diff --git a/lib/_internal/twilio_voice_web.dart b/lib/_internal/twilio_voice_web.dart
index d454c54c..4275f248 100644
--- a/lib/_internal/twilio_voice_web.dart
+++ b/lib/_internal/twilio_voice_web.dart
@@ -726,7 +726,8 @@ class Call extends MethodChannelTwilioCall {
       _cancelNotification(callSid!);
 
       CallStatus callStatus = getCallStatus(_jsCall!);
-      if (callStatus == CallStatus.ringing) {
+      // reject incoming call that is both outbound ringing or inbound pending
+      if (callStatus == CallStatus.ringing || callStatus == CallStatus.pending) {
         _jsCall!.reject();
       } else {
         _jsCall!.disconnect();