diff --git a/ui/text_selection.js b/ui/text_selection.js
index baa6f79c61..ed85caeffd 100644
--- a/ui/text_selection.js
+++ b/ui/text_selection.js
@@ -111,11 +111,11 @@ shaka.ui.TextSelection = class extends shaka.ui.SettingsMenu {
   onCaptionStateChange_() {
     if (this.player.isTextTrackVisible()) {
       this.icon.textContent =
-          shaka.ui.Enums.MaterialDesignIcons.CLOSED_CAPTIONS_OFF;
+          shaka.ui.Enums.MaterialDesignIcons.CLOSED_CAPTIONS;
       this.button.ariaPressed = 'true';
     } else {
       this.icon.textContent =
-          shaka.ui.Enums.MaterialDesignIcons.CLOSED_CAPTIONS;
+          shaka.ui.Enums.MaterialDesignIcons.CLOSED_CAPTIONS_OFF;
       this.button.ariaPressed = 'false';
     }