You can clone with
HTTPS or Subversion.
Issue 505 from bugs.joindiaspora.com
Created by: Wavesonics
On Mon Nov 1 20:03:57 2010
There should be a wizard in the Account UI for migrating your seed from one pod to the another, all server to server.
This way contacts could be notified of the move in a secure way, and the old account could be deleted when the move was complete.
There is a $70 open bounty on this issue. Add to the bounty at Bountysource.
Comment by: Hexagon
On Mon Nov 1 20:45:46 2010
Comment by: Cathryne
On Fri Nov 26 18:43:11 2010
+1 with a user-defined overlap time until the old account automatically closes.
This is sincerely critical .... any idea on the state of this ? (or the partial photo & xml export ? )
It's not being worked on yet. I guess it'll come somewhere during beta. On the one hand I think it's a shame, on the other hand I'm glad they are working on more usable things first.
I'm willing to work on this with someone else. Have a good amount of programming experience, but just learned Ruby...also, due to classes, unable to work on it every day.
Anyone else willing to help with this?
If there s need for it, i d be willing to help with this:
databases, replication, migration (12 yrs mysql, 15 yrs general sql), db architecture,
coding: C, perl, php
no skills in ruby at all :(
Linking diaspora discussion on this topic here
I've sent ideas to diaspora-dev in this mail thread, thanks for the discussion, guys!
great. i ll gladly contribute where it s needed -
i m blank on ruby though.
my feeling is that we ll have to look a little bit at database structure, redundancies, in the process -
though you rightfully say it s out of scope here -
but it s something i ll gladly comment on / help with.
Any progress on this? Seems like an important feature before going to beta.
It's not on the beta checklist, and though it is an important feature, I don't think it need be -- Diaspora's built on an iterative development process, so "Beta" is much more fluid (and possibly having less substantial meaning) here than it is in other sorts of Free Software projects. That last sentence is my opinion only, so it's fine if you feel differently.
More directly, I'm trying to learn the internals of Diaspora (strong documentation is...lacking), before I attempt this, as well as coordinating a release for my own Free Software Project in the next two weeks. I plan to attack it around Thanksgiving (US one, three weeks away). That's my approximate timeframe.
I'm not sure if or when I'd be able to help out on this, but whoever works on this, it would be ideal if the system could take care of updating all your followers/friends of the move for you. Transparently, too, so the remote pods will just receive an update when they next check for information. It just seems important that this doesn't recreate the hassle of changing email addresses or phone numbers.
Perhaps it would be a good idea if there is functionality to not only move accounts, but in the same process to merge accounts...
And perhaps to sync more than one instance of an account between two or more servers: for redundancy purposes.
Would the move generate a HTTP 301 Permanent Redirect to the new page location, or would the old pod mirror the updates from the new pod?
That would depend on whether one moved or merged the account (301) or synced them (mirror). Although you should be able to log into either pod if you're syncing.
Follow up #2616
Hey, is this really abandoned? You advertised this feature on your very fist landing page:
I would like to see this feature implemented soon
Yes, this would be great. What would happen if a pod closes down or doesn't update the version of Diaspora??
This issue is closed but linked to from
#2616 (mentioned as 'follow-up') is closed as well, so the only 'status' might potentially exist in a mailing list archive.
Wouldn't it make sense to update the home page to stop sending people here? I'd vote to remove that 'coming soon' feature, because it seems it's not. At the very least the link to this specific issue should be removed.
This is essential for the long-term viability of the Diaspora mission; the whole point ti to have freedom of movement. Still, great job Diaspora HQ.
This feature would be handy. Also since this is clearly dead, the "coming soon" should be removed from diasporaprojects home page.
https://groups.google.com/d/topic/diaspora-discuss/zOpARcOPfoM/discussion is the accumulated feature discussion for this issue.
This is still high priority, but apart from many ideas we never really got any code for this...
So we can't move pods easily yet? We just have to delete our old account and make a new one? I thought this was going to be a main feature but seems its not completed. I see that I can export data but not import. Least on Diasp.org which I plan to move from soon.
I've been waiting quite a while (years, by now) to sign up on a pod since it's unsure if I'll be able to move to a self-hosted pod later on. I was happy when I saw the "Coming soon" on the main page but apparently this is not something that's in the works. Is there any word on what the problem is? The UI? The code? The security?
Even a stupid migrate process would be cool to start off with - just to be able to import old posts (not trigger any federation for them) and do an automatic aspects creation and contact adding.
It would be great to have this function! I myself for example would be very interested in migrating from the joindiaspora-pod to a pod here in Europe. I feel that a function like this would make it more convenient for a user to continue using diaspora when their pod may be shutting down. It would be simple and great just to migrate to another pod and keep on interacting like nothing happened. It is a decentralized idea going well together with the idea of the concept of Diaspora*.
The lack of this feature is the only thing keeping me from signing up for and donating to Diaspora. I'm sad to see that its development has apparently been abandoned - seems like a pretty core concept.
I wouldn't say it has been abandoned - it is a constant discussion topic among not only users talking about features but also many devs that write code for Diaspora. You have to remember that no one writes code for Diaspora for a living any more - it's all volunteers. So this kind of big features will take time. It is a must feature that has to be done at some point though, sooner the better.
some facility for removal of dead handles would be good to include, maybe generate a webfinger on 404 to a guid or whatever :)
It is something as simple as an import feature for the data it lets us export, it isn't rocket science. Seed migration was one of their MAIN advertising points and it has yet to be implemented or even trial implemented. Diaspora* just isn't functional enough and uses very unpopular software among developers. It isn't worth many people's hassle. It did what it set out to do, proved you can have decentralized social networks. Problem is, it just doesn't have really any use. Even if they finished it not enough people even know about Diaspora* to matter. Tech. is an industry where you have to stay focused and working, if you fall too far behind you'll be left there and that is what has happened to Diaspora*. For me personally, it just isn't worth the time to set up and work on. Social Networks of all kinds are declining anyways as people lose faith in Facebook, have no use for Twitter, Google+ is only used by google fanboys and their friends, and things like this were never finished with the basic essentials.
Please keep the discussing issues on Github - this is not a discussion forum but a place to follow up on issues relating to Diaspora*. There is no point fretting about the missing feature - it will be implemented when some developer writes the code. All the devs do this on their spare time and without any compensation. If you really demand something to be implement it - do it or find someone to do it! That is the true power of open source :)
You seemed to have missed the point, it isn't just a missing feature. It is a flagship feature that has been used in advertising Diaspora* since the start. That is a major issue and should be given utmost attention and it isn't. YOU were discussing what someone else had said and making excuses, and I was doing the same by commenting on what you said and removing the excuses... You can't blame the fact it is volunteer, several volunteer software developers and even OS developers have brand new features working and testing on a daily basis. You can't state something as a flagship feature then ignore it.
JosephBeck hit the nail on the head - from an end-user perspective, the ability to control your own data is THE distinguishing feature of Diaspora over other social networks. Without the option to migrate pods this feature doesn't exist. There is obviously a lot of other work being done on the project, but it's doomed to obscurity as long as the core functionality is crippled.
@JosephBeck @Gimeit no one is ignoring this feature, I don't know a single person who is somehow participating who is ignoring this or doesn't want it done :)
The reason this isn't implemented is not because it is not wanted but because there are a limited amount of devs working on the code and to be frank there are a lot of things to do and fix - this is only one of them. Recently the most active contributors have been concentrating on code cleanup since the whole community governance thing. But the truth is that more devs are needed to keep things rolling - so if you know some Ruby just jump in and help create an awesome open source social network :)
@DeadSuperHero just noticed this issue is closed for some reason - can you open it? :D
lol I love how every feature on this issue tracker is "urgent" and the project is totally "worthless" without it.
edit: Incidentally, running your own pod is still the easiest way to be a part of DIASPORA. You can own your data, but at this time you must be self-reliant to do so. Soon, we hope to incorporate this feature, but we want to make sure it's done in a safe and robust way.
@dskvr The only bottleneck in getting a pod up and running at this time is command-line and Rails experience. We're working on an app right now (might even be out there in beta) that will provision new pods on Heroku, so you basically click a button, enter in your Heroku account and API key, and the app does the rest of the work. The other leg of that is what I'm working on, an app that will tag the latest releases on Github and send an API call that redeploys your app. This way, we can actually institute a kind-of continuous integration system, making sure each of our pod servers are up to date all the time. In situations like when the Rails XML/mass-assignment vulnerabilities were exposed this week, it would be super cool if we could ensure security across our ENTIRE network, without needing root access to each box.
That being said, this is still an issue that needs dealing with. I don't think a Github Issue is the place to discuss how to best move forward on this, so I made a Loomio discussion: https://www.loomio.org/discussions/1653
If you're on our Loomio, please vote on the current proposal and if we get a majority amount of "No's", we'll discuss how to best implement this feature.
I really don't see any point in voting about this feature :) Who wouldn't want pod migration to happen?
The problem is no one has done it yet and all the developers are now doing this as a hobby. So until someone picks this up nothing much to debate (except technical ideas of course) :P
@jaywink that's what I meant the Loomio for, discussing how we're gonna do this. Just wanted to make sure we actually did want to do this before assuming you guys know what I'm thinking :)
@tubbo Thanks for your response, means a lot. @jaywink The truth, gotta love the truth. If I find myself in a position to dedicate time to this feature, I will. Unfortunately, hobby-projects have been on the backburner for years :-(
Note: I would put my two-cents on loomeo, but it's closed to registrations. Not that it matters too much since I have little to no say in the 'development priorities' of Diaspora considering I have made 0 commits to its' repo.
Like over 90% of the people there... Just get your email address to anyone of us an you're in.
I just posted a $50 bounty that'll go to the person whose pull request gets accepted for this. I'd love to see this added, it's essential to the project...
Everyone that +1'd should consider adding to the bounty, we could make it worthwhile for a dev:
Yeah, what the hell. I added 10 bucks to the bounty - hopefully somebody will pick it up.
Just put your emails here and we'll invite you to join the discussion
So how is this coming along?
ongoing discussion: https://www.loomio.org/discussions/1653
Dudes. Adding YET MORE barriers to entry (I have to join Loomio now? WTF is Loomio. I don't want to join more crap to talk about crap I'm already talking about here) is not helpful.
I'm stuck on a pod with an outdated version of Diaspora and no other-platform export plugins. I can't easily move. Given the entire point of Diaspora and the fact that it was a core feature, that's a problem.
"Incidentally, running your own pod is still the easiest way to be a part of DIASPORA."
That's also a problem. It "only" requires Rails and command-line experience! That is a 20-mile high barrier to entry to the average person. Hell, I've been a developer for 20 years and it's still something I'm unwilling to do because I don't have the time, money, or server space to do it (partly due to the choice of Rails, but that ship has LONG sailed) and I know precisely jack and squat about Ruby or Rails, having come from the Python and ::hrk:: PHP worlds.
Diaspora-type censorship resistant networks might be critical to humanity's future, but they will remain unused unless developers MAKE IT EASY.
No, I am not joining yet another goddamn platform to say that. If somebody wants it on Loomio, paste it please.
...and the friggin' Bountysource URL is dead so I can't donate to any bounty, which I am prepared to do despite having not enough money for cat litter, in case anybody's questioning deeds vs words. :p
Let's be honest, Diaspora* has dropped the ball and it isn't going to be going anywhere now. Any hype is dead and by the time they get their crap together, there will be a newer and better alternative. It's quite sad, but I've all but given up hope in this project. It has been years and it is STILL lacking this. Not having one of your main selling points / advertised features is a colossal failure. Maybe one day Diaspora* will make some worthy progress to make it a contender to things like Facebook and Google+. That day is not any time soon it seems.
Doesn't matter where the discussion is held, nothing is happening.
@gordon-morehouse here is the up-to-date bug-bounty ticket: https://www.bountysource.com/issues/59067-seed-migration-wizard which has already $60 on it.
We're all aware that diaspora* is not easy at the moment. That's why we're keeping 0. in front of the version number, to say it's stable, but not really ready to be deployed /maintained / updated easily. We just need more time, money and people working on it. But trust us (and join us ;)) we're going slowly but we're going the right way.
@JosephBeck a project is alive if people is believing in it. And there is still people believing in it ;)
@gordon-morehouse we recently launched a "big" pod in France: https://framasphere.org (which already has 6000 users in only one month). We want to create a new community so we will probably be able to raise some money and improve diaspora*. The pod migration is one of the features we want to work on. Still many things to do, but hopefully we will success to do something ;)