Skip to content


Switch branches/tags

Name already in use

A tag already exists with the provided branch name. Many Git commands accept both tag and branch names, so creating this branch may cause unexpected behavior. Are you sure you want to create this branch?

Latest commit


Git stats


Failed to load latest commit information.
Latest commit message
Commit time

Occupy Hong Kong: Macro scale, micro-adaptations

![Occupy Hong Kong on October 1, a national holiday] (photos/scale1.jpg "View looking east to Admiralty")

Back in 2011, I was small part of the Occupy Wall Street movement (occasionally helping stock the kitchen and First Aid tents in Zuccotti Park), so arriving in Hong Kong, I had a sense of what Occupy Central with Love and Peace would look like.

This morning, I headed over to Central, the main street through Hong Kong's financial district, to see the occupation trying to secure for Hong Kong the democratic election they were promised in 2017. Walking east from the ferry terminal, the scale of the event certainly seemed like Occupy in New York -- hundreds of people, many wearing that dazed, curious smile people get when they see their fellow citizens behaving as if politics could include them.

Walking uphill on Central, now turned into a political pedestrian mall, felt like a kind of elongated Zuccotti Park. Then I got to the crest of the roadway, and looked down towards the Admiralty neighborhood, the moment captured in the picture above.

And I realized how wrong I was about the size. Occupy Central is absolutely massive, endless participation as far as the eye can see. (Amazement at the scale of the event seemed to be a common reaction -- my picture includes several other people holding up their cameras at about the same spot, having had roughly the same reaction.)

![Occupy Hong Kong on October 1] (photos/scale2.jpg "View looking west, back from Admiralty")

I took my kids with me, and while I have never lost my midwesterner's wonder at tall buildings and big groups, my kids have grown up in New York City and now Shanghai, so crowds don't impress them much. What they were interested in (and what came to interest me) were the ways the occupation is adapting to the need to inhabit a two-mile stretch of asphalt 24/7.

The first thing we noticed was the need to alter the surface of the space, to take an impersonal environment and modify it to say "We're here. This matters." Cities are occupied, every day, by their residents. To make an occupation different, to kick off a political conversation in what had just recently been a transportation corridor, requires taking urban-scale space and adding human-scale adaptations.

Someone could update Stewart Brand's How Buildings Learn to talk about the way various Occupy movements adapt seemingly impassive urban space to their particular needs, both rhetorical and practical.

One common pattern is signs, of course...

![A warning to the police] (photos/nuremberg_sign.jpg "A warning to the police")

![One message, many languages] (photos/wall_signs.jpg "One message, many languages")

![A clear statement of purpose] (photos/nomination.jpg "A clear statement of purpose")

A clear statement of purpose: Beijing has said the only candidates who can stand for office in 2017 will be hand-picked by them; the Occupiers want to be able to nominate candidates, not just vote for them.

Media is also a hugely important part of Occupy Central. All political movements look for coverage, of course, but here, evidence that an event is being documented takes on an additional resonance, since every bit of independent documentation knicks at the government's ability to keep coverage of the event limited to its side of the story. Though the peer communication app FireChat is getting a workout (and a lot of attention as a result), the real social media story here is about publicity, not privacy. For people who want to be heard, the event has to carry past the streets of downtown Hong Kong, and outside the bounds of legacy Chinese media.

![A photos of photos at the event the photo is documenting] (photos/photos.jpg "A photos of photos at the event the photo is documenting")

Some of what was posted on the walls was just evidence that the event was being documented (making this picture fairly meta.)

There were also practical adaptations by the score. One of the first ones we came across was about wayfinding. Because the occupation is in the middle of a formerly busy street, there are no guides for pedestrians, so maps were drawn up and posted, to help people find their way along the avenue.

![Ad hoc wayfinding: A map of the protest, for people not used to walking in the middle of the street] (photos/map_and_sign.jpg "Ad hoc wayfinding: A map of the protest, for people not used to walking in the middle of the street")

The most famous practical adaptation, of course, was the umbrellas.

Because the first clash of the protest involved occupiers defending themselves against pepper spray with umbrellas, this has become known as the Umbrella Movement.

![Occupy Hong Kong: The western-most barricade, decorated with broken umbrellas] (photos/umbrellas_barricades.jpg "Barricades decorated with broken umbrellas")

Even broken umbrellas can serve a second, rhetorical function. Tied to the the western-most barricade on Central, the umbrellas say "This is where business as usual stops and our particular temporary autonomous zone starts."

Since Hong Kong is, per Wikipedia, "a monsoon-influenced humid subtropical climate", umbrellas are ubiquitous; politicizing them provides some of the hiding in plain sight symbolism An Xiao Mina has written about so brilliantly. It also means that political symbols are readily for sale in a country known for subtle and pervasive symbolic control.

![Umbrellas at the ready, for rain or pepper spray] (photos/umbrella_armory.jpg "Umbrellas at the ready, for rain or pepper spray")

An array of donated umbrellas looks like a combination of a yard sale and an armory.

Likewise, the site of the occupation is distinctly not pedestrian friendly. Central is essentially a downtown highway, with borders to match. As people flow in by their thousands, they need to be able to do something the roadway's designers explicitly tried to prevent: cross the street. There are several improvised barrier crossings, often staffed by volunteers.

![Ladder added to get people from the nearby Admiralty subway over the barrier] (photos/crossing1-1.jpg "Ladder added to get people from the nearby Admiralty subway over the barrier")

![Stairs added to get people over the barrier] (photos/crossing2-1.jpg "Stairs added to get people over the barrier")

The other famous adaptation was to tear gas, with impromptu gas masks being created out of goggles and saran wrap, which they now stock by the bale.

![Saran wrap, ready for defense against tear gas] (photos/gas_mask.jpg "Saran wrap, ready for defense against tear gas")

The occupation doesn't go in for political graffiti -- most signs are made and put up, rather than being painted directly onto walls. (Indeed, we saw protestors carefully scrubbing graffiti off the roadway today, an elaborate signal that this movement does not aim to destroy or deface property.)

![Any visible surface can become a political billboard] (photos/signs_on_the_ground.jpg "Any visible surface can become a political billboard")

![Chinese characters are modified to become logos for the movement] (photos/umbrella_sign.jpg "Chinese characters are modified to become logos for the movement")

My friend Marianne Manilov pointed out to me that Occupy Wall Street strengthened its political message enormously with a commitment to look after anyone who showed up. In the industrialized world, taking care of other people has become a radical political act. The occupiers of Hong Kong have created an impromptu but effective distribution system for food, water, first aid, cooling supplies.

![Food and water for whoever needs it] (photos/abundance.jpg "Food and water for whoever needs it")

The speed with which the participants in this movement have built an encampment with food and water and first aid and even border crossings is impressive. They have shown us, at a scope unimaginable even in Zuccotti Park in 2011, what it means to occupy a space. The odds against this movement are serious, but they have shown that adapting urban space to political communication is an act of shared imagination and adaptation.


Photos of Occupy Hong Kong, October 1






No releases published


No packages published