Ten Simple Rules for Creating an Effective Lesson
Switch branches/tags
Nothing to show
Clone or download
Fetching latest commit…
Cannot retrieve the latest commit at this time.
Failed to load latest commit information.


Ten Simple Rules for Creating an Effective Lesson

  • There are many kinds of lessons, formal and informal, from seconds long to lifelong
  • This guide is about prepared instructional plans and content for half an hour to a day

A Little Bit of Theory

  • Psychology of learning
    • Load short term memory
    • Keep it there long enough to transfer to long term memory
    • Create links so that knowledge is retrievable (bigger obstacle than outright retention)
  • Goal for novices is to build a mental model
    • Following a path through a concept map helps ensure connectedness
    • Naming subgoals help
  • Cognitive load - learners are trying to
    • Recall factual knowledge
    • Choose a solution strategy
    • Formulate a response
    • Use tools,
    • So teach these all separately and synthesize as a lesson in its own right
  • While we're here, a few myths:
    • Mindset and stereotype threat are probably not as important as initially thought (this is how science progresses)
    • VAK learning styles
    • The "Pyramid of Learning"
    • And teaching evaluations are suspect, as are self-assessments

1. Use Learner Personas to Define Your Audience

  • A lesson is a user interface for knowledge, so borrow methods from user interface design
  • You are not your learners (expert blind spot)
  • General background
  • What they already know
  • What they think they want to know
  • What they actually need to know in order to achieve their aims (which may be different from what they think)
  • Special considerations (e.g., accessibility, child care)
  • How the lesson will help them achieve their aims
  • First four parts are usually shared across multiple lessons and instructors

2. Write Summative Assessments to Set Concrete Goals

  • "Understand linear regression" is vague; a specific exercise makes aim much clearer
  • Also helps communicate value of lesson to learners
  • Derive learning objectives from what learners will do to demonstrate knowledge
  • Remember, "understand X" isn't checkable
  • Draw a concept map!
  • This series should be "7 plus or minus 2 Rules"

3. Write Formative Assessments for Pacing, Design, Preparation, and Reinforcement

  • Spend 1-2 minutes checking in with learners via formative assessment every 10-15 minutes
  • Pacing: are they still with you?
  • Design: they act as milestones building toward the summative assessment
  • Preparation: everything in the summative assessment should be exercised by a formative assessment
  • Reinforcement: learners remember more if they use material right away (problem isn't forgetting, but access)
  • Doing this almost always tell you that you're trying to cover too much
  • Makes prerequisites explicit
    • Enumerating prerequisite knowledge and skills helps you overcome expert blind spot
    • And helps stitch lessons together
    • Be careful not to intimidate learners who have impostor syndrome
    • As with summative assessment, works best when concrete
    • Not "understand linear regression", but "can do the following"

4. Design for Peer Instruction

  • Scalable approximation of individual tutoring that engages learners
    1. Students do pre-class reading
    2. Instructor poses question
    3. Students vote publicly
    4. Students discuss reasoning with each other
    5. Students re-vote
    6. Instructor reviews
  • Crou2001 and Port2016 are just two examples of studies showing its effectiveness
  • In practice, often do some instruction in class, but always leading to peer discussion as quickly as possible
  • E.g., type and run a few lines of code, then ask "what happens if I add X?" or "what line do I add to achieve Y?"
    • Thanks to Mark Guzdial for this example
  • The Discussion Book has many other methods (e.g., think-pair-share)

5. Use Worked Examples

  • Learners learn faster from worked examples than they do from solving problems on their own
    • They eventually need to do the latter, but step-by-step explanation of why and how helps more
  • Live performances (music, programming, theorem proof) are effectively worked examples
    • The "PEE" in "PETE"

6. Use Concreteness Fading

  • PETE (Problem, Explanation, Theory, Example) goes from specific and tangible to more abstract
  • What is the authentic problem that the lesson solves next?
  • Explain a concrete solution
  • Fill in the underlying theory
  • Provide a second example so that learners will understand which parts generalize
  • Authentic problem may be an end goal, or in later lessons, may arise out of a previous solution
  • Build a usable mental model so that learners have somewhere to put knowledge, then correct the model as necessary
  • E.g., ball-and-spring model in chemistry, evolution solely by descent, CPU-memory-disk model in computing

7. Show How to Detect, Diagnose, and Correct Common Mistakes

  • One aspect of worked examples that's important enough to deserve its own section
  • Novices spend much of their time making mistakes and trying to fix them, because they're novices
  • Including DD&C in the lesson reduces frustration, which in turn accelerates learning
  • Also helps solidify their mental model

8. Eliminate Incentives for Cheating

  • Cheating is usually not a symptom of moral failing, but a rational response to poorly-designed incentives
    • Beck2014 found that cheating is no more likely online than in person
  • Motivation and demotivation in adult learners
    • Motivators: agency, utility, communality
    • Demotivators: unpredictability, unfairness, indifference
  • Examples from Lang2013:
    • Set the cost of failure very high
    • Rely on single assessment mechanisms like multiple-choice tests
    • Arbitrary grading criteria

9. Be Inclusive

  • Choice of language or examples will tell people whether or not they're welcome and likely to be taken seriously
    • If you don't already know this, you're probably a member of a privileged group
    • DiSa2014a demonstrates effectiveness
  • Do not use a deficit model ("they" are missing something, "they" need to try harder)
  • Vision, hearing, and mobility/dexterity challenges
  • Economic disadvantages

10. Make Collaboration with Other Instructors Natural

  • FAIR Principles for data (findable, accessible, interoperable, reusable) also apply to lessons
    • But "reusable" is aiming low
    • DiSa2014b shows that lessons are often not findable
  • Instead of one author broadcasting for others to use, foster collaboration in a teaching commons
    • Open source software and Wikipedia demonstrate the benefits
    • Increases inclusivity and reduces lesson maintenance burden
    • And it's more fun