Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 40 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.Sign up
x/net/http2: make Transport send GOAWAY? #18340
We previously debated whether the Transport should send GOAWAY frames on shutdown, but couldn't think of a useful reason why.
The spec does say:
Or code is like:
// TODO: do clients send GOAWAY too? maybe? Just Close: cc.tconn.Close()
But I'm still not quite sure why a server would care.
Hm. GOAWAY is roughly "Don't initiate any more streams."
In vanilla H2, the only practical protocol-visible application of a client->server GOAWAY would be to stop the server initiating any more pushes, I think. However, protocol extensions or other ALPN tokens might change that.
Inside the implementation, I suppose it would also give the server an opportunity to release resources in a slightly more ordered fashion (depending on how you close the transport connection).
So, it's polite, and it's a SHOULD in the spec (it says "endpoints," not just "servers"). What are the downsides of sending it?
Anything to add, @martinthomson?
That about sums it up. Though I would add that if a server is tracking whether individual requests are getting through, GOAWAY helps with that. The server never really had any certainty here, but I am aware of cases where there are optimizations that apply when you know that a client had gotten the message.