Skip to content

When using nth_percentile, correct value is not always returned if using MAX consolidation #3059

@frontierliu

Description

@frontierliu

Version: Cacti 1.2.5/Linux
When I created a graph that the datasource consolidation function of MAX, the 95th_percentile function return a lower value than the right one. By checked the csv outport file, I confirmed that the 95th_percentile function only use the avg cf datasource to calculate result.

I check the source code of nth_percentile in lib/graph_variables.php , Line 32-36:

function nth_percentile($local_data_ids, $start_seconds, $end_seconds, $percentile = 95, $resolution = 0, $peak = false) {
$stats = json_decode(rrdtool_function_stats($local_data_ids, $start_seconds, $end_seconds, $percentile, $resolution, $peak), true);

    return $stats['avg'];

}

In line 129-139, the $stats have complete description of MAX and AVG:

    if (cacti_sizeof($fetch_array)) {
            $stats['avg'] = nth_percentile_fetch_statistics($percentile, $local_data_ids, $fetch_array, 'AVERAGE');
    }

    if (cacti_sizeof($fetch_array_max)) {
            $stats['peak'] = nth_percentile_fetch_statistics($percentile, $local_data_ids, $fetch_array_max, 'MAX');
    }

    return json_encode($stats);

For some unknown reason, function nth_percentile ignore the $peak parameter , directly return the 'avg' value. I think it is a bug of function nth_percentile, I modifed it in lib/graph_varialbes.php line 32-36:

function nth_percentile($local_data_ids, $start_seconds, $end_seconds, $percentile = 95, $resolution = 0, $peak = false) {
$stats = json_decode(rrdtool_function_stats($local_data_ids, $start_seconds, $end_seconds, $percentile, $resolution, $peak), true);

    if ($peak) {
            return $stats['peak'];
    } else {
            return $stats['avg'];
    }

}

In Cacti 1.2.6/CentOS 7.6, I have confirmed the modification is ok and get the right value of 95th_percentile of MAX_cf datasource.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugUndesired behaviourresolvedA fixed issue

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions