x/tools/gopls: increase max number of completion candidates for unimported packages

[110y]

This is a feature request.

gopls version

latest master branch (fa10359)

What did you want to see?

• Make the max number of completion candidates for unimported packages configurable.

What did you see instead?

The current implementation uses hard-coded number (5) for the unimported package completion. Though I know the unimported package completion is expensive, I think it's worth making the number of candidates for it configurable (actually, I'm using my own forked version of gopls that uses over 100 for unimported completion candidates for a long time.)

[110y]

I send a PR that implements this feature request: golang/tools#442

[findleyr]

@110y thank you for the request, and your report that the current number of unimported completion candidates was too low -- I had not heard this, but it makes sense.

Before we add a new configuration options, I want to answer the question: why couldn't we just increase the current hard-coded default? Why would it be the case that 100 works better for you, but not for others?

In general, I think we need a framework for addressing these types of requests for new configuration, so I took this opportunity to file #61001.

[adonovan]

Note that #60964 is a dup of this issue. Bumping up the threshold constant (to, say, 10) would solve that specific problem, though I suspect it would cause some other package to fall just beyond the threshold, moving the problem rather than fixing the whole class of problems. But maybe that's acceptable if the larger value is enough to dampen the expectations of exhaustiveness (like the way that no-one looks at page 2 of the Google search results). My point is that increasing this constant from 5 to 10 could be a tactical fix that doesn't require adding a configuration knob, or deciding on the framework for such knobs.

[gopherbot]

Timed out in state WaitingForInfo. Closing.

(I am just a bot, though. Please speak up if this is a mistake or you have the requested information.)