some solution when using onChange and onComposition in React input and textarea components
JavaScript HTML
Latest commit 7c93ce7 Jan 4, 2017 @eyesofkids update
Permalink
Failed to load latest commit information.
controlled update Jan 4, 2017
env update Jan 4, 2017
uncontrolled update Jan 4, 2017
LICENSE Initial commit Dec 31, 2016
README.md update Jan 4, 2017

README.md

Demo

https://eyesofkids.github.io/

demo for japanese input method

  • input = pure onChange events
  • inner = onChange + onComposition events corrections

What is Composition Events problem?

Composition Events will be fired when users type some text from IME. Developers can use these events to help change Event to capture the input text correctly. The change event occurs when a control loses the input focus and its value has been modified since gaining focus.

The main problem is when users type these words from IME and do something like search the database or filter out from some data, sometimes these functions will be unworkable. For example, if users type "ni" during the composition session, maybe it will be one of "你尼泥腻" in Chinese or one of "にニ尼煮" in Japanese. But in this moment, the change event also be fired. If the search or filter functions of the application are designed to be invoked when change event occured, there maybe something wrong logically. These functions should be invoked after users finished the composition session.

In React, there are three synthetic events - onCompositionEnd, onCompositionStart and onCompositionUpdate. If the input components(<input...> and <textarea.../>) are "uncontrolled", we can use them to help onChange to capture the text correctly. The only different point is Google Chrome change its events sequence after v53. Check Cinput.js and Ctextarea.js files.

But if these input components are "controlled", it will be hard to solve the problem.

Because these the value of a controlled component is came from state. We can't modify state directly and the only way to update state is using this.setState() to schedule update. But this.setState() may be asynchronous.

After test, i found different OS/browsers could have different results. I have written some code to solve it. But i thought it isn't a good solution. It uses the browser detection and two properties of the state object. One is for input, another is for internal functions(search, filter...etc). It can't just use one property of the state object because i can't stop any change events, state need it to update the value of the input element. If i stop some change events during composition session, i would get nothing after typing these words from IME.

Maybe someone could help to test and give me some idea for the solution. The better solution is to revise the events of controlled components in React.

Infos

Online Test

https://eyesofkids.github.io/

boilerplate

The boilerplate is here.

Test Results

IME & Words for test

  1. Japanese: Stand Hiragana IME, "kimi no na ha" 君の名は
  2. Traditional Chinese: Zhuyin IME, "su3 2k7 au/6 y7" 你的名字
  3. Simplified Chinese: Pinyin IME, "ni de ming zi" 你的名字

React Component

  • Controlled/uncontrolled input component()

by OS

i have resolved these problems listed blow, the code is here.

macOS

  • Chrome v55: composition problem
  • Safari: composition problem
  • Firefox: composition problem
  • Opera v42: composition problem

Win7

  • IE 11: "NO" problem
  • Chrome v55: composition problem
  • Firefox v50: composition problem

Win10

  • IE 11: composition problem
  • Edge v38: composition problem
  • Chrome v55: composition problem
  • Opera v42: composition problem