Skip to content

Behaviour of hired photographers #87

Closed
tommorris opened this Issue Apr 27, 2013 · 2 comments

2 participants

@tommorris
The Hack Day Manifesto member

At Yahoo! Hack Europe, I just watched a professional photographer hired by Yahoo photograph an attendee who is asleep. blog post

This seems really shitty and problematic. It certainly left me with a very bad taste in my mouth.

Would there be any objections to adding words to the manifesto to the effect of "if you are going to hire a semi-pro or professional photographer for the event, instruct them to have some respect for attendees and not take photos when they obviously do not want to be photographed or cannot object to being photographed"?

There are moral and legal objections regarding privacy. Wikipedia's photo hosting site, Wikimedia Commons has grappled with this—see COM:IDENT. If an attendee doesn't wish to be photographed individually, event organisers should respect that wish. Photographs absolutely should not be taken when people are asleep since they are not in a position to reasonably object. Care needs to be taken to balance the openness and public nature of the event with the privacy of attendees.

This is something which has a gendered aspect too: just as women (as well as children, LGBT people and other groups) are harmed by real name policies, lack of respect for privacy at conferences may subject attendees in marginalized groups who naturally have a higher risk of online harassment to further unwanted risk and thus alienate them from the community and from attending future events.

@cbetta
The Hack Day Manifesto member
cbetta commented Apr 28, 2013

Sounds like we should write about it but not too much. Something along the lines of what you said is good.

I don't want to have a 5 page document on best practices for photographers when photographing events (which some people could easily write). Just saying

@tommorris tommorris added a commit to tommorris/hackdaymanifesto.github.com that referenced this issue Apr 29, 2013
@tommorris tommorris adding section in privacy/photography
per issue #87
f37f5f4
@tommorris
The Hack Day Manifesto member

I've submitted a pull request - #88

Rather than merge it in myself, I'll leave it for @danielknell or someone else to merge it in.

@tommorris tommorris closed this May 21, 2013
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.