Move compressed file(s) to the Bin after extraction / Move original file(s) to the Bin after compression

[nikzic]

Hi,

I just updated to Catalina and I noticed that these two options are not working any more. I tired unchecking and rechecking them but they still do not work. Can you look into this?

Thanks!

[aonez]

Hi @nikzic! Just checked and it's working for me. Does it fail always for you? Can you try for example in the Desktop?

If it fails, can you take a look at the Console.app (filtered by Keka) to see if there's any log there?

[nikzic]

Hi @aonez, thanks so much for the quick reply. I just played around with it a bit, and it seems this is happening only on iCloud folders. Since my Documents and Desktop are in iCloud, the issue is present. When I try to zip/unzip something in non-iCloud folders, everything works perfectly. Before Catalina, this issue was not present in iCloud folders. I tried disabling the option "Show warning before removing from iCloud drive" in Finder preferences, wishfully thinking that may help, but it didn't. The issue is present on both my macs. In the Console, I don't see anything related to Keka, i.e. there is no item that has "Keka" in the Process column. Any other tips? :) BTW, Keka has access to my whole disk. I also now granted it access to iCloud folders specifically, but it is still the same.

[aonez]

Reproduced! Thanks @nikzic, I'll do more testing tomorrow.

[aonez]

This is the error:

Error Domain=NSCocoaErrorDomain Code=3328 "“file” couldn’t be moved to the Bin because the volume “Macintosh HD” doesn’t have one." UserInfo={NSURL=file:///Users/user/Library/Mobile%20Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/file, NSUserStringVariant=Trash}

[aonez]

I've reported it to Apple via the Feedback Assistant, stating that:

Calling trashItemAtURL with a path from iCloud Drive results in an error.

To reproduce:

Call trashItemAtURL with an iCloud Drive path (/Users/user/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/file)

Result:

The call fail to move and will return an error with a message stating that the file couldn’t be moved to the Trash because the volume doesn’t have one.

Expected:

The file will be moved to the iCloud Drive trash, located at /Users/user/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/.Trash

Catalina is half backed.

Will do a workaround, but this should be fixed by Apple. @nikzic if you can report it too.

[nikzic]

Thanks a lot, @aonez. Just reported it too