New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Reenable video support #628
Comments
An iframe embed would be nice. An additional option for plain What I don't like is the reuse of the [flash] BB-Code. It's confusing and I guess there are users who don't know what Flash is. What about something like [media] or [video]? I'm not against rewriting old Flash embeds to iframe embeds, if possible. I just don't think [flash] is the right name for non-Flash content. |
Hmm, it's an argument.
I would tend to |
What is about |
That's a valid proposal. I am a bit indecisive how to handle the issue. Yes, the common implementation for videos nowadays is to embed it in an |
Nearly from the beginning of the project My Little Forum 2 there was the feature to insert videos into the entries with the BB-code
[flash]
. The BB-code got transformed into a HTML-elementobject
with the mimetypeapplication/x-shockwave-flash
in the functiondo_bbcode_flash
. Because Youtube as the main source of videos discontinued the flash support years ago we removed the Flash-support in MLF2 with version 20220508.1 (2.5.0) of My Little Forum – amongst others because no one intervened.That causes all inserted videos in old forum instances, that had and used the Flash-support before, to be broken. Now, after the child has fallen into the well, someone stated (thread in the project forum in german language), that his forum will lose to much content with this change to be willing to upgrade. That is in general a comprehensible decision.
In the linked forum thread we discussed a few options and compared it to the solution in another software project (namely in phpBB). It is possible to reimplement the feature with generating an
iframe
instead anobject
. This is the estabished solution nowadays.A further idea is, to provide a further BB-code for inserting videos directly with the HTML-element
video
. But this solution would only work with videos that are available under a static URL and which does not need the player UI from the providing source (like Youtube, Vimeo, Peertube etc.). So I'm (at the moment) not convinced, that this is worth the effort.I would like to reintroduce this feature. I propose to reuse the BB-code
[flash]
with the modern transformation to a video-technique agnosticiframe
. I also like the idea to have the possibility for displaying videos independently from the big video providers like Youtube and Vimeo withvideo
. But that's another story.Any thoughts?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: