Skip to content
Random Sampling in Clojure
Find file
Latest commit d453940 @ashenfad ashenfad v3.0.0 -> v3.0

Random Sampling in Clojure


sampling is available as a Maven artifact from Clojars.

For Leiningen:

[bigml/sampling "3.0"]


This library supports three flavors of random sampling: simple sampling, reservoir sampling, and stream sampling.

Simple sampling is the best choice if the data is small enough to comfortably keep in memory. If that's not true but the sample you want to take is small enough for memory, then reservoir sampling is a good choice. If neither the original population nor the sample can reside in memory, then take a look at stream sampling.

As we review each, feel free to follow along in the REPL:

user> (ns test
        (:require (bigml.sampling [simple :as simple]
                                  [reservoir :as reservoir]
                                  [stream :as stream])
                  (bigml.sampling.test [stream :as stream-test])))

Simple Sampling

sample.simple provides simple random sampling. With this technique the original population is kept in memory but the resulting sample is a lazy sequence.

By default, sampling is done without replacement. This is equivalent to a lazy Fisher-Yates shuffle.

test> (simple/sample (range 5))
(2 3 1 0 4)

Setting :replace as true will sample with replacement. Since there is no limit to the number of items that may be sampled with replacement from a population, the result will be an infinite length list. So make sure to take however many samples you need.

test> (take 10 (simple/sample (range 5) :replace true))
(2 3 3 2 4 1 1 1 3 0)

Each call to simple/sample will return a new sample order.

test> (simple/sample (range 5))
(0 2 3 1 4)
test> (simple/sample (range 5))
(3 1 4 2 0)

Setting the :seed parameter allows the sample order to be recreated.

test> (simple/sample (range 5) :seed 7)
(2 1 3 4 0)
test> (simple/sample (range 5) :seed 7)
(2 1 3 4 0)

Any value that's hashable is valid as a seed:

test> (simple/sample (range 5) :seed :foo)
(1 0 3 2 4)

The underlying random number generator may also be selected with the :generator parameter. The two options are :lcg (linear congruential generator) and :twister (Marsenne twister). The default is :lcg.

test> (simple/sample (range 5) :seed 7 :generator :lcg)
(2 1 3 4 0)
test> (simple/sample (range 5) :seed 7 :generator :twister)
(4 3 0 1 2)

Weighted Simple Sampling

A sample may be weighted using the :weigh parameter. If the parameter is supplied with a function that takes an item and produces a non-negative weight, then the resulting sample will be weighted accordingly.

test> (take 5 (simple/sample [:heads :tails]
                             :weigh {:heads 0.5 :tails 0.5}
                             :replace true))
(:tails :heads :heads :heads :tails)

The weights need not sum to 1.

test> (frequencies (take 100 (simple/sample [:heads :tails]
                                            :weigh {:heads 2 :tails 1}
                                            :replace true)))
{:heads 66, :tails 34}

Reservoir Sampling

sample.reservoir provides functions for reservoir sampling. Reservoir sampling keeps the sampled population in memory (the 'reservoir'). However, the original population is streamed through the reservoir so it does not need to reside in memory. This makes reservoirs useful when the original population is too large to fit into memory or the overall size of the population is unknown.

To create a sample reservoir, use reservoir/create and give it the number of samples you desire. The resulting reservoir acts as a collection, so you can simply conj values into the reservoir to create a sample. For example:

test> (reduce conj (reservoir/create 3) (range 10))
(5 7 2)

Similarly, a collection can be fed into the reservoir with into:

test> (into (reservoir/create 3) (range 10))
(7 0 8)

To see how the reservoir changes as items are added, we can use reductions:

test> (reductions conj (reservoir/create 3) (range 10))
(() (0) (0 1) (0 1 2) (0 3 2) (0 3 2) (5 3 2) (6 3 2) (6 3 2) (6 3 2) (6 9 2))

For convenience, reservoir/sample accepts a collection and a reservoir size and returns the final reservoir:

test> (reservoir/sample (range 10) 5)
(0 9 2 1 4)

Both reservoir/sample and reservoir/create support the :replace, :seed, :generator, and :weigh parameters.

test> (reservoir/sample (range 10) 5 :replace true :seed 1 :weigh identity)
(7 2 4 5 1)

One caveat is that samples for reservoirs using :weigh won't be in a random order (with respect to item weights). So you may need to shuffle the results if that's important for you.

Merging Reservoirs

Reservoirs may be merged with reservoir/merge. The resulting sample will be similar to a single reservoir over the entire population. For example:

test> (reduce + (reservoir/sample (range 0 10000) 500))

test> (reduce + (reservoir/merge
                 (reservoir/sample (range 0 5000) 500)
                 (reservoir/sample (range 5000 8000) 500)
                 (reservoir/sample (range 8000 10000) 500)))

With reservoir/merge, reservoirs may be built in parallel on subsets of the population and combined afterwords, even if the subsets are of varying size.

Reservoir Implementations

Lastly, there are two implementations of reservoir sampling available: :insertion and :efraimdis. :efraimdis is the default and generally the better option. :insertion does not support the :weigh parameter, however it can be faster when sampling from small-ish populations or when sampling with replacement.

The implementation may be selected when calling either reservoir/sample or reservoir/create by using the :implementation parameter:

test> (time (count (reservoir/sample (range 10000) 2000
                                     :implementation :efraimdis
                                     :replace true)))
"Elapsed time: 4197.798 msecs"
test> (time (count (reservoir/sample (range 10000) 2000
                                     :implementation :insertion
                                     :replace true)))
"Elapsed time: 651.868 msecs"

Stream Sampling is useful when taking a large sample from a large population. Neither the original population or the resulting sample are kept in memory. There are a couple of caveats. First, unlike the other sampling techniques, the resulting sample stream is not in random order. It will be in the order of the original population. So if you need a random ordering, you'll want to shuffle the sample. The second caveat is that, unlike reservoir sampling, the size of the population must be declared up-front.

To use stream sampling, call stream/sample with the population, the desired number of samples, and the size of the population. The result is a lazy sequence of samples.

As an example, we take five samples from a population of ten values:

test> (stream/sample (range) 5 10)
(1 2 4 7 9)

As elsewhere, stream/sample supports :replace, :seed, and :generator:

test> (stream/sample (range) 5 10 :replace true :seed 2)
(0 0 4 6 7)

Out-of-bag Items

If an item isn't selected as part of a sampling, it's called out-of-bag. Setting the :out-of-bag parameter to true will return a sequence of the out-of-bag items instead of the sampled items. This can be useful when paired with :seed.

test> (stream/sample (range) 7 10 :seed 0)
(0 2 3 5 6 7 9)
test> (stream/sample (range) 7 10 :seed 0 :out-of-bag true)
(1 4 8)


It's computationally expensive to select the exact number of desired samples when using stream/sample with replacement. If you're okay with the number of samples being approximately the desired number, then you can set :rate to true to decrease the computation cost. When this is the case, the probability of selecting an item will be calculated only once and then applied to each item in the population independently. As an example:

test> (time (count (stream/sample (range 10000) 5000 10000
                                  :replace true)))
"Elapsed time: 374.021 msecs"
test> (time (count (stream/sample (range 10000) 5000 10000
                                  :replace true :rate true)))
"Elapsed time: 33.923 msecs"

:rate is also useful if you want to sample the population at a particular rate rather than collect a specific sample size.

To illustrate, when stream/sample is given an infinite list of values as the population, the default behavior is to take the requested samples from the expected population. In this case, it means taking exactly one sample from the first thousand values of the population:

test> (stream/sample (range) 1 1000)

However, when :rate is true the resulting sample is also infinite, with each item sampled at a probability of 1/1000:

test> (take 10 (stream/sample (range) 1 1000 :rate true))
(1149 1391 1562 3960 4359 4455 5141 5885 6310 7568 7828)


While stream sampling does not yet support sample weights, the cond-sample fn can be useful for fine tuned sampling.

cond-sample accepts a collection followed by pairs of clauses and sample definitions. A clause should be a function that accepts an item and returns either true of false. After each clause should follow a sample defition that describes the sampling technique to use when the condition is true.

As an example, we'll use the well known iris dataset:

test> (first stream-test/iris-data)
[5.1 3.5 1.4 0.2 "Iris-setosa"]

There are 50 instances of each species:

test> (frequencies (map last stream-test/iris-data))
{"Iris-setosa" 50, "Iris-versicolor" 50, "Iris-virginica" 50}

Let's say we want to sample all of Iris-setosa, half as many Iris-versicolor, and none of the Iris-virginica. If you knew the population for each class ahead of time, you could use cond-sample like so:

test> (def new-sample
         (stream/cond-sample stream-test/iris-data
                             #(= "Iris-setosa" (last %)) [50 50]
                             #(= "Iris-versicolor" (last %)) [25 50]
                             #(= "Iris-virginica" (last %)) [0 50]))
test> (frequencies (map last new-sample))
{"Iris-setosa" 50, "Iris-versicolor" 25}

If you did not know the class populations ahead of time, a similar sample could be done using :rate. Also, an item that doesn't satisfy any condition will be left out of the final sample. So Iris-virginica does not need to have its own clause:

test> (def new-sample
         (stream/cond-sample stream-test/iris-data
                             #(= "Iris-setosa" (last %)) [1 1 :rate true]
                             #(= "Iris-versicolor" (last %)) [1 2 :rate true]))
test> (frequencies (map last new-sample))
{"Iris-setosa" 50, "Iris-versicolor" 23}


The stream/multi-sample fn can be used to generate multiple samplings in one pass over the population. The fn takes the population followed by sets of sampling parameters, one for each desired sampling.

Each set of sample parameters should be composed of a consumer fn, the sample size, the population size, and optionally the parameters :replace, :seed, and :rate.

multi-sample will generate a unique sampling for every parameter set. Whenever a value is sampled, it will be consumed by the parameter set's consumer fn. A consumer fn should accept a single parameter.

As an example, let's imagine we're running a retail store and want to distribute awards to the stream of customers entering the store. To do this we'll create two samplings from the customer stream: 1 out of 100 will win a gift certificate and 1 out of 500 will win a Hawaiian vacation.

test> (defn award-gift-certificate! [customer-id]
        (println "Customer" customer-id "wins a gift certificate."))
test> (defn award-hawaiian-vacation! [customer-id]
        (println "Customer" customer-id "wins a Hawaiian vacation."))
test> (def customer-ids (range 1000))
test> (stream/multi-sample customer-ids
                           [award-gift-certificate! 1 100 :rate true]
                           [award-hawaiian-vacation! 1 500 :rate true])
Customer 161 wins a Hawaiian vacation.
Customer 427 wins a gift certificate.
Customer 627 wins a gift certificate.
Customer 646 wins a gift certificate.
Customer 661 wins a gift certificate.
Customer 731 wins a gift certificate.
Customer 745 wins a gift certificate.
Customer 786 wins a gift certificate.
Customer 794 wins a gift certificate.
Customer 833 wins a Hawaiian vacation.
Customer 836 wins a gift certificate.


multi-reduce is very similar to multi-sample, except every set of sample parameters defines a sampling along with a reduction function. So each set of sample parameters should be composed of a reduce fn, an initial reduce value, the sample size, the population size, and optionally the :replace, :seed, and :rate parameters.

multi-reduce will return a seq of values, each value being the final reduction for a sampling. A reducer fn should accept two parameters.

An example:

test> (stream/multi-reduce (range) [+ 0 20 30 :seed 3]
                                   [+ 0 20 30 :seed 4])
(273 330)


Copyright (C) 2013 BigML Inc.

Distributed under the Apache License, Version 2.0.

Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.