Submission Review Guidelines

Categorization of the Presentation

Categories for each submission listed on Submission-Categorisation.

Not a judgement of quality, but useful for later pruning.

• Beginner-Friendliness
• Real World Application
• Type Theory
• Proofs
• New Languages
• Web
• Graphics
• Artistic
• Evangelism

Things to consider

• Breadth of appeal
• Breadth of application
• Ambition
• Novelty
• Language-Specificity
• Polish (hard to determine from proposal)
• Clarity
• Substance
• Structure
• Freshness (has the talk been given before?)

Things not to consider

• If there are too many/few talks in this category
  • This should be done after assigning a score so as to avoid favouring early/later submissions