5.0682158341239276, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4268279525463194, + "CVC4": 4.8678028148461063, + "CVC3": 4.3032645221633929, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.240753805687177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.24483834888072 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.38454497988155, + "veriT": 11.688585957232199, + "Yices": 10.845208774999808, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.789101173714817, + "CVC4": 13.359332361692367, + "CVC3": 14.234682519282448, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232610104353004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.438978425546981 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1515170676836508, + "veriT": 11.521912750596398, + "Yices": 11.715747373853361, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1895308683381103, + "CVC4": 13.938794079636397, + "CVC3": 9.5293401648761034, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225908072821305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.682574452344504 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0940479739390234, + "veriT": 8.5548159645183155, + "Yices": 6.0945186434227665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7827196174151911, + "CVC4": 8.6544091040787041, + "CVC3": 8.5540115591039871, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7523260407903551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7493969054501655 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.961382211606029, + "veriT": 10.72184372689614, + "Yices": 11.020461134378253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.04732473035277, + "CVC4": 8.7184798037772566, + "CVC3": 8.3675346982815526, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.473539339878535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.361095552573163 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238610951771575, + "veriT": 10.162595837109833, + "Yices": 10.330234583328666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957806994966852, + "CVC4": 0.16885471269266664, + "CVC3": 13.54648072304675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.458672581962455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.293518793456244 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.815876861423686, + "veriT": 10.550251037633624, + "Yices": 9.2316003071334993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.461837155226826, + "CVC4": 4.420128256292494, + "CVC3": 12.45411628354986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6569741992412066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1574098602381362 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13884685884012499, + "veriT": 1.4040054339289749, + "Yices": 0.130307553325575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12930151188733749, + "CVC4": 1.991849871887948, + "CVC3": 0.13147155049164996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.388809248951375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3864309804630874 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3838327521812763, + "veriT": 4.5703130418019269, + "Yices": 8.0338764587481286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5992573097298619, + "CVC4": 1.6578172436179617, + "CVC3": 2.9136395313441095, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6368972331213112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9873554184777156 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.207988585998157, + "veriT": 8.6721016380587521, + "Yices": 9.7504881670708823, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3834253705314943, + "CVC4": 3.264377584650588, + "CVC3": 8.9349212493188812, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0955988685223694, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1924086262298674 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0735450265159923, + "veriT": 14.184598481974568, + "Yices": 12.47236249329189, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.539272928560404, + "CVC4": 13.42993092622539, + "CVC3": 7.9382924886985622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.105737273804239, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.10435697287037 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.106236777927915, + "veriT": 9.1362280347678713, + "Yices": 9.632731147198264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.664962009863727, + "CVC4": 0.16693579856922225, + "CVC3": 9.4454033575736798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8541102309321955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8202287633489753 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2336922268322548, + "veriT": 5.5058284019658696, + "Yices": 12.234876388243173, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4687134755074585, + "CVC4": 4.8627872970736243, + "CVC3": 3.4758751280002378, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3221169715568033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7270726701079817 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.652778148651123, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25279102804139997, + "veriT": 10.629214007104732, + "Yices": 4.9486787624158017, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.452700067539, + "CVC4": 0.17338839169420001, + "CVC3": 2.2425118778855802, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.152358667477, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15233874857140001 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8514398225848323, + "veriT": 9.8466229542018304, + "Yices": 9.9392826142949016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0986287561762031, + "CVC4": 2.5910218518264783, + "CVC3": 6.0542070797890668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.781605179025743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7928375364388662 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.771099617926013, + "veriT": 9.9355854537954329, + "Yices": 5.4246444513666727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9335350279979999, + "CVC4": 5.5818415070981509, + "CVC3": 5.0158987467471414, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.014338828974781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.030322451136467 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7664898355309075, + "veriT": 12.388608463487802, + "Yices": 1.1532113547810003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8434311933655962, + "CVC4": 4.4597227038289216, + "CVC3": 4.5062900673965451, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.734288253377443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.852986173359108 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6502184710198842, + "veriT": 13.199503452187361, + "Yices": 10.27414705885745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6053938912775898, + "CVC4": 6.8705254380607013, + "CVC3": 4.8480948546876359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.211189983676553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.211032746795494 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2344319820404053, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9166665077209473, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.761609989885509, + "veriT": 9.2772516589761178, + "Yices": 9.01906814389468, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.14878618059608, + "CVC4": 2.2846645002692347, + "CVC3": 12.200500752574888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1811094911270938, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.398230061655726 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7859569333399454, + "veriT": 10.12166538712793, + "Yices": 8.1422223521953789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1055038169631004, + "CVC4": 5.9396067673589981, + "CVC3": 3.0020622324878361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2892507077462092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3165724580268119 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2235813659891818, + "veriT": 3.6578434020664514, + "Yices": 9.0482599911927259, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.55182079336263634, + "CVC4": 5.4381237926136352, + "CVC3": 6.0365316143191823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.276795858427983, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.914288707845342 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3106308287388218, + "veriT": 2.8892593807451248, + "Yices": 3.5477761297650332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8486821609487727, + "CVC4": 2.6569836022823252, + "CVC3": 2.7808797271943502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5888225115125372, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5581401409719784 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1801257289706868, + "veriT": 5.9800756945686748, + "Yices": 7.4770253766546952, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3969216463135092, + "CVC4": 5.1532099415440005, + "CVC3": 6.728643151168769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.198005478451166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1958337851219651 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.535847283448998, + "veriT": 10.094477035731042, + "Yices": 10.101741289287778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5317747448656078, + "CVC4": 7.719283228210319, + "CVC3": 4.0794293264108399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.218047858833533, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.21882525099543 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4434096558136309, + "veriT": 5.8060682913826662, + "Yices": 12.699075434728298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7476074854255694, + "CVC4": 8.6232356400600647, + "CVC3": 6.660413169938515, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6820185254083557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4124614869917611 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2562384286370001, + "veriT": 0.13098013622696664, + "Yices": 0.13256861677581114, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2535953902491221, + "CVC4": 3.2844527967382104, + "CVC3": 0.13663330491262221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1455998262041111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14156269344866668 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13650096168766665, + "veriT": 5.1107399527080331, + "Yices": 7.4580200842696982, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13356038079116667, + "CVC4": 0.14518720978683333, + "CVC3": 2.4758585208808359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.144358353016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13472410241883334 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4226188659667969, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13032120676446668, + "veriT": 5.9822516090136615, + "Yices": 4.6545480715541485, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1295269589196, + "CVC4": 0.13700459423553332, + "CVC3": 0.12891524957013334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12951850737260001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13006893973026667 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18461529050599998, + "veriT": 0.16094823929644, + "Yices": 4.1658713502989801, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18395919417209997, + "CVC4": 0.19773855899350001, + "CVC3": 0.17357453295104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1819672647078, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18611733744699999 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0361776732929999, + "veriT": 9.4478737486301476, + "Yices": 10.51599229932655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0029974532113828, + "CVC4": 6.8270957438505322, + "CVC3": 9.6701610686730142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1670484138268513, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4106828281870394 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.541634593455225, + "veriT": 10.002536833662356, + "Yices": 10.171601010330384, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.004874113896108, + "CVC4": 8.1536201519915021, + "CVC3": 4.5480095575142734, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4401588406382917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2973426476054204 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19285352212423079, + "veriT": 13.583126112516229, + "Yices": 10.843723882621287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.95303615604361547, + "CVC4": 6.571312051924517, + "CVC3": 13.153058298827441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.955023024930098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.951481408965986 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2040723804267666, + "veriT": 5.8226904192067144, + "Yices": 5.0927918115692608, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5975031373306057, + "CVC4": 6.304186052429591, + "CVC3": 3.7957197917441059, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0202589647845253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.006535960516012 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5414324381140494, + "veriT": 10.198895365447417, + "Yices": 11.309480650658562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.98531667053477, + "CVC4": 14.280843132272237, + "CVC3": 6.3735016951135686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.96462005624859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2070368172741528 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15600915208410002, + "veriT": 0.1355933632844, + "Yices": 0.14607921962001999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15132999923593998, + "CVC4": 1.5886931160951172, + "CVC3": 0.15603539595894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16265001016599998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16500408406177999 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.148250463025, + "veriT": 7.0550763550665012, + "Yices": 0.15786485452724999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16028724314050002, + "CVC4": 0.17133929582075, + "CVC3": 0.1464614438955, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15592982212000001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15551532640900001 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23907308931610907, + "veriT": 0.17284900056567271, + "Yices": 7.2474300447147355, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.5731037307296637, + "CVC4": 1.5137324782298216, + "CVC3": 0.21218483847945455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20986326605710001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20822076122135458 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 52.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8596571784736664, + "veriT": 6.5573521498951743, + "Yices": 11.602342920084672, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.859050535625167, + "CVC4": 9.8423275829017758, + "CVC3": 10.370026531651934, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7099189963276658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7956684987660125 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.413037056945655, + "veriT": 5.4106870408103962, + "Yices": 3.2968044900644067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1424172655357641, + "CVC4": 5.4927352812880184, + "CVC3": 1.4559763386684998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17335594897800002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16930485963831252 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 67.0, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3116048976276602, + "veriT": 8.6317895717721527, + "Yices": 9.2995564351487232, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7424436523475229, + "CVC4": 7.3943069871501486, + "CVC3": 9.4932770820817289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5339317357202127, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4280609351788645 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8585489988327026, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6701988515405999, + "veriT": 12.697076514522365, + "Yices": 4.9695005117798106, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.224225245410654, + "CVC4": 0.82514674603212501, + "CVC3": 4.0025517054858124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.067251418405422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.059012982849775 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0452916728656154, + "veriT": 11.779779237032272, + "Yices": 11.441513232234866, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6802030563123775, + "CVC4": 9.6184591430198374, + "CVC3": 9.5144812639517458, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.189247496185214, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.484234578467577 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9804697346463329, + "veriT": 11.190018436683054, + "Yices": 2.1538990417781663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0763260762720348, + "CVC4": 7.2596784865025183, + "CVC3": 4.8522434961290006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1999134022702362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2021913593268394 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0136110782623291, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6256968539752199, + "veriT": 14.219555646873166, + "Yices": 14.19647990767101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.456352899855375, + "CVC4": 14.376254459773719, + "CVC3": 5.562557986958681, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.227675833997267, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.231106671410258 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.068048779378824, + "veriT": 13.418714347079609, + "Yices": 12.657328791179618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.004138257487657, + "CVC4": 14.473783451783214, + "CVC3": 13.431848654410468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.358281519804816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.908164300900813 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2452827394916017, + "veriT": 13.188934913833474, + "Yices": 9.7046158120525945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.948915687763126, + "CVC4": 13.016020230299015, + "CVC3": 9.6623632962739929, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.097659749098499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.104031015768664 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.940325925391051, + "veriT": 10.520917110745627, + "Yices": 11.016141050230411, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.231523738011717, + "CVC4": 13.119356508362813, + "CVC3": 12.455065288455124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254554105719606, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.780901002768859 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.133885366535871, + "veriT": 14.216893908117346, + "Yices": 13.953356688543193, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.520391763888215, + "CVC4": 13.513608432985615, + "CVC3": 13.498006849567973, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239007577805575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.2400388882531 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1124155406372278, + "veriT": 12.475435289313058, + "Yices": 11.563139219669569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8038190616303442, + "CVC4": 12.773872626455256, + "CVC3": 6.9613664283136538, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2206719391586898, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2138575908573666 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 113.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.587035260044829, + "veriT": 7.1347730354380401, + "Yices": 8.3835200021739649, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.018761834014908, + "CVC4": 10.07726977920041, + "CVC3": 6.4046015226144322, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6220529071283938, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0519242880735877 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14738479647702502, + "veriT": 5.3788287004009474, + "Yices": 0.12451926323645002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18864313934800001, + "CVC4": 0.1688739775185, + "CVC3": 1.8163000643152001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.146708781292575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13976097136839999 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4790704858403334, + "veriT": 10.855251883498383, + "Yices": 8.6678234760513, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4242096845498393, + "CVC4": 2.7542813786639275, + "CVC3": 4.0276172825205707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7193462110523092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7177209299905591 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4309757984855533, + "veriT": 11.062714871395103, + "Yices": 11.139942027219005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.599996477978445, + "CVC4": 14.484206814848505, + "CVC3": 10.134859060219684, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.244472701735273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.253934706658589 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6415484514375036, + "veriT": 11.009350473092464, + "Yices": 7.4679107398150286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0157997325991293, + "CVC4": 0.31475507711337497, + "CVC3": 1.1390462262481251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2092657640975, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20316972324324997 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1136724948883057, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3712217261450963, + "veriT": 12.441368676873152, + "Yices": 11.141428373597478, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.72398397773518, + "CVC4": 5.2829704609840755, + "CVC3": 14.235352520697164, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5600846279531044, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.796728851768229 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7835228101859997, + "veriT": 9.6813682284427287, + "Yices": 13.099808795652716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.357429395305063, + "CVC4": 13.253685032055641, + "CVC3": 11.722770762231219, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6335509291681998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4058281894331714 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 68.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7520468975401311, + "veriT": 10.562121914699334, + "Yices": 9.8216649428714398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8069788779621074, + "CVC4": 14.383618746205826, + "CVC3": 9.4768075461562962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.996509236816529, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.957070384071882 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8827671145530003, + "veriT": 7.408095483163275, + "Yices": 10.224145477390131, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7737564439674038, + "CVC4": 8.1856824639040777, + "CVC3": 7.4157862884339574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3835128964059509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3720216195798649 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1966161727905273, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 95.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.391911140713052, + "veriT": 10.779227607818331, + "Yices": 11.453101586955446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973768424565284, + "CVC4": 14.501253303379611, + "CVC3": 14.095031600067864, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.087455958008787, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.833931662125726 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.990003353694114, + "veriT": 14.231729929028322, + "Yices": 13.680059056663197, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.382533592277101, + "CVC4": 14.487962044729306, + "CVC3": 13.439372361195529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255909478788976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.257926281363469 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 167.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.379815765957245, + "veriT": 14.226386438244633, + "Yices": 13.995273457193091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960048564532476, + "CVC4": 14.549445043296377, + "CVC3": 7.4947745747094432, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.88154653097148, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.227885156146062 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.521011645576904, + "veriT": 12.803435185573436, + "Yices": 12.737166795245395, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977387542611559, + "CVC4": 14.524103603123272, + "CVC3": 13.008818998172991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.456550352079505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.681419054886847 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9614319376147824, + "veriT": 14.234507242461881, + "Yices": 14.15924495132152, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.190828344593987, + "CVC4": 14.691290286797539, + "CVC3": 10.446796044862666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.541529341989218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.332460381349549 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12841806164299999, + "veriT": 0.10158280551024737, + "Yices": 0.10320244078905789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12422731516389475, + "CVC4": 0.12957974632231581, + "CVC3": 0.10561725565226843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12290122639273685, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1219057477831158 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12380244469286189, + "veriT": 0.095065560547842862, + "Yices": 0.09845640872469047, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12122684683173335, + "CVC4": 0.11935910726451902, + "CVC3": 0.10349864848359523, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11843957279436665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11825058599739048 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8128492345361096, + "veriT": 1.7717321251236668, + "Yices": 1.7987286705716665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9199127512681997, + "CVC4": 0.14512779402566667, + "CVC3": 2.4619934589808024, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12728830365933333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4830312461541233 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0711701572427117, + "veriT": 9.0493655700384217, + "Yices": 9.9743810243742068, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2254161738697684, + "CVC4": 0.1482925401196, + "CVC3": 0.63417713518722219, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14871405851695554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8297146998877718 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6990950107574463, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5357145071029663, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5833465532530298, + "veriT": 5.5914291139380765, + "Yices": 5.6893500587157, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0211939103311689, + "CVC4": 3.0976375146238762, + "CVC3": 2.4536825059645002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8316450747634603, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.139997755800191 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7082789568101875, + "veriT": 8.7392105020112787, + "Yices": 9.1248687006209277, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0763888055243438, + "CVC4": 0.18178869097485714, + "CVC3": 6.7634405039532748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.96863757329239353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1894822655014021 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236447663259989, + "veriT": 10.148909539663078, + "Yices": 10.329589355756385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955768933411312, + "CVC4": 0.15458016598623076, + "CVC3": 13.059812299216803, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1531263760043077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.254805289326317 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.051293880328355, + "veriT": 10.144219403500498, + "Yices": 10.300814620313, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.726509408790587, + "CVC4": 0.17731480328349997, + "CVC3": 10.299570345612661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.958877044288675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.345041677563408 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.937185258806471, + "veriT": 9.4464499077304787, + "Yices": 12.227188916197559, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.40205443030486, + "CVC4": 5.2290062413333249, + "CVC3": 13.963266116391928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1434998190083832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.261967693810929 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.61701666274597, + "veriT": 13.396218048389869, + "Yices": 8.4900671596494313, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.145311501304224, + "CVC4": 6.0534112111771332, + "CVC3": 5.3465245919010549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8746219996153264, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2059152858943873 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.751410335183568, + "veriT": 12.132325486926554, + "Yices": 11.896873655468557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.407970356868155, + "CVC4": 11.289072884768087, + "CVC3": 13.91532989133368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.215098108563605, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.212367554169036 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.363694139738449, + "veriT": 11.534924727979339, + "Yices": 12.445110580328766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3388613626728283, + "CVC4": 11.737027948507315, + "CVC3": 9.4807200376167788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.059883316955982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.987511475659598 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.211613606694366, + "veriT": 10.370525381282899, + "Yices": 8.2762980581246826, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.350391204807433, + "CVC4": 8.5927970255258543, + "CVC3": 7.9426903319834521, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.092702262154315, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.091520427528534 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5585346152803368, + "veriT": 10.684146388978945, + "Yices": 10.81910035784839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.110382212276285, + "CVC4": 2.8338903690558754, + "CVC3": 10.261763732112303, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1229437102634954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9176392022359074 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15134676252828574, + "veriT": 4.398450298481686, + "Yices": 6.8669496289635479, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14807511830100001, + "CVC4": 3.1807585131981839, + "CVC3": 0.13668508244635716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14153187427692857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7555093382549007 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7750000953674316, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6745148337178972, + "veriT": 4.3619853228197245, + "Yices": 2.6999002914607253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8510757072620265, + "CVC4": 2.6354077245679308, + "CVC3": 0.41946101290135002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8349041376793334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6345163819167068 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5620439605843441, + "veriT": 2.9407382222665559, + "Yices": 13.755956819390704, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6386443573313252, + "CVC4": 8.6799877005003925, + "CVC3": 9.4751822346116228, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0437732664224066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.04364133326147 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1833333969116211, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8166664838790894, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.245804820997543, + "veriT": 7.3095422805182855, + "Yices": 10.337926081793713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.761366336099881, + "CVC4": 2.1852610702237953, + "CVC3": 9.211411726265041, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.860141938368647, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7582855278126495 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.419487967123692, + "veriT": 10.358294320527538, + "Yices": 10.1877387465195, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.023862025836332, + "CVC4": 5.4429212448293223, + "CVC3": 12.062890778164602, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.75119723373081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.311616673271754 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0266246168524855, + "veriT": 11.330689075267264, + "Yices": 8.2975430775321435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2789065235526778, + "CVC4": 6.0821803712057374, + "CVC3": 8.0383543963236139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9183391640843945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8692597493360203 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.955374513062331, + "veriT": 11.262465402031108, + "Yices": 10.816230432205137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.898387139390367, + "CVC4": 7.7250007459250245, + "CVC3": 7.3833183041424908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.382356912395581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5928181703009283 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3986006994411291, + "veriT": 9.0468916455036172, + "Yices": 8.9732282737611193, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9849692123375364, + "CVC4": 7.3720612704326376, + "CVC3": 5.6069385948239674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.201108987138868, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.377142043621145 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14821356512299999, + "veriT": 9.2609313909936404, + "Yices": 7.1755356101737453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.35767801761433332, + "CVC4": 4.8445468836549752, + "CVC3": 0.12917965590628888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2298637434138889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2327960528261111 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9091464929704909, + "veriT": 9.6055001769852701, + "Yices": 10.460681330217161, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.407803784786037, + "CVC4": 4.5198826648091304, + "CVC3": 11.412589191491721, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5854267619991447, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3995744536266006 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.651017958291749, + "veriT": 7.8964012976443785, + "Yices": 4.3260605845264175, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9072815131410628, + "CVC4": 1.5761307138396761, + "CVC3": 1.0610476188300748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3048984052270565, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5967035837812391 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8819444179534912, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0147997882463144, + "veriT": 7.0850892877581551, + "Yices": 7.1638598464582088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5546407779308868, + "CVC4": 3.506829889604818, + "CVC3": 0.84596027261060014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0147673296939601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0191722302679125 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0954544544219971, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1156589353662767, + "veriT": 13.801768896660263, + "Yices": 8.7790355409971568, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.226890711852622, + "CVC4": 13.432610098804469, + "CVC3": 12.004095116922924, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.435901235811693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.143011970828937 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3036393816899565, + "veriT": 10.109349806939498, + "Yices": 10.110492439121773, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.02933228006334, + "CVC4": 7.6967166835748335, + "CVC3": 5.1002059811087728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.458652312674577, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.478048549505864 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5505056381225586, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.747946782551951, + "veriT": 8.0381944012698341, + "Yices": 7.8564600294395257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4521833023023261, + "CVC4": 5.2990013874498603, + "CVC3": 3.5878023132207559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6138386376242959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9948430129872738 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9001222914993328, + "veriT": 12.71574244257148, + "Yices": 11.200376105569275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9199702291480323, + "CVC4": 9.940459417227558, + "CVC3": 8.7664117955766674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.88408675209697, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.885722443498414 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1916666030883789, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8183645278377614, + "veriT": 6.182128614018656, + "Yices": 10.047752233175876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1335862112746655, + "CVC4": 10.937219275349541, + "CVC3": 6.0855977752670007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2013857369880574, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5045368613501262 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7548697419375032, + "veriT": 4.6642534267777362, + "Yices": 10.97214115436304, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7862280093607827, + "CVC4": 12.43474187345023, + "CVC3": 11.627557284750418, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.136170799354625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.141976894914304 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13395547743933331, + "veriT": 14.212594091463165, + "Yices": 3.2964787049407547, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13542608428841665, + "CVC4": 1.3884415215331227, + "CVC3": 3.4231467851889863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5259148410759167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4666966885048227 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 48.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5957188101964848, + "veriT": 7.5025692331191598, + "Yices": 11.199882061937295, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7459700695778615, + "CVC4": 1.487467596778532, + "CVC3": 11.39250591959477, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0294653132454208, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8095790322220262 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18284798165206667, + "veriT": 5.7033247189812641, + "Yices": 6.0935121405787891, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26142692846833332, + "CVC4": 3.2339348709273659, + "CVC3": 4.0972814537033999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7734370027005433, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5508732018397904 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9653568313594931, + "veriT": 4.1175855623745194, + "Yices": 8.9842666071916444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0994624998350782, + "CVC4": 4.9812222289813501, + "CVC3": 3.0446749518109222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7851203334101884, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9858063370053092 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 51.0, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16734836042527274, + "veriT": 0.15389466080921818, + "Yices": 0.16227503814809097, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16246393461154549, + "CVC4": 0.1851582384090909, + "CVC3": 0.16360255344254546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17686089490063636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17148431464718183 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1030219750422727, + "veriT": 7.6945480388807459, + "Yices": 4.7836689753472106, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0310781366090911, + "CVC4": 1.5068859431510668, + "CVC3": 0.19849246262855455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.709270788030619, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.70158420946666 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1805900917828889, + "veriT": 2.4285052753133329, + "Yices": 11.765668620683114, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18947625826644446, + "CVC4": 0.21063955277599999, + "CVC3": 4.8793629189113217, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7566274902827135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7514951299503538 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3248843792278215, + "veriT": 9.7026456814901554, + "Yices": 13.688014482698838, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.546164375451089, + "CVC4": 11.4649856123318, + "CVC3": 7.4400723489448799, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7315493433540201, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.93111266793337 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0674660205841064, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17884464422457141, + "veriT": 0.15281950540461905, + "Yices": 0.18106997010519046, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18264286088699999, + "CVC4": 0.19861506203666668, + "CVC3": 0.17683091339433332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18242067019723812, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18259969043285715 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22809019025266666, + "veriT": 9.4204815784967852, + "Yices": 0.16020430140808331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9064008737383336, + "CVC4": 0.1990030242835, + "CVC3": 0.78785467516966667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16987831999208333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17205333912433332 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 45.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0728070735931396, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14842161544521429, + "veriT": 6.9802468395000448, + "Yices": 6.8293747421238962, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16604084620907145, + "CVC4": 12.223042489026186, + "CVC3": 0.094915309617457158, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23080344071401429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17791906166618571 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8616930759399, + "veriT": 1.339709340397925, + "Yices": 1.3368663229682627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8641708784281747, + "CVC4": 12.522641859346091, + "CVC3": 0.094107002802912496, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8339205253760094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8417196329582124 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.50857201085288883, + "veriT": 6.77081180993979, + "Yices": 6.8243718158661677, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1334767020935841, + "CVC4": 3.4416075268607891, + "CVC3": 3.2951254197928797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.015034172704798, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5876931444092532 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13970358530609089, + "veriT": 7.0550480232304187, + "Yices": 1.7566109776536363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14026596218218182, + "CVC4": 0.17001753875290909, + "CVC3": 1.4138567016241619, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9860760423560793, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9840599024945704 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.30423269870187503, + "veriT": 13.709339080903492, + "Yices": 5.8171454718106466, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0295477377049531, + "CVC4": 9.1504007141036663, + "CVC3": 6.8687767703907445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.267812667287931, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.268091562908532 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5162060982228001, + "veriT": 10.187307221730801, + "Yices": 11.109565067630381, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.007195386511544, + "CVC4": 14.275031548525735, + "CVC3": 3.7770048514743166, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.62505106978216, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1352243861635625 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.458809769934962, + "veriT": 7.4152947986454514, + "Yices": 8.7328579823017556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.908273391578327, + "CVC4": 12.991505753709077, + "CVC3": 8.5362512981920773, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0969884532180458, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8258979365371601 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245621036405812, + "veriT": 10.740025876195187, + "Yices": 10.587157307878115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.271859001165682, + "CVC4": 12.373395498330268, + "CVC3": 14.152835814490661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231614576685581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.470134240914419 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9604751919379999, + "veriT": 13.713665163890525, + "Yices": 12.051685628398007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1641411035818745, + "CVC4": 10.841709011127797, + "CVC3": 10.403201930775781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.722096859471218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.722767676520899 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 75.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9922919748895831, + "veriT": 4.483500566159786, + "Yices": 1.31178668963875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0439958605572501, + "CVC4": 4.5540442840259612, + "CVC3": 1.1993697707628332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.30772363750216669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.30461729620883332 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.525201158818418, + "veriT": 10.464927090290384, + "Yices": 4.563330237707266, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6303383792213317, + "CVC4": 8.2232658406962997, + "CVC3": 3.0921884380116818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.815465965747292, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.062221835168549 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.273252276668947, + "veriT": 13.820912751060584, + "Yices": 11.920549252710199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.000377856026063, + "CVC4": 14.091554345463653, + "CVC3": 11.573304995276279, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241404700295021, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238860779447583 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257092329572721, + "veriT": 10.636558860782676, + "Yices": 10.36493629789689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.978953593327244, + "CVC4": 14.27730495524478, + "CVC3": 13.794329948696246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.333709672961033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.38311352860708 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1636869297826902, + "veriT": 11.979527586554955, + "Yices": 12.042966062663453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.392513554233865, + "CVC4": 9.8761596702519103, + "CVC3": 8.2757966468736033, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.186149242650195, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.175740705255896 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 85.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5049600475433262, + "veriT": 11.409578601505585, + "Yices": 9.5610829526524679, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1868300731355763, + "CVC4": 1.4529463617362308, + "CVC3": 0.4708254564223846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3186520734540164, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3340221032777073 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8661840169444579, + "veriT": 10.239722277568786, + "Yices": 5.8194383439402744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4774957848412975, + "CVC4": 7.460855833062781, + "CVC3": 7.0894935678954587, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0375108701170808, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1870573330949012 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15827247685308571, + "veriT": 0.17028714667262856, + "Yices": 0.6296822214019, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.70503626372457151, + "CVC4": 0.14722549645557143, + "CVC3": 0.13530939553140001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14032037340325715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14015735211301428 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1583578734802655, + "veriT": 13.411979782134708, + "Yices": 13.458310463176835, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5487187492362748, + "CVC4": 14.298197269431416, + "CVC3": 3.5680053428828211, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.249392236170161, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6024144671129363 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8335435981284958, + "veriT": 11.760048588335044, + "Yices": 6.3207321530334468, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.559271770570998, + "CVC4": 3.5121136764744323, + "CVC3": 6.7139554019344763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20198566620426667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20093063569033334 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1577500585092153, + "veriT": 14.22305117338489, + "Yices": 13.104661804772528, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.867876429768236, + "CVC4": 12.333503679807139, + "CVC3": 10.235623385362025, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.08836732724599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.049343464990216 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 77.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.837866513681353, + "veriT": 13.005625943039998, + "Yices": 12.036705435384668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954950880750122, + "CVC4": 14.553950752188964, + "CVC3": 14.22951432838604, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255326753511563, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.933890285000899 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4634797681920322, + "veriT": 13.926383229512396, + "Yices": 13.014563101257783, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.184202035020695, + "CVC4": 13.189974114358945, + "CVC3": 12.276252947592381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0763549949303632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.122491297932644 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 109.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1600267424249679, + "veriT": 11.687907340472396, + "Yices": 10.491449608241618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.335220856441596, + "CVC4": 9.8521407335290672, + "CVC3": 8.1990026796783564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.197674057488953, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5341406974468157 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 169.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 40.0, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7909096476882578, + "veriT": 13.055107276049593, + "Yices": 13.955336478439765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1971361473828681, + "CVC4": 14.629791673444069, + "CVC3": 14.606436871148594, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.159264178884978, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.009508584741743 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3510187827089037, + "veriT": 13.566393972445075, + "Yices": 14.221926396946133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965100733612578, + "CVC4": 13.358653792243246, + "CVC3": 12.027871828419959, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.08253622782968, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.077891762004255 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.541880501862321, + "veriT": 14.235440869164885, + "Yices": 14.242817298485235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966433729983271, + "CVC4": 14.530802297283847, + "CVC3": 12.451559047711243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252769172443706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.256965472806243 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.28271506825102, + "veriT": 14.273767626765146, + "Yices": 14.077986626234075, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.001402205270644, + "CVC4": 14.989136615318841, + "CVC3": 14.272349594850994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.110501728540283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.109940971086671 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249749132070539, + "veriT": 12.902144461425193, + "Yices": 13.00723512360767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.311832189470399, + "CVC4": 14.436679138741153, + "CVC3": 11.485899524776089, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.709395332236531, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.298113584738489 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12246010517360871, + "veriT": 0.093940967565504366, + "Yices": 0.095537688553995692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11963110908586957, + "CVC4": 0.12107135861595653, + "CVC3": 0.098203322209821739, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11794976380752174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11677562568847828 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12524086690063202, + "veriT": 1.2853931015721118, + "Yices": 1.287944165868228, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14559756843433599, + "CVC4": 1.801354941952207, + "CVC3": 0.090110353956704012, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7991977777857102, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7993311978756115 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4692987193199998, + "veriT": 0.10949113385644998, + "Yices": 1.8032888817417334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4652875888931667, + "CVC4": 0.13621003296449999, + "CVC3": 0.11682049046799999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1302151978045, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16128615055483334 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8765926339080794, + "veriT": 8.1553773880090876, + "Yices": 8.2307923543948007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1145875034228538, + "CVC4": 5.0871649012034856, + "CVC3": 7.2732114231221177, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8390731264974098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0631170899842957 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20555178876239585, + "veriT": 9.9555177634550613, + "Yices": 10.141367896232522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.30993581575208334, + "CVC4": 0.1517621476144583, + "CVC3": 0.60113214111539581, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14907905251058332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8542082791078887 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.553468388463939, + "veriT": 12.470315867796614, + "Yices": 12.119073913801092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.491725665944568, + "CVC4": 13.536634114840915, + "CVC3": 10.728928306390507, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.141207805834101, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.10288695335068 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6307274143001322, + "veriT": 9.492601249100602, + "Yices": 6.0245605700163622, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7577152380383847, + "CVC4": 9.8364788621638493, + "CVC3": 9.5009280561745619, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3714665402389592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3729416015880629 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235193438709501, + "veriT": 10.177347156848333, + "Yices": 10.314358791531113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953542371427043, + "CVC4": 0.16369789719711111, + "CVC3": 10.854737788243646, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9492338053998584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.54680063570385 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.403557997127193, + "veriT": 11.172217573046332, + "Yices": 11.378230467023879, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.99831448207785, + "CVC4": 9.7842146070270104, + "CVC3": 12.189133149679815, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.911895477846933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6620320638072599 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.128131589291835, + "veriT": 8.401799151184882, + "Yices": 9.7321582632470598, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.049125602863986, + "CVC4": 0.1714429450634706, + "CVC3": 10.153770507958253, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1249267052359073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.605902611192157 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4807682675159479, + "veriT": 6.6001655767550522, + "Yices": 5.8487480827104426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0828707569944083, + "CVC4": 0.51887108889288891, + "CVC3": 4.8568646289035451, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8332449250289446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9617448811216649 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5569062840350003, + "veriT": 5.7360591154122362, + "Yices": 9.3122363470182172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7609382652679724, + "CVC4": 11.460524122727712, + "CVC3": 1.7582291525257836, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.405982812363535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8171618498723721 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2734111539212147, + "veriT": 11.944590980095493, + "Yices": 6.2268271836766109, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.596311251759454, + "CVC4": 6.2604422452309008, + "CVC3": 9.1065459671968441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5358246141601306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5330524632867721 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13636484757549999, + "veriT": 8.9231950586524924, + "Yices": 10.33532871635439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.135751253751, + "CVC4": 2.9664377954338041, + "CVC3": 0.12238674357999998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13798460616559999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1370446286309 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.365627896657276, + "veriT": 11.029024074726609, + "Yices": 10.630738571814716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.921375098622557, + "CVC4": 3.358785322327138, + "CVC3": 11.854696984584246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1668131951248495, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.956779010122659 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1747330868642383, + "veriT": 10.166889002903638, + "Yices": 10.309576170357001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.647082245172822, + "CVC4": 0.23800787953545452, + "CVC3": 9.4243159670479315, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.419486385859658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.386337130922463 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240155908849221, + "veriT": 10.159880686473064, + "Yices": 10.3414695425086, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965023789055389, + "CVC4": 0.16324784079720003, + "CVC3": 12.714379349476429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.89447365912023213, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.363959857731041 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.419468410778073, + "veriT": 13.497670208593785, + "Yices": 13.195462531042049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.000651802526553, + "CVC4": 11.762313531072175, + "CVC3": 12.822297819191608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.138572343502016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.113063391615061 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.590278148651123, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2517480850219727, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6496490337470995, + "veriT": 11.315413868299437, + "Yices": 7.1856495338679691, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.53756236610913, + "CVC4": 1.8108551814528451, + "CVC3": 10.57836744169817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8738828033392094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6074564130274229 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19389573722121251, + "veriT": 2.6575371556686496, + "Yices": 5.2086914016043755, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17227670428262501, + "CVC4": 1.9503723574159491, + "CVC3": 0.1726819772375125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7233998838823603, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0015325782838915 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.416417711986, + "veriT": 9.4645580553375144, + "Yices": 10.371802957302258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7470703078218843, + "CVC4": 6.0427848696760265, + "CVC3": 2.6075635282838681, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8772650442431993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7957464512330026 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9847730337026919, + "veriT": 5.0360088460604659, + "Yices": 10.865790813793129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.880548178981674, + "CVC4": 8.710193404598586, + "CVC3": 4.6431782333256013, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7980580329902853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7947828195930216 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7136775949864731, + "veriT": 10.107752153738588, + "Yices": 10.1080087112562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.354338842823248, + "CVC4": 9.789750987183, + "CVC3": 3.6963052626553585, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.517993593275875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.532534363916344 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0172414779663086, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.85261730376764289, + "veriT": 1.5536582328555, + "Yices": 2.1256884009569248, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.85260579449592855, + "CVC4": 1.2288311195922312, + "CVC3": 6.2178395003093794, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1603583807128657, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1575720216564056 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8970178602473222, + "veriT": 5.6621200563826477, + "Yices": 3.9258825814013623, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4779964683075004, + "CVC4": 1.9763259634326451, + "CVC3": 1.5333967150933627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4215425131782506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.288330756106701 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3875000476837158, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17543948761933334, + "veriT": 1.2682797340339333, + "Yices": 1.2719344586883112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17853800217466664, + "CVC4": 0.1826998345882222, + "CVC3": 0.16726143194682225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1761338677223333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17593527973166664 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.92219417416600002, + "veriT": 9.8209929110828753, + "Yices": 4.2868860172245409, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.99151222304799991, + "CVC4": 1.4117589584064116, + "CVC3": 3.5915600645780352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2985193880921448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3128437854852368 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2128925953891105, + "veriT": 7.0519601410912829, + "Yices": 9.010509462563272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.419710052888107, + "CVC4": 6.671565925470353, + "CVC3": 0.45961003132414285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2311780187670882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.84808411852471 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5926008048438571, + "veriT": 5.1618768231735119, + "Yices": 9.7920891332980737, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6107482387023142, + "CVC4": 12.758703346953936, + "CVC3": 7.1148924712764208, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1155182672006365, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1110509392551968 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6828446445495002, + "veriT": 13.066060672490895, + "Yices": 10.203823704355541, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4211052536336037, + "CVC4": 10.937668853807892, + "CVC3": 9.7816826810088759, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.546184976736079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.237855449989556 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7136410007755032, + "veriT": 12.17580191816767, + "Yices": 10.781929646812847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.229790818861053, + "CVC4": 5.6883774630876012, + "CVC3": 3.0412704975537714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238796298901187, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237836898161641 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5247459215197878, + "veriT": 12.690730645711909, + "Yices": 12.472538687507924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2795141073986489, + "CVC4": 14.447312224732322, + "CVC3": 13.205674208889391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.972152026003959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.96942293720833 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1592016220092773, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 29.0, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1522359362264, + "veriT": 4.9722540780589526, + "Yices": 11.923714210846304, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1539761521152201, + "CVC4": 11.452383329220428, + "CVC3": 6.2408557286283202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14645096393919999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1452716684524 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.46565126238766669, + "veriT": 9.180792646740132, + "Yices": 4.929972010110081, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8372940532441671, + "CVC4": 2.7314061435753558, + "CVC3": 0.43420554601566669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8725715184722524, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.864615928797976 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4177505669918391, + "veriT": 9.7086702782946315, + "Yices": 6.176204740799645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.397990998009206, + "CVC4": 11.706154706194637, + "CVC3": 6.3007720092728077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1301139291855016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0393112450319837 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6172165870666504, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.868275448135844, + "veriT": 12.587145453241902, + "Yices": 13.441255989506175, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.345341723322766, + "CVC4": 11.849705888861033, + "CVC3": 12.154736984410926, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.639817888497067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.673194596020105 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.051822616174289, + "veriT": 12.367020565303877, + "Yices": 12.437949350950914, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5713101818078163, + "CVC4": 11.971095866830257, + "CVC3": 6.9971304331768609, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.697888964329531, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.543152198330988 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8104674816131592, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5517307518373573, + "veriT": 6.7223991105411045, + "Yices": 3.7674876960833572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0593944011970828, + "CVC4": 5.197375262670163, + "CVC3": 0.60578667780001427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1985527098756901, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0917510737206868 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.789845074468005, + "veriT": 9.5084259728435949, + "Yices": 9.7364298611114943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.428638284057728, + "CVC4": 3.7427836170089557, + "CVC3": 11.898395469746005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9928577368791576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.381246928167979 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 63.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2480422564223332, + "veriT": 14.21534449537757, + "Yices": 3.3575635288604602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2557390602170004, + "CVC4": 2.9171766857586419, + "CVC3": 2.8215981487556552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.484890387911118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.48958314928959 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19469203357666667, + "veriT": 13.061169158145203, + "Yices": 11.592214939008455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.7083167516515001, + "CVC4": 8.8280893266774321, + "CVC3": 12.858791242271193, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.076462860616994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.072460508328689 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.522320036336402, + "veriT": 13.531975843339746, + "Yices": 6.8827671580845511, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8066832557663197, + "CVC4": 5.1305708973170931, + "CVC3": 7.2023889634780529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5415968389291237, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5417626752672131 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1701569190829995, + "veriT": 7.16439950259167, + "Yices": 2.4373099394160733, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2601776642866662, + "CVC4": 2.6488062541499668, + "CVC3": 2.4910441009907207, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.45701001714533346, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.45643921599900006 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14733337432362498, + "veriT": 1.8871609823775721, + "Yices": 0.139938028918875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14699553997637499, + "CVC4": 0.153334304301875, + "CVC3": 0.13853255308262499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.149539379167375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.148714823267875 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15336163953525001, + "veriT": 0.12828363975224999, + "Yices": 0.144822361955875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15676404753862502, + "CVC4": 0.17314673073962503, + "CVC3": 0.1538528445165, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16639069162424999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16527286802475 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17341742962020001, + "veriT": 0.15519356878310001, + "Yices": 0.16417646088819998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17408348374329999, + "CVC4": 0.19833012271150002, + "CVC3": 0.17700891702159999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18411556449640001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18503051623719999 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6490678019021887, + "veriT": 3.1862768247292799, + "Yices": 6.0702517702646883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8862344595894047, + "CVC4": 4.4712319355322894, + "CVC3": 1.6247616247254446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6227844998949355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3269539458714392 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.97183824651174999, + "veriT": 6.6155104068164094, + "Yices": 4.6013942860176344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3763319144081965, + "CVC4": 2.4896192571473601, + "CVC3": 0.11939773552724164, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4346061790565814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4544834671059166 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7232426741059896, + "veriT": 6.1601780948123768, + "Yices": 4.9814801323700015, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.136621027169209, + "CVC4": 8.4953015983469271, + "CVC3": 4.8371762637661533, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.666483890806882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6390245515153499 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1575164794921875, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2945536105229749, + "veriT": 12.731710257966323, + "Yices": 12.795586337130713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.079527713102852, + "CVC4": 12.720551975098441, + "CVC3": 11.137512060026383, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.496754839775194, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.704713425657035 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8411400434548462, + "veriT": 11.419245106832907, + "Yices": 5.4705927224713173, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.575136416209042, + "CVC4": 10.247516105342758, + "CVC3": 3.4146326356450296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2298106464962122, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2263545292063776 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3379224040750324, + "veriT": 3.3544946185225837, + "Yices": 3.3676518440919438, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2020169842388437, + "CVC4": 2.2061059878823071, + "CVC3": 3.050834215283452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6540948842033663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6282625848822834 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5050072524245262, + "veriT": 10.407287538308303, + "Yices": 10.030202696180281, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1047027398812963, + "CVC4": 10.719848595808305, + "CVC3": 3.0440012014881686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.205509723651879, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5178636242726906 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.500730244431026, + "veriT": 12.183245347343114, + "Yices": 10.079020987236303, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.480052181669301, + "CVC4": 10.39868260981854, + "CVC3": 8.6581750840847214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.977953238811965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.282710590783205 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254524776523382, + "veriT": 11.555932804629393, + "Yices": 10.51780680202725, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968523658597226, + "CVC4": 14.381710572515523, + "CVC3": 14.241167573391548, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256160712148082, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.529798793850999 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.935328483581543, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.266439724630525, + "veriT": 10.20146486128175, + "Yices": 10.405105404269833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.989716781702464, + "CVC4": 14.299089319285551, + "CVC3": 14.269167807717382, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.099233734508422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.686516080118528 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.082519692970086, + "veriT": 13.725297329555783, + "Yices": 12.404067792977798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.391277672390933, + "CVC4": 11.165309282892508, + "CVC3": 12.770549151828908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234988518632646, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.877487394516603 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6900614880698708, + "veriT": 8.8738238312447173, + "Yices": 9.7670158349644645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.308131021076568, + "CVC4": 8.6551231013052146, + "CVC3": 5.0876122195368554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5385824275278743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9000010486002914 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4015726203236669, + "veriT": 13.049919718787375, + "Yices": 8.7519959439517887, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2405984420231988, + "CVC4": 6.3875881801573753, + "CVC3": 2.1868223036107906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.226570601925545, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.23723264181295 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9817075729370117, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4730244569024, + "veriT": 11.478716326340146, + "Yices": 3.442216504861439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2484308834160576, + "CVC4": 3.2673063461747072, + "CVC3": 1.5352752692060001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0152436931316049, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21679450820169999 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8244439061433075, + "veriT": 13.936636608413234, + "Yices": 7.9063528204965978, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.905583663934914, + "CVC4": 5.2441787022492505, + "CVC3": 4.4503928660153891, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9175075746394032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9838839303784699 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7110949754714966, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0866534954984548, + "veriT": 8.2092451718517125, + "Yices": 8.3399824622200001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.529858108546803, + "CVC4": 8.1164700517494293, + "CVC3": 9.2170450276286076, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7185779284447111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.053662304394472 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0191295146942139, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 141.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.650880756995726, + "veriT": 14.231501469655914, + "Yices": 13.145147632972233, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951765524620875, + "CVC4": 14.82489498069183, + "CVC3": 14.226434587857609, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255424770090217, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.247773506330121 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.048627681703266, + "veriT": 12.865865992256134, + "Yices": 12.286892396937816, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.596997839558929, + "CVC4": 13.333942104528473, + "CVC3": 13.241027023408487, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.214920412580231, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.202608615574732 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249066193832284, + "veriT": 11.462780714574365, + "Yices": 12.294183174244321, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968862928376982, + "CVC4": 14.641020670639692, + "CVC3": 14.248345260567252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.263722141880473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.561368584807639 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3891914993329602, + "veriT": 12.971660032194643, + "Yices": 13.736679531233124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.440652532204327, + "CVC4": 14.515439093468549, + "CVC3": 11.501876865959924, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.911297736358579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.909422736835774 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1545023918151855, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0318106327109309, + "veriT": 9.4544405224614128, + "Yices": 4.154915882027268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8439404087590634, + "CVC4": 5.4644583983726767, + "CVC3": 9.9509941465792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7871372181910106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8072262918215163 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2504431790167017, + "veriT": 12.55207115297628, + "Yices": 12.959314908063879, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.350995475142165, + "CVC4": 14.160569051341627, + "CVC3": 12.095038943602319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8207618561075241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7745921443983992 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.466159339775542, + "veriT": 13.561595588789965, + "Yices": 13.503924667711352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977511029736858, + "CVC4": 14.490026212238584, + "CVC3": 8.0536671212147439, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.827811735874191, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.847818896089825 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 72.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.522881932517768, + "veriT": 11.69799860759305, + "Yices": 12.252185083297102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4903851542306334, + "CVC4": 14.521328584354391, + "CVC3": 12.811824261596918, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252840071418165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.986450230794938 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26180945636799, + "veriT": 12.909303689945469, + "Yices": 13.544973808604219, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.982679829043855, + "CVC4": 14.37437841017992, + "CVC3": 13.552422030320777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.55989949485523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.16394944280996 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3349707958443213, + "veriT": 11.971321515041227, + "Yices": 13.912927325488086, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964178002817498, + "CVC4": 14.637769235438766, + "CVC3": 12.434599629100099, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.882721678988423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.87474938594786 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.833643250414609, + "veriT": 14.257530619490039, + "Yices": 14.247243658500977, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.459720000195553, + "CVC4": 14.618479806450674, + "CVC3": 9.48487445545606, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.181728457823823, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9049418762099837 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 58.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4166665077209473, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12991278439686366, + "veriT": 0.10097693842163183, + "Yices": 0.10293786180414094, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12775749206436363, + "CVC4": 0.12596850985836364, + "CVC3": 0.10674294767172726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12706949243140905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12328397181228185 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2948412326897647, + "veriT": 0.088372092937200011, + "Yices": 0.092245804963723546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2937382886260116, + "CVC4": 0.11646535846741767, + "CVC3": 0.09579261046383529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11281846583420001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11198166859742942 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.0625, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3197861496093264, + "veriT": 7.0654638935525194, + "Yices": 8.0114973642777443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4799827526886835, + "CVC4": 6.6636543037599587, + "CVC3": 6.409013651873618, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8544019992834659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4337625177897921 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20909430482353128, + "veriT": 10.162461726659471, + "Yices": 10.357776581803876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26323925630393741, + "CVC4": 0.15021649541549997, + "CVC3": 0.6895593894966876, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14890191863581248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.426158507588699 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19035622641355554, + "veriT": 7.933211509013999, + "Yices": 10.60955206417211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31746878154800001, + "CVC4": 0.15092984013122221, + "CVC3": 0.26593168388733335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14925927028266664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6908622740285657 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8090909719467163, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3756045514545714, + "veriT": 7.0170422786288436, + "Yices": 7.0559586402249783, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.650097068248078, + "CVC4": 4.3886454654306153, + "CVC3": 3.322003314716143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1632002415240912, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2843340837952928 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.606243481322114, + "veriT": 10.162337489649554, + "Yices": 10.322133824424277, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.949876378761944, + "CVC4": 0.1697969065127222, + "CVC3": 11.319751079537475, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15036906356583332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.244461638348916 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233515617130191, + "veriT": 10.150778136046377, + "Yices": 10.307184604204249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948827470051008, + "CVC4": 0.245815246205875, + "CVC3": 12.112332894181204, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2915891379856648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.190883894446024 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.217464228114219, + "veriT": 7.9905045733167457, + "Yices": 10.454189881258481, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.364073252531462, + "CVC4": 0.16700546328916668, + "CVC3": 12.702866208144913, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14771401639833334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5773747531186331 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.905947054044402, + "veriT": 8.4966129580175824, + "Yices": 10.336475610745749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.507572459402835, + "CVC4": 1.3463091571009096, + "CVC3": 11.877691193153789, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.905821262459428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.346697287466695 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2426052775098384, + "veriT": 9.5701588642764754, + "Yices": 9.4743299534420444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.450927557051099, + "CVC4": 2.3281926838743705, + "CVC3": 6.5654727939799873, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.181012166885203, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.926272507072957 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9424918472213957, + "veriT": 9.6865470528610604, + "Yices": 10.981077365339518, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3251776504399579, + "CVC4": 12.911531789699978, + "CVC3": 9.7023549417539208, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.719444432367084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9734863721412257 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3935047263262255, + "veriT": 13.081927410101283, + "Yices": 12.68158698782095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6847785182377244, + "CVC4": 9.1544337417481252, + "CVC3": 7.6461065794940621, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.840758835777544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.84371789086866 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.715333840695111, + "veriT": 12.319850965281512, + "Yices": 10.689704252054554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.971041703008977, + "CVC4": 5.3268671176263345, + "CVC3": 12.549166915506639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1242989727490063, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.789992978050243 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2117195299597681, + "veriT": 10.449946152045522, + "Yices": 4.4770403286536853, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0097176686999902, + "CVC4": 0.28554332712371433, + "CVC3": 2.432420510144421, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9287344793946097, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9533045603884336 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.081552711123225, + "veriT": 11.864216758440159, + "Yices": 10.729839428778567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.199370588185895, + "CVC4": 9.126334259415378, + "CVC3": 13.844694333595113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.854182849051623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.913358352283781 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.198175633618435, + "veriT": 10.92437577540427, + "Yices": 9.2892877778981813, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.715103313162054, + "CVC4": 5.8335402402210859, + "CVC3": 9.9175136665721961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4677956758756068, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5785766637138163 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1107983105542312, + "veriT": 8.5005710700466004, + "Yices": 10.162468120670216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5229311824124965, + "CVC4": 8.9987799094224847, + "CVC3": 7.3837901012862144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2296389756955062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2487087517475164 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13863856633733332, + "veriT": 0.11146173572250001, + "Yices": 9.2233812840617393, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13666647363833331, + "CVC4": 7.2287142144297825, + "CVC3": 6.4966110697746666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.28175213500933338, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.28738098442133331 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.719836833194751, + "veriT": 11.677509246761538, + "Yices": 10.963429701367616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.141260192506561, + "CVC4": 3.8678835557845268, + "CVC3": 10.970195905941766, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.473984370806459, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.326444496568785 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1821607740914528, + "veriT": 12.694395577514319, + "Yices": 5.7308246625391943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.557249042506947, + "CVC4": 0.30345178417224999, + "CVC3": 8.3490787645642026, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4331321356282256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6440457374416155 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0908196059579991, + "veriT": 14.155301815106535, + "Yices": 11.474869521964544, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9938522292369623, + "CVC4": 14.407661801498987, + "CVC3": 8.6792920647731862, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.55395025390091, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.554503307735104 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2540800775688563, + "veriT": 9.5148756999436781, + "Yices": 7.167205062860643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4825498027161368, + "CVC4": 7.5585152473443129, + "CVC3": 5.8421581172336419, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.730840229235653, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.741052269020914 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7898588906283344, + "veriT": 10.635569437599983, + "Yices": 11.056121077391209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7814533616896675, + "CVC4": 12.40442510570246, + "CVC3": 6.9312935872672217, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.642716387228615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5441281814921339 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1041665077209473, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6164968417031034, + "veriT": 2.7453670933699552, + "Yices": 1.1768924109123222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3265451155740022, + "CVC4": 1.7605139278893269, + "CVC3": 1.6376577197166995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6555753939056026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6567321026953321 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1409017817619826, + "veriT": 2.6698958097217123, + "Yices": 4.0053400558180119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9092321480064212, + "CVC4": 3.169833014465016, + "CVC3": 1.9095993372717242, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8782042097568825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8779407589824204 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13164372684132727, + "veriT": 3.7383182483163542, + "Yices": 8.866189270803341, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12855579091532726, + "CVC4": 3.2441403661865564, + "CVC3": 2.0674664144301818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6580583064312697, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.636896770105559 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0499999523162842, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0296210399829944, + "veriT": 5.7054447272225328, + "Yices": 10.415630679857866, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5969779609936814, + "CVC4": 5.5938719080793922, + "CVC3": 2.0105198206459534, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.922633872585719, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.492332061081143 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8414086934780638, + "veriT": 5.6903576458002663, + "Yices": 6.8615281068264222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4158157957064983, + "CVC4": 4.9458780171935874, + "CVC3": 1.8242581985276098, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3143749267335352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7901593117915073 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.600413840190848, + "veriT": 10.123472184272972, + "Yices": 10.127078993640371, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.065624195010299, + "CVC4": 4.5553400559472141, + "CVC3": 4.968130715844878, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.611523725344222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.426284113872882 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8735608790764542, + "veriT": 3.5861939432041421, + "Yices": 13.394463669882565, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8770861978428361, + "CVC4": 13.94377906914538, + "CVC3": 10.930004570094034, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6500115965513089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6454985867980834 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1697764742599048, + "veriT": 11.165490276656605, + "Yices": 11.157869748937243, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5720390965951587, + "CVC4": 14.351572286643732, + "CVC3": 11.942761773850135, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.572960258414751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.554357970256321 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24959973725974999, + "veriT": 7.4519253535079883, + "Yices": 3.3389654876864627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2509511384626772, + "CVC4": 1.3459023253627911, + "CVC3": 1.0581144323011449, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6259531452697575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4907542082778664 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7965514659881592, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.76723861826276, + "veriT": 9.6107159730656218, + "Yices": 6.5776857214416395, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7541161501333047, + "CVC4": 0.22445114837450003, + "CVC3": 5.0156111284923597, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.051076347048217, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6281899393459254 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16764582943641174, + "veriT": 0.70522726135039404, + "Yices": 4.2140045259871144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0489208165628034, + "CVC4": 2.6489105361157375, + "CVC3": 0.27871157877258823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2885484036422632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1039073673441271 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4653094699864999, + "veriT": 1.628462723461036, + "Yices": 1.5828050930194717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1877086731096442, + "CVC4": 0.1799688840777143, + "CVC3": 1.904228915886788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4605037503949996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4612254875249286 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.995960489821384, + "veriT": 6.5374689335299232, + "Yices": 12.135067989664845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.549890746709149, + "CVC4": 0.17417955473923075, + "CVC3": 12.445435725490443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3353191594361169, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5476774586979793 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0044121742248535, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6408830075473335, + "veriT": 4.5902651680255548, + "Yices": 7.7939064693559095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5290117139768888, + "CVC4": 12.772516275368837, + "CVC3": 1.6723110807472223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4188257857420945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0339658424219591 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2558436358613942, + "veriT": 8.1513319308784205, + "Yices": 9.9980061283607924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8843842174591643, + "CVC4": 12.063296253006193, + "CVC3": 9.1109052273447606, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.891831175079728, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.309798568969301 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.044725774560733, + "veriT": 11.1823071429816, + "Yices": 11.084274491854517, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.20221251255116, + "CVC4": 2.3600401635534354, + "CVC3": 7.3005697012450428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2020811122110704, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.946417395821729 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8030030727386475, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0302118997782728, + "veriT": 11.68569631117119, + "Yices": 9.1198653056238168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.106798655669499, + "CVC4": 9.0752115200619023, + "CVC3": 12.331927725092026, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.470247267723149, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.627342518959182 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17097056938485714, + "veriT": 0.87185340199457151, + "Yices": 3.0534311906754286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17477772378364284, + "CVC4": 4.1980080230423242, + "CVC3": 1.1776076662416952, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2665558516287554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.372846000719167 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3825615068477499, + "veriT": 0.106964635105225, + "Yices": 0.11072532569487502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3776624127062502, + "CVC4": 0.141818400384875, + "CVC3": 0.11502848717075001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.139139386901625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.132791588887125 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14235505916355554, + "veriT": 9.2086119597621146, + "Yices": 0.1500575203208889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15047280186611112, + "CVC4": 0.16029477273777779, + "CVC3": 0.13884152856388887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14801616825933336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15051843867944445 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17303827623520002, + "veriT": 0.15308528847450001, + "Yices": 1.5644121281586185, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1720544123828, + "CVC4": 0.20436898897799999, + "CVC3": 0.17779637210990001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18140484776010002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18151325189539999 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1520856251513846, + "veriT": 0.12764278360576922, + "Yices": 0.1416077760793846, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15585587627246153, + "CVC4": 0.1645382508170769, + "CVC3": 0.14623291748884615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16388316979946155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16180671599723076 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1978739832804126, + "veriT": 3.6109274558865865, + "Yices": 1.6699700666853285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3019793771555781, + "CVC4": 2.2248474634558875, + "CVC3": 2.1913726854726492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2005982467588505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7838539070844419 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0682429350946485, + "veriT": 10.216873187747675, + "Yices": 6.1942036358378774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3898222060206731, + "CVC4": 4.3683888432928741, + "CVC3": 4.7286837907478434, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7675474943455711, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1435210158254288 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.440742079332775, + "veriT": 2.6258142607185815, + "Yices": 3.6612304641472928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0365996928035757, + "CVC4": 10.741730320804599, + "CVC3": 0.13761981225582498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.34915138111140626, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.29959537222391253 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.623666629596161, + "veriT": 4.4321924710233427, + "Yices": 4.5845874238127431, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8365338226428607, + "CVC4": 2.2566997219034048, + "CVC3": 3.2209016717531433, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3690005325059138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3666426590559246 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6408496228247031, + "veriT": 9.4099486961585477, + "Yices": 5.9464621142097265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.026759831449628, + "CVC4": 12.767862834949623, + "CVC3": 5.0878979833557656, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3747501101388595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3415983579433544 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.94860906680507684, + "veriT": 4.060175346687747, + "Yices": 10.002249493196151, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.95307178055753838, + "CVC4": 8.9244913622961075, + "CVC3": 8.1898389150056961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18779244806838463, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18466359930523077 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 134.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.517339474638435, + "veriT": 10.2105552671743, + "Yices": 10.353710063802001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.22655147291753, + "CVC4": 14.454889869093687, + "CVC3": 13.040024440768445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.283195080253094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.853905516294612 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0942572680824443, + "veriT": 9.8635498731059954, + "Yices": 6.4010907512631245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4054823692874443, + "CVC4": 13.016751925214033, + "CVC3": 5.0733361070320484, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5598278909042556, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5563452793044741 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12869114504110002, + "veriT": 14.207663771340652, + "Yices": 0.1911796645851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15331341079729999, + "CVC4": 0.15885050724540001, + "CVC3": 0.1515821920331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.879577332402162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.971750557676032 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.558765607155147, + "veriT": 12.170277721374518, + "Yices": 12.519247212481327, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7351644366833696, + "CVC4": 13.272865301520339, + "CVC3": 9.6227759638846084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.744276063632602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.747113847145551 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8787448856154167, + "veriT": 13.804900727622776, + "Yices": 7.4002909207607583, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2587029929620233, + "CVC4": 6.0830156767300121, + "CVC3": 8.7685894166070319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240451673065115, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236575432171282 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7889569371509997, + "veriT": 12.721932384662436, + "Yices": 6.1703366146240928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5009917758605709, + "CVC4": 2.4519177722732137, + "CVC3": 2.4252696876361708, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2208082846173811, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9390954478311899 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.798239536243619, + "veriT": 11.655337349887532, + "Yices": 12.911745763228266, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.177832471039615, + "CVC4": 13.901429600051845, + "CVC3": 9.9556765136615795, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.030343300733886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.014438440161415 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.256428609761903, + "veriT": 10.868635140856513, + "Yices": 10.361082538680501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979488409234902, + "CVC4": 14.277936649277274, + "CVC3": 13.909277668394729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.87400618692719, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.606737545351251 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0552611824314884, + "veriT": 11.669891409046528, + "Yices": 10.923868972653636, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.602431479202686, + "CVC4": 9.0770190278394658, + "CVC3": 9.7310438870566092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.204139855819761, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.194153963704922 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9958652540430508, + "veriT": 13.537293844261875, + "Yices": 10.327557258671026, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0494585105302354, + "CVC4": 9.9647676941438785, + "CVC3": 4.8701532557438805, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.221622246734611, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.232042704904595 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.32610666737122224, + "veriT": 13.758835895116281, + "Yices": 12.336891568797665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8336335111785251, + "CVC4": 10.285967865708162, + "CVC3": 5.303201149139829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.693643333055677, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6924275136492994 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20608389466146154, + "veriT": 5.7223136206433987, + "Yices": 1.227496570201327, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34694391856192308, + "CVC4": 1.302067236014401, + "CVC3": 0.18906713323976923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1648763684420769, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15863502764030768 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2737194494886346, + "veriT": 9.7524307152037508, + "Yices": 3.275194367630005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7448207472373438, + "CVC4": 3.5379876170395779, + "CVC3": 11.03141804701578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2442777326624444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4342766869941248 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3171033681302671, + "veriT": 12.294076062800652, + "Yices": 9.6457750434249316, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.981537581050967, + "CVC4": 5.8800082668906937, + "CVC3": 4.4763137952762486, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0794372308887978, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1038457010404628 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9363669260851104, + "veriT": 9.9472004947966948, + "Yices": 8.7131914604814451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.828508296174224, + "CVC4": 5.3197886722152639, + "CVC3": 11.13299671425891, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7346479896003899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3802370005338913 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9210382842601659, + "veriT": 13.652811796857648, + "Yices": 13.740743726592065, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4801742462721208, + "CVC4": 12.037353043928684, + "CVC3": 13.498492845880181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.905124513116162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.905592767106953 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.182909562993361, + "veriT": 13.851847458358924, + "Yices": 13.853697364207294, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.30643747417996, + "CVC4": 14.34672823313324, + "CVC3": 12.790805082453831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.291888096782429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.291398715623004 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.042098397029463, + "veriT": 11.563870807800006, + "Yices": 12.34512579658427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.983296137517835, + "CVC4": 14.544097821040793, + "CVC3": 9.5824201416071553, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.059438199001177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9364009103657089 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 471.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.662785512224646, + "veriT": 12.626421424484025, + "Yices": 14.009203669685812, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965298400053351, + "CVC4": 14.84766996272376, + "CVC3": 13.576017090286257, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260487522575989, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.257978942465494 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.036378235796889, + "veriT": 12.66348087449021, + "Yices": 14.113130080651919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.037363138570454, + "CVC4": 14.392146920304704, + "CVC3": 12.827241205607152, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.948689055622136, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.195967753936133 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8053792704284461, + "veriT": 14.248830091314664, + "Yices": 14.253771107887593, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.263201295602192, + "CVC4": 12.494398846136123, + "CVC3": 13.742821706918408, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6520257524548585, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6763502697633603 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.237950441058182, + "veriT": 11.942071294385743, + "Yices": 12.010782033692839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.998716973907124, + "CVC4": 14.569434184397002, + "CVC3": 14.289479131089324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.956966442005386, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.245080130349384 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240472784052864, + "veriT": 13.06688393119094, + "Yices": 13.873225157392554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.720943441587545, + "CVC4": 14.778162582720347, + "CVC3": 7.7470395874432274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.936479589398262, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.742744464868405 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12177971114896427, + "veriT": 0.094692125246535738, + "Yices": 0.096282137150953587, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11947996533639285, + "CVC4": 0.1220533490682143, + "CVC3": 0.098465766204557145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11882440037421428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11724746746647141 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11999403765179524, + "veriT": 0.56266214624309518, + "Yices": 0.56641628983338577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12804193519117621, + "CVC4": 0.78247747787582644, + "CVC3": 0.092820609879200003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.78074052066707234, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.77963956782637278 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3466720818311111, + "veriT": 0.09280032176463332, + "Yices": 0.10296888959791112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3385781298364443, + "CVC4": 0.12761985101177778, + "CVC3": 0.10678493750045555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12997778020777778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12549208019699998 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.68363209515385592, + "veriT": 9.124606481240555, + "Yices": 9.6864258418779094, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.76800033565799741, + "CVC4": 0.14726174654648275, + "CVC3": 0.59882699855762078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14770185407544825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8881434329108977 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7029409408569336, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0662896112704416, + "veriT": 7.8403755561149184, + "Yices": 7.9064531032483076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8977813317580825, + "CVC4": 3.8642451666711408, + "CVC3": 3.1832834249414166, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7041226490803441, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3823421274173757 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.108406779182781, + "veriT": 11.284702294582566, + "Yices": 10.722837449947836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.615056462628091, + "CVC4": 4.6821966389787342, + "CVC3": 11.95783247465506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2330533167495927, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.065487224314204 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6522918562487297, + "veriT": 9.9697408429967549, + "Yices": 10.672959070949087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0782617231980414, + "CVC4": 4.0949821916319458, + "CVC3": 10.275392156480736, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4953223383192409, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4777831668110002 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242311662850241, + "veriT": 10.160639580309416, + "Yices": 10.327049854660919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96257297446728, + "CVC4": 0.15562731499408333, + "CVC3": 12.143221684405376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17505289587799999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.331107799009821 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.223430427218615, + "veriT": 10.1663566440305, + "Yices": 10.306880870577874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.760972192446697, + "CVC4": 3.8796925404581506, + "CVC3": 14.246731765119542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6854137600713401, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.697783744300063 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0066065896490972, + "veriT": 5.4482122622426896, + "Yices": 7.8098254979270987, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1664160448383862, + "CVC4": 1.6815677827287083, + "CVC3": 5.7516363718713945, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3065701262679603, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3056649662166873 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.737313813600533, + "veriT": 14.230887840408823, + "Yices": 12.892468734292654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.280953357465942, + "CVC4": 13.472496583982338, + "CVC3": 8.9313391477739863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7054493856180706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.730298588250788 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6270123293559049, + "veriT": 9.2861792106581191, + "Yices": 9.8144443630239699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.145508404883897, + "CVC4": 4.2606343667746485, + "CVC3": 9.4004367827502247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.207300685569109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.488889201795208 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0027357102283752, + "veriT": 12.680924813223282, + "Yices": 1.84383368812068, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5650474058850001, + "CVC4": 2.1582550733908077, + "CVC3": 1.9458742072263149, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234617092985754, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.232810453913238 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.118606557414287, + "veriT": 11.32702982415916, + "Yices": 10.759538264235829, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952947482493068, + "CVC4": 7.32377809287419, + "CVC3": 11.695781034781234, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5302940523174957, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.246528630934661 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.063764583043236, + "veriT": 11.395179659589862, + "Yices": 10.82029806496563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.065217995450357, + "CVC4": 5.1275499496164514, + "CVC3": 8.4491420794477694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.207799396558512, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.526983949795348 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.937104406215334, + "veriT": 7.9425757987759278, + "Yices": 11.489973584826281, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8548385060826362, + "CVC4": 10.776068953423691, + "CVC3": 4.5420566872376593, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5363615276145595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4285871439003648 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.140424414243032, + "veriT": 7.9387617042972209, + "Yices": 10.321179544339666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.701762863691012, + "CVC4": 0.1789519833048889, + "CVC3": 11.120422401601401, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.950428043062601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.226721352875732 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.210407869605318, + "veriT": 9.165910933496475, + "Yices": 10.312167863281898, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.676657696745659, + "CVC4": 0.15749251040266668, + "CVC3": 11.198002072229841, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.979590995011016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7856771757106475 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236187690224069, + "veriT": 11.640701078193665, + "Yices": 11.592691230244505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951260328816204, + "CVC4": 4.1455318321556796, + "CVC3": 14.596122539689036, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5601665021932201, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.390995238969749 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13922742376709094, + "veriT": 0.13451553073221817, + "Yices": 6.8427884799449989, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14243677307558181, + "CVC4": 6.6412047355846173, + "CVC3": 5.823723955640034, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5523414689111439, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5531335673728868 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8786764144897461, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7407735473199559, + "veriT": 9.5314085805107798, + "Yices": 8.3937168279476158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5575755171300578, + "CVC4": 5.7033327445305373, + "CVC3": 2.6083159918042669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3903822728269937, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.445130424622536 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5554544651217803, + "veriT": 14.181415541065908, + "Yices": 10.768838009040415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.303610112751302, + "CVC4": 14.503416333730691, + "CVC3": 10.519839789627831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.919758300257225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.916498014708241 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0954544544219971, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7646073252206547, + "veriT": 10.569082980989689, + "Yices": 11.690610641470462, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6034495082645472, + "CVC4": 12.887740933043112, + "CVC3": 7.4499350022323441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.68751185270434, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4393747604753031 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9375, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8606332488188393, + "veriT": 5.9868031675386169, + "Yices": 9.5194241848463346, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2190469121936491, + "CVC4": 3.0323704295929095, + "CVC3": 6.0622932622242081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4823406752773778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9294613822435354 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1485049006904187, + "veriT": 3.7686083139741426, + "Yices": 3.6639334348900929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7332342300166759, + "CVC4": 3.2863178461885987, + "CVC3": 3.1377623754975414, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1598064339823377, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1584076227108691 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0566135120468858, + "veriT": 8.8751550354011304, + "Yices": 10.487669952520472, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4591167368706301, + "CVC4": 11.012047579555684, + "CVC3": 3.2512348721739288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.214141313647659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.608198583149614 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.574635212904193, + "veriT": 10.120018397618821, + "Yices": 10.113873118579738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.254598909049207, + "CVC4": 5.6423726432053503, + "CVC3": 4.0464809459999369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.365302413234891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.396844419469636 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12362758926822856, + "veriT": 8.6557737362663705, + "Yices": 8.6586778296010856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11893349855651428, + "CVC4": 4.9983347381065881, + "CVC3": 3.1459793559954283, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0864553844337097, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0505761048891644 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1711481310554683, + "veriT": 9.2505277763847236, + "Yices": 9.2550172082123332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.483787168168746, + "CVC4": 10.25843280985489, + "CVC3": 6.1581101217343415, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2517870597508738, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2598337247794289 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1446817725678999, + "veriT": 1.1187697769199101, + "Yices": 4.0613860675482716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1423488237088999, + "CVC4": 3.0476210604097025, + "CVC3": 1.15085774020441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5655186380615294, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5643395236901181 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9255237508888867, + "veriT": 7.0157776510464815, + "Yices": 11.459980600633614, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8728465101655329, + "CVC4": 12.717271160532899, + "CVC3": 11.256480876125053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6095491354430402, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.011192349494741 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0426813248989166, + "veriT": 1.9155629406783283, + "Yices": 2.1824336913291971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3696336992634164, + "CVC4": 0.19828077350700002, + "CVC3": 6.2756119248761921, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0209888016729165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0185916805210835 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16570801357633333, + "veriT": 0.14950738673366668, + "Yices": 1.7209998409615916, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16497999200722221, + "CVC4": 0.17628155560755554, + "CVC3": 0.15798553046066666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17250626572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17299620732277779 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 46.0, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1919290382828667, + "veriT": 9.9997469322099999, + "Yices": 9.4442733027936203, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4326252272432232, + "CVC4": 6.1922599115054373, + "CVC3": 8.2477734324451077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.717849100124749, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.879976526389955 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7804012125378539, + "veriT": 4.5042901550318595, + "Yices": 11.343987143785894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.005255471385591, + "CVC4": 9.458494045048937, + "CVC3": 9.375133314947794, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1068744541008184, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4720911942977906 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.202016327316625, + "veriT": 1.6109257113356124, + "Yices": 2.662642635081125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4651053290132503, + "CVC4": 2.0252697728193425, + "CVC3": 0.22304133828012498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.19323260330615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1869228241643652 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18509820246942857, + "veriT": 6.5096631160535168, + "Yices": 5.7320417898458214, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0585468391497144, + "CVC4": 0.23337619620814284, + "CVC3": 5.0952989112947318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19071347094434291, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1905078023363857 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3736565222353807, + "veriT": 10.162238885090657, + "Yices": 10.238114913457284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6025751120999896, + "CVC4": 8.2100460857156303, + "CVC3": 4.504400311197684, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.257384739906838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6617508598035009 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4920514974109675, + "veriT": 2.7817153724508135, + "Yices": 3.309389813914172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.793473812423235, + "CVC4": 11.468294018654596, + "CVC3": 0.1197185354218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2410733834822133, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21522641023758665 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 45.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8000664204863526, + "veriT": 10.618494575736436, + "Yices": 10.800207491061029, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.454687635293929, + "CVC4": 0.66310935684862315, + "CVC3": 1.1710208454679232, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6071289036480279, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.798075212990751 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.569286284956082, + "veriT": 10.799321238578244, + "Yices": 10.73038745351837, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.976174909598198, + "CVC4": 14.507622023983503, + "CVC3": 10.003510405668896, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0805731861831998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5257043926229965 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 63.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13357182807018184, + "veriT": 11.64362910896083, + "Yices": 0.11490194015763637, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13283271181681819, + "CVC4": 0.31803324670663635, + "CVC3": 0.12088049690672725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.421729659353351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4190672640688013 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3947385209729999, + "veriT": 14.211192142828722, + "Yices": 1.7746258393594549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5029395634256251, + "CVC4": 3.8632737511058299, + "CVC3": 1.9003824842270403, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.193120209820563, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.221224994013504 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0248231947257858, + "veriT": 12.171123663704561, + "Yices": 13.590520538446569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2135053431415459, + "CVC4": 9.3137325811345697, + "CVC3": 12.179131863757279, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.245009066660105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.245615661862669 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6918531001025547, + "veriT": 12.84636004303616, + "Yices": 8.4888951628477312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5485246942330475, + "CVC4": 7.8058107371586516, + "CVC3": 5.5784336257066292, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1986667703075664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0658314700595435 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8100509643554688, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8673368565467041, + "veriT": 9.7584234813253374, + "Yices": 5.9802109192018378, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4908172996598559, + "CVC4": 8.0259040272248026, + "CVC3": 6.6307589936552507, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.32996203230768, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.364764282778403 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 32.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14513159792900002, + "veriT": 0.12299413299662501, + "Yices": 0.137609797582875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1412222185525, + "CVC4": 0.16131275657081248, + "CVC3": 0.1399551335353125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1581569704900625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15752274157393747 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16627959757511113, + "veriT": 0.14496080185444446, + "Yices": 0.15674553754088891, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16957574696044445, + "CVC4": 0.19518032000999999, + "CVC3": 0.16901796269466668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18170918541722222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18022115773544445 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14441670701287498, + "veriT": 8.4631545186318391, + "Yices": 0.129226231661625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.145027929645, + "CVC4": 0.160331655859, + "CVC3": 0.13656432982862501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14985259036512499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.151116017185875 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6783083685698141, + "veriT": 2.3447705546700024, + "Yices": 8.9056393702241987, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9245918636393453, + "CVC4": 2.4767270410698736, + "CVC3": 3.441069358212284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4165489646634937, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7443637263047833 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2560447745158596, + "veriT": 9.3892828270142417, + "Yices": 7.6901430913074922, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7706200464468651, + "CVC4": 8.2340415498033526, + "CVC3": 2.1538639847974634, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.87063629320038383, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.85959430113578905 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7132873369129893, + "veriT": 14.213536323920907, + "Yices": 12.168673844331293, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7374797832993716, + "CVC4": 12.84764153706104, + "CVC3": 6.9106554592550289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.751846781055379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.65993717770786 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9444481430384739, + "veriT": 5.8269141221489944, + "Yices": 13.491730616477675, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5026423125424886, + "CVC4": 14.45286870141029, + "CVC3": 11.872242001280382, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9022633415072026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9027822479477594 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1135369426940001, + "veriT": 11.038738735943571, + "Yices": 6.1301489997586796, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2892395550613163, + "CVC4": 6.3322443395968619, + "CVC3": 3.703733883120349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1922346409157916, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1902456868753744 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247479915905709, + "veriT": 12.071108523700889, + "Yices": 12.600490107822733, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.53748544476302, + "CVC4": 11.846354821675968, + "CVC3": 11.146654471917472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.963099470840231, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.125289745797589 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5253034143457502, + "veriT": 9.464813419326136, + "Yices": 0.76915002370883334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7287639548668334, + "CVC4": 0.49104416929450001, + "CVC3": 7.0588039633291162, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16889210752066666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16534804666049999 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.563101771665, + "veriT": 13.431469504941427, + "Yices": 7.2882763203751493, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.531862988293568, + "CVC4": 5.2288000876660679, + "CVC3": 1.9888584959005002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3989661220827001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4463215793235 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7718682128529206, + "veriT": 14.237723693015338, + "Yices": 14.083250394899551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.913907526927972, + "CVC4": 14.450744255746963, + "CVC3": 13.698029823768465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1943020121943535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1599467437535003 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9564538032041066, + "veriT": 13.534377088214358, + "Yices": 12.700881587380941, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7063856175172285, + "CVC4": 11.085140734068077, + "CVC3": 5.5907643656643415, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.155394514325138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.110526636329872 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 51.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0102815628051758, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.285185639517243, + "veriT": 13.819803819691051, + "Yices": 13.538319061931944, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.162582672505696, + "CVC4": 12.939184110089764, + "CVC3": 14.169187209094423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.829485184320271, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.998212182509935 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245875980343984, + "veriT": 12.955784151842183, + "Yices": 12.893889228615542, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96422128041929, + "CVC4": 14.363813299807751, + "CVC3": 13.288938882014026, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.879220655620999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.3556142800239 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.434423020409159, + "veriT": 11.439202884884242, + "Yices": 11.676320369600532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.305651646637203, + "CVC4": 8.6254725534122159, + "CVC3": 12.447598564005858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2528432916895849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.82218587246218 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4571578761859598, + "veriT": 12.396106222212724, + "Yices": 10.68317570448599, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4934541232026302, + "CVC4": 11.782099097666428, + "CVC3": 9.176892756453725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.748836585426256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.690881973732447 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 288.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.413298378307349, + "veriT": 9.9302891909699937, + "Yices": 12.091619504040912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971737129574077, + "CVC4": 14.655087352989685, + "CVC3": 8.9120040901420943, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.450805308046531, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5025996977193739 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247605811923469, + "veriT": 11.199838883414685, + "Yices": 12.949084357348761, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.185271863209318, + "CVC4": 14.703973090021533, + "CVC3": 13.688666727906707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.969363191218612, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.915971205418648 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.594355595937174, + "veriT": 14.248305386107772, + "Yices": 13.765328998029975, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971807622719217, + "CVC4": 14.430310371082037, + "CVC3": 12.439724439000061, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.157482282129086, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.213812262280651 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 219.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2632075127993048, + "veriT": 14.003370619829866, + "Yices": 13.894824266882443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.395403204264639, + "CVC4": 12.933642447698576, + "CVC3": 12.338345677720671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.428470745358942, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.255111659535899 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.131133823556949, + "veriT": 13.546912871199895, + "Yices": 14.22489867579448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.262155660549622, + "CVC4": 14.738610501332808, + "CVC3": 9.6407585933370807, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.874221526391949, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.449504126720512 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24731395035062, + "veriT": 13.715660427722636, + "Yices": 14.24159273682943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971241357976917, + "CVC4": 14.591499359285006, + "CVC3": 13.450713534157178, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.218817148614225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.240668788260464 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 74.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.875, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12868393843792306, + "veriT": 0.098907318220642332, + "Yices": 0.10261234270528076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12570644327980768, + "CVC4": 0.12735837047088461, + "CVC3": 0.1056824046049423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1248968500276923, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12232715063566155 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11044961056993481, + "veriT": 0.082897767379926088, + "Yices": 0.087249415579517389, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11038857687909133, + "CVC4": 0.10683281384489998, + "CVC3": 0.088585053497495639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10525529268482173, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10458990010784783 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1666665077209473, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1697509459930933, + "veriT": 3.5564240241341087, + "Yices": 3.5940653058359859, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2608710089760291, + "CVC4": 2.2658630427223505, + "CVC3": 4.1550600267345086, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1556087827553898, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1683891959813142 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7861833447824447, + "veriT": 0.091239249054355556, + "Yices": 0.088730072379111111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7862454161014449, + "CVC4": 0.121069308078, + "CVC3": 0.096241248116844452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11896632692444443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12011895049811111 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.60809344715813762, + "veriT": 9.8769637938594848, + "Yices": 10.386402989961285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.71432915756416948, + "CVC4": 0.15003256951128571, + "CVC3": 0.60724461618177139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14924193451471429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.969889189493836 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6881719827651978, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0433299550190789, + "veriT": 2.8238081921579532, + "Yices": 3.5496994155531998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6138762442596408, + "CVC4": 0.15635113911293333, + "CVC3": 2.1188215460112971, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3297833460645414, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5331483372631061 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247750665461279, + "veriT": 10.1603702024971, + "Yices": 10.367892304365901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961116290382529, + "CVC4": 0.15398131770119999, + "CVC3": 11.024122356723799, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15460472910530002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.401364236818653 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235270854357875, + "veriT": 10.153959071913125, + "Yices": 10.31212098138475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950530805760518, + "CVC4": 0.24425598262475001, + "CVC3": 11.769109995657523, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2925972067272902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.218347163377908 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.59478057447207, + "veriT": 7.9372171872932205, + "Yices": 10.309631050379, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.660953718328418, + "CVC4": 0.28181791116222221, + "CVC3": 8.3115713786058798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9003835229938586, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.524040504336394 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.038461446762085, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.870432424654613, + "veriT": 10.920959532746568, + "Yices": 10.310306751915997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.348478879356309, + "CVC4": 5.1314201642502839, + "CVC3": 9.8842861229639674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9744638505716932, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.627881613618406 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.2421225998709, + "veriT": 10.166105466603391, + "Yices": 10.329176712669668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957163609082265, + "CVC4": 0.16731886229666668, + "CVC3": 12.644631792464894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8991860407088605, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.271047420015103 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.433429518971526, + "veriT": 10.979035713590196, + "Yices": 10.461526515045444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.407723169513401, + "CVC4": 10.813961361931156, + "CVC3": 13.629115238449769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3740852752413844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1680967661915567 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2366209046315566, + "veriT": 10.397082449093588, + "Yices": 7.357119464658, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3693175988605919, + "CVC4": 2.395173890876531, + "CVC3": 9.5439898627175399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0465295325251063, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.087011276717737 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.673060597369215, + "veriT": 12.262883751329483, + "Yices": 12.541598594929834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.560285634807876, + "CVC4": 11.528505604963961, + "CVC3": 9.7405852443337846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.104112535755887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.606791482876638 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13601585534104998, + "veriT": 6.3541953299888743, + "Yices": 9.4143921238875397, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.155291833715125, + "CVC4": 3.783298592742979, + "CVC3": 1.8991217290569928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6466240767442306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12737229779544998 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1782874156630738, + "veriT": 11.439935548494953, + "Yices": 9.3435361265670061, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5139609852988398, + "CVC4": 8.4443572057648897, + "CVC3": 7.830465052110049, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1955616307938914, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4441999632723093 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 67.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1714286804199219, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7321429252624512, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1583944552497996, + "veriT": 10.179536201202989, + "Yices": 6.5726449813593977, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1634946768015997, + "CVC4": 5.9330299370324777, + "CVC3": 5.9670501365720154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8176276676654206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8133670117170855 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8772201595885232, + "veriT": 10.942419295849522, + "Yices": 11.565381854691692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4811108153610189, + "CVC4": 13.151103025046194, + "CVC3": 6.9544543661152263, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231031384131962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.125966909333652 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5479417288941921, + "veriT": 7.4009948720498171, + "Yices": 2.4865590887809779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9940927297159874, + "CVC4": 4.5258666434012547, + "CVC3": 0.30509274842042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.555044130184414, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6722415592991151 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.13983603945809, + "veriT": 2.4487731698487765, + "Yices": 4.5492195866396337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1936631267326212, + "CVC4": 2.5410424531737257, + "CVC3": 2.4556943237639843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2971707035906508, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2981622929803147 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7419454341391327, + "veriT": 8.4123480311406187, + "Yices": 7.5815058769810442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2431346714773674, + "CVC4": 4.0474567478383126, + "CVC3": 4.0011607404426206, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0064339946265033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5052674396104098 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9761164975977348, + "veriT": 10.090744205500975, + "Yices": 12.46082338505456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2494706223273129, + "CVC4": 10.948683657972181, + "CVC3": 11.022875049458021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.698057231092896, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.739825941196447 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0954544544219971, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8376624584197998, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8730105744138346, + "veriT": 7.3535805344409866, + "Yices": 6.9346165424908772, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2073591534199899, + "CVC4": 1.6632904672959592, + "CVC3": 6.8218910380980384, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0611521131583741, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1420991024078235 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7614202968130668, + "veriT": 9.5281401374071617, + "Yices": 10.431504364492728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1078034490638249, + "CVC4": 9.8931741826167183, + "CVC3": 9.9188347010326297, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.222134345016141, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.793293585752073 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.552291193583867, + "veriT": 11.635089855622569, + "Yices": 11.502805197082667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.527527257090622, + "CVC4": 6.5275829115245818, + "CVC3": 14.181415255117406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7514373726226307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.584619094779127 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8946008339263019, + "veriT": 1.3791852198012875, + "Yices": 3.6085890930573372, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9807738841208105, + "CVC4": 3.6652681957333559, + "CVC3": 3.1342657230427236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8967463669348144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8994293620848941 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.411422167649, + "veriT": 1.4027670892359008, + "Yices": 10.574009699375488, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4069596885914997, + "CVC4": 5.4540887762953476, + "CVC3": 6.6462577280355868, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9528696707667197, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9475657310119843 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 40.0, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7014579458848527, + "veriT": 13.182066378129415, + "Yices": 12.245328840146144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9684348398807607, + "CVC4": 12.278934558270041, + "CVC3": 10.167991543681028, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.11286076624307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.132461742140013 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.202480257805032, + "veriT": 8.2979696391983584, + "Yices": 14.061691724850089, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.716352405213886, + "CVC4": 7.0059574550426769, + "CVC3": 10.468955425394086, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8390379505537595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8260557186563906 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1222020511496875, + "veriT": 5.1068328284693623, + "Yices": 1.350547017074575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12943600853991249, + "CVC4": 1.8867486071557462, + "CVC3": 0.12116408248487499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1184475117537625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11655792674516249 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.899281525918167, + "veriT": 10.354464776742892, + "Yices": 10.78549171196199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7479452709160395, + "CVC4": 9.8216890102086847, + "CVC3": 3.6186637981995537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.778022502742707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3071719845047705 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.839593818662049, + "veriT": 10.166336524841899, + "Yices": 10.3507672619285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.48706344645772, + "CVC4": 0.16147539131689997, + "CVC3": 12.197873927498126, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16513990483300001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.298603355219997 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4763524221451041, + "veriT": 6.5867402268133342, + "Yices": 12.963304209235696, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3540929757384852, + "CVC4": 0.51612359792244444, + "CVC3": 4.7785184823420002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14434406415700002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8734366191713647 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 46.0, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8111857035853278, + "veriT": 4.7166220423885301, + "Yices": 7.148915263411963, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2338283430910657, + "CVC4": 1.8082274329626218, + "CVC3": 5.1816175758112477, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7953499977543119, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4735449029368515 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6032288109469999, + "veriT": 3.5486749216681424, + "Yices": 5.8982752924702861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5217026160277145, + "CVC4": 9.2833127124439834, + "CVC3": 3.8618988774245198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.237614144757089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.234888510176301 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 79.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14243481679114284, + "veriT": 2.1440143679093833, + "Yices": 0.16063487586142858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18737361059542854, + "CVC4": 2.2699957243228801, + "CVC3": 1.6716629419644284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6518740014589519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2029123092903271 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14396643082892308, + "veriT": 1.9776157951955848, + "Yices": 0.9837513480936384, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15214754736738462, + "CVC4": 0.16285096727861539, + "CVC3": 0.13407706283062309, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15410840765256922, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14766249424066924 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4018517377627, + "veriT": 7.4041253490052101, + "Yices": 7.5945916279120125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4211419137762249, + "CVC4": 0.30995790123801248, + "CVC3": 5.2188645061813785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5118590687308187, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5191753735672355 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5901557149043217, + "veriT": 6.8296665783403654, + "Yices": 7.7452404519816982, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6596229622173517, + "CVC4": 11.509203708444025, + "CVC3": 5.3195586429502999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6787187567187427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1341821441160151 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1041938138, + "veriT": 11.27196449931817, + "Yices": 1.4108869794740875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3966080228629152, + "CVC4": 1.5242986277813471, + "CVC3": 1.1565666486698474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3950771543809308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0786632718265539 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 50.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 21.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9798437266553739, + "veriT": 12.173449122712764, + "Yices": 10.072760204914276, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4177277195905362, + "CVC4": 13.349381287294779, + "CVC3": 12.824547477414376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.852988012346561, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.297817802631462 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7878018529858715, + "veriT": 10.181802228633, + "Yices": 10.3358462371603, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6073395917445357, + "CVC4": 14.273297120609147, + "CVC3": 5.9823449346899578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254953750566695, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.468392617150636 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 37.0, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26631577408557144, + "veriT": 13.054274288419341, + "Yices": 1.585116791699857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2869224311364227, + "CVC4": 2.3442039544712512, + "CVC3": 0.58748697175999998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9464859894632367, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.506144419296219 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1188829951942223, + "veriT": 12.84337581636145, + "Yices": 10.867762301821285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6339042598880313, + "CVC4": 8.8417294148356333, + "CVC3": 6.6343834623582412, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.662055820161084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.66434971091757 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1798400763205219, + "veriT": 13.643785126997276, + "Yices": 14.210394181379286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3852895242866055, + "CVC4": 2.332903217697317, + "CVC3": 14.146053809586762, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.672124550275031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.177095809227989 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16411197029571428, + "veriT": 2.1464529441507163, + "Yices": 9.1706196362281016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.32440907743442854, + "CVC4": 10.33985345412051, + "CVC3": 4.5591537565298568, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15293503235100001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14998481702614286 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.976313440413724, + "veriT": 12.002854374381439, + "Yices": 10.472955835144566, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.663745724048015, + "CVC4": 13.371529342097192, + "CVC3": 11.086606172178129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.944056723126874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.180551446559832 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4763936747947541, + "veriT": 12.05720437525078, + "Yices": 7.7384131179149938, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.592309206742371, + "CVC4": 13.252934579728855, + "CVC3": 5.1272098593303488, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.418192552890627, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.42012334945672 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2874379201615191, + "veriT": 13.756569568582755, + "Yices": 11.068361285069777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1384467950391119, + "CVC4": 1.9019799353989038, + "CVC3": 1.0671610784080001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5408611388710405, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.531199874575556 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.028294563293457, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9354394674301147, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5706803575471429, + "veriT": 0.1260144157114286, + "Yices": 0.12793504797228569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5755218934654285, + "CVC4": 0.16387285710714283, + "CVC3": 0.13975311839714286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14793660318214283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14782539813942858 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15493240494446156, + "veriT": 0.13018997487915385, + "Yices": 0.14382532505407691, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15126601033507692, + "CVC4": 0.1709925871486154, + "CVC3": 0.15001141340492305, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16451517682399996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16292827437030766 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1715688705444336, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20626513301975002, + "veriT": 7.544581205056601, + "Yices": 2.7028136381496668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1820971919822501, + "CVC4": 1.401565873385894, + "CVC3": 1.3161906743096445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2478218487620021, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2588129466136748 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.62430889281777779, + "veriT": 1.7016658593071039, + "Yices": 1.7171163966089653, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.80554959796641, + "CVC4": 0.20909200078644447, + "CVC3": 1.2933580167897778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17478498904322221, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17394296593022221 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9908061036375519, + "veriT": 4.3568179685121979, + "Yices": 4.3543176948976221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3069625496653874, + "CVC4": 2.9870236710751055, + "CVC3": 3.2189626557322271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22578974160870002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22106980586620004 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4274887079658383, + "veriT": 7.7867475008636466, + "Yices": 7.6587885875298358, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4035386072748288, + "CVC4": 4.02298039476646, + "CVC3": 2.0776896824517026, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2535247402861307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2631266542869843 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1344714164733887, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7739283582868515, + "veriT": 4.9098385085679865, + "Yices": 3.992874105463788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6176274530706634, + "CVC4": 12.360731314942354, + "CVC3": 1.979253833481482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2310214690126413, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0103777888998287 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6324281423261437, + "veriT": 8.2058066615586682, + "Yices": 12.518568497771403, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7966034548139227, + "CVC4": 8.0387690462539254, + "CVC3": 11.416865968335561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9883372197273319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9797936207926563 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 97.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.869411525041965, + "veriT": 10.970652820746434, + "Yices": 10.994516319833011, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.890716878095342, + "CVC4": 13.219305227530679, + "CVC3": 11.209907166224324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.552399477227809, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.469896917955845 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5559030293544724, + "veriT": 13.35307807417739, + "Yices": 9.5743274313657007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0226222422943874, + "CVC4": 6.5683598304654192, + "CVC3": 6.598674457571267, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.490468031578426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4866143649327039 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 45.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 286.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 110.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.121000726345477, + "veriT": 13.339772969243704, + "Yices": 8.8831798119869347, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.710039217867989, + "CVC4": 14.583773452217649, + "CVC3": 12.826714836922699, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242699407707399, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.938408847049864 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.3017883669582857, + "veriT": 13.059881492049071, + "Yices": 7.7401168154411648, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.97435486241071434, + "CVC4": 6.2802886130889712, + "CVC3": 0.30246516871000001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.224409670203256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.231599989364138 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8518041169423323, + "veriT": 12.854407374866845, + "Yices": 10.945795837388992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.073072175131928, + "CVC4": 12.057524566881858, + "CVC3": 11.19830109343305, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9132683133676647, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8859109899316735 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 206.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.41547206746338, + "veriT": 14.224428014146119, + "Yices": 12.077317805365855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956322228730389, + "CVC4": 14.424968602127596, + "CVC3": 14.225455886657134, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.322328522161573, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236794817789221 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259056031840302, + "veriT": 10.1911665437186, + "Yices": 10.339288844464921, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973866583988388, + "CVC4": 13.569880974734431, + "CVC3": 13.027256134300568, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.461490516120381, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.976429847187738 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9516540653583609, + "veriT": 12.179103589605177, + "Yices": 13.695916936216065, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6873569626511813, + "CVC4": 14.513366728990341, + "CVC3": 9.9867971518640104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4720723832123959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4685354026896773 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 176.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4175349912558755, + "veriT": 14.214453467193941, + "Yices": 4.2290952914988074, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.843753181864681, + "CVC4": 2.169678232908375, + "CVC3": 12.488817917045292, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4372137988002169, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4629638214712797 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9998885125538948, + "veriT": 12.758819783157342, + "Yices": 13.554752171487877, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.577572480871069, + "CVC4": 14.16572817076934, + "CVC3": 14.234010032011023, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3788977764504269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.348031941441441 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0928387798826362, + "veriT": 12.803274521547177, + "Yices": 3.742779347978141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1225178016217274, + "CVC4": 4.2182242187224448, + "CVC3": 0.53142694517181821, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23789328144136365, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.23565603606799998 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7171700000762939, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5227220460209665, + "veriT": 7.8255420350107192, + "Yices": 9.0632655863635332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.712656515254212, + "CVC4": 8.1411956676577901, + "CVC3": 9.667569234451669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.682284391455694, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.413283029688847 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 204.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.586658250607025, + "veriT": 12.771798897815517, + "Yices": 14.024993117435519, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.204685283993605, + "CVC4": 14.544451831560071, + "CVC3": 13.441134863326285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.144442765998804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.071070138501325 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1036997998819773, + "veriT": 14.245149110087857, + "Yices": 14.003293114763673, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.192082079194259, + "CVC4": 14.62880783646805, + "CVC3": 10.915085529361667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.941590306845299, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.784275480438943 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.252048011781449, + "veriT": 11.793333445180341, + "Yices": 13.038781762316276, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.011851899758284, + "CVC4": 14.689429331121573, + "CVC3": 14.020568918938329, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.216242700145894, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.053616098024881 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.589084848870376, + "veriT": 13.955556296682577, + "Yices": 14.244145907644485, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971691336824913, + "CVC4": 14.588328953585256, + "CVC3": 11.875186847655103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7818608907496305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0646993544234906 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 61.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12331109756787646, + "veriT": 0.091711902059791156, + "Yices": 0.095656071620935285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12082925546766472, + "CVC4": 0.12059296652834117, + "CVC3": 0.099808441630594116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11726914764575881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11716044584497651 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12504969887783332, + "veriT": 0.09825139951685001, + "Yices": 0.10275145454184999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12639109383183333, + "CVC4": 0.12577234100905002, + "CVC3": 0.10448727371950833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12071004792516665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11858763245405 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9025684591693262, + "veriT": 2.8087460365859518, + "Yices": 3.2445329463686403, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0871120676223534, + "CVC4": 2.0372841440458349, + "CVC3": 2.0208272625902084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15573725210086667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0448794336406988 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.79192568449996836, + "veriT": 9.745350265846751, + "Yices": 9.9259650808023192, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.86881361415115554, + "CVC4": 0.14838687258145836, + "CVC3": 0.68417699456295822, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14897589255487501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.941032815899021 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18722463523025001, + "veriT": 7.6549312035601247, + "Yices": 10.647359972532625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.37380668846499998, + "CVC4": 0.14943904219925, + "CVC3": 0.26077057649924995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.148154698270625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6240979971751357 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.235099093948595, + "veriT": 11.168801905792201, + "Yices": 11.656652771523547, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.346201660288672, + "CVC4": 11.7776747343481, + "CVC3": 10.101762998633497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.416966998856289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.749115933197531 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0714285373687744, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.41428542137146, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0146458649530592, + "veriT": 4.1575880275488002, + "Yices": 9.0661032601923175, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8916192658109363, + "CVC4": 0.16693148110100001, + "CVC3": 3.2829594071138986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.158998182111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7832072224189472 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.358018891893456, + "veriT": 10.185110994495501, + "Yices": 10.329221542121333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959931766615862, + "CVC4": 0.15575910792, + "CVC3": 9.2238564272255008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14557676281583334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.840009916314385 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237460329812714, + "veriT": 10.152956233941856, + "Yices": 10.326636752828716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959750123431363, + "CVC4": 0.20913732189007145, + "CVC3": 13.55467021620667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.717513891406703, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.283707219407571 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.085454808638374, + "veriT": 10.435455903533221, + "Yices": 6.7138997121972208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.316648723486392, + "CVC4": 1.9583995553848308, + "CVC3": 8.9455718961101844, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9477888302448774, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4285032802313307 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.103928215931992, + "veriT": 8.9925827725942913, + "Yices": 10.307721633474932, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.673239203787009, + "CVC4": 1.7752684433753947, + "CVC3": 9.419945861244738, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.311879941371791, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.690429246203811 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7761606674524781, + "veriT": 8.1167146489383004, + "Yices": 9.1795026255349477, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.505862790014271, + "CVC4": 10.299967056351838, + "CVC3": 9.9928903066520594, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2777249326944498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2099381794935686 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.774340511033305, + "veriT": 10.407854215499654, + "Yices": 10.151267531449246, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4720887325455614, + "CVC4": 2.984103752591206, + "CVC3": 8.9403200807091103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5353294562304614, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1770356834340951 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2701487692489051, + "veriT": 6.6450685325316687, + "Yices": 5.6349752399413839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4755643327369024, + "CVC4": 0.44960001198707694, + "CVC3": 1.3142818578770559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.455353244816826, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.272462380010559 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5368161980384549, + "veriT": 10.852382930629195, + "Yices": 11.568489058450998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7651493173023107, + "CVC4": 7.0592757396387071, + "CVC3": 9.8128727850041209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3086846908286773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5584387786420795 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7034485340118408, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8645814331016606, + "veriT": 12.179870876378862, + "Yices": 9.6692846560226631, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2317081227150002, + "CVC4": 7.3760704176827865, + "CVC3": 11.876716383134243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8564758545079068, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7102133270046878 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.228849453993273, + "veriT": 9.5979308606787601, + "Yices": 10.033681133418376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.001904268762383, + "CVC4": 0.175427881545375, + "CVC3": 10.661803867590235, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8544728688667089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3483212980823147 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.446430983265975, + "veriT": 13.352323975175766, + "Yices": 13.563426004624436, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.72864167612161, + "CVC4": 12.637171343790245, + "CVC3": 15.067873545742337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.875313477218327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.872211826910199 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.615789532661438, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0026001459961522, + "veriT": 9.9235978565436813, + "Yices": 8.82748248438741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8693317279728809, + "CVC4": 3.480772764541769, + "CVC3": 7.3078089942858862, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9772182630549313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9927976250521322 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1535639977793339, + "veriT": 11.610979860453611, + "Yices": 1.8720524832313614, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.339087149388571, + "CVC4": 2.3302495150276985, + "CVC3": 0.18679065779814286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.804263702612545, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.804994385293439 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1918827433743031, + "veriT": 4.1793767355611458, + "Yices": 8.1235357361453886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8823566636596651, + "CVC4": 10.440056344101182, + "CVC3": 4.2021225606656998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.217037199937044, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2340236172074244 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.94433175613441644, + "veriT": 1.2492997180126582, + "Yices": 1.2476623433266651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.93945840234341682, + "CVC4": 1.2750922188158123, + "CVC3": 1.2542413743681415, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.094304887878350008, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.096928176710291677 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0165763044162013, + "veriT": 9.4867010660945699, + "Yices": 5.9968052026074359, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0687411514878615, + "CVC4": 2.5285611151021032, + "CVC3": 2.5622516615195177, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3511644698110441, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3473449556636652 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8528139591217041, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5371721216142982, + "veriT": 12.171059274626632, + "Yices": 9.7375963452619914, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.809311553704026, + "CVC4": 3.8941480743710004, + "CVC3": 1.2264780008156, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.830404586759377, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.827980526633604 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9542985002559465, + "veriT": 7.9304458029169638, + "Yices": 5.444270067270546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0989242970083204, + "CVC4": 3.1221250579105448, + "CVC3": 2.9720676773312404, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15315033957100002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15221027217319999 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13756804368612499, + "veriT": 0.11466390312579375, + "Yices": 0.24648832164506251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14099412005456252, + "CVC4": 0.189512143059125, + "CVC3": 2.6852407492205002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2461106622683329, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2404017999385371 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5962699474660229, + "veriT": 9.5287105602255142, + "Yices": 9.7240711865803231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.614500705816817, + "CVC4": 9.6928306148557226, + "CVC3": 9.5460020588157484, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7104084885290893, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6542827428943303 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.97574364320392304, + "veriT": 14.206460724727727, + "Yices": 1.0031786672885386, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2846169249320001, + "CVC4": 6.0320210033940933, + "CVC3": 1.2386599958149156, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8907549743874839, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8865421200027281 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6828682381584343, + "veriT": 14.185979927553396, + "Yices": 10.70244692002534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.294791116934936, + "CVC4": 14.51715867705853, + "CVC3": 11.285461565606747, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.217911552262038, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.220172862654211 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5910342507344919, + "veriT": 9.8175402214464302, + "Yices": 9.2838496838181399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8241806547299082, + "CVC4": 12.265296875362976, + "CVC3": 8.1910255495846673, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.074611615813994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.085584980828381 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.839376740390353, + "veriT": 9.6933438197062198, + "Yices": 9.5375502674536854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.445676446506157, + "CVC4": 0.15775236024269232, + "CVC3": 10.794702248354223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5750328438375387, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.670925648408497 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5627513169631335, + "veriT": 5.2103392247047324, + "Yices": 6.8969672175443337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2124610288250999, + "CVC4": 5.8672772690131252, + "CVC3": 0.29213015045166668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8578881766969468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9008514958272187 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.782832757110041, + "veriT": 9.646947239039612, + "Yices": 9.5699159225159018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.077235382616395, + "CVC4": 9.0825867859094522, + "CVC3": 5.9488126930088816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.890041569531327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.427228911794538 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6515931313049999, + "veriT": 3.8958370040674493, + "Yices": 6.2704716863031242, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6490759411442499, + "CVC4": 5.0297777255947382, + "CVC3": 2.8240614313271255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6598811098989859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7451594431594546 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.570147285154599, + "veriT": 9.1007439170513926, + "Yices": 9.8617231286047158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7312904148846631, + "CVC4": 2.7936314866484775, + "CVC3": 8.1688652284285457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1265549330004543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1501114350859476 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22526577734683331, + "veriT": 13.544566918113111, + "Yices": 3.9001989035143332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0176690839043334, + "CVC4": 2.5346491690442039, + "CVC3": 2.7011577690332254, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.968273724811583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.44078286897367 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.158978059155819, + "veriT": 13.643304059841432, + "Yices": 12.388241866137767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.077648134227902, + "CVC4": 11.860036380177428, + "CVC3": 10.241693740068445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.238661485981378, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.187688678986058 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7750000953674316, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.552753441198675, + "veriT": 9.739591576416192, + "Yices": 8.0677654121869882, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0626285228502645, + "CVC4": 7.3091097749183298, + "CVC3": 4.6456138933377717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2616724572547602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8469925633489153 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.49681893800945559, + "veriT": 7.0634103839510418, + "Yices": 2.3968171585070999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4391720763067415, + "CVC4": 3.2841243486343688, + "CVC3": 3.2588833961688812, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2727374069390183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6600732422047164 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5657387939006666, + "veriT": 2.9475509310275467, + "Yices": 12.796357748464681, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4982926508626, + "CVC4": 7.244691258129798, + "CVC3": 9.1661134271772031, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9578680346147963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9546530534597628 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.458168993128945, + "veriT": 12.195028918742972, + "Yices": 12.60325523769785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7866694877382887, + "CVC4": 12.119260936746244, + "CVC3": 12.834088477793014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.0979557552053, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.097629580762762 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25718364853072728, + "veriT": 1.9917607514597286, + "Yices": 10.930017512734709, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.44357696328981822, + "CVC4": 0.18613022047454544, + "CVC3": 3.0021762483064549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4435021945913418, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4463687187898975 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2120247098385, + "veriT": 1.4705186821364047, + "Yices": 3.2039979356016817, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20945533529025001, + "CVC4": 1.9864947501687313, + "CVC3": 1.6496466497902507, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21578175553874998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21574910768399999 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.315794109498162, + "veriT": 8.9554018576714114, + "Yices": 8.1094378772038223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5406339173908243, + "CVC4": 7.0279974575555846, + "CVC3": 0.38237348025490908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2891833573172242, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.423139376561814 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.855991005897522, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8992567257959951, + "veriT": 9.9928214307598093, + "Yices": 10.736417724921974, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.584975467972166, + "CVC4": 6.295772415673385, + "CVC3": 10.979168536513516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.066143145536994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.669658648730714 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15759790177358335, + "veriT": 4.9804616868825464, + "Yices": 0.13549917466966666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.64050824951741669, + "CVC4": 0.16105079394425001, + "CVC3": 0.15179213913466669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14496193249833333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14347190719800001 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17808639113090002, + "veriT": 0.16224984107360002, + "Yices": 0.16315346655070001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17730108631640001, + "CVC4": 0.20726430645049998, + "CVC3": 0.17979232283070001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1919156141526, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18806436802819998 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15748829556725, + "veriT": 0.13086860318933333, + "Yices": 0.15016765292891665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16043994073199999, + "CVC4": 0.17267821261533334, + "CVC3": 0.15415415812158331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16740327139824998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16898956336216664 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3314766697235001, + "veriT": 6.1922030117432501, + "Yices": 3.2177515997659754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4805751172172856, + "CVC4": 0.19461051111535713, + "CVC3": 0.69665506617073558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17531256788051428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17600510601300709 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0938925743103027, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9726626419609508, + "veriT": 11.473252923624862, + "Yices": 13.214942458656777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.786137540797993, + "CVC4": 5.6116342037323559, + "CVC3": 4.7821047307543054, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9858506426587512, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.982433381332998 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4534594920908566, + "veriT": 4.8987770758051399, + "Yices": 6.0401418225604724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5628021455433596, + "CVC4": 2.7996495966925745, + "CVC3": 2.6345094182536726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4612705184576651, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4956742166913064 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1141023635864258, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1197586984940795, + "veriT": 1.10179799197009, + "Yices": 1.0951774576211499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1199598425845902, + "CVC4": 12.886885950745883, + "CVC3": 0.092147799245539994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14337475235274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14607914359613999 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.32549167220620001, + "veriT": 8.1404861592522018, + "Yices": 5.7815232038046824, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5503024196736999, + "CVC4": 4.7680019695538949, + "CVC3": 4.1943521744812777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0511338545787043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6546528272104055 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7082590901451384, + "veriT": 7.8899139758832337, + "Yices": 9.4658168452349027, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7227161070619683, + "CVC4": 1.718197792884562, + "CVC3": 4.7525931289252226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8697388870321552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8866218303362752 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.859796644806014, + "veriT": 11.466574770994093, + "Yices": 11.200793800133546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.332777932477589, + "CVC4": 13.575474976152655, + "CVC3": 13.397619865300287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2418640777122576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1968988544639734 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5075902577153002, + "veriT": 8.3899227564268521, + "Yices": 9.59837811160169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.514266388971047, + "CVC4": 7.3220941647945068, + "CVC3": 0.26692124810599999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5595522941248534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4255007560492645 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.489772596699856, + "veriT": 10.718402602541779, + "Yices": 11.775469153024291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.224659307850011, + "CVC4": 14.433140974689874, + "CVC3": 9.5509470141934472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.275296802989502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.829400369796119 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236279925275497, + "veriT": 10.36143807074383, + "Yices": 10.193495902220349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95124989470709, + "CVC4": 14.445396834496677, + "CVC3": 12.989231928766172, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.747036942385886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.545600277850417 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.784657114932386, + "veriT": 13.767726158238373, + "Yices": 12.796752661022158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.778184797884627, + "CVC4": 14.57676606215462, + "CVC3": 9.7939952996518187, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23530815076662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.232429455918824 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6579877773539007, + "veriT": 12.162321477660504, + "Yices": 10.23116605179322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.282110862831999, + "CVC4": 9.1859042538920583, + "CVC3": 7.3344848105650478, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.994979934889663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.993074392883623 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 87.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17185791540768891, + "veriT": 4.0634940879006045, + "Yices": 1.6893967863070958, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26228050381055551, + "CVC4": 1.7236209341145172, + "CVC3": 4.31424451865304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7124426010332141, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7036466758091595 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7465296354019841, + "veriT": 12.616390664695704, + "Yices": 11.640932119691458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5938567035578295, + "CVC4": 8.6385503252372793, + "CVC3": 5.9911045268474021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.648942816734948, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.39149441449103 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.32878102805449999, + "veriT": 10.026989784535186, + "Yices": 3.5891257035270998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2439661028350213, + "CVC4": 1.6466134201769862, + "CVC3": 1.3602894192018002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4090469915296122, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1336135992447858 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.347050465900403, + "veriT": 13.196447705615315, + "Yices": 12.793724442192321, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.089771823890482, + "CVC4": 13.198912097814615, + "CVC3": 12.572436121384492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.41608933022400002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.36956610346133334 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0339584350585938, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.652245391128279, + "veriT": 13.722863534130589, + "Yices": 11.763866266866954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.944018788991167, + "CVC4": 13.506082406111197, + "CVC3": 12.693404987269821, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238190993499423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.850037229720897 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3313539129515402, + "veriT": 11.86358661265384, + "Yices": 8.7196930286687433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.996550783044739, + "CVC4": 8.8195948663649091, + "CVC3": 11.880469172681003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0703500701184998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1314749653732501 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.638750266238414, + "veriT": 13.422762176254082, + "Yices": 13.618922708164328, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964603915267338, + "CVC4": 13.891111147369873, + "CVC3": 14.23392068485777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.137884941825124, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.752850145997284 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 134.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3500602338795371, + "veriT": 9.1045651094558426, + "Yices": 9.5474897762163202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4263622512294054, + "CVC4": 11.744154141277864, + "CVC3": 10.189597422028267, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.984853709016205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9576349523071137 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 133.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5585835668085224, + "veriT": 13.482964722512982, + "Yices": 13.219579661868323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956442297411378, + "CVC4": 14.546405881560439, + "CVC3": 11.496480501357949, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242725399577706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.24090149436549 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.251842391375895, + "veriT": 10.214990166874779, + "Yices": 12.814872318811398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972769023202412, + "CVC4": 14.75941579670603, + "CVC3": 14.252220755239895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.271368660535366, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.271377046968942 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248937893372606, + "veriT": 12.946899198913302, + "Yices": 14.236346253367515, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967148529522214, + "CVC4": 14.403789491392908, + "CVC3": 13.189592399707594, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.184267373215846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.19851377415732 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.992681778145819, + "veriT": 14.232202403893767, + "Yices": 14.425099892457807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.629044529744654, + "CVC4": 12.845763732782617, + "CVC3": 13.978277385060601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25460320741718, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.254460288360356 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2860242440793588, + "veriT": 12.917088613207381, + "Yices": 12.99446409671512, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.427483776051233, + "CVC4": 12.392836398015332, + "CVC3": 11.951782370804297, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5813673728578159, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1800096868016396 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26463864490233, + "veriT": 13.761743568890211, + "Yices": 13.474098950050571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.985732170826521, + "CVC4": 14.831204757851653, + "CVC3": 14.26990391910935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.761381330786289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.425196632272346 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12666698327344, + "veriT": 0.096835489294224003, + "Yices": 0.098488291347212001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12301196391396001, + "CVC4": 0.12276891832183999, + "CVC3": 0.10222727400266801, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12114867011184, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.120270472090608 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11741005487768948, + "veriT": 0.61192141132783162, + "Yices": 0.61502642710288424, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12782663783155787, + "CVC4": 0.85026281356214506, + "CVC3": 0.090420226530957895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.84928410855608516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.84865698389216992 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6602099423467855, + "veriT": 1.3851955647712613, + "Yices": 1.1356067397389251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7398318795254939, + "CVC4": 1.9117481144317827, + "CVC3": 0.13302159727664997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.153952977652625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15907330548949999 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2289665922139514, + "veriT": 9.8329235589965869, + "Yices": 9.9393084523826332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5853273272346433, + "CVC4": 5.0854872974901513, + "CVC3": 7.3976421773686178, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8419218703660762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.95560620583762 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2068063877307143, + "veriT": 10.166550306876358, + "Yices": 10.356766312440998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27691653909785713, + "CVC4": 0.14970706029289288, + "CVC3": 0.66807003749435723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1484579332905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.451221712206094 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17670778117944444, + "veriT": 6.8086816982092229, + "Yices": 6.9362571236681116, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28623171758055554, + "CVC4": 0.15559334355111112, + "CVC3": 0.24397072211933335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14903306244188888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0324066209404443 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.491867664305342, + "veriT": 12.058790268672038, + "Yices": 12.253026836436673, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.575141939578279, + "CVC4": 12.758759266400032, + "CVC3": 11.161447220478502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.00636830093797, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.707188262892746 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.038461446762085, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9984622271113013, + "veriT": 3.4668812152515107, + "Yices": 4.697047704926109, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8625373537760024, + "CVC4": 1.8001911732985068, + "CVC3": 1.9381771478247443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7099036054024153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3851928787177012 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7888889312744141, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.925511820847024, + "veriT": 10.472526816525988, + "Yices": 10.443336587103538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.586229581397735, + "CVC4": 1.2965976753887423, + "CVC3": 10.566812897200229, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2270818862555872, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.478720928955832 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241189649613448, + "veriT": 10.157574209669141, + "Yices": 10.329911677849713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959598804456315, + "CVC4": 0.25253483650457148, + "CVC3": 11.991822031724466, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2950043629209773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.364194131116966 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237328909756789, + "veriT": 10.153099859155223, + "Yices": 10.335126860542891, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959889625088348, + "CVC4": 0.15799359872044444, + "CVC3": 14.23986158634926, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14482454003222223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.635435991925865 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.41883025837825, + "veriT": 10.554838946759338, + "Yices": 9.2777172634172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.514390368363934, + "CVC4": 0.1472177562815, + "CVC3": 8.6308732585439412, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15608062516500001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0472514304863658 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8285715579986572, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24538960210276, + "veriT": 10.160937812158625, + "Yices": 10.340836528052, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96520823954519, + "CVC4": 0.16765517840762498, + "CVC3": 13.313431605655978, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2114387828126363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.33396805259104 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238265214534771, + "veriT": 10.167576395938124, + "Yices": 10.323130298218874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952343747855881, + "CVC4": 0.159985235407375, + "CVC3": 8.0876000509293675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9597635678803442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.208981103168172 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3091639541866749, + "veriT": 6.615268720413308, + "Yices": 5.9971977679177932, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5999712592995623, + "CVC4": 1.8091980820803006, + "CVC3": 3.9318666365254691, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3930881574690623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4858247180251709 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9374581138723332, + "veriT": 10.835818056610172, + "Yices": 9.7481586253603343, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.48463887709522, + "CVC4": 6.6447959841013997, + "CVC3": 10.917464368265131, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9678983571818449, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0994631731460469 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12893704520062499, + "veriT": 8.87361644106333, + "Yices": 9.5109581726952985, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12918036997019375, + "CVC4": 2.7775320083682811, + "CVC3": 0.13732717185631249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16473504955581875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16641499141353125 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7210188277734595, + "veriT": 7.4103792047409547, + "Yices": 3.2910035067588836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5857650590165262, + "CVC4": 6.7380553763773516, + "CVC3": 6.5054466568850726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9546628844230223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.955597481481242 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1521476081117998, + "veriT": 7.1262900057897003, + "Yices": 7.3243297405547505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1521085344977997, + "CVC4": 5.8467969998651119, + "CVC3": 2.5709753934188195, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7150719782603403, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9422032069357114 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8393015740067238, + "veriT": 13.005278872445537, + "Yices": 10.952212363917091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.141228793083341, + "CVC4": 12.441873351834403, + "CVC3": 8.9872925159119763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.784542143833711, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.790679092268441 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0570067579943228, + "veriT": 3.0472998537660567, + "Yices": 6.646833414764429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0115841368547098, + "CVC4": 3.078090452578143, + "CVC3": 0.26018505817257143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16641934910848571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16700256580474285 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.89382081614343, + "veriT": 8.1224486734781216, + "Yices": 7.3888231945861502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9901026975826563, + "CVC4": 1.952645600266699, + "CVC3": 1.8860060823467777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8972824175810081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8940882849365874 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14552665835611112, + "veriT": 0.1318271221914111, + "Yices": 6.1449044709320129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14562755022555557, + "CVC4": 0.14713569171744445, + "CVC3": 1.2825190425847446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20354059975966668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1885602751521111 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2529694902707367, + "veriT": 8.3865086483998361, + "Yices": 8.5526020647759804, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6644794618110614, + "CVC4": 10.596131980519738, + "CVC3": 9.4311837827582181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5686778833094532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0638162783438698 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.470378743160451, + "veriT": 10.763052988533028, + "Yices": 11.497663650509583, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.098121541965151, + "CVC4": 2.0273961657114459, + "CVC3": 12.296176452609188, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8959741284320328, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.227879603768233 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.838823262400281, + "veriT": 14.227379109908817, + "Yices": 12.06987878766177, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.606699179602925, + "CVC4": 13.632495164164347, + "CVC3": 10.866830698692183, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.791052273529298, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.790858298810821 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2999999523162842, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.671417787700852, + "veriT": 10.159800378808189, + "Yices": 10.234790012665099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.326133238788625, + "CVC4": 3.4294230592601633, + "CVC3": 5.4602675847138435, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238812050481535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.576180284115386 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9076061461810951, + "veriT": 11.858429581851853, + "Yices": 7.146702553466187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0453898493622624, + "CVC4": 7.3351117290009826, + "CVC3": 6.5872410422373902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5662280083420832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5889130119138768 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1976547942672999, + "veriT": 5.1596747441799016, + "Yices": 3.5814440848560225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2561524120238006, + "CVC4": 0.19357908699410001, + "CVC3": 2.2335333644898898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5935764894773445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5922817924751831 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.928050897838772, + "veriT": 4.7501303556280998, + "Yices": 3.2166150360696082, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4331694580088863, + "CVC4": 1.2867674294244238, + "CVC3": 1.234664839677498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9410431387293148, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9559722978626359 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1756970410872452, + "veriT": 10.751673371169963, + "Yices": 10.425356531955, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9728045160530687, + "CVC4": 6.809442647193392, + "CVC3": 5.0589873519939959, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.107513187305473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.031162378636278 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.360156344341272, + "veriT": 10.835099754889841, + "Yices": 11.394575187233499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.143295986639716, + "CVC4": 6.8516543544125694, + "CVC3": 9.2845611161985104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6083201635104007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.159885280175535 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7368449741756407, + "veriT": 8.7514323605613011, + "Yices": 11.546235359164577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.790346084752918, + "CVC4": 9.4888448996757351, + "CVC3": 5.9530242280701398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5209564128305093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9036919182909164 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0198817266735611, + "veriT": 10.13042054469854, + "Yices": 6.82497529068067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7957624693970589, + "CVC4": 0.97486378596933321, + "CVC3": 3.5984375024454476, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8134721132207836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8335573300849284 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.401467996158093, + "veriT": 11.595997054635081, + "Yices": 8.1762176770373056, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.014334226530517, + "CVC4": 12.862600706601857, + "CVC3": 12.374248265727617, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.440627115816792, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.257283110002534 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5938750189688253, + "veriT": 5.5886384880513607, + "Yices": 13.398135947411294, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.026351583772982, + "CVC4": 8.6893360307307717, + "CVC3": 10.903211663090065, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1763415751783555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1554898885665832 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2151646960752229, + "veriT": 11.968360657913028, + "Yices": 6.6336724304883514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4410586340188756, + "CVC4": 12.488248207285645, + "CVC3": 11.6655707229794, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5773328442523553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.986875031888307 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1849870874438881, + "veriT": 2.6543333218657494, + "Yices": 3.9700295728431247, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3861463988680702, + "CVC4": 7.2714305118612863, + "CVC3": 1.9751596553975554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1183736476778199, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7369363741760848 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 23.0, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2450548266222221, + "veriT": 14.207334873587998, + "Yices": 0.218943348747, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2450490804031109, + "CVC4": 0.16768283040355556, + "CVC3": 0.13921574817077775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.354146918177367, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.397778262090783 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16261480959033334, + "veriT": 12.663538036454401, + "Yices": 12.944957170239601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25377550198955556, + "CVC4": 3.472944408447145, + "CVC3": 11.11408134370927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6687352050735811, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5877576032293881 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0706595340226714, + "veriT": 4.5251071034206607, + "Yices": 6.3681595097114005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2391999248597241, + "CVC4": 3.1700947609652474, + "CVC3": 2.9994694302013576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3859399195217534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1843797173399055 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1069619655609131, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8320173810424167, + "veriT": 0.9755297916329333, + "Yices": 6.8388559594370664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8320153073278336, + "CVC4": 1.3552300801159862, + "CVC3": 0.15827268196208333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16512798047615837, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16100433327408334 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2627938319891667, + "veriT": 0.12944543649216667, + "Yices": 0.13836064695749997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2616829704348334, + "CVC4": 0.17134832481199999, + "CVC3": 0.14693406689472222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16136703208111111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16020206317494443 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1729815006256104, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14553645670841664, + "veriT": 11.577052483512199, + "Yices": 0.14956000821591667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16637580791891668, + "CVC4": 0.17156437510133335, + "CVC3": 0.55222294824466667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15213957559708333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1515811618025 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15714783538400004, + "veriT": 0.13557551792221428, + "Yices": 0.1528328005592143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1588298333075, + "CVC4": 0.17611194597085714, + "CVC3": 0.15606339635457142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17243496663278574, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17212148823342854 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15981644473884446, + "veriT": 7.2444502955186891, + "Yices": 5.4872281404351044, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2830628730575118, + "CVC4": 1.7237955105297138, + "CVC3": 2.0837223631304669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9435483106066249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9511902191358301 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8062074689494585, + "veriT": 5.9802087984765473, + "Yices": 5.3718721031267647, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5763987132979125, + "CVC4": 11.257649778707252, + "CVC3": 6.4248212488756211, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7962575821849152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7715445694282623 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8507002116675766, + "veriT": 1.2533522690601635, + "Yices": 1.8743497154358306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9175622384147877, + "CVC4": 8.896726410547755, + "CVC3": 0.25828271947038461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17298003535861539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17155600003707694 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1094164848327637, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.72467253665334275, + "veriT": 6.1905933934153277, + "Yices": 7.6028993029730172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2925687766292286, + "CVC4": 8.3667242222751472, + "CVC3": 1.6244162886808573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1850044095085774, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1810917691109979 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4749463844987343, + "veriT": 8.6964217390401721, + "Yices": 4.5568224603332492, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3416489292933367, + "CVC4": 9.0890277431125313, + "CVC3": 7.8928014408440976, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.382266204669035, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.192283736564461 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.55230186640712498, + "veriT": 9.436684035075805, + "Yices": 7.9986308995741249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2522254397839907, + "CVC4": 10.775353796149869, + "CVC3": 1.4972580757057501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252705402578155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.919820877838491 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1561437475586072, + "veriT": 3.1327519044042518, + "Yices": 1.5274240270216251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3032515750892602, + "CVC4": 2.7281938898898295, + "CVC3": 1.9061266094831546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9107712088204238, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5248226152286737 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7724366151368551, + "veriT": 13.833876336062417, + "Yices": 6.2966699013170304, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2987352535533088, + "CVC4": 0.48775156970199995, + "CVC3": 4.3942793311798924, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.939097102078893, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.93576666762546 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.755090076169358, + "veriT": 11.330567328121397, + "Yices": 10.952908662164454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.852538760399574, + "CVC4": 13.223545958637265, + "CVC3": 13.70451910822281, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.279248874520967, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.188926708333044 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9341790676116943, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6685609817504883, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4988639028008812, + "veriT": 10.390695925454152, + "Yices": 7.4476457520760739, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9337948410395667, + "CVC4": 9.8756786476455023, + "CVC3": 3.4406887258566954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2647450662667925, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2821532073187107 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3079515064402427, + "veriT": 12.990826363110349, + "Yices": 12.920311890657425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.864162729761693, + "CVC4": 7.3093531849615729, + "CVC3": 8.4218508184742955, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.035118875335963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.00907934781727 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.256797811467223, + "veriT": 10.199577519975287, + "Yices": 10.384416997303287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.984469166334526, + "CVC4": 14.28413269073978, + "CVC3": 14.261265548827598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.258226607913555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.864157479503302 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24286554719631, + "veriT": 13.224976783572165, + "Yices": 11.272446914875616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956036949812566, + "CVC4": 13.562869228732376, + "CVC3": 14.235952806355476, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254900588501568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.530365433189703 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.531088196098429, + "veriT": 11.848043172070138, + "Yices": 11.983354286264674, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.986456069119615, + "CVC4": 14.611137223248505, + "CVC3": 11.582598668134834, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.831361642985186, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3661915755575791 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.360991671347648, + "veriT": 14.224479398403815, + "Yices": 13.967591038910317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.090549073025091, + "CVC4": 14.465424997369869, + "CVC3": 6.8853129479717037, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233859315497991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.239741202923215 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7303762942128333, + "veriT": 11.72726266903493, + "Yices": 13.593558747105654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6469122273888779, + "CVC4": 12.041613444767393, + "CVC3": 12.85521904153606, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.902516074337326, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.844076705862596 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.515752432436075, + "veriT": 13.835201875057686, + "Yices": 13.562309726401631, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.990754229232564, + "CVC4": 14.547244174599808, + "CVC3": 14.254151229019417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.057072296213409, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.054298893957272 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6280316862436433, + "veriT": 11.010343550066333, + "Yices": 8.9488416496743302, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2328754409104583, + "CVC4": 14.37710562308007, + "CVC3": 10.982552490789178, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.40583989271407, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.105272767168952 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.232064256154889, + "veriT": 12.014612436493859, + "Yices": 11.589419070885548, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.770017898252521, + "CVC4": 14.44864377200647, + "CVC3": 12.902120979020269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.479410356408062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.228272251011852 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0237795184273244, + "veriT": 4.4186828753625296, + "Yices": 3.25814990195139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8041805226576011, + "CVC4": 2.6706126865147715, + "CVC3": 3.5259371919488895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15282121981604707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14855130833382943 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9016201281571403, + "veriT": 9.6744799661709902, + "Yices": 9.3731192034433821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8269421361254503, + "CVC4": 2.3835318825009999, + "CVC3": 2.1761745353382858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.225803761391177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3416946267137373 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4487769169969882, + "veriT": 14.26637704966638, + "Yices": 4.8565653177452477, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9899243216301459, + "CVC4": 2.4383500091067747, + "CVC3": 3.8650891760469723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.34786377766371429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.34358725099885717 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 173.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5688206097180002, + "veriT": 14.218364631848573, + "Yices": 9.0494513972597126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5423606713945546, + "CVC4": 9.3721291202307473, + "CVC3": 7.645076806090854, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7458738582706363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.741275303278599 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 251.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.797774779529117, + "veriT": 13.332739684221401, + "Yices": 14.243805520968655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.438198132485487, + "CVC4": 14.316149471446133, + "CVC3": 13.14097952732441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.656927646511784, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.693808357569647 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7509642561605565, + "veriT": 12.144624144939332, + "Yices": 13.268472268954941, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.333793179845497, + "CVC4": 13.773188527721338, + "CVC3": 14.167928963850706, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6793825298806819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4859167782498819 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 219.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.940147372797371, + "veriT": 10.845812605827634, + "Yices": 12.279730933416422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.132953729569406, + "CVC4": 14.761429609358894, + "CVC3": 11.279279276316396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.786660098127882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.67722976391463 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6732617177528404, + "veriT": 14.245438894685885, + "Yices": 14.061757512229242, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.187971014575345, + "CVC4": 12.944704329749671, + "CVC3": 12.86932971910068, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.502550329413562, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.504284670303457 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.265392284920617, + "veriT": 13.321921856154116, + "Yices": 13.862871217649074, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.983773298909068, + "CVC4": 14.699742506565643, + "CVC3": 13.494125995468533, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.775900211020577, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.335539832557517 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12388546310130001, + "veriT": 0.093726189208556659, + "Yices": 0.097076834102999998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12159848364536668, + "CVC4": 0.1217873565682667, + "CVC3": 0.10039221690567667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11990279362909999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11757924476195332 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0909083176459884, + "veriT": 0.79115229476719928, + "Yices": 0.65867101866977251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1404496235089587, + "CVC4": 1.0906096772790836, + "CVC3": 0.1034865663486069, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12153728691241379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11924106103478965 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.646585572187064, + "veriT": 6.7991463496380771, + "Yices": 6.9175073745199995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.119378858227343, + "CVC4": 0.14472558905022223, + "CVC3": 3.5223413765245257, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14354815620677777, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2793257546903245 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20880381896840741, + "veriT": 10.166199669528888, + "Yices": 10.349704510032666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26185573338644447, + "CVC4": 0.14898608807681482, + "CVC3": 0.6844901930215187, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14803173480355558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.451154606012294 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20416870771925, + "veriT": 10.168879682738, + "Yices": 10.342022530284749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.45903078220437499, + "CVC4": 0.15386095835225, + "CVC3": 0.30014713652174996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15059642132824999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0859890700407728 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5505056381225586, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2583334445953369, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8587360111884776, + "veriT": 3.9445020910320912, + "Yices": 6.2499938456709847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3648910196906314, + "CVC4": 1.8050705157009312, + "CVC3": 1.6201072642529999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1462810686760836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0747037495226142 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.681157883118129, + "veriT": 10.79267825755467, + "Yices": 9.7417071949349356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.228869118995803, + "CVC4": 6.2222164514891487, + "CVC3": 11.10076757905226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8528000757865124, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.788497675894931 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4271592833129016, + "veriT": 13.995013198118006, + "Yices": 12.241154908583681, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7606958819533727, + "CVC4": 13.981864089966312, + "CVC3": 8.6681735804389213, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.453803490221523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.453327381307666 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1714286804199219, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.503408531269542, + "veriT": 8.9160303595741244, + "Yices": 10.3432704720685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.136157060580473, + "CVC4": 0.17372656564649996, + "CVC3": 12.002317611385394, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6448402338095658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.328765242771601 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.676743865318707, + "veriT": 10.835046875709473, + "Yices": 10.558501990062501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.150718711383375, + "CVC4": 2.6430787810394407, + "CVC3": 9.6761537577676027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4909714466914386, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.743412022928974 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1709549664821974, + "veriT": 5.8095127363212962, + "Yices": 8.1306781618880049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7227579640557105, + "CVC4": 2.6318263717014507, + "CVC3": 6.9162640283053323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0307139273457095, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9850841890714461 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.230613929274529, + "veriT": 10.151724198629427, + "Yices": 10.299789396390143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.942665504044681, + "CVC4": 1.3535750741337143, + "CVC3": 12.343007229127858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.015562813663895, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.989526610875435 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.54565288338503, + "veriT": 13.538631933761343, + "Yices": 12.681483931792831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.142244813513164, + "CVC4": 6.6606590599842868, + "CVC3": 9.8238682795090444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.008935099525326, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.144805682995049 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247771479337965, + "veriT": 10.165329745410112, + "Yices": 10.350392704873109, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965551030941441, + "CVC4": 0.16009838414166666, + "CVC3": 15.469988534030112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16483615778088889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.437828541327049 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.550866977728262, + "veriT": 10.972821085778001, + "Yices": 12.937195611302968, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.028541589054166, + "CVC4": 0.22760409015366667, + "CVC3": 11.283809514094424, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2091534857556061, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0388306072015983 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6918348996017158, + "veriT": 6.4447410991876088, + "Yices": 9.4917241534682208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6119690549928265, + "CVC4": 1.1331320429889999, + "CVC3": 8.1973504873061334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.859275308428356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.747096578310761 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7336737751668654, + "veriT": 1.991364612443411, + "Yices": 1.8037928596693944, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0309887924867409, + "CVC4": 2.0219960272382407, + "CVC3": 1.776114099332029, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3038266750222212, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3181195330128572 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2952900632250124, + "veriT": 8.4694327195994497, + "Yices": 8.5526464983403994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7739309819824047, + "CVC4": 4.4352576386458384, + "CVC3": 9.0144656441943809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2716454337166132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0537939688220046 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1689408777494874, + "veriT": 11.405720888608517, + "Yices": 12.878606107348167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6619324114986593, + "CVC4": 8.2902159497101664, + "CVC3": 6.6752629608942895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1216317229681518, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1797278962616407 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.129006227678156, + "veriT": 12.675721255200131, + "Yices": 10.430527460300084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.589966527849219, + "CVC4": 9.5614232541661757, + "CVC3": 12.401501044483647, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.999644493577176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.146600718673383 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.190058741443111, + "veriT": 8.3570188350094217, + "Yices": 12.338005485015374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0831159958197496, + "CVC4": 8.5149112388406927, + "CVC3": 8.2484733541176016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0255163022565963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0571076757240014 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2472540656826197, + "veriT": 7.79750974840106, + "Yices": 10.827526145353392, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2111311833445999, + "CVC4": 8.6807583565246631, + "CVC3": 9.9074069594534784, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0564644911833727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0608981559484136 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13862891881663636, + "veriT": 14.210861883842922, + "Yices": 2.7717363228807277, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19151586575109089, + "CVC4": 2.8453192958001412, + "CVC3": 2.6874330934311628, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8022294497544902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8058279092360738 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7775772798317853, + "veriT": 14.211516858875745, + "Yices": 10.602520410087148, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.008335770035114, + "CVC4": 8.9890630090851129, + "CVC3": 9.2852804037416092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.222052968395838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.226151771637982 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7527780532836914, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236672892258014, + "veriT": 11.976847985872983, + "Yices": 10.970079933349256, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952843699897276, + "CVC4": 6.7162287439856287, + "CVC3": 13.169779900046741, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6696967261306526, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.610592051942234 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237033092324694, + "veriT": 10.153355363828915, + "Yices": 10.331886467081832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959806941961169, + "CVC4": 0.15895970854425001, + "CVC3": 13.491401363930052, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14483823289916667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.276064006108506 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.098102477641193, + "veriT": 11.905350520962545, + "Yices": 3.4112130442050925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1197975733514305, + "CVC4": 4.2831309022767527, + "CVC3": 4.159499184895969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1550192291854575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1568068227314985 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.225670564760513, + "veriT": 9.9421568732712764, + "Yices": 9.6121880747263333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.766798841896428, + "CVC4": 7.9978583141698731, + "CVC3": 10.283829254461269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.179421870909664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.057385525568449 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3665087196442807, + "veriT": 5.0125571748503637, + "Yices": 9.0760447633637149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3863803762590736, + "CVC4": 4.3077868994257713, + "CVC3": 4.4440959289588244, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.659424984192308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3657518833144637 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2489437896845388, + "veriT": 10.476262945774588, + "Yices": 11.831607336467274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9040395805300889, + "CVC4": 10.331464158741516, + "CVC3": 9.4657697620891827, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.230054049472855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.414933185453053 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.132962736377294, + "veriT": 10.820905302327471, + "Yices": 9.212297061318349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.027484991553747, + "CVC4": 11.869318658967519, + "CVC3": 11.795489955620591, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.263892919648871, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.7127211196254 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1081869602203369, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6789419330150999, + "veriT": 8.0998141032930366, + "Yices": 10.680408253976035, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9432054987285419, + "CVC4": 7.3917669220481317, + "CVC3": 8.0103163710651817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.581906925599439, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.503487808027021 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1756897488790177, + "veriT": 10.106048248195773, + "Yices": 10.110306611713714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5854982204154648, + "CVC4": 4.3810313671461403, + "CVC3": 2.1481219000823533, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3569002459861981, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3879923727795775 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6224729115403427, + "veriT": 1.568841087779957, + "Yices": 5.9393387330129288, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1626964584282571, + "CVC4": 7.6318177850582263, + "CVC3": 0.21857252552699999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.183039587161411, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7516033026628997 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14649489303158333, + "veriT": 1.9738895792576499, + "Yices": 1.7834536770879665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.66666903938818345, + "CVC4": 0.14065205976680001, + "CVC3": 0.13577618352116669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13679568807950002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13289173353354999 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.649134261566215, + "veriT": 7.7863449637188777, + "Yices": 8.7163199593595948, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.520520451821529, + "CVC4": 7.3260535766789552, + "CVC3": 6.4197278551910992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1062733462367849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8408299302129301 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4017853736877441, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13242458026444445, + "veriT": 9.8895605489808567, + "Yices": 9.8919793271833143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13422925045866668, + "CVC4": 6.4049536305834698, + "CVC3": 0.13636630111622222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19387120173266664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1980749432432222 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13605374750650001, + "veriT": 6.7839734028484999, + "Yices": 4.1383452171981112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14374368076883329, + "CVC4": 0.14409595552016666, + "CVC3": 0.15179404006233332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13327866221966667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13253903668483333 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.92013253925907701, + "veriT": 0.13870342845148462, + "Yices": 7.6930070049640022, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.91981345069769216, + "CVC4": 2.3407247436924754, + "CVC3": 1.7077094683693845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15844372300653844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15528824724007692 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6310968302604913, + "veriT": 8.028054963604708, + "Yices": 8.515595682337894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6749077129265606, + "CVC4": 6.644354191606987, + "CVC3": 8.2170208866790855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1807883809682718, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4214527441770031 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9554364681243896, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4125741975358752, + "veriT": 3.1540604043960556, + "Yices": 6.2008018380742724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4363237733960001, + "CVC4": 5.4711678257692435, + "CVC3": 1.649487802628625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2751328277985503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.727993844078676 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.951278487404657, + "veriT": 10.569438030924571, + "Yices": 10.585162804804101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.290764473740323, + "CVC4": 12.500506449823526, + "CVC3": 9.5969970522688648, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.224789450076258, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.904092379853431 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18028185698509089, + "veriT": 7.9981408076808087, + "Yices": 9.3205787220240364, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3602015315486364, + "CVC4": 7.0289862915818135, + "CVC3": 10.304399994432393, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1398962519441742, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4906690402237555 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.02886962890625, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12518311037144444, + "veriT": 0.10374083154641112, + "Yices": 0.10629096737524445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12357586203348887, + "CVC4": 7.9747482956527715, + "CVC3": 0.11767010091771112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13069163393688887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1291533204293111 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21705335642653331, + "veriT": 2.9537885285464802, + "Yices": 6.4458985501661115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8784122845438502, + "CVC4": 1.187475507156516, + "CVC3": 0.23405462078566666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.120855859217347, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1180038051669345 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12784403658177779, + "veriT": 9.7093144464913799, + "Yices": 7.5814253090459438, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13402129369681109, + "CVC4": 4.8584621195711284, + "CVC3": 1.6957002122689682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6682171599961864, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6739904356086222 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5559213537018692, + "veriT": 10.1896672669835, + "Yices": 10.658061355856825, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9217431583202105, + "CVC4": 14.276465663665677, + "CVC3": 4.0624974119242703, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.152325643333091, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.817721355769722 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.527490306899383, + "veriT": 7.9808984408655688, + "Yices": 6.8410081056252832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.126024489610305, + "CVC4": 6.0644230937550487, + "CVC3": 1.3113978585034998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0021940038762618, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3833051829784164 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7198549714079148, + "veriT": 14.236828374117412, + "Yices": 13.049065422525539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0855403059311426, + "CVC4": 14.570811546655607, + "CVC3": 12.219289637665327, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24837611534964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.253540795178964 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.654949289932674, + "veriT": 14.213684853689713, + "Yices": 5.2997734742655149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7091965637744302, + "CVC4": 3.3547382937219252, + "CVC3": 6.071638601975943, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.424131754768553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.417678130295515 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 74.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19572891952014287, + "veriT": 8.0388662609413952, + "Yices": 8.1955093229481939, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.30705970734678573, + "CVC4": 8.3759105827836819, + "CVC3": 8.2527748261287055, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8077333869569054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.595615017743639 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2439158474027652, + "veriT": 10.473090251055767, + "Yices": 3.8342219657005785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9318664943524819, + "CVC4": 7.7583770516959598, + "CVC3": 2.9305441495594002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18348384887553332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17883559323206663 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5651184421524289, + "veriT": 10.478319517779472, + "Yices": 5.6156523497826196, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4331772363537905, + "CVC4": 4.4095173577744537, + "CVC3": 10.904596517220611, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.184523947908755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.554545991292441 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0233330726623535, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16313915830533335, + "veriT": 0.14304892591933335, + "Yices": 0.15463612568083332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16556210354983333, + "CVC4": 0.19116470944916666, + "CVC3": 0.16717179717066669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17833504677199999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17778805838033332 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14862163887738464, + "veriT": 4.1438834657883286, + "Yices": 0.91027004528092315, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16402924398823074, + "CVC4": 1.2494485312188255, + "CVC3": 1.6051474692040562, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0229677697935828, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.030094925608495 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4855578440151112, + "veriT": 0.13230978862666667, + "Yices": 0.14144996015177777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4875426609479998, + "CVC4": 0.16600005097922221, + "CVC3": 0.14652533617155555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16019458366566666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16358530759588891 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8081231839472744, + "veriT": 11.375622313167119, + "Yices": 6.1763508902821647, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4747135015093118, + "CVC4": 7.297966968205948, + "CVC3": 3.8855606946267205, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7475064647863969, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.720600258566479 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0175375938415527, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 32.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1960951248765124, + "veriT": 14.21571096609232, + "Yices": 12.302626067185573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8057071626096324, + "CVC4": 12.839100102333784, + "CVC3": 5.0552860097353953, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.547291820288077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.495208985344572 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.261001863150396, + "veriT": 10.187215288612501, + "Yices": 10.3737112547105, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98961956182667, + "CVC4": 14.282313414849419, + "CVC3": 14.259699174481398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256872129840373, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.896030160394799 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.49022330602941, + "veriT": 10.769540559963415, + "Yices": 11.544817819941134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957362732069637, + "CVC4": 13.334313319681883, + "CVC3": 6.599430013910224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.256060525622571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.619704712847826 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.654964146327627, + "veriT": 13.691870925386054, + "Yices": 14.028004758579581, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.256423534812898, + "CVC4": 14.28116484186361, + "CVC3": 13.917748916540592, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.245363661390234, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.248966980366092 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3191588887874293, + "veriT": 9.5434485733660583, + "Yices": 7.4302962764972991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6066917363380648, + "CVC4": 8.6141724698481266, + "CVC3": 5.7137174247032441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8743786658281829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8713871705458986 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 94.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2257327310211643, + "veriT": 13.322813464508927, + "Yices": 10.197322438425212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.085954580250712, + "CVC4": 5.6624613368306242, + "CVC3": 7.8626137578472584, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1962716297310125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2486839326206685 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.7532984090871, + "veriT": 11.007939878469235, + "Yices": 8.6386376110405365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4989355870634222, + "CVC4": 8.7891692686309906, + "CVC3": 3.211460125691294, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20537404461049999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1989884589199 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17925702233412499, + "veriT": 0.16242320130837501, + "Yices": 1.021391505977, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.120868422921625, + "CVC4": 0.14952609748662499, + "CVC3": 0.13925111872075002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13619388227387499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.132220463662375 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.056232991865043, + "veriT": 11.449455524581209, + "Yices": 10.571615699820759, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.621019388669342, + "CVC4": 9.650542185782264, + "CVC3": 9.6721334540350767, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.126101636943504, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7954943409432946 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3270776570575258, + "veriT": 13.661615534635322, + "Yices": 13.464373544191769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.465762466599289, + "CVC4": 14.360974769789172, + "CVC3": 14.211202248897505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6313371648528361, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5757330649002625 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.729292567168404, + "veriT": 12.747534585702706, + "Yices": 11.992532286484677, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.969615388632558, + "CVC4": 12.593514803380101, + "CVC3": 12.357419160119713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.830776274742371, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.976922468979575 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.256493786008974, + "veriT": 10.225952938768799, + "Yices": 11.334113668837301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97684743991752, + "CVC4": 14.440930702553601, + "CVC3": 14.252772356795948, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.269807283904949, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.11837560435697 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.229834685636176, + "veriT": 13.211589872048375, + "Yices": 13.901971861379563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.250862464696853, + "CVC4": 14.550322811888471, + "CVC3": 8.5144025114181385, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.452974337443644, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9325851420377873 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0801748859228617, + "veriT": 12.773763759157136, + "Yices": 13.882759720577349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1318553526405966, + "CVC4": 13.172588058644157, + "CVC3": 13.219260020208042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.991842200910362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.928241727884165 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7265738955893184, + "veriT": 12.08644219486767, + "Yices": 13.318457908053698, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980099045922334, + "CVC4": 14.424628095961562, + "CVC3": 13.084665712819165, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.259670570260143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.57568235247796 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.616603009916153, + "veriT": 14.24764716280983, + "Yices": 14.249157568938093, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.554015832428609, + "CVC4": 14.413084689401979, + "CVC3": 8.588081362211156, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4444507903767514, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.110526305688694 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.266077074074232, + "veriT": 13.250492758433786, + "Yices": 13.502357625877305, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980360067159053, + "CVC4": 14.706673594426466, + "CVC3": 13.82457365694888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.315081987530323, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.308586017791937 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10479300993999499, + "veriT": 0.076280171428014992, + "Yices": 0.080792375836570007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10387761655594499, + "CVC4": 0.10169325587788502, + "CVC3": 0.081950279852915003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.099801398968130006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.098267548266970012 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1265275948357778, + "veriT": 0.096815236530737037, + "Yices": 0.099192866868455562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12258240046318519, + "CVC4": 0.12517726975874074, + "CVC3": 0.10232507321695924, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11994293597296296, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11873432128801482 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8280298407368392, + "veriT": 2.367921166572053, + "Yices": 1.9246451225979111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9832967423422119, + "CVC4": 3.2813957237911695, + "CVC3": 0.13728795249831111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1603970723423333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15739665244111112 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1676675312349, + "veriT": 2.9312890763096524, + "Yices": 3.9654875983802804, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15788299725799998, + "CVC4": 3.115791932753091, + "CVC3": 2.9464462945336396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9582017809265464, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9795658030713925 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.69279764562845647, + "veriT": 10.163746250817001, + "Yices": 10.353213818756865, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.76900642287343923, + "CVC4": 0.14922208766162068, + "CVC3": 0.69448480230186227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14883704430548275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.425430633298964 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19465446203749998, + "veriT": 9.1608391914523004, + "Yices": 10.464325744415801, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.33556788777869995, + "CVC4": 0.1517292552916, + "CVC3": 0.29661710309650002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15067333325810001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5718186103461003 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 67.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7551364898681641, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.114325830017883, + "veriT": 11.465868907796457, + "Yices": 11.081942033738002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.119218132126958, + "CVC4": 8.2434473722232369, + "CVC3": 9.8630996778104887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8263648679844211, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.872929716774633 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.122452937420055, + "veriT": 9.685285248815541, + "Yices": 10.336711135616071, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.330370183069787, + "CVC4": 1.3029815209249471, + "CVC3": 9.0047318968208874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8548793717256937, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6062216787770467 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24148139056207, + "veriT": 10.490865058020823, + "Yices": 10.451639675947231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958350382396285, + "CVC4": 1.2904129846921408, + "CVC3": 12.504682578621678, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9916127478035595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.538943317681067 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238614707572411, + "veriT": 10.154372925379455, + "Yices": 10.341499329524638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965703710885293, + "CVC4": 0.1586794769001818, + "CVC3": 13.997195569184761, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14568012435563638, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.337559762937454 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6109071234690164, + "veriT": 7.1408355558158805, + "Yices": 13.062301185464813, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7268606370506312, + "CVC4": 3.0503549177372014, + "CVC3": 8.2368422288805778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.277246711635142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8099953120556123 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.953421253771566, + "veriT": 9.466534171512647, + "Yices": 9.2831176880039745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.163437092672616, + "CVC4": 8.4323721995658385, + "CVC3": 12.665386377845246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.667660995243258, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.840574908502942 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6226603687528014, + "veriT": 8.7499733482824507, + "Yices": 7.7019980651150624, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9032258492001013, + "CVC4": 1.0593065917332571, + "CVC3": 4.7690842102527231, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5387321529717592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8234865955144572 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.718126415268854, + "veriT": 11.817895303340224, + "Yices": 11.894895991920983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.243337702366214, + "CVC4": 9.6610747108324251, + "CVC3": 12.533283277849023, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.079874677630471, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.802332731075087 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6480113151446254, + "veriT": 12.449748903342853, + "Yices": 3.9610435772665129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6494496518271249, + "CVC4": 3.738851105594494, + "CVC3": 3.0026491944811364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.470520651121632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.470754202229219 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8908189739370771, + "veriT": 13.28991106710429, + "Yices": 13.575684973795992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8831986008364332, + "CVC4": 14.286482645098213, + "CVC3": 13.167589295112416, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.934980503146466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.725392375230324 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.338796296583826, + "veriT": 10.588777847537868, + "Yices": 9.3718685502841748, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.581389185791775, + "CVC4": 7.9595799220291017, + "CVC3": 12.66328654102009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24953722161213, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.877398649651115 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.481052193309575, + "veriT": 10.571432744572705, + "Yices": 10.205111078968363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.067535916211581, + "CVC4": 7.0999003775218137, + "CVC3": 12.82929076830257, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0168309696172972, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.295259685349917 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.85142988870378, + "veriT": 9.1620207690465012, + "Yices": 10.342059084079697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.50264394413421, + "CVC4": 0.17498175282529999, + "CVC3": 12.434645077853151, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6172686492728623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.33371997110631 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.480115937276882, + "veriT": 10.165334829664285, + "Yices": 10.310186043578572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.945029885970753, + "CVC4": 0.5643775314034285, + "CVC3": 12.346415136991753, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.037094121650492, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.553653332888173 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8785125186179634, + "veriT": 12.989417496609729, + "Yices": 11.554630308012531, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6098708617169475, + "CVC4": 10.384578985235539, + "CVC3": 8.8551782763171669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.288398612184954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.333665010389115 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4727275371551514, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0828634087126803, + "veriT": 2.7341664777464305, + "Yices": 1.676756877729169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9471111238107954, + "CVC4": 1.2192937796215804, + "CVC3": 1.360683918613623, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1307585857914077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8562273822493656 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8452379703521729, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3830117261819623, + "veriT": 8.1997167920953018, + "Yices": 10.132471839005857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5092733319237857, + "CVC4": 8.9867531995037631, + "CVC3": 2.2809675068702289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4483989505890271, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.496642210383742 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.949475323423151, + "veriT": 14.219459202832468, + "Yices": 12.371818312196478, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.303974478524673, + "CVC4": 12.278424974821204, + "CVC3": 10.576277618541047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.878278201792135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.874211376778055 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.383975648862801, + "veriT": 11.169190691173663, + "Yices": 9.4437954364575081, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.820891811703406, + "CVC4": 1.3321940115976938, + "CVC3": 14.541815331833808, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1983790405091455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.052977236532884 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6534941709459998, + "veriT": 1.4881726511967037, + "Yices": 1.8927800882346457, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9028021222411251, + "CVC4": 0.16548344670712498, + "CVC3": 6.7021954335080123, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6524331344406251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6516223306482498 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.318584604370661, + "veriT": 9.889061361156001, + "Yices": 10.10735560128604, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.83832925022533, + "CVC4": 0.64044351578199987, + "CVC3": 7.4487981039456423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15591988691642858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5530141612369208 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4171863218095861, + "veriT": 4.1931067854528585, + "Yices": 10.948591784307807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6947208124890931, + "CVC4": 7.8242837430000582, + "CVC3": 4.4183659173645999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.048919696270592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7846751321593928 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.36654722923085, + "veriT": 12.726888857439105, + "Yices": 12.182501324611451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3801598239077082, + "CVC4": 13.39497546266306, + "CVC3": 10.908221716353646, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.337045486524033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.373065361649401 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4754477259138459, + "veriT": 5.9310842331736149, + "Yices": 10.975108729031199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5334546634263075, + "CVC4": 8.9484335980349421, + "CVC3": 9.8008342189657505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3641784507893737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3589369395793565 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6837295090897517, + "veriT": 13.756384388767101, + "Yices": 1.2443351802175222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7623250533246366, + "CVC4": 0.17388361581100001, + "CVC3": 3.2628274620803603, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2959122264821108, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8885852599245165 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13789751763827274, + "veriT": 14.20629748974592, + "Yices": 0.11499851521818183, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22853261840345454, + "CVC4": 1.4994387541689849, + "CVC3": 0.13831118359763636, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.279150995604361, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.356507097298616 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3870032771150056, + "veriT": 14.216985109802586, + "Yices": 9.8770451568495758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9812198456112036, + "CVC4": 7.672879094233398, + "CVC3": 9.5417253024261388, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.72397535287589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.719146063860292 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.059028148651123, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20281447489874999, + "veriT": 6.3985830689091259, + "Yices": 10.214995047966999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.66652771345850004, + "CVC4": 7.2208888081984899, + "CVC3": 3.7000579275341736, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.179313727453351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.767033246679601 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2212816148111258, + "veriT": 10.566410045914949, + "Yices": 10.200307613288549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2515287976627576, + "CVC4": 9.8247766997585178, + "CVC3": 6.3451429842654505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.223500669323117, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.221536166373523 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.205606751089221, + "veriT": 7.0389601032796616, + "Yices": 12.839959247020833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3320388644257375, + "CVC4": 8.4423487876676866, + "CVC3": 4.0474638950547144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.286116006249348, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8370087135125257 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.131140674427875, + "veriT": 9.3590698228993574, + "Yices": 9.8724522659504537, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.155016898829375, + "CVC4": 3.7932463953232549, + "CVC3": 1.8877211081204679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12711244375462502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12953655199612499 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14294094630444443, + "veriT": 3.4889281231288445, + "Yices": 4.9622668664692053, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16859926022399999, + "CVC4": 1.7185582267857411, + "CVC3": 1.2738024623972222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14011086453177779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14044425875111111 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.987383172994349, + "veriT": 8.5083829171655037, + "Yices": 7.4184113344916174, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5543657596904401, + "CVC4": 10.624265491429675, + "CVC3": 8.4494485185592012, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2616397694849635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7681694801770487 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4225348765573336, + "veriT": 3.801053825614833, + "Yices": 6.7722355970129167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2893388485715174, + "CVC4": 2.0811863617128332, + "CVC3": 0.15663598869916665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8019521497144284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.831187218845713 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.39101722671243, + "veriT": 8.7503103674316502, + "Yices": 10.033558686631421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.255868009190502, + "CVC4": 10.832468512601059, + "CVC3": 10.735694825671741, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1472413003530235, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.071065940201136 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 61.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9470454681388745, + "veriT": 5.1867980666000291, + "Yices": 5.6701450604688066, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.97958290128325, + "CVC4": 5.6942453388077316, + "CVC3": 6.2212583741071823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4727288680285495, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4698063199651576 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.02886962890625, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9028561115264893, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13868907465355554, + "veriT": 0.11457746211543333, + "Yices": 2.8068644887336873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13835167512455557, + "CVC4": 1.7052187539515855, + "CVC3": 0.12063414681822222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.28965690945988887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3715326256154039 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9646604061126709, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5977713175837143, + "veriT": 0.14587310569985718, + "Yices": 0.15119716345428572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5993639271314286, + "CVC4": 0.20135199977114285, + "CVC3": 0.17138929809300002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17734057138557144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17792644382514286 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15864289565, + "veriT": 0.1353105625438889, + "Yices": 0.14462329363177778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15343421068044444, + "CVC4": 0.17293808349799999, + "CVC3": 0.15092194140999998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16615322047744444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16356104934500001 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13588923641453332, + "veriT": 6.7727275154608426, + "Yices": 1.4530701176345333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1356720810866, + "CVC4": 0.14422328796313336, + "CVC3": 0.12470745881606667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14121476925199999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13747860594519998 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1644144058227539, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21862033906342854, + "veriT": 6.4925326003614794, + "Yices": 9.0455744349529201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9285735088975715, + "CVC4": 0.22791098406071428, + "CVC3": 5.6800993420378765, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2206134246202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21886417996224286 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16858702978314286, + "veriT": 2.1600668900750088, + "Yices": 0.31439562261385712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.196859486867, + "CVC4": 0.20408441282385717, + "CVC3": 0.51901403924242862, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17993225188100001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18139590022871427 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6734035689454858, + "veriT": 4.9494409358902685, + "Yices": 6.2121509252720397, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7673830753418809, + "CVC4": 3.7130880601163936, + "CVC3": 5.2454735617599733, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8167657184176473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5145088072558899 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0111110210418701, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7652988474050302, + "veriT": 1.659085276138754, + "Yices": 2.006856623551676, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0704690261785679, + "CVC4": 12.157863849141268, + "CVC3": 0.97784634071490761, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2976052253477737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0597808497204655 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8027249932593667, + "veriT": 5.1514905394329, + "Yices": 9.3044972626422062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2852075748546623, + "CVC4": 4.9710839295149265, + "CVC3": 5.2983025320673338, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.30657906404399998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.32363620065100002 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12991514204849999, + "veriT": 8.6233563901237709, + "Yices": 5.1421222017903752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15951711560953752, + "CVC4": 0.13116193473892501, + "CVC3": 0.12635259645975, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6603040359755061, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6903468168079869 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5703210097311426, + "veriT": 2.9667214910026138, + "Yices": 2.9715562437166141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.573301770557157, + "CVC4": 11.667343466172253, + "CVC3": 1.8841799225195142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19521664701857142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17200313947657145 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 93.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5386158864533623, + "veriT": 12.685345315335184, + "Yices": 11.469493782486458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.934504492304381, + "CVC4": 12.599100870757187, + "CVC3": 9.8172037782398629, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.197305623959107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.529827677107987 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3410672893234619, + "veriT": 14.256488447241093, + "Yices": 8.6264593640941083, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7397833626548902, + "CVC4": 4.5257544802536929, + "CVC3": 3.4109835218481002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.731670036014, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6493920393859991 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 56.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2150309293983002, + "veriT": 11.883683911902899, + "Yices": 10.475058948298749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2150685755418333, + "CVC4": 5.3787722779539742, + "CVC3": 11.894894128529858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.906781586183287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.903282871136668 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0931989210074287, + "veriT": 12.599672365639906, + "Yices": 7.5335626116769481, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4426198275445716, + "CVC4": 10.527365689877708, + "CVC3": 8.2699506530321489, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2816207064782854, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7187149358448572 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4799969158502302, + "veriT": 13.05345967598377, + "Yices": 11.204255507105582, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7609642242925982, + "CVC4": 11.0794882085476, + "CVC3": 9.8047824296445327, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230965040984566, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.228192587840882 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9341790676116943, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6696009635925293, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5222785130630099, + "veriT": 8.7755494354301362, + "Yices": 5.5361870124537793, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0583347960333951, + "CVC4": 6.5284323657295218, + "CVC3": 4.7597850163498379, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.974111127589607, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.992169633676351 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.435139746141683, + "veriT": 13.489737575219451, + "Yices": 12.186233037923904, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.249844922725801, + "CVC4": 13.02509152502317, + "CVC3": 11.146257508922435, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.208699576669712, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.184352124361046 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7110949754714966, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.266197416256558, + "veriT": 12.420098741540096, + "Yices": 11.75847055461441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.579834586104203, + "CVC4": 9.6492476676330678, + "CVC3": 14.265584969562566, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.713441907022691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.040960945535021 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.264260364052882, + "veriT": 10.95054036031962, + "Yices": 10.789447533569888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.984777187663626, + "CVC4": 14.297402878280309, + "CVC3": 14.262588843900181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.263907312669044, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.213808817160913 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 242.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.244680865896077, + "veriT": 13.933899081896751, + "Yices": 13.575580334018534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.61190405602939, + "CVC4": 14.518829820773261, + "CVC3": 12.511852952614722, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235906228806698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237123738212324 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.255962848554461, + "veriT": 13.848586231771217, + "Yices": 13.657051886755577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.144093395966905, + "CVC4": 14.633598772921658, + "CVC3": 14.050081971034311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.436946654631701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.191688671436708 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2383109868209123, + "veriT": 11.553630404868484, + "Yices": 10.505163876762504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9822121839095397, + "CVC4": 14.439062929275055, + "CVC3": 8.5107571474347008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.874782849742452, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.872597497455395 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.255701892917264, + "veriT": 11.012055660476076, + "Yices": 10.431649535397037, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980652043866105, + "CVC4": 14.346526258962985, + "CVC3": 13.014566409859707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.424011805518996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.546344607166466 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19830965148405003, + "veriT": 5.3307750537886189, + "Yices": 2.7838974502271765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.76284532028599994, + "CVC4": 2.5164974940158209, + "CVC3": 5.946343717033554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16375185433289999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16362694510534165 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 46.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.554528281496646, + "veriT": 11.882084707442218, + "Yices": 12.426739760729141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.45879663961545, + "CVC4": 11.116094675791318, + "CVC3": 6.6663365944929751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.44021088189292, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.229577919388664 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9085322783984686, + "veriT": 11.954254550262853, + "Yices": 2.7467325799870017, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8541301392072045, + "CVC4": 2.3729123260168685, + "CVC3": 2.7209185971389842, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.77281964411575022, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.78838350190683337 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 58.0, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4173887024732785, + "veriT": 10.757831460234019, + "Yices": 9.7266583320792552, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7584972854868024, + "CVC4": 10.099815341945487, + "CVC3": 14.236792503198011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1653833386519308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.869573352222923 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.018500073898373, + "veriT": 13.796851934052413, + "Yices": 13.690044270605458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.803213430248885, + "CVC4": 14.395719830370151, + "CVC3": 14.225852661563149, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0440379161501596, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.73948955005336 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 134.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6829481587753392, + "veriT": 13.56101604789948, + "Yices": 13.816053410537842, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.228035974243044, + "CVC4": 14.414057029739405, + "CVC3": 11.152389567912884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.042564238677684, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.899568863843326 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244577348629207, + "veriT": 10.756056458077181, + "Yices": 12.405324550124419, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96202980587943, + "CVC4": 14.718683047905451, + "CVC3": 13.907021369746827, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231638835464382, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.246587332100509 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.147904014861421, + "veriT": 14.252644645853112, + "Yices": 14.058298342908413, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.602230837128049, + "CVC4": 13.551725311236906, + "CVC3": 10.941402100672361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6194739481944058, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3768231353439457 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.121763943773, + "veriT": 0.99414725464390929, + "Yices": 0.99575096107898176, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13788191498206362, + "CVC4": 1.3917197831798234, + "CVC3": 0.089787005310981813, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3891380311559656, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3876464008011025 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11831416192166666, + "veriT": 0.088529820056058348, + "Yices": 0.092131376162808351, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11559846653387501, + "CVC4": 0.11754873808591666, + "CVC3": 0.094587490137995833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11549479019212501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11372086316204166 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3141739655964231, + "veriT": 1.0053982674875455, + "Yices": 1.0267727327579002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3702695391754727, + "CVC4": 0.13099517607736363, + "CVC3": 1.3875938539498014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12670274134618181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4054053586282491 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1225397891113886, + "veriT": 9.9476533050410882, + "Yices": 10.379615158873783, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2282611335913387, + "CVC4": 0.14941826295123911, + "CVC3": 0.64255598300804351, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14851165923597828, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.48438569446612 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1547620296478271, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7571430206298828, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1835151060237656, + "veriT": 8.1800897680153337, + "Yices": 8.2434023143239745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4225664099562287, + "CVC4": 5.0977725537058838, + "CVC3": 4.1968786241560005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1222753914319741, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.809176084758711 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.619047999382019, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.06382698485673, + "veriT": 10.154335628761084, + "Yices": 10.295817730838332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.941057426275615, + "CVC4": 0.98259608581458313, + "CVC3": 13.12915327559263, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8767514202812556, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.615390853156661 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.104200768521585, + "veriT": 10.1587905968127, + "Yices": 10.323025436659, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950421551409963, + "CVC4": 0.1707179796394, + "CVC3": 10.414629945844322, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1424570112471, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.131515434008763 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9740042189994256, + "veriT": 10.535867584234278, + "Yices": 7.6986078822887354, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1168041421433959, + "CVC4": 1.652932453933138, + "CVC3": 4.9794014550464194, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7139418697228512, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8379794228748176 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.171624117453764, + "veriT": 9.3933230981471549, + "Yices": 10.330199922668614, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.832409673323127, + "CVC4": 0.17269075211461538, + "CVC3": 12.519760131406798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.075280778462302, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.279392179393538 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.87931328641648, + "veriT": 11.522253292317618, + "Yices": 10.29995969549274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.347550584571003, + "CVC4": 1.8046242002957287, + "CVC3": 10.673769074523381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.954471759490804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.554273506895923 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.83878281951552, + "veriT": 13.809851114652526, + "Yices": 12.600820102991722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.227994234656254, + "CVC4": 13.217063283193038, + "CVC3": 10.61532237111717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.819489695191113, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.507976416825851 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.886679558963095, + "veriT": 10.834797385708335, + "Yices": 8.6285059452571176, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.485090021015701, + "CVC4": 0.15567701550149998, + "CVC3": 9.9528533834474189, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8671899474005569, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4749139774930047 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236586648338752, + "veriT": 10.161785666941428, + "Yices": 10.33139479270557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955401482920413, + "CVC4": 0.20235594742785715, + "CVC3": 14.149694748977733, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1960951004883347, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.247845793006883 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6455996706296201, + "veriT": 14.239548864849324, + "Yices": 8.096567798174366, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.699597436758571, + "CVC4": 14.269120725695254, + "CVC3": 11.254460076311279, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9825107370299353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9802654091705385 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.893686574619817, + "veriT": 13.008602021698207, + "Yices": 13.979127417061944, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.516706325840694, + "CVC4": 8.246327887639568, + "CVC3": 14.690279401833209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.975363220950017, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.966649845749998 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4862690704031896, + "veriT": 4.8269613720969078, + "Yices": 8.02913014339107, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6096252982774693, + "CVC4": 2.6822092985828276, + "CVC3": 2.4963122245234826, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9440541854749753, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9952739412085894 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.020195876332123, + "veriT": 10.490041744414292, + "Yices": 10.393468208834385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.583270693045751, + "CVC4": 2.1232189998470661, + "CVC3": 7.6382747787971104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6129998781860131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.708309064688207 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5750000476837158, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.899854395624615, + "veriT": 1.3678853836392753, + "Yices": 1.3933768567910123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9831157068211094, + "CVC4": 0.14526074859287502, + "CVC3": 0.25745539472662499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14089190993287501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5436272842701158 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8174354090173335, + "veriT": 4.1984719102263783, + "Yices": 9.8482873619380484, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8155036125505, + "CVC4": 5.0930036081205339, + "CVC3": 4.2055585661953492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2622399386108523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2398415959435622 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1770547251236998, + "veriT": 11.881954498908787, + "Yices": 8.6493528166363856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.439028648731917, + "CVC4": 6.5912555368349093, + "CVC3": 10.089812723765139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1120191634709879, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.278485433226571 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8601624449901211, + "veriT": 7.1705115480499613, + "Yices": 2.9095032462082364, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6041849357057334, + "CVC4": 1.7638357414735353, + "CVC3": 1.5176386731690259, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5275765924719211, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.525317298334981 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.84552219474735713, + "veriT": 14.209171761149742, + "Yices": 1.1196401942257241, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.87307673561857158, + "CVC4": 0.86712575571592854, + "CVC3": 0.84678080775600006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.636217964526081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.678770093947307 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6930907332538947, + "veriT": 9.5993453907649346, + "Yices": 8.9134591809166928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.704148282526782, + "CVC4": 10.55242350482518, + "CVC3": 8.2982561325894952, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8341327622979442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3427572412207969 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7527780532836914, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.58571457862854, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.251926543489628, + "veriT": 10.192625539505876, + "Yices": 10.368954908103625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975443774641281, + "CVC4": 0.18208575743062502, + "CVC3": 12.816928778105723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16994806019287501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.473411281175451 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.791545569563906, + "veriT": 10.755068934281118, + "Yices": 10.582454852103966, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.28195063237869, + "CVC4": 2.2049453506812351, + "CVC3": 13.265971540587511, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7702784062966468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.775920028438255 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.338797308159254, + "veriT": 14.210959195947767, + "Yices": 1.7986498917677143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.230985262343664, + "CVC4": 2.2063872838793022, + "CVC3": 2.153969777005718, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1850391014637403, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1868051663987469 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.487344285951565, + "veriT": 12.175790678326507, + "Yices": 11.216018631054711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.931674709134755, + "CVC4": 12.275976780951767, + "CVC3": 14.00732429070036, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.879344830755448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.798152767448913 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8379774934309991, + "veriT": 3.7219828453454302, + "Yices": 3.8133218436692111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.991365149645421, + "CVC4": 0.99600028783563377, + "CVC3": 0.72646476952536843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.077311802302802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.387656218785132 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.044104874935007, + "veriT": 10.147885327961625, + "Yices": 11.290810370736214, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.759483111836563, + "CVC4": 10.789973076346648, + "CVC3": 11.751796415961012, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238543711979432, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.715437517700504 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.492303373282622, + "veriT": 11.897550141891008, + "Yices": 13.431290595359741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.727967964524604, + "CVC4": 10.090713394231011, + "CVC3": 12.891181799440893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.058695955134725, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.328532349582805 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3125, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1079545021057129, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9562196741333322, + "veriT": 4.8462327751787306, + "Yices": 1.3156688614744374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8028602689597646, + "CVC4": 4.3026872153421927, + "CVC3": 3.6166288813855494, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.9744682987051515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.9747805911527494 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15676156185581253, + "veriT": 2.9047244314755001, + "Yices": 1.3667561170303375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.50540249986138752, + "CVC4": 1.9139353277893909, + "CVC3": 1.9003861539244993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8982535080347951, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8957489447517955 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13355887421872498, + "veriT": 6.3547982153575493, + "Yices": 9.8806603368970336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13100485315791249, + "CVC4": 1.3923046380370376, + "CVC3": 1.455896048226125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8709968022413104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.854922295898197 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5212211507550548, + "veriT": 7.0507184019608449, + "Yices": 6.9839423332561923, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6836451064908458, + "CVC4": 7.470002644456196, + "CVC3": 7.2074589760641459, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9416246213629993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9322584824487556 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.03125, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1717879987916778, + "veriT": 9.0096565294608446, + "Yices": 10.176764048555334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22709786304988888, + "CVC4": 3.2801196639735064, + "CVC3": 0.17819032015058889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.201041661356026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9052906962610869 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2474095302724031, + "veriT": 10.151730558253572, + "Yices": 10.220691420777285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7977513553245119, + "CVC4": 10.677785715503841, + "CVC3": 9.3448769941612735, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24137721975921, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.964170093510493 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3212696273375484, + "veriT": 0.97358973211158339, + "Yices": 6.2023825753624768, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.38538280440916667, + "CVC4": 0.16651043979191665, + "CVC3": 1.04168252368175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3239601216853967, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2502910697529575 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6788746002537298, + "veriT": 7.6206623565322502, + "Yices": 7.6253488674358749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8661918170761211, + "CVC4": 8.9667062073365287, + "CVC3": 3.6685527329616465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7803998917936306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7896032367719132 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.472893680183458, + "veriT": 7.4496444007276308, + "Yices": 6.7659620969797993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6139287876614286, + "CVC4": 10.75290661340185, + "CVC3": 4.419259279838383, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8323125135628704, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8360826563683563 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5400378613808297, + "veriT": 10.814564070148942, + "Yices": 10.806415198727711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8753438698295994, + "CVC4": 11.464901628754072, + "CVC3": 8.2595650345480376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.648008085909346, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.648165966245637 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2891335740200782, + "veriT": 9.3411074658358562, + "Yices": 7.4578742759151435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4995302990854027, + "CVC4": 12.339377419692596, + "CVC3": 8.2093567143865354, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.687967175789762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.084303557929163 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.958764511781129, + "veriT": 7.9048681210067082, + "Yices": 8.9597993917075875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.802942349754729, + "CVC4": 1.9708694440673109, + "CVC3": 7.0152280735614649, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4790260559971251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4776379849278749 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2138965057634152, + "veriT": 13.068154456321412, + "Yices": 11.932044240887839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8547037039566279, + "CVC4": 2.8602485311443746, + "CVC3": 10.271790496834852, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.246505652353067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.841428803153619 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6358946659968754, + "veriT": 3.6422573994014624, + "Yices": 13.487689836978028, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6625811964954997, + "CVC4": 12.773511543894319, + "CVC3": 10.00273682336733, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.171324289761875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16985863988837502 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.432599795523259, + "veriT": 10.1085059918552, + "Yices": 10.113129291726265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.86234779388778, + "CVC4": 4.3649423060550179, + "CVC3": 5.3783462258712129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.844443877326992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.841131050041771 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6685224523408957, + "veriT": 7.2958362313357421, + "Yices": 9.9426370037404119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5515175488408639, + "CVC4": 12.254279866927297, + "CVC3": 4.177291472663069, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6176981746847305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1303321317895314 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5651727683824999, + "veriT": 3.119520862232275, + "Yices": 5.1926978945893749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4446800529675476, + "CVC4": 7.409705225754065, + "CVC3": 0.38942615855262497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4394280828186927, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0476682061462688 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1303626819728182, + "veriT": 1.9238740680956274, + "Yices": 1.9780531409913635, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13080269030490907, + "CVC4": 2.7083923793752631, + "CVC3": 0.11902475772000001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13628317011954544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12937792875045454 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2588521377468333, + "veriT": 2.4201047384659535, + "Yices": 11.920283146629666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.54273254398883319, + "CVC4": 0.24403427211233333, + "CVC3": 0.23807662259366666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.232616903071, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22783861864849997 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11496194487581333, + "veriT": 9.7323814246062543, + "Yices": 6.4094955470846138, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12264211286231333, + "CVC4": 5.7818139747347361, + "CVC3": 3.3720984092999093, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1118576396242048, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1224675862358597 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2569289207458496, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3566848832818574, + "veriT": 9.6274179469394419, + "Yices": 7.8366569222809668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1566630764284582, + "CVC4": 2.338500082969428, + "CVC3": 2.4410893850166944, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.226464040661957, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.227764598411465 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8732183221327059, + "veriT": 13.504714768579147, + "Yices": 9.9172441107645088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8709570995131308, + "CVC4": 11.92466045580785, + "CVC3": 11.951900080708935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.032437308651781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.559523596058256 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4003402163697896, + "veriT": 10.963380853660651, + "Yices": 5.6531961608323842, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6498391819804352, + "CVC4": 2.401227154917962, + "CVC3": 1.4481242664553848, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2999581688645678, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2368515487908684 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.399866459224997, + "veriT": 1.3238484607807779, + "Yices": 9.1467449077142913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5869055338937175, + "CVC4": 11.448928782509736, + "CVC3": 6.0079230315424441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.760026474688233, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7511681885564918 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9937499761581421, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2498674842959234, + "veriT": 0.1551424987496923, + "Yices": 0.15582942855746154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2633083520352311, + "CVC4": 1.2767481930362405, + "CVC3": 0.17682343416284613, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17021806492623076, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17323173018269231 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1715688705444336, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15133619252388886, + "veriT": 7.434319607192573, + "Yices": 1.2696555415266668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16277695511455556, + "CVC4": 1.7379120281733034, + "CVC3": 1.7164952304718595, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4104577114713974, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4178789925294926 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15457081859499999, + "veriT": 0.12622501189576923, + "Yices": 0.14824839305084614, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15636331933746156, + "CVC4": 0.16973681579007691, + "CVC3": 0.15191174836192306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16411618186346152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16674445198307691 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5332589211078425, + "veriT": 5.9111381395564697, + "Yices": 4.347062477216423, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7881482945608775, + "CVC4": 4.5305017859665062, + "CVC3": 4.6283001866772038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2254359293167112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.698924688299555 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 81.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.228580826127631, + "veriT": 12.17120440881871, + "Yices": 11.40615080812737, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.943515064090827, + "CVC4": 13.136704145577886, + "CVC3": 12.577059816726621, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.907063981186232, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.907398147106401 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.266283978333124, + "veriT": 10.189396358050001, + "Yices": 10.382054272438999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.983657430696846, + "CVC4": 14.283672743181041, + "CVC3": 12.886054304108617, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.2575266296686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.455917418517572 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.898873781106531, + "veriT": 12.251813487507548, + "Yices": 11.652923119967312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.059648600423278, + "CVC4": 14.448762987194996, + "CVC3": 7.5625844855813691, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8370428606691522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.217098502099351 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4137375020243939, + "veriT": 13.206389992490855, + "Yices": 8.1550518335789981, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.714438500183217, + "CVC4": 5.9387352586939501, + "CVC3": 5.1238428009180472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.088332118080327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.104077613120992 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0163397346673242, + "veriT": 13.847845057819248, + "Yices": 5.8080642423430939, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1908467731692474, + "CVC4": 0.87247956617959999, + "CVC3": 3.2244993812842773, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21287118625399998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21381811964129999 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14924022075588569, + "veriT": 0.12725772453335715, + "Yices": 0.62178145173922861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.68821132082514302, + "CVC4": 0.13538823239057143, + "CVC3": 0.12426289380565714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12832556822194285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12475348918131428 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.53668405979750011, + "veriT": 14.214118675644045, + "Yices": 14.006722690227596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9981093295636958, + "CVC4": 14.631373595017179, + "CVC3": 7.154250636883269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.745876418708784, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.702475710160792 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9825310707092285, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.753403973928036, + "veriT": 12.22031359628218, + "Yices": 12.697499440945316, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.570087976354026, + "CVC4": 14.296690066584638, + "CVC3": 13.032570617539902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.769431608689276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.997420845087172 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2318885353364379, + "veriT": 13.290470819699092, + "Yices": 10.079103575734077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6376197308168408, + "CVC4": 13.322081989821056, + "CVC3": 6.9119635407058446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8383057053508853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6248771512633091 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2911845885962001, + "veriT": 10.19853069941867, + "Yices": 4.3507560999382999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4546030599776016, + "CVC4": 1.4204702965388001, + "CVC3": 1.8415079266318848, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4096381490617844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4256043402867249 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.905077898299635, + "veriT": 13.004822803002988, + "Yices": 11.244794729355219, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.994809938651439, + "CVC4": 11.817872785821423, + "CVC3": 13.661637109498526, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.431947311769175, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4977040142688924 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1507542000754185, + "veriT": 12.906689111502068, + "Yices": 12.333184700564917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.524471187130281, + "CVC4": 3.6797507235292977, + "CVC3": 2.8928307344036495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22165307242144441, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5067124630690383 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9905199141009717, + "veriT": 10.890121835300874, + "Yices": 11.875395154926043, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9681091172786029, + "CVC4": 12.720948768983162, + "CVC3": 13.053936573115726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.716164790079752, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.328995589685082 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.264815690397352, + "veriT": 10.261935099573572, + "Yices": 12.613820623103875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980117322635083, + "CVC4": 14.401842925871547, + "CVC3": 13.945616041505611, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.852568626034584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.588694824206566 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 490.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3251038532629416, + "veriT": 13.618467008114013, + "Yices": 13.513594144766193, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.278906004337767, + "CVC4": 14.606300055207674, + "CVC3": 13.038611484700851, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.05988182561461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.054490637700425 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245880578614818, + "veriT": 12.889724171574329, + "Yices": 12.972596001681049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.982983897046926, + "CVC4": 14.642172814781921, + "CVC3": 13.026482374664491, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255570847231638, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.264131762736172 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.138209236460641, + "veriT": 13.911874279459752, + "Yices": 13.86982107399689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.280746256426816, + "CVC4": 14.731737341034027, + "CVC3": 10.047394921285319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.195442577928835, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5160144715089263 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12992870526737499, + "veriT": 0.10131620838781669, + "Yices": 0.10162888122752084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12656328097066669, + "CVC4": 0.12763883376095833, + "CVC3": 0.10642452563157083, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12583532775104167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12291082520845836 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12154711380407002, + "veriT": 0.58846264931642001, + "Yices": 0.59259061183960005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13028825814172501, + "CVC4": 0.81931618961743768, + "CVC3": 0.094469043257674995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.81454459388765588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.81378175134729636 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1497003665584096, + "veriT": 1.3781064037408113, + "Yices": 1.1276771005876751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2357249444286182, + "CVC4": 1.8996521583577828, + "CVC3": 0.1236584081273875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14730340432774999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.145162958435125 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7021170509237393, + "veriT": 1.2180395283697778, + "Yices": 1.24339828394, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7685897044546888, + "CVC4": 0.15114343005677777, + "CVC3": 1.6867638997756016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13563223059144444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7057657553457488 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4122752214162246, + "veriT": 10.163119467955571, + "Yices": 10.354493614801687, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5232435010399878, + "CVC4": 0.14934705737205714, + "CVC3": 0.68823148354617147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15009333462225713, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.419186544460636 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19755693595520002, + "veriT": 9.1631770438606015, + "Yices": 10.467591973492301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.42310213399020002, + "CVC4": 0.15174883916350002, + "CVC3": 0.28413875230270003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14934514736450002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9924624600922263 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8205313000382919, + "veriT": 11.60247380465513, + "Yices": 12.465747376751048, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0370450374067222, + "CVC4": 12.531296676573534, + "CVC3": 10.244942119713354, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.139948665897176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.178041369838267 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4920635223388672, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7938692070251729, + "veriT": 4.1442566496109006, + "Yices": 8.0538922011512177, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0970807789082446, + "CVC4": 0.1662002555855, + "CVC3": 5.3853533639883988, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15542675960060001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7380025426925583 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.107976966687469, + "veriT": 9.7931410467644824, + "Yices": 9.781951045541124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.734521773321099, + "CVC4": 1.0827231002274778, + "CVC3": 10.18979513508112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7306521466309448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.79967720188557 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239202007004019, + "veriT": 10.160836128001332, + "Yices": 10.336043397006417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959887173918789, + "CVC4": 0.16845084951824998, + "CVC3": 14.240826086103398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14870830215258332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.790855722156932 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8166664838790894, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.49348775904965, + "veriT": 8.9060637630783752, + "Yices": 10.308304408697875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.118771421937581, + "CVC4": 0.17245212080575001, + "CVC3": 12.049832213042658, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.913219875980683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.17548317070718 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.898272368807403, + "veriT": 10.363992698088197, + "Yices": 10.34492862763258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.55612853029306, + "CVC4": 2.2290973248707968, + "CVC3": 10.199357792057702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9695028182854868, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.730057698747816 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3186048066017024, + "veriT": 9.4328573317729703, + "Yices": 9.5009816427468277, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6054975047100886, + "CVC4": 4.3877272950961066, + "CVC3": 7.4259955898684904, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1816625019673128, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5722788181056249 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3483904239754461, + "veriT": 8.1647036329036329, + "Yices": 7.1978428596831279, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6231176431221672, + "CVC4": 7.251656606831868, + "CVC3": 2.5577689730906124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.179669482437002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1817717269823831 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7738201544585941, + "veriT": 7.6535754730283152, + "Yices": 5.7448894274830629, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9385594056723146, + "CVC4": 0.21757627630190909, + "CVC3": 4.1041281678138155, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2399414373732176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.409968572906108 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6946928804171182, + "veriT": 9.1854321233100062, + "Yices": 11.789816836886887, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7092554356080072, + "CVC4": 5.9844589455904664, + "CVC3": 8.4095725994709465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.290757581932631, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8135265847971258 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3923075199127197, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6840963802252036, + "veriT": 6.732399512541571, + "Yices": 3.6130032631916711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2260649773743477, + "CVC4": 5.9949843657616313, + "CVC3": 5.7376625429492103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3427671283854137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.342481128450566 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5084682863092409, + "veriT": 9.9188727180179228, + "Yices": 7.8391388609264476, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4251135592512663, + "CVC4": 9.154028349817894, + "CVC3": 7.2381986033331698, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6567465695774475, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7235979834357558 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0371776277097999, + "veriT": 5.5326925355118144, + "Yices": 8.3899797643766068, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6750721489759632, + "CVC4": 4.5884762230950011, + "CVC3": 2.808792766647469, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19482388617521817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19297489136347271 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 27.0, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.598356866925032, + "veriT": 6.129579993242201, + "Yices": 9.3038387611602005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.024135746122647, + "CVC4": 2.9798867728905116, + "CVC3": 10.550821364032227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8079075724088156, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8137454253806968 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.739291016968643, + "veriT": 12.195048749278966, + "Yices": 11.935627892130316, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.425744049123942, + "CVC4": 5.7705118932693056, + "CVC3": 13.023262030988269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1954280350766151, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.786827412359337 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1419127662533262, + "veriT": 2.3345625582068106, + "Yices": 1.1109586564381546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3727341866836689, + "CVC4": 1.5133951327398962, + "CVC3": 2.3920652084438627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0709755547785269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0813052857217373 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.12585682485953, + "veriT": 10.989550098506495, + "Yices": 2.5088846897493724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1324277293732998, + "CVC4": 1.6048157774597354, + "CVC3": 2.5379200413754059, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5307746154666206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5294328040200003 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0858255933947945, + "veriT": 12.648431397333235, + "Yices": 10.825305375580301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.365361333250011, + "CVC4": 11.247315108502262, + "CVC3": 6.6978901858388316, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3071335447579191, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3023911305145681 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2915841393753731, + "veriT": 4.2593621988190833, + "Yices": 4.6003874017281134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3522452686509554, + "CVC4": 0.97307600197302513, + "CVC3": 2.1613094713316201, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4459771671582247, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4353711379134837 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6248727511432635, + "veriT": 8.2975743973299299, + "Yices": 8.2746141627117957, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7913058115790204, + "CVC4": 11.536689595790325, + "CVC3": 4.9102699194823014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.425065654960921, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.665071840006968 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.889171125395102, + "veriT": 10.114242902563799, + "Yices": 10.108257618180822, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.95548600534236, + "CVC4": 4.6020899409852216, + "CVC3": 3.6346005536287884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.906907205393829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.916352064959771 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19676921562166663, + "veriT": 5.9968861910466336, + "Yices": 10.161848895603443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23896613662961672, + "CVC4": 2.5178518198503737, + "CVC3": 0.13015108511383336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.28749355768024998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22873389180551665 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7613790968593679, + "veriT": 4.6882387591564152, + "Yices": 13.956851727102711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9557558371853898, + "CVC4": 8.2533743965610107, + "CVC3": 9.5540854473983359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3225909567478356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8811285420111759 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.369730580908092, + "veriT": 7.430795298258138, + "Yices": 9.9587595653581023, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.659824334846201, + "CVC4": 11.737598316458488, + "CVC3": 9.5046154461474899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.77120700458547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.194580894360053 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13573555745242857, + "veriT": 4.1407060848751955, + "Yices": 6.4101310505696016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16947271501399999, + "CVC4": 2.9971862312829995, + "CVC3": 3.4813369669968575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9912347125444287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9897163303578571 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14588627323259998, + "veriT": 0.12969311727703997, + "Yices": 0.13872688018960003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14453772924380001, + "CVC4": 0.16070084572159998, + "CVC3": 0.14019422081839999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15619339756129999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15204000005000001 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3864774565792499, + "veriT": 9.0373177392252479, + "Yices": 3.8929092809012502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4213144092182499, + "CVC4": 1.9862000743631452, + "CVC3": 1.4633282720758749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1983560003400253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6744578348468169 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1565893583718889, + "veriT": 10.013147017263679, + "Yices": 8.0622084890389178, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2987544720208994, + "CVC4": 11.391428556369872, + "CVC3": 2.576991586616511, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4049374629057354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5327208002433625 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5944936886379204, + "veriT": 6.1606582625336896, + "Yices": 13.635518952408713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7050276161460363, + "CVC4": 6.3556585047518537, + "CVC3": 10.013050778899473, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.187703028136597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.164135061967583 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3512116984895828, + "veriT": 6.0664445673950071, + "Yices": 13.1898256773922, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4403804326759166, + "CVC4": 14.579650285720525, + "CVC3": 13.000480515279682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6395691657631648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6699022518666631 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6899039745330811, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.151517495507736, + "veriT": 11.774332201902153, + "Yices": 11.880969938287951, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.243111030349937, + "CVC4": 5.909153397624757, + "CVC3": 15.234941994526247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3210549184765235, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.037824106505109 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9650298802007686, + "veriT": 7.7704366057028533, + "Yices": 8.2732756625745445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4041113368780991, + "CVC4": 0.76110217435612493, + "CVC3": 7.7638882010515768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8400083450937323, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2641888253567712 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9869496417118304, + "veriT": 8.5777700665623566, + "Yices": 5.4564568582585844, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6535147287301291, + "CVC4": 3.1093498386779901, + "CVC3": 0.35002329155440004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19635998379646669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6650799417652717 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 73.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.703069812257187, + "veriT": 12.371818407277264, + "Yices": 7.9671643508331789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.061744647152853, + "CVC4": 2.0407156084873708, + "CVC3": 8.8218199499145342, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.214629074296222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.406187317418839 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8704924059502543, + "veriT": 11.814737639795215, + "Yices": 11.494028650547396, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3417480357398874, + "CVC4": 13.084508687536651, + "CVC3": 10.940771386145013, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.703130891006404, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.565081055218204 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8342854976654053, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14667200570872729, + "veriT": 6.5255105528694166, + "Yices": 0.20508253392709094, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13570452168518179, + "CVC4": 0.39806591387118184, + "CVC3": 0.15022677926336361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5546491203932931, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5515417890501233 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.29100282707971425, + "veriT": 13.066994059698287, + "Yices": 6.563123028723143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6409524128291431, + "CVC4": 6.3295281525574696, + "CVC3": 4.5501239174018151, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.054141944134427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.179273061046375 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 52.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7318891574952904, + "veriT": 9.6172247114377942, + "Yices": 10.074782187067727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.081180223416556, + "CVC4": 5.4003750676120852, + "CVC3": 7.7054301027051997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.675504545047204, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.292530558966117 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.725955821864504, + "veriT": 14.223275479969557, + "Yices": 11.800312010117599, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.745547144938229, + "CVC4": 14.718227775892021, + "CVC3": 14.213364127608237, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233709063590522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230904080907006 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.557207830422727, + "veriT": 13.40577856787173, + "Yices": 8.4439937817589534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9680575243665626, + "CVC4": 5.9554766883627659, + "CVC3": 7.4859614750049843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.32119045602318, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.284984880727443 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7099988378790547, + "veriT": 13.631097888956775, + "Yices": 5.2374094655375645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0363734502168773, + "CVC4": 2.6650598175207572, + "CVC3": 4.3397720848443688, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.196355537072398, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.190832458987899 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25275835865253843, + "veriT": 0.17782741078023079, + "Yices": 7.9318471337047738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.64625760577815383, + "CVC4": 3.4634209286684476, + "CVC3": 0.22635299393930766, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.52843203680876916, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7911331813207618 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9711539745330811, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.603739795608444, + "veriT": 0.14127676562122224, + "Yices": 0.13760604743311111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6054129943835544, + "CVC4": 0.1758626111003333, + "CVC3": 0.15458406415533332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16143900893322222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16302918353922222 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1729815006256104, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14606193243433335, + "veriT": 7.8107888237861305, + "Yices": 0.14819272887222221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1641702186158889, + "CVC4": 0.16810194379911111, + "CVC3": 0.4185717929065555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15504866545644444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15652234766500001 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15183783397633335, + "veriT": 0.12760115600458335, + "Yices": 0.14725847552316668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15281110510425003, + "CVC4": 0.16755916718666666, + "CVC3": 0.14946091868233335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16260489686483334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16476899455916669 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1064753532409668, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6061446104592854, + "veriT": 4.3872846398696712, + "Yices": 4.9782252344152216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8774538990738143, + "CVC4": 8.2186839130435398, + "CVC3": 1.754680506951471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2304437956305505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2259393694970897 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.973882824087394, + "veriT": 11.651168247842948, + "Yices": 12.148429675818006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.07724903020506, + "CVC4": 9.0763277947581535, + "CVC3": 8.4793601289730294, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.597080347483077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5746116480984016 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.77330338413057131, + "veriT": 10.483444299847745, + "Yices": 11.081462740313457, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4948601303524289, + "CVC4": 6.2554241266907953, + "CVC3": 6.8355159049093572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7832481176895716, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8539132274865717 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4835780210234466, + "veriT": 4.8143145106091678, + "Yices": 2.4228459579517834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6069279068629223, + "CVC4": 12.016868036205034, + "CVC3": 1.9546898609665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16682354254451667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16135949470298333 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.77301826201099999, + "veriT": 9.8681877263074398, + "Yices": 2.536692947779565, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4091574793963879, + "CVC4": 2.6135821272895829, + "CVC3": 6.2983355344581993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0654225108863322, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5486005968798349 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.851237147368725, + "veriT": 13.2286238228399, + "Yices": 9.7329007828088656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.781365619393451, + "CVC4": 11.040259606792873, + "CVC3": 10.763591438837983, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.686356391710646, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.114092131378756 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6685609817504883, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2358742914701173, + "veriT": 8.4325913110553063, + "Yices": 4.6572913376712961, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7517256911767021, + "CVC4": 6.5231142398009796, + "CVC3": 5.0233123597589522, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.751898869803254, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.76333481060065 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3320385527138461, + "veriT": 11.787923515052599, + "Yices": 4.0027773729984721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5502201757630156, + "CVC4": 11.157279093336895, + "CVC3": 9.5703570720963267, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5613016487928988, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9451466596962312 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.246424876474226, + "veriT": 10.149199773515374, + "Yices": 10.258607570056874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.136873360023657, + "CVC4": 14.626174668274345, + "CVC3": 12.577783804549824, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.980482277032806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.750611401029904 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4211741180825044, + "veriT": 13.402041490586107, + "Yices": 12.69214858130505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.014934713306753, + "CVC4": 9.5859503343779835, + "CVC3": 10.273385525528623, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.240232749099373, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.119635531181062 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.930830249246851, + "veriT": 13.294453160096133, + "Yices": 11.429633481457918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956700863783777, + "CVC4": 12.481354331629083, + "CVC3": 13.61651274117521, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247684508424332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.034339331981737 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.273892490947054, + "veriT": 10.240726330787, + "Yices": 10.450050518186332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.991010097037973, + "CVC4": 14.302557802622514, + "CVC3": 14.262152833824343, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.274790838347053, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.348736408919416 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.269895265231103, + "veriT": 13.066358128261125, + "Yices": 13.56802754420416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.653434879685935, + "CVC4": 9.8419803562251058, + "CVC3": 12.48160291644022, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242371556274799, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.24096672560502 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 273.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7689366921020606, + "veriT": 7.0575591315502022, + "Yices": 2.8376545925623606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.113213341163771, + "CVC4": 1.8655710648094572, + "CVC3": 1.642392623626701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1676555946906464, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1468368473153743 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.54155572168562, + "veriT": 14.247100297340234, + "Yices": 14.248746243118218, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979906954053837, + "CVC4": 5.2264594113161555, + "CVC3": 5.1849790346863598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8988750428266554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8958203413468544 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.272093200005167, + "veriT": 14.208714352999916, + "Yices": 13.9054762516921, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9660155082239115, + "CVC4": 13.286567754669198, + "CVC3": 0.55971612951600003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.219459807183576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4707083138210901 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.86339588766309983, + "veriT": 10.676589611280125, + "Yices": 7.4465736448024655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7121800879924001, + "CVC4": 7.3092216293781105, + "CVC3": 7.3664872566521016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.680605647697033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6023812315015236 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.784684055806576, + "veriT": 13.219098896873049, + "Yices": 12.357855855096631, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.057350583623235, + "CVC4": 13.508422345718825, + "CVC3": 11.127582549271819, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.968211005955899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.579119711116336 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.385390885940378, + "veriT": 11.961039711490729, + "Yices": 11.659505598976965, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980556235084251, + "CVC4": 14.316793704106635, + "CVC3": 14.265332414905085, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.281756497710489, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.664961121659431 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8112706051831697, + "veriT": 13.031028454367586, + "Yices": 13.750462665530511, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.500689059538621, + "CVC4": 14.577074039668583, + "CVC3": 8.8036734228760665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.067027333154412, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.776564195858125 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 68.0, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5990470034452819, + "veriT": 11.798497259274086, + "Yices": 12.854507266340816, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8162403123886453, + "CVC4": 13.694528112215213, + "CVC3": 13.209595759675475, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2533357561132223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1172662139124445 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0524567856826268, + "veriT": 14.247958925172771, + "Yices": 12.293624246038448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.796623530925652, + "CVC4": 12.791826397965464, + "CVC3": 15.136253106067684, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3022070222034205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3057483942821353 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.979538870104705, + "veriT": 12.244140726507577, + "Yices": 12.209587764834525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.633562239693095, + "CVC4": 13.183836427601618, + "CVC3": 8.8436708671688855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9305717439054115, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2437507948964637 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.142813299383635, + "veriT": 12.511600792518266, + "Yices": 13.220967483178514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.64274124105366, + "CVC4": 14.547232705260951, + "CVC3": 14.001232688640952, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.219459140513887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.642692627299308 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12083036728612, + "veriT": 0.092990892851412002, + "Yices": 0.09497465688369601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11679095638516002, + "CVC4": 0.11917389256247997, + "CVC3": 0.096443714047920001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11672310677327999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11636031802981602 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10255325008488, + "veriT": 0.074652650613139998, + "Yices": 0.078559346383975007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10075802216227001, + "CVC4": 0.097813505593499994, + "CVC3": 0.079533519125604996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.097521498886864996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.095990797991654997 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.764062152844545, + "veriT": 0.099496140630472726, + "Yices": 1.0231712616942272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7591497522127266, + "CVC4": 0.13084397320999999, + "CVC3": 0.1065994254290091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12576140742390909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1452197213208182 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2114095540050256, + "veriT": 8.6565420711491896, + "Yices": 8.7496005906826007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.569714480740668, + "CVC4": 3.8524422766756139, + "CVC3": 9.0277371620293412, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6622700158153076, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.360547395817388 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20844670087318751, + "veriT": 10.163388272770939, + "Yices": 10.354956939782532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2590328595313125, + "CVC4": 0.14889632204228126, + "CVC3": 0.69285454226059373, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14827953739237498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.423983252982721 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17698905978541668, + "veriT": 6.8119847773870825, + "Yices": 7.8946536107329157, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.30990305734425, + "CVC4": 0.15404742245808331, + "CVC3": 0.23453954771841667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14855981663475001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7717620365090077 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8174605369567871, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.088302096743091, + "veriT": 13.020940462526287, + "Yices": 12.942403936894353, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.129671915544787, + "CVC4": 13.528421187218676, + "CVC3": 10.063098614108391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.219705732789276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.144046591416405 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8533567162949973, + "veriT": 3.4987207948206667, + "Yices": 4.6963593011128886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1053362724045321, + "CVC4": 0.16366787239538888, + "CVC3": 3.5231235535875509, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8393234107548126, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2526274355620455 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1594561020606, + "veriT": 1.5333825834176997, + "Yices": 2.1628986865559998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.15312901050978, + "CVC4": 2.9695739576684361, + "CVC3": 1.5446352573092097, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5426254492472122, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2619882168137206 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.134116987031625, + "veriT": 7.5966413134366997, + "Yices": 7.6019946339703761, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12937576134237502, + "CVC4": 1.9030282224721902, + "CVC3": 0.12251049692462498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13233806534787501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.131212042222875 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.170372209125112, + "veriT": 11.244957266822448, + "Yices": 8.4041174864329165, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.688208155701526, + "CVC4": 1.1164301846329097, + "CVC3": 8.3058679201873886, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3696665285543257, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3090845725770421 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.254163321832008, + "veriT": 11.196674087824697, + "Yices": 10.598430876513328, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.743924384722476, + "CVC4": 6.8761976716228439, + "CVC3": 12.380747774373489, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.068807770217516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.461846623234207 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.740538842596804, + "veriT": 8.8341582969656862, + "Yices": 9.483209929570334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.281629981564803, + "CVC4": 0.212746327535, + "CVC3": 9.3949357107780482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8417002800992757, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.897300869106489 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234714686624322, + "veriT": 10.161949254989556, + "Yices": 10.311375206384112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.945091208209078, + "CVC4": 0.23766736439422223, + "CVC3": 13.410225647285465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7788243770743222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.134076396360454 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.822120399386085, + "veriT": 9.5526897841469776, + "Yices": 10.881852460141202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.458216227010499, + "CVC4": 1.6418281789016702, + "CVC3": 10.437233703665388, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9666284075829816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9645433535892245 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5983088403157701, + "veriT": 5.675258060206235, + "Yices": 10.289047484142598, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9539173023602401, + "CVC4": 1.8395205541350705, + "CVC3": 2.7424580953980962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0240886975931858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9721324159726263 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0826835053942174, + "veriT": 7.9641345953727019, + "Yices": 8.3430180438056549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3630095630359484, + "CVC4": 6.3126487866325052, + "CVC3": 7.137961826155081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8209151978341991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5497495266271297 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8811933688391151, + "veriT": 1.3578224241372625, + "Yices": 1.3794416634046873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9687561681447718, + "CVC4": 0.1330216324895, + "CVC3": 0.2521009643894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15539561864212501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5489087296463533 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7285715341567993, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.875705700059678, + "veriT": 12.601072796333895, + "Yices": 12.833595019105855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.476305701893478, + "CVC4": 5.9389735711452607, + "CVC3": 5.6971836211773983, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6331079104297617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6140114134217347 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.801125486680379, + "veriT": 12.865367284994704, + "Yices": 10.287465837436633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.68419040744222, + "CVC4": 3.3191217728408247, + "CVC3": 9.6152781733928627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.416505885448514, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.330952491069191 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1585120372571405, + "veriT": 14.225509347635594, + "Yices": 9.8104244755825576, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.387302194070148, + "CVC4": 13.431362174689252, + "CVC3": 10.362905154873685, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239996762444735, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238572645869652 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4216244845817005, + "veriT": 11.383343063874083, + "Yices": 7.1553445061686958, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3547933580136995, + "CVC4": 7.4116032001259544, + "CVC3": 6.869274313614727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6296507930482562, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.65383301427355 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3416061474947081, + "veriT": 5.2210251853120528, + "Yices": 6.1380544188265258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8398081827284178, + "CVC4": 5.7561201319363722, + "CVC3": 3.1514439236818084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3843291474516799, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1711007618234976 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9567117993500001, + "veriT": 4.2109140255292461, + "Yices": 9.3046179955356649, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3030116495861672, + "CVC4": 7.2523947811162577, + "CVC3": 2.1199076058444999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.682302656116981, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.255756573382891 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 23.0, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.043748160175967, + "veriT": 9.2692670797242869, + "Yices": 8.9699705211567142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7343290082318408, + "CVC4": 10.721508889677747, + "CVC3": 10.272309037404755, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.205068177975487, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.788736693529946 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.48519077790754, + "veriT": 10.124618626954666, + "Yices": 10.121860452725443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.971558135071774, + "CVC4": 5.1023290790328364, + "CVC3": 5.5785564675420893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235761695268074, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.232199361367869 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18057793360579999, + "veriT": 6.1115408897849601, + "Yices": 11.720861806268099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.43179599924659995, + "CVC4": 11.435725779819293, + "CVC3": 9.1869560937858328, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5916807013726597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5892277928546701 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2003078423169597, + "veriT": 10.503335816818813, + "Yices": 7.531098045444879, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6707356849525166, + "CVC4": 8.8632457206379343, + "CVC3": 13.172909048463923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2207370231829611, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.485763848850262 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5694221662048571, + "veriT": 3.5802256447336638, + "Yices": 13.337003452075374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6034908528049285, + "CVC4": 8.5357699370703166, + "CVC3": 12.365456509312326, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2820771445137713, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2568233746901205 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2193851382282332, + "veriT": 4.3357527293331479, + "Yices": 3.130794014599088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4145917051344727, + "CVC4": 0.18896396147511998, + "CVC3": 0.18144292471466664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18223028105873335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6468172433056247 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.447935286603109, + "veriT": 9.9539448102345993, + "Yices": 8.3134227623630004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.077263303384523, + "CVC4": 0.17756820270479998, + "CVC3": 11.526616540749377, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.98757111562829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.938815695015046 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8270592555568594, + "veriT": 9.3641989656990354, + "Yices": 13.075017887868848, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.121636383000773, + "CVC4": 6.0098831847322458, + "CVC3": 8.9169693349858701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3279733913995004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8427185137979842 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5223792684672306, + "veriT": 2.0542659914721257, + "Yices": 5.66744293101653, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6884027300573843, + "CVC4": 0.25537588820415386, + "CVC3": 2.1944568967447795, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7056437907996163, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7076448951312022 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.49315665876844444, + "veriT": 4.5544522463093999, + "Yices": 6.6011172515145757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.74830448598666666, + "CVC4": 0.1631706315308889, + "CVC3": 1.4608547255772224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7027956496726, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2594890346145382 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1514793804115, + "veriT": 1.2301794297242852, + "Yices": 0.22403335229233332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18683395854491666, + "CVC4": 0.1829068447574167, + "CVC3": 0.14516907956675001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17995991755283328, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17530674898491669 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3829855582710686, + "veriT": 10.191481030647376, + "Yices": 10.3599522578685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8498572675592779, + "CVC4": 10.765956414063552, + "CVC3": 2.2634115639290004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.745967729875272, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.978480646338678 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.796568591579549, + "veriT": 4.2244594475991999, + "Yices": 7.6575285538316704, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.086369357343962, + "CVC4": 9.3811539132314046, + "CVC3": 1.7562979684007236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5884822858036391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4935580598579339 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2257893048187558, + "veriT": 11.71873320451159, + "Yices": 10.406971327771206, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.258053507421028, + "CVC4": 14.507124169078931, + "CVC3": 8.7621820565204658, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247130263367779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.524402141230434 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13337827571409999, + "veriT": 9.9847528574996609, + "Yices": 2.9373748092021001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.134050163123, + "CVC4": 2.9771820541514558, + "CVC3": 2.936314246326579, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7952808738920654, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7902295605067646 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4776885128181334, + "veriT": 14.211163556484861, + "Yices": 0.21160277412626669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5205555274700664, + "CVC4": 0.17899478829033333, + "CVC3": 0.13191397631980001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.114980890095415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.11939091408904 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8337814807891846, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.34003566244114281, + "veriT": 11.031424033502876, + "Yices": 5.8743590864448807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4380915385958755, + "CVC4": 6.4917828527682984, + "CVC3": 5.4050554866994514, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4659269879478423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4743530838456045 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6134415862793707, + "veriT": 13.636043422228884, + "Yices": 7.2459229791865836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.809474935285869, + "CVC4": 4.3376027472587451, + "CVC3": 8.1988843196057406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.212185469461982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2091045822054358 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6052329233660552, + "veriT": 11.877156962916123, + "Yices": 9.8913734110868816, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7627239514354871, + "CVC4": 12.082616745621673, + "CVC3": 11.826821547519843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.188060021729006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.187342544020245 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2993622897614951, + "veriT": 13.04903778326163, + "Yices": 7.733292627990016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0498447246825453, + "CVC4": 3.4278093307837443, + "CVC3": 6.1901968592285481, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23720928925864, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.23823176234963 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7832040786743164, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3331743650280341, + "veriT": 10.158857728315143, + "Yices": 11.409559625416245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.043602233875362, + "CVC4": 8.3352234852333122, + "CVC3": 8.5245037522980844, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249838993040091, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.004794335470864 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 55.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9937499761581421, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9234374761581421, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13160793720345715, + "veriT": 2.9685883447138854, + "Yices": 6.4344081490394691, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13481506734847143, + "CVC4": 8.2361137632685679, + "CVC3": 0.13537097927714287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.33088738701884285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7314454214703621 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2338150985764003, + "veriT": 2.9425162670614418, + "Yices": 0.12160394270981997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2448459046356408, + "CVC4": 5.8228905414307688, + "CVC3": 2.9365973676839863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9479006440871509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9461751470613988 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 110.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 91.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17233152380160002, + "veriT": 0.14771853873179999, + "Yices": 0.22574161239469998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18037696522920002, + "CVC4": 0.18911951265269997, + "CVC3": 0.18355677293849998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17807717520880001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18153133805920002 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5488172713320778, + "veriT": 5.1420068572251161, + "Yices": 9.8295851284868014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.946736180915885, + "CVC4": 0.19287161848149995, + "CVC3": 2.7744210089466672, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5091915561924496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5277755188270399 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5059189735927156, + "veriT": 11.204214419482065, + "Yices": 6.5148765308454459, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6400979779712581, + "CVC4": 4.9888468445397853, + "CVC3": 6.9349618520740428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9474108217297328, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3979352982095623 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19682130562860004, + "veriT": 5.7437322317942501, + "Yices": 0.17605238988809999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22381441035360003, + "CVC4": 0.22197818464730004, + "CVC3": 0.43451722007119997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21115214874169999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1954193711095 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15294030958470589, + "veriT": 0.12824873394488234, + "Yices": 0.14570707062794119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15630284104870587, + "CVC4": 0.16811133476211765, + "CVC3": 0.14882027478747056, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16402756897923529, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16438366821729411 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4551478776143663, + "veriT": 9.6019233808981266, + "Yices": 6.3091641474317042, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8311363181061555, + "CVC4": 5.550175534976062, + "CVC3": 5.632853950383935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0792275023454274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0691023458460709 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8638510346741031, + "veriT": 8.4300105550379012, + "Yices": 7.4508258002836554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2479348422788163, + "CVC4": 12.249079509720737, + "CVC3": 11.434839755447278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.375599519089802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.026568861913342 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.47832874610320009, + "veriT": 4.3229456358275398, + "Yices": 11.965608843507606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0683590687175211, + "CVC4": 11.7353704248591, + "CVC3": 5.3337307062922008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5928156380124532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5786146042904639 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 21.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6518939733505249, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.586275612974732, + "veriT": 12.843539312420228, + "Yices": 7.1287133042237327, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.379736766909696, + "CVC4": 6.7118872504859128, + "CVC3": 1.2996178466710071, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.714838664899766, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.726468370985209 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.7644938286995, + "veriT": 12.702559907402778, + "Yices": 11.944868852939862, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.249348661204541, + "CVC4": 12.916122754117644, + "CVC3": 12.716975913097933, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.056928888834088, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.059924391356665 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 56.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2578779891286698, + "veriT": 10.134092603933082, + "Yices": 4.3304693999529871, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5780255245361028, + "CVC4": 3.1202098313475459, + "CVC3": 5.5003108298448309, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1088396856107461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6607304433948755 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9611192570139551, + "veriT": 12.894802942489953, + "Yices": 11.739047099503884, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.293854080258241, + "CVC4": 4.8255987987627966, + "CVC3": 5.7420455414384195, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5418267872627114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3141597284315418 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 173.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1240384578704834, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9797239303588867, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9861323565979738, + "veriT": 13.598134703506657, + "Yices": 13.562358631592913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.984110185496714, + "CVC4": 14.614266568379358, + "CVC3": 11.971272861817292, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.94901804432944, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.946463541169912 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 218.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.790044082186769, + "veriT": 11.613455599691971, + "Yices": 10.578247952660714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.99456433918637, + "CVC4": 11.490902284395901, + "CVC3": 14.273125082349067, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239248699613977, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.141749711470609 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.000347260027359, + "veriT": 11.262270487844523, + "Yices": 10.835418393828437, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967679012795831, + "CVC4": 14.573390923562442, + "CVC3": 14.244959238960519, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260216000614866, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.935476091554905 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5371961856351133, + "veriT": 12.781959620160633, + "Yices": 8.7968854272225308, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.733071497056585, + "CVC4": 13.392652150805585, + "CVC3": 8.9518297019959139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.252349817511625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.842880445848118 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2809983434089873, + "veriT": 7.2666954196393911, + "Yices": 8.6649698569150786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4505802334448319, + "CVC4": 7.7304799372074706, + "CVC3": 3.2635774549478334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.720152564388322, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.70623776286652 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5990852046016846, + "veriT": 9.4689193857921783, + "Yices": 5.416254501819787, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1595650756852356, + "CVC4": 6.8574076198124576, + "CVC3": 8.276405643460425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7379134966798597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3114729640746772 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6094312980302221, + "veriT": 12.41932230732017, + "Yices": 12.895139731149957, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.50012712950508, + "CVC4": 14.520342578606497, + "CVC3": 10.059041572961778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5647892096841698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5660115165791275 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2528317856252, + "veriT": 8.2364823492061365, + "Yices": 0.55332399179919989, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7968310431176002, + "CVC4": 0.47963211632080005, + "CVC3": 5.9750836402270924, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17860216247980001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16865297965359999 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 78.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.763043963263678, + "veriT": 14.230948522144612, + "Yices": 14.260845671628974, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.004216866435566, + "CVC4": 14.435614464046012, + "CVC3": 13.395250387882486, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.210804402030442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.04421367317533 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.389988342856743, + "veriT": 11.399449250728424, + "Yices": 12.331928874344205, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.981766914258841, + "CVC4": 14.420860573906578, + "CVC3": 14.07803897744714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.068874489905612, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.383065579130099 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.000479834927678, + "veriT": 14.226258526847065, + "Yices": 14.267621115386605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.073000355130139, + "CVC4": 14.586515532122332, + "CVC3": 12.24360804599983, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.087074572395089, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9047588484248497 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13189866703361902, + "veriT": 1.0466753845111239, + "Yices": 1.0492094528228477, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14544963762419047, + "CVC4": 1.4668427710807959, + "CVC3": 0.099191579962380955, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4599029356819924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4583795986585359 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.90613989892534819, + "veriT": 0.079535736884420005, + "Yices": 0.080952886044884001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.906314736073216, + "CVC4": 0.10332919546469999, + "CVC3": 0.084283535290527997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10242693527624398, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.103242684750596 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4269960244780937, + "veriT": 4.6344787845014848, + "Yices": 6.7020171454427535, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5898281713166234, + "CVC4": 4.6102839436418028, + "CVC3": 3.4106321207648005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3357055831966509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4509937427527433 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.2250000238418579, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.7104104339936157, + "veriT": 10.166736896692395, + "Yices": 10.354169281895038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.8013998068925261, + "CVC4": 0.14996881660507144, + "CVC3": 0.69075036092846409, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15018484216314287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.424844497912677 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20114783040366666, + "veriT": 10.165189915907666, + "Yices": 10.342850672788668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.33448437052666669, + "CVC4": 0.15325218642250002, + "CVC3": 0.31062214348100003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15087000633100003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.549120228284 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.768048076607698, + "veriT": 13.338634749841054, + "Yices": 12.049719481900702, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.97301089129243, + "CVC4": 13.561274338443432, + "CVC3": 10.694006523895405, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.833566312988092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.870676843114547 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9633539699658771, + "veriT": 5.6727443816593723, + "Yices": 8.2671373505951227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5970365946453366, + "CVC4": 2.0168325962391158, + "CVC3": 4.6387354980810285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3202392649340129, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8787104676243853 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13772214871437499, + "veriT": 5.6109018984181951, + "Yices": 6.8858796898663899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13259226493675, + "CVC4": 7.1989079852503091, + "CVC3": 0.13928239966387501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8926093582959902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13408960200887501 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241267659790005, + "veriT": 10.152613805934564, + "Yices": 10.337292677046438, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960821727230059, + "CVC4": 0.1560536258014375, + "CVC3": 11.51659629397145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.86105980422234263, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.368809216105106 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.395549058586317, + "veriT": 11.546828371087798, + "Yices": 8.9378393550492934, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.373620163861105, + "CVC4": 2.5789025918991078, + "CVC3": 9.7168922443497099, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3101577169383782, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9286314412739358 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.868809245876401, + "veriT": 10.529716096996804, + "Yices": 10.460242915930456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.517618673138726, + "CVC4": 1.5366484117751495, + "CVC3": 10.898878443667829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4250861446946415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.526706144849674 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.552704037068152, + "veriT": 8.4834902191116672, + "Yices": 10.975367930778098, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.154475903367674, + "CVC4": 0.18313017887533334, + "CVC3": 13.993650612585645, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14682111588533334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8792711448227966 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.248865689280644, + "veriT": 9.4493404433988566, + "Yices": 10.342514335591858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.919466844939427, + "CVC4": 0.17158275185914285, + "CVC3": 12.693213341404284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0305836503572277, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.329601590494475 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.210164042516574, + "veriT": 10.737807793663844, + "Yices": 10.314662081717497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.742927380515768, + "CVC4": 4.5092717251674452, + "CVC3": 8.0426415849992576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.391632028629783, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.302855314970028 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233351357273191, + "veriT": 10.1626015587512, + "Yices": 10.291860973201333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951530962246741, + "CVC4": 2.0713605358114675, + "CVC3": 11.483212379043238, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1261336076016475, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.976153480231462 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8611308988040314, + "veriT": 9.1573585412939238, + "Yices": 9.1993618161434885, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2161261668980003, + "CVC4": 1.8300552887681665, + "CVC3": 4.4838744077589352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9006763286811896, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7157383483070943 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20663856745197001, + "veriT": 4.548543786372834, + "Yices": 8.6544243779246006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25156875381891003, + "CVC4": 1.5796946118150579, + "CVC3": 1.6569959466250996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1775465566603263, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2831723349233801 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1180553436279297, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.21322653982245, + "veriT": 6.666754333335458, + "Yices": 5.7716537364422003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.417755827432146, + "CVC4": 5.6264319058481798, + "CVC3": 3.9454078762081028, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8036003031338659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5324264463422654 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.552587943211321, + "veriT": 10.678446608400083, + "Yices": 9.3928898900712383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.943809832437887, + "CVC4": 9.5176895310779575, + "CVC3": 10.540509014860696, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.662909404891725, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.661745470682009 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20583030884133333, + "veriT": 7.1078584468917514, + "Yices": 9.8866040309919772, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.85319612567, + "CVC4": 2.547967037998021, + "CVC3": 2.5325359101361991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1925382496253762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.740585942272717 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240463347167477, + "veriT": 10.156389886296834, + "Yices": 10.338901317804831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95743597337872, + "CVC4": 0.16260185461383334, + "CVC3": 12.606511283469443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8071180868962013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.648162536175057 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6444546859346314, + "veriT": 9.1484572033402038, + "Yices": 9.9913704745530403, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9724293316638057, + "CVC4": 2.9172227314751376, + "CVC3": 9.7787904091444702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2891547255097238, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3467340070410785 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6045392034463326, + "veriT": 6.3762730777341732, + "Yices": 0.14160348225296665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3867921255041109, + "CVC4": 0.13117124083622222, + "CVC3": 0.13546735817513333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12621688442644446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12381189625233333 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0334460120326838, + "veriT": 10.185343660217251, + "Yices": 11.245842276004421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5229581692243688, + "CVC4": 10.778611485789758, + "CVC3": 7.2068695107846912, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0603263478805092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.928964371613036 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8358667240048154, + "veriT": 7.9030840900204806, + "Yices": 9.1552244403642504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.875243729335377, + "CVC4": 2.0645221700907452, + "CVC3": 2.9184446767885572, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.738616860093407, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.730979473911493 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7016521722977078, + "veriT": 14.200789495103196, + "Yices": 9.4869390183869289, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.181400220150447, + "CVC4": 14.617479083589114, + "CVC3": 12.188553209959435, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.971296395596799, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.970303718393547 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4444417505666758, + "veriT": 10.126320506779674, + "Yices": 10.149272406789224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7390531287640663, + "CVC4": 11.75284911762607, + "CVC3": 12.056777629309641, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.227255464633442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.866134351063634 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 15.445243759198696, + "veriT": 10.790767918096932, + "Yices": 10.562182542420567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.939988384663005, + "CVC4": 10.082477935510786, + "CVC3": 6.8561010946135488, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.745061379030894, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.760245699553598 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15068037198807693, + "veriT": 12.051863161307157, + "Yices": 5.5913950273063069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1693144068711539, + "CVC4": 0.19213426541584616, + "CVC3": 5.5530042009785081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9052341715045031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8981732989216606 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.590278148651123, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.240384578704834, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7999843798068387, + "veriT": 10.154756028805096, + "Yices": 9.5268265352686097, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.338030727912022, + "CVC4": 8.049962205367029, + "CVC3": 6.8287829607855235, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5250743605253154, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5134735672481865 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3021667857095824, + "veriT": 0.89985333270558487, + "Yices": 6.7156655182429592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4244451571104615, + "CVC4": 2.3257882361553217, + "CVC3": 3.3027499032509007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6250512599023477, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4777732091052593 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15958841757715386, + "veriT": 3.2137266458698921, + "Yices": 4.3001132718135135, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15937663867069229, + "CVC4": 0.16442418024930769, + "CVC3": 0.14753216765784616, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15437131458876924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15665306800776924 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.25862162477498, + "veriT": 7.73102046455009, + "Yices": 8.7386103262743404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5746863721830318, + "CVC4": 3.7330942334772375, + "CVC3": 3.0420765858860874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.42544743545537494, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2196163871392316 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2608822053955739, + "veriT": 8.854381639142856, + "Yices": 12.552902290816141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5916770389975641, + "CVC4": 9.8014806054803696, + "CVC3": 9.1097631861590909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4533428505713477, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9983510116049565 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14656285764476251, + "veriT": 5.47678447212646, + "Yices": 8.0455649767871602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16449889107037499, + "CVC4": 9.1350103333139447, + "CVC3": 7.5931272423521925, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7332301376822707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7288535464872639 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 21.0, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1719153375852507, + "veriT": 13.557924552383765, + "Yices": 7.1459637586997324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0411308396227508, + "CVC4": 10.899557188549235, + "CVC3": 10.318179407880711, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.990335291664834, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.004438106081485 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.217302860234688, + "veriT": 7.3474657815378901, + "Yices": 13.201880988455697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.081667085536806, + "CVC4": 9.0326366210150457, + "CVC3": 12.461807969683194, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6027006358027052, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5623166827773431 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.93984666579823062, + "veriT": 2.2895271087961486, + "Yices": 2.9955501045557038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.056218515265323, + "CVC4": 4.2576685439575988, + "CVC3": 4.4962704570561938, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.93210837782561518, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.93103714347892308 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14180212194015385, + "veriT": 0.89146754948252294, + "Yices": 1.0278100567479231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13830757950538461, + "CVC4": 0.18452094979446151, + "CVC3": 0.13853477694292307, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1526347217693077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14858380253707693 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15627790528300001, + "veriT": 8.8099167626587107, + "Yices": 4.6184934055712779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1330393505339371, + "CVC4": 1.7271468801718493, + "CVC3": 0.16281640450322221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1147639426984179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.132551899937654 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1471119960763412, + "veriT": 9.3162135670349304, + "Yices": 7.8552815214510163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2718103250826642, + "CVC4": 2.605566634255744, + "CVC3": 2.0285462008073334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6157029622641552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.622977649305831 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.699829893540679, + "veriT": 10.586626076350516, + "Yices": 11.48533285590632, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4757461832553975, + "CVC4": 14.476535219805461, + "CVC3": 11.947932449087578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.703067769230822, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.833768878658697 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.615789532661438, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.660478576894956, + "veriT": 12.95169816490006, + "Yices": 13.629075611146204, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.30178612523445, + "CVC4": 7.2694756856479152, + "CVC3": 10.058723078650775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6239274574524494, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6099895150148837 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.48397209838436361, + "veriT": 7.4374990637099083, + "Yices": 7.5570230075751823, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.496660098988702, + "CVC4": 10.422109353876703, + "CVC3": 3.0531394376211964, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251349502902672, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.00453243024023 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.885485164941175, + "veriT": 12.693881253715215, + "Yices": 12.340172977226, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.482100531607715, + "CVC4": 14.678445303632142, + "CVC3": 13.576811685153217, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.956071886164723, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.844018743676173 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.891523303753168, + "veriT": 10.135718102309918, + "Yices": 10.271207826623167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.945556337025961, + "CVC4": 4.2058943941139342, + "CVC3": 9.4558623599334179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.882691459485899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.683894814847099 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20405273065383334, + "veriT": 11.525304280543546, + "Yices": 7.0498142358929776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4796315498655888, + "CVC4": 5.0480893670074964, + "CVC3": 5.7928415753313773, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5283659754499896, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1690961115017706 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.109333104383198, + "veriT": 13.540525723122906, + "Yices": 7.9159569379801944, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.057338168683595, + "CVC4": 1.5222352378271016, + "CVC3": 8.0876851545260067, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.885560783636032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.88020490624082 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 62.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9937499761581421, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9218150867386252, + "veriT": 0.15406365336962502, + "Yices": 0.15170555127375002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9217824838616253, + "CVC4": 1.9614096754161405, + "CVC3": 0.16703219439737502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17372750687037497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17156737960224999 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1715688705444336, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1473628066472, + "veriT": 5.2614343592811279, + "Yices": 1.1487290651122, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1540055486737, + "CVC4": 1.5861653628638097, + "CVC3": 0.1487842950686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19023584997350002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17893233376330003 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15135976860966666, + "veriT": 0.12685395701825, + "Yices": 0.14677852066625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15361535800991666, + "CVC4": 0.16641474116658331, + "CVC3": 0.14998846920225001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16203936328708332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16345132909849999 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7606002291145384, + "veriT": 0.925751942226123, + "Yices": 8.1624639432911508, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.053301483953077, + "CVC4": 0.97257380725946174, + "CVC3": 1.1388868588750769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19493171560299999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19162889499392308 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8400313509163908, + "veriT": 6.5146670163666265, + "Yices": 6.325519607572712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9085107388897367, + "CVC4": 8.4952126824852616, + "CVC3": 2.3984937493384915, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.248609413165767, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4646133586545664 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6980870246851976, + "veriT": 10.192308180115784, + "Yices": 5.0248229429310127, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9483311171394728, + "CVC4": 6.2261671607416504, + "CVC3": 7.1858182165295386, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2097024245398345, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.209057627189706 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 53.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.724683583997308, + "veriT": 8.9452530689329777, + "Yices": 10.696854222342049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.906251287092722, + "CVC4": 10.856970149522628, + "CVC3": 7.7516444839227496, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2391775344290519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1437572438617503 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9278968033644612, + "veriT": 12.267745137188095, + "Yices": 7.8381453833449228, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5509180154156272, + "CVC4": 10.465397179123036, + "CVC3": 3.1169479226711712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.884374673468542, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.79262281892998 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3293731337698027, + "veriT": 14.251705892872904, + "Yices": 8.2328977782059809, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3172981193753186, + "CVC4": 0.76039558776085714, + "CVC3": 0.69861580802357159, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22439868430814286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21861886921842857 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 194.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.219900106951034, + "veriT": 11.469375760109124, + "Yices": 12.37614888778973, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.490934566548336, + "CVC4": 13.866978720768765, + "CVC3": 11.682490713716682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.044996784662311, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.041094880397393 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.27433927083605, + "veriT": 10.222042083095584, + "Yices": 10.4185380392915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.995894695302219, + "CVC4": 14.310241095062958, + "CVC3": 14.275189993161788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.274780114362068, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.431488006308376 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 108.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.006872603765503, + "veriT": 11.513513745661562, + "Yices": 11.881352949881139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.389124575212213, + "CVC4": 14.507973241112859, + "CVC3": 13.357365058805298, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239754837605815, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.296105167944953 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2988246070595277, + "veriT": 13.647852240839816, + "Yices": 9.6821350614800625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.780356899749398, + "CVC4": 10.69514516088149, + "CVC3": 3.2501216279508962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.823666173768446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.844965319507596 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6269166934202133, + "veriT": 13.920750023697998, + "Yices": 13.46522738716096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.861725450341229, + "CVC4": 14.563288958841186, + "CVC3": 14.231373392763714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.029863943474185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.662985922157134 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4483692025859973, + "veriT": 11.699110158777616, + "Yices": 10.437369363509426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.699677460039938, + "CVC4": 11.904381882384046, + "CVC3": 9.3675908792042701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1019171201186575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7369024399867934 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25698940861533331, + "veriT": 10.291969035989679, + "Yices": 6.390479644861375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3316069243191686, + "CVC4": 6.6752166338650083, + "CVC3": 0.32472654568100001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5192191416780219, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5546616134797548 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.55299448223233327, + "veriT": 11.98965243017925, + "Yices": 2.5280283446255556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8565046047203104, + "CVC4": 0.69203639430200015, + "CVC3": 14.168035907239441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18761598142055555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7648731410547436 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6892316067343911, + "veriT": 14.221605185245204, + "Yices": 13.5070404478741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.470952792149133, + "CVC4": 11.849537174079, + "CVC3": 11.719818011315294, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.150478093121276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.124957983272083 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 152.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2484965131184973, + "veriT": 13.496032405664016, + "Yices": 13.747667324129791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.836096687223183, + "CVC4": 14.606610443722751, + "CVC3": 10.278880802579998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.622571478945135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.563424750723879 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.183029163101025, + "veriT": 12.7942256355692, + "Yices": 12.711688332670064, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.669090460925377, + "CVC4": 13.074820639992213, + "CVC3": 14.069263713919906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.273039266278348, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.200185524848729 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3820002543751908, + "veriT": 2.7726826829509426, + "Yices": 4.8760426343983641, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2329567359755575, + "CVC4": 4.3161426834268042, + "CVC3": 2.8619834042603993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.245639026542448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2645810463943272 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 320.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 600.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244714933035333, + "veriT": 13.729532058956838, + "Yices": 14.293314008911633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963974846358511, + "CVC4": 14.310972137534762, + "CVC3": 13.78377295607455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249008459102024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.246552162656963 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.756009894029102, + "veriT": 13.735349141779723, + "Yices": 13.900808788299816, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.413920696635232, + "CVC4": 14.432107111260985, + "CVC3": 13.888153031627764, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8878570877147496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5816602955819441 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.183178927489891, + "veriT": 13.414214414776939, + "Yices": 13.490955716529431, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.935711085765695, + "CVC4": 11.812861896617138, + "CVC3": 8.8410907703108457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0658429085595325, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0608244541465703 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.499173633600199, + "veriT": 11.783548982580022, + "Yices": 13.31412005494391, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.14037323954768, + "CVC4": 14.544243589814199, + "CVC3": 9.3603979975299207, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.172690999765363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.431492124095556 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259667545823584, + "veriT": 13.922479352453202, + "Yices": 13.631470656253372, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976248136991032, + "CVC4": 14.538795939424864, + "CVC3": 14.257307898491851, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.932169870997237, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.692014209115166 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 68.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12509621160026088, + "veriT": 0.096267125875373921, + "Yices": 0.097630853683291316, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12307683758969568, + "CVC4": 0.12422340701200001, + "CVC3": 0.10318350345461738, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1195984230432174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1200362926258261 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12076456531761109, + "veriT": 0.092524050238050007, + "Yices": 0.097101906532372217, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12054644390778889, + "CVC4": 0.11715784464550555, + "CVC3": 0.10027047962837778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11528894825265557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11666147516558888 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5786130774386669, + "veriT": 1.6532711418744956, + "Yices": 1.6660808783835448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5692321918586662, + "CVC4": 1.7760215777270505, + "CVC3": 1.6656432319254497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.684716406462748, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6839400748933846 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.2613635063171387, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3757574631369527, + "veriT": 10.168801494467887, + "Yices": 10.354211300721083, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5046741384680109, + "CVC4": 0.14979065081005555, + "CVC3": 0.6603501190647223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14786194313549997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.326154904464262 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1666665077209473, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4046354744240537, + "veriT": 3.9951926131602593, + "Yices": 4.7535944235100107, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1288553773028918, + "CVC4": 2.672756555379475, + "CVC3": 2.0749984852025314, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5260083454598297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9301030991553603 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.550225418837494, + "veriT": 8.9844371766386342, + "Yices": 10.491505437170817, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.263537139829479, + "CVC4": 3.6937176194186891, + "CVC3": 10.864998567731874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1198207865194556, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.028652242142778 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4871190024235226, + "veriT": 13.52947357580293, + "Yices": 11.841443354117295, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5766964279969375, + "CVC4": 14.849133444693082, + "CVC3": 11.645959133729264, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.574620747826676, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.591129249071152 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.367648512696773, + "veriT": 9.0894033908478296, + "Yices": 10.660983283625162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0318784524071649, + "CVC4": 13.546911851417395, + "CVC3": 8.4292470959878454, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8773322924922287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0379571784385515 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6810385262757919, + "veriT": 5.0569558671311663, + "Yices": 8.8759269788594892, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1072481820141338, + "CVC4": 7.3946606808498396, + "CVC3": 6.3454119069575787, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8700391600685524, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8849150806055199 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14396244633487501, + "veriT": 3.8671173894578499, + "Yices": 8.6881151053205485, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.164653176248375, + "CVC4": 5.5613337598817942, + "CVC3": 1.8954344952335926, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6552487880524804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13537227110512501 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6219022714712179, + "veriT": 3.0721431671079324, + "Yices": 6.8283126870654289, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7643505515651539, + "CVC4": 3.9645607938309753, + "CVC3": 3.0997075683982791, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1761265370662193, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4209936096320503 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.907932935881945, + "veriT": 10.165329323169001, + "Yices": 10.308670400766571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.361020949930735, + "CVC4": 0.15844224865014286, + "CVC3": 4.7289350193184614, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7604563142666445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.135676745177387 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.971991893571239, + "veriT": 10.1556119433425, + "Yices": 10.317276406768901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.946083519697819, + "CVC4": 0.1752878147528, + "CVC3": 10.245332470296114, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1439624567128, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.043274010113876 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238707105333699, + "veriT": 10.156544684117101, + "Yices": 10.3275575958421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958338990894253, + "CVC4": 0.22489354752350002, + "CVC3": 12.459587475639649, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3630302074969842, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.354643428275477 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243147491390182, + "veriT": 10.169785500357728, + "Yices": 10.349147104139091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966017034479963, + "CVC4": 0.16815567185836364, + "CVC3": 14.248633253094262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15114601175645453, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.321748213627279 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238633762887124, + "veriT": 10.161010889476428, + "Yices": 10.326414838500572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956195407539187, + "CVC4": 0.16738772651871425, + "CVC3": 13.655852446319999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4782308346331767, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.246135544355893 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.162813537958002, + "veriT": 10.167059524807875, + "Yices": 10.310671423098125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.945206036157122, + "CVC4": 0.86373095474337491, + "CVC3": 12.580863382296453, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.225947330290053, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.885642363644727 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6798951371351993, + "veriT": 12.252353559216557, + "Yices": 10.569984010481965, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.289439588632172, + "CVC4": 11.081074635393293, + "CVC3": 12.035348183620149, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5485764406967615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.473323337587848 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4078229851723432, + "veriT": 6.0089191142838549, + "Yices": 6.6643197944969881, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5248448267203063, + "CVC4": 3.1336541217332412, + "CVC3": 2.5406239959157704, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.894720083174068, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9360695821922409 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7342176969136023, + "veriT": 11.442477010384065, + "Yices": 9.9684240205272818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7473119339011647, + "CVC4": 11.12379069511967, + "CVC3": 3.4497579416618089, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.071160585493137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.077747852596538 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2333852993679564, + "veriT": 8.5389399917903841, + "Yices": 11.334336036802682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4988262490010236, + "CVC4": 6.305087588167841, + "CVC3": 5.8018367884469022, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2259171959727846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5983999781139921 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7710832124073272, + "veriT": 7.0932912464125337, + "Yices": 5.3838440416478797, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1960702022826739, + "CVC4": 0.37102772703359999, + "CVC3": 0.14542227093863999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3028577401099595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3583245215880124 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.902284926395033, + "veriT": 9.3542165344338652, + "Yices": 9.0557372346295502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5619418400439997, + "CVC4": 11.338845907551951, + "CVC3": 8.6417168930412096, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.360578775714306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.626560703860314 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.694835030371095, + "veriT": 11.309597029358811, + "Yices": 11.092467833818215, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.273326249851062, + "CVC4": 4.6993622823415802, + "CVC3": 14.947528898568885, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6027333156925891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.947151223059334 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.970524322919015, + "veriT": 11.037333702310203, + "Yices": 11.047741206200371, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.742417701003861, + "CVC4": 3.6127743746899976, + "CVC3": 13.192886914345006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9230790819415882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.678060308383504 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7736249771299981, + "veriT": 8.538935603509751, + "Yices": 8.4509575967004817, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.263114588407673, + "CVC4": 1.4056206464510426, + "CVC3": 2.3010755797222728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.405742386463899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.420918181557328 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.881522293056058, + "veriT": 4.5123431750499883, + "Yices": 5.0613630490812493, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8240984855174602, + "CVC4": 3.1869132424131368, + "CVC3": 2.5456962120391156, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6017005180901789, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7394207902359762 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5594207115042571, + "veriT": 10.168691105075411, + "Yices": 0.087510974397428581, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9308502026654286, + "CVC4": 0.11480174436114286, + "CVC3": 0.091273931246257142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11302639203478572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10967655088288571 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.424508637712667, + "veriT": 2.3299800935359776, + "Yices": 2.3381450647144444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4252023338233468, + "CVC4": 5.4947712405185927, + "CVC3": 5.0840271915367889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2616567525513416, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2595151538443177 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8499206568547333, + "veriT": 11.498476149345482, + "Yices": 12.217471386314514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.181173853742907, + "CVC4": 8.0065272343137064, + "CVC3": 11.737482076270652, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6468503281776803, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6787012847799101 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 148.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2503660903186113, + "veriT": 2.3353792828618776, + "Yices": 12.153625165082209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2619711992632332, + "CVC4": 10.909755132279766, + "CVC3": 8.2621992690944257, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7045624495739775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7031674346413024 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9400618532319935, + "veriT": 9.5052998543552381, + "Yices": 10.658356288103915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.887917090841517, + "CVC4": 10.358545374582672, + "CVC3": 5.5550894165512146, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0823574151291169, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4555348532270473 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7099904608889522, + "veriT": 7.9822872108457146, + "Yices": 9.7885622111244786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9325523838980851, + "CVC4": 8.5141406460567755, + "CVC3": 8.0678519456881705, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8208949283139084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5679790399708642 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22015185603992857, + "veriT": 0.84948635206430001, + "Yices": 5.998196811232317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.36779151989500009, + "CVC4": 0.2007037422658571, + "CVC3": 0.18391961954907141, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15602922027942859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15245114730328571 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5531025552142688, + "veriT": 8.9545548190644162, + "Yices": 10.945657360851285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6324828160124452, + "CVC4": 4.3957624568991154, + "CVC3": 8.8883939791898818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2666030802337715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.96774951050892 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1624995589867275, + "veriT": 11.669674871198831, + "Yices": 10.647120196205213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.142867113752319, + "CVC4": 3.2614417949230989, + "CVC3": 2.7086334943718078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0042458119109492, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3281170340938626 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1580040454864502, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18582921698092722, + "veriT": 4.4430394668941142, + "Yices": 5.8282501517404484, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34775507854388182, + "CVC4": 2.7644572307220185, + "CVC3": 0.17655849777258184, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.33999997148691818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.34001694473660909 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18776045118849996, + "veriT": 4.8839832788530559, + "Yices": 7.295901179410766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20767695023066665, + "CVC4": 7.393579480841372, + "CVC3": 8.4155467448016363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1964548034777378, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3634027369145327 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5634918482203974, + "veriT": 10.78112766125669, + "Yices": 7.6185213157430036, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3085713194581849, + "CVC4": 12.096952388293705, + "CVC3": 2.7818861641072101, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.369860204416067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.409822698187893 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0458003582049278, + "veriT": 11.494466116907173, + "Yices": 12.819842472626632, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2672266638399625, + "CVC4": 7.4748343980955472, + "CVC3": 7.5398950241000122, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9437608402573634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3823432650461829 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.669030006538589, + "veriT": 9.4943008085349039, + "Yices": 9.6743088219794355, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.404853278357644, + "CVC4": 6.2969519758596766, + "CVC3": 8.6428943181187456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9922096658170396, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0619457685667619 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.67634685805411, + "veriT": 12.220835383588994, + "Yices": 10.968011259857549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.693932578698796, + "CVC4": 13.159076218021744, + "CVC3": 13.448151774852349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.268874205465695, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.990430699764874 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0654906715285928, + "veriT": 9.0649097467777899, + "Yices": 9.2085576953410886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5263332772706137, + "CVC4": 12.697345738816137, + "CVC3": 2.810062875907283, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.686326678350799, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9391335010055268 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.914421127439792, + "veriT": 3.6262677943247419, + "Yices": 8.520286529971191, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.87743676377362501, + "CVC4": 3.8372220055013271, + "CVC3": 0.15228831408224999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4021311720106038, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4032707442527701 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 61.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13211123868225, + "veriT": 14.206119974474037, + "Yices": 0.21555326355087501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16702056561637499, + "CVC4": 0.16807979508312498, + "CVC3": 0.122824427759125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.397233718340306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.389881301467859 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5733574165325714, + "veriT": 14.212480263014859, + "Yices": 3.5899113553856972, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.749826397865857, + "CVC4": 4.3973551813901306, + "CVC3": 4.1579278239122903, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.028791025122484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.054413666055259 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14711787584181815, + "veriT": 11.437258424935182, + "Yices": 0.12426708267781819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14334089515945456, + "CVC4": 1.4982014299554216, + "CVC3": 1.4159000985097796, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7081391673505255, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7061709858448069 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.44925048316477778, + "veriT": 11.955293324128595, + "Yices": 13.41471945174515, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1732353250323939, + "CVC4": 14.569626736028921, + "CVC3": 12.730298121040336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242516938799504, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.244426428381864 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.838651688532944, + "veriT": 14.207987914139325, + "Yices": 12.660497841918676, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4518613025634544, + "CVC4": 5.1818056783443645, + "CVC3": 10.239745470750101, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.474059785503337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.39036947231086 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4357397741779867, + "veriT": 11.749027804494355, + "Yices": 9.6723091021373815, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7100530500394671, + "CVC4": 3.6964994507351463, + "CVC3": 1.7610867270356947, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0541455578680807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0137657074799202 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 55.0, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16070818041677776, + "veriT": 8.1990972030786491, + "Yices": 3.9423419300161715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25553291032766667, + "CVC4": 4.8623000522363258, + "CVC3": 3.2825086706292739, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6480081719813504, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6691428381773181 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 62.0, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16661967571347058, + "veriT": 0.15064110910064707, + "Yices": 0.15860899258452943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1825478493832941, + "CVC4": 0.18092215988988233, + "CVC3": 0.17377854583152941, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17528510460705882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17544115062429411 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1486586271619998, + "veriT": 5.5717306232895343, + "Yices": 0.13225799042040004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1578893710905001, + "CVC4": 1.5744796480748124, + "CVC3": 0.38034450931609998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14633051273280001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14787806831699998 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1793389159766496, + "veriT": 12.409860056206192, + "Yices": 7.7275740754598088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5982125695912703, + "CVC4": 8.7830827525750177, + "CVC3": 7.278375634728862, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6889373363831588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6812772181605302 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.132449596684788, + "veriT": 11.319088596825935, + "Yices": 10.533052701098084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.526850662385856, + "CVC4": 14.291626798288771, + "CVC3": 12.527788426638853, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243081725926521, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.435318764627782 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2027309449173714, + "veriT": 8.7926015210149266, + "Yices": 2.9974609298484713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27414174186099999, + "CVC4": 0.28947969103871429, + "CVC3": 3.9265021713435431, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.174691073687911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1738165171843269 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.688067751887127, + "veriT": 13.625104898866303, + "Yices": 12.57639047911057, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.900542474209637, + "CVC4": 3.649112344898704, + "CVC3": 3.9126047758286777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4369757082265178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0086474144672781 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4762491970169997, + "veriT": 13.666524938905072, + "Yices": 7.9081623098113383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4921868856599998, + "CVC4": 5.0577475603460336, + "CVC3": 8.442517679124327, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9625531184619485, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9011593305216428 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 190.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.214108215137664, + "veriT": 9.8903901836834347, + "Yices": 9.710030075318004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.493012282092677, + "CVC4": 9.4348952682918377, + "CVC3": 7.8142409452728536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5517939865711483, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5298023380676327 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.232776770806904, + "veriT": 12.614284448739983, + "Yices": 12.114409452718609, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951868901691663, + "CVC4": 14.410828198907272, + "CVC3": 13.904497237622115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.102594293945572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.5706265351045 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 197.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.250916022333561, + "veriT": 10.504497617030605, + "Yices": 10.620378724593708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967596135679976, + "CVC4": 14.54670219773528, + "CVC3": 12.543395065831168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247549841035733, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.575482491012542 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.181482049591303, + "veriT": 12.158074072638957, + "Yices": 10.766248341575118, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.978448581975053, + "CVC4": 10.501610923230629, + "CVC3": 14.266016706632168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.217824765332926, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.017172669700059 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 53.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 272.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0420004323713306, + "veriT": 13.78061321185694, + "Yices": 13.631934809053057, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948723234969524, + "CVC4": 14.358895012864942, + "CVC3": 14.227993058089529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.817953975743443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.81774495739371 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.457274058046394, + "veriT": 13.207237867217133, + "Yices": 12.994589753637463, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954307703026371, + "CVC4": 14.454769213667847, + "CVC3": 13.103543303550813, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243293980168344, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.829263222857975 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1940987758034289, + "veriT": 14.244009731419915, + "Yices": 12.732515037249387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.936589903023879, + "CVC4": 13.44047208139421, + "CVC3": 12.955385295043561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.982035818985734, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.985555313638207 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7965749587488666, + "veriT": 9.617476659634244, + "Yices": 11.028818387943753, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4590783892529977, + "CVC4": 7.6373135391434479, + "CVC3": 5.3149478600021194, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.880407020689985, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.897543039799535 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 635.0, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.690757636982951, + "veriT": 14.23049670044788, + "Yices": 14.235619864776558, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954424308296435, + "CVC4": 13.041165928387368, + "CVC3": 13.937659633817438, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7294365121739723, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7860915981153163 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 83.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 98.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26420601713979, + "veriT": 11.945735475067035, + "Yices": 13.636183671548196, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.010041742666045, + "CVC4": 14.49282627736387, + "CVC3": 13.484108864892534, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.140454733024553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.710234794686395 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.276554840456742, + "veriT": 14.269872815851086, + "Yices": 13.711019569022231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.994463779879055, + "CVC4": 14.716638627175428, + "CVC3": 13.671397918200357, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.281858003483197, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.281396031794142 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.106567904371591, + "veriT": 14.230112298666171, + "Yices": 14.230616662034777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.623437692894253, + "CVC4": 14.58883440649838, + "CVC3": 12.71427473531527, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.097213033732752, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.163462050888976 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.420329738381565, + "veriT": 12.513388496360392, + "Yices": 10.618457995420425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.40878060790744, + "CVC4": 12.187790824468101, + "CVC3": 10.455953395390354, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8049712684715553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.378881689596934 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13412380751878947, + "veriT": 1.1499471815242264, + "Yices": 1.1496348274028736, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15110648244715791, + "CVC4": 1.6071803054105112, + "CVC3": 0.10179024131137368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6040108805706759, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6023095062549502 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3074780679404281, + "veriT": 0.08043652233352, + "Yices": 0.081401715789279988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3083940273450878, + "CVC4": 0.10591503376605199, + "CVC3": 0.085482650490228004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10521545356923599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.104699565271424 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7016193939218205, + "veriT": 3.8515585618360775, + "Yices": 5.0607632726841585, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8708315787638203, + "CVC4": 4.9346344744906032, + "CVC3": 1.3480389743167958, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3600481005812275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.384707046961372 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2043693588160882, + "veriT": 9.5719841409464124, + "Yices": 9.7515045426122366, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26047479775594118, + "CVC4": 0.15036132762544113, + "CVC3": 0.62616673698782355, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14631768861482355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.302260144767406 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4857641565312729, + "veriT": 11.642008724704606, + "Yices": 11.749527508780044, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3262308749364546, + "CVC4": 12.522308631614321, + "CVC3": 8.7576803889357269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225797291930883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.690506929800785 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4920635223388672, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8866605477144711, + "veriT": 4.6004613259980003, + "Yices": 6.9539863290944446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5472543253780451, + "CVC4": 0.15884466794433333, + "CVC3": 4.0553693296205564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15676753511811115, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6530909002916117 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7333334684371948, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.873156384281096, + "veriT": 10.535887396260984, + "Yices": 10.473490545011636, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.526943097181386, + "CVC4": 1.5034745382408767, + "CVC3": 10.051080679816002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4500791849134647, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.644725456274205 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.552688177710106, + "veriT": 10.274751958560406, + "Yices": 10.31700589409478, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.747466863575092, + "CVC4": 1.0602517811175651, + "CVC3": 9.3082036490174911, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0429795349854052, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.503686039105533 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.253129242655946, + "veriT": 8.7348519973992858, + "Yices": 10.332097855738429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.872376152503815, + "CVC4": 0.17049595784071428, + "CVC3": 11.188649016531631, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.229641976494767, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.28539540802012 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9166665077209473, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.253029249960953, + "veriT": 10.202488789543777, + "Yices": 10.361564284469887, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974131669292584, + "CVC4": 0.17891257500977778, + "CVC3": 14.260194127850045, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16484852637700001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.381828816995053 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.169413669326312, + "veriT": 11.899629746243823, + "Yices": 7.6466359227336813, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.905713907246087, + "CVC4": 2.2219277690200925, + "CVC3": 8.3996716197358534, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1491154106038599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7561194537843967 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8234092764801253, + "veriT": 9.2885283263871674, + "Yices": 10.020169966095372, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1445507718649113, + "CVC4": 7.6071063698244865, + "CVC3": 7.1952754337002274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6929240895900213, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5576732665465611 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7759608960623705, + "veriT": 8.9042241236284543, + "Yices": 5.851938409941531, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3561385935417447, + "CVC4": 1.5208292962825183, + "CVC3": 4.5357402646616123, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1061453455828403, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6160776430618888 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3394107166046032, + "veriT": 12.351253449905149, + "Yices": 12.179596855530212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.730228126842559, + "CVC4": 6.931594677490728, + "CVC3": 10.43073495239369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.935640550875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.894485057584236 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9166665077209473, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6590006198428862, + "veriT": 7.4173721496653036, + "Yices": 8.6515111732472008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7089390333057297, + "CVC4": 10.21655975343597, + "CVC3": 6.6668185335659071, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.006203225474355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7057867490845009 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3076656622024299, + "veriT": 3.569602615261271, + "Yices": 1.520481916701357, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4235653900609142, + "CVC4": 4.238616723480761, + "CVC3": 2.108717490217757, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5384300998704858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5381961081440141 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0715036741493946, + "veriT": 0.77891698084624683, + "Yices": 3.6119032078327562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.115312682659505, + "CVC4": 0.14172274226326667, + "CVC3": 0.19826733943128003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13329132809700001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.88062647555677509 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13479974523924998, + "veriT": 5.9401583010383163, + "Yices": 8.2934100966296942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13214698930383331, + "CVC4": 0.14152307454158333, + "CVC3": 0.12064029392216667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13458362141341665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13327998584824999 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5227274894714355, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.460514010808259, + "veriT": 14.200954200241183, + "Yices": 9.4365581253926329, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.367504671641299, + "CVC4": 14.587375627480965, + "CVC3": 12.287676903828849, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.229804878418113, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230158973782478 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.52535166059883331, + "veriT": 11.341512002054555, + "Yices": 10.599493771563518, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5682166886412183, + "CVC4": 7.1131191062776677, + "CVC3": 2.6557290285273472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3928139418695515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4053195555410856 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.478237566719411, + "veriT": 11.656336434687324, + "Yices": 11.063776813843115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.359369461744226, + "CVC4": 5.1012766852599949, + "CVC3": 12.0466552380202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.485041621225044, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.112046692546459 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.027100146185035, + "veriT": 14.216408362418004, + "Yices": 11.760169071370889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.633487893644533, + "CVC4": 14.696346510962208, + "CVC3": 13.59187969130809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.149945964974519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.145149397725895 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1793263459462997, + "veriT": 10.002593509577576, + "Yices": 12.790010567780087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2897852612604996, + "CVC4": 13.1693477028772, + "CVC3": 13.481018941602816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8939692960866097, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9330760117215355 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.723326320917231, + "veriT": 11.43196985624221, + "Yices": 10.50504644666092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.571784173432691, + "CVC4": 8.2005283895177641, + "CVC3": 2.9434364286271189, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4251671117779852, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4957787771117976 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4583334922790527, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1124999523162842, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4697803529432334, + "veriT": 4.1506085748593078, + "Yices": 1.7932292173479834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.072268186671967, + "CVC4": 1.795720038821, + "CVC3": 0.18051996478543331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12496162769628334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12571004363668334 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.589898170139131, + "veriT": 8.5812151703305979, + "Yices": 10.476775550742683, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0289914062029943, + "CVC4": 8.550026764122876, + "CVC3": 5.7736895916076296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.980650881170229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.995225455448736 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14724161878642855, + "veriT": 2.987872778306957, + "Yices": 3.5771046275798439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15064246328342853, + "CVC4": 0.15798885730614284, + "CVC3": 0.15976935495738573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15198254122042856, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14715665816085716 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6928705441042857, + "veriT": 8.4776766531790884, + "Yices": 9.9715994110890893, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3649834309352435, + "CVC4": 12.453857217080651, + "CVC3": 10.63493170341685, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.224389310906092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0480288362262424 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.371126190123196, + "veriT": 10.141689092350781, + "Yices": 11.310998522432898, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.644114932422038, + "CVC4": 8.0201390826114416, + "CVC3": 9.2136438228966764, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.066863302802041, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.723454845686858 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8698007213414445, + "veriT": 7.4839617399212157, + "Yices": 10.379195794950542, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0099376437193612, + "CVC4": 6.1797873541226176, + "CVC3": 2.973479355303136, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0372384404039954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2702095678383909 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1607289645097998, + "veriT": 4.3496408637247397, + "Yices": 4.7317306452609005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1873917814392998, + "CVC4": 0.18595801039669999, + "CVC3": 6.7264338800605596, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5747322411773448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5739956423941828 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.800778053970012, + "veriT": 9.1274731788171231, + "Yices": 10.065831521562258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.732610494311606, + "CVC4": 3.5272642844124307, + "CVC3": 4.9961169484100481, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3078088885266528, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3040014293689399 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13334900585414286, + "veriT": 6.1514290518008723, + "Yices": 0.11354966942657142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12965224438614284, + "CVC4": 0.15468373639685715, + "CVC3": 0.11980867425114286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1455368830825488, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1478543551929508 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.477236028503625, + "veriT": 13.700131452544577, + "Yices": 1.8794549737605455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.259356341784883, + "CVC4": 2.0444982527013518, + "CVC3": 1.5635227267015401, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.106714300636737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.698619232803704 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 40.0, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2028122668502288, + "veriT": 9.0253775584038713, + "Yices": 13.44061039708861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.609539731932049, + "CVC4": 8.4196672268266006, + "CVC3": 11.766841939266227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.265899249590078, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.230901330072868 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9164054197944234, + "veriT": 10.975737899525456, + "Yices": 10.662026733816818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4971433562222121, + "CVC4": 4.9990919151170017, + "CVC3": 12.001078058853816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9086379300943335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2844885638141639 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4620034851392223, + "veriT": 4.8063584093171325, + "Yices": 7.943273432882445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6048969396266668, + "CVC4": 4.0411261049675273, + "CVC3": 2.9638151764435152, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8694239196646452, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8653859304233178 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25521043701577778, + "veriT": 0.91944130584293327, + "Yices": 4.9233022105503146, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.52833687172744459, + "CVC4": 0.25698306413622224, + "CVC3": 3.7094999102774446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7389724850419634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7377416010476301 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1578263667824, + "veriT": 0.13963927214412, + "Yices": 0.15188362023893337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15003243150200002, + "CVC4": 0.18551998005013334, + "CVC3": 0.15209783493753332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17299977512699999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16603348492459999 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1788999643759919, + "veriT": 11.07861246990084, + "Yices": 4.2005033639980907, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3090076433055975, + "CVC4": 7.2449422644090786, + "CVC3": 6.694356488824531, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5217147974733347, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2018764521708682 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26633046154019996, + "veriT": 2.2213302085816, + "Yices": 10.301723448952856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.48986715480493337, + "CVC4": 0.2607461689094, + "CVC3": 1.1893943991154574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1802384629102947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1785682449305457 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1777393554692317, + "veriT": 6.6961116969754526, + "Yices": 10.53156354079268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4486856371178645, + "CVC4": 12.694129119332578, + "CVC3": 7.225620195627477, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7312977573402293, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.049666405085308 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1678595509037399, + "veriT": 1.8651828100572219, + "Yices": 1.7195066303585216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.217662289935262, + "CVC4": 0.20051969490900001, + "CVC3": 1.0897060356928643, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16608686499731432, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7484622578837814 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1715688705444336, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23939454051856254, + "veriT": 7.9839095325951543, + "Yices": 0.1659590059301875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1066722593640623, + "CVC4": 0.20318440087318751, + "CVC3": 0.18122772886656247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17566814058968749, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17583895896431248 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15644932709712497, + "veriT": 0.13215228862999998, + "Yices": 0.15048075814287501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15948474935649998, + "CVC4": 0.17399508375200001, + "CVC3": 0.15459877345924999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.168257505564125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16860267965324999 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0952915536310295, + "veriT": 10.468196772732886, + "Yices": 10.87343136986923, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5692939088379854, + "CVC4": 12.557888510698557, + "CVC3": 4.0933513701674533, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.378045791259179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.178396763738654 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7861230373382568, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16234866158416669, + "veriT": 7.1638742592918518, + "Yices": 2.1792195220064943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21379655329216671, + "CVC4": 2.7405898845784744, + "CVC3": 0.17947953828899998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7951023414552467, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7944743805132699 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0140685153979168, + "veriT": 13.883084763998616, + "Yices": 7.8569614349844992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2669190900758334, + "CVC4": 3.9147889750338791, + "CVC3": 8.3688116298682491, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.661480333655225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.652787959988638 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6597985092629042, + "veriT": 14.219457303845383, + "Yices": 13.096700086944132, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.376912396502137, + "CVC4": 12.155945352914408, + "CVC3": 4.9884754436914784, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.224631669581974, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.228129314898627 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.787994252306005, + "veriT": 12.974705104434413, + "Yices": 10.01314690298323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.9502988868002, + "CVC4": 11.035473071595483, + "CVC3": 12.938272208308186, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8709357025218178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.197188513136128 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9545035362243652, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1342258469954549, + "veriT": 9.3027319779363165, + "Yices": 5.049538255977418, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4798824068392822, + "CVC4": 10.318396183870705, + "CVC3": 9.846882511222173, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.318021728885018, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3466315261067425 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0682068612633122, + "veriT": 4.9574447506799002, + "Yices": 2.7978949948798864, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2139515555856, + "CVC4": 7.2210827201979289, + "CVC3": 0.26302917554802502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19976359798626253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.175630246970675 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1922196736791504, + "veriT": 9.5104157902104003, + "Yices": 8.3119300004668304, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5748194658621957, + "CVC4": 4.4635541088913309, + "CVC3": 4.6396925449587352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2757177031793647, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2969252031345135 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20445847028499997, + "veriT": 3.4876047679017557, + "Yices": 8.6802886138561686, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9204731637013335, + "CVC4": 13.024701636055207, + "CVC3": 4.7218957579552221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9034933975887864, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8774562233952614 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9450869560241699, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7160055637359619, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2283571389644017, + "veriT": 8.8878333639394977, + "Yices": 7.3794428588029231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3190682448763518, + "CVC4": 8.5406214219780665, + "CVC3": 5.098046242261554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3476807041523706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1733359744627574 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9266503839667628, + "veriT": 13.730160347745359, + "Yices": 11.922733148807309, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.467228012374353, + "CVC4": 6.5385814329007133, + "CVC3": 8.3674630535811527, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.975040866052174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.916594440522861 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8339979648590088, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.663120128993093, + "veriT": 10.916734839414588, + "Yices": 11.087714141525531, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.999445998756132, + "CVC4": 14.446775573680446, + "CVC3": 12.029107359607265, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.282933966839588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5736245964938167 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.252732120702664, + "veriT": 10.776253199600148, + "Yices": 11.024265079672901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977349725428839, + "CVC4": 14.382617814231594, + "CVC3": 14.255282646312841, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252887450881445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.663631968631281 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 117.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.230253630884242, + "veriT": 14.230272047629624, + "Yices": 13.191022187129271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.356263853454532, + "CVC4": 14.623191864689799, + "CVC3": 14.226970654149124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249159745606111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.245768608671565 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8826594643308079, + "veriT": 14.22179137341343, + "Yices": 13.350626368137585, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1851379871207914, + "CVC4": 11.271444839418143, + "CVC3": 10.811187819770744, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236823837356123, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237725863826 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 100.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7745020786221173, + "veriT": 11.803530627479221, + "Yices": 8.371987104615437, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2758888848816836, + "CVC4": 11.708879205791574, + "CVC3": 5.2963899292158096, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2611273566217918, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9999644260173932 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 96.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234813040837842, + "veriT": 10.15418467610575, + "Yices": 10.774010187398721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.949395627390668, + "CVC4": 14.254858696173338, + "CVC3": 12.79896864828558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.226406656495312, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.885231694037728 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7472848437231718, + "veriT": 13.012617771911929, + "Yices": 11.950182233074958, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.386051309455326, + "CVC4": 4.9883041056049073, + "CVC3": 5.3497711220347242, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1541475924018476, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4594528922913037 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 263.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0847611427307129, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.59025273109066667, + "veriT": 8.3539407739436076, + "Yices": 8.3698310053001794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.85721827520758342, + "CVC4": 8.4096772097998933, + "CVC3": 0.41936072383066669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3762727521628566, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3745542910811157 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1584529663817804, + "veriT": 7.1828044760972531, + "Yices": 0.87357071873728986, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3726639817424999, + "CVC4": 0.51623888027000009, + "CVC3": 7.0907718514354796, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15191902408683999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14829577356353002 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8984076786230784, + "veriT": 11.640758422219763, + "Yices": 11.719332168786293, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.060374043074448, + "CVC4": 8.2973210819818188, + "CVC3": 9.3684648729424413, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5100431579730098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5409723150827435 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3156633632824155, + "veriT": 11.532484947538315, + "Yices": 12.96746773976796, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5921245555880432, + "CVC4": 14.74795294881433, + "CVC3": 13.914558228920393, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.616667997575044, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.61758690879782 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7539012993090228, + "veriT": 13.229225603386368, + "Yices": 14.241129044396157, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975005988148137, + "CVC4": 14.386885482619713, + "CVC3": 8.7117531652390987, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.795165517298129, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.809678724118445 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.954806803741905, + "veriT": 14.27014085555709, + "Yices": 14.153997765127114, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.004855372099508, + "CVC4": 14.583364461671735, + "CVC3": 13.508200640865129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.029114882077147, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.039381913597424 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239514032358665, + "veriT": 14.235183618009124, + "Yices": 13.631846707035921, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957477843947732, + "CVC4": 14.76063492987493, + "CVC3": 14.255154301543486, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.262959528028174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.353609666847836 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.44314252050328, + "veriT": 11.889952612572376, + "Yices": 12.486281222882933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.543070705900419, + "CVC4": 14.409682325546914, + "CVC3": 13.856050938911006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.266814682580929, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.034118878607085 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 36.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.291928570159094, + "veriT": 14.235863636160378, + "Yices": 14.243737727207387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968825508874399, + "CVC4": 14.398332401257449, + "CVC3": 12.825633757815627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.515366905006267, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.51564430703297 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.489397868374688, + "veriT": 12.727006947471347, + "Yices": 12.747588329007472, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.196016152902818, + "CVC4": 12.829503447058018, + "CVC3": 7.7597192360216667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5677405086903751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9516978310455433 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11552807519888125, + "veriT": 0.087078407801668742, + "Yices": 0.091010366704843734, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11330906979800001, + "CVC4": 0.11145814865359373, + "CVC3": 0.09422363664813127, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11036810562745623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11131582697458124 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12771981031487997, + "veriT": 0.098925164899732007, + "Yices": 0.101879892850952, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12332978467916002, + "CVC4": 0.12618258680711997, + "CVC3": 0.10259376953970001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12334194096655998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12067695366465601 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5337223828665287, + "veriT": 1.1122773237090291, + "Yices": 0.91005684319962987, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6042365503521943, + "CVC4": 1.5471108785877263, + "CVC3": 0.11427639198063, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13342420937240002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13276231409120001 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4270890615551506, + "veriT": 2.2981557730961604, + "Yices": 3.2510957528900817, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4827574190583819, + "CVC4": 1.4920470962993138, + "CVC3": 2.6832477222055422, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4150684309312482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7103138964557458 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.59154191375072884, + "veriT": 9.3263738856023863, + "Yices": 9.4986471054117487, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.68368892217193711, + "CVC4": 0.15008633199227775, + "CVC3": 0.56467244348602774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14799714953949997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1683969736888464 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1769005447877632, + "veriT": 12.504927913861167, + "Yices": 11.551430109049468, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9734609091908393, + "CVC4": 13.15620304934891, + "CVC3": 9.0951380951057743, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.046096465021385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.010407900158468 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.41428542137146, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4798736091876599, + "veriT": 6.1515636108184006, + "Yices": 9.053991352553119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8050576648626446, + "CVC4": 0.16604269096779997, + "CVC3": 3.489976394859899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15133742623159999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7071907045445815 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7888889312744141, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239395373911501, + "veriT": 10.186050464108572, + "Yices": 10.330181473470285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955571389307876, + "CVC4": 0.15647863958514283, + "CVC3": 11.724753977599065, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3623427486835746, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.286534619019799 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24322727105938, + "veriT": 10.15925505347486, + "Yices": 10.341081118351001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961682808170789, + "CVC4": 0.159478964024, + "CVC3": 12.475687500734717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18891541620850003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.380834838116844 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.778291993862007, + "veriT": 10.948613984033205, + "Yices": 10.628885454873352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.030874697480824, + "CVC4": 3.0171798872307294, + "CVC3": 11.403360810423575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9492163764734043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6288735735854694 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240676164606334, + "veriT": 10.169281929566417, + "Yices": 10.323382626421417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95507574507644, + "CVC4": 0.17024924558516671, + "CVC3": 11.379220989296073, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.72013178176511, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.254431689212469 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.936317509090379, + "veriT": 10.202407929440666, + "Yices": 10.315549479900112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953663074886622, + "CVC4": 1.3583521607497779, + "CVC3": 11.95318216942675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1227813856449238, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.230646636522916 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.169389428964543, + "veriT": 11.728620120339791, + "Yices": 10.564236999683994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.53082762882643, + "CVC4": 13.57473297528972, + "CVC3": 13.205195004325816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.417312384620597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.39119273193652 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.424422024910311, + "veriT": 6.3971833949582493, + "Yices": 9.1023368678588721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4009239358339443, + "CVC4": 0.51184866721112499, + "CVC3": 8.9512018105702928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5740385653431606, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3844424034308584 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13891498387258336, + "veriT": 6.6144334275926768, + "Yices": 7.3107529239473061, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19344192540266666, + "CVC4": 3.8356435554460684, + "CVC3": 2.497506627051874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3037772236035829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3032452773819829 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6730204820632935, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2803868021026639, + "veriT": 5.9127895042104281, + "Yices": 7.4786831955605715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5329347574867338, + "CVC4": 0.30040078809699999, + "CVC3": 2.4583286430103368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1730578627322235, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.392154178945379 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1535891346721092, + "veriT": 13.195981552657686, + "Yices": 9.0605464208972872, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3948284360795324, + "CVC4": 8.4747868231865677, + "CVC3": 10.22005327996014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.717750685211758, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.739628266054584 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.203577303014079, + "veriT": 9.6562213782866984, + "Yices": 8.3444910251139408, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.293403607329564, + "CVC4": 7.4612286696198513, + "CVC3": 7.1576168878221695, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9368582887591028, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9320553315219549 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1464273894902233, + "veriT": 7.4843934392470262, + "Yices": 10.090234530095527, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2006236569369384, + "CVC4": 7.4564311864145614, + "CVC3": 3.9098711887831263, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8082191307567461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4546343512238193 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9662195114320908, + "veriT": 4.5098912242831926, + "Yices": 3.7643064848197798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9666231654435451, + "CVC4": 1.49333977598358, + "CVC3": 1.9635757423599998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4270155304901146, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4298542330992066 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.137397487511423, + "veriT": 0.82699343735858577, + "Yices": 0.84274527709484282, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1786990216209412, + "CVC4": 0.15133649434349999, + "CVC3": 0.20863330036915714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1817252205599286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.97299692324834475 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5227274894714355, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4474109459163325, + "veriT": 12.176150909181107, + "Yices": 7.965770067692576, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.561518361582371, + "CVC4": 12.585672144419046, + "CVC3": 9.6956967852765192, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.090348999945139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.10422210717495 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.799053128445113, + "veriT": 14.23695607540667, + "Yices": 13.704871674709509, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.342458840357427, + "CVC4": 13.720421082897934, + "CVC3": 10.935427983056236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.446777112812038, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.442221703937387 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.48694085535864, + "veriT": 9.8954474200386731, + "Yices": 8.811460799765257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.889834458439962, + "CVC4": 0.15634531869757143, + "CVC3": 11.274201834274104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6160267602749387, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.002972026310516 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8564105033874512, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.277173341860812, + "veriT": 8.842330666798647, + "Yices": 9.6447744354037717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5443977401669899, + "CVC4": 4.2409030777149246, + "CVC3": 5.2837510753033916, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17677289337845453, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1972887003207147 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.555531651417811, + "veriT": 11.507654248174291, + "Yices": 9.0516762971310509, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.836700106587948, + "CVC4": 4.9720299629017557, + "CVC3": 12.400964780809986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8523339667399945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.544332388021736 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.936107011470851, + "veriT": 12.734696784626486, + "Yices": 12.937319457493167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.549173159636588, + "CVC4": 9.451531124169847, + "CVC3": 14.411189841285307, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.040006637167995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.098367629598698 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2215768830249916, + "veriT": 11.869692277492385, + "Yices": 13.376931644437169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6269996202099426, + "CVC4": 4.455551858048314, + "CVC3": 5.8218096376251198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7090496824268024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9046571593318617 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1828998534276005, + "veriT": 6.020993405187105, + "Yices": 11.929184494042246, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1753418633738999, + "CVC4": 5.9855061227542077, + "CVC3": 8.8566772124579192, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0432935206003227, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.041380443835076 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2327844521810167, + "veriT": 14.19607501123807, + "Yices": 7.1367000290541585, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2975967724124997, + "CVC4": 7.2164120921387429, + "CVC3": 6.5671507533803188, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9407053864501442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.987266568078212 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9437537982751376, + "veriT": 9.577035702134852, + "Yices": 10.419959400199884, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0381756133758966, + "CVC4": 12.192662478767888, + "CVC3": 9.2747649664764005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.121053768204392, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.512424242131166 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2202899736766915, + "veriT": 10.334399793892945, + "Yices": 6.2844071160789037, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4903617296801093, + "CVC4": 1.2556700668243352, + "CVC3": 3.40516568069076, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2271787523293267, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1830783429068576 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2485152111059783, + "veriT": 9.3429114297950449, + "Yices": 9.354196940955676, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.670291217508721, + "CVC4": 8.1055309611349582, + "CVC3": 4.2470624049711834, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.146999962140391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.917014891942642 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4324715137481689, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1869277177909092, + "veriT": 3.2197774775391816, + "Yices": 10.501417503873025, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0947930755679098, + "CVC4": 8.9025719962263352, + "CVC3": 4.8977131191796879, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.130015688183347, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1290252494320026 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5870209611398325, + "veriT": 7.0394562123805278, + "Yices": 8.0746293050639988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5846747607070117, + "CVC4": 5.9838444833114455, + "CVC3": 4.881029986610594, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4082470484984064, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4046524551962323 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13628689528272728, + "veriT": 2.8419502661000093, + "Yices": 5.4130365989699021, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13272148655481819, + "CVC4": 0.15970492486654544, + "CVC3": 2.2934566557389093, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9858787646613152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9862090364135976 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8238645654610774, + "veriT": 10.517708772699274, + "Yices": 10.570012626429506, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.070435147672073, + "CVC4": 7.7191929293453114, + "CVC3": 5.324219601007667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1931356133709174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.401391352390524 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3263805816527054, + "veriT": 3.2123627229865352, + "Yices": 9.5359586073251972, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9173678413681765, + "CVC4": 9.5713782624716295, + "CVC3": 7.8371485049013909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17506212345917646, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1696555502135294 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.22861508818203, + "veriT": 10.342102371744586, + "Yices": 11.677490389506483, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.170836836824547, + "CVC4": 10.436887149539674, + "CVC3": 12.47822649663139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7487831855063938, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.738995225708345 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5375656936734279, + "veriT": 7.5728544372889619, + "Yices": 5.0627456657882854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3871042800061417, + "CVC4": 12.531787262425013, + "CVC3": 1.8514195239615714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.218823914636889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.218356824811659 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 36.0, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.89242478259433344, + "veriT": 8.4995515182266672, + "Yices": 6.9375475284375332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5871681075217232, + "CVC4": 9.5684549438736131, + "CVC3": 3.1499200079577192, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5390531490423136, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.541661003278187 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5028666844832923, + "veriT": 10.219700973843, + "Yices": 10.349968731043699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.516134299179237, + "CVC4": 14.282162112586287, + "CVC3": 7.5504549146934696, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254582586524952, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.608874499215737 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.141766897158, + "veriT": 14.207951290800006, + "Yices": 0.13963024917830771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23459314370407691, + "CVC4": 2.4333159626799747, + "CVC3": 0.12430756961846154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7165903028366625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7326108944962222 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22588218632877777, + "veriT": 13.755147392206675, + "Yices": 7.4115557927719697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0711589845538887, + "CVC4": 5.943076758697865, + "CVC3": 8.0057669371494793, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.657728642705004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.659495891408479 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7997691361263737, + "veriT": 14.207449658050599, + "Yices": 13.523466437211875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.741413574424097, + "CVC4": 10.949118146011408, + "CVC3": 10.813665191029601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.224843037094677, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.226160545808817 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8957325220108032, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2944091912575901, + "veriT": 9.4690714577331416, + "Yices": 9.1650162232265142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9718075536427619, + "CVC4": 10.308871571480781, + "CVC3": 9.890065187247993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.298752918178113, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.171077867069972 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2126032863468943, + "veriT": 9.1276406657171911, + "Yices": 9.5153415160861616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2416683601762735, + "CVC4": 8.6886794523158084, + "CVC3": 7.2018346264656756, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6997524137421838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7000850940434162 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 71.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15767580934333331, + "veriT": 0.13904939699500002, + "Yices": 0.15473092396222221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15470778182511113, + "CVC4": 0.17310554192077776, + "CVC3": 0.15829569879544444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16470283302377778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16674498732222223 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14885815778433334, + "veriT": 11.610181882827666, + "Yices": 0.16018891277683336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16344545526500001, + "CVC4": 0.17244347576133334, + "CVC3": 0.14820021408850001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15224647753766668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15307978894716667 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 34.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17493076113544445, + "veriT": 0.15176619643277778, + "Yices": 0.1629679875051111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17755859806077778, + "CVC4": 0.20838011294377776, + "CVC3": 0.17824121286255556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18819948323211111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18684985960277775 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15313846020516667, + "veriT": 0.13001886312416666, + "Yices": 0.14570831523858332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15480069745508332, + "CVC4": 0.17013933310633333, + "CVC3": 0.15143967393733335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16654087977858331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16576396990991668 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 96.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23083266076962497, + "veriT": 0.20043965160475, + "Yices": 7.3535181180598412, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.45750029261937508, + "CVC4": 0.2334813311765, + "CVC3": 0.21799373786437498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21675396028499999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.214539581510125 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1760003994993276, + "veriT": 7.0394748538044256, + "Yices": 10.509403974733328, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.291865932835035, + "CVC4": 4.3264786393592871, + "CVC3": 4.5383242621887536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1650089953080469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4732569876231691 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 44.0, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6313444984296117, + "veriT": 8.0944780763790511, + "Yices": 6.3338218089915621, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8078690736393468, + "CVC4": 3.672515568220208, + "CVC3": 0.10115257738231251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4421917829113458, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4641085855106191 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6862608604244929, + "veriT": 0.78735847924633751, + "Yices": 2.6317375898722912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6735652768911509, + "CVC4": 5.6011322820377254, + "CVC3": 1.5074517596795001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19010407099264998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18312030007629998 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4828859398347891, + "veriT": 11.039135084949834, + "Yices": 9.8899157086445548, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.723541487451552, + "CVC4": 11.707667672267117, + "CVC3": 7.6865627801835847, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2521945112074468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2442041942803401 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0009554682876249, + "veriT": 10.435863776813552, + "Yices": 7.4789772392138474, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.966595552398786, + "CVC4": 5.570067412675499, + "CVC3": 1.6358511376689997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.273922412003573, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.499429302871988 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9615789651870728, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6759259700775146, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8913228312895844, + "veriT": 10.758308565644768, + "Yices": 8.8291533716246722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.106493588635775, + "CVC4": 11.048692661422722, + "CVC3": 7.3051828793759448, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.262831477853549, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.276109808668629 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 72.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5741593559827747, + "veriT": 13.644230303799418, + "Yices": 12.277954668355843, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.21237998653287, + "CVC4": 8.951856392231873, + "CVC3": 9.7070417655146635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.145068198137698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.76148425361529 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.027727484335664, + "veriT": 11.453678104187695, + "Yices": 11.277468059747227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979493772490914, + "CVC4": 13.617988424884354, + "CVC3": 13.410890388011955, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252241637643662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.788688206664276 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.481113981791558, + "veriT": 12.692618068971832, + "Yices": 13.839769699407519, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.771783169180615, + "CVC4": 14.44559167823768, + "CVC3": 14.083631275948616, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235145500753509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.239404222599706 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.726087869180224, + "veriT": 14.224224849591913, + "Yices": 13.125944225302577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.237638488766493, + "CVC4": 13.252967734826322, + "CVC3": 14.045231086390084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235784430659463, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238164636484321 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1535358428955078, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0168042182922363, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.160859386740407, + "veriT": 12.637598651140758, + "Yices": 11.882667867068722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.37394506539165, + "CVC4": 5.8228322408183661, + "CVC3": 2.1609415514723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2335594565173649, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3364716439209765 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6947359104790838, + "veriT": 11.218882686553677, + "Yices": 10.362613077335627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6053529754761624, + "CVC4": 9.8936477491444403, + "CVC3": 3.3538642630559377, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6851680279676717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6740765622878295 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.477430423588538, + "veriT": 10.797263610521155, + "Yices": 1.4473545944760928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6412356509837474, + "CVC4": 1.5219190928585229, + "CVC3": 8.9669290664808887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16883744919554544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15831322210781817 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247554994104549, + "veriT": 11.511657513085739, + "Yices": 10.955123908024113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963216299574128, + "CVC4": 14.375118471971325, + "CVC3": 13.546714925987724, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.826750857553145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.582989694116826 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5967722475030985, + "veriT": 13.720973553896735, + "Yices": 13.986204292964388, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.104645438112672, + "CVC4": 9.7576461544598807, + "CVC3": 7.5859733913468315, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.40939002146761, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.377945905424506 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.83158961803716, + "veriT": 10.668875576356658, + "Yices": 10.674073942947985, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.529485352775271, + "CVC4": 13.231729525238411, + "CVC3": 14.112850631944529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.665229538366024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.670140895970006 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.382704564002335, + "veriT": 12.035114103886478, + "Yices": 13.732420967916287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.545803995669491, + "CVC4": 14.383574098747109, + "CVC3": 6.764684134118319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8208696782178979, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8510071791997476 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7846288408255431, + "veriT": 14.229253705110656, + "Yices": 13.881603793312971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958955820400176, + "CVC4": 14.520409926301999, + "CVC3": 11.58484534000209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246818628121117, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.246495239024066 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 83.0, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.703434871811833, + "veriT": 13.116465035352773, + "Yices": 12.866747097902952, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965949844168808, + "CVC4": 14.557341668832665, + "CVC3": 13.105750895542853, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255927741423772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.255965235436111 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 303.0, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9456428974971356, + "veriT": 12.59568589009516, + "Yices": 12.707681799466938, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.356358379808711, + "CVC4": 10.931251206108483, + "CVC3": 12.9787914888683, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2751678203829999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4810854515436689 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.717414167268222, + "veriT": 13.104546691644929, + "Yices": 14.161295950880788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.333000902428665, + "CVC4": 14.62267930770208, + "CVC3": 13.740946848701602, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.252611380895104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.278207618657229 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.325596912154182, + "veriT": 13.882170925588081, + "Yices": 13.875337149719067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.013528779266576, + "CVC4": 14.709771317355671, + "CVC3": 13.238628318654616, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4973219404948037, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4579116162684143 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.975885952388511, + "veriT": 13.447540567381562, + "Yices": 13.371872360443843, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966146851350191, + "CVC4": 14.735723571087233, + "CVC3": 14.258504230033443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.543647607268074, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.986493931343812 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.597104581839723, + "veriT": 13.768479860627767, + "Yices": 12.386170366274156, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.240481310566789, + "CVC4": 14.822539580833428, + "CVC3": 9.7282616023178559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.522236511360985, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.949859201827771 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11941983388309522, + "veriT": 0.090659735254347631, + "Yices": 0.093484079715371426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11635163031828571, + "CVC4": 0.1187845175017619, + "CVC3": 0.095314923772119031, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11630783212971428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11505363747276191 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12318033265442106, + "veriT": 0.61418941477533173, + "Yices": 0.61970037903500519, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13343847629008418, + "CVC4": 0.85733384925551337, + "CVC3": 0.096060231968668419, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.85316552215589569, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.85107664667285943 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.668483092640022, + "veriT": 8.4107820557088946, + "Yices": 8.0369458598713894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.142718172215522, + "CVC4": 4.9442209589127764, + "CVC3": 7.9863223875394782, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7363078016588593, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9935678751854908 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1714284420013428, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13352813681057144, + "veriT": 1.5276086539131428, + "Yices": 3.2034248655791422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19573861191342856, + "CVC4": 0.13581891228214288, + "CVC3": 0.13067136749401428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12931503853357143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7374114554150124 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.99035923147434646, + "veriT": 10.166098857741332, + "Yices": 10.353724556473111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0782698160908741, + "CVC4": 0.14885908490500002, + "CVC3": 0.70193042355616664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1473635950162778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.451797292934616 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20132326478328569, + "veriT": 10.164954751538001, + "Yices": 10.340768421300998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34760023671928569, + "CVC4": 0.15285431837642857, + "CVC3": 0.32129922184085713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15152504956942861, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6836200680148572 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8452379703521729, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2504728528968236, + "veriT": 6.9059929955696218, + "Yices": 8.2537130759371227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4354591141873634, + "CVC4": 2.0094855535333656, + "CVC3": 2.1946035606362502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9101886522878238, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7797014692458877 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.904199968608996, + "veriT": 7.7928991477423351, + "Yices": 9.3809622067883804, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.452043152183322, + "CVC4": 0.17507161207333333, + "CVC3": 10.682136817706761, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.090706635702801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.517513805386576 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.610632288972623, + "veriT": 10.662808359709043, + "Yices": 10.513575969314063, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.352209214544565, + "CVC4": 2.0106632166214555, + "CVC3": 9.3377718720595606, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9055498842475791, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.414101423981998 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238312332846769, + "veriT": 10.152460997333288, + "Yices": 10.321083516071285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955833897323444, + "CVC4": 0.15695844961471431, + "CVC3": 9.4103482241712104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3422150711565664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.281252683456387 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248003402356726, + "veriT": 10.196936672319817, + "Yices": 10.350423000042817, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966872898827127, + "CVC4": 0.17977028043899998, + "CVC3": 14.250939553098696, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15938079286281817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.291277947421918 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2936400507214696, + "veriT": 9.8647681361078376, + "Yices": 9.3143768892909318, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3433858317673479, + "CVC4": 4.95802994507447, + "CVC3": 10.184123661316344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0728931838131546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2934298173165182 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.079475811204336, + "veriT": 12.319452615141717, + "Yices": 12.364119938503224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.145562962259762, + "CVC4": 12.609817976156279, + "CVC3": 11.251298283915817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.071062165266095, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.140991970205883 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.779909593682252, + "veriT": 10.427954019970931, + "Yices": 10.292438981687221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.412190434075249, + "CVC4": 1.2702795021454445, + "CVC3": 5.9827396833713395, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.106726378016253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.516820199768596 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.665520886098923, + "veriT": 9.03071812803889, + "Yices": 10.263604612472054, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.297527373102087, + "CVC4": 4.855632129613225, + "CVC3": 11.192369645716285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0525039841808521, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1251266919912855 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8133975209071274, + "veriT": 11.185703368629428, + "Yices": 8.7980677805555469, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9364438320594539, + "CVC4": 5.8668504857329635, + "CVC3": 8.1714364672289381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9559805636514902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.283666631240195 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18538831530155558, + "veriT": 9.1196841421830328, + "Yices": 9.5309980364007245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.44021121713988898, + "CVC4": 8.2715904678330787, + "CVC3": 1.8213245610348601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.972844015804406, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9947084564977153 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5125000476837158, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0454545021057129, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.384561326936579, + "veriT": 10.537972916564138, + "Yices": 9.4811884948186123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.258955844346879, + "CVC4": 8.2204426718461274, + "CVC3": 10.377722835903739, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.66336525163473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.392655536793827 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0127464964709274, + "veriT": 7.004967532798652, + "Yices": 6.9220854388865698, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.121452209755005, + "CVC4": 7.0565928890704521, + "CVC3": 4.229425061580729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1535706794712195, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1587545005968849 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3475283610711806, + "veriT": 7.792662069169662, + "Yices": 1.2070869765226275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8325808367549934, + "CVC4": 7.9436290726665444, + "CVC3": 7.8002228781571095, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9629724571597857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.962050833850935 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3622413367974442, + "veriT": 8.6072189613408909, + "Yices": 2.7567596354439998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3516400899109997, + "CVC4": 0.16990249665466664, + "CVC3": 2.3647068536342224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7560218094404267, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7487727185328505 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2613635063171387, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15241493665775716, + "veriT": 5.1674355501810849, + "Yices": 6.7199682266072225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17521619955345, + "CVC4": 1.5888055307411857, + "CVC3": 1.6580202136888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1347357584611406, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1168686368694893 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4371347098624474, + "veriT": 1.0474491795597274, + "Yices": 1.0636067556397271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5001237494733524, + "CVC4": 0.16165155859181818, + "CVC3": 0.23723416530718183, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15858034748527272, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1777428932554479 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14532747591133333, + "veriT": 1.2639719907631113, + "Yices": 12.143220411815642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14264874571222222, + "CVC4": 8.0905091319740148, + "CVC3": 7.8138583685411112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.521016646409, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5019097210061108 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1106481359666245, + "veriT": 10.854764229397182, + "Yices": 11.497989833596925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5090107328428584, + "CVC4": 12.715019069623954, + "CVC3": 11.033580859031796, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.394504368805187, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.767926157257113 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7928569316864014, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.789467660510041, + "veriT": 12.748317675763701, + "Yices": 11.94099052332729, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.731206682143002, + "CVC4": 12.636957171762813, + "CVC3": 14.216590355362001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.018437885352627, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.826670576959591 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239532739526163, + "veriT": 12.099205225543363, + "Yices": 12.251368113017802, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96244722254611, + "CVC4": 4.6905207348732878, + "CVC3": 13.229146805382454, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7477523814148133, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4114542771123961 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8786764144897461, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9003378405547009, + "veriT": 11.243261060983738, + "Yices": 10.658246810398699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2562564486061589, + "CVC4": 3.4553368454415359, + "CVC3": 2.0923207723380695, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.299949112875876, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.375951596780711 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.256081923097017, + "veriT": 11.191218972227841, + "Yices": 12.794981311932958, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.518527993174068, + "CVC4": 7.5494065012692371, + "CVC3": 10.690095786345562, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6265460355096391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.67994711505272 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0181262306809167, + "veriT": 10.349879647485277, + "Yices": 11.366593913019811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0177763431632858, + "CVC4": 14.189515925040482, + "CVC3": 6.0555312666699681, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225521380309434, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.938873510046514 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9808280632960056, + "veriT": 5.8326183987008573, + "Yices": 8.6938200698801005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5997304537102313, + "CVC4": 3.703613838287787, + "CVC3": 2.1590194080641818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3738474543584278, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4027894307276094 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3549901791058003, + "veriT": 4.9283206419943282, + "Yices": 11.084537007970351, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3069693993918996, + "CVC4": 14.25893680168935, + "CVC3": 11.859329321561001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8901231701950305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8934549227366411 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3142626496166141, + "veriT": 7.6993507389706259, + "Yices": 6.1328054011242275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0213349824289155, + "CVC4": 1.8280185376232536, + "CVC3": 2.0432445332141054, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8701134014435095, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8901732487849703 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7241255257885741, + "veriT": 8.9858260616852412, + "Yices": 12.004124631369137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.802840448847282, + "CVC4": 1.8566603165159721, + "CVC3": 12.059521562242852, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7482058382471339, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7457680937176756 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.683067309170234, + "veriT": 10.611771329231944, + "Yices": 10.619792378328334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.31777670208386, + "CVC4": 1.8103133746758009, + "CVC3": 12.004242956776485, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7366571710289567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.514201999907145 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2194727061727, + "veriT": 2.3474281409568856, + "Yices": 9.8221444520898551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2285052038630404, + "CVC4": 5.4694139392725072, + "CVC3": 2.3088502541686999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3810092962804337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5829546188479053 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4269684143843939, + "veriT": 7.7768700044674661, + "Yices": 6.7864620711211119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5308174525467173, + "CVC4": 7.3257199615998561, + "CVC3": 1.7552245600122998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2382799508276001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4591564886095432 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7786049336186927, + "veriT": 10.659884036858687, + "Yices": 7.3154637396026851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2744073843298054, + "CVC4": 8.9913315543799683, + "CVC3": 5.0886844553372308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.56245788113872, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.971166994606817 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5033166233472, + "veriT": 0.12126608330609999, + "Yices": 1.0908118746865207, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5726897320172202, + "CVC4": 4.8754991041979263, + "CVC3": 1.5413012558852535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14959081840733332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14644558167233335 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14299004756477779, + "veriT": 7.9414205650790137, + "Yices": 6.2632397237826662, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21209271786188888, + "CVC4": 0.30714225891422225, + "CVC3": 1.7038627220174201, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.271469125031166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2701584105179848 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.683806784176229, + "veriT": 10.748032629472183, + "Yices": 9.5685515448266045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.433849644289184, + "CVC4": 10.462082104604551, + "CVC3": 10.941952456518885, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.95966397221156, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.423765531377848 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 63.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5720021268057145, + "veriT": 14.207970910468807, + "Yices": 0.22660084610985712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6343352391513573, + "CVC4": 1.2330432306601311, + "CVC3": 0.14097448158521428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.97110823915548, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.993567916976433 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8914139270782471, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.599288281329253, + "veriT": 11.282760291687053, + "Yices": 7.9977696781558016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.553412543984477, + "CVC4": 3.6111325286084384, + "CVC3": 2.8417944073688179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.867904377058052, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.865831821046118 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.411811168367199, + "veriT": 14.220198405111194, + "Yices": 13.084689674791377, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4869090168320103, + "CVC4": 7.9159361887501412, + "CVC3": 12.456061792215223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235296454072968, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.235577493950453 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4783944773847688, + "veriT": 1.6921802058132305, + "Yices": 1.7449038321624617, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4900862477913845, + "CVC4": 2.3637585804965391, + "CVC3": 2.3442117861145961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0387475808878137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0449776528814181 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14701357411566668, + "veriT": 0.12511012243875, + "Yices": 0.13533680774208334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14477706589233333, + "CVC4": 0.16193172286991667, + "CVC3": 0.14323674195841665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16044963421091665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15939773317149999 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12497348394044444, + "veriT": 11.26518167970608, + "Yices": 3.4681320330716443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13929471036910002, + "CVC4": 0.14105430305510003, + "CVC3": 0.11903957383312222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2307304833300385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2491273419421218 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14289083295562857, + "veriT": 2.1381017565208373, + "Yices": 2.1423075388645123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15295827969180001, + "CVC4": 4.2174938834512963, + "CVC3": 0.49219039424171429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15119121899417146, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14770161836768572 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17676450100176, + "veriT": 7.3932608594645206, + "Yices": 7.4141719808567697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18381207089508, + "CVC4": 4.4483924333713913, + "CVC3": 6.3865790163259311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9365895735459411, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0940652198902194 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 130.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8639274835586548, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.292523880493691, + "veriT": 10.188162883931572, + "Yices": 10.917922755034265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.146589354688308, + "CVC4": 10.301040755802251, + "CVC3": 13.707943560569907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.26085862496554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.74395565470914 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6859067946951409, + "veriT": 9.8853359707347259, + "Yices": 9.2911745187498376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.050488956726115, + "CVC4": 12.86808779060031, + "CVC3": 9.7627357160983603, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0664180233181275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0449119383513912 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 61.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.202534709777523, + "veriT": 12.23517198188398, + "Yices": 6.6987570238478247, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8090911698494931, + "CVC4": 8.8064232610463637, + "CVC3": 5.2182119564524116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5179520131344546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1595195553370909 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8411576564831664, + "veriT": 2.448445418972296, + "Yices": 0.15291408785016666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8497096302325835, + "CVC4": 2.5446481252299042, + "CVC3": 0.16538235162308335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17849764665525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17098674268683334 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2352520362592183, + "veriT": 9.7644419417525725, + "Yices": 6.4170242664278758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4789564716057644, + "CVC4": 6.5676537573706613, + "CVC3": 9.2913811740303256, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3602494073590297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2412660120000218 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.027146577835083, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244969128254526, + "veriT": 10.478085338518188, + "Yices": 10.595468800521134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968240799282926, + "CVC4": 14.165812734932578, + "CVC3": 12.640253947386661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.75445899756359, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.674181363812503 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.273966620746537, + "veriT": 13.120118039427757, + "Yices": 12.130441402371128, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.385016101257442, + "CVC4": 13.359733921838785, + "CVC3": 13.994558107237669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241319358765212, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.985573030287481 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.883989082968677, + "veriT": 11.700400381074244, + "Yices": 11.526602873748551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.135306119037468, + "CVC4": 13.064270280778805, + "CVC3": 7.0715250530487426, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5447367477139444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.525375550245492 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4526388155265715, + "veriT": 13.381333236597856, + "Yices": 13.347951484095491, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3852322070718621, + "CVC4": 14.570450271383256, + "CVC3": 6.150678287692263, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.835622797585886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.725848283773503 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8810939935786135, + "veriT": 13.189692585119639, + "Yices": 8.7794062260465751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5494701529467338, + "CVC4": 7.4594035373786696, + "CVC3": 5.433219193659153, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.763311440049963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.760074031299476 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1019477844238281, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3045853856988439, + "veriT": 9.8262053055120653, + "Yices": 10.655243168917574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.637572127556985, + "CVC4": 7.1354133765438759, + "CVC3": 1.8952565017610681, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7313938567060772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7325828901581692 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.358741976111776, + "veriT": 12.305737719101128, + "Yices": 12.109457517721625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.015187121272078, + "CVC4": 12.031981471960844, + "CVC3": 12.084523620958651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.075669567735392, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.586134439564066 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 375.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24358360648219998, + "veriT": 7.6730812894341947, + "Yices": 4.7435477644654851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.42633758833230773, + "CVC4": 0.42507939322476912, + "CVC3": 0.15227425748598461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6480125395602192, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6437023579919083 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0024323555218162, + "veriT": 11.369520294645636, + "Yices": 5.1289058438652857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3222000238975156, + "CVC4": 0.37445951645255554, + "CVC3": 1.2596889997030003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21813850853922223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21267028938255553 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 78.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9091184088939168, + "veriT": 11.188853301029797, + "Yices": 9.5227555962668102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.786224432628103, + "CVC4": 5.6452545824241396, + "CVC3": 12.026626194288781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1028802715680306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8046521834953326 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9245018045903652, + "veriT": 12.743536361727219, + "Yices": 14.091896043266072, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.108578066242917, + "CVC4": 14.656147143635073, + "CVC3": 13.890154753460802, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9650784281923768, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9659161177614521 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.89428493918011, + "veriT": 13.876362870177879, + "Yices": 12.991254277902831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.145043441615499, + "CVC4": 14.399842196208022, + "CVC3": 13.67012522800214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.401302350329443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.625951326489597 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5205720395829161, + "veriT": 12.481252129577378, + "Yices": 12.242238982084919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0186106713190579, + "CVC4": 12.074710066649054, + "CVC3": 10.519152469821163, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.451797578523463, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.940858468517455 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.387333568382893, + "veriT": 9.8108563289765947, + "Yices": 11.125418202260603, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.768372003882787, + "CVC4": 13.375579400536461, + "CVC3": 12.958206078853369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.111566493493985, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.338660923902633 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 228.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9519805247158057, + "veriT": 13.144100409447729, + "Yices": 13.427818977362451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956658039751678, + "CVC4": 14.70850079372752, + "CVC3": 11.588916553566964, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.08441843262451, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.129550754175536 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.44471400539703, + "veriT": 14.228446323241585, + "Yices": 13.774200128457769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.274201063692855, + "CVC4": 14.34375110171432, + "CVC3": 12.592623888601882, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.245339349059508, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.252575108211326 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.268716783295048, + "veriT": 11.422327893820151, + "Yices": 14.307848568225722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.983156671170883, + "CVC4": 14.390902093350345, + "CVC3": 13.357201288840582, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.23825975034384, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.050101913895087 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.741307772364268, + "veriT": 12.049666624175796, + "Yices": 12.164247744036182, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.753153496569304, + "CVC4": 12.986534142259647, + "CVC3": 13.961445667076742, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7539823219703639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1368115853559235 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.226329620558975, + "veriT": 14.233955309082429, + "Yices": 14.157618497628119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.581638411284334, + "CVC4": 14.828979001491527, + "CVC3": 6.05965519017305, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.161735909168323, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.326611595939911 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.123290099481296, + "veriT": 0.49063803372919201, + "Yices": 0.49438600258448007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12641747894141198, + "CVC4": 0.68329799562430626, + "CVC3": 0.094672738142616009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.67826872035141283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.6775576079631811 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4200120957464155, + "veriT": 0.083747016655861539, + "Yices": 0.085750249307280757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4194132751831652, + "CVC4": 0.10827349297509231, + "CVC3": 0.088781814243996171, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10865354257318077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10724675435236154 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1714284420013428, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5777156352617283, + "veriT": 3.9493491278782913, + "Yices": 5.9350986270955799, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6439544775891952, + "CVC4": 4.5298363688301171, + "CVC3": 2.9592989664618399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9748827583101463, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9868588869899919 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5666591586186036, + "veriT": 10.163257542425226, + "Yices": 10.355641895991869, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.68267538709491, + "CVC4": 0.14787891800032257, + "CVC3": 0.69921379844016152, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14857867920674195, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.444563213766555 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20114783040366666, + "veriT": 10.165189915907666, + "Yices": 10.342850672788666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.33448437052666669, + "CVC4": 0.15325218642250002, + "CVC3": 0.31062214348100003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15087000633100001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.549120228284 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4278163975685896, + "veriT": 12.353209670349839, + "Yices": 13.010890110905255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7320815079283545, + "CVC4": 11.80987513980725, + "CVC3": 11.011292056869168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.889990956866027, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.028534553598352 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9166665077209473, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5493310451679321, + "veriT": 7.4960109984389973, + "Yices": 9.2640948894583293, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3982547006713943, + "CVC4": 2.626235322573987, + "CVC3": 2.6746399131791665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4995307153429316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8384832703380454 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7888889312744141, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242723311950567, + "veriT": 10.17873319991625, + "Yices": 10.341237524277373, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961904216397764, + "CVC4": 0.16384612235887502, + "CVC3": 10.268421579263178, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5462147985665602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.379048978497959 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.620231329525167, + "veriT": 10.152000300662857, + "Yices": 10.313813439770144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950963918621969, + "CVC4": 0.16894492574614287, + "CVC3": 11.664669944338877, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18291025271514286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.563521012254942 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.42567691147611, + "veriT": 10.145612534351921, + "Yices": 10.291482571497399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.470379062497404, + "CVC4": 0.1519689225883, + "CVC3": 11.508276862139359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7140149257193507, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.1138008607114 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243651023893351, + "veriT": 10.172923914604167, + "Yices": 10.325524204146832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957761229452126, + "CVC4": 0.17176922322199997, + "CVC3": 12.975071813849732, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.887045067220443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.321058703488566 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.187044095963445, + "veriT": 9.8292432248668504, + "Yices": 8.4820356628885172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.819256003053082, + "CVC4": 2.6737422164009605, + "CVC3": 11.43897337946772, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.347721559194531, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9726924324762916 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.469255292594752, + "veriT": 10.670972763289281, + "Yices": 9.0209046628738765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.096291482012276, + "CVC4": 1.9659039262723648, + "CVC3": 10.122213540595769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4604566543924191, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.170094483815097 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13742224702477779, + "veriT": 3.5503319189107332, + "Yices": 4.5674900392328439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23284215543622222, + "CVC4": 0.32916021355833336, + "CVC3": 0.16399259356188889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6793483141686307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7018066293066976 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7750000953674316, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.844419639370436, + "veriT": 5.4351379086369427, + "Yices": 3.8659608667990577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0039652198552727, + "CVC4": 3.525488701617645, + "CVC3": 3.2209327272077197, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8007196318132506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7994002206088853 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1412437609795, + "veriT": 3.4503772335756335, + "Yices": 9.8499055158950419, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13706660464033335, + "CVC4": 2.4987868071310952, + "CVC3": 0.13985171953166667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4870674394883547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15799427161733332 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3317731479281534, + "veriT": 9.4864200303286896, + "Yices": 3.0705621834501664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4596954681162475, + "CVC4": 3.7318412385504858, + "CVC3": 3.3427327846165142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6683505802614422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.672211952534548 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9452180861791337, + "veriT": 11.95153517419182, + "Yices": 7.9211977879119519, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2366309368272939, + "CVC4": 9.6907038908338983, + "CVC3": 6.520749850619989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9280752287917036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3777167625080331 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13692875268395002, + "veriT": 0.11379651912498998, + "Yices": 0.11942027722736, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12312977585358001, + "CVC4": 0.15308962425860001, + "CVC3": 0.1380835349492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1767178552285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16777898865956001 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4868257868186188, + "veriT": 7.055497964371563, + "Yices": 5.2485506984617807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8534915413678839, + "CVC4": 5.0170758284994283, + "CVC3": 4.4712723018900578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2573970946928563, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4935195562085664 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.631836042118854, + "veriT": 12.196933120961804, + "Yices": 13.93033813291577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8478059474265365, + "CVC4": 14.526215352984199, + "CVC3": 13.125851425786538, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.061974991972324, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.080847773495872 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.552012334243569, + "veriT": 7.8640936429571031, + "Yices": 12.339912842112374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.930029744234904, + "CVC4": 6.221096910588086, + "CVC3": 12.42621615744906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2200028237973841, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5541706755669065 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9632843186805253, + "veriT": 11.231534702485495, + "Yices": 8.9083592918102852, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.357050390990997, + "CVC4": 0.15615211197844445, + "CVC3": 7.0914885329837549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2121940756024649, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2950144957710883 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.816826483531882, + "veriT": 14.230447623376769, + "Yices": 13.496256548645674, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.43685691040346, + "CVC4": 13.740398926377265, + "CVC3": 11.175715333186567, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243580838877412, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.241017117710353 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.230638212706605, + "veriT": 14.016457724760615, + "Yices": 13.458226647301018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958900840463373, + "CVC4": 7.2231168074186485, + "CVC3": 11.192123810068262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2044090677761803, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2416443314950678 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0954544544219971, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1035128093785733, + "veriT": 8.4547220585064018, + "Yices": 9.5269140292048213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6783667387569867, + "CVC4": 6.1566804827007502, + "CVC3": 6.3895396258854174, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.153351514024081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.710817476566113 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.896953163186696, + "veriT": 11.489667342302871, + "Yices": 9.746629358453907, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.358980110978164, + "CVC4": 7.8567118360719119, + "CVC3": 10.707326388098762, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4863320384246137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.505659445395155 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5767304787789884, + "veriT": 4.5627732543380892, + "Yices": 9.8158484753678881, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6890461583784933, + "CVC4": 9.0238274549388358, + "CVC3": 7.35731989029206, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0815515794142758, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0668949383064747 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.686966326756441, + "veriT": 7.9048695966268072, + "Yices": 7.0120910162506309, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1740411946805303, + "CVC4": 2.0353931090097852, + "CVC3": 2.1509637135651185, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9423141036854847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9879659134117977 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2460086939846666, + "veriT": 9.5163141152872335, + "Yices": 3.226409018148682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2441973027347779, + "CVC4": 2.8366034056904201, + "CVC3": 2.8025826799189879, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5841243532144471, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5780030501596833 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8122179473434168, + "veriT": 14.214044532870373, + "Yices": 0.16328513479966666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8330263204864166, + "CVC4": 0.22120019750033335, + "CVC3": 0.13116121066916667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.061593011083138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.060411668857318 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.118285829285167, + "veriT": 3.19683876566208, + "Yices": 0.98182893033382101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7718899726155035, + "CVC4": 1.3162840069031345, + "CVC3": 3.4191844455986908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3384136480930433, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3370696466749656 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17165752927064287, + "veriT": 0.88890545324621428, + "Yices": 5.6104476673854284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18534259035735712, + "CVC4": 0.18327308937135714, + "CVC3": 1.6302031615047858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1828635288246798, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1829386663568391 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7480206946244288, + "veriT": 6.6860858350563097, + "Yices": 12.201338452950335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3637818252182146, + "CVC4": 4.3419934737965002, + "CVC3": 3.4649191515983127, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2925415430964962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2731630722074385 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6210109414317557, + "veriT": 7.2837826295054295, + "Yices": 7.3861539394789997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9433244204270297, + "CVC4": 3.589265568451085, + "CVC3": 7.464004339678076, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1730730696142286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0564580588728507 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.38961553585725, + "veriT": 0.11691980841646252, + "Yices": 0.12424314749728751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3826590405557626, + "CVC4": 3.6810875799800549, + "CVC3": 0.12789292789370002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14776239510325001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14133272143675002 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14410489116218181, + "veriT": 0.12351635732463637, + "Yices": 0.13590867631945455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13992558505954544, + "CVC4": 0.16072012844072728, + "CVC3": 0.13602020711654547, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1579690686030909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15680595915763637 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15352606899874999, + "veriT": 0.13769764599137502, + "Yices": 3.672737367297179, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15283171455987501, + "CVC4": 0.18762880616012501, + "CVC3": 0.15153742612575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.170710954967875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1696070611945 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.682193462547501, + "veriT": 10.289292820623997, + "Yices": 8.88826381961956, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.270999840790562, + "CVC4": 2.8298779697977565, + "CVC3": 13.326714320913426, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0341941559913637, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.867456542553784 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1333334445953369, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4130002147689376, + "veriT": 0.75600950911412501, + "Yices": 1.6579389256067754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.516821076095775, + "CVC4": 2.8526573880141699, + "CVC3": 1.0407725910301509, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.327325215249715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3268322676789763 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2565406353573541, + "veriT": 6.0219559738858983, + "Yices": 8.8315858253977666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1590686664594498, + "CVC4": 8.7586849473971782, + "CVC3": 5.270429768215279, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7723810779626046, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.14414216219614 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9797461032867432, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.64314858911597, + "veriT": 11.821235157717023, + "Yices": 12.185209691084818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.070150431405668, + "CVC4": 14.296025617779136, + "CVC3": 13.490727352215902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.265112393865897, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.394834873995773 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7608808941535807, + "veriT": 6.039488325949435, + "Yices": 4.3194332697875479, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.327662757205873, + "CVC4": 8.4935406509978701, + "CVC3": 2.8826779678287502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21906617069533332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21321091659483329 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 62.0, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.684077008693323, + "veriT": 8.1860951292169482, + "Yices": 8.7831022547889486, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.256556695336033, + "CVC4": 0.28423135190280002, + "CVC3": 1.7794681071290464, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5153130110820774, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.545045467051998 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9756904126848589, + "veriT": 8.4060847141512287, + "Yices": 3.3421269970937812, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1174470785572499, + "CVC4": 8.7840891529171934, + "CVC3": 2.9594897986826831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9246285211471998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3506694350711994 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1698031216980769, + "veriT": 0.1500389025576154, + "Yices": 0.15488467080761539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17060473055238462, + "CVC4": 0.19156962734276922, + "CVC3": 0.16893469046453846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17965599938984617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17765505271800003 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.129645945476625, + "veriT": 3.1222850491073082, + "Yices": 9.9342139964899605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.140632361708625, + "CVC4": 1.9669099796264793, + "CVC3": 0.43536487430837501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13562295821148751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13766478235025001 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4286833859152188, + "veriT": 12.959671002349346, + "Yices": 3.3577943769049621, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4054350461398997, + "CVC4": 8.5990289277580896, + "CVC3": 2.5133999635594444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.67026225106229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.508800272360853 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1458521263651, + "veriT": 13.805000244359652, + "Yices": 1.3024560775993002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20393603447529998, + "CVC4": 1.5871720391778574, + "CVC3": 1.3508289812955583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.560280027362358, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.315485354239735 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.38984216913245451, + "veriT": 12.015737514306243, + "Yices": 8.0855520498144084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6323434699443018, + "CVC4": 13.048647922677123, + "CVC3": 5.8616898302432467, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.970086136420461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.262273678654095 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1841084857502491, + "veriT": 13.305144396373107, + "Yices": 11.760852912774688, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8494534583293358, + "CVC4": 11.727421917878774, + "CVC3": 11.406411700156713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.220818663977923, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.221598325728458 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0618524418735262, + "veriT": 9.1917737323737096, + "Yices": 9.6207084482375311, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7341967311971818, + "CVC4": 13.233479531339297, + "CVC3": 8.8519089442617531, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.060962604937654, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4905215050477256 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16469366089740001, + "veriT": 4.9588985111500339, + "Yices": 9.7902434019929387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2291046873399099, + "CVC4": 7.5773243382509676, + "CVC3": 8.8502461606906486, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5451948567126745, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5418505051551197 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17840129684270001, + "veriT": 6.3660898135306017, + "Yices": 0.1449465044223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18427538163169999, + "CVC4": 3.1804838464849459, + "CVC3": 0.17038410600430001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17501820346460001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16780078921780001 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3034347129994517, + "veriT": 11.670742502258484, + "Yices": 10.221172840269029, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7582352240992378, + "CVC4": 14.324903812056432, + "CVC3": 13.569718551930819, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4099171064576739, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.523760208659894 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2237190005457141, + "veriT": 13.076383256334188, + "Yices": 11.653214322170649, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5426187216350282, + "CVC4": 0.76786474182200004, + "CVC3": 3.5685303502257142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2377020879948164, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4900657483506938 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.22902271899483, + "veriT": 11.951931088167022, + "Yices": 11.23482760011315, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.949017405028927, + "CVC4": 13.422563873772155, + "CVC3": 13.333997678770512, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.314825881794592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238111412470857 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.260562933265795, + "veriT": 10.187889598890273, + "Yices": 10.377026571812998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.987590989508965, + "CVC4": 14.284551843671965, + "CVC3": 14.261956226727881, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256928341506161, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.423689695089193 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5082623520407896, + "veriT": 13.814142662674609, + "Yices": 12.510101549262213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.512537183958298, + "CVC4": 14.620873683877893, + "CVC3": 8.8435389363924433, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236236879812969, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.235466190373316 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 156.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1461150026684765, + "veriT": 9.7596113804752633, + "Yices": 4.1337268821720192, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7820974213392065, + "CVC4": 5.8831883317013336, + "CVC3": 5.7913063909562545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6054014913300616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6071924163180231 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257724437723725, + "veriT": 10.872952109250001, + "Yices": 10.983466377935455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.164441258105201, + "CVC4": 14.517575170748524, + "CVC3": 14.255581136002363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.525875988445813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.519394047526157 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.72815760665012497, + "veriT": 13.514358413805624, + "Yices": 10.80132517187743, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8693345848012113, + "CVC4": 9.214832752739385, + "CVC3": 1.586048440982875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6950611575115846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6899015408979534 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.44932291803744445, + "veriT": 2.0008585042786491, + "Yices": 3.2605453139614919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.59774347769688885, + "CVC4": 3.3178767187973044, + "CVC3": 0.28183342305944442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17856350963199999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17614527311755554 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5529177551252333, + "veriT": 12.544859898406889, + "Yices": 8.9614043123448006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1977392025149083, + "CVC4": 2.1219902072218528, + "CVC3": 3.4198631669948201, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9706962364558915, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.965034370396566 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.343825487777439, + "veriT": 13.777721903197504, + "Yices": 13.480375741744137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.993169874118866, + "CVC4": 14.379629869365841, + "CVC3": 12.311466340854139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.804497988969072, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.7149923859595 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 48.0, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.13650436399705, + "veriT": 13.308966813412024, + "Yices": 13.31904275897497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.193277480215961, + "CVC4": 14.419869075845829, + "CVC3": 12.426392740086552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8466043188669516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9443224541150057 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.252430218172529, + "veriT": 14.238393779380988, + "Yices": 13.453649343650323, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.969098484696026, + "CVC4": 14.390981255001217, + "CVC3": 14.241118634592134, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.263302550735665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.263151762723126 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2297366291072649, + "veriT": 12.241773285869558, + "Yices": 10.839992671360548, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.202726320774667, + "CVC4": 7.1639500206567277, + "CVC3": 10.847178055170589, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4515826060988943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8783661519582235 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6743325987742725, + "veriT": 7.5008313751283167, + "Yices": 9.376834505925423, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9920695279043725, + "CVC4": 9.1691829453603493, + "CVC3": 8.1759573899297227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.715079768142427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.291356990415432 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1445515155792236, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0315780639648438, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.506753296155393, + "veriT": 14.248793177940009, + "Yices": 13.423681398053601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.149984493903281, + "CVC4": 14.647038150736849, + "CVC3": 13.873559411755535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.137294970689313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.196985748282264 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.280234696711352, + "veriT": 10.825271039104056, + "Yices": 11.117186821084001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.02830958822633, + "CVC4": 14.530716046311568, + "CVC3": 14.276014823430208, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.285567357397436, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.230230368880211 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.41704031819323, + "veriT": 13.509275933364405, + "Yices": 14.125811007557049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.966948648680189, + "CVC4": 14.505515358505988, + "CVC3": 11.063433120157878, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6827908422988305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.685522755523154 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 66.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4896986608425191, + "veriT": 13.418965700164744, + "Yices": 14.100603643405886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958298118345862, + "CVC4": 14.638299568894416, + "CVC3": 11.494342098009799, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.218036295370229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.203604482463287 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.719974071776603, + "veriT": 12.783375363008789, + "Yices": 14.368294929548746, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980631720763018, + "CVC4": 14.564132651054935, + "CVC3": 13.12877036982912, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.94225277038157, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.271660410153396 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7124282329938971, + "veriT": 14.246647017743594, + "Yices": 14.241837915783378, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7670133476626866, + "CVC4": 14.523233310392664, + "CVC3": 6.7426727849451797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.098419992291396, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4969228581111249 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 77.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12356313534900001, + "veriT": 0.095968758848269234, + "Yices": 0.098365857242853849, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1224839270323846, + "CVC4": 0.12269013619084615, + "CVC3": 0.10085575545106154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12306066111400002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11822580261176922 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13610705026837777, + "veriT": 1.7563008179730391, + "Yices": 1.7596441631317168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16419046033932777, + "CVC4": 2.4683024291175428, + "CVC3": 0.09581492575413332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4600062293131977, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4583136920016213 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6183666257486271, + "veriT": 6.0017582783284977, + "Yices": 7.5137786511924087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8204728480461814, + "CVC4": 3.319041621260169, + "CVC3": 6.2104169124221622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1573950194141571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0018737300006944 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2078781478437742, + "veriT": 10.167159562402968, + "Yices": 10.353955471637773, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26017893471025805, + "CVC4": 0.14968328725506452, + "CVC3": 0.68621995028896776, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14835268613277422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.449957974595407 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16720307000050003, + "veriT": 5.1350859376273332, + "Yices": 7.1433387501841663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27432373114966668, + "CVC4": 0.15345164906383335, + "CVC3": 0.2068400051388333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14765769926299999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6780684278006812 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.054850108207678, + "veriT": 13.216826146670344, + "Yices": 12.083930319357453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.952774447653448, + "CVC4": 13.335917104968464, + "CVC3": 11.643180540815676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.944664615914586, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.062589344032849 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3385646660708832, + "veriT": 6.8224703141395002, + "Yices": 8.6191822138698342, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1987262704772963, + "CVC4": 0.15918358889916664, + "CVC3": 1.0540876345808332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15532004063649998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3183034997013987 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1761551463556597, + "veriT": 4.4268558532322428, + "Yices": 4.4873285787877135, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4837561096543173, + "CVC4": 0.150694902785, + "CVC3": 5.1893806617396043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7485649210345016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9305664563467575 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.863802412871822, + "veriT": 10.187231771331646, + "Yices": 10.305253432672119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954471273944117, + "CVC4": 3.0812901758912261, + "CVC3": 11.343975696132119, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4767126023546968, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.998130200151104 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.528855742663275, + "veriT": 8.2580250086007361, + "Yices": 7.2879871030231484, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0303520319274106, + "CVC4": 0.8776883981691499, + "CVC3": 8.424891985627589, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6113425135149075, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1174357975934548 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13621368508818182, + "veriT": 5.5558398137901452, + "Yices": 6.8522309648519384, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15025611256845453, + "CVC4": 5.3679921844086795, + "CVC3": 1.4231513232219766, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4112174314377202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13290688832327271 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23850290334105, + "veriT": 10.153215317696, + "Yices": 10.329165667325833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958103795451606, + "CVC4": 0.15496968658666668, + "CVC3": 8.615574202706501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8741813075869942, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.332687341685407 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243096505613961, + "veriT": 10.164715087929384, + "Yices": 10.335177437530847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960700930929853, + "CVC4": 0.15119280022146153, + "CVC3": 12.273589704616096, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14781102325423076, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.298835114274327 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1160038263192877, + "veriT": 8.5000584924199991, + "Yices": 8.6402387879346652, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.472591216392866, + "CVC4": 0.17463485543666668, + "CVC3": 7.6810106793772057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4250059470768672, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.690718832477714 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.790783118568973, + "veriT": 9.3896529180926436, + "Yices": 11.636471975371416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.029477215657367, + "CVC4": 4.5347538185262994, + "CVC3": 11.620046145171271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.545227399564908, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.530554326814423 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.426165745820789, + "veriT": 7.6919184727889958, + "Yices": 5.5961160226566724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1432853555329092, + "CVC4": 4.1459903346839795, + "CVC3": 2.7025798414470938, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7773502181322018, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5655099319772978 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1612705448031342, + "veriT": 11.03457833784095, + "Yices": 9.0754640712154355, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3716175655254688, + "CVC4": 8.8018481819317795, + "CVC3": 11.818117792078997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.098524761916977, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.196987566507042 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 50.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1293201446533203, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4203393804155, + "veriT": 4.9219387555465648, + "Yices": 6.99612291647375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.418188450329875, + "CVC4": 9.0498747937518917, + "CVC3": 1.4332303908052502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.963784584516624, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.976330316716159 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1630973454907334, + "veriT": 5.6095912610374654, + "Yices": 5.240025040214749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5238369700735932, + "CVC4": 2.3234004176304208, + "CVC3": 1.8639198755813651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1652874013980092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1676544532602176 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3482726927114443, + "veriT": 7.678051748273889, + "Yices": 6.6082228186782404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3475602352495559, + "CVC4": 0.141114476287, + "CVC3": 0.14914053603640001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7679807614597642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8251488036361971 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2926258855783601, + "veriT": 9.0008331290679404, + "Yices": 10.756006944848199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.485693465113716, + "CVC4": 3.1799513599331664, + "CVC3": 4.073058644532809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.409702482716455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.40799972491414 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.050167597999939, + "veriT": 11.230795665556741, + "Yices": 10.312273609228557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.754219750312567, + "CVC4": 4.5917490501069933, + "CVC3": 11.352987667812293, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1942414803572099, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.440068978565115 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9030232054550549, + "veriT": 14.229017626522813, + "Yices": 10.491120272370422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.517318592067488, + "CVC4": 14.084626468990974, + "CVC3": 11.874003831176751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6550047948270894, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6531727928204294 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4975838563200687, + "veriT": 10.52619537548459, + "Yices": 9.483991562682073, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.062759522574682, + "CVC4": 10.784108944762524, + "CVC3": 10.140625080966775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.95858919217021, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.691550667229711 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2022166400237477, + "veriT": 7.6515895442816246, + "Yices": 9.5508409138566197, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5637826361066942, + "CVC4": 2.0085214241777951, + "CVC3": 7.9752032106144997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16554267571137499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9212929696470145 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5320640889231543, + "veriT": 7.3984067595477176, + "Yices": 9.0828134496824084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.576732685717416, + "CVC4": 9.0189809797772007, + "CVC3": 2.8316967332941019, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5661617004788106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4559567830102824 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 61.0, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1350022510694, + "veriT": 3.1210547130176503, + "Yices": 3.5892846322158958, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1315326560407, + "CVC4": 0.19305003362119999, + "CVC3": 3.3686749530172002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5592811514301399, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5533174511780141 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4806941233009923, + "veriT": 1.7795457262225669, + "Yices": 1.8069626451714997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6006622809897664, + "CVC4": 4.8345015857831664, + "CVC3": 2.464215540360537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4791722227869677, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9936295731759441 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5810450059612462, + "veriT": 7.5949485876564777, + "Yices": 8.7793560989126451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6467215069316561, + "CVC4": 2.3559525231012866, + "CVC3": 4.4501848349847295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.031382148249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.03440422839228 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0107578036198335, + "veriT": 9.3389404699881968, + "Yices": 10.27021119186006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2119542182801333, + "CVC4": 7.2110525435310793, + "CVC3": 1.04249174282525, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.737935475687769, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5587965535705637 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3917227642596626, + "veriT": 9.7267189392552122, + "Yices": 7.0984889715097141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6235975615568499, + "CVC4": 7.8323637670026551, + "CVC3": 2.7528798567571249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2731711105027657, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2509813791770945 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.131291546171, + "veriT": 7.9063577146201522, + "Yices": 1.364316796080125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13675953612049999, + "CVC4": 0.14187749408949998, + "CVC3": 0.11833704438116251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13126887741475002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13231492612470003 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14684022209257144, + "veriT": 2.5774928310024201, + "Yices": 2.5627374314254223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13963016398776429, + "CVC4": 0.14779242166871431, + "CVC3": 1.5954782148336784, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14485423641757142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14388870026905001 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8651671352070993, + "veriT": 11.796323644026559, + "Yices": 8.918028771452466, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1220135321925682, + "CVC4": 11.532764996806852, + "CVC3": 12.309998199031417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5894291308731061, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8808317141703625 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1604205060195, + "veriT": 0.14811577314150001, + "Yices": 0.15889167723841666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15812072038891667, + "CVC4": 0.18474403099558334, + "CVC3": 0.16033390071441667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1746356335400833, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17156862142525001 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1096038525048701, + "veriT": 10.135379419327178, + "Yices": 11.075532640419334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4368905579991225, + "CVC4": 6.7347029825044338, + "CVC3": 5.6585307349539908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3256189674743313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3774903022436495 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7008628692375867, + "veriT": 7.0976515713307302, + "Yices": 8.7554567036912925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.563686883396084, + "CVC4": 8.856644683408943, + "CVC3": 8.3646430915860694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6132384647086093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6021792846596732 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.422659345489741, + "veriT": 7.3280282072318563, + "Yices": 10.731528887644522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.823519427197494, + "CVC4": 14.53451281407529, + "CVC3": 9.1374565568027144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8709977891489409, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2054605911578102 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.606460938197027, + "veriT": 7.1668260101686361, + "Yices": 13.927733044187196, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.659606537480828, + "CVC4": 13.506181976367163, + "CVC3": 11.920742652763753, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7549348735063068, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7974178757679509 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5523810386657715, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.224576261559408, + "veriT": 11.586488073306677, + "Yices": 11.745167368615881, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.942559256748119, + "CVC4": 3.874847670175424, + "CVC3": 12.605665752952905, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.569035715764207, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.535224971669422 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3884459480153279, + "veriT": 8.5763087090630954, + "Yices": 9.8658415294044897, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2967199864594603, + "CVC4": 1.8448066384113524, + "CVC3": 8.1325654018247473, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0819497177254842, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5562545372810295 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2928070755330543, + "veriT": 7.475050278658844, + "Yices": 7.7945963865179992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.010178017753029, + "CVC4": 9.7858751954157128, + "CVC3": 5.4285553537583615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5320381030300236, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5042837349339724 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9626116730234717, + "veriT": 10.994955243648924, + "Yices": 11.121322931833381, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6905795247758011, + "CVC4": 14.412589932957488, + "CVC3": 4.9047467527406408, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.261283593606516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.084263313921468 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.965903373286954, + "veriT": 13.313335121290217, + "Yices": 11.964591925685024, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.532046280163534, + "CVC4": 11.480040218325113, + "CVC3": 14.791941096213286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.672409499375521, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.231055482995052 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.502914100906763, + "veriT": 10.184854017866625, + "Yices": 10.344780333390124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.976534280216518, + "CVC4": 9.0570334836074107, + "CVC3": 12.345619177491901, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252592504012705, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.719668625439887 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1468638462567, + "veriT": 14.209049195988456, + "Yices": 3.8274692412667322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3351542562114003, + "CVC4": 4.6176959876264387, + "CVC3": 4.3568658504118556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.97414164290891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.977057826177099 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9025423345236661, + "veriT": 12.693752949209042, + "Yices": 1.6622171226864164, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0146308052551376, + "CVC4": 1.6352633214163728, + "CVC3": 0.46772479893066671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.018038235391459, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0157253729139191 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3788130414649986, + "veriT": 11.043559165109917, + "Yices": 11.018609278252926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6831181998483089, + "CVC4": 12.68783427718472, + "CVC3": 11.455506723517374, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.228924213307026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.229906923567038 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 41.0, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24679263247683333, + "veriT": 0.17817030334083336, + "Yices": 7.2180744279659592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.52897211230383334, + "CVC4": 0.22714839331716666, + "CVC3": 0.22172150663500001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21799605585966667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21864422545833331 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0113635063171387, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17037205632090913, + "veriT": 0.1476246131498182, + "Yices": 0.15563858869372729, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16892898410063636, + "CVC4": 0.19854879270454545, + "CVC3": 0.16977369105354548, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17966394422054546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1798670917333636 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19172854153587501, + "veriT": 1.9271471232263222, + "Yices": 0.21208480588375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18933402679099998, + "CVC4": 0.20987548590237504, + "CVC3": 0.18671400183137499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19303338858612501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18863051425725003 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5010305552313998, + "veriT": 4.2650788457109368, + "Yices": 4.1335872527629585, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5134131478833597, + "CVC4": 5.8128679776293426, + "CVC3": 2.9399687676301278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8553956361795958, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8369084125337025 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.71809412275044437, + "veriT": 11.33819467508995, + "Yices": 8.2663354473698085, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0945184900166662, + "CVC4": 11.188751780221406, + "CVC3": 8.3490694646520502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0029485250769135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5479505655312478 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1229432705407456, + "veriT": 3.8747993057356664, + "Yices": 1.353352784720425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6320098069866571, + "CVC4": 11.09509996261532, + "CVC3": 1.091321401688077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.334477384678098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3296177366802828 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6496514110185272, + "veriT": 13.932484386721802, + "Yices": 12.289645044940896, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8143333800460208, + "CVC4": 9.1756436636730605, + "CVC3": 9.2963101613960344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8660328450646979, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8533610522916772 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 189.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257381642237897, + "veriT": 10.180445739141716, + "Yices": 10.346478793697285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97933938785855, + "CVC4": 14.377279232339578, + "CVC3": 13.64865318424587, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.025607407387723, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.412251603381886 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.231316370940879, + "veriT": 13.84630550369709, + "Yices": 13.862787731673489, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.652703260260683, + "CVC4": 12.912833359103537, + "CVC3": 11.666006364940769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23207778829101, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.042747519687081 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8800950050354004, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9406009617469633, + "veriT": 13.311372586104916, + "Yices": 13.602658870479818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6215902946534362, + "CVC4": 13.097250571607212, + "CVC3": 4.4226487988095533, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.11364894403787, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.106802498988062 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2283753967212565, + "veriT": 11.03904565950022, + "Yices": 7.256915731297326, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7337830611719784, + "CVC4": 13.185278154260557, + "CVC3": 10.712890240176485, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.027497209326572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.474153192137294 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5465199820582054, + "veriT": 12.652564570814649, + "Yices": 5.4051697988463312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9137477864766632, + "CVC4": 3.9351220773519224, + "CVC3": 4.0606984189935948, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.870390922866109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.483712069462445 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0932085514068604, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.406339349919123, + "veriT": 9.7083593100569967, + "Yices": 9.4930095653498938, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7465869687538085, + "CVC4": 8.958487258903153, + "CVC3": 0.98308840197024994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1316688388350844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3306062999508468 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 76.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21310042862366665, + "veriT": 3.468959755672667, + "Yices": 3.4823182184169998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.30864903153716666, + "CVC4": 0.32220718163266665, + "CVC3": 0.16178419159816668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.858556098009096, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.860223176792366 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16123402984306667, + "veriT": 9.0262515732185697, + "Yices": 0.13890001038203334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27920257462433334, + "CVC4": 0.18429868552366668, + "CVC3": 1.6404021485188669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15839319742264443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1534738992696778 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 204.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.424454732748059, + "veriT": 13.06358686012366, + "Yices": 12.553293334046442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957119154782522, + "CVC4": 14.28802953378945, + "CVC3": 13.278437698168149, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.211215269174668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.265133303212382 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.375248813756212, + "veriT": 13.609361146099131, + "Yices": 13.180143601551887, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.511194235801829, + "CVC4": 12.318824811219089, + "CVC3": 13.214849751721269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.1553172278538, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.384741030168819 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3438943351042374, + "veriT": 12.248563886772597, + "Yices": 13.17815585735538, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.159994725196045, + "CVC4": 13.615419289630262, + "CVC3": 14.138484016717088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3630523478291918, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1669783799144708 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8749485115312043, + "veriT": 11.305553286632207, + "Yices": 7.8201046248841859, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9696419496475865, + "CVC4": 9.1286099522622131, + "CVC3": 7.9746216742022726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4404630352989494, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1958738598569245 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6788541135416644, + "veriT": 11.366235830167039, + "Yices": 10.145553117735227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.487584443845199, + "CVC4": 8.9066968017559613, + "CVC3": 7.4208554180986139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.306701615305897, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.642375496724949 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 197.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.982370466740882, + "veriT": 12.217427459194727, + "Yices": 12.556899958939717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.09645262735442, + "CVC4": 14.56396214101532, + "CVC3": 13.842608342632452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.106124270758764, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.367592773140853 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8789071603350003, + "veriT": 13.158099778434076, + "Yices": 12.990520606361521, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.641300911215346, + "CVC4": 14.493659537478349, + "CVC3": 12.701605491375558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.91588278891053, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.112185520677881 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1753065586090088, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.260744362726193, + "veriT": 13.261697061768606, + "Yices": 13.582842232230769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.978276253666101, + "CVC4": 14.724401353697255, + "CVC3": 13.03230044430398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.069256462337277, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.953245136065284 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.923138265090433, + "veriT": 13.374056921249929, + "Yices": 13.974141903706633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.970772587685946, + "CVC4": 14.641057195407674, + "CVC3": 12.916299508669965, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237243912616112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.23351563160972 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13043661243614288, + "veriT": 0.10133712057982858, + "Yices": 0.10422399157237501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12613609621060715, + "CVC4": 0.12968540394400002, + "CVC3": 0.1063786567926857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12382466892292855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12208373686705 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10713759639905331, + "veriT": 0.079277629947953343, + "Yices": 0.08373283707018668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10720744973460002, + "CVC4": 0.1037770145864, + "CVC3": 0.084909488834393324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10115112785405334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.099894739716400005 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9574863220566554, + "veriT": 2.1406299047750679, + "Yices": 1.7418153102031801, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0966006130229893, + "CVC4": 2.9631273216536522, + "CVC3": 0.13218113952480998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15762099974420002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15421431541040004 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16312198688820001, + "veriT": 2.9307644810889526, + "Yices": 4.9869664910651803, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1593722751088, + "CVC4": 3.1055089306934911, + "CVC3": 2.9462593940241097, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9572096724889461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9845256701084923 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3148159276410079, + "veriT": 9.8999883862449725, + "Yices": 10.07932412838421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4239693640000362, + "CVC4": 0.1501829447282105, + "CVC3": 0.67705006118521061, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14892323064557891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.706364366604751 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7487759449655975, + "veriT": 11.242066127171171, + "Yices": 11.871524147300278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8429057125698911, + "CVC4": 12.504615309900634, + "CVC3": 8.3751457917332583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.940478295547571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.403737465579214 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.967221722270514, + "veriT": 10.174742850143833, + "Yices": 10.309448245747832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.095062555299895, + "CVC4": 0.15892009646233332, + "CVC3": 7.2963368627200751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.901607850599504, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.153403757556269 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8203408547310003, + "veriT": 4.8141451456144235, + "Yices": 6.5133089915660163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8124476704411669, + "CVC4": 2.625360277284654, + "CVC3": 1.8355088559381667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4883934451284313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3628092216422258 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.290683244672856, + "veriT": 11.105942374260211, + "Yices": 11.181717160747953, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.840920001230284, + "CVC4": 5.7845327335572616, + "CVC3": 12.182886131897986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.577093690070158, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.286881262116546 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5411426620972453, + "veriT": 6.8258231660971669, + "Yices": 8.6522251631837062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.041692582399678, + "CVC4": 0.40676429728150015, + "CVC3": 9.5760773270195649, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9279188708835528, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6821623997183988 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.967306200749123, + "veriT": 10.425758333034389, + "Yices": 10.420507376915999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.633771989871855, + "CVC4": 1.1595749249767762, + "CVC3": 12.460870404087133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1203859647117755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.061257822754344 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.697083354679675, + "veriT": 11.169257354792959, + "Yices": 10.760781975974693, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.959112316245083, + "CVC4": 5.5103288242926336, + "CVC3": 8.7948231367592946, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.220824473019249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.366659522977175 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247209225854931, + "veriT": 10.536587387886724, + "Yices": 9.4192672013076351, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.53892146795646, + "CVC4": 0.15661507719563636, + "CVC3": 12.969625841794503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15092226037172729, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.388581576792118 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7880175422660756, + "veriT": 5.3912036600471334, + "Yices": 10.008048943761711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0506161556180311, + "CVC4": 4.6147905467461117, + "CVC3": 6.5383891887865193, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9707756908813527, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0756082079522828 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1292377208506861, + "veriT": 10.919668067506743, + "Yices": 9.2912169129910307, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3897584033601285, + "CVC4": 5.4232814122926296, + "CVC3": 7.5710402991292378, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1926915457589882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.099611784725386 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0337858255789962, + "veriT": 5.2860109229013821, + "Yices": 8.60027807140718, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9939258840273508, + "CVC4": 3.0850631434640765, + "CVC3": 4.6736065844916439, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0712828195267425, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0545461824990765 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16208782636409999, + "veriT": 1.16348083504071, + "Yices": 5.2366683861594101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15345927621330002, + "CVC4": 8.6828768525188131, + "CVC3": 0.16922753805910001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1946745859616978, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2064248866344998 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2196969985961914, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.706105045320301, + "veriT": 12.81579579220978, + "Yices": 11.920410404078162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.128846289766402, + "CVC4": 14.111920683072281, + "CVC3": 11.464157841421471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.450364184677799, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.456633186970638 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0963381604576363, + "veriT": 9.5153748007848389, + "Yices": 12.618370781525636, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1044652179913639, + "CVC4": 5.3394363128058204, + "CVC3": 5.2925339599656658, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4634245378439035, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1995522514606287 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.015951607797012, + "veriT": 9.1461556709861007, + "Yices": 10.673464508365296, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.535789202901118, + "CVC4": 3.6337021200786368, + "CVC3": 11.966129789531935, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7942885087815679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.792783067901192 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3760452098267155, + "veriT": 8.313277292384857, + "Yices": 6.2569882484126005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5221070535215002, + "CVC4": 5.0753461824097634, + "CVC3": 3.1150316278523631, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8765425089918448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7572853522993723 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19322790318192856, + "veriT": 3.1665857342609849, + "Yices": 3.5559740182374542, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.91770713174915719, + "CVC4": 2.1800975515554915, + "CVC3": 0.13896116439914286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.26343023000614285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20949827325004286 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6485945556137391, + "veriT": 12.824437931099453, + "Yices": 11.812338280987904, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5464323823059871, + "CVC4": 14.111162129088159, + "CVC3": 10.409551435581397, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.773585859210982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.775478014021957 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.933326697645782, + "veriT": 10.108768643970677, + "Yices": 10.114109004898046, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.955842149428754, + "CVC4": 5.1408553227591671, + "CVC3": 4.0038017280052571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.590376880750846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.611134845573529 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1345349638466002, + "veriT": 5.7466457796329902, + "Yices": 8.8070175882647526, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2391414255692399, + "CVC4": 8.6066902688015752, + "CVC3": 6.4627178260009801, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7544099949265917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.752239972338236 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8926457303681854, + "veriT": 9.6831827294780446, + "Yices": 9.5703729383609328, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.748107449212588, + "CVC4": 10.195681153719429, + "CVC3": 8.4214059732713427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.560788551575115, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5507392078795039 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1339392298701316, + "veriT": 10.61880218650202, + "Yices": 7.0637955611340173, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.010324367662358, + "CVC4": 7.9717366148847164, + "CVC3": 6.0815754232296779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8229178332974287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0642944089420023 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4251568672160699, + "veriT": 4.4478239949315483, + "Yices": 4.4215239924436229, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5072843142199481, + "CVC4": 2.036832230295492, + "CVC3": 7.0270797656635731, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4319159224952047, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4294851424663984 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13701637996988233, + "veriT": 0.70153825463134711, + "Yices": 8.3713978153435722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13733207043423531, + "CVC4": 0.97626621387697765, + "CVC3": 1.4160834356520002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.96804993452167054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.96712052372124357 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11661927043315384, + "veriT": 3.6570363366840266, + "Yices": 1.6333914686456847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11170513259240769, + "CVC4": 3.3825384948912673, + "CVC3": 0.1006171817349846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12128790726338462, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11341766671553846 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0812989192741105, + "veriT": 7.0808893720077704, + "Yices": 2.8616133277856655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.349066376074334, + "CVC4": 3.4163501453830496, + "CVC3": 1.3840604250356665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4272762109860366, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9903348985549849 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7065994739532471, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.596265525584574, + "veriT": 11.355553980778947, + "Yices": 11.441756732418199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.026648488115299, + "CVC4": 7.4545279704723004, + "CVC3": 13.405198954572569, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.195196782628396, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.913421558464313 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8779838835456477, + "veriT": 9.5221086253488227, + "Yices": 8.2319333804980559, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6674888408366701, + "CVC4": 4.25043700510638, + "CVC3": 1.3065085328758335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5289946567682691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4108780838851276 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7251665887991532, + "veriT": 13.303744259743405, + "Yices": 13.315013766941631, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.369427644614623, + "CVC4": 12.307443735258525, + "CVC3": 13.202135066262514, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.379721781779269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.942193708848865 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9467785358428955, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19753968255227275, + "veriT": 3.676051947881231, + "Yices": 4.0570935898770415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24552236520690907, + "CVC4": 1.5489422466835057, + "CVC3": 0.71244249280429084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9630249057521922, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9842631348798569 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.878171302890376, + "veriT": 10.552748259675413, + "Yices": 10.620596681391332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.531414525805559, + "CVC4": 1.7931175588007091, + "CVC3": 7.3602564088347568, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4846629904367428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.675052043697304 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8771369457244873, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 37.0, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9544052046816249, + "veriT": 12.703250571583693, + "Yices": 4.0571553949714998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0305479958142501, + "CVC4": 7.3339052304045271, + "CVC3": 1.7275822549108226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23831689632792, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.078469912175168 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21251412727627272, + "veriT": 9.62329988792359, + "Yices": 2.4551051735480942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5630422513646325, + "CVC4": 2.8334170904921105, + "CVC3": 1.7100665933082289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2644618343397891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.982893860386036 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.08359776206834, + "veriT": 13.711186312765461, + "Yices": 7.3401397089803897, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6513352511428749, + "CVC4": 2.157590756764483, + "CVC3": 9.1251705676729529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.481333662557537, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.483714102407429 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9256642950822611, + "veriT": 13.492701820140361, + "Yices": 12.821646666625536, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7774362231857772, + "CVC4": 5.7631633322837583, + "CVC3": 11.997541026467621, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.173841447450569, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.165458470579107 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7471379604914072, + "veriT": 3.3585580388633849, + "Yices": 13.547352329020811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6958014017671112, + "CVC4": 12.980538575295077, + "CVC3": 12.586528094900993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.854484803607745, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8709599013457439 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2384220629095992, + "veriT": 12.793046596416065, + "Yices": 13.794354669340873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3627481917901001, + "CVC4": 14.501798090652969, + "CVC3": 13.126234028107296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.990127353746919, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.059120576522577 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2224696014164254, + "veriT": 12.083908476500227, + "Yices": 6.1415928139345386, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0438815931679022, + "CVC4": 14.803226360073939, + "CVC3": 3.4522653120445894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243665455602947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.08840550534911 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.110386452565621, + "veriT": 11.510977023054823, + "Yices": 10.947689103610223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.141372907249243, + "CVC4": 9.4912821371685379, + "CVC3": 14.231286920482752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.790996732107661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.672558363031888 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1726820849170998, + "veriT": 0.15642588757320003, + "Yices": 4.2253633171513005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1815856747758002, + "CVC4": 5.8173175103080084, + "CVC3": 0.17903598880010002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.72003253728049998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6450223372166537 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 86.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21626940157112501, + "veriT": 1.9269588396316384, + "Yices": 7.2011869407855293, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.43074146976287503, + "CVC4": 0.20399867297287502, + "CVC3": 0.19683469708738749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19663425220117497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1959254975297125 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16577549665556249, + "veriT": 1.909211565715947, + "Yices": 0.15994623698206251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1684605466710625, + "CVC4": 0.19205284307574999, + "CVC3": 0.16690732163337499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17894926822868751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17513948572675 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4852495894796665, + "veriT": 0.1345411554956667, + "Yices": 0.13435532754722224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4810373966014443, + "CVC4": 0.16691632183577776, + "CVC3": 0.14484941538188889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1610981588812222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15858992438500003 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14883714250116667, + "veriT": 8.2404761441236705, + "Yices": 0.143979814624, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17188522919166668, + "CVC4": 0.17692002190091669, + "CVC3": 0.76168326755274995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15665338413025001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16130194044183335 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2341032239951648, + "veriT": 10.131462837999777, + "Yices": 11.490795859050081, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.633338485701312, + "CVC4": 6.5449273038381275, + "CVC3": 4.7284700036504326, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6456492434526595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9507288793609927 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4469984198470556, + "veriT": 3.9067279520001246, + "Yices": 3.9865133013345249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5527042731989482, + "CVC4": 6.7565416870174237, + "CVC3": 1.7291598395306749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9766799000166746, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9578100031780346 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.867562254101645, + "veriT": 9.0103232336894337, + "Yices": 8.3747986827174365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2108550358062775, + "CVC4": 9.6510511452269157, + "CVC3": 12.381355290557064, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6596671698518382, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0927198646360061 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18127085342928573, + "veriT": 6.1991314991921405, + "Yices": 12.190381926596894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20087496140300001, + "CVC4": 6.3828539042315793, + "CVC3": 5.1408917745926406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7499648604084281, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8147398734764284 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1824046907685961, + "veriT": 5.3689242810895834, + "Yices": 4.0133945463470679, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2821962697846461, + "CVC4": 7.3209847752087018, + "CVC3": 2.4006221514942001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3789777309088003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6389383978847001 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5763460481552798, + "veriT": 9.0191641522720332, + "Yices": 9.0726340295605521, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.468944267438024, + "CVC4": 12.091501425345092, + "CVC3": 10.2014216759137, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.678819559614753, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.256536540164191 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6671065092086792, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9855939491350421, + "veriT": 9.1754615062200262, + "Yices": 3.1066655580468163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4878165198827848, + "CVC4": 3.8256236927267633, + "CVC3": 2.2431153972278435, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2156749087883014, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2424889784427178 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9341790676116943, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7274763330228788, + "veriT": 14.116741258081319, + "Yices": 12.553286233573541, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.805586933796308, + "CVC4": 8.9364546905868227, + "CVC3": 8.2710684912943115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.059700664007613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.002396870035259 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.278442287086117, + "veriT": 10.228836435624389, + "Yices": 10.421337778551221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.998953227548546, + "CVC4": 14.313784683057508, + "CVC3": 14.277289163329202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.275359387768894, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.897761566060185 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243442516166535, + "veriT": 11.992216793885131, + "Yices": 11.933849425214257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964052191173241, + "CVC4": 14.671260670324269, + "CVC3": 12.910577853676969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252462364477871, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.627056423117587 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.406036263382997, + "veriT": 11.601021958978952, + "Yices": 11.570082929661762, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.994654404588974, + "CVC4": 11.41199886745699, + "CVC3": 14.285761641119137, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.708125884219456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.001623626751474 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2144106866200364, + "veriT": 13.385552449922146, + "Yices": 13.904290353624864, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.323048786813093, + "CVC4": 14.44423498857342, + "CVC3": 13.677344172610768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244213456428646, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.243111783959522 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.472537550026946, + "veriT": 14.234091833722397, + "Yices": 13.684748652338271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.275630646511294, + "CVC4": 14.387969859469971, + "CVC3": 13.60506012392211, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.0323645230394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.055940932739659 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2007738332766, + "veriT": 9.7820689731595358, + "Yices": 7.0210825070051373, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1476359377389809, + "CVC4": 3.122575831144772, + "CVC3": 2.4018607512552004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8151706357269983, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2631618804048674 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.44163794005407, + "veriT": 14.26928624404915, + "Yices": 11.46209951743943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.197207081025308, + "CVC4": 3.2895362372416854, + "CVC3": 3.3593956488179608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.39840523354019997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.38469533858499999 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4751906713664078, + "veriT": 11.643860578666233, + "Yices": 10.339274157146441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2174749312618554, + "CVC4": 11.212895383777457, + "CVC3": 7.7198617925635933, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4933712694857793, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4876595420307401 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 272.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234169305416168, + "veriT": 10.149306964379363, + "Yices": 10.579579750122626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.617874752178142, + "CVC4": 14.550739942082616, + "CVC3": 13.183389207792773, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.564073719760062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.434526417770776 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 113.0, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.58935773653300005, + "veriT": 7.2519440698167115, + "Yices": 7.1776757634297708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.98703105816983339, + "CVC4": 7.2184972516733374, + "CVC3": 0.4901217275621666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5321996912782132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.524436691790898 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1963334083557129, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1754979794063587, + "veriT": 12.884331340860163, + "Yices": 11.910282049814779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.382011114927641, + "CVC4": 10.590854422581685, + "CVC3": 12.164857714121847, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.231092106805237, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2300670390735373 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.058498790564022, + "veriT": 12.635425794418975, + "Yices": 13.424563116500432, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972963847188907, + "CVC4": 14.348212795262864, + "CVC3": 13.916387115113892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255772392770515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.631010083045638 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5630770620873493, + "veriT": 14.234317300727518, + "Yices": 12.63510994862756, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1106829962111515, + "CVC4": 13.400007052682129, + "CVC3": 14.225796966635874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8963435429574544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6447471715887292 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 124.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9222176749963698, + "veriT": 11.960459897816992, + "Yices": 12.521025957697738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.529581016455307, + "CVC4": 14.43772484754807, + "CVC3": 10.619996601499428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.092839797752156, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.990294696387702 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244622148392665, + "veriT": 11.831194545785488, + "Yices": 13.500790902595694, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962967512471051, + "CVC4": 14.568267621054039, + "CVC3": 13.046764163464529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.205923023776085, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.206021205989067 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.147205367750665, + "veriT": 14.242314234638421, + "Yices": 14.234644418293785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.924396901772518, + "CVC4": 12.525047349882696, + "CVC3": 7.6047523908200318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3337576742344144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6312687922659137 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.875, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12435625004400003, + "veriT": 0.094551714290558642, + "Yices": 0.097480133613872422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12268561375872414, + "CVC4": 0.12647823273303452, + "CVC3": 0.10194966979911035, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12149382448917241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11920644869299998 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10748280370192274, + "veriT": 0.080543613829827276, + "Yices": 0.084225599662809097, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10817095057252274, + "CVC4": 0.1038442236976682, + "CVC3": 0.085058155105413646, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10302894910790911, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10196599451442276 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8996195734556252, + "veriT": 1.8685046445614077, + "Yices": 3.1484251310776878, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8950553128044998, + "CVC4": 1.9895956078209318, + "CVC3": 1.8790433632091685, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8937709856505913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9172912997580578 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.4500000476837158, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6424902278822122, + "veriT": 5.5468213277006146, + "Yices": 9.63490368164077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4757289230851329, + "CVC4": 0.16195830584946155, + "CVC3": 2.8138755908570312, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7979223538548363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5171611652194166 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6254453782919471, + "veriT": 7.1416601212196404, + "Yices": 6.8909881291689929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7497485475470258, + "CVC4": 7.4779750903526949, + "CVC3": 5.6961821313067871, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.114353251897601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.149201217538675 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5505056381225586, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7430440792308577, + "veriT": 10.800296254582225, + "Yices": 9.0793598766278425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1369825938544285, + "CVC4": 1.5625318612442329, + "CVC3": 8.9796110540193723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5057160379843886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4798896344837829 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.130428963895111, + "veriT": 10.046652778342832, + "Yices": 10.660780034383428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.294824865496441, + "CVC4": 9.096503771466999, + "CVC3": 10.024662575225655, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8667372974367709, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1572509547934811 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.350271514736283, + "veriT": 10.1970691148155, + "Yices": 10.333183207149501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963681281348945, + "CVC4": 3.7332116989710005, + "CVC3": 9.957628465494901, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4325415531024008, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.793031034954431 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.485926314599959, + "veriT": 9.4962595561776677, + "Yices": 9.6579200811677328, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.974416518865233, + "CVC4": 0.356911614908, + "CVC3": 12.792153169677768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4637882681482974, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.759124308616066 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8452379703521729, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.871293063860016, + "veriT": 10.788717539519205, + "Yices": 10.538514735647539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.209080056671286, + "CVC4": 2.4495432457541759, + "CVC3": 10.576735422361187, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3107409074461742, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.581741898988087 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23736281672727, + "veriT": 11.175396833027753, + "Yices": 11.155749267484831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953169889932413, + "CVC4": 3.712007943262206, + "CVC3": 12.33330342720088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.195682673884181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.038767668914653 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.988125569909279, + "veriT": 13.199129905909942, + "Yices": 9.6427467777313556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1681999104301317, + "CVC4": 6.4182222131545466, + "CVC3": 10.514270630447543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.688371828802735, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.840304213854573 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3949885732491882, + "veriT": 8.8690989641203739, + "Yices": 10.064000000689198, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8582338405071912, + "CVC4": 1.6867708033391282, + "CVC3": 7.2681994820741185, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4049940621949881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6238251505758088 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2027566083496235, + "veriT": 8.910995627094831, + "Yices": 6.2344627091442471, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0113710181903315, + "CVC4": 7.8607478084283082, + "CVC3": 3.8056096815143903, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.58572369221692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.595848186935077 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.707658585180768, + "veriT": 13.133623250844506, + "Yices": 12.56037593362448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.384834073178125, + "CVC4": 13.711354013854667, + "CVC3": 12.70974644405306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.21484751465152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.211053413903752 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2122402352541597, + "veriT": 14.228235380648002, + "Yices": 14.245612643172894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2995247013522038, + "CVC4": 11.136314983404919, + "CVC3": 9.3559838531892741, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.383145076179666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.452370846491959 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.184598933115228, + "veriT": 5.1395381881124331, + "Yices": 5.2545819470350006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5441311884704838, + "CVC4": 0.19347677124100002, + "CVC3": 10.657941253225262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5082910574251858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7168585404377863 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9619546759155333, + "veriT": 2.9410960523377732, + "Yices": 12.99884589207571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8169273239866, + "CVC4": 8.6457954198796436, + "CVC3": 10.578737788029006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.150589893354192, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1328572253517253 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7255646713267874, + "veriT": 12.605099184494652, + "Yices": 6.1677958888785867, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7347319903323752, + "CVC4": 3.7935788278970128, + "CVC3": 5.8085143073029117, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4384488859951778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4372156864366596 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13879597793335294, + "veriT": 14.208232739284805, + "Yices": 0.30245520758505878, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22127269201494115, + "CVC4": 1.9170953204629217, + "CVC3": 0.14143243295888236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.215623508304059, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.231421570445109 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8166912671925557, + "veriT": 11.860281819293439, + "Yices": 8.4274622577666971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6818687914993538, + "CVC4": 9.9614397804147128, + "CVC3": 6.0113168362946618, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5251923445955189, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5272300034728197 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7637219429016113, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5679311923203965, + "veriT": 10.166768858434352, + "Yices": 10.348447242207451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.683814580117464, + "CVC4": 0.14932186924109678, + "CVC3": 0.70741073533132259, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14908443761235482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.447997146199343 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20327200235927273, + "veriT": 10.167857285060455, + "Yices": 10.339683333731456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.44818633893454546, + "CVC4": 0.15321325118463636, + "CVC3": 0.31850855880690909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15192406828900001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.641284136866016 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6586539745330811, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242510728565438, + "veriT": 10.163744462270051, + "Yices": 10.33809214407805, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961210845415408, + "CVC4": 0.1592830508675, + "CVC3": 11.49362744196306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2692041760205484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.326573318238452 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.369806287093359, + "veriT": 11.506757097340852, + "Yices": 9.8627732365954852, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.756345938412103, + "CVC4": 3.7786920309132879, + "CVC3": 13.064918202487464, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9137499267245817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.218243603539056 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1629435293364461, + "veriT": 4.144010534739377, + "Yices": 1.7966552360000001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4845656819093329, + "CVC4": 2.6262738807974335, + "CVC3": 2.4828452561119243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4899646508048932, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4953381530004712 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0438295452819171, + "veriT": 9.4764531969890822, + "Yices": 5.4464782542875545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8269097426463681, + "CVC4": 1.7449387348995602, + "CVC3": 6.0900079647861602, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3002259246796601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.545542922301264 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8462411510949126, + "veriT": 13.706392543648708, + "Yices": 8.7109750784081257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7997404982220822, + "CVC4": 9.0393577223856596, + "CVC3": 10.926516349500055, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.474304191120487, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.01024709561927 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6046317062774333, + "veriT": 6.3738001277899476, + "Yices": 6.4943071416144305, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.375134151486054, + "CVC4": 3.1297149255753158, + "CVC3": 1.6238130717309354, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6112499784580532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.014752567104484 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.331751444730733, + "veriT": 10.837577801421943, + "Yices": 10.516608812719456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.175739432949277, + "CVC4": 8.3736275316589897, + "CVC3": 11.797836578161025, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237558849045662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.267940207300922 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3511010928277134, + "veriT": 7.2442801419866631, + "Yices": 11.719267891345611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4745809142015256, + "CVC4": 12.394283486888053, + "CVC3": 6.5268110084181021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.035051065213795, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.786249831389207 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2797745241590777, + "veriT": 0.90995314333750021, + "Yices": 0.91180477942077498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3385845925491358, + "CVC4": 0.18521937949727499, + "CVC3": 0.089319605800133331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.277649577387902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2810048721702076 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13315024854542856, + "veriT": 7.2400947490715435, + "Yices": 9.2560184415066669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13228481179871429, + "CVC4": 6.1907705415217942, + "CVC3": 0.12079137557071429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12885155922057143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13230571052642859 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14989505051411667, + "veriT": 8.4472353024952493, + "Yices": 10.148420049477465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14631356426216666, + "CVC4": 0.14946391866433331, + "CVC3": 0.14467917885951667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6950596104628834, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6117960542431646 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1555610150271316, + "veriT": 2.6379166211717835, + "Yices": 4.8033863616623167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2159965988503334, + "CVC4": 1.3412103275304632, + "CVC3": 1.0501689643540333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15774709570783335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0801608455942178 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6103200078694861, + "veriT": 5.1694693709971995, + "Yices": 11.613055201067143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.788527560929472, + "CVC4": 6.7067424306629606, + "CVC3": 2.6123156351442307, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5912672206510905, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4195260211534082 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7658254983559805, + "veriT": 4.1905246030668994, + "Yices": 5.7038554264377019, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6849013357954985, + "CVC4": 2.8485744858964974, + "CVC3": 2.0359931302914305, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4941035156274989, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.491212975829141 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9612176276108846, + "veriT": 10.370123597146465, + "Yices": 10.42728587642225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9622029202974511, + "CVC4": 12.329765836704363, + "CVC3": 8.419995083126139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.345544248106162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.927255345539358 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1254300653939664, + "veriT": 8.1292389106685476, + "Yices": 9.5417375909132502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7767926126759521, + "CVC4": 8.4725969272982073, + "CVC3": 8.4178958175928447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8358773481741544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8511316075449962 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22610495789850002, + "veriT": 2.11039217474818, + "Yices": 4.9123693862154223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.43481219632766005, + "CVC4": 2.9682522959833939, + "CVC3": 0.16567831421180002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11668214300802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11965594212126 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3402003832265912, + "veriT": 11.152066888198037, + "Yices": 11.236476090510251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2349187324404785, + "CVC4": 9.5607920902752586, + "CVC3": 7.3936283999056895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7752137311868275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.426205682795043 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6668252152044998, + "veriT": 6.5505146404200296, + "Yices": 6.2809600131265277, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9694527315117503, + "CVC4": 4.5660084299726451, + "CVC3": 5.9486635901858298, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7356390171096585, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2193734931921885 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15221087928844446, + "veriT": 1.5985245066498579, + "Yices": 0.1468503974708889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14716489729244445, + "CVC4": 0.18232927827855555, + "CVC3": 0.14840173267855555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16933417643022222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16610524513355551 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6969264910832225, + "veriT": 1.7151596931523563, + "Yices": 5.752774278387573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.697352407340122, + "CVC4": 14.34393761271191, + "CVC3": 2.4710284539177336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14475444211344446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14272096354455555 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.87168969574420008, + "veriT": 12.866254940566721, + "Yices": 6.4322927080183803, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8398013826125106, + "CVC4": 4.0503541114515329, + "CVC3": 5.6586892294024649, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.728042956643205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1084124483930635 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3966373558798626, + "veriT": 13.780992056063587, + "Yices": 13.538302562116858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9810134218015154, + "CVC4": 14.907264117244004, + "CVC3": 9.5255681447633904, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24194962692537, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.001823773655685 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8875796852681912, + "veriT": 13.547297658649518, + "Yices": 8.9506242698936678, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0515892817522516, + "CVC4": 0.30427173750566666, + "CVC3": 3.0732563125452494, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8622519698137561, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1981081133296989 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2716338728216665, + "veriT": 1.2533024513372224, + "Yices": 6.641064988859819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2757493329613334, + "CVC4": 4.8690118093333634, + "CVC3": 1.7283902136139704, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7163524859783974, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.906094296401744 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14892439963818183, + "veriT": 3.9687172706223777, + "Yices": 0.14034090493790907, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14553108754990909, + "CVC4": 0.17191448569536363, + "CVC3": 0.1470904107391818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15490753509445457, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15786627813109091 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16932405544835294, + "veriT": 0.14727272322547055, + "Yices": 0.16066897453505888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17044212040199999, + "CVC4": 0.19309332717041178, + "CVC3": 0.16872657404117647, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18247621015235294, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18092611499258826 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5378309907205354, + "veriT": 7.1002438376543413, + "Yices": 7.0942727979094, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6085846948543443, + "CVC4": 8.6848926399051756, + "CVC3": 1.5105375804336845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3062621283824773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2970640608452646 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9565625190734863, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9968630120837607, + "veriT": 8.8780867854457242, + "Yices": 5.6720485161584149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0403610185162364, + "CVC4": 12.534083044398571, + "CVC3": 9.9174133946344813, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0634847347154253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9567495408803159 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9669723383664248, + "veriT": 6.8827380166940015, + "Yices": 7.877631318125653, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3745241374484554, + "CVC4": 9.0389306828198759, + "CVC3": 3.676718107503417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8593584037525646, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1022921355936717 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 55.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25986734476478573, + "veriT": 4.6272131437471433, + "Yices": 11.973217133991657, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.5190827130832143, + "CVC4": 0.22711281875328568, + "CVC3": 1.2658393354184898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2093450544373159, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2076797586060848 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5401047340314356, + "veriT": 10.197058362947381, + "Yices": 4.9461771335168168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3080759020379045, + "CVC4": 5.4050774266441923, + "CVC3": 3.0498032501282499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21084984450112501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20575020526912502 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9351869821548462, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259277368862854, + "veriT": 10.177351668620545, + "Yices": 10.357979034561454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.983218234235341, + "CVC4": 14.343101960021359, + "CVC3": 13.870841374566986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.112288458600244, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.806855600699004 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.953266922573892, + "veriT": 14.210851404214685, + "Yices": 12.702777411813942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.942897058573351, + "CVC4": 13.494900519489384, + "CVC3": 13.127444349738028, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.890316258200953, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.885958974253604 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25694610488399999, + "veriT": 12.982487956046667, + "Yices": 11.843020965771151, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1672061951215, + "CVC4": 12.077320450731818, + "CVC3": 4.2671775821914997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.907553272604877, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.903630181968113 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0403125830739608, + "veriT": 12.612087031809196, + "Yices": 11.695728396855888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.540724437346512, + "CVC4": 11.730919632846522, + "CVC3": 11.727634709439617, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6307807309978362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.960216374912324 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.730320383717217, + "veriT": 14.215409864825419, + "Yices": 13.51995775933427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.894404369781117, + "CVC4": 14.338279170635916, + "CVC3": 14.218383266873113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228387741922315, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230868101661587 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4745593288383843, + "veriT": 12.218483871279256, + "Yices": 12.1781545186345, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.022033708859853, + "CVC4": 12.57017358853526, + "CVC3": 4.8599600994026417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.575223222672227, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.470135692637909 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0353181300951744, + "veriT": 13.413299011604934, + "Yices": 7.7919356526962122, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4608047710772718, + "CVC4": 11.480179493075534, + "CVC3": 8.6313850405656947, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8141660349761048, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8179261591392555 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.98907851508569233, + "veriT": 5.4588258509750993, + "Yices": 0.2919313247073847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1402331158936154, + "CVC4": 0.28973053698900003, + "CVC3": 5.4739379142823372, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17494396376592308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17080819476230769 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 139.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6194502416279084, + "veriT": 11.216213961300408, + "Yices": 5.6587881623960454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0765540600916914, + "CVC4": 6.7635034047799634, + "CVC3": 2.1020861165667504, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8135481305194032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6669735182021004 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.166372537612915, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9347334525378184, + "veriT": 13.121788286143772, + "Yices": 11.285063091961785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.153170904680922, + "CVC4": 8.0364629411358326, + "CVC3": 13.265843893520257, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.266275006318109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1199212542348658 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9459907722093521, + "veriT": 9.485041238012748, + "Yices": 14.237700067452169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.256058925109633, + "CVC4": 14.762806304036138, + "CVC3": 14.245433536525324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.31675585392200001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.267500237976875 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257794398212146, + "veriT": 13.393127116242495, + "Yices": 12.027689744814504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.983081570965641, + "CVC4": 14.410790629238514, + "CVC3": 14.018914461397816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.299058418739421, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.730318206691491 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4535114298099394, + "veriT": 11.136047161303527, + "Yices": 10.933377453321125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8706815309360483, + "CVC4": 5.7601439350143471, + "CVC3": 9.034249056071797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.498290111303907, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.490597129890791 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 269.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.84943139285258, + "veriT": 11.109286830300233, + "Yices": 12.257085601999433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977545744324496, + "CVC4": 14.543102920652151, + "CVC3": 12.113797400585081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.985727177309917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.442796687489231 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.284058120441774, + "veriT": 14.234223339403879, + "Yices": 13.831340840627062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.186118930444293, + "CVC4": 14.606349886532014, + "CVC3": 13.765166565492173, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.010627144169209, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.033440196035857 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0820895662257772, + "veriT": 13.350962546575326, + "Yices": 13.235227241087715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968620786557665, + "CVC4": 13.031511278047835, + "CVC3": 12.171366797954976, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.693074631544675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.037433210891562 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.265271649574451, + "veriT": 13.773265489706896, + "Yices": 14.212737408008609, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980591540464502, + "CVC4": 14.719774802225016, + "CVC3": 14.099016896409541, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.740449932767261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.749414826959351 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.252174819965557, + "veriT": 11.414881539883165, + "Yices": 13.255741795958949, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.159387305463557, + "CVC4": 14.573972378169604, + "CVC3": 10.900490295262367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.039661728847722, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.606502330949464 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12591679437412498, + "veriT": 0.099129573581024991, + "Yices": 0.10068870256535833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12282825250770833, + "CVC4": 0.12593236381645834, + "CVC3": 0.1036515514489625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12072057445112501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12054797932797501 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11621846781859441, + "veriT": 0.089559136437872222, + "Yices": 0.092586255599144449, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11675936774481666, + "CVC4": 0.11274889804626111, + "CVC3": 0.094086272231316659, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11231649474103333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11005064696646667 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5941442504014689, + "veriT": 1.5777570039656272, + "Yices": 4.2015570953041719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6908826852982779, + "CVC4": 2.1661489270188943, + "CVC3": 0.1474243197618143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1599875059772857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20665332307500003 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1957298041617319, + "veriT": 6.428097478390109, + "Yices": 6.5080270210838425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5005708771490465, + "CVC4": 2.2673842334043508, + "CVC3": 6.2564741864098394, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1575524566972475, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7902946807841502 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21065597253948151, + "veriT": 10.163963236968145, + "Yices": 10.35559725627137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26370179669288885, + "CVC4": 0.15033277357125924, + "CVC3": 0.71526552207633354, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14873729039311112, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.40831554161268 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19089657833469997, + "veriT": 8.1558884103866998, + "Yices": 10.582870304013699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34457613753290001, + "CVC4": 0.15003021998759999, + "CVC3": 0.2834101142994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14954604690080001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0625696672905085 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1987418911964127, + "veriT": 5.1474710395673169, + "Yices": 6.920155666117668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5796685743617154, + "CVC4": 0.15828657636983332, + "CVC3": 5.2012201247909093, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9014960487520036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4969163184701708 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5982145071029663, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.2370062176602, + "veriT": 10.157673935461002, + "Yices": 10.322035935003273, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953831709831176, + "CVC4": 0.24983511066745454, + "CVC3": 11.631916184668713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1631239113273404, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.288084507131067 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238200433727895, + "veriT": 10.159866437774427, + "Yices": 10.339505529205571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955522450915803, + "CVC4": 0.1552164498732857, + "CVC3": 10.568675597201286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14298287721528571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.254970912046753 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24012381500741, + "veriT": 10.155021382994573, + "Yices": 10.336429854837572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959790731610465, + "CVC4": 0.153784142816, + "CVC3": 14.24048936992053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14712768755914288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.753101405992991 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.562207616592028, + "veriT": 9.1640471255838296, + "Yices": 9.2763739984034306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.362131436731792, + "CVC4": 0.16015258929483334, + "CVC3": 10.726041637411344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18952401684416667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5818054555967853 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.077284603530401, + "veriT": 9.3309281666257515, + "Yices": 10.327087482797749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.737762972426273, + "CVC4": 0.16875033909708334, + "CVC3": 11.679054650739936, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.337747681227599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.244259178098709 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7186363824663888, + "veriT": 5.510738990101717, + "Yices": 9.8214572899479204, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3349345304491864, + "CVC4": 1.7081489277138731, + "CVC3": 4.8066411506233608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1063167026471934, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.219789703091477 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.057518670944969, + "veriT": 11.062516583399523, + "Yices": 10.464565535454067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.571307935936389, + "CVC4": 7.825532310009975, + "CVC3": 11.14570614534791, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6050276279254003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.327611518817765 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8857946127918979, + "veriT": 7.8897666288280348, + "Yices": 7.9460341414535902, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.043401827647179, + "CVC4": 2.0042402129785715, + "CVC3": 9.6406201758045391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4768728903730111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6483508961437732 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4366203683174872, + "veriT": 7.5315900879131057, + "Yices": 10.027757947948569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3103732361714151, + "CVC4": 8.3639229205903014, + "CVC3": 6.4664963371155508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.99309221982731, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7477562698514513 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15445314015945455, + "veriT": 10.412633112013587, + "Yices": 7.4288713290141564, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.29445918706427276, + "CVC4": 7.9968482077197995, + "CVC3": 1.4725715822850467, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7324259481026978, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7759298295720782 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1724530135627558, + "veriT": 6.6753119563317256, + "Yices": 6.2025079422431775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.81835853317475, + "CVC4": 7.3760295930666153, + "CVC3": 3.1797407910719229, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1989824678733552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7050312395008205 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7803570057231335, + "veriT": 10.621477405229095, + "Yices": 9.1887942567277356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5375564532227459, + "CVC4": 11.625031148583313, + "CVC3": 5.9020235609147722, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.598665000213254, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.59559966876294 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5733943735916285, + "veriT": 4.2611431088427922, + "Yices": 3.2529382987155557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5675094045764502, + "CVC4": 2.8599199388775278, + "CVC3": 2.8856693022958995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1110735929613489, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1076812051431983 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.533858875071842, + "veriT": 1.11128525712842, + "Yices": 1.13067991022695, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6033761200129075, + "CVC4": 0.12826251211930001, + "CVC3": 0.22263859141874001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12968773927640001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2489111710919927 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8514793987487632, + "veriT": 13.284862295014838, + "Yices": 12.309353995213771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.09544435807617, + "CVC4": 12.261419296021161, + "CVC3": 12.886401798497934, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.966839157930588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.995679254010881 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8111756039240783, + "veriT": 6.8365746332584543, + "Yices": 12.1083942685169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8122411464163051, + "CVC4": 10.891362491160379, + "CVC3": 5.0363387417575129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.743473480808353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3139127020874835 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.981552156522158, + "veriT": 7.837104087683846, + "Yices": 11.219587197826975, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.532406126385325, + "CVC4": 0.15558517141107692, + "CVC3": 9.4725073332370311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7774299573537311, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7832517623612087 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.85977661183751419, + "veriT": 7.2670079283428732, + "Yices": 5.1433276539799975, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1374683650724287, + "CVC4": 1.1692598818934632, + "CVC3": 2.1422136660936202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.88690172239785714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.89812754160801433 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8755735309438588, + "veriT": 10.152989581407168, + "Yices": 10.302351001946667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2529070673331351, + "CVC4": 1.8150912115390003, + "CVC3": 8.7113046415746158, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.500985010707466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3162385060960702 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.788531662446665, + "veriT": 8.9227674838386903, + "Yices": 11.809316937092008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.593688643593634, + "CVC4": 4.1831421839952609, + "CVC3": 12.059595831039564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1434891986492604, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.715486584783376 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1885964870452881, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2139973662697248, + "veriT": 11.008766015558763, + "Yices": 12.041865528889275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.031471545834103, + "CVC4": 11.802545393264904, + "CVC3": 6.3287547192329852, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.205519960148491, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.201803509806984 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4542314479274072, + "veriT": 5.6129843042580987, + "Yices": 3.3084128044645427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9418180321071938, + "CVC4": 4.3593985886918558, + "CVC3": 3.7615198907149776, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9107184455590351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.052770687101949 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5030768997097139, + "veriT": 2.1369214743561038, + "Yices": 13.565102215857994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4707846437039995, + "CVC4": 10.272907256796634, + "CVC3": 8.5574273069942866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2540777260054092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2519172974394381 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2023464769786001, + "veriT": 9.6421882338824449, + "Yices": 12.798083124265096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3777548098469596, + "CVC4": 10.384702201206466, + "CVC3": 9.3654040146386848, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.000926308960951, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9992622502530359 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1602563858032227, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5976405093309474, + "veriT": 10.721155194881923, + "Yices": 11.958662540679216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.343332516479725, + "CVC4": 11.413517470828046, + "CVC3": 8.2733954608982376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.311882946430023, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.31185928453098 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.394310480182634, + "veriT": 14.197971351460072, + "Yices": 6.7185412761038092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.467578653596942, + "CVC4": 14.072739433117153, + "CVC3": 14.114495129811882, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.477817555759376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.458915865304878 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.640915739152076, + "veriT": 10.115234692869617, + "Yices": 10.113850346408624, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.829570172254442, + "CVC4": 4.7478429261388477, + "CVC3": 2.8686906545213495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.011162269185572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.01596987193096 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9969853004058287, + "veriT": 3.2969558043617897, + "Yices": 2.1436736541296564, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4937634771371315, + "CVC4": 2.4975435986840897, + "CVC3": 2.1439017475499349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1732588999567337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.927135032823222 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14345517309985714, + "veriT": 2.0080196847584459, + "Yices": 0.44059600229614287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15268586685471427, + "CVC4": 0.20885553387185718, + "CVC3": 0.14187490170328571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15195613740185715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14793616701000004 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4435405459852966, + "veriT": 13.516650558647697, + "Yices": 10.674668361448322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.074777625086075, + "CVC4": 6.2913198732579101, + "CVC3": 4.3199957179201096, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9995036658277883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8540525748138919 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24237546704276669, + "veriT": 4.1172432238536611, + "Yices": 1.4632711575105333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1289351903691558, + "CVC4": 2.9735401479311867, + "CVC3": 1.0738355114258209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0651395939602855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.88608397811848838 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6328146981906073, + "veriT": 10.668157950279229, + "Yices": 12.269770891500492, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9234587325363606, + "CVC4": 8.5338728658811203, + "CVC3": 4.9657162077726671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9928890589484132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.927850174186032 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9042100273071338, + "veriT": 5.0945849929894642, + "Yices": 7.7389026312913929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3379096367664194, + "CVC4": 14.418534998853083, + "CVC3": 4.3668136298201325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8976078987789764, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8253214583983879 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6436505317687988, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.229205744896417, + "veriT": 11.95594136296072, + "Yices": 11.662275565434767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.947568403197913, + "CVC4": 6.6862862392986777, + "CVC3": 14.217999891170557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8612210779614529, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.837724712277705 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22610710456050001, + "veriT": 5.1367468437907631, + "Yices": 7.7236939653077243, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5157297109239751, + "CVC4": 0.23785465591612501, + "CVC3": 0.42063702095950006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2199385023685068, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.92207054884196 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.398858792799725, + "veriT": 10.09374418030767, + "Yices": 13.348908920589835, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.093902620448219, + "CVC4": 6.0708044922824342, + "CVC3": 5.8982305052588817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2508882388769784, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6391245377819903 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2257311313446273, + "veriT": 12.205226614982434, + "Yices": 12.29589689624208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.339649933647161, + "CVC4": 11.620509225181497, + "CVC3": 7.4842975109397347, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.169914583815061, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.677465672534492 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.77979418639285, + "veriT": 11.514791083668705, + "Yices": 9.7061168903383788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.372825687865515, + "CVC4": 9.5939781953406751, + "CVC3": 13.071735363991777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.229673317980991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.473852130114752 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.33936589801742861, + "veriT": 13.047904233833377, + "Yices": 4.1808270474542466, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.372036144962733, + "CVC4": 4.469025270108661, + "CVC3": 3.4011218712866631, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4842535360153111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4957255695725653 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8809402267147504, + "veriT": 13.189575834576075, + "Yices": 0.53498262480408332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8916228412564995, + "CVC4": 0.34721898647816668, + "CVC3": 0.19015744851491664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.928709340158406, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.919335536687425 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9982521384134424, + "veriT": 14.218488828930374, + "Yices": 12.875932760831185, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9087436696196391, + "CVC4": 12.016391868997216, + "CVC3": 14.140093553304636, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235435368196509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.228355951553327 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0253190450201819, + "veriT": 11.655129094573224, + "Yices": 8.8514690359820882, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2183481871026363, + "CVC4": 3.0021476350702456, + "CVC3": 9.107755105646314, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1081305886620889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0466230770718115 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1094164848327637, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8685959577560425, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1652192605607068, + "veriT": 9.1840766797347015, + "Yices": 11.069590189060703, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4951275615415698, + "CVC4": 7.2784182871020819, + "CVC3": 10.628645241722564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8330038063997289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6914317806032013 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 75.0, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0111110210418701, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1741107530646402, + "veriT": 0.98093719998149986, + "Yices": 1.8294011601473334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2341468937423952, + "CVC4": 1.3687474138823559, + "CVC3": 0.17075523634216669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.28756869423991666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1043122054372194 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4956248523970279, + "veriT": 5.5677362678457882, + "Yices": 0.40006034967781423, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5534475503933276, + "CVC4": 12.292009009483765, + "CVC3": 4.1517234962531324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2003184911422653, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9171696202212849 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12170285222028573, + "veriT": 9.8356183023591885, + "Yices": 5.8107717591592154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11772666555270002, + "CVC4": 2.1449078407000899, + "CVC3": 2.1209970806946763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7177700461540741, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7576609363358324 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.27195533584209086, + "veriT": 0.21225855702609089, + "Yices": 9.7185331850508145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.75028721561309086, + "CVC4": 0.2391989720031818, + "CVC3": 0.23674294054054543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22789243542227275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2239986635389091 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7918342201274022, + "veriT": 13.892710272963415, + "Yices": 11.118854367021051, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3958307003735833, + "CVC4": 6.9233311850734065, + "CVC3": 5.2832811471066048, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7938648769233343, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.793016916050443 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1380720138549805, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.672063083175978, + "veriT": 12.192141531338573, + "Yices": 12.193169848772818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.164220694303726, + "CVC4": 12.921737493116959, + "CVC3": 11.091437594579723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5581207450169927, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.262638532067989 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2162003517150879, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.43715903648135557, + "veriT": 9.9581410680617477, + "Yices": 6.6347705272315425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8247782305318683, + "CVC4": 4.9055881675888964, + "CVC3": 9.3007338609604258, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4707951773602179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1820591213047589 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5903821469131427, + "veriT": 9.6039213036138893, + "Yices": 1.5938252917251428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6627986473828571, + "CVC4": 1.6433919335780003, + "CVC3": 1.9810070022935713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16969247056671427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16681699804757141 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.636374035560106, + "veriT": 8.3789684894143672, + "Yices": 9.3194518585170236, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.314784859254752, + "CVC4": 9.7993362779210464, + "CVC3": 6.5456341187595593, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9001014455381364, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8030825721446258 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1544731403162857, + "veriT": 0.13144621331585712, + "Yices": 0.14728192215114286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1556306897481429, + "CVC4": 0.17188275779471432, + "CVC3": 0.14964888939614282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16901979534528572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16718489763942859 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2255434543119468, + "veriT": 13.716126647190084, + "Yices": 2.9869221060952604, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0469777474177118, + "CVC4": 5.6728001870805471, + "CVC3": 4.9116397810319175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.019434006253515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.046818355358175 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.516577351597764, + "veriT": 13.765803421502447, + "Yices": 13.083823457432988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.724712950867287, + "CVC4": 12.876053623523683, + "CVC3": 12.779588407668392, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231701440281178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236197022610462 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 87.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24417585295062499, + "veriT": 7.9855127230880045, + "Yices": 5.6390837622093173, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.50698020656737508, + "CVC4": 2.1366404020068095, + "CVC3": 1.9212542989712218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4291703432792531, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4209197206707325 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8700065884175983, + "veriT": 11.929148830158161, + "Yices": 12.28848335186936, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.513598649812039, + "CVC4": 10.801137646286456, + "CVC3": 7.3164910952286766, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.7300938842395, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5198046981125035 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5483959177991293, + "veriT": 14.262078790959237, + "Yices": 8.071147307724182, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.809924491328536, + "CVC4": 4.831717276688078, + "CVC3": 3.5748710720711458, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4692161221664544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.503398603654182 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 104.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.916329910517495, + "veriT": 12.680650161296263, + "Yices": 11.764543651547076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.732133107338909, + "CVC4": 10.856583241110609, + "CVC3": 12.770969417748432, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.62624818796027, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.739265412362265 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.252343093423331, + "veriT": 10.199827417057715, + "Yices": 10.335888201948572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973473685110491, + "CVC4": 14.360645476572406, + "CVC3": 14.248908923683349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251182609929007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.440010883283199 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 181.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1088918028109234, + "veriT": 9.6330205403997766, + "Yices": 8.2902545588303695, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4226383037949137, + "CVC4": 9.1943023189196307, + "CVC3": 9.274351520915193, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7291783146667656, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5142534243139272 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1745615005493164, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.184138747277705, + "veriT": 12.504304111942611, + "Yices": 12.84541327907421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.942535769926387, + "CVC4": 12.921499857940807, + "CVC3": 13.95558598906522, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.538446630651144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.304719726933527 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2066425078831822, + "veriT": 13.169268549626853, + "Yices": 14.226426843901095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.819733622660614, + "CVC4": 14.61221364257697, + "CVC3": 14.203586459458837, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0174282963057779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1432761215998894 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 109.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.195455726296139, + "veriT": 9.714847239404147, + "Yices": 10.496515369780612, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.024690767423426, + "CVC4": 13.62127888770833, + "CVC3": 7.7178021933829415, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.500125046187881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3091555157908825 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 168.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.704124520186706, + "veriT": 13.238862729586781, + "Yices": 13.907015801898615, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964968937041251, + "CVC4": 14.654700212822952, + "CVC3": 13.79812970910268, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.26593034774973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.260470267986223 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6342636350226067, + "veriT": 14.239966429957457, + "Yices": 14.015700113055708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.945279542081931, + "CVC4": 14.538599288190392, + "CVC3": 11.439409743934817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.579080979635698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.595163711479513 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.209322160801481, + "veriT": 14.23285543539766, + "Yices": 14.02668741890696, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.190388754380397, + "CVC4": 14.524827112517398, + "CVC3": 12.851475449160962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255504284927515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.258956620900086 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 324.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25330760624273, + "veriT": 10.822781240734168, + "Yices": 13.081291042253616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965358780201212, + "CVC4": 14.690818435521857, + "CVC3": 13.986785704631696, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.355418199138873, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.901172428331396 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.262690802544121, + "veriT": 14.256354251217473, + "Yices": 13.855323841628721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.984241560953009, + "CVC4": 14.792562757442942, + "CVC3": 13.359570149860112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.010873141260468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.037100574574724 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 53.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13287226277913333, + "veriT": 1.5185730104669335, + "Yices": 1.5225680382380191, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15772797811871428, + "CVC4": 2.1314247408599747, + "CVC3": 0.097987970275366695, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1255332360490455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1250235788096803 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12796642176933337, + "veriT": 0.10171144485180555, + "Yices": 0.10398686510861112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1236075821276111, + "CVC4": 0.12444565519433334, + "CVC3": 0.10528097970568334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12320919914983335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1213867853059778 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7226058292428048, + "veriT": 0.84103115024023489, + "Yices": 2.1520641844978572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7663368541547104, + "CVC4": 1.1523914481439472, + "CVC3": 0.12964708929167859, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14522266160271427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17270271380735716 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.87966332371999134, + "veriT": 10.166459469590666, + "Yices": 10.348130406624716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.96322821472975828, + "CVC4": 0.15010039508695239, + "CVC3": 0.70283226302438107, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14895325033699999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.433870869379229 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1108393384528437, + "veriT": 5.6050701354535528, + "Yices": 7.191819138472181, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1885706209690801, + "CVC4": 3.1070311247412246, + "CVC3": 3.9142008849013972, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9570010050745466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7295583612130141 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0614731540457818, + "veriT": 10.87568041688988, + "Yices": 12.183465448261112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3052651545966665, + "CVC4": 12.462938827420032, + "CVC3": 9.0882744842792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.966639666306865, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.897085554623819 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.94786239192873, + "veriT": 10.173340721475334, + "Yices": 10.337820439881444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964564420168934, + "CVC4": 1.3478266385814446, + "CVC3": 9.0875450480551425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5565232818317503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.366062238255434 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.720401660597794, + "veriT": 10.441333011108798, + "Yices": 10.243044762446125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.343460041758444, + "CVC4": 4.9282546554478657, + "CVC3": 8.095740796022131, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8980621420421553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5058646630192651 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.261445790959623, + "veriT": 8.0322225238801437, + "Yices": 10.338489578064785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.830091144083621, + "CVC4": 0.1731601071637143, + "CVC3": 10.008804589009108, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.017385430324643, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.349059590966032 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.834755964359486, + "veriT": 10.838186256601039, + "Yices": 8.6120294995499993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.475061869185362, + "CVC4": 0.6330519752881667, + "CVC3": 11.886333356274415, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.549592484229839, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.380377495513713 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.254453578068099, + "veriT": 5.1382103433836663, + "Yices": 6.9218111879781672, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5833791863248186, + "CVC4": 0.15721383655716667, + "CVC3": 1.0537674291874999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15255561267866666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4906931801425785 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.697620452537947, + "veriT": 9.1548936693443448, + "Yices": 7.8839902672545392, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.422686045225774, + "CVC4": 8.664069428085396, + "CVC3": 8.3161271527841869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5143865934814098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5124143275862298 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4952531217393332, + "veriT": 6.6059363269819471, + "Yices": 9.2328410115870643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4933030749938885, + "CVC4": 9.7505612509457009, + "CVC3": 3.5097758585336667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5454452178458222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8851541672260907 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5258956483250374, + "veriT": 7.1542501956629296, + "Yices": 6.8515962856958952, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3499708260318943, + "CVC4": 7.4287245812644516, + "CVC3": 1.7212860181761314, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3382371871773611, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3385336217639034 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9052869063572098, + "veriT": 4.7473377574098476, + "Yices": 8.0519749405755139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0153314684386703, + "CVC4": 2.9446054256435468, + "CVC3": 3.6647518851622607, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5392236488865736, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8978842871310659 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242132738399826, + "veriT": 10.153692609465333, + "Yices": 10.340666731126166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958450781804123, + "CVC4": 0.15508937394274999, + "CVC3": 12.340121175083459, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17419031003483335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.337550406535124 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240650661569678, + "veriT": 10.1555079856783, + "Yices": 10.3412848424363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.969092815856252, + "CVC4": 0.1608178713442, + "CVC3": 14.248768338397815, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14629014817030001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.353727055094685 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.211974211807744, + "veriT": 10.429874049624257, + "Yices": 10.421793833053734, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.632626417922987, + "CVC4": 1.1954406863225764, + "CVC3": 10.704382981214657, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5483328481280982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.834398581437965 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7094291255818543, + "veriT": 6.9201219060660017, + "Yices": 10.521469945474886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.897607090589954, + "CVC4": 2.0322235179149137, + "CVC3": 10.46627084519557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4634082405226971, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2962882926666364 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2483349426667854, + "veriT": 12.602633123329017, + "Yices": 12.618582133666381, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6951091703032155, + "CVC4": 8.3638110704695929, + "CVC3": 8.4030597916533107, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2101092278731329, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7772011788036632 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1826065865923456, + "veriT": 10.258684869520712, + "Yices": 10.156979007290358, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5020006951636411, + "CVC4": 10.447056081317642, + "CVC3": 4.2314878722958982, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.20345350281193, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.259811909780344 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6873968492212565, + "veriT": 8.7962052427124, + "Yices": 6.8229545590259333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7658396361091346, + "CVC4": 0.13350930305611108, + "CVC3": 4.814535952219682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6370317256805191, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4202146334256467 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17501358965244446, + "veriT": 0.36842532566447778, + "Yices": 1.2614800750645445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.65689545613611111, + "CVC4": 0.16510705431344444, + "CVC3": 0.15497516524962221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.709462087876882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3884135567796572 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1942322558651099, + "veriT": 9.372671197759022, + "Yices": 8.5208673934741945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1522507740593273, + "CVC4": 4.4676230129363486, + "CVC3": 4.4797292678062295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1933181919403673, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.424494764244958 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6776475737179002, + "veriT": 10.711828902981997, + "Yices": 10.345693591838883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.295320398427382, + "CVC4": 7.4991487883953942, + "CVC3": 5.852306063059693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.824445379748635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.838439149092338 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4421270883297801, + "veriT": 12.81608093194564, + "Yices": 13.45663199695772, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5200867781167009, + "CVC4": 11.746202420867458, + "CVC3": 9.88845392745921, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.713016513563591, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.744986548923473 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.470736383246553, + "veriT": 10.166775035946333, + "Yices": 10.325380972753221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968462102124489, + "CVC4": 3.3035936451525911, + "CVC3": 13.275377664348781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8583450436099529, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.336022517660494 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6200245325684408, + "veriT": 5.0499337908657038, + "Yices": 6.4605194626013356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7095806895908989, + "CVC4": 5.767741851557866, + "CVC3": 6.1890137819616537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5687468394810802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5677455779912899 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14654821543788751, + "veriT": 1.916650180432296, + "Yices": 11.701988789756706, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15532660436537502, + "CVC4": 12.577763698470115, + "CVC3": 9.7221009566257948, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0408507516994474, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0407513659846694 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7719131675725452, + "veriT": 9.0900523162548001, + "Yices": 13.438560830166807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8061699380030913, + "CVC4": 13.789625528684274, + "CVC3": 13.091715745695559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0893138161586418, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0842474309361676 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5718845904900682, + "veriT": 14.205620468830427, + "Yices": 12.439924447538194, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6960956310842423, + "CVC4": 11.080410454023275, + "CVC3": 10.799556551003407, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.454317569435213, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.455675115787619 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3911968891889188, + "veriT": 8.1323566806018572, + "Yices": 9.6947274224051689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5702168509803176, + "CVC4": 14.319782148750821, + "CVC3": 12.469200566944913, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.949165512150035, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.91088984353868 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0146947102684289, + "veriT": 0.152132609985, + "Yices": 5.5960259697431294, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0154031698000003, + "CVC4": 0.17086250291728569, + "CVC3": 3.6294789289113329, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0281156129609652, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0262848259388395 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.344284479013199, + "veriT": 9.8755164316268544, + "Yices": 9.6778696665562798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.187301333849586, + "CVC4": 0.16121222464563159, + "CVC3": 10.909024415977999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16296844841942104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8792319792284999 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24421741670739999, + "veriT": 2.3076638233659263, + "Yices": 8.5820884672064484, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.45060467658799996, + "CVC4": 3.1460853235196717, + "CVC3": 4.2392358730416007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15507893485660001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15535594557500002 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14596619640518183, + "veriT": 0.13362506587312725, + "Yices": 0.16314951782772727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14393737295945452, + "CVC4": 0.17401291780790909, + "CVC3": 0.14475456491818181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15590829424009092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15329628883818183 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6592536375879998, + "veriT": 1.4174389772089921, + "Yices": 1.9027956369224319, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6583814944525002, + "CVC4": 1.9380692646348563, + "CVC3": 1.5977758609108759, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16726169202612501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16635641825737499 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20848591612000003, + "veriT": 4.2074366861500518, + "Yices": 7.9095491491588987, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2338361492978001, + "CVC4": 0.23479035139819998, + "CVC3": 5.0542843779950033, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0274413840561327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0250279252612597 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6014018544628001, + "veriT": 1.2565064683597109, + "Yices": 1.7120770310229876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6116837992809891, + "CVC4": 11.231935894055077, + "CVC3": 1.3322663394200442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7135920644282132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7143073258243595 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5018328191708479, + "veriT": 6.4820746387779238, + "Yices": 11.690885358799607, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7428859998301816, + "CVC4": 7.2635663369500696, + "CVC3": 6.7752166429277692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6314507259286755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6111246994722741 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12782492302724999, + "veriT": 5.6280676019889633, + "Yices": 7.3786878160613343, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17211905030661251, + "CVC4": 0.152756194406, + "CVC3": 0.12315628941832502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9670779312719218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9893304151072371 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7080540181237502, + "veriT": 12.178185814954073, + "Yices": 12.698306958121726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9271001760054389, + "CVC4": 10.930481384212804, + "CVC3": 7.2173352967692566, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1069466060117463, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0950073545594137 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2548145005715465, + "veriT": 11.092027928106843, + "Yices": 8.5728650042006365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.399246351220528, + "CVC4": 0.63624323719384612, + "CVC3": 0.31485476495346154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2554106109847847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2414698737608063 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8243670380918502, + "veriT": 9.7843758202644331, + "Yices": 11.091320246930428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.104311429331556, + "CVC4": 14.414110957041242, + "CVC3": 11.057514322284135, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.097895024317449, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.457030651326523 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.646908928943857, + "veriT": 7.5258707420305422, + "Yices": 2.538744848296417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6459331471381429, + "CVC4": 4.2864165087449431, + "CVC3": 2.0061844940153546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7805419901057142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8483347651294284 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0116281509399414, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8484845161437988, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5322580337524414, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.465246486357694, + "veriT": 11.761372708838509, + "Yices": 11.60404076538801, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.990431198064561, + "CVC4": 7.1112452619360997, + "CVC3": 12.154113950004671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0637729582622839, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7488152689110965 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4890556849809791, + "veriT": 10.099452072583221, + "Yices": 12.903069431836245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2019651750599234, + "CVC4": 5.6252654142016576, + "CVC3": 5.6796328862123557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7335872565508552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.913110654105493 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.295952761238178, + "veriT": 11.054924530215326, + "Yices": 10.985420736319735, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.001305231394443, + "CVC4": 11.609601693667644, + "CVC3": 9.6111962105438362, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252287676433218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.15392576344326 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3516099519723999, + "veriT": 9.7919003475185882, + "Yices": 9.4582237378691811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2825994030787995, + "CVC4": 11.593850134026505, + "CVC3": 3.8947341681293159, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6230144239039213, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3847317805860895 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7012745141983032, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8426500423889234, + "veriT": 13.899191401180504, + "Yices": 0.77592409681346142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6161858560524611, + "CVC4": 0.28776160645523075, + "CVC3": 0.18135391699476922, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.226849573739875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.23871727959871 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25413908592100004, + "veriT": 12.016188469612471, + "Yices": 8.8732927786726776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7387308125993386, + "CVC4": 8.4191401855772199, + "CVC3": 8.4229137858566308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9072050260975333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.561743803592087 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.154141023766809, + "veriT": 12.861738475625563, + "Yices": 9.0948277251273826, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.718163150966618, + "CVC4": 9.8475887892881264, + "CVC3": 11.163842570402158, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.500556480537, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.331001200986059 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8856209516525269, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0203892745661425, + "veriT": 8.1651129684436743, + "Yices": 0.13672416550642857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1359975685592856, + "CVC4": 0.24943720301300001, + "CVC3": 0.13232005123628571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13942939432542856, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13972384094485715 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.899802231753406, + "veriT": 14.213060478438342, + "Yices": 4.283502516102577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8976155065544651, + "CVC4": 5.1161942964805158, + "CVC3": 5.4223977373013241, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.816501213711938, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.817062054395317 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5392639115978717, + "veriT": 6.7591686064607162, + "Yices": 1.1273118481111599, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6096020300402381, + "CVC4": 1.5532527052057623, + "CVC3": 1.5329047482563831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2228878045555707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2431888740403227 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 47.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12740406054125, + "veriT": 4.8725860879893821, + "Yices": 1.3680991730238752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1323037325750375, + "CVC4": 1.8942068947198913, + "CVC3": 1.8786875533994667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5317736156746093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5433710446828666 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 34.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17825486197266666, + "veriT": 0.15860331044444445, + "Yices": 0.16652594149355557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19500436647899999, + "CVC4": 0.20409015327311109, + "CVC3": 0.19072295135422224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18388986649711109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.186604382974 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15072213652924998, + "veriT": 0.12622138202500002, + "Yices": 0.141830584309625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.148390188078625, + "CVC4": 0.16608450422475002, + "CVC3": 0.14469944813574998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.163150629479625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16155740569262497 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9972937968337616, + "veriT": 3.4620274174624002, + "Yices": 3.4852421691990005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1208175313535724, + "CVC4": 6.1154424184008471, + "CVC3": 2.4931025351403142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5535547246569936, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2984680645745446 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0152225494384766, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 67.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8151115076755442, + "veriT": 13.815847664724378, + "Yices": 12.786745745883014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8312043857078226, + "CVC4": 10.872674309888623, + "CVC3": 8.8247696624829679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.146769989265977, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.118073005820118 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 157.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.202764256157199, + "veriT": 11.0732694345008, + "Yices": 12.131196818323117, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.392715247494529, + "CVC4": 14.354885934571687, + "CVC3": 14.051276160780409, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242289870364646, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.632939866677496 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.687804415833817, + "veriT": 13.119190542023414, + "Yices": 13.371738797284626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.593450509967219, + "CVC4": 12.45087957325836, + "CVC3": 6.6964757086568731, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.884518824651686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.607966998689358 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.495494094604934, + "veriT": 12.745398861370676, + "Yices": 12.058946304960058, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957641634525261, + "CVC4": 14.350518004460305, + "CVC3": 14.230704627100879, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24380736701468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.468539508733972 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3731256442136273, + "veriT": 12.887476357916071, + "Yices": 8.9274141934381213, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.524560596412263, + "CVC4": 5.1130302950313302, + "CVC3": 7.5619956907335961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8887254698572216, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8226914616178425 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24255997814749999, + "veriT": 11.205659483355001, + "Yices": 11.82368273132694, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4256600559110004, + "CVC4": 12.184132995423248, + "CVC3": 2.576658652196667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.555185574877294, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5507604204238561 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1445889472961426, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.34849334623133332, + "veriT": 5.934901487699662, + "Yices": 5.4280553076948541, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7658715541315833, + "CVC4": 2.1084053763401513, + "CVC3": 0.98086891391975006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15828095455083332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15377827140933334 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 130.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.643401591194637, + "veriT": 13.032004708967085, + "Yices": 13.03492336759596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.681943822901562, + "CVC4": 12.011429023055859, + "CVC3": 11.920526425465932, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2845547404709663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.257312697220792 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3411712729343637, + "veriT": 13.485513716412113, + "Yices": 8.36959289756369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.568243844769091, + "CVC4": 6.7861886767922126, + "CVC3": 0.40836175632800004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4077120012114781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4697441909309141 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9205351584932693, + "veriT": 13.626430790830574, + "Yices": 6.4028130343215111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.023875045470575, + "CVC4": 6.0686881599019902, + "CVC3": 14.230096777825619, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6063016624348725, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5003356093264535 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8372676287333483, + "veriT": 4.9595829064811721, + "Yices": 9.5536913736305422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4047148406590448, + "CVC4": 10.152807942487849, + "CVC3": 8.2529289560458299, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7746953891062534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0355670775737638 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240510923908005, + "veriT": 13.290510509589607, + "Yices": 12.075788118049569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960755950355034, + "CVC4": 14.578705397897885, + "CVC3": 13.289685325424468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.608102608788284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.91655769878891 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 56.0, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8244374314403817, + "veriT": 6.961028002034972, + "Yices": 10.5864665946123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7189595073237882, + "CVC4": 11.695269792289405, + "CVC3": 7.9859489182113972, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7922002605490466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7890108252387771 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.556595443462715, + "veriT": 14.249152106209465, + "Yices": 14.070701425770494, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.810892708646364, + "CVC4": 14.474099993927821, + "CVC3": 13.827768651719051, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2687217709416743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4756987233944479 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5586575634101925, + "veriT": 10.770430905231672, + "Yices": 9.8460692311513665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4305448157305056, + "CVC4": 12.338811053809625, + "CVC3": 10.18226764437682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.393029856517188, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.956509099182133 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "false": 151, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 150 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0969947328797858, + "veriT": 13.909797171261198, + "Yices": 13.925333550596653, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.095977773628737, + "CVC4": 13.462371114075466, + "CVC3": 12.099623719811243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.087176132708644, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.785315697814388 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.271580872637953, + "veriT": 13.246587666247127, + "Yices": 14.172562660667349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.988157147347735, + "CVC4": 14.49875008031564, + "CVC3": 13.57795540555205, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.377461280838945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.27769214415828 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "false": 154, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 153 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.903785212129636, + "veriT": 13.574463983650388, + "Yices": 13.821526495920873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962158109445207, + "CVC4": 14.916391342556778, + "CVC3": 13.087748534975347, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.342340292281101, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.182360990448556 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.271058029198269, + "veriT": 10.815094718926391, + "Yices": 11.089416245977304, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.352541352007094, + "CVC4": 12.441229801644365, + "CVC3": 14.266024968955909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.275333816897563, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.622066220044628 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12461022350796, + "veriT": 0.09546894668061201, + "Yices": 0.10024654540255601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12060703362076002, + "CVC4": 0.12385562274284, + "CVC3": 0.10086537905651199, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12084024869755999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11834944356721602 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10614904543293999, + "veriT": 0.57409733401677998, + "Yices": 0.57736908897082506, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11459519399743998, + "CVC4": 0.80273128283617778, + "CVC3": 0.078056783803189977, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.80023844866126093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.80024088519861147 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5281781095220186, + "veriT": 5.4847467981139291, + "Yices": 6.2266276161792424, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8221379029293505, + "CVC4": 2.564698023389727, + "CVC3": 3.762645808473748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.326549027813311, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5666734677898466 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20715452227971057, + "veriT": 10.164698745368263, + "Yices": 10.352882014041001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28297337654384225, + "CVC4": 0.14932554058107897, + "CVC3": 0.62432623975199997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1486009113702895, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.168173156795495 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.456238312206789, + "veriT": 13.512418029973315, + "Yices": 12.485958574281621, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.402102396584434, + "CVC4": 12.495970523293549, + "CVC3": 10.483493740409319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.262165557636155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.318686924083631 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2204706413822706, + "veriT": 6.8399191188190001, + "Yices": 6.9223240448189998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1655328875533701, + "CVC4": 0.15855042744366668, + "CVC3": 6.1908931946797052, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0223687710157519, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5640767562273146 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15761604715040001, + "veriT": 1.5838816771303559, + "Yices": 3.6531080775686116, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1481593836689, + "CVC4": 1.5744141346842917, + "CVC3": 0.14492563945940001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8716299730033708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6495257692842715 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.811452954387718, + "veriT": 10.840952284223567, + "Yices": 9.616325665767981, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.159479163990497, + "CVC4": 1.3673366165447207, + "CVC3": 11.456110514025829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1448491729607104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.559989709501055 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.777481357413858, + "veriT": 10.620274810109866, + "Yices": 10.479742019898218, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.419293566668573, + "CVC4": 3.4485385183521573, + "CVC3": 13.031779085546694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2460717854871834, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.946619415019839 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235708598380604, + "veriT": 10.164720627014557, + "Yices": 10.305498399674113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955137107224333, + "CVC4": 1.7600238461217783, + "CVC3": 10.827678139649436, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0583740488357254, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.01750513946161 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.310756116075032, + "veriT": 9.4955707613908018, + "Yices": 10.325896533362664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.977301043373261, + "CVC4": 0.17000567207999998, + "CVC3": 13.281868965495558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.078621640873235, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.206549126872757 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.48183814625307, + "veriT": 10.165925555077933, + "Yices": 10.316789123629132, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948223714594613, + "CVC4": 0.25156969114506667, + "CVC3": 11.681971326503989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0750503775429125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.596993305228276 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3064264617285555, + "veriT": 6.1440114987978713, + "Yices": 6.150949432372415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3280702874254446, + "CVC4": 2.8521544281738431, + "CVC3": 1.3437206551647778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5922207619047155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1484279303583795 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.87639222445126, + "veriT": 6.8178649181506659, + "Yices": 11.628090932945643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.358958735400316, + "CVC4": 0.25601946975800005, + "CVC3": 13.757605735259295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.50454302128744444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5787846862864825 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1516657712360833, + "veriT": 9.9284124887928211, + "Yices": 10.204445212702845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.38034371716125842, + "CVC4": 7.6212581183420349, + "CVC3": 6.5445951461395415, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.514797056489053, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.42726637304448 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8456158365712163, + "veriT": 8.1189448593209779, + "Yices": 5.7664004800129725, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2054466913278841, + "CVC4": 5.188208838532506, + "CVC3": 4.7920438583453864, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1621598910499857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1568161372300629 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15409164968388889, + "veriT": 3.9175803533908402, + "Yices": 10.583804513460102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15116511395222224, + "CVC4": 4.8570839307191047, + "CVC3": 0.15798556427177776, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8458881252313883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1854520282188889 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9655845632664839, + "veriT": 2.1383586922954203, + "Yices": 2.17679446159761, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1012253939936749, + "CVC4": 0.16071008599870001, + "CVC3": 0.35406459214329999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1552451916183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3983010689518851 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1442486811051999, + "veriT": 5.334201410469376, + "Yices": 4.9849901278218471, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8993674927472002, + "CVC4": 3.9815054855591776, + "CVC3": 2.2718602818039999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9581396763236296, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9612223366247648 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5727274417877197, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.591052887200524, + "veriT": 12.171018360187906, + "Yices": 11.414737326576251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.148921738837727, + "CVC4": 7.3077001145066127, + "CVC3": 15.053058901992465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2749042286855765, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.238864400583651 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.974315165316467, + "veriT": 11.480718877941698, + "Yices": 12.440718759370611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3170306683677229, + "CVC4": 6.6587988468458024, + "CVC3": 8.1710058399908227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8497360925682429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7289909392671863 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.131640509029125, + "veriT": 11.132815648403852, + "Yices": 6.3564359838150617, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13312706627087498, + "CVC4": 1.9059725676440158, + "CVC3": 1.8759002438397743, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.229422492951514, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.300052836400534 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1933042308339088, + "veriT": 12.032024575551235, + "Yices": 10.174328412812182, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2872833577674108, + "CVC4": 10.133765924198729, + "CVC3": 4.5535642786971149, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.31008764663731, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.319085469584325 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5876913797608587, + "veriT": 10.075120575462915, + "Yices": 11.655569744027053, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.264925441393968, + "CVC4": 12.406988233146116, + "CVC3": 10.636041805437433, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.307979439491486, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.19541523620777 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.467649305225104, + "veriT": 10.974075735415436, + "Yices": 10.803587008014258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2595066345710286, + "CVC4": 3.0806308315462188, + "CVC3": 3.9166853324123436, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.034161193652066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.368135642207653 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1993105046086399, + "veriT": 8.145551912817508, + "Yices": 5.9411087730027718, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.357704989258675, + "CVC4": 4.0540381815000774, + "CVC3": 4.7565463244072648, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9618578544800354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8905564053098249 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5227274894714355, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2361111640930176, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.339350695835495, + "veriT": 8.8366628342684113, + "Yices": 11.940441022910857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.894955746429693, + "CVC4": 6.7584900412987281, + "CVC3": 12.561134127609133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3242830112552046, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4056146129317009 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4885583054252631, + "veriT": 7.0370400125201646, + "Yices": 10.520535187481364, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6562986786632745, + "CVC4": 6.6021464847982116, + "CVC3": 5.5473381246878501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1122286043938889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.144965841083778 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.339792095152463, + "veriT": 14.207924759320383, + "Yices": 11.582912138648201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.673188446705526, + "CVC4": 12.122874886181881, + "CVC3": 13.46589461290505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.647329483295565, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.644370256818972 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6906411608729384, + "veriT": 8.7829707060367177, + "Yices": 7.1506809773134377, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6751873605323999, + "CVC4": 4.5278078266035768, + "CVC3": 4.9106089252000311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4100594547883962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3943056695575189 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.386600257581375, + "veriT": 8.9189790007546268, + "Yices": 0.113736764651375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4178236996437501, + "CVC4": 0.15899392905912499, + "CVC3": 0.1167459019635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4151786361889682, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4133475008799499 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4785343737014698, + "veriT": 5.2167612640647771, + "Yices": 9.7477991881451764, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3739740933527766, + "CVC4": 1.5471240351486137, + "CVC3": 1.4706751659321198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4663722676413824, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4682767810864616 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.626560353264777, + "veriT": 3.2760848531713895, + "Yices": 1.257774204614178, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6840245106645551, + "CVC4": 0.18000024255455557, + "CVC3": 2.8629503523795585, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7375768733494334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7374580365451839 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7707607682199029, + "veriT": 10.998569684788688, + "Yices": 8.0870682274283219, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.908908853843457, + "CVC4": 0.160337837964, + "CVC3": 7.4517748004276045, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15414179420484617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5572839411434609 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6298302503862687, + "veriT": 9.9650408616239918, + "Yices": 9.4653012669892682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7404209361916521, + "CVC4": 9.8388140878047246, + "CVC3": 10.468547544616401, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6735731274601156, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2266154062829564 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19776869373600003, + "veriT": 0.12848164365653336, + "Yices": 6.4084288335504223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31294441997755557, + "CVC4": 5.1153450871580084, + "CVC3": 4.642229649470111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15525150963311113, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15620311119155553 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.156042059609625, + "veriT": 0.14077852685700001, + "Yices": 0.14791383994750001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15169031892074999, + "CVC4": 0.17317094642912498, + "CVC3": 0.148692429748875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16581610532075, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16242340173274997 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4425124900975845, + "veriT": 11.923177656968061, + "Yices": 6.1913924858647151, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6215859412865345, + "CVC4": 8.2606538131155762, + "CVC3": 2.859284874514858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243730557245655, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.567408961706848 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.230702665309721, + "veriT": 11.597555634459868, + "Yices": 11.26299798389145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.984157414920853, + "CVC4": 10.715414601767021, + "CVC3": 11.480600486164006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.463378141095976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.822791232642663 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7259555158219171, + "veriT": 12.51679133986419, + "Yices": 9.5911443138888792, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4823005909633333, + "CVC4": 3.8275160180694243, + "CVC3": 8.9086462384056926, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.960461876770941, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.972701269886981 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8308675289154053, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.32408192281412501, + "veriT": 2.6235554342390128, + "Yices": 5.0218974169044994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8268528967771154, + "CVC4": 3.6724217955141896, + "CVC3": 0.89713989325849997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4172508432175377, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.643094799361144 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5406159788951888, + "veriT": 9.449063066161365, + "Yices": 9.2193274635125686, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.319150679810697, + "CVC4": 5.8118180463353122, + "CVC3": 4.0512240537807278, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3022221315881293, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0592780409659888 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.16127701380125, + "veriT": 14.208481528999092, + "Yices": 7.4056657114246249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4428691831744107, + "CVC4": 5.7654914138783475, + "CVC3": 4.5439340717747161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.910473880747229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.918446673714257 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9992632116838567, + "veriT": 0.11818364025934285, + "Yices": 0.19947898195785713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0053774625001428, + "CVC4": 0.15194903131471429, + "CVC3": 0.12713736952742857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14762408205442859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14182298528614287 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1588349183178, + "veriT": 0.1352435889669, + "Yices": 0.15068607140250001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1545000048365, + "CVC4": 0.17866321427290002, + "CVC3": 0.1552750260089, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16921047497879999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1695385451891 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15045314050533332, + "veriT": 2.3268293585696203, + "Yices": 0.14571164968083333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14823094822899999, + "CVC4": 0.16977809853333334, + "CVC3": 0.1486863878785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16345777184950003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16456353475800001 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14957914285364285, + "veriT": 6.1225508461964244, + "Yices": 1.1571842482598917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17030965047185714, + "CVC4": 0.17809643589728572, + "CVC3": 0.50225375221057866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16022759473481427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16021665293412143 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.152291597485537, + "veriT": 7.4597649577959251, + "Yices": 6.2737761334178002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.217430521482616, + "CVC4": 2.5098449736629052, + "CVC3": 1.3049136930028131, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.965484825828991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9831776329964965 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.700765364756522, + "veriT": 7.7280364810198563, + "Yices": 11.230052622492272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8891496536726113, + "CVC4": 6.2430693391723393, + "CVC3": 8.6368232607872599, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8697146081313072, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0094069056670314 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 57.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4827304725366668, + "veriT": 1.7331725638436337, + "Yices": 7.3515816468849202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4830568897638887, + "CVC4": 14.523724751143829, + "CVC3": 4.6976839589247783, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15415359409722221, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15204674758033335 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1798979193241212, + "veriT": 0.142550117444875, + "Yices": 1.9352940491313528, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8649815061230584, + "CVC4": 7.3036028833821129, + "CVC3": 1.6541455149596249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7153748499048747, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7076103673445 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 114.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 52.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5072547210957774, + "veriT": 8.1611188731332085, + "Yices": 10.003159195157778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.772142176519111, + "CVC4": 11.943941475904348, + "CVC3": 7.5471377274334213, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1888245925589516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3581988829423848 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19732877011890909, + "veriT": 1.0295547193656365, + "Yices": 0.79058558470281814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.98181245007963647, + "CVC4": 0.169639520377, + "CVC3": 0.17814296229354545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15404500851845454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14583958256418181 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.55899974671800001, + "veriT": 10.594799635084021, + "Yices": 3.3367199019765774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.598845129515474, + "CVC4": 2.6296660854856388, + "CVC3": 5.6492656681434852, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5198612222136312, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5176089390966632 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2930264031639389, + "veriT": 10.459263324582857, + "Yices": 10.56693199588064, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.136359905816461, + "CVC4": 9.1553811654010886, + "CVC3": 4.0218686346532779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3424432226484688, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9552104594975415 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 77.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.095853890212615, + "veriT": 13.624729274017245, + "Yices": 5.0981245551466161, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.120123287903732, + "CVC4": 5.6937337857915296, + "CVC3": 9.6444803268140085, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.783197630591346, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.783973351870783 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8490840196609497, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1858321490197854, + "veriT": 13.047920125249155, + "Yices": 11.562495595559891, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.877934074412613, + "CVC4": 13.296323615518569, + "CVC3": 12.376547630420008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241463893910915, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236309370182116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.468331588001437, + "veriT": 13.023202625780161, + "Yices": 11.813254351359037, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.033323464949243, + "CVC4": 14.349363941407418, + "CVC3": 14.246010135277672, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.598889492941259, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.66822888181223 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3759060444394127, + "veriT": 12.112780238783573, + "Yices": 10.864389370417346, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.327833015303186, + "CVC4": 7.422161209030059, + "CVC3": 5.2798350780574133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6069432008932347, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0193624941050894 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 165.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.913056265424034, + "veriT": 11.864966438337348, + "Yices": 10.610297801032244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.654953329520373, + "CVC4": 13.288788387229431, + "CVC3": 12.014461493946049, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.511566067711881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.10399197476729 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1189154346646943, + "veriT": 12.290644176623129, + "Yices": 8.5278990625507767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7033299131320216, + "CVC4": 13.123257237891806, + "CVC3": 6.6241299242265743, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.070913580586284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.498429965852594 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7440089937883452, + "veriT": 12.372966373838757, + "Yices": 10.720434218895999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6619275264627955, + "CVC4": 4.6856768349317646, + "CVC3": 8.3965115928089844, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.76414479590092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.757100144203314 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259736078884853, + "veriT": 10.430820231041903, + "Yices": 10.686310708830758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979329091034638, + "CVC4": 14.513517381182128, + "CVC3": 13.594301480677062, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.262141869695029, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.374090681528903 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.028970978753684, + "veriT": 13.562546177899877, + "Yices": 13.076681354157083, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.220989025060474, + "CVC4": 14.280900946814775, + "CVC3": 13.651761513662331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.198513314402708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.923352892004557 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5237361292481664, + "veriT": 13.53934969518223, + "Yices": 13.369097454389667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.050611883495824, + "CVC4": 14.512055079833203, + "CVC3": 9.3525909497631652, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.900055750925686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5705945081045378 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.624291900292095, + "veriT": 12.618798999473624, + "Yices": 13.445236400933421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963395136229213, + "CVC4": 14.578246978030901, + "CVC3": 13.593141375474266, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.261329042048576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.260463637678374 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8853837718840563, + "veriT": 11.8468955904653, + "Yices": 12.516051547223711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.654090639871368, + "CVC4": 11.280436435919603, + "CVC3": 10.089708284762342, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2124460765322631, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2115487931422013 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1227217234703373, + "veriT": 12.041971556382698, + "Yices": 9.0316916520243389, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6209290903758227, + "CVC4": 7.239408347972482, + "CVC3": 6.9090921319650214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8161231976441847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2700538282931575 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4047487149987776, + "veriT": 6.8366542523617948, + "Yices": 10.042631971417951, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6210205663138426, + "CVC4": 11.278051831243831, + "CVC3": 5.1444652350781057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7429863026066847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7447290099419048 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.728426867085819, + "veriT": 13.714071274617918, + "Yices": 13.654076304736972, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.870688182796922, + "CVC4": 14.510775986906328, + "CVC3": 14.071121589075673, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6371477152807614, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.325726852079967 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 341.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.180085080120294, + "veriT": 13.655295599174456, + "Yices": 13.725830272867238, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957996730348549, + "CVC4": 14.497731532027695, + "CVC3": 13.864789691796815, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.562000961455379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.649422611438286 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.797156127204911, + "veriT": 11.118173778478516, + "Yices": 11.181972852625222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.10843654644464, + "CVC4": 14.537496626161492, + "CVC3": 14.003407410943185, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.267663512450396, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.619369441634015 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.091400941653024, + "veriT": 14.243152768520769, + "Yices": 14.068417162175692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.935030895741576, + "CVC4": 14.915005337346855, + "CVC3": 9.5436429576642219, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.084536933522568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.448898055373027 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12742665763157146, + "veriT": 0.099215936825571435, + "Yices": 0.10104034413810953, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12648468139490476, + "CVC4": 0.12572629048752382, + "CVC3": 0.10716453472734284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12541905952138094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12294702382423808 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12999697649279998, + "veriT": 1.2005149050490165, + "Yices": 1.2042050264269335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14876366961877779, + "CVC4": 1.6817181562411616, + "CVC3": 0.096495864924561109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6768670313522354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6761420840267365 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1302331709972782, + "veriT": 0.87605775899538674, + "Yices": 0.88161630927910573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1256401576340558, + "CVC4": 0.95231722162480303, + "CVC3": 0.88650171519644161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.90629891980042943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.90695755707752568 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3480634241386185, + "veriT": 10.165457591782813, + "Yices": 10.349448526126299, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4558656951608533, + "CVC4": 0.14934991266764863, + "CVC3": 0.71154750674937839, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14884959685345947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.432950021355081 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18644463227988889, + "veriT": 7.9295762091172231, + "Yices": 9.3407692125717787, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.32090164319911113, + "CVC4": 0.15180174988944445, + "CVC3": 0.27782454997344447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14953140880100002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4233283369125558 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.958269425257781, + "veriT": 9.7478663087080744, + "Yices": 10.609840327374565, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.574371300631116, + "CVC4": 1.2286153100345985, + "CVC3": 12.119557304182919, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.017659586144362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.493523612363932 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.925618251531052, + "veriT": 10.465961759022679, + "Yices": 10.435956319889616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.584596586472559, + "CVC4": 1.3235081804087416, + "CVC3": 9.6165329449724304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6530302334171152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.468108074203842 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24599577126628, + "veriT": 10.190390344342251, + "Yices": 10.337509772309, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963482573561521, + "CVC4": 0.1692269738205, + "CVC3": 12.598898243880967, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.920539301213801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.276734762494613 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.500409809306368, + "veriT": 9.0508280916172215, + "Yices": 9.1955157830078882, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.297833222009528, + "CVC4": 0.16170060777444442, + "CVC3": 2.7950240869479952, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.103310223766659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.688293013740982 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.2369968667369, + "veriT": 8.7232168718722853, + "Yices": 10.330735994448428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.850739589346004, + "CVC4": 0.16211809739757141, + "CVC3": 11.446834760284286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18217382795500001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.260125861069103 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7924939966873135, + "veriT": 8.5877458193463632, + "Yices": 9.4286890635895393, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7317574987132307, + "CVC4": 10.146215113973046, + "CVC3": 8.5960262026835608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1979314108070849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8025713916782271 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.666434752015569, + "veriT": 11.896546334513705, + "Yices": 12.121091209118253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.305608425929091, + "CVC4": 6.7623328278702983, + "CVC3": 12.659557199344302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9186834298745801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.42531395681074 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2596940079343861, + "veriT": 5.3532799985356574, + "Yices": 5.5697239992917789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4039509083832957, + "CVC4": 4.1142924107643211, + "CVC3": 2.3516823789888308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.73411337993931, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7633216326893315 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3520899057978966, + "veriT": 9.4679107901572124, + "Yices": 8.0815525572117863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4719953200077764, + "CVC4": 7.6479338241958637, + "CVC3": 7.6524868104412471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.393484830267944, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8221255116054955 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.92078974217857, + "veriT": 11.602343286366803, + "Yices": 10.799449087752924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.296177942701258, + "CVC4": 9.36545382603693, + "CVC3": 11.226497200054391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0313063513399019, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.059195644648074 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12236216301621666, + "veriT": 4.2631268111631666, + "Yices": 5.7781207173962494, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13637939871804999, + "CVC4": 1.8800013386076335, + "CVC3": 3.0504002639384784, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4351261056034139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4139258403447625 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.801948070526123, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4146079057147087, + "veriT": 13.021436302202686, + "Yices": 4.7376172933709668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3818109457016785, + "CVC4": 6.4223603576094774, + "CVC3": 6.1929217061640705, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1761783775812766, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1741260323567655 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.850059712515687, + "veriT": 13.336916598385878, + "Yices": 12.852973414690535, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.477706862663599, + "CVC4": 8.4439758715558799, + "CVC3": 11.20827549458461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6107242666487709, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9276915590977124 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16594455339612502, + "veriT": 8.4056799367967976, + "Yices": 10.695147725583737, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.117251122343875, + "CVC4": 9.0812506083314339, + "CVC3": 5.3915810677504998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1818259477032917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1973319766583082 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2671655816782934, + "veriT": 12.808225865244136, + "Yices": 11.031596729544216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3851212785659159, + "CVC4": 11.867326570719735, + "CVC3": 10.533566279515098, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.834530256216533, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.825667071664411 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.670193445799478, + "veriT": 11.056989452251797, + "Yices": 9.633876203143048, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.306560345209741, + "CVC4": 1.8024366472125513, + "CVC3": 12.032793335929746, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.856909448064993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.41594884143699 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0801279544830322, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7765782877125718, + "veriT": 10.691822396832759, + "Yices": 10.227727087456163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4592403025709633, + "CVC4": 12.461849859436624, + "CVC3": 6.0776217538484198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234496601562579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.2226609718213 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9860578402701821, + "veriT": 4.1407869789097997, + "Yices": 4.1993434769064404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1888503920261582, + "CVC4": 3.285773200012156, + "CVC3": 2.36079371231, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7753716106494331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1938619448911139 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3958334922790527, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7211174683027133, + "veriT": 3.6831293349627776, + "Yices": 6.6027014518369134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0953511052357205, + "CVC4": 3.2958511732319797, + "CVC3": 1.718369234610676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7416996491465024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7434125685437949 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4855367023819555, + "veriT": 5.1224536198164499, + "Yices": 7.6869706123409829, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6087717984256025, + "CVC4": 7.4535760573676022, + "CVC3": 1.8559279582826169, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7071803997241082, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7263642662839374 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3538057084091668, + "veriT": 7.6732849349370964, + "Yices": 9.2221920531548705, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9153361198879786, + "CVC4": 7.6059114492927291, + "CVC3": 6.573451422854272, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5125526217158551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6297964687576663 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.107829041969341, + "veriT": 14.20760689060277, + "Yices": 11.853490367687522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.244165170126488, + "CVC4": 12.295158979487923, + "CVC3": 12.229200205586691, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.216625173724722, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.216723859123354 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1450095396339088, + "veriT": 2.3979307547272821, + "Yices": 2.396706615416393, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2121379358120907, + "CVC4": 0.21029603873218178, + "CVC3": 2.7717316311567148, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20241371423936363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2017301353910488 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8708056346438644, + "veriT": 8.035126109686745, + "Yices": 11.32332274993111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.134456575896535, + "CVC4": 3.8209152832360136, + "CVC3": 8.5658390262400363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0283599330416147, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8118191067801135 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3514981020037002, + "veriT": 3.3233849635154664, + "Yices": 11.395558930085446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7652801325999004, + "CVC4": 0.20295947524280003, + "CVC3": 1.4467930639767901, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5620408497049398, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5658407411665136 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14123068563908334, + "veriT": 0.12200159946101664, + "Yices": 0.13272315961941669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13888905369341667, + "CVC4": 0.1595799429045833, + "CVC3": 0.13259938239158334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15192028939424998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14686881726350001 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7183756582820495, + "veriT": 4.6931109669535367, + "Yices": 7.306018317597661, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2531129515324695, + "CVC4": 11.70986554114927, + "CVC3": 1.1245880477003456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6870437041196347, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3486155542237608 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9323571635896801, + "veriT": 10.285088464552098, + "Yices": 11.923490332253433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1404876035760374, + "CVC4": 5.0152134989610175, + "CVC3": 8.5332463763156419, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1537725249757413, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6792060095335426 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0544425904715, + "veriT": 1.8737091046997756, + "Yices": 9.0603961448250168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0170357499580409, + "CVC4": 0.37959618054075001, + "CVC3": 0.13407329425262501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.156612113636625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15337649785125002 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.829050491184935, + "veriT": 3.8591909200198908, + "Yices": 6.6962251028042052, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.195978394242347, + "CVC4": 11.940502395857978, + "CVC3": 3.8428072150155135, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7156099851099076, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6955777284328257 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7220342420762478, + "veriT": 11.67153190938676, + "Yices": 8.7958018836436107, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.575940245854634, + "CVC4": 11.331866161330138, + "CVC3": 8.9679105682105416, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24269186617658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.744619382647526 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0695939532380001, + "veriT": 13.271539859803074, + "Yices": 4.2785603668904679, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3249437776170918, + "CVC4": 3.5502967596211112, + "CVC3": 2.765928392790074, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5363489054167365, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7371315156609475 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8443180322647095, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.899785631367791, + "veriT": 10.207263691889748, + "Yices": 10.378695270034751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979070720299596, + "CVC4": 14.28411665025024, + "CVC3": 11.421723755054531, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.265746983715971, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.292017254017683 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8261611833903952, + "veriT": 11.764641893957233, + "Yices": 11.194645697832888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5127499621027525, + "CVC4": 13.552177576585256, + "CVC3": 13.807707537868552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.85657141958092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.239291956104676 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 37.0, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3072178929742857, + "veriT": 14.209882363894396, + "Yices": 5.7611842737900352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4863522796317095, + "CVC4": 12.647201768510973, + "CVC3": 6.7575167022191875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.173427980955916, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.167738456488719 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9033154557729492, + "veriT": 9.6550360717237904, + "Yices": 3.3781753035416253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0388009776873854, + "CVC4": 3.8104378561144476, + "CVC3": 1.9088707815931529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6636025603918085, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6653962493911809 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1981840198815021, + "veriT": 13.67151369389887, + "Yices": 10.912206536230205, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9128487454943217, + "CVC4": 4.1829140909130196, + "CVC3": 9.7684356794461173, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.498326624596034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.474399350838116 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3721098956375248, + "veriT": 2.595058139472175, + "Yices": 2.593837057021275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3680300497908251, + "CVC4": 0.12255259355352502, + "CVC3": 2.6944548793980005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.25292379990875002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.26605420801649998 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20971934056871427, + "veriT": 4.430251338042857, + "Yices": 10.495678052444889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.4602097232829, + "CVC4": 6.2141301068469001, + "CVC3": 3.8224244496804474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9477752512153428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.372289988282442 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1069619655609131, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17142468371916667, + "veriT": 0.14673343243083334, + "Yices": 2.495256367842746, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17531295667140001, + "CVC4": 2.5455544393721947, + "CVC3": 0.16785975647973336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17728495934466668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17591185350429997 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1684246516997001, + "veriT": 0.14207698310770001, + "Yices": 0.16319321185160002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1861370015939001, + "CVC4": 0.18413233491459999, + "CVC3": 0.1615295890033, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17281267599689998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17126192056759998 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19507745432183332, + "veriT": 2.5207734046390962, + "Yices": 0.30076097700249999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21833438067016667, + "CVC4": 0.21168224698866667, + "CVC3": 0.21791570315200001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19779656983983332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.198317558152 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1497711277695, + "veriT": 7.0669930211390932, + "Yices": 0.14754422538383333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18446022498483336, + "CVC4": 0.17583396219949998, + "CVC3": 0.96767537865900011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15962752345483333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16145984450366666 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.555016052961074, + "veriT": 6.8050661241841501, + "Yices": 6.861893786608583, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.154857006402205, + "CVC4": 7.2982595938370567, + "CVC3": 4.9541987911163643, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8736498057975925, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3740100188747073 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9789334508416987, + "veriT": 8.5921826123521985, + "Yices": 6.1657711316036616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1257743706615102, + "CVC4": 11.638121854557564, + "CVC3": 5.4895481783445792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1405366755386197, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.66328180732798 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.5373770780635454, + "veriT": 8.3861668845626767, + "Yices": 8.924462551139678, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2954958119041819, + "CVC4": 2.7527081998806935, + "CVC3": 4.5344594148820025, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18772067161127273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18086400799772728 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3654584379528909, + "veriT": 6.9979369735566745, + "Yices": 5.0337173515090541, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9443275087024361, + "CVC4": 11.681610957628735, + "CVC3": 5.9794154516854867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3226642455353161, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8151173650220418 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9341790676116943, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.268285425040274, + "veriT": 10.761379392438391, + "Yices": 11.578350623619416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.966184229935029, + "CVC4": 14.681721956032609, + "CVC3": 8.7756771525645103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.898355749204743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6859081078581415 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.967042534523344, + "veriT": 11.77773627718247, + "Yices": 12.124042654387017, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4232057524030193, + "CVC4": 11.362059927632995, + "CVC3": 7.0522982427334009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.238415247297707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.234283784553497 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1161478693466265, + "veriT": 13.402426677977877, + "Yices": 12.448279253955112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.517735832066347, + "CVC4": 14.563142487755396, + "CVC3": 9.1818127659892212, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.668272483779457, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.665402003782704 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.455588359804542, + "veriT": 14.006375561741274, + "Yices": 12.296523984393968, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.232450597125606, + "CVC4": 14.296735924333859, + "CVC3": 14.016707050113883, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239469711642972, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237745294488258 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1465730667114258, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3373606237313842, + "veriT": 7.4874027256379554, + "Yices": 5.2359698523349509, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1787441874300488, + "CVC4": 2.8798174988635754, + "CVC3": 3.5228333089850326, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0608145741360955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0879367108555926 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 135.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.234393141201846, + "veriT": 11.346271681225572, + "Yices": 10.523764082400545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.57877196486584, + "CVC4": 12.126280855199507, + "CVC3": 8.6561897114773618, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23316630308523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.351497871206581 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.106492475841915, + "veriT": 13.548942705391966, + "Yices": 10.084825415262651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1029465071071094, + "CVC4": 10.997613116530864, + "CVC3": 2.6920368733886888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3722481343667816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2012357729270748 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1261476415292737, + "veriT": 13.059869432585526, + "Yices": 3.6021689675655928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3368503258950808, + "CVC4": 0.51402164815120011, + "CVC3": 5.1394165909702325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20678392157620001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20117820151990001 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.170201471920429, + "veriT": 12.375851566014113, + "Yices": 12.398926062253572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.938588782401427, + "CVC4": 8.7663735134041083, + "CVC3": 12.056895027757809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.859372582981033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8940558059286037 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 281.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9300885956572511, + "veriT": 8.1583147538859748, + "Yices": 9.691595066581435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.468340273267218, + "CVC4": 11.168043090296376, + "CVC3": 8.7783405814889548, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.981364506430422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.556560994848265 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3804578380504964, + "veriT": 12.354997705153838, + "Yices": 13.975790635154278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.153035317939068, + "CVC4": 14.626893752354482, + "CVC3": 14.26050930441092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1732230811081625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1721152526564294 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.041952623987219, + "veriT": 14.225462863672806, + "Yices": 14.225166495830498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.48944836352886, + "CVC4": 14.305153387551616, + "CVC3": 13.249381167355022, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3531987857848584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.669805536162233 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 168.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8146715128637529, + "veriT": 13.128381689435571, + "Yices": 11.935359467374271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952982883798652, + "CVC4": 12.291059533029896, + "CVC3": 8.15290722295234, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.262951567963254, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.23852638278076 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.050341192784879, + "veriT": 12.233389974306627, + "Yices": 13.623894081503286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972981903353247, + "CVC4": 14.790439386775949, + "CVC3": 12.905244090801588, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.269173522815427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.293091657432271 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6427707662502371, + "veriT": 14.229024437762066, + "Yices": 14.228081357953002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.140159939661524, + "CVC4": 12.715280091161699, + "CVC3": 10.227477007936555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7793144569645669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8093187332316036 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.620881106362214, + "veriT": 13.548114318810148, + "Yices": 14.412233327119205, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.512186550276835, + "CVC4": 9.899914056464274, + "CVC3": 13.642448934516059, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.21614831949571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.208624545862319 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.573579921056828, + "veriT": 13.03578572651308, + "Yices": 12.3233856641248, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.383813553857257, + "CVC4": 14.516879231686776, + "CVC3": 12.417050162992499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260978393034094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.683039877568216 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257324314624968, + "veriT": 13.969029408813297, + "Yices": 14.198297095425687, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.980391762597755, + "CVC4": 14.789459772489494, + "CVC3": 13.685502045757529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.077818835481757, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.105603647862649 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.595935750700399, + "veriT": 9.8372940771630279, + "Yices": 12.464521115273778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.910320787414305, + "CVC4": 14.643349520077773, + "CVC3": 4.8096921971759263, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.176423037758239, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4653571790156104 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12207840938557146, + "veriT": 0.090808621317280971, + "Yices": 0.094860589451514279, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12018826727385713, + "CVC4": 0.11978858114009523, + "CVC3": 0.097176501336138088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12058516149666666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11634908552509525 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11719326379229332, + "veriT": 0.74972481981790673, + "Yices": 0.75309770418395339, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12920763756549333, + "CVC4": 1.046676369945557, + "CVC3": 0.089253117878880003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0453033446305346, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0438159022660152 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9619227729706665, + "veriT": 0.10280521581844999, + "Yices": 1.7982772648362415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9615098376454156, + "CVC4": 0.12437154684016666, + "CVC3": 0.10786889918574999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1265074416085, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15346671912641666 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.60852557067464719, + "veriT": 9.9926270223907654, + "Yices": 10.164858597458254, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.67504573423137726, + "CVC4": 0.57100077449701292, + "CVC3": 1.4460356248560446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.54987311653550652, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.256029698793455 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18385323450381819, + "veriT": 7.4239118997980915, + "Yices": 9.6382653359880912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31357269294236362, + "CVC4": 0.15152430340836365, + "CVC3": 0.24716804674490908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1480213531000909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7822933142553712 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7029409408569336, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5252918746736666, + "veriT": 6.5038095777856499, + "Yices": 8.2181144781449742, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1388695924443333, + "CVC4": 5.0938443050188846, + "CVC3": 3.6764696151446672, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8417401037534402, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.540703367235146 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.238121232030181, + "veriT": 10.167454055353, + "Yices": 10.335137804309833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960117152206292, + "CVC4": 0.15643793811283335, + "CVC3": 10.286486367486205, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8896548340688319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.400557239531478 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.486195151374014, + "veriT": 11.899471110255062, + "Yices": 9.6540880426308586, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.7850280886239, + "CVC4": 6.4948526337166674, + "CVC3": 8.9945812451681437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1852475193142169, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.946725091613471 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.619287186819614, + "veriT": 10.153853012597143, + "Yices": 10.31515156986643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950022558327946, + "CVC4": 0.18082715591571427, + "CVC3": 11.663690684439855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16827079055014285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.012590651002332 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.22914348220916, + "veriT": 10.138693911970666, + "Yices": 10.303375903494445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.940295263918106, + "CVC4": 0.17117847068055556, + "CVC3": 14.219121988630377, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8889581610782535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.506998764979848 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2759851386900696, + "veriT": 9.9540909846095005, + "Yices": 9.9554772555049045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2107106585644223, + "CVC4": 6.7896697676536295, + "CVC3": 7.6934179572883128, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2788725919352864, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2781403132968077 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8723116620789524, + "veriT": 10.578087232676042, + "Yices": 7.0450033192497337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3660888044531028, + "CVC4": 0.41022659082359997, + "CVC3": 2.2241777229968824, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.271236892898944, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.03863737734415 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5393939018249512, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.592579387717016, + "veriT": 13.824034160866843, + "Yices": 13.580648781743859, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.154480568717295, + "CVC4": 9.0969093631864233, + "CVC3": 9.1902795117935927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2181966941841358, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2643054324102758 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.784904542886023, + "veriT": 12.360612969924338, + "Yices": 10.992000481153651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.948964866568685, + "CVC4": 13.49840056315122, + "CVC3": 13.169313072667368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242470322968462, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.166149103723752 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8516485691070557, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7113731422219551, + "veriT": 6.2418087681010324, + "Yices": 11.241764184585092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5031611841352328, + "CVC4": 4.6295824211309, + "CVC3": 6.7478759202973126, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.999512708955681, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1996698976129636 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236964704065647, + "veriT": 10.175318662698588, + "Yices": 10.359873560678352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956149569096217, + "CVC4": 2.7352408232587719, + "CVC3": 11.812219308638635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4618727092239494, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.465568046574111 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.54212627774406, + "veriT": 11.175668255771811, + "Yices": 8.9196811557359279, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.073484539522589, + "CVC4": 1.0000180906059166, + "CVC3": 8.2556802637354085, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.572810309092015, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.994639344989523 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.017295245016181, + "veriT": 12.370878357394769, + "Yices": 10.548969366425473, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.268230931394278, + "CVC4": 11.757535665619198, + "CVC3": 10.661082279638782, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.817912117807532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.818757659448158 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239681644416843, + "veriT": 10.155433311066801, + "Yices": 10.334346668166001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955473432113276, + "CVC4": 0.15994856426239998, + "CVC3": 12.622121078621543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7992980744868152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.307392206476905 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4477310638357981, + "veriT": 9.167194563138592, + "Yices": 7.4700035916994576, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8440995817914452, + "CVC4": 2.0737319284790612, + "CVC3": 11.190961025828768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2139148385495746, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4344567570793814 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12894645112522221, + "veriT": 0.099841103705322232, + "Yices": 4.9332849079407959, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12556852473518887, + "CVC4": 4.8706116492189802, + "CVC3": 5.1635019514120222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17300330538188891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17463998625996668 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.787978507977485, + "veriT": 13.694368742368457, + "Yices": 5.8882265906967008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.822457361739918, + "CVC4": 11.493100972986792, + "CVC3": 11.388373893124088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.798577290585996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.79535244729146 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0330036458175034, + "veriT": 5.5774426069949659, + "Yices": 4.5500028377122579, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9071628253750355, + "CVC4": 3.5250431279494832, + "CVC3": 4.1687438884072039, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8191383674894794, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5181879667807943 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2651200552619497, + "veriT": 12.04782993944689, + "Yices": 2.1237699297217185, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.58748610901338461, + "CVC4": 2.4911127613003279, + "CVC3": 0.91415353172753844, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5788544459027793, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5861903566701345 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.966953701842479, + "veriT": 9.644574330520939, + "Yices": 9.5529658756719122, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.5665271261139, + "CVC4": 8.8434581983259264, + "CVC3": 8.3355708783308007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8728930691234069, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9169435486680904 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3178469856692232, + "veriT": 0.95415557345874991, + "Yices": 5.5193715169153821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3716085298831799, + "CVC4": 4.8624895468293889, + "CVC3": 1.3106809891738951, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0026521764385743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.306800037062769 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13224654267057143, + "veriT": 7.1153966768548935, + "Yices": 9.1334481741187243, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12982644593699996, + "CVC4": 0.13804801003321429, + "CVC3": 0.13116021837485714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1341950628337143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13273462376707143 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8819444179534912, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.351946212610251, + "veriT": 9.1950443412301723, + "Yices": 10.782624431133295, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.686271751582671, + "CVC4": 2.593335996236108, + "CVC3": 9.5380129493970855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4806003125121703, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1163839864218321 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5692806079011525, + "veriT": 9.8471760939887556, + "Yices": 10.499421100688146, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0294103046380645, + "CVC4": 9.8174483100935053, + "CVC3": 7.2855779740290574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6054172199983228, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.983878903393601 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.152063108197, + "veriT": 1.2349201641321295, + "Yices": 7.9988657031687014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24367063343710002, + "CVC4": 1.7442232556741115, + "CVC3": 1.22491675324786, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5486817663216679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5667108146117275 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1333308223982002, + "veriT": 4.9348497790562558, + "Yices": 7.9958063181762258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1300741402778396, + "CVC4": 8.8926897405178167, + "CVC3": 4.2183612316085402, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7939163074341167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7913052425573719 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5037399952632056, + "veriT": 10.175842045329309, + "Yices": 9.2120246919126707, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.811099518898619, + "CVC4": 9.109152887603555, + "CVC3": 8.3320071032390963, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.833877104219074, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.633988853592959 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.9249714128253, + "veriT": 9.222970404940801, + "Yices": 9.1144611148705508, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.908084906929064, + "CVC4": 5.1215356835810022, + "CVC3": 3.1100179401200543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.534269773050307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.540925874600465 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24050254827274997, + "veriT": 6.8182017339178165, + "Yices": 9.8363087226589272, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.29945966044885003, + "CVC4": 7.2296708791089133, + "CVC3": 0.16178084586516667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7642907944257407, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1269792597936195 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0962192189647357, + "veriT": 9.9743030270574913, + "Yices": 11.584571157573894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5101492737774276, + "CVC4": 10.781529902341644, + "CVC3": 12.145274133566533, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.799185382592437, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.878328083937852 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1869372518695762, + "veriT": 6.6219466809644754, + "Yices": 12.211933775142425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9500332864808323, + "CVC4": 7.0084308314826584, + "CVC3": 11.090829251933666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1235466456836676, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1259605934607784 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0374097927777362, + "veriT": 6.3771584024821086, + "Yices": 15.130636157976717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1814437178138553, + "CVC4": 14.527306022156246, + "CVC3": 11.871489523295404, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9085348213149005, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8952324052093679 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.917041920501529, + "veriT": 10.906190234900157, + "Yices": 11.571292967324151, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.79855777848937, + "CVC4": 8.2540425136523634, + "CVC3": 4.1092343192014447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1577143204578881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.012711094726439 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.96419766272038465, + "veriT": 3.2920068789247483, + "Yices": 5.720545383693703, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7532538417252306, + "CVC4": 3.1345583563091308, + "CVC3": 3.683289548748526, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2805312116416767, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2805783409409557 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3950826258057298, + "veriT": 9.6199574900631664, + "Yices": 11.128487611425129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8459877971199008, + "CVC4": 10.418883721578164, + "CVC3": 8.6281882076619691, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.224253644294578, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.787441584267105 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.418356736584143, + "veriT": 4.2021671527766742, + "Yices": 7.0383661482505104, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6700075050812377, + "CVC4": 2.3973781617454839, + "CVC3": 0.99804149163864275, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1869044118299144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.183985296041544 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2996473354322999, + "veriT": 12.595911768553531, + "Yices": 8.6969816765844001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5218736339314649, + "CVC4": 10.291997821892167, + "CVC3": 3.6267064898942736, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.834760400270079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.595866359577531 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3774963820320001, + "veriT": 0.13540201264708887, + "Yices": 0.13608433319733335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3748453323547785, + "CVC4": 0.17378688100422221, + "CVC3": 0.14599713929699998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16081655828300001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15693138099866666 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14393111980388237, + "veriT": 0.12160108236088236, + "Yices": 0.13474621175405879, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14199802713852944, + "CVC4": 0.16003407320141178, + "CVC3": 0.14149095909370588, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15663285991176473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15717333389005878 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15383618755680001, + "veriT": 5.7674969676911427, + "Yices": 2.9808808054686375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16672454284380001, + "CVC4": 0.17800533557940001, + "CVC3": 0.15927299777679998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15881630420340001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15921297293219999 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.058279586226182, + "veriT": 10.16435708018737, + "Yices": 3.1474327793346641, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0665884378682726, + "CVC4": 4.0261405315585144, + "CVC3": 2.5722339402009635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4328478154216908, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4801654576767493 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.39470213059776926, + "veriT": 3.9142706285995454, + "Yices": 10.434014757656216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2642187731195382, + "CVC4": 1.3301872421332932, + "CVC3": 3.3422374087504396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3904167749871417, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3921054166494136 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6844874681741304, + "veriT": 1.0753300108500754, + "Yices": 1.0160965146638334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7919282662893785, + "CVC4": 11.492107367624639, + "CVC3": 0.27233174857941334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16799466547740002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16399147374642667 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1475264331819068, + "veriT": 4.3980708930827932, + "Yices": 10.344915914739753, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2490667038818626, + "CVC4": 7.2610765725411266, + "CVC3": 6.7519866950230361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.248725131733269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2584412052252252 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.420914767264563, + "veriT": 11.253035608491617, + "Yices": 11.932679993178807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.100918128064386, + "CVC4": 14.038530237300009, + "CVC3": 11.257784025419326, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.314128158588836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.987774307599436 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 52.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20102326277837501, + "veriT": 8.4212579077224987, + "Yices": 1.745106009240875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.60154833327200008, + "CVC4": 2.0503031829341074, + "CVC3": 1.9497119134428627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.864291218572351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8779236422344221 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.779143167752629, + "veriT": 12.660495766025946, + "Yices": 6.4202728409661614, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3874264390227831, + "CVC4": 7.8638857842756247, + "CVC3": 9.8311190397099875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7428842895956294, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.975072924113352 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.221516275290018, + "veriT": 11.623031673254092, + "Yices": 11.096750280338297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.836595698047836, + "CVC4": 12.251995909892818, + "CVC3": 12.20892358097989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1569757251778992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3274882858101265 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.673099683623359, + "veriT": 13.813734236820318, + "Yices": 11.665370304091116, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.230207408254719, + "CVC4": 14.613776106065856, + "CVC3": 12.966193333983796, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.832797737055051, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.830464615907214 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.283836734023749, + "veriT": 14.223820315781285, + "Yices": 13.150327263648235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.656641891450723, + "CVC4": 10.70332188077416, + "CVC3": 6.7937170411774348, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.175690554495121, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.158559224004481 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1933103511873786, + "veriT": 13.708309402475537, + "Yices": 11.149897361795142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8722315339193258, + "CVC4": 11.163598847818047, + "CVC3": 7.9780297987647479, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.755088100820922, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.085573129067047 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 203.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0896588882601455, + "veriT": 8.6076299208289999, + "Yices": 9.8660551407315129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.266242103312797, + "CVC4": 9.575309282126911, + "CVC3": 4.798151027275332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.213712386234342, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.21214338649745 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0870903109919192, + "veriT": 10.472390759488741, + "Yices": 4.7126269286873264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8176446967356226, + "CVC4": 4.2543344453733871, + "CVC3": 4.5302838315627891, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1923283303500769, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1896861964948604 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 114.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0599746704101562, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.750017053133085, + "veriT": 8.4120380674716095, + "Yices": 9.3629774520024309, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.497086260100962, + "CVC4": 7.2163015903107954, + "CVC3": 5.1781775551854281, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.56622957574751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6042435626352969 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.735971784179636, + "veriT": 11.463807039727619, + "Yices": 2.4796946245935456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9137789327417281, + "CVC4": 2.2437167700510909, + "CVC3": 12.408987271968737, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17117873536800002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16781206030790907 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1710432168097778, + "veriT": 5.4893494978371518, + "Yices": 3.2611275694928987, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.36712347416211116, + "CVC4": 3.3028141882024387, + "CVC3": 0.17720354277477779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14950207563833331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14537356355688888 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.81556707075942847, + "veriT": 10.500358723742144, + "Yices": 6.4512387107148124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6392803723979554, + "CVC4": 0.36986678801971423, + "CVC3": 1.6312772331058571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2093961978326728, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2029101370263877 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 146.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.866165666858571, + "veriT": 10.179174145710546, + "Yices": 11.037403751641374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973042112985949, + "CVC4": 14.371311466569056, + "CVC3": 11.226739255695863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260498055694422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.742136824975733 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5289491458414144, + "veriT": 12.682304977620189, + "Yices": 6.7320168909800033, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6295901845065321, + "CVC4": 1.9149216521793946, + "CVC3": 2.5239436466814444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7761161021197338, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7738626511115041 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3747024102113983, + "veriT": 12.041645326084302, + "Yices": 11.476909849510864, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.622597295922173, + "CVC4": 11.996246757501105, + "CVC3": 14.242503592927923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5459434756039814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2950889987516647 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9537617296491159, + "veriT": 11.809996710436167, + "Yices": 13.930282143031349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6129729929268848, + "CVC4": 12.861519963962975, + "CVC3": 11.044714563933692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.570686379729537, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2242910757942944 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.684007721681164, + "veriT": 10.545883333365953, + "Yices": 7.4579281676051563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2093505038557497, + "CVC4": 13.389236206327107, + "CVC3": 5.7149842281157142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.748547818508143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.318179133893521 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 106.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.894718337116192, + "veriT": 12.041751115564658, + "Yices": 12.933351193382226, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96178786217591, + "CVC4": 11.173369868099451, + "CVC3": 4.0720076259145488, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.05549142472041, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3490930551198304 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 52.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.250304355529817, + "veriT": 11.337916440778448, + "Yices": 13.724946050531031, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.480526655328104, + "CVC4": 14.388616149873016, + "CVC3": 13.172863553903584, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.874285965493527, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.727143798975748 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.794760628662658, + "veriT": 13.664451146321989, + "Yices": 14.318745919668626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960235477997912, + "CVC4": 14.793874362710122, + "CVC3": 13.872504445496768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.265543934698304, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.261956201915853 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4962414288526453, + "veriT": 12.978503905122263, + "Yices": 13.819942220316971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965506332503423, + "CVC4": 14.614662773523722, + "CVC3": 12.77894087752273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.206171372238074, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.896581885916889 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.690150065578171, + "veriT": 11.556829283889824, + "Yices": 11.671366526597124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.200448927297948, + "CVC4": 12.843632448216503, + "CVC3": 13.494225217312517, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.215289495917663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.572321227070962 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.008387035166781, + "veriT": 14.259366863116181, + "Yices": 14.152586686222261, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.389723482259507, + "CVC4": 14.731042178457527, + "CVC3": 7.513029121125455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.909790618014139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.469225744142461 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13345556765158334, + "veriT": 1.3423140696108, + "Yices": 1.3440111606957583, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15394645753137501, + "CVC4": 1.8847792229332738, + "CVC3": 0.097821824198483301, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.877642725018448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8766314299210327 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12790792239168078, + "veriT": 0.097955132848369264, + "Yices": 0.10410126558313076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12607409757844229, + "CVC4": 0.12416740994819613, + "CVC3": 0.10762297094658077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12134879111016154, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12109471835743847 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3448494179231751, + "veriT": 4.4701272831880905, + "Yices": 4.651550274999928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6453990868978732, + "CVC4": 4.203727234458003, + "CVC3": 2.185924644058145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18632866441735715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2068354916643198 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.76979142084288954, + "veriT": 10.166023530636442, + "Yices": 10.35085957701008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.84840543772730925, + "CVC4": 0.148866984772, + "CVC3": 0.71167411029587979, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14610594224304005, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.444589363338316 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20076085258136364, + "veriT": 10.166124732202817, + "Yices": 10.342760059454911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.41174205707472727, + "CVC4": 0.15205007044927274, + "CVC3": 0.33120882275945457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15225667134518181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9470012465853714 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.45075173893747, + "veriT": 12.947129314586427, + "Yices": 11.954694277657792, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.677460608435631, + "CVC4": 12.191981086507836, + "CVC3": 10.512139832616942, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.248721248952958, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.336017445879591 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7954682386538581, + "veriT": 6.1107519262970733, + "Yices": 4.3448551831677351, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5878767259017081, + "CVC4": 3.9630851080424461, + "CVC3": 3.1242344513527871, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.394766779731941, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3934055477054903 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.182855819317727, + "veriT": 11.385844117552786, + "Yices": 11.322840809254842, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.187252797643376, + "CVC4": 8.9887520158374024, + "CVC3": 11.983595212812171, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7249841759777489, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.084751019579844 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.65781991529424, + "veriT": 10.415896035507338, + "Yices": 10.3041114913536, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.470985799208842, + "CVC4": 2.2332907005411, + "CVC3": 11.321583668553062, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.936855202526016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.152021342506918 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9418951589871369, + "veriT": 9.9172541566968082, + "Yices": 8.2686009083704484, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3927313255728286, + "CVC4": 0.17071326094875, + "CVC3": 8.9449365738233979, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1415063555503657, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4950943402582055 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.224648927454593, + "veriT": 11.293749476872705, + "Yices": 11.338628477330152, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.939915021391105, + "CVC4": 10.331367025780301, + "CVC3": 14.214451438934969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3167761736524142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4611654687959632 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6643939604578231, + "veriT": 3.1418212005233586, + "Yices": 4.0177148849666882, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6554191177328215, + "CVC4": 1.9122031517280484, + "CVC3": 2.025441138735653, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9064492839951201, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.307366261419407 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8105242301883333, + "veriT": 10.625862570320752, + "Yices": 9.6689006875911634, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8283948447181828, + "CVC4": 8.551673412245643, + "CVC3": 8.244662807975903, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4022976153192186, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.397302620674556 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5612650468628826, + "veriT": 5.1579700029373328, + "Yices": 6.9208967089143343, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8791324891592809, + "CVC4": 0.15844720381533331, + "CVC3": 0.78440713095416659, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15268604298433333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4998651072850535 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12928698592250001, + "veriT": 7.4390421822989765, + "Yices": 8.1260767097936064, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15731477336283334, + "CVC4": 2.6551560157785867, + "CVC3": 2.4898753797212905, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12642974571433335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12758479063066666 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8953240814787224, + "veriT": 6.3604812721846749, + "Yices": 8.1236124501000333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9841893950413076, + "CVC4": 2.667568066160575, + "CVC3": 4.5366403368305424, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3631747800006471, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3344527722208355 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.712417090121232, + "veriT": 7.6640396089398752, + "Yices": 7.8038527063142498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.248777500441529, + "CVC4": 0.15807826433475, + "CVC3": 8.4144166918167436, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8589169287621503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.585193137380616 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240231785135984, + "veriT": 10.154878404383091, + "Yices": 10.330593000031635, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957621947906718, + "CVC4": 0.15745259892999999, + "CVC3": 10.421662030037318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2351041928526909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.330248760650854 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.964144721471875, + "veriT": 9.4818168095037336, + "Yices": 10.586262329570706, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.638790294449205, + "CVC4": 0.1604451586624, + "CVC3": 14.141126172961044, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.89613801061335041, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.602722018113122 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8804707993018068, + "veriT": 12.761171370521067, + "Yices": 12.188096614439905, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3101063700411046, + "CVC4": 9.3446575102117748, + "CVC3": 10.615005525980694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5761734021515963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2816163563271452 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8285713195800781, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.823376969575682, + "veriT": 12.184061502005248, + "Yices": 11.663915076194547, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.023164978797144, + "CVC4": 6.1151825960559387, + "CVC3": 12.485149495180867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.112889738753886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.798668001325414 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235603653312587, + "veriT": 11.442190498637897, + "Yices": 12.066527952558211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953979444278954, + "CVC4": 0.46590351405022218, + "CVC3": 10.337194163451294, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.686186697006317, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.143249875536164 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2409433004275696, + "veriT": 6.1422472943646254, + "Yices": 5.7717513721056317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9485079669219152, + "CVC4": 6.3349149668337379, + "CVC3": 3.1232881720051906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1271898568019498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1249847474209655 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1634844043001138, + "veriT": 12.826951568014204, + "Yices": 11.037288169408331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.721821705325514, + "CVC4": 9.517447435474633, + "CVC3": 3.1954982592459293, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.839355903655818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.840258323619461 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9896574806764784, + "veriT": 10.859316244298423, + "Yices": 10.501078226990412, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0769074827767691, + "CVC4": 11.729902494586616, + "CVC3": 9.1320258222647261, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.975581464245334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.987165504869717 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.589821364841846, + "veriT": 4.1851264250480993, + "Yices": 8.7247477301705718, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.825713401453037, + "CVC4": 0.21409785577849999, + "CVC3": 0.16262425952029996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5449007993674719, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0378949752925539 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4402372087525404, + "veriT": 9.9443166285005482, + "Yices": 9.3847730647461116, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3614164951371581, + "CVC4": 3.3095639486125488, + "CVC3": 4.9690824905532525, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7904798806439031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4573373106084357 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.086773356596359, + "veriT": 10.944220863669935, + "Yices": 10.418345491882947, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.316740193989418, + "CVC4": 3.035210226403271, + "CVC3": 3.7708608635417051, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.657692961257755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.677898772746545 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.392424100452875, + "veriT": 1.3536596385509001, + "Yices": 14.036043755414383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.38262429609325, + "CVC4": 12.483934747865664, + "CVC3": 9.447424785412796, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1919697233220141, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1919983938545293 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.80911575142813985, + "veriT": 7.6233749764127232, + "Yices": 4.6655280214924622, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.93693287481094645, + "CVC4": 2.2925124983337883, + "CVC3": 1.5115944138516402, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7664058777899765, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8006736359744422 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6475142654094279, + "veriT": 11.584202884465437, + "Yices": 8.5201831750292385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.791406060521906, + "CVC4": 9.345965370647825, + "CVC3": 9.2618697804016197, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2663055914343779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2109619307495691 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.728246873089875, + "veriT": 3.6805854874889681, + "Yices": 2.7004451580419992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8775761811515004, + "CVC4": 0.18814879211699997, + "CVC3": 0.185642395489625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6925689743272616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.30501966430825006 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2019040401295, + "veriT": 4.8492911958697782, + "Yices": 10.54031520969334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23002866140366365, + "CVC4": 4.0318151630152048, + "CVC3": 1.4195724969014027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.3058858648663727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.24337121038911819 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.510572496454833, + "veriT": 3.1377944495178336, + "Yices": 2.4860616945072627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6014352497850006, + "CVC4": 0.18142778907683332, + "CVC3": 1.8675608122009832, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.526872089533276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.524801346844756 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.839184016261905, + "veriT": 9.4876695821190999, + "Yices": 10.729301941204914, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.485455588465602, + "CVC4": 0.16382830454560002, + "CVC3": 11.876503673150218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16812072977540002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2013503436007014 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9103008065847078, + "veriT": 10.471121148164451, + "Yices": 12.549392120796657, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.042344716750593, + "CVC4": 12.605527640062077, + "CVC3": 10.884077167015564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.780815728845033, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.752175932245439 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5114083304456933, + "veriT": 4.6558520686832363, + "Yices": 7.6243892518773091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6374334287726375, + "CVC4": 2.8052620827998918, + "CVC3": 1.2315323511771821, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4179751490597636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9696073616946195 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6692754877735556, + "veriT": 9.5216738916389989, + "Yices": 8.0777800817380001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1676410127923216, + "CVC4": 11.137321429325199, + "CVC3": 1.5291590278613332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.250964678887719, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.847968264807291 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 81.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1903480201676, + "veriT": 0.12264085768624003, + "Yices": 1.5798337644686211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31466656211311006, + "CVC4": 1.585484450757449, + "CVC3": 0.15989359143335999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15822368370400003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15323941729939999 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.24690004999119, + "veriT": 5.51647512456789, + "Yices": 12.267200428123784, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.045492574478537, + "CVC4": 6.6316187680357377, + "CVC3": 3.2978601992271637, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2622078746954206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5738010424614202 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.24107743008841, + "veriT": 12.481956601973733, + "Yices": 11.723455248948701, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.825638831521646, + "CVC4": 11.549573805782794, + "CVC3": 7.4279252566772822, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.131605563025252, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.586940327032242 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6496801473780001, + "veriT": 3.6887163624614829, + "Yices": 13.976452809479335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6606751331748337, + "CVC4": 13.431682582006102, + "CVC3": 14.453429894925355, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1018976815946253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0897268552025707 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8876985311508179, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21153180998339999, + "veriT": 10.57108528950433, + "Yices": 3.0468977195225588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2608250276374708, + "CVC4": 6.0528313188006431, + "CVC3": 1.6931461434845578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2074156004837153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9753902208239333 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8349118909731874, + "veriT": 14.221331331786351, + "Yices": 10.183321432489201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0609034130935395, + "CVC4": 3.8610450522587056, + "CVC3": 10.080739531648319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.929198048682002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.934243733319244 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14272958790328574, + "veriT": 9.1788792793916283, + "Yices": 1.8010563288546426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22142851301035718, + "CVC4": 2.1919224740822658, + "CVC3": 0.13640660536635713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9351628127614662, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.936966669665634 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4667832479584124, + "veriT": 14.214189502007246, + "Yices": 10.813486730843287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.40123653937318, + "CVC4": 9.9922324794403909, + "CVC3": 4.8384132916165221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.046368195781094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.048549020478964 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 58.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7498710155487061, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7630680064380915, + "veriT": 10.212673679810802, + "Yices": 11.173293554579569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.663797047754956, + "CVC4": 14.317310947806234, + "CVC3": 12.520198566348048, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.278712050854599, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.002086481739639 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 50.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.323747599234153, + "veriT": 1.0206688380715454, + "Yices": 1.0255437849184545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3865785029322488, + "CVC4": 0.14931644904936361, + "CVC3": 0.1266059049229091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13768283339663634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13721290197218181 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.894616015584681, + "veriT": 2.6196455346978746, + "Yices": 4.3657647125395682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0228530508325608, + "CVC4": 2.0038408471798501, + "CVC3": 1.8873049944053075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4953859948207109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4952166035202832 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16519019480447142, + "veriT": 5.1419354122331216, + "Yices": 10.05639924944939, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17992069823452858, + "CVC4": 6.2129309560427748, + "CVC3": 4.9363865065123216, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1723604521720068, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0004847733189148 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26018556566739998, + "veriT": 0.182325032755175, + "Yices": 5.453374328837298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.68012807591653768, + "CVC4": 2.0041679097321299, + "CVC3": 0.22963341366562501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2192614292935125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21887865012036251 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4975339247748547, + "veriT": 10.145357347607604, + "Yices": 9.2018229228566319, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1537873423676537, + "CVC4": 8.775014791228795, + "CVC3": 9.8297879065446789, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5553596777175933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0742311133278211 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17833635294900002, + "veriT": 4.557901530381093, + "Yices": 3.5715793918301921, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1922914428686, + "CVC4": 7.2621140143227381, + "CVC3": 0.17111373805630001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.25165047454139999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21925738073929998 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0805301666259766, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8162230859938333, + "veriT": 0.12254685010516665, + "Yices": 0.13873885556116669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8170634244975001, + "CVC4": 0.16894643644666665, + "CVC3": 0.14674602982666665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15911057086966665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16044671574933331 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.163412225607, + "veriT": 0.14643315301312498, + "Yices": 0.16127194884224999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16794878307212499, + "CVC4": 0.186670484332875, + "CVC3": 0.16395682616062499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.183017997516875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18135359856962499 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8164047644179062, + "veriT": 10.989949706561172, + "Yices": 13.775287708577455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.8961413074985, + "CVC4": 14.328665496797715, + "CVC3": 12.216389370919055, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4615691366543446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4473938335680048 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3479609490627145, + "veriT": 11.667948328279868, + "Yices": 6.2236002053010759, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2630052277720463, + "CVC4": 4.5158697273186341, + "CVC3": 5.8737389835744125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6722368751077168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9895242309371373 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7735044956207275, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 111.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5560880402998549, + "veriT": 13.521816917551591, + "Yices": 12.574439612118562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2364063443887172, + "CVC4": 14.097615336372476, + "CVC3": 5.8668420325987674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.293227483714164, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.291534996061918 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.3533352741186, + "veriT": 12.587288442332035, + "Yices": 4.8480269620502003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2505630034746558, + "CVC4": 3.0922189256738433, + "CVC3": 3.1286066005073492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.65316030863946, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.665948031708707 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245258332219988, + "veriT": 10.170017806189232, + "Yices": 10.304293975999123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964955139242234, + "CVC4": 14.371360278099612, + "CVC3": 13.27284336223145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23806733267693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.914047738990879 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5739805448701212, + "veriT": 12.591241447123885, + "Yices": 12.527351995922691, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.375826636974889, + "CVC4": 13.191602326729273, + "CVC3": 10.950852383211251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.12705123272751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.123627958666209 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0203560699055467, + "veriT": 13.533162222911729, + "Yices": 13.03976173429708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.53653637780006, + "CVC4": 12.417377653936969, + "CVC3": 10.664997646346336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.879672994215134, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.880950057104309 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17228389439399999, + "veriT": 1.5408384422002144, + "Yices": 0.6406588166025714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.73616578301757152, + "CVC4": 0.15762147619571426, + "CVC3": 2.164944438853825, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1471500795762857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14184810059514286 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2183409815294604, + "veriT": 6.2082283098851709, + "Yices": 10.197355957297219, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6994714864781768, + "CVC4": 8.2490962642713139, + "CVC3": 4.4380063249127284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17978945332082857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17897424666187142 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 173.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5586617496652986, + "veriT": 12.19002584641354, + "Yices": 12.217269204672004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.267814013568481, + "CVC4": 7.598947949768335, + "CVC3": 4.870787797001312, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.838581638968757, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.562129182104091 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4844718485179, + "veriT": 14.226052635016307, + "Yices": 2.6455110814417728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4181717649609666, + "CVC4": 0.8660279571717, + "CVC3": 10.280897745755155, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5951766957931366, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5958534603924621 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3163024170896991, + "veriT": 8.5311472170964997, + "Yices": 4.2349434468230065, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5389767484260144, + "CVC4": 0.35177264659599999, + "CVC3": 0.57865643133099998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20732626306042853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20070073999871424 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1988954676681569, + "veriT": 13.341843666838603, + "Yices": 13.34006364564139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.448386364404238, + "CVC4": 13.674695848692869, + "CVC3": 14.268687182773496, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7460276859794073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.497181872293206 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.822190763685665, + "veriT": 13.82375325103391, + "Yices": 13.008081166223679, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.947027553917639, + "CVC4": 13.668576118598542, + "CVC3": 12.354931342806838, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.536983608742101, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.312502363264359 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4572424210619879, + "veriT": 13.816924242315201, + "Yices": 12.423129730986609, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.835573640306274, + "CVC4": 13.023522756824041, + "CVC3": 12.95907892242516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.877138183925027, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.952093701993993 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 119.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2908543629213485, + "veriT": 7.238607328897249, + "Yices": 9.136418534525049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8191019552075076, + "CVC4": 10.845942870312022, + "CVC3": 7.7554645851223469, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4121637074434883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0398932917221195 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9097090245219368, + "veriT": 13.672760139514164, + "Yices": 13.710610668259212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.804397736759551, + "CVC4": 14.492491066164007, + "CVC3": 13.092867636542154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.153125477952349, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.740295435522494 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 133.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6990770894481129, + "veriT": 13.701130987810823, + "Yices": 14.044423946371886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.046049076692363, + "CVC4": 14.490858115992511, + "CVC3": 11.156405184925822, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.170565424521984, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.017860918125312 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 197.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.261574975364381, + "veriT": 11.952351071360278, + "Yices": 13.637541531881102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.540207768787264, + "CVC4": 14.704591779280936, + "CVC3": 14.400994118229233, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.276146335834168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.860248289762668 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242400629014695, + "veriT": 11.356631472986512, + "Yices": 12.716092318515207, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961066037659018, + "CVC4": 14.384555087678942, + "CVC3": 13.732188397177335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232855001809877, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.223492911548252 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.256059412261259, + "veriT": 13.882593588251716, + "Yices": 14.129740341348558, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.997706578459411, + "CVC4": 14.788323464360184, + "CVC3": 13.762063642320902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.345868127522506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.729917420074111 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1260175970988846, + "veriT": 0.098298910867976944, + "Yices": 0.099847430616869209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12305124140461542, + "CVC4": 0.1240919368026154, + "CVC3": 0.10356388560723079, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12214622361100001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1213942436464308 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11871869595792608, + "veriT": 0.090163104863347832, + "Yices": 0.095888316476143473, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11820990456759133, + "CVC4": 0.11535407214645217, + "CVC3": 0.097269026348960869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11194930873315653, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11098194656496087 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1146948382881998, + "veriT": 0.088312826436819994, + "Yices": 0.084492673377890001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1157690903848998, + "CVC4": 0.11887097125570001, + "CVC3": 0.092770997746599998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11635990622020001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1164151595531 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.65951932458982765, + "veriT": 9.9707579034394076, + "Yices": 10.146459860324839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.74465036469203849, + "CVC4": 0.62576171914124068, + "CVC3": 1.5284388449273407, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.60175115705121707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.250109250053045 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18405942702488887, + "veriT": 7.9274104408079991, + "Yices": 8.0742891052441124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28989953274822222, + "CVC4": 0.15473676241277778, + "CVC3": 0.26448722780955553, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14961112044966665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1104478961235555 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.843702880312215, + "veriT": 12.425877019574703, + "Yices": 12.444965034969638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.857262340997675, + "CVC4": 12.484222365292936, + "CVC3": 10.742200466373564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.139953047851755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.102804916393701 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.41428542137146, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4729362968171573, + "veriT": 5.5401661504752306, + "Yices": 8.2683056734796612, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2104886256197327, + "CVC4": 0.16584914706746151, + "CVC3": 3.8451731091491461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9145508881915587, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7749919928634013 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236780606779146, + "veriT": 10.160163300694801, + "Yices": 10.335560001628599, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955437364048771, + "CVC4": 0.1535907957888, + "CVC3": 10.576304479745, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14150532990420001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.236017842893663 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9873858606342019, + "veriT": 8.1937695921757214, + "Yices": 8.0414623265006799, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1941221594738103, + "CVC4": 2.0527475219302129, + "CVC3": 7.7439013763069768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3798296349159238, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.177164412014822 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242890363498633, + "veriT": 10.167567423532082, + "Yices": 10.340729435754916, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959881077817796, + "CVC4": 0.15393415654375001, + "CVC3": 10.174219960972733, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0226198161135804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.363558577786206 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244340689994942, + "veriT": 10.172731138918778, + "Yices": 10.346212398731332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965619523560823, + "CVC4": 0.16855374412611113, + "CVC3": 14.248494743974199, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1507561618238889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.27973928680904 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.435049317097761, + "veriT": 11.685053838896266, + "Yices": 11.042237816431639, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.886855800873622, + "CVC4": 3.851708013382964, + "CVC3": 7.6562636394407964, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.376451897063513, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.569029260539402 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.208621993686123, + "veriT": 8.8725567376405632, + "Yices": 10.252887096960167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.680687526775946, + "CVC4": 6.5221875585608062, + "CVC3": 6.4097829489632652, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.008749398281108, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4610548915523172 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242992745873357, + "veriT": 10.165390689498571, + "Yices": 10.326438533683428, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955471813923092, + "CVC4": 0.16708326097185713, + "CVC3": 13.141610638581694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.761271891227921, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.255446201401286 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.845000814256732, + "veriT": 7.8320318825785842, + "Yices": 9.0333120783590619, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1348223194262417, + "CVC4": 0.66887409870384618, + "CVC3": 5.7859600271270653, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.367196066654075, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5229143100558664 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9122849101749293, + "veriT": 10.845293175984855, + "Yices": 9.2745477832441221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6107796050876564, + "CVC4": 6.4722106366629255, + "CVC3": 6.3811985774951241, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3344910376418522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3569781460810848 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1833333969116211, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0301687939880111, + "veriT": 10.170951780558388, + "Yices": 2.0357617874158569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1281665994312942, + "CVC4": 6.2720669886593088, + "CVC3": 6.147466184436845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1324651554510012, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1335910288766682 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5848113834496682, + "veriT": 2.9770836325190002, + "Yices": 6.7113304663409403, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.680358061280852, + "CVC4": 2.2051042180687959, + "CVC3": 3.5923926473661631, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1958111576106196, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1942384527072041 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5370037538884267, + "veriT": 12.310394361439547, + "Yices": 9.6793324555864171, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6717580814411255, + "CVC4": 10.539818933414189, + "CVC3": 7.1760577860969734, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.814403180249332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.822884443541266 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4741084153684749, + "veriT": 5.6728696416977726, + "Yices": 9.6770305730409003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.101313006030363, + "CVC4": 1.6828058838495714, + "CVC3": 3.0663332164798573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1742556729202649, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1701002475129529 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13466644381199999, + "veriT": 6.7714818741993108, + "Yices": 8.3420009638360746, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13201770706655555, + "CVC4": 0.14064594699211114, + "CVC3": 0.11951889582966668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13473970777522221, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13265187363955555 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3095235824584961, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1221556140789002, + "veriT": 0.091388849473100012, + "Yices": 1.62486003804445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1133505091159701, + "CVC4": 1.5364991874916558, + "CVC3": 1.1185048744582302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13141919599489998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13004611629507001 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4174641337925382, + "veriT": 5.6028030651560545, + "Yices": 1.0536368761353636, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.490952291889625, + "CVC4": 1.4928289212845984, + "CVC3": 0.22937562351690907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0496629020053636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0691833705045388 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1584308472193357, + "veriT": 9.2229039284392655, + "Yices": 2.9798586736768149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21815203486427856, + "CVC4": 2.2961287807189215, + "CVC3": 2.4110888378105284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1293132952109852, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1026199478509016 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4199055947820964, + "veriT": 5.4069775352046268, + "Yices": 13.473039415568119, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4723800011668438, + "CVC4": 9.9574796167807609, + "CVC3": 10.316534047381719, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4174520219243245, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4202801875058739 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7126949070042983, + "veriT": 11.165638592751202, + "Yices": 11.067230140020488, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.314662297341155, + "CVC4": 2.5311376567592223, + "CVC3": 7.618408042775302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5527259421781832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.715164763073894 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.805091264447903, + "veriT": 12.39879264269134, + "Yices": 11.744933843315346, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.422088610596571, + "CVC4": 8.8535763544019126, + "CVC3": 13.544534093966043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6623747596306924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9005168688047487 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8074437730782709, + "veriT": 14.207752925308649, + "Yices": 13.025928014399545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.064688013163497, + "CVC4": 13.345215078896024, + "CVC3": 11.08412122722423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.468369927926107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.503171302231406 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2960715117734605, + "veriT": 3.5888710229723326, + "Yices": 7.927147887118867, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7908301553971757, + "CVC4": 3.45019386919778, + "CVC3": 3.2759335252532829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3896894519799829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0867763938677033 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.6569293870509, + "veriT": 10.551072456186837, + "Yices": 10.272222387716933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.686283685820991, + "CVC4": 12.05389769355882, + "CVC3": 7.3216337019562365, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225680297406781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.219047702134866 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6810883684264524, + "veriT": 8.120286939330402, + "Yices": 10.989390149884375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2636212593321474, + "CVC4": 5.8098799919296509, + "CVC3": 8.8491330917052924, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.660581164738115, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.240215750610545 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1596177714070626, + "veriT": 8.8371274167521978, + "Yices": 7.7273082760126401, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2853403922813218, + "CVC4": 2.6662238389389668, + "CVC3": 4.8288849152863786, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9857234719773613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0752194818053393 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1461169293967997, + "veriT": 14.213960012553898, + "Yices": 0.1565838286108, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1433432687242, + "CVC4": 0.29055012600820002, + "CVC3": 0.13295593212180001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6029038610938411, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.600678919302819 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9511904716491699, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7615493753737874, + "veriT": 3.7403804408543286, + "Yices": 6.3215592066857873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9854988187362796, + "CVC4": 3.1602013038832051, + "CVC3": 6.0449278680588927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0338598835082533, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8186210791640272 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8893677654081253, + "veriT": 0.13527504325862502, + "Yices": 3.6434814068866439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8903850647315004, + "CVC4": 0.16115854921375, + "CVC3": 6.2189656112455829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4152926166380642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4126367231144688 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.508772211342427, + "veriT": 10.299607565993815, + "Yices": 11.735437181911557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.08680292811057, + "CVC4": 8.1191715224189451, + "CVC3": 13.230725489140081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8510674187694738, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.918910060263755 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7075960302685518, + "veriT": 8.2703745088080929, + "Yices": 10.049916180299991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7964777948872115, + "CVC4": 3.5042221154242292, + "CVC3": 3.0390854273302144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9687594154737771, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3762463306781392 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0750000476837158, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14666791981529997, + "veriT": 8.7405038767314451, + "Yices": 9.2569494250490667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15982194022278001, + "CVC4": 8.6097890855757466, + "CVC3": 2.9211522744946561, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0215801926001964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9834569135284732 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9882345843358182, + "veriT": 1.0998084198116362, + "Yices": 3.1820427646224361, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3393395081341253, + "CVC4": 2.7740890060368182, + "CVC3": 0.18158404644245457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17780691487727274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17408832258145454 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17981905228525003, + "veriT": 5.1018695270190326, + "Yices": 9.2152529408372974, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31728434478699996, + "CVC4": 5.5616636294800195, + "CVC3": 3.6452315724468609, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4465504614724924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1956349614510025 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1850144857287765, + "veriT": 14.207108372781224, + "Yices": 1.9744569001004943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4589020131048787, + "CVC4": 8.655082282189019, + "CVC3": 2.1689325585447454, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.115800911506442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.100129965329868 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1438078705106576, + "veriT": 10.195990813406899, + "Yices": 10.351812831949498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.007659749455403, + "CVC4": 14.278517743617019, + "CVC3": 4.2066388702699866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256066526752472, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.198921968875135 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4688342338541274, + "veriT": 12.182396017343072, + "Yices": 7.8036793482716078, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3100445691356386, + "CVC4": 2.8669623292162774, + "CVC3": 5.5362643008255752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4442465555400261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.95785493987899 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2433015116050079, + "veriT": 11.288149148533371, + "Yices": 10.80364174282095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.22528258106394, + "CVC4": 6.4045987412258896, + "CVC3": 11.491360926297387, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.660760021514964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.632638955204946 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6846541665219688, + "veriT": 0.97071937445316658, + "Yices": 1.0313018459204166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9869732638007234, + "CVC4": 0.26933347549883335, + "CVC3": 0.36079434345108335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21421565309883336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20500324994291666 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25600239932338459, + "veriT": 2.5321143197162308, + "Yices": 13.20823305721542, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.38958849886507696, + "CVC4": 0.26015762601246151, + "CVC3": 1.3325074822186818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3234835560371865, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3222538839055529 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8700765053042501, + "veriT": 2.6036566193121624, + "Yices": 6.0842577125078314, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8721396341423748, + "CVC4": 10.84530593650855, + "CVC3": 2.6667392392707376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8865304918201218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9012838828803744 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16314929094706668, + "veriT": 6.833585948324294, + "Yices": 2.138714485720667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20961342095773336, + "CVC4": 0.19022702080260004, + "CVC3": 2.9794089715454697, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17675676870966667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16916632512713334 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7362590364251851, + "veriT": 11.506238352920647, + "Yices": 12.068884053800785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.377432474791412, + "CVC4": 14.47031791916505, + "CVC3": 9.8157240234905014, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244633676151276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.427983289378602 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9434740267868555, + "veriT": 11.193494288069852, + "Yices": 6.3163669858222624, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0990943713860517, + "CVC4": 11.54771945475296, + "CVC3": 2.9357247041848273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.128315482093857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.042147223141393 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6589170558238755, + "veriT": 6.1562347205217014, + "Yices": 4.3970792780900503, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.66280151298225, + "CVC4": 9.0323481741047829, + "CVC3": 0.167982379942375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.32699607866710001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5518812371114541 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5841553634118277, + "veriT": 12.831788912460798, + "Yices": 4.4824771537504748, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.099544596713185, + "CVC4": 1.3447549875052331, + "CVC3": 6.4860847772081582, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0429280627205415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1470651225317212 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8797325680620149, + "veriT": 13.159575977629656, + "Yices": 13.672988481739537, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.094138032034444, + "CVC4": 0.96432548522966655, + "CVC3": 3.6591685075416698, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6206671987120762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5804207086865287 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.155619116645, + "veriT": 3.8806313630135501, + "Yices": 3.8798776713631251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16049183043037499, + "CVC4": 5.4603179265963204, + "CVC3": 3.6746497415509332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0089712748117692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0169275476598587 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15148625858099998, + "veriT": 6.1667306731991847, + "Yices": 0.17101486260099999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16528879832914287, + "CVC4": 0.17839689508528572, + "CVC3": 0.15571599657371427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16030857658585715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1613097757487143 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.159810004324, + "veriT": 0.135808718281, + "Yices": 0.15243645019046154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16376588572400003, + "CVC4": 0.17660107122469232, + "CVC3": 0.15835056965769229, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17308722893907691, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17208132087184616 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4299337223426516, + "veriT": 11.001144076312464, + "Yices": 3.9692057224736921, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6673838192763881, + "CVC4": 3.0973190524507386, + "CVC3": 4.110350677033769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9746576966124909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1806151469052621 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6997354030609131, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2072480391996576, + "veriT": 11.035792079067855, + "Yices": 4.8448632393982862, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6218027218869597, + "CVC4": 5.6213303597861559, + "CVC3": 4.9914262707047898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.765825303993731, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.781786720354221 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.017189122430997, + "veriT": 13.55566024397738, + "Yices": 13.251530047759296, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.646128611643279, + "CVC4": 12.558066329311535, + "CVC3": 4.1276607648811012, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.082412345008846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.04603605337565 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25091946425502, + "veriT": 10.164563864567999, + "Yices": 10.305543465697655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.975740545598487, + "CVC4": 14.366760067140635, + "CVC3": 13.778447073249499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249052662217723, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.024995057506665 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.234311762550728, + "veriT": 14.220309550426821, + "Yices": 11.404536860502912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.099550406062601, + "CVC4": 14.794697798900691, + "CVC3": 12.467325283413741, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237851703671037, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.231987027601816 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 95.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 99.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2457410855366211, + "veriT": 11.894943788363884, + "Yices": 7.9225216184184282, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7782284634017658, + "CVC4": 6.5399095062887822, + "CVC3": 4.2061203505935341, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.232216729906884, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.230283273184224 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15735407914681998, + "veriT": 4.012912549771861, + "Yices": 1.5339028978972848, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.195735504103, + "CVC4": 1.5682793847268213, + "CVC3": 2.8810476107079372, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14915078859176001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13951745558652001 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.570256035260714, + "veriT": 12.908978672507779, + "Yices": 8.9187737350360816, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.977001415246233, + "CVC4": 7.6441757887785053, + "CVC3": 14.259331791958196, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4115902462884815, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6375850782633741 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 312.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9360917006288574, + "veriT": 13.026257787875931, + "Yices": 8.5158758873863611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.354542705440771, + "CVC4": 4.3414723691493684, + "CVC3": 1.9152428814233164, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.79862411272200018, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.81588314714480015 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0661503547406523, + "veriT": 11.515684902197421, + "Yices": 13.415753167055865, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.300671654076309, + "CVC4": 13.834510337628972, + "CVC3": 14.252334901865471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8888727649273775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6941681123322569 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.7187984800863334, + "veriT": 9.213588104654697, + "Yices": 4.4597985516376717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6063008571495554, + "CVC4": 3.4372357560644136, + "CVC3": 1.4560177700749997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3338250158869642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3306204410964808 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 119.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2000538688672728, + "veriT": 10.16789502245193, + "Yices": 12.993610218871659, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.262775772261216, + "CVC4": 14.495031494145888, + "CVC3": 7.0928606284533293, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4229223548139931, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8811517623149632 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 198.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2478883485114238, + "veriT": 13.549846988845458, + "Yices": 13.983776528055101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959023513103107, + "CVC4": 14.398414115436125, + "CVC3": 11.911011094288995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.034904508943329, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.009872455559025 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.252752148246028, + "veriT": 13.346787208926933, + "Yices": 14.294336039023896, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973617580031313, + "CVC4": 14.609155756901762, + "CVC3": 12.852021635694575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.858546816351129, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.259777998214613 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8821615978523762, + "veriT": 12.638416559667903, + "Yices": 12.164601813173256, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8897658340934083, + "CVC4": 12.734122617253812, + "CVC3": 8.3328747339454559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.400692171737829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.400789804439988 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0974903106689453, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.253008991293731, + "veriT": 11.651905500064391, + "Yices": 11.248908412400249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.649878856116029, + "CVC4": 11.781519718362416, + "CVC3": 11.927755443610451, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.259853202804772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.789516339092961 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.762788981146779, + "veriT": 13.946379383544562, + "Yices": 14.055620448503209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.660322995008915, + "CVC4": 14.485689546711297, + "CVC3": 13.356395257818521, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.969609259674447, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.75488356857943 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.579943537488788, + "veriT": 12.940769517502368, + "Yices": 14.2255970621686, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.18558726487487, + "CVC4": 14.313526597123307, + "CVC3": 12.299152237847515, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8725597557823548, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8161305732522113 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 87.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12534004923726089, + "veriT": 0.096187753601839135, + "Yices": 0.098740404138795645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12187963799369565, + "CVC4": 0.12548922240017391, + "CVC3": 0.1017954197697087, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12220411235095653, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11929245971852173 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11949243743347618, + "veriT": 0.090556521880833324, + "Yices": 0.095602625436080946, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11778971379981906, + "CVC4": 0.11616099938838097, + "CVC3": 0.097260750550033331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11347834835679523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1119692414811619 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6813546548648626, + "veriT": 3.28911547269806, + "Yices": 3.4418372022849377, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8988842432305617, + "CVC4": 3.6879567287685653, + "CVC3": 1.0381646576252759, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1739567356865625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0581328436512962 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20825417888247824, + "veriT": 10.163864868919564, + "Yices": 10.354723234243346, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27987780004121737, + "CVC4": 0.14775939853978262, + "CVC3": 0.66379325909700004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14968895500852172, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.457961112275088 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19360121299945454, + "veriT": 9.2498498760512735, + "Yices": 9.415993101068727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31716803924445452, + "CVC4": 0.15377161738945455, + "CVC3": 0.29256675282600003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15055386397163636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4109963318509093 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7034485340118408, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3871942476351151, + "veriT": 5.1611910420861795, + "Yices": 7.5655017324341003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.632200094608045, + "CVC4": 3.0867943914042764, + "CVC3": 4.5155226420690999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2599992867329215, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8581956533509985 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240870041876471, + "veriT": 10.157686065202615, + "Yices": 10.328876829171692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956127508846906, + "CVC4": 0.1816961800260769, + "CVC3": 10.352822088057353, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.712911075114337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.254299458086599 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.213700759460435, + "veriT": 9.5088359995522005, + "Yices": 10.598918443352439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.636802447117248, + "CVC4": 0.18830115605540002, + "CVC3": 13.307920044952853, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.154940415985, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.520857639929243 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.378916083219409, + "veriT": 11.15858075992289, + "Yices": 10.846593658660248, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.919226960862867, + "CVC4": 6.1936664486142021, + "CVC3": 14.222207394442874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6610701352118049, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.77947579303609 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.214198511596882, + "veriT": 11.502540140012329, + "Yices": 7.0503652318997494, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.952185807743097, + "CVC4": 0.24141211295966661, + "CVC3": 7.0093816712261869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.400480362707095, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.37523218326727 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2207524144569613, + "veriT": 11.502607392660154, + "Yices": 3.5362530452063332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6295484693492499, + "CVC4": 0.26496153340844447, + "CVC3": 1.9036564480557061, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.51895728669766661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4997648128175527 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3754854068066107, + "veriT": 6.0961015268811423, + "Yices": 9.3173203929616193, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9406036318912172, + "CVC4": 3.7946712149763044, + "CVC3": 5.4626081070376751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5668766906893943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6714203473671727 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.419703010567634, + "veriT": 14.230771344529099, + "Yices": 13.991365844467287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.998931028124357, + "CVC4": 14.175273405592785, + "CVC3": 13.478550964002883, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238303728509916, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.240781716918573 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.511389250856352, + "veriT": 10.482213387775786, + "Yices": 9.6514651979001513, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.124942998500847, + "CVC4": 6.2404982318244331, + "CVC3": 7.9850493091597476, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.059253919220929, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.290497765356619 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8888888359069824, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23904479053726, + "veriT": 10.185071573183899, + "Yices": 10.3240144286034, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956661265787329, + "CVC4": 0.16301751031099998, + "CVC3": 11.641769748585187, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2524514276641412, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.891983107846944 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.548757027163584, + "veriT": 10.836056444772462, + "Yices": 10.53936508763783, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.150059843702694, + "CVC4": 7.4380517929957364, + "CVC3": 12.431530129908202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3210714086532889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.938089839803013 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8452379703521729, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234753529233371, + "veriT": 11.323891302456222, + "Yices": 10.809589345679697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.055500536003734, + "CVC4": 4.3976139287959155, + "CVC3": 10.806077547081344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2012412494696534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.056262643374664 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6847269504632996, + "veriT": 11.312037787269494, + "Yices": 7.3986332794341427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.710039537786981, + "CVC4": 0.98941347599185714, + "CVC3": 8.3323526440373179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.558158919457471, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.033571837231957 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.36938833378079, + "veriT": 11.864828035380079, + "Yices": 12.197212685870525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2595456698059078, + "CVC4": 14.262453887874223, + "CVC3": 9.0802350626240074, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.052045051985083, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.724562585252086 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.963203910473782, + "veriT": 9.5649153363930726, + "Yices": 8.5658841557166863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.229589553158901, + "CVC4": 2.8644510377000452, + "CVC3": 9.0172140545004869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1295761728377567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.322901821063581 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1825793088766918, + "veriT": 7.3125925049343259, + "Yices": 6.39805589628177, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4720124580972263, + "CVC4": 1.4437129497044081, + "CVC3": 11.259733323208161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0945723034519093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1760518284810644 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1207308326238182, + "veriT": 3.8926751008024429, + "Yices": 3.942310932846441, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1453120854853092, + "CVC4": 3.9865683877843647, + "CVC3": 0.25585561311049088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1596866153497034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1662198623721993 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2289260887368281, + "veriT": 8.4645085537253983, + "Yices": 4.4172192763067857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4302176992970406, + "CVC4": 2.7560743522072584, + "CVC3": 4.4422561571510224, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.951584419811681, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3995892523693598 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9409688245023773, + "veriT": 14.22255285248438, + "Yices": 11.930814363415569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.64993190580765, + "CVC4": 11.158415231127485, + "CVC3": 7.8427544311700554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8276605108308637, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8235948372156674 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9966327423914358, + "veriT": 2.293416043417241, + "Yices": 12.900993533616791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9399790287915384, + "CVC4": 5.6427370181561312, + "CVC3": 8.3989903334725486, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5411437292246979, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5109754795369237 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4226188659667969, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2344319820404053, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0779474866159999, + "veriT": 11.118444534980691, + "Yices": 9.3023773582799976, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7924144392684331, + "CVC4": 9.849383877979685, + "CVC3": 7.154982015485583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5214194114823698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5162999160874815 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3906655385323274, + "veriT": 2.0742216244015168, + "Yices": 0.8976009756601333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6794203513580364, + "CVC4": 1.3405634502655703, + "CVC3": 1.2438860722825247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.262817333304777, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2632568101131658 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1876720471060036, + "veriT": 9.7231921853334633, + "Yices": 10.111168024920138, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5905675111404687, + "CVC4": 9.5245870065182299, + "CVC3": 10.181473974245298, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.108210330966701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.91677551592198 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1486547390587356, + "veriT": 11.127371418512137, + "Yices": 7.6963904198786253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3312883753650917, + "CVC4": 3.7446883725010078, + "CVC3": 3.6622809084171091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9187004713779121, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7269654160393788 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.29624078339011112, + "veriT": 1.3209959025061111, + "Yices": 10.824170733600113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5569314910213334, + "CVC4": 11.176879837375157, + "CVC3": 0.30081090796500004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.701158982013686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3908511327059925 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2265276011014969, + "veriT": 5.4278194707052325, + "Yices": 4.2567218289687849, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3113309001803053, + "CVC4": 2.3376033738065338, + "CVC3": 0.12614459253293847, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13422920477616926, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13347797663435385 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8603894710540771, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22697143289322222, + "veriT": 3.4607998095743784, + "Yices": 7.5232445007244833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7828681321995512, + "CVC4": 1.73130741376164, + "CVC3": 3.1240031408698892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4064076870642541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0623419468549455 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4022190228001827, + "veriT": 8.7326509368674738, + "Yices": 9.1443184508288304, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9342249857015936, + "CVC4": 11.917933704437251, + "CVC3": 9.5693666492281508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.342082680982379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.880647490816303 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14489912377607142, + "veriT": 2.5576779421466114, + "Yices": 6.7197970128461764, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14671282491092857, + "CVC4": 0.15227824858514286, + "CVC3": 0.1384335619215, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15061065510507143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14829092631899998 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9325493209268334, + "veriT": 4.5924036674868978, + "Yices": 5.3587440662846504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6783037785735004, + "CVC4": 9.159468941136895, + "CVC3": 2.2694408044491667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5377251410567183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5365446982280737 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.889111928122345, + "veriT": 11.5575819046755, + "Yices": 11.234992998652492, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1537366192006964, + "CVC4": 6.316593802834082, + "CVC3": 5.0503201093385668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.667603627680663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.188912872697742 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0625, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.062892591918688, + "veriT": 11.303765881506251, + "Yices": 10.737066109703076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.841633429314971, + "CVC4": 8.1422240905160184, + "CVC3": 9.4895944307771991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236018300831304, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.399252574587532 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.708915102770554, + "veriT": 11.073801916962594, + "Yices": 12.210019503685251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6746705324121542, + "CVC4": 8.3652132517902729, + "CVC3": 9.906641907697999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7638546722133013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7166497077043301 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3060975568591, + "veriT": 1.10969159178313, + "Yices": 12.259153825560794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7438877347199, + "CVC4": 10.112163279243719, + "CVC3": 7.4384302844398009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5678823378188151, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5639681386556272 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1076865196228027, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8534551004614359, + "veriT": 3.6640485780991665, + "Yices": 3.4828649053800831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9146614753182769, + "CVC4": 2.5023640131178686, + "CVC3": 2.4981184762645738, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3554501628839351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8879862182969411 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 86.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16950633806187498, + "veriT": 4.3781151534062133, + "Yices": 6.1297029784450219, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.38616444242030001, + "CVC4": 3.6798798237063424, + "CVC3": 0.14085397714561249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23366281094817501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.24948821642553751 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1441226645066, + "veriT": 0.12326118667150002, + "Yices": 0.1326567404541, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13996967422659998, + "CVC4": 0.1566936949826, + "CVC3": 0.1379854478684, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1542882816508, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1509598845855 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21118643274162502, + "veriT": 0.18241599002912501, + "Yices": 0.20055350994350002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24579571762524999, + "CVC4": 0.229424873146375, + "CVC3": 0.20661405529650001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.214295233679375, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20387657426524999 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1557313617337143, + "veriT": 0.12938878044387142, + "Yices": 0.14028071180628571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15577770774199998, + "CVC4": 0.17793442350942859, + "CVC3": 0.15983224502814286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16456625581200002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1604473257825714 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1736016273498535, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20225814640941667, + "veriT": 9.4677661507884512, + "Yices": 2.6921872671706666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.30651471078266668, + "CVC4": 0.31245213478508332, + "CVC3": 0.15421131194149998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6764819211145849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6737724049287377 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.739214993604806, + "veriT": 11.670818770147143, + "Yices": 5.1599939181856245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3921605143812998, + "CVC4": 4.4460469244982495, + "CVC3": 9.9484967183682222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.680948089989116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6787833968801396 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13323173114286666, + "veriT": 0.10975682588550001, + "Yices": 0.1231985472046, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.138510062676, + "CVC4": 0.14399263249899999, + "CVC3": 0.12788408006276666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14229586643826667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14068035583586666 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.0, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8202844866037426, + "veriT": 2.3373387896378222, + "Yices": 2.3425540227936672, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9366873191179814, + "CVC4": 4.9571586808668249, + "CVC3": 1.704750043426718, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5683149673458991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5723902125185321 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17249223568400002, + "veriT": 3.1940607094109996, + "Yices": 13.003249001856911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.183171186486, + "CVC4": 4.6507753768138063, + "CVC3": 8.8790734867757912, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5989238666771421, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5948110048673185 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 59.0, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1864773378616, + "veriT": 13.859596714296636, + "Yices": 8.5968181946847935, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3203007018658628, + "CVC4": 13.16332147948952, + "CVC3": 8.7596471699890728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6961449536883633, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1723329841707271 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9272541596385897, + "veriT": 8.7332549749442041, + "Yices": 6.2107185511252885, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8431110211338693, + "CVC4": 4.7216274866359704, + "CVC3": 2.5556729621351306, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6547953934217277, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8541352697959073 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0148203358037353, + "veriT": 12.42360600329701, + "Yices": 12.882868495760544, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7195850618593562, + "CVC4": 14.427629966038678, + "CVC3": 11.290672621702655, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.3609062097816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.412743286568256 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.810834527015686, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15673084061064707, + "veriT": 10.07048796431666, + "Yices": 5.4845349316879952, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28668717152747059, + "CVC4": 5.2854249987888045, + "CVC3": 5.9512112106044484, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3590649034662223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2756727752517296 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.691834931621385, + "veriT": 14.207009266315753, + "Yices": 2.2585390979852522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8543611094866925, + "CVC4": 5.1152676919898088, + "CVC3": 1.6731207939721542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.68570119477867, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.700776655013303 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 132.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6632898532345415, + "veriT": 14.224666146518782, + "Yices": 14.165233620626569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1144615854370175, + "CVC4": 5.1044496309935861, + "CVC3": 14.2048634418818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.250648232046377, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.244570409300163 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7170701779679998, + "veriT": 13.186309727753109, + "Yices": 7.1754729524612069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2288528294096288, + "CVC4": 4.8141710328761844, + "CVC3": 4.2771386300401266, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.626026468560305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.379478079487644 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1986643661099396, + "veriT": 12.771915833121165, + "Yices": 11.359991661192373, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.606107108386607, + "CVC4": 6.205983925959786, + "CVC3": 2.314895838848241, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.853880210019768, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8463040152136587 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9051255522217723, + "veriT": 14.310331232779072, + "Yices": 11.094854748417569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.174934463212319, + "CVC4": 12.275042408751084, + "CVC3": 11.444632714279622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.449029040761879, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.422560094199397 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 102.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.955375880596824, + "veriT": 10.534451996466295, + "Yices": 10.67439522708734, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977791001495083, + "CVC4": 13.793767093126144, + "CVC3": 11.759566937593261, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256566291354034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.942053450010247 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8919000625610352, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.974960084354331, + "veriT": 14.232102191602376, + "Yices": 13.651812947546023, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951486280834946, + "CVC4": 14.634444718305971, + "CVC3": 14.237373718931053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253374828011919, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.250845688862203 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.807070188700321, + "veriT": 12.44089590754526, + "Yices": 12.854151768127672, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.444387643234693, + "CVC4": 14.671454127374846, + "CVC3": 14.121649237275939, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.196021883417188, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.094665087465556 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3530274827916227, + "veriT": 12.163572005769069, + "Yices": 12.281270757975911, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.774116783285475, + "CVC4": 13.492306220048517, + "CVC3": 8.7715031280767697, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.352378521952737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.020821852412404 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1609380662932391, + "veriT": 12.293138134717267, + "Yices": 11.415481337128865, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5346523464441342, + "CVC4": 12.427430903533804, + "CVC3": 4.3224970175834576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.220380465035609, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.229908498402008 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7731596265433298, + "veriT": 10.634126850926343, + "Yices": 7.0090276471964206, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9235369102096156, + "CVC4": 1.2822936821283166, + "CVC3": 3.8695293092322194, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0085437463867231, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0089221537485318 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 202.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6900176727330538, + "veriT": 11.513306923221563, + "Yices": 10.083099083858016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2582339691433013, + "CVC4": 9.8330528586173607, + "CVC3": 11.814862806391503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3160111061506732, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8320599949058245 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 220.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2605764187412642, + "veriT": 13.561041720573153, + "Yices": 14.165770521149545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.357260952058441, + "CVC4": 9.9970730676771762, + "CVC3": 12.569074621546463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.206903107896508, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.045435464030954 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.755003234267422, + "veriT": 12.265028695555891, + "Yices": 14.347774891976085, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.383378764353326, + "CVC4": 14.583459595206907, + "CVC3": 13.354435366295135, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.858726262263311, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.910533987796104 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 322.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 199.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0892752180762244, + "veriT": 12.52440841971424, + "Yices": 12.589304902521089, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.388827122711968, + "CVC4": 14.46531862515444, + "CVC3": 13.14394042606493, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.276494330537133, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.431207367194004 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 57.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7373533850795164, + "veriT": 9.9485306272500171, + "Yices": 13.206520264052186, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.700048316730005, + "CVC4": 12.733950993439043, + "CVC3": 10.118921512614557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.73323831183268739, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.70074752795443751 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.077818673948471, + "veriT": 13.65626710534154, + "Yices": 13.703178474671493, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.803013994121281, + "CVC4": 14.536525389422106, + "CVC3": 13.689792726002107, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1196186603276139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1976693689915638 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.40997040990216, + "veriT": 13.538104533418185, + "Yices": 13.550439766738531, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973366092694386, + "CVC4": 14.496552227360375, + "CVC3": 11.708593288207275, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.79191687588982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.215775312923229 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12912706554386313, + "veriT": 0.61847413830621056, + "Yices": 0.62276563543695784, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13484311273059474, + "CVC4": 0.86547605305250819, + "CVC3": 0.099421739060784206, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.86114000220375353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.8586591781559435 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11269569379806839, + "veriT": 0.085016221183342108, + "Yices": 0.090883610569200024, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11244485625655791, + "CVC4": 0.10989849389899473, + "CVC3": 0.091022488114126318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10746231073697894, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10613364853907367 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9336721572621425, + "veriT": 1.2451631277059545, + "Yices": 2.1531861875290002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.005668381289329, + "CVC4": 1.7163664733976958, + "CVC3": 0.13448164452925554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15037424968277774, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17205865585566665 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1784778312019673, + "veriT": 10.163655834916518, + "Yices": 10.354087295912757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2746480674538161, + "CVC4": 0.1484495604535517, + "CVC3": 0.68844460913472405, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14969471792686206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.418022726009111 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19061805331349999, + "veriT": 8.1519371408430956, + "Yices": 8.2700198316877387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27349460106200002, + "CVC4": 2.0032382445398067, + "CVC3": 2.0299261419611061, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9096313355597165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3154375424200575 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8871778867022453, + "veriT": 13.125641343504931, + "Yices": 13.277163803801743, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8297143774521185, + "CVC4": 12.132073549372574, + "CVC3": 9.9696236105705047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.154698358458312, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.313301275037697 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7613635063171387, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5277780294418335, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2421550234921517, + "veriT": 4.7192895317366359, + "Yices": 7.5790782295097276, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9350365050049696, + "CVC4": 0.23406970510045452, + "CVC3": 3.1349861322318238, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9384903109991045, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.642012483307967 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241529452968766, + "veriT": 10.177773898680375, + "Yices": 10.328260821461001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958724816622327, + "CVC4": 0.25110926265924999, + "CVC3": 10.287748083978087, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6933777598251005, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.286382133652964 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241751347006947, + "veriT": 10.161167574673499, + "Yices": 10.343416301597999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964157051369767, + "CVC4": 0.15643312701416667, + "CVC3": 11.808186757300726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14758278985716666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.335215023483613 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.666675551546868, + "veriT": 11.298150753897605, + "Yices": 6.1621316152174312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4646000540670521, + "CVC4": 3.4521876968661562, + "CVC3": 5.7002731200524437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14325122297655557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.145606641560887 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0510997071298807, + "veriT": 13.058917027669034, + "Yices": 11.243410996722019, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3496245237508084, + "CVC4": 12.720206347556466, + "CVC3": 11.059712279947338, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.216397854759935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.214472774867689 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.351157459523961, + "veriT": 11.877587345898649, + "Yices": 11.647507295459064, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.913923448304734, + "CVC4": 11.786575288696067, + "CVC3": 14.225639203648271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.785286340511007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.605786101668718 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2118514672687581, + "veriT": 12.256316534746208, + "Yices": 11.072599913097051, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.138639229295881, + "CVC4": 1.9603770879471301, + "CVC3": 10.123002335271373, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4423460070438248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6174948286391242 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5213619398171252, + "veriT": 6.8643146741988552, + "Yices": 5.8280123551483634, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4749165873579706, + "CVC4": 1.4739519976527553, + "CVC3": 2.7750200169043584, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6408844065482313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3579450634772758 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9576247404704361, + "veriT": 5.8828983957818979, + "Yices": 1.1769793010772445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3460680145698705, + "CVC4": 4.8982331124694154, + "CVC3": 4.7748825323598547, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6587256741261802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6603829738596656 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14798896953057142, + "veriT": 2.2642997116031429, + "Yices": 5.4543031444701899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14356063028878571, + "CVC4": 2.1692277286773449, + "CVC3": 0.13965241427028574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1540777197867746, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.94603159610616472 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.5543987194735, + "veriT": 10.177008593632179, + "Yices": 10.379402272736998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960021237397628, + "CVC4": 2.535693199878831, + "CVC3": 9.1912923556889208, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.610080544814311, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.806362039497554 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6124479605352917, + "veriT": 11.865773054384723, + "Yices": 12.549269257210018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8739968654752488, + "CVC4": 9.9702142120631283, + "CVC3": 13.626101771665109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7666684875262098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7248795664646668 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13766484844642857, + "veriT": 0.11703774173970714, + "Yices": 5.2839632764954771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13221399296526429, + "CVC4": 3.1985427713279964, + "CVC3": 3.8884245457849427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13734820742349999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13525775252169286 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 38.0, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.509490198345228, + "veriT": 8.9179855770757506, + "Yices": 10.343907745383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.136505892469931, + "CVC4": 0.16810224909487503, + "CVC3": 11.162061698644465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9728851716933313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.337226652738778 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1606808546438891, + "veriT": 5.1523160369196663, + "Yices": 6.9724824713682478, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5637588780611544, + "CVC4": 0.64074758826933331, + "CVC3": 5.0121349349978424, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8060782090942977, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.148619607848393 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7322869112017703, + "veriT": 9.5315804642573401, + "Yices": 10.617603102852724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3446591678581923, + "CVC4": 10.314067665802888, + "CVC3": 7.2913354097494265, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.100693705157962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.439259278016908 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.415255098863772, + "veriT": 10.9706958341232, + "Yices": 8.2811988689293408, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.986883463002494, + "CVC4": 0.15649890015259998, + "CVC3": 11.916122488197246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8083925998908166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0634631425651317 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6874565319942025, + "veriT": 8.7607704108556952, + "Yices": 7.4760412366131845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9939933526465667, + "CVC4": 1.9280225520118111, + "CVC3": 10.438915622006425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.45271505117775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.655935200447443 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8786764144897461, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.46070642079342861, + "veriT": 10.202880783876463, + "Yices": 9.1127240523999546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4976680663767254, + "CVC4": 4.1557649604255715, + "CVC3": 0.29396587491571424, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.533018356640579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.627243328909458 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6386930341998687, + "veriT": 12.948219259236419, + "Yices": 12.680534771899717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5415316893906352, + "CVC4": 13.367922834360947, + "CVC3": 9.0373537396402686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.22731825783481, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.21717832548897 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1897718476419072, + "veriT": 4.9842582994068332, + "Yices": 3.6713612795236501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4751309139785889, + "CVC4": 0.20899426999683332, + "CVC3": 5.0987100369054126, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1827586214065935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5266690234926124 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8988275614888162, + "veriT": 3.4394096868194439, + "Yices": 9.4669460396581151, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1034027504951114, + "CVC4": 2.8875386196242743, + "CVC3": 1.5456287688588664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0246280382255515, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0224020011090298 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1547620296478271, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.05718994140625, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.506126434397109, + "veriT": 10.797317472758911, + "Yices": 10.287448531869156, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6853717246247419, + "CVC4": 7.3146795038500825, + "CVC3": 4.8551100518358199, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.417386850034257, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.426613807009772 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2385625037070742, + "veriT": 7.4987843790512905, + "Yices": 11.569414136813542, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6880551616506896, + "CVC4": 8.9471288291475179, + "CVC3": 6.100219308022818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254273724454253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.942038168445173 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8074592283488331, + "veriT": 5.1159045701165162, + "Yices": 8.8327924808144811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8019134961115002, + "CVC4": 4.9781412965402936, + "CVC3": 5.7708847565901671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8380156634701335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8342920421007136 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3922014109960001, + "veriT": 6.3562837666554994, + "Yices": 10.216291621491626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4127499741652501, + "CVC4": 10.21612690320514, + "CVC3": 4.239466968752728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0029757997058497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0058042029876777 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0725970954840278, + "veriT": 3.455029397957555, + "Yices": 10.646812337187297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.308910526551494, + "CVC4": 11.123578426391113, + "CVC3": 10.600650372181807, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4520026040091469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4530049936960374 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7795057277712321, + "veriT": 9.21952961982349, + "Yices": 12.792078130978199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.185125017407305, + "CVC4": 11.630209803502115, + "CVC3": 12.654560215726031, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9741776513974223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9542900086314212 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8808911115377274, + "veriT": 1.2609141845428558, + "Yices": 9.0834132270910182, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3261512609571291, + "CVC4": 1.7604197146207152, + "CVC3": 1.047850414494667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7254963226650488, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4185431624204088 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0328651352045153, + "veriT": 10.643644068309994, + "Yices": 8.7050360607756918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6998490916968922, + "CVC4": 0.65090992650761537, + "CVC3": 0.52623577330592319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5888286811850643, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.240945085021112 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.470836917689875, + "veriT": 13.698317149150121, + "Yices": 1.8786390773629202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2325468468067582, + "CVC4": 2.0359639785874766, + "CVC3": 1.5462128164897901, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9946116671242118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5624051596128226 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3846325647540296, + "veriT": 10.736285630169441, + "Yices": 10.505931203624995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.615070577490361, + "CVC4": 14.373947479137454, + "CVC3": 4.4768689943359821, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.265585406810176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.594985338425484 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15304039497192307, + "veriT": 13.127327798345968, + "Yices": 6.1892857895491362, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.37825430080346162, + "CVC4": 8.0859312175416935, + "CVC3": 5.3811194367400086, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.972723213998629, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.990510621987248 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8161266301433443, + "veriT": 13.628775220433662, + "Yices": 11.411085797133339, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.830639806200313, + "CVC4": 9.5980676138487375, + "CVC3": 9.9286862395046125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.431677012036232, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.409731943397247 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7414145469665527, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1949766885603896, + "veriT": 8.9899467275515335, + "Yices": 10.572619167246746, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.305456582473397, + "CVC4": 8.7313986410708111, + "CVC3": 7.4045141930105505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.431908254764434, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.495196110820256 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.268842975598533, + "veriT": 10.204387764982, + "Yices": 10.377090982869223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98498374623342, + "CVC4": 11.885801370018866, + "CVC3": 14.192339057729889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.26833875695859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.657207733471552 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1203738591026666, + "veriT": 8.1218941729176688, + "Yices": 7.9034403528622228, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6206840561056328, + "CVC4": 0.53480476226200002, + "CVC3": 1.546462897964, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.067467902166493, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.107029203358573 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.21539870657843, + "veriT": 8.9889796600212755, + "Yices": 8.861569645785476, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.255898169444038, + "CVC4": 9.4489270669788166, + "CVC3": 8.4569037080701133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.102827549865093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.114061179555421 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15565766879341666, + "veriT": 2.6334612529765833, + "Yices": 6.8183362153777507, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15762516487141667, + "CVC4": 4.8546933379397883, + "CVC3": 3.6670611557033497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0805996382608107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9175951261981612 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9354394674301147, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.358768074730111, + "veriT": 0.11382747552228888, + "Yices": 1.6815302389605762, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3597273697027781, + "CVC4": 0.14943751017166665, + "CVC3": 0.12064845677333334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14186508800544445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13410946220344444 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 47.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13949338221330002, + "veriT": 0.11390168021420002, + "Yices": 0.1234719619121, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13439384979790001, + "CVC4": 0.14813437074740002, + "CVC3": 0.13143463847239997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.147211263308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14766631400919999 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15087283499912499, + "veriT": 0.12985872264574999, + "Yices": 0.14003397695824998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1486264437265, + "CVC4": 0.16903567371862499, + "CVC3": 0.14637014900299999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16406866130137499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16157505314525 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15570752362749998, + "veriT": 1.8133608768180531, + "Yices": 0.14940600359512499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16377733535600003, + "CVC4": 0.17296794241712499, + "CVC3": 0.153764533859375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16711086457212498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16810371066099999 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.403648267298244, + "veriT": 2.3589784761869073, + "Yices": 2.4369293232231097, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6253885179459759, + "CVC4": 0.22304255155363639, + "CVC3": 0.2037242559608182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4846361564047457, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4814901654827766 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14980171998499997, + "veriT": 8.8849227596053684, + "Yices": 8.8733819915940497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17164047305950003, + "CVC4": 3.2234535722845434, + "CVC3": 6.2622565999694757, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.95510545901815702, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.98666980862405007 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2908059651915531, + "veriT": 11.653253291908182, + "Yices": 7.6605728446972821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.78863753860537, + "CVC4": 8.5587764957515233, + "CVC3": 7.6631441053217602, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2345951543502842, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7137958630509074 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 47.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19823649344112498, + "veriT": 7.9108916928673469, + "Yices": 8.7480687711980831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23402326024131254, + "CVC4": 10.757383312347809, + "CVC3": 3.6327012421072169, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8642411002150236, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7701804518283422 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2936104107432858, + "veriT": 4.1878568489022614, + "Yices": 3.4055384941821285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3110535093801428, + "CVC4": 12.286530155325559, + "CVC3": 1.6880280167397146, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15477219775228571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15281083030757145 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2013294696807861, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.403615022837533, + "veriT": 8.3674847022472285, + "Yices": 6.8076830909078181, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.608527096972356, + "CVC4": 5.4454032187926664, + "CVC3": 4.2113343702384514, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.213070947560032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.211583808696719 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1435956326937742, + "veriT": 7.2378706405352986, + "Yices": 11.221853596929751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3473031790591712, + "CVC4": 8.4871976270011658, + "CVC3": 11.504778421513455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2267537138783693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2291407744036968 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5089761916616669, + "veriT": 5.5078891491347672, + "Yices": 1.0127879893286669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5224075239320001, + "CVC4": 4.0281792948591821, + "CVC3": 0.17069750323833333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17797980578053335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17029976297066665 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.595339336730436, + "veriT": 11.081484222863896, + "Yices": 3.0309463962519367, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.343272079309143, + "CVC4": 1.6210865899678026, + "CVC3": 10.029498127619304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.634036860181947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.629763760224515 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.781673078473319, + "veriT": 10.846458927802216, + "Yices": 5.1072323319995983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4912986678777296, + "CVC4": 12.498072665376387, + "CVC3": 6.3094039883821056, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.022491020211444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.652256150974207 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 109.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5434771190475685, + "veriT": 13.634157677590602, + "Yices": 13.028960620324341, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.405180416568758, + "CVC4": 7.1328661379964498, + "CVC3": 8.9061924654103493, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.066126849503851, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.062068016818985 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3412610993978982, + "veriT": 8.9835076074384652, + "Yices": 6.6897866151960006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1445159470833888, + "CVC4": 4.383963527355772, + "CVC3": 0.67631308390360012, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.41424270844276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.256837732455358 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.260569446334111, + "veriT": 10.185157917821249, + "Yices": 10.376292268306999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.982687632659463, + "CVC4": 14.281512443482962, + "CVC3": 13.912908745985042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254012175349578, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.153284148648467 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4636980175614376, + "veriT": 12.594458044948077, + "Yices": 5.2216162235915675, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6505027633352718, + "CVC4": 0.91586410919525008, + "CVC3": 1.6172227960475622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4517762244531334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4628294020468455 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 112.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.294831506575628, + "veriT": 12.992596665554899, + "Yices": 12.24077865005189, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4098486881532963, + "CVC4": 14.515553561897118, + "CVC3": 8.4841424750883654, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.856586302352934, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.565853990371995 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7452534657748719, + "veriT": 9.1971122521263684, + "Yices": 3.6120303651712593, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5276235314036741, + "CVC4": 4.0103358443815091, + "CVC3": 9.0637476676304889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6406089671933806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6878372551748506 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 86.0, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 47.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242521055747574, + "veriT": 12.773372402239319, + "Yices": 13.260619858208102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957101165607174, + "CVC4": 14.341402288666675, + "CVC3": 13.531875050833426, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.139566705612152, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.202544059564781 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.962477128506046, + "veriT": 14.23019590370045, + "Yices": 11.721220750097295, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.365721516073911, + "CVC4": 12.840667016146178, + "CVC3": 14.23077023058735, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.180523079822017, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.239141912055405 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.528688851497976, + "veriT": 11.86908621688473, + "Yices": 9.5436057560829983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.026658293953059, + "CVC4": 9.6330201960862691, + "CVC3": 11.878780001611311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.55630960392992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5579658291900689 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.288019817106656, + "veriT": 10.578466972842982, + "Yices": 11.790674915216158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.719370387887055, + "CVC4": 12.099723560805096, + "CVC3": 12.986738268644904, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3962749720057959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8474544349014401 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7664296000119766, + "veriT": 13.370993666350659, + "Yices": 14.230030800903801, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0285111386927532, + "CVC4": 14.374475510441474, + "CVC3": 13.268308777730608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3327459210723323, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2338862222785592 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 106.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3988918873247318, + "veriT": 8.8403505736604568, + "Yices": 11.508494543790208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.149258372992545, + "CVC4": 14.558022993223725, + "CVC3": 7.0923331663127271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.901915078114488, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0790501757116351 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 246.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1443109512329102, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.712912924498863, + "veriT": 13.418492631860889, + "Yices": 14.241495415315972, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958518443965739, + "CVC4": 14.511924209985287, + "CVC3": 13.29739120059055, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.779822132710532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.769345537972512 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5437923838547185, + "veriT": 13.094932067332325, + "Yices": 14.253764358911557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7173558727337905, + "CVC4": 14.409483879316918, + "CVC3": 11.6824408816665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241514177840084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.931148580507012 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7139334143553349, + "veriT": 14.237854126074257, + "Yices": 14.24161456127411, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.846211102737211, + "CVC4": 9.0959616733585165, + "CVC3": 13.716811869951448, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3135574284557281, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.33710213985111 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 341.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26156279883538, + "veriT": 10.628297422641344, + "Yices": 12.405327024003268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.978285187116001, + "CVC4": 14.565744439347419, + "CVC3": 14.105836318646091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.76716340198689, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.598403692873946 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248384053584166, + "veriT": 14.238632765844315, + "Yices": 14.239180082830421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.67353620859403, + "CVC4": 14.740834097903408, + "CVC3": 12.221969311942088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.202504817075615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.025229664398724 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11393222808224997, + "veriT": 0.6363675084954612, + "Yices": 0.63969561390890561, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12288730200912222, + "CVC4": 0.88666778594366424, + "CVC3": 0.086049817525294447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.88529149746346225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.88547287247075712 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12242014767500002, + "veriT": 0.090811686711468428, + "Yices": 0.096660989780757905, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12080896309294735, + "CVC4": 0.11983207009426317, + "CVC3": 0.098079387063905274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.117714806706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11615388025706315 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.3666665554046631, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.251579866302201, + "veriT": 9.4599524151158185, + "Yices": 10.799573097947311, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.528100154391559, + "CVC4": 5.5618850624556222, + "CVC3": 8.925035095273385, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8034053887349977, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.200347709189284 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0409517839607645, + "veriT": 6.1726910332655249, + "Yices": 8.7727783312897554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7416928091522856, + "CVC4": 6.5031926173942862, + "CVC3": 3.6407869741597145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1811035409935204, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3971452678704219 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7333334684371948, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.729510605737946, + "veriT": 10.666718402130352, + "Yices": 10.51039783386225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.353056405671786, + "CVC4": 2.0117815259390808, + "CVC3": 11.015505536102745, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.905062641813954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.995655174874461 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.780971896754487, + "veriT": 10.431803704292209, + "Yices": 10.299071431290665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.418176328934461, + "CVC4": 1.2705059401745, + "CVC3": 8.9922091394895336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0422192257345344, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.937668440156575 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.49732896228042, + "veriT": 8.9130331072968758, + "Yices": 10.33342184832525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.128630651983933, + "CVC4": 0.17330885085475001, + "CVC3": 12.454994265209166, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.402024700434673, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.273879961765534 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.702136916583308, + "veriT": 8.8870389313027491, + "Yices": 10.262378043172372, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.091463012985901, + "CVC4": 6.0414583063251737, + "CVC3": 11.633821936056222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1339268583061948, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2230570634534654 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0714285373687744, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7159655120341579, + "veriT": 6.5056507441338303, + "Yices": 10.29952083193109, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3389114281265684, + "CVC4": 12.84351819241483, + "CVC3": 6.7234395856368847, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.484713841997811, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2443058738273667 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8865500174444634, + "veriT": 14.221314314743601, + "Yices": 12.634651530081571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3401518038952656, + "CVC4": 13.336183262159075, + "CVC3": 11.919517780009551, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.713893970892967, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.769807609128563 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.980471793755198, + "veriT": 12.188442268184684, + "Yices": 12.683442758359526, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.416464159203494, + "CVC4": 7.3228795529856932, + "CVC3": 13.948578725762236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5254506989053853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8019060325060394 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241587873920707, + "veriT": 10.159866389014287, + "Yices": 10.333743828791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956621341724722, + "CVC4": 0.16672244021314286, + "CVC3": 13.75733223597428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7647483879614649, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.372445868298556 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.918026601017919, + "veriT": 11.791640490568112, + "Yices": 11.992836369669034, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.924963088124123, + "CVC4": 2.9487991960345465, + "CVC3": 9.8915032525553688, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.099205620601495, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.249245828767496 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.856216949389667, + "veriT": 13.87201799963294, + "Yices": 3.8066916304199698, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0577080104445891, + "CVC4": 3.1022146712074012, + "CVC3": 2.7594136030746932, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.839566418814215, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.542274599483157 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8289194107055664, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4361836333404678, + "veriT": 1.4257962967934557, + "Yices": 1.4689571089794458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4947485701504661, + "CVC4": 1.5680175110845733, + "CVC3": 1.4620072751738791, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5105909343455002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5015285814888117 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.44019765161688, + "veriT": 5.7677995177502712, + "Yices": 6.9554838440015789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0679648083199993, + "CVC4": 5.5374039495684322, + "CVC3": 4.4014007559019657, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9723423065466026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9728921731498534 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15633907113518183, + "veriT": 0.19150923696310002, + "Yices": 7.9101556547667906, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17302455878209091, + "CVC4": 8.065639547415957, + "CVC3": 8.0988974855467202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0208604243811585, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0191595458757332 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3043672765636529, + "veriT": 12.546139055686744, + "Yices": 8.4724180054638385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6911102565916298, + "CVC4": 10.616193945128913, + "CVC3": 8.9233705713492828, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.581116563537849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.607612777796994 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5504873516652715, + "veriT": 9.4431384050625429, + "Yices": 5.9280346086276188, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3752096762005257, + "CVC4": 0.3294427846723077, + "CVC3": 6.0330181801105747, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9648104485400015, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4431394493951561 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6041902638923125, + "veriT": 14.202845957351169, + "Yices": 5.6781745867138573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6003161803494015, + "CVC4": 8.6208549994539645, + "CVC3": 4.6589791357729213, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.973643937538872, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.985835553129343 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.380952000617981, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.6804343513846145, + "veriT": 8.0851320214123099, + "Yices": 8.5870502708401268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.73562947116665267, + "CVC4": 0.14967623970979313, + "CVC3": 0.53593421108496553, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15061057811772416, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3549643116285282 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7000000476837158, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5634925365447998, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7745163751054633, + "veriT": 4.1365853734782405, + "Yices": 4.2066172148047203, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.062900646951151, + "CVC4": 0.14596536892699999, + "CVC3": 5.2250140035343682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14337644367659999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6838966575187531 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239995552062847, + "veriT": 10.472860132020228, + "Yices": 9.5430659652635352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.592319634349241, + "CVC4": 0.15486667503653845, + "CVC3": 10.545380549838116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0058283744032679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.456491309452097 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.746828340505576, + "veriT": 12.163162007761034, + "Yices": 8.6263758457648461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.587387984180912, + "CVC4": 7.3939122214909005, + "CVC3": 11.394250058799981, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5270834765173671, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.912936800035096 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2900844840863332, + "veriT": 1.7143915702948596, + "Yices": 7.7078670756826666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2771539731841111, + "CVC4": 1.7445055625451156, + "CVC3": 1.3089943978875553, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4161647910695541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0767115757566188 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2786831972726169, + "veriT": 10.185412946904858, + "Yices": 10.305557218399858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.711970110498809, + "CVC4": 9.2339820793144973, + "CVC3": 9.3682005324240833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.259793085422652, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.18960362248149 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3798074722290039, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.851422347739614, + "veriT": 13.76326242646935, + "Yices": 12.288338736209344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.726963695505187, + "CVC4": 13.225552349264108, + "CVC3": 10.754307362984633, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.08456592745843, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.136855824961255 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1369580885734649, + "veriT": 6.603148297646718, + "Yices": 6.8804259167040565, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1882628862059215, + "CVC4": 2.5198459161729843, + "CVC3": 2.4452848779372096, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2782545509704841, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.156686452226841 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2661865249019248, + "veriT": 8.2955427979354699, + "Yices": 10.19641784642211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.55427545627591, + "CVC4": 8.9162406733989119, + "CVC3": 9.1309317409858295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.575379533437683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.019239358226361 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21181729218562501, + "veriT": 7.6413920439328251, + "Yices": 8.9366380946701369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1652655173973754, + "CVC4": 5.4455664231053289, + "CVC3": 1.9751236221943993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.90957384860587, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2404908139118387 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13102088467515385, + "veriT": 6.1124568060741478, + "Yices": 5.3499257821128632, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12772695446153845, + "CVC4": 1.2227584158187323, + "CVC3": 0.1333723021352308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13017903888576926, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13073687766623079 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9606187854669093, + "veriT": 2.87067291764069, + "Yices": 0.13555913442150908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5265416507934546, + "CVC4": 0.13610595735954545, + "CVC3": 0.14423223369543636, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.125760957772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12442762824909091 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4880811469340309, + "veriT": 3.4529866810996492, + "Yices": 10.500486791185162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6077911093734722, + "CVC4": 2.6336662152935264, + "CVC3": 1.8106538619456665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1513947081415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15113721013254999 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1618192054535772, + "veriT": 3.025475216455157, + "Yices": 4.6389147719086719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.653136069217624, + "CVC4": 0.20233620940428573, + "CVC3": 0.21386499289944286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9613362647123103, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5518960547476199 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0065580169297865, + "veriT": 9.6165593652657257, + "Yices": 8.7879611956151926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2083565213014236, + "CVC4": 10.279933222256435, + "CVC3": 10.715889598976577, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.037819830057336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7448338320755425 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2611505855442224, + "veriT": 1.6851795992687826, + "Yices": 6.9525142005325158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3318952284098886, + "CVC4": 8.0004763935442575, + "CVC3": 6.2193147072405441, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9872488474298757, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9914405207525538 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3940614929436577, + "veriT": 3.4753461002803006, + "Yices": 13.438498460886837, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9815230617975992, + "CVC4": 1.6112864030454439, + "CVC3": 4.5744582704885719, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3777663734799592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5092052174628403 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1310860961332185, + "veriT": 9.8774903478875586, + "Yices": 8.8509536523771128, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0773067631081963, + "CVC4": 11.117166382858866, + "CVC3": 5.0750146003389505, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.43657823169411, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.435072389854664 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.032051134838571, + "veriT": 10.940194326846111, + "Yices": 10.740537422939077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.987892212773167, + "CVC4": 12.731262764075925, + "CVC3": 12.6299249188184, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.14746577891426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.144852887490032 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0710785388946533, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1323495930442, + "veriT": 2.0992875047892801, + "Yices": 2.1002983400032003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1496855061264002, + "CVC4": 4.9440538225585895, + "CVC3": 2.5589487345849635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9455444022909596, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9408585227476842 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18086557505505554, + "veriT": 0.71755738556405546, + "Yices": 1.8379362975359446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.99829647778702091, + "CVC4": 0.19611673566561114, + "CVC3": 0.17938815170827777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18576831808266667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18346070938283332 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9989160299301147, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.11725409665, + "veriT": 2.9210748003629612, + "Yices": 0.09521913258829999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1562200019578803, + "CVC4": 5.7872636405041149, + "CVC3": 0.10853959521049998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14171702282367998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13891887359210001 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7163316576986252, + "veriT": 10.805142380967265, + "Yices": 5.818582155921125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9863629385612498, + "CVC4": 5.7407305399218824, + "CVC3": 3.0343986008019996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7504814027765345, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.714357507965845 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4526882680606952, + "veriT": 6.7762898544210382, + "Yices": 6.9354544064888097, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6796802795126988, + "CVC4": 0.16923622470573638, + "CVC3": 2.0423735202526361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0687586044453949, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0959023375297159 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18129113477920003, + "veriT": 6.2111986433663233, + "Yices": 12.191383596018117, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19867813120899999, + "CVC4": 1.6318915330215849, + "CVC3": 9.799985834741495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6116556756133424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6080423336962184 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7451639839951447, + "veriT": 12.382742605767838, + "Yices": 6.1064969265499593, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2347655793939785, + "CVC4": 12.11801035044887, + "CVC3": 10.725372593894868, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.196199609707264, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.755428750082338 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.564482109548647, + "veriT": 8.6100289316773022, + "Yices": 4.5653705593570901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.641536247862323, + "CVC4": 12.95861283743605, + "CVC3": 2.2997597706455997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17026236439439998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1668337952758 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.89801062701490009, + "veriT": 8.2302371324889521, + "Yices": 4.9283044651601919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8613526091149337, + "CVC4": 14.510498442102211, + "CVC3": 4.2072544298919068, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1926358306998965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1900328146297596 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16568047725624999, + "veriT": 2.6426079038573498, + "Yices": 7.7231535916794254, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17100925686524998, + "CVC4": 7.2501896229605265, + "CVC3": 0.17084840479675001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.51016543264184999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9626811343622834 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5740002380235616, + "veriT": 12.188390950466232, + "Yices": 13.123452831140407, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.071983792416642, + "CVC4": 12.052356836551015, + "CVC3": 9.7406160114337048, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.65535097791355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.683416378699128 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7613635063171387, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.51369882650021, + "veriT": 11.410763872293545, + "Yices": 7.3190502406497684, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.645571620207022, + "CVC4": 4.5716861678422722, + "CVC3": 10.763536735585861, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.387496168844088, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.51458065117694 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 66.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.35078661531266664, + "veriT": 11.081382822914362, + "Yices": 9.3150991267171115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2747694067824447, + "CVC4": 11.136503837027501, + "CVC3": 3.259743249781796, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.122245575568297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7100835018291161 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1100573539733887, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.465254865004767, + "veriT": 13.477833439716459, + "Yices": 14.582943693245522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7828422278496496, + "CVC4": 8.1978574356598113, + "CVC3": 13.662086229135618, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249058731932145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.241210295459586 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4671593201192312, + "veriT": 10.618166231625825, + "Yices": 10.91797069509774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9197682393510771, + "CVC4": 14.772872773519868, + "CVC3": 12.470210065370564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.840301181945405, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.8085868821309 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17514466947583332, + "veriT": 5.8534193112878548, + "Yices": 4.8290990792998256, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8656429714186664, + "CVC4": 5.0244618958023519, + "CVC3": 7.3173500868709995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7711778922541654, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6489393188973347 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.467223422421772, + "veriT": 10.349036398022575, + "Yices": 8.0395886100695062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8786315277173333, + "CVC4": 3.8546809923854259, + "CVC3": 1.7419626285597272, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0159710804075042, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0131809729455661 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 54.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.162936561413, + "veriT": 1.9036040999610793, + "Yices": 0.1616998244190625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16929059784175002, + "CVC4": 0.1897613041261875, + "CVC3": 0.16771844652037501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1720401341785, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17457037603937497 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2376527888188189, + "veriT": 10.914782397953859, + "Yices": 9.1592982608076401, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.66277928256142, + "CVC4": 9.8934980088535767, + "CVC3": 8.5151149064502896, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.435202423076408, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9541572917897758 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 38.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14801517692757146, + "veriT": 0.13177186934442858, + "Yices": 0.14072521028857143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14983999247785715, + "CVC4": 0.16755725496428572, + "CVC3": 0.14951974990399999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16740149929057144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16262860259357143 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15943879133210001, + "veriT": 0.13502183528999998, + "Yices": 0.15392336934979997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16260202455930001, + "CVC4": 0.17591719751090001, + "CVC3": 0.15814851339379998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16877300317289998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1727909246995 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.849794286243391, + "veriT": 11.784545525990977, + "Yices": 11.059296263075771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.482943707553313, + "CVC4": 14.612953015645695, + "CVC3": 13.743621384101479, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.071231212680274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.777695984227037 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.37412634678457135, + "veriT": 11.95018578976403, + "Yices": 7.2135432693569728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8376537558560111, + "CVC4": 4.3048190577040604, + "CVC3": 4.7558879135414829, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.908972767785631, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.910863268381121 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235111411809934, + "veriT": 11.303168897902127, + "Yices": 11.974427389794362, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95128681608935, + "CVC4": 13.094575855295391, + "CVC3": 12.049586918851402, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236745784603428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.038544549052984 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.579526351401122, + "veriT": 14.215348375501977, + "Yices": 13.087740425985416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8156174383471022, + "CVC4": 9.2798617142633084, + "CVC3": 7.3547885206397234, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.09074103381961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.058702375590443 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 106.0, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 72.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8901819525721146, + "veriT": 12.7001072312421, + "Yices": 10.570720651188498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7422356029012711, + "CVC4": 4.0333984396018483, + "CVC3": 1.8747197742535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7474626329050995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7478852807552192 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7103426454500212, + "veriT": 12.768649434374067, + "Yices": 8.7214053758208383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.952818348547988, + "CVC4": 12.65505684835456, + "CVC3": 11.72772650727809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7024730313228122, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.49513058056511 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6303913897972859, + "veriT": 7.3273060141126729, + "Yices": 3.6542387918094814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.665567759856593, + "CVC4": 0.25362802839112503, + "CVC3": 1.2759229028694374, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18275351690281252, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18263398664637501 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 176.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7077643640653788, + "veriT": 11.482091289599847, + "Yices": 4.3728477299253727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0628598225654047, + "CVC4": 4.053688732095666, + "CVC3": 10.742457215252651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9391595692974393, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9308666868777948 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.64879217419666657, + "veriT": 7.7841174720599708, + "Yices": 11.449138245123427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1425935312458453, + "CVC4": 11.33238946862827, + "CVC3": 6.3407617071215236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19022729528349999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1575116173301121 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.677064812507695, + "veriT": 14.236012001494675, + "Yices": 14.216026795863566, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.091350977193894, + "CVC4": 14.554334877346861, + "CVC3": 14.106396309335857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8424579508537642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7483938942169139 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.395022124908804, + "veriT": 12.759485277623368, + "Yices": 12.468313744140794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.637047167161795, + "CVC4": 13.110454861967035, + "CVC3": 11.999936529574164, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.776704169574707, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.210075543040459 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.646160520391433, + "veriT": 12.855426610173007, + "Yices": 12.860698967543017, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.985653385286147, + "CVC4": 14.474006887737453, + "CVC3": 11.579850632344369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5570440372160981, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7708187591985398 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2714222955030543, + "veriT": 9.7017576399497667, + "Yices": 10.208755198148044, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8237219198638748, + "CVC4": 9.0516447117626111, + "CVC3": 8.8412625424800986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.476762060825143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.23685722835495 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 168.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 100.5, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.391625659176233, + "veriT": 11.364195294887537, + "Yices": 12.0407780019284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974365314989825, + "CVC4": 14.507622569848445, + "CVC3": 14.102039227740091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.091106215234902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.840414673333123 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4129788509358372, + "veriT": 14.234070167996274, + "Yices": 14.236854317719711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.724166875459343, + "CVC4": 11.756331376707116, + "CVC3": 11.495890821436433, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3967570997874716, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8613335745062667 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "false": 154, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 436.0, + "true": 151 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "false": 153, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 152 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249566738064594, + "veriT": 10.702244568689816, + "Yices": 12.140740453320005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967691724905059, + "CVC4": 14.44957288097474, + "CVC3": 13.832070951521448, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.820337265856265, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.902104784930824 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.365120010904254, + "veriT": 14.235966645219289, + "Yices": 13.755065715000541, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.2241262012377, + "CVC4": 14.432819581092815, + "CVC3": 13.777367815179096, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.026008046270334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.045796040929304 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.18589295608356, + "veriT": 14.245275289778744, + "Yices": 14.088997496888798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.054173060783567, + "CVC4": 15.00296229152743, + "CVC3": 10.355378666926182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.109128025417789, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.544998865328491 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11988823262492858, + "veriT": 0.091084107653939275, + "Yices": 0.095084883427364306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11684502533607145, + "CVC4": 0.12029804176032145, + "CVC3": 0.096818328304067863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11786967805625001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11475467161104287 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11950457553095555, + "veriT": 0.090602756611161114, + "Yices": 0.096675238997377788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11879896709064444, + "CVC4": 0.11623179008115556, + "CVC3": 0.098791859100355539, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1138872540208222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11356187904112776 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5401842668069285, + "veriT": 1.1165938358888792, + "Yices": 0.91708403445112019, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6088101028242949, + "CVC4": 1.5414905376223262, + "CVC3": 0.11455251758339999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13993184038619999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13894899920050002 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9554945703933306, + "veriT": 2.1201916173518001, + "Yices": 4.1945882330127997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0951467213936406, + "CVC4": 0.14477373964879997, + "CVC3": 2.9488356315121425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13908442012700001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9840826800229481 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.646344506757213, + "veriT": 9.8492283842185646, + "Yices": 10.393084827212093, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.74481942520059141, + "CVC4": 0.14963302022978123, + "CVC3": 0.65121856715178128, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14973002634890623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.066841240108143 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19203803098900002, + "veriT": 8.9059968500582496, + "Yices": 9.0637652994903739, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31866062497775, + "CVC4": 0.15369903393537501, + "CVC3": 0.29687988676075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15087087916612499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3664113676010001 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7029409408569336, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.442470557255974, + "veriT": 8.9244011040678686, + "Yices": 8.9947469847717318, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8520542308301637, + "CVC4": 5.6964683500920232, + "CVC3": 6.7612405826541684, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5390110110438346, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.553196390510367 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.455527253434285, + "veriT": 10.426779202082654, + "Yices": 10.416480105967, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.627334173234244, + "CVC4": 1.1489633322389765, + "CVC3": 10.346583309616989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0813750994049756, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.634741244355217 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236743409678846, + "veriT": 10.145543020241124, + "Yices": 10.32013216067625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951258648324739, + "CVC4": 0.16276276465137496, + "CVC3": 13.205266368965558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.588093134355282, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.408783321292727 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241182553621837, + "veriT": 10.149107991706199, + "Yices": 10.324695672385499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960273835584298, + "CVC4": 0.15948927202440003, + "CVC3": 12.262614734479319, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5051148991799672, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.387605835466903 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0664904648173668, + "veriT": 10.319286132113183, + "Yices": 10.894484076540358, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5771393814053951, + "CVC4": 5.0192954252646755, + "CVC3": 8.9481607974710524, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9884138238726297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3991851427024313 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7933729229980717, + "veriT": 5.0970252906427129, + "Yices": 5.870663240531778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9140479983415841, + "CVC4": 0.27430206850211114, + "CVC3": 1.8341731390383726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6844874545871136, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.735417836359277 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6202295647222087, + "veriT": 9.9552918646650035, + "Yices": 9.6593985280707884, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3882668716768567, + "CVC4": 3.9093812346276922, + "CVC3": 11.506726293365528, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.705129154071489, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.90422147621357 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.22934873767861, + "veriT": 13.761261919307501, + "Yices": 13.256778765285157, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.263359762131634, + "CVC4": 11.865732150937568, + "CVC3": 14.243142318390133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.852130612663917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.849861205396348 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1802631899605789, + "veriT": 10.928609831409204, + "Yices": 12.943495147083874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4559469429394198, + "CVC4": 9.7986754779069649, + "CVC3": 9.2837718259361406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.468966832028816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.077362233768831 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.625, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.188832084184135, + "veriT": 10.620578237270871, + "Yices": 10.453908352509501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951689743592686, + "CVC4": 1.9224635073419736, + "CVC3": 13.319134134364269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5263531555423144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.383819675054225 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.554366706725586, + "veriT": 10.534206282953063, + "Yices": 10.340936045496163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.153415687822195, + "CVC4": 6.6386570585690938, + "CVC3": 11.760745780102861, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.319036749268899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.937664301486121 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5858455136975382, + "veriT": 9.5993562863405639, + "Yices": 7.8349697703622558, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2245379672711039, + "CVC4": 7.6640518557122856, + "CVC3": 3.7075875808618184, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8865614639183761, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9249693347063532 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8166664838790894, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.502139085813129, + "veriT": 8.9158453224406244, + "Yices": 10.336108120579, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.135712763153268, + "CVC4": 0.166622303701875, + "CVC3": 11.166376959271947, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.399919979629885, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.309111308290568 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.526750799164549, + "veriT": 9.8416707341676197, + "Yices": 10.27724338069288, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.875240840412607, + "CVC4": 0.15572505631933334, + "CVC3": 8.3247604145969429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5365673692682851, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.31339467314019 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245998729053701, + "veriT": 10.163625917520099, + "Yices": 10.3469593326853, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962105875337476, + "CVC4": 0.1602710838527, + "CVC3": 15.309716809691759, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.573181192852541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.391303486145343 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.287352403062693, + "veriT": 13.245285386865403, + "Yices": 12.479342451595615, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0497588681724075, + "CVC4": 9.8037912208668381, + "CVC3": 8.890749914329259, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8441215757935288, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.844519877945908 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0157076355980443, + "veriT": 10.373559859384507, + "Yices": 9.479015553512518, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9455071098511665, + "CVC4": 8.5030419320445603, + "CVC3": 7.6987787499300362, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3212099591989199, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3477593595436375 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8959801717841149, + "veriT": 1.3704927771054627, + "Yices": 1.3926013019799874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9822076314049468, + "CVC4": 0.14028596595624998, + "CVC3": 0.25667905683852499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14084569154912499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5404576778712034 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8610756932117498, + "veriT": 9.0037717204001186, + "Yices": 12.45640103680096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0043351427301248, + "CVC4": 12.972875717029424, + "CVC3": 10.470338774434101, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.717869950022353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.70811609995503 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4493622856664281, + "veriT": 14.225179958481357, + "Yices": 11.019008415473479, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.314266103376452, + "CVC4": 10.417801077293928, + "CVC3": 6.8430884839360573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.658990504667992, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.703583992999128 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5094315783839596, + "veriT": 3.4964069598683256, + "Yices": 3.6916294676536663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6887753866680413, + "CVC4": 0.22144063018691665, + "CVC3": 7.3348453486767147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1759626644869261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7779876453597816 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.772899102242266, + "veriT": 11.900945542171979, + "Yices": 11.99040903301888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8309423031148269, + "CVC4": 11.254242749552661, + "CVC3": 8.0672385646189166, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.556550625389031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.331305467073168 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8516485691070557, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234925414797729, + "veriT": 10.826498999722622, + "Yices": 10.453894392746383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957913095493899, + "CVC4": 2.6536077132666942, + "CVC3": 14.232548484221702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8411195274529701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.329633195261062 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7850360011435797, + "veriT": 5.1211397537197252, + "Yices": 5.8120572438442437, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3378717233808404, + "CVC4": 0.17411495568141666, + "CVC3": 2.6358245675799168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3668677780496736, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3671448291931796 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3691716820104851, + "veriT": 10.206971081670334, + "Yices": 10.360161865569667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.526300750356375, + "CVC4": 14.283490780453484, + "CVC3": 6.2508051836374738, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253617689092389, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.226459110437988 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3798074722290039, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9444444179534912, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9321541066281096, + "veriT": 9.0574747885698841, + "Yices": 10.398137431259771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3289025221046726, + "CVC4": 4.1711373492575659, + "CVC3": 0.32727240580627276, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7813033808083327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0189431054093268 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.097221851348877, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14442722511563635, + "veriT": 0.47993889190884542, + "Yices": 2.669119298222324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.61978683082776354, + "CVC4": 0.1468470146700909, + "CVC3": 0.1387439109708182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12870546315054543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12710348682399999 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13135195265971428, + "veriT": 4.9720740457599089, + "Yices": 9.0042854239707761, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13002555736928573, + "CVC4": 2.1558184720595031, + "CVC3": 0.12654403179857146, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13391122065328573, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13348603923985716 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16904916831566666, + "veriT": 3.4879072795855555, + "Yices": 7.3271411279056684, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17564223110877777, + "CVC4": 0.18545645995944446, + "CVC3": 0.18172148901400004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15842033336466665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16062841787755555 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2060563903504997, + "veriT": 8.166435338200781, + "Yices": 9.6628647296873318, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1867217343604954, + "CVC4": 5.9533929537119352, + "CVC3": 2.2539898211777993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1280356648983436, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0540491610591673 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6249331167949919, + "veriT": 6.2885974899101402, + "Yices": 6.5176680448001791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6910050890510302, + "CVC4": 0.55680972642079996, + "CVC3": 2.4604003734151396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9923900404524342, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6312793906700769 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.780548840114317, + "veriT": 10.118773224161625, + "Yices": 10.115639468289013, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5747771649514437, + "CVC4": 7.5262426937690723, + "CVC3": 1.9472928849126487, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.510229934673577, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.53564553677835 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.105555534362793, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5465600672221211, + "veriT": 4.5342861505149195, + "Yices": 7.5187149640124415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6577218893368511, + "CVC4": 0.28735943173939998, + "CVC3": 0.36269439867629993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9847819785453353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3838007909147994 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7905674273200338, + "veriT": 9.1960964935285254, + "Yices": 11.952297826034187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0794786556950466, + "CVC4": 13.061927497406888, + "CVC3": 12.409351571429861, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8251235464543782, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5662240894745905 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5366179663021251, + "veriT": 1.909155724283673, + "Yices": 12.098332684878187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.808216856654125, + "CVC4": 3.2031825014086945, + "CVC3": 5.5295106305322506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9393620510943137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9348387636813431 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0621557148030001, + "veriT": 2.0684482584550188, + "Yices": 1.0433409169981998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4368717759160439, + "CVC4": 9.0694864780963158, + "CVC3": 0.18047242209228753, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7915833749341608, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7887405812854502 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.174165763986613, + "veriT": 11.053532759657815, + "Yices": 12.215768114944041, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6267149360960627, + "CVC4": 9.512813146126943, + "CVC3": 7.2468628694716521, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9397797186623826, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.117271636299844 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.137790838857, + "veriT": 11.083115575132442, + "Yices": 4.8423732340717791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16032474369266667, + "CVC4": 4.8611450108540364, + "CVC3": 4.8191261755539649, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8903964051945259, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8769201332201888 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1602482020812, + "veriT": 14.202303488997226, + "Yices": 0.1179941413513, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31885546013499999, + "CVC4": 4.6010862350727511, + "CVC3": 0.13652184379150001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.833610292202255, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.855071170279592 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7841994762420654, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.38929473801238451, + "veriT": 10.795807203946767, + "Yices": 9.1846996927495592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8744817733895998, + "CVC4": 10.132942302391537, + "CVC3": 8.6764676422883991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2682849674032708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1776526789670463 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8771369457244873, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0739607326042764, + "veriT": 13.626576614172077, + "Yices": 6.6817653300243007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2885198811527134, + "CVC4": 0.39716306171085708, + "CVC3": 6.3900687629744608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.208472857316456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.211481150232686 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6463510876735001, + "veriT": 14.226603950856246, + "Yices": 13.472928573531561, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5048064871229707, + "CVC4": 9.7515831502502106, + "CVC3": 10.973314758478701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.070733386484163, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.070341707706845 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 122.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6558509451911112, + "veriT": 0.14025384862744442, + "Yices": 3.2639732990800456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.029644032017778, + "CVC4": 0.17335304093188889, + "CVC3": 0.17265410765933334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17408401777444446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17354311288933333 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14095761184141667, + "veriT": 0.11100510643458333, + "Yices": 0.12565453062000001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13537781910566668, + "CVC4": 0.15098332118816668, + "CVC3": 0.133876609285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1488547651809167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15223659178683333 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16995061410691667, + "veriT": 0.15241886269750002, + "Yices": 0.16213701281649998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17498755158583335, + "CVC4": 0.1909374106723333, + "CVC3": 0.17581146055874999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18102901671325, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18028872762058334 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.70230270527416661, + "veriT": 5.892770752304604, + "Yices": 1.2462092459731331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.71364520778222218, + "CVC4": 1.7412367616136484, + "CVC3": 0.41668338539027777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1533488074669889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15561362952816665 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1562421241951997, + "veriT": 10.081929030393713, + "Yices": 10.1043724034578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.57082075749849, + "CVC4": 4.399809659858513, + "CVC3": 7.540418382351386, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9607559473626015, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.512208214589112 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0417367763172503, + "veriT": 3.9056075247858004, + "Yices": 3.9733188302882749, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.149734809107728, + "CVC4": 9.0256010577257992, + "CVC3": 0.17271004154979999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.744204330763508, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7193882208423847 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0061530832935262, + "veriT": 2.132555834575069, + "Yices": 0.98260679968245712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1129183998597254, + "CVC4": 8.3055539835507037, + "CVC3": 1.8518140878000346, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.95274345477845002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.98495573995552144 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9131831778024524, + "veriT": 4.7202004016836705, + "Yices": 10.279113615451211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7856505093103472, + "CVC4": 5.9122483065465854, + "CVC3": 7.8388473470920506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4575699164855775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4390287416788627 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7116848970202305, + "veriT": 12.422052841716203, + "Yices": 9.1170158490523221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9777753640175781, + "CVC4": 12.808989894305261, + "CVC3": 12.396185530289156, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.200940383592686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.450468732728762 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0339004993438721, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 145.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1013086000248022, + "veriT": 13.547088438880275, + "Yices": 8.4772118649424826, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.059350379701602, + "CVC4": 7.9006717752206113, + "CVC3": 7.1554303093815177, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.21808044103107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.241657837406118 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.329513396916164, + "veriT": 13.629696278154466, + "Yices": 12.880555961738391, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.827968334509832, + "CVC4": 14.47007233934762, + "CVC3": 9.8231672800990193, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.326749333358638, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.288357329763821 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 134.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237114376940179, + "veriT": 12.219749159788606, + "Yices": 12.652280393514021, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950747652096586, + "CVC4": 10.744117275548687, + "CVC3": 7.0270318233345153, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234568873423823, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.466600318902884 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.927959736714765, + "veriT": 12.229746096839767, + "Yices": 11.019518980827183, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.498292397593321, + "CVC4": 14.520013505064906, + "CVC3": 12.917182263411553, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.269658434608647, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.86689823432024 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25465948808279, + "veriT": 10.200979442935923, + "Yices": 10.376180708745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.990175346959793, + "CVC4": 14.284061789095762, + "CVC3": 14.264558412696356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254679678725722, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.077424475913874 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.610730408662131, + "veriT": 12.054805925826123, + "Yices": 8.0267693243994298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2830393709227579, + "CVC4": 8.2370954033303754, + "CVC3": 10.70701419815359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0143019523234234, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9563668658984117 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.28555490935709998, + "veriT": 10.600993562348787, + "Yices": 10.93886595372398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9767521806750539, + "CVC4": 10.175641648119029, + "CVC3": 5.3520538505898996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9183235591887016, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9117536701089879 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.080533504486084, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5526034375973854, + "veriT": 12.523633366308406, + "Yices": 13.863887934560529, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7228552276820999, + "CVC4": 10.544335601501309, + "CVC3": 1.9367927851891702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2711411412757494, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3107554969167003 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19757728360845456, + "veriT": 1.9907178161486181, + "Yices": 4.6253047257839057, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.93122377071145468, + "CVC4": 4.0055298660384571, + "CVC3": 2.7805404462540499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14194129601881819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1381724759091818 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0463594403713588, + "veriT": 12.316677567043364, + "Yices": 6.6744927004930581, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4382169160064073, + "CVC4": 5.1326766194601117, + "CVC3": 7.9337159602121385, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6895340781904244, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7182862674138728 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.089245837848933, + "veriT": 10.462720151501808, + "Yices": 10.542554092645783, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.498202718769065, + "CVC4": 12.324879776731779, + "CVC3": 11.009801123891537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.3943365990628, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.577427922112786 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 58.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.772081872643282, + "veriT": 13.759031069881193, + "Yices": 12.720537259669769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.946709435692046, + "CVC4": 14.050441843676182, + "CVC3": 14.220265516158449, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8774766974928241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7936085048230321 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3505660631015708, + "veriT": 14.257522076772107, + "Yices": 12.336142576582814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.178144084033965, + "CVC4": 13.167054021923219, + "CVC3": 14.13128301272932, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0799390105812714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9894092316783265 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 106.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.21562900965304, + "veriT": 8.6448906215588952, + "Yices": 11.654786865126363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.804176403743474, + "CVC4": 14.483494856173948, + "CVC3": 7.4122045829242404, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7212509315318378, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9068891112769686 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1443109512329102, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.291380330587552, + "veriT": 11.560668584150056, + "Yices": 12.266437616541433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.12074004044784, + "CVC4": 14.651063388433634, + "CVC3": 13.984465192688555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.067048469347837, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.558423891069062 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.334601800495542, + "veriT": 13.729659176468772, + "Yices": 13.921042198389712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.390676151230434, + "CVC4": 14.564735752312108, + "CVC3": 11.631913769523443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255421455314963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.25160357773667 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.83606482848794, + "veriT": 11.003581103623819, + "Yices": 11.629976811152266, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.733000706601752, + "CVC4": 13.697683767516743, + "CVC3": 14.091778498061245, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256722066951195, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.867937690895133 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.969549871451319, + "veriT": 14.239244903557843, + "Yices": 14.241462967098524, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.645723619806111, + "CVC4": 13.454283458029778, + "CVC3": 10.142798204355541, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7960476618488581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5766272795558418 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.263391427463615, + "veriT": 13.893776228020943, + "Yices": 13.937368707203776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977212011280615, + "CVC4": 14.800266070311435, + "CVC3": 14.111229941067323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.794129119450355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.196268417355503 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.875, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12065384930184997, + "veriT": 0.091313572768404988, + "Yices": 0.093576394541210001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11825790702515002, + "CVC4": 0.1206863504653, + "CVC3": 0.096245518089159987, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11855525429609999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11546481195185002 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1076843432268095, + "veriT": 0.079737720903690454, + "Yices": 0.08459636020317618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10744203428517617, + "CVC4": 0.10260848715261904, + "CVC3": 0.085175726413633357, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1026556188871095, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10149669702340477 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8473170075511183, + "veriT": 0.81575684949659999, + "Yices": 1.5515994893021572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8942144849263709, + "CVC4": 0.13336379733171427, + "CVC3": 1.1144452206447082, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12486012610814286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.14706973461541 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.96147744470773133, + "veriT": 9.3484874471786767, + "Yices": 9.8304485913812556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0625214932978557, + "CVC4": 0.14853044091572978, + "CVC3": 0.62065599277737826, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14756327226910815, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6587974052182499 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1180553436279297, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8607079984673565, + "veriT": 7.1923637651037033, + "Yices": 7.8204895469571625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2321798072135586, + "CVC4": 4.2878671652891773, + "CVC3": 7.6706116219132836, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8441754074721493, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5453583300526539 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8759242414652748, + "veriT": 9.7473709284071397, + "Yices": 11.938788751247731, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9685185957735554, + "CVC4": 11.912521972593526, + "CVC3": 8.1764029425928655, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.074936307481165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.119574816270417 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2700591660722724, + "veriT": 1.2245018256189382, + "Yices": 3.8773661716550234, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1198964928897777, + "CVC4": 3.4696790097078694, + "CVC3": 1.2599336355799371, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4068866038486507, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2562785603133995 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.246000731983502, + "veriT": 10.181210935591, + "Yices": 10.347955225373335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967054825718229, + "CVC4": 0.15518580564566667, + "CVC3": 10.682243593046834, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15355938854316667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.370039814640288 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0791105979394739, + "veriT": 10.160230662846667, + "Yices": 10.302881180901833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.088904215055244, + "CVC4": 0.1860916246555, + "CVC3": 7.7712745280353657, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1491862520485, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.183155105743682 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23927919538531, + "veriT": 10.151337405008267, + "Yices": 10.326249442086132, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957445017858827, + "CVC4": 0.1776603342038667, + "CVC3": 11.881229710464046, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6600668242866601, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.315184587730544 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249779862447003, + "veriT": 10.181492387858183, + "Yices": 10.359003295926454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97061486531115, + "CVC4": 0.16983644570381817, + "CVC3": 14.256419828746953, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15731279785818181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.369875758331199 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235277051025616, + "veriT": 10.156801727088, + "Yices": 10.3158664596519, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.946902496561515, + "CVC4": 0.16718537848609999, + "CVC3": 12.911572201920842, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.036697669472648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.160004295433556 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.341064799713418, + "veriT": 9.576751910351744, + "Yices": 9.5767906294495013, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.802646581051066, + "CVC4": 6.4693269822689254, + "CVC3": 11.339177725883559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.804289530542468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.591157405890717 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0015429909736335, + "veriT": 7.9590195182652979, + "Yices": 7.4358905852235226, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3693015217670634, + "CVC4": 7.0412426453098966, + "CVC3": 4.904982469766769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4374348987119543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4445789081273883 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241660636507723, + "veriT": 10.157001852228555, + "Yices": 10.334548398580669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956265917489983, + "CVC4": 0.15973695737677776, + "CVC3": 14.386702077496937, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8621110057718324, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.320395894953073 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8373259066979504, + "veriT": 10.867584777776896, + "Yices": 11.671417924488413, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0725124223161835, + "CVC4": 6.9248970986898311, + "CVC3": 12.910657232028555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5567165326153214, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5832782138420294 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.246079577222028, + "veriT": 10.165110423526901, + "Yices": 10.344462174390699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963837116841271, + "CVC4": 0.1676092763714, + "CVC3": 13.112011031284549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17894584386990001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.37226373432701 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8819444179534912, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.810972212645074, + "veriT": 8.999680644590045, + "Yices": 10.389161681962097, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8868132623660987, + "CVC4": 1.7980817568663998, + "CVC3": 7.2222304182610264, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9428164630313898, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3935494604316219 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5823461641657142, + "veriT": 8.6988259399530232, + "Yices": 10.286461151334541, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1067730388484769, + "CVC4": 11.159626938658691, + "CVC3": 9.8073763662750917, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238714915680449, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.452059033752965 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1609732668437776, + "veriT": 10.004368561991109, + "Yices": 3.6248571555114211, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6504355087568623, + "CVC4": 4.4456900850882111, + "CVC3": 4.3611523972689223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3690521163941352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3689774700126183 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8368399222366811, + "veriT": 10.116908452829778, + "Yices": 10.113489468864332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6107257385030103, + "CVC4": 4.9436186827180144, + "CVC3": 0.90095625113133337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238463132096891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.23030136271106 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.045974281960419, + "veriT": 10.1016144244091, + "Yices": 10.104798429023523, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.326425667368289, + "CVC4": 7.3461506766482803, + "CVC3": 3.2034471154188129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.260997450447055, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.297878454826806 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13207266046963637, + "veriT": 1.9278886315769455, + "Yices": 9.2635605894343929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12919927484727275, + "CVC4": 4.1821054869724614, + "CVC3": 3.7779802303363637, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13800480236300003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12838731418472726 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8112791793586667, + "veriT": 2.4816683462122802, + "Yices": 0.26816889350683332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8679233982465, + "CVC4": 0.2146498479075, + "CVC3": 0.15132279856749997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8803340742819774, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8780130651858071 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5251084621015227, + "veriT": 9.4220478905534595, + "Yices": 13.059662772310931, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.00377630206656, + "CVC4": 2.3231141461656666, + "CVC3": 9.5290249896688248, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.63670068774737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1360567511653041 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0642224055589322, + "veriT": 11.713963781543267, + "Yices": 11.068218011704014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.898852682521046, + "CVC4": 7.8682396575609648, + "CVC3": 10.049002541550276, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7035396668811238, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.069602814449981 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8249391546187361, + "veriT": 4.6355373248976797, + "Yices": 9.3043501196283191, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9434879490746644, + "CVC4": 6.0305616092757717, + "CVC3": 4.1512037436789226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2175600404673022, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2212242219125491 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8285713195800781, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4921863932980703, + "veriT": 1.8015105651998919, + "Yices": 4.3316893453035581, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6120009713482872, + "CVC4": 0.15261466954625, + "CVC3": 0.31487578529626664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15388646430908334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0206379145148792 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6982489859478, + "veriT": 5.9539025243030057, + "Yices": 6.9882959516540399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9788349109002841, + "CVC4": 3.9074203170811446, + "CVC3": 5.4833901129398335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1949623909017948, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.189800849261256 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1515389655090198, + "veriT": 7.7948314275798767, + "Yices": 5.1872378446762006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1407719347272001, + "CVC4": 2.9768561425999112, + "CVC3": 4.2197339375198997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17109881116980002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16866964127103998 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2613635063171387, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.132214852647, + "veriT": 4.3910662796561857, + "Yices": 10.435307719469018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13170558837457141, + "CVC4": 0.13808339851042858, + "CVC3": 0.12861341298857143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13303841895657142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13384547869299998 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19392522149199998, + "veriT": 0.16907314940708332, + "Yices": 3.5037178794211505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1952834593345, + "CVC4": 0.19416061060500001, + "CVC3": 0.17783791001128332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18290019043766667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18622927915716667 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9790600010793331, + "veriT": 5.0080303071621728, + "Yices": 11.950152401390474, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8897917301809999, + "CVC4": 8.9578583597061474, + "CVC3": 10.718164242192946, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7988562592155084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7936736633161967 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1324467785082497, + "veriT": 8.9142912827768761, + "Yices": 12.748011293189927, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1725781416616252, + "CVC4": 12.855287867336974, + "CVC3": 11.439179624367346, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1638011551987155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1616963568894203 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.518548125660262, + "veriT": 12.40055706514398, + "Yices": 6.4668339860368347, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.495926673229294, + "CVC4": 9.0616643539547841, + "CVC3": 13.81759778353719, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.1970342286952, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.191620341039327 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0101353287937502, + "veriT": 4.950434174404287, + "Yices": 7.4087961872483676, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3287921551912767, + "CVC4": 6.4376519841437689, + "CVC3": 2.2594601744468341, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.557108436109802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8790837413729209 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.027778148651123, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6933335065841675, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25083496965975, + "veriT": 7.4433878845933537, + "Yices": 2.737437364134625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.44736864992737507, + "CVC4": 0.18293773174499997, + "CVC3": 0.29627216116162508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8750842435174633, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.468734215876376 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9184849108428983, + "veriT": 8.3840335607272163, + "Yices": 10.350640273588835, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2729249110034981, + "CVC4": 1.8479972806536544, + "CVC3": 3.7491094224466557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.215226372219, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1513010027956128 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16219867283511114, + "veriT": 3.2587589656781124, + "Yices": 3.6005699856298516, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23650686573311111, + "CVC4": 1.7352746013702052, + "CVC3": 1.7196374301225017, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15724547008844447, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6609699830486235 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.888940554555445, + "veriT": 11.056668456941608, + "Yices": 8.050883999001778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.628252755342904, + "CVC4": 1.9653614684612708, + "CVC3": 4.1695845395048288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8347347661464934, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.914024796318913 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.28794936881004546, + "veriT": 10.70482287913447, + "Yices": 6.031358863502291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5007117462444486, + "CVC4": 1.4306133333109508, + "CVC3": 1.4114559648863922, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4131049301534622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1637667826488478 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2381943386351999, + "veriT": 8.0084226847560185, + "Yices": 6.6666592041118973, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7860470730237479, + "CVC4": 11.667930823697327, + "CVC3": 1.6086209303918921, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8131334640379098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7031495038778424 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9392000077815146, + "veriT": 9.5715540107297645, + "Yices": 9.4654719690968783, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4839072450956117, + "CVC4": 10.3736438549605, + "CVC3": 7.712414657466466, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.722708605475995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.45244008509561 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.85952250343135717, + "veriT": 13.20071028622699, + "Yices": 0.11451375024685716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.9413810911151429, + "CVC4": 2.2677702262299055, + "CVC3": 0.12143609353042858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.032545487538751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.028773732828595 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21709342549318178, + "veriT": 13.473833523984137, + "Yices": 7.094225541287293, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5892199833409153, + "CVC4": 6.7727633203026363, + "CVC3": 10.15859372496778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.814787200078877, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.49489286182008 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6903519302149119, + "veriT": 14.217483498963562, + "Yices": 13.654430269623873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0766260501498399, + "CVC4": 8.129159009268939, + "CVC3": 14.196932032100369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.236542513671809, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.233964624510632 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7024634348575693, + "veriT": 12.649860906728964, + "Yices": 7.7087959899716294, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.251363982671668, + "CVC4": 6.6758336218190442, + "CVC3": 1.9570712451430288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.172715811690157, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1758832564077348 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14384530418618749, + "veriT": 0.11824814813437501, + "Yices": 0.1253086265703125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.139418078872625, + "CVC4": 0.15005394319831253, + "CVC3": 0.1310700637244375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14974219502149999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14874618070868748 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16570384345476924, + "veriT": 0.15194737489492308, + "Yices": 0.158896122753, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16109747807223079, + "CVC4": 0.1848545099666154, + "CVC3": 0.16748061337646153, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17170834283853847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17176895229753847 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14879326902066667, + "veriT": 6.960422035173905, + "Yices": 0.14632791820783334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15838328876733335, + "CVC4": 0.17441299827366666, + "CVC3": 0.14719625611933332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16201932662883334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15803864651033331 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17074811255162503, + "veriT": 0.15210474590500001, + "Yices": 0.16467193776174999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17845871706400002, + "CVC4": 0.18992940874599998, + "CVC3": 0.17303790552037498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17928788120462499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18211174727312499 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5803151932971478, + "veriT": 6.5460287654958691, + "Yices": 6.58888743128868, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9913854761456746, + "CVC4": 2.5643437697857023, + "CVC3": 2.5510111246812737, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5501232622312258, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0618133166987991 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.98025634017930008, + "veriT": 5.1183209157623004, + "Yices": 5.1973959676492489, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.99477346226259178, + "CVC4": 3.675378892576072, + "CVC3": 1.0080289392697332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5633981356674123, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5951064672074162 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6647745076884881, + "veriT": 7.2406736834187999, + "Yices": 5.7180645444671399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6141107386848272, + "CVC4": 5.6684020081586945, + "CVC3": 6.6177307723031511, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6609030239655889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.188615530301532 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 174.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1094164848327637, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.56826708813985705, + "veriT": 6.5053814277247186, + "Yices": 11.960142043815395, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7954356588593621, + "CVC4": 4.2456491780114174, + "CVC3": 6.2289814173057172, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0678440156456883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6579444241276371 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9893839363237253, + "veriT": 8.1864026684340256, + "Yices": 11.291785920433549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3208012242496636, + "CVC4": 9.6559917850776014, + "CVC3": 12.499128745898874, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.310280040927118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.566180977003857 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22625055817892728, + "veriT": 5.5768010466244995, + "Yices": 4.8611526469027018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0576969138462091, + "CVC4": 13.09344147933052, + "CVC3": 8.0133697981891867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.287024537500387, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1688410061121468 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.92627439265499989, + "veriT": 12.964394804695957, + "Yices": 9.1341091298722041, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.613612273492242, + "CVC4": 1.1394429324676363, + "CVC3": 0.4102964988802727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3463449469963638, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2690592603498185 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2412297070372293, + "veriT": 13.95440073727039, + "Yices": 9.1080692324562449, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5479463696007274, + "CVC4": 10.057133953449759, + "CVC3": 4.6193438776176725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.003973186582988, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.968034317618374 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.518306697102666, + "veriT": 13.75405552938285, + "Yices": 12.19321421732525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957637402936356, + "CVC4": 14.395426846476925, + "CVC3": 13.005142294260789, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.270376974775889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.915799069257353 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9363416060409024, + "veriT": 14.211096053575776, + "Yices": 13.772549404775413, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.624892579157708, + "CVC4": 14.27368070471422, + "CVC3": 12.923544112505212, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.847893469972144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.850070354076468 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.869686667112228, + "veriT": 10.193478199323199, + "Yices": 10.751476341762285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.504503687688668, + "CVC4": 14.278703663778511, + "CVC3": 14.195030596021928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246718396897004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.262284628008805 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5487476767077961, + "veriT": 8.1927620620548751, + "Yices": 7.6976948254097257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6926282503590517, + "CVC4": 9.7039117108516724, + "CVC3": 9.5536874483641778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2311465928562804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6150223016083753 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 76.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0510801173786999, + "veriT": 11.614171763350042, + "Yices": 3.2158542789123801, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2235074673931976, + "CVC4": 0.26955929845259996, + "CVC3": 1.0293744513459999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20206416700760005, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19811339258270003 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9062586815272105, + "veriT": 12.413005049455753, + "Yices": 9.2855497410435266, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.576956054634314, + "CVC4": 2.7052438636651113, + "CVC3": 1.6269585070206667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.777289015611351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8253583745364876 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2739414050668749, + "veriT": 11.081798312909672, + "Yices": 11.740196698099387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3504875746190304, + "CVC4": 12.150978296139328, + "CVC3": 6.4604626904221982, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2309799648312989, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2620234560512165 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.740783249870365, + "veriT": 12.191095234605932, + "Yices": 12.700622983573606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.247322420829281, + "CVC4": 12.656072280027807, + "CVC3": 11.090047103734729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.107092311515835, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.032738202459216 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7397859411967498, + "veriT": 12.544328281390115, + "Yices": 14.23903971462742, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6334005119085635, + "CVC4": 14.768462390453632, + "CVC3": 12.429862677042488, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.36058775494337503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21346389566749999 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3791443904225869, + "veriT": 12.420535769411341, + "Yices": 9.57421456666229, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.316971041835139, + "CVC4": 8.9374820061997511, + "CVC3": 14.237584874001998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5465483893342373, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3356802652927593 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 52.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1784543991088867, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 95.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.699615667856413, + "veriT": 11.288644009750504, + "Yices": 10.768913891269577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.981716910891723, + "CVC4": 12.984609897445953, + "CVC3": 9.8164823693979244, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.616585200940436, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.447599524172348 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.169801698560095, + "veriT": 10.957261583198886, + "Yices": 12.451130862636925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.981678500579166, + "CVC4": 14.549934930675386, + "CVC3": 12.934907342239434, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.885830473616942, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.916109287485638 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.900549121566483, + "veriT": 14.240785891392999, + "Yices": 14.091799912842042, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960973811756197, + "CVC4": 14.647134534954136, + "CVC3": 14.247491941271011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.074189463740096, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.085004944706917 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 104.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8981938699158101, + "veriT": 14.237244930227005, + "Yices": 14.10588738529502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2029858067843318, + "CVC4": 14.366594933942016, + "CVC3": 10.785477857145999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.790445859201805, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.699763320819777 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.160368412274593, + "veriT": 13.094033795470429, + "Yices": 14.243625254484291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972631878267348, + "CVC4": 14.696821906409417, + "CVC3": 11.788338778819789, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257826157210051, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.257303814660503 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 359.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2764896166208795, + "veriT": 12.186467749178941, + "Yices": 12.699070396981275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2821580595736997, + "CVC4": 14.384593520687911, + "CVC3": 11.927329816893248, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7928810745317616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2735564755957709 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.256836389207551, + "veriT": 13.88056917302926, + "Yices": 13.747782519695733, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.436333528685914, + "CVC4": 13.621978019783018, + "CVC3": 9.4820493537408552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.209515459146132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.486159018451996 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11974461532225554, + "veriT": 0.64119555956039453, + "Yices": 0.64498215701353334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13027488427470002, + "CVC4": 0.8934078179778755, + "CVC3": 0.092587672002355556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.88993147180515109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.89046063681623489 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12479110254107693, + "veriT": 0.099133762756446142, + "Yices": 0.0986132095742, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12224217863569233, + "CVC4": 0.12399852125296154, + "CVC3": 0.10313839429023076, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12197611168053847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12111728105338461 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6503597137978572, + "veriT": 0.95584398890857403, + "Yices": 0.78886352465849996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6992871962056624, + "CVC4": 1.3235479072306051, + "CVC3": 0.12546765402088333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14450747243174997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15298213765983334 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5536501292431844, + "veriT": 5.9546962856295238, + "Yices": 6.039920141814445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8754402007609334, + "CVC4": 1.4939473489621322, + "CVC3": 5.3740339977426901, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4235458444348845, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3175023657767948 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20891041697192306, + "veriT": 10.16582436983459, + "Yices": 10.355690570149692, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26256038557053846, + "CVC4": 0.14859201073517944, + "CVC3": 0.69629175679843591, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.149885006869, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.436774732317252 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18148344188184615, + "veriT": 7.0710743656933834, + "Yices": 8.9591467396534608, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31629435506453846, + "CVC4": 0.1520952406233077, + "CVC3": 0.25496794894353847, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14938090462146153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0462315072732449 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 89.0, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8148568271330934, + "veriT": 11.463091697748828, + "Yices": 11.94566449598817, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9742074501911979, + "CVC4": 12.949486678591313, + "CVC3": 8.7852731829039019, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.404647908783479, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.962160666250831 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6452077621151071, + "veriT": 2.5938030111003751, + "Yices": 2.5969133121532497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8245004785110321, + "CVC4": 0.36805749094524998, + "CVC3": 0.11219112718749999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6511097897532063, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6424527785823475 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8400299254101915, + "veriT": 6.5843270426419718, + "Yices": 9.4093542875841294, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8584711463096255, + "CVC4": 1.6431699179484169, + "CVC3": 4.1001656804067528, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5676378219724607, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.489162594565183 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8285715579986572, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4079771891146233, + "veriT": 6.5212361337091815, + "Yices": 10.58801659674609, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7368436352451297, + "CVC4": 5.3984713743800823, + "CVC3": 8.4122374959486894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.450776377423777, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8107622521155928 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.820979879009414, + "veriT": 10.816303649494028, + "Yices": 9.4132572825033822, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.467431691375765, + "CVC4": 7.4384820984119884, + "CVC3": 12.101493067516884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3030816202473812, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.624078045190215 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.943628853574202, + "veriT": 10.181945186929557, + "Yices": 10.326730935725443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959741030529788, + "CVC4": 1.3523702234675556, + "CVC3": 8.5916873943113785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.120544596663013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.620632543027002 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3278175945464872, + "veriT": 6.4924990120718027, + "Yices": 7.1889345560119073, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8200878992204066, + "CVC4": 4.1906569215436322, + "CVC3": 3.20955405316827, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4972529861024424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3635533720360273 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2601157167677579, + "veriT": 8.3715541137150122, + "Yices": 8.0798586174917553, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4794705803469608, + "CVC4": 3.222084206206429, + "CVC3": 8.0025027776492283, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1753070666712908, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9145957266499618 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17021015746512502, + "veriT": 4.4453836707571615, + "Yices": 1.9115897301279396, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.88303539787875, + "CVC4": 5.6460393993527305, + "CVC3": 0.24034614021875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0919675188691738, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0930907929064171 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1744217277755995, + "veriT": 6.3950602963939458, + "Yices": 13.250311827146168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1732857039104201, + "CVC4": 11.635404593912694, + "CVC3": 12.291799982833009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.29597209998024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3118673085972059 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240468347243784, + "veriT": 10.159766734733401, + "Yices": 10.338867591330802, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957619567286747, + "CVC4": 0.16443046078246668, + "CVC3": 11.682886124387052, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16535566830359999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.691373580310357 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.357568784914379, + "veriT": 8.8188996317180681, + "Yices": 8.9570273915642655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.979165527815159, + "CVC4": 0.20413257980253335, + "CVC3": 10.631067512098902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3608084678444214, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7461121314674539 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.4692075800311, + "veriT": 9.9285801185851952, + "Yices": 10.027562347383281, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.095356545807251, + "CVC4": 3.9681331069554808, + "CVC3": 10.839740083222944, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1163791246907397, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.703658799091102 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3848985803926253, + "veriT": 12.092108619588043, + "Yices": 7.6833530605069456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5937184751070159, + "CVC4": 4.4246589236014326, + "CVC3": 10.09487273885502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8242191965050623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.218540887840545 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234466636314835, + "veriT": 11.407675386290199, + "Yices": 11.272524742246166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950774332826064, + "CVC4": 1.9007696026856149, + "CVC3": 12.583748078957724, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2089789499589818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.187125936453482 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7393452065144288, + "veriT": 8.9587380686427949, + "Yices": 10.557129916322769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1277888335022777, + "CVC4": 0.27604695986923078, + "CVC3": 10.233519172817179, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5035572263262782, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3089200095142548 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3914041060069051, + "veriT": 6.2826103139439136, + "Yices": 10.173256738632281, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5472081555119184, + "CVC4": 1.8579452215114705, + "CVC3": 4.4608672207698641, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.414895052195706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4139618518171098 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9790446494126952, + "veriT": 10.388671303835117, + "Yices": 9.8570084861638154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7752181606763671, + "CVC4": 12.241644107142665, + "CVC3": 10.834277667131765, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.224984886813685, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.226561732756643 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.14756413368489, + "veriT": 13.110840480219487, + "Yices": 11.232993143677099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.072285925693045, + "CVC4": 14.558246842348201, + "CVC3": 12.331843131355567, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.120588137821057, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.118555344946754 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9630898579262883, + "veriT": 5.6026005893661797, + "Yices": 10.885932611012656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3752191972801571, + "CVC4": 1.695711332281221, + "CVC3": 7.9097827734411865, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8032942307725532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2084192902030768 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.497059195059855, + "veriT": 12.664966905537741, + "Yices": 12.179595706162218, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.142249245006084, + "CVC4": 11.258216061834386, + "CVC3": 12.296412198084418, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.166170847838602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.198153822252557 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7829410378272712, + "veriT": 8.4591003394922488, + "Yices": 8.462744985808639, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.053363593997476, + "CVC4": 1.6246243830840637, + "CVC3": 4.335272672445714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4642462441249757, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6678492313962447 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 53.0, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1237019262868002, + "veriT": 14.209547997983753, + "Yices": 4.319380025875514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1237133506799999, + "CVC4": 3.9637716971483554, + "CVC3": 3.9244627273880797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0537299270291083, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0411013869612979 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.76012356105268752, + "veriT": 14.209492123327284, + "Yices": 1.0874099627858125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1016871077775403, + "CVC4": 1.0976763683667168, + "CVC3": 0.36532654045312501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.707562964922708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.74708234703458 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9588566890477996, + "veriT": 13.12450639791307, + "Yices": 3.8461244560509815, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1933926565333426, + "CVC4": 3.1504333355962992, + "CVC3": 3.5716528247667938, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.64323729021792, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1762860130717439 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8982585601778519, + "veriT": 14.216988537111275, + "Yices": 12.735457204883284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6876517373243463, + "CVC4": 11.565293838316551, + "CVC3": 11.070204297837686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.222682513174362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.225206855349903 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8170514106750488, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.690052480040379, + "veriT": 12.179852979060033, + "Yices": 6.476846328482976, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.552475362878138, + "CVC4": 1.5901493832326647, + "CVC3": 8.618895041040151, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5469979172733019, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4724672313647176 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7895668020521969, + "veriT": 11.920595472525552, + "Yices": 5.960035671320143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.687501890625795, + "CVC4": 4.2789039765049806, + "CVC3": 10.648136768137336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.789443037141385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.382394776425686 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3446737219334166, + "veriT": 10.808678538785069, + "Yices": 13.195757283919894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8558030201397457, + "CVC4": 13.109799028301529, + "CVC3": 10.392851434854053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.068826420989092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.558032596818796 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.856704383238695, + "veriT": 11.866354592002367, + "Yices": 10.134769569992471, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.714285880178378, + "CVC4": 6.9028424243392505, + "CVC3": 10.993418347367646, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.217344655724835, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.899962258330419 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.280280193316553, + "veriT": 10.814477740316464, + "Yices": 10.97217696847113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.993409715194005, + "CVC4": 14.416079644781473, + "CVC3": 12.555821631206433, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.281844559240767, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.799463641680108 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1079545021057129, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7137674824608653, + "veriT": 7.7495326828043751, + "Yices": 9.2934436205323738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0303925709948416, + "CVC4": 5.5292350520489162, + "CVC3": 0.24298957872437499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7629099441590146, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7854173791658798 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13652563651889998, + "veriT": 10.023558703645811, + "Yices": 9.923789943044925, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2249291475629, + "CVC4": 1.7162100009311518, + "CVC3": 0.13282884662819999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5261458877913678, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5432635806544277 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17313233718787502, + "veriT": 1.398442076509675, + "Yices": 6.1739381247224303, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17487327910487499, + "CVC4": 0.17636756454687502, + "CVC3": 0.16624853240455001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16565657296550002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.169154451152875 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7933322581945035, + "veriT": 5.2489547217845001, + "Yices": 11.027010551023338, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.953660102554883, + "CVC4": 10.937524805796416, + "CVC3": 7.1202242515680725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.451186960486634, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.451237506765015 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15711246517914287, + "veriT": 4.2945499543662908, + "Yices": 3.3245219037622999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34366770278157144, + "CVC4": 0.16076647545957143, + "CVC3": 0.13659081809214285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14441733926428571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13978310910185715 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9883592678410071, + "veriT": 8.8655037980315861, + "Yices": 8.8546202446164877, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6686602141947686, + "CVC4": 10.382206401218108, + "CVC3": 5.5038606493050173, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.466730967485585, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.458332639051259 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4365093571077807, + "veriT": 4.9813253521222496, + "Yices": 7.5744600700037141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5378767624880556, + "CVC4": 7.6306596607057937, + "CVC3": 4.2162621475871376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1828335637160139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1800629933281694 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14846895272680002, + "veriT": 4.7554234132083435, + "Yices": 0.23616982433300002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16053229699819999, + "CVC4": 0.16230896416180002, + "CVC3": 0.13815748601360001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15120847019520001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1508953093214 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8605853966946633, + "veriT": 11.3017352741794, + "Yices": 10.249631151577303, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0086976058885915, + "CVC4": 14.500064704189896, + "CVC3": 4.2015727786835422, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2003426308360163, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0782526508473831 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0178570747375488, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.8973416391145691, + "veriT": 0.10788110970098463, + "Yices": 2.2753646731173207, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.89551534695664614, + "CVC4": 7.7435842881990204, + "CVC3": 0.11845065925521538, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13139136254793846, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12987902923841538 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1775209903717041, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.150664213386, + "veriT": 7.1746490312422333, + "Yices": 0.16860580764787497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16336495309962501, + "CVC4": 0.16990272456262501, + "CVC3": 0.15145328814087497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15542698895075002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.155181715735 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15158476888657144, + "veriT": 0.1338559272766143, + "Yices": 0.1437693034782857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15210697182515714, + "CVC4": 0.17761408289911426, + "CVC3": 0.15081465235514285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16767347046187142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1666000002780714 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1101400852203369, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9556100368499756, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.498830788866818, + "veriT": 0.98130496471858342, + "Yices": 0.99154062823699995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5605848426555475, + "CVC4": 4.9161778090467365, + "CVC3": 1.3296049684679521, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3392062589887319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1054479577855378 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.38355659437744438, + "veriT": 2.6285502630330004, + "Yices": 11.158028540360105, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1638313038147776, + "CVC4": 0.25587722822300002, + "CVC3": 0.33779814279844439, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23920314112422222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.23697831467966665 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1279320252097273, + "veriT": 7.5838435713611574, + "Yices": 3.7430438873296357, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12347876455892726, + "CVC4": 0.14646013545752726, + "CVC3": 0.12215969456981818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.25746631513136364, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.28107002172009088 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7305429579057356, + "veriT": 9.8527996712180688, + "Yices": 9.697362093947639, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0645906527572486, + "CVC4": 9.5815415755305242, + "CVC3": 0.30261606315955558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2454054476841111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20751197435188889 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 91.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.214495560084484, + "veriT": 6.4664838334587387, + "Yices": 7.0755022416803426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5279057644005158, + "CVC4": 2.3035427368207055, + "CVC3": 3.6686121765087836, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.486410698128398, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9280554814947077 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.92011399038177, + "veriT": 11.465963723353093, + "Yices": 11.488907248190868, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.232490081021263, + "CVC4": 13.105180665151655, + "CVC3": 11.268484170145291, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3293076800671049, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6644855254171844 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20515000846831999, + "veriT": 8.1705541985335692, + "Yices": 0.87336846472636009, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0193284142868, + "CVC4": 0.20606506029419996, + "CVC3": 2.946231103536038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15813102948116001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15741848102972 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0254974972805107, + "veriT": 4.5519287725699034, + "Yices": 11.910153329585226, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.969942688634069, + "CVC4": 10.219250159635532, + "CVC3": 9.2324463166618163, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3722837337934788, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3588491377247616 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1313191824703157, + "veriT": 10.191070689794666, + "Yices": 10.339324295979001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8228180452792184, + "CVC4": 14.265441987467236, + "CVC3": 6.6069583873938962, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.248546987670416, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.890402487338919 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9628061841335005, + "veriT": 12.45128316102315, + "Yices": 6.795457704197351, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6303936903176259, + "CVC4": 6.2500170209650419, + "CVC3": 2.0920778968024658, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7212046824113454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6565164258525673 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 48.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.970716377461518, + "veriT": 12.868567983669307, + "Yices": 11.747072413768773, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.615538070287142, + "CVC4": 11.368363958568738, + "CVC3": 11.728908566122632, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.01811403093879, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.929157256298314 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4491489164444, + "veriT": 7.3682094242086817, + "Yices": 7.3738699362025057, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6927738011870073, + "CVC4": 0.36189085231059998, + "CVC3": 3.2301107665542999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3991292444144712, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3982912507126724 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6043646994504313, + "veriT": 14.219118674599134, + "Yices": 12.7554593497073, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.939675668904158, + "CVC4": 14.667256983289239, + "CVC3": 14.213675446996309, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.718468236676316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.716485064614782 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8403772860367571, + "veriT": 13.006875872171998, + "Yices": 13.157084154273434, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5572492416578019, + "CVC4": 14.489024943895322, + "CVC3": 5.7289628140423563, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.417252464451701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.226190343235306 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.083931957315091, + "veriT": 14.230821512079117, + "Yices": 13.506951873134154, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952977177298834, + "CVC4": 14.476640016221026, + "CVC3": 14.245800691166945, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.43258329686544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.506989115964176 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.131382942199707, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257903870750324, + "veriT": 10.17154074490675, + "Yices": 10.331676309056025, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974022090732259, + "CVC4": 14.324520842363683, + "CVC3": 14.24726959806498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.256036241080903, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.135301496760258 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9668915271759033, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26681081117728572, + "veriT": 6.7891831553204929, + "Yices": 2.0970144549615717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4023877647995713, + "CVC4": 2.3650170501628343, + "CVC3": 0.52988938889514281, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18832916496342858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18088433049957139 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0686390021566883, + "veriT": 13.66199874235495, + "Yices": 13.702720419685999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.18624966719636, + "CVC4": 8.3675590090722665, + "CVC3": 4.6998098838306976, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.225569674900953, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8278617825324588 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3573636481111251, + "veriT": 13.198229374237959, + "Yices": 8.4024453505186081, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9230275849016252, + "CVC4": 9.3296973806248928, + "CVC3": 10.368236105134288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9816031948545116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9839824760147604 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.837304198130138, + "veriT": 11.951279701118791, + "Yices": 12.15091689190039, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.221738906516764, + "CVC4": 12.734143703180255, + "CVC3": 13.882026164352437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5708254782361557, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0313127962751718 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1727190017700195, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.054944846318365, + "veriT": 12.276682221006203, + "Yices": 14.240183701174567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963995942357792, + "CVC4": 14.421917018725798, + "CVC3": 12.300281618669766, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.008660420997886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.000695582137945 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.548753738868049, + "veriT": 14.230230142685059, + "Yices": 13.981084292193227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960247545934374, + "CVC4": 14.569332141080599, + "CVC3": 11.831294471625387, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225849828502842, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.133943860399734 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 363.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4166643868910072, + "veriT": 12.116425193801067, + "Yices": 12.707412057659296, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.835074428334654, + "CVC4": 13.04223433366325, + "CVC3": 13.220019511293774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3747548107623251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4382461009922394 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.664318241784356, + "veriT": 14.257516339467157, + "Yices": 14.143812023769796, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.052927266973491, + "CVC4": 14.630527805710042, + "CVC3": 11.559538849689273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.227417213592371, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.04214463404111 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12980294534185716, + "veriT": 0.10229838598688216, + "Yices": 0.10216567387959286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12647112007553571, + "CVC4": 0.12726160735082143, + "CVC3": 0.1063498341584964, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12621708951935712, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1234819954412143 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10085031464582941, + "veriT": 0.074845626640211757, + "Yices": 0.077332234674717656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.099336677261488232, + "CVC4": 0.098672908506747051, + "CVC3": 0.077960441192652941, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.098467420944458831, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.096217523165347055 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1237937055934992, + "veriT": 0.093573965600970005, + "Yices": 0.091491945416689993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.118197459246999, + "CVC4": 0.13089400514290001, + "CVC3": 0.10145566422568, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12225477399689999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12832262313659998 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.9474869414172119, + "veriT": 10.163240579634108, + "Yices": 10.358836147925395, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.035858846743412, + "CVC4": 0.14926095330939471, + "CVC3": 0.70050777025018429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14961896076018419, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.413120922698317 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1180555820465088, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1806189223836649, + "veriT": 5.566811020550646, + "Yices": 5.6138974301429716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2795278196328863, + "CVC4": 4.3844575144027012, + "CVC3": 6.1657512967903871, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1671376240903522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1781343599049521 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18520047571027273, + "veriT": 7.4255705213727277, + "Yices": 10.675115167985091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.33755312297709089, + "CVC4": 0.14888882282554547, + "CVC3": 0.26388537243481819, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14855142302227275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0429261049190988 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7034485340118408, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2277400842676429, + "veriT": 7.758012686455567, + "Yices": 7.7179957189568444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.8777907245561094, + "CVC4": 4.3850158456622577, + "CVC3": 3.3115920045434288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0918835712740842, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0222404794808391 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.229556393087057, + "veriT": 10.556452420928201, + "Yices": 10.700684101732993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.944186435277649, + "CVC4": 1.6573773148800313, + "CVC3": 13.943385854488676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2354269083912541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.580697037227436 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.852840210827072, + "veriT": 10.741747633985407, + "Yices": 10.543584972914573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.269874727712871, + "CVC4": 2.2855418998361636, + "CVC3": 10.452412075053445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1592126998562331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.348782039398127 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235619165697383, + "veriT": 10.148989352185799, + "Yices": 10.325595471350134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956870695625899, + "CVC4": 0.15555921954893334, + "CVC3": 11.350054134110913, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6368347275078643, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.276450483975591 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.040514291681575, + "veriT": 13.757477540922363, + "Yices": 12.81207624705336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.371714836481209, + "CVC4": 14.702883547761012, + "CVC3": 13.337573151661843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.240148454568523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.243305376617363 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.771043410966179, + "veriT": 11.71197239379585, + "Yices": 10.832212120882058, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4124280817891535, + "CVC4": 4.097432972180183, + "CVC3": 11.670056763081368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.45549771829363639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0184031264507203 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2586707438797866, + "veriT": 11.918641801463277, + "Yices": 12.407493648516851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3919261583808291, + "CVC4": 6.8387765558421183, + "CVC3": 10.495112258261249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7285604169924689, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7087662847403777 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.641948776947647, + "veriT": 12.959980144175328, + "Yices": 11.784201720922276, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.116229831435877, + "CVC4": 13.059331970388566, + "CVC3": 10.956031072457664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.992589751531781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.023967103290161 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.192880244475653, + "veriT": 10.608970358693746, + "Yices": 10.46073287203725, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955143968767704, + "CVC4": 1.9213700451239737, + "CVC3": 9.9802199926893085, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1831850880811388, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.040833247381569 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6836518049018281, + "veriT": 9.6832272923669898, + "Yices": 6.739341669509832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8177618288640041, + "CVC4": 9.2601555519062497, + "CVC3": 7.1518023462200588, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3023804923597844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2987063052443091 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9234898740391113, + "veriT": 9.5061432968268988, + "Yices": 9.3119616473627822, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4179785957969706, + "CVC4": 7.1120101250116852, + "CVC3": 4.0187165779982035, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9259084918941589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4008225641073411 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4156822838241556, + "veriT": 6.8344572490479516, + "Yices": 10.341311230707689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.071387956370277, + "CVC4": 0.43923471503480949, + "CVC3": 8.9301870200979785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.082167253444716, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.031898427658573 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13455785262799999, + "veriT": 0.1112799685631818, + "Yices": 0.11729651109495455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12546014419651819, + "CVC4": 0.13460743860945457, + "CVC3": 0.12282257917583635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12918959603118182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12877637545688184 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13581468237254546, + "veriT": 5.5509222762404455, + "Yices": 6.8521559581303739, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14710842772663638, + "CVC4": 4.0796332364816328, + "CVC3": 1.4351308459533405, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4094787614816293, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13140573807036365 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13481046608176925, + "veriT": 2.4199635333229539, + "Yices": 5.6751375820799996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13297455424247692, + "CVC4": 0.14075807936484613, + "CVC3": 0.12109521563550769, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13426418299130771, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13518456280690769 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.209498262097297, + "veriT": 12.060603970699649, + "Yices": 11.483947671673361, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.798902549969794, + "CVC4": 13.975637775415132, + "CVC3": 11.121596130844431, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.646179047482729, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.654137418176482 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9908329782753638, + "veriT": 4.0495657313753748, + "Yices": 13.697660175750739, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0137942371891824, + "CVC4": 13.327289024065321, + "CVC3": 11.913769240828556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.782654899577361, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7956010301698919 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0954544544219971, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8819444179534912, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8207450382059323, + "veriT": 6.9943504264971681, + "Yices": 7.6290913902584778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5429786929827713, + "CVC4": 1.6575310906243648, + "CVC3": 3.6258506978626364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7575233464723627, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8928971813240851 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22554231616339998, + "veriT": 13.278110998595164, + "Yices": 10.611254808876932, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8633708019163366, + "CVC4": 11.530131121625301, + "CVC3": 4.6733298951723494, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.686244008716534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.689725236162207 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2540355497945992, + "veriT": 8.6647534093409018, + "Yices": 9.8540920031568504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.112380041793926, + "CVC4": 8.6595301486746159, + "CVC3": 10.801289384656721, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.555463362615166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.759266364449161 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5944903077874235, + "veriT": 12.467313277642685, + "Yices": 5.9099210085071281, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8986462166006435, + "CVC4": 0.13661343231828571, + "CVC3": 7.3889002970475159, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1560466547527124, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9366948261627632 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3217041256357045, + "veriT": 4.7579190370467694, + "Yices": 7.5844061077415139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.58955538530523077, + "CVC4": 2.397006722371851, + "CVC3": 0.23841132257715383, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2672422820801768, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9795351040284928 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3904906196249991, + "veriT": 12.784431955844259, + "Yices": 10.318299467343405, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9435508873801535, + "CVC4": 11.166995026040373, + "CVC3": 7.5820057234886598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.850527270024275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.857065856124848 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9873700750865639, + "veriT": 8.8323959038643771, + "Yices": 11.156900442290798, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4966717580219475, + "CVC4": 11.80504222469051, + "CVC3": 10.852206018662294, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6825290300908549, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6807522945914792 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.069711446762085, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7736500009853735, + "veriT": 10.424580876271161, + "Yices": 10.443319518159312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.258069254728515, + "CVC4": 11.744290226804733, + "CVC3": 11.9795221359091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.129843151202483, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.798979569263373 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 15.013707745695175, + "veriT": 10.127781072032127, + "Yices": 10.195975401986171, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.940891695387668, + "CVC4": 5.7695346561192862, + "CVC3": 4.2191896511332496, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3834478404103869, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.41775331211122 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14118211598845454, + "veriT": 12.935817138538935, + "Yices": 7.6146758600791964, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16005734756218182, + "CVC4": 6.5751817008403615, + "CVC3": 7.0862641512229834, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.470481662493821, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.450356382206913 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9768310953002506, + "veriT": 2.9593134907192296, + "Yices": 12.682132123491684, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1236485356698265, + "CVC4": 4.5798457754243191, + "CVC3": 7.1933520413897982, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8643450978602871, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8473434691140769 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6179000568848569, + "veriT": 6.5230731932879253, + "Yices": 5.6848885721680968, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0637205622994279, + "CVC4": 5.7477060980447163, + "CVC3": 6.5709655779706893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6627274244631138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2170488249709157 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4450689050189931, + "veriT": 1.5657660821452859, + "Yices": 1.5943615435745713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5491002724280847, + "CVC4": 2.1651378671215133, + "CVC3": 2.1525574428813177, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.160782606752401, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7442694834313806 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16010586098689999, + "veriT": 0.14432724221120002, + "Yices": 0.15696840672680001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15527930929740003, + "CVC4": 0.1962442178604, + "CVC3": 0.15962347309329999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17700416637400002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1763236303939 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14493006082914286, + "veriT": 0.1231276435847857, + "Yices": 0.13888965708285714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14419419342964288, + "CVC4": 0.16276671006849999, + "CVC3": 0.14688986354607142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15984483710728573, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15986656970349999 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14929520009436364, + "veriT": 2.6916332256608322, + "Yices": 2.7088930791138517, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15348062722790909, + "CVC4": 0.16771662989081818, + "CVC3": 0.1492291385201818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.159291468932, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15528364985018184 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6829301006289858, + "veriT": 11.957546453136622, + "Yices": 6.1414101949339601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9696035346347562, + "CVC4": 8.9974221876929601, + "CVC3": 4.7380057611669901, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8262846515096198, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5228570290459347 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 64.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.83296864712145446, + "veriT": 4.8171988915924819, + "Yices": 9.3544330521211396, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5244696200631209, + "CVC4": 4.2299951695356306, + "CVC3": 0.26462620646454549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5778191337711336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4669487966247554 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.95646781397114278, + "veriT": 8.1835621701875834, + "Yices": 0.16579697726535714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9603453769523576, + "CVC4": 0.2153936027870714, + "CVC3": 0.25310936132042861, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18424657612921427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17512754702428571 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1960748364407499, + "veriT": 6.8127543266178661, + "Yices": 8.717887310697801, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7136885817499845, + "CVC4": 9.6528094960588167, + "CVC3": 1.9100945775961664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7757569588994868, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7655401232748891 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1028462042403602, + "veriT": 0.081155756701749987, + "Yices": 0.079153993313999998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.10473390110322, + "CVC4": 14.270734384977862, + "CVC3": 0.086732978306779993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10342389711683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10191736056770999 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.431836209281741, + "veriT": 6.1755040653326008, + "Yices": 8.3975708910367803, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.190137570593549, + "CVC4": 8.8355395328028727, + "CVC3": 3.0553484215490698, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7919511327492321, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6014002610551614 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6525356568389611, + "veriT": 9.2864197236726014, + "Yices": 2.2381966810003902, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3423584100460686, + "CVC4": 7.4573942696142241, + "CVC3": 4.9969409304079768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.116980960539525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.904171590903143 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 71.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8067029062732269, + "veriT": 7.1143135134398738, + "Yices": 4.3390750589140001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9133610819646316, + "CVC4": 0.20532407455988236, + "CVC3": 2.5191490116049282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9946018368945584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9262379618155006 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.4997434704985001, + "veriT": 10.181270613051101, + "Yices": 10.342506474096899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5663653127656643, + "CVC4": 14.273936773931917, + "CVC3": 3.8403127909228161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.263071050094984, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.151276092526977 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 132.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.321634079700029, + "veriT": 11.040773930949831, + "Yices": 11.838270698506443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.878410076024185, + "CVC4": 5.4637542045184535, + "CVC3": 11.721791365327258, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.659398115444223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.165063073995116 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5639969185069793, + "veriT": 14.229954488323742, + "Yices": 10.533115247839241, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3810072653300507, + "CVC4": 10.445263152308684, + "CVC3": 11.916773246278714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.264148120104387, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.254983416640959 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.236071856803286, + "veriT": 9.0426807897308645, + "Yices": 10.201757521948041, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2213118716458453, + "CVC4": 4.2486939580563599, + "CVC3": 5.0436888556686901, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1959447382348394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3192670251232377 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.267405617519797, + "veriT": 12.004863535712255, + "Yices": 11.755268664454867, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.450769524792296, + "CVC4": 14.60251982894839, + "CVC3": 14.253766821424948, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.229973750532801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.742359984122267 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.837398197855602, + "veriT": 10.797490304668456, + "Yices": 8.7523497647566284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5901928970871611, + "CVC4": 5.4527348901528079, + "CVC3": 6.1033050175370143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5398790287575563, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1735198531367388 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 81.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15954294296044444, + "veriT": 1.6898578967784585, + "Yices": 0.14357586509255552, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17906453327200003, + "CVC4": 1.7598070608689698, + "CVC3": 0.16127553536222225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.3662980449662222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.36852656239444442 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9585510296446103, + "veriT": 14.231119016401765, + "Yices": 11.866299240633875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.698529290329439, + "CVC4": 6.1249032754045158, + "CVC3": 4.348131623967415, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2759453945609582, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.234095377493329 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3137120350826668, + "veriT": 12.64435836911451, + "Yices": 0.13699225403977777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3409931529321113, + "CVC4": 0.43428354870711111, + "CVC3": 1.7176813508446367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.707742329887195, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7088062530951218 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 45.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 71.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.433569873108981, + "veriT": 11.915272826045328, + "Yices": 11.280026367011176, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.299941531982734, + "CVC4": 9.1099709899888524, + "CVC3": 9.9744927208511047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.021552826747538, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.196180228311018 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239912950495421, + "veriT": 11.909702905868453, + "Yices": 12.156844739830861, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.671111117315297, + "CVC4": 14.478041389507981, + "CVC3": 13.922438661052878, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.894138518650431, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.045779648846459 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0779994817634782, + "veriT": 9.1326824320988234, + "Yices": 10.66680435530129, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.427078162129671, + "CVC4": 11.356372092400433, + "CVC3": 7.9180242338888576, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2017311695141384, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3676408405609726 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3674728980664703, + "veriT": 12.194707830115947, + "Yices": 9.7031595524220933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2748165180932123, + "CVC4": 4.1864645984505158, + "CVC3": 4.7594832193359364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9382295575152266, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2121023865857516 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 88.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4814232038455835, + "veriT": 9.4570121647461995, + "Yices": 3.7090350065914754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.61019797761658, + "CVC4": 0.25032431527600002, + "CVC3": 0.24469111379733333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18658458041833334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18495310402774998 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4430969617016567, + "veriT": 13.134831245980443, + "Yices": 8.0157286676810209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.9577065709208, + "CVC4": 9.2448514557413439, + "CVC3": 5.367005139386797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9289411330413024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0093062279805185 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 139.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 105.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.796773566489959, + "veriT": 11.042584690525175, + "Yices": 12.416430505616077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.41431587373836, + "CVC4": 14.410849236714357, + "CVC3": 8.3287252205594609, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.913732977490955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.92034176675361 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3386425479902471, + "veriT": 13.720763073269726, + "Yices": 11.92917644860005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.996681719934665, + "CVC4": 9.2650107593593241, + "CVC3": 9.4159067574345485, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.381843363345574, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.330031482189261 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8822230100631714, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8948558249375917, + "veriT": 13.88785321467147, + "Yices": 13.75884035770147, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.633243521892226, + "CVC4": 14.423742941313412, + "CVC3": 13.640119814311143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251193516675423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.250588414311824 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235071890993336, + "veriT": 11.024232807703699, + "Yices": 11.830319974355445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955393224119971, + "CVC4": 14.703743997276812, + "CVC3": 14.223999597105214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.657312587632232, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.246851421428291 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0354713037111001, + "veriT": 9.7407786315247762, + "Yices": 12.620002133011701, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6103045349681029, + "CVC4": 13.30396170087397, + "CVC3": 6.1896486920048464, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2703017255629, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22834306948120001 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 69.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1485682053487034, + "veriT": 13.196806259932504, + "Yices": 9.3656803669136828, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.325091999252063, + "CVC4": 11.134105820847475, + "CVC3": 11.088307643641077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7321690364454043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7294961741460466 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.646162737045383, + "veriT": 13.046618399715403, + "Yices": 13.049730229447375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950322263734732, + "CVC4": 13.724788583880791, + "CVC3": 13.763511453521614, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.458829612608096, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.491458868745466 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 52.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.563133860344534, + "veriT": 13.90867471315245, + "Yices": 14.283035588145836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.102633884414528, + "CVC4": 14.386923290979496, + "CVC3": 11.78018659244286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.261418965534626, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.198178804003682 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3342817870772752, + "veriT": 13.664560688595021, + "Yices": 13.696782853160945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962563942046028, + "CVC4": 12.758578242043898, + "CVC3": 12.068729778905231, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.24245758925365, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.819478470747372 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.779370651090105, + "veriT": 12.563771502181167, + "Yices": 12.911851075615225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.141130723269384, + "CVC4": 14.449772035953963, + "CVC3": 10.411275494736953, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0949161084461752, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0979322569480958 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1332237615098846, + "veriT": 0.10232121080988076, + "Yices": 0.10530697517017693, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12940126470034619, + "CVC4": 0.13113878912957694, + "CVC3": 0.11085341302337692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12652106969542307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12617874280784619 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11655799058073181, + "veriT": 0.5374089812664592, + "Yices": 0.54206014950980019, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12330876224443181, + "CVC4": 0.74970208252854353, + "CVC3": 0.089260569930281822, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.74524126860379181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.74400523030337851 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.888964828904125, + "veriT": 1.8581887644234079, + "Yices": 3.1376627225651879, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8846894361855004, + "CVC4": 1.9879723498621817, + "CVC3": 1.8704600147827311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8827146545758413, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.905085514334433 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0838097561345643, + "veriT": 9.8491955734357486, + "Yices": 10.031019533395865, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1769287939140831, + "CVC4": 0.15000825653503125, + "CVC3": 0.68650514557218745, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14686286431606252, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.077279857241539 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19382882973400001, + "veriT": 8.7326357942994282, + "Yices": 10.522602613160858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.41328293698342849, + "CVC4": 0.15096410677357142, + "CVC3": 0.27373033901214283, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14882239125385713, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8937719260404533 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5156482297221432, + "veriT": 11.566433875495411, + "Yices": 11.462639990558227, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2702809196916292, + "CVC4": 11.903762974027405, + "CVC3": 7.4553416609114294, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.199264804106294, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.205511127940499 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7000000476837158, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3117012960481702, + "veriT": 3.5212125102654444, + "Yices": 4.7136860696565561, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8763238686024355, + "CVC4": 0.16322194590499997, + "CVC3": 2.6331033672593334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1022992502404332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.113457170899812 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14062604089085712, + "veriT": 2.1244401143046514, + "Yices": 3.5815312272873023, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13623767243742857, + "CVC4": 2.1631216037464167, + "CVC3": 0.13571130330785716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1533286196931316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14213318423642857 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.500588203237394, + "veriT": 10.170006863761376, + "Yices": 10.347555031173625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961938182764271, + "CVC4": 0.163635246214375, + "CVC3": 9.4592425131739297, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9775298865565132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.350540368362346 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.363043840794566, + "veriT": 10.156075017600848, + "Yices": 10.323245447522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.947490988146164, + "CVC4": 0.1639780381596154, + "CVC3": 10.719419540942654, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14142883791538463, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.14530152550568 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.783338658148026, + "veriT": 9.491757379885863, + "Yices": 10.954405198649447, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.304450867837376, + "CVC4": 1.8025445036658558, + "CVC3": 12.952541928798588, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15110230738799998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.836382145454408 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8452379703521729, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.846002956296275, + "veriT": 9.1667691138224008, + "Yices": 10.325757760017201, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.494480021092471, + "CVC4": 0.17484516827739999, + "CVC3": 12.449715295185634, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.163751547131064, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.285535272954286 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.826483342977454, + "veriT": 10.387780930744338, + "Yices": 10.379171261849894, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.469260072284367, + "CVC4": 4.1237841994303119, + "CVC3": 9.5737947288856695, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.76602085462984, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.070485129699282 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.701572728554133, + "veriT": 10.496671478396378, + "Yices": 9.7471867294268772, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.255557399900875, + "CVC4": 1.4606982500104102, + "CVC3": 11.877453651850765, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.490986897639913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7722492530382006 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0147416675075709, + "veriT": 10.45672201440067, + "Yices": 9.8690166728795674, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2188696400432164, + "CVC4": 3.2228049771575713, + "CVC3": 9.0300821849247601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.6619857185634901, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9307272681746577 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1610823017895, + "veriT": 6.1428802861335337, + "Yices": 7.8810512492427627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23620264678585001, + "CVC4": 7.1996900168631965, + "CVC3": 3.0343829030400955, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1751273847233792, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1758383473140404 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7073915737217567, + "veriT": 7.2141548616303357, + "Yices": 6.8870005391840765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.522627155509487, + "CVC4": 2.9816236140615189, + "CVC3": 2.8463678245315243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7916977399073346, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7786804516874826 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4453778823786401, + "veriT": 8.9439058566901366, + "Yices": 11.05043176274908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6206985960943392, + "CVC4": 12.078809276557001, + "CVC3": 8.4423794067227398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.713483649705106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2159290561713529 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4014058435651249, + "veriT": 4.9065331898545148, + "Yices": 1.9215686697767498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4030777504649998, + "CVC4": 0.16315050765524999, + "CVC3": 1.3947571308939999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.147231974862125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15176656103524999 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13539499581090003, + "veriT": 0.11289992554866998, + "Yices": 0.12013363420020999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12052902575914001, + "CVC4": 0.1531473927241, + "CVC3": 0.13638125413534002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17700197193649997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16895418441364002 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.704328942522128, + "veriT": 11.943275273178235, + "Yices": 10.9940262917375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.329163209402017, + "CVC4": 12.331094017463547, + "CVC3": 12.464604888133358, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.093140304076181, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.064225937825155 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9523998616593659, + "veriT": 11.638638776462187, + "Yices": 10.115606192357522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0946853924063138, + "CVC4": 11.192342648945138, + "CVC3": 10.483349844095985, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.399898432350346, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.417283036849671 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9497665616466957, + "veriT": 6.5154767905140316, + "Yices": 2.1167685540088002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0942865160961239, + "CVC4": 0.14431933392490001, + "CVC3": 0.22791762347368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3597358045779995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3575494560593553 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.547965160368136, + "veriT": 11.885410873838969, + "Yices": 11.962015816745991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2813855640659089, + "CVC4": 10.051908238091572, + "CVC3": 9.8677782251941206, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238808813829223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.757263339014541 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6802914968789233, + "veriT": 4.4882271498292896, + "Yices": 11.194965359463795, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6856555219895692, + "CVC4": 5.7469783645567185, + "CVC3": 5.2020315921579359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4797203442568585, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4696201966479312 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.465207382739928, + "veriT": 13.632051858376872, + "Yices": 13.659180948906954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.127209581311364, + "CVC4": 12.466136083252126, + "CVC3": 12.859941256424358, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.546275052777387, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.175556112690717 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.6433206542719091, + "veriT": 9.2334585846501813, + "Yices": 9.2807248545404537, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6812340391002287, + "CVC4": 13.11389740294884, + "CVC3": 7.8395074223975341, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.960007946318729, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.209023824649348 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3827455878894999, + "veriT": 3.6344810838257522, + "Yices": 11.377546879839924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.398140006402375, + "CVC4": 6.7672906792668313, + "CVC3": 5.3857817281533755, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1440938027127636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1429145750427443 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.810971877052455, + "veriT": 3.6514143132737273, + "Yices": 1.4244810274589115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8933718535531812, + "CVC4": 0.17400997214418182, + "CVC3": 1.4359312576866483, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3563494706614456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3556872210316948 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7817240745522609, + "veriT": 7.1592613628377695, + "Yices": 4.1457146219537595, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6911268938403801, + "CVC4": 3.1141789886111018, + "CVC3": 2.9832030692848543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1932312883006073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2136377159942002 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.951400175984947, + "veriT": 12.560244601630007, + "Yices": 5.2679781342452898, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.898580617135114, + "CVC4": 11.63353029074624, + "CVC3": 11.18883210251585, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.907665618655338, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.955164022316126 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.432814024498514, + "veriT": 9.5165790627527667, + "Yices": 11.445389329436408, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.18136491235412, + "CVC4": 6.9361204054153598, + "CVC3": 10.618001383551693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8529956892990098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2451718167580186 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0700790733636456, + "veriT": 12.300118802146605, + "Yices": 9.8799461387038949, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.127694972233398, + "CVC4": 2.298832084127326, + "CVC3": 4.2058775544616775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19725283947299999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1952693680517143 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8453234503790386, + "veriT": 10.127477847269793, + "Yices": 12.915490936540943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0945153004495616, + "CVC4": 5.00769746336137, + "CVC3": 6.5888269952602707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6583647561801484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.631583637550646 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2344319820404053, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.105555534362793, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.429900584450511, + "veriT": 8.1634291765585996, + "Yices": 8.3140930556873993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.003861757061522, + "CVC4": 0.16895038719040001, + "CVC3": 11.519967700045578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17454386092899998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1240502095932783 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.587310217031245, + "veriT": 6.1776669843639898, + "Yices": 9.0448156930658605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6687466554891683, + "CVC4": 11.747597668325865, + "CVC3": 5.7111428815544212, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8607811457541965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5343848634423569 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 81.0, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1401281340009, + "veriT": 2.1121441362352003, + "Yices": 9.7903765128688853, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1328277418896198, + "CVC4": 3.5533800964703177, + "CVC3": 1.2357086524070002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.953228693557743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1525582913949268 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1301052143208001, + "veriT": 0.1154116113194, + "Yices": 0.13430410574206, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1623060370434204, + "CVC4": 5.8185859019445783, + "CVC3": 0.12974775067992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15999078098399999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15718051878700001 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13295745494285713, + "veriT": 1.5392278147638714, + "Yices": 1.6622367960198574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12825054060900001, + "CVC4": 0.16268614220714284, + "CVC3": 0.12617727288671429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1512338442862378, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1474283117810424 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1779534004313463, + "veriT": 6.4708953331358572, + "Yices": 12.754463977951961, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3951241891783317, + "CVC4": 0.39452380731451431, + "CVC3": 0.55046797818121429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1688215012407595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.18912426261455 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3769160996798933, + "veriT": 11.069980675753648, + "Yices": 11.664946871608981, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.528291732356628, + "CVC4": 7.3466015996023115, + "CVC3": 9.9477058084260506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1638299178657947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.466239451668649 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.47699605260899997, + "veriT": 0.94246194662076921, + "Yices": 3.5803694228236083, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.73565865248600015, + "CVC4": 0.22716009778561538, + "CVC3": 0.2178467428196923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19351755562684614, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2788186685675929 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7022161414536265, + "veriT": 9.2699993005662815, + "Yices": 9.414196385772982, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.362543814156256, + "CVC4": 12.987214629291111, + "CVC3": 7.1191636096074351, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.966384936643648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.05342862938199 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13780575492245453, + "veriT": 14.208958851823558, + "Yices": 0.12414914588045455, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20460455805500002, + "CVC4": 1.5005486394012577, + "CVC3": 0.12501026455545453, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.395275332064084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.402813418770883 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.37037797973612502, + "veriT": 12.179105651541608, + "Yices": 12.163091575029572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1127659378620161, + "CVC4": 5.5827409660987906, + "CVC3": 11.486166522405172, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.11155851530277, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2429107659239893 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6385777749935002, + "veriT": 13.798938369469189, + "Yices": 5.4373235627482996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7147529183903645, + "CVC4": 6.0911826439916554, + "CVC3": 0.54613921035110002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1855961822656509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1850962250657044 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.227901506728051, + "veriT": 13.177485629584146, + "Yices": 12.849976087255358, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.237967520159756, + "CVC4": 10.137358161192049, + "CVC3": 14.210856901818826, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.096881465030961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.080755482713027 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 83.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1680189026482857, + "veriT": 0.14243220619314287, + "Yices": 0.24450166327662856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18442341357397143, + "CVC4": 4.2096810946316197, + "CVC3": 0.18193163280482855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16605297885371431, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16953128521908573 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9625100710256809, + "veriT": 3.1290788564275109, + "Yices": 13.885469245893246, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0733327451529666, + "CVC4": 1.9361386972306585, + "CVC3": 1.9051190666847939, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6711640649991546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6692796960288376 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1155433654785156, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19028705633164286, + "veriT": 0.16048545044150003, + "Yices": 0.18082337004871429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20810205387357142, + "CVC4": 0.21689961652764289, + "CVC3": 0.18778158556492855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19584172159792859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19245632122678566 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15014286349871428, + "veriT": 8.0496272520181407, + "Yices": 0.15176207385457147, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18062762749671427, + "CVC4": 0.17483107523885716, + "CVC3": 0.8496472482752857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15997492496800003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16041819779000002 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 52.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2029044055626059, + "veriT": 4.9834355746326571, + "Yices": 12.927832813980501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3656325462284418, + "CVC4": 6.9773684707914807, + "CVC3": 5.0163979984442495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4035786649301536, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8930944991824612 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2967912950470488, + "veriT": 1.7105765433363476, + "Yices": 1.4526185783803336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.554372740489633, + "CVC4": 6.5514196377056955, + "CVC3": 0.4494464236961111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22644257911777782, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21647004258422223 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 189.0, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9487285614013672, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.309604605135579, + "veriT": 10.711427898335216, + "Yices": 11.259320291122375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.177572799952673, + "CVC4": 14.295703792964733, + "CVC3": 12.25672372183667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.266540892539435, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.805568543121026 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.256239411132182, + "veriT": 10.184503256268602, + "Yices": 10.340278686386501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.981951979561662, + "CVC4": 14.423628828121888, + "CVC3": 13.408327804535412, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.936661683377176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.341135067953193 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5757671720097317, + "veriT": 12.879244412899688, + "Yices": 12.467972996559574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2610684815340534, + "CVC4": 14.693341470049047, + "CVC3": 5.2577186901554391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.577430476829226, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.617686509337515 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7192305326461792, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3754422547931493, + "veriT": 10.627248775643755, + "Yices": 6.4739657744584598, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8557186295863084, + "CVC4": 3.4974137755878369, + "CVC3": 6.4096281434109841, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.405800202698854, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.347079464265439 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 96.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3608429698318303, + "veriT": 12.472156773882924, + "Yices": 11.725123747238976, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9420880982208359, + "CVC4": 14.532662613463023, + "CVC3": 13.363682603537086, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.282175514957416, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.999049342682993 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8145081711118136, + "veriT": 12.865732131344554, + "Yices": 8.9302404765308463, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.711067264596304, + "CVC4": 1.7450974453683918, + "CVC3": 8.0357116061258118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.875598575149704, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.863359906001467 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.833866688647396, + "veriT": 13.239385504573816, + "Yices": 12.739513069908758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.732759434791168, + "CVC4": 14.580554676082436, + "CVC3": 10.898410360918575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260085010107744, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.37052828717672 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 54.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4989907326546668, + "veriT": 3.5277507249785667, + "Yices": 4.1436820128535903, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6266053757958332, + "CVC4": 7.2252071566302831, + "CVC3": 0.14508269128100001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19328761086866666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17721965144383334 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.761858159286168, + "veriT": 11.02887199273119, + "Yices": 12.399996055957482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.334033279772907, + "CVC4": 11.339699032758423, + "CVC3": 10.77047734610389, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4365894527590886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4335688746752702 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 143.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19200827477193336, + "veriT": 6.5589543491893254, + "Yices": 0.74288561757429994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.8285266143290001, + "CVC4": 0.17351206398983335, + "CVC3": 2.4350372334083645, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15052432155746664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15040715337043334 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7738344021204173, + "veriT": 12.204297822707163, + "Yices": 4.17190122730897, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.163545187235178, + "CVC4": 8.5034662352914001, + "CVC3": 4.2599009935299836, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7625504187534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8628497811494862 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.041844367980957, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.37377759411739997, + "veriT": 12.265234964454617, + "Yices": 13.765946314244786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6908420197400003, + "CVC4": 11.59291782955915, + "CVC3": 6.5545833292917433, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.73982375329129, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.716303593008833 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4913882711189288, + "veriT": 11.945512263071853, + "Yices": 8.5514816877444737, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7988567924564212, + "CVC4": 12.819167715616542, + "CVC3": 11.219918510360344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.908134620296241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.263010306368416 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.0, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6784109117989692, + "veriT": 11.432824424016554, + "Yices": 5.1345816677577316, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.153456153347488, + "CVC4": 4.2507672554644422, + "CVC3": 2.2164730155121322, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.908668162665168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8816155358756941 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1526765823364258, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0762483666521412, + "veriT": 10.40248049131247, + "Yices": 9.0218298126248389, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9268414117216803, + "CVC4": 11.545376412122101, + "CVC3": 6.3488180533353997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2896694614193347, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3983335727066981 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9858236675754037, + "veriT": 12.59108901201631, + "Yices": 12.895017820588933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.787622029638275, + "CVC4": 14.51678743480864, + "CVC3": 12.11754980984084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.465055051595176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.459208440263108 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1599349975585938, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.840543575226043, + "veriT": 13.478033794771056, + "Yices": 12.668275619329096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955151761419614, + "CVC4": 14.336770485058004, + "CVC3": 14.222423467129376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244839184697264, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.244619757145488 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23594584459212, + "veriT": 13.649843630206387, + "Yices": 14.235684590806249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956092606919096, + "CVC4": 14.298742432330254, + "CVC3": 13.303713861544713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9944466701045247, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8518462970947702 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3622655403675803, + "veriT": 11.951861343457288, + "Yices": 14.034271441586833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2365701082291389, + "CVC4": 13.129542585457255, + "CVC3": 10.959458839146809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1317649055247383, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1300605975496651 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 57.5, + "true": 146 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8912978239639617, + "veriT": 12.39231865908145, + "Yices": 11.157052450173421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.283412248521957, + "CVC4": 5.3169606870522177, + "CVC3": 6.9310610642114368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.47948111904354551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5259971377415176 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.483250678520953, + "veriT": 14.243066646675189, + "Yices": 13.359383108686833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.628929957025802, + "CVC4": 14.799179989727904, + "CVC3": 14.100892077900761, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2611011998931012, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2182163898315537 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 154, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "false": 151, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 197.5, + "true": 150 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.276260477313659, + "veriT": 14.235600882185501, + "Yices": 13.767089865837786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.273519009780124, + "CVC4": 12.657689633826653, + "CVC3": 12.723545388035289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253732775288876, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.255945909873081 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "false": 153, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 152 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259417186315016, + "veriT": 11.989110892997456, + "Yices": 13.594409676310233, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.073567566873447, + "CVC4": 14.802835721132249, + "CVC3": 14.247764638001476, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.207362766906298, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.80104330166442 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.48718142214093, + "veriT": 14.26054720388178, + "Yices": 14.091376088940004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98392578216616, + "CVC4": 14.832877831644545, + "CVC3": 13.67137082898458, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.569377662912389, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.611738850017007 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244836928382856, + "veriT": 13.037072239530454, + "Yices": 13.222893668501552, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.131870161890969, + "CVC4": 14.729094306802097, + "CVC3": 7.602738549970967, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.26485637194596, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.66428443313735 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12494366397060001, + "veriT": 0.094881860034766674, + "Yices": 0.098271825616949984, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12224067606313332, + "CVC4": 0.12327113318220002, + "CVC3": 0.10172432851994666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11942438013156667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11913949373323332 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11529514298231598, + "veriT": 0.48296718141862011, + "Yices": 0.48696150774504404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12246076564069998, + "CVC4": 0.67130128768039821, + "CVC3": 0.088822730201075992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.6705080999376607, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.66856517616919309 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1679981055174462, + "veriT": 2.6552968758774353, + "Yices": 2.155437540150325, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3434952619563623, + "CVC4": 3.6751957439501903, + "CVC3": 0.14311428040657501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16675340157687502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16217682313437501 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9625505344574723, + "veriT": 8.1454693070687192, + "Yices": 8.2692523027263611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4086914006471911, + "CVC4": 1.9945453092925569, + "CVC3": 3.9791513776259455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9032673327814664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3120355619790409 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20394278689948644, + "veriT": 9.6218322577279185, + "Yices": 10.42061843032981, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27087631780591892, + "CVC4": 0.15116491636016216, + "CVC3": 0.63378762541224321, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14774506155954054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.012843313068624 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 16, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4952170570339636, + "veriT": 10.849211509083757, + "Yices": 11.333271948993433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.544849137912724, + "CVC4": 10.833706962617981, + "CVC3": 8.4899561467713696, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.443435029508594, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.63005815033244 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249570312648029, + "veriT": 10.166807348532801, + "Yices": 10.333475074274499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96071743834052, + "CVC4": 0.1712033395434, + "CVC3": 12.67304930209842, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.828707548190536, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.352422224749455 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.572413007225023, + "veriT": 10.198361971367857, + "Yices": 10.327637350575856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958982204295291, + "CVC4": 1.6952100637100003, + "CVC3": 10.807320872986931, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8063419648203438, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.152575347679569 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7482861916115411, + "veriT": 9.2907034771235306, + "Yices": 6.6168481523918183, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1380409296667775, + "CVC4": 1.0810635385309999, + "CVC3": 7.4531457918888382, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2765597265084008, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2467574792371341 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6019556908554717, + "veriT": 6.8140878244151679, + "Yices": 8.6194188373789995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.049484320016115, + "CVC4": 0.21392677023433335, + "CVC3": 5.4077711229107424, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19153803198866667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.363261039686714 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.518423213466098, + "veriT": 5.4822344273470138, + "Yices": 9.7518651339803917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.628921457246884, + "CVC4": 2.5210978178257863, + "CVC3": 2.5203914119429545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.197966101394579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7313977072697577 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5982145071029663, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.832660593406235, + "veriT": 9.1667500540387987, + "Yices": 9.3415397066337995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.482788787649914, + "CVC4": 0.15577559211549999, + "CVC3": 9.3016376895375004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5596718974536179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.58723345799485 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235835069591515, + "veriT": 10.158868000212637, + "Yices": 10.330544840670543, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.952970129212122, + "CVC4": 0.16112325030899999, + "CVC3": 10.899267275615056, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14014302061672726, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.489466261471266 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23645864462809, + "veriT": 10.154326310925001, + "Yices": 10.333873121362499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957671890919865, + "CVC4": 0.16131822649112501, + "CVC3": 14.239436572108207, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.146537606804125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.059532703374412 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.785938218899981, + "veriT": 11.314779832706673, + "Yices": 9.970591789825999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.207226599176744, + "CVC4": 3.268698176709214, + "CVC3": 8.8922563060568311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0186663612984939, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.100680584302717 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17346564471896667, + "veriT": 11.742651364898846, + "Yices": 7.0792002648194163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20049874675688889, + "CVC4": 7.9883119342637015, + "CVC3": 9.2845359313796223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.552721055817794, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1061284008455257 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7071430683135986, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2133360636653308, + "veriT": 11.007254381503877, + "Yices": 9.2367054306705807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8762287608066135, + "CVC4": 7.4266145310499203, + "CVC3": 9.6202897247438113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9561019724729123, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9913041903011379 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.663967282739812, + "veriT": 14.219496287048347, + "Yices": 12.575656257686664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.853635481340028, + "CVC4": 14.696122990385375, + "CVC3": 13.350527060970222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.237297188935619, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.241389212719438 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8285713195800781, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4840609771918354, + "veriT": 7.4763909706904332, + "Yices": 8.8830602489657551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6644976201573281, + "CVC4": 10.347646260356539, + "CVC3": 4.4753709921377895, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9516737847903256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8457642549967339 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3719518402667816, + "veriT": 11.665938102545189, + "Yices": 9.0994320398032631, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.397475054606478, + "CVC4": 11.112282660002426, + "CVC3": 6.4350404577406115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.157617884554258, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.965777635277183 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1180553436279297, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.472113607344001, + "veriT": 10.975872424354243, + "Yices": 11.120541152883989, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.344322394397885, + "CVC4": 2.9845539525631279, + "CVC3": 12.237485996603144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9924833638691828, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.11625268755532 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4395331461468155, + "veriT": 7.4074765524077923, + "Yices": 7.0907403063181693, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7127011499827445, + "CVC4": 4.0474066849199906, + "CVC3": 8.5719063246639315, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6730748285883479, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4720839037237403 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2708334922790527, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9631041233048165, + "veriT": 4.969272535029531, + "Yices": 9.1784883402189603, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.698358022471, + "CVC4": 2.9874890364127245, + "CVC3": 4.2609515133008804, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9709858932603153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.192453360504679 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15873933273018334, + "veriT": 6.5384792761100634, + "Yices": 5.1489366396179994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15487961256483332, + "CVC4": 0.160996918696, + "CVC3": 1.8596792724555831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16207473567216668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15636959531653333 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5597892393172739, + "veriT": 13.733735606575671, + "Yices": 7.7850055991018356, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7511180770841808, + "CVC4": 9.3055896355696976, + "CVC3": 8.2382917629052255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.361998132053547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.360094380143627 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8786764144897461, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6949521784244475, + "veriT": 1.0773326528039364, + "Yices": 3.4701697768646325, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8238380794109941, + "CVC4": 0.20538270681990908, + "CVC3": 1.2162641448541089, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4147775542993999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4156730751266311 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0416665077209473, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26105009278899999, + "veriT": 7.975429290526364, + "Yices": 10.455714996424451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.70027237070499992, + "CVC4": 7.246110096731833, + "CVC3": 4.4141542222840933, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.437206989484938, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.567147504818548 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.136071934083275, + "veriT": 7.6463533672128996, + "Yices": 6.8761391522128159, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15958681672677499, + "CVC4": 5.1342911675871505, + "CVC3": 5.4414930635509995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0723066019299914, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0103781530427884 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.30153339514191674, + "veriT": 3.4820082172306002, + "Yices": 4.6711268308228888, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4043214542745697, + "CVC4": 1.3463263209748046, + "CVC3": 1.3260136053050262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3379344356765903, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1088799664115854 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.684363700272259, + "veriT": 9.0104273825936367, + "Yices": 8.8611529593489742, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5436667910190103, + "CVC4": 2.66386807671975, + "CVC3": 1.816107569410881, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.105980539688264, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.118140401976333 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2072762766800267, + "veriT": 8.7190357680289736, + "Yices": 11.582419804709515, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5387560804413241, + "CVC4": 9.3178003932129805, + "CVC3": 7.0831794709096476, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.585863849218212, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7718782015392538 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7138233193745318, + "veriT": 6.1745325591057734, + "Yices": 14.005781248130903, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7709566038573756, + "CVC4": 12.600497969386101, + "CVC3": 13.343818767134461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2944118952081576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2767137940720072 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4818491426070002, + "veriT": 8.5752530656927544, + "Yices": 0.17783682172700002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4816493712178667, + "CVC4": 0.29987183413673335, + "CVC3": 0.14334603426146666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9002011908899572, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9002042126880365 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9281250238418579, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6343258559961722, + "veriT": 8.1645682365893411, + "Yices": 9.3729830136127958, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4895621283235441, + "CVC4": 12.849973591889349, + "CVC3": 6.0071724536325686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.430168371467483, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0096493404597737 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1463988455734895, + "veriT": 6.3059122157644083, + "Yices": 11.225809812089766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5656968209621018, + "CVC4": 6.8521544254108981, + "CVC3": 2.4999379854121537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.41685718155714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3325719013727721 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8382274356422412, + "veriT": 5.2114625039369393, + "Yices": 9.705132386333533, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7840523990363479, + "CVC4": 3.750068691677062, + "CVC3": 6.3081356429237774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7104043199289443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.711241986878604 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13623256657822222, + "veriT": 1.2228300682687001, + "Yices": 1.2287421299006667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13629383840044446, + "CVC4": 0.15500150571311111, + "CVC3": 3.9595727707052237, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14948186160099999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14506732179744442 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3721346054004346, + "veriT": 7.7783397537102772, + "Yices": 5.0000367370524987, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6271120706996829, + "CVC4": 1.6353337624603625, + "CVC3": 5.9235823975769009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.668212925881571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0366677021497193 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 80.0, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14325430563716665, + "veriT": 2.4715977817984269, + "Yices": 2.1460107438049514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14770636556825001, + "CVC4": 1.0527686762203334, + "CVC3": 1.1220160461684998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.98629810790075012, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.98541738761766651 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14677526676369998, + "veriT": 0.12754129364819999, + "Yices": 0.18789024130309998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18440358011300001, + "CVC4": 0.1782200348561, + "CVC3": 0.14226802144949999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17692175798570001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17580519364730002 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16780895035069232, + "veriT": 1.2680069940006595, + "Yices": 5.5735156833638939, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17205736728361537, + "CVC4": 0.18460632404192309, + "CVC3": 0.17025681195361536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17703728600599997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1695897163140769 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19234384777750002, + "veriT": 9.113515804894158, + "Yices": 1.8737865536497955, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6127186483505906, + "CVC4": 2.515640000292211, + "CVC3": 2.4880423085177257, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5040653514481397, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5011420225233709 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17060915279083333, + "veriT": 0.147678268398, + "Yices": 0.16081310999199999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17715100212983334, + "CVC4": 0.19858666093683333, + "CVC3": 0.17568973159783333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18362467101049998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18245180708916667 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5576152714325922, + "veriT": 11.877276094191345, + "Yices": 11.225189490734133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3955646977733949, + "CVC4": 12.152904744392378, + "CVC3": 10.949171180579301, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9954418480377125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7882089245237012 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1219949722290039, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9657459259033203, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7023360708615005, + "veriT": 8.4139861139468213, + "Yices": 3.3456853217377498, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5576998363629251, + "CVC4": 3.7547370347595401, + "CVC3": 3.6699216066593277, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0440051433027202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0003871194817426 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0633238490861816, + "veriT": 4.5065549199063959, + "Yices": 1.9442673652699545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.084813906193409, + "CVC4": 9.1563890171493529, + "CVC3": 0.14287412351354545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21230655334136364, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18368185792007274 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.423357440602329, + "veriT": 5.8357049825241178, + "Yices": 6.1954187567074834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.820607212570204, + "CVC4": 7.3620976577744921, + "CVC3": 2.1650721565536664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.37445803456333332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7061973395334515 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5913797044042344, + "veriT": 8.8904821271519001, + "Yices": 8.2846828329934645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6723376185316461, + "CVC4": 13.316585405160147, + "CVC3": 8.1005966980329518, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9425926395079198, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.928055499528698 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.71823921876641, + "veriT": 7.6517274354090006, + "Yices": 12.526218470031626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.258877903386098, + "CVC4": 9.7669006719631319, + "CVC3": 10.705997470817838, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.714883218632616, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2333264269221278 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 33.0, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15424051861400001, + "veriT": 14.205917226201036, + "Yices": 0.11827650111509093, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.31138123552436359, + "CVC4": 4.1921249709297737, + "CVC3": 0.13712860998145454, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.672239994989917, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.706147658142374 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18942324043799999, + "veriT": 8.8261795788653981, + "Yices": 4.7565248017403823, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.55115596103083331, + "CVC4": 5.0233199971765261, + "CVC3": 4.4043062939960693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1850949803298718, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1843160369882808 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 52.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8547510344343445, + "veriT": 13.636228108319596, + "Yices": 9.6870891905568044, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3009894338932408, + "CVC4": 9.8969487438653196, + "CVC3": 10.557788378491495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.770847061344687, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.632753823175879 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6426026136371665, + "veriT": 13.682440217698193, + "Yices": 6.7248020403960505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1002582266778331, + "CVC4": 0.44208398343433331, + "CVC3": 2.7116416679573558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8353369303428702, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8340096352174582 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9759976088187123, + "veriT": 11.742436066627333, + "Yices": 6.1693549714976532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4582572431759697, + "CVC4": 8.4152780727615344, + "CVC3": 7.0279292201505159, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.296521167124183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.316247616827621 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.684958367922981, + "veriT": 10.650318287734036, + "Yices": 12.829483945249263, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.307903752920062, + "CVC4": 14.285632287835265, + "CVC3": 8.0030200971660506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.084648750564945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.087998945268408 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.263169318590807, + "veriT": 11.348194415361666, + "Yices": 10.377021992175928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98644290156342, + "CVC4": 14.287101739756595, + "CVC3": 13.669880176546558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.896954910009159, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.85052681233241 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20584933886116002, + "veriT": 6.179965968924936, + "Yices": 0.49378518373153002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.82312417417140016, + "CVC4": 0.17253666251970001, + "CVC3": 0.20552042518777996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15267044168608002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14582915845541 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.59525680595087493, + "veriT": 12.700948070530064, + "Yices": 7.4315251116571606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9157968683572513, + "CVC4": 5.1079668149360948, + "CVC3": 1.9668593529327028, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2681896837147137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2446437781600892 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8812011989708104, + "veriT": 11.931387070962741, + "Yices": 10.77322902284415, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.603620147937649, + "CVC4": 10.290222507189432, + "CVC3": 2.8448247359384786, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.380402359842991, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.112104279579029 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.108216503336962, + "veriT": 14.216635475613426, + "Yices": 13.477388179520602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.592690202097671, + "CVC4": 14.366566377418836, + "CVC3": 14.221588053778843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2056982057539845, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2011525643952066 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6171575018141171, + "veriT": 12.78361855257266, + "Yices": 7.9326803514281998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9034129152860242, + "CVC4": 1.7968431176949786, + "CVC3": 4.748544565601776, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21852347864063637, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.391686888830276 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2560196017599994, + "veriT": 9.0286353616393331, + "Yices": 9.0255004088719506, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4699328998309271, + "CVC4": 8.3538703504710519, + "CVC3": 5.9352377509804066, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.952566206088258, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.948860481461988 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245269040929426, + "veriT": 12.048207626209614, + "Yices": 11.374713962978152, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.499507481856812, + "CVC4": 13.888464711831203, + "CVC3": 14.238623156755571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241088674426663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.162797811431666 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 111.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9134169059676953, + "veriT": 11.93672550826119, + "Yices": 9.8666836869529, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6145689212522658, + "CVC4": 3.0599816449457911, + "CVC3": 3.8575733599964752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9199987064914961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9178672147483304 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.35912251028169, + "veriT": 13.647530210623726, + "Yices": 13.811489389704958, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954055804165224, + "CVC4": 14.285017757617416, + "CVC3": 13.762422987647247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.212355767251987, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.074589282222854 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4876976953774577, + "veriT": 13.546057211005007, + "Yices": 12.076606326288427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.37803829361129, + "CVC4": 12.720646183536623, + "CVC3": 14.177833847684008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2734815158589621, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2182307448965917 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7543343466683687, + "veriT": 10.960023851062758, + "Yices": 10.089037947510757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7585662561175202, + "CVC4": 10.97977284462748, + "CVC3": 9.1492012192651622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.708057856535024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3563839825710287 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 133.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.501352944653719, + "veriT": 12.228572436309751, + "Yices": 12.794827949546326, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.670677280709299, + "CVC4": 14.561692915262649, + "CVC3": 13.682284089901259, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.111433963454408, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.282861628377685 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1617541313171387, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1788146255119543, + "veriT": 13.546956265805399, + "Yices": 13.547933014040524, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.058496732198064, + "CVC4": 14.416518274266437, + "CVC3": 6.0485023824173325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.624441237114096, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3129307935601133 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2073395241519997, + "veriT": 13.827287943928464, + "Yices": 14.088147030809264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.703479101083079, + "CVC4": 14.638165722892534, + "CVC3": 11.384424790621901, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.250863604374715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.247081500498263 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.928363561630249, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.18136808793227, + "veriT": 13.652617368526426, + "Yices": 13.819807646962195, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.540768641367148, + "CVC4": 12.612481191468026, + "CVC3": 13.929577573621861, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249319670689625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.250234074692518 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.255808766253908, + "veriT": 11.357418531675211, + "Yices": 14.11938375056687, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97445402961954, + "CVC4": 14.621729932646186, + "CVC3": 13.831354682858693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.966035684070174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.224046237735335 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5326004827261128, + "veriT": 14.239848888868314, + "Yices": 14.240720235636912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.111401942541869, + "CVC4": 12.501796365102116, + "CVC3": 12.62814241223724, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6428785251320059, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6673608124660122 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.270351614075722, + "veriT": 13.601951313931757, + "Yices": 13.515660353576626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.993307474937401, + "CVC4": 14.824839169132801, + "CVC3": 13.397124968560291, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.324144405736098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.815735175801288 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11995496842066666, + "veriT": 0.090263184123988885, + "Yices": 0.095575803797538883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11946771157365557, + "CVC4": 0.11382081333418886, + "CVC3": 0.099734847290822215, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11250273910076111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11279278670966665 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1350780642810476, + "veriT": 0.10800561382365238, + "Yices": 0.10833067531088096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13157995320590476, + "CVC4": 0.13200445856095236, + "CVC3": 0.11270610610735236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13218464487371429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12798898179572382 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2331046133205139, + "veriT": 1.0193658628637909, + "Yices": 1.9588712456541728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2915919046146551, + "CVC4": 0.14093167813872728, + "CVC3": 1.4004031890081468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13406395325563636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4332089689385219 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7690362412847693, + "veriT": 10.163422851314445, + "Yices": 10.352015121556249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8953401017159861, + "CVC4": 0.15132882212669443, + "CVC3": 0.70082079642886119, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14713014662291668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.431691113869654 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17918234369033337, + "veriT": 6.8138335402278889, + "Yices": 9.4804961088254434, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28364317098877773, + "CVC4": 0.15100777523033335, + "CVC3": 0.23500893034866666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14727192047233331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0418430793744444 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9460982311832868, + "veriT": 12.151111579098478, + "Yices": 10.872243987183651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7038977973057712, + "CVC4": 13.760754591579461, + "CVC3": 8.8778053461919288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.210460501118378, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.216895752681415 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6601887054196256, + "veriT": 5.0372706345852212, + "Yices": 5.1376031911162165, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1954816583237111, + "CVC4": 3.4506882254947207, + "CVC3": 4.1591005973868551, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2715013987078141, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.738056376337572 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0999999046325684, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.852962408248388, + "veriT": 9.9887266532962702, + "Yices": 10.28596910739442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.418420604273956, + "CVC4": 1.7429477184259476, + "CVC3": 12.006287814767234, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.744217782071829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.689405522099165 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4439509503909038, + "veriT": 7.9982707121361427, + "Yices": 9.417025148267923, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6867234963417364, + "CVC4": 1.7006192015574941, + "CVC3": 10.445030164252815, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.173936254400358, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3482595330691476 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237287957370981, + "veriT": 10.161495566344001, + "Yices": 10.3381917111225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956974395720763, + "CVC4": 0.16672505795183334, + "CVC3": 11.196102158421937, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14820267174999999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.772151256818008 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.296281751722242, + "veriT": 10.166221148675, + "Yices": 10.316734423749168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95385213099658, + "CVC4": 0.16079631666183333, + "CVC3": 11.271878643196588, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1018055355126235, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.727450383556418 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.193628191673092, + "veriT": 8.4627802000445342, + "Yices": 10.922101924243599, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.671170310941022, + "CVC4": 0.14985195828600001, + "CVC3": 9.4302994347821052, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4838024852190679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.436128714476177 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7750000953674316, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3000001907348633, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4139311497875102, + "veriT": 4.8900320631215557, + "Yices": 4.1526864907526235, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6759057333115681, + "CVC4": 3.9533190485349166, + "CVC3": 3.6409290167608797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4179526701366303, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4171792066810305 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.929443830951751, + "veriT": 10.688913531786216, + "Yices": 10.96063690320371, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.665466154830149, + "CVC4": 12.062405572607702, + "CVC3": 8.011647376799564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.466123274493961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9703238050853571 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2790781336994712, + "veriT": 12.543808277093177, + "Yices": 8.3547901084535034, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7807218578372215, + "CVC4": 5.9672650248390138, + "CVC3": 8.693621468186647, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.409172538314944, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.408147874530666 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1844744587409348, + "veriT": 5.0130709087041661, + "Yices": 7.085433963461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3963303490445247, + "CVC4": 2.1893897534585722, + "CVC3": 5.9892278308272973, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16853094848457142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3973540256392054 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12350175340792, + "veriT": 5.3581834448241743, + "Yices": 0.10168761418450001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12327796728, + "CVC4": 1.6041706885444582, + "CVC3": 0.10793290178918998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1220492704937999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1196467424200198 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6964649584649809, + "veriT": 6.0467918218908245, + "Yices": 13.546044600763567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6568947393453541, + "CVC4": 12.085251351349173, + "CVC3": 11.749904781612519, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2234827179063483, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2427586041213043 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.75, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.472327033919701, + "veriT": 13.407119199710717, + "Yices": 13.458519169323392, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.000556951411252, + "CVC4": 11.865493094695157, + "CVC3": 15.238353527367185, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.730352368684551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.857274431549783 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.092992955493937, + "veriT": 11.957368243094745, + "Yices": 12.821771017075557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.230256249137501, + "CVC4": 4.0800157439840952, + "CVC3": 10.595733271445763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8977162398811718, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5368526946625813 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2444443702697754, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.961538553237915, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6051679915762556, + "veriT": 9.162977245735787, + "Yices": 10.799640738485337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2695497480035467, + "CVC4": 8.9444851995921262, + "CVC3": 4.7169808658108954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.650724989052085, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.943323774832038 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.316369752762672, + "veriT": 7.4451638416670001, + "Yices": 11.753640888173727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4695723881784568, + "CVC4": 4.0418930040588998, + "CVC3": 6.3447191171735451, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7498062718350309, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2696529696690622 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.697783223950246, + "veriT": 13.261506192648657, + "Yices": 9.4914215630132741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.699670184516716, + "CVC4": 13.724368195710175, + "CVC3": 12.557694829376867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.279602767552587, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.274279918871555 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6441041617535954, + "veriT": 6.5193336748440727, + "Yices": 7.1491959883314111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1665660692212203, + "CVC4": 2.3213213321052497, + "CVC3": 9.0960524236475884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6352463954036009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6336872956130115 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.839408511688262, + "veriT": 10.1674405658709, + "Yices": 10.338540778488802, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.485314356640805, + "CVC4": 0.17104390859820001, + "CVC3": 11.796627770051035, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5756006181510114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.279830285075766 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19853179791025, + "veriT": 7.5300323236680873, + "Yices": 7.2651873481574754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4512384463276249, + "CVC4": 7.3828733371928781, + "CVC3": 8.3098173927496255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2673233229236773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2345112081625187 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2286606381283636, + "veriT": 0.12619125468638182, + "Yices": 4.5500145339096205, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.43291674948772718, + "CVC4": 0.20276105027754543, + "CVC3": 1.110207896707182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.152888313646, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15229420103800004 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7026644945144653, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1746435929151176, + "veriT": 6.6543330271465608, + "Yices": 1.9114138158410712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2367924944498039, + "CVC4": 0.25665403920535712, + "CVC3": 1.189080731296311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.082153407218852, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.727559701876361 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8054139132480809, + "veriT": 7.2576651004760793, + "Yices": 8.2456965644377824, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0261690087124791, + "CVC4": 1.8172190969857178, + "CVC3": 3.7246424092873585, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5011737716263234, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8581737582049511 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1775178047166701, + "veriT": 13.540826203626931, + "Yices": 4.8363983470142884, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6757871090282306, + "CVC4": 4.3581440627591777, + "CVC3": 8.5789620843214163, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5845150033334527, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3830960544328836 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14925113047622224, + "veriT": 4.8129971808551479, + "Yices": 1.3041929553032188, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17930103120388888, + "CVC4": 1.7235585159788718, + "CVC3": 0.13140619496255557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14251590267033334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14118095368700001 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1979722140891007, + "veriT": 14.220665020119316, + "Yices": 7.654237183569899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9848314158749645, + "CVC4": 4.7754425035944186, + "CVC3": 7.5422016825892442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.572978623991995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.578961451842636 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5491514661005734, + "veriT": 11.749051134123524, + "Yices": 12.340340022788494, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3067895086075598, + "CVC4": 8.1060572340540862, + "CVC3": 8.0481322126430257, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9864973831692376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.367225995833975 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8528139591217041, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.925447594874038, + "veriT": 10.971864799418878, + "Yices": 9.4975085781951769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.01393168829544, + "CVC4": 1.6004884487300646, + "CVC3": 12.837253063216744, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5529252511791021, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.54818558773756 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6986734867095947, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.018268235284664, + "veriT": 12.406062323337579, + "Yices": 6.5652310303874435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.502052357364729, + "CVC4": 3.287124636901293, + "CVC3": 7.5361732459334529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2761694447654541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2294977631157558 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0176361822409423, + "veriT": 5.0172718687054445, + "Yices": 3.4765713280801673, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0574026770538385, + "CVC4": 0.16347207183533335, + "CVC3": 2.0539969208248126, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4781009430316465, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4786079082492538 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2815957067685124, + "veriT": 12.218795438877908, + "Yices": 8.1222365250981099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8336474302523964, + "CVC4": 11.483381636335071, + "CVC3": 8.1894120992544011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257391741494086, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.765173945637445 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.509775625252542, + "veriT": 10.812286493660793, + "Yices": 4.7085985204090095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.491913621316044, + "CVC4": 2.123511466904775, + "CVC3": 4.9144320141813109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230495213191451, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.455074526671188 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3431370258331299, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9605744602720483, + "veriT": 7.1350550322072595, + "Yices": 7.2602735306739605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1375594855893452, + "CVC4": 6.3971395646112201, + "CVC3": 3.684486698888608, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1437205838638445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.139618672352503 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1294556703780769, + "veriT": 7.6545595260811776, + "Yices": 7.9734840934312849, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12984447057746154, + "CVC4": 0.13741411021338459, + "CVC3": 0.11466198641726155, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13289424970592309, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13010162115430768 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2183330818265352, + "veriT": 10.695246428608154, + "Yices": 10.109301334711128, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0332575881619102, + "CVC4": 13.179681007216336, + "CVC3": 7.8706033736501393, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.646346196264391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.639292965356569 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.877884575865412, + "veriT": 9.2735317819660938, + "Yices": 9.1245380931102194, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.141295152978952, + "CVC4": 9.3512898306174037, + "CVC3": 7.9136343700847016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8016157456786921, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8145200847223126 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15625000435000003, + "veriT": 1.2433340208810111, + "Yices": 10.187370102705167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15549671551277777, + "CVC4": 0.15825811764644446, + "CVC3": 0.14051298846566665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15511768411655555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15419108279399998 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1827629532025004, + "veriT": 0.1448952888383, + "Yices": 1.5549176622615206, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3493112049644997, + "CVC4": 0.1708842662567, + "CVC3": 0.1642196761162, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16988803981980002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16689546636579999 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14001503269618179, + "veriT": 7.4721632633595592, + "Yices": 0.1380023005379091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14365033067899999, + "CVC4": 0.15514855454027274, + "CVC3": 0.13388770796545454, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14657587572881819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14859014105163634 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9935064315795898, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18067830945410002, + "veriT": 0.1578974312011, + "Yices": 0.16128666968380001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18365404921720002, + "CVC4": 0.21241297239890003, + "CVC3": 0.18711919566340002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18497244459920004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18644289567889999 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1617904656561111, + "veriT": 0.13998425950455556, + "Yices": 0.15261630830522221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.162603142703, + "CVC4": 0.18052654908066668, + "CVC3": 0.16002081170844443, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1733762666168889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17193270712799999 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9889574216704957, + "veriT": 3.7155645942224056, + "Yices": 8.4728438387595766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2450903099046089, + "CVC4": 1.9863802307506444, + "CVC3": 7.2191729038608843, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.217838261468442, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2275025259987213 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0728070735931396, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4955071958548558, + "veriT": 0.72304918167759991, + "Yices": 0.71894817155193746, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4949077803826309, + "CVC4": 13.380325532213302, + "CVC3": 0.10083006514485, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11545256839621251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11522344615351252 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9479801718990055, + "veriT": 10.6837713536083, + "Yices": 6.0202857446945117, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9282020380344074, + "CVC4": 8.1536966593621578, + "CVC3": 2.5363485571457778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0592511261471955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0710514511724458 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2247476577758789, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 75.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23435275949318182, + "veriT": 12.363095943505623, + "Yices": 8.9550130648718955, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0544068061721819, + "CVC4": 6.6137428925792907, + "CVC3": 1.8319657316019269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3883395960604474, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6399813113290747 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21514569079612497, + "veriT": 8.5442818915329095, + "Yices": 1.8991303955844192, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.47105424269350005, + "CVC4": 1.9466931305115911, + "CVC3": 0.20251340506024998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16614867930900001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16083811725837499 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1469993686430948, + "veriT": 10.945557870711449, + "Yices": 3.1907252400878767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0612016594722053, + "CVC4": 3.7413279568303777, + "CVC3": 9.9917853564834154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.444803768516223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.098111934792367 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.576498326459931, + "veriT": 11.143844736379902, + "Yices": 11.657863539218589, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.330596695958034, + "CVC4": 11.153296116094509, + "CVC3": 9.0242193677970555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.574044987137379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.440246556813136 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1315429924090221, + "veriT": 5.1966770500698454, + "Yices": 10.403375626902216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.488453799421448, + "CVC4": 9.4798447239931978, + "CVC3": 9.3082212305634027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1346780407033847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8741291133129501 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9351869821548462, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6514924764633179, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.252869439871191, + "veriT": 12.464415686081017, + "Yices": 5.3152800025920754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8775144523877954, + "CVC4": 6.3396388993069035, + "CVC3": 4.3681931223896422, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6866914901102801, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6893035162111181 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 169.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 134.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9045283681527252, + "veriT": 12.690843937372453, + "Yices": 13.527180814493217, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.156666699634288, + "CVC4": 12.94909672075239, + "CVC3": 8.844657793679449, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235393768558765, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.239331333231533 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.258557900847636, + "veriT": 11.367916203226917, + "Yices": 11.257851924023084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.982285077709648, + "CVC4": 14.301053059493293, + "CVC3": 14.261910050257582, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.262938041016699, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.247276503395877 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5137543945374023, + "veriT": 12.565301237845761, + "Yices": 13.697242540408618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1752772799352496, + "CVC4": 14.558390819636209, + "CVC3": 10.234514496500891, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.127194229004825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.122612528233212 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 105.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2536696088034827, + "veriT": 12.241379507656566, + "Yices": 7.7369163149901086, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2391389967162931, + "CVC4": 4.9372661193867629, + "CVC3": 3.4748426142271422, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.035815777753891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0585860663564466 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21538320761659996, + "veriT": 2.994994058012892, + "Yices": 0.50082010232910013, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.67585209153089998, + "CVC4": 0.20331399690420002, + "CVC3": 2.9096337751700778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15832200048459999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15228236891469998 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7819681243240479, + "veriT": 11.887552451701858, + "Yices": 9.5480388770011064, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.187005028585988, + "CVC4": 4.2927155535911128, + "CVC3": 2.0204832356310001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1872488192943333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2239425933598336 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5301400587979965, + "veriT": 11.705195948328255, + "Yices": 11.139675866928709, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0716503117414344, + "CVC4": 12.44395964879746, + "CVC3": 6.7175593384963648, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.227753555320055, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4402574158267942 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.269701983523591, + "veriT": 11.985880257994827, + "Yices": 11.664172152770758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.969505344621203, + "CVC4": 14.31582476322304, + "CVC3": 12.406082288329015, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.442181985173031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.745458725732609 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1963334083557129, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.657217918611025, + "veriT": 11.316355612083091, + "Yices": 11.38929475248753, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959242677954665, + "CVC4": 13.824794738020193, + "CVC3": 14.235367916710894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.67288055137473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.12239131470727 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1393804332639625, + "veriT": 14.272824666503865, + "Yices": 14.270927071917706, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.520610342684702, + "CVC4": 14.759228337839033, + "CVC3": 13.951515151805211, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7968878495917004, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8818899509439 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 90.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5340398538643472, + "veriT": 12.863904402234715, + "Yices": 11.84253283080052, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7427859143227433, + "CVC4": 8.6983354523425298, + "CVC3": 13.548787720525416, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.777305782444282, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.106575045068274 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 168.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7128824327004519, + "veriT": 13.979815572725453, + "Yices": 13.948987119210271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958999227289945, + "CVC4": 14.384186926919888, + "CVC3": 12.301744738107539, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.172684029511338, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.162684419205611 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.473733866954614, + "veriT": 9.5209902129655646, + "Yices": 12.09033290369781, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.970609442666317, + "CVC4": 14.776002414038587, + "CVC3": 10.910350834770711, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.502292468797185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.034094503437093 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8975135194134465, + "veriT": 14.249975595048062, + "Yices": 14.256602423415492, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.265408385391238, + "CVC4": 12.378010920964572, + "CVC3": 12.284318177466242, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0111772064223636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0422009356525272 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 38.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.267457021220475, + "veriT": 14.229304227459059, + "Yices": 14.377496845736939, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.137904169932185, + "CVC4": 14.640832792077623, + "CVC3": 13.053871840353679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252371039560455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.256806866084682 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259875303090713, + "veriT": 12.638490960697021, + "Yices": 13.03938547627707, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974701474553763, + "CVC4": 14.68262929384348, + "CVC3": 14.27133347304113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.397340906393286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.158778692580032 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12940167255382604, + "veriT": 0.10227669325574784, + "Yices": 0.10215220230266522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12712062510504349, + "CVC4": 0.12715194170291302, + "CVC3": 0.10772707442643478, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12654618740878262, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12373613301996522 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11788603770874284, + "veriT": 0.089971018926052373, + "Yices": 0.094580263614861895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11838638625801903, + "CVC4": 0.11512825758854288, + "CVC3": 0.096079227025461927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11273583822152855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11156747460680953 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8546186718542206, + "veriT": 11.096447286044032, + "Yices": 10.214372832419512, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.102783667195506, + "CVC4": 12.533834858484012, + "CVC3": 8.3902658143575461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9183295973983867, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9146629748290174 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0955523639707296, + "veriT": 5.8653070063045005, + "Yices": 8.4098015275938298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7605925485044986, + "CVC4": 0.15995126786664285, + "CVC3": 3.7236762304970377, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15389252110992854, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4579961976545199 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2033991994268938, + "veriT": 7.4582408718401947, + "Yices": 6.9951823918859866, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8609494871194379, + "CVC4": 3.8710204361838012, + "CVC3": 4.7672454819204262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3719232867013105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2251054127205023 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243999859399803, + "veriT": 10.172165388826199, + "Yices": 10.340676083386901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961811623292732, + "CVC4": 0.15818391957390002, + "CVC3": 9.3054557902713064, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3754522658681836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.34686450477397 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.967948025035339, + "veriT": 10.430916751643723, + "Yices": 10.424794439391999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.634682028027306, + "CVC4": 1.1595874177939096, + "CVC3": 12.970327559818866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5573412941238285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.871195548379076 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.830168388972373, + "veriT": 10.579584800570625, + "Yices": 10.679961015195813, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.46354494380132, + "CVC4": 1.1654548152308, + "CVC3": 12.502223563102721, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.872205179144773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.256339860758461 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4508434986762584, + "veriT": 12.184429818141464, + "Yices": 5.2218562500285879, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7479366451262806, + "CVC4": 0.38632053993562504, + "CVC3": 7.2636249924282437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4948870502389999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9911383562015459 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1547620296478271, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7965514659881592, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5679651543173039, + "veriT": 9.5947505039427519, + "Yices": 4.4807721071129407, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2898163847177999, + "CVC4": 4.5420572037626545, + "CVC3": 3.9775095173370461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9993394350997464, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9942954170204565 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.529655783094042, + "veriT": 12.478585751768424, + "Yices": 12.2053276275036, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.853436208653223, + "CVC4": 4.9853706766262018, + "CVC3": 9.5169000766259213, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6328825423463158, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5809790998833808 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1427957936555817, + "veriT": 1.7893384683802682, + "Yices": 7.5756453217608852, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2442467848516614, + "CVC4": 0.19988551528157142, + "CVC3": 2.1473518097822701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8764179573053312, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8756443861316756 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9487153040849368, + "veriT": 11.411348253224464, + "Yices": 12.770830166096303, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6385845067593685, + "CVC4": 14.425324327340755, + "CVC3": 9.2810790161206729, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.431529032038725, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.631627607264083 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.371733066996027, + "veriT": 10.693271182546621, + "Yices": 9.6659354624204603, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.592463494997213, + "CVC4": 2.2772449346348211, + "CVC3": 12.786088283186045, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1906324775037245, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.618556200559196 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.188708359167526, + "veriT": 7.3991853272844841, + "Yices": 5.5624597367990001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5477280962630431, + "CVC4": 2.0218083311820259, + "CVC3": 11.91061964721823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4302312433428215, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8374945209286135 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.59526733181253855, + "veriT": 13.987574516264933, + "Yices": 7.0494861735132153, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1477556608691586, + "CVC4": 6.4573033926276606, + "CVC3": 3.5052260769194135, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.261978912191019, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.301675142454833 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7500910405073231, + "veriT": 14.208287084811641, + "Yices": 10.663074853372049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.207370425057483, + "CVC4": 11.704522113572821, + "CVC3": 8.7494559090163264, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.664964453547281, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.667136669700218 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.79351502472360658, + "veriT": 7.1164944059627304, + "Yices": 0.77319208379229321, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.78942476850793342, + "CVC4": 2.7698844094546113, + "CVC3": 0.78041240582883986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4610464526584666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4566903488618399 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2243032096100697, + "veriT": 11.996725282083204, + "Yices": 7.9328332014385978, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4197212208813506, + "CVC4": 2.3218506913684194, + "CVC3": 6.7582635080361104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0445903525328504, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6745827591760518 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1505291771911024, + "veriT": 6.2802723154433586, + "Yices": 12.646911467681845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0682033722754616, + "CVC4": 13.369402002785552, + "CVC3": 13.619722931628154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5759584701595699, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5997411232909897 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7527780532836914, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2580185418421843, + "veriT": 9.045504602041138, + "Yices": 9.2099152907052613, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3738615304144681, + "CVC4": 0.14795218142888886, + "CVC3": 0.55921301763061126, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14711122852897221, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0468221965085771 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234385307247752, + "veriT": 11.971489965979764, + "Yices": 10.8318738605271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.946711922036933, + "CVC4": 6.7245440991011476, + "CVC3": 12.926410696753425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6631040823181769, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.66379147849524 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.039464663078576, + "veriT": 10.370537088196743, + "Yices": 9.8457175197679483, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.72480561554751, + "CVC4": 0.16333480638865, + "CVC3": 10.951910940576088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.829591245284772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.845267734812705 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2517422550586668, + "veriT": 1.2280065039435555, + "Yices": 2.3689354172227777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2453929025021111, + "CVC4": 1.8121605515649557, + "CVC3": 1.7048793348204383, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.103784380214897, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5958233080801243 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2552790759244452, + "veriT": 7.7178513264525606, + "Yices": 5.8077278829516672, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5640811771677487, + "CVC4": 1.7270670689641454, + "CVC3": 5.0427024203612723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7162439303734636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8749654289150879 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.094778128827302, + "veriT": 11.357467555692425, + "Yices": 10.270068278976446, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.628127657570886, + "CVC4": 11.716762676558277, + "CVC3": 13.568980663891685, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235652338693349, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.356590602859903 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 37.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5625, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1451806313023649, + "veriT": 11.545383154303373, + "Yices": 12.70089258642858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2296531514793116, + "CVC4": 11.681169003270407, + "CVC3": 8.2798626126281949, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.324699697506041, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.638879461074698 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.568196170127778, + "veriT": 0.86042435860893118, + "Yices": 0.86541170493177866, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2220867746570889, + "CVC4": 0.11160832844436112, + "CVC3": 0.10053476507297779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10783839213306666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1105403373765889 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0416665077209473, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4870395158436942, + "veriT": 2.4472344654394114, + "Yices": 8.9380980333352866, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8068804767133848, + "CVC4": 2.9431576383531253, + "CVC3": 1.7216562977743104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6796550170851179, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.676480014360707 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16660912258752941, + "veriT": 6.8747705894467463, + "Yices": 8.7397772072610387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.44538244246923536, + "CVC4": 0.36398585360429409, + "CVC3": 0.17950822736652944, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.796074110407021, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8159491681501501 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7383174369170311, + "veriT": 5.691973563762434, + "Yices": 6.861323556032767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.91078871528722216, + "CVC4": 3.2934529506878163, + "CVC3": 0.22641747359786665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.289306611972366, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.227692952695115 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5397835855556448, + "veriT": 10.132303674137647, + "Yices": 10.134108957637574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2231400395470704, + "CVC4": 4.3109839908292455, + "CVC3": 5.063341177123819, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.993234211678669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.75641727719942 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1400161733962006, + "veriT": 0.10506449914966001, + "Yices": 9.3027123997112007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1320308729930395, + "CVC4": 10.015022365230926, + "CVC3": 5.1848631085877006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16489137793162001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16056947228400001 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8898241440339092, + "veriT": 9.0847456661754329, + "Yices": 5.1324321593353908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1056228363617269, + "CVC4": 8.9121609302368956, + "CVC3": 9.1799576835725158, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6072991324848775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.604236390214087 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4260514003159788, + "veriT": 11.193719383988759, + "Yices": 12.884969966373951, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.875523906658756, + "CVC4": 14.611759039034903, + "CVC3": 12.365726552970125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.894025315494437, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.430676759636844 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.99893793304931, + "veriT": 5.82326425112264, + "Yices": 12.97760606016943, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.502413831777048, + "CVC4": 2.5986512004211626, + "CVC3": 7.3645296319767839, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6264694730196165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6154341923467102 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.962453691565521, + "veriT": 10.945106630566796, + "Yices": 11.42151950487969, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.606143906830845, + "CVC4": 10.328484140414178, + "CVC3": 6.8831671350432906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2707247763581009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.8967341510259 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6117783116695714, + "veriT": 1.5890665989232855, + "Yices": 4.4485137187504291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6236052359125712, + "CVC4": 1.606856907654286, + "CVC3": 1.9230112201171168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1868409113625424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.18701481169406 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14863864519344447, + "veriT": 0.12798086258559999, + "Yices": 0.14142467826300001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14297975840577778, + "CVC4": 0.17020919292555556, + "CVC3": 0.14341872334077777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16261812782344445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15760828677155556 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.553158381021857, + "veriT": 0.10340695859465716, + "Yices": 0.11258161880294285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5512869089171717, + "CVC4": 4.1729040149059973, + "CVC3": 0.11731635105602857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13165158221742859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13212482594142855 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.28454026245337499, + "veriT": 7.8873979135169892, + "Yices": 9.3125624482583724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5100691835959701, + "CVC4": 7.3951625368721485, + "CVC3": 0.33525834522824999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.676583342387552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6726910763392544 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1469055562562222, + "veriT": 3.9132386815828344, + "Yices": 0.1851262694618111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19380935070877778, + "CVC4": 0.17902813338911111, + "CVC3": 0.14143583364767778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1719027644486, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17013859315929999 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19397781437309092, + "veriT": 2.8778609035971638, + "Yices": 11.831297449505099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34859122173288187, + "CVC4": 4.0439972451701314, + "CVC3": 0.18451279442190002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4302006734649793, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4343307888098178 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15755448995223073, + "veriT": 7.6220323867162172, + "Yices": 0.16610920597938461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17932103977930769, + "CVC4": 0.1796464356523077, + "CVC3": 0.34322942837146148, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16370511937600002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16312176172553847 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19599932156364283, + "veriT": 5.9353255537268392, + "Yices": 10.775004818248629, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6400682526449999, + "CVC4": 1.236418301752489, + "CVC3": 8.5142694539498542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2157340106374588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2140637004912989 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0419111040670535, + "veriT": 4.8433103780208775, + "Yices": 1.3809184866795445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1414000623840375, + "CVC4": 6.5442419937329142, + "CVC3": 0.24154121449311117, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16389544299212222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15977245661116671 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4526997168878726, + "veriT": 8.9526474441540813, + "Yices": 8.7066192722508458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3762724007828124, + "CVC4": 12.86664735772648, + "CVC3": 11.142774210816677, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4066335351102772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.060329174268226 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7104357945806745, + "veriT": 7.4411680887195466, + "Yices": 7.7268419892020912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5413914282792138, + "CVC4": 11.760863527905052, + "CVC3": 1.9141299733896893, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8650831263510668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.728565549207735 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2415951659704705, + "veriT": 8.0444416439789297, + "Yices": 8.7211814704892578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7975152464962898, + "CVC4": 10.057930243751834, + "CVC3": 4.6260324293113824, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7065506979364626, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9075656314289411 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1398043632507324, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.789775844646182, + "veriT": 0.10979173187368181, + "Yices": 0.44490204576600001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1245699068483637, + "CVC4": 1.4348414052477387, + "CVC3": 0.12820490499563636, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14437791023336366, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14672269564099999 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24333974558531432, + "veriT": 6.4288118210626166, + "Yices": 2.9927433603216573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.43285005059057141, + "CVC4": 0.39626754450699997, + "CVC3": 4.0570123420426247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1744848957820704, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1704265794963602 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2595896572579459, + "veriT": 14.254316895944751, + "Yices": 11.433846690122042, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.959493835220636, + "CVC4": 10.885858336728324, + "CVC3": 10.064644944911484, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1804071302198, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3302753768267994 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 140.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8110784338829422, + "veriT": 13.39589891459703, + "Yices": 9.6187902526586218, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5416117270316523, + "CVC4": 6.1111200040208811, + "CVC3": 8.0264000679091723, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8941228743466887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.818882099205382 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.568734189711838, + "veriT": 11.910608168026418, + "Yices": 10.498819218218779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.969232592296178, + "CVC4": 14.473290784054941, + "CVC3": 13.652819064033272, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.06354431211061, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.432224302850855 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.50765216503862498, + "veriT": 9.1843949090033998, + "Yices": 4.1275533162646258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3587101286080534, + "CVC4": 3.7739079450810897, + "CVC3": 0.34976090527675002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.72788205466588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.049992787210723 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1347064313075719, + "veriT": 13.38081761739465, + "Yices": 12.832713670227713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6463875477476266, + "CVC4": 14.253795753531392, + "CVC3": 10.662340719221461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23423577475331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.233869336376111 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0592527403263272, + "veriT": 13.105532521586332, + "Yices": 9.1805983933845994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.819669834255796, + "CVC4": 0.47676401937299995, + "CVC3": 4.3231042451748127, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21697306838428571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5403898744478135 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.685757745378393, + "veriT": 13.151846828094875, + "Yices": 12.287992032714579, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.94963778986846, + "CVC4": 13.887407899751834, + "CVC3": 13.410765090401013, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.365952182488961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.950622124262164 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 62.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1589139407767934, + "veriT": 11.098738328571319, + "Yices": 10.290351391315021, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.319354507058453, + "CVC4": 10.61116622543568, + "CVC3": 12.577759244432963, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.150068615386035, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.200180423099205 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.36311179963845458, + "veriT": 10.568072711950226, + "Yices": 4.1668080580753077, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9561244847220911, + "CVC4": 6.8347620801781295, + "CVC3": 0.37297656363536363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.934829583504683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.951323253076341 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7053552745923479, + "veriT": 11.676162542834962, + "Yices": 11.194753593424682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.182387291460726, + "CVC4": 11.886021139920134, + "CVC3": 11.541144757281867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.8474186203706, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.133914065255476 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23624812241166668, + "veriT": 13.534710216923637, + "Yices": 11.696147583066677, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.87892183993538, + "CVC4": 10.228654892479156, + "CVC3": 3.0190866520536246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9073950961882336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9038057706815152 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1010988073679586, + "veriT": 14.221935364965853, + "Yices": 12.307008999729753, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.221534041036897, + "CVC4": 14.496627200027815, + "CVC3": 11.136363834492709, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.036029846830962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.980326445000449 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.394637023615706, + "veriT": 13.145216375536318, + "Yices": 13.711237036054591, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960504598254607, + "CVC4": 14.872207396363367, + "CVC3": 14.256442642385446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.862003390041037, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.895474192046807 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 70.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.252052467287966, + "veriT": 12.916087441524018, + "Yices": 8.6139145618155464, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.52569065324915, + "CVC4": 7.4716546428737232, + "CVC3": 9.8537454840470797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.933872406121683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3213206683609791 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257933415761686, + "veriT": 12.218631722876738, + "Yices": 11.950231424225956, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.981075267509041, + "CVC4": 14.304216462387787, + "CVC3": 14.2547817924744, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232961631853827, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.696785258158066 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9666597781292277, + "veriT": 9.5310051331883017, + "Yices": 12.810413998884778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.881452985568073, + "CVC4": 13.340266415827996, + "CVC3": 10.920973595073361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3503129631379318, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.131733162995034 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8550797902088334, + "veriT": 9.9103958268002135, + "Yices": 5.0216481796288583, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.446792366775579, + "CVC4": 5.5199109551739882, + "CVC3": 9.4612586130181153, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2224448278061667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.218860480528 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 243.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.33362786842938, + "veriT": 11.653998183775338, + "Yices": 12.072548203412616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966871759047905, + "CVC4": 13.199830151513181, + "CVC3": 11.950302192920054, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.597189350702111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.782146275719441 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1738095043934997, + "veriT": 14.636005286253333, + "Yices": 11.326284472616559, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.408963054075642, + "CVC4": 9.0329197436313446, + "CVC3": 8.2936209055317587, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.476563628182804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.430978287741823 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 204.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9939685125692126, + "veriT": 12.920218573588642, + "Yices": 12.68449696340833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.556717846270326, + "CVC4": 12.117179436759784, + "CVC3": 14.419845037788619, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.27459207661547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.297672609416738 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 303.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.262451822849483, + "veriT": 11.472778253920398, + "Yices": 14.085339994445917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.045918263887026, + "CVC4": 14.705970593162982, + "CVC3": 14.25359738322644, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.17557587349271, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.780084270885068 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259813910546546, + "veriT": 14.250790530888072, + "Yices": 14.247981330295318, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974653098497791, + "CVC4": 14.832929675740795, + "CVC3": 12.8713767595296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.973845658930598, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.976731227493415 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 57.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11858861575334483, + "veriT": 0.089497018843934475, + "Yices": 0.094514354450979304, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11523810554272415, + "CVC4": 0.11909525878665519, + "CVC3": 0.095130497950331031, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11456257423682759, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11375133409166896 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10407285794078666, + "veriT": 0.074715597326846669, + "Yices": 0.081176446097326674, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10418309494656666, + "CVC4": 0.099220037462426663, + "CVC3": 0.081680753145333337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.097280635370673316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.096868787464646652 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3910686678972866, + "veriT": 1.3697710474894487, + "Yices": 1.119305325316325, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4784483120637439, + "CVC4": 1.9010158114520328, + "CVC3": 0.11924905334981249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14025680459137502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13961080196025 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4508917921883464, + "veriT": 9.2793654960353642, + "Yices": 10.513145538905967, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7701170930739245, + "CVC4": 5.0837767701511511, + "CVC3": 5.1240887631515042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8430518217993539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8822278587149466 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20292657002237499, + "veriT": 9.8553713350360308, + "Yices": 10.030556486050719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28509472265578129, + "CVC4": 0.15002279347446873, + "CVC3": 0.61612883343037494, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14997908382196873, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6008989401104543 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1208333969116211, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7894084453582764, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5454167121461824, + "veriT": 7.4952268382300842, + "Yices": 8.4179351134234039, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3855150221678096, + "CVC4": 2.6279335248399422, + "CVC3": 2.6668109840029999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4941853116745532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8944901025524512 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242153990881835, + "veriT": 10.1765482893476, + "Yices": 10.32986908586, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960854960061543, + "CVC4": 0.15693173311759998, + "CVC3": 12.057018136447192, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4058711687372023, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.336673585649326 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.912025195739782, + "veriT": 10.738026205639761, + "Yices": 10.560521678438338, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.265812220741921, + "CVC4": 2.2541149819994493, + "CVC3": 11.229495496386559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1567415615838321, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.743811133266021 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.128452218910525, + "veriT": 7.4384152071859093, + "Yices": 11.40330423187407, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.655431560509966, + "CVC4": 0.17531913549372727, + "CVC3": 13.851180593244123, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15780979043490909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2714715933088492 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5105241607652382, + "veriT": 4.16471401928096, + "Yices": 2.0521366015383333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6251458070477804, + "CVC4": 0.1933796449803333, + "CVC3": 2.5180932356787831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19853565558233333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1242598250220373 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4072597667109994, + "veriT": 11.095572677141757, + "Yices": 9.0990645873378124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5908806628814398, + "CVC4": 9.7404653163760653, + "CVC3": 10.677106791407885, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7374125156551385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.735023138024115 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6172165870666504, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.314519923814801, + "veriT": 13.398509660256176, + "Yices": 12.744467065571747, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.565766915655875, + "CVC4": 14.630881971613841, + "CVC3": 13.834751930786961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23307730681679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236905674139013 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.378159099368403, + "veriT": 10.995070482594993, + "Yices": 8.1020203104912145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.499775685892043, + "CVC4": 3.4693993850782214, + "CVC3": 11.196899447285036, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0996443855457159, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4720510412367407 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8285715579986572, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.234312115986512, + "veriT": 10.160959068876499, + "Yices": 10.322941693110666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954433927151555, + "CVC4": 0.16689413202916667, + "CVC3": 13.603700660546004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.025820552647275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.262936625842222 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.777342136366919, + "veriT": 10.405411640493153, + "Yices": 10.332861205338109, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.411144760123145, + "CVC4": 2.9170030868151731, + "CVC3": 7.992247616900455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242095393564618, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.807669767587718 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3534110487459916, + "veriT": 8.666891705542799, + "Yices": 9.88182770320401, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2784172120794315, + "CVC4": 10.221858258458033, + "CVC3": 6.1684508065082291, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.978953582255343, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4771210541452984 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8279264689919485, + "veriT": 1.0384307817692728, + "Yices": 6.9526835197423082, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2362106746195929, + "CVC4": 6.6402869268725473, + "CVC3": 0.16649112969234545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8275508052668297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4750845465510716 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.612537699909109, + "veriT": 9.4588074825234116, + "Yices": 7.1541765678855365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3468993522223487, + "CVC4": 9.7358683498914154, + "CVC3": 7.8632581281566756, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8223491035844122, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8236479092067333 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0766249698918333, + "veriT": 4.7193726474464093, + "Yices": 9.4540510567494742, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9540643627317076, + "CVC4": 5.9900110336156001, + "CVC3": 3.0418511290953631, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.818040672104985, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.417037354776614 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7452858644520757, + "veriT": 11.341613511169216, + "Yices": 9.9513369052370049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5772088842595977, + "CVC4": 10.401552135565638, + "CVC3": 7.2869469677703345, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.039972183131516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.049382581558016 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.033333941827593, + "veriT": 10.108388448002385, + "Yices": 10.110670688210586, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.191817763239374, + "CVC4": 10.305554801322801, + "CVC3": 7.2805313614103255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233148151313248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.225313888153391 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.157997325950419, + "veriT": 9.3865002250181551, + "Yices": 9.561729585732385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.82153070091984, + "CVC4": 0.15878211911384615, + "CVC3": 12.370574385080207, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3268903691592571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.509398998720533 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.701662361432009, + "veriT": 10.86965033542395, + "Yices": 10.915704914120782, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.13893522121384, + "CVC4": 11.841098462098765, + "CVC3": 11.448712822881788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.067619076318806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.065965265389517 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.278201094828157, + "veriT": 5.6022100047458556, + "Yices": 8.2781096533055383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5570309774043345, + "CVC4": 2.8668858827788841, + "CVC3": 6.963950506935273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17507569372209092, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3556963745506199 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.58571457862854, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.559630392891775, + "veriT": 5.1905908182742495, + "Yices": 6.9813136251910821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5288308536836892, + "CVC4": 0.30497928957908332, + "CVC3": 2.834258386343476, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.140564316158668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.091488548254029 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13735836555824998, + "veriT": 5.3992876184161389, + "Yices": 1.386031697177875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13296052270775, + "CVC4": 0.14605681741012499, + "CVC3": 3.6467543997467535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.158437506679625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5659706997407883 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.39796130429283338, + "veriT": 8.8330518906442794, + "Yices": 8.6968622259139856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9565488595474281, + "CVC4": 3.310634206678305, + "CVC3": 0.44831711536055546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8071881398776861, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5559196080087005 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15002302024475, + "veriT": 14.2066621124231, + "Yices": 0.24774501519775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26469097606762498, + "CVC4": 2.0329118429613549, + "CVC3": 0.13602189775162499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.009788207902297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.017974723501389 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0780202593603332, + "veriT": 9.5153303909471028, + "Yices": 2.9984583184625806, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0518438591686667, + "CVC4": 2.7165834709990224, + "CVC3": 0.22597038762516664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5344652409380704, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5370839828516107 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5609467406187436, + "veriT": 12.800857319333849, + "Yices": 11.232534154534134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1804187362482086, + "CVC4": 9.1116458709293955, + "CVC3": 9.6540264824786171, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.61829033718354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.548246316639855 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8961035013198853, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4173192239013335, + "veriT": 11.343631343097027, + "Yices": 10.41506118119265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4002663834999076, + "CVC4": 14.277405356155313, + "CVC3": 10.139882518027918, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257055897603701, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.041397944668548 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.329044340419973, + "veriT": 9.0733338444911613, + "Yices": 9.5568471961176602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.163133658867142, + "CVC4": 14.770050696005184, + "CVC3": 9.217950142754793, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2131405659919849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2114130001692445 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0691315635768497, + "veriT": 10.180564716934128, + "Yices": 5.427548560180643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2932458427022491, + "CVC4": 5.6146226558951575, + "CVC3": 6.8305160447462256, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.166241204553421, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.166574001133636 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.917650097360966, + "veriT": 10.355599300438136, + "Yices": 11.500282386071294, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.321509319399539, + "CVC4": 4.9217178328323969, + "CVC3": 11.879711400856049, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0609878350341013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.925439644326564 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2843588768579481, + "veriT": 8.454315050969079, + "Yices": 7.2329574494400681, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1748936379922839, + "CVC4": 7.4740415991594427, + "CVC3": 7.8138256105423727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.641995234790075, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4474350399582283 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14508418475600002, + "veriT": 6.6310258294418531, + "Yices": 7.8077049899846704, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14136549625725001, + "CVC4": 0.15193044499066669, + "CVC3": 0.13974801489000002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14696107007991668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14534312585008333 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.48755248126995998, + "veriT": 8.3536095342926604, + "Yices": 8.1809925725075594, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3139759911064273, + "CVC4": 5.3141469652545918, + "CVC3": 5.1302487035436624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5278809584678488, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9952132280225756 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12801566140525, + "veriT": 0.10224396098098751, + "Yices": 0.10486303922460001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1196923082018375, + "CVC4": 0.126582619150375, + "CVC3": 0.11106649612089999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12463918560725, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1230382392423375 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6636011685310628, + "veriT": 2.6383905617335124, + "Yices": 5.6978810340863788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3429800209966092, + "CVC4": 0.16464499254474999, + "CVC3": 0.33756631187963748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.157847140815875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9484007973423174 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.77114356155181252, + "veriT": 1.9038826927052477, + "Yices": 11.308599397805473, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.78934370015037514, + "CVC4": 7.6278659114168903, + "CVC3": 8.210767195780555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5656597490017408, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5643427630203108 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4583640678589997, + "veriT": 13.811052482405147, + "Yices": 6.6102242993868368, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5859180629728975, + "CVC4": 4.8043657335538299, + "CVC3": 3.6916147417549823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6665900868813743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6966685442403318 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2058104140567245, + "veriT": 10.516185920983526, + "Yices": 7.4512737343597646, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6950362867467028, + "CVC4": 11.61873321834558, + "CVC3": 11.911381190557417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9319386381850538, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.814413360269167 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6949025016452668, + "veriT": 8.204310894854812, + "Yices": 2.6000582134421202, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.873833543483558, + "CVC4": 8.6856908849169869, + "CVC3": 0.29993348544753334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7276167336877055, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7311822803483023 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7267510813189877, + "veriT": 5.6994465929857778, + "Yices": 5.728979805412, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8082544897835606, + "CVC4": 8.0012345536387919, + "CVC3": 7.9814880236719308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7272429927579847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4398300293781254 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3769835996467779, + "veriT": 0.19251435564444447, + "Yices": 8.0046693024519051, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7518152902621111, + "CVC4": 0.23752940175744447, + "CVC3": 0.23893143841611111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22672548731922224, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22578442738466664 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 122.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14770168446766666, + "veriT": 0.12532289618466666, + "Yices": 0.13637639654316666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14448073836266667, + "CVC4": 0.16285335420633335, + "CVC3": 0.14190117643083333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16112846104999998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16008082839533333 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17369384049600001, + "veriT": 0.15525994113258826, + "Yices": 0.16099961638823529, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17868753835470588, + "CVC4": 0.19752992534494118, + "CVC3": 0.18005471676988236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18275159089982354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18329112709058823 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18414192192458331, + "veriT": 3.2821425647444911, + "Yices": 1.0335739235621417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19125941196124999, + "CVC4": 1.3814802965003194, + "CVC3": 0.38231148126425002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18594859212574166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18478763075766666 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8173181772946512, + "veriT": 10.618242760975306, + "Yices": 11.428623149218966, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9800462309456233, + "CVC4": 8.8018777208536534, + "CVC3": 8.3287210116330783, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9852520166796523, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5118391560322415 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4161755411227674, + "veriT": 9.9307609370720744, + "Yices": 8.1231439168383819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1338018574156532, + "CVC4": 5.3257122543036255, + "CVC3": 3.4925443782697299, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8727422828310782, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8644994377431168 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.797695901095266, + "veriT": 5.3645302482837414, + "Yices": 4.4744543407122972, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7355008825840432, + "CVC4": 8.2916698970705021, + "CVC3": 1.2890379892094384, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.32533786315472851, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.31674994077750002 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 45.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1560530662536621, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15315358086066669, + "veriT": 5.8379344484501878, + "Yices": 7.5049964836255905, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17920091549333336, + "CVC4": 2.5435467495222883, + "CVC3": 4.8534578782395057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17494916872766667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16811986112483335 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8509738756358081, + "veriT": 3.4852031476324665, + "Yices": 10.460554113836453, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7568542261976505, + "CVC4": 9.6856845993999787, + "CVC3": 10.60234149464145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8610597593403426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8219072868183215 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1443828000925071, + "veriT": 11.643270310624105, + "Yices": 10.226719538338665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8640913739522968, + "CVC4": 13.220884455353037, + "CVC3": 12.749983287655693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.868227018817315, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.936356562631573 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243429956065972, + "veriT": 11.264957684689763, + "Yices": 10.37400774601368, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962002440826423, + "CVC4": 14.51934126060825, + "CVC3": 13.084559208037552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.733239288179561, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.203089866674514 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259450978555595, + "veriT": 10.191440952525625, + "Yices": 10.376830575236625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.986319691220478, + "CVC4": 14.282722168723726, + "CVC3": 14.261536077236887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.25627384911644, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.430399879353237 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.057512230921612, + "veriT": 11.504502035641659, + "Yices": 11.952022243123757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.773555032832782, + "CVC4": 13.394256634304499, + "CVC3": 9.3664217764625537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.517749725776596, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.513487060121342 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.613313568655923, + "veriT": 12.187294238960655, + "Yices": 10.689473880928308, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.556049812320778, + "CVC4": 7.7180164460013101, + "CVC3": 10.429776039080663, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.908754922627548, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.905004963598733 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8197957635528352, + "veriT": 13.888072031457773, + "Yices": 8.2424155150702845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9579807584063706, + "CVC4": 13.109530794267208, + "CVC3": 13.118390990775175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.746647399377105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.749103822813289 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 189.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9351807488507968, + "veriT": 1.34523879274925, + "Yices": 2.2694880657601249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3426295105479245, + "CVC4": 1.9989217362381262, + "CVC3": 1.8937760601671092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5939853971424054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6494017995647132 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.27884247666549999, + "veriT": 13.079580723654377, + "Yices": 4.9733484265944856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.204340459655401, + "CVC4": 4.1785600078090965, + "CVC3": 0.3065439905074, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9977622626143177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0172044724340719 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.314217786104175, + "veriT": 13.833109252710752, + "Yices": 11.409659471905716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.861248331603889, + "CVC4": 10.892869535993846, + "CVC3": 10.365195305090447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4288080928092732, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1164147146754955 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9123239517211914, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1227613282678792, + "veriT": 13.646962931909901, + "Yices": 13.082933148085177, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.381196853633552, + "CVC4": 14.400205184266456, + "CVC3": 12.821326941703905, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.158577223330841, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.158669902205364 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 291.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.695164595294794, + "veriT": 12.494632256547336, + "Yices": 9.2200604906568184, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957947600572234, + "CVC4": 10.699270456608673, + "CVC3": 9.9531278595771138, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.197341984370835, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2751549341593353 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2485572930146454, + "veriT": 12.751597909554752, + "Yices": 13.543038776111826, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.151185676747017, + "CVC4": 11.410977568960371, + "CVC3": 11.930837173404333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.80598288816208352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.65541145665158329 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7583482551856444, + "veriT": 12.822567315163926, + "Yices": 6.4341895771039983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2192609702696542, + "CVC4": 4.5567374177195523, + "CVC3": 7.6257735945542535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19883158534619999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19846630426870002 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.535376999085708, + "veriT": 13.900969138144154, + "Yices": 13.748366223123645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.350514542324758, + "CVC4": 14.592678219502021, + "CVC3": 14.156326122105567, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.313250806902003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0258686736545251 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 245.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3007701643318281, + "veriT": 14.03402696464209, + "Yices": 13.897882406190567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.018517151350691, + "CVC4": 13.189530808453549, + "CVC3": 9.7930237258347788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.161781842123924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.020956322826384 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.828106671713527, + "veriT": 11.257564959977756, + "Yices": 11.416587981516049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.995511106429246, + "CVC4": 14.513881781830261, + "CVC3": 10.90722100341489, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.285220945430165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6064598400188963 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.257953540966799, + "veriT": 12.494782060342077, + "Yices": 12.722059228743015, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.258557649901464, + "CVC4": 14.598096771229271, + "CVC3": 13.626176442281027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253930014779929, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.25543553765411 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.297465409932661, + "veriT": 14.235511040499821, + "Yices": 14.237054793190126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.737287319093172, + "CVC4": 10.609478101934315, + "CVC3": 13.505968835763111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9791300079915093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0185335304178151 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.260858970070768, + "veriT": 10.270292410479, + "Yices": 12.350172242666799, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.981280223016693, + "CVC4": 14.442675382805231, + "CVC3": 14.259834649419645, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255566652615441, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.73055249095321 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 301.0, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.254148684641882, + "veriT": 13.565544581130906, + "Yices": 14.128549704270084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.585395053685238, + "CVC4": 14.648673847618207, + "CVC3": 8.5394718090711716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.420442651175817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.170478496315647 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.256143011044289, + "veriT": 14.251102833247238, + "Yices": 13.921458957034606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97657644042348, + "CVC4": 14.890749760032152, + "CVC3": 14.256459742594702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.701614530652803, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.737825790179329 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12061471301980953, + "veriT": 0.093807866686604777, + "Yices": 0.096809232984652355, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11839353064433336, + "CVC4": 0.12076817568776191, + "CVC3": 0.097814252754747616, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11995171323285717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11629483400647619 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10872449929903914, + "veriT": 0.081141456042208696, + "Yices": 0.084924122490978263, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10749914526485217, + "CVC4": 0.10539703729571738, + "CVC3": 0.086561307230382592, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10357043473116957, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10289692192853044 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9222510608106944, + "veriT": 2.6574183943461849, + "Yices": 2.1588815409432125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.096793341603487, + "CVC4": 3.6791896106476907, + "CVC3": 0.147101676274775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.168333674716625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16538932422975 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15183012991633332, + "veriT": 2.4464309500512935, + "Yices": 2.4674612700761505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14047632886566666, + "CVC4": 2.6110765626714092, + "CVC3": 2.4633902607478748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4807286330577885, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4793780239394105 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1770209220048791, + "veriT": 10.165214844811278, + "Yices": 10.353361577371622, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2752098717452571, + "CVC4": 0.1482430323543793, + "CVC3": 0.69283799492658615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14669121926444825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.441314174826802 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16148347618559999, + "veriT": 4.1284776586188006, + "Yices": 6.4959603318311991, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27229994254789996, + "CVC4": 0.15344921180740001, + "CVC3": 0.19561564007859999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14733038070890001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2477008792417092 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8552150734173134, + "veriT": 7.3969177818776526, + "Yices": 7.5403648303550561, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0823512582610375, + "CVC4": 7.4991488622786466, + "CVC3": 4.8732680991120452, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2678683792127323, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3222407550108288 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.655565934026397, + "veriT": 9.509018298182454, + "Yices": 9.5957412102221085, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.131927293196366, + "CVC4": 3.3679035616422714, + "CVC3": 9.1521711712157199, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2122704742388457, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1700711037672065 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20615438366042857, + "veriT": 3.0461728950692857, + "Yices": 4.5580656168477143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.207909776625429, + "CVC4": 0.17093014321185712, + "CVC3": 0.38755674221685721, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8259091264134844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5616638531620826 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.688634798604351, + "veriT": 8.1969981800397083, + "Yices": 10.310077244738666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.173920416469665, + "CVC4": 1.2837129115076666, + "CVC3": 8.8756644370818005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.112795642751365, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.61166777826524 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.214590108438589, + "veriT": 10.597799085033452, + "Yices": 10.614304608992404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.677831393697216, + "CVC4": 4.9493087207679327, + "CVC3": 11.035570776249983, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1689879983169291, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.501305284797098 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.619047999382019, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24440278692083, + "veriT": 10.159554981887167, + "Yices": 10.341037715507833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95997926538711, + "CVC4": 0.21141733771416668, + "CVC3": 11.711676229339188, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9879512666435699, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.38809347640048 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.714983255354186, + "veriT": 11.680163534363814, + "Yices": 10.859947679285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.149994906678858, + "CVC4": 5.7211850259119919, + "CVC3": 10.515934629987999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4232423669148622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.331944917613249 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.425057970696315, + "veriT": 10.665821276605477, + "Yices": 10.528612964514346, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.345614602067103, + "CVC4": 1.9783739685829558, + "CVC3": 11.007024871627699, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0266560516975849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.058441115390025 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.51680351914567, + "veriT": 8.3925459659330581, + "Yices": 11.016807889640518, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.110488142954001, + "CVC4": 0.1699307572242941, + "CVC3": 13.982143994495502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1708225845164053, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2901788130240224 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2514320223223345, + "veriT": 9.5482362204032647, + "Yices": 4.7869245905383613, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4597855432706353, + "CVC4": 4.8048017559078895, + "CVC3": 6.7042120767241746, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.867111903862626, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5753889906276406 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11981250452127273, + "veriT": 1.913356576376527, + "Yices": 7.0421156218841876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12002923153270909, + "CVC4": 0.12450527373893637, + "CVC3": 0.10395044243641817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12064951040645454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12088921018005455 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1718063535452057, + "veriT": 9.0938133094076523, + "Yices": 8.4946451289510314, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9188044091991392, + "CVC4": 10.521802737363192, + "CVC3": 4.2633523778165801, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0512730598756246, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0450585165192532 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9278021054305756, + "veriT": 5.0170641204437283, + "Yices": 7.1311386389322422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0079515285067622, + "CVC4": 0.17863198501699995, + "CVC3": 3.9270131180830372, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7054315234976902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7062777063652812 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12549065928337499, + "veriT": 0.096796770683887506, + "Yices": 0.097856386791875014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12115027788639998, + "CVC4": 0.12021301021049999, + "CVC3": 0.10870539655094999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11798142932575001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11581321617047501 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0181205272674561, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8603894710540771, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6770834922790527, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.048173948944244, + "veriT": 11.451223763981314, + "Yices": 12.111777100516111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.5169386605799, + "CVC4": 9.326136125676328, + "CVC3": 10.84781844316587, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.015361478375166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.428703941022203 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7782282859617144, + "veriT": 12.014871847859315, + "Yices": 12.524273371822176, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4029445678448575, + "CVC4": 8.3546186547885668, + "CVC3": 8.4877087676479288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3818883730592617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.326685153987067 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.053741532081534, + "veriT": 11.455242036744281, + "Yices": 8.9590047931415562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0081004523838146, + "CVC4": 1.5640672426785716, + "CVC3": 4.8712426924793917, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0006710649445714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0364496472822855 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.140227473233454, + "veriT": 12.826372736143808, + "Yices": 11.46699569816982, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.559702679494208, + "CVC4": 12.653593502053225, + "CVC3": 8.2952104685030612, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.184754531105266, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.18743409576275 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.464520967134705, + "veriT": 10.710992853963822, + "Yices": 8.7828438964348585, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.827874029788914, + "CVC4": 0.16732441357114286, + "CVC3": 6.7674246632803676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1154409212465932, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.496600274779828 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.120054492979984, + "veriT": 11.889376355222607, + "Yices": 11.549072173831663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.981078308254515, + "CVC4": 13.404297609436817, + "CVC3": 13.278936684694116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5756958356591415, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0798825040707083 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8856209516525269, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7130160513546064, + "veriT": 6.6133101520308033, + "Yices": 7.2150230268810009, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8138251945740409, + "CVC4": 1.7464302183237301, + "CVC3": 1.4545381223895089, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1694640781901988, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8925963287318517 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5997215260458129, + "veriT": 13.459995770778857, + "Yices": 10.450856562884722, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.130302638449781, + "CVC4": 14.452650494970857, + "CVC3": 11.999042800096175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.768274341765608, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.7656941803317 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2956080430481443, + "veriT": 7.8454967785786307, + "Yices": 8.7054869797193071, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.557636512669241, + "CVC4": 5.1934744337397198, + "CVC3": 7.2622754394302982, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.998036543454861, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.471250876613594 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8619050979614258, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15636787580758332, + "veriT": 3.7900018831296833, + "Yices": 3.715576363282203, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26298348145275002, + "CVC4": 0.17527947833250002, + "CVC3": 2.1372497565399251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7945125416870997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7883354235198312 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1718746550872288, + "veriT": 10.18968112869538, + "Yices": 11.602976336332745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2877827832378808, + "CVC4": 7.3382069140317574, + "CVC3": 6.4916874354485801, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.677760875692115, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.646857943997972 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6317236412381102, + "veriT": 13.555433352569366, + "Yices": 11.341426666180796, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4506055644241513, + "CVC4": 12.634893639986592, + "CVC3": 11.742597739614995, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.248114968271622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.777675609635088 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8177445131574999, + "veriT": 7.7693430469533906, + "Yices": 9.4074551874430163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3336316536477133, + "CVC4": 3.1611483933987694, + "CVC3": 6.0645898083649419, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.415743000691084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.789358162682458 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20593674917871427, + "veriT": 13.64721426473699, + "Yices": 7.6382697357260794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.88445476043585713, + "CVC4": 2.2281519386556035, + "CVC3": 0.33107925124557142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7776888454950885, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4444142689794415 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8070348120517243, + "veriT": 12.719970590456622, + "Yices": 8.3226154708318223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9221110534536647, + "CVC4": 4.4569280905469393, + "CVC3": 6.2792594886399389, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.589256919134144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6547872196467068 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9061044895310415, + "veriT": 9.6578768688745473, + "Yices": 3.8310994735712183, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.032076854735855, + "CVC4": 2.1062899647172344, + "CVC3": 1.899870999191182, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8982268176274593, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9003107780996171 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9583957264992282, + "veriT": 11.185031101471791, + "Yices": 10.972619767261875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.070699605291372, + "CVC4": 14.642437156822183, + "CVC3": 9.0565840841113054, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.230423776463867, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.226575480500289 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0571419871076913, + "veriT": 12.605473998885918, + "Yices": 9.9854224056203886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.291695243692709, + "CVC4": 12.246740211584113, + "CVC3": 11.467803423471711, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240886122375054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.312558318687696 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.9000000953674316, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6443458960138617, + "veriT": 7.9000305835881237, + "Yices": 10.868730020184699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6207111491215631, + "CVC4": 0.18963988220900002, + "CVC3": 5.6005506030540007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.194589734683368, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5921179638372038 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8025923901688499, + "veriT": 11.217662118575127, + "Yices": 4.1383241679312048, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8005023963101996, + "CVC4": 2.6137952219911762, + "CVC3": 3.5485406985937669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4890196380490481, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4850105453048461 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3051245157426319, + "veriT": 10.520178448231494, + "Yices": 12.636628314963366, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.569440059287416, + "CVC4": 9.8420162098403612, + "CVC3": 11.056803113678791, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.832595561813067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.844749407853364 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.91368064087284617, + "veriT": 12.836985708556291, + "Yices": 4.6055209430589548, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7315001761042306, + "CVC4": 3.5645328426671812, + "CVC3": 3.5796107042097534, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.171808190935955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.800141924537716 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8900912573763753, + "veriT": 5.4351262490615708, + "Yices": 14.214115548664674, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8986851762985006, + "CVC4": 12.903819950835853, + "CVC3": 14.552102619475145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2483519568074888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2316463904286339 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.294625015567085, + "veriT": 11.073581665955087, + "Yices": 11.014019507076572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.403333546929872, + "CVC4": 2.2914468266179426, + "CVC3": 1.9235396560108464, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7492651619780253, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.044142634005103 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.3095235824584961, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2607532666769057, + "veriT": 6.7745974522712338, + "Yices": 3.447947265649189, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4247350422269003, + "CVC4": 3.3574998363839663, + "CVC3": 1.7104815911155764, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5054186676509866, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5206373835300662 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18691751986700003, + "veriT": 0.17383699561528568, + "Yices": 6.4542964584312896, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.44550236390402859, + "CVC4": 2.1958928428907383, + "CVC3": 0.17093371263900001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1701581409010143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17579312811685716 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17661435571110001, + "veriT": 0.15928344224120003, + "Yices": 0.16617572288202001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17328040572030001, + "CVC4": 0.19748223535249998, + "CVC3": 0.17003327527869999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18890397411249998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18519029650519997 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6179915496631478, + "veriT": 8.3390650221831972, + "Yices": 7.9170012572130224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5225113548384996, + "CVC4": 5.6168107575661868, + "CVC3": 7.8565747576106215, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6005948977570252, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8178864980734364 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8688444253036414, + "veriT": 7.5083003569888058, + "Yices": 12.305978139742971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8379831660450776, + "CVC4": 11.80937719146487, + "CVC3": 8.3217033937276508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6084804983238605, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5490565502837743 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19820690869245453, + "veriT": 5.2705930699128949, + "Yices": 8.6847204494927155, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25301460574682733, + "CVC4": 10.688140880746182, + "CVC3": 5.1354092067181876, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4667864972554538, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3999982964279354 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0111110210418701, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.91323871486700015, + "veriT": 0.12316125520184616, + "Yices": 1.2149115080594759, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.90989240403407701, + "CVC4": 0.16206572104623079, + "CVC3": 0.13695045975823075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15228173861892308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.151547662606 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7926632029231333, + "veriT": 0.10564382388143334, + "Yices": 0.10538501095997499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7949489481192584, + "CVC4": 9.5927347665405147, + "CVC3": 0.11624126546426668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13043796749044168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12926373635250835 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16013828279749998, + "veriT": 0.13486843959418998, + "Yices": 1.6110304537121702, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16873974172413, + "CVC4": 0.16621568292874001, + "CVC3": 0.1678504126806, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15926918156603001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16275587302934999 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 54.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16222976721245713, + "veriT": 8.4417637416670583, + "Yices": 8.4535432422624641, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17385917418369998, + "CVC4": 0.17253894525855712, + "CVC3": 3.1130790755690003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.35796379943442858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.38053940496228567 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9092932923454116, + "veriT": 11.141599158095712, + "Yices": 9.8907867957806026, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0007891177243935, + "CVC4": 7.2863299702816722, + "CVC3": 6.9894446720908583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.241356764437509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.613553689735308 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19719219238410002, + "veriT": 2.9877315031625016, + "Yices": 0.18539983184860001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22259137072109997, + "CVC4": 0.2171127566346, + "CVC3": 0.18637990392430001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20705752602059996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19377263449050003 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1076924800872803, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5464745548206817, + "veriT": 7.043048022922016, + "Yices": 3.3570134829058569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7734192988305857, + "CVC4": 8.2632693829246016, + "CVC3": 6.206734509245516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1932641743366954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3609655821754121 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3208867530690458, + "veriT": 6.9773787024485863, + "Yices": 7.8251653554448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.384629665008388, + "CVC4": 7.403315746095589, + "CVC3": 0.99401401122283328, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4647444927959932, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2730853523633447 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.306416266755928, + "veriT": 11.879171309679625, + "Yices": 10.489007422442617, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.060371617874308, + "CVC4": 11.672391444283889, + "CVC3": 9.5213155476139661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9642957620556176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3354094972482127 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3028073718884765, + "veriT": 6.2639352003170998, + "Yices": 1.0452823616631948, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4282593424095773, + "CVC4": 0.2414466941634375, + "CVC3": 0.33037530306518748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19297535667949997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19126771748718752 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2774261485852634, + "veriT": 10.1656713699899, + "Yices": 9.0387164608687751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3102249184502703, + "CVC4": 14.439557815706234, + "CVC3": 13.120688703731114, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.919946810283903, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.663125931346134 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.80257888813600009, + "veriT": 6.2029319641609018, + "Yices": 7.6425083850920741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2372361759585715, + "CVC4": 6.3529535480421098, + "CVC3": 5.6215620730234717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6455723774177766, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6469595156790238 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.9649099658824, + "veriT": 11.536944439299297, + "Yices": 10.840970711524241, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.573333945917538, + "CVC4": 14.511764517147112, + "CVC3": 13.853724389883679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24861270316295, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.089237823375901 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.671315118043067, + "veriT": 11.533478818997192, + "Yices": 12.864813058425229, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.389590766521129, + "CVC4": 14.336661705156818, + "CVC3": 6.9631720546301246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.564719928320182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.47985860164636 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 89.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17695893136857777, + "veriT": 7.0534833988766517, + "Yices": 0.13734395050373335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24693239524444444, + "CVC4": 1.7425470055053838, + "CVC3": 4.8632549861214907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7216464869037476, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7155043612258327 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.70480758575437497, + "veriT": 11.285049570714527, + "Yices": 11.818222889923344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0543831723121571, + "CVC4": 7.5403321404448675, + "CVC3": 6.8470850765463167, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4763233087623178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4966085027431468 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2829578253604308, + "veriT": 14.242388971228932, + "Yices": 4.1163847934346158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4218727476633184, + "CVC4": 2.1903863221433753, + "CVC3": 1.4673936652693751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.337902452584, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3822304952658129 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.3333068160739, + "veriT": 12.454965051099423, + "Yices": 12.561857782816618, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959608228477173, + "CVC4": 14.333116459309357, + "CVC3": 14.237038978114725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.251915990524218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.212194725404183 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6966373920440674, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2338092766247559, + "veriT": 9.5920390877876951, + "Yices": 10.727268002492471, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.392678258624807, + "CVC4": 12.652058417540319, + "CVC3": 9.4405784420644583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1524724225280352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1018438626138547 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 151, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 138.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5856430670585429, + "veriT": 12.413882847216465, + "Yices": 12.925037283317465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.316175073169363, + "CVC4": 11.628926632228518, + "CVC3": 8.7739837165683934, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.245129043661613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.922428648131655 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1875965595245361, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.489578451101266, + "veriT": 11.708932096416651, + "Yices": 12.291438330983933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965416203775323, + "CVC4": 14.650599040670054, + "CVC3": 14.111085409841051, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.107904206622758, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.385750831694072 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.715117590559325, + "veriT": 10.114862820104243, + "Yices": 13.81632685954237, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968464993252281, + "CVC4": 14.600191339160268, + "CVC3": 14.249858258681472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.777360189002302, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.03913997013014 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.250577779547951, + "veriT": 14.240466517743394, + "Yices": 14.240009371780378, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.479656777867348, + "CVC4": 14.494937841663477, + "CVC3": 12.105444053814582, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.248879332985123, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.153105698120672 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 225.0, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.70641721403305, + "veriT": 13.821299316240593, + "Yices": 13.779323553812983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954975170043634, + "CVC4": 14.554019185987645, + "CVC3": 12.850581004286138, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239050843300134, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.240324779344599 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.986447680506558, + "veriT": 13.562299716535378, + "Yices": 14.404713353443038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.985082866055906, + "CVC4": 14.366959794391422, + "CVC3": 13.937234619313109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.220013501500013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.057332529671333 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.898487648112392, + "veriT": 12.189145981626162, + "Yices": 12.277511561894206, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.307569046684302, + "CVC4": 11.965049242377532, + "CVC3": 13.594318822031957, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.257054507330623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7835254236716613 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "false": 156, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 792.5, + "true": 153 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "false": 155, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 154 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4443874849738414, + "veriT": 14.230088146630358, + "Yices": 14.236763322602688, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.165241299620126, + "CVC4": 14.442226692720105, + "CVC3": 10.857501877844445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1392944446685664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2920378132738985 + }, + { + "index": 155, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3507941223832498, + "veriT": 13.712199237408084, + "Yices": 12.006635692996307, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.360558739648951, + "CVC4": 8.9782858592339903, + "CVC3": 14.158512482783703, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.65749350788562499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.567407606378875 + }, + { + "index": 156, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.46234151523049, + "veriT": 13.851383297531104, + "Yices": 13.724336983142141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.977306147674749, + "CVC4": 14.681920675429717, + "CVC3": 12.144691444125538, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.31648975845909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.000679393621818 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12736825579405264, + "veriT": 0.096315593014684203, + "Yices": 0.099116716315889461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12427850623489474, + "CVC4": 0.12499205229189472, + "CVC3": 0.10270888475607368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1207296036934737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12052514054078949 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10945678873607501, + "veriT": 0.081963696720608339, + "Yices": 0.085955218714625012, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1103064921471875, + "CVC4": 0.10414004676095832, + "CVC3": 0.087434202956991669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10442180472156666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10430969152100417 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4912704495505471, + "veriT": 1.803927745196215, + "Yices": 1.4713043859367669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6018558653236576, + "CVC4": 2.5003257959532106, + "CVC3": 0.13377189423255001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15566558642333334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15702114691383331 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20731301034387095, + "veriT": 10.16549295235316, + "Yices": 10.350174453581872, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25977829207193548, + "CVC4": 0.14817716567038711, + "CVC3": 0.68020127145606468, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14844863739383871, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.431398057469499 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19645737949916667, + "veriT": 8.6583506481471897, + "Yices": 8.7650326230857249, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27617095261041663, + "CVC4": 3.8509477890376136, + "CVC3": 3.7330578007312702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6649898510321823, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0817259696255315 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 47.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5137233334924467, + "veriT": 11.861425052700026, + "Yices": 11.502644076740189, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2780970385268748, + "CVC4": 13.017492028570588, + "CVC3": 9.5761378956612919, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.442935113158446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.888816365422889 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.335654835555637, + "veriT": 10.156586284358564, + "Yices": 6.2550565704064178, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.41508750349211, + "CVC4": 9.3165440458088096, + "CVC3": 8.9133869093436839, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1592421660625432, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1591086787609939 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.667366125053391, + "veriT": 9.1732451331517009, + "Yices": 10.319913762655899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.497763321751915, + "CVC4": 1.2325145008115002, + "CVC3": 9.632362978135399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2283270176976782, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.218154282796714 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1577283618439176, + "veriT": 6.844970889412374, + "Yices": 9.6502471821047262, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2987538276691777, + "CVC4": 4.4044372525327216, + "CVC3": 4.9185007839620543, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8435066913426805, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6453682128060931 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7926997697561173, + "veriT": 4.9727889580651929, + "Yices": 6.3715993417189996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7855701937341752, + "CVC4": 2.9892433674088776, + "CVC3": 3.1817489591822041, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9813348524233922, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2231363536545121 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.201043525267574, + "veriT": 11.701752315815868, + "Yices": 10.572532501440149, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.059826703091801, + "CVC4": 13.629890316307597, + "CVC3": 12.246314330446808, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5163831802996874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4577011061611804 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5357145071029663, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1650667134686619, + "veriT": 4.4569860198718452, + "Yices": 3.1011926456144998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2498817225298353, + "CVC4": 2.0028267043872976, + "CVC3": 1.6505119265947501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5546195619596332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9899957109627717 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7333334684371948, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240869901176596, + "veriT": 10.180765324774445, + "Yices": 10.327806287506224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957226882781434, + "CVC4": 0.23277815543566666, + "CVC3": 11.887447425932942, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8415823961361499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.301786693240798 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.50313191405132, + "veriT": 8.9152404381468742, + "Yices": 10.338039623436689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.135516569603212, + "CVC4": 0.17101659224381249, + "CVC3": 11.560506083159471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.562250671218429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.314384254738066 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6835013701991288, + "veriT": 7.6572425359572494, + "Yices": 7.759268677871666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.259036494645828, + "CVC4": 1.12868471437675, + "CVC3": 9.6731891459217447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9709879392862488, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.186372945664223 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9858701452500309, + "veriT": 8.8912473256515874, + "Yices": 9.6564417477484366, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1279638436086366, + "CVC4": 1.4168690515864999, + "CVC3": 4.1782751954021249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9158404533905136, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0493726166233497 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248984766708238, + "veriT": 10.169390068288859, + "Yices": 10.363763602867285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967128623781392, + "CVC4": 0.16610805755100003, + "CVC3": 12.186662357450128, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16323579773342858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.470469180274193 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.217166439840515, + "veriT": 7.6502007765654989, + "Yices": 11.305662400418273, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.759679266300463, + "CVC4": 0.167431517143625, + "CVC3": 13.877522339852428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14981978040687499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4987223962902831 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.668541050332642, + "veriT": 12.508530445534934, + "Yices": 12.153683194953054, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.308604329427217, + "CVC4": 8.3830645828923469, + "CVC3": 12.672175426244598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.229501792532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.768234035420232 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.9000000953674316, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5208011121326876, + "veriT": 11.472023600177742, + "Yices": 10.882163109687015, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3108203952688298, + "CVC4": 8.0637889104551164, + "CVC3": 8.1818256310128064, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.995971175280973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.080141689517539 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5399805778561477, + "veriT": 5.3062664116225911, + "Yices": 8.2933861169674703, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0022142236649323, + "CVC4": 2.8537987198504093, + "CVC3": 1.9328444462771044, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5961607391751071, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6117457650674734 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2221482038605989, + "veriT": 10.918533636982893, + "Yices": 3.2869066499450001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2846129207426666, + "CVC4": 2.1197012992802695, + "CVC3": 4.6024794051707554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6566763343272202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0286762735914756 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.032506360771215, + "veriT": 5.9718970483397928, + "Yices": 6.0263899898968383, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.341134328663321, + "CVC4": 1.4393560923531348, + "CVC3": 4.9232555980295478, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.091851367947458, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.983048176066916 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14228426728356877, + "veriT": 2.1873402960766, + "Yices": 3.2504936413178567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.61496196389968749, + "CVC4": 0.141195334993375, + "CVC3": 1.0097280897099832, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1269592635901875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12721185812299377 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1515286883219025, + "veriT": 8.4236631442110923, + "Yices": 5.822325454592014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3538146153712374, + "CVC4": 5.7922721078791382, + "CVC3": 4.1395700065252381, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1681140412546869, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1683177175662438 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0717949867248535, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1989042252943038, + "veriT": 6.8919254455396608, + "Yices": 8.0757756394065883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7176570208548245, + "CVC4": 9.7551903101975395, + "CVC3": 7.7210814182438803, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1738099522668852, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1569657305601462 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.617632437246371, + "veriT": 8.1629472128185316, + "Yices": 12.197631307644151, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.255804621804149, + "CVC4": 6.4978646768853254, + "CVC3": 6.2824463477755987, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.849307211060708, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.234404113271115 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1598641828915999, + "veriT": 1.6148241267585264, + "Yices": 14.335266686944342, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1796047252169004, + "CVC4": 11.773453617633512, + "CVC3": 14.117547871800003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9303100043619859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9069605501602442 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.482890320191695, + "veriT": 12.170270410336482, + "Yices": 10.61723190648426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.780058649278724, + "CVC4": 8.4049246618511546, + "CVC3": 7.3511310698595711, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234908128199478, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.234284461936875 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.38748360660062, + "veriT": 7.7644052770224219, + "Yices": 11.70301750070011, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6176625076884807, + "CVC4": 12.661358059462069, + "CVC3": 11.422241572148755, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9753495335986222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9751169093118461 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.608586376366384, + "veriT": 7.5804557290153287, + "Yices": 9.7471223210148459, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.166047929004634, + "CVC4": 11.438190573809134, + "CVC3": 13.423659764113026, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.655235650843796, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.630958654452655 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7430496184386977, + "veriT": 8.5190794373568188, + "Yices": 6.7561603880942451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7803444045317462, + "CVC4": 5.844727431338848, + "CVC3": 8.0366675739739986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9961361398290896, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1765594369433323 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9937499761581421, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0873407931186065, + "veriT": 4.9594793169152771, + "Yices": 4.2554448397720988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1317141645859792, + "CVC4": 11.820967683602461, + "CVC3": 0.95948820436602611, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0378542350150268, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4423217329221074 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0896475369852143, + "veriT": 4.4635918133405754, + "Yices": 3.7559579324031431, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8259668160974281, + "CVC4": 2.6881708368397668, + "CVC3": 1.9881388682581882, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2250876010044438, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2222858727735675 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1344026077179, + "veriT": 3.8639211752910501, + "Yices": 3.867893588772775, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13176346417111251, + "CVC4": 0.13585833103760001, + "CVC3": 2.7165450895754377, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9899802847359969, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0107845719690247 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13644128505978573, + "veriT": 0.11259593504599287, + "Yices": 0.12466214185663572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13638030123459285, + "CVC4": 3.1759490385494624, + "CVC3": 0.12876237166612856, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14562595997364289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14578831820242857 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1421403884887695, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23834680431455554, + "veriT": 1.3475883243795557, + "Yices": 13.37294989931363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0728103467772643, + "CVC4": 0.23413629928377777, + "CVC3": 0.22821992670622226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21912985447244443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21087652904633333 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16134558502599999, + "veriT": 5.0266712095978079, + "Yices": 6.2509671558763724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18329969463117143, + "CVC4": 0.18306044149065714, + "CVC3": 2.5244465301512657, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1741270677069462, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1797697065673125 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 67.0, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.351258277747565, + "veriT": 11.308849234591523, + "Yices": 10.808105878336791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7913875579437253, + "CVC4": 6.3599139030805816, + "CVC3": 10.379105553829437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.846445534242964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.700885250404937 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5030988639612795, + "veriT": 2.4765231113434276, + "Yices": 3.5222290084143331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8201491715466667, + "CVC4": 0.15398633069183335, + "CVC3": 0.13727746190903331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4840327680875909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0630837350842559 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2007693299065672, + "veriT": 11.508127129049273, + "Yices": 10.666563859806166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5638478976395591, + "CVC4": 0.28755974048266669, + "CVC3": 7.1999514504583537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.67669362981616665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3478490916914003 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.009729544581178, + "veriT": 10.026215969110865, + "Yices": 10.161265875519913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.916819986338702, + "CVC4": 3.312801602800266, + "CVC3": 13.229982639078274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9145057078419097, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.449256650696221 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9128142419928986, + "veriT": 7.5367027780744724, + "Yices": 7.756528436627292, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2203501031556527, + "CVC4": 7.067714383693315, + "CVC3": 5.6488888763589635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.093478503157781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.390653086983669 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5983786455765481, + "veriT": 11.529717535473628, + "Yices": 11.405481924775744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.914207188840164, + "CVC4": 14.392465696813268, + "CVC3": 7.8795780434852247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.571011434057722, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.50360558695972 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1511693480375, + "veriT": 14.211013054729543, + "Yices": 2.9340707852285135, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2035611057200994, + "CVC4": 4.0565251682253614, + "CVC3": 2.5395402660467896, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.888234570274907, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.877782881306825 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.27746478583236361, + "veriT": 13.107509112887897, + "Yices": 13.735997448046037, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0018477169177333, + "CVC4": 8.1146166384546898, + "CVC3": 13.514814458935392, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.381819131959684, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.063442692196908 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9696237902248983, + "veriT": 11.94133076170823, + "Yices": 7.9936040478064712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0950357829247137, + "CVC4": 7.5045398422590708, + "CVC3": 8.9396836322313824, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9509383768012007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9518884523907563 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.290379741648769, + "veriT": 9.5576339543043876, + "Yices": 1.345447020897923, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.98788868560038456, + "CVC4": 0.2721895206000769, + "CVC3": 1.2475788437986841, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0742552320971201, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.046784960309874 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13866075287579999, + "veriT": 2.9391731656545015, + "Yices": 7.7663484810399002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1332770751248, + "CVC4": 0.18357542462939999, + "CVC3": 0.13374376288289999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14593363030609999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1472122475006 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.272154373724376, + "veriT": 10.796058147498725, + "Yices": 8.9830164471354284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.519163269571052, + "CVC4": 12.310850755240221, + "CVC3": 14.262243387122595, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.276143471326451, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.778885016171154 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.516746962485856, + "veriT": 12.68104260741816, + "Yices": 10.940571676848737, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.248362365537073, + "CVC4": 12.303885948767824, + "CVC3": 5.7737619097593136, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8977287169411348, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.895894155888902 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 112.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.0, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 73.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 73.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.56614377603145449, + "veriT": 10.552016011263236, + "Yices": 11.915475663329767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3722784468198181, + "CVC4": 13.13069865748348, + "CVC3": 10.902137483414121, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9676437057478031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8313272129757019 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5753474929584099, + "veriT": 12.367523260811652, + "Yices": 11.024497999415457, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.546552168211882, + "CVC4": 11.146825025006123, + "CVC3": 9.8074557663090154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.61323314095309, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.568998991622999 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.178741193147445, + "veriT": 11.825385201024885, + "Yices": 11.151866379175019, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.102709911018536, + "CVC4": 14.683828479072723, + "CVC3": 13.065276281799777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.962071133375034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.935529393805673 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26977135039369998, + "veriT": 10.875276571832677, + "Yices": 6.4478767741925678, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.87241681170369989, + "CVC4": 6.4806087792779534, + "CVC3": 7.7063846063955399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.963561851830443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.491675428688298 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9466092167099702, + "veriT": 8.7836342160835397, + "Yices": 2.3578830340880015, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5023007790376792, + "CVC4": 1.9515650495295036, + "CVC3": 1.929915656104642, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20395498328387499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20143910651712499 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.302682024114747, + "veriT": 14.248415185375574, + "Yices": 12.24144568895999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.601442699584622, + "CVC4": 8.3183035993968009, + "CVC3": 8.0606944714534148, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7133476901118359, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.71249642519345 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235598238212544, + "veriT": 11.947922648798441, + "Yices": 12.016713317867358, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948530954292888, + "CVC4": 14.803811017875212, + "CVC3": 7.4987861712984092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232232070257636, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.902098947670883 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.505473923991314, + "veriT": 12.242755237851377, + "Yices": 9.6423434147341247, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.147771950508616, + "CVC4": 12.164858368759202, + "CVC3": 14.260127240408547, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255675621488063, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.191606906865678 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6149996124730279, + "veriT": 14.224556306315318, + "Yices": 12.472434346376499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.471305062535739, + "CVC4": 14.692376503324743, + "CVC3": 14.232796774909502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243355400576254, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.24243931520607 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1360480045996502, + "veriT": 9.7825963880249613, + "Yices": 13.332307860127065, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.281996156982567, + "CVC4": 14.480571450307355, + "CVC3": 4.5228190023664565, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0363159046885695, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0186132584929286 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2100869873806044, + "veriT": 11.460102719590822, + "Yices": 5.6462186514997654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7086597353118123, + "CVC4": 1.7990150623732499, + "CVC3": 8.4394726135099152, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4540228257613128, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0630007159501682 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.56354499171245331, + "veriT": 9.4319128423401146, + "Yices": 4.00623847110763, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7776647531498013, + "CVC4": 3.490750495157275, + "CVC3": 0.28075052680796003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.791242729607295, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8183785411843436 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.360843483701264, + "veriT": 9.8920439187579348, + "Yices": 9.529350254592714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.183283682964898, + "CVC4": 6.4829486410089734, + "CVC3": 10.220116864919081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2219280114448505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.546975909063567 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7676337602695735, + "veriT": 12.514388379151184, + "Yices": 14.11253981836656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.633034139176999, + "CVC4": 14.622305092169993, + "CVC3": 6.9303497629074675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8509512675795659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8699006982975082 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 147.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.278981259918261, + "veriT": 10.238656637037, + "Yices": 10.446316614512625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.997757753350907, + "CVC4": 14.329364985413761, + "CVC3": 14.286836098828202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0411490723283787, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.464861230463733 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.392972441054392, + "veriT": 13.973882860693578, + "Yices": 14.236548773708018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.966920802387465, + "CVC4": 14.457886995119102, + "CVC3": 12.952550272411878, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.227644557334269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.237550272282602 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245879802747741, + "veriT": 10.589928776877015, + "Yices": 11.868144993169402, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959771671548287, + "CVC4": 14.452942970210676, + "CVC3": 13.072899530741221, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.753860044706105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.208451492434415 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2975575557379884, + "veriT": 13.148468224174213, + "Yices": 13.167277360231633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.339346483029411, + "CVC4": 11.893665541853048, + "CVC3": 13.411107225243398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.191115172082486, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.911207619405606 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.281922604797657, + "veriT": 14.273616778673361, + "Yices": 13.501304874463326, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.999681906826442, + "CVC4": 14.771300176558986, + "CVC3": 13.226662286844363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.018568283984541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.982028554124778 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3535069994713029, + "veriT": 12.768897301846062, + "Yices": 9.6344586053347587, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6445260377190007, + "CVC4": 8.589725013681095, + "CVC3": 9.9823939408668121, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5621190840096126, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5688721123449554 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.18352231684139, + "veriT": 14.221761991040069, + "Yices": 13.281636128194265, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.516705184505788, + "CVC4": 9.2407482135898285, + "CVC3": 13.827789502745686, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230000022646699, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236791885491579 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.375, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12917680055067743, + "veriT": 0.10156839508330322, + "Yices": 0.10204946870493872, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12747713000774194, + "CVC4": 0.12873679879951611, + "CVC3": 0.10830798065403548, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1261382843531613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12484307214016128 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10624146381244706, + "veriT": 0.077805044214005886, + "Yices": 0.08183640469524707, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10697796207301764, + "CVC4": 0.10270909491367645, + "CVC3": 0.08309646372065882, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10119062532288824, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.098507634622717652 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5816379450917779, + "veriT": 1.6610761700677401, + "Yices": 2.8023488598857229, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5770476198031105, + "CVC4": 1.7715545754887174, + "CVC3": 1.6697738128584054, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6885289520693036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7030437958978293 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6867474416834545, + "veriT": 10.165880729876106, + "Yices": 10.351490692452316, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8135131543233072, + "CVC4": 0.14997688512552629, + "CVC3": 0.71659646036205271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1491617814356842, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.424413707141683 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17573268959177779, + "veriT": 6.8087407966444449, + "Yices": 6.9375623268948887, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.30582658351800002, + "CVC4": 0.15494373388855556, + "CVC3": 0.25159481527622218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14942031468577779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3423220312346666 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7029409408569336, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7670016340895986, + "veriT": 7.7441945513857666, + "Yices": 5.0579516700004996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7678145172161095, + "CVC4": 2.260473364636554, + "CVC3": 2.8234434808470161, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.8890575784702661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2274435725265374 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.457833667119186, + "veriT": 10.025147961659647, + "Yices": 10.055262749960468, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.684793191681841, + "CVC4": 2.1340175486516859, + "CVC3": 9.4525103043795298, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0210602147826844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8209854814343576 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249338968158298, + "veriT": 10.1663152703275, + "Yices": 10.351148419799713, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965787294980174, + "CVC4": 0.16611637545799998, + "CVC3": 12.286396013768092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16336375519399998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.383071796531777 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.4389379142706, + "veriT": 10.145726338812999, + "Yices": 10.300566819981, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.941306340748056, + "CVC4": 0.22451746688029997, + "CVC3": 11.605210670528392, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.717466208346107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.400948928001117 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1607769227458999, + "veriT": 6.2047596734081063, + "Yices": 9.6011207269471601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1696964204058, + "CVC4": 3.0054592061673011, + "CVC3": 4.2251410748051654, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5727762707730546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21754316223029999 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.681446812486087, + "veriT": 9.7554019916812464, + "Yices": 11.165857607216726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.271241157649417, + "CVC4": 6.7306529862984981, + "CVC3": 12.917443244399434, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1327691094805736, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.821921696064841 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3328774116704363, + "veriT": 14.227178583675121, + "Yices": 14.155379002788919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.963722879935155, + "CVC4": 14.572254038526271, + "CVC3": 14.617638275920559, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.935676248186716, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.937284354695151 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.019946074267775, + "veriT": 9.7410573948292836, + "Yices": 11.976399051481399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.819299206235479, + "CVC4": 5.8522995528122115, + "CVC3": 7.7952610396304838, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0456432185980002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2684150207538849 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.625, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.273764031331462, + "veriT": 10.631296802722247, + "Yices": 10.464521664602751, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957982598343875, + "CVC4": 4.6020214474410999, + "CVC3": 11.013134377077574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4479064815049698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.404829454145906 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.776756278322642, + "veriT": 11.518336083619374, + "Yices": 11.322371450645758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.624873687069289, + "CVC4": 8.3064847151798595, + "CVC3": 10.634180916496664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8548143781140229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.642574367634507 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2594782423943784, + "veriT": 10.208541463256768, + "Yices": 10.864298649666409, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9494591763914135, + "CVC4": 12.313056909258915, + "CVC3": 3.5608976427353922, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.386549410324209, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8446502025017475 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9285714626312256, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.681745474378429, + "veriT": 10.84779145543445, + "Yices": 11.785661979722999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.321281780631701, + "CVC4": 6.4810058235451811, + "CVC3": 9.7528186136699482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231205435032214, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.556684384633737 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.312088819421684, + "veriT": 11.903955249092276, + "Yices": 10.63452407929876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.883687933729769, + "CVC4": 2.675736176023372, + "CVC3": 12.485597926786289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.451220922482394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.875133106769928 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233582323055902, + "veriT": 11.38158660442903, + "Yices": 11.288602969633354, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.941029305270145, + "CVC4": 1.8852085589412706, + "CVC3": 12.004781392909866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2104541483953692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.763402123207277 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4793192146180165, + "veriT": 11.2166196307668, + "Yices": 7.1582316020742338, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5237756512698333, + "CVC4": 7.4322021536962817, + "CVC3": 6.5140444775843918, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9728120456215192, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9747071456972636 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1208553641362, + "veriT": 11.987631253077453, + "Yices": 12.166013680374736, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1158031682952814, + "CVC4": 12.585668541380214, + "CVC3": 7.1347889846667005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.393236845149051, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9923664291071344 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9888978081051576, + "veriT": 5.9131663036170581, + "Yices": 5.6439320579511367, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1036979936665272, + "CVC4": 1.8823197589110243, + "CVC3": 1.3735352337115019, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8018083398254392, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7987105864643747 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4911232558198848, + "veriT": 4.6240086550412309, + "Yices": 10.529263242195656, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6572907801899266, + "CVC4": 3.9784045227550515, + "CVC3": 6.8985457713025662, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6636992011196834, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4265228731003776 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14049082884622222, + "veriT": 8.803012645890302, + "Yices": 7.6953708105411369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14199989838300001, + "CVC4": 1.7171754387031692, + "CVC3": 0.12961648421911109, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14070047312800002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14263530514611111 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25991999842285557, + "veriT": 5.7293672217041332, + "Yices": 9.1578228955353325, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1619898523153336, + "CVC4": 9.5824411524029234, + "CVC3": 3.3933831244306103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.121647384959926, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.166536494953126 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4442251166456432, + "veriT": 9.0503468582502844, + "Yices": 11.061129808750426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3611430687371069, + "CVC4": 14.238424474768825, + "CVC3": 4.8808871282600279, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.263637515769146, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.491210901683827 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12634317039449999, + "veriT": 0.099950376433357149, + "Yices": 2.8283510426263185, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12020401390335002, + "CVC4": 2.1636708090814261, + "CVC3": 2.6172388042914143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12305425559621429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12032058227989285 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8786764144897461, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5007886641093717, + "veriT": 7.2023199359082684, + "Yices": 7.49565968963699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0845105805852038, + "CVC4": 2.5256193019891668, + "CVC3": 0.23608966981108334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9260884356520878, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0047652325656005 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14366108904844446, + "veriT": 1.2345360530292888, + "Yices": 1.2632150430127778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16465093475322223, + "CVC4": 1.7405605548191561, + "CVC3": 2.4371925782793338, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9820363284661227, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6360503184446236 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0787880420684814, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1869237819485399, + "veriT": 12.86737346335676, + "Yices": 12.219716158713807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7734121480617393, + "CVC4": 13.186627001588045, + "CVC3": 10.911105145701503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.800712296276256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.468314955788685 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.689898034088396, + "veriT": 10.76364282446611, + "Yices": 11.427899681435111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.326906018003106, + "CVC4": 6.7527717649339207, + "CVC3": 6.8957868890046603, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0063454425824183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.317088849314757 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5227274894714355, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6920890369160206, + "veriT": 5.7213234627835305, + "Yices": 2.7086326952962625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7475179100736256, + "CVC4": 1.9470414599616657, + "CVC3": 2.0581895798464198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4382294253621692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2136952260411613 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1648097186092006, + "veriT": 10.676742843505613, + "Yices": 10.5862440622929, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1948263507074399, + "CVC4": 9.0435701516957288, + "CVC3": 9.8786487467727664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6017500419918154, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5985227713019672 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.94864818885500013, + "veriT": 6.2577721420906984, + "Yices": 13.715412729297318, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6317129843974003, + "CVC4": 5.886909307429705, + "CVC3": 6.6764016325582016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1880458623248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0045310886553414 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.075519498613044, + "veriT": 9.2211174527556174, + "Yices": 14.195392611797715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.981345906296086, + "CVC4": 9.1377479357130085, + "CVC3": 10.923381925428899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1658407001307269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.143576503788438 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9819527311828686, + "veriT": 5.126949651517557, + "Yices": 1.8067391814832587, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2604889107202908, + "CVC4": 2.551508486798808, + "CVC3": 1.3233305152577823, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4774363449085679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4785408169306948 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2118898418676016, + "veriT": 7.2592369810440704, + "Yices": 9.274657193132354, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5887201331259035, + "CVC4": 11.162848388034263, + "CVC3": 8.1623003547760682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1152425383996505, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0661656098214021 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.571153899819675, + "veriT": 10.114983482570132, + "Yices": 10.114348512059777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8995108536935827, + "CVC4": 5.5210297938656101, + "CVC3": 4.0573164148790246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233648992982005, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.232338857465461 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3982548742401251, + "veriT": 2.7739978177785543, + "Yices": 0.20694969348164374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4076254132075625, + "CVC4": 0.16986108122881249, + "CVC3": 0.14474036531538126, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.91703419913155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9133531737626739 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6424516705376249, + "veriT": 1.3682907090010377, + "Yices": 1.5958122591237875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4919459380830595, + "CVC4": 12.490158419152271, + "CVC3": 0.17804696033907502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.140746143820875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13909443278475001 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8090324006829999, + "veriT": 11.869602967431257, + "Yices": 11.804230944914773, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.81997780806, + "CVC4": 9.6870921637022871, + "CVC3": 9.532791455876815, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5618415660988276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5454728738893744 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13525493672237501, + "veriT": 14.201958930166519, + "Yices": 0.10327158662825001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18203928536975, + "CVC4": 1.9977940702396046, + "CVC3": 0.11072677014925, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9378458915450825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9372196347547614 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12996066959200001, + "veriT": 14.20866878909548, + "Yices": 0.43793201852069996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16898720718560001, + "CVC4": 0.19193847149400001, + "CVC3": 0.15452772457140002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.862267507271506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.905563520856607 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19964965023833334, + "veriT": 13.668714284593545, + "Yices": 2.815533185477924, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1642725272563377, + "CVC4": 5.1735441692712012, + "CVC3": 4.4860460937533349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2131145828154608, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9784266233287271 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1500876567211762, + "veriT": 14.223521440664221, + "Yices": 12.492397445403144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.474641825973089, + "CVC4": 13.484311149512193, + "CVC3": 14.227457682183235, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235448610642814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236024157242415 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.96694290653123, + "veriT": 14.221713663593144, + "Yices": 5.6255293398846824, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.131607393106894, + "CVC4": 2.1284638505175781, + "CVC3": 10.69430713535168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.72972712740949, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.729733424487012 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1002855703668608, + "veriT": 12.555606650337603, + "Yices": 8.1709606408388868, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5732648805034399, + "CVC4": 1.6943947804340795, + "CVC3": 5.5694998213378302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.378842229327585, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2823051873435221 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0662720269364181, + "veriT": 3.7422498873384824, + "Yices": 6.6766122686093947, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2173612338282183, + "CVC4": 1.4173973156849271, + "CVC3": 2.1012073333280821, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5200926049558954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5357826137870754 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4226284206482953, + "veriT": 7.4241057592760731, + "Yices": 10.738228897001276, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2175803260033931, + "CVC4": 13.058242454777345, + "CVC3": 2.7524534175401167, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2014273604835619, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6981883924832655 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 51.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24531979492599998, + "veriT": 2.5290170158380962, + "Yices": 2.6491516855955344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.54828626901300004, + "CVC4": 0.22396861988283334, + "CVC3": 0.24604798357549998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21353740112849998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21702919624399999 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14393418265183333, + "veriT": 0.12078615984883333, + "Yices": 0.13292994456519999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14153091129673334, + "CVC4": 2.5127304377818613, + "CVC3": 0.13615254984689998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15678660557650001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15470927911880003 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18357608741369999, + "veriT": 0.14946911937890001, + "Yices": 0.1877759842044, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2162984179154, + "CVC4": 0.20898231013270002, + "CVC3": 0.17844526713760001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18395670706930001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18454515861920001 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7090391999149999, + "veriT": 0.134247163822, + "Yices": 0.13627949186177776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7096436867262224, + "CVC4": 1.7323957983367917, + "CVC3": 0.13815084606688888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15200137935877781, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15308559538411112 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.576308801681976, + "veriT": 6.5460433323906573, + "Yices": 6.5453984229944009, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6500354546338434, + "CVC4": 7.4267296140779226, + "CVC3": 5.2625870407325133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.27212314202580001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.23801954601390002 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2823533952151429, + "veriT": 3.6742160032790174, + "Yices": 7.7886614169463142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4934285854036187, + "CVC4": 7.6456637891056003, + "CVC3": 3.4555931666296922, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6321095296354908, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6048287800711005 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 77.0, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0740853520760001, + "veriT": 12.477739024348139, + "Yices": 8.8619882989783392, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2133436783648568, + "CVC4": 12.281251480096847, + "CVC3": 10.037553099333062, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8302240446380988, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6196808961365097 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.316315809761946, + "veriT": 11.727456414180242, + "Yices": 10.294954278700338, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.175819283520882, + "CVC4": 14.479389894236228, + "CVC3": 10.974195415387456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.463835767010199, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.571625960774323 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6504208292363707, + "veriT": 12.956156961523693, + "Yices": 7.2315516095882995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2362269178023997, + "CVC4": 2.0526739619182695, + "CVC3": 3.5123333380814366, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9777642359835337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2575551692501508 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 267.0, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235986091990412, + "veriT": 12.172807332061474, + "Yices": 11.759137902368979, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.946942136189126, + "CVC4": 14.824246797192787, + "CVC3": 7.6311284313192118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.834787821286026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.467792655360018 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.085075541853502, + "veriT": 10.968228463740067, + "Yices": 12.652224416167263, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.136900266696955, + "CVC4": 14.263853767317935, + "CVC3": 13.326550592285511, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232222723462224, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.673816031219326 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5929802046096313, + "veriT": 10.160914387841833, + "Yices": 6.9407119169496836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.711090705037618, + "CVC4": 9.631911969703415, + "CVC3": 9.81266899828249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5631134479683428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1527413499433603 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0135287251601031, + "veriT": 12.262765666699547, + "Yices": 12.608409883570477, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.691976604347253, + "CVC4": 10.061877335980579, + "CVC3": 10.311208777983442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.263459738107722, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.080597045920703 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6991271637190817, + "veriT": 14.218319609080018, + "Yices": 12.129773110481176, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5389470160453635, + "CVC4": 13.352587394705766, + "CVC3": 6.0436812117786927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.602498452747737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.599554016116135 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 107.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1173825263977051, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4521303163256558, + "veriT": 10.504873866381196, + "Yices": 4.3743331135565287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8292430955539345, + "CVC4": 0.57144537251125016, + "CVC3": 5.8013406238825675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21189663894287503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20738381303125 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17099304867697498, + "veriT": 6.6450834075255996, + "Yices": 1.8361072754657375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.82519885294275008, + "CVC4": 0.16795775060724999, + "CVC3": 1.7911559252494251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9025618633563166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8991336574254785 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1172714294310788, + "veriT": 12.421543164703118, + "Yices": 11.950443322791704, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.541338164778525, + "CVC4": 11.167722898185831, + "CVC3": 7.5131659738587873, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7931354233893728, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.9598859019284172 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7380111179553637, + "veriT": 9.3243919333199869, + "Yices": 5.2296272694006554, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5271282524137151, + "CVC4": 5.4031318761611082, + "CVC3": 1.6674944917991228, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4934741485807737, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4918139936055435 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3687607398229931, + "veriT": 13.603850402044829, + "Yices": 14.068885508048483, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4845340094927391, + "CVC4": 13.243581563159374, + "CVC3": 11.310190443932509, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.341772871028686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.319962777836444 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 41.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.411853807589221, + "veriT": 10.609001617977222, + "Yices": 10.637407442574681, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.99137954718022, + "CVC4": 9.9564893197447599, + "CVC3": 8.9615539957488828, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8278455532826943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2090509299350698 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.789424924442265, + "veriT": 13.480575910450584, + "Yices": 13.156959432823056, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.532344266700068, + "CVC4": 14.359851957591779, + "CVC3": 14.218772680197912, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.974664644086381, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.921255252623796 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 134.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4220844286970156, + "veriT": 10.373769017664191, + "Yices": 11.093785433550448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.037380286779767, + "CVC4": 13.396697711954371, + "CVC3": 10.662918396137872, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.185382009219721, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7114767657492678 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.176047159092962, + "veriT": 12.504316034226504, + "Yices": 13.897146902215777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.327893381647486, + "CVC4": 12.615161969148485, + "CVC3": 13.722369099642671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252632297701535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.251834258240221 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247244532143409, + "veriT": 10.604064712100982, + "Yices": 11.596610236841915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.922345739466682, + "CVC4": 14.569432438681854, + "CVC3": 13.889604964589338, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.26335128062637, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.19155300470236 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1812766674824982, + "veriT": 13.238502714992594, + "Yices": 13.764851084090942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.142764646218398, + "CVC4": 14.727088396998226, + "CVC3": 12.952838948980638, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.191181148394502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.221431928626016 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.957429484729364, + "veriT": 13.874051275696633, + "Yices": 14.082016378051708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.208931016477788, + "CVC4": 14.532590614607564, + "CVC3": 8.8326762093957445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2426564251656824, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0736245486086364 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 61.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12763500807716666, + "veriT": 0.097555958128480003, + "Yices": 0.099948182069810002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12462197988410001, + "CVC4": 0.12629482288526669, + "CVC3": 0.10515987562305668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12410824019823333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12122586307623336 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10791633123135294, + "veriT": 0.08145099721567646, + "Yices": 0.082559859805182351, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10767455650634707, + "CVC4": 0.10495792044382352, + "CVC3": 0.085931277736288239, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10484476073187647, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1037037132636647 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4389094866971988, + "veriT": 3.9052390118961737, + "Yices": 4.9696492241248755, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6951468626722939, + "CVC4": 1.9281767822581577, + "CVC3": 3.6766643939750909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16237322194725001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7066209987719345 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.2250000238418579, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9642165956341546, + "veriT": 10.162850121695291, + "Yices": 10.353634403006875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0989310544320081, + "CVC4": 0.14757374736866666, + "CVC3": 0.71536439421770837, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15012489567204165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.422647591492934 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19629219810899998, + "veriT": 9.3910904941206148, + "Yices": 9.5501544508699787, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34271584326800003, + "CVC4": 0.15052257202823074, + "CVC3": 0.3053785073032308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14955939706838461, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5640018787933845 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.579168622159106, + "veriT": 13.626752301479513, + "Yices": 12.553287482890028, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.733996176288343, + "CVC4": 12.32941834530971, + "CVC3": 11.889893324464484, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.273467474214094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.300499302915297 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1079152275188449, + "veriT": 5.0473947271114348, + "Yices": 5.0929607033579982, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4255256376331227, + "CVC4": 1.4992183796440841, + "CVC3": 5.005415669609679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7401322831560546, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6814516250905198 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.555207575038214, + "veriT": 10.58327970060242, + "Yices": 10.063404491740497, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.330434719869238, + "CVC4": 4.1160658525520422, + "CVC3": 9.5348459042370237, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1121787437004969, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.424065621713005 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.448433246231836, + "veriT": 11.181988710315707, + "Yices": 10.759832452550567, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.762343832939182, + "CVC4": 3.7511187630127862, + "CVC3": 12.950435381927008, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6830180021597547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.037401998524379 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247319354979032, + "veriT": 10.180587102054727, + "Yices": 10.359885638986091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97057914994561, + "CVC4": 0.17482909304827274, + "CVC3": 14.25664554375234, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15622801724481819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.366995735523373 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.548094938317989, + "veriT": 10.533780233433896, + "Yices": 10.253751236507, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.144366117746884, + "CVC4": 4.197092221988834, + "CVC3": 10.252384605452866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3362157406828645, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.868532824081392 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5844175571588295, + "veriT": 6.8338618419812498, + "Yices": 10.336907678975166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.063785814102998, + "CVC4": 0.18134834646391665, + "CVC3": 8.9492496546658646, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.67597132021835, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.324692620534798 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1872667414370284, + "veriT": 7.6622867846186251, + "Yices": 9.0724477999540607, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.252610691215638, + "CVC4": 0.51682966224775007, + "CVC3": 10.712420148810125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6567233624952973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.745315234458042 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7933977735414874, + "veriT": 10.958414153966647, + "Yices": 8.2260282518242001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1377142162836673, + "CVC4": 5.8060646088712593, + "CVC3": 5.8249859575319292, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.660698332839627, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2510531022939624 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4119805994120704, + "veriT": 8.4995856064580515, + "Yices": 7.4189189298013085, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0451108907409092, + "CVC4": 2.7006340874546528, + "CVC3": 2.6785147280484845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4714215637399588, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2405825442988091 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.8285713195800781, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2249999046325684, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.972776156646324, + "veriT": 7.00399894410101, + "Yices": 3.8661132520759134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1296993984084054, + "CVC4": 5.0943173416531389, + "CVC3": 4.7896194582793976, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8026171782193838, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8012502818564302 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8184462560781665, + "veriT": 1.7974642916045001, + "Yices": 10.15654893448786, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8125934021715, + "CVC4": 7.3013759907472933, + "CVC3": 1.8353744389238333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.191047176984938, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5328203839360457 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.440031132824446, + "veriT": 13.177490099885095, + "Yices": 11.886512380959221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.359839564990523, + "CVC4": 10.325358108607139, + "CVC3": 11.511240735070134, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.697699691070994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.69825640536523 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.161986094773904, + "veriT": 7.4702191088521426, + "Yices": 11.479415002935069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2783787492694136, + "CVC4": 4.8612686031900587, + "CVC3": 6.4996968412963803, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5155018487902367, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5465026053304722 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.22151221362989998, + "veriT": 2.5100005288991314, + "Yices": 1.1470696217002598, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6020364788846255, + "CVC4": 1.616689556410186, + "CVC3": 1.5259597446220587, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4534607426971409, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4670449902494926 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5571432113647461, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13520801451849998, + "veriT": 3.6851624046955935, + "Yices": 5.9956333579315659, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13612985167514285, + "CVC4": 0.14316691446157145, + "CVC3": 0.12488784587876431, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1383784156625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13569572206992855 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1510386336666099, + "veriT": 9.8759338952188038, + "Yices": 4.958311361655495, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1542886625526199, + "CVC4": 8.9715230207208165, + "CVC3": 2.18970739639115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8155903003668286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8260102217518863 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.914081967233541, + "veriT": 11.086151406919178, + "Yices": 9.7579106952355392, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.576767795651659, + "CVC4": 2.3753814924889403, + "CVC3": 10.1079315544296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.1804250899667323, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.923287608994086 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2271962411846484, + "veriT": 11.045588371824902, + "Yices": 10.37283343165409, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.990170777379646, + "CVC4": 1.7278840606570001, + "CVC3": 5.149331015799075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6027475087499017, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4572091017138566 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8444445133209229, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2514343126200229, + "veriT": 13.409705725323317, + "Yices": 12.387171137570016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.444332973615602, + "CVC4": 12.594415471861952, + "CVC3": 8.7260089584309881, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246103148521845, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.24505632166651 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.830038749501437, + "veriT": 13.391363529883705, + "Yices": 12.753947986807379, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.147485908693827, + "CVC4": 13.492900560042013, + "CVC3": 13.540893970605907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.221808643431695, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.929094758184528 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3172009853275339, + "veriT": 8.1731291226159399, + "Yices": 10.506952734999851, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5769439436126578, + "CVC4": 8.5348903050677816, + "CVC3": 5.3354423321478004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4174684536265119, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4512395521402368 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8852190525325225, + "veriT": 14.20366302213359, + "Yices": 8.1302334093616579, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9145045879173024, + "CVC4": 12.99709087359655, + "CVC3": 14.274581447051558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.177798957311516, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.1745848415376 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.081901961927153, + "veriT": 10.122096296323498, + "Yices": 10.110591864734836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1612027558624654, + "CVC4": 3.177393758296104, + "CVC3": 0.80164936863799996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235128331103617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.229173236591862 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 30.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1963039322792, + "veriT": 2.9702907150085505, + "Yices": 4.5725023990880578, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2510095601652997, + "CVC4": 0.19696528983730002, + "CVC3": 5.0485654962460762, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3980671992679659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3982074911249516 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4984279073931699, + "veriT": 11.418432431087286, + "Yices": 9.7788400153203625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.451324610751904, + "CVC4": 0.17762937951390911, + "CVC3": 9.9471233173433813, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16584746518877272, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7876669896858948 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3913336930248752, + "veriT": 8.9836755330738534, + "Yices": 10.334041495223914, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4094244656348742, + "CVC4": 6.9948540191032791, + "CVC3": 7.3915018291403296, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.70520782529263, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.704792991661215 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24002715337393751, + "veriT": 1.6180440083092624, + "Yices": 5.6959675680731339, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5674103793739376, + "CVC4": 2.0397849654585918, + "CVC3": 0.24537053733343747, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3161254998484733, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3119519806940216 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11653706606895455, + "veriT": 0.99954930019022725, + "Yices": 1.0042934532203638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11395358578324545, + "CVC4": 3.9723874793919367, + "CVC3": 0.094221722476999989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12044259957802726, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11266910449511819 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1343253113144041, + "veriT": 10.889744456547069, + "Yices": 10.088935431808876, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.838721169014265, + "CVC4": 0.67896390376885718, + "CVC3": 0.4303728983222857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1828648107369819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.219660856635178 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.655733958525342, + "veriT": 10.478694392018058, + "Yices": 10.054600676573171, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.934739445388336, + "CVC4": 10.50052173190206, + "CVC3": 9.107619031181228, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.800362192229853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7003850899745494 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2255318443457845, + "veriT": 10.201072376163749, + "Yices": 10.356110285302002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.511880732500289, + "CVC4": 14.279720083260733, + "CVC3": 5.3564612991372007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.261213671991362, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.505967905155217 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2040918131943696, + "veriT": 6.1816258775727499, + "Yices": 14.187566749164676, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3491240034770469, + "CVC4": 13.249862007711627, + "CVC3": 13.442440328433387, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6368356508835715, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6240267674981697 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9569594860076904, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7016720771789551, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0373529164558577, + "veriT": 13.626066785605449, + "Yices": 2.4383896494684913, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2867378400135716, + "CVC4": 2.3757407271992088, + "CVC3": 2.2224402086123596, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.225205179987622, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.21934061941503 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14485625584880002, + "veriT": 9.982004657838365, + "Yices": 2.9988318084248005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14205255401720002, + "CVC4": 1.7530731186958364, + "CVC3": 1.547768857126478, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7367893455818835, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7336585552474566 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0427469087762729, + "veriT": 14.210615999407539, + "Yices": 2.4878742694566487, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0633581120154547, + "CVC4": 1.0649816225474547, + "CVC3": 2.3297922974273959, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.564727357760567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.613582697659966 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4426926225377814, + "veriT": 14.219544384243399, + "Yices": 8.0871701017864837, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.328505934384081, + "CVC4": 9.2098764248285487, + "CVC3": 6.9591036901565051, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9592579271180313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9543380178701586 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6572487255902135, + "veriT": 14.207320835515873, + "Yices": 11.187649294494474, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3085273744848545, + "CVC4": 6.6114122795486594, + "CVC3": 10.048650819145085, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.219135264582778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.217899786018901 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8188154697418213, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3613609170820808, + "veriT": 10.171935756947416, + "Yices": 10.94493961083456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.605115831691281, + "CVC4": 8.4547107841962639, + "CVC3": 12.83987554007294, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.812130622906727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.365602383578917 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.013283412771, + "veriT": 0.30084285898714291, + "Yices": 0.11814505399307143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7177724666511431, + "CVC4": 0.14608583025957148, + "CVC3": 0.14226447174771428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14069222765428571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13978075657485714 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14744276500318182, + "veriT": 0.12542409886699998, + "Yices": 0.14219970751827271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14468278388927272, + "CVC4": 0.16437214719709092, + "CVC3": 0.1462726470390909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16141575520136364, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16073972948863638 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.25368992107133331, + "veriT": 0.19028642090199999, + "Yices": 5.0538833663634133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.5553464361478333, + "CVC4": 0.2432879148115, + "CVC3": 0.23088430647483335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22705828726416666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22528784102133334 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14738694407127273, + "veriT": 8.9814811289265357, + "Yices": 0.16265336267341818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16445549156299999, + "CVC4": 0.1655719548479091, + "CVC3": 0.14443660752047272, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15082122385970909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14919281081085456 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 46.0, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15418332728199999, + "veriT": 3.5722324332599231, + "Yices": 1.5748651165108145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16982614155885714, + "CVC4": 2.2053527814315479, + "CVC3": 0.50720948155642864, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1700140551919857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16705650541257144 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2781432128423331, + "veriT": 0.14473043583666667, + "Yices": 0.15394870417955556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2789400912112221, + "CVC4": 0.18399157952599998, + "CVC3": 0.16305827517733332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17453549327077778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17464090406466667 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19374331834114283, + "veriT": 2.9998947591408429, + "Yices": 3.6617722368172543, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23121553392935715, + "CVC4": 6.2254659672856176, + "CVC3": 0.16012048539360002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.32176829816528574, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.27949751687071428 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4982851347219057, + "veriT": 8.6334632366646371, + "Yices": 7.2770690919223471, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6577300586311878, + "CVC4": 5.603226570787422, + "CVC3": 6.8699187549976761, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5842778915549656, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5881435417308647 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 162.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 55.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 38.0, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0132676626870607, + "veriT": 2.9689679032704288, + "Yices": 2.9714415814995001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1618595310121362, + "CVC4": 10.365886025742611, + "CVC3": 4.154120652121482, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9836068505413302, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9682708906689514 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16784556761132308, + "veriT": 1.7441230697559997, + "Yices": 10.984020797188579, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16568022983919231, + "CVC4": 1.2851432901561262, + "CVC3": 0.17915124634692309, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18288033306171536, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17653385948683847 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6512092232362381, + "veriT": 11.929052148874659, + "Yices": 6.3987895850357681, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.085953624438198, + "CVC4": 10.683116004407307, + "CVC3": 8.4234912363361509, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7093186913554659, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1545463874972661 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16893976569859998, + "veriT": 2.140797834257, + "Yices": 7.3838050021328083, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23607544722150001, + "CVC4": 10.194202957345791, + "CVC3": 6.0350538496998398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6380687875089996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2425921846237999 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.401108568617342, + "veriT": 13.724445198527864, + "Yices": 13.722706050488938, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.197469877217351, + "CVC4": 9.1637772223606113, + "CVC3": 9.3480746715682734, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.538852133424964, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.478203737877156 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.938601016998291, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 110.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248991436791412, + "veriT": 12.219056324264699, + "Yices": 11.367946474803365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967055161826945, + "CVC4": 12.324619760320747, + "CVC3": 12.224654886635479, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.051071943078986, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.994120348470995 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.766035515995512, + "veriT": 10.478554087026627, + "Yices": 10.666502245460858, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.996851345304069, + "CVC4": 14.318889572646366, + "CVC3": 14.27744633803402, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.27624196695052, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.589294275455096 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.865084627968923, + "veriT": 14.235908768317012, + "Yices": 14.6908964772504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.577327391985696, + "CVC4": 14.741647782244684, + "CVC3": 12.846546120759644, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.055277851419532, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.056615972922534 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7565974255038466, + "veriT": 10.708231484397437, + "Yices": 9.3718939918183324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.390769178700838, + "CVC4": 9.7963590813710386, + "CVC3": 12.723961969410286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0609180408136218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.85225230596253 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2941438943855079, + "veriT": 14.044460463632451, + "Yices": 11.703150162087329, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.779230631310076, + "CVC4": 3.8347189227313363, + "CVC3": 9.3319281470252236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.139348151302793, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.042505716945637 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7409594799208179, + "veriT": 13.10133042647429, + "Yices": 12.333935944159203, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.227060497910731, + "CVC4": 14.585240468526631, + "CVC3": 14.071046787398542, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.232300231164595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.235589743642306 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1352590173147532, + "veriT": 10.726563750149866, + "Yices": 12.923491836996948, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0966489434885522, + "CVC4": 14.466943769114705, + "CVC3": 8.9873409824387043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.233838974298521, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.233296540312796 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 43.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4193292836591933, + "veriT": 11.05350778560449, + "Yices": 11.901226932795302, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.246542583816677, + "CVC4": 7.7743416822378633, + "CVC3": 9.5768280486049289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0977609921157541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4730543643325396 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3509918927597657, + "veriT": 12.490991753761197, + "Yices": 3.3273873846334494, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.946425901398344, + "CVC4": 0.30618090234966666, + "CVC3": 0.48507608877444447, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20841516801911114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20244164882444443 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7305522900223522, + "veriT": 13.316483955577855, + "Yices": 11.321031940629313, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8900521664848249, + "CVC4": 8.9272267145954718, + "CVC3": 5.8465660481852337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.211600208915826, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.129080500805934 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7955299821432118, + "veriT": 10.198447052685479, + "Yices": 12.238312592251926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.358717220124277, + "CVC4": 12.712166447588087, + "CVC3": 9.1560714716308986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8733915796818468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5476548455302228 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 65.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 111.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2557224328651371, + "veriT": 13.211499986236971, + "Yices": 12.630038584760831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.772362293702484, + "CVC4": 13.362010661153205, + "CVC3": 11.885840019491098, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.076365082054643, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.074298009847391 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242057929576776, + "veriT": 11.650563227590023, + "Yices": 13.743892863116727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962847145072127, + "CVC4": 14.555858877398807, + "CVC3": 13.51680264744923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.208609687090389, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.144980762651839 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.968416243142215, + "veriT": 13.007927838112865, + "Yices": 14.240530004509539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.970117680253827, + "CVC4": 14.370504975103984, + "CVC3": 12.604256475139749, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.653495928674916, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.980549200489484 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1305803895730202, + "veriT": 13.646624216904582, + "Yices": 11.342433499001327, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.854961647682, + "CVC4": 9.9563855622017083, + "CVC3": 11.159490975617972, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9444111180243153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.860005278043924 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0199888397803694, + "veriT": 13.555777702511692, + "Yices": 11.266213782255244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.042311027594273, + "CVC4": 12.428143496599857, + "CVC3": 9.4614318473232597, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6692095872133361, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4610427866393421 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12204688773131581, + "veriT": 0.091588704829052639, + "Yices": 0.09494045173664209, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12019725469626316, + "CVC4": 0.12057085379852635, + "CVC3": 0.098024719639305258, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11976710220721054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11595965607290525 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10746594528498236, + "veriT": 0.66231296525474703, + "Yices": 0.66686308576629405, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11644550977980589, + "CVC4": 0.92862853438395032, + "CVC3": 0.078928400987388236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.92620724750195405, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.92459107827897813 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8140209617617735, + "veriT": 0.96172738086015752, + "Yices": 3.3389474105845416, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8714628259989126, + "CVC4": 1.3171724538824385, + "CVC3": 0.13092305997958334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14337150789058331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1841521389649167 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20593177947704763, + "veriT": 10.166241290256762, + "Yices": 10.353285701485143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25954607282152375, + "CVC4": 0.14915454883319049, + "CVC3": 0.71440173379333327, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14904425099085716, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.433134200577454 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5144387478683481, + "veriT": 6.9991463129857507, + "Yices": 7.6596537333691845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6847135356237333, + "CVC4": 0.85591942789283115, + "CVC3": 2.2231312285367748, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.81369455826727299, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2464148122921008 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7527780532836914, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0056645960586925, + "veriT": 3.7829911325397814, + "Yices": 4.7592917323615458, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5345009465282011, + "CVC4": 0.15433889986845453, + "CVC3": 3.4460943745181112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.166723568102592, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2080130406639595 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.496313812846523, + "veriT": 10.89416629165588, + "Yices": 10.582306424796636, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.07655268021901, + "CVC4": 2.8537050074292996, + "CVC3": 10.530766676223635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6985887260779329, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.729959440802695 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.017410916996662, + "veriT": 10.832389820754628, + "Yices": 10.589700371307906, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.252840853338119, + "CVC4": 2.6899645656042837, + "CVC3": 8.2542802933459232, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.69332054299755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7987297027495632 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.714928508135051, + "veriT": 10.833497637003136, + "Yices": 10.626113168260629, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.165998579295538, + "CVC4": 2.5501840503232742, + "CVC3": 12.067353842858909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5200544303405032, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.906789923572006 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237710180681054, + "veriT": 10.151215052638443, + "Yices": 10.331151159176223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963208421294345, + "CVC4": 0.15354956556300001, + "CVC3": 14.240734314338027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14166377550622222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.268607950084904 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3283003810562612, + "veriT": 5.9596238082147774, + "Yices": 4.6705663268122226, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4492479128983335, + "CVC4": 1.7450956897425156, + "CVC3": 1.7822148596738414, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4107271498920095, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4648218767839696 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2645759372954584, + "veriT": 9.0541582794409887, + "Yices": 8.7609803912280704, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0099666060704546, + "CVC4": 6.772688828732722, + "CVC3": 5.8288088810614118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0478723112055208, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0392837112463491 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.774223123555068, + "veriT": 12.309168722061653, + "Yices": 13.343584905320972, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.935534768671813, + "CVC4": 6.650604253051017, + "CVC3": 13.299486658155878, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5017892191913464, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5009872715133401 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6977684497833252, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.413518604081389, + "veriT": 10.948456346114849, + "Yices": 10.527304564728301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.989863795012042, + "CVC4": 13.158194077465623, + "CVC3": 14.221710918266462, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.823577856198062, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.246523005301459 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.43545659916879, + "veriT": 8.1754339002061993, + "Yices": 8.3051354437710003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.004267593357593, + "CVC4": 6.4917035822303149, + "CVC3": 11.246353754047446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252111363951006, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.878780798543636 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3609337630272478, + "veriT": 10.183290197063318, + "Yices": 6.1444125113676549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.579572849014941, + "CVC4": 8.2220239448226788, + "CVC3": 5.2521216615959503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5322949612955377, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8514825347884472 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4282699307913567, + "veriT": 13.040470154964765, + "Yices": 4.1905527858672142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5381146848012857, + "CVC4": 4.3867182104760394, + "CVC3": 3.6194148478527297, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.223755518842639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.224656526924701 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9374865702187005, + "veriT": 12.277990532485575, + "Yices": 11.683722991716976, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.071139671150556, + "CVC4": 13.464069107981256, + "CVC3": 10.149280184648601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.132672159478952, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.166286014757683 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8452379703521729, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235903557107918, + "veriT": 10.16749166408675, + "Yices": 10.314968836702999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950535235681675, + "CVC4": 0.16907431519550001, + "CVC3": 13.705177374708384, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.824723507263165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.218079687990228 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.900474647937223, + "veriT": 9.2616632467827262, + "Yices": 9.3993971335928173, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.612880029415839, + "CVC4": 1.1391580494610909, + "CVC3": 5.0332722232315712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8855231935629675, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.213989807392936 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2621469249518891, + "veriT": 9.526261367104043, + "Yices": 7.0777370446096493, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2636159729550003, + "CVC4": 4.4146583088736167, + "CVC3": 5.9660077918155894, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.350950889511064, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8687893482010693 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3210469886729888, + "veriT": 4.0872493986265992, + "Yices": 1.7343784344479334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9249161442893721, + "CVC4": 2.599893095774791, + "CVC3": 2.4245937430647495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4406533532655206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4432317678376982 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16094280821863635, + "veriT": 3.2851260741095887, + "Yices": 9.0655216531466269, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.50162767896418181, + "CVC4": 7.9825731616167728, + "CVC3": 1.1604852213082728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1479590061006038, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.325096257996802 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8992546605013652, + "veriT": 1.3748040216688375, + "Yices": 3.159849550391741, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9885845621998219, + "CVC4": 1.9281196600949979, + "CVC3": 2.4595386472198997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1422307140705, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5416750854097034 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.43423041373409, + "veriT": 13.807253490746689, + "Yices": 12.55634855150312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.854925610972682, + "CVC4": 11.459154676040884, + "CVC3": 6.7152431392250396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.424580689187696, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.537934069995051 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5088000923311613, + "veriT": 7.9156002600765492, + "Yices": 9.2804306553869633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2876170654911903, + "CVC4": 5.9559532935214579, + "CVC3": 4.2511261843407189, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8415919918795307, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8399643799674275 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2986111640930176, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1916690052829946, + "veriT": 5.9500513416520686, + "Yices": 5.6710766119698723, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5561079652437853, + "CVC4": 3.1213687483069448, + "CVC3": 8.3984760750014651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16293291320050002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5512037705155399 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.604675003824985, + "veriT": 6.1523801632450006, + "Yices": 9.2990441205353793, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.027486902453177, + "CVC4": 3.2825085492375115, + "CVC3": 7.8920106950417805, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8088890946383689, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8586808441408511 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4056466628572331, + "veriT": 10.512107887535866, + "Yices": 3.2447931982724274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4204634449567997, + "CVC4": 3.365339877951504, + "CVC3": 2.4481274756934113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8255104218889553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8212974522600192 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.773839485918558, + "veriT": 11.718608826162232, + "Yices": 9.5456673318927976, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.336299322065228, + "CVC4": 5.7428417985371123, + "CVC3": 13.467231439394407, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5762924285560098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.456602026062923 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3111237371691939, + "veriT": 3.6020742562351407, + "Yices": 7.8961071960122879, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7162963418170807, + "CVC4": 0.28185802864642856, + "CVC3": 2.2595321471450824, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4060965392340168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0067515007589019 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14662462367207141, + "veriT": 13.919057580278519, + "Yices": 0.83942676135407146, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22827130714628571, + "CVC4": 3.275007247571434, + "CVC3": 0.14510691086464284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0298920865853383, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8238698956805184 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.262962818145752, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0583329200744629, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8015977850104399, + "veriT": 9.3856325491616648, + "Yices": 9.6682516243651868, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9520247179180288, + "CVC4": 5.4729922075140145, + "CVC3": 6.3134720527220791, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.145316975258231, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.012309505222985 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4690313979388363, + "veriT": 6.7587440768932661, + "Yices": 9.1118363817068779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5881509943468477, + "CVC4": 5.8063316475796372, + "CVC3": 5.9932208102641811, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0939781538359155, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0579616123712183 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15118553305544447, + "veriT": 4.7983182524352888, + "Yices": 3.4624133359564997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.64552956486966673, + "CVC4": 0.14749654217844443, + "CVC3": 0.16907307290200002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13054286612344443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13028509532366667 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4972688428520318, + "veriT": 5.9330073012057118, + "Yices": 10.25265571900923, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7584857151654889, + "CVC4": 7.8735403184954542, + "CVC3": 6.3287707298279239, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0543565743491365, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8447664137346607 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.295098597944822, + "veriT": 10.113326190951437, + "Yices": 10.113905034987853, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.913663273869275, + "CVC4": 5.5180432202382628, + "CVC3": 6.6945863361598983, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.441126935858172, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.46004523787629 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6212140263794019, + "veriT": 7.817336078339677, + "Yices": 10.947668463646398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3936519497849065, + "CVC4": 11.309323100046438, + "CVC3": 11.200325506653774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1603896821510746, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9793603012109058 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.31266204453455554, + "veriT": 6.8044946120999112, + "Yices": 9.6374832040593539, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3233244902237398, + "CVC4": 7.9829503535011606, + "CVC3": 0.67497626246922227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4147723655863205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0264358236802096 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 79.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0916664600372314, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7887700881548334, + "veriT": 4.1208468119930179, + "Yices": 1.7733034025655501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7905426525901669, + "CVC4": 1.7931791599011664, + "CVC3": 0.18206237501284997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4737887120382607, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4688954544952995 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15909133662237501, + "veriT": 0.1463172527495, + "Yices": 0.1552158026165, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15318747871437499, + "CVC4": 0.17304253885474999, + "CVC3": 0.15701870964449999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16691387859275003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16183091012287501 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.206878653436875, + "veriT": 7.9126460097849138, + "Yices": 3.6233851204637069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2302461698599125, + "CVC4": 7.4400078112768675, + "CVC3": 0.1274030955672, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.34099796236088747, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.25072086231150004 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13761019887583079, + "veriT": 7.2289250561684693, + "Yices": 12.05086024942662, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13560333081728462, + "CVC4": 3.4074176938819298, + "CVC3": 3.6167424347046166, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.29329496186069232, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.30695241355992309 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1829879819615652, + "veriT": 6.2811188492743844, + "Yices": 8.1530181787356852, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7079125227455787, + "CVC4": 4.5119455964178723, + "CVC3": 0.15921362347623078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9189972012099297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4446025156097306 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1605215616041478, + "veriT": 2.0125063215590857, + "Yices": 2.1354709910994512, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2602676968748328, + "CVC4": 0.15346928561114287, + "CVC3": 2.1574451818319589, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14689241248342855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14764977648585714 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19416020858649996, + "veriT": 0.16840057412397, + "Yices": 2.2689532173732805, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21112109879300997, + "CVC4": 0.20249406163638001, + "CVC3": 0.20536306909834004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18605935118691003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19118604764024999 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9347037330535803, + "veriT": 10.310349955821831, + "Yices": 9.3993432498473677, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.753039790977871, + "CVC4": 3.100158072288663, + "CVC3": 1.431652983502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8492493287717853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.141772978242091 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.274484878804914, + "veriT": 13.043457926936847, + "Yices": 8.8532130006535947, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.048171879917756, + "CVC4": 7.1794310833097272, + "CVC3": 11.419397210263025, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.430301664843196, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.319731769418659 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26885398611766664, + "veriT": 0.16763635077450001, + "Yices": 4.9530441470389013, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.83930469794800011, + "CVC4": 0.21913895918516668, + "CVC3": 0.22737659649799999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21715759151866668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22032455667499998 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17882888027257143, + "veriT": 5.9692254570829606, + "Yices": 0.20139127170585716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17872950711728569, + "CVC4": 0.191448410406, + "CVC3": 0.16725183183685718, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17822024562471431, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17284034882185711 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15884539619400001, + "veriT": 0.13820615102833333, + "Yices": 0.14885604271888889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16144977983755554, + "CVC4": 0.18091655721344446, + "CVC3": 0.1565937189412222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17290583817855554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17108184967411111 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9121449847935623, + "veriT": 5.2683482753967308, + "Yices": 3.3990999475103814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9200623208474377, + "CVC4": 5.2175752337662136, + "CVC3": 1.7975817030757661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.323090235345036, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.298892390684055 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.81006101548087994, + "veriT": 1.0737747201270351, + "Yices": 7.1208788359198136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.81758445821241987, + "CVC4": 8.7258806174779426, + "CVC3": 4.4963864420126578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0874946736185682, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.085931179997806 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 63.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8137331265194216, + "veriT": 12.486002979236677, + "Yices": 7.3400958828803695, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.18461386438557, + "CVC4": 14.325598823925223, + "CVC3": 6.7514620029859742, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1971264171796063, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3419170126649931 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4038393323372098, + "veriT": 9.0884086857535031, + "Yices": 2.3299738912951184, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6504317460518241, + "CVC4": 4.3993337762393612, + "CVC3": 3.3840240108137141, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3651970925254995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6357715188704773 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.5564005558923637, + "veriT": 13.566473120892942, + "Yices": 11.986016157903634, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0988120053253216, + "CVC4": 5.7039302637312099, + "CVC3": 6.700571494243615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.395197527259665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.39660482650541 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 22.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 78.0, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233297201890156, + "veriT": 13.200259251897652, + "Yices": 11.589272554719242, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948610378398598, + "CVC4": 11.879145759884363, + "CVC3": 13.201914200102774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.03310314097811, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.035518150589624 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.272393418014859, + "veriT": 10.21232300425075, + "Yices": 10.4071193951275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.993629948324072, + "CVC4": 14.302898793705317, + "CVC3": 13.927595536349971, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.26892100331508, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.916110567343445 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.99737639438562509, + "veriT": 13.206940748351151, + "Yices": 10.605781792892671, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.282310569179328, + "CVC4": 6.2816251507927126, + "CVC3": 6.8841331717207499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.960858897019341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.961351502336019 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 79.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4331964296086017, + "veriT": 11.627767152686896, + "Yices": 10.724970811053941, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.2453462827023287, + "CVC4": 0.60595844663354537, + "CVC3": 2.2272734054493637, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8590352259093148, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8568150637185337 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 36.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5162812958003133, + "veriT": 9.6229553717924468, + "Yices": 10.428489131143404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.827753159515721, + "CVC4": 7.1645846592953175, + "CVC3": 6.4756667486940129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1697675797728975, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7308748872734214 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5612007976678699, + "veriT": 14.274381691588522, + "Yices": 6.5084725439308286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8869435095646701, + "CVC4": 3.5973720582779833, + "CVC3": 3.4197008994014007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.41879885263977779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.40725311157222222 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.091048586710663, + "veriT": 11.149131323445012, + "Yices": 12.30516847362019, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.423521346431134, + "CVC4": 12.975710536498159, + "CVC3": 9.6906604155786304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.11059942480167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5549196460950103 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 88.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0181624889373779, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.867965290641445, + "veriT": 13.143753294524416, + "Yices": 11.683903308813306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.172248674923274, + "CVC4": 12.052642301451693, + "CVC3": 12.043537037510548, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.202574314496587, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.674500300329903 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7787289691734385, + "veriT": 13.625744995492928, + "Yices": 13.523342823775806, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2655807012296822, + "CVC4": 14.708301284738758, + "CVC3": 3.4953874777752132, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.668570764913754, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.635136232565772 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9888449872534073, + "veriT": 10.488181089587423, + "Yices": 4.9273811112931156, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4586330589543963, + "CVC4": 7.3195729883864447, + "CVC3": 8.728389154333005, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0927608126130011, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0963194961566778 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6080619623082004, + "veriT": 14.235459079277669, + "Yices": 14.249852959140663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.073792436361096, + "CVC4": 14.400448130859004, + "CVC3": 11.112552373314273, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.610222181489057, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.616952399345751 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.414518989422628, + "veriT": 13.403715667406273, + "Yices": 11.564794750980036, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950668848424167, + "CVC4": 14.690988529618313, + "CVC3": 14.217613718107202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.691796591360848, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.236185017200608 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.730623079433995, + "veriT": 9.6601825296545609, + "Yices": 9.336454407799156, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.551040434222038, + "CVC4": 10.882581568210195, + "CVC3": 10.174284012566783, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.217383251992258, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.243499249923142 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 51.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0959904373910003, + "veriT": 11.475075984299441, + "Yices": 7.0738857540136628, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5265498433587839, + "CVC4": 7.592372874243642, + "CVC3": 10.340974446669469, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9434283704689819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9403109922616755 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 217.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 147, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 284.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6385444427206615, + "veriT": 9.851231444342039, + "Yices": 13.615465380247548, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.580688238562754, + "CVC4": 12.181268452808666, + "CVC3": 9.7191382272816487, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2086427116334582, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1954738581927833 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 181.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6160632675537148, + "veriT": 14.227150877422885, + "Yices": 14.016899968856473, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.581609629883022, + "CVC4": 10.695304251086295, + "CVC3": 11.96630459059624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.24097564561661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238361821008258 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.843961753270197, + "veriT": 13.825189480665856, + "Yices": 14.232422736652349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.488764414550866, + "CVC4": 14.34378954689814, + "CVC3": 13.211716909671356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.752305118737558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.59529414707985 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1554713037395619, + "veriT": 11.346136658425969, + "Yices": 13.721622941349422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.801720653469191, + "CVC4": 14.155656032468505, + "CVC3": 14.016228058863431, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4250352389651297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2899999366653203 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3629679323684893, + "veriT": 13.827175639730211, + "Yices": 13.682788025737935, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.253068031167777, + "CVC4": 14.638451641091743, + "CVC3": 11.567693561859098, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.858127233734578, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.865939303331364 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.039769466464161, + "veriT": 12.152700957447667, + "Yices": 12.90051666377353, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.996020828120365, + "CVC4": 14.597949477428214, + "CVC3": 13.958059911708986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.409893447078099, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.999136465106181 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12193104064100002, + "veriT": 0.092189144787133345, + "Yices": 0.095674815768741664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11902489235995838, + "CVC4": 0.12047287811412501, + "CVC3": 0.09715895077044584, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11812463728962501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11557618961563333 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11936827870635293, + "veriT": 0.090244453667358823, + "Yices": 0.096304798557517654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1180627101125, + "CVC4": 0.11616248767795294, + "CVC3": 0.096442956003882349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11223478248482352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11125335063745881 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0389319688526975, + "veriT": 1.2379321492923989, + "Yices": 1.0149700946675224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1134034622003277, + "CVC4": 1.705366676441918, + "CVC3": 0.12336895814083333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14663219457277776, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14789393554399999 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2229608872339615, + "veriT": 8.6561868166590656, + "Yices": 8.7661702671076007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5798665532119376, + "CVC4": 3.8510869478569889, + "CVC3": 3.9678166099940868, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6711476374831826, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3116848902216507 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20601598539083335, + "veriT": 10.169319736286248, + "Yices": 10.349850374477167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26184179082036113, + "CVC4": 0.15040241740613888, + "CVC3": 0.70666229894997223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14926203220672218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.420821948694021 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18469671113331251, + "veriT": 7.6514044306102491, + "Yices": 9.2194007820572512, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34317741936293744, + "CVC4": 0.15182277962475002, + "CVC3": 0.267993838678875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14948187865556248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2968932855875117 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7613635063171387, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7386364936828613, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0034593298498615, + "veriT": 8.1554111302593864, + "Yices": 8.2516543217138718, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2600937713288243, + "CVC4": 2.0112514985034902, + "CVC3": 2.4363639485966249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9048948560971986, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7316038299009922 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242827187683895, + "veriT": 10.170020262648134, + "Yices": 10.335627933525469, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961660241210536, + "CVC4": 0.15971878523959995, + "CVC3": 10.760923731411378, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6479615184451997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.327671186577863 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.230875285008176, + "veriT": 10.153373823457143, + "Yices": 10.314966071609001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.943328613889431, + "CVC4": 0.18530956518357145, + "CVC3": 13.824266814754093, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8032635247598046, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.941086466077712 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6674519261114256, + "veriT": 9.9009256152599505, + "Yices": 7.2191317220352502, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8436801520193029, + "CVC4": 3.8235653608167199, + "CVC3": 7.4259793323143271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0370441809011082, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5559546733322982 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.837151837143487, + "veriT": 12.697594886648787, + "Yices": 11.38831052188926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.906444076924663, + "CVC4": 9.3471468321516635, + "CVC3": 14.227477708399665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9499559343331327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.174128540857343 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20441375203799997, + "veriT": 0.16524008372458893, + "Yices": 8.0883275675018869, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24099017128366665, + "CVC4": 0.17257276807677779, + "CVC3": 0.22376006946084445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7343537523697274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6566401298365099 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7299465359234594, + "veriT": 11.066526229783541, + "Yices": 12.185314761961758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1600420046276385, + "CVC4": 3.190955604660473, + "CVC3": 10.271610800992818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0100328196202506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3339671059912286 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5342612933907627, + "veriT": 10.525373484555738, + "Yices": 1.9899319035155001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8575081191013254, + "CVC4": 7.2405191154059176, + "CVC3": 7.2557820227339063, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.903018711556131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.435331449010349 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6207907052838522, + "veriT": 13.533730693433403, + "Yices": 13.106061348773887, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.856737960456149, + "CVC4": 14.53271540332207, + "CVC3": 15.063197030591477, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.556631072918762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.557993579597271 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.647609857647698, + "veriT": 11.540523500789517, + "Yices": 12.260777465720563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.262985719460053, + "CVC4": 7.6192690218560486, + "CVC3": 12.090173363514578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.357080980943953, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.049098678360551 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9801444756856545, + "veriT": 11.253439386114403, + "Yices": 10.465265098360621, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.110688364146979, + "CVC4": 12.454695534201411, + "CVC3": 6.7908987519314774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9128105580181289, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3780187192441966 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.724009039354158, + "veriT": 10.445155890002795, + "Yices": 10.303654082721625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.354948023479926, + "CVC4": 1.41269273126275, + "CVC3": 12.78902089844247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.39222419778833, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.680429458336366 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242432655967491, + "veriT": 10.157733653921667, + "Yices": 10.318718265997417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958287928525415, + "CVC4": 1.3715066551082433, + "CVC3": 11.185091565104313, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5825162128751959, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.429877150406789 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1623461432838917, + "veriT": 6.3402018351648799, + "Yices": 9.2450942494423156, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5405029553140324, + "CVC4": 2.9807263099725048, + "CVC3": 6.6331380685754056, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0521657031116183, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.614696751583014 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.133077407038875, + "veriT": 1.3934865866310875, + "Yices": 0.115510325562225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12977273845246251, + "CVC4": 1.981725242159448, + "CVC3": 0.12168947029414998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3826214268601251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3784878462010874 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5311600144885462, + "veriT": 9.0745801092595055, + "Yices": 11.294626351345187, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6888722057463132, + "CVC4": 12.647557422662617, + "CVC3": 4.7188210597758795, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.94562047888939, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8626841385362045 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.439960208126454, + "veriT": 14.235831885333596, + "Yices": 11.025797125886022, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.969425305353351, + "CVC4": 12.039995319719115, + "CVC3": 6.5126249101567275, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.738503320859166, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.738086600984193 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8309519290924072, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.952990702452047, + "veriT": 4.3509512724043811, + "Yices": 2.6955567040086721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1014826496053205, + "CVC4": 3.1453134268641447, + "CVC3": 7.0304622913213226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15699140365229997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1533194480533 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6597418428897304, + "veriT": 9.0755740403788803, + "Yices": 4.6827098905631139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8395629752042915, + "CVC4": 0.15415549533141668, + "CVC3": 7.9131675434839499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.317875510016034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.939743889485555 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1517606862359999, + "veriT": 6.3256611598421797, + "Yices": 0.10995481729468333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0020983004256685, + "CVC4": 2.5036464501843878, + "CVC3": 2.475229040196226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.179229574556944, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.176209157697786 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2619390399743171, + "veriT": 14.23194686656468, + "Yices": 10.209101143753374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6527295723795268, + "CVC4": 4.7580345079233597, + "CVC3": 7.0526149770408235, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.475189293602501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.515838527288782 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.119748058938329, + "veriT": 10.163836388203556, + "Yices": 10.347499624947444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.680525743004067, + "CVC4": 0.16110261408277779, + "CVC3": 10.579184737799419, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1683645350478889, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0052289681695665 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.453998996550578, + "veriT": 6.7415293577807196, + "Yices": 13.89608974035041, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4286176915916, + "CVC4": 12.610339496224457, + "CVC3": 11.962120246245011, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2809894540826896, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3188850760215409 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5247070146039885, + "veriT": 13.104226265346009, + "Yices": 12.014945266061915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3840647092646119, + "CVC4": 11.906902950958019, + "CVC3": 9.4245526069420098, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.045648670805649, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.111100068722809 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.83261336626292859, + "veriT": 1.0857495790521356, + "Yices": 0.080555532453071427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.82924616753727154, + "CVC4": 1.1179118869599105, + "CVC3": 1.0979923592056928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10586595110744287, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11065169338567858 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14962133919933332, + "veriT": 5.1165650861083423, + "Yices": 10.015091925622665, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14355158383391667, + "CVC4": 4.8572089732779897, + "CVC3": 0.15080800179100001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4852016015601537, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0784880778435255 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1081869602203369, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8975694179534912, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 20.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4980480968884509, + "veriT": 6.8103037664122432, + "Yices": 9.984530220427434, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1091435305185247, + "CVC4": 0.2372827708933333, + "CVC3": 6.149947306592531, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.109131571038807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.468358827020971 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.35021575459899995, + "veriT": 9.173480894283303, + "Yices": 8.8008963756890015, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.15773770849722, + "CVC4": 9.5718229105827799, + "CVC3": 2.9777227018807633, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.551920477878129, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4817627552366401 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19736257840357144, + "veriT": 2.9728076556221708, + "Yices": 1.5664907399037145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.86826109588942857, + "CVC4": 2.1683748192128891, + "CVC3": 0.30323330656528574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.166299530269542, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7089695993921001 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9621214763928536, + "veriT": 7.6187469539535426, + "Yices": 7.6586205998307433, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5482716716777847, + "CVC4": 11.482093925272604, + "CVC3": 4.3879506904328966, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.707086855329282, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.518769926790313 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.704863700206628, + "veriT": 9.5489034156514236, + "Yices": 10.469520734169928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.028522583944062, + "CVC4": 11.737622216662512, + "CVC3": 6.9917026799481636, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.345912308655421, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.811494300200618 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8341106900470909, + "veriT": 9.2697845849262226, + "Yices": 11.242263374369932, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5592834144859999, + "CVC4": 9.3414358982436632, + "CVC3": 7.5718843627357275, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5726202627585231, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0061108874469937 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 9.0, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1176766980028594, + "veriT": 6.8385955198189494, + "Yices": 6.9512617497951501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5636828047724727, + "CVC4": 2.5383390846809433, + "CVC3": 2.6866069424615024, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5130407638311807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7628643525563747 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16910645110425002, + "veriT": 0.1518744190795, + "Yices": 3.1684545727676654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17008922420262498, + "CVC4": 0.17836089116974999, + "CVC3": 0.16139930567999999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17374454186712499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17547013922937499 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4116345316678887, + "veriT": 9.8106474096910308, + "Yices": 12.032607021506443, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7373659794333332, + "CVC4": 10.320620269017185, + "CVC3": 11.310716704423877, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5211560542098885, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5191980389389927 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9721972715291178, + "veriT": 9.0816006679743069, + "Yices": 7.8717244606405643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4656465456562717, + "CVC4": 14.651984311155481, + "CVC3": 9.8706738779916279, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.169750492855023, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.453582676169891 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15585428914925001, + "veriT": 3.5493739860458331, + "Yices": 3.4738378866244997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9246209569182611, + "CVC4": 0.30879266755525003, + "CVC3": 0.16959168770783331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3174554412852231, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3297615476963565 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.497774420600068, + "veriT": 11.950016475128971, + "Yices": 11.194967173917414, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.530594377676181, + "CVC4": 6.3455885321083016, + "CVC3": 10.127085632787974, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.061203099079188, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.90426061333366 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4943237067152504, + "veriT": 14.218776424516701, + "Yices": 11.692250717342038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5468597900657501, + "CVC4": 3.2777739667997325, + "CVC3": 12.469969048446327, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.471253060774176, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.471914927908566 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1231171992940698, + "veriT": 9.9690138188447772, + "Yices": 7.2917606747240908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.9416032984412865, + "CVC4": 6.1403318222408503, + "CVC3": 2.1547049693484297, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9217652221212385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.482945432165245 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0554855125693636, + "veriT": 0.12240907369618183, + "Yices": 0.14101293040754545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0522490994042728, + "CVC4": 0.16462301380709091, + "CVC3": 0.14189028425054545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15824805163136363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16000781867236363 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14727975601514284, + "veriT": 6.1734758715064029, + "Yices": 2.1676179901542123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16087292899542857, + "CVC4": 0.16947623597614286, + "CVC3": 0.14833050161272857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15991179638848571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15586452098152859 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10412156840719999, + "veriT": 0.080080060998783328, + "Yices": 0.080934405778016666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10441582714353331, + "CVC4": 9.5326677093368541, + "CVC3": 0.092324359930966673, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1047918387647, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10531097286633333 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.31206414523881815, + "veriT": 0.22409416140027272, + "Yices": 7.9570952569038447, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.78382905842009087, + "CVC4": 0.27280349784772728, + "CVC3": 0.28148833037109089, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.26062807227863638, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2581754709871818 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3139600794730373, + "veriT": 9.8152354594901094, + "Yices": 5.4587291488784091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3708104821221989, + "CVC4": 1.3465458178532115, + "CVC3": 1.1823352880427902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5894979820674457, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6530534119664901 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9033032856888354, + "veriT": 3.1375795918273912, + "Yices": 11.320767296799302, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.002987053470842, + "CVC4": 9.0674720199802987, + "CVC3": 6.5654986105035009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14621380293774999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14272322263699999 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 80.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0910260677337646, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9846650761630737, + "veriT": 5.4571507542506241, + "Yices": 5.3181910592243673, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0542063294766706, + "CVC4": 8.4156992397798334, + "CVC3": 1.3240656932660371, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4839835051096963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0433806763065019 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3198023311207807, + "veriT": 10.833982229187702, + "Yices": 8.3657044734246551, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.629478853333191, + "CVC4": 6.1651536038697357, + "CVC3": 8.8205728139456525, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.598076379141832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.952952227227412 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.405906462222603, + "veriT": 9.7463477032397119, + "Yices": 9.7676640376717945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.790884285094766, + "CVC4": 12.677679627898812, + "CVC3": 11.279340439779116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5432768190762154, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5258829280645116 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 61.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15515222460614284, + "veriT": 3.9783534816855499, + "Yices": 0.14842840367871429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.159670023681, + "CVC4": 0.17522438238357144, + "CVC3": 0.1526484820372857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1676292229792857, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16852458194728573 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.44626564715744443, + "veriT": 13.318150741808077, + "Yices": 9.1083636041997291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9021354164211344, + "CVC4": 2.5151392159352217, + "CVC3": 1.7420549689255556, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0471289589370589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3340080342905156 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9295055866241455, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 185.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.40582663053779, + "veriT": 12.855107294333001, + "Yices": 11.67574118875789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.276500800130714, + "CVC4": 13.609561679492138, + "CVC3": 6.9688214813717844, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.967053064847756, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.96744095752247 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.272989365966598, + "veriT": 12.475733731834667, + "Yices": 12.023680285274088, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.985238789134339, + "CVC4": 13.135540128358912, + "CVC3": 14.282337226314285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.597502806350313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.32951628555624 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.267760591948193, + "veriT": 10.237114042328249, + "Yices": 10.418085155368001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.990916828082151, + "CVC4": 14.317408574469844, + "CVC3": 14.276305956501892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.526011099706038, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.441937523243384 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.097607509376452, + "veriT": 14.230919513356838, + "Yices": 14.65801035920625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.049945611937538, + "CVC4": 14.729949621972578, + "CVC3": 12.554758974741084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255552833050274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.506095917468425 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 14.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.703264222833667, + "veriT": 13.553104617539518, + "Yices": 12.438117036780163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.945090311442547, + "CVC4": 14.554647568077144, + "CVC3": 12.11968115580189, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237612925825815, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.235808818203855 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0523376082692497, + "veriT": 14.388297563771689, + "Yices": 12.682619252786697, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.020666888411164, + "CVC4": 7.2816970582556042, + "CVC3": 13.747360788327695, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.144311249272771, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.058111994774762 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 171.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 32.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7655403980250517, + "veriT": 9.8731636540143022, + "Yices": 9.6406674387096718, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6654670272812471, + "CVC4": 11.281319197724805, + "CVC3": 4.1743663038235583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2142350331122316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2327419312606658 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0628654956817627, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9262969324547914, + "veriT": 12.199459823219795, + "Yices": 10.635816774858078, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5417643150729159, + "CVC4": 14.418795070983487, + "CVC3": 12.082836833255575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.248211075996402, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.76553293338865 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237273101136813, + "veriT": 10.1671602910325, + "Yices": 11.23329777237841, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95009756225004, + "CVC4": 14.52790444702517, + "CVC3": 12.909616365007519, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.923002347765227, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.525823012443547 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1497227382936428, + "veriT": 12.876527748840209, + "Yices": 8.2065820546916921, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9394975129282326, + "CVC4": 9.9302134486696154, + "CVC3": 8.8888868298467756, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8502754418327392, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.722354104117473 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.36281499679504287, + "veriT": 3.479660015454257, + "Yices": 1.1441259003095055, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.46503990817278573, + "CVC4": 1.2342350463593614, + "CVC3": 2.2270554084317884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16389934940691428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15132335460057858 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.499116314663125, + "veriT": 13.202576233366118, + "Yices": 6.0920521295143253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4308226612351334, + "CVC4": 5.6699978827186603, + "CVC3": 5.9628599635510202, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4598696430200899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4564913234463512 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0168144702911377, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8412847642349899, + "veriT": 13.590163355354221, + "Yices": 9.5885207178900824, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.478621793686507, + "CVC4": 2.7289559963174095, + "CVC3": 3.9307984514317638, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5687451412668589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0479103929048499 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 295.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 40.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6253046760377403, + "veriT": 8.1665286649386886, + "Yices": 11.192917775734459, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.033956811704533, + "CVC4": 11.964762839371835, + "CVC3": 5.4766505031044446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2450631911616021, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2545727874309112 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.699439896644888, + "veriT": 13.577994145391711, + "Yices": 14.16742762343779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.943609716065698, + "CVC4": 14.678228817135704, + "CVC3": 13.124756774727349, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.214410749363251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.232019669688826 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236120852017356, + "veriT": 13.650447054957612, + "Yices": 13.346691977579667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958208785263492, + "CVC4": 14.498372515985793, + "CVC3": 13.765156142475471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.180684643263529, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.901594553359985 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 343.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1472017043054858, + "veriT": 12.706247464522386, + "Yices": 13.771165210353971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.981050337460225, + "CVC4": 13.918788420059023, + "CVC3": 12.93129144646057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4081431826419997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4548036926425549 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6833864620050623, + "veriT": 14.244067144142935, + "Yices": 14.281229331174369, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.452477378355926, + "CVC4": 14.657440854507247, + "CVC3": 14.163740906519603, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8886810164419785, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9984097798524827 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.325432096090344, + "veriT": 13.846424875085637, + "Yices": 13.768592536075715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.560644766814537, + "CVC4": 14.866972003546502, + "CVC3": 10.912134672487557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.247693849342586, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.965472125297278 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13384332729839168, + "veriT": 0.92683166252346239, + "Yices": 0.93219390000934588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14546745644467918, + "CVC4": 1.2999539128388546, + "CVC3": 0.099376447315133329, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2933481980716348, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2907682765800439 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.95470146848844184, + "veriT": 0.093324905458179175, + "Yices": 0.095864630652158347, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.95390317144330006, + "CVC4": 0.11808299259562083, + "CVC3": 0.10004414371767083, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11731431452054582, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11736951019230417 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.875, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.439440654771218, + "veriT": 8.7871509176057021, + "Yices": 7.9291999197551739, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.952546816342213, + "CVC4": 7.9503403510319774, + "CVC3": 5.3292383457347174, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5004985056721574, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.334122020235152 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1714284420013428, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14056763343439999, + "veriT": 1.1079964350145, + "Yices": 4.4447207918673994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18002614567619998, + "CVC4": 0.1428502141671, + "CVC3": 0.13484438834481, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13578490618069999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2802378493661088 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20593211946611539, + "veriT": 10.163406755059693, + "Yices": 10.347002795163657, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27486317410507694, + "CVC4": 0.1498064079596923, + "CVC3": 0.62518513430734624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14945623505365385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.704945012843833 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 77.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.089491339330353, + "veriT": 12.892060270495362, + "Yices": 12.013646263696941, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.310758787045494, + "CVC4": 12.579888334500001, + "CVC3": 11.091292562977307, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.991954441623401, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.082068510228494 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.56541648199033334, + "veriT": 8.1607180795778351, + "Yices": 8.2077773112100374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2177225209952578, + "CVC4": 0.14834465390816667, + "CVC3": 0.46687119410450001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14064176539616668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7811710463459032 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.323070328557845, + "veriT": 10.179153803300375, + "Yices": 10.3313504789405, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963306926730324, + "CVC4": 2.8391825065417504, + "CVC3": 7.6782081675391325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2094658873967514, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.28559149814728 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7083334922790527, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.831029263989958, + "veriT": 10.570723674123284, + "Yices": 10.470919170482802, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.474788141031487, + "CVC4": 1.6468954137299643, + "CVC3": 10.956843613091863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5542487559797633, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.853884890537607 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247465132111975, + "veriT": 10.1677274015485, + "Yices": 10.365877167240125, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964316567716907, + "CVC4": 0.16329312837625001, + "CVC3": 12.210406730671519, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15856969125631248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.635147542687479 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.712582533304509, + "veriT": 10.412966873001796, + "Yices": 10.16773153408975, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.339851206319718, + "CVC4": 10.209658747157118, + "CVC3": 12.812792110271682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6778964389174575, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4124092284222485 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.455139719300067, + "veriT": 8.1633541601266, + "Yices": 10.326559411692399, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.032388529968213, + "CVC4": 0.174001532322, + "CVC3": 10.689692093375331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237893548141681, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.255093381875742 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.527860718285082, + "veriT": 11.51460809450721, + "Yices": 11.127807919890076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.759023533404353, + "CVC4": 6.0272567503034518, + "CVC3": 12.243651548627792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2237388189868579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.438379783655911 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2031446233745884, + "veriT": 8.4612524209682878, + "Yices": 6.2135711141249219, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1495777924864967, + "CVC4": 2.3019601471776725, + "CVC3": 3.0000487838249614, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7239538562774914, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6474730660741503 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4424279169535312, + "veriT": 4.4320475243637141, + "Yices": 7.4469626047172133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5041077509553995, + "CVC4": 0.57412829661857145, + "CVC3": 2.4374843806270641, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1944312098006167, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2944871735121115 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3001259516589396, + "veriT": 3.5964502809467001, + "Yices": 9.1689244107685557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.570228056203371, + "CVC4": 3.8956760394765144, + "CVC3": 3.3193398125118176, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.739277356542241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.873475416353342 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9166665077209473, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6830365879013733, + "veriT": 8.6420310334175028, + "Yices": 9.9347520388874653, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5950901476649353, + "CVC4": 9.325261152526112, + "CVC3": 9.6800671858424217, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.461056104925376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.711456198339558 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8120440927768868, + "veriT": 5.3637395758985909, + "Yices": 3.2010144264961919, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6555070323365566, + "CVC4": 5.4346885291364657, + "CVC3": 5.363898167423792, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6216973905171912, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6198359302584033 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.134351280345125, + "veriT": 2.6103828381305125, + "Yices": 9.6614715681621757, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12744974425737501, + "CVC4": 0.15070371583637499, + "CVC3": 0.135243078966125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.136537103277, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13445707842525001 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14583409354816665, + "veriT": 0.12642726985444999, + "Yices": 0.13009028171500001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14185760558583335, + "CVC4": 0.15646657063641667, + "CVC3": 0.14098865544041669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1565194698953333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15851337630950002 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0988811703498094, + "veriT": 11.574314432050778, + "Yices": 9.8036488633099115, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5543748763825622, + "CVC4": 13.213997173752325, + "CVC3": 12.917403171992135, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.220360993753873, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.227628547579881 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6960426676230753, + "veriT": 12.474692996569031, + "Yices": 7.6223147357969285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.162460078419496, + "CVC4": 11.02417094190017, + "CVC3": 11.471176136865783, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.477033303517993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.476795254291726 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7092072397937255, + "veriT": 7.3394473512237353, + "Yices": 10.057217093401418, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7057976346239707, + "CVC4": 7.6259660835526839, + "CVC3": 4.6134700640455391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.007569286014849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.757540853582375 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14857251985513334, + "veriT": 1.0851465063001471, + "Yices": 10.466600295867515, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15339715950473334, + "CVC4": 6.791579957716027, + "CVC3": 5.9766474159750311, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2065518242935056, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1984181527631703 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.48066052096163, + "veriT": 11.930938873423507, + "Yices": 9.7614655543463318, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.157906285101179, + "CVC4": 4.6739758256063109, + "CVC3": 12.560064355870701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0302647173188797, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8452177779311008 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4399638285277776, + "veriT": 4.3750524671294251, + "Yices": 2.9662912559626671, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9077631066693153, + "CVC4": 3.2945677484284683, + "CVC3": 2.8314309963383679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7249905130818983, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4184613782054472 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17705577411266668, + "veriT": 7.8105687618942463, + "Yices": 12.349893670454113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.60723955295208343, + "CVC4": 7.2416475882663498, + "CVC3": 6.3438454181533812, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6775723072726096, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7193146279276688 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5378629872168634, + "veriT": 12.33978415288898, + "Yices": 11.443599786399831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3227224791237262, + "CVC4": 9.4261519657893782, + "CVC3": 11.040376664402078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.133597606315929, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.638532725172947 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.75209068036362, + "veriT": 9.1057578819336094, + "Yices": 10.114053174028268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.573646662579684, + "CVC4": 3.6420189639221503, + "CVC3": 3.129676593519032, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.536189443086535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.543920750773651 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3512083037807101, + "veriT": 9.1292004167390708, + "Yices": 12.352864220980008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4135113323374724, + "CVC4": 0.21457945195781816, + "CVC3": 8.6244021315176624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0965806794306363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1084001997248301 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.89454945539742858, + "veriT": 2.6290688119728314, + "Yices": 1.8787611523045946, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1067391971654998, + "CVC4": 0.17456454339171429, + "CVC3": 0.16244480203299999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17011355797335717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16857379759607147 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18188295024724999, + "veriT": 3.6376585780220996, + "Yices": 7.1933360120092482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25136420758487499, + "CVC4": 0.20055740990574999, + "CVC3": 6.7799809182456254, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.723134582181448, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.716761763273428 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.220168302594242, + "veriT": 9.3761790772675493, + "Yices": 11.537660883601562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.763114093116718, + "CVC4": 4.1858951637546742, + "CVC3": 13.183423775695315, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.18078408165269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9799489172877749 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1652193487430882, + "veriT": 7.5984357527701469, + "Yices": 10.733510707914839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2553984830596772, + "CVC4": 12.756823909573157, + "CVC3": 9.4334097018693797, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.538480980969454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0521910959897749 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5173538696306479, + "veriT": 1.8249954174219998, + "Yices": 5.9009644751490358, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6763047250321748, + "CVC4": 4.8899972261170808, + "CVC3": 2.5216478081534071, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7654342118470931, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9156470455490044 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7400983547612618, + "veriT": 11.206764136913213, + "Yices": 11.993379000329474, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.092988240775322, + "CVC4": 13.274799176658499, + "CVC3": 7.5406542402716754, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2716575211157233, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0598690446663612 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.661646490591332, + "veriT": 10.574162320942929, + "Yices": 10.847763038602698, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.153819682727626, + "CVC4": 7.6570186818887649, + "CVC3": 6.9517563696236149, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2118116433672865, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.953894331942919 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.30663901437211111, + "veriT": 13.30797251906265, + "Yices": 6.3822049951406843, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7197161939374581, + "CVC4": 3.7197718517501812, + "CVC3": 5.8235046527016312, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.966716345661869, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.217573339411611 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9114395548574996, + "veriT": 8.4391016606726534, + "Yices": 6.0091679830939579, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2118326136503565, + "CVC4": 1.5598854499649815, + "CVC3": 0.20976294410949997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1664171299517729, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1558513959713315 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1009621620178223, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.641036986731625, + "veriT": 3.1325651103559382, + "Yices": 1.3733688965690001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6415521594405003, + "CVC4": 1.9267958639008542, + "CVC3": 0.1352672756973875, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14262515290728753, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1445191526192125 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14486306220342859, + "veriT": 0.1231312867697143, + "Yices": 0.13552400552771429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.144707832846, + "CVC4": 0.16290049604414289, + "CVC3": 0.15025189645657142, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15835245578171428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15504874289599999 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17264264332436363, + "veriT": 0.15065912674218182, + "Yices": 0.15400569930327274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17121461735327273, + "CVC4": 0.20112072516963633, + "CVC3": 0.17572267157418181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18104103267663635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17846978051263634 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1729815006256104, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18098056264377782, + "veriT": 8.9930149057929185, + "Yices": 1.3209241503608891, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27448954544077775, + "CVC4": 0.26625213453300001, + "CVC3": 0.69517965183355557, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7174729488938274, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7180793740626292 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.62349196253744443, + "veriT": 1.7003983289783262, + "Yices": 1.715703764238854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8052226801630762, + "CVC4": 0.20736220266988895, + "CVC3": 1.292205871380111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17127955903966668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17311433744544444 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15064576648785716, + "veriT": 10.179384278411403, + "Yices": 0.36960539759099997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26129646538585716, + "CVC4": 2.3162703365542621, + "CVC3": 0.1470876553964286, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.869963079582883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.873029588249469 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16794740258399998, + "veriT": 3.4715776572135497, + "Yices": 1.9180710570596167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18906968653045, + "CVC4": 2.5297320728334785, + "CVC3": 0.18182430582206666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21884169654249999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2323174522093 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 58.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4062322141921779, + "veriT": 12.565254629488274, + "Yices": 12.018650705648096, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.532508111816366, + "CVC4": 8.8735369470189376, + "CVC3": 9.9778964602463027, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.254447868596056, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.238405899848708 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.90579554056775, + "veriT": 7.866039850016306, + "Yices": 4.4414823827541738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5174881630462673, + "CVC4": 6.0358563125180984, + "CVC3": 0.15622101529116666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6332449598901275, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.62177347018772 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6664651881851382, + "veriT": 12.759236088242396, + "Yices": 3.6308262273895475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8507011408736234, + "CVC4": 3.6624810163165509, + "CVC3": 12.503541467798051, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23269648906490908, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.22600619411336362 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6607285070795168, + "veriT": 7.5267412575002517, + "Yices": 3.8346915422984953, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7147064890150761, + "CVC4": 6.6530781373086594, + "CVC3": 3.5936188622909073, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4510888607890395, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4922025123311986 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2406958819608658, + "veriT": 13.575799488404369, + "Yices": 10.901654036598593, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6470384557100513, + "CVC4": 6.3182585666605169, + "CVC3": 4.9437558557394432, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8938777295610567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1875691731606848 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 76.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0055862746443989, + "veriT": 8.0097590536357615, + "Yices": 6.9265556688085663, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9057514315488948, + "CVC4": 9.2557054285572242, + "CVC3": 7.2735593564107708, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.717805213122125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.721391989751478 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.93981489755249981, + "veriT": 12.201915906244079, + "Yices": 14.241463495529221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7698785030346338, + "CVC4": 13.100691319389796, + "CVC3": 10.63832787428016, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.912070631261738, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.868472889810954 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2442389323398944, + "veriT": 3.6397893068936282, + "Yices": 7.5960831947635592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6196618191133094, + "CVC4": 4.3367528031782721, + "CVC3": 1.7735613853829997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.660962193869751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6605597941955628 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.188283923602331, + "veriT": 9.5917186501957072, + "Yices": 11.590510092107126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.70409137519909, + "CVC4": 6.4607672143411179, + "CVC3": 2.9500358548277226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2290646580517501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2882641743212342 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.298935717013846, + "veriT": 9.5705692798939204, + "Yices": 10.460423534912998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.13764270759056, + "CVC4": 14.425834021817414, + "CVC3": 1.231191886087154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.018212429429971, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.075888169428961 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.078463179916394, + "veriT": 13.766376684681296, + "Yices": 7.6284890554044278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0097814628528852, + "CVC4": 8.4028073752141612, + "CVC3": 9.5340136912206663, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241432450091764, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.235077034090024 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7767854928970337, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.523130237603288, + "veriT": 11.355751578033177, + "Yices": 10.923760789393571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.966724322235541, + "CVC4": 13.486771656232573, + "CVC3": 13.968405765826059, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.258383919259554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.375163537578768 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7711498088032327, + "veriT": 12.192081257735481, + "Yices": 12.921602012499045, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.711872933024964, + "CVC4": 8.0411390450634546, + "CVC3": 8.0375305796253205, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.883070852344941, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.881534646772101 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.25906850423622, + "veriT": 10.189200427996798, + "Yices": 10.3851280175602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.984361870672711, + "CVC4": 14.284456694373597, + "CVC3": 14.261143591380357, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257117329729232, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.441353945677958 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2483442531600675, + "veriT": 10.449844485102961, + "Yices": 6.5548079787369664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6383802520879804, + "CVC4": 2.0792654671525459, + "CVC3": 0.40075306318327275, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2809465151114545, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.320182808759182 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6671065092086792, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4039315721036956, + "veriT": 9.3260623781075722, + "Yices": 5.9397507201205215, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8105385207153875, + "CVC4": 7.4607345787483759, + "CVC3": 3.9484517487320687, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2143344587434424, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2340201088268596 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0367398262023926, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 325.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.753365776485879, + "veriT": 11.96279783733736, + "Yices": 11.713849407556685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.097159327524876, + "CVC4": 12.521681680867951, + "CVC3": 8.7379206748950971, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.265010327672902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.591777914918808 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.799032972989883, + "veriT": 10.638581111560697, + "Yices": 10.513068757234333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967003279281451, + "CVC4": 14.62433367427492, + "CVC3": 14.243226520665369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.716507407364483, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.629259694527118 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7517580869406704, + "veriT": 14.219129291811813, + "Yices": 13.541374969524016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.224249510424157, + "CVC4": 14.41786820932685, + "CVC3": 13.305585038997155, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23300612697574, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.234489974581463 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.720988155191295, + "veriT": 14.232279658552116, + "Yices": 14.143367590391628, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.444401976212713, + "CVC4": 9.2734224710351594, + "CVC3": 13.965501283687532, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247244331785225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.249082051015995 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 27.0, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4272883050855998, + "veriT": 12.64309664250742, + "Yices": 4.7131181354654004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.709239728478062, + "CVC4": 3.2643788712663619, + "CVC3": 9.7605538189575238, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0262442962636422, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7631425913392444 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.9666381427351, + "veriT": 12.024247954987963, + "Yices": 11.905097231410881, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.17183421997915, + "CVC4": 14.615676638452511, + "CVC3": 12.860147999908456, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.249576313431511, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.886208192719971 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1753211715585934, + "veriT": 3.5989983477553968, + "Yices": 7.1407362032949537, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3935871710039516, + "CVC4": 8.4130413804686111, + "CVC3": 4.2249919899841393, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1688059673359188, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1641081889044678 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 356.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 243.0, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 168.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3453958340899153, + "veriT": 13.307672933594901, + "Yices": 11.788846737441338, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6013429663717584, + "CVC4": 12.941029948465459, + "CVC3": 9.9288090718741131, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3130173439502579, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2174485863153333 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 141.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3858879201284271, + "veriT": 13.90209291007683, + "Yices": 14.169469056199111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96479543577915, + "CVC4": 14.424704481085925, + "CVC3": 10.379934641156996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.594222158127927, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.520091067689462 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7589466863249363, + "veriT": 13.711247207218692, + "Yices": 14.223040085923039, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.108091388130621, + "CVC4": 12.734754449443978, + "CVC3": 13.796074623662811, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0874758040985171, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2921414613215507 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8983349826005078, + "veriT": 12.50975262125815, + "Yices": 14.238647791135717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.995579655221873, + "CVC4": 14.555855088523272, + "CVC3": 13.457334503772943, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.63677147977636361, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.61321796964409092 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.39314962638977, + "veriT": 14.232192364615168, + "Yices": 13.975224096088317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.826397047457023, + "CVC4": 14.665569249371025, + "CVC3": 8.958433283285661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.048179499062506, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.358100235825606 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 61.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12903396687078181, + "veriT": 0.99920820167729552, + "Yices": 1.0028426602109863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14161214335308636, + "CVC4": 1.4002134334694143, + "CVC3": 0.094348928006913621, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3957614325545926, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3934821469712479 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1065076121861, + "veriT": 0.078833736076127287, + "Yices": 0.08341962707449091, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1077155332092727, + "CVC4": 0.10194904668595454, + "CVC3": 0.084455321288881793, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10174073735956363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1001774865227909 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4500000476837158, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1714286804199219, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.511749907395938, + "veriT": 11.098299004263088, + "Yices": 10.534459887724248, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7117572634884137, + "CVC4": 12.674491762715459, + "CVC3": 6.5383499256369788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2371239392101376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.232443433532163 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.524652280917, + "veriT": 3.0538632062681432, + "Yices": 4.5885290037244291, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.407835699110203, + "CVC4": 0.16714671637157141, + "CVC3": 0.48561161324085717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2961246344296722, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.395516887881213 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.435652425132233, + "veriT": 8.7183591939568874, + "Yices": 9.5336256679146363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.967098007239251, + "CVC4": 0.17711819661281819, + "CVC3": 9.7934747292596498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5747638699987165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.337266158782457 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.556156011031938, + "veriT": 10.548565083529061, + "Yices": 10.291918754140168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.146055350033757, + "CVC4": 1.824820893606, + "CVC3": 10.256274965937118, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3198417249289065, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.723594868784993 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240241116084349, + "veriT": 10.174408313673332, + "Yices": 10.341157369459557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958962322379168, + "CVC4": 0.15783635486888889, + "CVC3": 11.399755202919151, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15020680766022221, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.2479449371345 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.612491302825157, + "veriT": 10.142637229468429, + "Yices": 10.30054102912043, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.938788363088378, + "CVC4": 0.206864183634, + "CVC3": 12.424020088327678, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3260231805856324, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.704560535865284 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.431453763008999, + "veriT": 12.569380193358771, + "Yices": 12.069101049499016, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.567521494591501, + "CVC4": 8.7776624208214304, + "CVC3": 6.5218035613225371, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.828623394327934, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.575908839042972 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.610561327736924, + "veriT": 10.463247429632641, + "Yices": 9.9271142118779601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.344978905786354, + "CVC4": 0.80111347494524998, + "CVC3": 10.623705348962702, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1388778299041782, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.483504965752793 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.444619120911472, + "veriT": 8.9357411391196973, + "Yices": 9.5007780235761992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.34999178101889, + "CVC4": 0.34140933510973331, + "CVC3": 12.014082793551426, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7494254613604077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0675557724969185 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7928569316864014, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.800400807241028, + "veriT": 13.950414778998727, + "Yices": 12.99139179794456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.1671728548144, + "CVC4": 9.9438833141162633, + "CVC3": 7.3733189719427212, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6325965819145907, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6787045356863026 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9408613148495228, + "veriT": 14.237569059666422, + "Yices": 13.394252271760834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9321519546331567, + "CVC4": 10.671453452294847, + "CVC3": 4.6523504895638164, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.352992156993068, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.393884701852281 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2714263238373706, + "veriT": 4.1441013452046356, + "Yices": 4.311343568726457, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4333863492071197, + "CVC4": 3.5013396672198329, + "CVC3": 7.5366648776161655, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2803200398033794, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2815379712999064 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.771529599003197, + "veriT": 10.170279438162375, + "Yices": 10.265460405613624, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951116349717836, + "CVC4": 5.0213337758423764, + "CVC3": 13.115744443724235, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.1606906232958956, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5256616216098138 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5252356150408026, + "veriT": 4.0009431312128605, + "Yices": 4.3417973017138163, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.082261114686947, + "CVC4": 2.5402032615376107, + "CVC3": 0.97095946094371244, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.901853162698331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3017706693539943 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.4458291319935253, + "veriT": 13.784108151160545, + "Yices": 11.232813397215637, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7095080880859896, + "CVC4": 12.08336851204983, + "CVC3": 10.904141901211393, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.240866004403077, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.254620599615698 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6072233487297618, + "veriT": 5.2078016592434002, + "Yices": 12.918660236519957, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5721878307142858, + "CVC4": 9.4492952851300345, + "CVC3": 9.3580488070271546, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0445863020463113, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0583058850416496 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 32.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 48.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7941717191575002, + "veriT": 14.211099203207644, + "Yices": 4.77449100208469, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7970257840173331, + "CVC4": 4.1648477679052958, + "CVC3": 4.1311333594033153, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9587205771847014, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9428343741866083 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15010599851628573, + "veriT": 14.211168447642848, + "Yices": 0.17181973823542857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24993735352671426, + "CVC4": 2.2813149307868339, + "CVC3": 0.13038420607342857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.108172917937335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.113306799291536 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9008219950391481, + "veriT": 13.760615631031078, + "Yices": 7.1083690197641092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3089519023208389, + "CVC4": 8.391497124011563, + "CVC3": 6.4988053672892017, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9151927304865266, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.530387774415364 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.855991005897522, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.3642854690551758, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.69160439106320049, + "veriT": 9.8162297392829636, + "Yices": 10.005667763698346, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.76503729795351483, + "CVC4": 0.14996609884724132, + "CVC3": 0.67665480241196552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14959784218106892, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.039021349896002 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19345448212174998, + "veriT": 8.9069595997450008, + "Yices": 9.0599813166153744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.35257977338712498, + "CVC4": 0.15422356357424999, + "CVC3": 0.29153562365774999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.150550926685875, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.677113375207 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.1235099712165, + "veriT": 8.4145864828210808, + "Yices": 10.438312788892143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.674839319658114, + "CVC4": 1.8133518768969072, + "CVC3": 9.9797902620401331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4705076746333496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.644959090415698 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4706118597987796, + "veriT": 1.7654654238441667, + "Yices": 1.7614600438358332, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5909701206866602, + "CVC4": 0.16883937761949999, + "CVC3": 2.4544662688372068, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4669787005420356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4697670518892383 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240075761628423, + "veriT": 10.152754242676938, + "Yices": 10.3322386264465, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963657113163528, + "CVC4": 0.16092197359831251, + "CVC3": 12.119185462695775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.85046486509665509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.368152390779954 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.844306171212935, + "veriT": 11.680345080231346, + "Yices": 7.9939754204083462, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.16844374422449, + "CVC4": 1.9515058451212057, + "CVC3": 10.029574768945213, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9004778868518772, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8545623863701088 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 40.0, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7017937897067572, + "veriT": 8.4977449480900642, + "Yices": 6.0473377020553638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8385470568628657, + "CVC4": 4.1897926908515082, + "CVC3": 2.7443878201645409, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.376719157229775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8628634086371374 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.029507124925467, + "veriT": 13.391549347397847, + "Yices": 5.7580357865831058, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7321999431539998, + "CVC4": 4.5574332916081648, + "CVC3": 4.4408130008345683, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9909418722173888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9197311898895109 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9075983133557752, + "veriT": 8.4376512497674163, + "Yices": 7.9949041292639214, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4319073900328103, + "CVC4": 1.2568368344131626, + "CVC3": 4.2740062186826133, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7301908036783527, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.533469630526913 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3916100663851114, + "veriT": 11.293573771323222, + "Yices": 5.9818883498715438, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3545529349222956, + "CVC4": 11.139304168735531, + "CVC3": 9.2353665083260097, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.676413161031149, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.328335869129926 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5612233599334058, + "veriT": 11.146668191675284, + "Yices": 10.316369256744638, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.33707794692269, + "CVC4": 2.1022226185836299, + "CVC3": 4.9970209070176299, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.223821944108444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.451119681332772 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.394437012263388, + "veriT": 10.862545553088028, + "Yices": 10.559904479650955, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.454938006500731, + "CVC4": 13.145573640469571, + "CVC3": 13.43049891432787, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.161690923409745, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.218588762088968 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.0, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8526493999359888, + "veriT": 12.580304352496285, + "Yices": 12.443606088003733, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0055247860918133, + "CVC4": 8.7416282408048396, + "CVC3": 12.160465210209866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.034554919792795, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.103048281123019 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0801279544830322, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8341514735895892, + "veriT": 3.1594478928630534, + "Yices": 3.1605900125998385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4717419511997587, + "CVC4": 1.7973046589424229, + "CVC3": 0.13571412871904615, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2711478285474804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2743848890330449 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6843515905871467, + "veriT": 8.8809356835916251, + "Yices": 8.9069677429800613, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.58252500125212503, + "CVC4": 5.4427443128967106, + "CVC3": 2.0258010895247742, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.275461833147075, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.299685324689838 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0075461529515906, + "veriT": 8.9534506112790719, + "Yices": 10.344958895876927, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8592417119403848, + "CVC4": 12.760684999931692, + "CVC3": 8.2424730414445726, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233827972521272, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.662531671112941 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1301204334339006, + "veriT": 4.1122899316775188, + "Yices": 7.279275526733036, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.13326989089764, + "CVC4": 8.3179985578820315, + "CVC3": 3.3925174776424809, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9425757219312723, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9363409914202956 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1830271267992885, + "veriT": 4.1535260426180791, + "Yices": 12.698651667484684, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1660774838982046, + "CVC4": 7.9043629690452839, + "CVC3": 6.2112292515575653, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4629283783387335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4921030985231392 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1323336509111, + "veriT": 9.9089411923427715, + "Yices": 9.9110349254249819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13405398200720001, + "CVC4": 7.1900812907770746, + "CVC3": 0.13487035907259998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18650213871940002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1912351609997 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13481980980314284, + "veriT": 7.2547341177045146, + "Yices": 4.4031399239160001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13720901208099998, + "CVC4": 0.14207779489271427, + "CVC3": 0.1337531827712857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13070055268571429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13245652889971429 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.34114915151800002, + "veriT": 1.883758721198892, + "Yices": 3.5437925371796588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4595339928004865, + "CVC4": 1.385787840669555, + "CVC3": 1.374064672940168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.375678827006757, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1464142472773353 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14200555665711112, + "veriT": 2.8010535250209316, + "Yices": 9.0646256208653337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15724573721566668, + "CVC4": 2.9128521847149411, + "CVC3": 1.4428175344364442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8139719083329222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.8144887608087981 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5151784739824121, + "veriT": 8.8447005727028749, + "Yices": 11.181847165210073, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8313708025825655, + "CVC4": 9.6885957382472068, + "CVC3": 11.825881617158919, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230173856657565, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.22376978713365 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2586788058442906, + "veriT": 2.0716083252343225, + "Yices": 8.2019794203410239, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9404964624131189, + "CVC4": 2.2217249475972123, + "CVC3": 5.1200079180976727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6515187599328571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6538062578464285 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9136306884938676, + "veriT": 10.854715191704793, + "Yices": 7.5832167917311208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.373010646359093, + "CVC4": 5.1309244147555608, + "CVC3": 2.9295347994597498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0024937502149367, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.43486393214117 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5405245176337123, + "veriT": 5.1831009197408164, + "Yices": 7.0106835062519322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4787078829532208, + "CVC4": 12.489339618135739, + "CVC3": 1.676367447593714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.212525365663085, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1083803174271107 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5526107485323115, + "veriT": 12.387821217318846, + "Yices": 13.023389368857362, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7679988268579518, + "CVC4": 7.9409105511839746, + "CVC3": 10.394912295219026, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252454740705955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.122832336414957 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 57.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5848282364864423, + "veriT": 2.1719604427843899, + "Yices": 4.1818933294063898, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0326588395717953, + "CVC4": 5.8080953859587652, + "CVC3": 2.9951985549030651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9725530835861895, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9331033884778073 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 23.0, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15110546549750001, + "veriT": 0.13270151121162499, + "Yices": 0.1445436783895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14956789024987499, + "CVC4": 0.178190472594625, + "CVC3": 0.15044634673474999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16563081684024999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.167472041305125 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8031448877875, + "veriT": 0.11773067427433336, + "Yices": 0.13027263787150001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8012123555993336, + "CVC4": 0.1605444996375, + "CVC3": 0.13373387637750001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14642234228183335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14768470704366668 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.2462021958193, + "veriT": 0.19944743203329998, + "Yices": 7.2831348452375719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.42164938115990003, + "CVC4": 0.24968744733309997, + "CVC3": 0.23435698305980002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.228924811615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2276953820282 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12572359807890909, + "veriT": 11.807524298131899, + "Yices": 3.2289165326522014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14047334226854546, + "CVC4": 2.7257653701856062, + "CVC3": 0.12665159236248183, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1327288981398182, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13264158712373636 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4027180154208747, + "veriT": 1.8917312616101332, + "Yices": 0.143074660884875, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4162349922159998, + "CVC4": 0.16872943163887499, + "CVC3": 0.454131117221375, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16262357536387501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.162413189657625 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8261370688495333, + "veriT": 1.7730389340151165, + "Yices": 2.4360662145676466, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8520424577806336, + "CVC4": 14.282146706270092, + "CVC3": 0.094917973089666652, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2555582490986833, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19422093338128332 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1555430960771318, + "veriT": 8.8790072877685624, + "Yices": 3.9378366931322266, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2567892643349801, + "CVC4": 2.3694860401494511, + "CVC3": 1.2630774439236818, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7147971404293973, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.7197548443267889 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5163514914500427, + "veriT": 6.7692293178825667, + "Yices": 3.4464993147666667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8019606218877762, + "CVC4": 12.136676402035512, + "CVC3": 9.5174649023525344, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.0861780680063093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4274437769350685 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 76.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1336252019558177, + "veriT": 10.173307209592211, + "Yices": 12.207530930023376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.829906523174847, + "CVC4": 11.880299585747231, + "CVC3": 10.588650232700063, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3826120063613558, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3534656274673971 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7106444660683306, + "veriT": 9.212910884271972, + "Yices": 6.0414940185202726, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1517192795992663, + "CVC4": 2.1879416901803466, + "CVC3": 2.322825231637041, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2054753145729391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3918025479916833 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9295055866241455, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6992693814955837, + "veriT": 7.3724145209384311, + "Yices": 5.8599342516303601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7306723753637332, + "CVC4": 5.6667921434501345, + "CVC3": 5.4663534806360712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.170200057787188, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.181487095026293 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 102.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.558293385357429, + "veriT": 13.227384022568913, + "Yices": 13.271538848497967, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950302461497886, + "CVC4": 12.89490172114292, + "CVC3": 4.9688017606850643, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239592486780507, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.887107131166481 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2333521948569972, + "veriT": 11.743020013688287, + "Yices": 12.582572681495442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6967201287027862, + "CVC4": 12.785949140996246, + "CVC3": 12.959041461354737, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.686522109389061, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.36005671899118 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.953433344966603, + "veriT": 10.237690479311167, + "Yices": 10.964082572761166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.211338326797872, + "CVC4": 14.440883747176267, + "CVC3": 12.057332929169961, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6039602540533071, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5727963162073824 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.924766320243632, + "veriT": 12.781242351484655, + "Yices": 11.841009869230549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972187153343203, + "CVC4": 13.562565453792025, + "CVC3": 13.033326725458103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.897840682849081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.842029177070334 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.510786396694014, + "veriT": 14.235256329602112, + "Yices": 13.855292557592804, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.102513297422297, + "CVC4": 14.643288776203956, + "CVC3": 13.974594416221892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.993988738137293, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.017346558498106 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.188870906829834, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9734530448913574, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.38006024264688887, + "veriT": 9.8029688219438693, + "Yices": 0.46824908186544456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2133991410061116, + "CVC4": 0.30113268272177779, + "CVC3": 0.8540519362711112, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20484406607222225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.20399582637444441 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.275332171168631, + "veriT": 10.192889621018617, + "Yices": 9.1685528046038236, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9912620724471539, + "CVC4": 3.8897259311128658, + "CVC3": 3.4208899846893708, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8044518540377297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4910041403747458 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.806909199256022, + "veriT": 13.761191231391164, + "Yices": 13.78238640833095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.997673978434102, + "CVC4": 11.302650829948117, + "CVC3": 12.792556782770436, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4547108165236349, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.10564289151369 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 11.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2220427803575689, + "veriT": 10.465151952790015, + "Yices": 7.4091122467328363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7786093803437639, + "CVC4": 10.975325277174067, + "CVC3": 8.5256041183555098, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6494718157839046, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6147899830108052 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.141243299274969, + "veriT": 12.220903590228884, + "Yices": 11.077674620710471, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.571102199657368, + "CVC4": 14.364038604157672, + "CVC3": 10.8577303278351, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.335482759449466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.272301306714706 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20844830722212498, + "veriT": 10.23557598453945, + "Yices": 10.720941759733533, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.42922412817075001, + "CVC4": 10.768622323020285, + "CVC3": 2.1382630304882215, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9355470041010352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9298106263076735 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 149.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5042547272213422, + "veriT": 10.560907764915758, + "Yices": 11.776577385426716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2190378507267408, + "CVC4": 12.973846558564105, + "CVC3": 11.62247647333594, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.031350253905844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.031763479828326 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1642136573791504, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.213044916234555, + "veriT": 12.017869237241054, + "Yices": 12.420210868183069, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962422526087737, + "CVC4": 14.597507466903629, + "CVC3": 13.019792486789305, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231998849981251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238609571582437 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2449780069624872, + "veriT": 10.386579551462349, + "Yices": 14.059705464478711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965285525034739, + "CVC4": 14.639909466139978, + "CVC3": 13.206179784131026, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5477827193783007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5385031834415841 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "false": 151, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 150 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237689430917897, + "veriT": 11.49618178462925, + "Yices": 12.445300310328204, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950749719926838, + "CVC4": 14.494188014638789, + "CVC3": 12.784513368086863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.241687120017168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.244633875554618 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.22981917652567, + "veriT": 14.218735217870835, + "Yices": 14.228952165460374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.949657876352997, + "CVC4": 14.289835557657852, + "CVC3": 13.818296019826391, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.010186640693185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.884731990495593 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "false": 156, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 37.0, + "true": 153 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "false": 155, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 39.5, + "true": 154 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3619499920078573, + "veriT": 14.251228737901361, + "Yices": 12.256154527493297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8002163343861621, + "CVC4": 12.656949947912622, + "CVC3": 14.638007186896049, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4011154889688795, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2946979759905952 + }, + { + "index": 155, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9997593507098061, + "veriT": 13.710758172313289, + "Yices": 13.755836030477411, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.300667355660089, + "CVC4": 12.447552343936019, + "CVC3": 13.102896614175068, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0941253576330001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.028773353900625 + }, + { + "index": 156, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.064420950757567, + "veriT": 13.588096575942929, + "Yices": 13.724636237503361, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.93752647788657, + "CVC4": 14.607645900069592, + "CVC3": 6.8108591718296312, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.334031510972499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.166693146110406 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 67.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13827137295281819, + "veriT": 1.007977073109982, + "Yices": 1.0086798406117683, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15221530724763638, + "CVC4": 1.4104314242475777, + "CVC3": 0.10559174034921361, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4062622335964927, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4031662934784479 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1094796230913577, + "veriT": 0.080472013073449991, + "Yices": 0.086404396646042297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1086730443172077, + "CVC4": 0.10550193399749613, + "CVC3": 0.08738274301083078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10405128488717308, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10312196249237693 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.855991005897522, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9796401021108236, + "veriT": 5.3162370557334313, + "Yices": 5.0395543411910584, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2391197921600732, + "CVC4": 3.9438611721327725, + "CVC3": 3.8831301458496341, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6410719780539191, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4573990180625396 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20772291901404, + "veriT": 10.167157025697279, + "Yices": 10.35394915114912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26026253463476001, + "CVC4": 0.14922122250888001, + "CVC3": 0.6930181338405198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14773401362855998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.450067688378754 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18827480355739998, + "veriT": 8.1531165621271988, + "Yices": 8.3008911812892006, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.364829401961, + "CVC4": 0.15484906891040001, + "CVC3": 0.2631965596284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14933661891720001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8443160698686176 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3168167461335001, + "veriT": 9.9307690192453748, + "Yices": 10.00597539616723, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7357711307460111, + "CVC4": 3.8615531947030379, + "CVC3": 3.2829029661920002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6675985279230807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.503725394651383 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.707414058553548, + "veriT": 8.3453444188830002, + "Yices": 10.331329459758818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.30021246549752, + "CVC4": 0.171564869827, + "CVC3": 11.068202895456071, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.448687821655168, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.282425219288811 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.734353923619697, + "veriT": 7.6916741065063761, + "Yices": 10.337526732373, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.269817469897411, + "CVC4": 1.9289470382404896, + "CVC3": 9.0265740219759323, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.7311686054634929, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9544285436693905 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.572107213018915, + "veriT": 10.156308501868647, + "Yices": 10.319976471673174, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954087492602348, + "CVC4": 0.15925654185382351, + "CVC3": 10.32667201630683, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.80233778338279305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.441288109798007 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236976577604297, + "veriT": 10.153676557038089, + "Yices": 10.330012753193818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963282784158876, + "CVC4": 0.2943243830891818, + "CVC3": 14.241039012921492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.72082601662081813, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.304857481153123 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.423797039727177, + "veriT": 8.9600728494901922, + "Yices": 6.2510337642730009, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.041167874758219, + "CVC4": 0.15255566235739998, + "CVC3": 7.4911131697433575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16966147929940001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8754034925490002 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.4320872164174911, + "veriT": 7.9646295881105571, + "Yices": 6.0032625645870619, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4293663669947314, + "CVC4": 6.3948195751794774, + "CVC3": 7.3418479219810102, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.122553645953158, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.158924697504414 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6742769609147938, + "veriT": 9.1427851182040403, + "Yices": 9.195920177042769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1420190177020899, + "CVC4": 7.5472257308281083, + "CVC3": 9.6665607279937777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9301125918201887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9285365078747336 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.41332353368344443, + "veriT": 7.6156283560537537, + "Yices": 9.3917023843882461, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1011748776398367, + "CVC4": 7.9207530737898475, + "CVC3": 1.8465209950025643, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0156597858294809, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9059511482911908 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.05707798897795, + "veriT": 10.120129050106142, + "Yices": 10.213078891687715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.561170496109877, + "CVC4": 6.5105111143296126, + "CVC3": 14.21512631703194, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.639914884863291, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.700425873791795 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0673993743860086, + "veriT": 11.504436085331834, + "Yices": 11.719938650873095, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6350754762413011, + "CVC4": 2.9812001517137423, + "CVC3": 5.3240158778812701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2690091241505357, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.28899599761227 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13754198688514285, + "veriT": 12.196961613771338, + "Yices": 0.34809918057071426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17744976280471428, + "CVC4": 0.2772313074714286, + "CVC3": 0.14140285060971428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.206923715848742, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.200723338359666 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12752424427287501, + "veriT": 0.110000830426775, + "Yices": 0.23595392323657499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12718633780075, + "CVC4": 0.17940431073337498, + "CVC3": 2.6757470842652502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.140413486029, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13479827294687502 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 64.0, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.167079523931112, + "veriT": 6.6656909273703322, + "Yices": 9.4357625124749127, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4771120492353944, + "CVC4": 0.20068374938128572, + "CVC3": 8.1769048234747057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3300165951015064, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3903539760409069 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.253055679076143, + "veriT": 13.189164687195916, + "Yices": 6.7183215486195804, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5143393202483351, + "CVC4": 9.2246380313924856, + "CVC3": 3.7763659378347727, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2047903020042536, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.20205575668259 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8079512654462135, + "veriT": 8.7944450318847416, + "Yices": 5.709953204154667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5960384508131646, + "CVC4": 0.15960284368833333, + "CVC3": 0.56289170813777778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9672745080712746, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.966074628924785 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.988807676044882, + "veriT": 10.661105422618203, + "Yices": 9.0522045292921245, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.858139181675746, + "CVC4": 3.6933543157579281, + "CVC3": 12.477375568035981, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6861698836180139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.378850006708003 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.67799536366641, + "veriT": 12.240497672154603, + "Yices": 11.03925635859231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.697431263635178, + "CVC4": 14.38515459007688, + "CVC3": 13.486579630166064, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.262412996419105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.861581828492714 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1283984189542959, + "veriT": 11.058456121213727, + "Yices": 10.757259359238839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951461038081984, + "CVC4": 9.1546439291396418, + "CVC3": 6.9641867977193765, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239377764245724, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.171960666438981 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0313491663836061, + "veriT": 12.173177312769539, + "Yices": 5.3306933914245889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0558949522485879, + "CVC4": 1.6148187407631411, + "CVC3": 3.1095211164313246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.051674442769583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.044808555374365 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.149157958021624, + "veriT": 10.484689834702543, + "Yices": 10.479947375486271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961539872819106, + "CVC4": 3.7573554358153056, + "CVC3": 12.125676785735694, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0799469624978419, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.882798904404323 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9491078147942442, + "veriT": 10.957338927268648, + "Yices": 8.2358827209994008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.977260133695424, + "CVC4": 3.5739156255459839, + "CVC3": 11.411027461510225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.111935470064024, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.419967476867994 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6787502303124544, + "veriT": 14.189301713447287, + "Yices": 11.999268055330736, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.378895925729488, + "CVC4": 12.142603655532993, + "CVC3": 9.3331033510220873, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.456806160588632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.456093799266972 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.980162617638427, + "veriT": 11.407163196464641, + "Yices": 8.2805716609323827, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.531598962564924, + "CVC4": 0.2456484905176923, + "CVC3": 13.692350735193175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4208899611650319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.012290390961498 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8845968204555286, + "veriT": 6.8294583814528336, + "Yices": 6.9602676434646655, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7930104377664771, + "CVC4": 0.17014955767850001, + "CVC3": 7.0816979615441369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16908550968433333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1065023766023065 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12955727137488887, + "veriT": 0.10237739936897777, + "Yices": 0.10765748613094445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12687965649707778, + "CVC4": 0.12683372141644444, + "CVC3": 0.11514873613980001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12434596179322223, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12441854356596667 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.213960636981753, + "veriT": 11.221506522633685, + "Yices": 7.858949688759199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.485996708485459, + "CVC4": 7.4545367090644801, + "CVC3": 7.634706715962122, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5385099459796834, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.031361265002113 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6752175408858045, + "veriT": 12.543839446575316, + "Yices": 4.5560753986829505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7805744311866132, + "CVC4": 4.0901266556225613, + "CVC3": 6.0412245653088652, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.323304133919404, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.355105376897905 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0330754209155897, + "veriT": 4.5362848495732555, + "Yices": 13.222049571473049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0008848796883076, + "CVC4": 10.155023958374843, + "CVC3": 9.5126039190362324, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.608390835067679, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6254941905076983 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 31.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4698693217383632, + "veriT": 12.7078526344753, + "Yices": 11.56881674745645, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4833418705839998, + "CVC4": 11.53050798768834, + "CVC3": 7.7516684101690227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.0744733229804257, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0696951898149578 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.9362395403784127, + "veriT": 6.1045274287707336, + "Yices": 4.3405020538712042, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4365568457244144, + "CVC4": 3.9119492773736537, + "CVC3": 3.6100599735240397, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3922266491172639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.3886968790400473 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1079545021057129, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18329839971949999, + "veriT": 2.9096858022289163, + "Yices": 0.13615404072319168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.89961321504933311, + "CVC4": 0.17291048341125001, + "CVC3": 0.16728332008766666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16319568199949999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16249861407308333 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13489733638499998, + "veriT": 7.5976608390704747, + "Yices": 7.6020721816446262, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.129529591886, + "CVC4": 1.90383458355294, + "CVC3": 0.1233212526745, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.132215772470125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13124797965125001 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.55542651261935005, + "veriT": 3.9019312514602622, + "Yices": 9.2238324356344776, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8599170562318719, + "CVC4": 4.9496342644408271, + "CVC3": 4.996729199656329, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4188062781893311, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7161879432443286 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.105555534362793, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3801099480349128, + "veriT": 7.1735856624448546, + "Yices": 10.301453949444078, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4099854364946209, + "CVC4": 5.1383986878505006, + "CVC3": 1.350978081596969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.998373584414594, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.073774457495373 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.221915209204214, + "veriT": 10.122759003292137, + "Yices": 10.137905850787336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3701795712679843, + "CVC4": 8.1350887872812212, + "CVC3": 4.8398366445109042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.875824330563319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.517124589644048 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17224055091531251, + "veriT": 7.909295343630669, + "Yices": 9.0806136300876616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19504356485076252, + "CVC4": 1.9183902314280554, + "CVC3": 0.10910462106737501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23669429523562496, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18942335538166252 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14277084331599998, + "veriT": 2.4757450453357293, + "Yices": 7.0972136031242616, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15114907480964704, + "CVC4": 5.9547558609854558, + "CVC3": 3.2691773984540826, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19889939212929408, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19776110660223528 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0779447844968928, + "veriT": 7.7625788365814241, + "Yices": 6.9309365068051223, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.579846459971078, + "CVC4": 7.8113380363297606, + "CVC3": 8.1702040229427002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7794754080455322, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7787600579585812 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1466967170445068, + "veriT": 10.828723801718327, + "Yices": 11.22314866144138, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2183697436769254, + "CVC4": 11.048587310016655, + "CVC3": 10.861858219958508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5611506966579238, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.924521197095723 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23042950281299998, + "veriT": 1.7344674665015856, + "Yices": 5.7606378147299679, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.95293343595571434, + "CVC4": 1.2532573550521957, + "CVC3": 0.23016455365235711, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.196306514498729, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1918023006322869 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16859962809010004, + "veriT": 0.1490281836756, + "Yices": 0.1575720432153, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1639095971732, + "CVC4": 0.19484354780070001, + "CVC3": 0.1709417543084, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17762027798569999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.179338506615 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13730399497009091, + "veriT": 8.3432081363221187, + "Yices": 1.9572387874604547, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14952256573281819, + "CVC4": 2.7364856724396063, + "CVC3": 0.13712723886038181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14371931180869091, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14103382295330907 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0728070735931396, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7873569777103628, + "veriT": 4.660145013896936, + "Yices": 4.9882307429444444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1450076754113541, + "CVC4": 10.459618064571664, + "CVC3": 1.1235325190329815, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2163545813312542, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9369327385873678 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0645874857135273, + "veriT": 9.4165515711887871, + "Yices": 5.6092367008069814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4259171801028252, + "CVC4": 1.0734709659094543, + "CVC3": 4.1077615231799092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.31989392288209084, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.34205952167781822 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1316272510072856, + "veriT": 11.612224842822544, + "Yices": 7.0091661836755703, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1518494660371426, + "CVC4": 4.2088922374006508, + "CVC3": 10.091340747435606, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.205617628498132, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.201574203806102 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6077438801166064, + "veriT": 7.3913025552837546, + "Yices": 8.9233674181135374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.043083751052192, + "CVC4": 2.4597608511756293, + "CVC3": 1.8201894410420001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.6090027511056144, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.842875141386104 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1455504894256592, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0797080993652344, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4856926047509411, + "veriT": 12.368507824002888, + "Yices": 8.3400379806151097, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6261272967260094, + "CVC4": 9.3330608432149766, + "CVC3": 4.846482788271536, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.473370331386656, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3358948397592973 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.977628094522826, + "veriT": 12.200408666654397, + "Yices": 12.39309311040758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.612930392209211, + "CVC4": 12.778602964248144, + "CVC3": 9.9553388405366192, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.002444212517306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.281445290005909 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8178948668178334, + "veriT": 0.17741948252816667, + "Yices": 8.9453261776506121, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8173263587363333, + "CVC4": 9.7063446485059774, + "CVC3": 5.2900576641674997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16070446043666667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15833878056600001 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2867426937515996, + "veriT": 5.0697585595938426, + "Yices": 6.7253993144354896, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.36864017396889, + "CVC4": 5.4060973861935135, + "CVC3": 6.4809802174048663, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1246973426911762, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1456386328070955 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.31927428076033332, + "veriT": 11.593287640523805, + "Yices": 12.356571058465185, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.92711944690344461, + "CVC4": 2.5281642092458587, + "CVC3": 2.0333695941637928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7162352115338209, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7133564250679543 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15348339455510002, + "veriT": 0.13375328974840001, + "Yices": 0.1472019084983, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15233076720829999, + "CVC4": 0.17386180998360001, + "CVC3": 0.15217417282090001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17141135972399998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16776183712499998 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15891465904269231, + "veriT": 6.6359697557364195, + "Yices": 1.2409749355840052, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2141795195013077, + "CVC4": 1.2682259348695111, + "CVC3": 1.8742439556053081, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.9489301401497694, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.95304024999223058 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6592589616775513, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0200697048667076, + "veriT": 11.50462505881309, + "Yices": 5.4379685477131785, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3294493673984418, + "CVC4": 5.1807031151262191, + "CVC3": 4.4101359274401002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.2736406161207317, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2781436173852132 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248588349900837, + "veriT": 10.748453791889684, + "Yices": 11.082945041849626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968076308670286, + "CVC4": 13.540979609157819, + "CVC3": 13.20780072525614, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244563243810456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.833733157123023 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3262538490454414, + "veriT": 13.362524253878851, + "Yices": 13.386943708969337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.642631338523282, + "CVC4": 14.339934018238504, + "CVC3": 8.1138259551544998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.663056951438438, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.663189621442614 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.150595478770557, + "veriT": 12.484280371553822, + "Yices": 12.244325253409258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.613709368719404, + "CVC4": 14.474696063827082, + "CVC3": 11.678078127122919, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.062314675140783, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.847035330562537 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 189.0, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15335325385593335, + "veriT": 1.8667797870778335, + "Yices": 0.11948377800221667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.21247014409699996, + "CVC4": 0.15722470518183332, + "CVC3": 2.4959934422134293, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15076393518529999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14353593942035001 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2749887665863264, + "veriT": 12.605555542973569, + "Yices": 8.3542132237521525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.728300502574613, + "CVC4": 5.4620454231678721, + "CVC3": 3.0264761297763116, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7109937381823874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4721857604960844 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.33034403074368, + "veriT": 11.114330260778358, + "Yices": 10.973287023222326, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.857360913017752, + "CVC4": 3.5033528009802652, + "CVC3": 2.8397982604381147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3522976596184901, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1424534424236292 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.150052045749277, + "veriT": 12.806937241025889, + "Yices": 10.313518959158705, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.320531699118707, + "CVC4": 9.4777484061833182, + "CVC3": 13.410460742300879, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2253981479325153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2726305994243408 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.85690036487753, + "veriT": 14.231760959995308, + "Yices": 13.93276188699126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962282611537349, + "CVC4": 14.331225318926125, + "CVC3": 14.236002766539368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.286628011982296, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.286711573276907 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9741799941045324, + "veriT": 12.568161990711728, + "Yices": 12.553948918274878, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0137033213329687, + "CVC4": 14.489090811364731, + "CVC3": 10.016218958926833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2292778601543262, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2288934300496219 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7729100664942692, + "veriT": 10.822593580057021, + "Yices": 11.565114387336337, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.018984660914073, + "CVC4": 9.5716969267860961, + "CVC3": 12.436927621831368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.54891192103941, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.350751814788965 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 106.0, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.676313391079491, + "veriT": 9.9285264483818079, + "Yices": 12.082819576423917, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973395276269434, + "CVC4": 14.652076028521183, + "CVC3": 6.2116434514382934, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.446972348403529, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7053617375274124 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 136.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9376511239362362, + "veriT": 13.662720063929333, + "Yices": 14.183649168979334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.169176272034095, + "CVC4": 14.606989445359785, + "CVC3": 10.603043333015728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.711100880934524, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.712827417573658 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "or", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.041948539279435, + "veriT": 12.990801331593875, + "Yices": 13.743405861097679, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.624805028708435, + "CVC4": 13.553690191355706, + "CVC3": 13.147245103039021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.230135221282165, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.222922336802336 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.256852870095113, + "veriT": 13.357462618919422, + "Yices": 13.986816465729657, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.996989980167491, + "CVC4": 14.712222514309607, + "CVC3": 12.710836753122832, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.20934651905503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.086215954390667 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 59.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13184924176911111, + "veriT": 0.10567523344934815, + "Yices": 0.10625430500093333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1291874061007037, + "CVC4": 0.12920808289318519, + "CVC3": 0.11149470007840369, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12745742064662963, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1267049971922741 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10376576139075, + "veriT": 0.075592044594166671, + "Yices": 0.080799293538972236, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10556695538393333, + "CVC4": 0.099070615758638889, + "CVC3": 0.081184662044933326, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.098773837147883334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.097301693234344441 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.393949252671602, + "veriT": 7.355059332088004, + "Yices": 8.9833850591343936, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.7304393469768442, + "CVC4": 4.4322099012099931, + "CVC3": 6.0334545616635706, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6481667286438353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3177883609748466 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20364410147584849, + "veriT": 9.5565798285591512, + "Yices": 9.7277228110740008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.30204036960596969, + "CVC4": 0.15186593295893938, + "CVC3": 0.58404101217278803, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14807414119160603, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3818119467664314 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6915760040283203, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6214658311512018, + "veriT": 8.1719623373644215, + "Yices": 7.0786902175877264, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1348463773846227, + "CVC4": 1.5057636986084473, + "CVC3": 5.4782650804376578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4498826064145547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4904999241518944 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 18, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.699313276643846, + "veriT": 10.563447835086183, + "Yices": 10.473720023820299, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.469727959121244, + "CVC4": 1.6468457905313645, + "CVC3": 10.024285383879761, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5491098402890631, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.125420527756422 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.242831387571004, + "veriT": 10.166778359669667, + "Yices": 10.336690960559501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962224503431091, + "CVC4": 0.186309833318, + "CVC3": 12.662578436809399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4061700474179948, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.30346195711927 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9499964698929588, + "veriT": 9.1643280587059692, + "Yices": 5.686059769407998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9567149111389277, + "CVC4": 3.7767876545420762, + "CVC3": 7.1745901057302977, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9162155440417952, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0950814790917951 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8529493368733956, + "veriT": 11.674466886174692, + "Yices": 14.272747646683486, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8173860432629017, + "CVC4": 5.9131628655941082, + "CVC3": 12.336377490730854, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4174551382585943, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4251257581072405 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.844634625498315, + "veriT": 11.94124278905716, + "Yices": 10.874561139368971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.42563642808109, + "CVC4": 13.619695873546055, + "CVC3": 14.212909375578274, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.223922139199013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.878128157370703 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.223354299665591, + "veriT": 9.5957595991274172, + "Yices": 10.787874829603696, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.834934613665022, + "CVC4": 3.7670505242174173, + "CVC3": 8.503503760415887, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4541656942568615, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7201577103831687 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1593959887626673, + "veriT": 7.4708256584880663, + "Yices": 1.9604798276158, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2340729291866666, + "CVC4": 0.28421413651783334, + "CVC3": 0.34940707941316668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.396593672175394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.36223961717578 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.625, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.185843510788754, + "veriT": 10.658926047231423, + "Yices": 10.476979451272571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954062801966968, + "CVC4": 2.1694848794569697, + "CVC3": 11.544922657857564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4505836820974078, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.668490747651502 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.629305444012955, + "veriT": 9.0332732818059114, + "Yices": 10.193389235934571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.13806702207803, + "CVC4": 9.6610721052389419, + "CVC3": 9.8365605995093031, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.4176136541743318, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9113054072330149 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243948953610113, + "veriT": 10.161547741255223, + "Yices": 10.337956435690222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961606471816456, + "CVC4": 0.16606681119644442, + "CVC3": 13.416104813013654, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9935554562433602, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.317380104195992 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5345379824092715, + "veriT": 10.455761647974741, + "Yices": 9.2570166088502113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8884508743601049, + "CVC4": 2.9816874980679122, + "CVC3": 9.1402837087214657, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.11958940369499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.763918551861627 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.193475946685364, + "veriT": 13.048454026978177, + "Yices": 8.2815125867237729, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1264971876181562, + "CVC4": 6.5131365077592891, + "CVC3": 4.8576425275010662, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8824895338307552, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0255882869116597 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240315629899785, + "veriT": 11.330530925026219, + "Yices": 11.453794436750728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958112149419703, + "CVC4": 0.50679957370342854, + "CVC3": 12.644038764292478, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2089813092451251, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.170468317155994 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4928598792652865, + "veriT": 11.653975830068545, + "Yices": 12.206951251823993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.5865168228911433, + "CVC4": 12.480162849802102, + "CVC3": 10.552953664371801, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.224907770395303, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.296574212497195 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12874388655533334, + "veriT": 0.10023867043320833, + "Yices": 3.7273273568211387, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12648536698819998, + "CVC4": 3.6906580108254019, + "CVC3": 3.9070059165234503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18013170612041671, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17837879198603332 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2898551668025995, + "veriT": 10.369247140937322, + "Yices": 5.7590820626000685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6114429176274001, + "CVC4": 5.8151861010085586, + "CVC3": 4.5407508171403794, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.406708646888008, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.421762715935397 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.005710093147092, + "veriT": 11.057136491373749, + "Yices": 9.4677172249472559, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.510916292984369, + "CVC4": 3.4031819192296147, + "CVC3": 14.038885467028807, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9818002760281468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.918885918358034 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0357718837645322, + "veriT": 8.8165425750587794, + "Yices": 6.9712534616903667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.519315947365968, + "CVC4": 4.9886596199999795, + "CVC3": 3.3637243934202474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8169080029121396, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.179104463535996 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1165447188733229, + "veriT": 8.3523143585368107, + "Yices": 4.8084793782188431, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9435901811458955, + "CVC4": 2.8180999756739737, + "CVC3": 2.5110516509144585, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0554351977824044, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0790565906666281 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7637219429016113, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.23096997591017, + "veriT": 12.698144837626572, + "Yices": 11.084443039889113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.947917766256751, + "CVC4": 9.3855136923616449, + "CVC3": 14.231539721581544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9491131618070394, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.174085686839476 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0335526002391244, + "veriT": 10.683616841914089, + "Yices": 5.9279249335154427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7354667295135684, + "CVC4": 3.7228360599134893, + "CVC3": 7.2007849667477268, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9479505325460238, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8618196915444418 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0600528221560932, + "veriT": 11.957136313422172, + "Yices": 11.695132994411241, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.62612796243695, + "CVC4": 12.22400507947042, + "CVC3": 8.7616521497166566, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.704562834503555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.353832514931479 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7869896909188332, + "veriT": 2.4225022878100329, + "Yices": 0.06761408026183334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7816292372991003, + "CVC4": 2.4473691946589238, + "CVC3": 2.4262561202958826, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.094505709290199982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.094894602326183339 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14135460699511426, + "veriT": 5.4001431460793325, + "Yices": 7.5850776218508926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13431669751482858, + "CVC4": 2.5743177515217508, + "CVC3": 1.6454291871570714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.1181782585414206, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7034905199566266 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1481704711914062, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0710785388946533, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1833915441342304, + "veriT": 7.9010905477609219, + "Yices": 10.182824348551721, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.28658285202114, + "CVC4": 6.1857349031127526, + "CVC3": 3.1772749378433622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9592134449648881, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3173912431957966 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3209625114413335, + "veriT": 8.837721700835159, + "Yices": 12.222040213487922, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3913503523369113, + "CVC4": 8.1573586217958152, + "CVC3": 2.4125153304042222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8905429120525246, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8091662681406819 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15174349056392858, + "veriT": 4.4138222808974286, + "Yices": 6.1695904707870008, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2694923668469111, + "CVC4": 2.1750338876289419, + "CVC3": 0.16058532815442858, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18403194103478571, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18455536892564287 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1971785536699748, + "veriT": 5.1622660624991807, + "Yices": 7.9823903506059901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6333791830245215, + "CVC4": 2.4048034286546582, + "CVC3": 2.1656029628162039, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.972803182475487, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9732334339400834 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6210409340240015, + "veriT": 8.6855052020685957, + "Yices": 8.9761068438875267, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.766663616541432, + "CVC4": 11.894834527153643, + "CVC3": 8.2873051999976965, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.393506940886031, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.144129674347868 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.053324560513476, + "veriT": 10.109513138593389, + "Yices": 10.109417063043425, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.153962274777832, + "CVC4": 3.9107810039924997, + "CVC3": 2.403780431008006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.869596770809423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.879983850041977 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3273214451525295, + "veriT": 5.8883989752292676, + "Yices": 4.0958439679929208, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.5006616779217654, + "CVC4": 2.7155888735529103, + "CVC3": 1.9388877322090001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14744781757270589, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14295065463688236 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6413738860378935, + "veriT": 9.7550510462898039, + "Yices": 8.226878210573112, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4584410643086159, + "CVC4": 2.0376211119936092, + "CVC3": 2.0790401130486242, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0131688319382199, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.696072358893245 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.411025555415254, + "veriT": 11.159419384676843, + "Yices": 11.578637495314847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.986080778378858, + "CVC4": 14.449762897190755, + "CVC3": 13.498586345465332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.423585340493853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.713947839819163 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.001977787384928, + "veriT": 3.1557801121081956, + "Yices": 7.6901234557009772, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0050713130286151, + "CVC4": 5.3458055535740598, + "CVC3": 4.5668638420883578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1895951303120444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1836262599624217 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3942835377525507, + "veriT": 6.6652525436393493, + "Yices": 9.5479418413925714, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.652653887297979, + "CVC4": 11.295555768525277, + "CVC3": 4.2901044412853073, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1595887190516629, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.187191644497139 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6974209128456188, + "veriT": 10.185299131577667, + "Yices": 10.324444888339, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.156270862745171, + "CVC4": 14.261747624198001, + "CVC3": 8.7149523490951051, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.239881373716669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.521500090250715 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9007689952850342, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1464426886647143, + "veriT": 14.207551972912105, + "Yices": 0.59592215946242855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20459161728071429, + "CVC4": 6.3657040414867305, + "CVC3": 4.1937432526175922, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.202027141059158, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.199334014944384 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0476334537015455, + "veriT": 14.208946636966276, + "Yices": 2.4881980528069216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0710807177202728, + "CVC4": 1.0724057598023635, + "CVC3": 2.3224221607463047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.816744262885775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.828539096259441 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.043701400196559, + "veriT": 14.229744414072723, + "Yices": 10.495243127686244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0924043216400001, + "CVC4": 5.0972787875506578, + "CVC3": 14.232000093961739, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242993796361535, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.246925771732474 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1667665370421467, + "veriT": 14.222778589703504, + "Yices": 10.399215101899859, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.462791375393515, + "CVC4": 10.370916976378293, + "CVC3": 6.6700365896168226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.823296912572891, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.827878554852484 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8020085096359253, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7193083471682282, + "veriT": 10.168020486685398, + "Yices": 10.694759919666787, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.802497981190362, + "CVC4": 8.6958525189909679, + "CVC3": 11.475993282980147, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.136016017904623, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.084391224288078 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 49.0, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15176799200160002, + "veriT": 0.13274600721073335, + "Yices": 0.14474352407533334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14851251542146665, + "CVC4": 0.16534378611833336, + "CVC3": 0.14692283750000001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15790362449473333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15848910949853334 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9430995953047367, + "veriT": 5.9169452859207272, + "Yices": 3.1157874800839602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0950127596416666, + "CVC4": 5.790968293045724, + "CVC3": 1.5363890652587933, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2499017911572576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.2600571197893835 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13737878816749999, + "veriT": 3.6497381595441518, + "Yices": 0.135312107705575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14408757523462501, + "CVC4": 0.16074685112099998, + "CVC3": 0.13400320297677501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15514274935047501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15091932910154998 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 119.0, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 50.0, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23464020137469999, + "veriT": 0.2126622561823, + "Yices": 10.668051007713812, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.40737353802440002, + "CVC4": 3.0555127877699535, + "CVC3": 0.2336639541678, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.49807387727439989, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4575959755073269 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9635254803348889, + "veriT": 6.1203928774996594, + "Yices": 6.1841660216314995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1180635109939576, + "CVC4": 3.0183101480263148, + "CVC3": 0.14919156274630002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7862066671956738, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8100126478857348 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8150162179512366, + "veriT": 9.8194821522704423, + "Yices": 12.98728128831192, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1033466614724592, + "CVC4": 8.793277692300336, + "CVC3": 10.688052610241744, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.5957532931737965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4413680621265161 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 68.0, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19143296530042855, + "veriT": 4.1894039164829389, + "Yices": 3.1111822339437145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20069411452342859, + "CVC4": 0.22864092355542859, + "CVC3": 0.53735680155114285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19169993788742859, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19298265432542852 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4542256382052861, + "veriT": 0.14451462344257143, + "Yices": 0.14969153292071427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.453937434697429, + "CVC4": 4.2119670591404645, + "CVC3": 0.14531165192185713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15380908955785713, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15574913791071429 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9131068805234053, + "veriT": 10.108030591075062, + "Yices": 6.68111431340576, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1959349414732783, + "CVC4": 6.9573202442466853, + "CVC3": 2.5561954377365113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6164252837860054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.59127204169519 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7517514538569516, + "veriT": 8.6706222116164238, + "Yices": 13.712876887841885, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3390207665138405, + "CVC4": 12.914350940235128, + "CVC3": 10.550666978197537, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.502448281716267, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.437217284455013 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.37761462122374995, + "veriT": 9.1067246611349422, + "Yices": 10.694671016221241, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2789726925625833, + "CVC4": 2.8035566489159542, + "CVC3": 0.48399390409874998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15223578021583334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14993917422933334 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.543451484494712, + "veriT": 12.4836713424615, + "Yices": 7.6874986742114926, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.80821522500419, + "CVC4": 10.572176013404954, + "CVC3": 9.6175429823976639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.995053045423839, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.198236879541765 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.32131695019576673, + "veriT": 5.1104554425217001, + "Yices": 5.1173933552832169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.80528355477283331, + "CVC4": 0.32910919483349999, + "CVC3": 0.14079449699246668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1803688820659559, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1725977536943972 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4134965832961437, + "veriT": 13.031805434674562, + "Yices": 9.3819393072738357, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.935250831269177, + "CVC4": 3.4992512356652572, + "CVC3": 5.8348925982738713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3336726639512952, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6254970292056461 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 28.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.285540613135273, + "veriT": 12.172406944239976, + "Yices": 12.038041185044703, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.447896636874262, + "CVC4": 13.859097331485041, + "CVC3": 13.735504756230519, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.174479629173215, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.226328577425958 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239949890332937, + "veriT": 10.137794240587301, + "Yices": 10.22431640922083, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964708434193387, + "CVC4": 14.421156811542858, + "CVC3": 14.227910094984153, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240270533611106, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.798325953922184 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5991997481601432, + "veriT": 12.020899178590962, + "Yices": 12.544988416110682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0875002805462763, + "CVC4": 13.143618741064051, + "CVC3": 9.2274511027040074, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.462215017273312, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.467507811020198 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1626565456390381, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21898398671337502, + "veriT": 10.974859515443764, + "Yices": 6.6861829348775625, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6244368709642352, + "CVC4": 5.6438935062999862, + "CVC3": 6.7635275182238752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18361989995137498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1769384068665 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.434072636394399, + "veriT": 10.815423665773995, + "Yices": 14.177807639744325, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6095931545227433, + "CVC4": 14.56397094625841, + "CVC3": 13.759124724965492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7822854721468957, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6967923380978043 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.784392229209609, + "veriT": 12.223807550934461, + "Yices": 12.733590633285035, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.207141809726176, + "CVC4": 12.959285988479495, + "CVC3": 6.3059353234106954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.50580391082792, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7204374062449741 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 197.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2662861418840001, + "veriT": 14.240369210096929, + "Yices": 13.998628136308362, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.111540194230196, + "CVC4": 14.741760857294693, + "CVC3": 12.120943587069831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.259157639143771, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.258752566538277 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.260845910645982, + "veriT": 12.008679382035542, + "Yices": 13.17072573047667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.978273365541982, + "CVC4": 14.446231893855275, + "CVC3": 12.789752598627368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3046346977275114, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0257424845048622 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.251881635011168, + "veriT": 14.25292829564602, + "Yices": 14.257054933582745, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973709173424895, + "CVC4": 14.94500728326441, + "CVC3": 13.103196323714204, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.472328937401306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.51162082854324 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 166.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0049198831344444, + "veriT": 3.9022920271779373, + "Yices": 5.7023128487090036, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7285903745688582, + "CVC4": 6.5608585363274114, + "CVC3": 1.9428461254842944, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7371267136141291, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7350535616262381 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.247949574141531, + "veriT": 12.230395732652285, + "Yices": 12.078018369343482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.97658336781253, + "CVC4": 14.483359543176803, + "CVC3": 11.822305577663869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.788027544275467, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.901509601153181 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 188.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 247.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.444448204127099, + "veriT": 13.41649254724787, + "Yices": 12.316351229502621, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.474180986541374, + "CVC4": 14.072788449832203, + "CVC3": 11.298449588393563, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.858783291765121, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.574154995046154 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.73708507000433, + "veriT": 8.1906527495855919, + "Yices": 8.6896976469305027, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.518816627880838, + "CVC4": 8.1165106130813456, + "CVC3": 6.1207671073923446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3457920034324768, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3012930420221096 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 236.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.921501673810996, + "veriT": 14.012948105241405, + "Yices": 13.494787081189026, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953002086496511, + "CVC4": 14.336739002680474, + "CVC3": 13.08277455853127, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.21845968137908, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.113755264851337 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 264.5, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1411522173122179, + "veriT": 14.21340733637382, + "Yices": 8.3010263226181173, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.20180983553316, + "CVC4": 8.9796033121059544, + "CVC3": 13.791358797955763, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8214405719134321, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8220289192404984 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 151 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.212428939738885, + "veriT": 12.686952008557057, + "Yices": 12.683149470554165, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.830977253721983, + "CVC4": 9.8788533041812467, + "CVC3": 13.820194135522851, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.279864544452668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.22059418535118 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24810349694963, + "veriT": 13.149512559141805, + "Yices": 12.869553393922054, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.004727032166038, + "CVC4": 14.692311203103236, + "CVC3": 14.238938277751071, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.269690055820384, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.417403668417279 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12512704604595654, + "veriT": 0.096373329332626115, + "Yices": 0.098888493681613052, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12279185815978262, + "CVC4": 0.12404888696073914, + "CVC3": 0.10197941779559129, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12162300618839131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11991609643013046 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.75, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0798591839977449, + "veriT": 2.4227696637578764, + "Yices": 2.2684820881077385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1561572901833257, + "CVC4": 3.3905085031364446, + "CVC3": 0.11513534105062308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.30514248549748, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3087126581378352 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11473411892339284, + "veriT": 0.085537731763007149, + "Yices": 0.090345710762271422, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1149673362126143, + "CVC4": 0.11102180910806428, + "CVC3": 0.092223127247949996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10841818844284286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10691990881371428 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5559437451348952, + "veriT": 9.1574461725489602, + "Yices": 9.2789932373389821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.03180603247201, + "CVC4": 2.6182079716195759, + "CVC3": 7.3997890419419798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4934841600644551, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.955237047433 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 12, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20823313629861906, + "veriT": 10.164649048289142, + "Yices": 10.354663636231285, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.26105133240319051, + "CVC4": 0.14789621453552379, + "CVC3": 0.68807113974857137, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14800889077504764, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.464629900618187 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18244638888780002, + "veriT": 7.1497041919775004, + "Yices": 9.5669699727655999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28666058482729995, + "CVC4": 0.15192017591829998, + "CVC3": 0.2395655230598, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14826285680659998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.435397135436109 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7067869901657104, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.41428542137146, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9643857957042159, + "veriT": 6.8319208784868337, + "Yices": 8.6190546094536682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3467499148675373, + "CVC4": 0.15992141314533334, + "CVC3": 0.98958686904749993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15497747425933334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3214153442630252 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6181819438934326, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.236322848007799, + "veriT": 10.175898453311556, + "Yices": 10.320937156573001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.951715721521314, + "CVC4": 0.4027064799684445, + "CVC3": 12.782424209996911, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5431387317133733, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.259847544389093 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.251553494655345, + "veriT": 10.191572763419, + "Yices": 10.36799994285575, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974585723737951, + "CVC4": 0.18087729146162501, + "CVC3": 12.725493792831973, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16901045612512502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.446232330587724 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.384741801681193, + "veriT": 11.359488673418864, + "Yices": 9.5287177306637023, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.70751923821021, + "CVC4": 2.7817464023115419, + "CVC3": 7.9057517243065663, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6298950302978734, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.186032628482856 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2684505478396666, + "veriT": 7.1472600178416581, + "Yices": 4.824095449196296, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2765403775587778, + "CVC4": 3.3699697592890434, + "CVC3": 2.8247061480753421, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7274005867552509, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7263268298563639 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.981612179647287, + "veriT": 12.017707607301174, + "Yices": 5.8742031556154615, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.858678683427108, + "CVC4": 0.16109537973276922, + "CVC3": 7.0916290054110265, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4360746117738135, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2267908550963842 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.72500097385273, + "veriT": 9.4170683463757818, + "Yices": 9.2252128237391258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.092445623783703, + "CVC4": 2.0160490410647642, + "CVC3": 10.820732215377351, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.633602515195767, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.099926117889352 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2229950077661687, + "veriT": 7.0528824611657184, + "Yices": 10.878882572077982, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8083880909732266, + "CVC4": 6.4345498965828005, + "CVC3": 6.3530632931403295, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.815724247795405, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0852250853043177 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.407111105952142, + "veriT": 12.032100470988105, + "Yices": 12.103316031667712, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.862813384932895, + "CVC4": 14.538892380730006, + "CVC3": 13.508445322740677, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.294323991163502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.173479849878733 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.344540755780306, + "veriT": 10.350485901140223, + "Yices": 9.5352046367414243, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.472847838354166, + "CVC4": 6.1330303650159506, + "CVC3": 12.408364730843001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.985992058969337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.432948096781359 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9166665077209473, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244501790263023, + "veriT": 10.169311012667416, + "Yices": 10.337988704788417, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961077921259273, + "CVC4": 0.16869422199591666, + "CVC3": 13.540615424663136, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1630447515356632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.288724861047527 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2916665077209473, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.329812818301329, + "veriT": 11.645470407910105, + "Yices": 8.3661877440042023, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.73551353266051, + "CVC4": 2.3238049868229287, + "CVC3": 7.2381819167071404, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4497876944473482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.182653481023783 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.805804415109503, + "veriT": 10.685986184754597, + "Yices": 10.456700985420124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.35699913493435, + "CVC4": 4.6843777321922317, + "CVC3": 10.580044624825549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8840508070911692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.672512136389592 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8780606223831464, + "veriT": 6.1520740715085012, + "Yices": 8.9628127947803495, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3140309847349894, + "CVC4": 11.016541195568493, + "CVC3": 3.9767092808257472, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.197998735692988, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2066024232057027 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 47, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5963290858921342, + "veriT": 11.034042376441976, + "Yices": 6.4861374888440588, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3355648122505368, + "CVC4": 2.1869192276065248, + "CVC3": 1.9526282958009287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1822348798490356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3834328491363674 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.233732520807386, + "veriT": 10.665054822798409, + "Yices": 10.82115502890257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95158932869268, + "CVC4": 0.31462571535512501, + "CVC3": 12.766367434843321, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9667266373200629, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.63817656712056 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.897853628149811, + "veriT": 11.865137111794475, + "Yices": 9.2093389720086076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.311437882322961, + "CVC4": 12.26114446444987, + "CVC3": 11.419255106389789, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.87804443603377, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8731079731339069 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6598074113887176, + "veriT": 4.5045036519169024, + "Yices": 4.4523999075828549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3016524511108525, + "CVC4": 2.4618470668256531, + "CVC3": 6.8707941275542703, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6489622533826473, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6474519783004737 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.839936884382022, + "veriT": 10.677658890998835, + "Yices": 10.847703178348381, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.719362336974273, + "CVC4": 0.70383909991908344, + "CVC3": 8.0040308894534071, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15348332841999998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6765510390260658 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7340947451346249, + "veriT": 6.922658262090267, + "Yices": 12.739720611018146, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6620089546347492, + "CVC4": 12.726223325460893, + "CVC3": 13.295421171394404, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.189197912132158, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.207747470929638 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8738689422607422, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3259265985835564, + "veriT": 11.869849855382116, + "Yices": 3.3326173442462661, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6471443602654863, + "CVC4": 2.6833593218161318, + "CVC3": 2.818525864708985, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5340461943010486, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.526563390736082 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8070765800775623, + "veriT": 14.211584413766944, + "Yices": 4.996117923264527, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0684337917870157, + "CVC4": 5.5452642886614143, + "CVC3": 3.8029560357908583, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.879973031859661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.897572036391152 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6168511771568745, + "veriT": 11.943830825577981, + "Yices": 11.142929535074735, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6083690086008753, + "CVC4": 12.172438327708699, + "CVC3": 7.7757320176506246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.442959533452365, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.699812898595278 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3652809177250669, + "veriT": 2.8005788530963138, + "Yices": 0.78389483871873566, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7524467951912595, + "CVC4": 2.1783052460583705, + "CVC3": 2.0954994033669423, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1039565144481802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1029546928969778 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3123969806740983, + "veriT": 5.1110223937700665, + "Yices": 7.1344388590792134, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3682608388440052, + "CVC4": 1.3357831450884097, + "CVC3": 1.2994077948153282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4819490140945946, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3071469033728607 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6641260932076203, + "veriT": 10.121828539549375, + "Yices": 6.3985710545919376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.852393396361522, + "CVC4": 3.6691259699027943, + "CVC3": 5.4171494949561225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.838567265362153, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2530955224277704 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1605676038844477, + "veriT": 6.3770718103925876, + "Yices": 5.8155240660847376, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7523630134177499, + "CVC4": 5.4461393566808436, + "CVC3": 1.4939324225845876, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2352511697635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6237533484592015 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0375166139805425, + "veriT": 5.6105111532973515, + "Yices": 11.958402794078753, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0128516248348141, + "CVC4": 7.8606572084117889, + "CVC3": 6.1396061373239998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.19971287605542, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3581517876462517 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.363183045554889, + "veriT": 4.389916442096844, + "Yices": 2.4211816849455556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3820984691433336, + "CVC4": 0.15190631270333332, + "CVC3": 0.15263709079675555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13416865994766669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13251285337933333 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14618998721271428, + "veriT": 1.5550321834948573, + "Yices": 3.5826724992198464, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15675204093488571, + "CVC4": 4.1689896458692246, + "CVC3": 0.15906864197728571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1445511805642208, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7009661936397735 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1597956159374814, + "veriT": 7.5329959228788272, + "Yices": 7.2410625499900139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6825143033190955, + "CVC4": 0.37342634074279996, + "CVC3": 0.14870187873714283, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1086325770980969, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1350921254756967 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.540738131676072, + "veriT": 10.108393435894566, + "Yices": 10.108885526546933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.494159393284301, + "CVC4": 5.1349160854145008, + "CVC3": 4.0921845951925908, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228126633676892, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.225094530468157 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.540836025820965, + "veriT": 4.1487638032784497, + "Yices": 13.524620515658686, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6867498345719358, + "CVC4": 12.150149242590754, + "CVC3": 10.47593059363707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.808742021617773, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5975325371033584 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.368503540212485, + "veriT": 10.52062208199219, + "Yices": 10.548990547901255, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6490123424763707, + "CVC4": 13.558851305547435, + "CVC3": 11.219286612814502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.396880898846367, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.404631026688637 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.74156131711328, + "veriT": 9.954906505540162, + "Yices": 10.024998964092642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.555908096147581, + "CVC4": 7.6556867655014695, + "CVC3": 7.5516245875810046, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.53758379763413, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.849503368761996 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8555740842808335, + "veriT": 1.8298866462971664, + "Yices": 3.4972655482661668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8697532146929998, + "CVC4": 1.84578370695, + "CVC3": 2.2167511906611366, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5271430284244665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5262480956237368 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14226601604292857, + "veriT": 0.12273712121905714, + "Yices": 0.1349012809827857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14010947937599999, + "CVC4": 0.16363410612792859, + "CVC3": 0.13603421150835712, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15542269642328568, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15257007338328571 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.965801476119909, + "veriT": 0.12593005365709092, + "Yices": 0.14225190707000002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9636348437750002, + "CVC4": 0.17034658977781819, + "CVC3": 0.14351600715372725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16004571231681819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16216556681954544 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9886741498219858, + "veriT": 4.1348186205828625, + "Yices": 7.7261934140496251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3674157830263813, + "CVC4": 7.3114820228708108, + "CVC3": 2.0067448163816803, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.0409885869988456, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1227415299663352 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15405743225268748, + "veriT": 9.5851785550604731, + "Yices": 1.0475057195717754, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28192017935831254, + "CVC4": 0.16307075341781249, + "CVC3": 0.44720229893015001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14803374371272501, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.149963455254675 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 148.0, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.916264022277375, + "veriT": 1.3961425192507999, + "Yices": 1.4067939233525877, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9112710670592499, + "CVC4": 1.9514210399709793, + "CVC3": 0.15669453668550001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16852810748661248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16635741098937501 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16416895675877777, + "veriT": 0.13673280499244445, + "Yices": 0.15389762066022222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16843430119844444, + "CVC4": 0.17955696377200001, + "CVC3": 0.1617002618757778, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17194435508933334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17176052574066666 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3706619692797486, + "veriT": 11.535462857566291, + "Yices": 8.5080011836061686, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7594726209770677, + "CVC4": 3.9562218353409038, + "CVC3": 5.7965718238811803, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7453949778169284, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6538952534549978 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 42.0, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2197775875732004, + "veriT": 9.8107858722581121, + "Yices": 10.787287103148799, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0094517219956005, + "CVC4": 8.7931566411668811, + "CVC3": 8.0210570108688266, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.435858818538968, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.813742010147477 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20469264240416665, + "veriT": 9.6715284953124883, + "Yices": 3.791856723396998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.7013244450785, + "CVC4": 5.0183055013506914, + "CVC3": 1.4362082819694919, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.8006218351603902, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5365120568748174 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.210218800084082, + "veriT": 7.8108103464619898, + "Yices": 3.6023299107119904, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.596015029559203, + "CVC4": 5.9174793191457482, + "CVC3": 4.4867180866230481, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4031994957307692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2135772436747434 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2167372627250375, + "veriT": 12.485885596514011, + "Yices": 6.6753864213120142, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4137638501221872, + "CVC4": 12.960582906591977, + "CVC3": 6.551108248319724, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.23981992153127, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.900152015709725 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 64.0, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12271523746533332, + "veriT": 1.7640975697121002, + "Yices": 1.7930473264951166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13609355147238333, + "CVC4": 3.6611224060532734, + "CVC3": 0.11781056430873332, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18002541594218335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19203989865313334 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1521405842828103, + "veriT": 10.366622744856816, + "Yices": 8.9655048933270454, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.185884809508404, + "CVC4": 2.0004832500118122, + "CVC3": 2.2976701002822746, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1034315203084997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.8518881188671249 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.105086088180542, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1483279456325004, + "veriT": 7.3475806598970506, + "Yices": 3.5125884588765999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1524336183884003, + "CVC4": 8.6733785115242732, + "CVC3": 0.14530528876829998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23842886267989996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.2034149319685 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2354641250736789, + "veriT": 9.5611261937120631, + "Yices": 9.5764996242534171, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5825194571741594, + "CVC4": 6.8196827519395926, + "CVC3": 6.6662183607823495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3792454102358311, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3384265361996226 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.938601016998291, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6518939733505249, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2989419922643837, + "veriT": 12.175489104611964, + "Yices": 7.7526005780975682, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8324567706143569, + "CVC4": 9.0066145617382727, + "CVC3": 6.5152613308751954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7150114705001478, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7171511507916666 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 81.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.418123405237534, + "veriT": 12.358530735550103, + "Yices": 13.548878320039863, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.798836538789756, + "CVC4": 13.193960122431623, + "CVC3": 11.779270321339913, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228872662301205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238538230765174 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.860162643532602, + "veriT": 13.126039285932116, + "Yices": 11.803783680778082, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95433540090608, + "CVC4": 14.461968115985259, + "CVC3": 14.230230168553506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.244788931058936, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.476728234763833 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.378454962850199, + "veriT": 13.322899948178422, + "Yices": 12.18716466287256, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.258891682222933, + "CVC4": 13.094646719099194, + "CVC3": 13.938142794167621, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238111184873581, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.930248393844515 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3178245272145999, + "veriT": 13.410207966635408, + "Yices": 13.74707116040253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.109191340371135, + "CVC4": 10.619827747072955, + "CVC3": 10.13796832185427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.722045443618041, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.719504644211376 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2306875055575008, + "veriT": 14.239415452429389, + "Yices": 4.194511021375253, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3256757344214285, + "CVC4": 8.2769417502796507, + "CVC3": 6.4124617277561793, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.222750729195976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2261049249812785 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.889164489478242, + "veriT": 10.214212381047833, + "Yices": 11.525955911796261, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.610872385038084, + "CVC4": 14.322932461304703, + "CVC3": 10.65648738338991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.869060489965698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.871334346806833 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 215.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.0899992597046984, + "veriT": 11.186441792222562, + "Yices": 6.1051624924184758, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9611947580215903, + "CVC4": 4.2290199014829399, + "CVC3": 8.1211836291499271, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3319857260130576, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3666952622000306 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24408889401449999, + "veriT": 4.0747370782843655, + "Yices": 1.8323575696210834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4866229602094345, + "CVC4": 1.3664804321337385, + "CVC3": 0.21973586690583335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5126272580154994, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2786165387901947 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.388885179146607, + "veriT": 14.276723063775211, + "Yices": 12.785332802481532, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.732197073031092, + "CVC4": 6.1131807816957906, + "CVC3": 6.7145975767095889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2149373430935624, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2045489937419291 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1531565189361572, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.3632455967253971, + "veriT": 12.353993246814001, + "Yices": 12.37143699141736, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.003947190654278, + "CVC4": 12.982972682259254, + "CVC3": 10.336674895214744, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1244445021645371, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.0111057897893287 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.874031770085287, + "veriT": 13.858758548862482, + "Yices": 13.94880289294597, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.527832293532567, + "CVC4": 14.368075172731711, + "CVC3": 13.041847053780716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.578381631923316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.777433380360693 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2132980443296084, + "veriT": 10.791851936949682, + "Yices": 10.924009427638577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5272721978297046, + "CVC4": 9.6359042543089899, + "CVC3": 11.912502878864775, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.770761481636377, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.089825014595082 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 127.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.742655739029523, + "veriT": 9.2267682244392688, + "Yices": 11.217369271735752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.94116460573369, + "CVC4": 14.494503331541608, + "CVC3": 10.285374090525377, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.433165082744104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5908952991766832 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1393294334411621, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.720566822823102, + "veriT": 12.503877545140858, + "Yices": 12.190555749785759, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.255400302098778, + "CVC4": 12.75316319155039, + "CVC3": 13.6215710909682, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.243072820700073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.245893181529857 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.248696658770223, + "veriT": 11.537949582111272, + "Yices": 13.211469531696084, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.868651056640715, + "CVC4": 14.578239988037831, + "CVC3": 13.400299825590869, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.177824882566007, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.117937197667349 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8752203001869896, + "veriT": 14.228285952959137, + "Yices": 13.868372475116148, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95792985299725, + "CVC4": 14.581831259845229, + "CVC3": 11.007005638997571, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.243683611108404, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.24233892765562 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.266324668477475, + "veriT": 14.258082488769245, + "Yices": 14.078915340837312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.466501773860045, + "CVC4": 14.767269309286899, + "CVC3": 11.203940852460249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.001030885186482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.644333593739089 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 67.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1263955038786552, + "veriT": 0.09522691439818276, + "Yices": 0.098478393286610344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12290930545434482, + "CVC4": 0.12528905183996553, + "CVC3": 0.10261801984496549, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11959515130327587, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11897739840986207 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11352950904595716, + "veriT": 0.08545926215884285, + "Yices": 0.090192766681564271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11356429351283573, + "CVC4": 0.10867856053707856, + "CVC3": 0.092604103701878562, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10926898996965714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10745208672548569 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9545930442295942, + "veriT": 2.1273911798583294, + "Yices": 2.9664099761169602, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0911614742598159, + "CVC4": 1.551930261802926, + "CVC3": 1.5379909784008716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14571719882349998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.565322630696774 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6132490789051626, + "veriT": 10.16284174519263, + "Yices": 10.347064021722067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7633922644029527, + "CVC4": 0.14955118897726666, + "CVC3": 0.63226695318780002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15021818402853335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8165075086753042 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.699602484703064, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4677835852108583, + "veriT": 9.0372708707465623, + "Yices": 9.0747512934348169, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.6790627610695275, + "CVC4": 6.5052654995555264, + "CVC3": 8.0191168555083188, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7847113881666008, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3534410585813852 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0131012231425744, + "veriT": 5.1850065034317501, + "Yices": 7.8189619149373755, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2130046812452386, + "CVC4": 0.163037755644375, + "CVC3": 0.94487624826749994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5883069653109256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.942860265271879 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.49936333041523, + "veriT": 10.896883977129061, + "Yices": 10.597031074701908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.08138158508047, + "CVC4": 2.8518388110362989, + "CVC3": 10.544909790741364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7026325558285693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.771207082123611 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8838749083044668, + "veriT": 9.4886286581266859, + "Yices": 9.7948981599107778, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.130021734311242, + "CVC4": 1.771568499915001, + "CVC3": 8.0152433437695674, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3675409731779355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1948217429959627 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243911691533643, + "veriT": 10.163853307180144, + "Yices": 10.342383862652998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963854760607914, + "CVC4": 0.15947547352928573, + "CVC3": 12.079679277632099, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16512076417092855, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.381430964269537 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.4377787678571, + "veriT": 11.780837678696253, + "Yices": 11.367203712393781, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.947700106414919, + "CVC4": 5.9872856883208847, + "CVC3": 11.604724087908579, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.314766279653492, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.481042874688809 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.767623555829507, + "veriT": 11.756582045519924, + "Yices": 12.116832180469718, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.471353088500576, + "CVC4": 11.868831642170324, + "CVC3": 14.217877126379463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.119393744197177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.73246246599977 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.741443820258684, + "veriT": 10.336704883442806, + "Yices": 11.292079327625375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.584290326267801, + "CVC4": 1.1241520663321249, + "CVC3": 12.544182700558705, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4694351589923489, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.208561506158755 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.563535656878003, + "veriT": 14.207625804524051, + "Yices": 4.3531143900812994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.111477561840445, + "CVC4": 3.4358861993920464, + "CVC3": 0.80113775005249999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0277072370746723, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0497260103406876 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7014472683971764, + "veriT": 11.330077675344635, + "Yices": 11.988359264828325, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5814425024021865, + "CVC4": 12.625612420675996, + "CVC3": 9.3088084773961679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.483199230318352, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.230930910152354 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8851934721359536, + "veriT": 10.101292648762501, + "Yices": 11.884372372848899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9022024747010229, + "CVC4": 9.5790256611651436, + "CVC3": 3.2649501482221082, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3985748422700341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2682116771814673 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.953736359315849, + "veriT": 10.365961433954698, + "Yices": 10.356590280687914, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.562003607769006, + "CVC4": 4.0116829565972134, + "CVC3": 10.557749227759318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0352720160373892, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.797793268498296 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.501297449397569, + "veriT": 8.9148718017066244, + "Yices": 10.324305295469999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.127020674879923, + "CVC4": 0.17413503837674998, + "CVC3": 11.537323370703396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.911735661904686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.279974694021966 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.481446267744321, + "veriT": 11.167782458761568, + "Yices": 10.753337867895862, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.618321946260714, + "CVC4": 5.6642613011722736, + "CVC3": 9.9621502630500665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9432356714437495, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6378469865982481 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.848883372571283, + "veriT": 9.4844736492278034, + "Yices": 9.5270996387851259, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.768344506102819, + "CVC4": 6.2824377171975474, + "CVC3": 10.74831983746088, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4158671031689831, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6598954812350355 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13449407776658179, + "veriT": 13.088040843742881, + "Yices": 7.9772398261671613, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14016457179927275, + "CVC4": 10.394845855579211, + "CVC3": 10.126210195796105, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6072760544666043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5937291365310386 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7638888359069824, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.2409568249132858, + "veriT": 3.4807080346016894, + "Yices": 2.0694036660890998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0755544682269065, + "CVC4": 1.691994084480094, + "CVC3": 1.4855022872071897, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9109393699124948, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9137865285909483 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14041179323704997, + "veriT": 3.494405035030923, + "Yices": 10.016661802765945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.37426147984176872, + "CVC4": 3.4235045827154891, + "CVC3": 0.84907313889274993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6469563563926806, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.894064546915275 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8983331511959274, + "veriT": 1.3754662107453126, + "Yices": 1.4018901549905001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9768607902249218, + "CVC4": 0.164972636508875, + "CVC3": 0.27981463192915007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19885406534837499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5897767670575285 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1742424964904785, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5939263572620508, + "veriT": 11.182748284658681, + "Yices": 10.158500204142824, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3534459458631218, + "CVC4": 9.4006297041346816, + "CVC3": 6.3345963912442498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.727171989753316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.595444555259183 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5604448260732333, + "veriT": 4.1817023401132589, + "Yices": 9.8896356108800685, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8554559328206333, + "CVC4": 4.206444252350459, + "CVC3": 1.9264218621748335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.870495922060603, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3925231694789302 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.422127956044301, + "veriT": 8.1683510210267993, + "Yices": 8.2858108614038883, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.993066849602224, + "CVC4": 0.61716124530219996, + "CVC3": 8.3241545208313603, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.609620576046327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.049377210587901 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.440199235932532, + "veriT": 8.9357541421259992, + "Yices": 6.3864517405392496, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.69984510856649995, + "CVC4": 0.17509257302925002, + "CVC3": 0.27573606512725002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7705824964566013, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.794584943576206 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.496219148520622, + "veriT": 1.9689181464951666, + "Yices": 1.7862432923331335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1384515468242693, + "CVC4": 0.15807364840300001, + "CVC3": 2.497817109200072, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0101947516715097, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0280676508445423 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5227274894714355, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13443098270744444, + "veriT": 2.3395304731245998, + "Yices": 4.3662669824011608, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14265173865488887, + "CVC4": 0.14347095481822222, + "CVC3": 0.1268811288277111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13725933755866665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13714828439400004 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6600599988857891, + "veriT": 12.90289022510815, + "Yices": 8.1842087100275549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1378440336394711, + "CVC4": 6.6590925377004586, + "CVC3": 7.8282579977879863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4072848516363177, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1009903379502868 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.719790341896598, + "veriT": 10.269416859166229, + "Yices": 10.775534855904796, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.26261283906112, + "CVC4": 2.2429482642414662, + "CVC3": 2.0447379990368417, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5957284650834471, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3148173545801569 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.287527646638944, + "veriT": 8.913730371556591, + "Yices": 8.7628048165238397, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5112229570732811, + "CVC4": 12.676948903787302, + "CVC3": 10.174090612921857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.67704409546897, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9235505122329393 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.839809080519153, + "veriT": 10.095298413889132, + "Yices": 10.10149469549269, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.952886902526805, + "CVC4": 6.1595916116487093, + "CVC3": 6.4171641203566736, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.221747716224849, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.20667279873247 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0992521825587396, + "veriT": 13.262376011450487, + "Yices": 7.2610661986330047, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6515822479814788, + "CVC4": 3.6600222127293343, + "CVC3": 4.6402776047343552, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6331984462330817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8188713736799 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6998370880516283, + "veriT": 7.2002901334234677, + "Yices": 13.375601149704034, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7796339614888748, + "CVC4": 10.887400190878163, + "CVC3": 10.570716844804704, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0618093340864743, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0924067586863657 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1079688971364448, + "veriT": 12.637847330284371, + "Yices": 13.75094493309099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.1848646181991107, + "CVC4": 14.592029650443124, + "CVC3": 12.582809914485717, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.442606155223034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.488036789708637 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8619050979614258, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7400219440460205, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14684991081742857, + "veriT": 0.12675718727485716, + "Yices": 3.0442860382077144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14173041129542857, + "CVC4": 0.17529450048157141, + "CVC3": 0.15162972454171428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.209562457099434, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3396370474298323 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1480598958255, + "veriT": 0.14091793594622501, + "Yices": 0.27890726492099999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18990079551224998, + "CVC4": 0.22772620890424999, + "CVC3": 1.4316706467726252, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18924955933249998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.189191821648 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8461701371440054, + "veriT": 8.8262415309037738, + "Yices": 11.334297732535511, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.077079695756928, + "CVC4": 7.3684057136898042, + "CVC3": 4.2423952713495963, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4929221561998993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.980559619767174 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2579851150512695, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.7628114198828, + "veriT": 10.571216585668649, + "Yices": 10.727290912438912, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.004710476966403, + "CVC4": 0.31777633711859998, + "CVC3": 8.4883441257034384, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1613817890184, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1227462289397572 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.492550890847987, + "veriT": 8.3110726055353421, + "Yices": 11.090558327749823, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.631308758917684, + "CVC4": 7.1948307469135209, + "CVC3": 5.4779615724216368, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.430851844574397, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.589584552044203 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3248563433481999, + "veriT": 3.3827195366479996, + "Yices": 9.0589114812341833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.2499591781771002, + "CVC4": 1.7474082480851738, + "CVC3": 0.36499958332530003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6031242992929209, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8299504125672126 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9271535873413086, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1960686078208407, + "veriT": 4.0097302162681911, + "Yices": 7.9695254076208952, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3396127550409029, + "CVC4": 7.2271325690741355, + "CVC3": 3.1833463260018737, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3743736801598385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1436961925469165 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 21.0, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1614584922790527, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1401449820547, + "veriT": 0.12111989110500002, + "Yices": 0.13299247539850001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13737023157049999, + "CVC4": 0.15889205955500002, + "CVC3": 0.13423442459660001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15480492620159997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15065157039009999 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1540122942768333, + "veriT": 0.13138411825508334, + "Yices": 0.14935326009250002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14995505680941668, + "CVC4": 0.17522085557625, + "CVC3": 0.15211908176949998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16847005399250001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16740455475183333 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16934950390788886, + "veriT": 4.5419379478652404, + "Yices": 0.20702550680588891, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17218218642177777, + "CVC4": 0.19235341041244444, + "CVC3": 0.16562773233300002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17443524818422224, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17318387597588888 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4339075975461428, + "veriT": 2.1378858279988662, + "Yices": 0.13270704158771426, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.444341240609428, + "CVC4": 0.15951018794114288, + "CVC3": 0.48784505120300004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15025004924142854, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15348563107085714 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14536406103874999, + "veriT": 3.419732181998866, + "Yices": 4.0841268733397298, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17198124227836664, + "CVC4": 11.878203232231073, + "CVC3": 0.077574689010566675, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.23760959490468336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17842725159314998 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7970018811814334, + "veriT": 8.4321174167671504, + "Yices": 8.4866787048850174, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8051349575439504, + "CVC4": 1.7949271069240167, + "CVC3": 3.9035696157877502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6266157998976625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6670366397767 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 39.0, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5445916266367417, + "veriT": 9.0956444048133651, + "Yices": 5.3960240446356131, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6727700259147649, + "CVC4": 10.786689738397124, + "CVC3": 9.6112535460338666, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2050522987909673, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8863014861201934 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7500149053370326, + "veriT": 3.9973218030929463, + "Yices": 13.377728432310247, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8270098163213611, + "CVC4": 1.8587456169663534, + "CVC3": 1.762987326775824, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7464395797535555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9786099680306666 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2852639331147424, + "veriT": 0.15654776032477141, + "Yices": 1.7373724879556571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.2911888907039, + "CVC4": 14.298725592079839, + "CVC3": 0.23789582130157144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14682879745729999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14507795541512855 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9876854778790856, + "veriT": 14.26435922185504, + "Yices": 7.2354378988126715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.140922459164269, + "CVC4": 3.2218375196949629, + "CVC3": 2.6817992750788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6750551335742832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6734908534548165 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.415437109323658, + "veriT": 12.762395854402502, + "Yices": 7.7622533523341728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.106316593495775, + "CVC4": 14.329216985468101, + "CVC3": 7.7810866902786442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2836288917719045, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7654322758051899 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5828011098401333, + "veriT": 13.268280718641988, + "Yices": 2.1967101853602324, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3902669274605772, + "CVC4": 2.1780802486086399, + "CVC3": 0.39744623964606668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.069707209524786, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.084274699391141 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.34977282346062499, + "veriT": 12.190783969495712, + "Yices": 11.556391975741928, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6031150736757072, + "CVC4": 7.6806323655248372, + "CVC3": 9.5716814591201516, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.096240538037309, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.914257269270696 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23777078288362502, + "veriT": 6.8795607171816133, + "Yices": 7.7778768147563309, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.7442242180657499, + "CVC4": 8.9773761288156813, + "CVC3": 3.0265685214310989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6707299169440883, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6736680623747073 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8887745307161881, + "veriT": 11.507022209994242, + "Yices": 6.7523124799560028, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3408795127954454, + "CVC4": 7.3592159790798997, + "CVC3": 10.901684632591328, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6692904031349354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5214467105670391 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.845669781532557, + "veriT": 12.87317937176956, + "Yices": 8.3664995703178633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.858569908069889, + "CVC4": 5.2723401319619274, + "CVC3": 8.5592563385963061, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.245412447372107, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.620080470519682 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5234253416914998, + "veriT": 12.063599779370769, + "Yices": 5.4219016969383826, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7596618206440127, + "CVC4": 0.96408110274659997, + "CVC3": 1.983253726810716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9161808683264818, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9179088081348248 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 59.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.804277871607544, + "veriT": 11.156711988715745, + "Yices": 11.875470959288274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.351828338586811, + "CVC4": 14.672039628431195, + "CVC3": 13.568856830755681, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.242652099291766, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.465276687629096 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8747759975162288, + "veriT": 8.3663542647596199, + "Yices": 10.54438755602464, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.9962252611636675, + "CVC4": 10.755788562333217, + "CVC3": 4.097986549908728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2851080655654421, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2445400783317275 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 30.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6759259700775146, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2103544076940356, + "veriT": 11.042287188296202, + "Yices": 3.3704807174910099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7982765824875218, + "CVC4": 4.4354797989557584, + "CVC3": 3.6930987841309428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.98563767608039, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.002303796893342 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 200.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.273006542355409, + "veriT": 10.792704302759111, + "Yices": 10.604493669643, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.985757682184712, + "CVC4": 13.486306793229355, + "CVC3": 12.499807790393406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.265170490491128, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.269911357397095 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.272466596965202, + "veriT": 10.215095380326, + "Yices": 10.404214882259124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.996710859875632, + "CVC4": 14.302093117979911, + "CVC3": 14.271589607060362, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.272408266517539, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.423785831553655 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.533678707792632, + "veriT": 12.732799864576089, + "Yices": 11.433975150007127, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.093814161636404, + "CVC4": 14.774075935427591, + "CVC3": 13.728039092855253, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237911955539722, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.953839471407541 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5087361913826332, + "veriT": 13.193894397449988, + "Yices": 11.961615882882155, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2239935950227974, + "CVC4": 14.502831001788099, + "CVC3": 7.0775030957590284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228596097423807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.231270246735821 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.941104772590716, + "veriT": 11.399894899215431, + "Yices": 12.958631658366333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964050333927299, + "CVC4": 13.054610859706671, + "CVC3": 14.245619098997569, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228406613391357, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.852802944976087 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 59.0, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.28590423444407503, + "veriT": 2.6337512593164001, + "Yices": 7.9295602726714076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.118428961668835, + "CVC4": 5.6244051258966286, + "CVC3": 1.9883769934879554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9010777939392807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3498729628092638 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5291029478562033, + "veriT": 14.25816860028022, + "Yices": 5.5007393642401317, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.045427782983412, + "CVC4": 5.6785190714027136, + "CVC3": 3.3615838918786007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.005216689578909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0656923420582731 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.222900293948312, + "veriT": 13.535819354369707, + "Yices": 13.246661976535668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.949154494947075, + "CVC4": 14.317776236515181, + "CVC3": 14.220933182436184, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5499442067347147, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5445896582446306 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 212.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 145, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0537681579589844, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.6784395434692447, + "veriT": 12.900397763053576, + "Yices": 13.000489774208873, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.193694495002378, + "CVC4": 14.465970724645068, + "CVC3": 6.8035705558395927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.631118583999864, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0164433123603125 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2262584761145923, + "veriT": 10.189970797831155, + "Yices": 7.5430962824584942, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5898319744354623, + "CVC4": 7.4938623947804857, + "CVC3": 6.2546775100416845, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0040187887701064, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.007681746353815 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 154, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 153, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 149 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7877150994960189, + "veriT": 13.420186555682076, + "Yices": 14.234976422459315, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.99542886474228, + "CVC4": 11.847716274825405, + "CVC3": 12.728738337625487, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.209156854223469, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.106099719377701 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 181.5, + "true": 151 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247583150238651, + "veriT": 13.759504372934281, + "Yices": 13.959242384148389, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.143852266887968, + "CVC4": 14.348195864520653, + "CVC3": 13.033010779176003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.116040503696317, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.129935911639153 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.250129928568063, + "veriT": 11.403691323836796, + "Yices": 12.492802632771715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961773462425564, + "CVC4": 14.686119834122788, + "CVC3": 13.972476237080086, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.73018117786744, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.262400000862746 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6403796819311403, + "veriT": 11.405956354878878, + "Yices": 11.639226395126526, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4856311915064104, + "CVC4": 8.9752508626513325, + "CVC3": 10.70999555486501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.6187277966975397, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6208572631888281 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "false": 156, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 226.0, + "true": 155 + }, + { + "index": 155, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8066646794541796, + "veriT": 14.224989567614115, + "Yices": 13.396214916058307, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.630444736002371, + "CVC4": 11.200307004891044, + "CVC3": 13.094188434831848, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4654381213753125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4864563517681875 + }, + { + "index": 156, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.922174930970954, + "veriT": 12.931682745016149, + "Yices": 12.784967220959352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.978605878697053, + "CVC4": 14.519873034810038, + "CVC3": 12.522766161129331, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.350478672690658, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.310122728791308 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 42.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 4, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12376278823596001, + "veriT": 0.094725929230304012, + "Yices": 0.098142452925039994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12136953970228002, + "CVC4": 0.12521715219876001, + "CVC3": 0.101215333263384, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12050200601244, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11928905089736 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10900419108898574, + "veriT": 0.081990776050604772, + "Yices": 0.085529541515180968, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.10784146586416668, + "CVC4": 0.10535070491070953, + "CVC3": 0.086410737787323805, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10447613737018094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10360529728620002 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 6 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8755690252710426, + "veriT": 12.137800199308513, + "Yices": 11.98464227698657, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.04712537738834, + "CVC4": 12.264725436504525, + "CVC3": 9.6335604882251307, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.417790956027853, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.535895011439122 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 13, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5840165646133655, + "veriT": 6.7638596689173482, + "Yices": 8.8223295090889771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6507124493928202, + "CVC4": 6.0788595541498749, + "CVC3": 6.3904388647798713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7748141029933642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2159395330937759 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.0926403368500175, + "veriT": 3.5043081587534535, + "Yices": 3.229514278202569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4822086964131933, + "CVC4": 1.2895153324934343, + "CVC3": 1.4369546765811689, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2068582145476172, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7539091568070715 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2217210814438557, + "veriT": 5.8131122498920007, + "Yices": 8.5498283339376258, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4933085189794522, + "CVC4": 0.16990307683387498, + "CVC3": 5.9430688982533892, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.9860795294201385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.002311473690567 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.180090533328709, + "veriT": 9.7091761544952568, + "Yices": 10.396679617401524, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.816220043828627, + "CVC4": 3.369145405037334, + "CVC3": 12.299478171996002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.118281676935597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.981166354622827 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.428484552487902, + "veriT": 10.975698113726267, + "Yices": 10.6180242612927, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.994782400850269, + "CVC4": 3.1238114119073286, + "CVC3": 10.930111822586037, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3055583259243893, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.844805502402295 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.235953674319607, + "veriT": 10.166270425510126, + "Yices": 10.278624841841999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954705732631872, + "CVC4": 3.6810039706522408, + "CVC3": 12.427383746604155, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6108297573787445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6463007471427229 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6028145958240287, + "veriT": 10.419754166717713, + "Yices": 6.9782342390154488, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7832238308776134, + "CVC4": 0.21562642252037501, + "CVC3": 5.6365256547903861, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.8077565067831962, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9888801037286914 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0909811582296731, + "veriT": 8.1551276814282883, + "Yices": 7.8996381042272734, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3485994784166726, + "CVC4": 5.4403137363694674, + "CVC3": 7.092367772144172, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.60019436813878, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1080583848906933 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.225156934955846, + "veriT": 14.230072571976557, + "Yices": 13.158492420378584, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.751297877711993, + "CVC4": 14.870232197752378, + "CVC3": 13.569112097251063, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.750390588679949, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.749308359237149 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1714286804199219, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9370946036634162, + "veriT": 12.449373742999926, + "Yices": 8.2523102374373671, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.781321272371075, + "CVC4": 11.047502334522665, + "CVC3": 9.7782222710720781, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.481612575564229, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.482524613751604 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5571432113647461, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1384814106687, + "veriT": 4.3167355589662755, + "Yices": 5.8697805603243047, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.89047192653147, + "CVC4": 3.9662545915370773, + "CVC3": 1.2593320537991199, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9472070639260299, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9440313185469349 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8867854961799524, + "veriT": 7.1106600361904944, + "Yices": 9.2501490581855172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7918005285910139, + "CVC4": 13.582882396707868, + "CVC3": 8.6314814245507154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9679531173694844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9761867899343075 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21336268687080664, + "veriT": 9.058614392550238, + "Yices": 4.7271963350578687, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.27303345635246667, + "CVC4": 0.17250543441466665, + "CVC3": 0.93123711270125986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0979574104966301, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.9116719117358709 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.222738093217449, + "veriT": 11.506371541412278, + "Yices": 9.283568332602135, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.746668567113744, + "CVC4": 2.5156217113889148, + "CVC3": 13.88933383543233, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.2526066867275683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4012921433208039 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241870029869599, + "veriT": 10.160791676192002, + "Yices": 10.331095288568141, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959697825929092, + "CVC4": 0.26864058148028569, + "CVC3": 13.658623496696762, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.625462553553096, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.323781188590582 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6632019543163197, + "veriT": 5.6615212090255334, + "Yices": 6.4326032955447419, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8472184387385471, + "CVC4": 0.57154959334416666, + "CVC3": 8.2058842283230078, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.40007674391758336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3317521996149764 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4736627954795454, + "veriT": 9.0837463135993648, + "Yices": 7.2416554556732837, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5147277899961082, + "CVC4": 6.0450905398483545, + "CVC3": 5.6880133705847218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.305554923003861, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.983630612768073 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.615182614823008, + "veriT": 13.402241647877204, + "Yices": 8.3461849578278606, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.768158887009685, + "CVC4": 11.806738324516711, + "CVC3": 14.373846753785816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.432963156591642, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.230274810201449 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2003110743300813, + "veriT": 6.1451162910640678, + "Yices": 11.069655011710847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.368206721173701, + "CVC4": 2.6311908853854189, + "CVC3": 2.4258983761885409, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1700717796525693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1683922769650765 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 16.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14426283106980001, + "veriT": 11.381822499407116, + "Yices": 0.1062865492504, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.2218836602334, + "CVC4": 3.1091943756169673, + "CVC3": 0.11904327952180001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7677288049974234, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7655014329011918 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13521211725366666, + "veriT": 14.213463388693897, + "Yices": 0.27734942026466669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18972253503533332, + "CVC4": 0.17945882481916664, + "CVC3": 0.13264857965899998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.09892262408613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.089241383326845 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9689278251248612, + "veriT": 13.584753327502826, + "Yices": 7.5901810931846301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.2995229649680233, + "CVC4": 6.029728764238194, + "CVC3": 7.3129640700641811, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2745714012146685, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7413552142656155 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.3999999761581421, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.89421292889474746, + "veriT": 10.163438314302583, + "Yices": 10.349575255612173, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.97911645183253293, + "CVC4": 0.14926196208048775, + "CVC3": 0.69819735170078034, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14915122191078048, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.429799605251683 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20030576247522222, + "veriT": 10.166638579439443, + "Yices": 10.344931190956222, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.37713073730433333, + "CVC4": 0.15330648760933333, + "CVC3": 0.30364342016377777, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15058568429977778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.1288049814168892 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7551364898681641, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.701158242285683, + "veriT": 7.4065716785253297, + "Yices": 3.9452314537197499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.957203823651579, + "CVC4": 0.14071431501600001, + "CVC3": 4.2934714017289002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13748642012587503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3791253682922928 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.958936652043615, + "veriT": 9.3989508366120198, + "Yices": 7.8007253105556256, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.505748979626214, + "CVC4": 0.14692969856487501, + "CVC3": 10.724075826834254, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13759613185950001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5480128201688146 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.030057973767521, + "veriT": 12.171605278879614, + "Yices": 6.2091514074235779, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.405295606694201, + "CVC4": 7.427706171734366, + "CVC3": 8.5899329456714497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.599029577240076, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5926726538143328 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9095674213908396, + "veriT": 12.522624644424683, + "Yices": 10.354620658773355, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.309985551671863, + "CVC4": 13.039878026374291, + "CVC3": 11.958995424509643, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225938315798279, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.970389963856606 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13219353480450002, + "veriT": 0.10202996901196, + "Yices": 2.1376231049937999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12346968613742, + "CVC4": 2.9516112011641829, + "CVC3": 0.12584573821616002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9427046291771841, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12379354232018 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4132765043874018, + "veriT": 10.102631250734527, + "Yices": 6.4697493209602728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4868756778230441, + "CVC4": 5.2719489866645262, + "CVC3": 1.4045512280914625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.410301467642411, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4142395412555595 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6995257785071747, + "veriT": 6.6234521678100631, + "Yices": 6.7283847237916268, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9156966173234307, + "CVC4": 0.35384187061563632, + "CVC3": 0.15623703991415458, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3525218451661578, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4186868643131616 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6338318792022499, + "veriT": 6.9195876778181304, + "Yices": 9.4830978885325514, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7689471737416045, + "CVC4": 11.101169199040777, + "CVC3": 3.2174878739862898, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.715068167158178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.018858314949213 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9192061157840106, + "veriT": 2.8083730702586251, + "Yices": 7.9106209461603463, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.74488455056012504, + "CVC4": 0.15705412566937502, + "CVC3": 0.18397709149962499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9094455092738194, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9094308728177496 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.05718994140625, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1529754782963328, + "veriT": 10.544846367579757, + "Yices": 10.227465945597555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.355820152254525, + "CVC4": 7.2557343862218699, + "CVC3": 3.4061711925765659, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.651746146496908, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.6501539362994 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8766518970602721, + "veriT": 4.4901065695344542, + "Yices": 11.429181106523915, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1509225352968269, + "CVC4": 10.497121420144966, + "CVC3": 6.5676210104384953, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.986260398692876, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.982630805037553 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12726709259124999, + "veriT": 7.7718640030011352, + "Yices": 5.1018934906186244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15038044461912503, + "CVC4": 2.6290541671897509, + "CVC3": 3.05052444931425, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6275155039562503, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6189054407822496 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.472801664650591, + "veriT": 9.6204144833608076, + "Yices": 9.3885331281102999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8308851349684447, + "CVC4": 12.301361445678131, + "CVC3": 6.8484438898935602, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.2378213382965, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4896979663437886 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0045461200053751, + "veriT": 5.5209831123176309, + "Yices": 6.3302961735759711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7607977424919072, + "CVC4": 4.8816514744872412, + "CVC3": 2.6985444254228335, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1695955535651, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16963604987735836 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18251214230799997, + "veriT": 13.537357547151231, + "Yices": 7.3885902808020711, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.55764614298300008, + "CVC4": 0.85044649782850001, + "CVC3": 7.2037104604969704, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1978122251239336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1948107188566892 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.792859795204704, + "veriT": 7.0163857342415969, + "Yices": 6.4573402929733801, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.083995486453805, + "CVC4": 5.9973382230156416, + "CVC3": 0.33079048138700007, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9907027811974403, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6137745570832074 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.6728058292492104, + "veriT": 0.12656451384978945, + "Yices": 0.13951767273915791, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.67041675616305263, + "CVC4": 0.16357792485710526, + "CVC3": 0.14430356580084211, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15594596885605264, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15660205112889472 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15675363402377776, + "veriT": 6.4017701599789154, + "Yices": 0.16486142420644445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16537240904933334, + "CVC4": 0.18352800367644445, + "CVC3": 0.15730695483222223, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17145521048744444, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16612456336655557 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 82.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1564884199432401, + "veriT": 6.4267700801085867, + "Yices": 4.4170232867004717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.2731395710068192, + "CVC4": 0.18908108324571429, + "CVC3": 4.1794984414704475, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16322107836505714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16390565403052856 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.27610617788087499, + "veriT": 2.0049006216278831, + "Yices": 12.510024386696479, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.71352220561699997, + "CVC4": 0.24730752125487498, + "CVC3": 2.3107999346908574, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.992506499040928, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9901003314175234 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1064753532409668, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8776185419374909, + "veriT": 1.0347267924823729, + "Yices": 1.0345976334616274, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9117352259572638, + "CVC4": 6.6261579336815091, + "CVC3": 0.13426933196881816, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18638211768147273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18338210881807274 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7316731982484734, + "veriT": 8.1280121217008929, + "Yices": 10.716013499441715, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6478375494708084, + "CVC4": 10.246966236804694, + "CVC3": 8.4411002967484325, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5853905182812316, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5842514159296002 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 70.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 152.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3206078009693165, + "veriT": 12.369230374065843, + "Yices": 12.490621627615853, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9939326927802767, + "CVC4": 13.2663380230337, + "CVC3": 12.893745127404406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240492972621139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.977078500160918 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2832541023876001, + "veriT": 8.9812154324629798, + "Yices": 6.6289694023241994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6170347498970798, + "CVC4": 8.7297500119264093, + "CVC3": 1.8295408816410004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.0858159774164236, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.4827139515238175 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249454040648029, + "veriT": 10.986130021564788, + "Yices": 11.099853494335257, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964695685420129, + "CVC4": 10.720025377736631, + "CVC3": 12.89955489778168, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.088576465993913, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.614200405734696 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 21.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4152361536803335, + "veriT": 4.988031702245447, + "Yices": 4.7124476690470605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3241735205881113, + "CVC4": 8.0086721214882122, + "CVC3": 0.13667978294055555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19344068909455553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1706927696311111 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9347534044633843, + "veriT": 10.509642373318787, + "Yices": 7.1740750678402954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.3058093135714142, + "CVC4": 7.2233365862195242, + "CVC3": 7.1180346452473104, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.2484093212955543, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.243031149313599 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0020481627572981, + "veriT": 13.449430560359819, + "Yices": 6.9874405451261792, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.1097336910104545, + "CVC4": 9.2905160049708648, + "CVC3": 2.7084160722537134, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.223388880006402, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.153842898367254 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 52.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9945408405108274, + "veriT": 11.219416048422792, + "Yices": 9.5584110608948603, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.894408784501422, + "CVC4": 5.109053601795396, + "CVC3": 6.8114322214446554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.615833533672548, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.921360255610198 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9848027056497355, + "veriT": 12.635429397700086, + "Yices": 8.6545401000878641, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8163788924009232, + "CVC4": 0.30443225473011115, + "CVC3": 2.8899069744957782, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0962806945689363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0859657042836339 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9676968008059221, + "veriT": 11.787565459624291, + "Yices": 11.548604046579271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.242101108447409, + "CVC4": 10.239997856402743, + "CVC3": 12.126179503208753, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.398609275187418, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.024833668059513 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 74.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6671065092086792, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.2221325788255242, + "veriT": 7.5974061093111516, + "Yices": 3.610888545257724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.73438731274981, + "CVC4": 4.3500534656137111, + "CVC3": 4.3048229162734684, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.655489903100145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.688422994346464 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0152225494384766, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.654931273503863, + "veriT": 12.496880247223794, + "Yices": 13.595498128329051, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960510006538863, + "CVC4": 14.572216079334316, + "CVC3": 12.522260118865455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240971147499719, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.248087916973992 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.24585203350281, + "veriT": 10.713084453143122, + "Yices": 10.391639902205839, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968378138191223, + "CVC4": 14.386566557467034, + "CVC3": 14.242698027353986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253052637806276, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.191428314254514 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.294176061597044, + "veriT": 10.765711834432315, + "Yices": 10.9467669010089, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.003336425034192, + "CVC4": 14.437806061416024, + "CVC3": 12.602541149775645, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.29324970861412, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9984578779921378 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.992279053313136, + "veriT": 14.234265817906149, + "Yices": 13.266892802016571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.822459662109056, + "CVC4": 14.484045878778547, + "CVC3": 12.23955487473655, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.250581608511807, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.248620957144892 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.333147756663678, + "veriT": 14.236413166585455, + "Yices": 14.234066982493301, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.414433776246723, + "CVC4": 14.614357575729141, + "CVC3": 14.251533989278899, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.977126198100038, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.001215490306164 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8797645809870547, + "veriT": 13.717037473412542, + "Yices": 13.723025956485216, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5983218574669307, + "CVC4": 12.734365010688913, + "CVC3": 12.389819866543993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.493981965524739, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.49062584078105 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1377701759338379, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.699687541385499, + "veriT": 8.3957430452780049, + "Yices": 7.3221308463472186, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.3809601494783541, + "CVC4": 7.3395524694801644, + "CVC3": 2.828592865032558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.3605964436223306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.337519088768667 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9602173504671976, + "veriT": 13.469408572821173, + "Yices": 12.605401884956954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.564124820111612, + "CVC4": 12.606432451658886, + "CVC3": 15.039749106503685, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4023694661452399, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3632618239629526 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 43.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.52348334907837, + "veriT": 12.729591728178963, + "Yices": 11.930917566696072, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.705060807106035, + "CVC4": 14.377528055126609, + "CVC3": 11.839478573525305, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.470740850919297, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.293427671603698 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 139 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.252124074400975, + "veriT": 10.75668836507178, + "Yices": 13.25000267849931, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.969087009286364, + "CVC4": 14.479703193316482, + "CVC3": 13.228845260652596, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.045944002047202, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.903274759849685 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.097655219382041, + "veriT": 14.237917415729397, + "Yices": 14.10665843812493, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96535918949413, + "CVC4": 14.369682449815942, + "CVC3": 12.018081454380489, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.253531441047871, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.258261313288676 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2808387494145403, + "veriT": 9.7819397662911118, + "Yices": 14.240200525762406, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.973641616758723, + "CVC4": 14.493485813581362, + "CVC3": 13.572764811706866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6864891492051477, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.184945039347289 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5446638438720521, + "veriT": 11.258163333771488, + "Yices": 5.4562199204202368, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1407591384256852, + "CVC4": 1.8252758789184427, + "CVC3": 1.8835396300031804, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7063280962331131, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6965804948303524 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.770675728887582, + "veriT": 13.070898666650928, + "Yices": 11.102397530372842, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.282446983977954, + "CVC4": 12.694988767545439, + "CVC3": 13.289904299800506, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4373520877755812, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7582851263284702 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8266128942164741, + "veriT": 13.670836993510074, + "Yices": 14.29798010862261, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5590874290565377, + "CVC4": 14.485958921765084, + "CVC3": 11.764064550170767, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.4957021438370544, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.3163449873218727 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.1666665077209473, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1418686823984, + "veriT": 1.2554162970989728, + "Yices": 2.0406344475572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15838587891124228, + "CVC4": 1.7574857190881681, + "CVC3": 0.10793580385203461, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7486342983398906, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7626965065862688 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7804892915213502, + "veriT": 0.08459819930250001, + "Yices": 0.087262350056222224, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7800452854812054, + "CVC4": 0.11232763069551667, + "CVC3": 0.091510312346827771, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11039694872143888, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10911240364842779 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 7 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.8092832882746945, + "veriT": 8.3509103686154287, + "Yices": 8.4362520534030701, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0934483470242258, + "CVC4": 4.5903346886023364, + "CVC3": 7.2891703732477264, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3658581361224185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4342017840448076 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20678724786963631, + "veriT": 9.9378200551690199, + "Yices": 10.11877704305043, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.28241728803970462, + "CVC4": 0.15047438209988634, + "CVC3": 0.63591836716959105, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14822717926772724, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.313711675536398 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9736778408705664, + "veriT": 12.858751051486314, + "Yices": 11.627565446672627, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.1162182271050458, + "CVC4": 10.935483222797194, + "CVC3": 10.356401902140226, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.378719278592285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.409991868636922 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8186466100582419, + "veriT": 5.1278492243404941, + "Yices": 5.813276247276562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7678138266827501, + "CVC4": 2.8012177197850354, + "CVC3": 3.5284585527282308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2473690996736586, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2867747018187057 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.922370677771598, + "veriT": 10.374827480601448, + "Yices": 10.34115957945558, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.555495775143614, + "CVC4": 3.1225790511899638, + "CVC3": 10.62216178862421, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7582221348326001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.240648007042523 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.975176801485862, + "veriT": 9.2546394402436363, + "Yices": 10.334170492350818, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.631318172291868, + "CVC4": 0.17144888515336362, + "CVC3": 12.279469162400868, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9320453024275661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.295480336330213 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4883488534800557, + "veriT": 6.7993954366919995, + "Yices": 10.352924486815331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.008244247666161, + "CVC4": 2.9666294422593342, + "CVC3": 9.5251736823696227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.5479529334482116, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5932372045293386 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 12.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.093012625081542, + "veriT": 10.636076892625923, + "Yices": 10.49597049114918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.387851286241682, + "CVC4": 1.9218505984686056, + "CVC3": 10.466692572969356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.447495514322982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.942577527531519 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0187727180975017, + "veriT": 11.175410202902819, + "Yices": 10.748367968946612, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.629493653872458, + "CVC4": 3.8746346757180512, + "CVC3": 5.0803423906731755, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.6336583192784886, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.762191495248409 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243163662451062, + "veriT": 10.152687043552069, + "Yices": 10.336495624301287, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96113831969123, + "CVC4": 0.1558011949385, + "CVC3": 11.323581150888909, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.96269539868989162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.364734711987946 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240145541046425, + "veriT": 10.1540281667146, + "Yices": 10.3383458655677, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.967031616641099, + "CVC4": 0.15503738013749996, + "CVC3": 14.245606408458446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14535953031029997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.336744762523754 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15503292181448888, + "veriT": 7.6963900746850253, + "Yices": 8.4219551596848543, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22338607944122224, + "CVC4": 4.8431464149717032, + "CVC3": 3.3040276408592906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1859670945695111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.674414983021892 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "float", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8074732054742082, + "veriT": 5.6718620565549731, + "Yices": 4.7893199017711217, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2993874485901227, + "CVC4": 5.4482536547487319, + "CVC3": 4.250817752745502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1471063647323234, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1465057921804709 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0348480594347871, + "veriT": 2.4882370238293361, + "Yices": 3.7298171650067706, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0718596417907631, + "CVC4": 2.5333631259500073, + "CVC3": 2.0283273543326064, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4847312901880874, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.93544606852388212 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8491756940049502, + "veriT": 11.856697328891633, + "Yices": 11.268580502982307, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8452627391734691, + "CVC4": 10.98153501518572, + "CVC3": 10.095956561266481, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8657831303224146, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8544920513679894 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9237980601535343, + "veriT": 5.8567815117889666, + "Yices": 6.6134173813932939, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6297859470791636, + "CVC4": 2.6407187018686282, + "CVC3": 1.5126992327026489, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.829496215674105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.704303532107911 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1489655115795, + "veriT": 1.875314190291125, + "Yices": 9.8122199190632724, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.156743166583375, + "CVC4": 10.773823669444226, + "CVC3": 9.7466908414038009, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7793892143537502, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8008591543754999 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 48, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.71310808129043, + "veriT": 12.319746931719235, + "Yices": 12.980479553963072, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.852141032201585, + "CVC4": 7.424121971836839, + "CVC3": 11.537609764054194, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.9636884399384522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.8305839417803877 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8358180369478332, + "veriT": 7.4831390337036412, + "Yices": 9.2077908528100014, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.8185493174065004, + "CVC4": 4.8721173129042095, + "CVC3": 4.8602939454842318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5167075551074376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0649273903719614 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.037797741109072, + "veriT": 11.457604741338669, + "Yices": 11.508787128808018, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.681970575552022, + "CVC4": 1.5122005007364325, + "CVC3": 14.095309796999789, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3657262914244921, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.224705527663192 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7855984103969131, + "veriT": 11.294285572686112, + "Yices": 10.694773383573395, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.717649757958014, + "CVC4": 10.881929117544779, + "CVC3": 12.294809169936336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.3851337785539641, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1196874063155278 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.740484758343557, + "veriT": 14.197631288178018, + "Yices": 11.060945654858596, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.559571840383777, + "CVC4": 14.429049756472548, + "CVC3": 11.993911364179787, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.207999015178313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.208142126015524 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0956069279564282, + "veriT": 11.401754559908444, + "Yices": 11.407980415693221, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4787514883131632, + "CVC4": 11.753007655913814, + "CVC3": 9.0326309516621581, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.397920355911104, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.452255826827271 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3838177945281398, + "veriT": 10.107853458594485, + "Yices": 10.108856324244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.760644125957386, + "CVC4": 5.0262776010578749, + "CVC3": 3.3070222284111428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231769610173981, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.227243336972721 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7546432569351251, + "veriT": 7.4132445590961105, + "Yices": 4.7562495034506176, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6726923135750553, + "CVC4": 2.7461105954626652, + "CVC3": 4.1749440818110521, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.7314090106536142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2471569388399795 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.686548228782673, + "veriT": 5.2568660583666169, + "Yices": 9.2141100903024231, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9898870208161079, + "CVC4": 0.20667822658099996, + "CVC3": 3.689202852691249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9873519864967211, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1090238789178564 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19897410328738463, + "veriT": 3.3375452440273845, + "Yices": 4.2012218195543056, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25271134588870769, + "CVC4": 1.2850276419215516, + "CVC3": 0.18776672444184614, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19345960725570002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19089787246300002 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9528965799020233, + "veriT": 7.0266439458842687, + "Yices": 7.8707043703598307, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8879238814933252, + "CVC4": 0.36736695183127277, + "CVC3": 5.9535547678454881, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17271822075836363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.2989711258620265 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8244950771331787, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3122313422596834, + "veriT": 3.5057081539024111, + "Yices": 5.8256151645006664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4673637635743226, + "CVC4": 4.882650655769762, + "CVC3": 3.3336417290986198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4285992742114173, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9161094623332122 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.200814547465065, + "veriT": 10.19966861396945, + "Yices": 11.125987106441746, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.568204763477386, + "CVC4": 13.408245504353575, + "CVC3": 9.7360705867309356, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234182249594383, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.546153720307242 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3864819897010001, + "veriT": 11.003142560016693, + "Yices": 6.3142718019798005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4984537184556999, + "CVC4": 11.640332433858681, + "CVC3": 2.8112573925815996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.486581758798261, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.708180905020885 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.456537382845186, + "veriT": 10.934111403367137, + "Yices": 11.744512484672555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.910122168213134, + "CVC4": 12.583867192173585, + "CVC3": 11.872963524117687, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.64050723610802, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.604061789980477 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.6195612136071293, + "veriT": 5.2792048928572717, + "Yices": 7.5516863247144723, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2393752418987045, + "CVC4": 8.8321456917416548, + "CVC3": 1.3216900409936001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.9804147212587093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1284379893017915 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 34.0, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8215411231837497, + "veriT": 13.191679504887407, + "Yices": 3.6536634688994658, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3464077474893914, + "CVC4": 3.9370477801145785, + "CVC3": 2.9908191622387057, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.575180682641613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7098410882343629 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5661259102248573, + "veriT": 12.20307987471935, + "Yices": 1.9899012693643774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6009678967724283, + "CVC4": 2.2741732799328287, + "CVC3": 2.1471509054281888, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9775472611089775, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9804935132198977 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3692355844243611, + "veriT": 14.220967469435976, + "Yices": 12.815172368182859, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6260785226136152, + "CVC4": 8.068009050406447, + "CVC3": 13.045618418283198, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.228717408505522, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230426870353442 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0847170869876432, + "veriT": 12.388728277472058, + "Yices": 6.3347720840284456, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3264093149833798, + "CVC4": 3.3598595975012095, + "CVC3": 6.176288000424889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6978734079661617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5919321917030995 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2003596450686, + "veriT": 13.65266833222389, + "Yices": 1.4344446568990668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.290907009533333, + "CVC4": 0.13839435422260002, + "CVC3": 0.10793373239046668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13362322475753333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12372769518639999 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7832040786743164, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1324965505697921, + "veriT": 10.165319450108223, + "Yices": 12.09723323115049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2795646794624442, + "CVC4": 14.293112522027782, + "CVC3": 13.085292159190114, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.255211295356098, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.616644940775833 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1834675554210055, + "veriT": 4.6493124045137142, + "Yices": 5.4470664734569123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7999301132058561, + "CVC4": 5.2452174095123141, + "CVC3": 6.1850603669836053, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5754476834484095, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.1787900191627037 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 16.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1595433235781001, + "veriT": 1.5637062971519107, + "Yices": 3.172507974713803, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1858856560757003, + "CVC4": 0.1776887687132, + "CVC3": 0.15374547773180999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16476365778444002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16121924384347003 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.52749363207385713, + "veriT": 2.1883393382702891, + "Yices": 10.554642528945166, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1263743344532857, + "CVC4": 2.2458941645468302, + "CVC3": 1.6332655200782857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22119012620885717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.21962470500242856 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.141244872267, + "veriT": 0.11980155092799998, + "Yices": 0.13419824614918183, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1372652745983636, + "CVC4": 0.15878112848863635, + "CVC3": 0.13534302034190906, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15565578226418178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15502978018254543 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4132731405539998, + "veriT": 0.1409208548025, + "Yices": 0.14765386712075002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4170081859554999, + "CVC4": 0.17897393768062503, + "CVC3": 0.16427450528074999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16824916778537499, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16840217750287501 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15025527040216666, + "veriT": 4.7148331358454145, + "Yices": 0.14398307815949998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17309224694100001, + "CVC4": 0.16908657011583336, + "CVC3": 0.55724773588900001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15799754619749998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15979910165916666 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0860509872436523, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4625310012618007, + "veriT": 5.8643013705931102, + "Yices": 1.3957853385087429, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4726827342674644, + "CVC4": 9.2676411888745029, + "CVC3": 1.1470509842324019, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1329389188762735, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1311901261781285 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5918397983484684, + "veriT": 9.9435851311941708, + "Yices": 10.519907385853795, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0611137962722701, + "CVC4": 6.4284401499456392, + "CVC3": 5.870186079495701, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.44463109677579993, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.44411400809320006 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16612199948109091, + "veriT": 4.6734555448290456, + "Yices": 7.0445512655146363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.24808318278854546, + "CVC4": 13.185138324687603, + "CVC3": 7.5544995856944981, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3679599481586475, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4178004705614242 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243070617012373, + "veriT": 11.882847597053772, + "Yices": 10.812979428168388, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.959763110275862, + "CVC4": 14.661293805104439, + "CVC3": 10.711087203294564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.423513477833248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.755403336677508 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 108, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 65.0, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.255821258991187, + "veriT": 10.776326582262397, + "Yices": 10.579200777472284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.986940048502015, + "CVC4": 13.475938600272032, + "CVC3": 14.263186469191558, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252876761343286, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.04717262216516 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.265788618181343, + "veriT": 10.192957204120331, + "Yices": 10.378551338855667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.981911885944974, + "CVC4": 14.280309941133668, + "CVC3": 12.884022487905627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257672367291093, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.466447775479377 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5977325360306462, + "veriT": 11.951396548161542, + "Yices": 13.378033339639162, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.329087515703785, + "CVC4": 10.158023610676116, + "CVC3": 10.969109868310555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.113495144662355, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.110677190335467 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3010897375112194, + "veriT": 14.217598875783111, + "Yices": 4.4268204565294331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8462565389346683, + "CVC4": 5.101211159545608, + "CVC3": 1.745722143145972, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.116791240874141, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.133234445643327 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 25.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0953466633602347, + "veriT": 7.638598892136681, + "Yices": 1.3023058595624881, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4024507683896146, + "CVC4": 1.095079245593517, + "CVC3": 2.8925912633393049, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14787814599045335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14671692832380667 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 40.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.025451800453499, + "veriT": 11.904430393541986, + "Yices": 11.713037176493629, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.291146377046797, + "CVC4": 7.2789649156233773, + "CVC3": 6.5163341389173626, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.228717262114486, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7852970652897415 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.50864454158188876, + "veriT": 12.876845456180682, + "Yices": 3.5791857963934439, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.914236161395003, + "CVC4": 2.6849354410972222, + "CVC3": 0.25816288534033333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2201805005742248, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2724705277200945 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 153.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.104573890182438, + "veriT": 13.299529339057818, + "Yices": 13.141157370434918, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.539274065903616, + "CVC4": 7.7312693041901035, + "CVC3": 8.1876559916189766, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.97683988353976, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.025989758006808 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0430857640914422, + "veriT": 7.4943180553581099, + "Yices": 4.002568946218819, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.1441518368632684, + "CVC4": 4.6959034472397123, + "CVC3": 7.3724700215359533, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.21012241293059999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.4331040062944242 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5244705563288621, + "veriT": 14.214575635948361, + "Yices": 8.7345390034299442, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.60840729639863, + "CVC4": 9.2025431210581239, + "CVC3": 14.218570423863923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4160854963525722, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4149212474378707 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7623086756898712, + "veriT": 12.774195849840179, + "Yices": 12.807593765217087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.093690623395513, + "CVC4": 11.341540920214619, + "CVC3": 14.267344634815503, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5364393104259388, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4484677930764898 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.82586632183855, + "veriT": 13.13491442481167, + "Yices": 12.86092710565204, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.311968475977823, + "CVC4": 14.483223686034462, + "CVC3": 12.797119900491134, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.850375825947122, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.364146757156483 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.269993912694133, + "veriT": 11.069922402304858, + "Yices": 12.287391263317447, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6685313659881391, + "CVC4": 6.4544036092525854, + "CVC3": 11.595037772166751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238360586236512, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.151019984721239 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 45.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.641593979072898, + "veriT": 12.186097590485284, + "Yices": 13.014463059464699, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.955667738497013, + "CVC4": 14.841622436915008, + "CVC3": 10.60323726876029, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.999034760953043, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.175324552911668 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.251236456653009, + "veriT": 11.628020456103114, + "Yices": 14.089552134316719, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965011843982547, + "CVC4": 14.523214440522958, + "CVC3": 14.094808488413689, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.618086964494125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.644012185639687 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.850221741348252, + "veriT": 13.364824335861037, + "Yices": 14.255934246691092, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98012263472704, + "CVC4": 14.4334825913682, + "CVC3": 8.5069370835637397, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8909368682900363, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.566597499808676 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.01641706771542, + "veriT": 12.903305213446568, + "Yices": 13.347750030336799, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.997421820018587, + "CVC4": 14.651513385399069, + "CVC3": 12.83482600325201, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.260696830482996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.937150415615875 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.2720305101686931, + "veriT": 13.776894076074122, + "Yices": 13.722427868293243, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4325155313643787, + "CVC4": 13.125528694675619, + "CVC3": 15.371770594922953, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.540721575362001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.177032129416196 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 0.875, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12909445297103847, + "veriT": 0.099630876264596172, + "Yices": 0.10230913043477693, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12627632696773078, + "CVC4": 0.12605104704346154, + "CVC3": 0.10659557516078846, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12393659273530769, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12310283023690002 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11277035485642915, + "veriT": 0.084288405205124997, + "Yices": 0.09003074582028335, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11302480354480833, + "CVC4": 0.11042102340077915, + "CVC3": 0.091844460659358321, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.10744463073633331, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.10673686294810415 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8972186050924158, + "veriT": 1.6134562674782349, + "Yices": 2.2661713397411121, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9350501289018247, + "CVC4": 1.065524152718466, + "CVC3": 1.8804469319077728, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0155310917704832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9078134785744503 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 9, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7156661366722772, + "veriT": 10.165770319602105, + "Yices": 10.354469174557071, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8860137688807446, + "CVC4": 0.14823178941792858, + "CVC3": 0.71832398925510699, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15036278593696425, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.434585503195496 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18003113465615386, + "veriT": 7.0700301967326924, + "Yices": 8.0814995369063087, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34292275182238457, + "CVC4": 0.1535418994813077, + "CVC3": 0.24706998332869232, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14874756682707693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.4558631346919366 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.080130839555489, + "veriT": 13.710912208259261, + "Yices": 12.586355991338827, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.760046221492836, + "CVC4": 14.027863356071752, + "CVC3": 11.176044035944699, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.088011041143677, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.143436753925904 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8042160146097785, + "veriT": 7.9339130574652001, + "Yices": 8.0496462302079994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.660945963333374, + "CVC4": 1.3478604997812225, + "CVC3": 7.5361320699627372, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3915466796951961, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.7418813357724012 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.356184934586464, + "veriT": 10.879863010848037, + "Yices": 10.78791132681771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.916935205768663, + "CVC4": 11.089909234881235, + "CVC3": 11.954913128204584, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5922271916088651, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9158890541244302 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.239850439069812, + "veriT": 10.172673147353951, + "Yices": 10.328041173368899, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.956848327349203, + "CVC4": 0.16386952525915, + "CVC3": 13.344850268298535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7850706534532765, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.26861013712001 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.725280778316041, + "veriT": 10.676361099251855, + "Yices": 10.48557185732475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.344209657161283, + "CVC4": 2.1022882688548306, + "CVC3": 12.362514230939952, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6500173781756837, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.494156106742874 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3117424829875883, + "veriT": 9.2511786788187269, + "Yices": 10.310723450873001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.601016571922084, + "CVC4": 0.15855462575554546, + "CVC3": 5.7556697002425929, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17143108962045453, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.018020193623549 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5363553532757983, + "veriT": 8.11382731300138, + "Yices": 9.2200479960944488, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.048667949666422, + "CVC4": 0.41259917680320007, + "CVC3": 3.1188032301683455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5244491478886193, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8173350539337108 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.5571432113647461, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 30 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1714286804199219, + "true": 31 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9375, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.0517578899980045, + "veriT": 8.1627828700881153, + "Yices": 6.9586144494517139, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7383411820902221, + "CVC4": 8.2585878203110124, + "CVC3": 5.0568193643131529, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4341031254056631, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.8879319387856901 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0055454148937848, + "veriT": 11.425647415225033, + "Yices": 7.0719274803758854, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.094141752597153, + "CVC4": 8.9215268748522814, + "CVC3": 9.8218731428112243, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.429500770702912, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.427973521479547 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5195865719426411, + "veriT": 6.6212117920721703, + "Yices": 5.874306832580344, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.837083982612973, + "CVC4": 2.8705250636439117, + "CVC3": 3.181711483658471, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7327543779163512, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4675963938758247 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5896532476033567, + "veriT": 1.1040773270372071, + "Yices": 4.1230701869255562, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7077619604411569, + "CVC4": 1.1331319085888532, + "CVC3": 1.1153298754696641, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11945352447675714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11872800808579285 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8544111865342714, + "veriT": 7.5944019727526388, + "Yices": 12.787938818127522, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9620863538050504, + "CVC4": 13.067078771460345, + "CVC3": 10.536267836384352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.416305621524613, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.439565137535787 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.66663875829631, + "veriT": 11.143998195439385, + "Yices": 11.444996235878582, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.320875271225921, + "CVC4": 2.2842421395395696, + "CVC3": 12.997506778233889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.3395901932919045, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.531067276238302 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.247747813684857, + "veriT": 13.650461968001547, + "Yices": 12.647192603940601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.975141126032378, + "CVC4": 12.062810903778116, + "CVC3": 10.987456293845124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.374383539918819, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.957652762748191 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.919573299598679, + "veriT": 11.859618208120052, + "Yices": 11.341411359733852, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0792471221980673, + "CVC4": 10.978679893365509, + "CVC3": 8.4508311604675175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7972827497048325, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.839861397335282 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 45, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5804641729363631, + "veriT": 10.636374745050615, + "Yices": 12.730698533716671, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.8580634018468096, + "CVC4": 0.18703925762930768, + "CVC3": 8.7546937348011902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17096950435376923, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6320926422273514 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9263603585260318, + "veriT": 6.1801052660085665, + "Yices": 5.8726024554476002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1553816989268171, + "CVC4": 2.2474112969271607, + "CVC3": 4.7322156505770065, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6734157815435804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.2584614875266595 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5887357910926458, + "veriT": 5.3262856595369001, + "Yices": 4.3335254728718748, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.8487671840714262, + "CVC4": 3.6947689032368225, + "CVC3": 3.6692928435691994, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.383042373500148, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.839795861735201 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6721804357479737, + "veriT": 9.9838675825330441, + "Yices": 10.975462376874752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.726962962935183, + "CVC4": 2.7186862034657278, + "CVC3": 9.8296967118224927, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.676118373525066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.112495676368253 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 32.0, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.21181030211819998, + "veriT": 13.40134272388714, + "Yices": 2.6222951489322766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.6557750980794066, + "CVC4": 3.0241333702342219, + "CVC3": 4.1248875742026359, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9277341995928428, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2870909259196175 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4721011645850739, + "veriT": 14.214587861557643, + "Yices": 11.612187609688057, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.6117577544246355, + "CVC4": 4.2006778248948349, + "CVC3": 12.471068945623983, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.229603985573668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.23206098133857 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.0553603416934545, + "veriT": 10.366838756198208, + "Yices": 0.12852160882936364, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1270741940647273, + "CVC4": 0.16579554015463638, + "CVC3": 0.12288608770699999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7930911299210113, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8045735557170417 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7551364898681641, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.890897728987133, + "veriT": 8.486558385256167, + "Yices": 8.6294571523378334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.490645852817224, + "CVC4": 0.16061146874883334, + "CVC3": 10.971769020124974, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14878771953966666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3538530796082355 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6990950107574463, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6172165870666504, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.99416538313832, + "veriT": 10.791362649544126, + "Yices": 10.828400356390322, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.112959104215653, + "CVC4": 13.082034542865207, + "CVC3": 12.830054870826924, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.835980636777034, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.644649236946554 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.04204809257218, + "veriT": 12.179066825899968, + "Yices": 3.5208828300064994, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.367721090950738, + "CVC4": 0.22366409093416664, + "CVC3": 4.8462232551366036, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.3319489557508639, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.6923828143797124 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.149728771963121, + "veriT": 10.155203934374335, + "Yices": 10.305948947389334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.978351809188283, + "CVC4": 7.195441811739645, + "CVC3": 11.79494839359625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231758927559955, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.597913140431897 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0109998261966187, + "veriT": 12.480846355722226, + "Yices": 10.28933283058935, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2169691392216997, + "CVC4": 14.312641983096924, + "CVC3": 11.73130861859787, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.238831809883667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.358975763294479 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1321696512325263, + "veriT": 7.3721720920092784, + "Yices": 10.031962021986592, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15030419362510528, + "CVC4": 0.24446018742799999, + "CVC3": 1.6110386654241835, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13523083475736844, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13112710397736843 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.05718994140625, + "true": 70 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 72, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9027779102325439, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.0583941031308797, + "veriT": 5.9496548306088055, + "Yices": 9.9019886739026841, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.5454471069993287, + "CVC4": 1.1679340983387254, + "CVC3": 2.4173191516683601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.731209473415145, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6488232358163302 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1070527762599089, + "veriT": 6.488359235527418, + "Yices": 11.658885308647079, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4063723893895455, + "CVC4": 14.138610459261134, + "CVC3": 6.4512933875530507, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.113916932083157, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.1092140700777939 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7544567824419031, + "veriT": 8.4493732910107848, + "Yices": 6.8123863816589845, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0878303926598862, + "CVC4": 9.5438910797525107, + "CVC3": 4.817889498156017, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9276321911622674, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4785355652626961 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.105555534362793, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1390875029738125, + "veriT": 2.6497305260392374, + "Yices": 1.3601961947312999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1629158331425625, + "CVC4": 3.6625264972058926, + "CVC3": 0.11822245252525, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.132943883829025, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1315281977735375 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14066737543785712, + "veriT": 2.1343784791210547, + "Yices": 9.8856563371638071, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16090373109114284, + "CVC4": 1.5765712929198572, + "CVC3": 1.8111028677919998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5677469197325717, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.567797509620857 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.061320541084803, + "veriT": 6.4396801684072909, + "Yices": 12.724173234558965, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6032109256945732, + "CVC4": 4.4787613431507252, + "CVC3": 6.0797175898685714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1874222077388037, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.214685140960011 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9667117947165966, + "veriT": 8.8863483274447308, + "Yices": 9.1226519188067847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6506621848911607, + "CVC4": 9.1102445687280706, + "CVC3": 8.0686175953016779, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.6886571224634732, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.6782168088852689 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1449791880469999, + "veriT": 4.9426726537523367, + "Yices": 2.1644634306057999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1954851049586002, + "CVC4": 5.0884675462138329, + "CVC3": 4.7285440223171635, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0280281994661591, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.7990786258404823 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.99531028877249994, + "veriT": 0.14521873859641668, + "Yices": 1.8275453377375834, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.99474293997316676, + "CVC4": 1.3356004877721892, + "CVC3": 0.15296951121549998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.27343930859641663, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0889145163085527 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13764571301155556, + "veriT": 3.1769271951481732, + "Yices": 0.13294820266466667, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13951919894077777, + "CVC4": 0.14820194651888891, + "CVC3": 0.13215824776244445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14622270641255555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14335267772711113 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15138742860233331, + "veriT": 0.13152730429216666, + "Yices": 0.14339011430600002, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15142989187883335, + "CVC4": 0.16939907437266666, + "CVC3": 0.14916469830766665, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16852623617100002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16417786260433331 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17143443145250001, + "veriT": 0.14387152995999999, + "Yices": 0.15979171478049997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17473421178500001, + "CVC4": 0.1956314682851, + "CVC3": 0.17116838183249999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17971472346309997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18108960255589998 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2335847875731103, + "veriT": 4.9467907556492712, + "Yices": 6.7906463834731321, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5584019488961305, + "CVC4": 1.9761182386825265, + "CVC3": 2.2676885404695679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9596065602268693, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5951783328220117 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 55.5, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19941514121616669, + "veriT": 4.4072314161722277, + "Yices": 8.0493446329372933, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0370493849845834, + "CVC4": 2.5701393161355583, + "CVC3": 5.3196547452254075, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3812990450180351, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3810274451639322 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5276555098062063, + "veriT": 14.230412224800885, + "Yices": 9.5405991079871857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2253052961919444, + "CVC4": 14.617586586781407, + "CVC3": 13.052096012649217, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.188969749444281, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.589253029618865 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.7127464233845986, + "veriT": 11.88855936366665, + "Yices": 8.0859701537849986, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9671453752571342, + "CVC4": 9.7258124125075742, + "CVC3": 9.408071918158214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254486483213256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.959962946029533 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 42.0, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1499358622261, + "veriT": 10.158937194471401, + "Yices": 4.2844438501862605, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14524008259222002, + "CVC4": 3.1115842727297984, + "CVC3": 4.3686979022683685, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3704143390133137, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3681733789712904 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6675822010232366, + "veriT": 11.607165201450977, + "Yices": 5.7293035868240159, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9103142281850038, + "CVC4": 7.5833602111101923, + "CVC3": 2.7405196959598768, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5655825461565982, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.250993909119687 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 105 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1531818440228154, + "veriT": 5.3692864764537704, + "Yices": 3.2029879654399078, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17262733897285382, + "CVC4": 1.2534607437293206, + "CVC3": 0.93772807636918465, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.3470766636418423, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3575611758780148 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.234324634619711, + "veriT": 1.6718673975804699, + "Yices": 3.2035759414391505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2440426102098554, + "CVC4": 11.213995979586882, + "CVC3": 2.3896133141551115, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12705284146947779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12351626241236666 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.66780657318831, + "veriT": 6.1570999952110022, + "Yices": 3.1447398119279999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.757546792091905, + "CVC4": 9.7909433453485715, + "CVC3": 3.2985065677745, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15956068670062498, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15633943614162499 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.808334232224392, + "veriT": 12.282542793082843, + "Yices": 13.204669669922763, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.883016773786184, + "CVC4": 9.0136558867877792, + "CVC3": 7.1199691320239209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5125998168200709, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4903012622553309 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 112 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 84.0, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4061544895627867, + "veriT": 11.386121372810257, + "Yices": 7.6020624048970769, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3639539364756255, + "CVC4": 2.4039020229608434, + "CVC3": 5.1207922473425285, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.189287370924105, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1866256980362335 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.931046503040932, + "veriT": 10.87699485431655, + "Yices": 11.63544041383326, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.534808004142624, + "CVC4": 12.079140055341481, + "CVC3": 11.739182739011902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.857524518965811, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.417137957571539 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.0300437776725, + "veriT": 12.441351802760686, + "Yices": 12.467147994880738, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.506487188181353, + "CVC4": 1.7648576937525859, + "CVC3": 0.88740852781120017, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6494198558612865, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3670136897839806 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 128, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9771240668481189, + "veriT": 6.585818231606015, + "Yices": 4.0142620451518756, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1740047628003669, + "CVC4": 5.0126534886680485, + "CVC3": 3.4753192847479184, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.778245002413319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.7861389294988546 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 38.0, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6904764175415039, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6999963496830492, + "veriT": 10.271364080551113, + "Yices": 6.4378290666585487, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.0027419383464649, + "CVC4": 8.5323066350267798, + "CVC3": 2.3308203575889337, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.335634294273067, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.3757176359019052 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 69.0, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1173781672084813, + "veriT": 12.592206080074245, + "Yices": 12.650237758863055, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.137748724957195, + "CVC4": 8.2239223734164959, + "CVC3": 6.6770582553130495, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.843083415398985, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.784162718378218 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.270519802253823, + "veriT": 13.54706340788235, + "Yices": 12.444283583337954, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.948900874283774, + "CVC4": 14.729808816449323, + "CVC3": 8.1255584894484318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237043280588319, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.752757230543182 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.742287186991915, + "veriT": 11.864172314169329, + "Yices": 11.383843941669577, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.134169298063989, + "CVC4": 14.45473591961732, + "CVC3": 13.190933171411054, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.246706380547439, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.549819124995667 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3832039680188464, + "veriT": 11.089238532211944, + "Yices": 13.844051359444686, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.6669791337430726, + "CVC4": 12.840188969879215, + "CVC3": 11.021688297125685, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.4271612898209263, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4262095104268822 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 187.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 90.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1778502714695698, + "veriT": 11.267956054027193, + "Yices": 10.922613889219312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0661026438964392, + "CVC4": 14.376390507043427, + "CVC3": 11.091655972273134, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240863137090862, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.175420538207129 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 126.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.132182134267429, + "veriT": 13.047521213914617, + "Yices": 12.635787611397172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8969350912704073, + "CVC4": 14.408807588740448, + "CVC3": 9.2185334389639113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1292051440343327, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1359537226181997 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2407080493388385, + "veriT": 14.222664778576283, + "Yices": 11.948853295650997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.047561407875932, + "CVC4": 12.311928491720257, + "CVC3": 10.407486727952328, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.897389397957385, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.894786280945398 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 182.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.69601224485395, + "veriT": 10.811020586319755, + "Yices": 11.914777739520513, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.312962055798822, + "CVC4": 14.616017636352398, + "CVC3": 12.36897954521049, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2772540147418185, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.053205926488971 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1517460346221924, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.957272560947555, + "veriT": 13.82573378397124, + "Yices": 13.830226270482973, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.421605927301881, + "CVC4": 12.869481959253925, + "CVC3": 12.612580561813227, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.217262301799614, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.224880201556623 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247161701780456, + "veriT": 11.216777280323793, + "Yices": 12.913711177014513, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.964805920766851, + "CVC4": 14.374757003737237, + "CVC3": 13.064378576069601, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.237869761394945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.229420030509665 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.22921967161661, + "veriT": 14.218328951027773, + "Yices": 14.225051036976204, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.95036357536409, + "CVC4": 14.28041420606462, + "CVC3": 13.860582505207045, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.517144156308285, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.512857233872284 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3505447144532106, + "veriT": 12.915173293971911, + "Yices": 6.3050705601950243, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2857872696584245, + "CVC4": 5.1488269138714244, + "CVC3": 9.5943689213984573, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7476628434156218, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.1667941056023707 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 239.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2818427407258888, + "veriT": 14.228960027441664, + "Yices": 14.336078474359548, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.104986385800499, + "CVC4": 13.772946415840689, + "CVC3": 13.884885923771122, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9200948130915139, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.0148207404340122 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.788395464935588, + "veriT": 13.830110498612189, + "Yices": 13.374281996933352, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.99626021743247, + "CVC4": 14.599335471384295, + "CVC3": 11.556418316620928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.179172072493529, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.786278087029801 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 61.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12265175292057143, + "veriT": 0.092495979389521449, + "Yices": 0.096900272623214309, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11767786382278575, + "CVC4": 0.121803972547, + "CVC3": 0.097267772477399997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11678873516910714, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11584045286037858 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12118096952529372, + "veriT": 0.71321543244548113, + "Yices": 0.71599222447463118, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13073072508301872, + "CVC4": 0.99301572412920336, + "CVC3": 0.093036545791900002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.99126041142441368, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.99049686407638937 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1229223872559997, + "veriT": 0.097083943313741664, + "Yices": 1.7942193946649836, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.1215028402119165, + "CVC4": 0.12421231497033332, + "CVC3": 0.10454190802973333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12250489366733334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14800973622208333 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.20837788228678572, + "veriT": 10.16882958588957, + "Yices": 10.347731727143108, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.25914486826725003, + "CVC4": 0.14875915144596427, + "CVC3": 0.70581871822839304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14870145267271426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.429900697284921 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18434382298400001, + "veriT": 7.2929988205701433, + "Yices": 9.0594615827265716, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.34963613693685708, + "CVC4": 0.15224834943442858, + "CVC3": 0.25321880742671427, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14891637936171429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.0366776026484539 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 36, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.727214758675558, + "veriT": 11.95640211475143, + "Yices": 12.29361569352543, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5760736241036053, + "CVC4": 12.846932798028636, + "CVC3": 10.235757461706028, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.278651485646208, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.560796918711779 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.6904168081375541, + "veriT": 6.5544921103517977, + "Yices": 6.6288911899568985, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.5490990598562551, + "CVC4": 1.637925610496892, + "CVC3": 3.6560810957298999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5525253968537587, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0889157251010388 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17267750825822223, + "veriT": 2.8497439035560621, + "Yices": 6.2709080961360124, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17842723105488889, + "CVC4": 1.7368672209012803, + "CVC3": 0.17095535787311111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6280687307281232, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4496840339520158 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244034580793716, + "veriT": 10.830719907369827, + "Yices": 8.6207050119424995, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.167343361709882, + "CVC4": 0.15603729544116665, + "CVC3": 10.304988739044376, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17132582682950001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4618416839579336 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 22 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 26, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7749999761581421, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 25, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.731433600520059, + "veriT": 10.66846928437398, + "Yices": 10.520319079480501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.356419235507309, + "CVC4": 2.0102427518243307, + "CVC3": 10.564770457879, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9080775896634541, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.653195632924179 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.986668604813708, + "veriT": 10.156224082132775, + "Yices": 10.340041740965331, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.963684558171813, + "CVC4": 0.14834713853522224, + "CVC3": 12.848396830365791, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14536292124144443, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.697793115636284 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 27 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8999999761581421, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240631846330666, + "veriT": 10.165288713421454, + "Yices": 10.329812706211909, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958010037626622, + "CVC4": 0.16492729581854546, + "CVC3": 13.206737245514605, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.4581726437883695, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.276368325840847 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.50907408556423, + "veriT": 10.188933795959251, + "Yices": 10.355390087551623, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.958874770675477, + "CVC4": 1.758350583216223, + "CVC3": 12.555556121799439, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.9430675007817388, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.034606265143275 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.54551488669828, + "veriT": 10.815625466165374, + "Yices": 10.823831438391023, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.137162562549642, + "CVC4": 8.8687898798819891, + "CVC3": 13.538550019616245, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.8476723366693237, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.2380642078196828 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1876611268955832, + "veriT": 10.991108433125255, + "Yices": 8.5459815491724669, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6916555592031903, + "CVC4": 0.43589995468083337, + "CVC3": 7.2198241028355197, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7299756472726617, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5657103280636679 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.406010867488998, + "veriT": 11.587219795170871, + "Yices": 11.953422859104881, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9213249446799097, + "CVC4": 9.7304635766232295, + "CVC3": 9.0029805572381214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.5102711626323151, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.2825570930772177 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15248973839656668, + "veriT": 7.4683174240761661, + "Yices": 10.885457404399007, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.20135690083183336, + "CVC4": 4.8466401178002094, + "CVC3": 2.0657296030402077, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1687358724812755, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.911040151121127 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9104857342808366, + "veriT": 6.9779961500441701, + "Yices": 4.3726030914874574, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.672156782638238, + "CVC4": 4.4091286105212841, + "CVC3": 4.1263096573835991, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1421357255720208, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1399260571633691 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.5583446017885798, + "veriT": 10.637942307781589, + "Yices": 12.144696531072046, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8093575302533065, + "CVC4": 11.299880766035868, + "CVC3": 7.6665822519471396, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.8081304296080241, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.6554565311596292 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13637077379818, + "veriT": 5.1114554683473896, + "Yices": 6.5244974607617463, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13384595096763, + "CVC4": 1.1425080791678301, + "CVC3": 1.1845976215278999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.5225235098493484, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5119058889896577 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4126191620870381, + "veriT": 1.0192698472559181, + "Yices": 1.0360162062927363, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4705932453240158, + "CVC4": 0.14096096261145455, + "CVC3": 0.21962762777167272, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15189807818572729, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1663665275156934 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 80, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.7888889312744141, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 15.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0801279544830322, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 50 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7867134809494019, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 53, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6076924800872803, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4705682732930434, + "veriT": 8.4699028946792776, + "Yices": 10.902442478141744, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3237740845098545, + "CVC4": 1.762455794514457, + "CVC3": 6.6371664147804577, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1988159410477222, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.458256433051696 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.45676071318346, + "veriT": 11.161951274770502, + "Yices": 9.5384662058589988, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.906886336735843, + "CVC4": 3.785156055911076, + "CVC3": 12.477126202359385, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.2900191540213379, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5994265345570025 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1948721560405584, + "veriT": 3.6560368556843388, + "Yices": 6.4187154920004286, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9332961872338768, + "CVC4": 2.2627264951861337, + "CVC3": 2.1728112798064765, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7237751995628683, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7492968384177905 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 58, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.0563726666441831, + "veriT": 8.2063819082796154, + "Yices": 10.857899111023764, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8518357049636265, + "CVC4": 8.1967561883498767, + "CVC3": 10.333401287487517, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.126017987585216, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.679398105232883 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.803666237502915, + "veriT": 10.117805528222222, + "Yices": 10.103926614177546, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1000933058702032, + "CVC4": 7.0732116931536444, + "CVC3": 1.8684891325013548, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.234028608760376, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.224467591219188 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "false": 61, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 60 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.807198469082975, + "veriT": 13.209242775073578, + "Yices": 10.095103449508752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.262333633901417, + "CVC4": 14.837688020947867, + "CVC3": 14.940504846831912, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.634032127586632, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.634971881876268 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4706777603894094, + "veriT": 12.581042934683875, + "Yices": 11.26589331544614, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.581841198451382, + "CVC4": 10.091074387547074, + "CVC3": 5.5536985143147213, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.188330708849628, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.935741267825613 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "false": 64, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 63 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8822481084857934, + "veriT": 11.924881116096637, + "Yices": 11.254037588200404, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4611543480227844, + "CVC4": 11.154029931855009, + "CVC3": 9.5200806953083479, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.444469722063122, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.448004412827812 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8803215744212332, + "veriT": 6.397716968365625, + "Yices": 5.7366201574716271, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7149898818118468, + "CVC4": 1.9294852922822072, + "CVC3": 5.294031482280289, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9203903373173854, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3972812877587435 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13230331868681999, + "veriT": 5.9699114955899741, + "Yices": 0.093002403766559993, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.75633456691040002, + "CVC4": 0.13009337170999999, + "CVC3": 0.1154340391019, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12071794007139999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12046543776143999 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2596427440721572, + "veriT": 5.8975944717076763, + "Yices": 6.4522752973769837, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4335575657579662, + "CVC4": 4.3021764129282323, + "CVC3": 4.6710877218346205, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1221998871131174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1300367903080311 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.5115287432006665, + "veriT": 9.2176775630445142, + "Yices": 4.5976707253228666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3844118817095561, + "CVC4": 0.15880285086699999, + "CVC3": 3.903057830369709, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1415086593307778, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.13587047954788889 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 71 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1500000953674316, + "true": 73 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1884115766266596, + "veriT": 6.6861294443734147, + "Yices": 11.838824550637709, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7239057743748285, + "CVC4": 6.7405519728876389, + "CVC3": 9.8192993801702251, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9175086869278237, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.5190796380745635 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.884216235390527, + "veriT": 13.007403792917255, + "Yices": 12.639621687552212, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.356174581294933, + "CVC4": 8.3048143204992364, + "CVC3": 12.475206445941639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5033790666718119, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.538886778962997 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.529832142955204, + "veriT": 10.276972122298524, + "Yices": 9.8775093936343481, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8002240671685712, + "CVC4": 13.290055366373018, + "CVC3": 12.697132245571993, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.829632204175008, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.376752214436136 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.195174357664689, + "veriT": 10.16835425461441, + "Yices": 11.826415937786164, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.577388071506856, + "CVC4": 8.936571139118735, + "CVC3": 3.0878714764985808, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2293975816414759, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.2642994656646884 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.28279111707649995, + "veriT": 9.17240361406677, + "Yices": 2.9480262378690725, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.1055816255258128, + "CVC4": 3.2425495006136629, + "CVC3": 2.4275408725951642, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0621282633372999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.37108435876570001 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.382920251482, + "veriT": 14.210956134107924, + "Yices": 6.2446828141350652, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.50973358637925, + "CVC4": 5.7014333332903409, + "CVC3": 7.1850683397127817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.750894274141553, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.758261015623868 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15502050007055557, + "veriT": 1.6898516761011777, + "Yices": 12.98753944986408, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16100226626077779, + "CVC4": 8.0106688515924258, + "CVC3": 10.156341932311555, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7806400024286668, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7644770376458889 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9516627037850567, + "veriT": 8.1762481142815826, + "Yices": 10.630640263895167, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.672071397943826, + "CVC4": 8.6495908042575618, + "CVC3": 5.782961661287831, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.4040818246097295, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.413679332765975 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3240710136429952, + "veriT": 2.8375254500026275, + "Yices": 2.854960998308, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0748587146174211, + "CVC4": 2.7094393888542068, + "CVC3": 1.4078217557301111, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4064297963350094, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1420296474378331 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 34.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 94, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 24.5, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.0238351155339442, + "veriT": 1.4656119968613399, + "Yices": 1.5144666876605333, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1179602983581289, + "CVC4": 0.17503594677286666, + "CVC3": 2.2257666566617336, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16115017112186666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6479113657215376 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.31725084372644441, + "veriT": 1.3021561851255667, + "Yices": 9.1745083399666765, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0723571565944443, + "CVC4": 0.24393415972999996, + "CVC3": 0.25988867757888889, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.24253863354166669, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.24127730977844447 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1614584922790527, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.924857497215271, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1509180194774, + "veriT": 2.9687007096402214, + "Yices": 3.126035528743897, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.19045346579799999, + "CVC4": 0.21734318019939999, + "CVC3": 0.15751301660302, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18203506617927998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18102427893694001 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14749310866283333, + "veriT": 0.12517636544466665, + "Yices": 0.12807296808441668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14279171187566667, + "CVC4": 0.16259715276591669, + "CVC3": 0.14156494525158334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15561392403991667, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15312435201691668 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15674211707714286, + "veriT": 6.17406007622718, + "Yices": 0.16293949032657146, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18707647871842856, + "CVC4": 0.18520027172428571, + "CVC3": 0.86057980597614292, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16991094124071429, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16971701974571429 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16416226726866667, + "veriT": 9.7288876889641021, + "Yices": 4.9706363851401525, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17367715227, + "CVC4": 2.6259273314953226, + "CVC3": 2.4183768532044136, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3489116302386117, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.4345062863651128 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7501064125551968, + "veriT": 1.6440106338076463, + "Yices": 1.8226848551732771, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.8191882416652088, + "CVC4": 10.999462771131995, + "CVC3": 1.21082064863907, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2708724295499172, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0593417863520487 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.1861456883992941, + "veriT": 6.2457688965110654, + "Yices": 10.202988133003752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3915122074244703, + "CVC4": 2.7807827751590923, + "CVC3": 9.0565625525930287, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5008141198099816, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5007120440959261 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 104 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16613072073575003, + "veriT": 12.447459113774586, + "Yices": 1.8728336704348709, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.33418656576087497, + "CVC4": 5.683318031818315, + "CVC3": 0.16873944197724999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.503612143863538, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.499763550086767 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7304655062037144, + "veriT": 13.06324892589828, + "Yices": 14.09324850286794, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2817919413025063, + "CVC4": 8.2661577648092361, + "CVC3": 13.497752713587047, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254599773730421, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.253650014040725 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.258944284797, + "veriT": 11.076768594952272, + "Yices": 1.6701199324035556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.901862074046849, + "CVC4": 1.9596068381524967, + "CVC3": 0.54213286309344455, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7089626547442525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.7099607132283194 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 62.5, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1931220143913475, + "veriT": 9.1752270590599263, + "Yices": 13.123164125668501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4545440876449085, + "CVC4": 7.4063519757055252, + "CVC3": 6.3458116869835255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4922194544823766, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.218368014944748 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 114, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 51.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.2879551187794762, + "veriT": 11.702417858734659, + "Yices": 11.898030504662225, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.4619368881466706, + "CVC4": 14.366839233164546, + "CVC3": 12.621349369055679, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.245388429763009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.163668987332764 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.7303280042284719, + "veriT": 10.978445826024736, + "Yices": 10.360624149142549, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.957004305141798, + "CVC4": 8.7445780209802688, + "CVC3": 11.720391158953669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.916989825805306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.029040608545369 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3801983262797677, + "veriT": 13.307428636720891, + "Yices": 8.6026845493252964, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.7441351175846247, + "CVC4": 0.33983260959237499, + "CVC3": 2.3492775114885172, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4316488455521865, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4264580609906332 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 118, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 160.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3062519438513078, + "veriT": 8.486227975944896, + "Yices": 6.4724174260105709, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9684326478402312, + "CVC4": 11.037116238863263, + "CVC3": 5.06149384752021, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4354684267634426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.421525363738392 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.048789471795625, + "veriT": 12.265468049530387, + "Yices": 7.2412013742863159, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.9301594203523749, + "CVC4": 11.208459747556722, + "CVC3": 4.8869141015923043, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.670473110410466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.33569476179979 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 27.5, + "true": 120 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7299193515683609, + "veriT": 10.950550418888408, + "Yices": 6.1759452724047739, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9002816913510276, + "CVC4": 4.2485977662398655, + "CVC3": 4.2756304514534671, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.0262679885181427, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9515743399037142 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1556676540802, + "veriT": 0.13213931026440001, + "Yices": 0.14667786198220001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.1606070991511999, + "CVC4": 0.17018746179479999, + "CVC3": 0.15237920000459998, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16546978563120002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16575144093040001 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 131, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 28.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "eps", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 126 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1491218523845159, + "veriT": 13.711995426095955, + "Yices": 9.1954383121976395, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0090158488630472, + "CVC4": 7.03778356544451, + "CVC3": 5.7471913027326158, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.219098017513534, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.239230306104634 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3425572730033917, + "veriT": 13.093914423169, + "Yices": 13.577587365037827, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.939069442579967, + "CVC4": 14.395207761058057, + "CVC3": 9.448093229110313, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.578231294896337, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.57959758168448 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.303019385346765, + "veriT": 12.844910102839568, + "Yices": 12.461059413687847, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.582382667237626, + "CVC4": 14.603596139364292, + "CVC3": 13.414470834871208, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.225951057138191, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.202081588837714 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.260573450205635, + "veriT": 10.196574315692688, + "Yices": 10.381125159389375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.982042110283986, + "CVC4": 14.283266232816656, + "CVC3": 13.485900661036872, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254537641919555, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.164314555127572 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 135, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 187.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 13.0, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1368352695309927, + "veriT": 11.861064172103966, + "Yices": 11.214036905606482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6841626170358923, + "CVC4": 10.095378652456594, + "CVC3": 3.4068398424606863, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.589691682810638, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.508006113203413 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.26502883818654999, + "veriT": 8.6046722150985122, + "Yices": 4.1457849802021505, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7706673920018354, + "CVC4": 4.323336600583203, + "CVC3": 0.1946882168954833, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.5052039387838079, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5411604258530356 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 45.0, + "true": 136 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 138 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.928757255163605, + "veriT": 11.989164507130905, + "Yices": 8.0102851752037427, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.123154793060859, + "CVC4": 2.4877499665096825, + "CVC3": 5.1042822871514222, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2116762777836865, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8085014927936822 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.250673994489286, + "veriT": 13.022090579669072, + "Yices": 12.66694570359032, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.730333496842821, + "CVC4": 11.602458953850473, + "CVC3": 13.240532261299881, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.857734377656538, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.83684006544231 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.780832193128486, + "veriT": 13.055492184881349, + "Yices": 13.069831397081916, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.763762113289202, + "CVC4": 14.437844435315027, + "CVC3": 13.629919410331249, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.249533566654273, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.241689205154618 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6536325053686856, + "veriT": 13.423287959971764, + "Yices": 13.139503448139482, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.521530016963133, + "CVC4": 14.455302872533485, + "CVC3": 11.736650122817341, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.939621589261793, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8617172632446417 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7734527266485864, + "veriT": 10.17888854023021, + "Yices": 12.122920043367534, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.517594292846953, + "CVC4": 12.0477821598584, + "CVC3": 10.060763012943113, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.72939785750207697, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.5122691037864882 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 109.0, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5604447089083688, + "veriT": 7.6353294556317541, + "Yices": 9.4586804993431475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.523523892282606, + "CVC4": 12.133560400765736, + "CVC3": 7.4670390433764622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.90803312912476, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.1499645152334583 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 152, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 134.5, + "true": 148 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1703416439080527, + "veriT": 12.98124473237729, + "Yices": 13.273371859033563, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.190026719900329, + "CVC4": 14.783351564163674, + "CVC3": 12.586178422299051, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.257887131196567, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.198090509120867 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "false": 151, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 150 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.251014908957275, + "veriT": 11.534600981433769, + "Yices": 13.892857473998717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971476474254128, + "CVC4": 14.550728148560941, + "CVC3": 13.449893680343997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.969391819144878, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.20796217945778 + }, + { + "index": 151, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.889837646971316, + "veriT": 14.234519519772594, + "Yices": 13.743961935536939, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.836015350796592, + "CVC4": 13.087275399527023, + "CVC3": 13.537835075994941, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.510819964768082, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.584823005620096 + }, + { + "index": 152, + "false": 154, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 153 + }, + { + "index": 153, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.7788978119177745, + "veriT": 13.246135427274167, + "Yices": 13.30368942043701, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.582026646598027, + "CVC4": 12.818044485479028, + "CVC3": 13.243088882409474, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.234216893732814, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.5336992322012293 + }, + { + "index": 154, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.821576427149532, + "veriT": 14.248919049976903, + "Yices": 13.914922478366691, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.011992996656016, + "CVC4": 14.856136371297623, + "CVC3": 9.6809278135887595, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.890741839145436, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.312806491528468 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 60.0, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13064647292120835, + "veriT": 0.10087378512598337, + "Yices": 0.10464914762614168, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12654843558445836, + "CVC4": 0.1298416354433333, + "CVC3": 0.10644196253119997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.12491279847020832, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.12224047623221668 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12785798055842779, + "veriT": 1.2003492991076277, + "Yices": 1.2035692112965668, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14741054147490557, + "CVC4": 1.6811919008764673, + "CVC3": 0.095230423546694448, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6779387241704466, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.6759755680565867 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.341767068249812, + "veriT": 1.9490361298654901, + "Yices": 2.7096541452053633, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.4630026906251041, + "CVC4": 1.4338151780254782, + "CVC3": 1.415901981496265, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14789647328099997, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4459738002027036 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6592142822745966, + "veriT": 10.168000492663863, + "Yices": 10.352171766535895, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.779150837012565, + "CVC4": 0.14777579560499995, + "CVC3": 0.70383951407727607, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1487763455715862, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.439259000735831 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19617563558411114, + "veriT": 9.0507648023073344, + "Yices": 9.2097025345546673, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.45100306557188891, + "CVC4": 0.15484686168355555, + "CVC3": 0.27020656771444446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14962924713444445, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4218923870574747 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 14, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.0852765591128612, + "veriT": 12.723946455260213, + "Yices": 11.582498089228979, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.017675565651027, + "CVC4": 11.772007899456989, + "CVC3": 11.175213487200692, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.592006292055174, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.842069942248783 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6333334445953369, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2485520315899179, + "veriT": 4.1986777844635004, + "Yices": 7.3276537973844, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0222188776978154, + "CVC4": 0.1651292031213, + "CVC3": 3.209873301094246, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3588299850108614, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.895985931638904 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16686157661672729, + "veriT": 1.9433063901848, + "Yices": 6.5803010809848184, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15672206594372728, + "CVC4": 5.2949231894304427, + "CVC3": 0.16535936294754547, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7044017295552583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.2147347274052653 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.856944310641772, + "veriT": 9.5749463569290292, + "Yices": 10.357828078721997, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.46586261828846, + "CVC4": 2.0725593779466585, + "CVC3": 9.7871360084892967, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9090859820044521, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.791583284486704 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.656779737229645, + "veriT": 10.566843506903425, + "Yices": 9.307190886457601, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.471168514935147, + "CVC4": 1.3131747519288002, + "CVC3": 11.225633081534664, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1541924963691002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.675456766331024 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7638890743255615, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 32, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.857190989027893, + "veriT": 10.667573170012229, + "Yices": 10.506580534878626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.352740348559781, + "CVC4": 2.0217181253963306, + "CVC3": 10.662074839839637, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.6208696034856178, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.18871509449588 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6875, + "true": 28 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 29 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.250422721420268, + "veriT": 10.1773155483474, + "Yices": 10.357432153489501, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.972279747602268, + "CVC4": 0.16714514085010002, + "CVC3": 11.794522578309389, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16593364381320003, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.449728968151701 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.240678651680984, + "veriT": 10.149587705189502, + "Yices": 10.345151232548499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.954097398222977, + "CVC4": 0.15338513564599998, + "CVC3": 12.844850241759978, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.162075863446, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.285884701209481 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.716102315947184, + "veriT": 10.834244268984804, + "Yices": 10.632512578635462, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.172160825244346, + "CVC4": 2.5489827218012739, + "CVC3": 14.245781355140677, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4956743683901697, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.86916554648378 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.523849391601916, + "veriT": 5.8226787672046605, + "Yices": 8.2071712588901971, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.085732211701595, + "CVC4": 0.35152247958300004, + "CVC3": 9.0413730006614124, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5072514966064037, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8012026431113655 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9961877848362404, + "veriT": 8.8064872332071698, + "Yices": 9.7356480139721846, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3738041104884449, + "CVC4": 1.2178171995180831, + "CVC3": 5.8301704720824992, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.982219837473699, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.9239516945619899 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.163984082324899, + "veriT": 11.188431119040731, + "Yices": 10.516282874238872, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3972269694858466, + "CVC4": 8.9444779204777678, + "CVC3": 9.456952107568398, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.916736129464066, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.938826429975252 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 93, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 19.5, + "true": 37 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.7038459777832031, + "true": 38 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 40 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2065559310478324, + "veriT": 11.575956546057382, + "Yices": 10.800569151357555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6330467320946767, + "CVC4": 3.7634606132947606, + "CVC3": 11.54089241729025, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.1650413514388829, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.1255002462922503 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.677107639133112, + "veriT": 13.837701730230862, + "Yices": 13.38396645725485, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.534411258692778, + "CVC4": 14.656496674436561, + "CVC3": 13.237680989441587, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.606158470746406, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.609028176355611 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.6809337136495568, + "veriT": 7.567433086581322, + "Yices": 9.9484350123890586, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2380762624571346, + "CVC4": 3.4249702674310982, + "CVC3": 4.2840237352196144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9441351134611295, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5361661224224417 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 9.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 46 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.995755101024125, + "veriT": 1.8251332541026124, + "Yices": 0.060668605437575004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6071930052175007, + "CVC4": 1.8470023519331054, + "CVC3": 1.8271637793824622, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.081527067885912491, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.085429120883437501 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12887331810325711, + "veriT": 5.8151465974994716, + "Yices": 9.8456514062133049, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12778205070118573, + "CVC4": 1.5629920380709001, + "CVC3": 1.6319531725829999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1138591152714978, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.0936412793213681 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 51 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.212024527069181, + "veriT": 9.4034720759801811, + "Yices": 12.058309191298767, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.216970841619558, + "CVC4": 12.581090713374781, + "CVC3": 10.211850165204639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.231302887369162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.234576760818186 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 54, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1833333969116211, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.2805068657570158, + "veriT": 7.1052411623937104, + "Yices": 7.8302145733352813, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.5984050840945767, + "CVC4": 4.5983509864017877, + "CVC3": 2.9271315407061627, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.8831984595868416, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9258637227818731 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 56, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6354319684599279, + "veriT": 3.3267722711559751, + "Yices": 5.0876158411706811, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.9862546438839424, + "CVC4": 0.99571461751631696, + "CVC3": 0.37909941548918236, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.99111104919659687, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.9661939341550001 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5535602236158714, + "veriT": 6.1574848261886359, + "Yices": 8.4231522728709365, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.5566165411654571, + "CVC4": 10.330444578052198, + "CVC3": 8.6561146888053564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.178184837108041, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1730872829746963 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 7.0, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.317042510963, + "veriT": 1.9468838279675387, + "Yices": 2.4244391764328781, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.221529205350778, + "CVC4": 1.7393655353039723, + "CVC3": 0.19421258690844445, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2767437205523637, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.6387720185739014 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.595837159234801, + "veriT": 9.1741575219526013, + "Yices": 10.325380732025099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.492461948410286, + "CVC4": 1.5833706100529659, + "CVC3": 10.260189056341492, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8007158748370831, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.223150535800997 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.6038626882744511, + "veriT": 9.0982431283872121, + "Yices": 10.523329290824728, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.7187408130303914, + "CVC4": 1.6811909183125715, + "CVC3": 1.9616542104376882, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1930204279651138, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.8822990558463055 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 1.0, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.865574756114377, + "veriT": 12.42889640919023, + "Yices": 10.338213940954523, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.265243641566387, + "CVC4": 8.7575028692771344, + "CVC3": 11.030714317800607, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.9565665960960388, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.5904615010067449 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 67 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.210988736365126, + "veriT": 11.292035283449605, + "Yices": 10.363085139623681, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.903773676686123, + "CVC4": 12.153859242364385, + "CVC3": 10.2295932200532, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.229746901707687, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.230454647528195 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9124205183660683, + "veriT": 5.1211952359929995, + "Yices": 5.6500763276976205, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.9969906537619702, + "CVC4": 10.723434403131312, + "CVC3": 6.0454613485003437, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.1714322139142954, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8277564224160363 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.8479202583908627, + "veriT": 9.4711906915601798, + "Yices": 11.047314403215976, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.9504934111546888, + "CVC4": 11.330242810374065, + "CVC3": 8.1683055882632463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.109305659599938, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.667102598675299 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3669914963860865, + "veriT": 3.7684890371580906, + "Yices": 5.1368195649736998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.263780533069294, + "CVC4": 1.4346645360919597, + "CVC3": 1.4815800164141544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.728751120693225, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.725404585456314 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7872420910787774, + "veriT": 8.5951485906387575, + "Yices": 5.5942383097908985, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8190680593940405, + "CVC4": 10.661153272575079, + "CVC3": 8.5669408369489695, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5209705800997995, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5156596565844005 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 78, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 26.0, + "true": 76 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1904092749610857, + "veriT": 7.7025691422311962, + "Yices": 9.1652880465962099, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0401765697633678, + "CVC4": 1.9407364251337504, + "CVC3": 3.9708733932756255, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.164685464970625, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16472435288932502 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.692806875726915, + "veriT": 8.1393420341925289, + "Yices": 9.3330934575922448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.4500925089364607, + "CVC4": 12.426676536067211, + "CVC3": 10.510030185683565, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.935382895915827, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.481326918886225 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 86, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 81 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "false": 83, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 82 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.143082419282375, + "veriT": 0.13382743911903749, + "Yices": 0.19160958613349999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14248092491012501, + "CVC4": 0.20743482428849999, + "CVC3": 2.7005120344092499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1662134158935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16247770405587497 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18083923227566667, + "veriT": 1.8190100949321835, + "Yices": 4.2571948720667123, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18698236394849999, + "CVC4": 0.19508137639100001, + "CVC3": 0.17311152420816667, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17899254773966666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17493648134566667 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.05739371464125, + "veriT": 10.064365112617727, + "Yices": 4.8872794549808312, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0002781919750414, + "CVC4": 1.5978462421828752, + "CVC3": 1.609807737979025, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3858960072177249, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.383750482510175 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16842399965414284, + "veriT": 0.16261674861492859, + "Yices": 9.4355706870671998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17398845512721431, + "CVC4": 3.2173717561669148, + "CVC3": 0.17221529792157145, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.46850481580792858, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5680670441464923 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.7695482052667413, + "veriT": 6.2703835439676654, + "Yices": 5.9852257496543553, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2976722632828599, + "CVC4": 3.6921318259786609, + "CVC3": 1.3073936931994046, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.3049248353794676, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4905698506652412 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1715782061389977, + "veriT": 10.617101539036479, + "Yices": 12.423582798535186, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.731186200929644, + "CVC4": 12.736434155129379, + "CVC3": 9.2009987179435928, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8637061631662171, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.7173629633008627 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 89 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 90 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14770129998733333, + "veriT": 1.6862088880978419, + "Yices": 0.14408863917061113, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14679567339216665, + "CVC4": 0.16485358898811109, + "CVC3": 0.14301232721144444, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15732330031183334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.15896064918927777 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9274837554867497, + "veriT": 0.15310412368762499, + "Yices": 0.15933132743199996, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9296691206875001, + "CVC4": 5.4923593131404216, + "CVC3": 0.15338340273887499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16029554022962497, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16055041316825 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7082582922477014, + "veriT": 12.233211619412801, + "Yices": 4.2067910525677172, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4282535059953556, + "CVC4": 2.4108884817383114, + "CVC3": 2.5148844218686315, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2130803544489996, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5131557182222855 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "false": 100, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 95 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 33.5, + "true": 96 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "false": 98, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 97 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.56139110104074996, + "veriT": 10.190949270253626, + "Yices": 10.345469605627375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.426636661133573, + "CVC4": 14.276945562996993, + "CVC3": 1.6103142995987498, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.254004973337301, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.157298577794574 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1925149883793074, + "veriT": 7.0211123920800906, + "Yices": 10.663361523638708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.7747010496136459, + "CVC4": 11.037147115110338, + "CVC3": 11.111846353984884, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0227700789606242, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0178156725307925 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.244504500891935, + "veriT": 10.49029880217744, + "Yices": 10.445663170575642, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.559470101015195, + "CVC4": 14.442894098091941, + "CVC3": 14.238898750929986, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.233800499045536, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.731211033348233 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.82757809091166656, + "veriT": 7.5197989679988062, + "Yices": 4.4059400112308058, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4898406067830603, + "CVC4": 5.2663414167828284, + "CVC3": 0.19294348649877774, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.120454714197948, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0627610827327372 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 35.5, + "true": 102 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8887500762939453, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4068808133721249, + "veriT": 14.209812373842929, + "Yices": 0.11148057224199999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4566064427615, + "CVC4": 2.1558366760283545, + "CVC3": 0.13415272432012501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.4229120595057054, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4172285976814383 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14790999009674999, + "veriT": 14.216465177973099, + "Yices": 3.8267234807028752, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.17770992150137499, + "CVC4": 0.18481046091325001, + "CVC3": 3.6567929101537668, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.032367379374591, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.028415801013868 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 107, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4643583588915057, + "veriT": 11.955568730347538, + "Yices": 9.7463672870532374, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.9253006108497335, + "CVC4": 14.463663215371964, + "CVC3": 13.369526305473334, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.752938752518752, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.314394030298164 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9206349849700928, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 48.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.480101648162, + "veriT": 13.187420112547681, + "Yices": 8.8838496669009626, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.6592294879762051, + "CVC4": 7.4904952830930895, + "CVC3": 7.0189769939160742, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.856916563494661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.817586997396937 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.585611830647899, + "veriT": 11.942633446889502, + "Yices": 6.7993281743351623, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5541963124178739, + "CVC4": 2.0278916517067311, + "CVC3": 2.4345697960685624, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9531980007157426, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9492869455950217 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.50423451444744449, + "veriT": 14.213745940597024, + "Yices": 10.195488045490762, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7532213336144444, + "CVC4": 6.6929996939041096, + "CVC3": 1.9630362939051262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8410011789401199, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8413697257188844 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "false": 122, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 113 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 8.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 179.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.5311626617349416, + "veriT": 12.47155122789591, + "Yices": 6.1484878832772978, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.7271850643551296, + "CVC4": 8.5404373988958415, + "CVC3": 6.4074380953745891, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.77801808745353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.38761181434335 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.232571717425218, + "veriT": 12.447608520102536, + "Yices": 12.255943454103262, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.950980616812961, + "CVC4": 14.481090701216159, + "CVC3": 9.7119655039368613, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.235845737918645, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.701439027066803 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 121, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 5.0, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 31.0, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.33469894175172499, + "veriT": 4.365684698338927, + "Yices": 4.3718938417910689, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.91916457436812493, + "CVC4": 1.9467900490890846, + "CVC3": 1.8092373768455501, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6473050976723882, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6441875590886856 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9980886165494596, + "veriT": 14.241349428094047, + "Yices": 5.9853949843635421, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.0209661055329882, + "CVC4": 3.2885070928554549, + "CVC3": 3.4241080977459881, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7169195218674203, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.746342664016399 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1235998704915895, + "veriT": 11.915030130802418, + "Yices": 12.986562585881718, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.8414806679811733, + "CVC4": 14.450956400313894, + "CVC3": 9.6534130675200025, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.981915821522664, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9787537329727591 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 85.5, + "true": 124 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.831665310421785, + "veriT": 11.840898108035839, + "Yices": 11.111327676964384, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.965983933694702, + "CVC4": 10.801372103724344, + "CVC3": 8.8776255841243721, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.606511066719026, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.352097873681791 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.30801007349230003, + "veriT": 9.1878570743891483, + "Yices": 9.8038535739219306, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3605815638588001, + "CVC4": 10.129536497428946, + "CVC3": 4.8099390707924004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.560256043898447, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.54253397908837 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "false": 144, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 23.5, + "true": 127 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 49.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "iff", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 90.0, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.259880458031684, + "veriT": 11.804286555112226, + "Yices": 11.863930601243151, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.516447943759271, + "CVC4": 14.431292094754639, + "CVC3": 13.550668774592364, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.767775194902224, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.850949677510837 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 191.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.1843656845140664, + "veriT": 13.23263831728617, + "Yices": 13.24274229495102, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.376921620400902, + "CVC4": 14.657448622002198, + "CVC3": 10.053371495218038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.261884635857353, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.80810083780708 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 2.0, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.249314850515919, + "veriT": 11.08061491886167, + "Yices": 14.414588050742475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.971596007176796, + "CVC4": 14.633414279167146, + "CVC3": 13.876843315884457, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.180006611834671, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.193248741982964 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.186898099160095, + "veriT": 13.856947233881494, + "Yices": 13.315942755169003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.144269890543818, + "CVC4": 14.373660122272037, + "CVC3": 12.849946285789743, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.197964232401695, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.028147668972229 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.8679377815189913, + "veriT": 14.217127995559252, + "Yices": 13.855713809522916, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.117582808234621, + "CVC4": 14.40428442537562, + "CVC3": 12.055026062088434, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7957432290088633, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7945142985515652 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.038302231432965, + "veriT": 11.719139844619615, + "Yices": 10.648422916962661, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.17583571424746, + "CVC4": 11.131233330246543, + "CVC3": 7.48076859194442, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.9906270728369932, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.4115778806962869 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 57.5, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.9316363386424076, + "veriT": 11.954598546548558, + "Yices": 13.541270098726244, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.021175972725556, + "CVC4": 13.858943346066697, + "CVC3": 12.829693489090175, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.3999243132998334, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3131008245073332 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "false": 143, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 211.0, + "true": 142 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7437981487901171, + "veriT": 13.042974150006811, + "Yices": 11.084583399964737, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7205087335246017, + "CVC4": 6.5593369847056193, + "CVC3": 13.139704076297514, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.2151226404786382, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.2201833291140805 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.921310076418351, + "veriT": 12.89714740323357, + "Yices": 12.956327621385137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.399438363703291, + "CVC4": 14.441905392630408, + "CVC3": 13.937996666044954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.203916011416283, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.921522987802037 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.69059265110792, + "veriT": 14.247496525059688, + "Yices": 13.60831543727743, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.982442202280897, + "CVC4": 14.867303727651997, + "CVC3": 14.249288702263835, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.273994658269684, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.269370413433736 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.270422818336431, + "veriT": 13.771371187545528, + "Yices": 14.023362503666316, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 15.077307539702922, + "CVC4": 14.562855517342468, + "CVC3": 13.085258053135092, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.351867806446934, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.018028510506037 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 106, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 5, + "type": "node", + "feature": "true", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.11346546655272306, + "veriT": 0.46552472091257313, + "Yices": 0.47047726888173852, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12084660644650383, + "CVC4": 0.64697056012736376, + "CVC3": 0.087825681454299989, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.64609799034900073, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.64523707534876251 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12110151921859262, + "veriT": 0.091273769586448172, + "Yices": 0.092462248041548137, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.11884296724281482, + "CVC4": 0.1205906955492963, + "CVC3": 0.09680831380822591, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.11742181221881481, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11555694511222223 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9698371728233939, + "veriT": 2.843289386193947, + "Yices": 4.6993828304878944, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1067687358881146, + "CVC4": 2.3033770964593989, + "CVC3": 2.254737959347564, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.85487176215883665, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2952340921277967 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "false": 43, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 8 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 10 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 18.5, + "true": 11 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 24, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 15, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.5357145071029663, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6051631266012731, + "veriT": 4.6106380451994022, + "Yices": 5.6897556600975872, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.3914423274994312, + "CVC4": 1.6501445284701384, + "CVC3": 2.7407815365617703, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1037185202808999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.459789150844891 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 23, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "false": 20, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 17 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 19, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.125, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8405744282401901, + "veriT": 9.9133238757364559, + "Yices": 9.2734736097443236, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.077069659313695, + "CVC4": 8.4219571772442468, + "CVC3": 9.2719995462364508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5328218986004405, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.423799722066711 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.575561340831298, + "veriT": 11.125137370847206, + "Yices": 10.998287932880523, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.15027625327617, + "CVC4": 7.155221583561393, + "CVC3": 11.102123840953817, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0944531501963901, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.895516108815132 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 21 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237473078369142, + "veriT": 10.162579630986889, + "Yices": 10.323684071129444, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.953055959353113, + "CVC4": 0.16557425633455553, + "CVC3": 13.746874853357339, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.022661779991441, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.217857195291575 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.731287655777146, + "veriT": 10.667703359496105, + "Yices": 10.50729387880375, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.35306582076521, + "CVC4": 2.0558543688418305, + "CVC3": 11.47342667756751, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.2800948854231313, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.000245515542725 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.8006061139190792, + "veriT": 5.8207912748408326, + "Yices": 6.9968548861711133, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.0832166695866059, + "CVC4": 0.62301004099266655, + "CVC3": 7.1878793507809284, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4591792159637302, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3248248397668014 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.4847479009824442, + "veriT": 9.7460426450892221, + "Yices": 5.6028096161559766, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9057622820555551, + "CVC4": 6.1178031706221496, + "CVC3": 3.5579688974856669, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3933049677667118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.3904513341101215 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14458632326514284, + "veriT": 0.12467523241652857, + "Yices": 0.13314953823492856, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13329213338552856, + "CVC4": 0.16817860151742856, + "CVC3": 0.15734166633517144, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.20371305877100002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.19197815218338571 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.3350782307636655, + "veriT": 9.2374018846630594, + "Yices": 9.7772884692140707, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.7196270619427005, + "CVC4": 6.0507258900385965, + "CVC3": 5.0845369214292013, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.0721843123472947, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.0985229994802719 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.898825592918298, + "veriT": 13.092037392347807, + "Yices": 9.5393321941747651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.816094080549627, + "CVC4": 11.579622472290946, + "CVC3": 10.460265818721545, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.9350832103046436, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.520625380790815 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243825437020515, + "veriT": 10.158297019251572, + "Yices": 10.351652172726572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960251020668712, + "CVC4": 0.17786102021364286, + "CVC3": 14.770202180642693, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.95738535451547, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.442702678637273 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 33, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 25.5, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.17747863670830769, + "veriT": 9.5084690074779719, + "Yices": 6.6682195323281821, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.35941394940569221, + "CVC4": 2.3492007471995162, + "CVC3": 5.268234745912725, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.0881997024615162, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.0762217019580265 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "false": 39, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0717949867248535, + "true": 34 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 35 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1903357850970995, + "veriT": 11.531151306513149, + "Yices": 8.7592805188629992, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.5048622586344695, + "CVC4": 0.19939652497300003, + "CVC3": 7.5374101383349785, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1901259781646933, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.0811846823077893 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.880031137420689, + "veriT": 13.537508673985473, + "Yices": 12.354421921956297, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.557889511045524, + "CVC4": 9.1937598230621571, + "CVC3": 8.3363240136638428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2158261656159368, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7465694259349496 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.30123508812444444, + "veriT": 8.6170566733990857, + "Yices": 3.3165968047130807, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.4939503624143473, + "CVC4": 3.5468227499285145, + "CVC3": 2.6901227290332934, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.7407291151798172, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9722308154491368 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5048179157322306, + "veriT": 10.47733005979963, + "Yices": 1.2341949323016788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.574276562724692, + "CVC4": 1.2574530723719604, + "CVC3": 0.96692773661973852, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.239910848019873, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.25389629266876 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "false": 42, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 41 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.5720778288346668, + "veriT": 14.223568850243129, + "Yices": 9.9630794451692957, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0185918080182716, + "CVC4": 8.6086630910643667, + "CVC3": 6.9100776513569304, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.996275403608735, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.030088971144659 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.553467768359283, + "veriT": 14.223578086335573, + "Yices": 12.136699229072121, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.94031253376051, + "CVC4": 13.428622262145671, + "CVC3": 12.812119689298214, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.006015646266786, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.005629947100841 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6939799785614014, + "true": 44 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.69210164128144203, + "veriT": 10.166302027329689, + "Yices": 10.34569857375886, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.78916236737175616, + "CVC4": 0.15012398503613797, + "CVC3": 0.63694327102403459, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14920330717393102, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.131271169717108 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 14.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 49, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.245283767369656, + "veriT": 10.166526000819715, + "Yices": 10.34499206271693, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962567595489491, + "CVC4": 0.15637499127621426, + "CVC3": 11.598230311636218, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.9236112472883702, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.474299884776951 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.8826695537179017, + "veriT": 7.8359540571207411, + "Yices": 6.9059131456081664, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0362404655618889, + "CVC4": 2.6341913692411834, + "CVC3": 6.0205908985980967, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.4992911640432269, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.4749754029376447 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.440239463030549, + "veriT": 11.542588592925236, + "Yices": 10.14791258132086, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.408396652627077, + "CVC4": 11.186792882331167, + "CVC3": 11.511525316660197, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.252718957701985, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.658650172653317 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 52 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 85, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 55 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 11.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.4226188659667969, + "true": 57 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 59 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.3031620175925687, + "veriT": 7.5355615644154534, + "Yices": 8.7988792379628435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3522208287569599, + "CVC4": 5.0772872764362198, + "CVC3": 4.4011626310005143, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4674810065311554, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0633525770222283 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 62, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.4181220795561229, + "veriT": 5.0029322202285069, + "Yices": 3.9188860265306076, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.4150483857217773, + "CVC4": 3.4907183494408573, + "CVC3": 2.0228374672131459, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.162124697756391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1558648000704212 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.79108734748811205, + "veriT": 0.24022704948631815, + "Yices": 1.9165610559763777, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1886737028770804, + "CVC4": 0.16641393909031818, + "CVC3": 0.13962315480096363, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14125945537272727, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.14058366006920908 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0954544544219971, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "false": 66, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 65 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.6563565147713855, + "veriT": 6.4419177729087647, + "Yices": 7.3877309202917143, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7866111298788576, + "CVC4": 6.1950805322231828, + "CVC3": 0.23684402774238575, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1653276078300916, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.3734630120592026 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9795798966601206, + "veriT": 10.580052582994218, + "Yices": 10.22007362022476, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8907597696977483, + "CVC4": 7.6981346949106673, + "CVC3": 7.9969503578583403, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.607445286699978, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.626678983597394 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "false": 69, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 68 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.3693157486061662, + "veriT": 6.4082896914696672, + "Yices": 9.932275861978594, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.63547964863584605, + "CVC4": 6.7047222449848913, + "CVC3": 3.8327296570376705, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.24149007458492305, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.9543681871362477 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15866896634542857, + "veriT": 1.5672871651217142, + "Yices": 3.0059217259138569, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.15338155584228572, + "CVC4": 2.2993756643072101, + "CVC3": 0.153217593269, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1815919499503278, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.1801022663610259 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.3668540900595554, + "veriT": 9.0453199847986916, + "Yices": 8.6838623149255945, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.4529991413761616, + "CVC4": 6.2004960345011639, + "CVC3": 4.9986598064900676, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.64929617145906, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.375692252748404 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 15.0, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.3749253640833627, + "veriT": 8.4442945529124547, + "Yices": 8.8455504383564278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.291335843578414, + "CVC4": 13.387779540751055, + "CVC3": 3.3278866566885719, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.702923424842052, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.424487952205393 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "false": 75, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 74 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14081137249799999, + "veriT": 0.11630392453423333, + "Yices": 2.5618188448113126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.14923488045649999, + "CVC4": 2.510803342447081, + "CVC3": 1.8244493251850002, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.8656599403878333, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.8630770839161668 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.1781203638707458, + "veriT": 10.473383739799967, + "Yices": 5.2042380508188435, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.353074912681512, + "CVC4": 5.6051796438272516, + "CVC3": 4.4157565290550318, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.717528183315492, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.537693560652754 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 77 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 79, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 10.0, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4215434804681248, + "veriT": 0.15634312454050001, + "Yices": 3.1888112734022731, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.4401081362982502, + "CVC4": 1.9351251298980339, + "CVC3": 0.18016118614787499, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.3388489493945, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.567377087365579 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 44.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16472534382849999, + "veriT": 0.14321026112350002, + "Yices": 0.1572148667555833, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16487859206416666, + "CVC4": 0.19398729338475004, + "CVC3": 0.16746560648850004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17671891091733335, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17947280941458332 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16492681336266665, + "veriT": 2.3836337039457374, + "Yices": 0.15045139053083334, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16550430094416665, + "CVC4": 0.18298865808250001, + "CVC3": 0.16125799090883333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17275278901933336, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1719020855175 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 84, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1580040454864502, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23583132284341668, + "veriT": 6.0366765339293664, + "Yices": 13.598086253110353, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.37821727237516667, + "CVC4": 1.4265910286771526, + "CVC3": 0.23957703676200001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.22992948643440828, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.23018502079433331 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.177637553802, + "veriT": 2.2010322278524521, + "Yices": 6.1996002034878908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.18555439098814283, + "CVC4": 2.2338563499412771, + "CVC3": 5.9906244695993154, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.772266071035836, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8505352726824826 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 87, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 36.0, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10113064848885557, + "veriT": 5.628705046840655, + "Yices": 5.6290593901553336, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1002707608354, + "CVC4": 6.3695400800128716, + "CVC3": 2.3862028781969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7872879640554526, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.813307406545722 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 41.0, + "true": 88 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.476540920846398, + "veriT": 3.1354463400094925, + "Yices": 5.5772322653247475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.537315671794518, + "CVC4": 13.252968167964058, + "CVC3": 1.8369794222784617, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17414970428176924, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.031315836592209 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0948353148208962, + "veriT": 6.2443324926547197, + "Yices": 2.3169602550296, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3701747320844468, + "CVC4": 10.839369649991458, + "CVC3": 2.8232855751515999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.8182754617344354, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8129787339151546 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "false": 92, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.9455881118774414, + "true": 91 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.1054788525581629, + "veriT": 7.4563643184522794, + "Yices": 5.1158527278500001, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.1629894611377445, + "CVC4": 0.31378272367416665, + "CVC3": 1.1006365975173333, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.5274702723176468, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.5250897445907139 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.3182495607935687, + "veriT": 9.6172926004304706, + "Yices": 9.7785091530919814, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.2848713088990689, + "CVC4": 13.919944769853874, + "CVC3": 11.560653180901074, + "Z3-4.4.1": 9.7925835593236723, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.7650595069489032 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4320870752025714, + "veriT": 2.1297342527722645, + "Yices": 15.15096003945251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4262377280555709, + "CVC4": 14.567470073294134, + "CVC3": 10.830307812430902, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.18791492252071432, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.18226734310971429 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.9054547055274065, + "veriT": 9.3615406976225515, + "Yices": 10.261890032233079, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6178671456139675, + "CVC4": 3.4094566921439586, + "CVC3": 4.7559148266026661, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.7922921078840441, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.351275738597125 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 99 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 101, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.9781745388021914, + "veriT": 10.186767633039246, + "Yices": 10.309600673780889, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.3545660336929455, + "CVC4": 14.433994546973249, + "CVC3": 10.986333517458103, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.981532829590984, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.690087642006882 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.42034470385103, + "veriT": 6.7885848055583429, + "Yices": 8.6335852085041545, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5452828093128703, + "CVC4": 10.911157441856117, + "CVC3": 4.7794653927660802, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.86114205048779, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.5534289827833812 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 103 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18055383353922222, + "veriT": 13.30854880152557, + "Yices": 8.4484642613580956, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.69166486504399993, + "CVC4": 0.81299390755133327, + "CVC3": 7.967068878430366, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9804648816012262, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9744998481668983 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.9791191492828628, + "veriT": 12.688261539052371, + "Yices": 11.91590791847708, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0979412898967498, + "CVC4": 11.030918903782601, + "CVC3": 10.686887325382203, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.360894133170341, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.364152956512774 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.7256477767043075, + "veriT": 9.5304088852493809, + "Yices": 3.630762800669284, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3218515534698889, + "CVC4": 4.9447822813660007, + "CVC3": 1.0214706202874788, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5166707743201111, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.5079972995212554 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 130, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "false": 110, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 109 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.247797230643227, + "veriT": 10.90319423891339, + "Yices": 10.494813583158036, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968145347713039, + "CVC4": 13.686260642768159, + "CVC3": 13.750339759670954, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.755633010367022, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.576255639442179 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 17.0, + "true": 111 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.4460767612558669, + "veriT": 11.995500245274599, + "Yices": 12.649956968278262, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.95067447772143, + "CVC4": 14.639585292409301, + "CVC3": 13.341054986189853, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.240550366035306, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.238021317365547 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.954229695119615, + "veriT": 14.223122583418013, + "Yices": 8.3723549302615901, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5816379304623114, + "CVC4": 6.328529549963724, + "CVC3": 1.2840942163583999, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.047638872631936, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.01471892837993 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 23.0, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 115 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "false": 117, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 72.5, + "true": 116 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.221019519592959, + "veriT": 12.358261708543578, + "Yices": 11.452311275805949, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.13206298178666, + "CVC4": 2.1563715344357455, + "CVC3": 3.8471759957245464, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.578873576613368, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.572243745581881 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 119, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.5014148063699049, + "veriT": 7.4747510763022627, + "Yices": 3.0382317357382593, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.7925306393953253, + "CVC4": 1.7783370383233434, + "CVC3": 1.6811768576663446, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4460721997414367, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1875187796967979 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.4772161498841943, + "veriT": 14.250585104430984, + "Yices": 7.7010305688211229, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.2238993301537224, + "CVC4": 2.4956523027826361, + "CVC3": 2.4306366373938535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.377210256457214, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.3727702496624095 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 123, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.237691104416026, + "veriT": 13.309651737441204, + "Yices": 12.145932528421278, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4910558934231899, + "CVC4": 14.492548136743892, + "CVC3": 6.480142644022866, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.7833000527052798, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.7868000953815555 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.24365228372887271, + "veriT": 10.776315102490104, + "Yices": 5.151000392884705, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.3167716248864547, + "CVC4": 6.7252066652862306, + "CVC3": 6.7227157809010949, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.4552885623078118, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.4512381108138539 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 173.0, + "true": 125 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.1590644394637808, + "veriT": 14.211343613673124, + "Yices": 7.9282346474425145, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.843096822607396, + "CVC4": 8.4456845420842992, + "CVC3": 12.783692708508399, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9789945574936887, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9770287694851199 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.752304407333213, + "veriT": 11.841918653626772, + "Yices": 13.861504596626038, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.76307542253153, + "CVC4": 14.362644126341051, + "CVC3": 12.361165279425382, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.433744015429227, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.414719571647693 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 129, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 41.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.2394853302307, + "veriT": 14.231721681097969, + "Yices": 13.227905739377062, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.961950985100328, + "CVC4": 14.420219669318842, + "CVC3": 14.235832475320997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.259430948185871, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.254748255694683 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.887434772077896, + "veriT": 12.818281797273062, + "Yices": 13.328499410933635, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.534315024259683, + "CVC4": 14.728702271938774, + "CVC3": 12.294551556744263, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3520589274528083, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.6791702631353598 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 140, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 26.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "false", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 132 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 133 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "false": 137, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 22.5, + "true": 134 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.253414848286498, + "veriT": 10.959020276682901, + "Yices": 13.998344359390792, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.9686209639948, + "CVC4": 14.548066858894327, + "CVC3": 13.950024571889877, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.885169901953635, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.84674321668909 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.257214611147072, + "veriT": 10.2177213769852, + "Yices": 10.390046250980101, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.974271846990689, + "CVC4": 14.509944033416406, + "CVC3": 12.923358802806851, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.990250152247205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.847016943075989 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.223991071847633, + "veriT": 13.658856158262527, + "Yices": 14.236215005299247, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.968085093450716, + "CVC4": 14.327409494920845, + "CVC3": 11.271188827432429, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.736626427952009, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.250760674874757 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.1672651263662654, + "veriT": 14.231364801567649, + "Yices": 14.058167284319874, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960874271907528, + "CVC4": 14.524160028499773, + "CVC3": 12.133306258322181, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247896203921071, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.248574769325971 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.764809682284715, + "veriT": 13.421601668451151, + "Yices": 12.405314068179552, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.213640540466626, + "CVC4": 7.6563591654435328, + "CVC3": 14.250610379975001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.799314081732774, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.75483145213339 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 441.5, + "true": 141 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8531212722533352, + "veriT": 14.240409657451844, + "Yices": 14.242902166421448, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.740013140682629, + "CVC4": 12.00511615143053, + "CVC3": 13.013462550222091, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.3194570057004125, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.3457202446862153 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.261990048355788, + "veriT": 13.816872033150025, + "Yices": 13.641444225306691, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.979102158358703, + "CVC4": 14.743816391044241, + "CVC3": 14.273559486221282, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.36296001823, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.070642118172415 + } + ], + [ + { + "index": 0, + "false": 116, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 56.5, + "true": 1 + }, + { + "index": 1, + "false": 11, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 2 + }, + { + "index": 2, + "false": 8, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 3 + }, + { + "index": 3, + "false": 7, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 4 + }, + { + "index": 4, + "false": 6, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 5 + }, + { + "index": 5, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12726621434766666, + "veriT": 0.098398230067373332, + "Yices": 0.10066385503234666, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12444715590893332, + "CVC4": 0.12462118113973332, + "CVC3": 0.10290564574508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.1229862956696, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.11998553813914668 + }, + { + "index": 6, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.10807645807678125, + "veriT": 0.69968303888685623, + "Yices": 0.70297952493886251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.1191791889621, + "CVC4": 0.98104816214789725, + "CVC3": 0.080525515569474987, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.97761196633948866, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.97698378136040176 + }, + { + "index": 7, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.9713139341559711, + "veriT": 0.93729989925708335, + "Yices": 1.8032528358441831, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.0220342433189331, + "CVC4": 0.13855239484666668, + "CVC3": 1.2896599668649262, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.13065776747416666, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3197145528929783 + }, + { + "index": 8, + "false": 10, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 9 + }, + { + "index": 9, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8951385911348755, + "veriT": 10.16397454152456, + "Yices": 10.34747051491788, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.0268914705279437, + "CVC4": 0.14942358101864003, + "CVC3": 0.71576699576876013, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14853517121120002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.429163686225765 + }, + { + "index": 10, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.19448996569037499, + "veriT": 8.9095685536001241, + "Yices": 10.496109901171499, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.32877652148912501, + "CVC4": 0.15137577750299999, + "CVC3": 0.29003521434137502, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.15011894986650001, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0412355298625116 + }, + { + "index": 11, + "false": 77, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 12 + }, + { + "index": 12, + "false": 74, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 13 + }, + { + "index": 13, + "false": 41, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.8660714626312256, + "true": 14 + }, + { + "index": 14, + "false": 38, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_quants", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 15 + }, + { + "index": 15, + "false": 17, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 16 + }, + { + "index": 16, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.0113316665725991, + "veriT": 8.3484255682053039, + "Yices": 9.5520120305648923, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.893076872325028, + "CVC4": 11.144658362634402, + "CVC3": 7.0428537966646196, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.705052432372655, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3650566040187417 + }, + { + "index": 17, + "false": 31, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 18 + }, + { + "index": 18, + "false": 22, + "type": "node", + "feature": "size", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 19 + }, + { + "index": 19, + "false": 21, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 20 + }, + { + "index": 20, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.103374893618481, + "veriT": 8.6361312378400008, + "Yices": 10.345230625285078, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.719751249505711, + "CVC4": 0.1685123489683846, + "CVC3": 10.787606776805969, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.5863787411118455, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.351719318404404 + }, + { + "index": 21, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.5458090455288107, + "veriT": 5.7458679423130006, + "Yices": 6.9818339265107774, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.138896080439368, + "CVC4": 0.16956541892988886, + "CVC3": 0.86725779106622225, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6297890850740115, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.018333312986417 + }, + { + "index": 22, + "false": 30, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 8.5, + "true": 23 + }, + { + "index": 23, + "false": 29, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 24 + }, + { + "index": 24, + "false": 28, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 25 + }, + { + "index": 25, + "false": 27, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 26 + }, + { + "index": 26, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.241986316342233, + "veriT": 10.151817702700273, + "Yices": 10.324798358758727, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.960937796923444, + "CVC4": 0.15417171726090906, + "CVC3": 11.350457726724578, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.2018616429732256, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.319191328939256 + }, + { + "index": 27, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.65875519215929, + "veriT": 10.739968190823404, + "Yices": 10.533443120500857, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.268995426954637, + "CVC4": 2.2764616022515205, + "CVC3": 10.555114501153428, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1559425460822332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.675735161298508 + }, + { + "index": 28, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.824368633746841, + "veriT": 10.850319157535639, + "Yices": 10.600803887895628, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.151626792190953, + "CVC4": 2.5730639187246074, + "CVC3": 9.9353107109637762, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8462976632360713, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.665568239038338 + }, + { + "index": 29, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.237390037112021, + "veriT": 10.149729083284221, + "Yices": 10.328096904335556, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.962288608397804, + "CVC4": 0.14939411457166668, + "CVC3": 14.237650917984048, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14219217703611109, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.265080604701275 + }, + { + "index": 30, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.187307699556362, + "veriT": 8.8921797028975504, + "Yices": 10.742041778412199, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.63554421061542, + "CVC4": 0.34866144285575001, + "CVC3": 10.510937943915406, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.7910451497454081, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.0250148177578664 + }, + { + "index": 31, + "false": 35, + "type": "node", + "feature": "divisor", + "threshold": 12.0, + "true": 32 + }, + { + "index": 32, + "false": 34, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 1.6904764175415039, + "true": 33 + }, + { + "index": 33, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.4292490929079067, + "veriT": 11.672685421108959, + "Yices": 9.1178385075161241, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.6162936441291178, + "CVC4": 5.6051506312489714, + "CVC3": 9.1834515712602851, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.086202712756597, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.4949333683688044 + }, + { + "index": 34, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.9562710532114149, + "veriT": 6.9349775499019088, + "Yices": 4.1559669050585004, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.0898218231750318, + "CVC4": 2.2140570218100999, + "CVC3": 3.040162751223968, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.0184016309431825, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.0079547000095257 + }, + { + "index": 35, + "false": 37, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 36 + }, + { + "index": 36, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5949718260789751, + "veriT": 10.626812314405781, + "Yices": 10.360150439151999, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.727944525986697, + "CVC4": 2.0158778401525139, + "CVC3": 6.4210098005562397, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.464179589700899, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.599938594148719 + }, + { + "index": 37, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.085890767983518, + "veriT": 10.970346818632366, + "Yices": 9.9774423550428573, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.866168821577858, + "CVC4": 6.3361318848014365, + "CVC3": 12.17425029907497, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.1374397556916751, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.9139267607752508 + }, + { + "index": 38, + "false": 40, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 6.0, + "true": 39 + }, + { + "index": 39, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.486971321290996, + "veriT": 13.122716560555558, + "Yices": 11.931064013788832, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.208900681378013, + "CVC4": 14.836478590110261, + "CVC3": 12.562524192769535, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.231771688116783, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.232336583683965 + }, + { + "index": 40, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.5799800305292111, + "veriT": 10.714235869299731, + "Yices": 10.811609814668005, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.725995417109472, + "CVC4": 8.0432082114557542, + "CVC3": 4.8202464496487352, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.2813060872089643, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.6326438151302733 + }, + { + "index": 41, + "false": 71, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 42 + }, + { + "index": 42, + "false": 44, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 43 + }, + { + "index": 43, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.3931073665624023, + "veriT": 11.915036825425846, + "Yices": 12.106649654990067, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.6157686697176548, + "CVC4": 12.002477726316839, + "CVC3": 9.5052552376750832, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.736014120432595, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.555264936718459 + }, + { + "index": 44, + "false": 46, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 45 + }, + { + "index": 45, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.12733370941262856, + "veriT": 6.3908599388385872, + "Yices": 6.3952010233271226, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.12207815126102142, + "CVC4": 0.84557006391867151, + "CVC3": 0.87743194471465713, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.1199490958760345, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1094416368122697 + }, + { + "index": 46, + "false": 52, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 47 + }, + { + "index": 47, + "false": 51, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 48 + }, + { + "index": 48, + "false": 50, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 49 + }, + { + "index": 49, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.321982830626201, + "veriT": 11.017263633310874, + "Yices": 10.862377528977451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.476980164912835, + "CVC4": 7.7850852899103016, + "CVC3": 12.296919677613431, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.4022798726057797, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.111206199820918 + }, + { + "index": 50, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1533583412766113, + "veriT": 6.4827372105790211, + "Yices": 13.002988906591206, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.0654772995031667, + "CVC4": 5.1292742341086681, + "CVC3": 10.587779977766642, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.0094066640935129, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9729401199416685 + }, + { + "index": 51, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1447834222541371, + "veriT": 0.83756405843246429, + "Yices": 4.3798828680244517, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.1940577818922338, + "CVC4": 2.1711873692511312, + "CVC3": 2.2002996343960288, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.17195806950550002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.97213829728138035 + }, + { + "index": 52, + "false": 60, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 7.5, + "true": 53 + }, + { + "index": 53, + "false": 55, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 54 + }, + { + "index": 54, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.9610103985873177, + "veriT": 10.382097846930854, + "Yices": 7.3358230828210651, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.3563917701935448, + "CVC4": 1.7511021047172133, + "CVC3": 7.5820548067874718, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.738904216181143, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.8894410223160634 + }, + { + "index": 55, + "false": 57, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 56 + }, + { + "index": 56, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.173016261852108, + "veriT": 11.324598626039002, + "Yices": 10.660031405947349, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.35701281828511, + "CVC4": 11.744642176616892, + "CVC3": 11.455615104726855, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.809034465903258, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.821891122540677 + }, + { + "index": 57, + "false": 59, + "type": "node", + "feature": "depth", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 58 + }, + { + "index": 58, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.795636274375533, + "veriT": 12.552495699961637, + "Yices": 11.37504030380275, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.0621956464941782, + "CVC4": 12.021215592331071, + "CVC3": 9.9335387065112997, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.221654612978403, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.220570915828393 + }, + { + "index": 59, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.16392806120366665, + "veriT": 8.4578213604638321, + "Yices": 8.4864400752103339, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.22219454362316668, + "CVC4": 7.2009898804749142, + "CVC3": 1.9495789497285001, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.7912169637040565, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.8011002778432088 + }, + { + "index": 60, + "false": 68, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 61 + }, + { + "index": 61, + "false": 63, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 62 + }, + { + "index": 62, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5633309500262396, + "veriT": 6.9391162220756391, + "Yices": 5.2142253712588813, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.8273297809950044, + "CVC4": 0.15826283522675, + "CVC3": 8.6704497055901086, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1167553180356071, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.3485021660721781 + }, + { + "index": 63, + "false": 65, + "type": "node", + "feature": "impl", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 64 + }, + { + "index": 64, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.23522101521200001, + "veriT": 0.2832716964891, + "Yices": 6.6621743167451815, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.3014146473111001, + "CVC4": 3.0124346729446505, + "CVC3": 0.21713038365640003, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.3881165516501621, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.5291871887614308 + }, + { + "index": 65, + "false": 67, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 4.0, + "true": 66 + }, + { + "index": 66, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.6394275917043633, + "veriT": 4.493083430555143, + "Yices": 10.350318949491475, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.6157963950081662, + "CVC4": 2.4597063975709368, + "CVC3": 3.3279811208035714, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.1982948217350242, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.9549752657144284 + }, + { + "index": 67, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.2189980567960887, + "veriT": 10.118451514750671, + "Yices": 10.120404823525414, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.966637459338509, + "CVC4": 12.058328230850398, + "CVC3": 6.1878510230474486, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.821730781196804, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.834683849819969 + }, + { + "index": 68, + "false": 70, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 17.5, + "true": 69 + }, + { + "index": 69, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.361939360018507, + "veriT": 13.256202306840411, + "Yices": 10.59844278873855, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5045283051689502, + "CVC4": 8.9636759610577617, + "CVC3": 8.8001405351561015, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.94297556955598, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.953618365157293 + }, + { + "index": 70, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5413869749394795, + "veriT": 10.828286360442803, + "Yices": 10.4247534179705, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 10.025401063352726, + "CVC4": 5.0282016756748922, + "CVC3": 4.907401670482094, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.382257864666661, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 8.605120535692997 + }, + { + "index": 71, + "false": 73, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 72 + }, + { + "index": 72, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.8909886888018743, + "veriT": 13.131903516413308, + "Yices": 12.482535683466526, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.8694177567087689, + "CVC4": 13.557760548989124, + "CVC3": 12.210582294819707, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.627184781747861, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.624597265407264 + }, + { + "index": 73, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.8289120022440768, + "veriT": 4.6574692325837903, + "Yices": 12.677734074712157, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.8710997951099628, + "CVC4": 11.899446773221436, + "CVC3": 12.223939264402532, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8234400794139454, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.8019258650814072 + }, + { + "index": 74, + "false": 76, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 13.5, + "true": 75 + }, + { + "index": 75, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.2420670914588887, + "veriT": 9.5125455670953123, + "Yices": 1.6554459502810155, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2371661868476669, + "CVC4": 1.2657382502957779, + "CVC3": 1.2320985991865554, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.6632130388747912, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.6612123609358491 + }, + { + "index": 76, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.9162637518127692, + "veriT": 14.212431024781782, + "Yices": 2.9082337355319909, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.0018913006659231, + "CVC4": 4.705083284215938, + "CVC3": 5.5558318714883139, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.219175674933648, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.190713919463548 + }, + { + "index": 77, + "false": 105, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 78 + }, + { + "index": 78, + "false": 82, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 79 + }, + { + "index": 79, + "false": 81, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 80 + }, + { + "index": 80, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.895372210284476, + "veriT": 9.1653013681260482, + "Yices": 9.0579016070894998, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.486949345011098, + "CVC4": 2.6246245231060343, + "CVC3": 13.020626708437042, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.5001873016842686, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.9555854137013799 + }, + { + "index": 81, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.1958181329500013, + "veriT": 8.8997615097082488, + "Yices": 11.415173777847251, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.5588325118085207, + "CVC4": 0.17476244834075, + "CVC3": 6.9609039461976439, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.6689709809622788, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.931595669121025 + }, + { + "index": 82, + "false": 104, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 83 + }, + { + "index": 83, + "false": 91, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.0486116409301758, + "true": 84 + }, + { + "index": 84, + "false": 90, + "type": "node", + "feature": "if", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 85 + }, + { + "index": 85, + "false": 89, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 62.5, + "true": 86 + }, + { + "index": 86, + "false": 88, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 18.0, + "true": 87 + }, + { + "index": 87, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.13982265835846153, + "veriT": 0.11335326686846152, + "Yices": 0.11873149051615385, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.13512737885599999, + "CVC4": 0.14678551699153847, + "CVC3": 0.1227420960466923, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.14524034890476922, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1444450446097692 + }, + { + "index": 88, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.14771517422709091, + "veriT": 3.2292554023383007, + "Yices": 6.71645927570572, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.16266737939581818, + "CVC4": 1.4462777958337518, + "CVC3": 0.14267165621173639, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.2842308904094909, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.1714738045117576 + }, + { + "index": 89, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.4426703234142852, + "veriT": 0.13218944481828571, + "Yices": 0.13346635432328571, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.4472975639847139, + "CVC4": 0.162155426445, + "CVC3": 0.1484298376952857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.41230742134757142, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.41246099260185715 + }, + { + "index": 90, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.3871922230817493, + "veriT": 2.6324831717261623, + "Yices": 3.0612932286851611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.3846081471831742, + "CVC4": 12.621726042149154, + "CVC3": 1.4329106497406374, + "Z3-4.4.1": 3.609257526944087, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 3.6166490274959671 + }, + { + "index": 91, + "false": 97, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1426150798797607, + "true": 92 + }, + { + "index": 92, + "false": 96, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1072793006896973, + "true": 93 + }, + { + "index": 93, + "false": 95, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 6.5, + "true": 94 + }, + { + "index": 94, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.6854193701516671, + "veriT": 8.7933060407912169, + "Yices": 5.667434171429111, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 5.6974767646186883, + "CVC4": 3.468372310309733, + "CVC3": 1.5893936626269798, + "Z3-4.4.1": 7.9578044577169482, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 7.9562560857904776 + }, + { + "index": 95, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.63328090463105258, + "veriT": 7.3782002644170399, + "Yices": 12.85768125121097, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.799203068376332, + "CVC4": 7.6523592016762967, + "CVC3": 1.7376611573896317, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.52077099413436845, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.38691276203421054 + }, + { + "index": 96, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.2922892761057856, + "veriT": 11.258838265069684, + "Yices": 11.401431406733675, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.159237702162896, + "CVC4": 8.4696830356501014, + "CVC3": 9.376759678156283, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5440372066050205, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.7363171972852287 + }, + { + "index": 97, + "false": 99, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.5, + "true": 98 + }, + { + "index": 98, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.8679499550666627, + "veriT": 3.0130409735932049, + "Yices": 10.656277513493908, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.2785160465759695, + "CVC4": 6.0471306591928951, + "CVC3": 4.1554354041383004, + "Z3-4.4.1": 5.500836160121418, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.4902050694760902 + }, + { + "index": 99, + "false": 103, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.2523808479309082, + "true": 100 + }, + { + "index": 100, + "false": 102, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 38.5, + "true": 101 + }, + { + "index": 101, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15271066655599999, + "veriT": 0.13127277416825001, + "Yices": 0.14996344283175, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.148103416639875, + "CVC4": 0.17896991467487497, + "CVC3": 0.15107363590625, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16801934327475002, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.1674850076545 + }, + { + "index": 102, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.15982262041174999, + "veriT": 8.8352778514342685, + "Yices": 1.9389280592707128, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.175289457028, + "CVC4": 0.18797994857350001, + "CVC3": 0.16507291539374996, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16911375794424999, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17014673271074998 + }, + { + "index": 103, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.7104966663204246, + "veriT": 1.6461826246294284, + "Yices": 3.381420304879557, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 6.7044342892302096, + "CVC4": 4.3313165050212179, + "CVC3": 0.43098843697285716, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.249379758240583, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2459961432353359 + }, + { + "index": 104, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 5.9173369852585527, + "veriT": 9.0029602326748961, + "Yices": 7.3205918299409003, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4201537893537566, + "CVC4": 8.8285687793562424, + "CVC3": 7.4249712717234786, + "Z3-4.4.1": 11.44461994442765, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.971932697371098 + }, + { + "index": 105, + "false": 113, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 42.5, + "true": 106 + }, + { + "index": 106, + "false": 112, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_branches", + "threshold": 48.5, + "true": 107 + }, + { + "index": 107, + "false": 109, + "type": "node", + "feature": "wild", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 108 + }, + { + "index": 108, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.4113028850498031, + "veriT": 10.947057116805478, + "Yices": 10.820984252034398, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 4.3210658145361469, + "CVC4": 9.8138109354656038, + "CVC3": 8.013660124174308, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.060500491948817, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 11.622357128649666 + }, + { + "index": 109, + "false": 111, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 3.0, + "true": 110 + }, + { + "index": 110, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 1.1518945157588998, + "veriT": 14.20755294019528, + "Yices": 2.4245454116384, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 1.2114758441561, + "CVC4": 1.7720241155829837, + "CVC3": 1.5887443620407367, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.657447876793734, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.655910190116575 + }, + { + "index": 111, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.18478381837988889, + "veriT": 9.7173112208441204, + "Yices": 6.8057351679997611, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.36859549147711113, + "CVC4": 3.3809534804313395, + "CVC3": 4.5538533134683838, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.8459251450451681, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.84618211853644 + }, + { + "index": 112, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.188547573802125, + "veriT": 0.17520896975950001, + "Yices": 8.503474843960273, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 0.23654179800225, + "CVC4": 11.033911393895799, + "CVC3": 5.297099676375125, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.19392959857525, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.17982926810087499 + }, + { + "index": 113, + "false": 115, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_preds", + "threshold": 2.5, + "true": 114 + }, + { + "index": 114, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.659473047107296, + "veriT": 11.937117730334361, + "Yices": 11.968370619805871, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.289811072246474, + "CVC4": 12.704031619977121, + "CVC3": 12.583337360633463, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5743435023430692, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 5.8440686966144648 + }, + { + "index": 115, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.7889274883660589, + "veriT": 12.0650466254289, + "Yices": 12.389403954394377, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.4059533484609634, + "CVC4": 7.4670370094661678, + "CVC3": 6.8708589674991867, + "Z3-4.4.1": 12.782160412828235, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.70331018780421 + }, + { + "index": 116, + "false": 142, + "type": "node", + "feature": "let", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 117 + }, + { + "index": 117, + "false": 127, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 29.5, + "true": 118 + }, + { + "index": 118, + "false": 120, + "type": "node", + "feature": "func", + "threshold": 69.5, + "true": 119 + }, + { + "index": 119, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.7399706885062605, + "veriT": 12.993788245721568, + "Yices": 12.029568323121367, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 8.9604736241101683, + "CVC4": 9.8443635957029834, + "CVC3": 5.7395948004053912, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.214103303067711, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.212869806059315 + }, + { + "index": 120, + "false": 126, + "type": "node", + "feature": "case", + "threshold": 1.5, + "true": 121 + }, + { + "index": 121, + "false": 125, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 20.0, + "true": 122 + }, + { + "index": 122, + "false": 124, + "type": "node", + "feature": "int", + "threshold": 10.5, + "true": 123 + }, + { + "index": 123, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.243507569933548, + "veriT": 11.963418586966194, + "Yices": 10.971622758693407, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.96192353484259, + "CVC4": 14.657667802984207, + "CVC3": 11.506577055109595, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.320514524298019, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.909002982010046 + }, + { + "index": 124, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.250928638232182, + "veriT": 11.097438607147062, + "Yices": 10.667658806101555, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.97770705739749, + "CVC4": 13.016258427860095, + "CVC3": 14.253562417216703, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.247305145477863, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.650278894452306 + }, + { + "index": 125, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 9.5636229931639427, + "veriT": 11.49192131197672, + "Yices": 9.6536465168023451, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.32321433002557, + "CVC4": 14.494637102613686, + "CVC3": 14.218476597475247, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.389591750911332, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.770771634967685 + }, + { + "index": 126, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 6.2020601008898604, + "veriT": 14.221302369770333, + "Yices": 11.989848787863654, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.5213495449667302, + "CVC4": 12.865276784580864, + "CVC3": 8.1431819934148209, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.227156131158047, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 14.234463756730074 + }, + { + "index": 127, + "false": 139, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 4.5, + "true": 128 + }, + { + "index": 128, + "false": 134, + "type": "node", + "feature": "var", + "threshold": 169.0, + "true": 129 + }, + { + "index": 129, + "false": 133, + "type": "node", + "feature": "not", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 130 + }, + { + "index": 130, + "false": 132, + "type": "node", + "feature": "zero_ar", + "threshold": 0.5, + "true": 131 + }, + { + "index": 131, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 0.84958039424171428, + "veriT": 10.848699816783997, + "Yices": 9.0374731934675978, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 2.52903473042167, + "CVC4": 4.4864045801960613, + "CVC3": 1.646173615340857, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1922384467749847, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1895335470884749 + }, + { + "index": 132, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 4.1716795135960796, + "veriT": 11.713525611835443, + "Yices": 12.137729146749445, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.85012212486108, + "CVC4": 13.12344762643097, + "CVC3": 2.8426260717307672, + "Z3-4.4.1": 8.7714560806538451, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 9.415789321412058 + }, + { + "index": 133, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.1210190977138179, + "veriT": 7.4983470065821196, + "Yices": 0.85207566665754553, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 3.9302875462493834, + "CVC4": 0.50412171258754546, + "CVC3": 7.7900547471661277, + "Z3-4.4.1": 0.16914583358072724, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 0.16232048798527271 + }, + { + "index": 134, + "false": 136, + "type": "node", + "feature": "avg_op_arity", + "threshold": 2.1087884902954102, + "true": 135 + }, + { + "index": 135, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 10.176723949718015, + "veriT": 14.236371854999396, + "Yices": 11.882977368071868, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.74275400199612, + "CVC4": 2.9836770615691068, + "CVC3": 7.2526686031143006, + "Z3-4.4.1": 6.5871583107371698, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 6.5838554625208072 + }, + { + "index": 136, + "false": 138, + "type": "node", + "feature": "n_ops", + "threshold": 328.5, + "true": 137 + }, + { + "index": 137, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 2.6655621217978407, + "veriT": 9.4997168875663629, + "Yices": 14.237133095587136, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 7.58696583871175, + "CVC4": 14.496117130724159, + "CVC3": 12.254932125628544, + "Z3-4.4.1": 2.2621256575249391, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 2.2066783055321202 + }, + { + "index": 138, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 8.5462613144059461, + "veriT": 12.47337005942982, + "Yices": 12.523631255598787, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.593030241898845, + "CVC4": 12.845688301740031, + "CVC3": 14.169550249358741, + "Z3-4.4.1": 1.6283146935968573, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 1.3217075256107143 + }, + { + "index": 139, + "false": 141, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 52.0, + "true": 140 + }, + { + "index": 140, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 11.414042661695785, + "veriT": 12.388460252539236, + "Yices": 10.475165764870351, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 11.49533905149433, + "CVC4": 11.617922965364686, + "CVC3": 12.808077578698752, + "Z3-4.4.1": 4.1554882847614998, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 4.1944121396458884 + }, + { + "index": 141, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.644325314346014, + "veriT": 13.400657211470355, + "Yices": 13.405606664314789, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 13.55052607850385, + "CVC4": 14.418215363273461, + "CVC3": 13.553473377033651, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.074001020366296, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.177311809801143 + }, + { + "index": 142, + "false": 150, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 69.0, + "true": 143 + }, + { + "index": 143, + "false": 149, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 46.5, + "true": 144 + }, + { + "index": 144, + "false": 146, + "type": "node", + "feature": "forall", + "threshold": 5.5, + "true": 145 + }, + { + "index": 145, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 7.7228660237968674, + "veriT": 10.174700494218392, + "Yices": 10.072222312266181, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 9.7472193500978204, + "CVC4": 10.807777674775471, + "CVC3": 11.882070761040477, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.744701547979719, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.29476113633574 + }, + { + "index": 146, + "false": 148, + "type": "node", + "feature": "and", + "threshold": 29.0, + "true": 147 + }, + { + "index": 147, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 13.347984386679284, + "veriT": 10.956983270835922, + "Yices": 11.141607445659126, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.98538473879684, + "CVC4": 14.563123325248405, + "CVC3": 14.262056715287565, + "Z3-4.4.1": 14.276124156474935, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 12.701437507835255 + }, + { + "index": 148, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 12.765635438338036, + "veriT": 13.419852924088886, + "Yices": 14.163840466904144, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.048198269195684, + "CVC4": 14.572875302507205, + "CVC3": 10.7643860675038, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.778172088886356, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.904339365635206 + }, + { + "index": 149, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 3.8854739252335997, + "veriT": 13.437272030592977, + "Yices": 13.408086756140717, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 12.722283798697443, + "CVC4": 11.912710566297232, + "CVC3": 12.839225515426847, + "Z3-4.4.1": 10.508567384903776, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 10.116662416514277 + }, + { + "index": 150, + "Alt-Ergo-1.01": 14.26190609018577, + "veriT": 13.987847565994507, + "Yices": 13.879587858660916, + "Alt-Ergo-0.95.2": 14.681281851640346, + "CVC4": 13.67803422825347, + "CVC3": 14.262524321794508, + "Z3-4.4.1": 13.857474100314194, + "type": "leaf", + "Z3-4.3.2": 13.681141267253848 + } + ] +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/output_eval_files.py b/output_eval_files.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a851b30 --- /dev/null +++ b/output_eval_files.py @@ -0,0 +1,174 @@ +import json, common, itertools +import numpy as np +import pandas as pd +from pandas import DataFrame, Series +from sklearn import metrics +from sklearn.ensemble import RandomForestRegressor +from sklearn.tree import DecisionTreeRegressor +from subprocess import call +import matplotlib.pyplot as plt +import compare_regressors as cr + +""" +Outputs a number of files for evaluation + +Andrew Healy, Aug. 2016 +""" + +def tree_from_sklearn(dt, features, outputs): + + t = dt.tree_ + + nodes = [ {'index': i, + 'type':'node', + 'feature': features[t.feature[i]], + 'threshold': t.threshold[i], + 'true': t.children_left[i], + 'false': t.children_right[i] } + for i in xrange(t.node_count) ] + + for i, n in enumerate(nodes): + if n['false'] == -1: + temp = {} + temp['type'] = 'leaf' + temp['index'] = i + for j in xrange(dt.n_outputs_): + temp[ outputs[j] ] = t.value[i][j][0] + nodes[i] = temp + + return nodes + +def forest_from_sklearn(rf, features, outputs): + + return [ tree_from_sklearn(dt, features, outputs) + for dt in rf.estimators_ ] + +train = DataFrame.from_csv('whygoal_valid_test.csv').fillna(0) +rf = RandomForestRegressor(n_estimators=100,random_state=42,min_samples_leaf=5) +X = train.drop(common.IGNORE, axis=1) +y = {} +for p in common.PROVERS: + y[p] = train.apply(lambda x: + common.new_score_func_single(x[p+' result'], x[p+' time'], 10.0), + axis=1) + train[p] = y[p] + +y = DataFrame(y) +rf.fit(X, y) + +important = Series(rf.feature_importances_, index=X.columns).sort_values(ascending=False) +# attribute to tell how important the input variables are +# to the Random Forest when making decisions +print important +with open('feature_importances.txt','w') as out: + out.write(str(important)) + +f = forest_from_sklearn(rf, X.columns, y.columns) + +with open('forest.json', 'w') as jfile: + json.dump(f, jfile, indent=4, separators=(',',': ')) +print('forest written') + +test = DataFrame.from_csv('whygoal_test.csv').fillna(0) + +X_test = test.drop(common.IGNORE, axis=1) +y_test = {} +# how do the 8 solvers do on the test set? +for p in common.PROVERS: + y_test[p] = test.apply(lambda x: + common.new_score_func_single(x[p+' result'], x[p+' time'], 10.0), + axis=1) + test[p] = y_test[p] + print 'avg time for {}: {}'.format(p,test[p+' time'].mean()) + +y_test = DataFrame(y_test) +num_provable = test.apply(common.provable, axis=1).sum() +print '{}/{} are provable'.format(num_provable, test.shape[0]) + +# save the cost predictions for each goal +test = pd.concat([ test, + DataFrame(rf.predict(X_test), + columns=['Predicted '+c for c in y.columns], + index=X_test.index ).fillna(0) ], + axis=1) +# and turn them into rankings +predictions = DataFrame(rf.predict(X_test), columns=y.columns, index=X_test.index ).fillna(0) +pred_ranks = predictions.apply(common.get_strings, axis=1) + +actual = y_test.apply(common.get_strings, axis=1) +worst = actual.apply(lambda x: x[::-1]) + +output = { 'Valid':common.is_valid, + 'Invalid':common.is_invalid, + 'Unknown':common.is_unknown, + 'Timeout':common.is_timeout, + 'Failure':common.is_error} + +results = {p : + {o: test.apply(lambda ser: fun(ser[p+' result']), axis=1).sum() + for o, fun in output.iteritems() } + for p in common.PROVERS } + +print('files: {}\ntheories: {}\ngoals: {}'.format( + len(test['file'].unique()), + len(test['theory'].unique()), + len(test['goal'].unique()) + )) + +test['key'] = test.index +test['rf'] = pred_ranks +test['best'] = actual +test['worst'] = worst + +for x in ['rf', 'best', 'worst']: + + test[x+' time'] = test.apply(lambda ser: common.time_to_valid( ser[x], + test.ix[ser['key'], common.TIMES+common.RESULTS ] ), axis=1 ) + test[x+' result'] = test.apply(lambda ser: common.best_result_from_rank( ser[x], + test.ix[ser['key'], common.RESULTS ] ), axis=1 ) + + +results['Where4 Forest'] = {o : test.apply(lambda ser: + fun( test.ix[ser['key'], common.REV_MAP[ser['rf'][0]]+' result'] ), axis=1).sum() + for o, fun in output.iteritems()} + + + +results['Best'] = {o : test.apply(lambda ser: + fun( test.ix[ser['key'], common.REV_MAP[ser['best'][0]]+' result'] ), axis=1).sum() + for o, fun in output.iteritems()} + +results['Worst'] = {o : test.apply(lambda ser: + fun( test.ix[ser['key'], common.REV_MAP[ser['best'][-1]]+' result'] ), axis=1).sum() + for o, fun in output.iteritems()} + +# this one takes the most common result among the solvers for each goal +results['Random'] = {o: test.apply(lambda ser: + fun( common.avg_result(ser[common.RESULTS]) ), axis=1).sum() + for o, fun in output.iteritems()} + + +table = {'Best' : cr.evaluate(actual, actual, test), + 'Worst' : cr.evaluate(worst, actual, test), + 'Where4' : cr.evaluate(pred_ranks, actual, test)} + +table['Where4']['score'] = metrics.r2_score(y_test, predictions, multioutput='uniform_average') + +results = DataFrame(results) +results.to_csv('data_for_second_barchart.csv') +print results + +#Be careful! don't want to overwrite the csv file below mistakenly + +# s = 'aAzZ34vy' +# N = len(s) +# all_orders = [''.join(rand) for rand in itertools.permutations(s, r=N)] + +# this one takes a while: find the average time for every permutation +# to return a Valid/Invalid answer on the test set + +#test['rand time'] = test.apply(lambda ser: np.mean([common.time_to_valid( rand, +# test.ix[ser['key'], common.TIMES+common.RESULTS] ) +# for rand in all_orders]), axis=1 ) + +#test.to_csv('data_for_second_linegraph.csv') diff --git a/readme.md b/readme.md index ec0bf34..aac52ff 100644 --- a/readme.md +++ b/readme.md @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -# Predicting SMT Performance for Software Verification +# Predicting SMT Solver Performance for Software Verification ## Andrew Healy, Rosemary Monahan, James, F. Power ### [Principles of Programming](http://www.cs.nuim.ie/research/pop/) Research Group, Dept. of Computer Science, Maynooth University, Ireland @@ -41,4 +41,11 @@ Disjoint partitions of `whygoal_stats.csv` for testing (25%) and training/valida Perform KFold cross-validation on the training set to compare a number of regressor implementations from Sci-kit Learn. Renders `compare_regressors.pdf` which is the full version of Table 2 in the paper. #### `permute_rankings.py` -Find values for the 'Random' strategy by averaging values for all possible rankings. Is slow because it has 8! rankings to get through. +Find values for the 'Random' strategy (either train or test) by averaging values for all possible rankings. Is slow because it has 8! rankings to get through. + +#### `output_eval_files.py` +Outputs several data files used in the Evvaluation section: +- `forest.json`: a JSON representation of the trained random forest - suitable for use when compiling the OCaml binary +- `data_for_second_barchart.csv`: results for each prover and strategy for the test goals +- `data_for_second_linegraph.csv`: how long each strategy took to return a Valid/Invalid answer for the test set +- `feature_importances.txt`: how important the input variables are to the Random Forest when making decisions