This repository describes an error in the OpenJDK font rendering on Ubuntu and other Debian-based distributions which is fixed in OpenJDK 12. The bug itself is described on this page under the Report Classification heading. See the repository Wiki for more information about this repository and detailed test results of OpenJDK (Java Swing) and OpenJFX (JavaFX) with different versions of the FreeType library.
- 2018-10-08: Published this repository to demonstrate the problem.
- 2018-10-11: Helped create Java bug report JDK-8212071, “Need to set the FreeType LCD Filter to reduce fringing.”
- 2018-10-16: Provided the fix, available in OpenJDK 12 build 17 or later.
- 2019-02-07: Created Ubuntu bug report Bug #1815119, “Backport JDK-8212071 font fix to OpenJDK 11.”
- 2019-03-19: The JDK 12 General-Availability Release is published and includes this fix.
- 2019-09-23: The fix is backported to Oracle JDK 11.0.6 with JDK-8231359, scheduled for January 14, 2020.
- 2019-10-17: Marked Ubuntu bug report Bug #1815119 as "Fix Committed."
- 2019-10-30: The fix is backported to OpenJDK 11.0.6 with JDK-8233221.
- 2019-10-31: The fix is backported to OpenJDK 8 Update 242 with JDK-8233329.
- 2020-01-14: Oracle JDK 11.0.6 is available with the fix.
- 2020-01-15: OpenJDK 11.0.6 is available on Ubuntu 18.04 LTS with the fix.
- 2020-01-17: OpenJDK 8 Update 242 is available on Ubuntu 16.04 LTS and Ubuntu 18.04 LTS with the fix.
Issue Type: Request for Enhancement
Component: Client Libraries
Subcomponent: 2d: Java 2D API
Operating System: Ubuntu
Java Release: 12
Reduce color fringes in FreeType subpixel rendering
The text in Java applications often has severe color fringes using OpenJDK on Ubuntu. I may have figured out why, along with an easy fix.
The problem originates in decisions made by the developers of FreeType, Debian, Fedora, and OpenJDK concerning the Microsoft ClearType patents.
In 2007, FreeType 2.3.0 added a compiler configuration macro to the file
FT_CONFIG_OPTION_SUBPIXEL_RENDERING. If defined, the FreeType library includes patented ClearType techniques in its subpixel rendering.
But there’s a catch. When the ClearType methods are enabled, the subpixel rendering is not filtered, which results in severe color fringes. Clients of the FreeType library must make an explicit call to the function
FT_Library_SetLcdFilterto apply color filtering. The filter was disabled by default, explained one of its authors, “to avoid major surprises to existing clients, including libXft and Cairo which already perform some wacky color filtering on top of FreeType.”
In 2009, Debian created a patch to FreeType 2.3.9, named
enable-subpixel-rendering.patch, that defines the macro and enables ClearType-style rendering. The change log states, “This is considered no more or less evil than the bytecode interpreter which we also enable.” Ubuntu, based on Debian, applies the patch as well. Fedora created the same patch in 2007, named
freetype-2.3.0-enable-spr.patch, but does not apply the patch by default.
In 2017, FreeType 2.8.1 included a new subpixel rendering technique, called Harmony, that is nearly identical in output to the ClearType technique but uses a different algorithm, avoiding the patents. FreeType now uses Harmony subpixel rendering when the ClearType methods are disabled, with no need for clients to set the LCD filter. (This would have been a good time for Debian to remove its subpixel rendering patch.) The latest Fedora Workstation 28 runs FreeType 2.8.0, which does not include Harmony.
In 2019, the Microsoft ClearType patents expire.
So now we have two variants of the FreeType library: one that requires a function call to set the LCD filter in Ubuntu and other distributions based on Debian, and another that doesn’t require the function call in Red Hat Enterprise Linux, Oracle Linux, and other distributions based on Fedora.
This is a request for OpenJDK to reduce the color fringes in subpixel rendering by adding the following two lines to
#include FT_LCD_FILTER_H FT_Library_SetLcdFilter(scalerInfo->library, FT_LCD_FILTER_DEFAULT);
There are alternatives to setting the filter:
Bundle the FreeType library by default and always use the new Harmony subpixel rendering technique. This option removes the uncertainty in the library at the expense of an additional 4.6 megabytes to the installed size—an increase of less than one percent. OpenJDK 12 even includes the latest FreeType 2.9.1, a newer version than the one found on most systems.
Wait another year and see what changes are made to FreeType, if any, when the ClearType patents expire. This option, though, doesn’t solve the problem that users of Ubuntu and other Debian-based distributions have now.
To demonstrate the problem, I built four versions of the JDK from the latest OpenJDK sources. I built a version that uses the system FreeType library and another that uses the bundled FreeType library. Then I changed the OpenJDK code to set the default LCD filter and built the two versions again.
The system library is FreeType 2.8.1 in Ubuntu 18.04.1 LTS, which has the Debian patch applied (ClearType methods enabled), while the bundled library is FreeType 2.9.1 in OpenJDK 12, which uses the library default (ClearType methods disabled). I wrote a simple Java Swing application called FontDemo that displays two text areas with the Source Code Pro font in TTF and OTF formats (the latest non-variable download). The results are shown below.
System FreeType Library
In this case, setting the LCD filter is critical. The screenshots below show the ClearType-style rendering without setting the LCD filter on the left (lcdnone), and after adding the change to set the filter on the right (lcddefault). The ClearType configuration macro is defined in the Ubuntu build of FreeType, so the function to set the filter returns success (0) when called and applies color filtering.
|Before (system, lcdnone)||After (system, lcddefault)|
The color fringes are more visible in the images below, cropped from the TrueType font in the upper text areas and scaled by 800 percent.
|Before (system, lcdnone): ClearType with no fitler|
|After (system, lcddefault): ClearType with default filter|
Bundled FreeType Library
In this case, setting the LCD filter does nothing. The screenshots below show the FreeType Harmony rendering without setting the LCD filter on the left (lcdnone), and after adding the change to set the filter on the right (lcddefault). The ClearType configuration macro is not defined in the OpenJDK build of FreeType, so the function to set the filter returns
FT_Err_Unimplemented_Feature (7) when called and does nothing. The two images are identical.
|Before (bundled, lcdnone)||After (bundled, lcddefault)|
The two TrueType scaled images are also identical.
|Before (bundled, lcdnone): Harmony|
|After (bundled, lcddefault): Harmony|
System / OS / Java Runtime Information
The test system is a QEMU/KVM guest virtual machine running Ubuntu 18.04.1 LTS (Bionic Beaver) with the details shown below. The display is a 27-inch Dell UltraSharp U2717D monitor with a resolution of 2560 × 1440 pixels at 109 pixels per inch.
ubuntu@bionic:~$ uname -a Linux bionic 4.15.0-36-generic #39-Ubuntu SMP Mon Sep 24 16:19:09 UTC 2018 x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux ubuntu@bionic:~$ ldd --version ldd (Ubuntu GLIBC 2.27-3ubuntu1) 2.27 Copyright (C) 2018 Free Software Foundation, Inc. This is free software; see the source for copying conditions. There is NO warranty; not even for MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. Written by Roland McGrath and Ulrich Drepper. ubuntu@bionic:~$ getconf GNU_LIBPTHREAD_VERSION NPTL 2.27 ubuntu@bionic:~$ $HOME/opt/jdk-12-system-lcdnone/bin/java -version openjdk version "12-internal" 2019-03-19 OpenJDK Runtime Environment (build 12-internal+0-adhoc.ubuntu.jdk) OpenJDK 64-Bit Server VM (build 12-internal+0-adhoc.ubuntu.jdk, mixed mode)
For background information on LCD filters see Section 2.2.1 of The Raster Tragedy at Low-Resolution, which has an interactive demonstration of the filters used in ClearType (Microsoft), CoolType (Adobe), FreeType (open source), and Quartz 2D (Apple). Hover your mouse over each of the samples in the illustration to remove the filter.
Full Test Results
The results of 28 tests using seven versions of FreeType, with and without the ClearType methods enabled, and two builds of the latest JDK, with and without setting the LCD filter, are found on the Wiki page OpenJDK FreeType Tests.
For the results of the corresponding tests with the latest JavaFX, see the Wiki page OpenJFX FreeType Tests.
Below is the relevant section of the file
ftoption.h in FreeType 2.9.1 bundled with OpenJDK 12.
/*************************************************************************/ /* */ /* Uncomment the line below if you want to activate LCD rendering */ /* technology similar to ClearType in this build of the library. This */ /* technology triples the resolution in the direction color subpixels. */ /* To mitigate color fringes inherent to this technology, you also need */ /* to explicitly set up LCD filtering. */ /* */ /* Note that this feature is covered by several Microsoft patents */ /* and should not be activated in any default build of the library. */ /* When this macro is not defined, FreeType offers alternative LCD */ /* rendering technology that produces excellent output without LCD */ /* filtering. */ /* */ /* #define FT_CONFIG_OPTION_SUBPIXEL_RENDERING */