New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Copter: hard Yaw can cause all motors to idle when yaw released. #836
Comments
AndKe, |
Logs: Anyway - With your knowledge, you're most likely right regarding the reason, but I think it's funny it did not happened at the greatest rotation speed, but after the yaw speed were successfully reduced. I did not test how fast/much rotation is needed,(like, if 180degree at full stick is enough) but I can imagine a fast approach with hard yaw right before touchdown, could result in crash. |
I guess this user's motor stalled/got out of sync while testing: he's log is not as clear, but I see similarity: |
ok great. i'm going to close this issue then. If that's not ok just post a comment below and we can re-open. |
Please consider re opening. This is pretty dangerous in hard wind, I did some one fast yaw today, and wind flipped the hexa once I released yaw, (because motors went to idle, and the angle toward the wind caused a extra quick flip) - It recovered with great authority and continued as if nothing happened :) I do not have a new log for you, because logging stopped at line 220k due to the usual FAT/cluster problem, I am using a sd that have less problem with that, but not perfect. |
It's best if you try this for yourself, be sure to have idle spedd up on motors, or some might stall.
Fly at least 5 meters AGL (in my case, position hold) , and apply full yaw, You'll get up to something around 200deg/sec (default) let it reach full rotation speed, then release stick.
At least 50% of the time, rotation will break, the all motors will go to idle for half a sec or so,. causing a fall, then they recover.!
Attached screenshot:
from position 26.5, you can see 3 motors speed up, 3 go easier, I let the yaw stick go around pos27.16 you can see the pihhawk counter the rotation - then all motors go to thr_min, and it falls.
And a zoomed in:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: