yypushback() behaviour on surrogate characters

[hurricup]

Are there any plans to do something with, I'd say, inconsistency, when [^] matches 2 chars utf-16 emoji, for example, but yypushback(1) will push us back by 1 char only, in the middle of the pair.

Or this is intentional behavior and in this case, it would be nice to mention this in documentation.

[lsf37]

Sorry, somehow the notification mechanism seems to have failed, and I only saw this just now.

Interesting question. I'm not sure what the semantics should be, i.e. whether yypushback should refer to Java chars or full Unicode code points. Java char is certainly easier in the implementation.

Does yypushback(yylength()) do the correct thing for [^]?

@sarowe do you have an opinion on this?

[lsf37]

Sorry, somehow the notification mechanism seems to have failed, and I only saw this just now.

Interesting question. I'm not sure what the semantics should be, i.e. whether yypushback should refer to Java chars or full Unicode code points. Java char is certainly easier in the implementation.

Does yypushback(yylength()) do the correct thing for [^]?

@sarowe do you have an opinion on this?

[sarowe]

I don't think it's unreasonable that Java programmers have to know about the char/code point duality, so I think it's reasonable for yypushback(int) to deal strictly with chars. Maybe we could add a yypushback_codepoints(int) (or something like that but better named) ?

[sarowe]

I don't think it's unreasonable that Java programmers have to know about the char/code point duality, so I think it's reasonable for yypushback(int) to deal strictly with chars. Maybe we could add a yypushback_codepoints(int) (or something like that but better named) ?

[lsf37]

Ok, I agree. I guess we mainly should document the current behaviour more clearly.

[lsf37]

Ok, I agree. I guess we mainly should document the current behaviour more clearly.

[lsf37]

Have now mentioned this behaviour in the docs, as requested, in 846d20c

[lsf37]

Have now mentioned this behaviour in the docs, as requested, in 846d20c