Skip to content
Permalink
Branch: master
Find file Copy path
Find file Copy path
Fetching contributors…
Cannot retrieve contributors at this time
51 lines (37 sloc) 2.77 KB

Reason Why for a 2-Level model ?

General

Mapping a ecosystem essentially consists of identifying "WHO? does WHAT?, HOW? and WHY?".

The answer to each of these questions can advantageously be provided via a "2-level" model :

  • A 1st level which refers to "Intentional" concepts (relating to the finality of the thing).
  • A 2nd level which refers to "Extensional" concepts (relating to the nature of the thing)

Simplified model : Basic Model

For example, the answer to the question "WHO?"
is given at the 1st level by the intentional concept #Agent (= "the thing that acts (whatever its nature)") then it is completed at the 2nd level by different extensionals concepts
Classically it can be about the following concepts:

  • #Person: A particular individu
  • #Organization: A set of #Person or #Organization #
    But potentially it can just as well be one or the other of the following concepts:
  • #Project: Specific initiative of a #Person or #Organization
  • #Software: A software-type product (e.g. an AI instance that performs taxonomies)
  • #Product: A hardware-type product (ex: a self-driven "taxi" car that offers trips)

The answer to the question "WHAT?"
is answered at the 1st level by the intentional concept #Deliverable (="the thing that is delivered/developed/specified (regardless of its nature)") then is completed at the 2nd level by different extensional concepts that take into account "the nature of the thing" (at a more or less detailed level depending on the need): #Product, #Service, ...

A similar "mechanics" applies for the answer to the other questions ...

Advantages

This two-level approach has the advantage that an intentional model can be defined that is "orthogonal" (= independent) to the extensional model.

This provides a generic model of the ecosystem description that can be specialized according to the type of ecosystem to be mapped.

Note: Note the extensional model itself may have a certain level of genericity if it is possible to manage in the form of taxonomies the different concepts that are potential candidates for being classes of the ontology.
Example: #Product hasType #ProductType (Software, Hardware, ...)
=> This possibility depends on the need (or not) to manage particular relationships between these concepts.

Appendix

A proposal for a "generic" Intentional Model (for ecosystem mapping)

Intentional Model

(Simplified) Use Case related to the project itself EBR Use Case

You can’t perform that action at this time.