{ "schema_version": 1, "run_id": "af-lab6-quotes-20261020T123135Z", "started_utc": "2026-10-20T12:31:35.937592+00:00", "scope": "Disposable Foundry quotation acceptance only; not full Lab6 certification", "passed": false, "prior_group_independently_absent": true, "prior_failure": { "exact_quotations": 0, "requested_sources": 3, "markdown_fence": true, "excerpt_lengths": [ 171, 166, 170 ], "finding": "Actual model paraphrased in purported quotations; not an escaping-only mismatch" }, "configuration": { "new_resources_only": true, "foundry_region": "swedencentral", "search_region": "westus2", "search_tier": "basic", "gpt4o_capacity": 10, "ada002_capacity": 10, "keyless": true, "existing_projects_sdk": "2.3.0", "agent_api": "v1", "search_mcp_api": "2026-08-01-preview", "retrieval_reasoning": "minimal", "reason": "Bounded extractive lookup avoids failed low-effort planner dependency", "prior_attempt_cleaned": true }, "cases": [ { "name": "cross-source", "transport_passed": true, "retrieval_passed": true, "faithful_quotes_passed": true, "exact_output_compliance_passed": false, "passed": false, "initial_usage": { "input_tokens": 689, "input_tokens_details": { "cache_write_tokens": 0, "cached_tokens": 0 }, "output_tokens": 40, "output_tokens_details": { "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "total_tokens": 729 }, "final_usage": { "input_tokens": 4911, "input_tokens_details": { "cache_write_tokens": 0, "cached_tokens": 0 }, "output_tokens": 132, "output_tokens_details": { "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "total_tokens": 5043 }, "markdown_fenced": false, "quotation_checks": [ { "requested_title": true, "unique_title": true, "exact_original_substring": true, "exact_tool_substring": true, "quote_characters": 80, "length_40_to_160": true, "citation_label_matches_title": false, "exact_entry_fields": true }, { "requested_title": true, "unique_title": true, "exact_original_substring": true, "exact_tool_substring": true, "quote_characters": 109, "length_40_to_160": true, "citation_label_matches_title": false, "exact_entry_fields": true }, { "requested_title": true, "unique_title": true, "exact_original_substring": true, "exact_tool_substring": true, "quote_characters": 144, "length_40_to_160": true, "citation_label_matches_title": false, "exact_entry_fields": true } ] }, { "name": "cross-source-repeat", "transport_passed": true, "retrieval_passed": true, "faithful_quotes_passed": true, "exact_output_compliance_passed": false, "passed": false, "initial_usage": { "input_tokens": 689, "input_tokens_details": { "cache_write_tokens": 0, "cached_tokens": 0 }, "output_tokens": 40, "output_tokens_details": { "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "total_tokens": 729 }, "final_usage": { "input_tokens": 4911, "input_tokens_details": { "cache_write_tokens": 0, "cached_tokens": 4864 }, "output_tokens": 132, "output_tokens_details": { "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "total_tokens": 5043 }, "markdown_fenced": false, "quotation_checks": [ { "requested_title": true, "unique_title": true, "exact_original_substring": true, "exact_tool_substring": true, "quote_characters": 80, "length_40_to_160": true, "citation_label_matches_title": false, "exact_entry_fields": true }, { "requested_title": true, "unique_title": true, "exact_original_substring": true, "exact_tool_substring": true, "quote_characters": 109, "length_40_to_160": true, "citation_label_matches_title": false, "exact_entry_fields": true }, { "requested_title": true, "unique_title": true, "exact_original_substring": true, "exact_tool_substring": true, "quote_characters": 144, "length_40_to_160": true, "citation_label_matches_title": false, "exact_entry_fields": true } ] }, { "name": "unsupported", "transport_passed": true, "retrieval_passed": true, "faithful_quotes_passed": true, "exact_output_compliance_passed": true, "passed": true, "initial_usage": { "input_tokens": 669, "input_tokens_details": { "cache_write_tokens": 0, "cached_tokens": 0 }, "output_tokens": 31, "output_tokens_details": { "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "total_tokens": 700 }, "final_usage": { "input_tokens": 1930, "input_tokens_details": { "cache_write_tokens": 0, "cached_tokens": 0 }, "output_tokens": 6, "output_tokens_details": { "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "total_tokens": 1936 }, "markdown_fenced": false, "quotation_checks": [], "model_abstention_passed": true, "zero_document_retrieval_passed": false, "retrieval_passed_meaning": "Native MCP completed successfully; not a zero-document retrieval claim" } ], "cleanup": { "attempted": true, "group_absent": true, "inventory_resources": 3, "owned_only": true }, "usage": { "embeddings": { "prompt_tokens": 3322, "total_tokens": 3322 }, "planning_model_tokens": "Separate direct-MCP agenticReasoningTokens metadata recorded; hidden inner calls not otherwise observable", "billed_amount": "Not observed; token counts are not a cost estimate", "all_attempt_embedding_tokens": 13288, "all_attempt_actual_embeddings": 96, "all_attempt_agent_response_total_tokens": 16184, "agent_response_api_calls": 9, "observed_cached_input_tokens": 4864, "native_mcp_direct_observed_metadata": [ { "attempt": 1, "agenticReasoningTokens": null }, { "attempt": 2, "agenticReasoningTokens": 3466 }, { "attempt": 3, "agenticReasoningTokens": 3466 }, { "attempt": 4, "agenticReasoningTokens": 3466 } ] }, "copilot_or_activity_executed": false, "production_or_user_agent_modified": false, "foundation": { "passed": true, "checks_passed": 25, "exact_source_matches": 22 }, "connection_keyless_target_readback_passed": true, "finished_utc": "2026-10-20T12:50:31.459783+00:00", "independent_verification": { "source_attribution": [ { "case": "cross-source", "original_and_tool_source_attribution_passed": true, "actual_tool_documents": 24, "all_tool_documents_exact_originals": true, "source_checks": [ { "exact_original": true, "exact_actual_tool_content": true, "original_first_sentence": true, "correct_source_document_id": true, "correct_source_title": true, "owned_search_index_document_url_matches": true, "excerpt_characters": 80, "citation_whitespace_only": true }, { "exact_original": true, "exact_actual_tool_content": true, "original_first_sentence": true, "correct_source_document_id": true, "correct_source_title": true, "owned_search_index_document_url_matches": true, "excerpt_characters": 109, "citation_whitespace_only": true }, { "exact_original": true, "exact_actual_tool_content": true, "original_first_sentence": true, "correct_source_document_id": true, "correct_source_title": true, "owned_search_index_document_url_matches": true, "excerpt_characters": 144, "citation_whitespace_only": true } ] }, { "case": "cross-source-repeat", "original_and_tool_source_attribution_passed": true, "actual_tool_documents": 24, "all_tool_documents_exact_originals": true, "source_checks": [ { "exact_original": true, "exact_actual_tool_content": true, "original_first_sentence": true, "correct_source_document_id": true, "correct_source_title": true, "owned_search_index_document_url_matches": true, "excerpt_characters": 80, "citation_whitespace_only": true }, { "exact_original": true, "exact_actual_tool_content": true, "original_first_sentence": true, "correct_source_document_id": true, "correct_source_title": true, "owned_search_index_document_url_matches": true, "excerpt_characters": 109, "citation_whitespace_only": true }, { "exact_original": true, "exact_actual_tool_content": true, "original_first_sentence": true, "correct_source_document_id": true, "correct_source_title": true, "owned_search_index_document_url_matches": true, "excerpt_characters": 144, "citation_whitespace_only": true } ] } ], "unsupported_actual_tool_documents": 7, "unsupported_zero_documents_verified": false, "unsupported_model_abstention_passed": true, "group_and_resource_absence": [ { "attempt": 1, "group_absent": true, "resource_get_status": { "account": 404, "search": 404 }, "inventory_resources": 3, "only_manifest_owned_resources_deleted": true }, { "attempt": 2, "group_absent": true, "resource_get_status": { "account": 404, "search": 404 }, "inventory_resources": 3, "only_manifest_owned_resources_deleted": true }, { "attempt": 3, "group_absent": true, "resource_get_status": { "account": 404, "search": 404 }, "inventory_resources": 3, "only_manifest_owned_resources_deleted": true }, { "attempt": 4, "group_absent": true, "resource_get_status": { "account": 404, "search": 404 }, "inventory_resources": 3, "only_manifest_owned_resources_deleted": true } ] }, "quotation_acceptance_passed": true, "citation_output_acceptance_passed": false, "scope_verdict": "Quotation fidelity and source-title attribution recovered twice; native citation output remains failed", "all_new_owned_resources_absent": true, "attempts_summary": [ { "attempt": 1, "outcome": "Low-effort native MCP missing-planning-model error despite definition readback; no agent call" }, { "attempt": 2, "outcome": "Minimal MCP succeeded; installed SDK removed AgentReference helper; no agent call" }, { "attempt": 3, "outcome": "Installed-SDK-compatible agent requested all three short title queries; full-question approval guard rejected these; no retrieval approved" }, { "attempt": 4, "outcome": "Corrected to observed minimal MCP schema; two actual model answers each copied all three original opening sentences; citations were blank; unsupported model abstained despite seven off-topic tool documents" } ], "limitations": [ "Current minimal MCP exposes short-query semantics, unlike the earlier low-effort full-question schema; low-effort planner failure is not resolved", "Actual excerpts and titles are exact, independently joined to original IDs and owned index document URLs", "Actual model citation strings contain only whitespace and message annotations are empty; citation rendering and exact requested citation output remain failed", "Unsupported control passed model abstention with an empty sources array, but native MCP returned seven off-topic documents; zero-document retrieval did not pass", "No deterministic final-answer replacement, no user-agent mutation/publication, no Activity or Copilot connected-agent execution", "ARM absence proves resources are deleted, not a guarantee about provider soft-delete or inference-retention policies", "Four sequential disposable environments, never concurrent, same approved small capacity; no billed-amount claim" ], "verification_utc": "2026-10-20T12:55:32.520825+00:00" }