diff --git a/bip-0003.md b/bip-0003.md index 8923933fe0..02192301f3 100644 --- a/bip-0003.md +++ b/bip-0003.md @@ -37,7 +37,10 @@ Some BIPs describe processes, implementation guidelines, best practices, inciden the Bitcoin protocol, peer-to-peer network, and client software may be acceptable. BIPs are intended to be a means for proposing new protocol features, coordinating client standards, and -documenting design decisions that have gone into implementations. BIPs may be submitted by anyone. +documenting design decisions that have gone into implementations. A BIP may be submitted by anyone, +provided it is the original work of its authors and the content is of high quality, e.g. does not waste +the community's time. No content may be generated by AI/LLMs and authors must proactively disclose +up-front any use of AI/LLMs. The scope of the BIPs repository is limited to BIPs that do not oppose the fundamental principle that Bitcoin constitutes a peer-to-peer @@ -477,7 +480,7 @@ repository](https://github.com/bitcoin/bips) where it may get further feedback. For each new BIP pull request that comes in, an editor checks the following: -* The idea has been previously discussed on the Bitcoin Development Mailing List +* The idea has been previously proposed by one of the authors to the Bitcoin Development Mailing List and discussed there * The described idea is on-topic for the repository * Title accurately describes the content * Proposal is of general interest and/or pertains to more than one Bitcoin project/implementation @@ -486,7 +489,7 @@ For each new BIP pull request that comes in, an editor checks the following: * Motivation, Rationale, and Backward Compatibility have been addressed * Specification provides sufficient detail for implementation * The defined Layer header must be correctly assigned for the given specification -* The BIP is ready: it is comprehensible, technically feasible, and all aspects are addressed as necessary +* The BIP is ready: it is comprehensible, technically feasible and sound, and all aspects are addressed as necessary Editors do NOT evaluate whether the proposal is likely to be adopted.