Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 28 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.Sign up
Comment should be optional for test case run #77
Description of problem
Cannot set test case run status without a comment
Component (web, API, etc)
Version or commit hash (if applicable)
How often reproducible
Steps to Reproduce
Status should be recorded either w\o comment if it's empty or with comment, if it's not empty.
Possible solution - make it optional only for "Success" status
I will look at the status table issue, looks like a bug.
I'm still not sure if we want to make comments optional. If they are optional there will be people who simply set the status and forget/don't bother to comment even on failure. I've seen people do this on a regular basis. Then it becomes impossible to figure out what went wrong unless you talk to them or read the bug reports.
Right, that's what I mentioned in "Additional info". Maybe it makes sense to improve the behavior:
"Failed" is discussible, since there is "Bugs" field, so if tester submits a bug, what else should he\she write in comment? "Test failed, see issue QQQ-1"?