Skip to content

Thermostat doesn't work #66

Closed
frabcus opened this Issue Dec 23, 2012 · 11 comments

7 participants

@frabcus
Owner
frabcus commented Dec 23, 2012

Literally - the heating is just always on when it is on.

Fixing this with a thermostat in the hall is also a bit pointless - at least get one that can be moved elsewhere in the house, and that can be turned on and off over the Internet. Otherwise seems a bit pathetic in 2013.

@canadaduane

I just bought a nest 2. It's awesome. Just know that the glass on the front is supposed to have a stylish "crack". I thought mine was broken and returned it before realizing the new one had a "crack" in the exact same spot.

@frabcus
Owner
frabcus commented Dec 27, 2012

Nest looks ace - however, I'm not sure it works well with UK boiler/radiator based heating systems.

Also, doesn't look like it helps me add separate control of different rooms to the system.

@canadaduane
@duncanparkes

I've been wondering about LightwaveRF (http://recombu.com/digital/news/lightwaverf-home-automation_M11004.html). Does the X10 stuff provide boiler interlock, or does it just turn on and off individual radiators? Currently our thermostat is in a room which has an open fire, a log burner, and two radiators with thermostatic valves...

@spmason
spmason commented Jan 7, 2013

I've been looking at this for a while and have come up with a few options I'll share here:

  • This Honeywell solution looks almost perfect to me. But unfortunately no iPhone control..
  • The Heatmiser WiFi thermostat looks good, but it's just a stat and I want radiator/zone control..
  • The LightwaveRF heating controls sound good on paper but I've heard people mention that they're not that reliable. It's also hard to find these for sale online. I have just ordered some LWRF lighting and electricity controls though
  • These FS20 controls were recommended on a few forums I read, but it seems a bit more involved than just fitting a stat and a few TRV's, plus everything seems to be in German. It also seems that these are the same controls marketed by HouseHeat. iPhone control is most likely possible via FHEM and the PC module

I haven't even considered X10 as I have powerline adapters in my house and I hear they don't play nice together

@mildmojo

I've been impressed with Radio Thermostat's wifi-enabled thermostats & cloud/mobile service. I've got the 3M-branded 3M50 (their CT30) which goes for about $100 in the US. iPhone/Android/web remote control would get you control away from the thermostat. I don't know what a real multi-zone system looks like, but the web/mobile UI can control and schedule multiple thermostats individually. The company's published docs for the control/inquiry REST API exposed on the devices themselves, too, which is nice.

Also see the recent Almond+ kickstarter. $100 USD for an 802.11ac router with a small touchscreen and Zigbee + Z-Wave wireless device control for things like thermostats and lighting. It apparently extends those device controls to phones & tablets over the internet, too. Projected delivery in late summer.

@Floppy
Floppy commented Aug 25, 2013

Just happened to pop by, and I can certainly recommend the Heatmiser wifi thermostats as well. Controlling your heating with your smartphone is rather good, and they have a published protocol if you want to hack your own.

@frabcus frabcus removed the ready label Apr 14, 2014
@daz260 daz260 referenced this issue in canadaduane/house Jun 24, 2014
@canadaduane canadaduane Added bathtub plug, rack for keys, kitchen faucet aerator, silverware…
… stacker, and carpet corner support
4e681ef
@frabcus
Owner
frabcus commented Dec 12, 2014

In the end, I took easy / lazy route to this and got a Hive (by British Gas) while upgrading my boiler anyway (#1). It had good reviews (http://www.pcadvisor.co.uk/reviews/digital-home/3524456/hive-active-heating-review/) and is British, and doesn't involve more control of my life by Google.

So far, seems good - nicely made interface on Android, iOS and Web. And works and is useful to be able to control heating remotely.

I'm not convinced it is logging my temperature in detail permanently - you can only get lots of datapoints today yesterday in the graph interface, or average each day for longer periods. Average across whole day is useless!

Overall, I don't think this kind of thing is a life changer, but it is useful.

@frabcus frabcus closed this Dec 12, 2014
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.