Skip to content

HTTPS clone URL

Subversion checkout URL

You can clone with
or
.
Download ZIP

Loading…

Usage Terms unclear #68

Closed
splitbrain opened this Issue · 12 comments

7 participants

@splitbrain

The LICENSE file lists "all rights reserved" by different companies for all the emoji graphics. Technically this would make http://www.emoji-cheat-sheet.com/ a license violation unless these images where sub licensed to the site.

What are the exact terms under which these graphic files may be used? Can they be used in other (Open Source) projects? Under what terms can the images be redistributed?

@mvdkleijn

:+1: I too would like to know the answers to this @arvida

If the various companies have given usage and/or redistribution permissions concerning these images, please add that information or (better) add a link to each company's website that explicitly states that we can use and/or redistribute it.

@garrick-percona

I'd like to have this cleared up as well. The "Use on your website", coupled with "all rights reserved", is quite confusing. Particularly since the owner of this project does not seem to be the copyright holder.

@mvdkleijn

@arvida Any chance we can get this (relatively) simple question answered? :smile:

@arvida
Owner

Very sorry for not providing any clear answer on this. I am a bit unsure my self and hear different things concerning this from different people. I am a bit short on time a the moment, if anyone wants to investigate this more thoroughly I am happy to update the repo with any findings on this.

@mpa4hu

+1 this is very confusing

@mpa4hu

What about this https://github.com/github/gemoji
There is a license. This is normal to use it, just might be a good idea to give some credits

UPADTE:

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/22337295/license-of-apple-color-emoji-ttf

@splitbrain

gemoji gives a license for the source code only. strictly speaking redistribution of these icon graphic is illegal, even though the copyright holders seem not to enforce their copyrights.
This murky license might be okay for a personal project or website but it's unacceptable for any free and open source software project.

@joeljunstrom
Collaborator

I'm closing this since I do not think we will get a clearer view of the licensing issues regarding the emoji set. I can reopen if someone feels that should still be an "open issue".

@adam-lynch

I would think this is unresolved.

@joeljunstrom
Collaborator

But do you think it can be resolved? http://words.steveklabnik.com/emoji-licensing

@mvdkleijn

I also think it is unresolved and it's an important topic at that. It leaves a lot of unclarity and possibility to be sued by the copyright owners.

Strictly speaking this website is in violation and could (potentially) be slapped with a takedown or worse at any time.

@mvdkleijn

By the way, I read that post you referred to and the open phantom emoji are useless too. This will only be resolved if some designer makes some icons from scratch and licenses them clearly under MIT for example.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.