Skip to content

Loading…

Request: Show filter rules that are being applied #171

Closed
gohamstergo opened this Issue · 8 comments

4 participants

@gohamstergo

Perhaps where ublock says, for example: "on this page 5 or 2%" you could click on the 5 and it would popup a list showing what elements are actually being blocked. It's nothing super important, I just think it'd be cool to see what's being blocked, in addition to the number and percentage.

Thanks and keep up the good work :D

@gorhill

You can already see this in the Statistics tabs, if you enable the logging of requests -- disabled by default since most users won't care and this would consume more memory.

@Mikey1993

Well, if are concerned about memory, maybe give the user the ability to enable this feature (set it disabled by default), or is just if the feature is implemented (and not enabled) might consume more memory?

@Baegus

But that's how it is already. Check out the Statistics tab.

@Mikey1993

But it's not convenient for a novice user to debug why he is having a site breakage.

@Baegus

Well, if he knows how to read the log, he probably knows how to access the plugin's settings.

@Mikey1993

We are talking here about having displayed for the user a list with all the blocked elements on a the page via a handy balloon/popup menu or whatever.

This can be combined with a feature of disabling a rule (ability of most blockers) in a single mouse click conveniently (add it to the whitelist list) either from the statistics tab or some other menu.

@gorhill

We are talking here about having displayed for the user a list with all the blocked elements on a the page via a handy balloon/popup menu or whatever

I have already closed issues which were proposing this, for reason of feature creep: I figured that if I start to show the blocked requests in the popup (which I also don't like because clutter the popup with rather technical information), then users will want ability to turn off one single filters, etc etc.

I want to keep the main UI simple, and whoever has an interest in more technical info, that's the purpose of the Statistics tab. I just can't let feature creep take over, I am going to be very conservative with it (and this also allow me to not look up to an endless pile of work to do).

There is an issue already filed to be able to create an exception filter from a blocked net request in the Statistics tab (or the reverse, a block filter from an allowed request).

I really do not intend at all the clutter the popup, if anything , I want it less cluttered -- by finding a way to remove the text explaining the "power button" from it.

Anyone wanting more technical gadgetry, I suggest to install HTTP Switchboard.

@gohamstergo

Thanks for all the responses everyone. I can understand the desire for less clutter. It's a great tool, nonetheless

@smarinov smarinov pushed a commit that referenced this issue
@gorhill gorhill this fixes #171 65183f7
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.