Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Improving consistency with other platforms #143

Closed
23 of 24 tasks
carlinmack opened this issue Mar 21, 2020 · 36 comments
Closed
23 of 24 tasks

Improving consistency with other platforms #143

carlinmack opened this issue Mar 21, 2020 · 36 comments

Comments

@carlinmack
Copy link
Contributor

carlinmack commented Mar 21, 2020

Continuation of #105

Faces

Other

  • pinching fingers Pinching fingers should be closer
  • oyster - redesign - I don't think this should be purple at all
  • small aeroplane - tweet - no cabin, looks like a drone
  • waffle - tweet - add butter and syrup
  • japanese dolls - blog post - need to add scepter and fan, change skin colour to white
  • ringed planet - tweet - should add planetary bands, maybe adjust rotation to 26.7°
  • bouquet - not a bouquet!
  • custard - looks like a cake, not a creme caramel
  • mail box - should be isometric
  • spaghetti - all other platforms show a dish with a fork
  • atm sign - should say ATM and look like a sign (current design is really nice and should be moved to OpenMoji extras afterwards
  • christmas tree - needs to be a bit more decorative with a star on top
  • Black nib: - majority of platforms shows it as only the nib of a fountain pen. Some platforms (including openmoji) show it as a entire or almost entire fountain pen. It is very confusing as it is just the same as fountain pen!
  • Cinema - almost all platforms show as a symbol inside a square. Maybe to add a square around
  • crab - openmoji is only platform that shows crab facing downward. Design of claws could be improved
@Michele0512
Copy link

spaghetti dish: looks like a salad bowl more than a plate. (in all other platform is a dish; the curry rice is openmoji is a plate)
exploding head
exploding head (new design): I don't think should be white inside the mouth (it is not white in none of other platforms)
atm: wonderful design but only one without "ATM" and only one (except Mirosoft) with visible banknote

@carlinmack
Copy link
Contributor Author

  • yes!
  • agree
  • we'll move the current design to OpenMoji extras :)

@Michele0512
Copy link

christmas tree: in all other platform there is a star on top of tree, consider adding a star on top

@Michele0512
Copy link

Hot face: it is reddish-orange in all other platforms. Openmoji is the only one to show it as yellow. It only needs to change the colour
Black nib: majority of platforms shows it as only the nib of a fountain pen. Some platforms (including openmoji) show it as a entire or almost entire fountain pen. It is very confusing as it is just the same as fountain pen!
Cinema: almost all platforms show as a symbol inside a square. Maybe to add a square around

@Michele0512
Copy link

Construction: it is red and white only in openmoji. In all other platforms is yellow and black

@carlinmack
Copy link
Contributor Author

Fixed Construction :) 2622f79

@Michele0512
Copy link

crab: openmoji is only platform that shows crab facing downward. Design of claws could be improved

@lizbravob
Copy link
Contributor

Hi :)

I redesigned the faces 👀 Welcome any feedback 😬
faces_redesign.zip

Saludos 👋

@carlinmack
Copy link
Contributor Author

image
all great! no fixes :)

@mvolz
Copy link

mvolz commented Jan 20, 2021

I had a quick go at the pinching fingers...

1F90F oldsvg old version
1F90F_new svg closer pinch
1F90F v2 even closer pinch

Super preliminary- I'll try to work on it a bit more later. I think the closer pinch is looking more pinch-like now, but now the other fingers are out of proportion so I think they need a little re-working too.

pinching.zip

@b-g
Copy link
Member

b-g commented Jan 21, 2021

Hi @mvolz, many thanks for this! I would vote for the "even closer pinch" :) And yes the index finger looks a bit out of proportion now.

@mvolz
Copy link

mvolz commented Jan 22, 2021

pinching.zip
1F90F_new2_2

How is this?

@dnlutz
Copy link
Contributor

dnlutz commented Jan 22, 2021

i would leave out the knuckles, apart from that it's almost perfect!
… and it will be absolutely perfect if you could please correct these little dents ; )

maybe i would thicken the base of the forefinger a little bit (arrow)?

grafik

@mvolz
Copy link

mvolz commented Jan 24, 2021

Corrected bumps but - if you look at the other emojis none of them have the fingers out- we're the only ones. So I think we need to close the fist as well both for consistency's sake and also realism :). Most people pinch with the fist closed.

pinching.zip
1F90F

@dnlutz
Copy link
Contributor

dnlutz commented Jan 25, 2021

yes i think you are right, it's too differrent gestures.
we could keep this one as a special version and put it in extras-openmoji.

hands are quite challenging to draw … would you give the closed pinching hand a try? ; )

@lizbravob
Copy link
Contributor

Hola 🙃

I was improving some openmoji. Welcome any feedback 😬

openmoji_improving.zip

Greetings

@mvolz
Copy link

mvolz commented Feb 1, 2021

Hola

I was improving some openmoji. Welcome any feedback

openmoji_improving.zip

Greetings

Just one comment on 1F9AA - Getting rid of the purple (as it says in the description above so obviously not on you!) is in my opinion not enough because it's the wrong animal :/. This is a clam! But it's supposed to be an oyster.

I probably should have mentioned this earlier in the thread before you did the work >.<

Personally I think this emoji needs a total redesign so it actually looks like an oyster and not a clam (as per other emojis -> https://emojipedia.org/oyster/)

@carlinmack
Copy link
Contributor Author

image

@b-g
Copy link
Member

b-g commented Feb 1, 2021

@lizbravob Very nice! Many thanks! Some comments:

  • 1F4E6, I would mirror it so that the grey tape runs from left to right and hint a address or label of some kind
  • 1F9AA, I agree this should be oyster ... but I would preserve your version in openmoji-extras as an alternative
  • 1F9C7, I didn't recognize it being waffles. Sorry :) I would either try a round one like the Apple emoji or a stack of square waffles (like the stack of books)

@b-g
Copy link
Member

b-g commented Feb 1, 2021

@mvolz RE pinching hand: Let us know once your have a version with the fist more closed :)

@Ryuno-Ki
Copy link

Since I discovered the pinching emoji on Emojipedia right now, here's a fun fact: It looks like the sign (in sign language) for toilet.
Thumb and pointing finger form a c, the other fingers a w => wc.

@dnlutz
Copy link
Contributor

dnlutz commented Feb 17, 2021

… that means it is double useful ; )

@lizbravob
Copy link
Contributor

Hola! :)

I made the suggestions :) sorry for the delay.
What do you think?
Openmoji_.zip

@dnlutz
Copy link
Contributor

dnlutz commented Apr 16, 2021

thank you!
1F9AA oyster: very nice!
1F4E6 package: what about moving the dark grey thing a bit downwards so that it sits in the middle of the two light grey stripes?
1F9C7 waffle: already a huge step forward ; ) i would recommend lighter fillings. maybe the left and the right side a bit rounder (sketch attached)? with a small gap in between one can see better that it is two waffles on top of each other.
Bildschirmfoto 2021-04-16 um 11 43 56

@carlinmack
Copy link
Contributor Author

image

@b-g
Copy link
Member

b-g commented Apr 23, 2021

Added with 889fc9a 5 new 13.1 ones and 2 improvements. Contribution by Nelly Nieter. Thanks!

Moved old Fog to Foggy Mountain in extras.

Screen Shot 2021-04-19 at 09 22 34

@lizbravob
Copy link
Contributor

Holaa :) how about these waffles?

Perspective is hard for me, haha 👎 I'm trying.
Openmoji.zip

@b-g
Copy link
Member

b-g commented Apr 27, 2021

Nice! Plz check @dnlutz

Screen Shot 2021-04-27 at 08 22 33

@dnlutz
Copy link
Contributor

dnlutz commented Apr 27, 2021

i like it, thank you … the waffles look much fluffier now ; )

@b-g
Copy link
Member

b-g commented Apr 28, 2021

@lizbravob quick double check: Will use these improvements to update the existing OpenMojis. OK? (Or did I loose anything over course of the winding thread above?)
Screen Shot 2021-04-28 at 13 23 16

@lizbravob
Copy link
Contributor

YAY it's ok :)

@lizbravob
Copy link
Contributor

I had time to do the missing ones from this list 🙂ji
openmoji.zip

@lizbravob lizbravob mentioned this issue May 2, 2021
44 tasks
@b-g
Copy link
Member

b-g commented May 3, 2021

Wow nice II! @dnlutz @carlinmack anything to add before I merged it?

Screen Shot 2021-05-03 at 12 03 14

@carlinmack
Copy link
Contributor Author

carlinmack commented May 3, 2021

wow great!! it would be good to maybe preserve some of the old designs? especially the ATM one

@b-g
Copy link
Member

b-g commented May 4, 2021

Yay! I think we are done with this one. Closed. Many thanks @lizbravob 🙏❤️!!

@Alignitems
Copy link

Auto Rickshaw: It's yellow/green in all other platforms.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

8 participants