Chapter 6: Purely functional state

Tianxia Zhou edited this page Jun 30, 2016 · 12 revisions


  • Notes: Chapter notes and links to further reading related to the content in this chapter
  • FAQ: Questions related to the chapter content. Feel free to add questions and/or answers here related to the chapter.


State in Scalaz

The Scalaz library supplies a State data type that is a specialization of a more general type IndexedStateT, where State[S,A] = IndexedStateT[Id, S, S, A] and Id[A] = A.

You do not need to understand this more general type if you just want to use State[S,A]. But the general type has two additional features:

  1. The start state and end state of a state transition can have different types. That is, it's not necessarily a transition S => (S, A), but S1 => (S2, A). The ordinary State type is where S1 and S2 are fixed to be the same type.
  2. It is a monad transformer (see chapter 12). The type of a state transition is not S => (S, A), but S => F[(S, A)] for some monad F (see chapter 11). The monad transformer allows us to bind across F and State in one operation. The ordinary State type is where this monad is fixed to be the identity monad Id.

Pseudorandom number generation

The Wikipedia article on pseudorandom number generators is a good place to start for more information about such generators. It also makes the distinction between random and pseudo-random generation.

There's also a good page on Linear congruential generators, including advantages and disadvantages and links to several implementations in various languages.

Deterministic finite state automata

The State data type can be seen as a model of Mealy Machines in the following way. Consider a function f of a type like A => State[S, B]. It is a transition function in a Mealy machine where

  • The type S is the set of states
  • State[S, B]'s representation is a function of type S => (B, S). Then the argument to that function is the initial state.
  • The type A is the input alphabet of the machine.
  • The type B is the output alphabet of the machine.

The function f itself is the transition function of the machine. If we expand A => State[S, B], it is really A => S => (B, S) under the hood. If we uncurry that, it becomes (A, S) => (B, S) which is identical to a transition function in a Mealy machine. Specifically, the output is determined both by the state of type S and the input value of type A.

Contrast this with a Moore machine, whose output is determined solely by the current state. A Moore machine could be modeled by a data type like the following:

case class Moore[S, I, A](t: (S, I) => S, g: S => A)

Together with an initial state s of type S. Here:

  • S is the set of states.
  • I is the input alphabet.
  • A is the output alphabet.
  • t is the transition function mapping the state and an input value to the next state.
  • g is the output function mapping each state to the output alphabet.

As with Mealy machines, we could model the transition function and the output function as a single function:

type Moore[S, I, A] = S => (I => S, A)

Since both the transition function t and the output function g take a value of type S, we can take that value as a single argument and from it determine the transition function of type I => S as well as the output value of type A at the same time.

Mealy and Moore machines are related in a way that is interesting to explore.


If we specialize Moore so that the input and output types are the same, we get a pair of functions t: (S, A) => S and g: S => A. We can view these as (respectively) a "getter" and a "setter" of A values on the type S:

get: S => A
set: (S, A) => S

Imagine for example where S is Person and A is Name.

type Name = String

case class Person(name: Name, age: Int)

A function getName would have the type Person => Name, and setName would have the type (Person, Name) => Person. In the latter case, given a Person and a Name, we can set the name of the Person and get a new Person with the new name.

The getter and setter together form what's called a lens. A lens "focuses" on a part of a larger structure, and allows us to modify the value under focus. A simple model of lenses is:

case class Lens[A, B](get: A => B, set: (A, B) => A)

Where A is the larger structure, and B is the part of that structure that is under focus.

Importantly, lenses compose. That is, if you have a Lens[A,B], and a Lens[B,C], you can get a composite Lens[A,C] that focuses on a C of a B of an A.

Lenses are handy to use with the State data type. Given a State[S,A]. If we're interested in looking at or modifying a portion of the state, and the portion has type T, it can be useful to focus on a portion of the state that we're interested in using a Lens[S,T]. The getter and setter of a lens can be readily converted to a State action:

def getS[S,A](l: Lens[S, A]): State[S,A] = State(s => (l.get(s), s))
def setS[S,A](l: Lens[S, A], a: A): State[S,Unit] = State(s => ((), l.set(s, a)))

We cannot, however, turn a State action into a Lens, for the same reason that we cannot convert a Moore machine into a Mealy machine.

See the Scalaz library's lenses, the Monocle library for Scala, and the Lens library for Haskell, for more information about how to take advantage of lenses.

Stack overflow issues in State

The State data type as represented in chapter 6 suffers from a problem with stack overflows for long-running state machines. The problem is that flatMap contains a function call that is in tail position, but this tail call is not eliminated on the JVM.

The solution is to use a trampoline. Chapter 13 gives a detailed explanation of this technique. See also Rúnar's paper "Stackless Scala With Free Monads".

Using the trampolining data type TailRec from chapter 13, a stack-safe State data type could be written as follows:

case class State[S,A](run: S => TailRec[(A, S)])

This is identical to the State data type we present in chapter 6, except that the result type of run is TailRec[(S,A)] instead of just (S,A). See chapter 13 for a thorough discussion of TailRec. The important part is that the result type of the State transition function needs to be a data type like TailRec that gets run at a later time by a tail recursive trampoline function.


You can’t perform that action at this time.
You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session. You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.
Press h to open a hovercard with more details.