Skip to content


Subversion checkout URL

You can clone with HTTPS or Subversion.

Download ZIP


When passing in a collection of strings of the label_method should still be able to be applied. #32

jonnii opened this Issue · 8 comments

4 participants

Jonathan Goldman Justin French José Valim Jonas Grimfelt
Jonathan Goldman

For example when doing:

<%= form.input :gender, :as => :select, :collection => Profile::GENDERS, :label_method => :humanize %>

This won't work currently as in find_collection_for_column there's the optimisation:

  # Return if we have an Array of strings, fixnums or arrays
  return collection if collection.instance_of?(Array) &&
                       [Array, Fixnum, String, Symbol].include?(collection.first.class)

If you remove that it works as expected.

It might make more sense to check the existance of the label_method and the value_method and only collect if one is present.

Justin French

Good find! I think we should just apply the label method to each member of the collection. The default label method is to_s, which I'm pretty sure each of those classes respond to, even in Ruby 1.9.

Jonathan Goldman

Formtastic is pretty fab btw. Keep up the good work!

José Valim

Calling :to_s will make other things break. For example:

form.input :grade, :as => :select, :collection => Exam::GRADES


Exam::GRADES #=> [1,2,3,4,5]

If we convert to string, the rails select method will do object.grade == "1", since grade is an integer, it won't be able to mark the proper field. I would recommend humanize the strings in place:

form.input :gender, :as => :select, :collection =>
Justin French

Ok, very good point, but it's really confusing to have a :label_method that does nothing... I might see if there's a way to warn or raise when this option is used on these arbitrary collections.

Ultimately, I think the :label_method approach is flawed. Xavier Shay had a much nicer method which used a Proc, so this problem will "go away" when we move to that perhaps.

Jonas Grimfelt

I believe this solves the last "but", but maybe I missed something...?

collection.collect! { |v| (v.to_s =~ /^\d$/) ? v : v.to_s }

Note: Updated this, I was too sloppy last time.

Jonas Grimfelt

What's the status on this one? 8)

Justin French

I'm leaning towards the Proc idea... thinking ;)

Justin French

I'm closing this one with "won't fix". I can't settle on any one answer that I like. The Proc idea was recently implemented, so we have lots of choices. I'm not even sure I want :label_method to hang around long-term.

This issue was closed.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Something went wrong with that request. Please try again.