Permalink
Cannot retrieve contributors at this time
web-hack-mirror/mirror/2000/08/22/www.ad-rag.com/article.php3?sid=32&mode=threaded&order=0&thold=0
Go to fileThis commit does not belong to any branch on this repository, and may belong to a fork outside of the repository.
334 lines (300 sloc)
19.9 KB
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
| <html><html> | |
| <head> | |
| <title>Adland, the creatives playpen - Adland, truth on advertising</title> | |
| <style rel=stylesheet type=text/css> | |
| A:link { text-decoration: underline; font-weight: bold; } | |
| A:active { text-decoration: none; } | |
| A:visited { text-decoration: underline; font-weight: bold; } | |
| A:hover { text-decoration: underline; } | |
| </style> | |
| </head> | |
| <body bgcolor="#FFFF99" text="#000000" link="#660000" vlink="#000000" topmargin=5 leftmargin=0 rightmargin=0 marginheight=5> | |
| <table border=0 cellpadding=4 cellspacing=0 width=100% align=center> | |
| <tr><td> | |
| <CENTER> | |
| <table border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="3" width="98%" bgcolor="#666600"> | |
| <tr> | |
| <td> <a href="index.html"><img src="themes/adland/deflogo.gif" alt="Welcome to Adland, the creatives playpen" border=0></a> | |
| </td> | |
| <td align=right> | |
| <form action="search.php3" method=post> | |
| <font face=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2 color="FFFFFF"> Search: | |
| <input type=name name=query> | |
| </FONT> | |
| </form> | |
| <font face=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=1 color="FFFFFF">The <a href="badland.php3">Badland</A> pages are not included in the search.</FONT> | |
| </tr> | |
| <tr bgcolor="#CCCC66"> | |
| <td colspan=2> <font face=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2 color=330000>Adland, by the adgrunts for the adgrunts</font></td> | |
| </tr> | |
| </table></CENTER> | |
| </td></tr> | |
| <tr><td valign=top width=100%> | |
| <table border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=2 width=100%> | |
| <tr><td valign=top width=150> | |
| <!-- Blocks Init --> | |
| <TABLE WIDTH="160" CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0 BORDER=0> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=MIDDLE WIDTH="149" HEIGHT="11" VALIGN=BOTTOM><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutop.gif" width="149" height="1" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="100" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11" BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuleft.gif"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=CENTER bgcolor="#666600"> | |
| <FONT FACE=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2 color=#FFFFFF><B>Main Menu</B></FONT></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="100" HEIGHT="11" BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuright.gif"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=RIGHT BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuleft.gif" WIDTH="11"> </TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=TOP BACKGROUND="themes/adland/grid.gif"> | |
| <FONT FACE=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2><li><a href=index.php3>Adland home</a> | |
| <li><a href=topics.php3>News topics</a> | |
| <li><a href=adlist.php3>Adlands mailinglist</a> | |
| <li><a href=sections.php3>Ad rants, Ad books.</a> | |
| <li><a href=links.php3>Ad Links!</a><BR> Searchable link index. | |
| <li><a href=news.php3>Headlines worldwide</a> | |
| <li><a href=faq.php3>Adland's FAQ</a> | |
| <li><a href=stats.php3>Stats</a> | |
| <li><a href=top.php3>Top 10 articles</a> | |
| <li><a href=sitemap.php3>Sitemap</a><BR> | |
| <br></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=LEFT BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuright.gif" WIDTH="11"> </TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=TOP WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottomleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=MIDDLE WIDTH="149" HEIGHT="11" VALIGN=TOP><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottom.gif" width="149" height="1" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=TOP WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottomright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""> | |
| </TD></TR></TABLE> | |
| <!-- Show Left Blocks --> | |
| <TABLE WIDTH="160" CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0 BORDER=0> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=MIDDLE WIDTH="149" HEIGHT="11" VALIGN=BOTTOM><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutop.gif" width="149" height="1" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="100" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11" BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuleft.gif"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=CENTER bgcolor="#666600"> | |
| <FONT FACE=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2 color=#FFFFFF><B>Badland!</B></FONT></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="100" HEIGHT="11" BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuright.gif"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=RIGHT BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuleft.gif" WIDTH="11"> </TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=TOP BACKGROUND="themes/adland/grid.gif"> | |
| <FONT FACE=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2> Adland's most famous section <a href=badland.php3>Badland</A> is here.Ads shown side by side, Separated at birth or plain coincidence? An alien conspiracy or just a fluke?<br></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=LEFT BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuright.gif" WIDTH="11"> </TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=TOP WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottomleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=MIDDLE WIDTH="149" HEIGHT="11" VALIGN=TOP><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottom.gif" width="149" height="1" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=TOP WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottomright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""> | |
| </TD></TR></TABLE> | |
| <TABLE WIDTH="160" CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0 BORDER=0> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=MIDDLE WIDTH="149" HEIGHT="11" VALIGN=BOTTOM><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutop.gif" width="149" height="1" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="100" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11" BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuleft.gif"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=CENTER bgcolor="#666600"> | |
| <FONT FACE=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2 color=#FFFFFF><B>User Login!</B></FONT></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH="100" HEIGHT="11" BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuright.gif"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menutopright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=RIGHT BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuleft.gif" WIDTH="11"> </TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=TOP BACKGROUND="themes/adland/grid.gif"> | |
| <FONT FACE=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2><li><a href=user.php3>Your Account</a> | |
| <li><a href=submit.php3>Submit News!</a><BR> Becoming a user is simple, I don't care where you live, what your cat eats or any other longwinded forms, just sign up with your favorite handle. You can keep your email a secret from the sitevisitors and change the index.page to show your favorite topic first.<br></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=LEFT BACKGROUND="themes/adland/menuright.gif" WIDTH="11"> </TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=TOP WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottomleft.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=MIDDLE WIDTH="149" HEIGHT="11" VALIGN=TOP><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottom.gif" width="149" height="1" alt=""></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=TOP WIDTH="11" HEIGHT="11"><IMG SRC="themes/adland/menubottomright.gif" width="11" height="11" alt=""> | |
| </TD></TR></TABLE> | |
| <img src=images/pix.gif border=0 width=150 height=1> | |
| </td><td width=100% valign=top> | |
| <TABLE WIDTH=100% CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0 BORDER=0> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH=11 HEIGHT=11><IMG SRC=themes/adland/menutopleft.gif width=11 height=11></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=MIDDLE HEIGHT=11 VALIGN=BOTTOM><IMG SRC=themes/adland/menutop.gif width=100% height=1></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH=11 HEIGHT=11><IMG SRC=themes/adland/menutopright.gif width=11 height=11></TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH=11 HEIGHT=11 BACKGROUND=themes/adland/menuleft.gif><IMG SRC=themes/adland/menutopleft.gif width=11 height=11></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=CENTER BACKGROUND=themes/adland/menutitle.gif> | |
| <FONT FACE=Verdana,Sans-Serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2 color=#FFFFFF></center> | |
| <b>Big vs. Small</b><br><font face=Verdana,Arial,Helvetica size=1>Posted on Tuesday, August 22 @ 00:51:08 PDT | |
| </FONT></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=BOTTOM WIDTH=11 HEIGHT=11 BACKGROUND=themes/adland/menuright.gif><IMG SRC=themes/adland/menutopright.gif width=11 height=11></TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=RIGHT BACKGROUND=themes/adland/menuleft.gif WIDTH=11> </TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=TOP BGCOLOR=#CCCC66> | |
| <FONT FACE=Verdana,Sans-serif,Arial,Helvetica size=2> | |
| <a href=search.php3?query=&topic=6&author=><img src=images/topics/rant.gif border=0 Alt="Ad Rant" align=left hspace=10 vspace=10></a> | |
| This is the simplistic theory of an industry that lives and thrives | |
| on simplification (of products, of brands): if your agency is small | |
| you are creative, your ideas sparkle like diamonds, you are so hot it | |
| hurts. | |
| <P> | |
| If your agency is gargantuan, you are a slovenly dinosaur, Godzilla | |
| Incorporated, a coldbed of creativity, so entangled in red tape that | |
| it would make any bondage fan faint with arousal. <br><br>Small agencies (creative consultants, boutiques, farms factories, | |
| brand doctors, idea-circuses, thought-spunkers, whatever they're | |
| called) have progressive philosophies. Large agencies have a | |
| financial plan. Small agencies pay respect to their staff (i.e. team | |
| members). Large agencies pay huge wages to keep their staff (i.e. | |
| employees). | |
| <P> | |
| Small agencies work with the client - only together can they make the | |
| brand strong. Large agencies have account people to keep the client | |
| at arms length - don't let them interfere in the advertising process. | |
| <P> | |
| So on, so forth. | |
| <P> | |
| But there are enough exceptions to disprove this child-theory. | |
| <P> | |
| TBWA GGT etc (I think there are more initials in their alphabetic | |
| soup of a name) have hundreds of people crammed into their London | |
| offices. Yet, they produce some highly creative and imaginative work | |
| (Playstation, fcuk) against the odds of a supposedly unmanageable | |
| size. The same can be said for Abbot Mead Vickers - take Guinness for | |
| example or the monster BMP DDB Needham - they produce the freshest | |
| work in the guise of Volkswagen. | |
| <P> | |
| Then, the flip side. The relatively small in comparison creative | |
| shit-hot-shop agency called St. Lukes in London has an envious | |
| philosophy that would make any creative worth her salt pay money to | |
| work there. Yet, their work is often embarrassingly bad (I would give | |
| examples but am unable to remember any - only their excellent Ikea | |
| campaigns manage to deliver). | |
| Somehow the self-proclaimed beautiful strategies get drowned; perhaps | |
| the result of too many planning meetings or team-building get | |
| togethers or too much reverence to 'our friend the client.' The | |
| outcome is bland, the antithesis of all that was promised. | |
| <P> | |
| Even Mother, London's baby-genius, can, perversely, be said to suffer | |
| because of its size. Highly fashionable, it doesn't manage to | |
| permeate the mainstream with creative work, and gathers a reputation | |
| by working for relatively small clients within the safe confines of a | |
| Face-reading target market. Mother works on a planet where | |
| over-design masks under-ideas. | |
| <P> | |
| Large agencies tend to surprise more by breaking beyond their heavy | |
| bulk to produce good ideas, even when they're burdened with briefs | |
| that seek global campaigns. When they pull it off, they are producing | |
| far more creative work than a small agency which has its sticky paws | |
| on a small dotcom client or micro-brewery. Small agencies get the | |
| juicy sub-brands where mistakes can be afforded. Larger agencies have | |
| to sweat with the main important brands. Real creativity is pulling | |
| off a fresh idea for a generic household product, not wacky ideas for | |
| a local bagel shop chain. | |
| <P> | |
| However, despite this inescapably obvious fact, big agencies believe the hype. | |
| <P> | |
| We can see large agencies panic in the face of all these youthful | |
| start-ups and desperately grow their own volcanic acne by opening up | |
| things called Creative Pods within their own networks. | |
| These are small cells protected against the big bad bureaucracy of | |
| the actual agency. The cells contain comfier sofas, funkier lighting | |
| and idea-rooms for clients. Cross through the door to the other side | |
| into the real agency, and you'll be back in the drab uniformity of | |
| greying filing cabinets and dusty vertical blinds. | |
| <P> | |
| What does this say, this invention of supposedly zesty | |
| mini-structures within the rusty infrastructure of the whole agency? | |
| Is it an admittance that their working methods are a mess? Would it | |
| not be better to invest the money in finding new ways to make their | |
| size more fluid, rather than avoiding the problem by dripping the | |
| essence of their creativity into a shielded shop? | |
| <P> | |
| Isn't it more valuable to think about restructuring the whole rather | |
| than disintegrating the parts? It's compartmentalising rather than | |
| bringing together. The future surely = disenfranchised disillusioned | |
| employees. | |
| <P> | |
| (And don't they know? The pod will doubtless break away once the | |
| fruits of their labour start to sprout. Soon they will become their | |
| own start up without the huge shadow of the big agency interfering | |
| all the time. This, of course, has its own problems as the new | |
| creative pod will get to fully develop its own highly original | |
| philosophy and meet agencies like St.Lukes on Up Your Own Arse | |
| Avenue.) | |
| <P> | |
| And what about seeking work? Big v. small, what should you choose? | |
| Smaller agencies promise freedom, but as often as not, weigh you down | |
| with their good intentions. Your way of thinking could become diluted | |
| by joining their cult. | |
| <P> | |
| Larger agencies, through the anonymity of the size, can offer more | |
| opportunities to mess about and make mistakes. If the larger agency | |
| has an editing suite tucked away in their basement, or access to all | |
| the computer programmes you dreamed of, or a couple of dv cameras | |
| knocking about, you can experiment without making so much as a dent | |
| in their revenue. A smaller agency may not have the resources to give | |
| you a chance to play. | |
| <P> | |
| The good larger agencies, if you fight for it, will see no harm in | |
| throwing you the moist rump steak of a top tv brief, whereas the | |
| smaller agency, despite their reputation for risks, might find that a | |
| radio commercial 6 months down the line is a difficult thing to hand | |
| to you. The best choice is to try both and see where it clicks. Many | |
| hate the Mafia like intimacy of small agencies, preferring the social | |
| web of larger outfits. | |
| <P> | |
| This rant doesn't really have an end. Only to say, I know where I | |
| would rather work. Please end the rant for me, by posting your | |
| agreements or otherwise:-</TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=LEFT BACKGROUND=themes/adland/menuright.gif WIDTH=11> </TD></TR> | |
| <TR> | |
| <TD ALIGN=right VALIGN=TOP WIDTH=11 HEIGHT=11><IMG SRC=themes/adland/menubottomleft.gif width=11 height=11></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=MIDDLE HEIGHT=11 VALIGN=TOP><IMG SRC=themes/adland/menubottom.gif width=100% height=1></TD> | |
| <TD ALIGN=left VALIGN=TOP WIDTH=11 HEIGHT=11><IMG SRC=themes/adland/menubottomright.gif width=11 height=11> | |
| </TD></TR></TABLE> | |
| <p><center><a href="comments.php3?op=Reply&pid=0&sid=32"><img src=images/menu/english/comment.gif border=0></a></p></center> | |
| <table width=99% border=0 cellspacing=1 cellpadding=2> | |
| <tr><td bgcolor="#666600" align=center><font face=Verdana,Arial,Helvetica size=2 color="#FFFFFF">"Big vs. Small" | <a href="user.php3"><font color="#FFFFFF">Login</font></a> | <B>1</B> comment</font></td></tr> <tr><td bgcolor="#FFFF99" align="center"><font face=Verdana,Arial,Helvetica size=2> | |
| <form method=get action="article.php3"> | |
| <font color="#000000">Threshold</font> <select name=thold> | |
| <option value="-1" >-1 | |
| <option value="0" selected>0 | |
| <option value="1" >1 | |
| <option value="2" >2 | |
| <option value="3" >3 | |
| <option value="4" >4 | |
| <option value="5" >5 | |
| </select> <select name=mode> | |
| <option value="nocomments" >No Comments <option value="nested" >Nested <option value="flat" >Flat <option value="threaded" selected>Threaded </select> <select name=order> | |
| <option value="0" selected>Oldest First <option value="1" >Newest First <option value="2" >Highest Scores First </select> | |
| <input type=hidden name=sid value=32> | |
| <input type=submit value=Refresh></font> | |
| </td></tr></form> | |
| <tr><td bgcolor="#666600" align=center><font face=Verdana,Arial,Helvetica size=1 color="#FFFFFF">Needs translation</td></tr> | |
| </table> | |
| <a name="26"><table width=99% border=0><tr bgcolor="#FFFF99"><td width=500><p><b>Re: Big vs. Small</b> <font face=Verdana,Arial,Helvetica size=2>(Score: 1)<br>by <a href="mailto:mcronald@yahoo.com">The_Thirty_Second_Critic</a> <b>(mcronald@yahoo.com)</b> on Tuesday, August 22 @ 04:55:25 PDT<br>(<a href="user.php3?op=userinfo&uname=The_Thirty_Second_Critic">User Info</a>) </font></td></tr><tr><td>Well, where do I begin ? Ill break it down into three concepts: Creativity, Large vs. Small, and Restructuring <br> | |
| <br> | |
| Most importantly creativity Its no secret in big agencies, that in-the-trenches staff creativity is squeezed out during group brainstorms, and the upper-level account staff (those with client contact) seem to get all the praise and client recognition. However I cant tell you how many times Ive seen great concepts trashed by a stupid client. Clients are the deathblow to creativity, not whether its a big or small agency. <br> | |
| <br> | |
| Award winning work is the result of a good agency allowed to do its job (namely be creative), by the client. Agencies dealing with clients who already know what is creative, will suffer. Its a rule! <br> | |
| <br> | |
| Next up We can see large agencies panic in the face of all these youthful start-ups <br> | |
| <br> | |
| I think the statement is shortsighted. Big agencies have amazing mobility when it comes to responding to million-dollar RFPs and exceedingly detailed client changes on tight deadlines. The smaller shops just cant compete. Big agencies know the smaller agencies offer more personalize contact, however the panic is pure media myth. Big agencies deal in calculated risk, and small shops dont scare them. Large agencies thrive on competition. <br> | |
| <br> | |
| Lastly: Isn't it more valuable to think about restructuring the whole rather than disintegrating the parts? <br> | |
| <br> | |
| This is a complicated, trick question. Can you really imagine an accounting department, on deadline, surrounded by couches and mood lighting? Not everybody can focus in a casual friendly environment. Restructuring a big ad agency is a needless exercise. Big agencies know that people who need more decorative surroundings will find it in five-person loft space. They also know that the next round of college grads will fill the cubes of the recently departed. <br> | |
| <br> | |
| My two-cent conclusion will agree with your conclusion: Shop around and find an agency that is right for you. If the large agency experience makes you miserable then go for a start-up same goes for the reverse.</td></tr></table><br><p><font face=Verdana,Arial,Helvetica size=2 color=000000> [ <a href="comments.php3?op=Reply&pid=26&sid=32&mode=threaded&order=0&thold=0">Reply</a> ]</font><p></ul></p> | |
| </td></tr></table> | |
| </td></tr></table> | |
| </body></html> | |
| <font face=Arial,Helvetica size=1><center> | |
| Adland is hosted by Dabitch. You should read the <a href=sections.php3?op=viewarticle&artid=70>disclaimer</A>, it's healthy | |
| and nutritious.<br> | |
| All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all | |
| the rest © 2000 by Dabitch<br> | |
| This web site was made with <a href=http://linuxpreview.org/php-nuke.php3>PHP-Nuke</a>, a web portal system written in | |
| PHP. PHP-Nuke is Free Software released under the <a href=http://www.gnu.org>GNU/GPL license</a>.<br> | |
| <br> | |
| </body> | |
| </html> | |