Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

transaction not completing #956

Closed
ipxtreme opened this Issue Jul 10, 2015 · 15 comments

Comments

Projects
None yet
2 participants

I saw this notice and upgraded immediately to 10.2 windows wallet on 7/7. I did a transaction on 7/9/15 and it has 0 confirmations for 12 hours now. Why?

I have done other transactions before that time and after that time. They all have had successful confirmations.

Source File: _alerts/2015-07-04-spv-mining.md

Contributor

harding commented Jul 10, 2015

@ipxtreme I'm sorry to hear about that. Have you left your Bitcoin Core wallet open so that it can rebroadcast the transaction to new peers it encounters?

Note: I'm going to close this issue because it doesn't have to do with the alert.

@harding harding closed this Jul 10, 2015

an I tell if this was submitted on a different fork?

Contributor

harding commented Jul 10, 2015

Transactions are submitted to the network; even if they're mined in a block that later becomes stale (orphaned), the transactions can still be included in a block on the current chain. I suggest you just open your Bitcoin Core wallet to let it rebroadcast that transaction. If you'd like, you can provide me with a txid (or the whole raw transaction) and I'll help rebroadcast it using my node.

thanks. 78e43516e8cacff78ec507abc1c1defc3e4118f765e6637e32574dc6305d4d20

Status: 0/unconfirmed
Date: 7/9/2015 19:58
To: 1F3ZJtLqRYkhaZgdXkBNZkpm2NhbpPVzFX
Debit: -0.16852058 BTC
Transaction fee: -0.00000855 BTC
Net amount: -0.16852913 BTC
Transaction ID: 78e43516e8cacff78ec507abc1c1defc3e4118f765e6637e32574dc6305d4d20-000

@harding How do I rebroadcast it from a node? My brother can do it from his wallet too.

Contributor

harding commented Jul 10, 2015

@ipxtreme my node received it, so it may have been well propagated. However, it does pay very low fees (0.00002565 per Kb)---below the amount my node estimates will be confirmed in the next 25 blocks (0.00010346), so you're going to have to wait a while.

Your brother can help relay using Bitcoin Core by going to Help -> Debug -> Console and pasting in the following command:

sendrawtransaction 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

Thanks.

Sent from my awesome Android device

-------- Original message --------
From: "David A. Harding" notifications@github.com
Date: 07/10/2015 11:51 AM (GMT-08:00)
To: "bitcoin-dot-org/bitcoin.org" bitcoin.org@noreply.github.com
Cc: ipxtreme bitcoin@ipxtreme.com
Subject: {Disarmed} Re: [bitcoin.org] transaction not completing (#956)

@ipxtreme my node received it, so it may have been well propagated. However, it does pay very low fees (0.00002565 per Kb)---below the amount my node estimates will be confirmed in the next 25 blocks (0.00010346), so you're going to have to wait a while.

Your brother can help relay using Bitcoin Core by going to Help -> Debug -> Console and pasting in the following command:

sendrawtransaction 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


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

Still 0 confirmations. do you think the 25 blocks have past yet?

@harding do you think the 25 blocks are done already or still need to be found? I still see 0 confirmations. What about you?

Contributor

harding commented Jul 12, 2015

@ipxtreme it's confirmed now.

@harding thanks. I will include the fee from now on. is there a config in the wallet to auto include the fee for every transaction?

Contributor

harding commented Jul 12, 2015

@ipxtreme in the GUI, the Send tab has a fee chooser on the bottom of the screen in Bitcoin Core 0.10 and 0.11.

@harding thanks.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment